Presentation made by Lual A. Deng at a High Level Seminar 1: The Financial Crisis
Index [s3.amazonaws.com]€¦ · Index 255 Deng, Lual A., 107, 168, 169 Deutsch, Karl, 36 Deutsch,...
Transcript of Index [s3.amazonaws.com]€¦ · Index 255 Deng, Lual A., 107, 168, 169 Deutsch, Karl, 36 Deutsch,...
251
Abubakar, Dauda, 38, 40, 130“academic racism”, 187accountability, 225n54Adekanye, J.B., 41adheng, 96, 97adulthood, Dinka initiation into, 96Africa
change in politics, 14colonial government impact, 29control over resources, 170diversity in societies, xexternal involvement, 41in global economy, 63–64precolonial period, 39–40
African (Banjul) Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, 13, 48, 149, 174, 220n7, 241n22
personhood interpretation in, 51African Commission on Human Rights
and indigenous peoples’ rights, 158and pollution, 174
African culture, 77–82association with customary law, 176attitude toward, 162as foundation for development,
164–68knowledge about, 185–89need for documenting, 192
African National Congress (ANC), 72African socialism, Nyerere and, 25African states
political identity, 31
and Western democracy, xAfrican Union (AU), 6, 61
Constitutive Act, 124African worldview, xii, 175–78, 192Afrikaner political elite, 72Afro-Shirazi Party (ASP), 25age-set system, 199–200Agius, Emmanuel, 153agricultural practices
development in Africa, 245n88land settlement and control, 163loss of indigenous knowledge of sus-
tainable, 178Akan people of Ghana, 147
personhood and governance among, 85–90, 204
Ake, Claude, 41, 132, 133, 161on development, 167–68on power struggle, 163
alueth, 97American Convention on Human Rights,
Additional Protocol, 174American federalism, 112–13Amhara, in Ethiopia, 35, 68–69An-Na’im, Abdullahi Ahmed, 8, 13, 60,
146, 225n50on nation-state, 66on “peoples” definitions, 52
anarchistic societies, 138Anaya, S. James, 52ancestors
continuity, 78–79
Index
252 Identity, Diversity, and Constitutionalism in Africa
spirits of, 176Anglo-Egyptian Condominium admin-
istration, 22Angola, 7
civil war, 4colonial power impact on economy,
162constitution, 242n25
“animists”, 82anthropology, 187Appiah, Kwame Anthony, 7, 186Apter, David, 142Arabs, in Sudan, 34–35, 74Aristotle, 144army. See also militarism
and modernization, 118Arusha Accords in Rwanda, 109Arusha Declaration of 1967, 164Ashanti, 86, 88, 139associations, 140authenticité, 22, 25authoritarian rulers
colonial, 28vs. democracy, 130
authoritarianism, 64authority
of elderly members of clan, 79hierarchy of, 79–80
autonomy, 110, 111ayur, 97Azania Peoples Liberation Army
(APLA), 72
Baehr, Peter, 148Banjul Charter. See African (Banjul)
Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights
Bantu-Negroid, 35Bantu, ubuntu, 98–100, 204bany, in Dinka society, 96Beja, in Sudan, 74Belgian Congo. See also Democratic
Republic of the Congo; Zaireindependence, 4
Ben-Israel, Hedra, 53
Bentsi-Enchill, 40Biafra secessionist war, 4, 24Biko, Steve, 29, 81–82, 187, 189black consciousness, assertion of, 189Botswana, 37, 108, 123, 136, 210
government structure, 208managing diversity, 67–68
boundaries, during colonialism, 65Bowen, John, 155, 160British Commonwealth, countries join-
ing, 20Burundi, 7, 109
government structure, 208identity in, 35
Busia, K.A., 138
Cairo Summit, 65capitalism, opposition in Zambia, 26cash-crop economies, 162–63Cassese, Antionio, 49, 58, 65Chad, 4Chama Cha Mapinduze (CCM), 25Chege, Michael, 135–36, 140–41children, 78
relationships in polygnous societ-ies, 78
respect for Dinka ancestry, 92as soldiers, 126status of, 81
China’s People’s Daily, ixChristianity
in Africa, impact, 82in Nigeria, 71
church, 177cieng, 92–96, 204, 229n22citizens, sense of ownership in consti-
