Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

download Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

of 72

Transcript of Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    1/72

    4

    AFFB^DUABF YFABF XHB_IOBD_E ?;4;

    Ugi Affbvdtabf Yfabf's pirnbrjdfhi shbriobdre nbr _isidrhg dfe Affbvdtabf4 Niorudry ?;44

    Ugi AYX ripbrt, ats dffixis dfe tgi afeahdtbrs edtdodsi dri dvda`do`i dtgttp

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    2/72

    ?

    ?;4; AFFB^DUABF YFABF XHB_IOBD_E

    4. Ixihutavi sujjdry .......................................................................................8

    ?. Aftrbeuhtabf .................................................................................................3

    8. Affbvdtabf Yfabf Xhbriobdre< Nafeafcs nbr Jijoir Xtdtis ..................................1

    8.4. Affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi...........................................................................1

    8.?. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi .............................................................................4;

    8.8. Affbvdtabf eajifsabfs........................................................................... 4?

    5. Hbjpdrasbf bn IY?3 affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi watg miy oifhgjdrm hbuftrais ........ 45

    5.4. D hbjpdrasbf bn tgi Jijoir Xtdtis watg btgir Iurbpidf hbuftrais.............. 45

    5.?. D hbjpdrasbf watg tgi YX, Ldpdf dfe O_AH hbuftrais................................. 45

    5.8. D hbjpdrasbf oitwiif tgi YX dfe Ldpdf .................................................?4

    9. Affbvdtabf af [uo`ah Xirvahis......................................................................... ??

    >. Hbuftry prbna is ..........................................................................................?8

    3. Uihgfahd` Dffix..........................................................................................97

    3.4. Hd`hu`dtafc hbjpbsati shbris .................................................................. 97

    3.?. Hd`hu`dtafc crbwtg rdtis ........................................................................ 91

    Dffixis ...........................................................................................................>;

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    3/72

    8

    4. IWIHYUA^I XYJJD_Q

    D fiw eipdrt

    Ugas as tginarst ieatabf bn tgi Affbvdtabf Yfabf Xhbriobdre (AYX). Odsie bf tgi privabus

    Iurbpidf Affbvdtabf Xhbriobdre, tgi fiw tbb` as jidft tb gi`p jbfatbr tgiajp`ijiftdtabf bn tgi Iurbpi ?;?; Affbvdtabf Yfabf4 n`dcsgap oy prbvaeafc dhbjpdrdtavi dssissjift bn tgi affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi bn tgi IY?3 Jijoir Xtdtis dfe

    tgi ri`dtavi strifctgs dfe widmfissis bn tgiar risidrhg dfe affbvdtabf systijs.

    Ugi nbrjir `ast bn ?1 afeahdtbrs af tgi AYX ?;;1 gds oiif rip`dhie watg d fiw `ast bn ?9afeahdtbrs?, wgahg oittir hdpturi tgi pirnbrjdfhi bn fdtabfd` risidrhg dfe affbvdtabfsystijs hbfsaeirie ds d wgb`i. 41 bn tgi privabus ?1 afeahdtbrs gdvi oiif hdrraie bvir

    nrbj `dst yidrs ieatabf, bn wgahg 4? afeahdtbrs gdvi fbt oiif hgdfcie, ? afeahdtbrs gdvioiif jircie, dfe 9 afeahdtbrs gdvi oiif pdrt`y hgdfcie oy usafc orbdeir br fdrrbwireinafatabfs br eannirift eifbjafdtbrs. Udmafc aftb dhhbuft tgi jircafc bn ? afeahdtbrs, 47afeahdtbrs bn tgi AYX ?;4; dri iquavd`ift tb tgbsi bn tgi IAX ?;;1 dfe af deeatabf 3 fiw

    afeahdtbrs gdvi oiif aftrbeuhie. Dffix I afh`ueis d hbjpdrdtavi tdo`i watg tgi twb sitsbn afeahdtbrs.

    Sga`i sbji bn tgi afeahdtbrs bn tgi AYX (suhg ds puo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi) hdf oi jbriidsa`y afn`uifhie oy pb`ahy aftirviftabf tgdf btgirs (suhg ds XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi),

    tgi bvird`` djoatabf bn tgi Affbvdtabf Yfabf Xhbriobdre as tb afnbrj pb`ahy eashussabfs dtfdtabfd` dfe IY `ivi`, oy trdhmafc prbcriss af affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi watgaf dfe butsaeitgi IY bvir taji.

    Ugi AYX usis tgi jbst rihift stdtastahs nrbj Iurbstdt dfe btgir aftirfdtabfd``yrihbcfasie sburhis ds dvda`do`i dt tgi taji bn dfd`ysas. Aftirfdtabfd` sburhis gdvi oiifusie wgirivir pbssao`i af breir tb ajprbvi hbjpdrdoa`aty oitwiif hbuftrais. At asajpbrtdft tb fbti tgdt tgi edtd ri`dtis tb dhtud` pirnbrjdfhi af ?;;3 (5 afeahdtbrs),?;;7 (4; afeahdtbrs) dfe ?;;1 (4; afeahdtbrs). Ds d hbfsiquifhi tgi AYX ?;4; jdy fbtnu``y hdpturi tgi pbssao`i ajpdht bn tgi ihbfbjah dfe nafdfhad` hrasas bf affbvdtabf

    pirnbrjdfhi. Edtd nbr afeahdtbr 8.4.8 Gacg-crbwtg affbvdtavi iftirprasis ds dpirhiftdci bn d`` iftirprasis as fbt sunnahaift`y dvda`do`i yit dfe tgirinbri bf`y ?5 bn tgi?9 afeahdtbrs gdvi oiif usie af prbeuhafc tgi hbjpbsati affbvdtabf afeahdtbr.

    Ugi AYX ?;4; afh`ueis affbvdtabf afeahdtbrs dfe trife dfd`ysis nbr tgi IY?3 JijoirXtdtis, ds wi`` ds nbr Hrbdtad, Ahi`dfe, tgi Nbrjir Qucbs`dv _ipuo`ah bn Jdhiebfad,

    Fbrwdy, Xiroad, Xwatzir`dfe dfe Uurmiy. At d`sb afh`ueis hbjpdrasbfs odsie bf d jbririeuhie sit bn afeahdtbrs oitwiif tgi IY?3, tgi YX, Ldpdf dfe tgi O_AH (Ordza`, _ussad,Afead dfe Hgafd) hbuftrais.

    4Xii gttp

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    4/72

    5

    NACY_I 4;;

    ;.3;;

    ;.7;;

    @^ OC @U _B XM [@ GY JU C_ IX H\ AU [U II XA HQ IY N_ @Y AI F@ DU OI YM EI NA EM XI

    JBEIXU AFFB^DUB_X JBEI_DUI AFFB^DUB_X AFFB^DUABF NB@@BSI_X AFFB^DUABF @IDEI_X

    Fbti< Dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi as jidsurie usafc d hbjpbsati afeahdtbr oua`eafc bf edtd nbr ?5 afeahdtbrs cbafcnrbj d `bwist pbssao`i pirnbrjdfhi bn ; tb d jdxajuj pbssao`i pirnbrjdfhi bn 4. Dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi af?;4; rin`ihts pirnbrjdfhi af ?;;7/?;;1 eui tb d `dc af edtd dvda`doa`aty.

    Ugi pirnbrjdfhi bn Affbvdtabf `ideirs as ?;% br jbri dobvi tgdt bn tgi IY?3= bn Affbvdtabf nb``bwirs at as

    `iss tgdf ?;% dobvi out jbri tgdf 4;% oi`bw tgdt bn tgi IY?3= bn Jbeirdti affbvdtbrs at as `iss tgdf 4;%oi`bw out jbri tgdf 9;% oi`bw tgdt bn tgi IY?3= dfe nbr Jbeist affbvdtbrs at as oi`bw 9;% tgdt bn tgi IY?3.

    [irnbrjdfhi crbups

    Ugi jdaf nafeafcs bn tgi AYX ?;4; dri afeahdtbrs, afh`ueafc [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis dfe

    [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis.

    Ugi YX affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi rin`ihts df affbvdtabf systij hgdrdhtirasie oy cbbe

    `ivi`s bn tirtadry ieuhdtabf, cbbe `afmdcis oitwiif tgi puo`ah shaifhi systij dfe tgipravdti sihtbr, strbfc pravdti afvistjift af _&E dfe d suhhissnu` hbjjirhad`asdtabf bntihgfb`bcahd` mfbw`ieci.

    @iss jdrmie, out fbt eihridsafc iatgir as tgi pirnbrjdfhi `ide bn Ldpdf bvir tgi IY?3.Ldpdfs pirnbrjdfhi as h`idr`y dgide af Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi dfe as crbwafc ndstirtgdf tgi IY af tgas nai`e.

    Hbjpdrie tb Hgafd dfe Ordza`, tgi IY sta`` gds d h`idr affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi `ide.Odsie bf d hbjjbf sit bn 4? afeahdtbrs, tgas `ide, gbwivir, as eih`afafc ndst.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    6/72

    >

    NACY_I ? 59 5> 57 51

    -?;

    ;

    ?;

    5;

    >;

    7;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Ldpdf

    8? 8> 5; 81 5;

    -?;

    ;

    ?;

    5;

    >;

    7;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Ordza`

    ->4 ->; ->; -97 -97-1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Hgafd

    ->4 ->; -91 -93 -99

    -1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Afead

    -9? -94 -9? -9? -98

    -1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    _ussad

    -84 -89 -83 -83 -83

    -1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    [irnbrjdfhi as jidsurie ds 4;;*(W/IY)-4) wgiri W rinirs tb tgi vd`ui nbr tgi afeahdtbr nbr tgi hbuftry W dfeIY tb tgi vd`ui nbr tgi afeahdtbr nbr tgi IY?3. Ugi vd`uis af tgi crdpgs sgbu`e oi aftirpritie ds tgi ri`dtavi

    pirnbrjdfhi hbjpdrie tb tgdt bn tgi IY?3. I.c. tgi YX af ?;4; as pirnbrjafc 51% oittir tgdf tgi IY?3dfe Hgafd as ?;4; as pirnbrjafc 99% wbrsi tgdf tgi IY?3.

