International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

download International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

of 25

Transcript of International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    1/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor Porfos

    Fmtormbtfcmbi ^rbno bmn Notorgfmbmts ceTrf`o Nfeeoromtfbis ce Fmsuifm Gonf`fmo

    Gbttlfbs Loihio^cslfbaf Bfzbwb

    Mc. ??2Mcvoghor 842?

    Bsfbm Novoicpgomt Hbma Fmstftuto

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    2/25

    ^lo [crafmk Tbpor sorfos fs b `cmtfmubtfcm ce tlo ecrgoriy mbgon Nfs`ussfcm Tbpor sorfos1tlo mughorfmk ce tlo pbpors `cmtfmuon wftlcut fmtorruptfcm cr `lbmko. BNHFs wcrafmkpbpors roeio`t fmftfbi fnobs cm b tcpf` bmn bro pcston cmifmo ecr nfs`ussfcm. BNHF om`curbkos

    robnors tc pcst tlofr `cggomts cm tlo gbfm pbko ecr ob`l wcrafmk pbpor (kfvom fm tlo`ftbtfcm hoicw). Pcgo wcrafmk pbpors gby novoicp fmtc ctlor ecrgs ce puhif`btfcm.

    Pukkoston ftbtfcm:

    Loihio, G., bmn ^. Bfzbwb. 842?. Fmtormbtfcmbi ^rbno bmn Notorgfmbmts ce Trf`o Nfeeoromtfbisce Fmsuifm Gonf`fmo. BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2. ^cayc: Bsfbm Novoicpgomt Hbma Fmstftuto.Bvbfibhio: lttp://www.bnh.crk/puhif`btfcms/fmtormbtfcmbi-trbno-bmn-notorgfmbmts-prf`o-nfeeoromtfbis-fmsuifm-gonf`fmo/

    Tiobso `cmtb`t tlo butlcrs ecr fmecrgbtfcm bhcut tlfs pbpor.

    Ogbfi:

    Gbttlfbs Loihio:gloihioDbnhf.crk

    ^cslfbaf Bfzbwb:tbfzbwbDbnhf.crk

    Gbttlfbs Loihio fs b rosobr`l eoiicw bt tlo Bsfbm Novoicpgomt Hbma Fmstftuto (BNHF).

    ^cslfbaf Bfzbwb fs b rosobr`l bssc`fbto bt BNHF.

    ^lo vfows oxprosson fm tlfs pbpor bro tlo vfows ce tlo butlcr bmn nc mct mo`ossbrfiy

    roeio`t tlo vfows cr pcif`fos ce BNHF, BNH, fts Hcbrn ce Nfro`tcrs, cr tlo kcvormgomtstloy roprosomt. BNHF ncos mct kubrbmtoo tlo b``urb`y ce tlo nbtb fm`iunon fm tlfs pbporbmn b``opts mc rospcmsfhfifty ecr bmy `cmsoquom`os ce tlofr uso. ^orgfmcicky uson gbymct mo`ossbrfiy ho `cmsfstomt wftl BNH ceef`fbi torgs.

    [crafmk pbpors bro suhjo`t tc ecrgbi rovfsfcm bmn `crro`tfcm hoecro tloy bro efmbifzonbmn `cmsfnoron puhifslon.

    Bsfbm Novoicpgomt Hbma FmstftutoAbsugfkbsoaf Hufinfmk

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    3/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    Bhstrb`t

    Ogpfrf`bi stunfos cm plbrgb`outf`bis prf`fmk b`rcss `cumtrfos lbvo ecumn ovfnom`otlbt prf`os vbry b``crnfmk tc por `bpftb fm`cgo. ^loso stunfos bro typf`biiy hbson cmsurvoy nbtb ercg b suhsot ce `cumtrfos bmn `cvor cmiy cmo yobr. Fm tlfs pbpor, wo stunytlo fmtormbtfcmbi trbno bmn prf`o ce fmsuifm hy usfmk notbfion trbno nbtb ecr 2, F22

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    4/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    @cmtomts

    2. Fmtrcnu`tfcm ............................................................................................................ 0

    8. Hb`akrcumn ............................................................................................................ >

    0. Xoibton Iftorbturo .................................................................................................. 5

    >. Nbtb bmn Nos`rfptfcm .............................................................................................. ;

    >.2 Nbtb .......................................................................................................... ;>.8 Nbtb Nos rfptfcm .......................................................................................

    5. Ostfgbtfcm Xosuits ............................................................................................... 2?

    5.2 @cumtry Efxon Oeeo`t ............................................................................... 2?5.8 @cumtry-Tbfr Efxon Oeeo`ts ...................................................................... 2;

    ;. @cm`iusfcm bmn Nfs`ussfcm .................................................................................. 2

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    5/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    0

    Fmtormbtfcmbi trbno fs vftbi ecr b``oss tc gonf`fmos bmn ctlor gonf`bi to`lmcickfos,gbraoniy sc ecr sgbiior bmn ioss roscur`on cumtrfos. rbno stfguibtos cgpotftfcm,wlf`l fm turm ronu`os prf`os bmn ceeors b wfnor rbmko ce suppifors, fgprcvfmk so`urftybmn pronf`tbhfifty ce suppiy.([LC/[FTC/[^C 8420)

    2. FM^XCN_@^FCM

    Mcm-`cggumf`bhio nfsobsos lbvo ho`cgo b gbjcr puhif` lobitl `cm`orm fm hctlnovoicpon bmn novoicpfmk `cumtrfos. B``crnfmk tlo [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm ([LC)(8420b), mcm-`cggumf`bhio nfsobsos bro rospcmsfhio ecr bigcst twc-tlfrns ce biinobtls. [LC (8420h, 8420`) ostfgbtos tlbt 0>; gfiifcm pocpio wcrinwfno `urromtiysueeor ercg nfbhotos, wftl gcro tlbm ;2 hfiifcm ceoxpomnfturo ecr 8428, cr bhcut 22% ce tctbi lobitl `bro oxpomnfturo ecr bnuits.

    Nfbhotos c``urs oftlor wlom tlo pbm`robs ncos mct prcnu`o omcukl fmsuifm (^ypo 2) crwlom tlo hcny fs umbhio tc prc`oss tlo fmsuifm ft ncos prcnu`o (^ypo 8). Fmsuifm fsmoonon tc rokuibto hiccn sukbr. Nuo tc fts sfgfibrfty tc lugbm fmsuifm, bmfgbi fmsuifmwbs efrst uson tc trobt nfbhotos. Fm tlo 26).Po`cmn, tlo fmsuifm fmnustry `bm ho nos`rfhon bs cifkcpcifstf`, bs tlroo gbmueb`turorsncgfmbto tlo wcrin gbraot. ^lfrn, ercg bm fmtormbtfcmbi o`cmcgf`s porspo`tfvo, tlofmsuifm `bso fs fmsfklteui ho`buso tlo sbgo prcnu`t fs moonon fm bii `cumtrfos brcumntlo wcrin, hut gbmueb`turfmk cmiy tbaos pib`o fm b rostrf`ton mughor ce `cumtrfos hy bsgbii mughor ce prcnu`ors. _mrostrf`ton bmn cpom trbno ce fmsuifm fs tloroecro lfkliyfgpcrtbmt ercg b puhif` lobitl porspo`tfvo. Fm suggbry, fm tlo fmsuifm gbraot, b sgbii

    mughor ce prcnu`ors prcvfno b roibtfvoiy lcgckomocus kccn tc tlo omtfro wcrin. ^lfs`bso fs gobmfmkeui tc stuny ho`buso sfgfibr `cmnftfcms gfklt bppiy tc ctlor gbraots.Ospo`fbiiy fm `ortbfm mf`lo gbraots, gbraot pcwor fs `cm`omtrbton bgcmk b eowprcnu`ors tlbt bro cetom `cm`omtrbton kockrbplf`biiy. ^lo efmnfmks ce cur stuny gfklttloroecro ho ce roiovbm`o ecr ctlor so`tcrs.

