Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
-
Upload
hong-kong-mun-2013 -
Category
Documents
-
view
216 -
download
0
Transcript of Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
1/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
1
Forum: General Assembly Social, Humanitarian and Cultural CommitteeIssue: Integration of Refugees into New Societies
Chair: Tiffany Chung
Rapporteur: Michael Xu
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
2/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
2
Table of Contents
Angola 3Argentina .5Brazil ..6Germany ......7 Georgia .....8India ...9 Iran ..........11Israel ...........12Japan 13 Kenya ......14 Kuwait ...............16Libya ...........18Malaysia ...............19
Morocco ....... .22Palestine Liberation Organization (observer) ......23 Philippines ......25 Russia ............27Saudi Arabia ...28 South Korea ....29 Switzerland ...................30Syria ...............32Turkey .......33Uganda ..........35Ukraine ....................36
United Kingdom .....................37
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
3/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
3
Angola
Relevant Documents on Refugees in the U.N.
The 1951 Refugee Convention, establishing the UNHCR, spells out that a refugee
is someone who "owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of
race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political
opinion, is outside the country of his nationality, and is unable to, or owing to
such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country." The
1967 protocol also stated and explained the status of refugees.
Refugee Crisis in Angola.
As recently as a decade ago, Angola remained primary source countries for
refugees. The resumption of full-scale civil war in Angola in the latter half of
1998 not only halted the repatriation of Angolans from neighboring states, which
was underway, but saw fresh movements out of that country. In December 1998the United Nations estimated that about 330 000 Angolans were internally
displaced and had registered 255 000 as refugees primarily in Zambia, the
Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Congo-Brazzaville and Namibia. The
number of monthly registrations of new Angolan refugees steadily increased
from July 1998. Angola hosted about 12,100 refugees and 2,900 asylum seekers
at year's end. The largest group of refugees was 11,400 from the Democratic
Republic of Congo (Congo-Kinshasa), who mostly arrived in the 1970s. It is likely
there were more refugees among the estimated 400,000 Congolese living in
northern Angola, but there had never been a complete formal registration and
births and deaths often went unrecorded.
Steps to Reintegration.
1. Physical protection: UNHCR began but could not complete a comprehensive
formal registration exercise of all refugees and asylum seekers in Angola, which
it hoped to attempt again in 2008.
2. Freedom of Movement and Residence: Angola's 1994 Law on the Legal Regime
of Foreigners granted foreigners freedom of movement and residence.
3. Right to earn a livelihood: Refugees can enjoy the protection of Angolan labor
legislation, under the assistance of some organizations.
4. Public relief and education: Following UNHCR's 2005 handover of the schools
in Viana refugee camp to Angola, both Angolan and refugee children attendedthem.
Strategies by U.N.
1. Scaling up voluntary repatriation
2. Providing assistance packages to help former refugees reintegrate
3. Securing an alternative legal status that would allow them to continue to
reside in countries of asylum. Cessation clauses are built into the 1951 Refugee
Convention and the 1969 Organization of African Unity Refugee Convention.
They allow refugee status to end once fundamental and durable changes have
taken place in the country of origin and the circumstances that led to their flight
no longer exist. That is the case in all three countries of origin, Angola, Rwandaand Liberian and UNHCR has recommended that cessation of refugee status
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
4/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
4
apply for Angolan refugees who fled the country as a result of the conflicts
between 1961 and 2002; Liberian refugees who fled the civil wars between 1989
and 2003; and for Rwandan refugees who fled between 1959 and 1998.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
5/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
5
Argentina
Argentina is in full support to integrate refugees into our society and
recognizes the integration of refugees into new societies as an urgent problem
that needs to be addressed immediately. The root of the problem lies in security
problems and resource burdens, which result in inadequate recognition of
refugees. Host countries often blame refugees for the pre-existing social or
economics problems, such as the rise of criminal activities and street
prostitution. Although these claims may not be backed by substance, such claims
can result in policies against local integration and local resentment towards
refugees. In many cases, refugees live in camps that are unsafe and
unsatisfactory, with few means to support or educate themselves. Refugees are
often neglected by the local government and are not granted full asylum, refugee
status, permanent residency and other human and civil rights. They bypass
official assistance and find ways to self-settle amongst the local population.Argentina has been a member of UNHCRs Executive Committee since
1979 and it has demonstrated interest in protecting human rights and solving
refugee issues. Argentina itself receives about 1,000 refugees from 35 different
countries: Columbia, Peru, Cuba, Eastern European and African countries and
has been making steady progress in handling refugee issues over the past
decade. It expanded its refugee committee and adopted a more efficient
procedure to handle refugee documents. In 2005, Argentinas Congress passed alaw that provides a very solid framework for the full exercise of refugees rights.It guarantees the processing of asylum claims in a reasonable timeframe,
facilitates access to documentation, education, health and employment. It has
special provisions for refugee women, children and victims of violence. The
adoption of the migration law recognizes the right to migrate and guarantees
equal access to the public health and education system to all migrants regardless
of their migratory status. It also multiplies the possibilities for migrants and
persons of concern to be granted temporary and/or permanent right of legal
residence in the country.
Furthermore, since 2005, Argentina has coordinated a resettlement
program for Columbian refugees with HIAS and UNHCR. The Argentine
authorities issue legal documentation that allowed refugees to stay and work in
Argentina immediately. In every city, refugee families are assisted by a teacher, a
social worker and a psychologist to facilitate smoother integration process.Already, 101 refugees have been resettled in Argentina. All children are enrolled
in school, and the majority of adults have integrated into the job market.
Argentina will take on an active stance to integrate refugees into the
international society. Argentina will cooperate with UNHCR and various NGOs to
entitle refugees their basic rights, identity and welfare. This delegation will also
devise a program to blend refugees into new societies and strive to eliminate
discrimination and biases against refugees. Argentina urges all states to join her
to advocate refugee rights and solve refugee issues. Argentina has proved that
solving refugee problems is not difficult as long as there is support from UNHCR
and NGOs. We strongly encourage all member states to distinguish all
stereotypes on refugees and restore their entitled rights and freedom.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
6/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
6
Brazil
Although Brazil treated refugees to migrants in the period of World War
II, and prevented non-European refugees to have find their asylum in Brazil in
1950s, they started to gradually accept the roles of refugees, and moreover,
Brazil helped them a lot. And now, Brazil is one of the greatest country that has a
big influence to UN and to the world.
Brazil started to recognize refugees at the time period of 1990s, this act is
called The 1997 Brazilian Refuges Act, which was made by the President inBrazil, Fernando Henrique Cardoso. President Cardoso stated, due to severe andgeneralized violation of human rights, he or she is compelled to leave his or her
country of nationality to seek refuge in a different country. They gave refugeesrights to enjoy the association and paid employment the Brazil. The results of
this made more people to find asylum in Brazil, where they can enjoy life better
compare to their previous shelter.Brazils 1997 Refugee Law welcomes people who is in danger, or well -
founded fear of persecution outside the country to seek asylum in Brazil. Brazil
starts to offer people to come to their country and settle there. Providing them
with support as much as they can, to let them feel safe and secure to live in there.
In recent years, Brazil starts to actively support the UN and give
assistance for the problems about refugees. For example, in 2010, Brazil has
donate $3.2 million as the largest donation ever in the UNHCRs history. Thesefunds helped refugees in counties such as Sri Lanka, Haiti, Ecuador, Iran, and
Iraq. It granted refugees to have education and food. Brazil has one of the mostadvanced legislations in the world on refugees, has welcomed citizens of more
than 50 countries, and is now becoming one of the biggest donors to UNHCR,Mr. Amorim noted. Brazil is now very well known for giving a big help to the UN.