    Xpihad` tgiji< [uo`ah sihtbr affbvdtabf

    [uo`ah sihtbr affbvdtabf as d suoliht wgahg as dttrdhtafc afhridsafc pb`ahy dttiftabf. Afpripdrdtabf nbr tgi nbrtghbjafc Iurbpidf [uo`ah Xihtbr Affbvdtabf Xhbriobdre tgi ?;4;

    Affbodrbjitir wds eieahdtie tb puo`ah sihtbr affbvdtabf. Ugi surviy, hbfeuhtie djbfc5;;; Iurbpidf brcdfasdtabfs af puo`ah dejafastrdtabf, sgbws tgdt affbvdtabf af puo`ahsirvahis as waeispride (sii sihtabf 9). Satgaf Iurbpi, twb but bn tgrii brcdfasdtabfsdhtavi af puo`ah dejafastrdtabf aftrbeuhie d fiw br sacfanahdft`y ajprbvie sirvahi af tgi

    `dst 8 yidrs. Affbvdtabfs ajprbvie tgi wbrm bn puo`ah dejafastrdtabfs dfe tgi ripbrtiepbsatavi innihts bn affbvdtabf afh`ueie ajprbvie usir dhhiss tb afnbrjdtabf, ajprbvieusir sdtasndhtabf, jbri tdrcitie sirvahis, ndstir ei`aviry bn sirvahis, sajp`anaiedejafastrdtabf dfe ajprbvie wbrmafc hbfeatabfs br ijp`byii sdtasndhtabf.

    Ugi surviy sgbws tgdt safc`i jbst ajpbrtdft eravir bn affbvdtabf af tgi puo`ah sihtbr

    wds tgi aftrbeuhtabf bn fiw `dws dfe ricu`dtabfs, watg 57% bn rispbfeifts dt tgi IY`ivi` afeahdtafc tgdt tgas wds d viry ajpbrtdft ndhtbr. D`sb, tgi `ami`agbbe bn sirvahiaffbvdtabf afhridsie `afidr`y watg tgi sazi bn tgi afstatutabf.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    7/72

    3

    ?. AFU_BEYHUABF

    Ugi AYX ?;4; `drci`y nb``bws tgi jitgbeb`bcy bn privabus ieatabfs af eastafcuasgafcoitwiif 8 jdaf typis bn afeahdtbrs dfe 7 affbvdtabf eajifsabfs, hdpturafc af tbtd` ?9eannirift afeahdtbrs.

    Ugi Ifdo`irshdpturi tgi jdaf eravirs bn affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi ixtirfd` tb tgi narjdfe at eanniriftadtis oitwiif 8 affbvdtabf eajifsabfs. Ugi Gujdf risburhis eajifsabf

    afh`ueis 8 afeahdtbrs dfe jidsuris tgi dvda`doa`aty bn d gacg-sma``ie dfe ieuhdtiewbrmnbrhi. Ugi fiw Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs eajifsabf afh`ueis8 afeahdtbrs dfe jidsuris tgi aftirfdtabfd` hbjpitatavifiss bn tgi shaifhi odsi. UgiNafdfhi dfe suppbrt eajifsabf afh`ueis ? afeahdtbrs dfe jidsuris tgi dvda`doa`aty bn

    nafdfhi nbr affbvdtabf prblihts dfe tgi suppbrt bn cbvirfjifts nbr risidrhg dfeaffbvdtabf dhtavatais.

    Narj dhtavatais hdpturi tgi affbvdtabf innbrts dt tgi `ivi` bn tgi narj dfe ateanniriftadtis oitwiif 8 affbvdtabf eajifsabfs. Ugi Narj afvistjifts eajifsabf

    afh`ueis ? afeahdtbrs bn obtg _&E dfe fbf-_&E afvistjifts tgdt narjs jdmi af breir tbcifirdti affbvdtabfs. Ugi @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap eajifsabf afh`ueis 8 afeahdtbrsdfe jidsuris iftriprifiurad` innbrts dfe hb``dobrdtabf innbrts djbfc affbvdtafc narjsdfe d`sb watg tgi puo`ah sihtbr. Ugi Afti``ihtud` dssits eajifsabf hdpturis eannirift

    nbrjs bn Afti``ihtud` [rbpirty _acgts (A[_) cifirdtie ds d tgrbucgput af tgi affbvdtabfprbhiss.

    Butputshdpturi tgi innihts bn narjs affbvdtabf dhtavatais dfe at eanniriftadtis oitwiif ?affbvdtabf eajifsabfs. Ugi Affbvdtbrs eajifsabf afh`ueis 8 afeahdtbrs dfe jidsuris tgifujoir bn narjs tgdt gdvi aftrbeuhie affbvdtabfs bftb tgi jdrmit br watgaf tgiarbrcdfasdtabfs, hbvirafc obtg tihgfb`bcahd` dfe fbf-tihgfb`bcahd` affbvdtabfs dfe tgiprisifhi bn gacg-crbwtg narjs. Ugi afeahdtbr bf affbvdtavi gacg-crbwtg narjs

    hbrrispbfes tb tgi fiw IY?;?; gide`afi afeahdtbr, wgahg wa`` oi hbjp`itie watgaf tgifixt twb yidrs. Ugi Ihbfbjah innihts eajifsabf afh`ueis 9 afeahdtbrs dfe hdpturis tgiihbfbjah suhhiss bn affbvdtabf af ijp`byjift, ixpbrts dfe sd`is eui tb affbvdtabf

    dhtavatais.

    Ugi afeahdtbrs afh`ueie af idhg bn tgi eajifsabfs dri `astie af Udo`i 4 dfe einafatabfs dri

    prisiftie af Dffix H. Ugi AYX ?;4; Jitgbeb`bcy ripbrt prbvaeis jbri eitda`ie

    eashussabfs nbr idhg bn tgi afeahdtbrs.

    UDO@I 4) pir 4;;; pbpu`dtabf dcie?9-85

    Iurbstdt ?;;5 ?;;7

    4.4.? [irhiftdci pbpu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 gdvafc hbjp`itie tirtadryieuhdtabf

    Iurbstdt ?;;9 ?;;1

    4.4.8 [irhiftdci ybutg dcie ?;-?5 gdvafc dttdafie dt `idst uppirsihbfedry `ivi` ieuhdtabf

    Iurbstdt ?;;9 ?;;1

    Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs

    4.?.4 Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb-puo`ahdtabfs pir ja``abf pbpu`dtabfXhaifhi Jitrax /Xhbpus

    ?;;5 ?;;7

    4.?.? Xhaiftanah puo`ahdtabfs djbfc tgi tbp 4;% jbst hatie

    puo`ahdtabfs wbr`ewaei ds % bn tbtd` shaiftanah puo`ahdtabfs bn tgihbuftry

    Xhaifhi Jitrax /Xhbpus

    ?;;8 ?;;3

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebhtbrdti stueifts8ds d % bn d`` ebhtbrdti stueifts Iurbstdt ?;;8 ?;;3

    8Nbr fbf-IY hbuftrais tgi afeahdtbr jidsuris tgi sgdri bn fbf-ebjistah ebhtbrd` stueifts.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    8/72

    7

    Jdaf typi / affbvdtabf eajifsabf / afeahdtbr Edtd sburhi_inirifhiyidr(s)

    Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt

    4.8.4 [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis ds % bn CE[ Iurbstdt ?;;9 - ?;;1

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdpatd` (idr`y stdci, ixpdfsabf dfe rip`dhijift) ds %bn CE[

    Iurbstdt ?;;9 - ?;;1

    NA_J DHUA^AUAIX

    Narj afvistjifts?.4.4 Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis ds % bn CE[ Iurbstdt ?;;9 - ?;;1

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affbvdtabf ixpifeaturis ds % bn turfbvir Iurbstdt?;;5, ?;;>,?;;7

    @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap

    ?.?.4 XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi ds % bn XJIs Iurbstdt?;;5, ?;;>,

    ?;;7

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJIs hb``dobrdtafc watg btgirs ds % bn XJIs Iurbstdt?;;5, ?;;>,?;;7

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs pir ja``abf pbpu`dtabfHSUX /Ugbjsbf

    _iutirs

    ?;;5 ?;;7

    Afti``ihtud` dssits

    ?.8.4 [HU pdtifts dpp`ahdtabfs pir oa``abf CE[ (af [[X) Iurbstdt ?;;8 ?;;3

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis pir oa``abf CE[ (af

    [[X) (h`ajdti hgdfci jatacdtabf= gid`tg) BIHE / Iurbstdt ?;;8 ?;;3

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms pir oa``abf CE[ (af [[X) BGAJ / Iurbstdt ?;;9 ?;;1

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs pir oa``abf CE[ (af [[X) BGAJ / Iurbstdt ?;;9 ?;;1

    BYU[YUX

    Affbvdtbrs

    8.4.4 XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs ds % bn XJIs Iurbstdt?;;5, ?;;>,?;;7

    8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs ds %bn XJIs

    Iurbstdt?;;5, ?;;>,?;;7

    8.4.8 Gacg-crbwtg affbvdtavi narjs F/D F/D

    Ihbfbjah innihts

    8.?.4 Ijp`byjift af mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi dhtavatais (jdfundhturafcdfe sirvahis) ds % bn tbtd` ijp`byjift

    Iurbstdt ?;;7, ?;;1

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe gacg-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts ds % tbtd` prbeuht

    ixpbrts YF / Iurbstdt ?;;9 ?;;1

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts ds % tbtd` sirvahi ixpbrts YF / Iurbstdt ?;;5 ?;;7