    [lomovor b lcgckomocus kccn fs prcvfnon tc nfeeoromt gbraots, tlo efrst quostfcm bmo`cmcgfst bsas `cm`orms tlo nfeeorom`o fm prf`os. Trf`o nfeeorom`os gfklt ho tlo rosuitce gbraot sokgomtbtfcm, `cgpotftfvo prossuro, trbno hbrrfors, cr ctlor eb`tcrs. Amcwfmkwly prf`os nfeeor `bm biicw us tc hottor umnorstbmn tlo nrfvors holfmn prf`os bmnpcssfhiy nosfkm pcif`fos tc hrfmk prf`os ncwm. Fm tlo `bso ce fmsuifm, icwor prf`os wcuintrbmsibto fmtc hottor b``oss tc gonf`fmo bmn icwor `csts ecr lobitl systogs.

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    6/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    >

    [o gobsuron tlo prf`o ce fmsuifm hy usfmk trbno nbtb bmn `bi`uibtfmk umft prf`os ecrob`l `cumtry. ^lo umft prf`o fs sfgpiy tlo prf`o fm _P nciibrs ce cmo qubmtfty umft(gcstiy 2 afickrbg). _mft prf`os bro b aoy fmkronfomt ce ogpfrf`bi rosobr`l fmfmtormbtfcmbi o`cmcgf`s. Ecr oxbgpio, tloy bro uson tc `cgputo trbno prf`o fmnoxos(Hrcnb bmn [ofmstofm 8445) bmn torgs ce trbno, cr tc fnomtfey `cumtrfos spo`fbifzbtfcmsbicmk b ibnnor ce vortf`biiy nfeeoromtfbton vbrfotfos (P`lctt 844

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    7/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    ?

    Efkuro 2: Nobtls `buson hy Nfbhotos Goiiftus (8444, 842?, 8404)

    (444)

    Pcur`o: [LC Lobitl Ptbtfstf`s (8420).

    Efkuro 8 slcws tlo nobtls por 244,444 pocpio `buson hy nfbhotos goiiftus. ^lolfklost mughor ce nobtls wbs ro`crnon fm tlo Bgorf`bs fm 8444, wftl Berf`b bmnPcutlobst Bsfb `cgfmk fm so`cmn bmn tlfrn pib`o, rospo`tfvoiy. [LC ostfgbtos tlbt fm842? bmn 8404 tlo rokfcm wftl tlo lfklost mughor wfii rogbfm tlo Bgorf`bs, bmnPcutlobst Bsfb wfii ho`cgo tlo rokfcm wftl tlo so`cmn-ibrkost roibtfvo mughor ce

    nobtls `buson hy nfbhotos goiiftus.Efkuro 8: Nobtls por 244,444 Tocpio @buson hy Nfbhotos Goiif tus , hy Xokfcm

    Pcur`o: [LC Lobitl Ptbtfstf`s (8420).

    4 844 >44 544 4 ?4Nobtls

    [crin

    [ostorm Tb`fef`

    Pcutlobst Bsfb

    Ourcpo

    Obstorm Gonftorrbmobm

    Bgorf`bs

    Berf`b

    8404842?8444

    8404842?8444

    8404842?8444

    8404842?8444

    8404842?8444

    8404842?8444

    8404842?8444

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    8/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    5

    ^lo mughor ce nobtls tlbt bro nfro`tiy ifmaon tc nfbhotos goiiftus umnorostfgbtos tlolobitl prchiogs `buson hy tlo nfsobso. Ft fs woii amcwm tlbt cvor tfgo nfbhotosgoiiftus cetom nbgbkos tlo lobrt, hiccn vossois, oyos, afnmoys, bmn morvos, tlorohyfm`robsfmk tlo rfsa ce lobrt nfsobso bmn strcao. Ft lbs bisc hoom fnomtfefon bs tloiobnfmk `buso ce rombi ebfiuro fm gbmy novoicpon bmn novoicpfmk `cumtrfos. ^lo hurnomce tlo nfsobso cm fmnfvfnubis lobitl bmn cm lobitl systogs fs tloroecro suhstbmtfvoiylfklor tlbm tlo gcrtbifty stbtfstf`s fmnf`bto.

    Nfbhotos fs bm fm`urbhio, `lrcmf` `cmnftfcm, bmn pbtfomts bro typf`biiy trobton cvorsovorbi no`bnos, wlf`l `busos lfkl `csts ecr pbtfomts bmn lobitl systogs. [LCostfgbtos tlbt pocpio sueeorfmk ercg nfbhotos roqufro bt iobst twc tc tlroo tfgos tlolobitl `bro roscur`os `cgpbron tc pocpio wftlcut tlo nfsobso, b``cumtfmk ecr up tc2?% ce mbtfcmbi lobitl `bro hunkots ([LC 8420n). ^lo fm`robson lobitl `bro `csts`bm ho `cvoron hy lobitl systogs, hut fm tlo `bso ce woba lobitl `bro systogs tlofmnfvfnubis tlogsoivos moon tc efmbm`o gcst ce tlo bnnftfcmbi lobitl `bro `csts.Nfbhotos bmn fts `cgpif`btfcms tlus lbvo sfkmfef`bmt o`cmcgf` fgpb`ts cm fmnfvfnubis,ebgfifos, lobitl `bro systogs bmn `cumtrfos. Ecr oxbgpio, [LC ostfgbtos tlbt fm tlo

    porfcn 8445842?, tlo TX@ wfii icso $??< hfiifcm fm ecrokcmo mbtfcmbi fm`cgo nuo tclobrt nfsobso, strcao, bmn nfbhotos bicmo ([LC 8420b).

    ^lo rfsfmk provbiom`o ce nfbhotos lbs ion tc b surko fm nruk sbios ecr trobtgomtwcrinwfno. Ft fs ostfgbton tlbt sbios ce fmsuifm wfii fm`robso ercg $28 hfiifcm fm 844< tc$?> hfiifcm fm 8404. Fm tlo `bso ce tlo TX@, ft fs ropcrton tlbt sovorbi `cgpbmfosro`crnon bmmubi fm`robsos ce 84% cvor ro`omt yobrs (Hiccghork 8420). ^cnby, tlroogbjcr plbrgb`outf`bi `cgpbmfos, mbgoiy Mcvc Mcrnfsa, Oif Ifiiy, bmn Pbmcef-Bvomtfs,prcvfno tlo gbjcrfty ce fmsuifm tc wcrin gbraots. Lcwovor, gcro bmn gcro ic`bigbmueb`turors fm cee-pbtomt `cumtrfos lbvo ho`cgo b`tfvo fm tlo gbraot, ospo`fbiiy fmtlo TX@, Fmnfb, bmn tlo Xussfbm Eonorbtfcm.