Brazils goal referring to the problem of refugees would be to strengthentheir resettlement program, and also policies for the rights of the refugees. Brazil
believes that every countries should try and give support to refugees, as the
numbers are getting larger in some places. They should try to detect people in
need for help and protection. And finally, Brazil wants countries to give equal
rights to them, especially for refugee women to gain more recognition.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
7/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
7
Germany
Although German is not one of the most culturally diverse nations of
Europe, nonetheless it is indeed a destination for foreign immigrants, frompeoples of poor socioeconomic background who leave their origin in search for
better opportunities. Here in Germany we are extremely tolerant of such
immigration and since the post WW2 years, we have seen annual immigration
figures steadily rising before reaching its peak in the 1990s. Germany has aethnic breakdown of 80% ethnic German and the 20% remaining comprises
mainly of Eastern European minorities comprising of a sizable Arab, Russian,
Turkish and Polish population which makes up around 10% of the total
population.
Due to our long standing commitment and adherence to the Geneva
conventions on Refugees, our homeland has been a popular destination and for
this we have had to create more stringent regulations to prevent overpopulatingwhich would create for us a shortage of resources and a reduction of economic
opportunities. Regardless, we continue to be one of the most popular refugee
destination for we recognize the maltreatment of individuals due to their race
and religious orientation and would place their cause on the same priority level
as that of political asylum seekers.
Our political structure allows for smooth integration given a general
understanding and basic proficiency in the German language, of course we leave
the choice of language to newly settled to decided but otherwise-Germany has
been renowned for its internationality and the prominence of several other
major world languages for many years now and we hope that our judicial andpolitical structure for immigration will be a model for other nations with similar
situations so that the world will realize a greater level of political equality.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
8/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
8
Georgia
As a country with strongly relevant history, Georgia understands the dire
situations most refugees, asylum seekers, IDPs and stateless people over the
world experiences. Despite our current populations of official refugees stands
relatively low, the high amount of IDPs gives us distinctive experience in
assisting misplaced population in general.
Base on the long standing cooperation between UNCHR, Georgia believes
the essential point General Assembly should address is the matter of creating
legal framework for nations worldwide to apply when integrating targeted
populations in terms of, and not limited to, refugees into mainstream society,
while securing their safety.
As of now, the current population of concern within the border of Georgia
is around 338.828 people, including refugees, asylum seekers, stateless people,
and mostly IDPs.The Georgian government through the last decade had taken several
strategies with sufficient result in improving the life of refugees from Chechen
and IDPs generated from conflict between South Ossetia and Abkhazia.
We believe it is vital to provide durable housing and accommodation to
secure sufficient need for refugees. While promotion of a sustainable income-
generating program for refugees to be self-sufficient is necessary as well.
Community participation works are established, such as vocational
training, teacher training, agricultural support and promotion of education for
children. It is also notable some descendent of Chechen refugee had obtained
university degree, while the so called refugee schools are closing as mostchildren of refugee are merging into local schools to decrease social segregation
and isolation.
Legal documentation of refugees, including birth registration for infant
and identity documents for adults are given. This becomes relatively efficient for
refugees to support related government ministries in participating the process of
improving their own lives.
Meanwhile, aside the fact it is undeniable refugees need to be able to
access basic medical care, we discover psychological care is especially needed as
result shows many IDPs and refugees likewise suffer from decreasing mental
health due to the constant unstable experience.
Actions are also taken to assure security of the community from violenceby establishing assessment among members of community and providing hot-
line services. A safe house is also created in some region to proved shelter for
children, women, disadvantaged group and especially single handed mothers, for
emergencies such as gender based violence.
In conclusion, Georgia is interested in support positions that incorporate
sufficient legal frameworks that not just improve the lifestyles of refugees and
similar groups likewise (asylum seekers, IDPs, stateless people), but most
importantly to integrate into mainstream society of host society as safely and
efficiently as possible. We must stress actions taken that can potentially enhance
situations such as social segregation, cultural conflict or even political strand are
not desirable.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
9/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
9
India
Refugees are intrinsically an integral part of society and have a lot to
contribute as a legitimate social function. It is regrettable that in this day and
age, relatively little marked progress has been seen in trying to reintegrate
refugees into society. Often they are alienated, an unfortunate result of generally
negative attitudes towards them. Even in developed nations like Germany and
France, anti-immigration views, let alone them being accepted as legalmembers of society, permeate to the political level, with far-right groups
garnering much support for vehemently opposing Muslim immigrants. In India,
on the national level, there have been concerns relating to the unstable military
conditions in the state of Assam, where clashes have caused an internal exodus
of at least 400000 villagers. On the international level, millions of migrants flood
in from Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Afghanistan and Tibet, looking for
sanctuary.
It is Indias belief that national governments have the responsibility todirectly intervene in the introduction of refugees residing in a new country,
especially in terms of providing financial assistance and accommodating them.
One must recognize that most refugees are from underprivileged backgrounds,
and that a policy of immediate self-reliance will not bring any results.
India has always worked closely with UNHCR, pointing towards
accommodating refugees and the provision of better living standards. India has
provided long-term solutions, like legal assistance and work visas/work permits.
India will also continue her Community-based Development Program, an
educational and developmental program championed by local NGOs and UNHCR.
India will also do her best in seeking to repatriate those who wish to do so.
Indias budget for refugee protection and related affairs was US$7.5m last year.The difficulties of these displaced individuals should be of concern.
Bureaucratic red tape and problems in localizing must be dealt with. India would
like to commend the UNHCRs work in her refugee camps as regards legal andfinancial assistance, and would like its work to be applied wherever possible.
Free education is vital in any attempt in the reintegrating of displaced
individuals (DIs). Particular emphasis must be directed to localization, especially
when resettlement in their home countries will not be possible in the near
future. On the other spectrum of the educational system, the general public
should be advised of the legitimacy of refugees and public information sessions
should be held to avoid any of the misconceptions about these DIs that may havearisen. It is important that local councils do their best in ensuring that both
parties cooperate and jointly go forward towards harmonization. Notably,
employers must understand their duty to maintain this fine balance by providing
work opportunities for these DIs, or for the state to adopt voluntary
employment.
Also necessary is equality in societal regard. This must be administered in
two fronts; firstly, against discrimination in employment and secondly, in gender
equality. Women who are urban refugees are particularly likely to face
challenges coping with the new environments; these problems are existent even
here in India. There is a need to make sure that gender equality is promoted and
not kept by the conservative societies that these refugees may have come fromor have gone to.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
10/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
10
Ultimately, we would all like to see that every citizen of the world leads a
happy and healthy life. If political crises and civil strife can be diminished,
hierarchal dominions and dictatorial suppression abolished, then there would
not have been refugees in the first place. However, this worldly peace is far
beyond the limited scope of todays possibilities. Therefore, India would like to
repeat the message to the international community that so long as these DIs haveto face exodus, then nations with the economic means to accept them should
accommodate them with open arms.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
11/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
11
Iran
Integration of refugees into the host country has always been a challenge
for every state over the globe, in particular countries in Africa and the Middle-
East. At present, the Islamic Republic of Iran is one of the countries holding the
most refugees. The recent social instability and economic downturn highlights
the urgency for all nations to acknowledge and cope with the issue. The
challenge is to assist refugees achieving integration, which is paramount to social
harmony and the reestablishment of refugees. With the co-operation with the
Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, Pakistan and UNHCR, the Islamic Republic of
Iran, has in the past participated, and is still continuing her participation in
numerous projects assisting refugees, for example extending a health insurance
scheme.