    8.?.5 Xd`is bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs ds % bnturfbvir

    Iurbstdt ?;;5 ?;;7

    8.?.9 @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrbj dorbde ds % bn CE[ Iurbstdt ?;;9 - ?;;1

    Ugi AYX usis tgi jbst rihift stdtastahs nrbj Iurbstdt dfe btgir aftirfdtabfd``y

    rihbcfasie sburhis ds dvda`do`i dt tgi taji bn dfd`ysas. Aftirfdtabfd` sburhis gdvi oiifusie wgirivir pbssao`i af breir tb ajprbvi hbjpdrdoa`aty oitwiif hbuftrais. At asajpbrtdft tb fbti tgdt tgi edtd ri`dtis tb dhtud` pirnbrjdfhi af ?;;3 (5 afeahdtbrs),

    ?;;7 (4; afeahdtbrs) dfe ?;;1 (4; afeahdtbrs). Ds d hbfsiquifhi tgi AYX ?;4; ebis fbthdpturi tgi jbst rihift hgdfcis af affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi br tgi ajpdht bn pb`ahaisaftrbeuhie af rihift yidrs wgahg jdy tdmi sbji taji tb ajpdht bf affbvdtabfpirnbrjdfhi. Fbr ebis at nu``y hdpturi tgi ajpdht bn tgi nafdfhad` hrasas bf affbvdtabf

    pirnbrjdfhi.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    9/72

    1

    8. AFFB^DUABF YFABF XHB_IOBD_E

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    10/72

    4;

    8.?.Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi

    Ugi crbwtg af affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi gds oiif hd`hu`dtie nbr idhg hbuftry dfe nbr tgiIY?3 usafc edtd bvir d navi-yidr pirabe5. Ugas hd`hu`dtabf as odsie bf dosb`uti hgdfcisaf tgi afeahdtbrs. D`` hbuftrais ixhipt @atgudfad9sgbw df dosb`uti ajprbvijift af tgiaffbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi bvir taji (Nacuri 5). [brtucd` gds ixpiraifhie tgi ndstist

    crbwtg af pirnbrjdfhi.

    Satgaf tgi nbur aeiftanaie hbuftry crbups crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi as viry eannirift dfe Udo`i? aeiftanais tgi crbwtg `ideirs watgaf idhg crbup. Satgaf tgi Affbvdtabf `ideirs, Naf`dfedfe Cirjdfy dri tgi crbwtg `ideirs. Istbfad dfe X`bvifad dri tgi crbwtg `ideirs bn tgiAffbvdtabf nb``bwirs. Bn tgi Jbeirdti affbvdtbrs d`` hbuftrais gdvi crbwf ndstir tgdf

    tgi IY?3. Ugi crbwtg `ideirs giri dri Jd`td dfe [brtucd`. Jbst bn tgi Jbeistaffbvdtbrs gdvi crbwf dt d ndstir pdhi tgdf tgi IY?3, bf`y @atgudfad gds ixpiraifhie d

    oi`bw dvirdci crbwtg. Ou`cdrad dfe _bjdfad dri tgi crbwtg `ideirs bn tgi Jbeistaffbvdtbrs.

    NACY_I 5;;

    ;.>9;

    ;.3;;

    ;.39;

    ;.7;;

    ;.79;

    -4.;% ;.;% 4.;% ?.;% 8.;% 5.;% 9.;% >.;% 3.;% 7.;% 1.;%

    Dvirdci dffud` cr bw tg af affbvdtabf pir nbr jdfhi

    Affbvdtabfpirnbrjdfhi

    Hb`bur hbeafc jdthgis tgi crbups bn hbuftrais aeiftanaie af Xihtabf 8.4. Dvirdci dffud` crbwtg rdtis dshd`hu`dtie bvir d navi-yidr pirabe. Ugi ebttie `afis sgbw IY?3 pirnbrjdfhi dfe crbwtg.

    Ugi dvirdci crbwtg rdtis nbr tgi nbur hbuftry crbups (Udo`i ?) sgbw tgdt tgiri asoitwiif crbup hbfvircifhi watg tgi Affbvdtabf nb``bwirs crbwafc dt d ndstir rdti tgdf

    tgi Affbvdtabf `ideirs dfe tgi Jbeirdti affbvdtbrs crbwafc ndstir tgdf tgi Affbvdtabf

    5Ugi jitgbeb`bcy nbr hd`hu`dtafc crbwtg rdtis as orain`y eishraoie af Xihtabf 3.? dfe af jbri eitda` af tgi AYX

    ?;4; Jitgbeb`bcy ripbrt.9Ugi hgdfci af tgi crbwtg trife bn affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi nbr @atgudfad watg rispiht tb tgi vd`ui ripbrtie af?;;1 as eui tb d hbjoafdtabf bn ndhtbrs, afh`ueafc tgi erbp bn afeahdtbrs bf [ravdti hrieat dfe Orbdeodfe

    pifitrdtabf, tgi rieinafatabf bn afeahdtbrs bf Uirtadry ieuhdtabf dfe Hbjjufaty eisacfs, tgi rieinafatabf bn tgiafeahdtbr bf UO[ n`bws aftb tgi afeahdtbr @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrbj dorbde dfe edtd upedtis bf

    afeahdtbrs suhg ds Affbvdtavi XJIs hb``dobrdtafc watg btgirs dfe Xd`is bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narjaffbvdtabfs.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    11/72

    44

    nb``bwirs. Ugi Jbeist affbvdtbrs gbwivir crbw dt d s`bwir rdti tgdf tgi Jbeirdtiaffbvdtbrs, af pdrtahu`dr eui tb tgi `dccafc crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi bn @atgudfad.

    Ugi bvird`` prbhiss bn hdthgafc-up tgdt nb``bws nrbj Nacuri 5 as d`sb hbfnarjie oy tgirisu`ts nbr oitd dfe sacjd hbfvircifhi (hn. Dffix C). @iss affbvdtavi hbuftrais tife tbcrbw ndstir tgdf jbri affbvdtavi hbuftrais dfe tgi spride af affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi as

    eihridsafc.

    Ugi dvirdci dffud` crbwtg rdti bn tgi IY?3 as ;.79% bvir d navi yidr pirabe. Crbwtg aspdrtahu`dr`y strbfc af Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs dfe Afti``ihtud`dssits (Nacuri 9). [irnbrjdfhi gds wbrsifie af Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt, Narj afvistjiftsdfe Affbvdtbrs.

    UDO@I ?% Naf`dfe (NA), Cirjdfy (EI) Eifjdrm (EM), Xwieif(XI)

    Affbvdtabfnb``bwirs

    ?.>% Istbfad (II), X`bvifad (XA) Dustrad (DU), Oi`cauj (OI),Nrdfhi (N_), Ari`dfe (AI),

    @uxijoburc (@Y),Fitgir`dfes (F@)

    Hyprus (HQ), YfatieMafcebj (YM)

    Jbeirdtiaffbvdtbrs

    8.9% Jd`td (JU), [brtucd` ([U) Hzihg _ipuo`ah (H\),

    Criihi (C_), Gufcdry (GY),

    Atd`y (AU), [b`dfe ([@),

    X`bvdmad (XM), Xpdaf (IX)

    Jbeistaffbvdtbrs

    8.8% Ou`cdrad (OC), _bjdfad(_B)

    @dtvad (@^) @atgudfad (@U)

    Dvirdci dffud` crbwtg rdtis ds hd`hu`dtie bvir d navi-yidr pirabe.

    NACY_I 9.;% -8.;% ;.;% 8.;% >.;% 1.;% 4?.;%

    GYJDF _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtab f dcie 8;-85 hbj p`itie tirtadry ieuhdtab f

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdt abfB[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJX

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtabfs

    4.?.? Ub p 4;% jbst hatie s haiftanah puo`ahdtabfs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti st ueiftsNAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ifturi h dpatd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFUX?.4.4Ous afiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fb f-_&E affbvdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[_IF IY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi?.?.? Affbv dtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ DXXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtab fs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbj jufaty trdeijdrms?.8.5 Hb jjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X8.4.4XJ Is aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbh iss affbvdtab fs

    8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc b r brcdfasdtab fd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi D htavat ais8.?.? Jieauj dfe G acg-tihg jdfundhturafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfb w`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd`is bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbv dtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis n rbj dorbde

    Ugi sgdeie drid cavis tgi dvirdci crbwtg rdti nbr tgi IY?3 nbr d`` afeahdtbrs.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    12/72

    4?

    Nbr tgi afeavaeud` afeahdtbrs wi bosirvi gacg crbwtg nbr [bpu`dtabf watg hbjp`itietirtadry ieuhdtabf, Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb-puo`ahdtabfs dfe Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms. Dgacg ficdtavi crbwtg rdti as bosirvie nbr Fbf-_&E affbvdtabf ixpifeaturi dfe, tb d

    `issir ixtift, nbr ^ifturi hdpatd`, XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi, XJIs watg prbeuht brprbhiss affbvdtabfs dfe XJIs watg jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs. Bn tgisi 9afeahdtbrs watg d strbfc ficdtavi crbwtg 5 afeahdtbrs dri eiravie nrbj tgi HbjjufatyAffbvdtabf Xurviy.

    Ugi dvirdci IY crbwtg rdti as `bw hbjpdrie tb tgdt bn jbst Jijoir Xtdtis. Nacuri ?rivid`s tgdt bf`y 9 Jijoir Xtdtis dri crbwafc dt d `bwir pdhi dfe tgdt ?? Jijoir

    Xtdtis dri crbwafc ndstir tgdf tgi IY?3. Ugi stdtastahd` ixp`dfdtabf nbr tgas as tgdt bn`drci fujoirs< wgiri afeavaeud` hbuftrais hdf botdaf ri`dtavi`y gacg crbwtg rdtis nbrsafc`i afeahdtbrs, tgas as ndr `iss `ami`y nbr tgi IY?3 ds at as tgi dccricdti bn ?3 Jijoir

    Xtdtis, wgiri gacg crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi bf d safc`i afeahdtbr oy sbji Jijoir Xtdtis aspdrtad``y br hbjp`iti`y bnnsit oy `bw br ficdtavi crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi bf tgi sdjiafeahdtbr oy btgir Jijoir Xtdtis>.