tutional process, 15citizenship, 34civic spirit, 141civil rights movement in U.S., 114civil society organizations, and reform
demands, 14civil war
discussion and dialogue as alterna-tives, 142
Index 253
international law and, 59civilians, and coups, 122clans, 78
authority of elder members, 79loyalty to, 126
clans of chiefs, in Dinka society, 96Clutton-Brock, Guy, 137Cobo, José R. Martínez, 54
Study of the Problem of Discrimina-tion against Indigenous Populations, 154–55
coercive strategy, as cieng, 94Coetzee, P.H., 86–87Cold War, internal conflicts and super-
power involvement, 41collective dignity, and individual,
96–98“collective rights”, 112, 150
and individual rights, 133colonial borders, 6, 62colonial powers, 17
external domination, 63–64preferential treatment of groups, 4role in independent constitution
drafting, 20view of, 162–63
colonialismauthoritarian, 28boundaries during, 65continuity of institutions from, 21democracy model and, xiformation of centralized state sys-
tems, 40internal, 64–66struggle against, 62
colonizationhumiliations of, 168legacy of economic, 160–64
communalism, ubuntu and, 99“community”, 55
devolution of power to local, 201competition, 232n4
in global economy, 172Comprehensive Peace Agreement
(CPA) in Sudan, 4, 12, 22, 74, 76, 90, 112, 206
confederalism, 198Conference on Security, Stability, De-
velopment and Cooperation in Africa (CSSDCA), xii, 61
Conference on Security, Stability, Development and Cooperation in Europe, Final Act, 219n6
confidence, lack of, 167–68conflict(s)
causes for, xicultural perspectives, 104–05definition, 103Dinka view, 95preventing in South Africa, 73
conflict management, 103–29, 198–200goals, 127indigenous practices, 101interactive levels, 103–04power sharing and, 109–15
conflict resolution, 105role of customary law, 115–18secession in, 128
confrontation, vs. cooperation, 139Congo. See Belgian Congo; Democratic
Republic of the Congo; Zaireconsciencism, 21consensus
in African values, 107participatory governance, 135–42
consensus building, electoral democ-racy combined with, 90
consensus for decision making, 88–90democratic principles, 99, 129–42difficulty of, 141
consociational governance, 109–10constitution
modern, 10relevance in Africa, 29
constitutional commission, in Zambia, 26
constitutional dictatorship, in Ghana, 23
constitutional modelsaccommodating differences with, 5African burden from European,
27–30
254 Identity, Diversity, and Constitutionalism in Africa
French, 18importation of frameworks, 239n111origins in Africa, 17Westminster, 18–19
constitutionalism, 5African responses to challenges,
205–11colonial legacy, 17–21commitment to, 117contextualizing, 12–13and cultural diversity, 195definition, 3, 9–12external origins, 211new trends, 13–15overthrow, 18power elite in postcolonial, 132Western, vs. postcolonial Africa, 28
continental identity, 31Convention on Biological Diversity,
173, 188Convention on Refugees (1951), 7Conventional People’s Party (CPP;
Ghana), 22–23cooperation
in African worldview, 104vs. confrontation, 139
Côte d’Ivoire, 4, 7coup d’êtat
changing patterns, 121military, 119
crises of identity, 5crisis of liberalism, 149Cristescu, Aurelia, 54cross-cultural analysis, of local human
dignity vs. universal ideas, 146–47cross-fertilization
cultural, 190–93traditional and modern systems,
116cultural autonomy, 237n79cultural awareness, 192cultural chauvinism, reversing at-
titudes, 189cultural contextualization, 5cultural cross-fertilization, 190–93cultural diversity, 5
and constitutionalism, 195cultural liberty, 43cultural patterns, and constitutional-
ism development, 12cultural values, making state respon-
sive to, 21culture
definition, 105similarities among Africans, 8
