Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991,...
Transcript of Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991,...
![Page 1: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
TRENCHLESS TECHNOLOGY ROADSHOW May 28-29, 2014 – Scotiabank Convention Centre, Niagara Falls, ON
DevelopmentofaNorthAmericaDrinkingWaterPipelines’DefectCodingandCondition
RatingStandardDr. Rizwan Younis, Dr. Mark Knight
Centre for Advancement of Trenchless Technologies, University of WaterlooDr. Yehuda Kleiner Yeda Consultants Inc.Dr. John Matthews
Battle Memorial Institute, USA
![Page 2: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Outline
• Project Background• Project Scope and Framework• Watermain Defect Coding and Condition Rating• Q&A
2
![Page 3: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
ProjectBackground
• Civil Infrastructure Condition Assessment
• Distress/Defect Codes
• Condition Rating (defect scores and weights)
• Example
• Water Research Centre’s (WRc) Manual of Sewer Condition Classification
• WRc’s Sewerage Rehabilitation Manual
3
![Page 4: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
ProjectBackground(cont’d)
• Example – WRc Defect Coding and Condition RatingStructural and Operational Defects ‐ Examples
4
![Page 5: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
StructuralDefectScores(basedonWRc SewerageRehabilitationManual4th ed.)
Defect MSCC Code Description Score
Collapsed X 165
Spalling SSS Slight 5SSM Medium 20SSL Large 120
Wear SWS Slight 5SWM Medium 20SWL Large 120
Deformation D •0 – 5 %•6 – 10 %•> 10%
2080165
![Page 6: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
StructuralConditionGrades
• Structural Condition Grading Example
6
Internal Condition Grade (ICG) Peak Score
1 (acceptable)
< 10
2 10 – 393 40 – 794 80 – 1645
(worst, collapsed or collapse imminent)≥ 165
![Page 7: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
ProjectBackground(cont’d)
• No Standard Defect Coding and Condition Grading System for Watermains
• Water Research Foundation RFP 4498: Potable Water Pipeline Defect Condition Rating
• Project Duration: Jan. 2014 to Apr. 2017• Objective: Create a framework and contents of a standard defect coding and condition rating system for watermains
7
![Page 8: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
ProjectBackground(cont’d)ParticipatingUtilitiesandOrganizations1. Ontario Clean Water Agency, Canada2. Greater Cincinnati Water Works, USA3. City of Calgary, Canada4. City of London, Canada5. City of Waterloo, Canada6. City of Los Angeles, USA7. Louisville Waterloo Company, USA8. Miami Dade County, USA9. Monroe County Water Authority, USA10. Portland Water Bureau, USA11. Washington Suburban Sanitary Commission, USA12. Halifax Water, Canada
8
![Page 9: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
ProjectBackground(cont’d)TechnologyProviders
•Pure Technologies
• Echologics
•Russell NDE Systems Inc.
9
![Page 10: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
ProjectBackground(cont’d)TechnicalResourceTeam1. Philip Wildbore, DEFRA, UK2. Cliff Jones, Vice President, Ontario Clean Water Agency3. Dr. Balvant Rajani, Rajani Consultants Inc.4. Dan Ellison, HDR5. Chris Macey, AECOM6. Dr. Declan Downey, Trenchless Opportunities Ltd.7. Dr. Samuel Ariaratnam, Arizona State University
10
![Page 11: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
ProjectScopeandFrameworkRequirementsandGuidelines1. Flexible Framework – incorporate variety of information
• Failure modes and mechanisms• Visual understanding and classification of pipe failures• Consider criticality of pipelines• Defect codes and condition rating system• Decision criteria to categorize pipes for various rehabilitation and replacement techniques
2. Cater for Reactive Approach3. Also consider Selective Inspection
11
![Page 12: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
1. Pipe criticality and priority ranking for evaluation (Dr. Kleiner)
2. Development of defect coding and condition rating system (Drs. Younis and Knight)
3. Rehabilitation or replacement decision making (Dr. Matthews)
ProjectScopeandFrameworkMajorTasks
12
![Page 13: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
OverallFrameworkPipe criticality and priority ranking for evaluation
13
![Page 14: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
OverallFrameworkPipeCriticalityandPriorityRankingExample: Kleiner at el.
14
![Page 15: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
OverallFrameworkDefectCodingandConditionGrading
15
![Page 16: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
OverallFrameworkDefectCodingandConditionGrading(cont’d)Defect Coding
16
![Page 17: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
OverallFrameworkDefectCodingandConditionGrading(cont’d)• Pipe Failure Modes and Mechanisms
Internal and External Factors Contributing to Water Pipe Failures (Uddin, Hudson, and Haas, 2013)
Select Failure Modes for Water Pipes (WSAA, 2012)
17
![Page 18: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
OverallFrameworkDefectCodingandConditionGrading(cont’d)
• Defect Identification• Example: Metal Loss
Source: http://www.ge‐energy.com/content/multimedia/_files/downloads/MagneScan_Threat_Matrix.pdf
![Page 19: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
OverallFrameworkDefectCodingandConditionGrading(cont’d)• Defect Coding – Defect Description Procedure
Example of Corrosion defect Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐1991, 2004) 19
![Page 20: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
OverallFrameworkDefectCodingandConditionGrading(cont’d)• Defect Coding –Defect Description Procedure
Example of Location and Dimension for Metal Loss Defect (POF, 2009)
20
![Page 21: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
OverallFrameworkQuantificationofDefects
• Defect Scores and Weights
• Develop measurement scale
• Appropriateness of defects and corresponding scores and weights
• Expert Judgement and Empirical and/or other Computational Tools
• Validation: Face and Content Validity; Reliability (consistency;
stability)
21
![Page 22: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
OverallFrameworkDecisionMaking
•No renewal or re‐assign pipe to one of the four
inspection tiers (i.e., Tiers 1 to 4 mentioned in Task 1)
•Rehabilitation
•Replacement
22
![Page 23: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
OverallFrameworkDecisionMaking
•Rehabilitation or Replacement Decisions Guidelines
• Open cut replacement
• Online replacement without upsizing
• Structural or semi‐structural spot repair
• Structural or semi‐structural lining system
23
![Page 24: Inc. Battle Memorial Institute, USA - cattevents.ca · Attributes Parameters (ASME B31G‐ 1991, 2004) 19. Overall Framework Defect Coding and Condition Grading (cont’d) •Defect](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022011803/5b5db2c87f8b9aa1428ebcf1/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
TRENCHLESS TECHNOLOGY ROADSHOW May 28-29, 2014 – Scotiabank Convention Centre, Niagara Falls, ON
Questions?