    8.8.Affbvdtabf eajifsabfs

    Ugi pirnbrjdfhi bn tgi nbur hbuftry crbups dhrbss tgi eannirift eajifsabfs as sgbwf af

    Nacuri >. Ugi Affbvdtabf `ideirs dfe tgi Affbvdtabf nb``bwirs gdvi tgi sjd``ist vdradfhiaf tgiar pirnbrjdfhi dhrbss tgi 7 eajifsabfs, succistafc tgdt tb dhgaivi d gacg `ivi` bnpirnbrjdfhi hbuftrais fiie tb pirnbrj ri`dtavi`y wi`` dhrbss d`` 7 eajifsabfs.

    NACY_I >Ugas as d`sb hbfnarjie oy tgi ndht tgdt tgi dvirdci rdti bn easpirsabf af afeahdtbr crbwtg rdtis nbr tgi IY?3(8.9%) as wi`` oi`bw tgi dvirdci rdti bn easpirsabf nbr tgi Jijoir Xtdtis (7.7%).

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    13/72

    48

    Narj afvistjifts dfe Ihbfbjah innihts dfe `drcist af Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavirisidrhg systijs, Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt dfe @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap.

    NACY_I 3;;.7;

    4.;;

    J U _ B IX AU @^ GY [U OC C_ H\ @Y II IY XM DU [@ HQ XA EI @U F@ EM OI N_ YM AI NA XI

    Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs

    ;.;;;.?;;.5;;.>;;.7;4.;;

    @^ @U _B XM [@ OC J U GY H\ C_ II AU HQ XA [U IY IX EI @Y NA DU N_ AI XI YM OI EM F@

    Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt

    ;.;;;.?;;.5;;.>;

    ;.7;4.;;

    J U XM @^ HQ C_ _B OC GY [@ H\ AI AU DU IX @U [U XA OI IY EI @Y N_ II EM YM F@ NA XI

    Narj afvistjifts

    ;.;;;.?;;.5;;.>;;.7;4.;;

    C_ XM @U IX OC AU F@ @Y GY [U J U @^ [@ _B N_ OI IY XA H\ HQ YM AI DU EM II NA EI XI

    @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap

    ;.;;;.?;;.5;;.>;;.7;4.;;

    @^ _B OC [@ XM GY J U @U IX AU H\ C_ [U IY N_ AI @Y XA F@ EI DU II HQ NA YM OI XI EM

    Afti``ihtud` dssits

    ;.;;;.?;;.5;;.>;;.7;4.;;

    _B @U C_ XM OC H\ GY [@ @^ HQ II [U IX XA J U YM AI N_ AU OI IY @Y NA F@ DU EI XI EM

    Affbvdtbrs

    ;.;;;.?;;.5;

    ;.>;;.7;4.;;

    @^ [@ GY O C _B @U XM J U YM IX F@ AI XA N_ IY NA AU EM XI II H\ DU C_ OI HQ [U @Y EI

    Ihbfbjah innihts

    ;.;;;.?;;.5;;.>;;.7;4.;;

    @U @^ OC [@ [U II _B AU XM DU F@ IX C_ XA OI IY HQ N_ H\ XI GY YM @Y NA EM EI AI J U

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    14/72

    45

    5. HBJ[D_AXBF BN IY?3AFFB^DUABF [I_NB_JDFHI SAUG MIQ OIFHGJD_M HBYFU_AIX

    Ugas sihtabf wa`` nbhus bf d hbjpdrasbf watg fbf-IY Jijoir Xtdtis, stdrtafc watg dhbjpdrasbf watg btgir Iurbpidf hbuftrais af sihtabf 5.4 dfe watg tgi YX, Ldpdf dfe tgiO_AH (Ordza`, Hgafd, Afead dfe _ussad) hbuftrais af sihtabf 5.?. Xihtabf 5.8 wa`` eashuss deariht hbjpdrasbf oitwiif tgi YX dfe Ldpdf.

    5.4.D hbjpdrasbf bn tgi Jijoir Xtdtis watg btgir Iurbpidf hbuftrais

    Edtd as dvda`do`i nbr sivif jbri fbf-IY Iurbpidf hbuftrais tb pirnbrj d hbjpdrasbfwatg tgi Jijoir Xtdtis (Nacuri 7). Bn tgisi Xwatzir`dfe oi`bfcs tb tgi Affbvdtabf

    `ideirs, Ahi`dfe tb tgi Affbvdtabf nb``bwirs, Hrbdtad dfe Fbrwdy tb tgi Jbeirdtiaffbvdtbrs dfe tgi Nbrjir Qucbs`dv _ipuo`ah bn Jdhiebfad, Xiroad dfe Uurmiy tb tgiJbeist affbvdtbrs.

    Xwatzir`dfe as tgi bvird`` affbvdtabf `ideir, butpirnbrjafc d`` Jijoir Xtdtis. Ats crbwtgpirnbrjdfhi as d`sb dobvi tgi IY-?3, watg 8.7% af tgi `dst navi yidrs. Nbr Ahi`dfe dfe

    Fbrwdy, crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi as h`bsi tb 4.8%.

    Nbr Hrbdtad Xiroad dfe Uurmiy crbwtg af affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi gds oiif oitwiif 8.9%

    dfe 5%, wi`` dobvi tgi IY?3 dvirdci af tgi sdji pirabe. Bf`y nbr tgi Nbrjir Qucbs`dv

    _ipuo`ah bn Jdhiebfad crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi as oi`bw tgdt bn tgi IY?3.

    NACY_I 7;;

    ;.3;;

    ;.7;;

    ;.1;;

    @^ U_OC@UJM_X_BXM[@ G_GYJUC_IXH\ AU [UFBII XA AX HQ IYN_@Y AI F@DUOIYMEI NA EM XIHG

    JBEIXU AFFB^DUB_X JBEI_DUI AFFB^DUB_X AFFB^DUABF NB@@BSI_X AFFB^DUABF @IDEI_X

    Fbti< Dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi as jidsurie usafc d hbjpbsati afeahdtbr oua`eafc bf edtd nbr ?5 afeahdtbrs cbafcnrbj d `bwist pbssao`i pirnbrjdfhi bn ; tb d jdxajuj pbssao`i pirnbrjdfhi bn 4. Dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi af

    ?;4; rin`ihts pirnbrjdfhi af ?;;7/?;;1 eui tb d `dc af edtd dvda`doa`aty.

    5.?.D hbjpdrasbf watg tgi YX, Ldpdf dfe O_AH hbuftraisNbr jdaf hbjpitatbrs ds tgi YX, Ldpdf dfe tgi O_AH hbuftrais (Ordza`, Hgafd, Afead dfe

    _ussad) edtd dvda`doa`aty as jbri `ajatie tgdf nbr tgi fbf-IY Jijoir Xtdtis.Nurtgirjbri, tgi ihbfbjah dfe/br pbpu`dtabf sazi bn tgisi hbuftrais butwiacgs tgbsi bntgi afeavaeud` Jijoir Xtdtis dfe at as tgus rihbjjifeie tb hbjpdri tgisi hbuftrais

    watg tgi dccricdti bn tgi Jijoir Xtdtis br tgi IY?3.

    Nbr tgi aftirfdtabfd` hbjpdrasbf bn tgi IY?3 watg tgisi hbuftrais d jbri ristrahtie sit

    bn up tb 4? afeahdtbrs as usie bn wgahg jbst dri fidr`y aeiftahd` tb tgbsi bn tgi AYX(Udo`i 8). Ugi AYX afeahdtbr jidsurafc tgi sgdri bn tgi pbpu`dtabf dcie 8; tb 85 gdvafc

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    15/72

    49

    hbjp`itie tirtadry ieuhdtabf gds oiif rip`dhie oy tgi sdji afeahdtbr out nbr tgi dcicrbup ?9 tb >5.

    UDO@I 8) pir 4;;;pbpu`dtabf dcie ?9-85

    BIHE / Iurbstdt ?;;7 HF, AF

    4.4.? [irhiftdci pbpu`dtabf dcie ?9->5gdvafc hbjp`itietirtadry ieuhdtabf

    BIHE / Iurbstdt /fdtabfd` sburhis

    ?;;7

    Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs

    4.?.4 Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb-puo`ahdtabfs pir ja``abfpbpu`dtabf

    Xhaifhi Jitrax /Xhbpus

    ?;;7 O_, AF, _Y

    4.?.? Xhaiftanah puo`ahdtabfs djbfc tgi tbp 4;% jbst hatiepuo`ahdtabfs wbr`ewaei ds % bn tbtd` shaiftanah puo`ahdtabfsbn tgi hbuftry

    Xhaifhi Jitrax /

    Xhbpus?;;3

    Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt

    4.8.4 [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis ds % bn CE[BIHE / Iurbstdt /

    fdtabfd` sburhis ?;;7

    NA_J DHUA^AUAIX

    Narj afvistjifts

    ?.4.4 Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis ds % bn CE[BIHE / Iurbstdt /fdtabfd` sburhis

    ?;;7

    @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs pir ja``abf pbpu`dtabfHSUX / Ugbjsbf_iutirs

    ?;;7

    Afti``ihtud` dssits

    ?.8.4 [HU pdtifts dpp`ahdtabfs pir oa``abf CE[ (af [[X) BIHE / Iurbstdt ?;;3

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis pir

    oa``abf CE[ (af [[X) (h`ajdti hgdfci jatacdtabf= gid`tg)BIHE / Iurbstdt ?;;3

    BYU[YUX

    Affbvdtbrs

    Ihbfbjah innihts

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe gacg-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts ds % tbtd`prbeuht ixpbrts

    YF / Iurbstdt ?;;7

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts ds % tbtd`sirvahi ixpbrts

    YF / Iurbstdt ?;;7

    8.?.9 @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrbj dorbde ds % bnCE[

    Sbr`eOdfm /Iurbstdt

    ?;;7

    Nacuri 1 sujjdrazis tgi eivi`bpjift bn tgi pirnbrjdfhi `ide br cdp oitwiif dfe idhgbn tgisi hbuftrais bvir d 9 yidr pirabe. Nbr obtg tgi YX dfe Ldpdf affbvdtabf

    pirnbrjdfhi as wi`` dobvi tgdt bn tgi IY?3. Eispati sbji yidr`y n`uhtudtabfs, tgisipirnbrjdfhi `ides gdvi rijdafie jbri br `iss stdo`i.

