RISE OF CHRISTIANITY. ESSENTIAL QUESTION Where did Christianity start?
INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
-
Upload
nayeli-amezcua -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
1/45
Japanese Journa l o f Re l i g i ous St ud i es 12 /1
INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY
IN A J A P A NE S E R U R A L C OMMUNI T Y
NISHIYAMA Shigeru
T HE P R OB L E M A ND T HE F R A ME O F A NA L Y S I S
The resul t s to dat e of s t udies on t he i ndi geni zat i on and
t r ansf ormat i on of Chr i st i ani t y in J apanese rural communi t i es canbe s ummar i zed in t wo t heses an indigenization thesis and a
transformation thesis. The indigenization thesis runs as follows
despite being a religion that as a matter of principle emphasizes
individual confession of faith and individual membership,
Chr i st i ani t y, in order t o establ ish it sel f in J apanese soci et y, has
had t o beco me a rel igi on t hat bases i t self on a gr oup unit , namel y ,
the ie or househol d. The tr ansf ormati on t hesis says: Chr i st ianit y
r eceives part icul ar l y s t rong i nf l uence f r om t he ancestr al cul t ,cent r al t o which is the Buddha al t ar .1
Both theses, however, leave something to be desired. For if , on
t he one hand, t heir f ormul ati on oft en l acks a cl ear anal yt i cal
framework, their method of substantiation, on the other, often
stops short at observation and interviews, failing to go on to
sy st emat i c dat a- gatheri ng by means of quest ionnair es.
This paper, therefore, proposes to reformulate these theses as
hypothetical propositions to be investigated in accordance with the
anal yt i cal f r amewor k pres ent ed bel ow, and t o consi der t hem more
precisely in l ight of the data (including questionnaire data)
gat her ed in t he course of t his monogr aphi c st udy of Fukuda
Tr ansl at ed by Dav i d Re i d f r om nNi hon sonr aku ni oker u kipisutokyo
no t ei chaku t o heny o—Chi ba k en Shi mosa Fukuda Sei kokai no j ir eiTf
日 本 村 落 に お け る 基 督 教 の 定 着 と 変 容 千 葉 県 下 総 福 田 聖 公 会 の 事 例 in
Shakaiqaka hvoron 社 会 学 評 論 26 (1975), p p . 53- 73.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
2/45
18 NI S HI Y A MA : Chr i s t i ani t y in J apan
Ang l i can Epi scopal Chur c h in Chi ba .
If t he t radit ional reli gions of J apan may be charac t er i zed as
forms of "institutionalized culture and the imported religion of
Chr is t i ani t y a form of non- insti t ut ionali zed cul t ure,”2 t he conceptof i ndige ni zat i on used in this paper may be def i ned as t he change
whe r e by a s peci f i c f or m of non- i nst i t ut i onal i zed cul t ur e as s umes a
new posit i on as a form of i nst i t ut i onal i zed cul t ur e wi t hi n a speci
f i c social gr oup. Corr espondi ngl y, t he concept of t r ansf ormati on
used in this paper may be defined as the change whereby, in the
repositioning process , t he non- insti t ut ionali zed cul t ural f or m,
coming into contact with institutionalized culture, f inds its
patterns unraveled and rewoven in a definite way. Religious
Figure 1
Patterns in Traditional Religions and Christianity
Dei t y Conce i v ed as Uni que and Uni ver sal
Individual
I II
Christ ianity
Traditional
religions
III IV
Deit ies Concei ve d as Mul t i pr esent and Part icul aris t ic
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
3/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L O F R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 19
patterns, moreover, will here be considered either central or
per i pheral , cent r al r eferr i ng to the char act er of i ts god- concept
(its religious symbol), peripheral referring to the unit of religious
membership.3 The patterns of traditional religions and Christianity
may be furt her cl ari f i ed as in Fig ur e 1 . The group indi cated in t he
t erm "gr oup uni t " (on t he ext r eme ri ght ) r ef er s in this si t uati on t o
t he househol d.
Fig ure 1 i ndi cates, t hen, our f r ame of anal ysi s . Our next st ep is
to reformulate the two hypotheses.
The indigenization hypothesis parallels the horizontal axis , the
transformation hypothesis the vertical. Both are capable of
r eformul at i on. That is to s a y ,( 1 ) Chri st ianit y , when adopt ed in t heJ apanes e rural communi t y,must t ake ei t her f orm II or f orm IV in
or der to bec ome fi rml y est abl i shed, and (2) of t hese t wo, it is
pecul iar l y l iabl e to t r ansf ormat ion in t he dir ect i on of t he f orm
IV- t y pe bel ief patt ern (t he ancestr al cul t ) . These t wo hy pot heses ,
deal i ng respect i vel y wi t h i ndi geni zat i on and t r ansf ormat i on,appear
to refer to completely different subjects, but if Figure 1 is taken
as a gui de to our t hi nki ng about t his mat t er , it becomes evi dent
that both hypotheses have to do solely with transformation in
q ua dr a nt 1 ( t he Chr i s t i a n pa t t e r n) . Th e o nl y di f f e r e nc e b e t we e n
t hem is whet her this t r ansf ormati on r efer s t o a cent ral or a
per ipheral pattern.
Because this difference is a serious one, the concept of trans
f or mat i on as used i n t his st udy wil l be di vi ded i nt o t wo subordi
nat e concept s, namel y, for m and subst ance. A n at t empt wil l be
made t o ver i f y t he t wo hypot heses in t erms of t hese t wo subordi
nate concepts. The f irst is transformation as change in form—the
hori zont al axi s in Figure 1 . The second is tr ansf ormati on as change
i n s ubs t a nc e — t he v er t i c a l a x i s i n F i g ur e 1 . Of t he s e t wo , i t i s
l ikel y t hat t r ansf ormat i on havi ng to do wi t h change i n for m is
alm ost inevitable for Christ ianity as accepted in Japanese rural
society .
This bri ngs us t o t he quest i on of whet her t he rel igi ous fai t h of
our r espondent s, members of t he Fukuda Angl i can Epi scopal
Churc h, has r emai ned at t he l evel of change in f or m, or whet her it
has gone on to the level of change of substance. In accordance
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
4/45
20 NISHIYAMA: Christ ianity in Japan
wi t h c onc r et e da t a t o be pr es ent ed, t his que s t i on wi l l be pur sued
in the sections that follow.
In order to substantiate these hypotheses, it is desirable that
t he obj e c t o f i nv es t i g at i o n s at i s f y t he f o l l owi n g r e q u i r e m e n t s : (1)
it should be a church located in a rural society where the tradi
t ional r eli gions have c omparat i vel y dee p roots, (2) it shoul d be a
church with a fair ly long history (at least two generations of f if ty
y ear s ) s i nce t he t i me of it s f oundi ng, (3) c hur ch member s and ot her
m em bers of this rural society are not to dif fer great ly with
r espect t o occupat i on or social s t at us, and (4) it is t o be a chur ch
t hat, in consequence of the foregoi ng, is to a cer t ain ext ent well -
rooted in this rural society. As wi l l be i ndi cat ed be l ow, Fuk ud a Ang l i c an Epi s copal Chur c h
sat i sf i es all t hese r equi r ement s,4 and hence may be t aken as an
appropriate object of investigation for the purpose of verifying the
foregoing hy potheses .5
THE ADOPTION AND INDIGENIZATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN
SHIMO FUKUDA
Fukuda Angl i can Epi scopal Chur ch was f ir st or ganized in Sep
t ember 1876, and it s chur ch bui l di ng r emains t o t he pr esent day in
t he Shimo Fukuda war d of Nari t a Ci t y. (At t he t ime t he church
wa s f ounded, t he full name of t he geogr aphi cal l oc at i on wa s Shi mo
Fukuda Vi l l age, Shi mo Habu Dis t ri ct, Shi mosa Count y, Chi ba
Pref ect ure.) Since a det ail ed paper has al r eady been pr esent ed on
the adoption and indigenization of Christianity in the community
of Shimo Fuk uda,6 t he pr esent paper , havi ng i ts own foc us, wil l
mer el y s ummar i ze t he mai n points ,
Locat ed 4 ki l omet ers sout h of t he Tone Ri ve r and 3 kil omet ers
east of t he nor t hern t ip of t he Inba Mar s h,Shimo Fukuda is an
agri cul t ur al communi t y said to have been or ganized in 16 82 .7 As
of t he y ears 1883- 1887, t here were 3 househol d associat i ons
(kumi)9 36 househol ds, and a t ot al popul at i on of appr oxi mat el y 200.
The communi t y held a t otal of 1,125 t an of l and,i ncl udi ng 570 t an
in ar abl e l and (380 in paddy l and and 190 i n f ar ml and), 350 t an in
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
5/45
J A P A NE S E J OUR NA L OF RE L I GI OUS S TUDI ES 12/1 21
None1- 4
5- 9
10- 19
20- 29
30- 39
40- 49
50 or mor e
Tot al 36 (100.0) 36 (100.0) 36 (100,0)
Source: Shimo Fukuda mur a kot akuchi sanr i n t anbet su chika chis o
gdkeicho (1885).
Not e: The asteri sk (*) ident if i es a f igure that has been adj ust ed in
order to make t he t ot al per cent age equal 100.0. It has t he same
significance in the table to follow.
woodl and, and 30 t an i n r esi dent i al l and.8 (One t an equals 2.45
acres or .992 hectares .)
Tabl e 1 s hows i n t an units the distribution of these types of
land among the households. If attention focuses on the riceland, it
wi l l be not i ced t hat onl y 10 hous ehol ds ( 2 7 .9 %) hel d mor e t han 10
t an of such land, whereas 16 households (44.4%) held none. This
appear s t o ref l ect t he l andowner- t enant f armer rel ati onship of
that day.
Tabl e 1
La nd Di st r i but i on among t he Househol ds
No. of Paddyl and Far ml and Woodl and
t an (including
Residential)
4 (38.9)3 (36.1)
3 ( 8.3)
2 ( 5.6)
3 ( 8.3)
0 ( 0.0)
0 ( 0.0)
1 ( 2.8)
9 (25.0)5 (41.6)
6 (16.7)
5 (13.9)
0 ( 0.0)
0 ( 0.0)
0 ( 0.0)
1 ( 2 . 8 )
■6(44.4)7 (19.4)
3 (8.3)
5 (13.9)
2 (5.6)
1 (2.8)
1 ( 2 . 8 )
1 (2.8)
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
6/45
22 NIS HI Y AMA: Chri st ianit y in J apan
Tabl e 2 indi cat es how the paddyl and was dist r i but ed among t he
various d o z o k u op ancestrally aff i l iated households. As may be
seen,only 5 affiliated households (A, B, C, D, and E) held more
t han 10 t an of paddyl and. Of t hese 5,onl y 2 (A a nd B) hel d 30 t an
op mor e. In t he A and B dozoku, t he 3 househol ds wi t h 30 t an op
more are particularly important for pursuing the question of the
adopt i on and indi geni zat i on of Chr i st i ani t y in t he communi t y. In
order to facilitate subsequent references, I shall give them iden
t if yi ng l abel s. In what f oll ows, accordingl y, t he A dozoku house
hol d wi t h 50 op mor e t an of r iceland wil l be referred to as a へ the
one wi t h 40 some t an as a ^f and the B dozoku househol d wi t h 30
or more t an of r iceland as b. It shoul d al so be note d t hat is t hehonke or head house of A d o z o k u and t hat is a br anch house of
st art ed duri ng 1865- 1866; b is the head house of B dozoku.
