Integrating Sustainment Throughout the Model-Based Enterprise
31
© 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Integrating Sustainment Throughout the Model-Based Enterprise April 2, 2019, Gaithersburg Maryland Dr. Marilyn T. Gaska Chief Engineer, Logistics and Sustainment / LM Fellow
Transcript of Integrating Sustainment Throughout the Model-Based Enterprise
4:3 PowerPoint TemplateIntegrating Sustainment Throughout the
Model-Based Enterprise
April 2, 2019, Gaithersburg Maryland
Dr. Marilyn T. Gaska Chief Engineer, Logistics and Sustainment /
LM Fellow
2NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
AGENDA
Digital Tapestry and Shared Data Perspectives
Industry 4.0 for Sustainment and A/V/MR
Digital Data for Additive Manufacturing for Sustainment
Agility and Affordability Challenge and Acquisition Approach
3NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
CASE FOR MODEL-BASED “X” WHERE X = SUSTAINMENT
“Product-Focused O&S Should-Cost Opportunities Early, Upfront Investment in Reliability, Maintainability and Supportability. Often, the greatest opportunities to save costs are manifested well before a weapon system is produced and deployed. Giving due consideration to reliability and maintainability and electing to pursue thoughtful trade decisions in the design affords the opportunity to reap tremendous life-cycle cost (LCC) savings. We like to talk about “upfront and early” since, notionally, 80 percent of O&S costs are determined during design development.”
AFFORDABILITY: TOTAL OWNERSHIP COST FOCUS
“Operating and support (O&S) costs historically account for approximately 70 percent of a weapon system’s total life-cycle cost”, GAO-18-678, Sept. 2018, p. 1.
Context / action space
CONTEXT AND USAGE MODELING AS PART OF MBE Gaska, “Improving Requirements Engineering (RE) to Support Cross- Discipline Collaboration on Complex Computer-Based Systems”, Thesis, Binghamton University, 1999
Understand interaction with world of operations and sustainment (O&S)
Collaborative Human Immersive Lab (CHIL) usage for design for operations and sustainment within context / world
Architecture 3D Modeling and Building Information Management
6NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
DESIGNING FOR A MAINTENANCE FREE OPERATING PERIOD “A maintenance free operating period (M-FOP) is defined as a period of time (or appropriate units) during which a system is both operational and is able to carry out its required function(s) without maintenance activities and without encountering failures”. (Hockley, “Maintenance Free Periods of Operation – The Holy Grail?”, RTO-MP-AVT-144, p 23-3.)
Design up front using MFOP models with mission availability focus Concept compared to warranties Additional selected references:
• Mitchell, “What the Customer Wants. Maintenance-Free and Failure-Free Operating Periods to Improve Overall System Availability and Reliability”, DTIC ADP010429, 2000.
• Guertin et al., “Impact of Maintenance Free Operating Period Approach to Acquisition Approaches, System Sustainment, and Cost”, NPS-LM-13-005, Jan. 2013.
Assure model based approach supports the lifecycle
Develop data analytics to address system of systems and context complexity
System of Systems Approach: Primary and Enabling Systems
GOVERNMENT MANDATE EVOLUTION
Gaska M, Bobinis J, and Galluzzo V, Application of System Design for Operational Effectiveness for Architectural Modeling of the SoS Relationship Between Primary and Enabling Systems, Complex Adaptive Systems Conference, San Jose, CA, Publication 5, November 3, 2015
8NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
System Elements Enabling System Elements
SYSTEM
System: An aggregation of system elements and enabling system elements to achieve a given purpose or to provide a capability.
System Elements: Also referred to as configuration items, subsystems, segments, components, assemblies, or parts.
Enabling System Elements: Provide the means for putting a capability into service, keeping it in service, or ending its service, e.g., processes or products used to enable system development, test, production, training, deployment, support, and disposal.
Each system element or enabling system element may include but is not limited to hardware, software, people, data, processes, facilities, and tools.