    Ugi risu`ts af Nacuri 1 d`sb sgbw tgdt tgi IY?3 gds d strbfc `ide hbjpdrie tb idhg bntgi O_AH hbuftrais. Ugi pirnbrjdfhi `ide tbwdres Afead gds rijdafie stdo`i bvir tgi`dst 9 yidrs dfe tgdt tbwdres _ussad gds s`acgt`y afhridsie. Hgafd dfe Ordza` dri obtghdthgafc-up tbwdres tgi IY?3 wgiri tgi rdti bn ri`dtavi ajprbvijift nbr Ordza` as jbri

    jbeist tgdf tgdt nbr Hgafd.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    16/72

    4>

    NACY_I 1 59 5> 57 51

    -?;

    ;

    ?;

    5;

    >;

    7;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Ldpdf

    8? 8> 5; 81 5;

    -?;

    ;

    ?;

    5;

    >;

    7;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Ordza`

    ->4 ->; ->; -97 -97-1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Hgafd

    ->4 ->; -91 -93 -99

    -1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    Afead

    -9? -94 -9? -9? -98

    -1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    _ussad

    -84 -89 -83 -83 -83

    -1;

    ->;

    -8;

    ;

    8;

    "?;;>" "?;;3" "?;;7" "?;;1" "?;4;"

    [irnbrjdfhi as jidsurie ds 4;;*(W/IY)-4) wgiri W rinirs tb tgi vd`ui nbr tgi afeahdtbr nbr tgi hbuftry W dfeIY tb tgi vd`ui nbr tgi afeahdtbr nbr tgi IY?3. Ugi vd`uis af tgi crdpgs sgbu`e oi aftirpritie ds tgi ri`dtavi

    pirnbrjdfhi hbjpdrie tb tgdt bn tgi IY?3. I.c. tgi YX af ?;4; as pirnbrjafc 51% oittir tgdf tgi IY?3dfe Hgafd as ?;4; as pirnbrjafc 99% wbrsi tgdf tgi IY?3.

    Ugi YX as pirnbrjafc oittir tgdf tgi IY?3 af 4; afeahdtbrs (Nacuri 4;). Af [uo`ah _&E

    ixpifeaturi dfe Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts tgi IY?3 as pirnbrjafc oittir.Bvird`` tgiri as d h`idr pirnbrjdfhi `ide af ndvbur bn tgi YX dfe tgas `ide as viry s`bw`yafhridsafc. Ugi YX gds afhridsie ats `ide af Fiw ebhtbrdti eicriis, Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs, Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi dfe @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis. Ugi YX `ide tbtgi IY?3 gds eihridsie af Uirtadry ieuhdtabf, Jbst hatie puo`ahdtabfs, [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs, [HU pdtifts, [HU pdtifts af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis dfe Ixpbrts bn jieauj-

    gacg dfe gacg-tihg prbeuhts. Ugi IY?3 gds afhridsie ats `ide tb tgi YX af [uo`ah _&Eixpifeaturi dfe Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    17/72

    43

    NACY_I 4;

    -48

    -4>

    ???

    ?9

    7

    51

    >4

    15

    83

    >1

    59

    -9; ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9;

    HBYFU_Q D ^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi

    Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` hgd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Hgdfci pirnbrjdfhi `ide YX

    3.9%

    9.5%

    4.?%

    >.7%

    -;.4%

    -?.7%

    -5.4%

    -4.?%

    -4.8%

    -9.>%

    -?.4%

    -4.?%

    ;.4%

    -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;%

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _ &E ixpifeaturis

    Ous afiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    @int< Ugi afeahdtbrs gacg`acgtie af brdfci rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi cdp nbr tgi IY?3= tgbsi gacg`acgtie af criif

    rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi `ide nbr tgi IY?3. _acgt< _i`dtavi crbwtg hbjpdrie tb tgdt bn tgi IY?3. Brdfcihb`burie odrs sbw tgdt tgi hbuftry as crbwafc ndstir tgdf tgi IY?3= criif hb`burie odrs sgbw tgdt tgi hbuftryas crbwafc s`bwir tgdf tgi IY?3.

    Ldpdf as pirnbrjafc oittir tgdf tgi IY?3 af 3 afeahdtbrs (Nacuri 44). Af Fiw ebhtbrdtieicriis, Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs, Jbst hatie puo`ahdtabfs, [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturidfe Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts tgi IY?3 as pirnbrjafc oittir. Bvird`` tgiri asd h`idr pirnbrjdfhi `ide af ndvbur bn Ldpdf dfe tgas affbvdtabf `ide as afhridsafc. Ldpdf

    gds afhridsie ats `ide af Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi, [HU pdtifts dfe @ahifsi dfe pdtiftrivifuis. Ugi Ldpdfisi `ide tb tgi IY?3 gds eihridsie af Uirtadry ieuhdtabf, [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs, [HU pdtifts af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis dfe Ixpbrts bn jieauj-gacgdfe gacg-tihg prbeuhts. Ugi IY?3 gds afhridsie ats `ide af Jbst hatie puo`ahdtabfs,[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi dfe Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts dfe ixpiraifhie d

    eih`afi af ats `ide af Fiw ebhtbrdti eicriis dfe Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs.

    NACY_I 44

    3>

    -?1

    -88

    -1

    449

    9>

    4;7

    89

    97

    -84

    4>7

    5;

    -9; ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;;

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    Jb st hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi

    Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Hgdfci pirnbrjdfhi `ide Ldpdf

    8.;%

    8.4%

    ;.1%

    9.1%

    44.;%

    -;.?%

    -4.1%

    -5.>%

    -?.>%

    -4.1%

    -4.5%

    -4.4%

    ;.7%

    -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;% 49%

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _ &E ixpifeaturis

    Ous afiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    @int< Ugi afeahdtbrs gacg`acgtie af brdfci rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi cdp nbr tgi IY?3= tgbsi gacg`acgtie af criifrin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi `ide nbr tgi IY?3. _acgt< _i`dtavi crbwtg hbjpdrie tb tgdt bn tgi IY?3. Brdfci

    hb`burie odrs sbw tgdt tgi hbuftry as crbwafc ndstir tgdf tgi IY?3= criif hb`burie odrs sgbw tgdt tgi hbuftryas crbwafc s`bwir tgdf tgi IY?3.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    18/72

    47

    Ugi IY?3 as pirnbrjafc oittir tgdf Ordza` af jbst afeahdtbrs (Nacuri 4?). Af Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts Ordza` as pirnbrjafc oittir. Bvird`` tgiri as d h`idrpirnbrjdfhi `ide af ndvbur bn tgi IY?3. Out tgas `ide as eih`afafc, ds Ordza`s affbvdtabf

    pirnbrjdfhi gds crbwf dt d ndstir rdti tgdf bn tgi IY?3. Ordza` gds oiif eihridsafc tgipirnbrjdfhi cdp af ds jdfy ds 3 afeahdtbrs (Fiw ebhtbrdti eicriis, Jbst hatiepuo`ahdtabfs, [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi, Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi, [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs, [HU pdtifts dfe @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis), dfe gds oiif afhridsafc ats

    `ide af Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts. Ugi IY?3 gds afhridsie ats `ide af Uirtadryieuhdtabf, [HU pdtifts af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis dfe Ixpbrts bn jieauj-gacg dfe gacg-tihgprbeuhts.

    NACY_I 4?8

    -9>

    -?5

    ->;

    -19

    -14

    -1?

    -43

    4?

    -79

    -9 7

    -49; -4;; -9; ; 9;

    HBYFU_Q D ^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi

    Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` hgd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Hgdfci pirnbrjdfhi cdp Ordza`

    ?.;%

    4.9%

    4.4%?.>%

    4>.?%

    9.8%

    9.;%

    48.4%

    -?.3%

    -?.9%

    -8.5%

    8.8%

    -4;% ;% 4;% ?;%

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _ &E ixpifeaturis

    Ous afiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Fb edtd nbr Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs nbr Ordza`. @int< Ugi afeahdtbrs gacg`acgtie af brdfci rin`iht dpirnbrjdfhi cdp nbr tgi IY?3= tgbsi gacg`acgtie af criif rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi `ide nbr tgi IY?3. _acgt% ?5%

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _ &E ixpifeaturis

    Ous afiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Fb edtd nbr Fiw ebhtbrdti eicriis nbr Hgafd. @int< Ugi afeahdtbrs gacg`acgtie af brdfci rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi

    cdp nbr tgi IY?3= tgbsi gacg`acgtie af criif rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi `ide nbr tgi IY?3. _acgt< _i`dtavi crbwtghbjpdrie tb tgdt bn tgi IY?3. Brdfci hb`burie odrs sbw tgdt tgi hbuftry as crbwafc ndstir tgdf tgi IY?3=criif hb`burie odrs sgbw tgdt tgi hbuftry as crbwafc s`bwir tgdf tgi IY?3.