With respect to UNHCR as a model, the Solutions Strategy for Afghan
Refugees as a road map, the Islamic Republic of Iran points to durable,
sustainable resolutions. Considering the long-term benefits for both the hostcountry and refugees, we propose the following two measures: 1) facilitating and
enhancing voluntary repatriation; 2) assistance in integrating. The Islamic
Republic of Iran would like to emphasize that both measures are conducted in
accord to the refugees will; the refugees are offered the freedom to decide.If one preferred voluntary repatriation, believing that there were better future
prospects in their countries, we would respect it. At the same time, adequate
assistance would be provided--- UNHCR would follow up and help them
reintegrating into the society. Moreover, to facilitate voluntary repatriation
successfully, nations ought to co-operate with each other, keeping up with the
updated news regarding the conditions of refugees and countries themselves.
On the other hand, for refugees continuing their stay, they would as well
receive corresponding assistance from the host country. These measures would
be aiming at establishing self-reliance and achieving social harmony.
Firstly, basic needs are the fundamentals of quality life. In order to assist
refugees integrating, basic needs must first be fulfilled, intensifying their social
safety nets. The Islamic Republic of Iran asks member states to take initiative to
improve community services and infrastructure, especially in the aspects of
health and food security, which are in urgent need.
Secondly, when tackling a problem regarding identity, a legal framework is
crucial. We strongly support issuing working, or better, residence permits to
refugees. Not only can this offer an acknowledgement of citizenship, but alsoenables them to have a chance of reestablishment.
Last but not least, education is a pivotal component of integration. The
Islamic Republic of Iran suggests offering education to refugees, to both adults
and youngsters. Through education, tolerance could be promoted. In other
words, difference in lifestyle and culture would be embraced. Moreover, the
language barrier that impedes basic integration can be broken down too.
All in all, the Islamic Republic of Iran totally understands refugees within
a new country often experience difficult adjustment problems, and thus propose
the mentioned measures to offer assistance, hoping to help them establish self-
reliance and achieve social harmony.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
12/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
12
Israel
In 2008, there were 4,000 Sudanese refugees in Israel, 1,200
from Darfur and the remainder Christians from South Sudan, because of the
Sudanese civil wars. Since 2006 60,000 people have crossed the Egyptian border
and into Israel. Israel played a great part in helping to define refugees and their
rights in the 1951 convention. Israel is currently making preparations to Syrian
Alawi refugees. Because Israel is in a war-plagued region, many refugees seek
asylum in Israel which has been causing an economic issue internally but also as
a Jewish state it is important to keep the native majority. To control the
inconsistent influx of refugees into the nation Israel enacted an Infiltration Lawin 2011. Israel feels that it is important to help refugees in need however they
should not be introduced into an unstable economy nor a country that isnt in astate to host them. Sometimes emergency asylum is needed and for those cases
Israel agrees that it is of great importance for the refugees to have somewhere to
go.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darfurhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Sudanhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Sudanhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darfur -
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
13/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
13
Japan
Japan has played a key role in the leadership in the humanitarian field in
the region and around the world, due to its approach to human security
commonly being regarded as progressive, imbued with liberal internationalist
commitment. The Japanese government has been offering to refugees and
internally displaced persons constructive conditions and a long-term solution.
When it established the resettlement pilot project in December 2008, with the
Government becoming something of a pioneer in terms of the Asia region, it took
another considerable step towards providing refugees residing in Mae La
refugee camp in Thailand with a good opportunity at living in safety and dignity.
The total figure of refugees and internally displaced persons under the
protection and assistance of the UNHCR and the UNRWA reached approximately
42.30 million as of 2009. As stated on the website of the ministry of Foreign
Affairs of Japan, refugees and internally displaced persons around the world
continue to be not only of humanitarian concern but also involve issues thatcould undermine the peace and stability of the concerned regions and the entire
world. This is why Japan, looking on events from the perspective of human security, places humanitarian assistance for refugees and internally displaced
persons at a very high level of its international contribution, leading them to
provide active support through many international organizations and extends
support to Japanese NGOs involved in humanitarian assistance. In response
to the mass outflow of Indo-Chinese (originating from Vietnam, Laos and
Cambodia) in the late 1970s, Japan acceded to the Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees on October 3, 1981, and then to the Protocol Relating to the
Status of Refugees on January 1, 1982. Every contract came into force the day it
was granted. In agreeing to the installation of said treaties, Japan amended the
Immigration Control Order to establish a recognition system for refugee status
and changed the title to the Immigration Control and Refugee Recognition, which
came into force in January 1982. People identified as refugees are given the
same benefits under the social security system provided to Japanese citizens and
other foreign nationals. Moreover, recognized refugees also enjoy protection
relating to entry into, departure from, and staying in Japan.
Japan, being one of the most advanced countries in terms of reintegration
of refugees, has already established a well-built relationship with the UNHCR. In
the year 2012, the government of Japan the UNHCR joined hands to implement
the pilot resettlement project, and support the setting up of a full-fledgedprogramme. Furthermore, it will encourage for the greater involvement of civil
society and local communities in assisting resettled refugees into local
communities. In addition, UNHCR has also undertaken a wide range of
awareness-raising activities in partnership with the Japanese national
association, including collaborative internship programmes and public events,
for example the Refugee Film Festival. Through these activities, the strategic
partnership with Japan International Cooperation Agency and Japanese NGOs
will become stronger than ever.
Japan was one of the first to open its arms to refugees seeking asylum.
Furthermore, Japan also became one of the first Asian countries to offer the
protection and benefits that refugees needed and craved, turning itself into ashining example of a country very much accepting of foreign cultures.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
14/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
14
Kenya
Settlement and reintegration of refugees have always been a key issue in
the United Nations SOCHUM committee and the Republic of Kenya has been
contributing to the debates with a high degree of involvement. At present, the
Republic of Kenya is the host country of more than 559,000 refugees from
various countries and the number is expected to grow. The Republic of Kenya
has currently two of the largest refugee camps in the world, the Dadaab and
Kakuma refugee camp, providing significant support to refugees. The
government of Kenya is therefore setting up more refugee camps to satisfy the
increasing demand and understands the importance of reintegrating refugees
into the society. However, with the rising number of refugees, the government of
Kenya faces social and economic problems that hinder the governments attemptin implementing such policies. The government of Kenya has been providing
refugees in the nation with basic necessities, such as food and shelter, and
assistance through the Department of Refugee Affairs which has consumed alarge percentage of the nations resources. The further influx of refugees placesfinancial burden on the government which is constantly trying to support the
basic needs of refugees. Consequently, scarce resources lead to low living
standards in camps, relying on the assistance of NGOs. The government of Kenya
is anxious about the settlement of current and future refugees entering the
territory and is also concerned about the reintegration of refugees which at the
current stage is not carried out effectively. The Republic of Kenya believes that
the core elements of the problems are the rising number of refugees and the lack
of resources. The drain on resources caused by building and maintaining refugee
camps is even threatening the quality of life of the local civilians. Furthermore,
the government recognizes the root of the problem as the instability of nearby
African countries. For example, asylum-seekers from Somalia, where human
rights are abused and civilians are physically harmed, are the majority among
the refugees within the nation; series of natural disasters also contribute to the
large influx of people into Kenya.