customary lawAfrican culture associated with, 176dispute resolution in, 108and human rights, 116role in conflict resolution, 115–18in Sudan, 206views on codifying, 234n43
Czechoslovakia, 56
Danne, Alexander, 115Darfur, 4, 74
international response to, 76decentralization, 110, 136, 201decision making, consensus, 88–90
democratic principles, 129–42difficulty of, 141
Declaration on the United Nations Conference on the Human Environ-ment, 173–74
deforestation, 203DeGeorge, Richard T., 50democracy
consensual, 99constitutionalism and, 11definitions of Western, xfear of, 29goals, 134governance, and human rights,
80–81imposed at independence, xilegitimacy and nationhood, 131–32liberal, majoritarianism in, 189more than elections, 132–36participatory, 200–01
democratic federalism, 112Democratic Republic of the Congo, 4, 7
Index 255
Deng, Lual A., 107, 168, 169Deutsch, Karl, 36Deutsch, Morton, 105development
as self-enhancement from within, 160–70
self-reliant, 202–03sustainable, 179Western concept of, 161
Development and Human Rights (Robin-son), 165–66
dheeng, 96dialectics, 191dialogue
promoting, 203–04to resolve political conflict, 142
Diamond, Jared, 173, 177dictatorship of numbers, risks of, xdictatorships, opposition to, 14deities, 79. See also Goddifferences, respect for, 80dignity, 9, 13, 79
individual and collective, 96–98as relation, 98
Dinka, 125–26, 229n25elder on dignity of human being,
147interaction with Missiriya Arabs,
199values, 90–98
ideals of human relations, 92–96quest for immortality, 91–92relationship between rain and
life, 178Dinstein, Yoram, 53discussion
in Ashanti culture, 88to resolve political conflict, 142
displaced persons, internally, 7dispute resolution, 100–02
in African customary law, 108district councils in Botswana, 68diversity, 196
Appiah on, 7–8in Botswana, 67–68colonial powers failure to recog-
nize, 20–21cultural, 5
and constitutionalism, 195in Ethiopia, 68–70historical roots of problems, 39managing, 66–76modalities for managing, 207–08in Nigeria, 70–72in South Africa, 72–74in Sudan, 74–76and unity, 3, 43–44
dom, 97Duchacek, 135“due concern”, 86
economic conditionsdependence, and autonomous mili-
tary, 120–21development, as threat, 28foreign interests in, 64legacy of colonization, 160–64primary problem in Africa, 166
elder members of clan, authority of, 79elections, 80
acceptance of outcomes, 133based on proportional representa-
tion, 227n80consensus building combined with
democracy, 90Elias, T. Olawale, 107elite
governing elite, 4power elite in postcolonial constitu-
tionalism, 132role of, 38
environmental concerns, 203emphasis of harmony and balance,
177right to health environment, 173–75
environmental policy, in South Africa, 178–80
equality, constitutional framework and, 61
Eritrea, 4, 7, 56, 69people’s involvement in constitution-
256 Identity, Diversity, and Constitutionalism in Africa
making process, 11Ethiopia, ix, 7, 128
constitution, 10, 242n25decentralized power, 114economics of power, 37and Eritrea, 4, 56, 69ethnic conflicts, 209identity, 35managing diversity, 68–70people’s involvement in constitu-
tion-making process, 11People’s Revolutionary Democratic
Front (EPRDF), 127ethnic dominance, 120ethnic groups, 32, 55
African state as composite, 4conflict between, 104diversity, 31, 120evolution of relations, 39–43fears of future and conflict, 37problems for, 110–11
ethnic identity, 31“ethnic wars of secession”, 222n30ethnically based federalism, in Ethio-
pia, 69ethnicity, 33
in Botswana, 67ethos of constitutionalism, 11Etzioni, Amitai, 48–49, 63European-model constitutionalism,
African burden from, 27–30Evans-Pritchard, E.E., 137exclusion, identity and, 36export crops, 162external self-determination, 58