    Gcst fmsuifm `cgos fm fmjo`tbhio ecrg, oftlor tlrcukl syrfmkos, poms, pugps, cr moonio-eroo novf`os. ^lo wcrin fmsuifm gbraot `cmsfsts gbfmiy ce tlroo prcnu`t `ibssos:ro`cghfmbmt lugbm fmsuifm, bs woii bs ebst-b`tfmk bmn sicw-b`tfmk fmsuifm bmbickuos.^lo ro`cghfmbmt lugbm sokgomt fs krbnubiiy hofmk ropib`on hy fmsuifm bmbickuos.Povorbi s`fomtfef` stunfos lbvo ecumn tlbt tloro fs `urromtiy mc ovfnom`o ce tlosuporfcrfty ce fmsuifm bmbickuos cvor symtlotf` lugbm fmsuifms fm tlo trobtgomt ce bnuitpbtfomts wftl nfbhotos. 2 Fm tlo eciicwfmk, tlo wcrn fmsuifm om`cgpbssos bii tlrooprcnu`t ibssos.

    0. XOIB^ON IF^OXB^_XO

    ^lo lobitl o`cmcgf`s iftorbturo lbs ropobtoniy stunfon wlotlor plbrgb`outf`bi`cgpbmfos bppiy `rcss-mbtfcmbi prf`o nfs`rfgfmbtfcm. ^lo efmnfmks lbvo hoom gfxon.Ecr oxbgpio, Nbmzcm bmn @lbc (8444) slcw tlbt ecr sovom `cumtrfos (@bmbnb,Erbm`o, Korgbmy, Ftbiy, Jbpbm, tlo _A, bmn tlo _P), `rcss-mbtfcmbi prf`os roeio`tfgpif`ft nfeeorom`os fm prcnu`t `lbrb`torfstf`s. Eurtlorgcro, tloy efmn tlbt strf`t prf`orokuibtfcm systogbtf`biiy icwors prf`os ecr cinor gcio`uios bmn kichbiiy nfeeusongcio`uios. Fm b ro`omt stuny, Gcroi ot bi. (8422) `cgpbro bvorbko plbrgb`outf`biprf`os fm 2> gfnnio-fm`cgo `cumtrfos tc tlcso fm tlroo lfkl-fm`cgo `cumtrfos bmn b icw-fm`cgo rokfcm fm wostorm Berf`b. ^lo butlcrs slcw tlbt scgo gfnnio-fm`cgo `cumtrfos

    2Ecr oxbgpio, tlo @bmbnfbm Bkom`y ecr Nruks bmn ^o`lmcickfos fm Lobitl ecumn fm fts 844< `cgpbrfscm

    ce tlo oeeo`ts ce fmsuifm bmbickuos bmn hfcsymtlotf` lugbm fmsuifm, tlbt fmsuifm bmbickuos ebfion tc slcw

    bmy `ifmf`biiy roiovbmt nfeeorom`os, hctl fm torgs ce kiy`ogf` `cmtrci bmn bnvorso rob`tfcm prcefio(Hbmorjoo ot bi. 844;).

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    9/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    ;

    pby gcro ecr plbrgb`outf`bis tlbm lfkl-fm`cgo `cumtrfos1 ecr oxbgpio, prf`os fmsovorbi gfnnio-fm`cgo `cumtrfos ox`oonon tlcso fm tlo _A ecr scgo yobrs ce tlo stunyporfcn.

    Bmctlor strobg ce rosobr`l lbs kbtloron strcmk ogpfrf`bi ovfnom`o ecr prf`o

    nfs`rfgfmbtfcm. P`lut bmn vbm Horkofja (26) `cgo tc b sfgfibr `cm`iusfcm, efmnfmk tlbt prf`onfeeorom`os oxfst b`rcss `cumtrfos1 lcwovor, tlo nfeeorom`os bro rbtlor sgbii.If`ltomhork (8422) efmns ovfnom`o tlbt plbrgb`outf`bi `cgpbmfos `lbrko icwor prf`osfm icw-fm`cgo `cumtrfos tlbm fm novoicpon `cumtrfos. P`lwoftzor bmn @cgbmcr (8422)stuny tlo prf`os ce 04 nruks fm 86 `cumtrfos bmn efmn tlbt gbmy prf`os bro suhstbmtfbiiynfs`cumton fm gfnnio-fm`cgo bmn novoicpfmk `cumtrfos, `cgpbron tc prf`os fmnovoicpon `cumtrfos, bmn nc mct ox`oon icmk-rum gbrkfmbi `csts. ^lo ogpfrf`biiftorbturo fs tlus mct `cm`iusfvo wlotlor prf`o nfs`rfgfmbtfcm tbaos pib`o, hut tlorosoogs tc ho `cmsomsus tlbt por `bpftb fm`cgo fs b notorgfmbmt wlom plbrgb`outf`bi

    `cgpbmfos sot prf`os.

    Fm tlfs stuny, wo uso umft prf`o nbtb tc notorgfmo wlotlor, fm tlo `bso ce fmsuifm, prf`onfs`rfgfmbtfcm fs bppifon cr mct. Lcwovor, cur pbpor kcos cmo stop eurtlor: wo mct cmiyicca bt fm`cgo, hut bisc bt vbrfcus ctlor gbraot `cmnftfcms bs pcssfhio prf`onotorgfmbmts. Hrcbnomfmk tlo oxpibmbtcry s`cpo ce prf`o nfs`rfgfmbtfcm fs tlo aoy`cmtrfhutfcm ce tlfs pbpor. Gcst spo`fef`biiy, wo tost wlotlor gbraot sfzo, `cgpotftfcm,trbno pcif`y, fmstftutfcmbi brrbmkogomt, bmn rokuibtfcm gbttor ecr prf`os. [o bro bhio tcnc sc ho`buso wo stuny b vory mbrrcw prcnu`t tlbt fs prcvfnon hy b sgbii mughor ceprcnu`ors. Cur pbpor fs tloroecro mct cmiy b `cmtrfhutfcm tc tlo lobitl o`cmcgf`siftorbturo, hut bisc tc tlo fmtormbtfcmbi trbno iftorbturo. ^lo trbno gcnois tlbt `cmstftutotlo host eft wftl cur sot-up bro tlcso hbson cm gcmcpcifstf` `cgpotftfcm. Fm tloso

    gcnois, kbfms ercg trbno bro typf`biiy norfvon ercg `lbmkos fm tlo mughor ce bvbfibhiovbrfotfos fm ob`l `cumtry, bs woii bs tlo gbraot sfzo (Arukgbm 26. NB^B BMN NOP@XFT^FCM

    >.2 Nbtb

    Gcst fmtormbtfcmbi trbno nbtb fs ro`crnon b``crnfmk tc tlo Lbrgcmfzon @cggcnftyNos`rfptfcm bmn @cnfmk Pystog (LP), wlf`l `ibssfefos bii trbno eicws fmtc brcumn 5,444prcnu`t krcups, cr suhlobnfmks. ^lo gbjcrfty ce efmfslon plbrgb`outf`bi prcnu`ts `bmho ecumn fm tlo lobnfmks LP 0440 (huia gonf`fmos) cr LP 044> (ncsfefon gonf`fmos).Fmsuifm prcnu`ts bro `cmtbfmon fm twc suhlobnfmks: LP 044002 gonf`bgomts`cmtbfmfmk fmsuifm (mct fm gobsuron ncsos cr put up ecr rotbfi sbio) bmn LP 044>02gonf`bgomts `cmtbfmfmk fmsuifm (put fm pb`afmks ecr rotbfi sbio). Fmtormbtfcmbi trbno cehuia gonf`fmos `cmtbfmfmk fmsuifm fs vory sgbii `cgpbron tc fmtormbtfcmbi trbno ce LP044>02 (ioss tlbm 4.42% fm 8424). Ecr cur stuny, wo wfii tloroecro cmiy tbao fmtcb``cumt trbno eicws bmn tbrfees ecr LP 044>02.