SYSTEM OF SYSTEM DEFINITIONS
9NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
AFFORDABLE SYSTEMS OPERATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS (ASOE)
ASOE CONTINUES TO PROVIDE A FRAMEWORK FOR ASSESSING
CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENTS THROUGHTOUT THE LIFE CYCLE
Primary & Enabling System Readiness
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
AcqLinks and References: •[1] Website: ACQuipedia – Sustainment Engineering •[2] Integrated Product Support Element Guidebook, Chapter 3 – Dec 2011
ENABLING DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT HISTORY: CONCURRENT ENGINEERING
Shared product, process and organization information as 1990s enabler focus of DARPA Initiative in Concurrent Engineering (DICE)
DICE “STAR”
Sharing Information
Douglas R. SNEAKERS: A Concurrent Engineering Demonstration System Concurrent Engineering. Thesis, Worchester Polytechnic Institute, 1994.
WETICE. 24th IEEE International Conference on Enabling Technologies: Infrastructure for Collaborative Enterprises. Larnaca (Cyprus), Greece. June 15-17, 2015.
Operations & Sustainment
Assembly, Test, & Launch
Gaska M. Importance of CM/DM in the Current and Emerging DoD Product Support Environment. Association for Configuration and Data Management Conference. Savannah, Georgia. March 3-5, 2014.
Oster C. Digital Tapestry. Model Based Systems Engineering Workshop at INCOSE International Workshop. Jacksonville, Florida. January 21, 2012.
13NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
DIGITAL THREAD: OVERVIEW AND INTRODUCTION TO EXHIBIT Aircraft Airworthiness and Sustainment Conference, Brench Boden, May 23, 2017
System Response & Degradation Model
Digital Twin
Employ System
Dr. Pamela Kobryn and Eric Tuegel, “Digital Twin and Digital Thread for Sustainment”, Aircraft Airworthiness and Sustainment Conference, May 23, 2017.
Mission: Establish a state-of-the-art proving ground for digital manufacturing and design that links IT tools, standards, models, sensors, controls, practices and skills, and transition these tools to the U.S. design & manufacturing industrial base for full-scale application
Announced in February 2014; UI Labs team selected in 2014
Builds on digital thread focus at National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST)
Rebranding as MxD – Manufacturing times Digital in 2019
Harris G. DMDII Institute Overview for The Lockheed Martin Mechanical Engineering and Advanced Manufacturing Workshop , 7 May, 2014. Approved for Public Release.
National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST). Enabling the Digital Thread for Smart Manufacturing Project. Internet. June 1, 2015.
DIGITAL MANUFACTURING AND DESIGN INNOVATION INSTITUTE
NIST MBE 2017
4
Landers T, Bijan Y. Practical Implementation of Model-Based Systems Development. NDIA Annual Systems Engineering Conference. Springfield, VA. October 28-30, 2014. and INCOSE, 2016
EXISTING LOGISTICS STANDARDS FOR MBE INTEGRATION
Aerospace Industry Association S-Series Standards
INDUSTRY 4.0 SUSTAINMENT INTEGRATION
Connected supply chain optimization (CTMA/DLA Partners 2018)
Internet of Things (IoT) for life cycle/service management
Augmented/virtual/mixed reality (A/V/MR) for maintenance
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
INDUSTRY 4.0 AND A/V/MR
Digital Thread and Industry 4.0 (Don Kinard, NIST MBE Conference, 2018)
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
SUPPLY CHAIN AND MAINTENANCE USE CASES Virtual Subject Matter Expert (SME) – virtual SME can see what maintainer sees
Hands free maintenance - use case synergy with manufacturing ( as early as Hopps, AeroDef 2013)
Heads up work instructions— Work Instructions in AR/ MR, with 3D overlays and text that links to a server
TechAssist at DoD Maintenance Conference 2017
Smart Glasses and AR in Aerospace Manufacturing: Finding the Niche (Christi Fiorentini, AWE, 2016)
Aeronautics Global field service collaboration and travel reduction
Training and Logistics Solutions
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
Early design with Collaborative Human Immersive Lab (CHIL)
Applying Virtual Reality, and Augmented Reality to the Lifecycle Phases of Complex Products (Rabbitz and Crouch, 2017)
A/V/MR leveraging the Bill of Materials (BOM) across the lifecycle (Don Kinard, NIST MBE Conference, 2018)
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP
TECHNOLOGY TO IMPROVE SUSTAINMENT OF LEGACY