Kenya being a signatory to the 1951 United Nations Convention, the 1967
Protocol and the 1969 Organization of African Union Convention, continues to
offer protection and assistance to refugees and asylum seekers by establishing
the Department of Refugee Affairs, under the Refugees Act 2006. The
government department provides services such as registration of asylum-
seekers, maintaining an appropriate registration and documentation system forrefugees and issuing identification cards to refugees. The Refugee Act 2006,
passed by Kenyan national legislative body, strengthens the nations protectionof refugees and is very well-perceived by the majority of refugees. The
governments current refugee policy requires all refugees and asylum-seekers tostay at the refugee camps assigned due to the safety and security concerns. Other
than refugees in camps, the government also recognizes the growing number of
refugees in urban areas who faces sever social problems, such as poverty and
discrimination. The Republic of Kenya, however, falls short of the urban
refugees demand for protection and assistance due to limited resources and thelack of legal recognition of them.
The Republic of Kenya is hoping for improvement in the protection andreintegration of refugees. In the coming SOCHUM conference, the delegation of
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
15/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
15
Kenya will be seeking for advice and practical assistance to the nation which
could be beneficial to the wellbeing of refugees in Kenya. The delegation is
determined to improve the living standards of refugees by resolving the issue
from its root. Firstly, the delegation would like to call upon the neighbouring
African countries to stabilise the internal political and social conditions in order
to reduce the export of asylum-seekers. Secondly, the delegation would like toask for funding and resources from other member states in order to maintain
good living conditions in camps and develop programmes to reintegrate refugees
into the society. It is unfortunately true that the government focuses on the
protection and settlement of refugees rather than implementing policies to
reintegrate refugees. Therefore, through funding and resources allocation, the
government would have sufficient capital to carry out the required measures.
The delegation strongly believes the problem of the lack of resources and
growing number of asylum-seekers must be resolved before the reintegration of
refugees should be carried out. The Republic of Kenya believes through
international cooperation and coordination, the issue can be eased globally.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
16/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
16
Kuwait
A. Background of the TopicFrom UNHCR: The Middle East subregion is marked by extreme volatility. The
civil unrest in the Syrian Arab Republic (Syria) poses a danger to the stability of
neighbouring countries: it has led to the massive displacement of civilians
including over 350,000 refugees. In addition, other refugee situations, such as
that of the Iraqis in exile and the flow of Somalis into Yemen, show no signs of
ending. For UNHCR, in 2013 it will be even more difficult to protect and assist
the growing numbers of refugees and internally displaced persons (IDPs) in the
region. But it is still difficult for most refugees to achieve integration and
acknowledgement of citizenship or official refugee status in host countries.
In your country's opinion, what are the main elements of the problem?The main elements of the problem are that the people escaping from neighboring
countries that are involved in conflict are becoming refugees that are having ahard time to adapt in the new country and society. In Kuwaits instance, theproblem we are facing is that displacement of more than 190 000 Syrian
refugees into Kuwait and neighboring countries such as Lebanon triggered by
the civil war.What are the roots of those elements?The roots of the problems lies mainly in the extreme volatility in the Middle East.
Civil unrest, religious conflicts and various types of violence poses a danger to
the stability in the region, and has led to massive displacement of civilians. Most
of these refugees come from Palestine, which is exchanging constant attacks with
Israel; and recently Lebanon and Syria, both suffering from bitter civil wars. Thesituation is heightened with the revolutionary wave of demonstrations, protests
and wars occurring in the Arab world since December 2010.What actions have been previously taken?Kuwait has sent supply aids to nearby countries that are affected by the inflow of
the large number of refugees, for example in Northern Lebanon. At the start of
the year 2013, we have delivered supplies that would hopefully cover the needs
of some 12,000 Syrian families displaced in Northern Lebanon. Kuwait would
continue to provide assistance to and care to their fellow Syrian brothers to ease
some of their suffering.
B. Position taken by your delegationWhat are your national interests in the situation?Reintegration of refugees is one of our priorities in humanitarian duties, due to
the large influx of refugee population from neighboring countries. We
acknowledge that refugees should have their rights safeguarded. We are
concerned of their social status, especially having lost their homeland and are
trying to adapt to our society. Furthermore, seeing them as our Arab brothers,
we equally value their presence in Kuwait, which ultimately, they are able to
contribute a significant amount of workforce to the country.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
17/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
17
What are your nation's policies on the topic?Our nations main policy is to offer them jobs. Most of the refugees are peoplewho are low-skilled or uneducated. To utilize them, we offer them labor jobs that
does not require higher skill levels. About 80% of the labor force in Kuwait
consistently comprises non-Kuwaitis since 1975, improving the production andeconomy of our country. From another perspective, it is also a process of
integrating them into the new society by giving them opportunities in the society
to earn a living and to ultimately work their way up.C. Proposal and JustificationWhat will you propose as a solution to solve the problem? In order to solve the problem of the massive population of refugees in the middle
east and in other parts of the world, we propose to implement our nationscurrent policy into other countries that are dealing with the similar problem: to
reintegrate the refugees by them offering jobs and opportunities, providing them
a way to move up from the bottom of the spectrum in a new society.What are your main reasons for supporting this position?By offering jobs to refugees, not only the country will benefit from extra work
force, the refugees themselves will also find a new direction in life and see that
there is hope for them to live and move up in the society provided that they work
hard. Overall, this is a win-win solution.What do you predict will be the main opposition to your proposals? We expect the opponents to our proposals will be criticizing our policy in the
expulsion of Palestinians from Kuwait in 1991. Our opponents will probablypoint to us as hypocrites. It is therefore important note that before the PLO
supported Iraqs invasion, we offered Palestinian refugees work and pay.However, our decision in expelling the Palestinian workers was solely a protest
in response to the PLO supporting Iraqs cause for invading us, and has norelation with this topic.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
18/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
18
Libya
Libya would like to take this international platform to address the issue of
refugees settling into new societies. Libya strongly relates to this issue for
currently, even after the fall of dictator Muammar Gaddafi, we are still
undergoing fighting from extreme Islamic militia groups. An estimate 200,000
people have been internally displaced, and more than 4,384 people are currently
refugees residing in foreign countries. As Libya finds a transitional government,
the process of democratic voting remains under pressure, for to take part, blood
is the payment.
The post-conflict transition in Libya is expected to open significant new
opportunities to further maintain human rights and the law. Determined to rise
to a better nation, we hope to work with other countries to create ties to solve
our countrys current problems, and in the future will be able to requite the aid.We strongly urge all member states to collaborate and ensure peaceful
coexistence between communities where the refugees and asylum seekersreside. Let us continue in bilateral action through consensus to achieve
everyones goal of amalgamating refugees amicably.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
19/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
19
Malaysia
Background of the Topic
Malaysia is not party to the 1951 Refugee Convention nor its Protocol and
does not have an asylum system regulating the status and rights of refugees. The
absence of a legal framework on asylum issues is a source of great
unpredictability in the lives of refugees in the country. This challenging
protection environment is placed within a context of some 3 million migrants,
1.9 million of whom are considered illegal.
Malaysian law makes no distinction between refugees and undocumented
migrants. Refugees are vulnerable to arrest for immigration offences. They may
be subject to detention, prosecution, whipping and deportation. National NGOs
have little capacity to support asylum-seekers and refugees, while international
NGOs are unable to operate in the country.
