Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron...

112
Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies Dr. Ron Martinez

Transcript of Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron...

Page 1: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies

Dr. Ron Martinez

Page 2: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Barriers to international publication of research

● Language (especially English)

● Lack of guidance around academic publishing practices

● Lack of writing guidance/support (even in Portuguese)

● Money

Dr. Ron Martinez

Page 3: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Sullivan, E. J. (2002). Top 10 reasons a manuscript is rejected. Journal of

Professional Nursing, 18(1), 1-2.

Page 4: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Two recent strategies at UFPR

● Centro de Assessoria de Publicação Acadêmica (CAPA)● Disciplina Transversal “Academic Writing in English”● Both: R$0,00 starting budget

Page 5: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

● Created in 2016 (Ron Martinez)● Initial team: 3 student volunteers, 1

professor● Mission: Provide UFPR space to

support writing● No start-up budget asked for or

required of university

Page 6: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

CAPA today

Page 7: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

CAPA today

Page 8: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 9: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 10: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 11: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 12: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 13: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 14: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 15: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 16: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 17: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 18: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 19: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 20: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 21: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 22: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 23: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 24: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 25: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 26: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 27: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 28: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 29: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Why create a “CAPA”?

Page 30: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

What many Brazilian universities do:

Page 31: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

How much does it cost to outsource article translation?

Page 32: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

How much does it cost to outsource article translation?

Page 33: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 34: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 35: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 36: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 37: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 38: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 39: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 40: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 41: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 42: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 43: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 44: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 45: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 46: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 47: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 48: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 49: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 50: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 51: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 52: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 53: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 54: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 55: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 56: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 57: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 58: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 59: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 60: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 61: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 62: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 63: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 64: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 65: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual support

Page 66: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Conventional model: individual supportPARTNER

MOU

Page 67: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 68: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal support

Page 69: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal supportPARTNER

MOU

Page 70: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal supportPARTNER

MOU

FULBRIGHTETA

PROGRAM

Page 71: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal supportPARTNER

MOU

FULBRIGHTETA

PROGRAM

PREPARATION FOR

INTERNATIONAL EVENTS

Page 72: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal supportPARTNER

MOU

FULBRIGHTETA

PROGRAM

PREPARATION FOR

INTERNATIONAL EVENTS

SUPPORT FOR “DISCIPLINA

TRANSVERSAL” (ACADEMIC WRITING)

Page 73: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal supportPARTNER

MOU

FULBRIGHTETA

PROGRAM

PREPARATION FOR

INTERNATIONAL EVENTS

SUPPORT FOR “DISCIPLINA

TRANSVERSAL” (ACADEMIC WRITING)

Page 74: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

How much does it cost to outsource article translation?

Page 75: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

How much does it cost to outsource article translation?

Page 76: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 77: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

How much does it cost to outsource article translation?

Page 78: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

How much does it cost to outsource article translation?

A

Page 79: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

What many Brazilian universities do:

Page 80: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

What many Brazilian universities do:

R$ 250,000 towards 210 articles

Page 81: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

CAPA expected 2019 output:

● 320 articles● Total cost: R$ 180,000● (Oh but so much more…)

Page 82: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Writing center model: communal supportPARTNER

MOU

FULBRIGHTETA

PROGRAM

PREPARATION FOR

INTERNATIONAL EVENTS

SUPPORT FOR “DISCIPLINA

TRANSVERSAL” (ACADEMIC WRITING)

Page 83: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 84: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Disciplina Transversal “Academic Writing in English”

Page 85: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

What is a “disciplina transversal”?

● “...disciplinas formativas que são comuns (transversais) a um conjunto importante de cursos (ex., estatística, metodologia da pesquisa, filosófica da ciência, etc.).”

● “Tradicionalmente, muitas dessas disciplinas são ministradas no seio de cada curso ou programa ao invés de serem ofertadas de forma mais abrangente.”

