INTERVIEW FINDINGS BY CATEGORY: EXPERIENCES WITH · PDF fileINTERVIEW FINDINGS BY CATEGORY:...
6
INTERVIEW FINDINGS BY CATEGORY: EXPERIENCES WITH NARCAN Page 57 Interview Findings by Category: Experiences with Narcan OPIOID CONSUMERS Interviewees were asked about their access to Narcan, as well as experiences being administered and/or administering the opioid antagonist. Emergent themes all appear to be barriers to access and use of Narcan. Figure 10. Perceived Barriers to Accessing Narcan Among Opioid Consumers
Transcript of INTERVIEW FINDINGS BY CATEGORY: EXPERIENCES WITH · PDF fileINTERVIEW FINDINGS BY CATEGORY:...
INTERVIEWFINDINGSBYCATEGORY:EXPERIENCESWITHNARCAN
Page57
InterviewFindingsbyCategory:ExperienceswithNarcan
OPIOIDCONSUMERSIntervieweeswereaskedabouttheiraccesstoNarcan,aswellasexperiencesbeingadministeredand/oradministeringtheopioidantagonist.EmergentthemesallappeartobebarrierstoaccessanduseofNarcan.
Figure10.PerceivedBarrierstoAccessingNarcanAmongOpioidConsumers
INTERVIEWFINDINGSBYCATEGORY:EXPERIENCESWITHNARCAN
Page58
Lackofknowledgeand/orawarenesswasacommondenominatorformanyoftheinterviewees’commentsonthesubjectofaccesstoNarcan:
“Iwouldn’tevenknow[wheretofindit]”
“Youalwaysseeflyersaboutitbutyouhavetotraveltogetit”
“Yeah,whenIcametoGroupstheyaskedmeifIwantedtogetaprescriptionforNarcanbutIsaidnobecauseIknowIamnotgoingtooverdose…IwassogratefulforSuboxoneandI’mnotgoingtooverdose.Plus,Inevershotupmypills”
“Idon’tknowifpeopleactivelygoandtryandacquireit…I’mnotsureifyouneedaprescription…I’venevertriedtoacquireitmyself”
TheseconsumerquotesarerepresentativeofapervasivelackofknowledgeabouthowtoaccessNarcan,lackofknowledgeaboutindicationsfortheuseofNarcan,lackofawarenessoflawsonwidespreadstandingorders(openscript)atpharmaciesacrossNewHampshire,andlackofinterest.
Levelsofknowledgeaboutaccessvariedbuttherewasapervasivesensethatconsumersdon’twantorneedit.Perceivedcostscombinedwithafalsesenseofsecurityposeasignificantbarriertoaccessformany:“‘Nobodythinksthey’regonnaOD…Nobodyisgonnaspend$50bucks,especiallyiftheyhaveaproblem[opioidaddiction].’‘Itdoesn’tseemlikethey’reaffordableunlessyougetitforfreefromanoutreachcenter.It’snothighonyourprioritytogotoaplacelikethatwhenyougotstuffthatyougottodo.Thatandyoudon’twantsomeoneNarcanningyouwhenyoudon’tthinkthatyouneeditbecauseitfeelsreallyhorrible.’”
Thislattersentimentintroducesanotheroften-citedbarrier,namelythatthephysicalsideeffects(e.g.withdrawal)fromNarcanthatsomehaveexperienced,andthatallseeminglyhaveheardabout,aretobeavoidedatallcosts.WhenaskedaboutsideeffectsofNarcanadministration,itbecameclearthatconsumersunderstandhowNarcanworks–itactsquicklytodisplacetheopioidsfromtheopioidreceptorsinthebrainandinsodoing,precipitatesnearimmediatewithdrawalsymptoms.