However, there have been some positive developments in 2010 and the
first quarter of 2011. These have included the emergence of opportunities forUNHCR to present proposals to the Government for the establishment of a legal
and administrative framework for the management of asylum, and the provision
of assistance to refugees. UNHCR was also able to advocate with the Government
for the latter to allow refugees the right to work, as well as to improve their
access to education and health care. Finally, UNHCR has continued to encourage
the Government to become a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its
1967 Protocol. The Government has indicated that it is currently considering
these proposals.
While cooperation with the Government of Malaysia has steadily
improved, the absence of a legal protection framework and weaknesses in the
administrative structure for asylum have caused many people of concern to
remain at risk. With limited State resources to call on in support of refugees,
UNHCR Malaysia continues to fulfil its mandate responsibilities for registration
and refugee status determination (RSD). It also continues to monitor detention
facilities, and works to secure the release of refugees, while supporting health,
education and community self-reliance programmes, and promoting durable
solutions for refugees and asylum-seekers.
The situation is particularly difficult for refugee children. In spite of the
Government of Malaysia having signed the Convention on the Rights of the Child
which obligates the Government to ensure education for all primary-aged
children in Malaysia, no refugee children are allowed to attend Governmentschools. Of the 20,000 refugee children in Malaysia, 12,000 of them are school-
aged. What education is available is provided by UNHCR in partnership with the
refugee communities and NGO partners. At present only 7,000 refugee children
are participating in the existing, very basic education programmes that are
available.
No significant change is foreseen in the situation of populations of
concern to UNHCR in Malaysia. UNHCR's estimates of some 15,000 new arrivals
in the country in 2012 are based on average yearly arrivals of asylum-seekers,
and the prevailing situations in refugee-producing countries.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
20/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
20
Position taken by Our Delegation
UNHCR's people of concern in Malaysia comprises a large population of
urban refugees, smaller groups of stateless people, and Filipino refugees in
Sabah. Refugees and asylum-seekers in urban areas are those of highest concern
to UNHCR in the country. Most refugees are unlikely to find durable solutions in
Malaysia, although several stateless groups and the Filipino refugees in Sabahenjoy some degree of integration, and stand better chances of obtaining
permanent residency or citizenship.
The lack of legal protection in Malaysia means that urban refugees face
grave protection risks on a daily basis. The refugee population in Malaysia also
includes a large number of Muslims from Myanmar's northern Rakhine State,
who are considered both refugees and stateless. However, we have already
provided them employment, education and minimum wage, if were to sign theUN convention, we would be compelled to treat the refugees better than our
people.
Proposal and Justification
Fair protection processes and documentation
Access to and quality of RSD procedures are improved.
RSD procedures are consistent with international standards. 90 per cent of people of concern have access to status determination
procedures.
Asylum-seekers are notified of the result of their application within70 days of the first interview, and within 110 days of the submission of an
appeal.
Basic needs and essential servicesThe health status of the population of concern is improved.
75 per cent of people of concern have access to primary health care.The population of concern has optimal access to education.
10 per cent of the population of concern aged 12-17 is enrolled insecondary school.
85 per cent of the population of concern aged 6-11 is enrolled inprimary school.
Community participation and self-management
Self-reliance and livelihoods are improved.
40 per cent of the population of concern aged 18-59 is self-employedfor more than 12 months.
Community mobilization is strengthened and expanded.
10 per cent of leadership/management structures are headed bywomen.
The working relationship between UNHCR and the Malaysian
Government has continued to improve, with constructive engagement in a
variety of areas, including the recognition of UNHCR documentation, and
improved access to refugees in immigration detention. However, many other
areas, including the access of people of concern to employment, and bettereducation and health care, still require improvement.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
21/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
21
Given the current absence of a legislative and administrative framework
to protect refugees, and the non-involvement of the Government in receiving and
processing people of concern, UNHCR will continue to register asylum-seekers,
undertake RSD and issue identity documents. Registration will cover the
remaining unregistered asylum-seekers in the country, as well as new arrivals.
UNHCR will continue to intervene in order to prevent the arrest, detention andrefoulement of people of concern, as well as to secure their release where
necessary.
UNHCR will seek resettlement for the majority of the refugee population
in Malaysia. At the same time, it will advocate with the Government for
temporary, local solutions in the form of residence and work permits for groups
of Muslim refugees from Myanmar's northern Rakhine State. To diversify
resettlement to a range of resettlement countries, including newly emerging
ones, UNHCR will promote fair and balanced resettlement opportunities for
various ethnic groups from Myanmar and other countries. UNHCR will also
continue to help its partners to provide humanitarian assistance to people of
concern in the areas of basic needs and access to essential services, with a
particular focus on health, education, community development and self-reliance.
Furthermore, UNHCR will advocate with the Government of Malaysia at
national and local levels, to ensure that the Filipino Muslims in Sabah and other
stateless populations are allowed to remain in the country. It will mobilize civil
society groups to gain a better understanding of the situation, and identify any
potential for change. If sufficient funding becomes available, UNHCR will
progressively increase its activities in Sabah towards strategic targets.
UNHCR Malaysia's operational strategy will require strong cooperation
with partners. Contributions from civil society and NGOs, the Malaysian
Government and the refugee communities themselves will be central in theshared effort. At the operational level, given the large numbers of urban refugees
and asylum-seekers, refugee communities are expected to be crucial partners in
a sustained community development effort to address the wide array of
protection and assistance needs.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
22/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
22
Morocco
The integration of refugees is a process in which parties concerned must
put substantial effort to ensure that no conflicts arise. The host country must
also help the refugees adapt to the host society without having to forego their
own cultural identity. However, there are a number of cases where newcomers
in a society have lost their cultural traditions and values. In order to protect
invaluable traditions, parties involved must take this process in an earnest
manner. The process of integration is challenging and gradual but economic,
social and cultural factors are important for the refugees ability to integratesuccessfully and become new members of that society.
The Kingdom of Morocco is fully committed to supporting integration of
refugees. For more than thirty years, Morocco has seen the Sahrawi people living
in the desolate Algerian Sahara. They are people exiled from their native
Western Sahara, which is now currently the southern part of Morocco. In recent
years, some of the population has chosen to return to the Western Sahara. Thenumber of refugees has been drastically increasing for the past few years. For
this reason, the United States Committee for Refugees and Immigrants (USCRI)
has been offering various programs that have been a substantial helping hand in
order for this process to run smoothly. Morocco will continue to invest in areas
such as improving infrastructure. Morocco and USCRI will continue to assist the
Sahrawi people to establish new lives and become active members in their new
community.
Similar to the case mentioned above, The Kingdom of Morocco will work
together with any organizations that are willing to assist refugees. Morocco is
aware that the issue of refugees reintegrating into societies is a topic that deeply
influences universal human rights. Furthermore, Morocco will assist other
refugees outside of Morocco if assistance is required. Morocco has a long
tradition of allowing refugees and migrants to settle in our country. Morocco has
ratified all the major international treaties, including the 1951 UN Refugee
Convention and its Protocol in 1967.
