7/29/2019 Invisible Urbanism

1/7

,-

)N+INSHASA4ALESOFTHE)NVISIBLE#ITY &ILIP$E"OECKWRITES

>che^iZd[i]Z[VXii]ViVcVcVanh^hd[i]ZY^[[ZgZcie]nh^XVah^iZhi]gdj\]l]^X]i]ZX^inZm^hihVcY^c"kZcih^ihZa[]ZaehjhidWZiiZgjcYZghiVcYi]ZheZX^XlVnh^cl]^X]i]ZbViZg^Va^ind[i]Z c[gVhigjXijgZ\ZcZgViZheVgi^XjaVghZihd[gZaVi^dch^ci]ZX^in!>ldjaYhjWb^ii]Vi^ci]ZZcY!^cVX^ina^`Z@^ch]VhV!^i^hcdi!dgcdieg^bVg^an!i]ZbViZg^Va^c[gVhigjXijgZdgi]ZWj^ai[dgbi]VibV`Zhi]ZX^inVX^in#I]ZX^in! cVlVn!Zm hihWZndcY^ihVgX]^iZXijgZ###i]Z^c[gVhigjX"ijgZVcYVgX]^iZXijgZi]Vi[jcXi^dcWZhi^c@^ch]VhVVgZVabdhiidiVaan ck^h^WaZdcVbViZg^VaaZkZa#&

>ck^h^WaZ

JgWVc^hb^c6[g^XVKn_VnVci]^GVd

^cXdckZghVi^dcl^i]

;^a^e9Z7dZX`VcY

6WYdjBVa fH^bdcZ

& &ILIP$E"OECK+INSHASA4ALESOFTHE)NVISIBLE#ITY'HENT,UDION

7/29/2019 Invisible Urbanism

2/7

-%

4HISUNDERSTANDINGOFTHECITYEXPRESSEDSOSUCCINCTLYBY$E"OECKISSHAREDBYALLTHREEOFUS"UTASANTHROPOLOGISTSSPEAKINGTOARCHITECTSWEAREALSOCONCERNEDWITHEXPLORINGTHERELATIONBETWEENVISIBILITYAND

INVISIBILITYANDWITHTHEhNETWORKSOFCONCRETEBECOMINGvAS!BDOU-ALIQ3IMONEPUTSITATONCEENGAGINGANDGOINGBEYONDTHEARTIlCEOFMATERIALINFRASTRUCTUREANDPHYSICALSITE'"UILTFORMMAYBEAS$E"OECKSTATEShPRODUCEDRANDOMLYINHUMANSITESASLIVINGSPACEv(!SURBANSTUDIESHAVETAKENAhSOUTHERNTURNv )WITHANINCREASINGNUMBEROFWORKSINMAINSTREAMURBANSTUDIESFOCUSINGONCITIESOFTHE'LOBAL3OUTHTHISCONTRASTBETWEENBUILTFORMANDLIVINGSPACEISINDEEDCRITICAL"UTEQUALLYCENTRALITSEEMSAREQUESTIONSOFGLOBALSCALEANDTHEPOSSIBLEPOLITICALANDSPATIALDESCRIPTIONSOFPARTICULARCITIESESPECIALLYTHESECITIESOFTHE3OUTHATTHEGLOBALSCALE

&ORTHISCONVERSATIONWETAKEASOURPOINTOFDEPARTURETHEMULTIPLEUSESDERIVINGFROMTHELATINROOTCAPITALISCHIEFPRINCIPALINTHESENSEOFSOVEREIGNPOWERWHICHISBOTHTHEROOTOFCAPITALASWELLASOF CAPITELLUMMEANINGhSMALLHEADvORTHEhTOPOFTHECOLUMNvINTHEARCHITECTURALSENSE*"YJUXTAPOSINGTHESEMULTIPLEUSESWEENTERINTOACONTRADICTIONWEARESPEAKINGBOTHABOUTTHESENSEOFlXINGOFTHEVANGUARDOFTHATWHICHTOPSOFFANDSHOWSOFFTHESOLIDITYOFTHEARCHITECTUREASWELLASTHATWHICHCIRCULATESANDCONTROLSTHEEXPRESSIONOFSOVEREIGNPOWERINTHEPOLITICALSENSEINSOFARASITISABLETOCIRCULATE

7EAREESPECIALLYCONCERNEDWITHWHEREWECANSITUATEhNETWORKSOFCONCRETEBECOMINGvBOTHINTERMSOFFORMSOFACCUMULATIONANDINTERMSOFTHEPOSSIBILITIESFORARTICULATINGPOLITICALPOWERINACONTINENTTHATISINCREASINGLYHELDHOSTAGETOGLOBALmOWSOFlNANCECAPITALRESOURCEEXTRACTIONANDMIGRATION7EFOUNDTHATTHEBESTPLACETOBEGINWASWITHTHETRANSFORMATIONSOFTHEPHYSICALENVIRONMENTOF!FRICANCITIES7HILE3IMONEUNPACKSTHEDEVELOPMENTSINANDAROUND$AKARANDTHEIRPOLITICALEFFECTSONOTHER3ENEGALESECITIESSPECULATINGONTHECAUSESOFSUCHMASSIVEINVESTMENTSINCONSTRUCTION$E"OECKREmECTSONTHEINTENSIlCATIONOFURBANITYWITHOUTARCHITECTURETHROUGHOUT#ONGOPARTLYALSOASARESULTOFTHEDIAMONDTRADE4HERELATIONSHIPBETWEENWHAT$E"OECKCALLSTHEhEJACULATIONvOFWEALTHANDTHEACCENTUATIONOFNONINVESTMENTINTHEPHYSICALSPACEOF+INSHASAISCONTRASTEDFOREXAMPLEWITHTHEIMAGINARYhURBANPLANNINGvENCOURAGEDBYTHEVARIOUSCHURCHESTHATHAVEGAINEDENORMOUSPOPULARAPPEALINTHE#ONGO#ANACONVENTIONALUNDERSTANDINGOFARCHITECTURESUSTAINTHEWEIGHTOFTHISIMAGINARYPLANNING#ANONETHINKOFTHECITYOUTSIDEOFMATERIALFORMSOFREPRESENTATIONANDASPIRATIONSUCHASTHOSEOFARCHITECTURE4HESEQUESTIONSALSOMOTIVATE$E"OECKSEXPLORATIONSOF+INSHASAATTHE6ENICE!RCHITECTURE"IENNALEANDHISMORERECENTEXHIBITION+INSHASA4HE)MAGINARY#ITYIN*OHANNESBURG

.ONINVESTMENTINMATERIALTERMSMIGHTALSOBELINKEDTOARETURNOF

THECOLONIALCOMPTOIRECONOMYTHEECONOMYOFTHETRADINGPOSTANDTHEGENERATIVITYOFCERTAINKINDSOFURBANPERFORMANCE4HESEPERFORMANCESARECENTEREDAROUNDTHEhHUNTERSLANDSCAPEvINWHICHCAPITALWORKSONLY

8Ve^iVa$8^in/>bV\^cVgnJgWVcEaVch

Kn_VnVci]^GVd/L]ViVgZi]ZheVi^VaZmegZh"h^dchd[XVe^iVa^cXdciZbedgVgn6[g^XV4=dlYdi]ZhZZmegZhh^dchgZaViZidZmegZhh^dchd[eda^i^XVaVcYhjW_ZXi^kZedlZg4

!BDOU-ALIQ3IMONE #URRENTLYIN$AKARYOUHAVETHERATHERRECENTANDSTILLOPAQUEPROJECTOFBUILDINGANEWCAPITALFORTHEMOMENTDESIGNATEDASh$UBAISUR!TLANTIQUEvSOMESIXTYKILOMETERSTOTHENORTH0ARTLYTHISREmECTSTHEGENERALIZATIONOFTHEREINVENTEDLOGICOFTHEENTREPTASSOCIATEDWITH$UBAIPARTLYITEMERGESFROMTHEFACTTHATTHEREEXISTSAKINDOFCONURBATIONTHATLEAVES$AKARANDTHENBEGINSTOLINKWHATWERESOMEMAJORSMALLCITIESLIKE4HIESAND-BOUR)NSOMEWAYSYOUHAVETHISRESIDUEOFAKINDOFCOLONIALBIFURCATION&IFTYYEARSAGO$AKARSTARTEDTOBECOMETOOOVERCROWDEDBECOMINGTOOMUCHOFATHREATTOCERTAINKINDSOFORDERANDPROCESSES$ENSEQUARTERSWEREDISPLACEDTO0IKINEAND'UEDIWAYEANDTHATINSOMEWAYSCULTURALLYBECAMETHEREAL$AKAR/UTSIDEOFCOLONIALSPECIlCATIONSTHESEAREASREmECTEDMANYOFTHETENSIONSOFURBANSPACESATTEMPTINGTOARTICULATETEMPORALANDSPATIALDIVERGENCE4HESAMEFOR&REETOWNTHESAMEFOR#ONAKRYTHESAMEFOR$AKARANDTOALIMITED

THROUGHITSINCESSANTCIRCULATIONRATHERTHANTHROUGHALOGICOFACCUMULATIONANDMAXIMIZATIONOFPROlT)TWORKSINOTHERWORDSTHROUGHTHECREATIONOFSOCIALNETWORKSTHATMAKEINVESTMENTSWORKFORTHEURBANHUNTER)NTHISLANDSCAPECOLONIALHISTORIESSEEMTOENDUREINASMUCHASTHECITYCONTINUESTOBESEENASASITEOFEXCLUSIONBYTHEVASTMAJORITYOFTHEPEOPLEWHODEVELOPED+INSHASAOUTSIDEITSCOLONIALBOUNDARIES)TISTHEREFOREAPLACEWHEREEVERYTHINGTHATCOMESFROMELSEWHEREFROMOUTSIDETHELUDICSPACESOFSOCIALNETWORKSINFORMATIONISTHOUGHTOFASBEINGTHERETOBEhRIPPEDOFFv

4HUSTHECONCENTRATIONOFPOLITICALPOWERINTHEREALMOFTHECAPITALCITYISCHALLENGEDBYITSCIRCULATIONINANDTHROUGHDIVERSESPACESANDAMONGTHOSENETWORKSTHATCONSTITUTETHEINVISIBLEARCHITECTUREOFCONNECTIONSOFTHECONTEMPORARY!FRICANCITY4HEPHYSICALASPECTOFTHECITYESPECIALLY

ASTHESIGNALOFAGROWINGDENSIlCATIONANDCONVERGENCEOFTRAJECTORIESHASHOWEVERALSOBECOMECRUCIAL!HISTORYOF$AKARFROMITSORIGINSINTHECOMPTOIRECONOMYANDITSTERRITORIALINCORPORATIONINTO&RANCETHATDElNEDITSRELATIONSWITHTHEOTHERCITIESINTHE3ENEGALESEMETROPOLITANSYSTEMREVEALSTHESENEWTRAJECTORIES4HESETRAJECTORIESAREATONCEGLOBALINTHEIRREACHCONTROLLEDBYACTORSFROMTHE3ENEGALESE-URIDDIASPORAASWELLASTHE,EBANESEDIASPORAWHILEALSOHAVINGEFFECTSATTHELEVELOFTHENATIONEXPRESSEDINTHEINVESTMENTSTHATNEWACTORSFROMTHEHINTERLANDAREMAKINGINTOTHELANDSCAPEOF$AKARGAININGNEWVISIBILITYFORTHEIRACTIVITIES