    Fm `cgpbrfscm tc ctlor gonf`fmos fm`iunon fm tlo LP 044> lobnfmk, LP 044>02 `cvors

    b roibtfvoiy sgbii rbmko ce nruks, mbgoiy hfcsymtlotf` ro`cghfmbmts ce lugbm fmsuifm

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    10/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    >4gonf`bgomts `cmtbfmfmk biabicfns cr norfvbtfvos tloroce, nfeeoromt nruks bro iugpontckotlor, bmn ft tloroecro ho`cgos bigcst gobmfmkioss tc `bi`uibto umft prf`os.Lcwovor, wo brkuo tlbt LP 044>02 fs pbrtf`uibriy woii sufton tc wcrafmk wftl umftvbiuos bs tlo plbrgb`outf`bis `cmtbfmon fm tlfs suhlobnfmk bro roibtfvoiy

    lcgckomocus.

    Eurtlorgcro, fm tlo ogpfrf`bi rosobr`l fm fmtormbtfcmbi o`cmcgf`s, umft vbiuos bro`lcsom ecr prf`o ostfgbtos. Ecr oxbgpio, umft vbiuos bro uson tc `cgputo trbno prf`ofmnoxos (Hrcnb bmn [ofmstofm 8445) cr torgs ce trbno, cr tc fnomtfey `cumtrfosspo`fbifzbtfcm bicmk b ibnnor ce vortf`biiy nfeeoromtfbton vbrfotfos (P`lctt 84402 lbvo fm`robson stoopiy, ospo`fbiiy sfm`o 8444.

    8^lfs efkuro bs b tlroslcin fs bpprcxfgbtoiy 24 tfgos ibrkor tlbm tlo sbgpio gobm ce tlo umft prf`o.0lttp://nbtb.wcrinhbma.crk/fmnf`btcr

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    11/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    6

    Efkuro 0: Ovciutfcm ce Uciugos bmn Ubiuos ce LP 044>02, 266?842?

    Pcur`o: _M @CG^XBNO.

    Efkuro > fiiustrbtos tlo `lbmko fm tlo trbno vciugos ce gonf`bgomts `cmtbfmfmk fmsuifmbgcmk Crkbmfsbtfcm ecr O`cmcgf` @c-cporbtfcm bmn Novoicpgomt (CO@N) `cumtrfosbmn mcm-CO@N `cumtrfos, sottfmk tlo vciugo fm 266? bs 244. ^lo moon ecr fmsuifmbppobrs tc ho krcwfmk fm hctl novoicpon `cumtrfos bmn novoicpfmk `cumtrfos. [lorobsCO@N `cumtrfos stbrton tc fgpcrt gu`l gcro ercg 8444 cmwbrns, mcm-CO@N `cumtrfoseciicwon cmiy b eow yobrs ibtor. Ercg 8444 tc 8420, tlo vciugo ce fmsuifm fgpcrton fmvbiuo torgs hy CO@N `cumtrfos krow hy 20.65% bmmubiiy1 fm mcm-CO@N `cumtrfos hy2?.4?%.

    Efkuro >: Ovciutfcm ce Fgpcrts ce LP 044>02

    ($, fmnoxon tc 266?7244)

    CO@N 7 Crkbmfsbtfcm ecr O`cmcgf` @c-cporbtfcm bmn Novoicpgomt.

    Pcur`o: _M @CG^XBNO.

    4

    ?

    24

    2?

    84

    8?

    04

    Uciugo

    266? 8444 844? 8424 8420Vobr

    266?-8420

    ^ctbi vciugo (gfiifcm umfts)

    8

    >

    5

    4

    4

    ?44

    544

    ;44

    .8.8 Gbraot @cgpotft fcm

    Bmctlor fmtorostfmk quostfcm tc bsa fs lcw tlo mughor ce oxpcrtfmk `cumtrfos lbs`lbmkon cvor tlo porfcn. B lfklor mughor wcuin fmnf`bto tlbt `cumtrfos fgpcrt tlofrfmsuifm ercg bm fm`robsfmk mughor ce scur`os, wlf`l `cuin iobn tc gcro `cgpotftfcm

    bmn pctomtfbiiy icwor prf`os.>

    B lfklor mughor ce suppifors gfklt bisc kc lbmn fm lbmnwftl krobtor suppiy so`urfty. Efkuro ? fiiustrbtos tlo mughor ce `cumtrfos ercg wlf`l`cumtrfos fgpcrt fmsuifm1 fm ctlor wcrns, bii trbno roibtfcms ecr LP 044>02. ^lo tctbimughor krow stobnfiy bgcmk hctl CO@N `cumtrfos bmn tlo ctlor `cumtrfos umtfi tloibto 8444s. Pfm`o 8424, wo chsorvo b sifklt no`ifmo.

    Efkuro ?: Ovciutfcm ce tlo Mughor ce Fmtormbtfcmbi ^rbno Xoibtfcms ecr LP 044>02,266?8420

    CO@N 7 Crkbmfsbtfcm ecr O`cmcgf` @c-cporbtfcm bmn Novoicpgomt.

    Pcur`o: _M @CG^XBNO.

    >.8.0 ^lo _mft Trf`o

    Bs oxpibfmon bhcvo, tlo aoy bnvbmtbko ce stunyfmk fmtormbtfcmbi trbno fm LP 044>02 fstlbt wo bro bhio tc `bi`uibto umft prf`os ecr ob`l scur`o1 ecr oxbgpio, cmo `bm `bi`uibtotlo umft prf`o ce 2 ak ce LP 044>02 tlbt @lfio fgpcrts ercg Nomgbra. Fm crnor tc bssoss

    wlotlor novoicpon `cumtry oxpcrtors `lbrko sfgfibr prf`os `cgpbron tc novoicpfmk`cumtry oxpcrtors, wo lbvo `bi`uibton tlo umft prf`o ecr ob`l scur`o `cumtry. Bvorbkfmkbgcmk novoicpon bmn novoicpfmk `cumtrfos, wo chtbfm tlo rosuit nopf`ton fm Efkuro 5.^lo ron bmn hiuo ifmos slcw tlo ovciutfcm ce tlo bvorbko ibmnon umft prf`o ecr LP044>02 `cgfmk ercg novoicpon `cumtrfos bmn novoicpfmk `cumtrfos, rospo`tfvoiy. Ft fsfmtorostfmk tlbt tlo umft prf`o ce fgpcrts `cgfmk ercg novoicpon `cumtrfos lbs hoom`cmstbmtiy bmn sfkmfef`bmtiy lfklor tlbm tlcso crfkfmbtfmk ercg novoicpfmk `cumtrfos.^lo kbp hotwoom tlo twc prf`o gobsuros lbs fm`robson ercg 8440 tc 844< bmn lbscmiy mbrrcwon vory ro`omtiy. ^rbno nbtb bicmo `bmmct rovobi wly tlfs prf`o nfeeorom`o

    >

    Trf`o `cgpotftfcm fm b `cumtry lbs hoom woii rosobr`lon. Ecr oxbgpio, soo [bmk (8445) ecr tlo TX@splbrgb`outf`bi gbraot bmn [fkkfms bmn Gbmoss (844>) ecr tlo _P gbraot.

    4

    844

    >44

    544

    02, 266?8446

    (sfgpio bvorbko)

    CO@N 7 Crkbmfsbtfcm ecr O`cmcgf` @c-cporbtfcm bmn Novoicpgomt.

    Pcur`o: _M @CG^XBNO.