Fallers, Lloyd, 138family, 78–79favoritism, and power stratification, 40fears of future, 38
ethnic conflict and, 37federalism, 110, 111, 237n79, 238n106
American, 112–13democratic, 112in Ethiopia, 69, 128
fighting. See violenceFoltz, William, 124force, constitution imposed by, 11foreign experts, and development, 169Fortes, M., 137–38founding fathers, vision, 21–27free-market economies, in Kenya, 25French culture
Africa political culture connection, 18
assimilation in colonial areas, 186“French model” for constitutions, 18fundamental rights, vs. instrumental,
134Funj group, in Sudan, 74future
developing vision, 204–05fears of, 38
gacaca, 100–02, 204–05Gambia, colonial power impact on
economy, 162Garang de Mabior, John, 75, 114–15gender relations
changing roles, 203cross-cultural perspectives, 180–83
generalization, danger of, 7–8genocide in Rwanda, prosecution of
those responsible, 101Gershoni, Yekutiel
on coups, 121–23on unconstitutional changes of
government, 124Ghai, Yash, 9, 17, 18, 19–20, 21, 27, 28Ghana
Akan people of, 85–90, 147, 204colonial power impact on economy,
162constitution, 20independence, 22–23
ghost marriage, 91global economy, competition in, 172globalization, 13Gluckman, Max, 107, 229n23Go, Julian, 20
Index 257
God, 79as father, 94respect for, 176views of, 147
Golden Rule, 86governance
among Akan, 85–90consociational, 109–10postindependence frameworks, 3
governing elite, 4Government of National Unity (GNU),
22in Sudan, 75
Green, Reginald, 29Groth, Alexander J., 36, 38, 39, 41group rights, 112
cross-cultural perspectives, 148–50groups, dignity for individual as mem-
ber, 153guier, 97Guinea, 22, 23Gyekye, Kwame, 86, 88
Haile Mariam, Mengistu, 127Haile Selassie, 69Hammarskjold, Dag, 4, 24Harambee, 22, 25Hardison, Preston, 188harmony, Dinka view, 95harvesting activities, 173Hatchard, John, 11Hausa-Fulani in Nigeria, 70Haysom, Nicholas, 206–07Helsinki Declaration, 220n11Henderson, Errol A., 119, 123Hodgson, Dorothy, 158–59, 172homogeneous society, 27honor, of colonial withdraw, 20Hountondji, Paulin J., 144House of Chiefs (Botswana legislature),
67human relations, Dinka ideals of, 92–96human rights, 87, 143–60, 201–02
central premises of framework, 152change and, 153
cross-cultural perspectives on indi-vidual and group, 148–50
cultural contextualization, 143–48democratic governance and, 80–81framework evolution, 150–54of indigenous peoples, 154–60international, 14traditional customary laws and, 116universality, 240n5as Western concept, 144
humanism, 22humanity, unity as creation of God, 83Hutu, 35, 217n13, 230n35
power sharing, 109
identity, 216n3conflicts, 36, 38, 41, 125crises of, 5discrepancies, 32levels of, 31myth of permanent, 91right to self-determination and
conflicts, 46subjective and objective elements,
32–39Igbo in Nigeria, 70Igbuzor, Otive, 9Ihonvbere, Julius, 14–15, 118, 132immortality, quest by Dinka, 91–92incorporation, politics of, 133independence, 18
constitution as cost of, 19democracy model imposed at, xiand identity conflicts, 40and ruling elites, 129
indigenous groupsdiscrimination against, 54–55human rights of, 154–60international law and, 222n27knowledge of, 186, 188–89movement, and environmental
protection needs, 172individual
in clans, 79as community member, 13
258 Identity, Diversity, and Constitutionalism in Africa
duty of, 81within social self, 86Western emphasis on, 12
individual dignity, and collective, 96–98
individual rightsand collective rights, 133cross-cultural perspectives, 148–50
“indivisible duality”, 149Indonesia, East Timor in, 56industrial world, development, and
danger to environment, 171influence, myth of, 91instrumental rights, vs. fundamental,