SYSTEMS
OSD Additive Manufacturing for Maintenance Operations (AMMO)
Collaboration on AM Business Model Wargames / Workshops
America Makes and Maturation of Advanced Manufacturing for Low-cost Sustainment (MAMLS) Phases I - III
AM Parts in New
Production Design for AM /
AM / Rapid Prototyping
Subtractive Manufactured / Replacement Part
Welding)
Mod/Upgrade)
Small Business /
SBIR
Depot
INDUSTRY USE CASES AND VALUE CHAIN Joint Staff Enterprise Development “JED” Talk June, 2015
25NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
OSD JOINT ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING WORKING GROUP (JAMWG) RELATED EFFORT
Kelly Visconti, Additive Manufacturing, OSD Perspectives, DoD Maintenance Conference, 2018
Project Managed by America Makes
26NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED CTMA/DLA PARTNERS 2018 MEETING
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
DATA AND MODEL SHARING
Initial Additive Manufacturing Sustainment Business Model Wargames 2016 at LM Center for Innovation, Suffolk, VA
Second Wargame at LM Global Vision Center (GVC), Crystal City, VA in 2017
2018 Workshop event at GVC included Working Group on Additive Manufacturing Model Exchange and Blockchain (see summary)
OSD JAMWG co-sponsoring 4th event June 18-19, 2019 at GVC with Working Groups aligned with Stakeholder Councils including Data and Model Sharing (Register)
AGILITY AND AFFORDABILITY CHALLENGE
Tech insertion mods and upgrades for enhanced capability
Defect/reliability/maintainability root cause analysis
Acquisition reform research (UMD)
SUPPORTING ADAPTIVE ACQUISITION CONCEPTS Capability
DevelopmentA
USD (R&E) - Mission Engineering - Rapid Prototyping - Technical Maturation - JROC Guidance
B Manufacturing Development
Production, Deployment and
- R&M feedback - Address DMSMS –
opportunity for tech / capability insertion
CONTINUOUS CAPABILITY
OPTIMIZATION
29NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED CTMA/DLA PARTNERS 2018 MEETING
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
Integrate “sustainment thinking” throughout the Model Based Enterprise
Build models with the life cycle in mind with cybersecurity protections and configuration management / data management (CM/DM)
Leverage use cases in AM and MR to test MBE approaches for sustainment
Extend commercial best practices where possible for A&D domain
Sustainment Thinking
31NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
ABSTRACT This presentation will highlight the importance of a model-based enterprise (MBE) to sustainment and across the life cycle. Model-based X where “X” is sustainment needs to be considered as part of the systems of systems engineering starting early in the life cycle. Computer-aided manufacturing, inspection tools, and approaches should be planned for use in sustainment to include repairs and ease of mods and upgrades to update capabilities. The complexity of managing the digital thread or tapestry is greater when sustainment is considered, with the need to linking and management the “as maintained” bill of materials for each delivered system. Application of data analytics and artificial intelligence (AI)/machine learning (ML) supports prognostics and health management and performance feedback. System of systems modeling methods that include application of the Affordable Systems Operational Effectiveness (ASOE) framework to help organize the sustainment considerations for both the primary and enabling systems to reduce life cycle costs and improve reliability and support return on investment (ROI) case studies. There are several opportunities for leveraging digital thread for sustainment as a concentration area. The first is application of augmented/virtual/mixed reality for maintenance opportunities and supported by global subject matter expert networks. The sustainment community pull for application of advanced manufacturing approaches to include additive manufacturing also relies on distributed access to technical data packages to support manufacturing at the point of need for parts that can be printed. A third focus area is on acquisition reform focus on capability management for legacy systems to meet the challenges of the National Defense Strategy. Systems designed with standards-based architectures and interfaces can support lower cost and more agile modifications and upgrades of both hardware and software in a system.