7EEXPLOREHERETHESEDISPERSALSOFCAPITALlNANCIALANDHUMANANDTHEIRRELATIONTOTHESECAPITALCITIES$AKAR+INSHASAAND+HARTOUMANDINTHEPECULIARRELATIONSTHATCITIESLIKE,AGOSHAVETOhCAPITALvINBOTHSENSESECONOMICANDPOLITICAL)NOTHERWORDSWETRYTOOPENTHEQUESTIONOFTHELOCATIONOFhCAPITALvINTHISCONVERSATION)NSODOINGWEATTENDTOOTHERFORMSOFINVISIBILITYASWELL&ORWHATHAPPENSINTHECOURSEOFTHECIRCULATIONOFCAPITALACROSS!FRICAISTHEGENERATIONOFCAPITALANDOFURBANITYOUTSIDEOFKNOWNFORMSOUTSIDEOFTHESTRUCTURINGCONTEXTSOFARCHITECTUREANDTHEPLANNEDINSERTIONOFMATERIALINFRASTRUCTUREh4HESECITIESAREOFTENINVISIBLETOTHEOUTSIDEWORLDv$E"OECKSAYSBECAUSEhTHEYFUNCTIONINWAYSTHATWEARENOTUSEDTOSEEINGANDTHEREFOREGOUNNOTICEDv4HUSWEFACETHEQUESTIONWHERESHOULDCAPITALTHECAPITALCITYBELOCATEDBYASKINGWHATISTHESCENESITEOFURBANACTION7EFACETHEQUESTIONOFWHATCONDUITSOFACCESSAREBEINGDEVELOPEDVINORDERTOFACILITATEINVESTMENTEXPANSIONACCUMULATIONORhEJACULATIONvOFCAPITALBYASKINGWHATFORMSOFSOCIALCOMPLEXITYAREBEINGEXPLOREDINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHESECONDUITS7HATSORTOFETIQUETTEISBEINGDEVELOPEDBYRESIDENTSOFTHESECITIESINTHEIRDRIVETOBECOMINGVISIBLEINORDERTOENABLESOCIALBEING7ETURNTOSITUATIONSOFBOUNDARYMAINTENANCEIN!BIDJANANDIN+HARTOUMANDWEALSOTURNTOTHEEMERGENTPLAYOFASPIRATIONSTHATREACHFORUNDERCODEDTERRITORIES2ECENT-ALAYSIANINVESTMENTSIN3ENEGALESESOCIALHOUSINGINTHENAMEOFANETHICAL)SLAMICPRACTICEASWELLAS#HINESEINVESTMENTINATRANSCONTINENTALRAILWAYSYSTEMREPRESENTGESTURESOFANEWKINDOFGLOBALPLAY)NTHISCONVERSATIONWETHINKTHESECONTRADICTIONSBETWEENTHEMATERIALANDTHENONMATERIALANDTHEVISIBLEANDTHEINVISIBLEARTICULATESTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENPOLITICALPOWERANDCAPITALANDREVEALSALIGNEDANDACCUMULATEDSTASHESOFWEALTHINITSMULTIPLEFORMS

6YJAYANTHI2AO

EXTENTFOR!BIDJANYOUHAVECOASTALCAPITALSWHEREGEOMORPHQUITELIMITEDINHOWTHEYCANGROW9OUHAVETHISKINDOFCONCENTRATHESEVERYLIMITEDPHYSICALSPACES)TBECOMESIMPOSSIBLETONA4HISKINDOFTRAJECTORYOFEXPANSIONTHENMAKESITQUITEPHYSICALLTOACCESSTHECENTERSOFPOWERANDCENTERSOFCOMMERCE3OINTEOF0RESIDENT!BDOULAYE7ADESAYINGWECANNOLONGERHAVETHEAWHEREWEHAVEITWECANNOLONGERHAVEMINISTRIESWHEREWEHAVEWEHAVETORELOCATEWEHAVETOBRINGTHEMOUTTOMAKETHEMMORESIBLETORECENTERTORECONSTITUTESOMEHOWTHEGRAVITATIONALlELDCAPITALMEANSINONESENSETHISOLDREITERATIONOFNEWGRANDWOTHEFORMERCENTER0LATEAUCONTINUESTOBEAHUGEBUILDINGSITEYOUSTILLSEETHESEIMMENSEKINDSOFCONSTRUCTIONSTAKINGPLACE

&ILIP$E"OECK)TSINCREDIBLE)JUSTDROVETHROUGHITACOUPLEAGO7HOSEMONEYISDRIVINGTHIS

!-3)NSOMESENSETHEAPPEARANCEOFCONTINUOUSDEVELOPMSIGNALSACERTAINAVAILABILITYOFTHISAREATOINVESTMENTOFALLKINDPLURALITYITSELFCANCONSTITUTEAPLATFORMFORREALOCCUPATION7HAPUTUPWILLINTHEENDBEUSEDINSOMEWAY3ORESIDENTSIN$AKARDUSUALLYHAVETHESENSETHATTHISISSOMETHINGTHATSBEINGINmATEAREBEINGBOUGHT4HERESAMARKET0EOPLEAREBUYINGTHESETHISPACEAPARTMENTSPACE

KG/>ihcdik^gijVa#!-3)CANTSAYFORSUREBUTTHERESAKINDOFPOPULARUNDERSTATHEREAREREALBUYERSFORTHESETHINGSREALOCCUPANCY

&$")THINKTHATISTHEDIFFERENCEWITHAPLACELIKE#ONGO#LE3ENEGALORIN$AKARYOUHAVEAMIDDLECLASSORUPPERMIDDLECLASPEOPLEMERCHANTSWITHlNANCIALMEANSWHOAREDOINGTHEIROWNTRANDCOMMERCEANDINVESTINGINTHEIROWNCITY)N#ONGOSUCHALOC

9V`Vg

@^ch]VhV

'!BDOU-ALIQ3IMONEh4HE6ISIBLEAND)NVISIBLE2EMAKING#ITIESIN!FRICAvIN5NDER3IEGE&OUR!FRICAN#ITIES&REETOWN*OHANNESBURG+INSHASA,AGOS$OCUMENTA?0LATFORM

($E"OECK+INSHASA4ALESOFTHE)NVISIBLE#ITY'HENT!MSTERDAM,UDION)6YJAYANTHI2AOh3LUMAS4HEORYv)NTERNATIONAL*OURNALOF5RBANAND2EGIONAL2ESEARCHVOL*7EBSTER$ICTIONARYONLINE

&OLLOWERSOF%TIENNE4SHISIKEDICALLINGFORABOYCOTTOFTHEELECTIONSBURNA+ABILAELECTIONBILLBOARDCENTRAL+INSHASA*ULY

@]Vgidjb

7/29/2019 Invisible Urbanism

3/7

-'

DLECLASSISABSENTANDTHEREAREOFCOURSEHISTORICALREASONSFORTHAT&ORALONGTIMETHEWHOLECOUNTRYWASRUNBYASMALLGROUPAPOWERELITEAROUND-OBUTU4HEREWASNOMIDDLEGROUNDBETWEENTHEVERYPOORANDTHEVERYRICH

-OBUTUSDOWNFALLCREATEDAVOIDINTHATRESPECT4HOSEWITHMONEYLEFT)N+INSHASAASARESULTTHEHOUSINGMARKETJUSTCOLLAPSED4HOSEWHOREMAINEDINTHECITYCOULDAFFORDTOBUYHOUSING4ODAYREALESTATEISBOOMINGAGAINASNEVERBEFOREBUTTHEBOOMISNOTCAUSEDPRIMARILYBY#ONGOLESE4HECAPITALmOWINGINTOTHECITYCOMESTHROUGHEXPATSANDFOREIGNERSTHELATTEROFTEN,EBANESEPEOPLEFROMOUTSIDEWHOSTARTTOREDEVELOPTHECITYBUTONLYTOACERTAINANDVERYMINIMALEXTENT

KG/L]ViVWdjii]ZY^VbdcYigVYZ^ci]Z

ZVgan&..%hVcYi]Z`^cYd[lZVai]^i\ZcZg"ViZY4LVh iViVaagZZXiZY^cl]VilVh]Ve"eZc^c\idi]Ze]nh^XVaheVXZd[@^ch]VhV4

&$"7ELLONTHEONEHANDITJUSTACCENTUATEDTHELEVELOFNONINVESTMENTINPHYSICALSPACEBECAUSEALLOFTHATMONEYWOULDLEAVE6ERYLITTLEOFITWOULDBEINVESTEDININFRASTRUCTURE/NTHEOTHERHANDITDIDHAVEAHUGEIMPACTINOTHERWAYSBECAUSETHEINFORMALDIAMONDECONOMYALLOWEDFORLOCALACTORSTOALLOFASUDDENGAINACCESSTOALOTOFMONEY0EOPLEOFTENYOUNGSTERSWOULDGOTO!NGOLATODIGDIAMONDSANDOFTENTHEYWOULDCOMEBACKWITHAOREVEN

KG/6cYi]ZnY^Yci cdll]ViidYdl^i] i4&$"7ELLMOSTOFTHETIMEITWASVERYQUICKLYEJECTEDANDSPENTKINDOFEJACULATEDREALLYALLOVERTHEPLACE&EWWERETHOSEWHOINVESTEDITINBUILDINGINHOUSESINPLOTSOFLAND"UTSOMEAREASOFCERTAINNEIGHBORHOODSIN+INSHASADIDWITNESSAMODESTCONSTRUCTIONBOOMTHANKSTOTHATKINDOFMONEY"UTALREADYWHENYOUTALKABOUTTHECAPITALOF+INSHASATHEQUESTIONIMMEDIATELYIS4HECAPITALFORWHOMORWHODElNEDWHATTHECAPITALISANDWHOHASACCESSTOIT)N$AKARITWASMERELYADISCUSSIONOFWHERESHOULDITBE )N#ONGOTHECOLONIALCITYREALLYEMERGED

ASANONPLACE)TWASDElNEDASAhCENTREEXTRACOUTUMIERvTHATISTHECITYPLACEDITSELFRIGHTFROMTHESTARTOUTSIDEOFALLLOCALLYEXISTINGCULTURALSOCIALANDPOLITICALFRAMEWORKS)NTHEPOSTCOLONIALPERIOD+INSHASABECAMEAMAJORPOLITICALCENTER"UTINRECENTYEARSEVENTHATROLEHASSLIGHTLYCHANGED)NTHELATESWESAWHOWREGIONALPLAYERS2WANDAAMONGOTHERSTRIEDHARDTOMAKETHECAPITALMOVEEASTWARDAWAYFROMA&RANCOPHONESPHEREOFINmUENCE)NTHEENDTHATHASNTWORKEDIFONLYBECAUSEOFTHESHEERSIZEANDWEIGHTOF+INSHASAASACULTURALCENTER!NDITHASOFCOURSEALSOREMAINEDANIMPORTANTPOLITICALCENTERBUTCONTRARYTOANEARLIERPERIODITISPERHAPSNOLONGEREXCLUSIVELYTHEONLYPOLITICALCENTER4HEREAREOTHERCENTERSOFPOWERASWELL7ITHTHE+ABILADYNASTY,UMUMBASHIFOREXAMPLEHASONCEAGAINBECOMEMOREIMPORTANT

!NDSECONDTHECAPITALALREADYWHENTHECITYWASFOUNDEDORWHENITGREWOUTOFREALLYA COMPTOIRECONOMYITWASATRADINGPOSTORIGINALLYANDTHENTRANSFORMEDINTOAHUGELABORCAMP4HECITYTHATTHE"ELGIANCOLONIALADMINISTRATIONDEVELOPEDWASADEEPLYSEGREGATEDONECERTAINLYINTERMSOFRACEBUTALSOINTERMSOFGENDERFOREXAMPLE"ASICALLYITWASADEPOTOFCHEAPLABORFORCE!CCESSTOTHECITYWASSTRICTLYCONTROLLED4HECITYITSELFWASDUALTHEREWAShLA6ILLEvTHEEXCLUSIVELYWHITECOLONIALHEARTOFTHECITYANDTHENTHEREWAShLA#ITvTHEVASTINDIGENOUSPERIPHERALCITYINHABITEDBY#ONGOLESE4HECITYINITSELFHASALWAYSMAINTAINEDASTATEOF