    ?. GO^LCNCICKV

    ?.2 Eb`tcrs Oxpibfmfmk Nfeeoromtfbi Trf`fmk

    Cur rosobr`l chjo`tfvo fs tc fnomtfey tlo gbfm notorgfmbmts ce prf`o nfeeorom`os b`rcss`cumtrfos. [o icca bt tlroo vbrfbtfcms ce fmsuifm prf`os:

    f. umft prf`o, f.o., vbiuo (fm _P nciibrs) nfvfnon hy vciugo (fm ak)1

    ff. umft prf`o nfeeorom`o ercg tlo bvorbko prf`o b`rcss bii `cumtrfos fm ob`lyobr1 bmn

    fff. umft prf`o nfeeorom`o ercg tlo bvorbko prf`o `lbrkon hy bm oxpcrtfmk

    `cumtry fm ob`l yobr.

    ?.2.2 _mft Trf`o

    ^lo umft prf`o fs `bi`uibton bs eciicws:

    () 7

    (2)

    f: fgpcrtfmk `cumtry, a: oxpcrtfmk `cumtry, t: yobr

    .2?

    .8

    .8?

    .0

    .0?

    .>

    Bvorbkoumftprf`o

    266? 8444 844? 8424 8420Vobr

    Ercg mcm-CO@N cumtrfos Ercg CO@N cumtrfos

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    14/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    28

    ?.2.8 _mft Trf`o Nfeeorom`o ercg tlo Bvorbko Trf`o b`rcss Bii @cumtr fos

    Ubrfbtfcms (ff) bmn (fff) bro hbson cm tlo fnob ce sc-`biion roeorom`o prf`fmk.?

    Xoeorom`o prf`fmk gobms tlbt prf`os bro sot hy `cgpbrfmk plbrgb`outf`bi prf`os ecrtlo sbgo prcnu`t b`rcss `cumtrfos. Butlcrftfos fm gbmy `cumtrfos brcumn tlo wcrin

    ([LC bmn LBF 8422) bppiy tlo roeorom`o prf`fmk gotlcn wlom rokuibtfmk tlo prf`o cegonf`fmos. Xosobr`l hy tlo CO@N slcws tlbt vbrfcus gotlcns bro uson, fm`iunfmkbppiyfmk nfeeoromt `cumtry hbsaots (CO@N 844

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    15/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    20

    Eurtlorgcro, fm cur rokrossfcm gcnoi, gbraot stru`turo nfeeorom`o fs `broeuiiy `cmtrciionecr. ^lo gbraot `cgpotftfcm fs gobsuron hy tlo mughor ce ecrofkm `cumtrfos oxpcrtfmktlo nruk tc `cumtry f. [o `cmjo`turo tlbt tlo prosom`o ce gcro suppifors lofkltoms tloprf`o `cgpotftfcm, wlf`l slcuin icwor umft prf`os. Lobitl `bro efmbm`fmk fs gobsuron hytlo por`omtbko ce cut-ce-pc`aot oxpomnfturo fm tctbi lobitl `bro oxpomnfturo. Lfkl cut-ce-pc`aot oxpomnfturos typf`biiy fmnf`bto tlbt ibrko pbrts ce tlo pcpuibtfcm bro mct`cvoron hy bmy lobitl fmsurbm`o. Bs b `cmsoquom`o, lobitl fmsurbm`o `cgpbmfos`bmmct ichhy ecr icwor prf`os bmn rokuibtcrs bro cetom woba, wlf`l ovomtubiiy iobns tclfklor nruk prf`os. Eurtlorgcro, wo fm`iuno tlo tctbi vciugo ce fmsuifm fgpcrton bmnbssugo tlbt `cumtrfos tlbt fgpcrt gcro slcuin ho bhio tc mokctfbto icwor prf`os wftlplbrgb`outf`bi `cgpbmfos. Efmbiiy, wo fmtrcnu`o tlo bppifon Gcst Ebvcron Mbtfcmtbrfees fm cur rokrossfcm. Lfklor tbrfees `cuin prcvfno fm`omtfvos ecr plbrgb`outf`bi`cgpbmfos tc bsa ecr icwor ibmnon prf`os. B lfklor fgpcrt nuty `cuin ho vfowon bs btbx tlbt fs prchbhiy hcrmo hy hctl tlo prcnu`or bmn pbtfomt.

    ^bhio 2: Notorgfmbmts ce tlo _mft Trf`o bmn tlo Trf`o Nfeeorom`o

    Ubrfbhio Noefmft fcm Oxpo`ton Oeeo`t cmTrf`o

    im(KNT por `bp) ^lo ickbrftlgf` bgcumt ce KNT por `bpftb +im(pcpuibtfcm) ^lo ickbrftlgf` sfzo ce tlo pcpuibtfcm +/-Novoicpon ^lo nuggy vbrfbhio, wlf`l fs 2 fe tlo pbrtmor

    `cumty fs bm CO@N `cumtry+

    im(`cgpotftcrs) ^lo ickbrftlgf` mughor ce ecrofkm `cumtrfosoxpcrtfmk tlo gonf`bgomts `cmtbfmfmk fmsuifm tc`cumtry f

    -

    im(C-C-T) ^lo ick-trbmsecrgon prcpcrtfcm ce cut-ce-pc`aotoxpomnfturo fm tctbi lobitl oxpomnfturo (%)

    +

    im(vciugo) ^lo ickbrftlgf` bgcumt ce fgpcrton vciugo cefmsuifm

    -

    im(tbrfee) ^lo ick-trbmsecrgon rbto ce tbrfee -KNT 7 krcss ncgostf` prcnu`t.

    Pcur`o: Butlcrs.

    ^bhio 8: Nos`rfptfvo Ptbtfst f`s

    Chsorvbtfcms Gobm Ptn. nov. Gfm. Gbx.

    _mft prf`o($444)

    22, 26 >82.?4066;5 4 2

    @cgpotftcrs 22,2688; >.C-C-T 22,55? 04.02

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    16/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    2>

    ?.8 Ostfgbtfcm Ptrbtoky

    ^lo oqubtfcms tlbt wo wfii ostfgbto tbao tlo eciicwfmk sfgpio ecrgs:

    () 7 +

    () 7 +

    (8) 7 +

    [o efrst fmtrcnu`o KNT por `bpftb, tlo pbrtmor `cumtry novoicpgomt nuggy, bmn tlogbraot stru`turo, bs woii bs fmstftutfcmbi vbrfbhios, bs fmnopomnomt vbrfbhios. [o bnntlo vciugo ce fgpcrts fm b sopbrbto rokrossfcm, bs tloy pctomtfbiiy fmeiuom`o tlo umftprf`o. Efmbiiy, wo bnn tlo bppifon tbrfee rbtos bs oxpibmbtcry vbrfbhios. [o nc tlfs ibstho`buso wo cmiy lbvo tbrfee fmecrgbtfcm ecr bhcut cmo-qubrtor ce tlo chsorvbtfcms1 tlus,tlfs sbgpio fs ronu`on suhstbmtfbiiy.

    [o bmbiyzo cur pbmoi nbtb usfmk efxon oeeo`t crnfmbry iobst squbros (CIP)rokrossfcms.

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    17/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    2?

    ?.8.8 @cumtry-Tbfr Efxon Oeeo`t

    Moxt, wo bssugo fmstobn tlbt tlo orrcr torg `bm ho nfvfnon fmtc `cumtry-pbfr-spo`fef`orrcr, bmn bm fnfcsym`rbtf` orrcr, .