Tabl e 2
Di st r i but i on of Paddyl and among Aff i l i at ed Househol ds
Paddy l and I ndependent
in t an A B C D E F G H I Househol ds a nd
Buddhis t Templ e
Tot al
None 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 2 1 4 16
1- 4 1 1 2 1 2 7
5- 9 1 1 1 3
10- 19 1 2 1 1 5
20- 29 1 1 2
30- 39 1 1
40- 49 1 1
50 or mor e 1 1
Total 5 4 5 3 2 2 2 4 2 7 36
Sour ce: Sa me as f or Tabl e 1.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
7/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 23
158.0
62.0
24.0
35.5
10.7
5. 3
5.4
4.7
331.7
141.1
69.0
80.2
21.7
26.2
20.2
10.6
14.1
29.7
0.6 ( 0)
7.3 ( 2)
Tot 36 313.5(100) 205.8(100) 225.0(100) 744.5(100) 16,707(100)
Source: Sa me as for Tabl e 1.
Not e: The doubl e ast eri sks (**) r ef er to t he Buddhi st t emple and
i ndependent househol ds.
Tabl e 3 shows t he si ze and ye n val ue of dozoku land holdings
as of 1855. In all categories the extraordinary size and value of
t he l and hol di ngs of A dozoku will be readily apparent. It is also
wor t h not i ng t hat whe n t he y en v al ue of t he t wo l ar ges t l and
owners, A and B, are added together, the total yen value of their
holdings is well over half of the overall total.
Tabl e 3
Size and Value of Dozoku Landhol dings
as of 1885
D NHo oo Number of t an
z .u - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
o s Far ml and Tot al
k oe Paddy l and (i ncl udi ng Woodl and Tot al
u fs Resi dent i al )
Y e n Va l ue
of the
(5(
(]
( 2〕
( 2〕
( 2〕
(44) 8,442(50*:
(19) 3,50 8 (21 〕
( 9 ) 1 , 4 4 4 ( 9)
( 1 1 ) 9 4 9 ( 6)
( 3 ) 570 ( 3)
( 4 ) 504 ( 3)
( 3 ) 396 ( 2)
( 1 ) 2 6 3 ( 2)
( 2 ) 1 1 9 ( 1 )
( 4 ) 512 ( 3)
72.7 (35) 101. 0 (45)
31.5 (15) 47.6 (21)
22.6 (11) 22.4 (10)
21.7 (10) 23.0 (10)
10.0 ( 5 ) 1 . 0 ( 1 )
1 1. 6 ( 6) 9 . 1 ( 4 )
7.3 ( 4) 7. 5 ( 3)
5.7 ( 3) 0.2 ( 0)
8.7 ( 4) 4. 8 ( 2)
14. 0 ( 7) 8. 4 ( 4)
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
8/45
24 NI SHIY AMA: Chri st ianit y in J apan
Wi t h r egar d t o t he r el i gi ous s i t uat i on i n Shi mo Fuk uda, a f e w
r emark s wil l suff i ce. As of t he peri od 1872- 1876, t he main reli
gious i nsi t ut ions in the communi t y wer e:
1 Shint o shri ne ~ a small , unr anked facil it y enshr i ni ng t he
t ut el ary kami of t he communi t y, namel y, Inari ,
the harvest god;
1 Buddhi st t emple—Shofukuji t emple, a br anch temple of Ei f ukuj i
temple aff i l iated with the Buzan stream of the
Shingi Shingon s e c t ;
1 Buddhi st chapel —Nankoi n whi ch, t hough r eal l y a unit of
Shofukuji temple, is generally known as Kannori
do , t he !lKannon cha pel ."9Ho us e ho l d a f f i l i a t i on wi t h Buddhi s t s e ct s as o f 1 87 3 wa s : 17
Shingon (wi t h over l ap int o anot her s ect in 2 househol ds), 9 Tendai ,
8 J i (wi t h overl ap into anot her s ect in 2 househol ds), a nd 1
unspecif ied.10
The process whereby Christianity was adopted in the community
is represented in Figure 2 in terms of the growing scale of its
adopt i on. This pr ocess may be div i ded into four st ages: St age I
beginning in 1877 when the head of household b became the f irst
pers on in t he communi t y t o r ece i ve bapt i sm (he was bor n in 1851
as the second son of a hat amot o house, a house directly respon
si bl e t o t he shog un, mar r i ed i nt o househol d b in 1872, and later
became t he f i rst past or of Fukuda Angl i can Epi scopal Chur ch);
St ag e II begi nning in 1881 when his el dest son and el dest daught er
(t hen age s 5 and 3) wer e bapt i zed; St age III beginni ng i n 1882
whe n t wo y oung men (t he n ag es 26 and 2 1 ) f r om t wo househol ds in
B dozoku r e c e i v e d b a p t i s m; and St age IV begi nni ng i n 1887 when
at l east one per son fr om eac h househol d in the A, B , H, and I
dozoku and f r om eac h i ndependent househol d r ec ei v ed bapt i sm en
masse on 8 Sept ember 1887.
The move fr om St age III t o St age IV shoul d pr obabl y be char
act er i zed as a "l ea p." The number of peopl e who had r ecei ved
bapti sm duri ng St ag e III was a mer e 5, t he number of househol ds
i nvol ved onl y 3—a nd all 3 fr om 1 dozoku. But St age IV opens wi t h
t he bapt i sm of 32 more peopl e, t he t otal of 37 r epr esent i ng 16
households belonging to 4 dozoku. The year 1887 also marks the
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
9/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L O F R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2/1 25
formal organization of Fukuda Anglican Episcopal Church; the
church building was erected the fol lowing y ear .
Figure 2
Broadeni ng St ages in t he Adopt i on of Chr is t i ani t y
Tabl e 4 gi ves a br eak down by age and sex of t he peopl e bap
t i zed in 1887. Over al l , t he mal es sl ight l y out number t he f emal es,
and hal f of t he t otal is made up of mal es and f emal es under age
30—though 2 of the 32 people are in their 70s. The core of the
group is comprised of young men, but rather than being heads of
households, t hese young men t end t o be t he el dest sons of house
hol d heads. In other vi l l ages and rural t owns dur i ng the Mei j i
peri od (1868- 1911), t he g eneral rul e was t hat "t he househol d head,
or he and his wi f e, bec ame churc h member s , and onl y t hen di d
other famil y members accept t he f ait h" (Mor i oka, e d” 195 9 , p. 61).
But in t he vil l age of Shimo Fukuda it was gener al l y t he househol d
hea dTs el dest son, or this s on and his wi f e, who fi rst j oi ned t he
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
10/45
26 NISHIYAMA: Christ ianity in Japan
Chur ch, af t er whi ch t heir chi l dr en and his parents accept ed t he
faith.
Table 4
A g e and Se x of Pe opl e Ba pt i zed i n 1887
Sex
Tn丨t al Ag e -
Mal e Femal e Unknown
0- 9 2 0 0 2 ( 6 . 3 )
10- 19 4 0 0 4 (12.5)20- 29 5 5 0 10 (31.2* )
30- 39 3 2 0 5 (15.5* )
40- 49 2 2 0 4 (12.5)
50- 59 2 0 0 2 ( 6 . 3 )
60- 69 0 2 0 2 ( 6 . 3 )
70- 79 1 1 0 2 ( 6 . 3 )
Unknown 0 0 1 1 ( 3 . 1 )
Total 19 12 1 32 (100.0)
Sour ces: Each househol ds recor d of deceas ed Chr i st i an member s,
the church membership record (revised version), and the church’s
l ist of deat hs, mont h by mont h, among chur ch member s.
Tabl e 5 gi ves a br eak down by dozoku of househol ds wi t h
per sons who had r ecei ved bapt i sm as of 1887, and Tabl e 6 does t he
same by kumi. In combi nat i on t hey s how how gr eat l y t he bapt i sms
of this period took place in dozoku uni t s and how much t hese
househol ds t ended t o cl ust er i n t he same nei ghbor hoods.
But how, t hen, c an the ”l eapTT fr om St ag e III t o St age I V be
expl ai ned?
Begi nni ng wi t h Sept ember 18 81, t he head of househol d b
engaged in evangeli st i c acti vi t ies for nearl y t wo and a hal f y ears
in t his communi t y wher e he l i ved, but his wor k was i mpeded by
vi gorous opposi t i on t hat s t emmed pr i mari l y fr om househol ds and
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
11/45
J A P A NE S E J OUR NA L OF R E L I GI OUS S TUDI ES 12/1 27
o f A dozoku. Duri ng t his peri od he opened a pr i vat e night-
school and sought to use it to facilitate his evangelistic work by
t eachi ng not onl y Chi nese and his t ory but also t he Bi bl e. When t he
fat her s and el der br others of t he night - school st udent s l earned
Tabl e 5: Dozoku Househol ds wi t h Per sons Recei v i ng Bapt i sm
No. of Househol ds No. of Househol ds
Dozoku in t he wi t h Bapt i zed Perc ent age
Dozoku Member s
A 5 5 100.0B 4 4 100 .0
H 4 4 100.0
I 2 2 10 0. 0
Indepe ndent 7 1 14.3
Tot al 22 16 72.7
Sources Sa me as for Tabl e 4.
Tabl e 6: Kami Households wi t h Per sons Rec ei v i ng Bapt i sm
Dozoku
No. of House hol ds
in t he
Dozoku
No. of Househol ds
wi t h Ba pt i zed
M em bers Per cent age
A 5 5 100.0
B 4 4 100.0
H 4 4 100.0
I 2 2 100.0
Independent 7 1 14.3
Tot al 22 16 72.7
Sources Same as for Tabl e 4.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
12/45
28 NI SHIY AMA: Chri st ianit y in J apan
t hat t he l ect ures i ncl uded mat er i al on "J es usi sm," t hey f or bade t he
chi l dr en to cont i nue (Iida 192 1,Yamagat a 1924, et c.). This was a
period when agricultural depression and the persecution of the
peopl e’s r ights move ment wer e becomi ng mor e and more i nt ense, a
per i od when Chr i st i ani t y, hit her t o conf i dent t hat nt he mor ni ng sun
was about t o r i se ov er eas t er n ski esff ( Rikugo zasshit J a n . 1 8 8 2),
began t o suf fer t ell ing bl ows fr om t he camps of emer gent ul t ra
nat i onal i sm, Confuci anis m, Buddhis m, Taoi s m, et c. t hat r ode the
wa v e s of pol i t i cal and economi c cha ng e. Chr i s t i ani t y no w f ound
itself fall ing into a situation where it was surrounded by enemies
on eve r y hand (Sumi ya 1961, chaps. 3- 4).