EXCLUSIONEVENTODAY&OREXAMPLEWHERETHECOLONIALBORDERSOFTHECITYENDTODAYTHEREALCITYSTARTSMUCHLIKE0IKINE"UTIN+INSHASAYOUHAVEACOLONIALCITYWITHAVERYSMALLHEARTWHICHSTOPPEDGROWINGINWHEN+INSHASASPOPULATIONDIDNOTEXCEED!FTERWARDMILLIONTOMILLIONPEOPLEHAVEBEENADDEDONTOTHATBUTINAREASTHATHAVENOTBEENURBANIZEDALONGFORMALLINES

4ODAYONEOFTHEACCESSPOINTSINTOTHEOLDCOLONIAL6ILLEISMARKEDBYASTATUEWHICH&ATHER+ABILAERECTEDINMEMORYOF,UMUMBA#ONGOS

BECAUSEYOUDONTKNOWWHETHERONTHETENTHDAYYOUWILLSTILLBETHERETODRINKIT3OYOUBUYWHATYOUNEEDINTHEMOMENT9OUDONTBUYAWHOLEBAROFSOAPBUTYOUBUYJUSTATHIRDOFITENOUGHTOWASHYOURSELFWITHTHISONETIME9OUDONTBUYAWHOLEPACKOFCIGARETTESYOUBUYJUSTONEOREVENHALFOFONECIGARETTE!NDSOALLTHEHEAPSOFFOODSTUFFSTHATYOUSEEATTHEMARKETAREMEASUREDBYTHEQUANTITYOFTHEBELLYTHEQUANTITYOFTHESTOMACH#APITALINTHATSENSESTARTSTOMEANSOMETHINGELSEITBECOMESSOMETHINGELSEAWAYFROMSTANDARDNOTIONSOFACCUMULATION

KG/Hdi]ZgZhVY^[[ZgZcihZchZdgjcYZg"hiVcY^c\d[^ckZhibZciVahd4

&$"7ELLTHEREISALOTOFINVESTMENTINSOCIALRELATIONSANDINONESSELFREALIZATIONTHROUGHTHESERELATIONSBUTFARLESSINVESTMENTINMATERIALINFRA

STRUCTURE.OTINBUILDINGSNOTINACITYTHATISSTILLPERCEIVEDASSOMETHINGTHATISNOTFULLYOURSAFTERALLTHOSEDECADES!NDSINCEITISNOTFULLYOURSITMEANSTHEREISNTASENSEOFRESPONSIBILITYABOUTITTHEMATERIALINFRASTRUCTUREANDEVERYTHINGTHATCOMESFROMABOVEANDFROMOUTSIDEISTHERETOBERIPPEDOFFTOBECAPTUREDANDTAKENADVANTAGEOFWHETHERLEGALLYORILLEGALLY4HETERMNOWISKISANOLAORCOMBINGYOURHAIRh#OMBINGvINTHESENSEPEOPLENOWGIVETOITMEANShSTEALINGvLOOTINGRIPPINGOFF)F)ASAWHITEPERSONWALKTHROUGHTHESTREETPEOPLEWILLMAKETHEKISANOLASIGNBYWHICHTHEYINDICATEh9OUARETHERETOBERIPPEDOFFvBASICALLYBECAUSE)DONTBELONGTHEREANDCANTHEREFOREBETAKENADVANTAGEOFWITHOUTANYMORALOBJECTIONSORFEELINGSOFGUILTORWRONGDOING3IMILARLYAMONEYCHANGERINTHESTREETMIGHTADVERTISEhDOUBLEKISANOLAvMEANINGh(EREYOUWILLBERIPPEDOFFTWICEv)TINDICATESTHATTHEMONEYCHANGERYOUAREDEALINGWITHKNOWSWHATHEISDOINGTHATHEISSHREWDANDSTREETWISE0ARADOXICALLYTHEFACTTHATHEISNOTTOBETRUSTEDISASIGNYOUCANTRUSTTHATGUY!NOTHERIMAGEPEOPLEUSEISTHATOFANINJECTION)NORDERTOSOCIALLYEXISTANDSURVIVEINTHISURBANENVIRONMENTONEHASTOKNOWHOWTOSTICKANEEDLEINTOSOMEONEANDSUCKTHEVICTIMSBLOOD3OTHATSTHEWAYINWHICHCAPITALMOVESINTHECITYTHATSWHATITISABOUT)TSNOTABOUTACCUMULATINGITSNOTABOUTMAXIMALIZING)TISNOTABOUTHAVINGBUTABOUTBEINGNOTABOUTPOSSESSINGBUTABOUTCONSUMINGABOUTSINGULARIZING

ONESELFBYIMMEDIATELYPUTTINGCAPITALINCONSTANTCIRCULATION

KG/Hd iYdZhci]VkZi]^hXVe^iVa^hi^Xcd"i^dcd[^ckZhibZci!l]^X]^hY^gZXiZYidlVgY

hdbZY^hiVci[jijgZ!Y^gZXiZYidlVgYhdbZ"i]^c\i]Vib^\]ibViZg^Va^oZVihdbZdi]Zged^ci^ci^bZ#

&$"3UCHASENSEISEMERGINGTODAYBUTINTHERELIGIOUSSPHEREWHEREMONEYHASCOMETOMEANSOMETHINGVERYSPECIlC7ITHIN0ENTECOSTALISMANDOTHERhPROSPERITYCHURCHESvYOUSEEHOWTHESWITCHTOWARDACAPITALISTNOTIONOFMONEYANDOFACCUMULATIONISMADE4HEREYOUALSOWITNESSTHEINTRODUCTIONOFNEWNOTIONSOFINDIVIDUALIZATION4HESECHURCHESTURNAWAYFROMOLDERCOLLECTIVEIDENTITIESBASEDONKINSHIPORETHNICBELONGING7ITHINTHATNEWRELIGIOUSPUBLICSPHERETHESEFORMERGROUPIDENTITIESAREDISFAVORED/NTHECONTRARYONEBECOMESANAUTHENTIC#HRISTIANASANINDIVIDUALANDTHROUGHONESOWNWORKANDEFFORT!NDTHATSTHECONSTANTMESSAGEOFTHESECHURCHES(EREONEWITNESSESTHEINTRODUCTIONOFANEWSUBJECTFORMATIONTHEINTRODUCTIONALSOOFANEWWORKETHOSANDOFNEWNOTIONSOFACCUMULATION)NTHESECHURCHESACCUMULATIONISNOLONGER

SOMETHINGTHATISSOCIALLYNEGATIVE)TISONTHECONTRARYSOMETHINGTHATISFAVOREDEVENTHOUGHTHEFRUITSOFTHATLABORANDACCUMULATIONAREOFTENNOTHARVESTEDINSTANTLYINTHISLIFE7HENPEOPLEGIVEMONEYANDGOODSTOTHECHURCHANDTOTHEIRPREACHERTHEYDOSOBECAUSETHEYBELIEVETHAT'ODWILLMULTIPLYTHESEGIFTSANDRETURNITTOTHEM$URING-ASSESANDPRAYERMEETINGSTHEBELIEVERSOFTENLISTENTOTESTIMONIESBYPEOPLEWHODIEDANDWERERESUSCITATEDTHROUGHTHEFORCEOFPRAYER/FTENTHEYREPORTBACKTOTHECHURCHCOMMUNITYABOUTWHATTHEYWITNESSEDINPARADISEh%VERY

lRSTPRIMEMINISTERAFTERINDEPENDENCE4HESTATUEITSELFISOFA,UMUMBAWHOSTANDSWITHONEHANDRAISED!NDTHEREAREALLKINDSOFPOPULARINTERPRETATIONSOFTHATSTATUE&IRSTOFALLIN#ONGOTHEREISNOREALCULTUREOFSTATUARYINPUBLICPLACESSOITSSUDDENAPPEARANCEGENERATEDALLKINDSOFCOMMENTS0AINTEDINGOLDTHEHUGEANDHEAVYSTATUEREMINDSONEOFTHEFORMER3OVIET5NIONSAESTHETICS4HElRSTREMARKSPEOPLEMADEWEREh4HISISGOINGTOBEHEAVYTOMOVEANDSTEALWHENANOTHERWAVEOFLOOTINGSWEEPSTHROUGHTHECITYv!NDSECONDh7HYISHESTANDINGTHEREWITHHISHANDLIKETHISv(ESBASICALLYSAYINGh3TOPYOUCANTGETINTOTHECITYv4OALLOFTHEMULTITUDESWHOLIVEINTHEPERIPHERALCITYTHATHASBECOMETHEREALCITYTHESTATUESAYSh9OURENOTALLOWEDTOCOMEINv)TSBASICALLYPERCEIVEDASTHEGOVERNMENTDENYINGACCESSTOALLTHESEPEOPLEWHOWANTTOGETINTOTHECITYBUTWHOARENOTALLOWEDTOWHOCANTAFFORDTO

WHOCANTMAKEUSEOFITWHOAREBLOCKEDANDEXCLUDED4HEAREASANDNEIGHBORHOODSTHATEXTENDBEYONDTHESTATUEARE

REFERREDTOASh,A#HINEPOPULAIREvORTHE0EOPLES2EPUBLICOF#HINABECAUSETHEYARESOPOPULOUS4HEYARECALLEDh"ANATERREROUGEvORTHECHILDRENOFTHEREDEARTHINREFERENCETOTHEDUSTYANDUNASPHALTEDSANDROADSINTHOSEAREAS4HEPEOPLELIVINGTHEREHAVENEVERHADAREALSENSEOFTHECOLONIALCITYASTHEIROWN6ERYOFTEN)THINKTHEYDONTFEELASIFTHECITYBELONGSTOTHEM)TSNOTTHEIRCITY

&ATHER+ABILA)BELIEVEUNDERSTOODTHATVERYWELLANDTRIEDTODECENTRALIZETHEURBANSPACEMUCHLIKE7ADE!SANALTERNATIVETOTHE#ENTRAL-ARKETINTHECOLONIALCENTER+ABILAORDEREDANOTHERMARKETTOBEBUILTINTHECITYSNEWERPERIPHERY"UTEVENTHENTHATMARKETPICKSUPONLYVERYSLOWLYBECAUSEPEOPLEDONOTREALLYCONSIDERITTHEIROWNITISATOPDOWNGOVERNMENTINITIATIVE)THASBEENTHERENOWFORALMOSTTENYEARSANDTHEFEELINGABOUTTHATMARKETISNOTGOOD0EOPLESTARTWORKINGANDFUNCTIONINGAROUNDTHEMARKETBUTTHEMARKETITSELFASACONSTRUCTEDSPACEBYTHEGOVERNMENTHASNEVERREALLYBEENFULLYADOPTED

3OTHATOTHERCITYTHATPERIPHERALCITYTHATISTHEREALCITYHASDEVELOPEDACCORDINGTOITSOWNNOTIONOFWHATCAPITALMIGHTMEANORWHATFORMSOFACCUMULATIONMIGHTMEAN