The Kingdom of Morocco suggests that the term stateless person, definedin the 1954 UN Convention, may somewhat lead to causing problems when
refugees integrate. This is because defining a person stateless is essentially the
same as discriminating those that do not have homes. Morocco believes that
discriminating these people can lead to issues of culture racial prejudice. As a
result of prejudice, Morocco has seen refugees suffer from environmentalisolation and lack of education as well as health care. In this way, redefining the
term will help reduce these prejudice views that people have towards newly
integrated refugees. The Kingdom of Morocco looks forward to support nations
with recommendations and ideas that will help all integration of refugees.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
23/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
23
Palestine Liberation Organization (observer)
Despite attempts made by the United Nations to uphold peace and
stability, there were frequent instances of unrest within and among the Arabian
communities- for example due to territorial settlements and/ or religiousdisputes. This created vast populations of refugees that were forced to flee from
home and take up residency at a new location. PLO deems this problem
especially severe when disputes with fellow Arabian states, such as Israel are not
uncommon. The number of UNRWA registered Palestine refugees by January
2010 were high at 1,983,733 in Jordon. The 1948 Palestine war turned 85% of
the Palestinian population into refugees. The PLO strives to protect its former
citizens of Palestinian civil rights by the policy of Palestinian right of return and
most importantly, stresses upon our refugee population of attaining equal civil
rights as that of local citizens of the host countries, maintaining strict loyalty to
the principle of self- determination.
PLO is pleased to observe that nearly 2 million Palestinian refugees havetaken residence in refugee camps in West Gaza, Jordon etc., revealing a certain
degree of societal, political and economic integration. However, it has also come
to PLOs alarm that though the Jewish Agency promised to the UN before 1948that Palestinian Arabs would become full citizens of the State of Israel, however
in practice, citizenship is not granted to our refugee population. The denial to
integration into the society is also apparent when the Arab League openly
instructed Arabian states to deny citizenship to PLO refugees. Furthermore, PLO
refugees in Jordon are deprived of basic human rights, for instance being barred
from 73 job categories, the Lebanese healthcare system or acquisition of job and
land permits. In addition, PLO refugees in India similarly face hardship insearching for employment opportunities. PLO is highly concerned with such
situations and sees an urgent need further reiterate the principle of self-
determination as explicitly listed in Articles 1 and 55 of UN Charter 3. We believe
that Palestinian refugees should be guaranteed with the right to self-
determination and we take the deprivation of their basic human rights as a
discriminative offence to the Palestinian population at large. By enacting the
principle of self- determination, PLO refugees are given the right to pursue their
own callings accordingly as that of local citizens of the host countries, enabling a
larger degree of integration into their host communities be it from institutional
or socio- economic perspectives. By imposing artificial restrictive measures
against PLO refugees, they are unable to decide their own courses of actions. Thisis an evident instance of violation of basic human rights, and the PLO sees an
urgent need to address such problem.
The PLO strives to protect our citizens rights by advocating the policy ofthe Rights of Return. Our claim is based on Article 13 of the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights, stating that "Everyone has the right to leave any
country including his own, and to return to his country". This policy is an
extension of the policy of self- determination and we welcome Palestinian
population abroad to return to their home state and reclaim their property and
assets accordingly. The PLO values the refugee population as an inherent part of
the PLO population and we insist on safeguarding the rights and freedoms of our
citizens.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_Rightshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_Rightshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_Rightshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_Rights -
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
24/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
24
Ultimately, the PLO parties to the policy of self- determination by
proposing the policy of the Rights of Return, exhibiting our extent in supporting
the retaining of basic human rights of our citizens. The PLO has always been an
avid supporter and abider to all UN legations, including that of Article 1 of the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights All human beings are born free and equal
in dignity and rights. PLO looks forward to offering our support in any policiesassisting integration of refugees into new communities and playing our part in
upholding human egalitarianism and world harmony.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
25/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
25
Philippines
As a nation which upholds a humanitarian spirit, the Philippines believes
that human rights should be universal and should never be dependent on the
presence or absence of a person's nationality or his affinity to his country.
Refugee protection remains urgently needed by those forced to leave their
countries, amidst the realities of conflict, violence and persecution.
The Philippines views integration as a flexible and bidimensional process.
Successful integration into new societies requires not only the refugees'
adaptation to the host society but also the malleability and the capacity for
change of the host society for the reception and integration of new groups.
The Philippines has a long tradition of giving sanctuary to stateless people
and establishing legal mechanisms to regularize their status. The refugee agency
is also supporting the government to amend its nationality legislation to prepare
for accession to the 1961 Convention. The Philippines was one of the first 23
countries to sign the 1954 Convention before it closed for signature on 31 Dec1955, and has now ratified it to put it into effect.
The Philippines remains the only country in the Asia-pacific region that is
a signatory to the 1951 Convention and its 1967 Protocol and with an
institutionalized refugee protection regime. The long-term goal is the
development of a working model that can be used to engage other states within
the region to accede to the 1951 Convention and to protect refugees in
accordance with international standards.
The Philippines was hailed by the UN refugee agency for being the first
country in the Asia-Pacific region to establish a procedure to protect both
refugees and stateless people. The Department of Justice of the Philippines
recently published a circular that enhanced its current system of determining
refugee status and put in place a procedure to ascertain whether a person is
stateless. The new procedure is an important step to ensure the Philippines
meets its obligations under the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of
Stateless Persons, which it ratified last year, the first ASEAN (Association of
South-east Asian Nations) member state to do so.
The new mechanism is a testament to the genuine humanitarian spirit in
the Philippines. This unified approach provides the widest possible protection
net for refugees and the stateless in the most effective way.
Refugees and stateless people are protected under Philippine law. With
the new procedure, there is a way to unify refugees with extended familymembers. Asylum-seekers have the right to a lawyer and interpreter during the
process, and they cannot be deported while undergoing the procedure, ensuring
respect for international law. Other safeguards to protect asylum-seekers and
refugees were integrated in the procedure, such as special measures for
unaccompanied children.
The Philippines believes that global legal instruments should be
established to explicitly cover the most important aspects of a refugees life.Refugees deserve, as a minimum, the same standards of treatment enjoyed by
other foreign nationals in a given country and, in many cases, the same treatment
as nationals. The country recognizes the international scope of the refugee
problem and the importance of international solidarity and cooperation in tryingto resolve them. It is the duty of the international community to ensure that all
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
26/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
26
refugees are afforded equality and respect. The complete social, cultural and
economic integration of refugees, can only be done along with the acceptance
and inclusion of the important contribution brought by such a diverse group to
different levels of the society where it has taken refuge.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
27/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
27
Russia
Concerning the plight of refugees, Russia is aware of the challenges facing
their integration globally. Russia signed the Geneva Convention on the status of
refugees and has developed its own refugee law. Between 2003 and 2010, more
than 600,000 stateless people were naturalized in Russian Federation. However,
statelessness still remains an issue of concern throughout the sub-region, mainly
as a consequence of the disintegration of the former Soviet Union and the
difficulties facing national minorities seeking to prove their citizenship. Up to a
million people are still displaced in the Caucasus region. Russia intends to solve
problems pertaining to migration, especially labour migration. We believe the
Russian society has an obligation to integrate refugees and migrants; as they
cannot return to their countries out of fear and have the potential to contribute
to the Russian Federation. The Russian delegation is determined to find a
common solution to this universal problem and looks forward to working with
Federal Migration Service, the UNHCR and other nations in this committee inestablishing effective frameworks and passing resolutions that will see the
successful integration of refugees into societies
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
28/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
28
Saudi Arabia
Armed conflicts, generalized violence and persistence violation of human
rights have long led to refugees seeking asylum in the developing world. In
todays social unrests and unstable transition phase in certain regions, morepeople will be forced to flee their homelands. Saudi Arabia is presently host to
291,000 refugees. The general conception of asylum seekers as financial burdenand confusion over refugees and illegal migrants create social tension in the host
country. In the face of possible economic and political strain faced by the
governments and racial and cultural discriminations, issues caused by the root
countries should instead be addressed.