134intellectuals, in Africa, 169interference, international assistance
as, 169internal colonialism, 64–66
vs. external rule, 195International Bill of Rights, 144international community, role of,
168–70International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights (ICCPR) of 1966, 47, 52–53, 144, 173
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), 47, 52–53, 144, 152, 164, 173
International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, 101
international human rightsadvancements, 14law, 150
International Labor Organization (ILO), 148
Convention 107 of 1957, 156Convention 169 concerning Indig-
enous and Tribal Peoples, 156, 223n38
international lawindigenous groups and, 222n27and self-determination, 218n1
international trade, and environmental practices, 245n91
Inyangamugayo, 101
Islamin Africa, impact, 82fundamentalism, 22law in North Sudan, 75in Nigeria, 70
Japan after Meiji Restoration, 166Jenkins, J. Craig, 119–21Jimenez, Vanessa, 34, 37, 71Judaic-Christian tradition, and human
rights, 144judicial structure in Botswana, 67justice
constitutional framework and, 61pursuit of, 106in Rwanda, 100
Kasavubu, Joseph, 24Kasfir, Nelson, 33, 125, 126Katanga, 4Kaunda, Kenneth, 22, 25–26, 137Keller, Edmond, 10, 35, 65–66, 69,
112–13, 134–35Kent, Robert, 10Kenya, ix, 123
colonial power impact on economy, 162
constitution, 20independence, 25
Kenya African National Union (KANU), 25
Kenyatta, Jomo, 22, 25Khadiagala, Gilbert, 10, 37, 67, 108, 136Khama, Tserena, 210kic, in Dinka society, 96kinship, 140
solidarity, 81Kissinger, Henry A., 132Kiwanuka, Richard, 50, 149, 150knowledge, promoting, 203–04Kposowa, Augustine J., 119–21kwihtura, 230n35Kwoth, 91
Index 259
Laakso, L., 34Lake, David, 36, 114Laremont, Ricardo, 34, 37, 71law. See also customary law
international, 218n1, 222n27Le Vine, Victor T., 17, 18leaders, evaluating performance, 29leadership
among Dinka, 97positions of, 80
League of Nations, 128legal framework, vs. leadership com-
mitment, 114Leinhardt, Godfrey, 93, 97, 98Lemarchand, Rene, 109, 110, 232n10
consociational models, 127Lesotho, proportional representation,
207levirate marriage, 91liberal democracy, majoritarianism in,
189Liberia, 7liberty, human rights emphasizing, 151Lichtenstein, 232n15Lienhardt, Godfrey, 93life, objectives in clan system, 81local communities, devolution of
power to, 201loyalty, to clan, 126Lumumba, Patrice, 24
majority votevs. consensus, 88in current democracy in Africa, 139in liberal democracy, 189
Makec, John Wuol, 108Malawi
colonial power impact on economy, 162
government structure, 208Mamdani, Mahmoud, 13–14, 42, 136,
144manhood, and warrior in traditional
societies, 125–26marginalized interests, inclusion in
democratic process, 133marriage, levirate and ghost, 91Martain, Jacques, 153Marxist ideology, 22material wealth, 161Matlosa, Khabele, 209Mauro, Francesco, 188Mazrui, Ali, 130, 134, 165, 205, 239n111Mbiti, John S., 176–77, 178Michalska, Anna, 49–50militarism, 235n48
impact, 118–26military coups
in Nigeria, 24threat of, 118–124
military dictatorship, in Sudan, 22minorities
affirmations of rights, 233n19assimilation as justification for
secession, 225n50federalism and protection of, 113marginalized voters, 135in Nigeria, 113protections against discrimination,
51rights, 110, 111–12and self-determination, 50–51threat to rights, 131
missionary schools, 177Missiriya Arabs, interaction with
Dinka, 199Mobutu, Joseph (Mobutu Sese Seko),
24–25modern constitution, 10Mohammed, Ismail, 10Mouvement Populaire de la Revolution
(MPR), 24Mozambique, civil war, 4muk, 97Museveni, Yoweri, 182Muslims. See IslamMuslow, Barry, 28mutual cooperation, 80myths, nationalist, in multiethnic
society, 28