Page 86: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Pilot: 2017

Page 87: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Pilot: 2017

Page 88: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Pilot: 2017

Page 89: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 90: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)
Page 91: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

2018: In English

Page 92: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

2018: In English

Page 93: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

2018: In English

Page 94: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Last day “Exit Ticket”

Page 95: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Last day “Exit Ticket”

Page 96: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Comments

● “Mais que a escrita em inglês, essa disciplina foi excelente para aprendermos mais sobre a estruturação de artigos.”

Page 97: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Comments

● “Mais que a escrita em inglês, essa disciplina foi excelente para aprendermos mais sobre a estruturação de artigos.”

● “Gostei muito por ser ofertada para diversos cursos, me senti parte de uma comunidade maior que meu universo de rotina.”

Page 98: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Comments

● “Mais que a escrita em inglês, essa disciplina foi excelente para aprendermos mais sobre a estruturação de artigos.”

● “Gostei muito por ser ofertada para diversos cursos, me senti parte de uma comunidade maior que meu universo de rotina.”

● “O que foi apresentado na matéria levarei para a vida toda! São dicas valiosas que talvez levaria anos para aprender (errando).”

Page 99: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Comments

● “Mais que a escrita em inglês, essa disciplina foi excelente para aprendermos mais sobre a estruturação de artigos.”

● “Gostei muito por ser ofertada para diversos cursos, me senti parte de uma comunidade maior que meu universo de rotina.”

● “O que foi apresentado na matéria levarei para a vida toda! São dicas valiosas que talvez levaria anos para aprender (errando).”

● “Deveria transformá--la num núcleo comum obrigatório a todos os programas de pós-graduação. Poderia ser a versão em português obrigatória e a versão em inglês optativa.”

Page 100: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Comments

● “Mais que a escrita em inglês, essa disciplina foi excelente para aprendermos mais sobre a estruturação de artigos.”

● “Gostei muito por ser ofertada para diversos cursos, me senti parte de uma comunidade maior que meu universo de rotina.”

● “O que foi apresentado na matéria levarei para a vida toda! São dicas valiosas que talvez levaria anos para aprender (errando).”

● “Deveria transformá--la num núcleo comum obrigatório a todos os programas de pós-graduação. Poderia ser a versão em português obrigatória e a versão em inglês optativa.”

● “Já tenho uma revista encaminhada para mandar meu artigo, e as dicas finais do professor ajudaram bastante nessa aproximação inicial!”

Page 101: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

JUST 6 MONTHS LATER....

402 responses

Page 102: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

JUST 6 MONTHS LATER....

402 responses

= 84 publications

Page 103: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

More to come...

402 responses

Page 104: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

More to come...

402 responses

= 289 potential publications

Page 105: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

More than “English”

“Meu trabalho ainda não foi publicado, mas foi submetido a uma revista. A disciplina contribuiu como escrita acadêmica de uma forma geral, mais até do que como ‘escrita acadêmica em inglês’.”

Page 106: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Barriers to international publication of research

● Language (especially English)

● Lack of guidance around academic publishing practices

● Lack of writing guidance/support (even in Portuguese)

● Money

Dr. Ron Martinez

Page 107: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Summary and conclusion

Page 108: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Summary and conclusion

● Total annual cost today: < R$ 200,000 each (CAPA and Transversal)

Page 109: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Summary and conclusion

● Total annual cost today: < R$ 200,000 each (CAPA and Transversal)

● Starting budget for both: R$ 0,00.

Page 110: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Summary and conclusion

● Total annual cost today: < R$ 200,000 each (CAPA and Transversal)

● Starting budget for both: R$ 0,00.● International publications since 2017: > 400

Page 111: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Summary and conclusion

● Total annual cost today: < R$ 200,000 each (CAPA and Transversal)

● Starting budget for both: R$ 0,00.● International publications since 2017: > 400● Feeling supported by your university: PRICELESS

Page 112: Internationalization of research: old barriers and new strategies · 2019. 4. 30. · Dr. Ron Martinez. Barriers to international publication of research Language (especially English)

Thank you!

[email protected]

www.drronmartinez.com