In contrast, by about 1887 the starting point of Stage IV, the
Chr i st i an Chur ch has under t aken a r evival movement as a way of
meet i ng this chal l enge. It t hus r ebounded fr om t he bl ows it had
suffered, and in suceeding years this carried over without a break
into a per i od of Wes t er nizat i on (Sumi ya 1961, chaps. 3- 4).
In connect i on wi t h the change fr om t he "per i od of conser vat i ve
r eact i on" t hat char act er i zed t he 1881- 1882 y ear s to the pal my
per i od of Wes t er nizat i on t hat began about 18 87 , publ i c opi ni on
reversed i tsel f with regard to Christ ianity . This eventuated theview that "from a religious perspective [people] are calling for
gr owt h on t he part of Chr is t i ani t y ” (Sawa 1938, v o l . 5, pp. 23- 24).
It is by no means i nconcei vabl e t hat t his change in publ i c opi ni on
concerning Christianity should have lent strength to the founding
of a c hur ch i n t he communi t y of Shi mo Fukuda,
If , however, we look in the community itself for factors that
assisted the founding of this church, it becomes necessary to
at t end t o the f act t hat t he gr oup bapt i sm admi ni st er ed in 1887
took place under the leadership of the eldest sons (then aged 20
and 16) of t he and househol ds of A dozoku, t he most
powerful d o z o k u in t he communi t y. At this peri od t he and
househol ds wer e t he l andowners in a l andowner - t enant far mer
r el at i onship l i nki ng t hem wi t h nearl y ev er y househol d t hat had
member s bapt i zed in this gr oup cer emony. It appear s, t her ef ore,
t hat t he act i ons of t he and households ser ved, on t he one
hand,t o bl ock t he adopt i on of Chr i st i ani t y up to 1882 and, on t he
ot her , t o mak e possi bl e t he TTl eap” t hat t ook pl ace in 1887.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
13/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 29
Fol l owi ng t he est abl i shment of t he chur ch, t he A and B dozoku,
whi c h Ta bl e 3 s ho ws as t he ones wi t h t he l ar gest hol di ngs , f or med
a com bination that perm itted Christ ianity a certain degree of
stability as it extended its influence within the community.
The factors that assisted Christianity’s indigenization in Shimo
Fukuda can be i dent i f i ed, t hen, as t he f ol l owi ng it ems ( 1 ) t he
l andowner - t enant f armer rel ati onshi p t hat obt ained bet ween t he
and and b househol ds, on t he one hand, and t he ot her
househol ds t hat ac cept ed Chr is t i ani t y, on t he other; (2) the dozoku
bonds among t he househol ds acc ept i ng Chri st i ani t y; and (3) t he
neighborhood- cl ust er r elat i onship.
In 1890 t he Fukuda Angl i can Epi sc opal Chur ch went on t oext end t he fait h to t he neighbori ng vil l age of Manza k i ,and t hree
y ear s l at er a chur ch was es t abl i s hed t her e. But be c aus e t hes e
assist i ng f act ors wer e l acking, t he chur ch was dissol ved in just
f o u r y e a r s .
Is it possible, then, to specify at what t ime the Christianity
adopt ed by Shimo Fukuda act ual l y bec ame i ndi genous?
If we take as criteria the establishment of Christianity within a
househol d (t hree generat i ons of f ami l y member s rece i vi ng bapt i sm)
and the acquisit ion of particularly important facilit ies by the
chur ch (a chur ch bui l di ng, l and, gr avey ar d, et c.), it t urns out t hat
t he t ime at whic h Chr i st i ani t y beca me i ndi genous in the communi t y
wa s t he per i od be t we e n 1907 and 1911. As Ta bl e 7 s ho ws , 8 7 . 4 %
of t he househol ds wi t h member s r ecei vi ng bapt i sm at t he mass
ceremony of 1887 had, by 1907, three generations of Christian
f ami l y member s .11 To this it shoul d be added t hat t he chur ch
acqui r ed it s gr avey ar d and paddyl and bet ween 1907 and 1911.
T H E C O N T E M P O R A R Y C H U R C H
This section will consider data essential to pursuing the ques
t ion of subst ant i ve c hange in Chr is t i ani t y t hat wil l be t aken up in
the next section.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
14/45
30 NI S HI Y A MA : Chr i s t i ani t y in J apan
In the Taisho Period
1912- 16
1917- 21
1922- 25
S u b t o t a l 1 ( 6 . 3 )
In the Showa Period
1926- 29 1 ( 6 . 3 )
S u b t o t a l 1 ( 6 . 3 )
Tot al 16 (100.0)
Source : Same as f or Tabl e 4.
Geogr aphi cal Dis t ri but ion of Chur ch Member s
As of 10 Se pt embe r 1 9 7 1 , 12 Fuk uda Angl i c an Epi scopal Chur c h had
a t otal of 108 member s . Of t his number , 79 (7 3. 2%) r esi ded in t he
Shi mo Fuk uda communi t y and 29 (26- 8%) out si dfe t he oommuni t y.
Tabl e 7
Y e a r s i n whi c h Hous ehol ds Pr oduc ed Thi r d- Gener at i on Chr i s t i ans
Y e a r s dur i ng whi ch
Thi r d Gener at i on Number of Households
Christ ians Received Baptism
In t he Mei j i Peri od
1887- 91 6 (37.5)
1891- 96 1 ( 6 . 3 )
1897- 1901 5 (31.0* )
1902- 06 1 ( 6 . 3 )1907- 11 1 ( 6 . 3 )
Subt otal 14 (87.4*)
0 (
0 (
1 (
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
15/45
J A P A NE S E J OUR NA L OF RE L I GI OUS S TUDI ES 12/1 31
Mor eov er , of t hese 29 non- resi dent members 19 (65. 8%) wer e
peopl e who had been r ais ed in t he communi t y but mov ed awa y
l at er in connect i on wi t h mar r i age, adopt i on, f ormat i on of an i nde
pendent househol d, or t he emi gr at i on of an ent i r e f ami l y. From
this we may gai n some i dea of t he cl oseness of t he connect i on
bet ween Fukuda Angl i can Epi scopal Chur ch and this part icular
communi t y ,
The Pat t er n of Exi st ence of t he "Chr i st i an Househol d”
In Shimo Fukuda, househol ds t hat have acc ept ed Chr i st i ani t y are
spoken of as "Chr i st i an house hol ds."13 Apar t fr om t he past or and
his f ami l y who come f r om out si de the communi t y, al l t he res i dent smember s of t he chur ch are member s of "Chri st i an househol ds^ t hat
over t he gener at i ons have f ol l owed Chr i st i ani t y as t heir "househol d
r el i gi on." Ot her t han such member s , t her e is not one "i ndiv i dual
beli ever 11 in t he ent ir e communi t y.
Duri ng 1 97 1,Shi mo Fukuda had a t otal of 54 househol ds. Of
this total, the number of Christian homes (including the pastor and
his f amil y) came to 2 1 ( 3 8 . 9 %) , t he remaining 33 (61.1%) being
Buddhi st househol ds.14 For t he geographi cal l ocat i on of Chr i st ian
househol ds wi t hin t he communi t y s ee Fi gur e 3.
Qui t e apar t fr om t he quest i on of whet her t he member s of
Chr i st i an househol ds are t o be count ed as chur ch member s’ 15
Chri s t i an househol ds and Buddhis t househol ds may be di st i nguis hed
on the basis of criteria such as f inancial support for the
chur ch16 and var i ous ki nds of vol unt ar y l abor,17 part i ci pat i on in
t he maj or chur ch ev ent s,18 and part i ci pat i on in the non- rel igi ous
voluntary association Yus a nk o.19 These routine pract ices ,
t ranscendi ng g enerat i onal changes in famil y members , ar e carr i ed
on in what may be r egar ded as generat i on af t er gener at i on of
t!intep- househol d co nt ac t .11
Tabl e 8 shows t he curr ent percent age of Chr is t i an househol ds
in each dozoku. The one Christian household in C dozoku got a
l ate st art s i nce it did not acc ept Chr i st i ani t y unt il s ome t ime
after the mass baptism of 1887. J dozoku was an i ndependent
househol d at t he t ime of t he mass bapt i sm, but it l ater est abl i shed
a br anch househol d of i ts own and t hus f or med a ne w dozoku. As
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
16/45
32 NI SHIY AMA: Chr is t ianit y in J apan
pigore 3
Location of Christian Households within Shimo Fukuda
as of Septerfcer 1971
Note: Christian households are identified with a • sign.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
17/45
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
18/45
34 NISHIYAMA: Christ ianity in Japan
Tabl es 10 and 11 i ndi cate t he degr ee of conve r gence i n cont act s
among Buddhi st and Chr i s t i an househol ds as r egar ds one r,non-
rel igi ousn househol d event in t he communi t y. Of t hese t wo Tabl es,
t he r esul t s shown in Tabl e 10 coul d have be en deduce d fr om Tabl e
8, but t hose of Tabl e 11 coul d not, f or t he peopl e wit h nando roles
ar e chosen not onl y f rom t he househol ds const i t ut i ng a dozoku, but
al so fr om nei ghbor i ng househol ds,20 In addi t i on, dozoku contacts
ar e r eciprocal , but nando- rol e rel ati onships ar e not.
Tabl e 10
Househol d Rel i gi on and Int ra- Dozofcu Cont act s
Christ ian Buddhist
Hous ehol ds Hous ehol ds
Chri st i an Househol ds 33 (76.7) 10 (24.4)
Buddhi st Househol ds 10 (23.3) 3 1 ( 7 5 . 6 )
Total 43 (100.0) 4 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 )
Not e: Thi s Tabl e i ncl udes 1 Chri st i an househol d t hat mov ed away
in 1961 but maintains its contacts.
