Innovation from Disaster - FIG

45
Christchurch Earthquakes Sept 2010, Feb-Jun-Dec 2011, Present Maurice Perwick RP Surv – NZIS Accred Hydro Level 1 www.eliotsinclair.co.nz Innovation from Disaster

Transcript of Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Page 1: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Christchurch EarthquakesSept 2010, Feb-Jun-Dec 2011, Present

Maurice PerwickRP Surv – NZIS

Accred Hydro Level 1

www.eliotsinclair.co.nz

Innovation from Disaster

Presented at th

e FIG W

orking Week 2016,

May 2-6, 2

016 in Christchurch, N

ew Zealand

Page 2: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

CHRISTCHURCH,BANKS PENINSULA , LYTTELTON HARBOUR, WAIMAKARIRI DIST..

SITE CALIBRATION – COMBINED GEOID

MODEL & INCLINED PLANE

Page 3: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Global Approach

Modern Techniques & Equipment

Use of Geoid –Spheroid Correction

Models

National Geodetic datum & CORS

Stable and Reliable Ground

Monumentation

Archiving & Access to Data

Baseline & As-Built Surveys

Best Survey Practise

Page 4: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Christchurch

Area: Total 1,426 km2 (550.6 sq mi) [Urban 452 km2 (174.5 sq mi)]

Population: 390,000

Page 5: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

4 September 2010 Earthquake

Greendale Fault

● Minor liquefaction to CBD

● Parapet damage

● Exceeded SLS event

Fault Line

● Structural damage largely confined to unreinforced brick masonry buildings

● Extensive liquefaction across eastern suburbs, Kaiapoi, Halswell, and Tai Tapu

Page 6: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Christchurch Earthquake - Liquefaction

Land Failure !!

Page 7: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Flooding & Subsidence from

liquifaction everytime a big shake

Page 8: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Vectors - Displacements

Lyttelton Port

Page 9: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Eliot Sinclair and Partners Ltd – Christchurch NZ

Intense monitoring of Tank Farm & Wharf

Differential

settlement

Tilting

High manifold

pressures

Rock column

failure

Stress on

Pipework / flanges

Load Bearing

Reduced

Page 10: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Eliot Sinclair and Partners Ltd – Christchurch NZ

Tank Settlements

Page 11: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Christchurch Earthquake22-Feb-2011 12:51pm

Images and data sourced from:

LINZ, GNS, USGS, WIKI, many Private Photo Albums, WWW public forums

The Second One !

Page 12: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

HomeWork

2.2g Vt

1.88g

Peak Ground Acceleration

20 Minute Journey- 3 Hours !

Page 13: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

My way home – impassible – huge detours !

Bridges Closed or Dislocated from Carriageway

0.3m – 1.5m Vertically

Page 15: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Home Sweet Home

Everything Trashed !

No telephone ( 14 days) TXT &

Car Charger only

No Power (10 days )

No Fridge / Freezer

No local shops & super Market

No rubbish Collection

No Water ( six weeks )

No Sewer ( one month, spa water

to flush)

No washing (body & clothes)

Rain Water captured- Boiled

Spa water – body wash

Gas BBQ & Hob

Bottled water

Page 16: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Marine Embankments Failed

Cashin Quay Breakwater

Lyttelton Port of Christchurch

Page 17: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Land interfaces collapsed towards

the deeper water

Page 18: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Lateral forces from the hardstand push

the decking seaward

Page 19: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Oil Wharf - Lyttelton

Note how the

shore has migrated

seaward and

settled behind the

wharf

Wharf becomes

deformed !

Page 20: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Gear Recovery – Day 3 (25/2/2011)

Burglar (level 5)

Crossed Army Cordon

Braved darkness & Quakes

GPS, Levels, Total Stations

Data recorders, Laptops

Dismantle our CORS

Grab our Server

Pluck our Plotters

Page 21: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

‘Our Office’

Bob’s garage (North West Christchurch)

Laptops / internet

Governance by

Remote control

wearysome

Field gear allocated to vehicles

to limit travel ( fuel rationed)

Permits sought to access city /

port

Page 22: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Total Deformation Contours – 22 Feb 2011

Our surveys confirmed the modelling outcomes

Page 23: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Coal berth reconstruction & loading ships

Winching along berth and turning with tugs

Page 24: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Bush Carpenrty

at its Finest

Windy Point Monitoring station -

Lyttelton

Page 25: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Reconstruction Monitoring

Cashin Quay

Daylight surveys

15 Minute Cycle

Real-time Reporting

Crucial during Construction

Remote & stable Reference Marks

Hierarchy of Offset lines

Page 26: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

No. 7 Wharf- Seismic Isolation Joint

Provided RORO functionality

Page 27: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Tracked 360 prism

on staff for bottom

Sewage treatment Plant

Liquifaction (shallowing)

Raw Sewage into Ponds

(Loss of Volume)

Clarifiers suffered mechanical

failure and uplift

Profiles & contours showed

differences

RTK GNSS

& 500KHz

for sludge

Page 28: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Other Tasks

Golf Resort

Ocean Outfall

Inspections

Side Scan

Mapping - 3D

Page 29: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Redcliffs Seawall collapse

500 KHz E/S Bow mounted

Page 30: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Acknowledgements

Fellow staff at Eliot Sinclair

Sam Cech - Surveyor & IT (Tatras Consulting Ltd)

Warren Haynes - Senior Surveyor

John Aramowicz – Geotech Engineer

Others

Neil Mclennan – Lyttelton Port of Christchurch

Local Internet sites reporting earthquake events

EQC, EQR, GNS,LINZ,T&T

Page 31: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Preparedness is the Key

But Nothing can Prepare you !

Share the resources and knowledge !

Use Imagination and be Brave !

Infrastructure Dies

Telephone-internet- communications

Power Reticulation

Water supply

Sewage

Stormwater drainage (flooding)

Traffic Management (traffic Lights)

Roading Network – essential services

Bureaucracy goes crazy !! Permits !!!

Conclusion

Page 32: Innovation from Disaster - FIG
Page 33: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Dangerous goods route to port

blocked for foreseeable future

Page 34: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Masonary cladding, Tile roof, unsupported

ground slopes

Munted !

Page 35: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Rescuers really did risk their lives

with ongoing shocks at PGG

Page 36: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Pick up sticks !

Will it fall down?

Page 37: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Fire danger !

Page 38: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Triage in local parks

Page 39: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Walking home thru the rubble !

Page 40: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

CDB

Destroyed !

Page 41: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Suburban perils

Page 42: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Eliot Sinclair and Partners Ltd – Christchurch NZ

Dust & liquifaction

Buildings & facards collapsed

Page 43: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Transport routes

severely affected

Page 44: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Eastern suburbs are flooded after Christchurch, New Zealand, was

hit by a 6.3 magnitude earthquake.

Page 45: Innovation from Disaster - FIG

Eliot Sinclair and Partners Ltd – Christchurch NZ