Itiswellknownthatpeopledependentonopioidswillcontinuetouseopioidsdespiteseverenegativeconsequencessimplytoavoidbecomingsickorgoingintofullopioidwithdrawal.Thus,itisunsurprisingthatconsumersdescribethephysicalsideeffectsofbeingadministeredNarcaninthefollowinghighlydescriptive,vividways:“[Youfeel]fuckingmiserableandhatewhoeverdiditto[you]”and“TheonlyeffectsI’vewitnessedafteryouuseitisthepersonisinstantly
INTERVIEWFINDINGSBYCATEGORY:EXPERIENCESWITHNARCAN
Page59
sick.Thethingisoncethey’reininstantwithdrawals,thefirstthingthey’regoingtodowhentheyleavethehospitalisthey’regoingtogooutandfindsomeherointomakethemselvesfeelbetter…I’vealwaystoldpeoplethatifIwasOD’ing,tryandgetmetocomebackontheirownandworstcaseuseNarcanbutIdon’twantitusedonme.”ThisquotesummedupwhyNarcanisaversivetomany–itcausesimmediatewithdrawal.Therefore,itiscommonforconsumerswhohavebeenadministeredNarcantouseopioidswithinhoursoftheirreversals.“It’ssadbutit’swhattheydo.”Nootherphysicalsideeffectswerenotedbyconsumers.
PerceivedstigmaisanotherbarriertoaccessingNarcan.Oneconsumersaidthathe“hear[s]thatnowinNHtheyaretryingtohaveanopenprescriptionatthepharmacyandIhaveaproblemwiththepharmacything…alotofusersdon’ttrustthepharmacies…itslegalbutmoststoresarenotparticipating.”AnotherconsumerthoughtthatyoucangotothepolicestationorthefirestationorahospitaltogetNarcanif“youwantitfortherightreason,”buthedoesn’t“thinktheywouldgiveittoastrung-outaddictwhoisjustgonnaoverdoseandtryandbringhimselfback.”AndyetanotherconsumeracknowledgesthathestolehisNarcankitsohedoesn’t“knowhownormalpeoplegetthisshit.”Thesensethatpharmaciesarechoosingnottoparticipateintheopenprescriptionmovement,thatonemightnotbeworthyofakit,orthatconsumersarenot“normal”allpointtotheperceivedstigmatizationofthispopulationandhowitimpactsaccesstoandtheuseofNarcan.
Fearofthepolice,aresultofalackofconfidenceinthegoodfaithapplicationoftheGoodSamaritanlaw,isanotheridentifiedobstacle.Forexample,oneyoungmansaid,“Ithinkpeoplesayitandit’slikenobodybelievesit[GoodSamaritanLaw].Somebodysays,‘Ohyoucancall,youwon’tgetintrouble’andpeoplearelike‘Dudeyou’refuckingdumb.I’mnotcalling’.’’
OnefinaldeterrenttowidespreadaccessanduseofNarcanistheragethatsomepeoplesuggestconsumersexpresstothefirstrespondersand/orfriendswhoadministerNarcanafteranoverdose.Exemplifyingthissentiment,oneconsumersaid,“Youarepissed.PrettymucheverytimeI’veoverdosed,andeverybodythatIknowhasoverdosed,hassaid,‘Iwasn’toverdosing.Iwasjustreallyhigh,andyouruinedit.’Butthentheparamedic’stheresaying,‘No,no,youweredead.’”Notably,justunderhalfofthisconsumersubsamplehadpersonalexperiencewithNarcan,thoughmanyofthoseinthiscategoryhavewitnesseditsadministrationonfriendsorfamily.
FIRSTRESPONDERSANDEMERGENCYDEPARTMENTPERSONNELR/EDpersonnelwereaskedseveralquestionsaboutNarcan.Therewasaprevalentsenseofamazementamongrespondersatthelife-savingeffectsofNarcan(e.g.,“Ifthere’sanymiracledrugoutthereforthattypeincident,that’sit”(Fire).)However,manyR/EDpersonnelwere
INTERVIEWFINDINGSBYCATEGORY:EXPERIENCESWITHNARCAN
Page60
quicktonotethatNarcan“‘isashort-termfix,unfortunately,foraverylong-termproblem”(EMS);“Ithinkit’sanecessaryevil.Imean,plainandsimple,itsaveslivesandIthinknobodywantstoseeanotherhumanbeingdie”(EMS).