Integrating Sustainment Throughout the Model-Based Enterprise
Agenda
Affordability: Total Ownership Cost Focus
Context and USAGE Modeling As Part of MBE
Designing for a Maintenance Free Operating Period
Slide Number 7
Slide Number 8
Slide Number 10
Digital Tapestry and Shared Data Perspectives: Integrated Data Management AS PART OF MBE
Digital Thread: Overview and Introduction to Exhibit Aircraft Airworthiness and Sustainment Conference, Brench Boden, May 23, 2017
Use of DTw to Inform Mx Planning
Today’s Institute Evolution: DMDII to MxD
Slide Number 16
Slide Number 17
Industry 4.0 Sustainment Integration
Slide Number 26
April 2, 2019, Gaithersburg Maryland
Dr. Marilyn T. Gaska Chief Engineer, Logistics and Sustainment /
LM Fellow
2NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
AGENDA
Digital Tapestry and Shared Data Perspectives
Industry 4.0 for Sustainment and A/V/MR
Digital Data for Additive Manufacturing for Sustainment
Agility and Affordability Challenge and Acquisition Approach
3NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
CASE FOR MODEL-BASED “X” WHERE X = SUSTAINMENT
“Product-Focused O&S Should-Cost Opportunities Early, Upfront Investment in Reliability, Maintainability and Supportability. Often, the greatest opportunities to save costs are manifested well before a weapon system is produced and deployed. Giving due consideration to reliability and maintainability and electing to pursue thoughtful trade decisions in the design affords the opportunity to reap tremendous life-cycle cost (LCC) savings. We like to talk about “upfront and early” since, notionally, 80 percent of O&S costs are determined during design development.”
AFFORDABILITY: TOTAL OWNERSHIP COST FOCUS
“Operating and support (O&S) costs historically account for approximately 70 percent of a weapon system’s total life-cycle cost”, GAO-18-678, Sept. 2018, p. 1.
Context / action space
CONTEXT AND USAGE MODELING AS PART OF MBE Gaska, “Improving Requirements Engineering (RE) to Support Cross- Discipline Collaboration on Complex Computer-Based Systems”, Thesis, Binghamton University, 1999
Understand interaction with world of operations and sustainment (O&S)
Collaborative Human Immersive Lab (CHIL) usage for design for operations and sustainment within context / world
Architecture 3D Modeling and Building Information Management
6NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
DESIGNING FOR A MAINTENANCE FREE OPERATING PERIOD “A maintenance free operating period (M-FOP) is defined as a period of time (or appropriate units) during which a system is both operational and is able to carry out its required function(s) without maintenance activities and without encountering failures”. (Hockley, “Maintenance Free Periods of Operation – The Holy Grail?”, RTO-MP-AVT-144, p 23-3.)
Design up front using MFOP models with mission availability focus Concept compared to warranties Additional selected references:
• Mitchell, “What the Customer Wants. Maintenance-Free and Failure-Free Operating Periods to Improve Overall System Availability and Reliability”, DTIC ADP010429, 2000.
• Guertin et al., “Impact of Maintenance Free Operating Period Approach to Acquisition Approaches, System Sustainment, and Cost”, NPS-LM-13-005, Jan. 2013.
Assure model based approach supports the lifecycle
Develop data analytics to address system of systems and context complexity
System of Systems Approach: Primary and Enabling Systems
GOVERNMENT MANDATE EVOLUTION
Gaska M, Bobinis J, and Galluzzo V, Application of System Design for Operational Effectiveness for Architectural Modeling of the SoS Relationship Between Primary and Enabling Systems, Complex Adaptive Systems Conference, San Jose, CA, Publication 5, November 3, 2015
8NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
System Elements Enabling System Elements
SYSTEM
System: An aggregation of system elements and enabling system elements to achieve a given purpose or to provide a capability.
System Elements: Also referred to as configuration items, subsystems, segments, components, assemblies, or parts.
Enabling System Elements: Provide the means for putting a capability into service, keeping it in service, or ending its service, e.g., processes or products used to enable system development, test, production, training, deployment, support, and disposal.
Each system element or enabling system element may include but is not limited to hardware, software, people, data, processes, facilities, and tools.
SYSTEM OF SYSTEM DEFINITIONS
9NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
AFFORDABLE SYSTEMS OPERATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS (ASOE)
ASOE CONTINUES TO PROVIDE A FRAMEWORK FOR ASSESSING
CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENTS THROUGHTOUT THE LIFE CYCLE
Primary & Enabling System Readiness
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
AcqLinks and References: •[1] Website: ACQuipedia – Sustainment Engineering •[2] Integrated Product Support Element Guidebook, Chapter 3 – Dec 2011
ENABLING DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT HISTORY: CONCURRENT ENGINEERING
Shared product, process and organization information as 1990s enabler focus of DARPA Initiative in Concurrent Engineering (DICE)
DICE “STAR”
Sharing Information
Douglas R. SNEAKERS: A Concurrent Engineering Demonstration System Concurrent Engineering. Thesis, Worchester Polytechnic Institute, 1994.