Saudi Arabia is not a party to the 1951 Convention relating to the States of
Refugees or to its 1967 Protocol, nor the 1965 Casablanca Protocol concerning
Palestinian refugees. However, Article 42 of the Constitution provides that theState shall grant political asylum, if so required by public interest. Migrants with
residence permits would be allowed to apply for asylum and have access toeducation. Since September 1998, Saudi Arabia has accepted the UNHCR
procedure to carry out refugee status determination for individual asylum
seekers on its behalf.
Nevertheless, Saudi Arabia has been greatly concerned with the problem
of African refugees. The kingdom has, and will continue to, provide assistance in
money, medical supplies, foodstuffs and shelter.
In regards to integration of refugees into society, it is not a top priority of
Saudi Arabias authorities. It can only do as far to cure the symptoms of refugeeissues, but not the root causes for the high influx of refugees. Simply giving
migrants the tools to succeed and fit into the new society do not fully cure the
problems of refugee flow. Humanitarian action alone cannot resolve the
fundamental economic, social and political problems for the flight of asylum
seekers.
Effective approach to the protection of refugees can only be provided
when the underlying key problems of refugee movement are addressed, and in
this context, poverty and security. Granting identity of temporary asylum and
giving humane treatment would only encourage more refugees, leaving these
problems unaddressed and contribute to further deterioration. Establishment of
a reliable conflict resolution mechanism that could ensure stability in regions is
integral. Assistance to promote coexistence, if not quite yet for reconciliation, in
affected areas and rebuilding communities and lives should be encouraged,which includes devising ways to bring people together and to raise awareness on
the importance and the potential to create a socially harmonious society.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
29/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
29
South Korea
The Republic of Korea has been a signed patron of the 1951 Refugee
Convention since 1992, and has been granting citizenship ever since. We believe
all economically secure nations should be open to welcoming refugees, and that
refugees should work towards integration with the local culture and society. We
are the first East Asian nation to pass a Law on the Status and Treatment ofRefugees which shall be in full effect on July 1st, 2013. It provides a clear legal process by which refugees may register for resettlement into South Korea, a
guarantee of their human rights, and allows them to bear a legal status in our
nation whilst pending. We believe all countries should implement such policies
in accordance to Articles 13, 14, and 15, of the Declaration of Human Rights
which promise the rights to leave any country, seek and enjoy another countrys asylum from persecution, and change his nationality. Finally, welove our North Korean refugees. Bring em in! The more the merrier.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
30/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
30
Switzerland
Switzerland is an open-minded and tolerant nation and firmly believes and
promotes the idea of integration of refugees. In the field of foreign affairs
Switzerland remains neutral and greatly committed, The Swiss attaches great
importance to basic social values such as democracy, respect of the rule of law,
equality for men and women and religious tolerance. Switzerland understands
and respects that integration covers all efforts which serve to promote mutual
understanding between the Swiss and foreign populations: Living together on
the basis of shared fundamental values and behavior patterns and information
are central concerns. The process of integration requires both the foreign
nationals' readiness to be integrated and openness on the part of the Swiss
population. Integration aims at creating favorable conditions for equality of
opportunity regarding access to social and economic resources. Over the past
few decades, Switzerland which brought over thousands of guest workers
from southern Europe after World War II has also become home to a largepopulation from the Balkans, along with immigrants from Asia and Africa.
Many originally came to Switzerland seeking protection, in contrast to
Switzerland's other, more numerous foreign residents: present-day European
Union (EU) and European Free Trade Association (EFTA) citizens who came to
work in Switzerland either as guest workers or under a bilateral agreement that
since 2002 allows EU/EFTA citizens to live and work freely in the country (the
European Union has 27 Member States while EFTA has four including
Switzerland). In 2008, Switzerland had over 1.6 million foreign residents
according to official government statistics, or 21.4 percent of the country's total
population (foreign residents do not include naturalized immigrants but do
include those born in Switzerland to foreign-national parents). An average of
40,000 foreigners has naturalized each year since 2002.Foreigners' sizable
share of the population sets Switzerland apart from other European countries, as
does the makeup of this group. Of those 1.6 million foreign residents, 62.6
percent were from EU/EFTA countries, mainly Italy and Germany. Since
2001, the Confederation has made funds available to promote the integration of
foreign nationals. Interested parties who organize relevant projects and wish to
apply for federal funding may submit an application to the FCF. As a rule, such
funding is only granted provided that cantons, communes or third parties
adequately participate in the costs. For information about project funding, you
may also refer to the cantonal and communal integration agencies (foreignnational services) and / or integration delegates. Furthermore, the Swiss
Refugee Council was established in 1936 which is a non-governmental,
politically and religiously independent umbrella association of all important
Swiss relief organizations working for refugees and asylum seekers. The Swiss
Refugee Council is committed to the rights and protection of refugees in
Switzerland, it calls for fair refugee status determination procedures, refugee
integration and a return in conditions of safety and dignity. The country of origin
analysis unit is an independent research center and its activities include
researching individual query requests, publishing country reports, thematic
papers as well as policy papers in order to foster an objective and fair trail for
asylum seekers in Switzerland. Switzerland encourages all delegates to takepart and join the integration of refugees as it is giving people are given the
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
31/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
31
accessible choice and dignity as an asylum seeker for further opportunities and a
second chance. Switzerland proposes clauses to be created to ensure the safety
and opportunity for refugees.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
32/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
32
Syria
The integration of immigrants into Syria, as well as the integration of
Syrian nationals overseas, while not of pressing concern towards the Republic,
are nonetheless important. The migrant population constitutes about 9.8% of the
total population; in recent years, the Republic has been promoting a policy of
reducing migration in Syria, and while conceding that not many significantly
constructive policies have been made, has not neglected the need to aid
immigrants to integrate, and has made it increasingly convenient for foreigners
to immigrate into Syria with the aid of overseas embassies; however, efforts to
integrate asylum-seekers have produced less evident positive results.
The Republic recognises the needs and benefits of smoothly integrating
immigrants into the local community, and the difficulties of immigrants in
establishing a livelihood without the aid of the government. The Republic is
willing to work with the UN to integrate immigrants, in accordance with existing
UN guidelines or new resolutions introduced insofar the Republic deems themreasonable and feasible.
The Republic suggests that the UN take measures to prevent lengthy or
troublesome application procedures for immigrants, as well as require member
states to implement or promote social programmes to aid the integration of
immigrants, and, in the long term, asylum-seekers into the community. The
Republic also proposes that member states are given guidelines and
requirements to fulfill according to their current state of development and
stability, since demanding that less-developed or war-torn countries implement
immigrant integrations within a short time period is likely to place unnecessary
burdens on their government; furthermore, more developed nation states can
provide positive precedents, as well as (and having sufficient resources and
ability to do so) aid in rectifying any inadequacies or inaccuracies.
The Republic also hopes that more religious tolerance can be introduced
into communities in which the majority of immigrants relocate into, in order to
further facilitate integration and minimise possible conflict. Syria, as a religiously
liberal and diverse country, believes that achieving greater religious tolerance is
essential to improving immigrant integration, and hopes that the UN can step in
to aid this process.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
33/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
33
Turkey
The fear of mass influx of refugees into Turkey remains a severe problem.
In 2008, Turkey received an estimated 13,000 new asylum applications
from people of Iran, Iraq, Syria are still getting into Turkey from the troublesome
Middle East. Many thousands more may be remaining in Turkey irregularly.