Tabl e 11
Household Religion and Nando Roles
Serving Households
Se r v ed Hous ehol ds - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Christian Buddhist
C h r i s t i a n 96 (76.8) 18 (22.2)
Buddhist 29 (23.2) 63 (77.8)
Total 125 (100.0) 8 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 )
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
19/45
J A P A N E S E J O UR N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 35
From Tabl es 10 and 11 it may be seen t hat t her e is a
pronounced t endency, s o far as t hese "non- rel igi ous” event s are
concerned, for Christian households to associate with Christian
househol ds a nd for Buddhi st househol ds to associ at e wi t h
Buddhi st s. But apart fr om t hese part icul arl y i mport ant household
relationships, the households of Shimo Fukuda, far from remaining
wi t hi n t he conf i nes of t hei r o wn r el i gi ous gr oup, ar e r el at i vel y
free about associat ing with each other .21
In comparing Christian and Buddhist households, one notes that
the form er general ly t race their founding to an ear l ier date than
the latter. Thus whereas 65.8% (13) of the Christian households
we r e f ound ed no l at er t han t he f i nal de c ade s of t he Edo per i od(1603- 1867), 60 .6 % (20) of t he Buddhi st househol ds wer e not
f ounded unt il af t er t he begi nni ng of t he Meij i peri od (1868- 1911).
Today , however , t he househol ds belongi ng t o t hese t wo gr oups
do not exhi bi t any conspicuous dispari t ies ei t her i n occupat i on or
in social status.
Tabl e 12 compares Chri st i an and Buddhis t households wi t h
respect to the proportion of total household income deriving from
possible types ranging from completely argicultural to completely
non- agri cul t ural . Type A r epr esent s income t hat is ent ir ely
Tabl e 12
Househol d Rel i gi on and Ty pe of Househol d Income
Type of Househol d Chr i st i an Buddhi st
Inco me House hol d House hol d
A 0 ( 0.0) 0 ( 0. 0)
B 3 (15.0) 6 (18.2)
C 6 (30.0) 4 (12.1)
D 5 (25.0) 12 (36.4)
E 4 (20.0) 3 ( 9.1 )
F 2 (10.0) 8 (24.2)
Total 20 (100.0) 33 (100.0)
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
20/45
36 NISHIYAMA: Christ ianity in Japan
agri cul t ur al , t ype B i ncome t hat is pr edomi nant l y agri cul t ural , and
t ype C i ncome t hat is mor e agri cul t ural t han non- agri cul t ural ; t ype
D i ndicat es i ncome t hat is mor e non- agri cul t ural t han agri cul t ur al ,
t ype E i ncome t hat is pr edomi nant l y non- agri cul t ur al , and t ype F
i ncome that is ent i r el y non- agri cul t ural . As t his Tabl e shows, t he
Christian households, partly because they were established earlier,
rel y somehwat more heavi l y on agri cul t ur al i ncome t han the
Buddhi st . The di f f er ence bet ween t he the t wo gr oups, howev er , is
not pronounced.
Today’s community, moreover, having experienced the
Occ upat i on l and r ef orm, is one in whi ch t he di st ri but ion of ar abl e
l and is f ar mor e equal t han it was at t he t ime t he church wasf ounded. J ust as t here ar e no househol ds wi t h mor e t han 30 t an
(7.4 acres op 3 hectares) of land, so there are none with no land
wha t ev e r . In pos i t i ve t er ms , t he l ar gest number of hous ehol ds (13)
now have mor e t han 10 bu t l e s s th an 20 tan (2.45- 4.9 a c r e s op
.992- 1.98 hect ares ) of ar abl e l and. Her e agai n, t here is no
conspicuous di f f er ence in percent age of l and holdings as bet ween
the Christian and Buddhist households.
The Rel i gi ous Pract i ces of Chur ch Member s
Tabl e 13 i ndi cat es, for chur ch member s r esi dent in t he communi t y,
t he number of mal es and femal es const it ut i ng f i rst - generati on
Chr is t i ans, second- generat i on Chr i st ians, e t c .22 If t he t ot als for
peopl e in t he f our t h t hr ough t he sixt h generat i ons ar e added
t ogether, t he resul t is over 50% of t he overal l t ot al —a fact
suggestive of the degree to which the Christianity of Shimo
Fukuda, f r amed by t he Chri st i an househol d, is const i t ut ed by
success i ve gener at i ons fr om househol d unit s. The hi gh perc ent age
of women (40%) count ed as f ir st - generati on Chr i st i ans der i ves
part l y f rom t he f act t hat most t he br i des who marr y i nt o Chr i st i an
households f irs t accept Christ ianity af ter enter ing their new
famil y, part l y fr om t he f act t hat t he f emal es born into Chr i st i an
househol ds, af t er gr owi ng up, usuall y marr y into househol ds out si de
t he communi t y.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
21/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 37
Fi r st 1 ( 2 . 9 )
Second 2 ( 5 . 9 )
Thi r d 7 (20.6)
Fourth 13 (38.2)
F i f t h 9 (26.5)
S i x t h 2 ( 5 . 9 )
Tot al 34 (100.0) 45 (100.0) 79 (100.0)
Not e: These fi gur es r epresent al l chur ch member s r esi dent in
Shimo Fuk uda, i ncl udi ng not onl y t he past or and his f ami l y but al so
family members who have left home.
In this connect i on it may be obser ved t hat t he major i t y of
Shimo Fukuda women who are raised in Christian households but
mar r y into non- Chr i st i an househol ds, whet her i nsi de or out si de t he
communi t y, cut t heir t ies wi t h t he church. Conver sel y, unl ess
there are strong reasons for doing otherwise, by far the greater
part of t hose who marr y int o a Shimo Fukuda Chri st i an household,
abiding by its customs, receive baptism and become members of
Fukuda Angl i can Epi scopal Chur ch. Agai n, the chi l dr en born to
Christian households ordinarily receive infant baptism soon after
bi rt h, and t hey r ecei ve conf i r mat i on when t hey bec ome middl e
school or high school students.
Tabl e 14 shows, f or t he t otal number of c hur ch members , t he
percentage of those who received baptism as infants and the
percentage of those who received baptism as adults. Attention is
invited to the fact that among church members resident in the
communi t y, t hose bapt i zed as i nf ant s account for more t han hal f
(60.8%) of the total.
Tabl e 13
Chur ch Member s Resi dent in t he Communi t y
Grouped as First and Succeeding Generations of Christians
Generat i on Mal e Femal e Tot al
3 (16.4)
1 ( 2 6 . 6 )
0 (25.3)
J
3
8
j S
(40
(4.
1317
d
8
2
6
8
1
0
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
22/45
38 NI SHIY AMA: Chri st ianit y in J apan
Tabl e 14
Infant Bapt i sm and Adul t Bapt i sm among Al l Chur ch Member s
Ty pe of
Baptism
R e c e i v e d
Chur ch Member s
Residing within
t he Communit y
Chur ch member s
Residing outside
t he Communit y
Total
Infant
Adul t
48 (60.8)
3 1 ( 3 9 . 2 )
12 (41.4)
17 (58.6)
60 (55.6)
48 (44.4)
Tot al 79 (100.0) 29 (100.0) 108 (100.0)
Table 15 pr e se nt s t he r es ul t s of as k i ng peopl e who r e ce i v ed
adul t bapt i sm and peopl e who r ecei ved conf i r mat i on about t heir
mot i vat i on for accept i ng Chr is t i ani t y. The it em i ncl uded a number
of possible responses, such as ”Because of the attractiveness of
Chr is t i an t eachi ngs,n ''Because of t he at t r act iv eness of the
past or 's personali t y and l i f e- out l ook,11 "Becaus e of t he att ract iv e
ness of a l ay bel i ever 's pers onal it y and l if e- out l ooktn et c.—
responses that could be regarded as indicative of active motivat ion. As i t t ur ned out , howev er , t he answer t hat t he over whel mi ng
majori t y of r espondent s sel ect ed was "Bec aus e Chr i st i ani t y is t he
rel igi on of my househol d." This is t he mot i vat i on gi ven by 7 8. 6% of
Tabl e 15: Mot i vat i on of Chur ch Member s Resi dent i n t he
Communi t y for Accept i ng Adul t Bapt i sm op Confirmation
Member s who Member s who
Mo t i v a t i o n R e c e i v e d R e c e i v e d
Adul t Bapt i s m Conf i r mat i on
Because Christ ianity is the
rel i gi on of my househol d 22 (78.6) 29 (67.4)
Ot her answer s
(7 sel ect i ons) 6 (21.4) 14 (32.6)
Tot al 28 (100.0) 43 (100.0)
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
23/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L OF R E L I G I OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 39
Not e: The t otal number of peopl e in Shimo Fi kuda who have
acc ept ed adul t bapt is m is 3 1 , none of whom have l eft home; t he
t otal number of people who have r ecei ved conf i r mat i on is 54» of
who m 4 ha v e l ef t .
Tabl e 16: Chur ch At t endance dur i ng t he Past Y ear
by Member s of Chri st i an Househol ds
Fr equency of Inquir ers ________ Ba p t i z e d _ Pe r s o ns _
At t e nd a nc e Unc onf i r med Co nf i r med Tot al
Near ly everySunday/2- 3 ti mes
per mont h 0 ( 0.0) 3 ( 17.7) 17 (39.6) 20 (33.4)
About onc e
a mont h 1 ( 4 . 5 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 3 ( 7.0) 3 ( 5.0)
5- 6 t i mes a y ear /
2- 3 t i mes a year 1 ( 4 . 5 ) 1 ( 5 . 9 ) 8 (18.6) 9 (15.0)
Al mos t nev er 20 (91.0) 13 (76.4) 15 (34.8) 28 (46.0)
Total 22 (1 00 .0 )1 7 (100.0) 43 (100.0) 60 (100.0)
Not e: "Inqui r er s" r ef er s to member s of Chri st i an househol ds who
have not yet bee n bapt i zed and t hus ar e not y et chur ch members .
The t otal number of bapt i zed persons who r emai n unconf i r med is
25 (of whom 1 has lef t home). The t otal number of bapt i zed
per sons who have r ecei ved conf i r mat i on is 70 (of whom 5 have l eft
home). "The past y ear " r ef er s t o t he 12- mont h per i od endi ng 10
Sept ember 1971. The same defi ni t i ons appl y in t he t abl es that
fol low.
those who received adult baptism and by 67.4% of those who
received confirmation—a passive response indicative of a
traditional orientation. This suggests that the life of faith is Shimo
Fukuda c ommuni t y t oday is per haps t o be char act er i zed as one of
s omewhat l ess t han consci ous, aut onomous commi t ment .