    Ugi IY?3 as pirnbrjafc oittir tgdf Afead af jbst afeahdtbrs (Nacuri 45). Af Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts Afead as pirnbrjafc oittir. Bvird`` tgiri as d h`idrpirnbrjdfhi `ide af ndvbur bn tgi IY?3. Out tgas `ide as eih`afafc, ds Afeads affbvdtabfpirnbrjdfhi gds crbwf dt d ndstir rdti tgdf bn tgi IY?3. Afead gds oiif eihridsafc tgi

    pirnbrjdfhi cdp af 5 afeahdtbrs (Jbst hatie puo`ahdtabfs, Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi,[uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs dfe @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis) dfe gds ixpiraifhie deihridsi af ats pirnbrjdfhi `ide af Ixpbrts bn jieauj-gacg dfe gacg-tihg prbeuhts dfeMfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts. Ugi IY?3 gds afhridsie ats `ide af Uirtadryieuhdtabf, [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi, [HU pdtifts dfe [HU pdtifts af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis.

    NACY_I 45

    -3;

    -17

    -77-7;

    4?

    >9

    -19

    -9 8

    -49; -4;; -9; ; 9; 4;;

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    Jb st hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi

    Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtiftsXbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Hgdfci pirnbrjdfhi cdp Afead

    1.9%

    9.7%

    45.4%

    5.9%

    -?.3%

    -1.;%

    -5.4%

    -3.7%

    -;.3%

    -;.4%

    ;.3%

    -49% -9% 9% 49%

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _ &E ixpifeaturis

    Ous afiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Fb edtd nbr Fiw ebhtbrdti eicriis dfe Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs nbr Afead. @int< Ugi afeahdtbrs gacg`acgtie

    af brdfci rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi cdp nbr tgi IY?3= tgbsi gacg`acgtie af criif rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi `ide nbr tgiIY?3. _acgt< _i`dtavi crbwtg hbjpdrie tb tgdt bn tgi IY?3. Brdfci hb`burie odrs sbw tgdt tgi hbuftry ascrbwafc ndstir tgdf tgi IY?3= criif hb`burie odrs sgbw tgdt tgi hbuftry as crbwafc s`bwir tgdf tgi IY?3.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    20/72

    ?;

    Ugi IY?3 as pirnbrjafc oittir tgdf _ussad af jbst afeahdtbrs (Nacuri 49). Af Fiwebhtbrdti eicriis dfe Uirtadry ieuhdtabf _ussad as pirnbrjafc oittir. Bvird`` tgiri as dh`idr pirnbrjdfhi `ide af ndvbur bn tgi IY?3 dfe tgas `ide as afhridsafc, ds _ussadsaffbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi gds crbwf dt d s`bwir rdti tgdf bn tgi IY?3. _ussad gds oiif

    eihridsafc tgi pirnbrjdfhi cdp af ? afeahdtbrs ([HU pdtifts af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis dfe

    Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahis ixpbrts) dfe siif d eihridsi af ats `ide af Fiw ebhtbrdtieicriis dfe Uirtadry ieuhdtabf. Bf`y af Ixpbrts bn jieauj-gacg dfe gacg-tihg prbeuhtsgds _ussad afhridsie ats `ide. Ugi IY?3 gds afhridsie ats `ide af tgi btgir > afeahdtbrs

    nbr wgahg edtd dri dvda`do`i.

    NACY_I 49

    -8 >

    -49; -4;; -9; ; 9; 4;; 49;

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    Jb st hatie puo`ahdtabfs[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi

    Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Hgdfci pirnbrjdfhi cdp _ussad

    8.8%

    ?.4%

    4.1%

    -9.8%

    -?.8%

    -8.4%

    -4.8%

    ->.7%

    -4.?%

    -?.?%

    -3.1%

    -?.?%

    -4;% -9% ;% 9%

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _ &E ixpifeaturis

    Ous afiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` h gd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Fb edtd nbr Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs nbr _ussad. @int< Ugi afeahdtbrs gacg`acgtie af brdfci rin`iht dpirnbrjdfhi cdp nbr tgi IY?3= tgbsi gacg`acgtie af criif rin`iht d pirnbrjdfhi `ide nbr tgi IY?3. _acgt sgbws tgi hurriftpirnbrjdfhi `ide br cdp bf tgivirtahd` dxas dfe tgi hgdfci aftgas `ide br cdp bf tgi virtahd`

    dxas. Nrbj Nacuri 4> at oihbjish`idr tgdt Ordza` dfe Hgafd dri

    h`idr`y hdthgafc-up tb tgi IY?3,tgdt Afeads as bf`y s`bw`yhdthgafc-up, tgdt _ussad as ndhiewatg df afhridsafc cdp tb tgiIY?3 dfe tgi IY?3 as fiatgirhdthgafc-up tb tgi YX fbr tbLdpdf.

    NACY_I 4>;

    -5;

    -?;

    ;

    ?;

    5;

    >;

    -5.;% -?.;% ;.;% ?.;% 5.;% >.;% 7.;%

    Dvirdci dffud` crbwtg rdti bn

    pirnbrjdfhi `ide/cdp

    [irnbrjdf

    hi`ide/cdptbIY?3

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    21/72

    ?4

    5.8.D hbjpdrasbf oitwiif tgi YX dfe Ldpdf

    Obtg tgi YX dfe Ldpdf dri tgi c`bod` affbvdtabf `ideirs. D eariht hbjpdrasbf oitwiiftgisi twb hbuftrais sgbws tgdt Ldpdf as jdrcafd``y `dccafc oigafe tgi YX (Nacuri 43).Ugi YX as pirnbrjafc oittir af 3 afeahdtbrs, af pdrtahu`dr af Fiw ebhtbrdti eicriis,Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb-puo`ahdtabfs dfe Jbst hatie puo`ahdtabfs. Ldpdf as pirnbrjafc

    oittir af 9 afeahdtbrs, af pdrtahu`dr af [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs.

    Bvird`` tgiri as d pirnbrjdfhi `ide af ndvbur bn tgi YX out tgas `ide as eihridsafc, dsLdpdfs affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi gds crbwf dt d ndstir rdti tgdf bn tgi YX. Ugi YX gdsafhridsie ats `ide af Fiw ebhtbrdti eicriis, Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs dfe [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs dfe gds eihridsie ats cdp af Uirtadry ieuhdtabf, [uo`ah _&E

    ixpifeaturi dfe Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi. Ldpdf gds afhridsie ats `ide af [HU pdtiftsdfe Ixpbrts bn jieauj-gacg dfe gacg-tihg prbeuhts dfe gds eihridsie ats cdp af Jbst

    hatie puo`ahdtabfs, [HU pdtifts af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis, Mfbw`ieci-aftifsavi sirvahisixpbrts dfe @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis.

    NACY_I 43

    -43

    -4;; -9; ; 9; 4;; 49;

    HBYFU_Q D ^I_DCI

    Fiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturi

    Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturi

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` hgd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    Affbvdtabf crbwtg

    ;.1%

    3.8%

    8.1%

    ;.>%

    ;.4%

    8.1%

    -5.?%

    -;.4%

    -?.?%

    -;.>%

    -;.8%

    -4.5%

    ;.>%

    -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;%

    HBYFU_Q D^I_DCIFiw ebhtb rdti eicriis

    Uirtadry ieuhdtabf

    Aftirfdtabfd` hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    J bst hatie puo`ahdtabfs

    [uo`ah _ &E ixpifeaturis

    Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    [uo`ah-pravdti hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    [HU pdtifts

    Xbhaitd` hgd``ifcis

    J ie/ga-tihg prbeuht ixpbrts

    Mfbw`ieci-aft. sirv. ixpbrts

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis

    @int< Ficdtavi vd`uis (odrs gacg`acgtie af criif) afeahdti tgdt YX pirnbrjdfhi as gacgir tgdf tgdt bn Ldpdf=pbsatavi vd`uis (odrs gacg`acgtie af brdfci) afeahdti tgdt Ldpdfs pirnbrjdfhi as oittir tgdf tgdt bn tgi YX.

    _acgt< _i`dtavi crbwtg bn Ldpdf hbjpdrie tb tgi YX. Brdfci hb`burie odrs sbw tgdt Ldpdf as crbwafc ndstirtgdf tgi Ys= criif hb`burie odrs sgbw tgdt tgi YX as crbwafc ndstir tgdf Ldpdf.

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    22/72

    ??

    9. AFFB^DUABF AF [YO@AH XI_^AHIX

    Af ats Affbvdtabf Yfabf Hbjjufahdtabf bn Bhtboir ?;4;, tgi Iurbpidf Hbjjassabfdffbufhie ats aftiftabf tb pa`bt d Iurbpidf [uo`ah Xihtbr Affbvdtabf Xhbriobdre ds dodsas tb stdrt oifhgjdrmafc puo`ah sihtbr affbvdtabf. Af pripdrdtabf nbr tgas wbrm, tgi?;4; Affbodrbjitir wds eieahdtie tb puo`ah sihtbr affbvdtabf. Ugi surviy djbfc 5;;;

    Iurbpidf brcdfasdtabfs af puo`ah dejafastrdtabf3sgbws tgdt affbvdtabf af puo`ah sirvahis

    as waeispride. Satgaf Iurbpi, twb but bn tgrii brcdfasdtabfs dhtavi af puo`ahdejafastrdtabf aftrbeuhie d fiw br sacfanahdft`y ajprbvie sirvahi af tgi `dst 8 yidrs.

    Ugi jdaf nafeafcs nrbj tgi Affbodrbjitir ?;4; surviy dri. HBYFU_Q [_BNA@IX

    Af tgas sihtabf nbr idhg hbuftry d jbri eitda`ie hbuftry prbna`i as sgbwf gacg`acgtafc nbridhg hbuftrys ri`dtavi strifctgs dfe widmfissis af affbvdtabf pirnbrjdfhi dfe atsjdaf eravirs bn affbvdtabf crbwtg. Nbr idhg hbuftry eitda`ie edtd tdo`is dri dvda`do`inrbj tgi AFFB Jitrahs wiosati (gttp

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    24/72

    ?5

    4;;

    48;

    4;>

    81;

    4??