)NORDERTOEXISTSOCIALLYINACITYLIKE+INSHASAEXPENDITURECIRCULATIONANDCONSPICUOUSCONSUMPTIONAREFARMOREIMPORTANTTHANACCUMULATIONORMAXIMALIZATIONOFPROlT!CCUMULATIONREQUIRESADIRECTIONALITYATELEOLOGYASPECIlCTEMPORALITYTHATISNOTTHETEMPORALITYOFTHECITYTODAY4HECITYONTHECONTRARYISASPACEOFTHESUDDENTHEUNFORESEENTHEUNEXPECTEDANDmEETINGMOMENT)NORDERTOSURVIVEINITONEHASTOKNOWHOWTOCAPTURETHATMOMENT)TISTHISPRAXISOFCAPTUREANDSEIZURETHATDETERMINESLIFEANDSURVIVALINTHECITYWHICHITSELFISOFTENCOMPAREDTOTHESPACEOFTHEFOREST!SSUCHTHECITYDOESNOTFUNCTIONACCORDINGTOASTANDARDCAPITALISTLOGICASWEKNOWIT4HECITYESSENTIALLYISAHUNTERSLANDSCAPE)NORDERTOSURVIVEINTHISFORESTCITYONEHASTOBEAGOODHUNTERTHATISKNOWHOWTOSEIZEANOPPORTUNITYANDKNOWHOWTOMAKETHATKNOWN4HENEWlGURESOFSUCCESSWITHINTHECITYWHETHERITBEPREACHERSPOLITICIANSORMUSICIANSAREINAVERYREALSENSETHECITYSBESTHUNTERSTHOSEWHOKNOWHOWTOCAPTUREWEALTHINJECTITAGAININSOCIALNETWORKSANDGAINSOCIALWEIGHTTHROUGHIT

4HATALSOMEANSTHATTHEURBANSCAPEISNOTSOMUCHSHAPEDBYTHEDYNAMICSOFMODERNITYBUTRATHERTHATITISCONSTANTLYINFUSEDWITHALLKINDSOFOTHERNOTIONSANDMORALITIESTHATOFTENHAVELONGSTANDINGRURALROOTS

4HEPRACTICESOFSEIZUREANDIMMEDIATEEXPENDITUREMAKEFORTHEFACTTHATTHEREISNOBUILDUPOFANYSURPLUSTHENOTIONOFACCUMULATIONISABSENT%VERYTHINGYOUHAVEOREVERYTHINGTHATISSOLDINTHEMARKETISEVERYTHINGTHATCANBECONTAINEDBYONESBELLYEVERYTHINGTHATCANBEEATENANDDIGESTEDIMMEDIATELYINTHEMOMENT4HEREISNOUSEINBUYINGTENCANSOFSOMETHING

THINGTHATWEGIVETOTHECHURCHEVERYTHINGTHATWEGIVETOTHEPREAISBEINGINVESTEDFORYOUINHEAVENvTHEYWOULDSAYh!NDWITHTHEYOUGIVETHEYAREALREADYBUILDINGYOURHOUSEANDYOURVILLAINPA7HENYOUDIEYOURHOUSEWILLBETHEREAHOUSETHATYOUWERENEVTOAFFORDHEREONEARTHv3OGIVINGINTHISRELIGIOUSCONTEXTHASBECOINVESTMENTINREALESTATEEVENTHOUGHTHATREALESTATEISLOCATED)NTHISSENSETHECHURCHESDOCONTRIBUTETOANEWFORMOFURBANBUTITISANIMAGINARYURBANPLANNINGINTHEHEREAFTER

)NTHOSECHURCHESWITHINTHESENEWFORMSOF#HRISTIANFUNDAYOUCLEARLYSEEHOWTHESWITCHISMADEFROMTHENOTIONOFTHEGIFTTOANOTIONOFCAPITALWITHALLOFTHEFALLOUTTHATITPRODUCESTOOBECMEANSTHATSTRESSISPUTONINDIVIDUALSUCCESSANDNOTONGROUP!NDITMEANSTHATTHENOTIONOFTHEGROUPOFWHAThFAMILYvISFOR

ISBEINGREDElNEDATTHEMOMENTAWAYFROMTHEREALITYOFTHEEXTFAMILYTOWARDTHENEWANDMORERESTRICTIVENOTIONOFTHENUCLEARFAMTHEPROCESSPEOPLEWHOMONEWOULDHAVEDElNEDASKINBEFOREABEINGLABELLEDASOUTSIDERSSTRANGERSOREVENWITCHES4HESEANEWGEOGRAPHIESOFINCLUSIONANDEXCLUSIONTHATEMERGEWITHINLOCALEANDREDElNETHEBOUNDARIESBETWEENINSIDEANDOUTSIDESTRANGERENDOGAMOUSANDEXOGAMOUS

!CITYLIKE+INSHASAHASREALLYBECOMETHEFAULTLINEWHERETHESETWENTLOGICSTHELOGICOFGIFTANDKINBASEDRECIPROCITYANDTHELOGICOFMEETSOFARWITHOUTREALLYMERGINGANDTHATPRODUCESHUGEUPHEAV

KG/>ci]ZWdd`!ndjiVa`ZYVWdjii]Z^Yd[i]Z_jc\aZVcY]dl^ihWZXdb^c\eVgi]ZaVcYhXVeZd[i]ZX^in#I]Z\gdli]d[X^in^hegZb^hZYjedci]^hZcXdbeVhh^ci]Z[dgZhi#

&$"7ELLAS)SAIDITSAGAINABOUTTHEHUNTER)NTHEFORESTINORDSURVIVEYOUHAVETOKNOWHOWTOHUNT)NTHECITYINORDERTOSURVIVHAVETOKNOWHOWTOHUNT7ELLTHATMEANSWHATDOESTHEHUNTERWHENHEGOESHUNTING(ECOMESBACKWITHMEATANDTHENDIS

ACCORDINGTOSPECIlCROLESANDRULESTHATINDICATEWHATONESHOONESMATERNALUNCLElRSTWIFETHEOWNEROFTHEGUNTHEOWNERWHEREYOUSHOTTHEANIMALONANDSOONANDSOFORTH!NDTHATSHMAKESTHATCAPITALGAININTHISCASEWORKFORHIM(EGAINSINSOTIGEBYINVESTINGINSOCIALCAPITAL

)NORDERTOSURVIVEINTHECITYYOUHAVETODOTHESAMETHING9OCONSTANTLYMAKESURETHATYOUCREATEANDINVESTINCERTAINNETWORKSARENOLONGERTHENETWORKOFTHEHOUSEHOLDMAYBEOROFYOURETHNORYOURVILLAGEBUTDIFFERENTKINDSOFASSOCIATIONSDIFFERENTKINDSOFCOOPERATIONMAYBEAGANGMAYBEALLKINDSOFGROUPS"UTYOUSTANTLYHAVETOINVESTYOUCONSTANTLYHAVETOBEPRESENTCONSTANTLYTOEXCHANGECONSTANTLYBEhINTOUCHvWITHOTHERS)NORDERTOSURVIVCITYYOUHAVETOKNOWHOWTODOTHAT

7HENPEOPLESPEAKOFTHECITYASAFORESTTREFERTOASPECIlCKINDOFFOREST)TSAFORESTINYOUCANBECOMEMODERNWHEREYOUCANATTAACCESSACERTAINMODERNITYEVENIFITSONLYINNARYORONEIRICFORM)GAVETHEEXAMPLETHECHBUTTHEBARISANOTHERCONCRETEEXAMPLEOFAS

WHEREYOUCANDOTHATANDTHECHURCHANDTHOVERLAPTOACERTAINEXTENT4HEYAREBASICALLYSAMELUDICSPACES

KG/>lVhVahd ciZgZhiZYl]ZcndjiVa`ZVWdjii]Z]daadl^c\djid[eda^i^XVaedl^c@^ch]VhVi]ZXdadc^Va@^ch]VhV!cdi

9V`Vg!@]Vgidjb!VcY@^c

7/29/2019 Invisible Urbanism

4/7

-)

!STATUEOF0ATRICE,UMUMBAERECTEDBY,AURENT+ABILAANDANUNlNISHEDTOWERBUILTDURINGTHELOOKDOWNON*EAN0IERRE"EMBASUPPORTERSASTHEYMAKETHEIRWAYTOARALLY+INSHA

7/29/2019 Invisible Urbanism

5/7-+

di]Zg@^ch]VhVl]^X]]VhYZkZadeZYaViZgdcVcYi]ZXdcXZcigVi^dcd[i]ViedlZg^cdi]ZgX^i^Zh!a^ ZAjbjbWVh]^#L]Vi^hi]ZgZaVi^dch]^eWZilZZci]ZhZkVg^djhXdcXZc"igVi^dchVcYZmegZhh^dchd[edlZg4L]Vi^hi]Z`^cYd[^beVXii]Zn]VkZdci]ZaVcY"

hXVeZd[i]ZXVe^iVaX in4

!-3,OOKINGATSOMEOFTHEOVERLAPSANDDIVERGENCESOF$AKARMAYBESOMEWHATINTERESTING"ECAUSEONEHASTOKEEPINMINDTHAT$AKARANDOTHER3ENEGALESETOWNSWEREACTUALLY

&$"4HOSEWERECOMPTOIRS

!-34HEYWERECOMPTOIRSANDALSOPARTOF&RANCEATONEPOINT$AKARWASLITERALLYINTEGRATEDINTO&RENCHTERRITORYANDDONESOINAWAYTOMARKTHESTRONGDIVIDEBETWEENTHECITYTHEURBANANDTHEHINTERLAND4HEHINTERLANDWASTHEPROVINCEOFTHE-ARABOUTAKINDOFRELIGIOUSPOWERTHATHADTOBECONTAINEDTHATHADTOBEMARKED)DONTKNOWALOTABOUTTHATHISTORYBUTITISACLEARHISTORYWITHRAMIlCATIONSTOTHISDAY

)NSOMEWAYSOUTSIDEOF+INSHASAISAHINTERLANDTHATISTEEMINGWITHCERTAINPOSSIBILITIES)TTEEMSWITHBOTHANEXCESSOFLIFEANDDEATH7HEREASOUTSIDEOF$AKARISINCREASINGLYAHINTERLANDTHATISOVER)TSWASTED

"UTWHATSINTERESTINGTOOISTHEFACTTHATYOUHAVE4OUBA)TWASARELIGIOUSCITYANDWASATONETIMEEXEMPTFROMTAXATIONANDHADNOKINDOFLOCALMUNICIPALSTRUCTURES4HEBUYINGANDSELLINGALLWASCONCENTRATEDASAKINDOFTERRAINOFTHE-URIDSTRUCTUREANDALSOEXEMPTFROMCERTAINKINDSOFAPPLICATIONSOFCUSTOMSLAW

4OUBAREALLYGREWALOTTHROUGHTRADESOITWASAKINDOF ENTREPTMASKEDASSACREDCITY4HENWHENPEOPLEBEGANTOREALIZETHATITWASASORTOFBOOMINGCOMMERCIALCENTERONTHEBASISOFILLEGALTRADETHEREWASTHEATTEMPTTODOMESTICATEITINSOMEWAY4HEDOMESTICATIONTHE

COMPLEXNEGOTIATIONSTOBRINGITSURBANECONOMYWHICHWASNOTJUSTANECONOMYOF4OUBABUTATRANSNATIONALECONOMY

KG/D[i]ZBjg^Yh4 +

!-34HATSOMEHOWSYMBOLICALLYANDADMINISTRATIVELYWASADMINISTEREDFROM4OUBA4HECOMPLICATEDNEGOTIATIONSTOTRYTOBRINGITINTOTHEAMBITOFTHESTATEMEANTTHATCERTAINDEALSHADTOBEWORKEDOUT!NDANIMPORTANTDEALWASTHAT0LATEAUTHECOMMERCIALADMINISTRATIVECOLONIALCENTEROF$AKARBECAMETHROUGHMANYDIFFERENTPOLICIESMANYDIFFERENTDEALSINCREASINGLYAVAILEDTOTHE-URIDS3OTHE-URIDSBEGANTOTAKEOVER4HEYBEGANTOTAKEOVERCERTAIN,EBANESECOMMERCIALINTERESTSPARTICULARLYTHATKINDOFINTERMEDIARYBETWEENWHOLESALINGANDRETAILING7HATWASINTERESTINGISTHATTHE$AKARURBANECONOMYINSOMEWAYSBECAMEANEXTENSIONOF4OUBA"UTYOUHAVETHENAKINDOFINDIGENOUSENTREPRENEURSHIPTHATREALLYISWITHINANURBANECONOMYANDISREALLYSTRONGUNLIKEINMANYOTHERPLACES