In point of f act , t he result s in t abl es 16- 19 conf i r m t his
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
24/45
40 NISHIYAMA: Christ ianity in Japan
Tabl e 17: Wor shi p Mat er i al s t hat Exi st in Chri st i an Househol ds
and ar e Gener al l y for t he use of t he Respondent
Ty pe of Wor s hi p
Posses-
Ma t e r i a l s i on
Inqui r er s Bapt i zed Per sons
Unconfirmed Confirmed Tot al
Bible Have
Not have
1 ( 4 . 5 )
2 1 ( 9 5 . 5 )
5 (29.4)
12 (70.6)
28 (65.1)
15 (34.9)
33 (55.0)
27 (45.0)
Pray er- Have
book Not have0 ( 0.0)
22 (100.0)5 (29.4)
12 (70.6)24 (55.8)19 (44.2)
29 (48.4)3 1 ( 5 1 . 6 )
Hymn- Hav e
book Not have
0 ( 0.0)
22 (100.0)
3 (17.7)
14 (82.3)
24 (55.8)
19 (44.2)
27 (45.0)
33 (55.0)
To t a l 22 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 7 ( 10 0. 0) 4 3 ( 1 00 .0 ) 60 ( 10 0. 0)
Tabl e 18: Bi bl e reading at Home dur i ng Past Y ear
by member s of Chri st i an Househol ds
Inquirers Baptized Persons
Unconf i r med Conf i r med Total
R
e Al most dai l y
a
d Onc e a wee k
B Onc e a mont h
i Al most neve r /
b Never
i . . ( .
0 ( 0.0) 0 ( 0.0) 1 ( 2 . 3 ) 1 ( 1 . 7 )
0 ( 0.0)
0 ( 0.0)
10 (45.5)
0 ( 0.0)
3 (17.7)
1 1 ( 6 4 . 6 )
3 ( 7.0)
10 (23.3)
28 (65.1)
3 ( 5.0)
13 (21.7)
39 (65.0)
e Subtotal 10 (45.5) 14 (82.3) 42 (97.7) 56 (93.4)
Never read it 12 (54.5) 3 (17.7) 1 ( 2 . 3 ) 4 ( 6.6)
Tot al 22 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 7 ( 10 0. 0) 4 3 ( 1 00 .0 ) 60 ( 10 0. 0)
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
25/45
J A P A N E S E J O UR N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 41
suggestion. These results are also of considerable importance for
taking up, in the next section, the question of substantive change
in Christ ianity .
Tabl e 19: Fami l y Wor shi p at Home dur i ng t he Past Ye ar
Frequency
Inquirers Bapt i zed Per sons
Unc onf i r me d Co nf i r me d Total
D Dai l y 0 ( 0.0) 0 ( 0.0) 1 1 ( 2 5 . 6 ) 1 1 ( 1 8 . 6 )
i Oc cas i onal l y 0 ( 0.0) 2 (11.8) 3 ( 7.0) 5 ( 8.)d Spec i al t i mes 0 ( 0.0) 0 ( 0.0) 4 ( 9 .3) 4 ( 6.5)
o Subt ot al 0 ( 0.0) 2 (11.8) 18 (41.9) 20 (33.4)
Never done so 22 (100.0) 15 (88.2) 24 (55.8) 39 (65.0)
No answer 0 ( 0.0) 0 ( 0.0) 1 ( 2 . 3 ) 1 ( 1 . 6 )
Tot al 22 (100.0) 17 (100.0) 43 (100.0) 60 (100.0)
C O N T A C T WI T H T R A D I T I ON A L R E L I G I ON
A ND T HE QUE S TI ON OF S UB S TA NT I V E C HA NGE
The probl em t o be consi dered her e is that of t he nat ure and
degree of substantive change that Christianity in the Shimo
Fukuda communi t y has exper i enced now t hat some ni net y year s
have passed since evangelism was begun. Particular attention will
be paid to the ancestral cult .
The Tr adi t i onal Rel i gious Facil i t i es of the Househol d
The r esul t s of t aking all t he households of Shimo Fukuda,
cl assi f yi ng them as ei t her Chr i st i an or Buddhist , and compar i ng the
t wo gr oups wi t h regar d t o their possessi on of r eli gious facil it ies
t radit i onal t o the househol d, ar e shown in Tabl e 20. The
"subst itute" referred to in the f irs t ty pe s ignif ies a place to
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
26/45
42 NIS HI Y AMA: Chri st ianit y in J apan
venerate the ancestors other than the tradit ional a ltar ; it is
pecul i ar to t he Chr is t i an househol ds. General l y it has a cross, a
phot ogr aph of t he decease d, a f l ower vase, and an incense bur ner,
but it may have, excepti onal l y, somet hi ng simil ar t o a mort uary
tablet but engraved with a cross .23
A bi r dTs ey e v i ew of Ta bl e 20 s ho ws t hat t he Chr i s t i an and
Buddhi st househol ds exhi bit di amet r i cal l y opposed t endenci es as
r egards possession of t wo ty pes of facil it ies: t he kami al t ar and
an alt ar f or t he kit chen kami op the well kami. Conversely, the
Chri st i an and Buddhi st househol ds (despi t e a sli ght l ag on t he part
of the Christians) tend to follow the same practice as regards
havi ng a pl ace t o vener at e t he ancest ors and a shri ne for t hehouse- kami . It s houl d be not ed, howev er , t hat what t hey hol d in
common is t he t endency to hav e a pl ace to vener at e t he ancest ors ,
but not t o have a house- kami shri ne.
The ci r cumst ances t hat r esul t in a l ow per cent age of house
kami shrines differ, however, for the Christian and Buddhist
househol ds. As menti oned abov e, t he Chr i st i an househol ds wer e
est abl i shed somewhat earl ier t han t he Buddhi st , 65 % of t he
Chri st i an househol ds havi ng been est abl i shed dur i ng t he cl osing
deca des of t he Edo peri od. At t he ti me they beg an, most of t hese
househol ds had a shr i ne for t he house- kami , but on acc ept i ng
Chr i st i ani t y dur i ng t he Meij i peri od, t hey r emoved o p discarded
this shrine along with other traditional religious facilit ies.24
Consequent l y, t he percent age of Chr is t i an househol ds possessing
such a shri ne r emai ns l ow to t he pres ent day. It s houl d al so be
i ndi cat ed that t he house- kami s hri nes of t his ar ea are const r uct ed
not of straw but of stone, so once thrown away, they are hard to
replace.
A s f or t he Buddhi st hous ehol ds , 6 0 .6 % of t hem we r e f ounded,
we ha v e s een, af t er t he ope ni ng of t he Mei j i per i od, but at t his
l at e dat e t hey gener al l y di d not est abl i sh new house- kami s hri nes.
Thi s is t he reason for t heir l ow per cent age.
The quest i on to be consi der ed her e is: what ar e the r easons
for the fact that both groups showed high scores with regard to
having a place to venerate the ancestors? For 78.8% of the
Buddhi st househol ds t o indi cat e t hat t hey have a buddha alt ar is
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
27/45
J A P A N E S E J O UR N A L O F R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2/1 43
Tabl e 20
Household Possessi on of Tr adi t i onal Rel igi ous Facil it ies
Type of Facil i t y Posses si on Chr is t i an Buddhi st
House hol d Househol d
A pl ace t o v ene r at e
the ancestors
H A Buddha alt ar
a A subst it ut e
6 (28.6)
6 (38.1)
26 (78.8)
0 ( 0.0)
e Subt ot al 14 (66.7) 26 (78.8)
Do not have 7 (33.3) 7 (21.2)
Ka mi al t ar Hav e
Do not ha v e
7 (33.3)
14 (66.7)
26 (78.8)
7 (21.2)
A hous e- kami
shrine
Have
Do not ha v e
3 (14.3)
18 (85.7)
7 (21.2)
26 (78.8)
Kit chen kami a lt ar ,
wel l kami al t ar ,et c .
Have
Do not have
2 (9.5)
19 (90.5)
19 (57.6)
14 (42.4)
Totals 2 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 33 (100.0)
hardl y unusual , g i ven t heir r el ig ious af f i l iat ion.25 At t ent i on
focuses, therefore, on the Christian households. Their s ituation can
be described as follows.
Most of t he Chr i st i an househol ds re moved or di scar ded t heir
buddha al t ars dur i ng t he Mei j i per i od (1868- 1911), and their
"altar less s tate" continued unti l the ear ly y ears of the Showa
peri od (1926- )• But f rom about t he t ime of t he ”Fi f t een- Year
Wa r ,T t hat be g an wi t h t he Ma c hur i an i nci dent of 1 9 3 1 , a g r owi ng
number of t hese househol ds began t o set up buddha- al t ar
subst i t ut es in order t o have a pl ace to "r emember ” t heir war- dead.
A t t his t i me, ho we v e r , al mos t none of t he Chr i s t i an hous ehol ds
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
28/45
44 NI SHIY AMA: Chr is t ianit y in J apan
act ual l y set up buddha al t ars. Thi s devel opment di d not occur unt il
after the end of the war—in fact, not until quite recently. Since
1970 many new houses have been built in Shimo Fukuda. In the
case of the Christian households, building a new house came to
i ncl ude, al most as if t aken for g r ant ed, pr ovisi on in t he house
design for a special place in which to venerate the ancestors, and
in this pl ace eit her a buddha al t ar or a subst it ut e was i nst al l ed.26
Of t he 6 Chr i st i an households t hat now have buddha al t ars, 3
obt ai ned t hem si nce 1970. It is i mport ant t o i ndicat e, howev er ,
that this revived interest in having a place to venerate the
ancestors resulted not only in reviving the buddha altar, but also
in bringing to l ife the buddha altar substitute. If the percentage ofChr i st i an househol ds wit h subst it ut es wer e el i mi nat ed fr om Tabl e
20 , t he i t em havi ng t o do wi t h a pl ace to vener at e ancest ors
woul d s ho w a maj or di s c r epa nc y be t we e n Chr i s t i an and Buddhi s t
househol ds.
Taki ng t he Chri st i an househol ds by t hemsel ves now, let us rank
t he it ems i n Tabl e 20 by per cent age sc ores , beginning wi t h the
lowest and ending with the highest. Facilit ies for the functional
kami of t he house (t he kit chen kami , t he wel l kami , and the l ike)
st and at t he bot t om. Next comes t he house k ami who pr ot ect s t he
area around the house and whose shrine stands outside. As for the
pr ot ect i ve spir it s i nsi de t he house, namel y, t he kami of t he kami
alt ar and t he ancestr al spir i ts , t he highest per cent age of special
f acil i t i es ar e found in connect i ons wi t h t he cul t (or r emembrance)
of the ancestors .
Chr is t i ani t y and Tr adi t ional Rel i gi ous Event s of t he Communi t y
Tabl e 21 shows, for Chr i st i an and Buddhist househol ds, the degr ee
of participation in the annual round of traditional religious events.