SomerespondersfearedthatthepublichasmisconceptionsaboutNarcangiventhatpatientsaresometimesbeyondthepointofrevival:“IcoulddumpagallonofNarcanintothemandit’snotgoingtowakethemup,andhavethefamilywonderwhy.Narcanhasbeenbilledasamiracledrugbypoliticians,andbureaucrats,andsocalledexperts.Whenthetimingisright,itisamiracledrug.However,itdoesn’thelpeverybody”(EMS).OneresponderwantedtobesurethatthosewhoareunfamiliarwithNarcanunderstandthatpeoplewhoareoverdosingareunabletogiveNarcantothemselves.AnotherexplainedthatthereversaleffectsofNarcancanwearoffquicklyandsendthepatientbackintoanoverdose.
R/EDpersonnelalsohadmixedviewpointsaboutwhetheradministeringNarcanintravenouslyorintranasallyissaferandmoreeffective.Whilesomebelievethatintravenousadministrationallowsproviderstobe“alotmorenuancedinhowweuseNarcan,sowe’velearnedtotailoritto,really,justtheirrespiratorydriveasopposedtohavingthembebothwideawakesittingupright,staringatyouinwithdrawal”(ED),othersbelievethatintranasaladministrationissaferforbothpatientsandproviders,aslongasproviderswaitasufficientamountoftimeafteradministeringeachdose.
“WhenyougaveanIV,ifyouadministeredittoofast,peoplewouldwakeupinstantly.Theywouldbeincrediblyviolentandangry,sonowyouhaveanangry,combativepatientandacontaminatedsharpneedleinthebackofaverysmallambulance,andthatposedahugeriskforus.Now,beingabletogiveitintranasallyismuchsaferforadministeringit.Theproblemwithitisthatitdefinitelytakesmuchlongertobeabsorbedintothebloodstream,andEMSprofessionalsandhealthcareproviderstendtonotbethatpatient.Whatusedtotake30seconds,maybe60secondstowork,sometimescantake5,maybeevenafull10minutebeforeitfullywakesthepatientup.Peoplebecomeimpatient,sotheygivemoreofit.Nextthingyouknow,youwakethepatientuptooquicklyandthey’recombativeandtheywannatearyourheadoff.ButintranasallyisamuchsaferrouteforadministeringNarcan.”(EMS)
INTERVIEWFINDINGSBYCATEGORY:EXPERIENCESWITHNARCAN
Page61
ThevastmajorityofR/EDpersonnelreportednounanticipatedsideeffectscausedbyNarcan.TherewasoneaccountofaNarcanadministrationresultinginanosebleedduetoimproperadministrationbyalaypersonwhoforgottoattachtheatomizer.Additionally,oneEDprovidercitedpulmonaryedemaasaknownsideeffectbutexplaineditiscausedbyadministeringtoomuchNarcanorgivingittooquickly.R/EDpersonnelhadneverheardofbraindamageasaresultofNarcanadministrationandconjecturedthatanyreportsofbraindamage“couldhavebeencausedbylackofoxygentothebrainpriortotheadministration[ofNarcan]”(Fire).WhilewithdrawalsymptomsareapotentiallyanticipatedeffectofNarcan,R/EDpersonnelexplainedthatthesesymptomscanbeattenuatedthroughcarefuladministration:“Ifyougiveitniceandslow,youcangettheexacteffectyouwant,butyoujustneedtobemindfulaboutthat”(Fire).