WETICE. 24th IEEE International Conference on Enabling Technologies: Infrastructure for Collaborative Enterprises. Larnaca (Cyprus), Greece. June 15-17, 2015.
Operations & Sustainment
Assembly, Test, & Launch
Gaska M. Importance of CM/DM in the Current and Emerging DoD Product Support Environment. Association for Configuration and Data Management Conference. Savannah, Georgia. March 3-5, 2014.
Oster C. Digital Tapestry. Model Based Systems Engineering Workshop at INCOSE International Workshop. Jacksonville, Florida. January 21, 2012.
13NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
DIGITAL THREAD: OVERVIEW AND INTRODUCTION TO EXHIBIT Aircraft Airworthiness and Sustainment Conference, Brench Boden, May 23, 2017
System Response & Degradation Model
Digital Twin
Employ System
Dr. Pamela Kobryn and Eric Tuegel, “Digital Twin and Digital Thread for Sustainment”, Aircraft Airworthiness and Sustainment Conference, May 23, 2017.
Mission: Establish a state-of-the-art proving ground for digital manufacturing and design that links IT tools, standards, models, sensors, controls, practices and skills, and transition these tools to the U.S. design & manufacturing industrial base for full-scale application
Announced in February 2014; UI Labs team selected in 2014
Builds on digital thread focus at National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST)
Rebranding as MxD – Manufacturing times Digital in 2019
Harris G. DMDII Institute Overview for The Lockheed Martin Mechanical Engineering and Advanced Manufacturing Workshop , 7 May, 2014. Approved for Public Release.
National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST). Enabling the Digital Thread for Smart Manufacturing Project. Internet. June 1, 2015.
DIGITAL MANUFACTURING AND DESIGN INNOVATION INSTITUTE
NIST MBE 2017
4
Landers T, Bijan Y. Practical Implementation of Model-Based Systems Development. NDIA Annual Systems Engineering Conference. Springfield, VA. October 28-30, 2014. and INCOSE, 2016
EXISTING LOGISTICS STANDARDS FOR MBE INTEGRATION
Aerospace Industry Association S-Series Standards
INDUSTRY 4.0 SUSTAINMENT INTEGRATION
Connected supply chain optimization (CTMA/DLA Partners 2018)
Internet of Things (IoT) for life cycle/service management
Augmented/virtual/mixed reality (A/V/MR) for maintenance
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
INDUSTRY 4.0 AND A/V/MR
Digital Thread and Industry 4.0 (Don Kinard, NIST MBE Conference, 2018)
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
SUPPLY CHAIN AND MAINTENANCE USE CASES Virtual Subject Matter Expert (SME) – virtual SME can see what maintainer sees
Hands free maintenance - use case synergy with manufacturing ( as early as Hopps, AeroDef 2013)
Heads up work instructions— Work Instructions in AR/ MR, with 3D overlays and text that links to a server
TechAssist at DoD Maintenance Conference 2017
Smart Glasses and AR in Aerospace Manufacturing: Finding the Niche (Christi Fiorentini, AWE, 2016)
Aeronautics Global field service collaboration and travel reduction
Training and Logistics Solutions
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
Early design with Collaborative Human Immersive Lab (CHIL)
Applying Virtual Reality, and Augmented Reality to the Lifecycle Phases of Complex Products (Rabbitz and Crouch, 2017)
A/V/MR leveraging the Bill of Materials (BOM) across the lifecycle (Don Kinard, NIST MBE Conference, 2018)
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP
TECHNOLOGY TO IMPROVE SUSTAINMENT OF LEGACY
SYSTEMS
OSD Additive Manufacturing for Maintenance Operations (AMMO)
Collaboration on AM Business Model Wargames / Workshops
America Makes and Maturation of Advanced Manufacturing for Low-cost Sustainment (MAMLS) Phases I - III
AM Parts in New
Production Design for AM /
AM / Rapid Prototyping
Subtractive Manufactured / Replacement Part
Welding)
Mod/Upgrade)
Small Business /
SBIR
Depot
INDUSTRY USE CASES AND VALUE CHAIN Joint Staff Enterprise Development “JED” Talk June, 2015
25NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
OSD JOINT ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING WORKING GROUP (JAMWG) RELATED EFFORT
Kelly Visconti, Additive Manufacturing, OSD Perspectives, DoD Maintenance Conference, 2018
Project Managed by America Makes
26NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED CTMA/DLA PARTNERS 2018 MEETING
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
DATA AND MODEL SHARING
Initial Additive Manufacturing Sustainment Business Model Wargames 2016 at LM Center for Innovation, Suffolk, VA
Second Wargame at LM Global Vision Center (GVC), Crystal City, VA in 2017
2018 Workshop event at GVC included Working Group on Additive Manufacturing Model Exchange and Blockchain (see summary)
OSD JAMWG co-sponsoring 4th event June 18-19, 2019 at GVC with Working Groups aligned with Stakeholder Councils including Data and Model Sharing (Register)
AGILITY AND AFFORDABILITY CHALLENGE
Tech insertion mods and upgrades for enhanced capability
Defect/reliability/maintainability root cause analysis
Acquisition reform research (UMD)
SUPPORTING ADAPTIVE ACQUISITION CONCEPTS Capability
DevelopmentA
USD (R&E) - Mission Engineering - Rapid Prototyping - Technical Maturation - JROC Guidance
B Manufacturing Development
Production, Deployment and
- R&M feedback - Address DMSMS –
opportunity for tech / capability insertion
CONTINUOUS CAPABILITY
OPTIMIZATION
29NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED CTMA/DLA PARTNERS 2018 MEETING
SUPPLY INNOVATION PANEL
Integrate “sustainment thinking” throughout the Model Based Enterprise
Build models with the life cycle in mind with cybersecurity protections and configuration management / data management (CM/DM)
Leverage use cases in AM and MR to test MBE approaches for sustainment
Extend commercial best practices where possible for A&D domain
Sustainment Thinking
31NIST MBE 2019 © 2019 LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
ABSTRACT This presentation will highlight the importance of a model-based enterprise (MBE) to sustainment and across the life cycle. Model-based X where “X” is sustainment needs to be considered as part of the systems of systems engineering starting early in the life cycle. Computer-aided manufacturing, inspection tools, and approaches should be planned for use in sustainment to include repairs and ease of mods and upgrades to update capabilities. The complexity of managing the digital thread or tapestry is greater when sustainment is considered, with the need to linking and management the “as maintained” bill of materials for each delivered system. Application of data analytics and artificial intelligence (AI)/machine learning (ML) supports prognostics and health management and performance feedback. System of systems modeling methods that include application of the Affordable Systems Operational Effectiveness (ASOE) framework to help organize the sustainment considerations for both the primary and enabling systems to reduce life cycle costs and improve reliability and support return on investment (ROI) case studies. There are several opportunities for leveraging digital thread for sustainment as a concentration area. The first is application of augmented/virtual/mixed reality for maintenance opportunities and supported by global subject matter expert networks. The sustainment community pull for application of advanced manufacturing approaches to include additive manufacturing also relies on distributed access to technical data packages to support manufacturing at the point of need for parts that can be printed. A third focus area is on acquisition reform focus on capability management for legacy systems to meet the challenges of the National Defense Strategy. Systems designed with standards-based architectures and interfaces can support lower cost and more agile modifications and upgrades of both hardware and software in a system.
Integrating Sustainment Throughout the Model-Based Enterprise
Agenda
Affordability: Total Ownership Cost Focus
Context and USAGE Modeling As Part of MBE
Designing for a Maintenance Free Operating Period
Slide Number 7
Slide Number 8
Slide Number 10
Digital Tapestry and Shared Data Perspectives: Integrated Data Management AS PART OF MBE
Digital Thread: Overview and Introduction to Exhibit Aircraft Airworthiness and Sustainment Conference, Brench Boden, May 23, 2017
Use of DTw to Inform Mx Planning
Today’s Institute Evolution: DMDII to MxD
Slide Number 16
Slide Number 17
Industry 4.0 Sustainment Integration
Slide Number 26