&$"4HATSREALLYDIFFERENTTHAN#ONGO)MEANINTERMSOFINDIGENOUSENTREPRENEURSHIPWHATHASWORKEDWELLINTHEPASTDECADESARETHOSEPARTSOFTHECOUNTRYTHATKNEWHOWTOEVADE+INSHASA!VERYGOODEXAMPLEARETHE.ANDECULTIVATORSANDTRADERSOFCOFFEEINASECONDARYCITYSUCHAS"UTEMBOINEASTERN#ONGOWHOTHROUGHTHEIROWNNETWORKSMANAGEDTOREALLYINSCRIBETHEMSELVESINTRANSNATIONALCOMMERCIALMOVEMENTSTHATLINKTHEMTO$UBAIAND!SIA6ERYWEALTHYAWHOLENEWFORMOFURBANIZATIONAKINDOFVERYPROVINCIALURBANISMALLOFITBECAUSETHEYARENOTUNDERTHECONTROLOFTHECAPITALCITYANDKNOWHOWTOEVADETHESTATE/THERWISEITWOULDNEVERHAVEHAPPENED4HEREALURBANGROWTHANDTHENOTIONITSELFOFURBANITYOFTENDEVELOPS)WOULDSAYOUTSIDEOF+INSHASAASLONGASITSNOTCONTROLLEDBYTHECAPITAL

4HESAMEISTRUEOFTHEDIAMONDTRADE%VENTHOUGHMATERIALLYTHEYDONOTREPRESENTMUCHLITTLEDIAMONDTOWNSTHATSPRINGUPALONGTHEBORDERWITH!NGOLAFOREXAMPLEORTHEGOLDMININGTOWNSINTHEEASTTHOSEARETHEPLACESWHERETHEIDEAOFCAPITALISMANDURBANITYISMOSTFULLYGENERATED"UTAGAINMATERIALLYTHESECITIESANDTOWNSDONOTCORRESPONDTOTHEFORMOFWHATWETHINKOFASACITY!NDYETITISMUCHMOREURBANINAWAYINITSDYNAMICSTHANWHATGOESONINTHEhREALvCITY

!-3)N3ENEGALINSOMEWAYSTHEPREDOMINANTMODEOFURBANACCUMULATIONCANBEATTRIBUTEDTOWHATGOESONOUTSIDEOF3ENEGAL4HERESNOTHINGWITHINTHENATIONOF3ENEGALITSELFTHATCOULDACCOUNTFORTHEKINDOF

&$".OBUTWITHIN3ENEGALTHEREARELOCALAUTHOCHTHONOUSGROUPSTHATHAVETHECAPACITYANDSTRENGTHTOIMPOSETHEMSELVESANDBECOMEKEYPLAYERSANDCONTROLTHATGAME)N#ONGOYOUOFTENDONTHAVETHESE

INTHATSENSE7HETHERSMALLTRADEANDCOMMERCEORINDUSTRIALACTIVITIESINTHElELDSOFMININGORWOODLOGGINGTODAYTHESEACTIVITIESOFTENWEREANDSTILLARENOTIN#ONGOLESEHANDSBUTARECONTROLLEDBYTHE,EBANESEFOREXAMPLEORTHE#HINESEFORTHATMATTER%VENINTHEEARLYYEARSOF+INSHASASEXISTENCETHETRADEWASNOTIN#ONGOLESEHANDSBUTWASOFTENCONTROLLEDBYWHATWERECALLEDTHEhCOASTMENvPEOPLECOMINGFROM&REETOWNOR$AKARORLATERTHE'REEKSANDTHE0ORTUGUESEANDNOWTHE,EBANESEANDTHE0AKISTANISANDSOON

7HENITCOMESTOTHEBROADERGEOPOLITICALGAME)MEANWHYIS5GANDATHERE7HYIS2WANDATHERE)TSEEMSTOBE#ONGOSFATETOALWAYSBEEXPLOITEDBYANDPROlTEDFROMOUTSIDERS#ONGOLESEEVENTHE#ONGOLESEGOVERNMENTTRIESTOGETITSHANDSONSOMEOFTHECRUMBSTHATFALLOFFTHETABLEBUTITNEVERFULLYCONTROLSTHEGAMEITSEEMSTOME7HEREASTHESE-URIDAREINCONTROLOFWHATTHEYREDOINGTOSOMEEXTENT

!-3!NDINCREASINGLYSO&$"!NDINCREASINGLYSOYESINCREASINGLYTAKINGOVERTHESTATE!-33OTHATSORTOFDIVISIONOFKEEPINGTHESTATESEPARATEFROM

CAPITAL$AKARSEPARATEFROM4OUBA

KG/>cegVXi^XVaiZgbh!^ihWajgg^c\#I]^hgZaVi^dcWZilZZci]ZXVe^iVaX^inVhi]Z

ZmegZhh^dcd[eda^i^XVaedlZgVcYXVe^iVaVhZXdcdb^XZaYd[deZgVi^dc

!-3)TSNOTTHERE&OREXAMPLEDURINGTHEPERIODSOFINTENSERELIGIOUSCEREMONYIN4OUBAYOUCANWALKDOWNTHEMAINSTREETOF$AKARANDHAVEALMOSTNOTRAFlC/THERWISESTREETSIN$AKARWHERE)USEDTOLIVENOTFARFROM0LATEAUWHICHUSEDTOBEAMINUTETAXIRIDETODAYTAKESANHOURANDAHALF

&$"!BSOLUTELY/REVENLONGERNOWBECAUSEOFTHEROADWORKS!-3"UTALSOBECAUSETHEREARELIMITEDFEEDERROADSBECAUSEOF

THEINCREASEDDENSIlCATION)NSOMEWAYSWHATACCOUNTSFORTHATKINDOFDENSIlCATION!LLRIGHTMANYOFTHE,EBANESEHAVEGONEAWAYHAVEBEENDISPLACED3OTHEYGOBUTMANYOFTHE,EBANESEALSOCONTINUETOHAVEIMPORTANTKINDSOFECONOMICCIRCUITS!STHEYREDISPLACEDFROMCERTAINKINDSOFECONOMICACTIVITIESBECAUSEOFTHEWAYSTHATMANYOFTHOSE,EBANESENETWORKSWEREIMPLICATEDWITHINTHESOCIALISTPARTYTHEYSIMPLYTAKEANOTHERFORMOFACCUMULATIONWHICHISTHROUGHEXTENDINGTHEIRREALESTATE3OYOUHAVETHESEBIG,EBANESEINVESTMENTSINBUILDING

.OWTHE-URIDAREALSOCAPABLEOFDOINGTHAT)MEANITSNOTTHATTHEPARTICULARFORMOFECONOMICACTIVITYISANYTHINGDIFFERENTFROMAKINDOFCORPORATESTRUCTURE4HEYDOTHATASWELL"UTTHEREISSOMETHINGIMPORTANTABOUTTHEMARKET4HEREISSOMETHINGIMPORTANTABOUTTHELOGICOFTHEWAYINWHICHTHEMARKETOPERATESASANINTENSELYMUTABLEFORM4HERESSOMETHINGVERYMATERIALABOUTTHEWAYTHATTHISMARKETOPERATESSMALLTRADERSWHOAREMORETHANSMALLTRADERSOFSHIFTINGALLIANCESTHATAREMADEVISIBLEOFAFORMOFVISIBILITYWHEREPEOPLECANWATCHOBSERVESEEWHATSGOINGONWHOSDEALINGWITHWHOM"UTTHATHASTOBESERVICEDSOYOUHAVEBIGTRUCKSCOMINGINANDTRAFlC

+ 4HE-URIDSAREPARTOFA3ENEGALESE3UlMOVEMENTCENTEREDONTHELIFEANDTEACHINGSOFALOCALSAINT

NAMED3HEIK!MADOU"AMBAALSOKNOWNBYTHEHONORIlCh3ERIGNE4OUBAvWHOLIVEDFROMTO

)TBECOMESADENSIlCATIONBYVIRTUEOFMULTIPLYINGTHESETRAJECTORIESINAWAYTHATSPARTLYSYMBOLICPARTLYAKINDOFNERVECENTER4HEANTECEDENTSWANTTOREPRODUCETHEMSELVESSPATIALLYYETVEEROFFANDTRANSFORMINTOASORTOF-URIDVERSIONOFCORPORATEHEADQUARTERSBIGBUILDINGSBECAUSETHEYREINVESTINGINTHATASWELLANDALSOTHEWAYINWHICH$AKARISINCREASINGLYIMPLICATEDINOTHERECONOMIESELSEWHERE&OREXAMPLETHEPOLITICALCRISESOF!BIDJANDURINGTHEPASTSEVERALYEARSHASMEANTKEYCORPORATIONSMULTILATERALSMOVEFROM!BIDJANTO$AKAR

"UTWHATSALSOINTERESTINGISTHEATTEMPTTOHOSTTHE/RGANIZATIONOFTHE)SLAMIC#ONFERENCEIN$AKARSOMETHINGTHATWASSUPPOSEDTOHAVEALREADYTAKENPLACE)THASBEENPOSTPONEDNOWTHREETIMESSONOWITSTOTAKEPLACEATTHEENDOF7ADEALWAYSSAYSTHEREASONFORTHISDELAYISBECAUSE$AKARNEEDSADEQUATEINFRASTRUCTUREINORDERTOSUF

lCIENTLYHOSTTHEMEETING&ORHIMTHATMEANSTHECONSTRUCTIONOFEIGHTNEWlVESTARHOTELSONTHE#ORNICHE

)NSOMEWAYSTHEINFRASTRUCTUREOFHOSTINGTHISMEETINGALREADYEXISTS)TALREADYEXISTSINTOURISTAREASOUTSIDETHECITY"UTINSOMEWAYSTHATSTOOMUCHAKINDOFBUDGETTOURISMBORDERINGONSOMESLEAZYACTIVITIESTHATCANTREALLYBETHESITETOHOSTAN)SLAMICMEETING-AYBEANYOTHERMEETINGCOULDTAKEPLACETHERE"UTBECAUSETHISISTHE/RGANIZATIONOF)SLAMIC#ONFEREANDASTHEBASISOFACCUMULATIONOFTHE-URIDSHASALWAYSINSOMESENSEBEENMARGINALTOTHERESTOFTHE)SLAMICWORLDTHEREISSOMEPERCEIVEDNEEDTOUSETHISGATHERINGASAWAYOFNORMALIZING3ENEGALSRELATIONSHIPSWITHTHE-USLIMWORLD

.OTTHAT3ENEGALITSELFHASNTALWAYSBEENSEENASPARTOFTHE-USLIMWORLD"UTINCREASINGLYASTHE-URIDSASSUMEINCREASEDPOLITICALANDECONOMICPOWERANDTHENBECOMEAVAILABLEASANEXPRESSIONOFACERTAINKINDOFNATIONALCOHESIONTHEDISTINCTIVENESSOF3ENEGALASANATIONBUTALSOITSINTEGRATIONINTOALARGERTHEATEROFOPERATIONSh7ERE-USLIMSWERECLEARLY-USLIMSWETAKE)SLAMSERIOUSLYvBUTTHEROLEOF3ENEGALBEINGINSOMESENSEh7ERE-USLIMSBUTWEREALSOADIFFERENTKINDOF-USLIMSv3INGULARITYISVERYMUCHWRAPPEDUPHISTORICALLYINTOASENSEOFNATIONALIDENTITYASENSEOFNATIONALCOHESION