260 Identity, Diversity, and Constitutionalism in Africa
Namibia, proportional representation, 207
naming, Dinka system for, 92nation, 36, 55nation building, impact in Africa, 167nation-states, 55
ethnic diversities converted to, 31as obstacle to self-determination, 66partitions of existing, 56sovereignty vs. self-determination,
48National Congress Party (Sudan), 22national identity, 31, 160National Islamic Front (Sudan), 22national leadership, model of, 18national self-consciousness, 53–54national sovereignty, challenge to, 104national unity, 6
preference for, 59–62, 126nationalism, vs. self-determination, 54nationalist myths, in multiethnic
society, 28nationhood, democratic legitimacy
and, 131–32“native” law, 117. See also customary
lawnatural environment, protection,
170–80natural resources, sovereignty over, 64nature
humankind’s relationship, 171–73as intermediary between man and
spirit, 176–77Ndulo, Muna, 10, 12, 21, 37, 40, 41, 66, 72Nebel, Arthur, 93“Negritude”, 22
Senghor’s development of, 190networks, 140Nhialic, 91Nigeria, ix, 7, 34
Biafra secessionist war, 4constitution, 20customary law, 117ethnic groups, 213n1federalism, 24, 112, 113government structure, 208, 209
independence, 23–24managing diversity, 70–72oil revenues, 71people’s involvement in constitu-
tion-making process, 11religious divide, 34resource distribution, 37self-identification, 38
Nilo-Hamitic, 35Nilotic societies of Sudan, 200Nimeiri, Jaafar Mohammed, 199Nkrumah, Kwame, 21, 22norms, 77
and constitutionalism develop-ment, 12
Nuba group, in Sudan, 74Nuer society, 138
religion in Sudan, 91Nwabueze, Benjamin Obi, 20Nyerere, Julius K., 20, 21, 25, 137, 139,
164–65, 168, 244n69
Obasanjo, Olusegun, 61oil
environmental degradation from production, 209
revenues in Nigeria, 71Okoth-Ogendo, H.W.O., 21Olukoshi, A.O., 34one-party state
Kenya as, 25Zambia as, 26
oppositional politics, threat of, 29Organization of African Unity (OAU),
xii, 6, 61, 149and colonial borders, 65
Organization of American States, 52, 148
Oromo, 127Osaghae, Eghosa E., 113Otunnu, Olara, 31Owusu, Maxwell, 27, 40, 132, 138, 142
on democracy, 129, 130on indigenous culture impact, 162
Index 261
Paancol, Bullen, 181Parti Démocratique de Guinée (PDG),
23participatory democracy, 200–01partition, preference for national unity
over, 59–62Partsch, Karl Josef, 51, 56peace, as goal, 105–09“peoplehood”, defined, 53“peoples”, concept of, 49–55“personal-self”, 149personhood, among Akan, 86–88Pitkin, Hanna Fenichel, 131pluralism, of African state, 4, 27plurality-majority system, election
based on, 227n80political elite, native, 20“political entrepreneurs”, 38political power, postcolonial, 163pollution, by Nigerian government, 174polyandry, 228n1polygamy, 228n1polygnous societies
in Dinka groups, 94–95relationships of children in, 78
polygyny, 228n1Post, Robert, 131poverty
alleviation, 165objective and subjective percep-
tions, 202power
devolution of power to local com-munities, 201
purpose for Dinka, 97sharing, and conflict management,
109–15stratification, and favoritism, 40use of, 65
power elite, in postcolonial constitu-tionalism, 132
power sharing, equitable, 128proportional representation, 207,
227n80prosperity, 37provincial government system, in
South Africa, 73Putnam, Robert, 141
race, 216n3as identity group, 33
racism, 34reversing attitudes, 189
Rashad, Adib, 162reconciliation, 80
as goal, 105–09reform, popular demand for, 14regionalism system in Ghana, 23relationships, African perspective on,
12–13relativism, 145religion, 5, 80
role of, 81–82representation, in Ashanti culture, 89repugnancy laws, 235n47resources, African control over, 170respect, 79“retribalization”, 126Rich, Roland, 150rights and wrongs, hierarchy of, 106rights, fundamental vs. instrumental,