The Christian events, Christmas and Easter, have been part of the
Shi mo Fukuda t radit ion for over 80 year s, so t hey ar e count ed
here as "t r adi t i onal .11
No at t empt wil l be made t o account for t he degr ee of
participation in each and every event, but it is remarkable that
t he one ev ent for whic h bot h gr oups of households show t he
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
29/45
J A P A NE S E J OUR NA L OF R E L I GI OUS S TUDI ES 12/1 45
Tabl e 21
Part i c ipat i on in t he Annual Cy cl e of Tradit i onal Rel ig i ous Event s
Ty pe of Event Part ic i pat i on C h r i s t i a n Buddhist
House hol ds Househol ds
Christ ian
Ea s t e r s e r v i c e at c hur c h ( Ma r /A p r ) Y e s 18 (85.7) 0 ( 0.0)
No 3 (14.3) 33 (100.0)
Chr i s t ma s s er v i c e at c hur c h (De c ) Y e s 2 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 6 (18.2)
No 0 ( 0.0) 27 (81.8)
Ot her
For New Y ea r hang fr esh st raw-
r o pe a nd pe nda nt paper - s t r i ps on Y e s 7 (33.3) 25 (75.8)
kami - al t ar No 14 (66.7* ) 8 (24.8)
Ot ok o obi sha ( Me n!s Yes 1 ( 4 . 8 ) 27 (81.8)
association) (Jan) No 20 (95.2) 6 (18.2)
Onna obisha (Wo me nTs Yes 0 ( 0.0) 25 (75.8)
as s oci at i on) (Fe b) No 2 1 ( 0 . 0 ) 8 (24.2)
Ser v e dur i ng meet i ng of Daishiko
(assn honori ng f ounder of Shingon) Yes 0 ( 0.0) 14 (42.4)
at Buddhist temple (July) No 2 1 ( 0 . 0 ) 19 (57.6)
Vi si t Shi nt o shr i ne dur i ng Y e s 1 ( 4 . 8 ) 17 (51.6)
t he Gi on Fes t i v al (J ul y ) No 20 (95.2) 16 (48.4)
We l c ome and s ee of f t he anc es t r al Y e s 15 (71.4) 26 (78.8)
spir its at the Bon Fest ival (Aug) No 6 (28.6) 7 (21.2)
House- kami r i t es dur i ng t he Y e s 1 ( 4 . 8 ) 17 (51.6)
Uj i gami Fes t i v al (Oc t ) No 20 (95.2) 16 (48.4)
Tot al 2 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 33 (100.0)
highest degree of participation, the welcoming and seeing off of
ancest r al spir it s at t he t ime of t he Bon Fest i val , corr esponds to
t he high per cent age of Chr is t i an and Buddhi st househol ds t hat
have special fac i l i t ies for venerat ing ancestors .
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
30/45
46 NISHIYAMA: Christ ianity in Japan
As f or par t i ci pat i on i n ot her ev ent s , t he hi ghs and l ows v ar y t o
some ext ent , but on t he whol e t he Buddhi st and Chr i st i an gr oups
demonst r at e a compar at i vel y high degr ee of part ici pati on in t he
events associated with their respect ive tradit ions. Conversely , for
events other than those associated with their own tradition, their
participation is low.
Tabl e 22
Par t i ci pat i on in Tr adi t i onal Bir t h and Gr owt h Cer emonies
Type of Cer emony Par t i ci pat i on Chr is t i an Buddhi st
House hol d Househol d
Shinto shrine visit with newborn Y e s 2 ( 9 . 5 ) 30 (91.0)
child No 19 (90.5) 3 ( 9.0)
Shi nt o shr i ne vi si t wi t h 7 and 3 Y es 2 ( 9 . 5 ) 30 (91.0)
y ear ol d gi r l s and 5 y ear ol d boy s No 19 (90.5) 3 ( 9.0)
Tot al 2 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 33 (100.0)
Tabl e 23
Part i c ipat i on in Ot her Cust omary Obser vances
Ty pe of Obs er v a nc e Par t i ci pat i on Chr i s t i an Buddhist
Ho us e ho l d Ho us e hol d
Me mor i al ser v i ce of pet dogs Y e s 0 ( 0.0) 25 (75.8)
(f or eas y chi l dbi r t h) No 2 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 8 (24.2)
Ri t es f or t he r oad- gui di ng kami Y es 2 ( 9.5) 14 (42.5)
No 19 (90.5) 19 (57.5)
Ta bo os on t he Da y of t he Rabbi t Y e s 2 ( 9.5) 10 (30.3)
(t o pl a nt o r s o w br i ng s ba d l uc k) No 19 (90.5) 23 (69.7)
Total 2 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 3 3 ( 1 00 .0 )
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
31/45
J A P A N E S E J O UR N A L OF R E L I G I OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 47
We t ur n no w t o t he de g r ee of par t i ci pat i on in t r adi t i onal
ceremonies pertaining to the birth and growth of children, the
subj ect of Tabl e 22. Her e t he dif f er ence bet wee n Chr i st i an and
Buddhi st househol ds is pl ain and cl ear. Tabl e 23 deal s wi t h the
degree of participation in other customary observances, and here
again the dif ference is evident .
No mat t er what non- Chr i st i an ev ent is consi dered, t hen, the
degree of participation by Christian households is invariably lower
t han t hat of t he Buddhi st . Wi t hout much exagger at i on one coul d
say that the Christian households participate in almost none of the
non- Chr is t i an events . For t his v ery r eason, t heir high degr ee of
participation in the welcoming and seeing off of ancestral spiritsat the t ime of the Bon Festival becomes all the more noteworthy.
Christ ianity and the A ncestral Cul t
The st r ong and dis t i nct iv e sent i ment s t hat t he J apanese peopl e
hol d wi t h r egar d t o t heir ancest ors has l ong been known. Thes e
sentiments go well beyond merely loving, respecting, and cherish
ing the memory of the dead; they entail addressing the dead in
pr ayer , r egardi ng t hem wi t h worshipful r espect , and beseechingt heir unse en ai d. When this st age has bee n r eac hed, it is appro
priate to speak of the "ancestral cult” (C f . Y a n a g i t a 1 9 6 9 , A r u g a
1 9 69 , T a k e da 1 9 57 , Mo r i o k a 1 9 59 , p. 3 1 , e t c . ). T he pos i t i on
adopt ed in this st udy is t hat when Chr i st i ans come t o hold ideas
about their ancestors and deceased family members that corre
spond to this st age, t heir fai t h may be r egar ded as havi ng under
gone a substantive change.
The fi rst quest i on t o be r ais ed in consi der i ng whet her such a
substantive change has occurred is this to what ext ent has t he
Chri st i an concept of monot hei sm ent er ed i nt o t he consci ousness of
Shi mo Fukuda Chr is t i ans? This is t r eat ed in Tabl e 2 4, whi ch
presents the results of asking respondents whether they agree with
t he vi ew t hat peopl e bel ongi ng to his or her rel igi ous gr oup shoul d
not wor shi p a kami or buddha of a di f fe r ent rel igi on.
For the purpose of analysis, the responses to this question are
mat ched wi t h t he earl ier r esponses to t he quest ion of whet her t he
r espondent ’s househol d has a pl ace to venerat e t he ancest ors.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
32/45
48 NIS HI Y AMA: Chr ist ianit y in J apan
T a b l e ? 4
Monot hei st i c vs. Syncr et i st i c Ideas about God
Quest i on: Do you agr ee t hat peopl e of your rel i gious group shoul d
not worship a kami or buddha of a different religion?
Response Ag r e e Disagree Do n ’t K no w To t a l
Chr i s t i a ns wh o ha v e a
buddha al t ar 1 (20.0) 4 (80.0) 0 (0.0) 5 (100.0)
Chr i s t i ans who hav e a
s ubs t i t ut e 4 (50.0) 4 (50.0) 0 (0.0) 8 (10.0)Christians who h av e no
special place 4 (66.6* ) 2 (33.4) 0 (0.0) 6 (100.0)
Tot al 9 (47.4) 10 (52.6) 0 (0.0) 19 (100.0)
Non- Chr i s t i a ns wh o ha v e
a buddha altar 3 (16.7) 15 (83.3) 0 (0.0) 18 (100.0)
No n- Chr i s t i a ns wh o ha v e
no special place 0 (0.0) 1 (100.0) 0 (0.0) 1 (100.0)
Tot al 3 ( 1 5 . 8 ) 1 6 (84.2) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 1 9 (100.0)
Not e: The res pondent s in Tabl es 24 and 25 wer e sel ect ed in t he
f ol l owi ng way. First , Chr i st i an househol ds wit h church member s
we r e c ho s en (20 hous ehol ds ). Sec ond, an equal number of Buddhi st
househol ds fo unded at appr oxi mat el y t he same t ime as t he
Chri st i an and simil ar i n other r espect s was sel ect ed as a cont rol
gr oup. Si nce, howeve r , it pr oved i mpossi bl e to quest i on 1 Chri st i an
ho us e ho l d,1 househol d was r emoved fr om t he Buddhis t g r oup, thus
maki ng 19 in each gr oup. The pr incipl e fol l owed in each cas e was
to interview either the head of the household or his wife. It should
be added that all of the Christians interviewed had received
confirmation.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
33/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 49
Si nce onl y one per son in t he non- Chr is t i an gr oup sai d that his
househol d had no pl ace t o vener at e t he ancest ors , t he f i gures f or
t his r espondent have been del et ed fr om t he anal ysi s; t he
non- Chr i st i an "Tot al " col umn is used inst ead. (The s ame hol ds t rue
for Tabl e 25.)
One point t o not e about Tabl e 24 is that a majori t y of t he
Christians (52.6%), even though this rate is lower than that for the
non- Chr i st i ans, r esponded that t hey do not agr ee wi t h t he vi ew
stated in the question. To the extent that Christian people
selected this answer, their fa ith ref lects , we venture to say , a
substantive change.
Whe n t he ans wer s t o t his que s t i on ar e mat che d wi t h t heresponses to the question dealing with provision of a place for
vener at i ng t he ancest ors , an int erest ing pat t ern emerg es . Of t he
Christians who agreed that one should not worship a kami or
buddha of anot her r el igi on, the hi ghest per cent age (6 6.6 %) is f ound
among t hose who Mhave no special pl ace " t o venera t e t he
ancest ors , t he next to t he hi ghest (50 .0%) among t hose who "have
a subst it ut e" (for t he buddha al t ar), and t he l owest (20 .0%) among
t hose who "hav e a buddha al t ar.11 Conver sel y, t he perc entag e for
Chr i st i ans di sagr eei ng wi t h t his v i ew was highest if t hey had a
buddha al t ar and the l owest if t hey had no special pl ace to
venerate the ancestors . The fact that the high percentage of
Christians with buddha altars who disagreed with this view (80.0%)
dif fer s onl y s li ght l y f rom t hat of t he non- Chri st ians (82.2%)
suggests that even today the buddha altar represents a tangible
power- base for t he ancestr al cul t .
