Introduction to Patents and Patent...

44
Introduction to Patents and Patent Searching Susan Shepherd Science & Engineering Library

Transcript of Introduction to Patents and Patent...

Page 1: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Introduction to Patents and PatentSearching

Susan ShepherdScience & Engineering Library

Page 2: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’
Page 3: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Patent Resources Guidehttp://libguides.ucsd.edu/patents

Page 4: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Today’s Workshop

What’s a patent?US Patents• Searching the USPTO Database

International patents• Searching esp@cenet

Other patent resources

Page 5: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

U.S. Constitution, Article 1, Section 8

“The Congress shall have thepower to promote the progress of

science and useful arts by securingfor limited times to authors and

inventors the exclusive right to theirrespective writings and

discoveries.”

Page 6: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

What is a Patent?

An official document, issued by the U.S.Patent & Trademark Office, grantingproperty rights to the inventor or assignee(owner of the patent).Term is generally 20 years from the date ofapplication in the U.S., if maintenance feesare paid.Effective only in the U.S., territories andpossessions.

Page 7: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Rights Granted by Patents

What is granted is NOT the right to make,use, offer for sale, sell or import, but theright to EXCLUDE OTHERS from making,using, offering for sale, selling or importingthe invention.Patents may be licensed by the assignee toanother party.

Page 8: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Types of Patents

Utility Patents - 20 years from filing

• Chemical• Mechanical• Electrical

Design Patents – 14 years from issue

Plant Patents– 20 years from filing

Page 9: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Design Patent Example

Page 10: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Plant Patent Example

Page 11: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Utility Patent Example

Page 12: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

What Can Be Patented?

Any new and useful process, machine,manufacture, or composition of matter, or

any new and useful improvement, subject tothe conditions and requirements of the law.

Page 13: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Requirement of “Useful”

The invention has a useful purposeThe invention will operate to performthe useful purpose, i.e. it works.

Page 14: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Requirement of “New”

The invention has not been disclosedbefore (novelty).• In the US, there is a one-year grace period after

public disclosure.

The invention is non-obvious to aperson having ordinary skill in the art.

Page 15: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Conception

Reduction to Practice

Invention Report

(Prior Art Search)

Patentability Decision

Draft Patent Application

From Conceptionto Draft Application

Page 16: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

The Patent Application

Description of the inventionOne or more claimsDrawing(s) if necessaryOath or declaration signed by inventorPayment of fee

Page 17: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Provisional Application

Claims not requiredLess expensive to fileIs not examinedEstablishes early filing dateAutomatically abandoned after 1 year,unless “regular” application filed

Page 18: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

From Application Filingto Granted Patent or Abandonment

File in USPTO

Assign to Examiner

Examiner’s Prior Art Search

Examiner’s Action

Applicant’s Response

Examiner’s Allowance

US Patent Issues

Abandonment

Page 19: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Minimum Fees Over Patent LifeRegular fee Small entity fee

Filing 300 150

Search 500 250

Examination 200 100

Issue 1400 700

Maintenance

3.5 yrs 900 450

7.5 yrs 2300 1150

11.5 yrs 3800 1900

Total 9400 4700

These fees are minimal compared to the attorney costs toprepare and prosecute the patent.

Page 20: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Sometimes Confused - Trademarks

A trademark is a word, phrase, symbol ordesign, or a combination of words, phrases,symbols or designs, that identifies anddistinguishes the source of the goods of oneparty from those of others.Searchable at USPTO websitehttp://www.uspto.gov/main/trademarks.htm

Page 21: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Sometimes Confused - Copyright

A copyright protects authors of originalartistic, musical or literary work, bothpublished and unpublished.http://www.copyright.gov/

©

Page 22: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Why Search for Patents?

New and innovative technologiesCompetitive intelligenceBackground on technologies not covered inthe journal literaturePatentabilityFreedom to operate

Studies have shown that up to 80% of all patents containnew information not published elsewhere.

Page 23: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Typical Patent Questions

Inventors looking for patentability• “I have an idea for an invention that I want to patent.”

Technology search• “I want to know what’s happening in the area of ____.”

Freedom to operate search• “I want to be sure my new product or process does not

infringe someone’s patent.”

Page 24: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’
Page 25: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

ClaimsClaims are carefully worded statements thatstake out the boundaries of the invention

Page 26: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Disclaimer

You can ‘search patents’ on the internet, butyou can’t ‘do a patent search.’To ‘do a patent search’ is to legallydetermine the “patentability” of aninvention.Internet searches can’t go back far enoughto examine all public-domain ‘prior art.’