134Rio Declaration on Environment and
Development, 174–75Robinson, Mary, Development and Hu-
man Rights, 165–66Rothchild, Donald, 36, 38, 39, 41, 114Rwanda, 7, 109, 217n13
Arusha Accords in, 109gacaca, 100–02, 204–05identity in, 35justice in, 100social mobility, 230n35traditional values in modern legal
codes, 205
Salim, Salim Ahmed, 66Scandanavia, economic aid to Tanza-
nia, 165secession, 55–59
262 Identity, Diversity, and Constitutionalism in Africa
in conflict resolution, 128discussion and dialogue as alterna-
tives, 142ethnic wars of, 222n30international community discour-
agement of, 58movements, international commu-
nity and, 195negative consequences, 60as option, 197referendum on, 129right to, 53, 225n46
secular democratic system, in South Sudan, 75
Seko, Mobutu Sese, 22Selassie, Bereket Habte, 205self-determination, 4, 5, 45, 127, 210–11,
223n32addressing dilemma of, 204in African context, 62–66dilemmas of, 196–97as emergent process, 61–62forms and degrees of, 5historical developments, 46–49of indigenous peoples, 157internal, 222n25internal dimension to, 64–66as legal and political concept, 46–66and minorities, 50–51vs. nationalism, 54reconciling unity with, 197–98relevancy of principle, 48–49risk of state dismemberment, 65and secession, 6United Nations and, 47
self-governance, 11, 127self-identification, 32, 33
of indigenous peoples, 155, 156self-liberation, constitutions and, 19self-preservation, 244n64self-realization, 244n64
development as, 168self-reliant development, 202–03Seligman, Brenda, 91Seligman, Charles, 91Senegal, 4, 22
colonial power impact on economy, 162
Senghor, Leopold, 22, 190–92sharia law, in Nigeria, 209Shivji, Issa, 59, 60Shutte, Augustine, 190–92Sierra Leone, 7Sklar, Richard L., 131slavery, Dinka condemnation of, 147Slinn, Peter, 28, 29Smyth, Marie, 126social consciousness, 21social democracy, 133social interaction, in cieng, 94social relationships, 231n4social responsibility, among Bantu,
98–100“social-self”, 149
individual within, 86social status, civic duties and, 87social values, consensus on, 27socialism, 21–22
in Tanganyika, 164tradition, and human rights, 151in Zambia, 26
society, 12–13, 55, 216n3nationalist myths in multiethnic, 28structure, 104traditional, impact of militarism on,
124–26solidarity rights, 150, 151Somalia, 7son of a woman, implication of being
called, 78soul of nation, governing framework to
embody, 3South Africa
consociationalism, 110constitution and customary law, 117decentralized power, 114environmental concerns, 172environmental policy, 178–80government structure, 208indigenous languages, 208managing diversity, 72–74National Environmental Manage-
Index 263
ment Act 107 of 1998, 180people’s involvement in constitu-
tion-making process, 11–12postapartheid reform, 37–38proportional representation, 207racially stereotyping model, 34
sovereignty, 225n54sovereignty of nation-state, vs. self-
determination, 48Soviet Union, 53, 56Soyinka, Wole, 165spirits
of ancestors, 176totemic system of honoring, 177
spirituality, role of, 81–82stability, ethnic diversity and, 120Stacey, Helen, 171, 179state
legitimacy of, 65population loss of confidence in,
160state in Africa, as threat, 41state power, 104stateless societies, 201Stockholm Declaration, 173substantive representation, 89Sucharitkul, Sompong, 158Sudan, 4, 7, 12
Arab-Islamic identity model, 69Arabs in, 34–35Comprehensive Peace Agreement
(CPA), 4, 12, 22, 74, 76, 90, 112, 206conflicts, 199Constitutional Court, 108court system, 234n46customary law, 117, 206Darfur, 4, 74, 76ethnic groups, 213n1independence, 22managing diversity, 74–76, 210minority rights, 112Nilotic societies, 200People’s Liberation Movement’s