Tabl e 25 pr esent s t he resul t s of measur i ng t hr ee di ff erent
att i tudes toward ancestral or m em orial r i tes and analy zing the
r esponses i n acc or dance wit h whet her t he r espondent 's househol d
has a buddha altar or substitute. The f irst question asks the
respondent's views as to the importance of such rites, the second
whe t he r t hey hol d t hat t he ances t or s wa t c h ov er t he l i vi ng
members of their l ineage, and the third about the attitudes
(feelings) they hold as they direct their attention toward the
ancestors in the special place provided for their venerat ion.
Th r e e s et s o f r e s po ns e s a r e p ar t i c ul a r l y wo r t hy o f a t t e n t i o n :( 1)
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
34/45
T a b l e 2 5
A t t i t u d e s T o w a r d A n c e s t r a l o r Me mo r i a l R i t e s
cno
C h r i s t i a n s J o n- C h r i s t i a n s
A t t i t u d eH a v e a
b u d d h a
a l t a r
H a v e a
s u bs t i -
t u t e
H a v e n o
s p e c i a l
p l a c e
T o t a l
H a v e a
b u d d h a
a l t a r
Ha v e n o
s p e c i a l
p l a c e
T o t a l
A r e a n c e s t r a l ( me mo r i a l ) r i t e s i mp o r t a n t o r n o t ?
I m p o r t a n t 5 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 7 ( 8 7 . 5 ) 5 ( 8 3 . 3 ) 1 7 ( 8 9 . 5 ) 1 8 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 9 ( 1 0 0 . 0 )
Un i mp o r t a n t 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 2 . 5 ) 1 ( 1 6 . 7 ) 2 ( 1 0. 5 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 )
D o n ,t k n o w 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 )
Do t h e a n c e s t r a l s pi r i t s w a t c h o v e r t h e i r o w n ?
T he y do 5 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 8 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 4 ( 6 6 . 6 * ) 1 7 ( 8 9 . 4 )T h e y d o n » t 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 6 . 7 ) 1 ( 5 . 3 )
D o n rt k n o w 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 6 . 7 ) 1 ( 5 . 3 )
1 7 ( 9 4 . 5 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 )
0 (0.0) 0 (0 .0) 1 ( 5 . 5 ) 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 )
1 7 ( 8 9 . 5 )
0 (0 .0 ) 2 (1 0 . 0 )
W h a t f e e l i n g do y o u
R e m e m b e r wi t h
u s ua l l y h a v e w h e n us i n g t he ! p l a c e w h e r e t h e a n c e s t o r s a r e v e n e r a t e d ?
r e s p e c t
L i k e t a l k i n g
wi t h a l i v i ng
0 ( 0 . 0 ) 4 ( 5 0 . 0 ) 2 ( 3 3 . 2 ) 6 ( 3 1 . 5 ) 2 ( 1 1 . 1 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 2 ( 10 , 5 )
p e r s o n
P r a y e r t o
t h e k a m i or
b u d d h a s f o r
1 ( 2 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 2 . 5 ) 1 ( 1 6 . 7 ) 3 ( 1 5 . 8 ) 2 ( 1 1 . 1 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 2 ( 1 0 . 5 )
p r o t e c t i o n 2
P r a y e r t o G o df o r t h ei r
( 4 0 . 0 ) 2 ( 2 5 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 6 , 7 ) 5 ( 2 6 . 3 ) 2 ( 6 6 . 7 ) 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 3 ( 6 8 . 5 )
s a l v a t i o n
I d o n f t
t h i n k a b o u t
0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 6 . 7 ) 1 ( 5 . 3 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( o . o )
a n y t h i n g
Ne v e r u s e d
2 ( 4 0 .0 ) 1 ( 1 2 . 5 ) 0 ( o . o ) 3 ( 1 5 . 8 ) 2 ( 1 1 . 1 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 2 ( 1 0 .5 )
s u c h a p l a c e 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 6 . 7 ) 1 ( 5 . 3 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( o . o )D o n f t k n o w 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( o . o ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 . 0 ) 0 ( 0 , 0 )
T o t a l ( 10 0 , 0 ) 8 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 6 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 9 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 8 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 ( 1 0 0 . 0 ) 1 9 ( 1 0 0 . 0 )
NI S HI Y A S A :
C h r i s t i ani t y
i n
J a p an
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
35/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 51
those aff irming the importance of such rites , ⑵ those
acknowl edgi ng bel i ef t hat t he ancest ors do wat ch over t he li ving,
and (3) t hose i ndi cati ng t hat use of t he ancest or- venerat ion pl ace
is acc ompani ed by t he f eel i ng of prayi ng to t he kami or t he
buddhas for pr otect i on. Of t he i t ems l eadi ng t o t hese r esponses,
t he f ir st deals onl y wi t h t he most general , superf i cial , and
peripheral kind of attitude, for the question speaks of ancestral
rites as embracing memorial r ites, though only the latter can
clear ly be said to involve no conf l ict with Christ ian faith. The
second item, however, dealing with whether the ancestors watch
over their l iving kin, introduces another attitude. In this case the
quest ion of confl i ct wit h Chr is t i an fai t h becomes harder t oanswer , for t his at t i t ude may i nvol ve t he i dea of nunse en ai d11
(di vi ne pr otect i on) or it may i nvolv e a compl et el y dif fer ent kind of
understanding. Be that as it may, aff irmation of the belief that
t he ancest ors wat ch over t heir own woul d seem t o invol ve great er
possibi l i ty for conf l ict with Christ ian faith than af f irm ation of the
importance of ancestral or memorial r ites. Finally, as over against
t hese f i rst t wo at t it udes, t he att i t ude t hat one is Mpr ayi ng t o the
kami or buddhas f or pr ot ect i on" when addres si ng onesel f t o t he
ancestors in the special place provided for their veneration is even
more definite,deeply seated, and central. For here the ancestors,
the deceased family members, are clearly placed on the same level
as t he kami and buddhas, and it is in t his capaci t y t hat t heir
"unse en ai dn is besought .
Wi t h r egar d t o t he i t em de al i ng wi t h t he i mpor t ance of t hes e
ri t es, al l t he non- Chri st ians aff i r m t heir i mpor t ance. As for t he
Christians, 100% of those with a buddha altar believe them
i mpor t ant , 8 7. 5% of t hose wi t h a buddha al t ar subst i t ut e, and
83.3% of those with no special place for venerating the
ancestors—a series of diminishing percentages; conversely, among
those who believe them unimportant, a series of increasing
percentages is found. The reason that as many as 89.5% of the
total num ber of Christ ians af f irm ed that these r i tes were
i mport ant is pr obabl y due t o t he f act t hat t he quest i on i ncl uded
t he t erm "memor i al ." Hence ev en t hough t he gr eat majori t y of
Christians said they believed the rites important, it would be a
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
36/45
52 NI SHIY AMA: Chri st ianit y in J apan
hasty judgment to say without further ado that their faith has
taken on an ancestral cult coloration.
The s econd i t em, rais i ng the quest i on of whet her t he ancest ors
wa t c h ov er t hei r own, r esul t ed i n pe r c ent age s t hat we r e near l y
i dent ical for both Chr is t i an (89 .4%) and non- Chr is t ians (89. 5%). But
whe t he r t his mea ns , f or t he Chr i s t i ans , t hat t hei r f ai t h has t ak en
on an ancest r al cul t color ati on is sti l l open to quest i on. For it is
by no means cer t ai n that t he t erm ,!wat ch ove r " is to be ident i fi ed
wi t h t he mor e speci f i c di vi ne pr ot ect i on s ug ges t ed by t he t er m
"unseen aid.”
If the Christians alone are considered in relation to this second
i t em, it t urns out t hat bot h those wi t h a buddha al t ar and t hose wi t h a subs t i t ut e we r e 1 0 0 % in ag r eement wi t h t he i dea t hat t he
ancest ors wat ch over t heir l ivi ng kin, wher eas t hose wi t h no
special place for venerating the ancestors were only 66.6% in
agr eement wi t h this i dea. It appears , t her ef ore, t hat t he responses
to t his i t em ar e not unr el at ed to whet her t he househol d has a
special place to venerate the ancestors .
Finally, let us consider the third item, the one having to do
wi t h t he !,f eel i ng of pr ay i ng t o t he kami or t he buddha s f or di v i neprot ect ion.” The perc ent age of non- Chri st ians giv ing this repl y was
68.5%, the percentage of Christians 26.3%. As compared to the
f irs t t wo i t ems, t he di f fer ence bet ween t he Chr is t i an and
non- Chr is t ian perc ent ages is consi derabl y gr eater . Among t he
non- Chr i st i ans, t he per cent age of peopl e who chose t his response
(6 8.5 %) far out wei ghs al l t he other r esponses t o this i t em, but
among t he Chri st i ans, t he res ponse t hat t akes fi rst pl ace is fr a
f eel i ng of r emember i ng hi m/her wi t h r es pect " (31 .5%). From this it
appears that the Christians of Shimo Fukuda, when compared with
t he non- Chr ist ians, have s ucceeded t o a fair l y high degr ee in
ext r i cat i ng t hemsel ves f rom t he t radit ional ancestr al cul t . Agai n,
it may be possible t o i nt erpret what we see here as a subst ant i ve
change in t he ancest r al cul t result ing fr om t he adopt i on of
C h r i s t i a n i t y .
On the other hand, if this situation is viewed from the
standpoint of Christian faith, it becomes apparent that if as many
as 26.3% of the Christians, when using the special ancestor
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
37/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L O F R E L I G I OUS S T UDI E S 1 2 /1 53
venerat i on pl ace, have t he "f eel i ng of prayi ng t o t he kami or t he
buddhas for prot ect i on," t hen t o this ext ent t he Chr i st i ani t y of
t his c ommuni t y has under gone a subst ant i ve change in t he
di r ect i on of t he ancest r al cul t . Wi t h r egard to t he it ems deali ng
wi t h t he "i mpor t anc e " of anc es t r al or memor i al r i t es and wi t h t he
quest i on of whet her t he ancest ors ar e bel i eved to "wat ch over11
their own, it was not possible to state f latly that a substantive
change had occur r ed, but wi t h regar d t o t his it em, it can be st at e
wi t hout equi vocat i on.
The Chr i st i ans1 r esponses t o this it em for m a di mi ni shing seri es
o f p e r c e n t a g e s t hose wi t h a buddha al t ar at 40 .0 %, t hose wit h a
substitute at 25.0%, and those with neither at 16.7%.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
The results of the foregoing study may be summarized as
f o l l o w s
1 . In t he Shimo Fukuda communit y, members hip in Chr i st i ani t y,
generation by generation, takes place in household units. The
Christianity of this community exhibits , in other words, peripheral
change.