)NSOMEWAYSTHEHOSTINGOFTHE/RGANIZATIONOFTHE)SLAMIC#ONFER

ENCESIGNALSALMOSTTHENORMALIZATIONOF3ENEGALSPOSITIONWITHINTHE)SLAMICWORLDSOITHASTOBEDONERIGHT"UTTOBEDONERIGHTMEANSTHATYOUHAVETOMAKETHISBIGINTERVENTIONINTOTHEBUILTENVIRONMENT4HEMONEYISCOMINGFROM$UBAIFROM+UWAIT4HESEHOTELSBASICALLYBELONGTOTHEMANDWHATISTHEIRINTEREST7HATISTHEINTERESTOFTHE%MIRATESINTHE'ULF4HElNANCIALLYAMBIGUOUSROLEOF$UBAI7ORLDANDITSREALESTATEARM,IMITLESSINTHEPROPOSEDCONSTRUCTIONOFTHENEWCAPITALSIMPLYACCENTUATESTHEIMPRESSIONTHATTHECOUNTRYISBEINGBROUGHTINTOAPARTICULARlELDOFORBITTHATISBEINGELABORATEDTHROUGHMAJORURBANANDlNANCIALENGINEERINGPROJECTSMANAGEDBY'ULFCOMPANIESACROSSTHE-AGHREB

3OMEHOWTHERESSOMETHINGABOUTLOCATINGWHATWILLBE'ULFOWNEDPIECESOFREALESTATEONTHE#ORNICHEFACINGTHE!TLANTICINTHEWESTERNMOST)SLAMICCOUNTRY!SIXHOURmIGHTFROM.EW9ORKTHERESSOMETHINGABOUTTHAT

&$"!REYOUSAYINGTHISORISTHISWAYTHISHASBEENPERCEIVED!-3/NTHESTREETIN$AKARTHERESTHISKINDOFTALKYOUKNOW

&$",IKEWEREINTHEMIDDLEOF!-3!LL)MSAYINGISTHATWHENYOULOOKATTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENCAPITALANDTHECAPITALCITYTHEKINDOFPROJECTOFCENTRALIZINGTHEKINDOFEXPRESSIONOFTHECAPITALOFTHENATIONALCOHESION

KG/I]ZlVn>b]ZVg^c\^i^hi]Vii]ZgZhhdbZgZaVi^dch]^eWZilZZcWZ c\Va^\cZYidi]ZhZdi]Zghdgihd[dlh[gdb9jWV^

dgZahZl]ZgZdci]ZdcZ]VcY!VcYdcdi]Zg]VcY!idi]ZgZ\ZcZgVi^dcd[i]ZXd[i]ZcVi^dc!Wjil]^X]\ZihZmegZhhZYi]^heVgi^XjaVglVn!l]^X]XVciWZZmegZl^i]djii]^hVa^\cbZci!g^\]i4L^i]djiibdkZbZciidlVgYWg^c\^c\i]dhZZaZb^cidi]ZheVXZd[i]ZX^in^cVkZgnXdcXZmegZhh^dc!i]ZWj^aY^c\hVabdhiWZXdbi]VibZY^jbVh^ilZgZ!l]ZgZ

!-39ESBUTCOMBINEDWITHAVERYOLDSTORYTOO7ADEISAVERY(ESINHISEARLYS(ESJUSTBEGUNHISLASTTERMINOFlCEATWHAT

AHIGHPOLITICALPRICEFORTHECOUNTRY(EKNOWSTHATTIMEISRUNNINHESWAITEDTOBEINPOWERFORALONGLONGTIMEANDSOMEHOWTHEOFTHEGRANDSTRAVAUXTHEBIGWORKS

&$"6ERY&RENCH,IKEA&RENCHPRESIDENT!-34OMAKETHEMARKTOLEAVETHETRACEWITHALSOVERYOLDID

ABOUTMAKING3ENEGALREALLYAMODERNNATIONTHATSREmECTEDINANOLDSTORY

>ck^h^WaZ>c[gVhigjXijgZ

KG/Ijgc^c\idVgZaViZYWjiY^[[ZgZcifjZ>lVcindjWdi]idZaVWdgViZl]ni]Zcdi^ck^h^W^a^inhZZbhhdVcVani^XVaanXZcig

i]^c`^c\VWdjii]ZXdciZbedgVgn6[g^XV&$"4HEQUESTIONSEEMSTOBETHETHINGSTHAT-ALIQWASTALKINURBANNETWORKSANDHOWPEOPLEMOVETHROUGHTHECITYMAKEUSECITYANDCREATETHECITYANDGENERATETHECITYWHILEDOINGSO(OWYOUCAPTURETHAT(OWCANYOUSTARTTOUNDERSTANDCAPTURECOREPRESENTURBANLIFE(OWDOYOUREPRESENTANURBANREALITYLIKETHCANNOT!LLTHEMEANSTHATWEHAVEATOURDISPOSALTODOSOWHETHWRITINGORWHETHERITSPHOTOGRAPHYSEEMTOBEINAWAYNOTSUFlCI

KG/Hdi]ZfjZhi^dc^hVahdVWdjiZe^hiZbdad\n]Vk^c\idYdl^i]i]ZdW_ZXi^ihZ>ihZZbha^`Zlg^i^c\VWdji ck^h^W^a^in^hegdYjXi^kZlVnd[YZhXg^W^c\l]Vih]V^c\^c6[g^XVcX^i^Zh#6cYeVgid[i]Z^ciZ^hVahdidjcYZghiVcYl]Zi]Zgi]dhZ[dYZhXg^ei^dcVgZeVgi^XjaVgdcanid6[g^XVi]ZnXVcigVkZaiddi]ZgjgWVcXdcY^i^dc

&$"7ELLINVISIBILITYCANMEANMANYTHINGS4HEREISINVISIBILITYLEVELSOFCOURSE4HEREISTHEFACTTHATTHESECITIESAREINVISIBLETO

SIDEWORLDBECAUSEPEOPLEDONTKNOWMUCHABOUT!FRICANCITIEISTHEFACTTHATTHESECITIESFUNCTIONINWAYSWERENOTUSEDTOANWETHEREFOREDONOTSEETHATGOUNNOTICED4HEREISTHEFACTTHATFOOFURBANPLANNINGANDSOONCONTINUEINVERYMUCHLITERALLYINVISILIKETHEURBANIZATIONTHAT)WASTALKINGABOUTURBANIZINGIN0ARADRATHERTHANTHEREALLIFE)NVISIBILITYMIGHTMEANANUMBEROFTHING

!-3)AGREE!SPARTOFTHIS.EW3CHOOLGRANTTHEREHASBEENPROJECTIN$OUALAFORTHEPASTEIGHTEENMONTHS/NEPIECEOFTH

9V`Vg!@]Vgidjb!VcY@^c

7/29/2019 Invisible Urbanism

6/7--

HAVEAWORKINGGROUPOFYOUNGMIDDLECLASSKIDSINAMIDDLECLASSAREAOF$OUALA"ONAMOUSSADI4HEYMEETONCEEVERYTWOWEEKSFOREIGHTEENMONTHS4HISNOTIONOFINVISIBILITYWASSOMETHINGTHATWASONTHEIRMINDSASWELL)TWASAWORDTHATWASUSEDITWASACONCERNTHATTHEYHADITWASAVERYPARTICULARKINDOFCONCERNBECAUSETHESEAREMIDDLECLASSKIDS4HEYCOMEFROMFAMILIESTHATARECIVILSERVANTSORLAWYERSORTEACHERSPROFESSORSBUSINESSPEOPLEANDLIVEINAQUARTEROF$OUALATHATHASMAYBEPEOPLE)TSNOTSMALLITSASIGNIlCANTCHUNKOFTHECITY

7HENTHEYTALKABOUTTHECHANGESTHATTHEYHAVESEENTAKINGPLACEOVERTHEPASTCOUPLEOFYEARSTHEDISCUSSIONSTARTEDONTHELEVELOFSOMETHINGVERYVISIBLE4HATISTHECHANGESINTHEBUILTENVIRONMENTANDTHEWAYINWHICHTHEREWASTHISPOPULARITYOFACERTAINKINDOFTILETHATWASBEINGPUTONTHEHOUSES/LDHOUSESWEREBEINGTORNDOWNANDONTHEFAADESOFTHESE

NEWONESTHATWEREBEINGBUILTWASAPARTICULARKINDOFTILEWHITETILE4HEYSTARTEDTOTALKABOUTTHEWAYINWHICHTHISWASAKINDOFUNEASYTHINGANUNSETTLINGTHINGFORTHEMBECAUSEITHADTHESECONNOTATIONSOFTHECEMETERYTHEMORTUARYOFDEATHTHEKINDOFTHEWHITETHATYOUWOULDPUTONGRAVES

4HEYWOULDTALKABOUTTHEFAADEASSOMEKINDOFDEATH)NMANYOFTHENEWCONSTRUCTIONSPEOPLEWOULDSPENDSOMUCHMONEYPUTTINGTHETILEONTHEFAADETHATTHEYDIDNTHAVEENOUGHMONEYLEFTOVERTOFURNISHTHEHOUSEINSIDE9OUDHAVETHESEBEAUTIFULNICEFAADESBUTINSIDESOMETHINGTHAT

&$"%MPTINESS!-3%MPTINESS3OAGAINSORTOFINTENSIFYINGTHISKINDOFCONNOTATION

OFDEATH4HEYWOULDSEETHEIRNEIGHBOURSBUTTHECONCERNWASh/KAYTHISISTHEBUILTENVIRONMENTITSANICEHOUSEBUTWHOISINSIDEv4HISTHINGABOUTBEINGVISIBLEINTHEBUILTENVIRONMENTWASALSOAKINDOFCONCERNABOUTWITHWHOMDOWELIVE4HESENSEABOUTLIVINGWITHPEOPLEYOUDONTQUITEKNOW

!NDTHENOFCOURSETHENOTIONOFTHELIVINGDEADTHOSEWHOAREABLETOOPERATEINTHECITYWITHOUTBEINGINTERRUPTEDWHOSEOPERATIONSCANNOTBEMADEVISIBLERENDEREDVISIBLE7EDONTKNOWHOWSOMEONESGOTTENTHEIRMONEY!LLOFASUDDENTHEYHAVEALOTOFMONEYORALLOFASUDDENSOMEONELOSESALOTOFMONEY/RALLOFASUDDENPEOPLEMOVEFROMA

HOUSEWITHOUTANYONEKNOWING)NSOMEWAYSTHEIRCONCERNWASh/KAYWEREALLSORTOFMIDDLECLASSIN

THISBOAT7EALLHAVESORTOFNARRATIVESABOUTHOWWEGOTHERE-YMOTHERMYFATHERTHEYWENTTOUNIVERSITYv"UTTHEYWOULDTALKABOUTGOINGTOSHOPATANEWMALLANEWSUPERMARKET4HEYWOULDTALKABOUTTHEANXIETYOFWITHWHOMWOULDYOUBESHOPPINGBECAUSEYOUNEVERKNOWWHOITISTHATTHESEPEOPLEARE3OTHECONCERNWASALWAYSTOMAKETHATWHICHISINVISIBLEVISIBLETOINTERRUPTITTOTRIPITUPTOlNDWAYSOFTRYINGTOSLOWDOWNPOSSIBLENEIGHBORSWHOCOULDOPERATEWITHSUCHSPEEDTHROUGHTHECITYTHATTHEYWOULDNTBEVISIBLE(OWDOYOUMAKETHEMVISIBLE(OWDOYOUTRIPTHEMUP(OWDOYOUSETUPROADBLOCKS

4HEYTHENWENTONTOTALKABOUTWHATPEOPLETHEYKNEWWEREACTUALLYDOINGTOTRYTOTRIPTHEMUP4HESTORIESGETQUITECOMPLICATEDANDQUITEPOLITICALANDINVOLVEOTHERTERRITORIESANDPEOPLEINTHECITYTHATTHEYWOULDNEVERDEALWITH4HENOTIONSOMETIMESOFVISIBILITYANDINVISIBILITYISACONCERNTHATPEOPLETHEMSELVESRAISE)TSAKINDOFLANGUAGETHATTHEYTHEMSELVESBRINGSOITSNOTANANALYTICALTHINGNECESSARILYIMPOSED)TCANBETHATBUT