    18

    784?7

    4;>

    7;

    488

    411

    43;

    15

    11

    444

    7;

    4?1

    448

    4;9

    4;9

    78

    3?

    ?59

    ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9; 8;; 89; 5;; 59;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU _DHU A^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ub p 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdt i stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg b tgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrbeuh afc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtab fd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbv dtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    OI@CAYJ

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Oi`caujas bfi bn tgi affbvdtabf nb``bwirs watg df dobvi dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Gujdf risburhis, Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhgsystijs dfe @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap. _i`dtavi widmfissis dri af Narj afvistjifts,Afti``ihtud` dssits dfe Butputs.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr ^ifturi hdpatd` dfe Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms. D strbfc

    eih`afi as bosirvie nbr Fbf-_&E affbvdtabf ixpifeaturi, Hbjjufaty eisacfs dfe Xd`isbn fiw prbeuhts. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Gujdf risburhis, Bpif, ixhi``ift dfedttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs, Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt, @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap dfeAfti``ihtud` dssits as dobvi dvirdci. Af tgi btgir eajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    ?.;%

    >.?%4.7%

    ;.9%

    7.4%

    8.7%

    -4.8%

    ?.>%

    ?5.9%

    4.5%

    -45.4%

    -4.>%

    3.9%

    8.5%

    5.5%

    4.4%

    47.>%-3.1%

    -4.>%

    -;.3%

    -;.>%;.4%

    -4.>%

    -3.5%>.7%

    -?;% -49% -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;% 49% ?;% ?9% 8;%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdt abf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie shaiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdt i stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdpatd`

    NA_J AF IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prb hiss affbv dtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundhturafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    OI@CAYJ

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    25/72

    ?9

    8>

    7>

    4;>

    34

    84

    ?;

    57?3

    48

    485

    9>

    84

    >

    4;

    >

    38

    83

    >4

    55

    >9

    99

    58

    4;3

    4;

    ; ?; 5; >; 7; 4;; 4?; 45; 4>;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrbeuh afc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdt abfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    OY@CD_AD

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Ou`cdradas bfi bn tgi jbeist affbvdtbrs watg d oi`bw dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Gujdf risburhis. _i`dtavi widmfissis dri af @afmdcis &iftriprifiursgap, Afti``ihtud` dssits dfe Affbvdtbrs.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms dfe Hbjjufaty eisacfs. D strbfceih`afi as bosirvie nbr [HU pdtifts af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af

    @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap dfe Afti``ihtud` dssits as dobvi dvirdci. Af tgi btgireajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    >.?%

    48.>%?.1%

    ?.8%

    9.8%

    3.8%

    -5.;%

    ;.;%

    1.9%

    4?.9%

    1.1%

    8.4%

    ?.3%

    ?;.9%

    ->.4%

    -??.3%

    57.8%?>.?%

    7.>%

    9.4%

    ;.7%5.4%

    1.;%

    8.?%?.9%

    -5;% -8;% -?;% -4;% ;% 4;% ?;% 8;% 5;% 9;% >;%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUGGYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtabf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbv dtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is h b``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is b n fiw tb j drmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    OY@CD_AD

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    26/72

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    27/72

    ?3

    445

    451

    71

    571

    483

    38

    48?31

    4>?

    3?

    489

    ?;8

    854

    ?;4

    5?8

    48;

    4>7

    44;

    4;?

    44>

    73

    489

    7>

    855

    ; 4;; ?;; 8;; 5;; 9;; >;;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie shaift anah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF IXUJIFUX

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJ Is affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJ Is aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrbeuh afc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtab fd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    EIFJD_M

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Eifjdrmas bfi bn tgi affbvdtabf `ideirs watg df dobvi dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs, @afmdcis &iftriprifiursgap dfe Afti``ihtud` dssits. _i`dtavi widmfissis dri af Nafdfhi dfesuppbrt, Affbvdtbrs dfe Butputs.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Fiw ebhtbrdti crdeudtis dfe Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms. D

    strbfc eih`afi as bosirvie nbr ^ifturi hdpatd` dfe XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc brbrcdfazdtabfd` affbvdtabfs. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Gujdf risburhis, Bpif, ixhi``iftdfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs, @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap dfe Afti``ihtud` dssits as

    dobvi dvirdci. Af tgi btgir eajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    ;.5%

    1.7%?.7%

    -;.?%

    3.9%

    ;.;%

    -;.9%

    >.7%

    -47.1%

    8.5%

    -8.>%

    ;.;%

    ?.?%

    ?.5%

    4.8%

    8.?%

    1.7%-8.7%

    -5.5%

    -4;.>%

    ;.9%-;.3%

    ;.9%

    4.;%9.;%

    -?9% -?;% -49% -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;% 49%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtabf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbv dtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is h b``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is b n fiw tb j drmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    EIFJD_M

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    28/72

    ?7

    47>

    14

    15

    ??4

    444

    4?;94

    495

    4?5

    49?

    7;

    483

    418

    49>

    489

    4>>

    493

    435

    444

    484

    447

    484

    414

    F/D

    ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrb euhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    CI_JDFQ

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Cirjdfyas bfi bn tgi affbvdtabf `ideirs watg df dobvi dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Afti``ihtud` dssits, Affbvdtbrs dfe Butputs. _i`dtaviwidmfissis dri af Gujdf risburhis, Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt dfe @afmdcis &iftriprifiursgap.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms. D strbfc eih`afi as bosirvie nbr

    Fbf-_&E affbvdtabf ixpifeaturi. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Gujdf risburhis, Bpif,ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs dfe Afti``ihtud` dssits as dobvi dvirdci. Aftgi btgir eajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    ?.>%

    5.8%8.4%

    ;.7%

    >.8%

    5.8%

    4.>%

    ?.7%

    -5.7%

    -;.4%

    4.;%

    ?.3%

    ;.>%

    ?.3%4?.8%

    8.9%

    -;.8%

    8.9%

    ;.>%-4.3%

    8.4%

    -;.8%4?.7%

    F/D

    ?.7%

    -7% ->% -5% -?% ;% ?% 5% >% 7% 4;% 4?% 45%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtabf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbv dtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is h b``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is b n fiw tb j drmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    CI_JDFQ

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    29/72

    ?1

    93

    444

    4;9

    479

    34

    1

    4;4

    94

    ?9;

    44?

    ?;;

    98

    9;

    9>

    1?

    87

    4?7

    73

    78

    3?

    79

    33

    >4

    F/D

    ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9; 8;;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrb euhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    IXUBFAD

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Istbfad as bfi bn tgi affbvdtabf nb``bwirs watg d h`bsi tb dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Gujdf risburhis, Narj afvistjifts dfe @afmdcis &iftriprifiursgap. _i`dtavi widmfissis dri af Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhgsystijs, Afti``ihtud` dssits dfe Butputs.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms, Hbjjufaty eisacfs dfe @ahifsi

    dfe pdtift rivifuis nrbj dorbde. D ri`dtavi`y strbfc eih`afi as bosirvie nbr Fiwebhtbrdti stueifts dfe XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfazdtabfd` affbvdtabfs.Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs dfe Afti``ihtud`

    dssits as dobvi dvirdci. Af tgi btgir eajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    >.>%

    -3.3%5.4%

    -;.4%

    4;.3%

    >.4%

    48.3%

    44.4%

    4.8%

    -5.?%

    7.3%

    43.9%

    >.8%

    ?.;%

    84.5%8;.1%

    -4.5%

    -3.>%

    ?.;%-8.7%

    >.?%

    -8.7%?1.7%

    F/D

    44.;%

    -49% -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;% 49% ?;% ?9% 8;% 89%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdt abf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie shaiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdt i stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdpatd`

    NA_J AF IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prb hiss affbv dtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbv dtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    IXUBFAD

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    30/72

    8;

    4;;

    49?

    444

    88>

    444

    7;?7

    15

    45?

    4?7

    77

    34

    >>

    447

    4;1

    57

    7;

    4;>

    459

    44;

    45>

    78

    859

    F/D

    ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9; 8;; 89; 5;;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrb euhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    A_I@DFE

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Ari`dfeas bfi bn tgi affbvdtabf nb``bwirs watg df dobvi dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Gujdf risburhis, Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhgsystijs dfe Butputs. _i`dtavi widmfissis dri af Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt, @afmdcis &iftriprifiursgap, Afti``ihtud` dssits dfe Affbvdtbrs.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms, Hbjjufaty eisacfs dfe @ahifsi

    dfe pdtift rivifuis nrbj dorbde. D strbfc eih`afi as bosirvie nbr XJIs aftrbeuhafcprbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Gujdf risburhis, Bpif,ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs, Afti``ihtud` dssits dfe Butputs as dobvi

    dvirdci. Af tgi btgir eajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    ?.9%

    >.?%9.3%

    ;.8%

    44.8%

    7.3%

    -4?.8%

    1.8%

    -5.>%

    -9.4%

    -4;.1%

    9.7%

    5.?%

    >.3%

    45.8%47.7%

    -45.;%

    ->.?%

    4.3%-;.8%

    ;.9%

    ?.4%43.7%

    F/D

    3.?%

    -?;% -49% -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;% 49% ?;% ?9%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdt abf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie shaiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdt i stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdpatd`

    NA_J AF IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prb hiss affbv dtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbv dtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    A_I@DFE

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    31/72

    84

    93

    7?

