Indian Magazine Congress February 24, 2014
description
Transcript of Indian Magazine Congress February 24, 2014
Indian Magazine Congress
February 24, 2014
Had Newsweek been in India, print issue of Newsweek would have continued to thrive and grow.
Magazines in 2013 grew by 5%Print: 10%; Overall Advertising 11.1%
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Proj0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
426491
581672 678
786
624
899
11501202
12621325
Source: Pitch Madison Media Advertising Outlook 2014
Global consumer magazine market US$81.9bn in 2012(CAGR of less than 1% over 5 years)
The largest market, USA, is expected to de grow (-1.3% CAGR over 2012-2017)
Emerging economies are growing at faster clip and proving to be resilient
Magazines are growing in emerging economies
South Africa
Brazil
China
Nigeria
Kenya
7
7
7
9
9
Magazine Expected CAGR Growth(2012- 2017)
Source: PWC – Global Entertainment and Media Outlook (2013- 2017)
One comes across many such remarks, indicating inherent strength in Indian Publishing Industry
Rising Incomes and Aspiration, are positive drivers for
magazine’s growth in emerging economies
5 insights, reinforce Magazines as a great medium
Magazinesare
#1in readerengagement
Social Interaction
Life-enhanching
Inspirational
Ad attention
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
106
111
112
116
96
103
95
95
101
89
99
96
TV Internet MagazinesSource: Experian Marketing Services, Simmons Multi-Media Engagement Study, Fall 2012
Insight # 1
Magazine
Newspapers
Websites
Radio
TV
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60%
10%
11%
18%
23%
51%
““I often find the advertising annoying”
MagazineAds are
LeastAnnoying
Base: All aged 15+Source: Absorbing Media, 2002
Insight # 2
Magazines capture
undivided attention91% of consumers when they read magazines are least likely to engage in other activity
Radio
Online
TV
Magazines
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
73
75
80
91
Source: Simultaneous Media usage study
Insight # 3
Magazines Websites TV
I pay attention to or notice ads 145 85 90
Ads fit well with the content 139 96 86It is a way to learn about new products 135 100 77
Inspires me in my own life 135 96 88
Gets me to try new things 131 100 81
I get valuable info from the ads 130 96 83Ads help me make purchase decisions 130 100 85I am more likely to buy products in ads 125 95 85
Inspires me to buy things 122 109 78
I trust it to tell the truth 113 107 84
It is an escape for me 111 77 114
Magazinesads are
Noticed and
Influential
Source: Experian Marketing Services, Simmons Multi-Media Engagement Study, Fall 2012
Insight # 4
Magazinestalk toSuperInfluencers
Newspapers
TV
Radio
Internet
Magazines
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
2
4
30
38
42
Base: Top quintile of usage for each medium among adults with a HHI of $50K+Super influentials are defined as people who have great experience in this topic and whose advice on this topic is trusted by friends and family membersSource: GfK MRI, Fall 2012
Number of times medium ranks #1 or #2 among super influential consumers across 60 product categories
Insight # 5
1. # 1 in engagement – Thanks to segmented audience of magazines
2. Ads are least annoying – Increasing efficacy of advertisements
3. Undivided attention – Critical in today’s era of multi screen consumption
4. Ads are Noticed and Influential – Opinion Makers
5. Speak to influencers – In era of social media connectivity, amplification of those with social clout : Critical
Why magazines have an Edge5
WHY MAGAZINES SHOULD FEATURE IN MEGA MEDIA PLANS?
Key Finding of Madison’s M:Spectra Once 70 @1+ thru TV is achieved Incremental reach is cheaper by using other media than
TV Magazine could feature purely as cost efficient choice
once diminishing return sets in TV
M:Spectra is a Madison proprietary tool that estimates combined reach across media
A proxy for single source data that is unavailable in India
Magazines can deliver on media numbers for high reach plans
Similar findings from other marketsBARB/TGI using fused data discovered
Shifting 25% of budget from TV to Magazines resulted in• Increase in gross ratings from 400 to 493 amongst All Women• Increase in 1+ reach from 73% to 87% Amongst Light Viewers of TV, “TV alone” plan was inadequateAdding Magazines doubled Gross ratings and increased reach from 50 to 76 doubled amongst light viewers
TV only (100% of Budget)
All Women
Light Viewers
Gross Ratings 400 163
Net Coverage (1+) 73.2 50.9
TV 75% + Magazines 25%
All Women
Light Viewers
Gross Ratings 493 309
Net Coverage (1+) 86.7 75.8
BARB/TGI fusion, using KMR-SPC’s Mercury software.
However, selection criteria should not be only based on Maximizing media numbers
But Medium’s ability to improve brand scores on key parameters
Madison Touch Point Study points
A proprietary study to understand role and influence of different media in different categories
FMCG, Top 6 Metros, Female 25+, Sample Size : 200+
Paid Owned Earned
Magazines play a key role in amplifying “Suitable for my needs” and in helping make Final Decision
TV
Radio
Newspapers
Health/Women's mag cooking sections
Brand FB page/website
Product Packaging
WOM Diet/health expert
WOM health/Diet Bloggers
Recommendation by neighbours friends ,family collegues etc..
You tube videos
30.0
80.0
Gen Info pc Info Brand manages health & weight Suitable for my needs Make Final Decision
Important to note: Multimedia usage is important!