    7+

    ^lo justfef`btfcm ecr tlfs bssugptfcm fs vory sfgpio bmn fmtuftfvo. ^lo prf`o hotwoom`cumtry fbmn `cumtry aslcuin ho nfeeoromt ercg tlo prf`o hotwoom `cumtry fbmn `cumtryja, ho`buso `cumtry pbfrs fa bmn fj prchbhiy lbvo nfeeoromt trbmsb`tfcm `csts nuo tcnfeeoromt kockrbplf`bi nfstbm`o, nfeeoromt ibmkubkos, nfstfm`t husfmoss `ustcgs, bmnnfeeoromt roifkfcms1 `bpturos tloso nfeeorom`os. ^lfs `cumtry-pbfr efxon oeeo`t CIPostfgbtfcm wcuin prcvfno ovom `iobror ovfnom`o ecr tlo oxfstom`o ce prf`o nfeeoromtfbtfcmhy cmtrciifmk ecr trbmsb`tfcm csts hotwoom fbmn a.

    ^lo oqubtfcm tc ho ostfgbton tlom ho`cgos:

    7 + + .

    ^bafmk tlo wftlfm trbmsecrgbtfcm, tlo oqubtfcm ho`cgos:( ) 7 ( ) + ( ) + ( )

    wloro 7 2

    # .

    ^lfs `bm ho rowrfttom bs:

    7 +

    Fm cur `cumtry-pbfr efxon oeeo`ts rokrossfcm, wo ostfgbto tlo efxon oeeo`ts ostfgbtcrs, .

    [lom wo rokross prf`o nfeeorom`o wftl tlo `cumtry-pbfr efxon oeeo`ts, tlo novoicpon-`cumtry nuggy vbrfbhio (^bhio 2) `bmmct ho fm`iunon ho`buso tlo prf`o nfeeorom`o

    noefmon fm oqubtfcm (0) birobny fgpif`ftiy `cmtrcis ecr tlo pbrtmor `cumtry nfeeorom`o. Ft fstlus gfsiobnfmk tc fm`iuno tlo novoicpon `cumtry nuggy fm tlo rokrossfcm gcnoi fmtlfs suhso`tfcm.

    5. OP^FGB^FCM XOP_I^P

    5.2 @cumtry Efxon Oeeo`t

    ^bhio 0 suggbrfzos tlo ostfgbtfcm rosuits ecr tlo tlroo nfeeoromt typos ce nopomnomtvbrfbhios: umft prf`os (`ciugms 20)1 prf`o nfeeorom`o 2 (`ciugms >5)1 bmn prf`onfeeorom`o 8 (`ciugms ;6). [o efrst mctf`o tlbt tlo KNT por `bpftb fs lfkliy sfkmfef`bmt

    ecr bii tlo tlroo nopomnomt vbrfbhios. ^lo efrst `ciugm slcws tlbt b 24% lfklor KNTpor `bpftb fgpifos b 5.

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    18/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    25

    fgpifos tlbt tlo prf`o kbp ercg tlo roeorom`o prf`o ho`cgos ibrkor fe tlo crfkfmbi kbp fspcsftfvo.

    ^lo `coeef`fomt ecr tlo pcpuibtfcm sfzo `cgos cut mokbtfvo, bs oxpo`ton, hut ft fsfmsfkmfef`bmt fm bii rokrossfcms. Cmo robscm gfklt ho tlbt tlo pcpuibtfcm sfzo fs mct bm

    bnoqubto prcxy ecr tlo gbraot sfzo ce fmsuifm prcnu`ts. Novoicpfmk `cumtrfos wftl ibrkopcpuibtfcms gfklt lbvo mct tlo efmbm`fbi gobms tc trobt nfbhotos bnoqubtoiy1 tloroecro,tlo vciugo gfklt ho icwor bmn prf`os rbtlor lfkl.

    [ftl CO@N oxpcrtfmk `cumtrfos, tlo umft prf`os bro systogbtf`biiy lfklor. ^lo sbgochsorvbtfcm lcins wlom wo icca bt prf`o nfeeorom`os. ^lo gbfm robscm ecr tlo lfklorprf`os `lbrkon hy CO@N `cumtrfos fs tlbt tlofr fmsuifm gbfmiy hoicmks tc tlo ibtostkomorbtfcm bmn fs cetom stfii umnor pbtomt prcto`tfcm.

    Eurtlorgcro, cur ostfgbtfcms slcw tlbt `cgpotftfcm fs bm fgpcrtbmt notorgfmbmt cefmsuifm prf`os. [o efmn tlbt tlo lfklor tlo mughor ce `cgpotftcrs (gobsuron hy tlomughor ce scur`o `cumtrfos), tlo icwor tlo umft prf`o ho`cgos bmn tlo prf`o nfeeorom`oslrfmas fe b pcsftfvo kbp oxfsts. Fm ctlor wcrns, `cgpotftfcm bgcmk fmsuifm prcnu`ors

    sfkmfef`bmtiy ronu`os prf`os.

    Cur rosuits eurtlor fmnf`bto tlbt tlo prcpcrtfcm ce cut-ce-pc`aot oxpomnfturos roibtfvo tctctbi lobitl `bro oxpomnfturo fs pcsftfvoiy `crroibton wftl tlo umft vbiuo. ^lo rosuit fsstbtfstf`biiy sfkmfef`bmt b`rcss bii spo`fef`btfcms, bmn sukkosts tlbt fm gbraots wftl ioss-novoicpon lobitl efmbm`fmk systogs, plbrgb`outf`bi `cgpbmfos tomn tc oxpicft tlofrgbraot pcwor tcwbrns fmmugorbhio btcgf` huyors. Ptromktlomfmk lobitl efmbm`fmk lbstlus mct cmiy tlo birobny woii-ostbhifslon pcsftfvo oeeo`ts, su`l bs prcvfnfmksbeokubrns bkbfmst `btbstrcplf` lobitl oxpomnfturos, hut ft gfklt ho bm fgpcrtbmtoiogomt fm hrfmkfmk ncwm prf`os ecr plbrgb`outf`bis.

    Moxt, wo bnnon tlo ickbrftlg ce tlo vciugo ce fmsuifm fgpcrton. Fmtorostfmkiy, wochsorvo b mokbtfvo bmn stbtfstf`biiy sfkmfef`bmt oeeo`t fm bii spo`fef`btfcms. Fm ctlorwcrns, lfklor vciugos hrfmk prf`os ncwm bmn ronu`o prf`o nfeeoromtfbis. ^lo rosuitfgpifos tlbt b 24% fm`robso fm tlo vciugo icwors tlo umft prf`o ce fmsuifm hy 4.>;%. [obisc mcto tlbt wlom wo bnn vciugo bs b vbrfbhio, tlo sfkmfef`bm`o ce bii tlo vbrfbhiosrogbfms.

    Efmbiiy, wo bnn tlo tbrfee rbto bs bm oxpibmbtcry vbrfbhio. ^lo sbgpio sfzo ho`cgossfkmfef`bmtiy sgbiior bs yobriy nbtb cm tbrfees bro rbtlor spbrso. B lfklor tbrfee soogs tclbvo b mokbtfvo oeeo`t cm umft prf`os, bs woii bs cm prf`o nfeeoromtfbis. [o amcw ercgtrbno tlocry tlbt b tbrfee nrfvos b wonko hotwoom `cmsugor bmn prcnu`or prf`os. Nuotc lfklor prf`os ecr `cmsugors, prcnu`ors moon tc icwor tlofr prf`o.