&$")TSANATURALTHINGTHATCOMESOUTOFTHEREALITYTHATPEOPLEINHABIT)N+INSHASATHESAME4HERELATIONSHIPBETWEENVISIBILITYANDINVISIBILITYISAVERYWEIRDONEINAWAYBECAUSEONTHEONEHANDINORDERTOEXISTSOCIALLYINTHECITYISALLABOUTBEINGASVISIBLEASPOSSIBLE)TSABOUT

APPEARANCE4HATSWHYYOUHAVETHATWHOLEPOPULARURBANCULTUREOF SAPEANDELEGANCEABOUTTHECLOTHESYOUWEAR)TSABOUTKNOWINGHOWTOPUTYOURSELFONSTAGEANDITSTHEONLYWAYTOACQUIRESOCIALWEIGHTANDIMPOSEYOURSELFINPUBLICSPACE!LLOFASUDDENTHEREISTHISPERSONEMERGINGTHISPREACHERPOLITICIANMUSICIANORBUSINESSMANVERYTHEATRICALANDVERYPHYSICALLYPRESENTALTHOUGHYOUNEVERSEEHOWHEGOTTHERE4HEMODESINWHICHVISIBILITYWASACHIEVEDREMAINEDRATHERINVISIBLE

!-34IMELINESS

&$"4IMEISVERYIMPORTANT!-34HECALCULATIONSOFACTINGINATIMELYMATTER&$"4HATSWHYEVERYBODYALSOSEEMSTOBEWAITINGALLOFTHE

TIME)THINK!-3'IVENTHESORTOFBIGMANORBIGWOMANSYNDROMEPARTICULARLY

INAPLACELIKE,AGOSYOUNEEDAPROTECTORYOUNEEDAPATRONYOUNEEDSOMEONEYOUCANHAVERECOURSETOYOUCANAPPEALTOWHOCANARBITRATEWHOCANMAKEADECISIONSOTHATYOUDONTHAVETOh/KAY)KNOWTHEONETHAT)APPEALTOTHAT)REGARDTHAT)OWETHAT)DEPENDONv4HISPERSONHASALOTOFOTHERPEOPLEAROUND7HATHAPPENSIFWEALLSHOWUPATTHESAMETIME(OWDOWEKNOWHOWNOTTOALLSHOWUPATTHESAMETIME

KG/IdXgdlYi]ZheVXZ4!-34OCROWDYES

&$")NTHISONEAREA)LIVEDINWHEN)WASLIVINGIN+HARTOUMPEOPLEFROM$ARFURWERELIVINGWITHPEOPLEFROMTHESOUTHINACOMPLICATEDRELATIONSHIPWITHLOTSOFTENSIONBUTLOTSOFCOMPLEMENTARITIES!STHEAREAWASGROWINGSOWEREDEMANDSFORSPACEANDSERVICES"UTITWASALWAYSINTERESTINGBECAUSETHEHOUSEHOLDSFROM$ARFURWERESAYINGh)MPLEMENT3HARIA7EWANT3HARIAWEWANTTOLIVEINTERMSOF)SLAMICLAW7EWANT

THISTOAPPLYTOOURSELVESv!NDSOTHESEPEOPLEWORKINGINTHEAREALOCAL.'/SACTIVISTSWERE

ALWAYSCONCERNEDTHATINSOMEWAYTHISWOULDCREATEALEGALISTICDIVIDEWITHPEOPLEFROMTHESOUTHWHOWOULDNOTFALLUNDER3HARIALAW4HEPEOPLEFROM$ARFURWERESAYINGh.OYOUDONTHAVETOAPPLYIT"UTWEWANTTOLIVEUNDERIT0LEASEMAKEITAPPLICABLEFORUSWEWANTITv4HEREWASALWAYSTHECONCERNTHATTHISWOULDPOLARIZERELATIONSHIPSMOREANDREALLYINTENSIFYCONmICT

EZg[dgb^c\JgWVc^in

KG/HdVgZi]ZgZeVgi^XjaVg[dgbhd[Zi^fjZiiZVhhdX^ViZYl^i]WZXdb^c\k^h^WaZ4

!-3)AMTHINKINGABOUTTHEWORK)DIDIN,AGOSWHICHWASSOMETIMEAGO)TWASINAPARTICULARNEIGHBORHOODIN,AGOSWHICHWASVERYPECULIARTO,AGOSVERYPARTICULARTO,AGOS4HERETHEQUESTIONSOFVISIBILITYANDINVISIBILITYWERELARGELYABOUTWITNESSING(OWDOYOUTURNYOURSELFINTOARECEIVEROFTHEKINDSOFINFORMATIONTHATMIGHTBEUSEFULTOYOUINORDERTOKNOWHOWTOINSERTYOURSELFINTOASOMEKINDOFEMERGINGDEALORSCENARIO"ECAUSEALLTHATTHISNEIGHBORHOODHADWASITSDEALSTHEDEALSTHATDIDNTTAKEPLACEINSIDEBUTALWAYSOUTSIDE4HEREWASALWAYSTHISKINDOFINCESSANTPROCESSOFVISITINGEACHOTHERSHOWINGUPVISITINGMAKINGONESELFVISIBLETOGOTOASTOREWHEREOTHERPEOPLEARESHOWINGUP"UTTHENASOTHERPEOPLEARESHOWINGUPHOWDOYOUNOTINSISTUPONYOURAGENDA(OWDONTYOUDOMINATETHISSPACETHISSCENEBUTHOWDOYOUBECOMEVISIBLEANDALMOSTDISAPPEARINTHEFACEOFOTHERSWHOAREALSOTHEREINSOMESENSEFORTHESAMEAGENDA"ECAUSETHISWASLARGELYA(AUSANEIGHBORHOODWITHINA9ORUBACITYORA-USLIMPLACE7EST!FRICAN-USLIMPLACEITWASNTTHATTHEREWERENTVISIBLEASSOCIATIONSANDVISIBLERULESANDVISIBLEREPRESENTATIVESOFTHEEMIRANDHISBUSINESSINTERESTS3OMEHOWINORDERTOMAKETHETHINGWORKPEOPLEHADTOPUTTOGETHERNEWCREWSWITHNEWKINDSOFSKILLSWITHDIFFERENTKINDSOFEXPERIENCESANDTRADESTHANINTHEPASTBECAUSEYOURETRYINGTOTAKEONSOMETHINGNEW9OURETRYINGTOCONlGURENEWKINDSOFDEALSNOWYOURETRYINGTOGOTONEWCITIESYOURETRYINGTOBUYNEWCOMMODITIESYOURETRYINGTORELATETOOTHERKINDSOFSYNDICATES

3O)WANTTOPUTTOGETHERANEWCREWBUTHOWDO)DOTHAT"UTALSOHOWDO)NOTENTER)TSCOMPLICATEDBECAUSETHISISASPATIALARENATHAT

KNEWITHADTOSURVIVEINSOMEWAYBECAUSE"ABANDIGAANDTHEMILITARYWANTEDTOSEIZEITBECAUSEITSANINTERLOCKEDANINTERSTITIALZONEBETWEEN,AGOSISLANDAND6ICTORIA)TWASCEDEDBYTHE"RITISHTOTHE(AUSAASAKINDOFSPACEOFOPERATIONSOTHEREAREVERYVISIBLESOLIDARITIESTHATHADTOBEMAINTAINED9OUCANTINCLUDEEVERYONEBUTYOUCANTBESEENEXCLUDINGPEOPLEINPARTICULAR(OWDOYOUCREATETHESENSETHATYOURNEWCREWSAREINSOMESENSESELFSELECTEDTHATYOURENOTTHEONEWHOSEXCLUDING

3OITSJUSTACOMPLICATEDKINDOFELABORATIONOFASOCIALETIQUETTEINAWAYAKINDOFBUSINESSPRACTICETHATHADTOKEEPCHANNELSOFINFORMATIONOPENHADTONOTKEEPSECRETSBUTHADTOHAVEANINFORMATIONALECONOMYWHEREYOUMINIMIZEDCOMPETITION)TWASALLDONETHROUGHTHESEQUOTIDIANPRACTICESOFHAVINGSITESTHATAPPARENTLYDIDNTSELLMUCHOFANYTHINGBUTWEREPLACESOFRECEPTION4HERESAWAYOFMANAGINGANECONOMYOFVISIBILITYANDINVISIBILITYWHERETHETWOHADTOBEBROUGHTTOGETHERINSOMEKINDOFFUNCTIONALCALIBRATIONANDRECALIBRATEDALLOFTHETIME

7ITHINTHELARGERSCOPEOF,AGOSGIVENTHEFACTTHATTHEREAREUSUALLYEIGHTPEOPLETOAROOMALWAYSINVERYDENSEQUARTERSHOWCANYOUKEEPSOMETHINGTOYOURSELF(OWCANYOUKEEPSOMETHINGAWAY)STHEREINANYSENSEPRIVACY0RIVACYDOESNTREALLYEXISTSPATIALLY)THASTOBEACALIBRATIONOFNOTSEEINGWHATYOUSEEANDALSOSEEINGWHATYOUDONTSEEBECAUSEYOUHAVETOBEABLETOSEE

%VENINTHEEVERYDAYCOGNITIONOFTHISKINDOFDENSITYVISIBILITYANDINVISIBILITYAREDAYTODAYMATTERS

&$""UTYOUALSONEEDTOBEINVISIBLEORTOKNOWHOWTODISAPPEARANDREAPPEARATAGOODTIME

"UTBECAUSEPEOPLEFROMTHEWESTWOULDTHENSAYh.OTH

THEPOINT7EWANT3HARIAFORUS7EWANTTOMARKTHEDIFFERENOURNEIGHBORSEVENMOREBECAUSEITWILLALLOWUSTODEALWITHMUCHEASIERWAY7HEN)THENDOALLTHESEOTHERTHINGSITSNOTDOINGITASPARTOFMYZONEOFOPERATIONBUT)MBECOMINGPARZONEOFOPERATION3O)MTHENEXEMPT)DONTHAVETOIMPLICATCANRETAINMYSENSEOFBEINGAGOOD-USLIMBECAUSETHATSMTIONINTHEIRZONEv

)NSOMEWAYSTHEDESIREFORTHELEGALISTICDIVIDEWASNTADESIREOFFCONTACTBUTQUITEONTHECONTRARYTOMAINTAINASENSEOFACERTAINTEGRITY

KG/>ihZZbhi]Vii]ZgZ^hVc^ciZgZhi^c\XdcigVY^Xi^dc]ZgZl^i]aVlh^ci]Zbjc^X^eVa!jgWVceaVcc^c\hZchZ!VcYi]ZhZdi]ZgjcYZghiVcY^c\hd[aVl!l]^Ydcifj^iZiZgg^idg^Va^oZ^ci]ZhVbZlV^cdi]ZgldgYh!cdifj^iZXjii^c\d[[dgodc^c\WZ]Vk^dgVcYgZhig^Xi^c\^iidVeVgi^XjaVghe]ZgZd[deZgVi^dc#>chiZVY!

jc^kZghVa^oVi^dc!WVhZYdci]Vil]^X]^hbdW^aZ!l]^X]XVcWZXVgg^ZYVgdjcY!i]i]ZeZghdc!i]gdj\]i]Z^gVW^a^inidVXiVWZ\dkZgcZYWnVhZid[ ck^h^WaZhigjXijgVi]Zgi]Vck^h^WaZWVgg^Zghd[i]ZlVnh^cl]^X]X^i^ZhVgZcdgbVaanjcYZghiddY