Paid Owned Earned
Cooking Oils could probably do without TV but NOT WITHOUT health/women’s magazines
TV
Radio
Newspapers
Health/Women's mag cooking sections
Brand FB page/website
Product Packaging
WOM Diet/health expert
WOM health/Diet Bloggers
Recommendation by neighbours friends ,family etc..
You tube videos
30
80
Gen Info Spc. Info Good for health/heart Brand suitable for me Convinces you to try
Important to note: Multimedia usage is important!
Paid Owned EarnedTV
Radio
Newspapers
Womens mag
Brand FB page/website
Product Packaging
Celebrity Endorser
WOM Beauty Bloggers
DOC/ Beauticien expert
Consumer reviews
30
80
Gen Info Spc Info Premium brand Brand suitable for me Trial
If Shampoo brands do not consider magazines, they are opting for a sub optimal strategy
Important to note: Multimedia usage is important!
Similar evidence from International Studies
• Study on how media impacts consumers as they go thru five identified stages of the buying process (purchase funnel)
• Studied impact across purchase funnel for• TV alone• Incremental impact of Online
to TV• Incremental impact of
Magazines to TV + Online
Process Impact of Magazine
Aided Brand Awareness
No significant difference
Ad Awareness -do-
Message Association TV showed the biggest percentage point change.
Brand Favorability Magazines held a significant leadcompared to either TV or online.
Purchase Intent/Consideration
Magazines significantly outperformed other media in driving positive shifts in purchase consideration/intent.Dynamic Logic, a company specializing
in advertising accountability aggregated 39 case studies for the study
Marketing Management Analytics (MMA), studied 186 brands across 13 different product categories
If brands increased allocation to magazines, effectiveness of TV increased.
Increase in brand metrics (awareness)
Diverting a portion of campaign budget to magazines improves effectiveness of lead media
0-4% 4-10% 10 + %
0.600000000000001
0.8
1.1
% of total spends of the campaign allocated to Magazines
Tele
visio
n Eff
ectiv
enes
s
At Madison, we have seen it in action
• For Saffola, we used magazines (along with other media) for an important campaign
• Saffola’s score as an expert on heart case increased from 59% to 67%
• Media Impact Analysis study independently conducted by Millward Brown concluded Print contributed to more than 50% of the brand equity uplift.
We can garner more benefits by thinking “out of the box”
Sampling thru magazines is a “no brainer” Segmented audience Publishers need to find innovative
ways to minimize leakage
As with any media, it pays to be innovative
Being Innovative in magazine pays
Execution Index
Standard flat advertisement 100
Inserts – linked to ad 112
Innovation 120+
Sampling 141
Stop Watch research; Sampling Innovations commissionedresearch among readers of Marie Claire magazine.
Not just a round shaped ad instead of square one• Clutter breaking but limited shelf life
Sustainable Innovation is by leveraging inherent strengths of magazines• Leveraging Magazine credibility• Speaking to influencers• Precise message for segmented audience
Being Innovative
Magazines offer stature
TIME Person of the yearNo other media but only a magazine can create such an
Iconic propertyProperty has stature because it is from credible magazine and has been consistent since 1927
Requirements to create iconic properties: Appealing to core audience Being consistent (Femina Miss India has been running since 1964)
Marketers need to embrace partnership Not ride on established property but co-create and
invest over long horizon for maximum impact
By Co-creating iconic properties, marketers can build stature for their brands
For Marico, we took social media outside of online world
Brands can use magazines to talk to Influencers
Insight that drove Marico’s thought process
Magazines build buzz. They excel in reaching people who shape attitudes and behavior.
Source: GfK MRI Fall 2011
Skoda targeting small set with relevant message
Simply Superb with Mansworld Created a special section in the magazine
where the brand communication “Legend is Back” was integrated into the editorial content
Prominent individuals spoke about their rules/ formulas that have worked for them
The readers got an insight into personality’s life and their philosophy
Ride to Glory with Harper Bazaar• Taking the same idea forward, Superb
targeted successful woman from different fields who spoke about their mantra of success
• The shoot captured the space and features of the car along with editorial content
• Massive 20,000+ enquiries recorded after the launch
• The search on Google for the brand Octavia shot up by 550%
• Sale target set for 2 months was achieved in just 3 weeks; whopping 1000+ cars were sold
• The entire success of the launch got highly appreciated and recorded as best practices by the Skoda headquarters
Results
For Marico, we took social media outside of online world
Brands can use magazines to talk to Influencers
MANTRAS FOR MARKETERS
Magazine offer segmented audience Evaluate on Cost per incremental Output (sales/brand metrics) vs. CPT
Multimedia is the only sustainable approach to beat clutter Allocate 10% to magazines, it improves effectiveness of other 90%
Innovate Magazines remain the best media to speak to influencers Innovation pays. If it is safe, it is risky.
Partner with publishers Co-Create enduring properties building on credibility offered by
magazines
RECOMMENDATION TO MY PUBLISHER FRIENDS
Commission research to amplify efficacy Study and record engagement metrics (ad avoidance /
Influence in purchase decision) Segment audience well and be true to your customers
Embrace digital media. An opportunity not a threat Magzter – Early example of how magazines can benefit
from digital media/ mobile explosion Magazines have more to gain
• Content rules : Online or Offline• Credibility of your magazines cannot be easily replicated