Page 27: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Disclaimer (cont.)

Prior art can be found in books, articles,conference papers, commercialpublications, advertisements as well aspatents.Professionally done patent searchestypically include a variety of databasesusing carefully constructed booleanstrategies and can cost $2000-5000.

Page 28: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Internet Patent Searching

To be comprehensive, you must search byU.S. Patent Classification.Keyword searching can lead you into theappropriate classification code(s).

Page 29: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Patent Title:“Generally spherical object with floppy filaments to

promote sure capture” (1988)

Page 30: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

USPTO Web Patent Database

http://www.uspto.gov/patft/index.htmlFind it from S&E websitehttp://scilib.ucsd.edu• Online Resources by Type

• PatentsIn order to view images of patent pages, youmust download the AlternaTiff plug-in fromhttp://www.alternatiff.com

Page 31: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Free Patent Printing

www.pat2pdf.orgConverts US patents to PDFCan print or save full document

Page 32: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Google Patents

www.google.com/patentsOver 7 million patentsFrom USPTO collectionUses Google search technologyBeware spelling errors, faulty OCR

Page 33: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Try It Out

Find patents for MP3 players assigned toApple Computer

• Google Patents:http://google.com/patents

Page 34: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

International Patents

There are no “world patents”Application must be filed in each countryPatenting cooperation treaties havesimplified the process

Page 35: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

World Intellectual PropertyOrganization (WIPO)

Headquartered in Geneva, SwitzerlandAgency of the United NationsAdministers patenting under the PatentCooperation Treaty (PCT)182 member countrieshttp://www.wipo.int/members/en/Searchable databasehttp://www.wipo.int/ipdl/en/

Page 36: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

European Patent Office (EPO)

http://www.european-patent-office.orgGrants European patents for contractingcountries to the European PatentConvention (EPC) – currently 31 members• http://www.european-patent-

office.org/epo/members.htm

Page 37: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’
Page 38: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

esp@cenet

http://www.ep.espacenet.comFree web patent database from EPOMore than 50 million patent documentsOver 70 countries and regionsMay be published in German, French,Japanese, or English

Page 39: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Other Patent Resourceshttp://invent.ucsd.edu

UCSD Technology Transfer and Intellectual PropertyServices Website (TechTips)

Downloadable Invention and Technology Disclosure Form

Page 40: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Other Patent Resourceshttp://www.vonliebig.ucsd.edu/

UCSD Von Liebig Center

Advisory services and seed funding toadvance commercialization of discoveries

Page 41: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Patent Resources Guidehttp://libguides.ucsd.edu/patents

Page 42: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’
Page 43: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Sources Used in this Presentation

Patent Searching Basics – CaseLearnshttp://library.case.edu/ksl/research/subjects/pa

tents/Patents%20-%20CaseLearns.pdfBrian GrayEngineering LibrarianCase Western Reserve [email protected]

Patents: What You Need to Know aboutIntellectual Property in 30 Minutes orLess

Penny Coppernoll-BlachReference LibrarianBiomedical LibraryUniversity of California, San [email protected]

Research US Patents on the Webhttp://library.ucf.edu/GovDocs/PatentsTrademarks/

Research.aspPeter Spyers-DuranUniversity of CentralFlorida

Searching US Patents and Trademarks on theInternet - University of Utah

http://www.lib.utah.edu/govdoc/pto/PTDL4.htmDave MorrisonDocuments and Patent LibrarianDocuments and Microforms Division, Marriott

LibraryUniversity of [email protected]

Page 44: Introduction to Patents and Patent Searchingbeweb.ucsd.edu/.../senior-design/courses/B/2009/BE187B_Slides_Pat… · you can’t ‘do a patent search.’ To ‘do a patent search’

Sources Used in this Presentation(continued)

Gordon, Thomas T. PatentFundamentals for Scientistsand Engineers. Boca Raton:Lewis Publishers, 2000. CallNumber: S&E Stacks T339.G67 2000

Grubb, Philip W. Patents forChemicals, Pharmaceuticalsand Biotechnology :Fundamentals of Global Law,Practice and Strategy. Oxford ;New York: Oxford UniversityPress, 2004. Call Number:S&E Stacks T 211.G76 2004

Wherry, Timothy Lee. Patent Searchingfor Librarians and Inventors.Chicago: American LibraryAssociation, 1995. Call Number:S&E Stacks T 210.W44 1995

Susan Shepherd

Head, Reference, Instruction & Outreach

Science & Engineering Library

University of California, San Diego

[email protected]

http://scilib.ucsd.edu