R/EDpersonnelreportedthattheavailabilityofNarcanhasincreasedincommunities:“It’ssoeasy,there’ssomuchNarcanoutthere.Everybody’sgivingitout”(Fire).OneEMSproviderdiscussedaprograminwhichheandhisteam“actuallydistributeNarcanouttothepreviousoverdosesthatwehaveintown”(EMS).However,R/EDpersonnelhadconflictingopinionsregardingwhetherthepublicshouldhaveaccesstoNarcan.Somebelievedthatpublicavailabilityisbeneficial:“Itcanappropriatelybeinplaceswhereaddictionoverdosesareknowntoincur.Thatincludesprivatehomes,orpartyareas”(ED).OthersthoughtthatmakingNarcanavailabletolaypeopleiscounterproductive:“Makingitmorewidelyavailable,they’reonlylivingtouseanotherday,asopposedtochangingthelifestyleorthebehaviorsthatareleadingthemtouse.Ithinkthatactuallywillatsomepointbecontributingtotheproblemandnotmakingitbetter”(Fire).
TherewasgreaterconsensusthatrespondersshouldcarryNarcan.“Inthemedicalsettingitisanessentialdrug.Ilikeitinthehandsofallfirstresponders,includingpolice,andfire,andEMS”(ED).However,oneresponderexpressedconcernsthatsomemedicalprofessionalsmayneedmoreeducationtoknowthatadministeringNarcanisonlyappropriateforopioidoverdosesandnotforothertypesofoverdoses.
SeveralpotentialunintendednegativeconsequenceswerenotedasaresultofNarcan’savailabilityincommunities.AfewR/EDpersonnelhadheardof“Narcparties”or“Lazarusparties,”inwhichpeopleuseNarcanwithasoberfriendsothattheycanusemoreorahigherpotencyofanopioid.OthersbelievedthatconsumerswhohavebeengivenNarcanbyabystandermaynotseekprofessionaltreatment.ManyR/EDpersonnelalsoworriedthatNarcanmaygiveafalsesenseof
“IthinkthebadsideisIdon’tthinkwe’recalledasmuchnow.Ithinkthey’rejustusingtheNarcanandthenjustsaying,‘Wedon’twantthepoliceortheEMSthere.’”(EMS)
INTERVIEWFINDINGSBYCATEGORY:EXPERIENCESWITHNARCAN
Page62
security:“IammindfulthatwhenapatientwhohasopiateaddictiondisorderpossessesNarcan,theysometimesmakeacognitivemistakethinking,‘Well,Iwillbeabletosurviveevenanoverdose,soIcanreallypushmyhighrighttotheedge.’Thatisfoolishthinkingcausedbytheiraddiction,anditcankillthem”(ED).OnerespondernotedthereissomuchNarcanavailablethat“wedon’tevenknowtheextentoftheoverdosesanymore”(Fire).AnotherresponderspeculatedthatNarcanisover-utilized,claimingthat“peoplehearoverdose,andthefirstthingtheywanttodoisgiveNarcan”(Fire).
SUMMARYOverwhelmingly,opioidconsumersreportsignificantbarrierstoaccessingandusingNarcaninNewHampshire,includinghighcosts,fearofpolice,fearofstigmatization,lackofknowledge(e.g.,access,indicationsandlaws),andfearofsideeffects.Sideeffects,notablywithdrawalandangerassociatedwithwithdrawal,wereadeterrentfromwantingNarcanadministeredduringanoverdose.
Conversely,R/EDpersonnelstateNarcaniswidelyavailableandalifesavingmedication.Althoughtherearemixedbeliefsonwhetheritshouldbeavailabletothepublic,therewasconsensusthatrespondersshouldcarryit.R/EDpersonnelalsosharedmixedrecommendationsonwhetheritissaferormoreeffectiveadministeredintravenouslyorintranasally,butagreedthatsideeffectsbeyondangerassociatedwithwithdrawalhavenotbeenobserved.