New Sudan legal system, 117regional autonomy, 112Sudan People’s Liberation Move-
ment/Sudan People’s Liberation Army (SPLM/A), 12, 74
superpowersexternal support from, 123involvement in internal conflicts in
Africa, 41sustainable development, 179“sympathetic impartiality”, 86
Tanganyikaconstitution, 20independence, 25
Tanganyika African National Union (TANU), 25, 164
Tanzania, 20, 25, 66, 123government structure, 208Scandanavian economic aid, 165
Teffo, Joe, 98territorial integrity, 6, 48, 56, 220n8Third Conference on Federalism (Brus-
sels, 2005), 114–15Third World Polities, 28Thomas-Woolley, Barbara, 65, 112–13,
134–35Tisdell, Clement, 175togetherness (ujamaa), 22totemic system of honoring spirits, 177Touré, Sékou, 22, 23traditional leaders
role of, 206status of, 199
traditional political conditions, limita-tions on current condition, 140
“tribal” identities, 36Tswana people, 67Turkey
constitution, 242n25cultural changes, 166
Tutsi, 35, 217n13, 230n35power sharing, 109
ubuntu, 98–100, 204Uganda, ix
Constitutional Commission, 11
264 Identity, Diversity, and Constitutionalism in Africa
government structure, 208people’s involvement in constitu-
tion-making process, 11–12women in political life, 182
ujamaa (togetherness), 22, 164–65United Nations, 6, 52, 144
Commission on Human RightsResolution No. 73 of 2002, 152Working Group on Indigenous
Populations, 156Conference on the Human Environ-
ment, 173–74Declaration on the Occasion of
the Fiftieth Anniversary of the United Nations, 220n11
Development Programme, 43Draft Declaration on the Rights of
Indigenous Peoples, 156–57General Assembly Resolution 3485,
219n6Human Rights Committee, 223n31Office of High Commissioner for
Refugees, 7Resolution 2625, Declaration on
Principles of International Law Concerning Friendly Relations and Cooperation among States of 1970, 57
and self-determination, 47United Party (UP; Ghana), 22United States
civil rights movement, 114ethnic identification in 1960s vs.
current, 197–98unity
in Dinka groups, 94and diversity, 3, 43–44reconciling with self-determina-
tion, 197–98Universal Declaration of Human
Rights, 144, 151universalism, 145universe, and Man’s understanding of
God, 176–77
valuesand constitutionalism develop-
ment, 12in indigenous African societies, 195
Van Niekerk, Marlene, 187Vasak, Karel, 150Vienna World Conference on Human
Rights 1993, 240n5Declaration, 219n6, 220n11Declaration and Program of Action,
57villagization, 165violence
in Dinka groups, 95in state formation, 27in Sudan, 74
vision for future, developing, 204–05
warfare, within countries, 13–14warrior in traditional societies, and
manhood, 125–26water, 178wealth
objective and subjective percep-tions, 202
purpose for Dinka, 97ubuntu and distribution, 99
West Africa, Akan people of, 85–90Western constitutions, 27Western democracy, definitions of, xWestminster parliamentary system of
government, 18–19, 20in Ghana, 22in Nigeria, 23–24
Weston, Burns H., 150Wilson, Woodrow, 128Wiredu, Kwasi, 86, 137, 140
on human rights violations, 145–46on representation, 89
womenchildbearing capacity as value,
229n19in public life, 203rights and roles, 181, 247n115,
247n116
Index 265
role of, 78status of, 81
“word”, 83World Conference on Human Rights
Vienna Declaration 1993, 57, 219n6, 220n11, 240n5
worldview, and African culture, 77–82
Yansane, Aguibou, 161Yoruba in Nigeria, 70Young, Crawford, 5, 20, 33, 34youth. See also children
involvement in governance, 89loyalty to clan, 126
Yugoslav Republic, 53, 56yuur, 97
Zaire, 22, 24–25Zambia, 22
government structure, 208independence, 25–26
Zanzibar, 25Zartman, I. William, 231n1Zimbabwe, ix, 107
government structure, 208Zolberg, A., 123