    24[o chsorvon

    bkbfm tlbt wlom wo bnn hctl tlo trbno vciugos bmn tlo tbrfee rbto, tlo rosuits rogbfmebfriy stbhio fm bii tlroo roiovbmt `ciugms, tlbt fs, (0), (5), bmn (6). ^lo cmiy ox`optfcm fs

    tlo sfkmfef`bm`o ce tlo prcpcrtfcm ce cut-ce-pc`aot oxpomnfturo fm (5) bmn (6), wlf`lnfsbppobrs.

    ^bhio B.8 fm tlo Bppomnfx lbs bmctlor rosuit ce rokrossfcms ce tlo umft prf`o, bmn tloprf`o rbtfc cm tlo sbgo sots ce oxpibmbtcry vbrfbhios tlbt bro uson fm tlo gbfmrokrossfcms. Pfkmfef`bm`o iovois ce vbrfbhios bro vory sfgfibr tc tlo rosuits fm ^bhio 0.

    24

    Cur umft vbiuos bro hbson cm `cst, fmsurbm`o, bmn erofklt (@FE) fgpcrt nbtb bmn tloroecro roeio`t tloibmnon prf`o.

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    19/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    2;

    ^bhio 0: Ostfgbtfcm Xosuits, @cumtry Efxon Oeeo`t

    (2) (8) (0) (>) (?) (5) (;) (0; 4.4606 4.284 4.45;4 4.4;5; 4.46;< 4.4;(4.4?>;) (4.4?>5) (4.240) (4.42?2) (4.42?4) (4.48;4) (4.42>0) (4.42>8) (4.48?;)

    im(pcpuibtfcm) 4.4>4< 4.46?8 -4.2> -4.444?6 -4.48>6 -4.465;;2) (4.4;68) (4.4>?4) (4.4>>5) (4.4;?0)

    Novoicpon 4.5 4.;>4 4.;50 4.4>) (4.44***

    -4.225** -4.4>;;

    *** -4.4546

    *** -4.4;;4

    *** -4.4>00

    *** -4.4?58

    *** -4.4;?8

    ***

    (4.40464) (4.44

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    20/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    2: Ostfgbtfcm Xosuits, @cumtry-Tbfr Efxon Oeeo`t

    (2) (8) (0) (>) (?) (5) (;) (?***

    4.24>***

    4.2?>) (4.248) (4.42;2) (4.4256) (4.404>) (4.425>) (4.4258) (4.4860)

    im(pcpuibtfcm) -4.2?> -4.4>5? -4.2< -4.2;> -4.40 -4.4?

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    21/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    26

    Cur rosuits `crrchcrbto obrifor stunfos tlbt ovfnom`on fmtormbtfcmbi prf`o nfs`rfgfmbtfcm.Fm ovory gbraot o`cmcgy, prf`o nfs`rfgfmbtfcm fs wfnoiy uson tc oxtrb`t `cmsugorsurpius. Lcwovor, prf`o nfs`rfgfmbtfcm ecr plbrgb`outf`bis fs cetom rostrf`ton fmncgostf` gbraots nuo tc tlo pbrtf`uibr mbturo ce puhif` lobitl, lobitl systog efmbm`fmk,bmn ce tlo plbrgb`outf`bi prcnu`ts tlogsoivos. Hy `cmtrbst, fmtormbtfcmbi prf`onfs`rfgfmbtfcm ecr plbrgb`outf`bis bppobrs tc ho `cggcm prb`tf`o. Fmtormbtfcmbi prf`onfs`rfgfmbtfcm `bm fgprcvo b``oss tc plbrgb`outf`bis ecr pbtfomts fm novoicpfmk`cumtrfos, bs ft biicws ecr ceeorfmk ce icwor prf`os. Lcwovor, tlo nokroo ce prf`onfs`rfgfmbtfcm ecr plbrgb`outf`bis rogbfms nohbtbhio. Fm ifmo wftl obrifor stunfos (o.k.,P`lwoftzor bmn @cgbmcr 8422), wo efmn tlbt tlo prf`o oibstf`fty fs hoicw umfty. Fm ctlorwcrns, icwor-fm`cgo `cumtrfos pby roibtfvoiy gcro ecr tlo sbgo nruk `cgpbron tclfklor-fm`cgo `cumtrfos. B prf`o oibstf`fty ce cmo wcuin ho gcro oquftbhio wlombssosson bkbfmst beecrnbhfifty roibtfvo tc fm`cgo. B prf`o oibstf`fty ce ibrkor tlbm cmowcuin gobm tlbt bs fm`cgo por `bpftb krcws, tlo prf`o ce nruks fm`robsos ovom gcro.Pu`l b roibtfcmslfp wcuin gobm tlbt nruks bro `lobpor fm pccror `cumtrfos nuo tclfklor prf`os fm gcro beeiuomt gbraots. Lcwovor, b lfklor oibstf`fty bisc trbmsibtos fmtc

    ibrkor prf`o nfeeorom`os, wlf`l tlom fm`robsos tlo fm`omtfvos ecr pbrbiioi trbno.Kfvom plbrgb`outf`bi `cgpbmfos bttogpts tc `lbrko nfeeoromt prf`os b``crnfmk tc tlofm`cgo por `bpftb, wlbt pcif`y cptfcms bro bvbfibhio tc kcvormgomts3 Cur rosuits lfmtbt sovorbi strbtokfos tlbt gfklt iobn tc icwor prf`os ecr fmsuifm. Efrst, fm`robsfmk tlomughor ce scur`o `cumtrfos prcvfnos b sfgpio, yot oeeo`tfvo, tcci tc ecstor prf`o`cgpotftfcm. Po`cmn, hufinfmk up lobitl efmbm`fmk systogs tlbt ronu`o cut-ce-pc`aotpbygomts soogs bmctlor suftbhio strbtoky tc hrfmk ncwm fmsuifm prf`os. Tbrt ce tlosooeecrts `cuin ho tc pcci tlo pur`lbso ce fmsuifm.22^lfrn, cur rosuits slcw tlbt fgpcsfmklfklor tbrfees icwors tlo umft prf`o. Lcwovor, fgpcsfmk tbrfees `cgos bt b `cst. [o amcwercg hbsf` trbno pcif`y tlocry tlbt hctl `cmsugors bmn prcnu`ors sueeor ercg woiebroicss nuo tc tlo fmtrcnu`tfcm ce b tbrfee. Fe tlo nogbmn `urvo fs rbtlor fmoibstf`, bs ft fs fm

    tlo `bso ce ifeo-sbvfmk nruks su`l bs fmsuifm, prcnu`ors bro bhio tc trbmseor gcst ce tlo`cst tc tlo pbtfomts. Fgpcsfmk tbrfees cm fmsuifm nruks fs tloroecro b rfsay pcif`y, bs gcstce tlo hurnom fs hcrmo hy tlo pbtfomts, mct tlo plbrgb`outf`bi `cgpbmfos. Oifgfmbtfmktbrfees wcuin tloroecro ho tlo gcro oeef`fomt pcif`y ercg tlo pcfmt ce vfow ce hctl puhif`lobitl bmn o`cmcgf` oeef`fom`y.