2. Going beyond mere peripheral change, Shimo Fukuda
Christ ianity a lso g ives evidence, part icular ly in relat ion to the
buddha altar and its substitute, of substantive change in the
direct ion of the ancestral cult . Again, the percentages for
att i tudes relat ing to ancestral r i tes suggests not only that these
att i tudes are c losely l inked to the presence or absence of
ancestral cult facilit ies, especially the buddha altar, but also that
the buddha altar continues to the present day to be a tangible
power- base for t he ancestr al cul t .
3. Consequent l y, t he pr imary f act or l eadi ng to subst ant i ve
change in the Christianity of this community is the ancestral cult .
It may be concl uded t her ef ore t hat t he t wo hypot heses pres ent ed
at the outset have been verif ied.
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
38/45
54 NI SHI Y AMA: Chri st ianit y in J apan
App endi x
This paper originated as an M.A. thesis presented to the Tokyo
Univ ers i t y of Educat i on in 1972. A summar y r eport was presented
t o the J apan Sociol ogical Societ y in 19 74 , and that summary ,
revised and corrected, forms the content of this paper.
From the writing of the thesis through the writing of this
paper, Professor MORIOKA Kiyomi provided me with a wealth of
i nst ructi on. Al so,at t he act ual r esearc h st age,a number of peopl e
in Shi mo Fuk uda communi t y ass i st ed me in mor e way s t han I can
begin t o count . To both I shoul d l i ke t o expres s my deep
appreciation.
Not es
1 . T he r e a de r i s r e f e r r e d t o Mo r i o k a 1 9 59 , p. 2 3 2; 1 9 5 7 , p . 4 ;
1 9 6 7 , p . 1 2 ; 1 9 70 b, pp. 1 42 - 1 43 , e t c .
2. This is not t o say t hat Chr is t i anit y as a whol e, i ncl uding
t hat of Eur ope and t he Amer i ca ,is a non- insti t ut ionali zed form of
culture; it is only to stipulate that the Christianity that came toJ apan, by reason of i ts rel at ively short hist ory her e, is a
non- i nst it ut i onal i zed for m. One shoul d al so bear in mi nd Dur khei m!s
character izat ion of "social facts" as consist ing of externality and
r est r aint (Durk heim 1895).
3. Th e t erm !Tuni t of r el i gi ous member s hi p” us ed in t hi s paper is
equi val ent to Mor i oka!s t erm, "soci al basis of rel igi on.” See
Mor i oka 1968.
4. Wi t h regard to requi rement 1 , see Sect i on IV; wit h regard to
requirements 2, 3, and 4, see Section III.5. It should be noted, however, that within the spectrum of
Prot es t ant denomi nat i ons, Fukuda Episc opal Chur ch bel ongs t o t he
strand that stands closest to the older traditions, namely,the
Roman Cat hol i c and Or t hodox. As c ompared t o other Prot est ant
denomi nat i ons, t he Angl i can or Episc opal Chur ch l ays onl y mil d
emphasi s on i ndi vi dual i sm; wi t h r egar d to mi ssi on wor k in
non- Chr i st i an count r ies, it endeavor s t o t ake as sympat het i c an
attitude as possible toward the cultures of these countries and the
feelings of their people, and it may be supposed that for this very
reason its faith, as compared to that of other Protestant
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
39/45
J A P A NE S E J OUR NA L OF R E L I GI OUS S TUDI ES 12/1 55
denomi nat i ons, is pr one t o subst ant i ve c hange. In this r espect ,
therefore, it is not altogether suitable as an object of
i nvest i gat i on. But when Fukuda Angl i can Epi scopal Chur ch is t aken
as our object and concretely considered with respect to the
problem of substantive change, it becomes quite diff icult to
ascer t ain whet her and t o what ext ent this denomi nat i onal fact or
plays a role. In this paper, accordingly, an analysis of this factor
wi l l not be under t ake n. I s houl d l i ke, ho we v er , t o ex pr es s he r e my
appr eciat i on to Profess or NIS HI Y AMA Toshi hi ko of Eichi Univ ersi t y
who, i n r es ponse t o a pr es ent at i on I made at t he 47 t h As s embl y of
t he J apan Sociol ogical Associ at i on, kindl y and apt l y point ed out
t he i mport ance of this denomi nat i onal f act or . I shoul d als o l ike t o
r efer t he reader t o an art icl e on t he Chr is t i an Univ ersi t y by
Tsukada (1971).
6. Nishiyama 1972, 1973.
7. See the Chi ba ke n Shi mos a no kurti Shi mo Hab u gun Shimo
Fukuda son s h i 千 葉 県 下 総 国 下 埴 生 郡 下 福 田 村 誌 (Chr oni cl e of Shimo
Fukuda Vi l l age in Shimo Habu Dis t r i ct , Shim5sa Count y , Chi ba
Prefecture; February 1884).
8. See the preceding reference; also the Shimo Fukuda mura
kotakuchi sanrin tanbetsu chika chiso gdkeicho 下 福 田 村 耕 宅 地 山
林 反 別 地 価 地 租 合 計 帳 (Memor i al cov er i ng t he asses sed v al ue of and
l and t ax on the ar abl e, res i dent i al , and woode d l and, in t an units,held by Shimo Fukuda Village; 1885).
9. See the previously cited Chronicle.
10. See t he document ent it l ed Mei j i go (mi zunoe, sar u) nen Inba
ken kankat sa dai- nana dai ka dai- ni shoku koseki no ichi (Habu gunt
Shimo Fukuda mura) 明 治 五 壬 申 年 印 旛 県 管 轄 第 七 大 区 第 二 小 区 戸 籍
之 一 ( 埴 生 郡 下 福 田 村 )(Househol d regis t r y n o . 1 for sub- dis t ri ct no.
2 in di st ri ct no. 7 of Inba Pre f ec t ur e (Habu gun, Shi mo Fukuda
Vi l l ag e). Febr ua r y 1873.
1 1 . Tne term nt hree generat i ons” means t hat t he f irs t famil ymember t o r ecei ve bapt i sm is count ed as t he fir st generat i on, and
that the next family members to become Christian are his or her
parent s, on t he one hand, and chil dr en, on t he ot her.
12. Most of t he dat a t o be c onsi der ed in this sect i on wer e
obt ai ned in a sur vey conduct ed for f our days begi nni ng on 10
Sept ember 1971. One part of t he dat a, howev er , comes fr om a
suppl ement ar y sur vey c onduct ed on 28 Nov ember 1 971.
13. The t erm "Chr i s t i an house hol d1' has a br oad and a nar r ow
meaning. The broad meaning includes the pastor and his family,
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
40/45
56 NISHIYAMA: Christ ianity in Japan
ev en t hough t hey come f r om out si de t he communi t y; t he narr ow
meaning ex cl udes t he past or and his f ami l y, l i mit i ng t he t erm t o
t hose c ommuni t y househol ds t hat for sever al gener at ions have
i dent i f i ed Chr i st i ani t y as their "house hol d r el i gi on.11 In this paper ,
t he narr ow meaning wil l be empl oyed. When it bec omes necessar y
t o i ncl ude t he past or and his f ami l y, a di f f er ent t erm wil l be use d,
namel y, "Chri st i an home.”
14. Ev en t hough l umped t oget her as "Buddhis t househol ds," their
actual sect af f i l iat ion shows considerable var iety . These sects and
t he number of househol ds af f i l i ated wi t h each ar e as f ol l ows
Tendai 1 7,Shingon 6, Ji 3, Ni chi r en Shoshu (Soka Ga k k a i ) 1 、Zen
( f ur t he r det a i l s u n s p e c i f i e d ) 1 , J o do 1 , Te nr i Honmi c hi 1 , Shi nt o
(Shi nt o f u n e r a l ) 1 , no ne 1 . T he r eas on f or t r e at i ng t hem as a
single category here is that, with the exception of the two
households aff i l iated with the Nichiren Shoshu (Soka Gakkai), all
participate cooperatively in the traditional religious ceremonies. In
this r espect t hey ar e to be dis t ingui shed from t he "Chri st i an
househol ds.**
15. In Shimo Fukuda t oday t her e is one "Chr i st i an househol d”
t hat bel onged t o t he churc h up to t he pr evi ous gener at i on, but
curr ent l y has no churc h member in t he househol d. Despi t e this
anomal y , it does not a l l ow its cont act wit h other Chr is t i an
households to lapse.
16. "Fi nanci al support ’1 means, of cour se, money gi ven t o t he
church through offerings, but the point to note is that most of this
support derives from a system in which a treasurer is assigned to
each kami and is responsible to visit each Christian household and
collect money for the church on a household basis. The money thus
collected is cal led j i kyu (sel f- support ), a ter m t hat began at an
earlier t ime when the church, seeking to eliminate reliance on
subsi dies fr om t he mi ss i on board and ot her churc hes, undert ook to
raise "of f er i ngs for t he sake of achi evi ng sel f- support .” Today ,however, the term simply identifies money given to the church by
the Christian households.
17. The vol unt ary l abor i ncl udes wor k in the Chur c hTs
paddyl and, of f er i ng hospit ali t y t o t he bi shop who comes eac h
aut umn t o admi ni st er conf i rmat i on rit es, etc .
18. Chr i st mas, East er , Thanksgiving, etc .
19. A vol unt ary associ at i on hel d on compl et i on of t he major
agricultural tasks of the year (planting and harvesting) as a form
-
8/19/2019 INDIGENIZATION AND TRANSFORMATION OF CHRISTIANITY IN A JAPANESE RURAL COMMUNITY.
41/45
J A P A N E S E J OU R N A L OF R E L I GI OUS S T UDI E S 1 2/1 57
of recr eat i on for t he women. I ts act i vit ies consist s pr i mari l y of
eating, drinking, and pleasant chatting.
20. vNando role" means t hat on the occasi on of a deat h, 5 or 6
pers ons from t he aff i l i ate d o z o k u and neighbor i ng househol ds t ake
compl et e r esponsibil it y^ on behal f of t he ber eav ed househol d
member s, for t he management of ever yt hing t hat must be done
from the wake through the funeral.
2 1 . One may ment ion, for exampl e, t he nei ghbor hood fel l owship
groups, the group known as kamasu nakama whose members pay
condol ence visit s on any member who suf fer s ber eav ement , t he
kyode keiyaku (f raternal covenant) group i n whi ch peopl e so
i ncl i ned for m bonds l i ke t hose bet ween br ot her and br ot her , and
the yoi and suketo groups that have as their purpose agricultural
cooper at i on and mut ual aid.
22. In this t abl e t he f irst pers on t o acce pt Chr i st i an fait h is
count ed as a f ir st - generati on Chr i st i an, his or her chil dr en as
second- generat ion,