We, Turkey appreciate the importance of human rights. We will provide equal
access to economic opportunities to ethnic minority groups. However, they must
also abide with my countrys law and order. Sometimes, we cannot accept all
nationals of countries outside the Council of Europe as refugees due to the lack of
resources in our own country.
As a result, we are being criticized as denying refugees and the refugees
are forcibly returned to Iraq despite fears for their lives. Some even said that we
have violated the rights of asylum-seekers on a regular basis even while their
asylum claims are under way and after they are granted refugee status and that
we do not conform to international standards.We must protest against these positions. Actually, Turkey is one of the
states and signatories to the Refugee Convention. We have settled thousands of
resettled Kurdish women in southeast part of Turkey. However, asylum-seekers
stayed in our country are always extending their stay. We are often in
difficulties in providing them with sufficient food. We have no choice but asked
them to go without much adequate legal procedure, returning them to countries.
We understand their lives may be at risk but we have no choice. That is the
situation that we seek any possible solution from this conference.
We do not find that refugees are denied opportunity to apply for asylum
either at Turkeys borders or after being arbitrarily detained. Actually, there maybe occasions that they do not submit a proper application and not because they
could not have access to a fair and satisfactory national refugee status
determination system.
In response to the above questions about the refugees in Turkey, we
agree that ethnic minority groups have interest in economic development of the
host country. The committee, however, must balance the competing interests of
governments, majority ethnic groups, and ethnic minorities to develop creative
solutions to this pressing problem to achieve optimum efficiency.
We appeal for financial support of accepting these refugees. It is good
that the Government of Japan and the United Nations (UN) decided to extend the
total of 1,030,000- dollar assistance through the Trust Fund for Human Securityto the project "Reintegration of Returning IDP/ Refugee Women in Community
Building" to be implemented by the United Nations Development Fund for
Women. We consider that continued financial support to the refugees and
suitable resources should be put to the host countries.
The financial support from other countries can be used for relieving
refugees from poverty and basic governmental services like education,
encourage active participation in the economic progress and development in
their country must be focused, as some ethnic groups remain at a severe
disadvantage because of both direct discrimination and indirect neglect.
We support the project of facilitating the process of reintegration of IDP/
refugee women into the society providing health care and education service,psychological counseling, and vocational training as well as awareness raising on
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
34/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
34
women's rights and gender issues through the media.
After careful consideration and for the best interest of the welfare of
people in Turkey, we have decided not to accept the request from the Amnesty
International, asking us to lift the geographical limitation and set a fair and
satisfactory national asylum procedure.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
35/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
35
Uganda
For millions refugees residing in nearby countries or farther afield, local
integration is one of the possible solutions for them, according to UNHCR. By
giving refugees opportunities to integrate and belong, they are able to becomeself- reliant and to contribute socially and economically. Nonetheless, at present,
many of the refugees are struggling to integrate into their local communities and
start their new lives. Our country, Uganda is concerned about this issue. Indeed,
over the past few years, Uganda has carried out various measures to address the
problem. In 1999, Uganda implemented Self Reliance Strategy, jointly drawn
with UNHCR. It aimed to empower the refugees to support themselves and
ensure the integration of refugees with nationals in the areas. It was followed by
Act of Refugees in 2006. Refugees were allocated lands for cultivation, granted
the same rights to work as nationals and access to elementary education.
Nevertheless, there are still constraints under the Uganda Refugee Act
and hinder local integration. Many of the refugee policies in Uganda can only beapplied to refugees living in the settlements. Refugees outside cannot have
access to education, and aids. This prohibits them from the prospects of
integration. As well as this, there are restrictions for the naturalization, legal
residency options and rights of refugees. As a result, without a legal status, they
are hard to break through the cycle of poverty. Also, the huge number of refugees
results in a heavy burden for the country both economically and socially.
To tackle the above problem, it is essential to reconsider the situation of
refugees and adopt a more positive, constructive, proactive approach. Refugee
issue should be addressed from its root cause such as promoting regional
stability. By doing so, refugees can return to where they belong and have theirinterests enhanced. Moreover, according to the Agenda for Protection announced
by UNHCR, the international solidarity and burden sharing of the integration of
refugees should also be noted. With reference to the 1951 Convention, UNHCR is
responsible for the protection of refugee. It should be further adopted as a
platform for cooperation, where countries share the responsibilities of refugee
protection more equitably. As the world is interconnected, only broad, deep and
sustained world cooperation can achieve better situation of refugees.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
36/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
36
Ukraine
Refugees are a displaced group of people, forced to flee from their native
country due to a threat in their safety, whether it be from war, persecution or a
natural disaster. They look to seek asylum in an alternate country, getting thereby any means possible. The real issue lies in whether this country will accept the
refugees, and what they will do to support these peoples needs-whether they bebasic, such as food, water or shelter, or complex, like a new job, right of abode
and citizenship. In 1950, the UN created the United Nations High Commissionerfor Refugees, an organisation solely dedicated to support and protection ofrefugees, and defending their rights and safety. They are the UNs primary sourcefor matters regarding the status of refugees.
The Ukraine fully recognises the needs of these displaced people, and
accepts the responsibility of trying to provide a stable environment in their time
of need. We are currently working with the UNHCR on a 10-point plan of action,
which will become a framework on which we will base our refugee policy. Thiswill help us to better fit the international guidelines provided by the UNHCR, and
will help to enhance communication within our government departments,
support the integration of refugees with whom returning to their homeland is
not an option, enhancing identification and classification of these displaced
people, and encourage the government to take responsibility for these people.
-
7/29/2019 Integration of Immigrants Into New Societies Position Paper
37/37
Hong Kong Model United Nations 2013 GA SOCHUM
United Kingdom
In the past decades, protecting refugees have been the core mandate of
the UN refugee agency. During these years UNHCR has offered protection and
assistance to tens of millions of refugees, finding durable solutions for many ofthem. In UK, we continue to take pride in welcoming migrants and refugees and
have made substantial contributions to enriching the economic and social life of
the country.
By "integration" we mean the process that takes place as refugees are
empowered to achieve their potentials as members of British society, to
contribute fully to the community and to become fully able to exercise the rights
and responsibility that they share with other residents.
In UK, multiple refugees integration projects have been set up, such asthe Refugee Integration and Employment Service operated by Refugee Action.
This new service provides support to recent refugees to help them to settle into
UK society and to find employment. General advice and support regarding issuessuch as housing, benefits and access to English classes is available for six months.
The service also assists refugees in job searches, job applications, CV-writing and
interview techniques for up to a year.
Unfortunately we also recognize issues regarding to some public
institutions, service providers and support services not addressing the needs of
refugees and their families. This kind of discrimination has strongly prevented
many refugees from securing jobs that are appropriate to their abilities in order
to live a life with adequate support.
Consequently, many migrants and refugees with good and useful
academic qualifications from abroad still find themselves trap in mean jobs withno potential for improvement whereas their skills could be better used if
empowered.
Furthermore, there is the problem of victimization of refugees provoked
by some media hostility that resulted in racial harassment and racially motivated
violence. In order for refugees to contribute fully to all aspects of the society,
they must feel safe and secure in the large refugee communities in UK.
All these strong obstacles and barriers to refugees integration evidentlyprevent many migrants and refugees from contributing to the developments of
their home countries or to invest in meaningful initiatives and projects back
home.
Therefore in conclusion, we will like to spread the idea of building acorrect attitude towards refugees from early age and that the media has to make
efforts to positively present the image of refugees and defend their interest in
the public.