    Efmbiiy, b wcrn ce `butfcm fs fgpcrtbmt. Efmbi nruk prf`os `bm ho vory nfeeoromt ercg tloprf`os ropcrton tc `ustcgs wlom omtorfmk tlo `cumtry. ^lo efmbi prf`o pbfn hy tlopbtfomt fs notorgfmon hy wfno brrby ce notorgfmbmts, su`l bs mbtfcmbi lobitl rokuibtfcmsbmn stbmnbrns, tlo gbraot pcwor ce mbtfcmbi rotbfiors bmn lobitl fmsurbm`o `cgpbmfos,bmn ncgostf` trbmspcrtbtfcm `cst. Fm crnor tc fgprcvo tlo beecrnbhfifty ce fmsuifm ecr biipbtfomts, gu`l gcro fs moonon tlbm tlo gobsuros fnomtfefon bhcvo. Lcwovor, tlo tlroogobsuros bro icw-lbmkfmk erufts wftl pctomtfbiiy ibrko homoefts ecr nfbhotos pbtfomts.

    22 ^lo TX@ kcvormgomt, ecr oxbgpio, fs tryfmk tc ifgft tlo fm`robso fm gonf`bi oxpomnfturos hy huyfmk

    gcro gonf`fmos fm huia bt icwor `csts (Hiccghork 8420).

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    22/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    84

    XOEOXOM@OP*

    Hbmorjoo, P., A. ^rbm, L. If, A. @fgcm, N. Nbmogbm, P. Pfgpscm, bmn A. @bgphoii.844;. Plcrt-b`tfmk Fmsuifm Bmbickuos ecr Nfbhotos Goiiftus: Gotb-bmbiysfs ce@ifmf`bi Cut`cgos bmn Bssossgomt ce @cst-oeeo`tfvomoss. ^o`lmcicky Xopcrt): 285 Gfiifcm bs Nfbhotos Pprobns.Poptoghor >.

    Hrcnb, @. bmn N. O. [ofmstofm. 8445. Kichbifzbtfcm bmn tlo Kbfms ercg Ubrfoty. ^loRubrtoriy Jcurmbi ce O`cmcgf`s282(8): ?>2?

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    23/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    82

    ^rf``c, B. @., ot bi. 842>. Pbeoty, Oeeo`tfvomoss, bmn @cst Oeeo`tfvomoss ce Icmk B`tfmkUorsus Fmtorgonfbto B`tfmk Fmsuifm ecr Tbtfomts wftl ^ypo 2 Nfbhotos:Pystogbtf` Xovfow bmn Motwcra Gotb-bmbiysfs. Hrftfsl Gonf`bi Jcurmbi0>6:k?>?6.

    [bkmor, J. I., bmn O. G`@brtly. 844>. Fmtormbtfcmbi Nfeeorom`os fm Nruk Trf`os.BmmubiXovfow ce Tuhif` Lobitl8?: >;?>6?.

    [bmk, V.X. 8445. Trf`o @cgpotftfcm fm tlo @lfmoso Tlbrgb`outf`bi Gbraot.Fmtormbtfcmbi Jcurmbi ce Lobitl @bro Efmbm`o O`cmcgf`s5:226286.

    [fkkfms, P. M., bmn X. Gbmoss. 844>. Trf`o @cgpotftfcm fm Tlbrgb`outf`bis: ^lo @bsoce Bmtf-fmeo`tfvos. O`cmcgf` Omqufry>8(84): 8>;850.

    [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm. 8420b. Nfbhotos Eb`t sloot, M028, Gbr`l 8420. Bvbfibhiobt lttp://www.wlc.fmt/gonfb`omtro/eb tsloots/es028/om/ (b``osson 28Poptoghor 8420).

    [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm. 8420h. [LC Lobitl Ptbtfstf`s, Trcjo`tfcms ce Gcrtbifty bmn

    @busos ce Nobtl, 842? bmn 8404. Bvbfibhio bt lttp://www.wlc.fmt/lobitlfmec/kichbiShurnomSnfsobso/prcjo`tfcms/om/fmnox.ltgi (b``osson 28 Poptoghor8420).

    [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm. 8420`. [LC Lobitl Ptbtfstf`s, Kichbi Lobitl Ostfgbtos.Bvbfibhio bt lttp://www.wlc.fmt/lobitlfmec/kichbiShurnomSnfsobso/om/fmnox.ltgi(b``osson 28 Poptoghor 8420).

    [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm. 8420n. Nobtls ercg @UN bmn Nfbhotos. Bvbfibhio btlttp://www.wlc.fmt/klc/m`n/gcrtbiftySgcrhfnfty/`vnStoxt/om/ (b``osson 20Poptoghor 8420).

    [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm, [crin Fmtoiio`tubi Trcporty Crkbmfzbtfcm bmn [crin ^rbno

    Crkbmfzbtfcm. 8420. Trcgctfmk B``oss tc Gonf`bi ^o`lmcickfos bmn Fmmcvbtfcm Fmtorso`tfcms hotwoom Tuhif Lobitl, Fmtoiio`tubi Trcporty bmn ^rbno. Komovb:[crin ^rbno Crkbmfzbtfcm.

    [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm bmn Lobitl B`tfcm Fmtormbtfcmbi. 8422. LBF Trcjo`t cmGonf`fmo Trf`os bmn Bvbfibhfifty Xovfow Porfos cm Tlbrgb`outf`bi Trf`fmkTcif`fos bmn Fmtorvomtfcms. [crafmk Tbpor 2: Oxtormbi Xoeorom`o Trf`fmk, Gby.Komovb: [crin Lobitl Crkbmfzbtfcm bmn Lobitl B`tfcm Fmtormbtfcmbi.

    \u V., ot bi. 8420. Trovbiom`o bmn @cmtrci ce Nfbhotos fm @lfmoso Bnuits. Jcurmbi cetlo Bgorf`bm Gonf`bi Bssc`fbtfcm 024(6): 6>

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    24/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    88

    BTTOMNF\

    ^lo eciicwfmk chsorvbtfcms woro nrcppon ercg tlo sbgpios ostfgbton ho`buso tloyworo ifaoiy tc sueeor scgo gobsurogomt/ropcrtfmk orrcrs.

    ^bhio B.2: Nrcppon Pbgpios

    @cumtry Tbrtmor @cumtry Vobr

    Korgbmy Nomgbra 2666Korgbmy Erbm`o 2666@rcbtfb Korgbmy 8420@rcbtfb Lumkbry 8420@rcbtfb Nomgbra 8420Bihbmfb Fmnfb 844>Lcmnurbs Tbmbgb 8444Gbinfvos Pfmkbpcro 266) (?) (5) (;) (; 4.860 4.0660) (4.426) (4.4;;>)

    im(pcpuibtfcm) -4.44448?2 4.480; -4.4580 -4.456? 4.446< -4.4;8> -4.2?? -4.266 -4.8>> -4.24; -4.2>< -4.845(4.44?) (4.4?0) (4.40;0) (4.408;)

    Chsorvbtfcms 22,00; 22,00; ?,868 22,00; 22,00; ?,868 22,00; 22,00; ?,868

    Mcto: Ptbmnbrn orrcrs fm pbromtlosos1 efxon oeeo`t CIP1 *p9 4.2, **p9 4.4?, ***p9 4.42

    Pcur`o: Butlcrs.

  • 7/26/2019 International Trade and Determinants of Price Differentials of Insulin Medicine

    25/25

    BNHF [crafmk Tbpor ??2 Loihio bmn Bfzbwb

    ^bhio B.0: Ostfgbtfcm Xosuits, @cumtry-Tbfr Efxon Oeeo`t Ostfgbtcr

    (2) (8) (0) (>) (?) (5) (;) ( 4.>(4.42;8) (4.4256) (4.404?) (4.4?5?) (4.4??;) (4.244) (4.4>) (4.4>;62* -4.848 -4.280 -4.>08*(4.4?0;) (4.4?8>) (4.45; -4.40?4 -4.4>66 -4.2;4 -4.202 -4.2;8 -4.22< -4.4