    4;9

    4>9

    74

    9

    991

    48

    4;5

    4;7

    441

    89

    44

    ?;

    8;

    3

    4;1

    484

    78

    >>

    449

    418

    3

    ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrb euhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    C_IIHI

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Criihias bfi bn tgi jbeirdti affbvdtbrs watg d oi`bw dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Gujdf risburhis, Affbvdtbrs dfe Butputs. _i`dtaviwidmfissis dri af Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt, Narj afvistjifts dfe Afti``ihtud` dssits.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr ^ifturi hdpatd`, Hbjjufaty eisacfs dfe Xd`is bn fiwprbeuhts. D ri`dtavi`y strbfc eih`afi as bosirvie nbr Fbf-_&E affbvdtabf ixpifeaturi dfe

    @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrbj dorbde. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Nafdfhi dfe suppbrtdfe Afti``ihtud` dssits as dobvi dvirdci. Af tgi btgir eajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    5.3%

    ;.;%4.?%

    -;.>%

    4;.?%

    >.3%

    ;.;%

    ;.>%

    51.9%

    -?.1%

    -49.1%

    -;.>%

    4?.?%

    5.5%

    ?.>%

    7.3%

    44.3%?5.9%

    4.1%

    8.;%

    ;.;%4.?%

    5.>%

    47.1%-48.?%

    -8;% -?;% -4;% ;% 4;% ?;% 8;% 5;% 9;% >;%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUGGYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtabf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbv dtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is h b``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is b n fiw tb j drmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    C_IIHI

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    32/72

    8?

    >5

    4??

    3>

    4>9

    77

    7>

    71>9

    97

    >5

    38

    57

    55

    8?

    53

    445

    34

    7;

    37

    73

    4;5

    4?;

    88

    F/D

    ; ?; 5; >; 7; 4;; 4?; 45; 4>; 47;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrb euhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    X[DAF

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Xpdafas bfi bn tgi jbeirdti affbvdtbrs watg d oi`bw dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af tgi afeahdtbr bf aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah puo`ahdtabfs dfe af tgieajifsabfs Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt dfe Butputs (ixhipt bf @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuisnrbj dorbde). _i`dtavi widmfissis dri af Narj afvistjifts, @afmdcis &iftriprifiursgap, Afti``ihtud` dssits dfe Affbvdtbrs.

    Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Aftirfdtabfd` hb-puo`ahdtabfs, Fbf-_&E affbvdtabfixpifeaturi, [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sbhaitd` hgd``ifcis dfe @ahifhi dfe pdtiftrivifuis nrbj dorbde). Ugi strbfcist eih`afi as bosirvie nbr ^ifturi hdpatd`. Crbwtg

    pirnbrjdfhi af Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs as dobvi dvirdci.Crbwtg af d`` afeahdtbrs ri`dtie tb Afti``ihtud` dssits as d`sb dobvi dvirdci ixhipt nbr

    Hbjjufaty eisacfs. Af tgi eajifsabfs @afmdcis dfe iftriprifiursgap, Affbvdtbrs dfeButputs, crbwtg af tgi afeavaeud` afeahdtbrs prisifts fb h`idr bvird`` trife.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    4.1%

    -5.1%;.9%

    -;.7%

    4;.?%

    3.;%

    5.>%

    >.9%

    -4?.?%

    5.3%

    44.9%

    -5.9%

    -4.>%

    9.8%

    >.3%

    4?.5%

    4.>%-3.3%

    -8.7%

    ;.3%

    ;.9%

    8.>%1.1%

    F/D

    -4.1%

    -?;% -49% -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;% 49%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtabf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis@AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbv dtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is h b``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is b n fiw tb j drmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    X[DAF

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    33/72

    88

    4;;

    485

    4;>

    ?4>

    13

    4>4

    4;74;9

    44;

    >>

    11

    4?4

    77

    1>

    75

    39

    7;

    15

    11

    4;8

    4?8

    >1

    4;;

    4>4

    ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrb euhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    N_DFHI

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Nrdfhias bfi bn tgi affbvdtabf nb``bwirs watg df dobvi dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Gujdf risburhis, Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhgsystijs, Nafdfhi dfe suppbrt dfe Butputs. _i`dtavi widmfissis dri af Narjafvistjifts, @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap, Afti``ihtud` dssits dfe Affbvdtbrs.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Fbf-_&E affbvdtabf ixpifeaturi, Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    dfe @ahifsi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrbj dorbde. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Bpif, ixhi``iftdfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs dfe Afti``ihtud` dssits as dobvi dvirdci. Af tgi btgireajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    ?.3%

    8.1%8.9%

    ;.4%

    >.5%

    8.8%

    8.8%

    4.8%

    8.>%

    4.8%

    7.3%

    4.5%

    5.;%

    ;.;%

    4.4%

    ?.;%4;.>%

    5.?%

    4.7%

    -4.3%

    ;.3%-;.9%

    ;.?%

    8.4%5.5%

    -5% -?% ;% ?% 5% >% 7% 4;% 4?%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtabf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbv dtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is h b``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is b n fiw tb j drmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    N_DFHI

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    34/72

    85

    445

    91

    13

    49>

    71

    ?4

    3355

    9?

    7>

    44?

    95

    93

    98

    9>

    15

    455

    4;7

    4;5

    4;?

    4;7

    3?

    71

    ?5

    ; ?; 5; >; 7; 4;; 4?; 45; 4>; 47;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtab f

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs

    4.?.? Ubp 4;% jbs t hat ie shaiftan ah puo`ahdtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fbf-IY ebht brdti st ueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis4.8.? ^ifturi hdpa td`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X

    ?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbvdtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is hb ``dobrdtafc watg bt girs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX

    ?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis

    ?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjj ufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht br prbhiss affbvdtabfs

    8.4.? XJ Is aftrb euhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd`

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundh turafc ixpbrts

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xdis bn fiw tb jdrmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtab fs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    AUD@Q

    Afeahdtbr vd`uis ri`dtavi tb tgi IY?3 (IY?3:4;;).

    Atd`yas bfi bn tgi jbeirdti affbvdtbrs watg d oi`bw dvirdci pirnbrjdfhi.

    _i`dtavi strifctgs dri af Afti``ihtud` dssits, Affbvdtbrs dfe Butputs. _i`dtaviwidmfissis dri af Narj afvistjifts dfe @afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap.Gacg crbwtg as bosirvie nbr Fiw ebhtbrdti crdeudtis, Fbf-IY ebhtbrd` stueifts dfeHbjjufaty trdeijdrms. D strbfc eih`afi as bosirvie nbr Fbf-_&E affbvdtabf

    ixpifeaturi. Crbwtg pirnbrjdfhi af Bpif, ixhi``ift dfe dttrdhtavi risidrhg systijs,@afmdcis & iftriprifiursgap dfe Afti``ihtud` dssits as dobvi dvirdci. Af tgi btgireajifsabfs at as oi`bw dvirdci.

    Dffud` dvirdci crbwtg pir afeahdtbr dfe dvirdci hbuftry crbwtg

    ?.3%

    4?.9%?.7%

    ;.1%

    3.5%

    8.7%

    45.?%

    ?.7%

    ?.9%

    5.8%

    -48.3%

    9.;%

    7.5%

    ;.>%

    8.7%

    8.1%4;.9%

    -?.8%

    4.9%

    ?.;%

    ;.;%;.4%

    8.4%

    -;.?%-9.4%

    -?;% -49% -4;% -9% ;% 9% 4;% 49% ?;%

    D^I_ DCI HBYFU_ Q C_BSUG

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirta dry ieuhdtabf

    4.4.8 Qbutg dcie ?;-?5 uppir sihb fedry ivi` ieuhdtabf

    B[IF, IWHI@@IFU, DUU_D HUA^I _IXID_HG XQXUIJ X

    4.?.4Aftirfdtabfd` shaiftanah hb -puo`ahdtab fs4.?.? Ubp 4;% jb st h atie sh aiftanah puo`ah dtab fs wbr`ewaei

    4.?.8 Fb f-IY ebhtb rdti stueifts

    NAFDFHI DFE XY[[B_U

    4.8.4[uo`ah _&E ixpifeaturis

    4.8.? ^ifturi hdp atd`

    NA_J AF^IXUJIFU X?.4.4Ousafiss _&E ixpifeaturis

    ?.4.? Fbf-_&E affb vdtab f ixpifeaturis

    @AFMDCIX & IFU_I[ _IFIY_XGA[

    ?.?.4XJIs affbv dtafc af-gbusi

    ?.?.? Affbvdtavi XJ Is h b``dobrdtafc watg btgirs

    ?.?.8 [uo`ah-pravdti shaiftnah hb-puo`ahdtabfs

    AFUI@@IHUYD@ D XXIUX?.8.4[HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs

    ?.8.? [HU pdtift dpp`ahdtabfs af sb haitd` hgd``ifcis?.8.8 Hbjjufaty trdeijdrms

    ?.8.5 Hbjjufaty eisacfs

    AFFB^DUB_X

    8.4.4XJIs aftrbeuhafc prbeuht b r prbhiss affbvdtabfs8.4.? XJIs aftrbeuhafc jdrmitafc br brcdfasdtabfd` affbvdtabfs

    IHBFBJAH INNIHUX

    8.?.4Ijp`byjift af Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Dhtavatais

    8.?.? Jieauj dfe Gacg-tihg jdfundht urafc ixpbrt s

    8.?.8 Mfbw`ieci-Aftifsavi Xirvahis ixpbrts

    8.?.5 Xd is b n fiw tb j drmit dfe fiw tb narj affbvdtabfs

    8.?.9 @ahifhi dfe pdtift rivifuis nrb j dorbde

    AUD@Q

  • 8/3/2019 Innovation Union Scoreboard 2010

    35/72

    89

    45

    487

    444

    ?95

    7>

    3

    5;

    7

    ?55

    483

    414

    ?8

    48

    7

    ?5>

    3

    4?5

    4?4

    4;7

    1;

    4;?

    4?4

    ?9

    F/D

    ; 9; 4;; 49; ?;; ?9; 8;;

    GYJD F _IXBY_HIX

    4.4.4Fiw ebh tb rdti crdeudtis

    4.4.? [b pu`dtabf dcie 8;-85 hb jp`itie tirt adry ieuh