International best practice in levee system flood risk ... … · June 2018 International best...
23
June 2018 International best practice in levee system flood risk analysis Ben Gouldby ASFPM Phoenix 2018
Transcript of International best practice in levee system flood risk ... … · June 2018 International best...
June 2018
International best practice in levee system flood risk analysis
Ben Gouldby ASFPM Phoenix 2018
© HR Wallingford 2018
Overview
Introduction to the levee partnership
St Louis pilot site analysis
UK Approach
Overview of approaches: comparisons
June 2018 Page 2
© HR Wallingford 2018June 2018 Page 3
© HR Wallingford 2018
St Louis:Upper Wood River Levee System
June 2018 Page 4
© HR Wallingford 2018
St Louis : method comparison
5June 2018
© HR Wallingford 2018
Range of structure types
June 2018 Page 6
© HR Wallingford 2018
All methods – risk based
June 2018 Page 7
Risk = f( Probability and consequence)
© HR Wallingford 2018
Load
Probability
SourceProbability
of failure
Load
Pathway
Pathway
DamageReceptor
Depth16th March 2018
© HR Wallingford 2018
A structured approach to the analysis of
the flood risk system
16th March 2018
© HR Wallingford 2018
Levee segmentation
June 2018 Page 10
© HR Wallingford 2018
Levee segmentation
June 2018 Page 11
© HR Wallingford 2018
All methods – integrated simulation
June 2018 Page 12
© HR Wallingford 2018
Environment Agency Consequences: Economic
June 2018 Page 13
© HR Wallingford 2018
14
Environment Agency ResultsAsset contribution to risk
Reported for
Residential and non-residential buildings,
And structural failure (breach) and non-failure (overflow / overtop /
seepage)
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
300,000
350,000
400,000
450,000
500,000
25242322212019181716151413121110987654321
EAD
($)
Asset ID
Seepage Breached
© HR Wallingford 2018
Rijkswaterstaat reliability analysis
15June 2018
© HR Wallingford 2018
USACE reliability
16June 2018
© HR Wallingford 2018
Environment Agency: formal reliability analysis
June 2018 Page 17
© HR Wallingford 2018
Summary of reliability analysis:Fragility
18
Formal reliability analysis
Expert Judgment
June 2018
Model parameters
June 2018
Formal expert elicitation
Model/data parameters
© HR Wallingford 2018
Summary of reliability analysis
19
Probability of failure
within the levee system
June 2018
June 2018
Probability of failure of
each segment
© HR Wallingford 2018
Rijkswaterstaat and USACE Consequences:Life-loss
20June 2018
© HR Wallingford 2018
Summary of consequences
21
Life-loss
June 2018
June 2018
Economics
© HR Wallingford 2018
Conclusions
• Fundamental concepts and principals consistent
• Differences in relation to treatment of consequences
• Differences in relation to the method flood levee
reliability analysis
• To a certain extent differences reflect the different
topographical feature of the countries
June 2018 Page 22
© HR Wallingford 2018
Questions?23
Rijkswaterstaat:
Deon Slagter, Cees Henk Oostinga + many others
USACE:
Eric Halpin, Tammy Conforti, Nate Snorteland, Jason Needham +
many others
Environment Agency:
Claire Hollingsworth, Adrian Rushworth, Dave Hornby, Owen Tarrant
HR Wallingford:
Jonathan Simm, Mike Panzeri, Gordon Glasgow
June 2018
Acknowledgements