!TRADITIONALDANCERANDCROWDSALUTE*EAN0IERRE"EMBAASHEWALKSTOARALLYFROMTHEAIRPORT+INSHASA*ULY

7/29/2019 Invisible Urbanism

7/7

.%

WVgg^Zghd[cZ^\]Wdg]ddYhdgWVgg^Zghd[VXXZhhdgigVchedgiVi^dc!^c[gVhigjXijgZd[kVg^djh`^cYh!VcYhddc#

&$""UTATTHESAMETIMEDOEXIST!-34HISISTHECLAIMTHATSMADEBYMYFRIEND/USMAN$EMBELEWHO

ISANURBANGEOGRAPHERIN!BIDJAN)FYOUREIN+UMASI;AQUARTEROF!BIDJANLARGELYPOPULATEDBY)VORIANSFROMTHENORTHOFTHECOUNTRY=THEKIDSARESTUCKIN+UMASIFORTHEMOSTPARTBECAUSESURROUNDINGTHEMIFYOUGOTO-ARCORYITSDANGEROUSTERRITORY9OUCOULDBEKILLEDYOUCOULDBEBEATENUP4HESETERRITORIESOFOPERATIONDEPENDONWHEREYOUREFROMYOURRELIGIONYOURREGIONANDYOURPOLITICALAFlLIATION4HETERRITORIALIZATIONISREALLYSTRONG

"UTWHAT$EMBELEDESCRIBESISTHATINSOMEWAYSITSIMPOSSIBLEFORTHISKINDOFSTRICTTERRITORIALIZATIONTOBEMAINTAINED3OMEHOWTHERESASENSEOFBOUNDARIESANDTHEBOUNDARIESAREDIVIDINGLINESBUTALSOWORKSINPROGRESSINSOMEWAYS4HEYBECOMESPACESOFREVISIONTRYINGTOCOMEUPWITHNEWTERMSOFCONNECTION"UTOFCOURSETHISISSOMEWHATINVISIBLEWORK(ECLAIMSTHATATTHESEBOUNDARIESTHERESALOTOFBOUNDARYMAINTENANCEWORKTAKINGPLACE4HEMAINTENANCEISNOTTOKEEPTHEDIVISIONINPLACENECESSARILYBUTTOWORKOUTWHATARETHETERMSTHROUGHWHICHTHEREISINTERCHANGE)TSIMPOSSIBLEFORPEOPLETOSTAYPUTNECESSARILY

7EKNOWTHATTHERESALOTABOUTURBANLIFETHATINCREASINGLYENABLESTHECAPACITYTOSTAYWITHINSEGREGATEDSPACESBUTWEKNOWALSORISKSATROPHYOVERALL)TRISKSTHEKINDOFURBANIZINGTRAJECTORIESTHATANURBANSYSTEMNEEDSINORDERTOBEABLETOFUNCTION7EALSOKNOWTHATTHESEKINDSOFSPACESOFSEGREGATIONAREDYSFUNCTIONALINSOMEWAYS)NSOMEWAYTHEBOUNDARYBECOMESAKINDOFPLACEWHEREITSTRANSGRESSEDNOTJUSTABOUTTRANSGRESSIONBUTABOUTTRYINGTOCOMEUPWITHSOMETHINGTHATYOUDONTNECESSARILYCOMMITYOURSELFTOWHICHISCONTINUOUSLYREVISEDWORKEDOUTALANGUAGEATERRAINOFTRANSACTIONITSELF

$EMBELECLAIMSTHATTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENCONTIGUOUSAREASWITHVERYDIFFERENTHISTORIESOFINHABITATIONWHEREEVERYONEISANENEMYTOEACHOTHERWHENYOULOOKATITASAKINDOFSYSTEMITCANTFUNCTIONJUSTSIMPLYBYBEING4HEREARETHESEPOINTSOFINTERSECTIONATBOUNDARIESBUTYOUCANTMAKETHEMTOOVISIBLEBECAUSEYOUKNOWTHATPEOPLEMIGHTBELOOKINGYOUCOULDBEKILLED4HERESSOMETHINGELSETHATDOESTAKEPLACE

;gdb8dadc^Vaid[lZlZgZidgZijgciddjgdg^\^cVaed^cid[YZeVgijgZVcYi]^c`VWdjii]ZegdWaZbd[i]Zk^h^WaZV\V^c!lZ]VkZidVahdXdc[gdcii]ZhZkVg^djh\adWVaigV_ZXidg^Zhd[ ckZhibZci^c

6[g^XVi]ViVgZVahd cXgZVh c\ank^h^WaZ#

!-34HE#HINESEWILLPROBABLYENDUPPUTTINGINONEBILLIONDOLLARSTO,AGOSANDMUCHOFTHATWILLGOTOTHECULTIVATIONOFAKINDOF#HINESEENTREPT)MNOTSUREIFTHISISSTILLTHECASEBUTATONEPOINTTHISWASTOBETHESITEOF#HINESEPERSONNELOFSERVICESBUSINESSESANDRESIDENTSOFTHOSETHATARERESPONSIBLEFORMANAGING7EST!FRICA

)TSALMOSTLIKEALARGEGATEDCOMMUNITYBUTITSALSOMORETHANJUSTAKINDOFRESIDENTIALFACILITY3OWHATHAPPENS!LWAYSTHETHINGISTHATUNLIKECOLONIALRELATIONSHIPSOFTHEPASTWHERETHEABILITYTOOPERATEWASPREDICATEDONALLOFTHESEOTHERANCILLARYACTIVITIESLIKECIVILIZINGMISSIONSANDDESTRUCTIVE

KG/I]ZY^heaVnd[ZmXZhh^kZedlZg!-39ESBUTTHISISh7ELLLEAVEYOUALONEIFYOULEAVEUSALONEv)TSAKINDOFCAPACITATIONOFAKINDOFPARALLELPLAYOFAQUIDPROQUO9OUALLOWUSTOBRINGOURENGINEERINGTEAMSOURSTAFFOURPERSONNELYOUALLOWUSTOEVACUATEPARTICULARKINDSOFRESOURCESAGAINUSINGOURINFRASTRUCTURETHENWEWILLPAYYOUFORTHERIGHTTOHAVEDONETHAT0ARTOFTHATPAYMENTISONCEAGAININVESTMENTININFRASTRUCTURE4HISISAKINDOFCONNECTIONTHATWILLHAVEREALLYMASSIVEIMPLICATIONS

KG/NZh!i]VihhdbZi]^c\i]Vi>lVciid]ZVgbdgZVWdji!ZheZX^Vaan^ci]Za^\]idjgY^hXjhh^dcVWdjii]ZdeZgVi^dcd[kZgnadl"ZcY8]^cZhZbZgX]VcihdggZiV^aZgh^ceaVXZha^`Z9djVaVVcYhbVaaZgidlchc6[g^XVi]ZlVnh^cl]^X]i]Zn ciZ\gViZi]ZbhZakZh^cidadXVacZildg`h!bVg`Zih!ZXdcdb^Xdlh!VcYhddc#=dlYdndji]^c i]^hbVhh^kZ^c[gVhigjXijgVa^ckZhibZciVcYXVeVX^iVi^dci]ViVg^hZh[gdbi]Vi^hY^[[ZgZci4DgbVnWZ^ihcdiY^[[ZgZci#L]Vi h^i\d^c\idYdidi]Z

h]VeZd[i]ZX indgi]Z[jijgZd[i]ZX in4;dgZmVbeaZ!>bi]^c`^c\d[i]ZlVni]Vi

@]Vgidjb^hWZ^c\igVch[dgbZY!cdi[gdbi]ZLZhiWji[gdb>cY^V![gdb8]^cV!VcYcdi^ci]ZigVY^i^dcVa[dgbhd[igVYZi]ViVgZ]^hidg^X#Ndj]VkZ]VY>cY^VcbZgX]VcihlVcYZg^c\VgdjcY6[g^XV[dgXZcijg^Zh!Xdb^c\^ci]gdj\]i]Z>cY^VcDXZVcigVYZ!VcYh^b^aVgani]Z8]^cZhZVhlZaa#7jii]^h^hhdbZi]^c\cZl#I]^h h8Ve^iVa!l^i]VW^\8!Xdb^c\ c[gdbi]Z:Vhi#I]VihcdihdbjX]Wj^aid[i]ZhZ]jbVccZildg`hWjiWj^aid[hdbZi]^c\bdgZ^c]jbVc!VXgZVi^dcd[Vc^c]jbVceaVi[dgb#>iegdWVWan]Vh\gZViZi]^XVa^bea^XVi^dch[dgi]ZlVni]ViVgX]^iZXijgZeVgi^XjaVgan^chZgih^ihZa[^cidi]ZX^in#

!-39ES4HE-ALAYSIANSFOREXAMPLEWANTEDTOMAKETHISDEALWITH7ADEWHERETHEYWOULDBUILDUNITSOFSOCIALHOUSINGBUTTHEYHADTOBEBUILTWITHINONEYEARANDITHADTOBEDONEUNDERPARTICULARKINDSOFCONDITIONS!NDINSOMEWAYSITWAS)TWASA-ALAYSIANCOMPANYTHATSPECIALIZESINQUICKHOUSINGCONSTRUCTIONFORLOWERENDCONSUMPTIONFROMWHICHTHEYTHINKTHEYCANPROlT)THASANTECEDENTSINAPARTICULARKINDOF-ALAYSIANASPIRATIONWHICHISTHAT-ALAYSIACANEMBODYA

KINDOFPROGRESSIVE)SLAMICCAPITALISMTHATISABLETOTAKECERTAINKINDSOFRISKSYETHASANINTERACTIONWITHOTHERlELDSOFPOSSIBILITY

)TSSTILLAPLAYINGlELD)N#ABO6ERDE)RISHINVESTORSWANTTOBUILDUNITSOFRETIREMENTHOUSINGFOR%UROPEANINVESTMENT)NSOMEWAYSTHEREISTHISSENSETHATTHEREISNOPLACETHATCANTBEINHABITEDTHEREISNOPLACETHATCANTBEPOTENTIALLYOCCUPIEDTHEREISNOPLACETHATISINSOMEWAYSOFFLIMITS"ECAUSEYOUSTILLHAVETHESEKINDSOFUNDERCODEDTERRITORIESTHEYALSOCANBECOMEPLAYGROUNDSFORTHEIDEASANDTHEASPIRATIONSANDOFAVARIETYOFDIFFERENTEXTERNALACTORS

4HE#HINESEJUGGERNAUTISTHEMOSTDOMINANTTHEMOSTVISIBLEKINDOFACTORINTHISBUTTHEREAREOTHERS

KG/>iheZg]VehVeegdeg^ViZidZcY]ZgZl^i]i]^h\ZhijgZidlVgYi]ZhZh^c\jaVgegd_ZXih

i]Vi]VkZ\gZViediZci^Va[dg\ZcZgVi^c\jg"WVc^hbWZndcYi]ZX^in^clVnhi]ViVgZeZg"]VehY^[[ZgZci[gdbi]dhZegd_ZXih[dggZcd"kVi^c\i]ZXVe^iVaX^ini]VilZWZ\Vcl^i]#I]Vc`hkZgnbjX]idWdi]d[ndj[dgndjgi^bZVcYZcZg\n#

!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS6YJAYANTHI2AOWOULDLIKETOTHANK+ANU!GRAWALFORINVITINGHERTOCONCEIVETHISCONVERSATIONAND!BDOU-ALIQ3IMONEAND&ILIP$E"OECKFORMAKINGITPOSSIBLE3PECIALTHANKSTO&ILIP$E"OECKFORHISHOSPITALITYIN"RUSSELSANDTO*ESSE7ILLARDFORASSISTANCEWITHTHETRANSCRIPTIONOFTHEENTIRECONVERSATION

9V`Vg!@]Vgidjb!VcY@^c