In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet Cultivar Frida, Through...
Transcript of In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet Cultivar Frida, Through...
American Journal of Agricultural Science
2016; 3(3): 27-34
http://www.aascit.org/journal/ajas
ISSN: 2381-1013 (Print); ISSN: 2381-1021 (Online)
Keywords Artificial Seed,
Sugar Beet,
Adventitious Shoots Sodium
Alginate
Received: March 13, 2016
Accepted: March 31, 2016
Published: May 6, 2016
In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet Cultivar Frida, Through Encapsulated Different Explants
Roba M. Ismail, Wesam M. Raslan, Gihan M. H. Hussein
Gene Transfer Lab, Plant Genetic Transformation Department, Agricultural Genetic Engineering
Institute (AGERI), Agricultural Research Center (ARC), Giza, Egypt
Email address [email protected] (R. M. Ismail), [email protected] (W. M. Raslan),
[email protected] (G. M. H. Hussein)
Citation Roba M. Ismail, Wesam M. Raslan, Gihan M. H. Hussein. In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet
Cultivar Frida, Through Encapsulated Different Explants. American Journal of Agricultural
Science. Vol. 3, No. 3, 2016, pp. 27-34.
Abstract Synthetic or artificial seed protocol is a powerful method for production of seed
analogues. It relies on in vitro encapsulation of any meristematic tissue by its coating
with suitable gelling agents. Here we describe the synthetic seeds production for sugar
beet (Beta vulgaris) cv Frida using encapsulation by sodium alginate. Different factors
affecting the encapsulation efficiency such as explant type, presence of BA and presence
of sucrose were studied. The best combinations for synthetic seed production found to be
using of 4% sodium alginate for encapsulation of shoot tip explants in presence of 1.3
mg/l BA or 4% sucrose. In case of adventitious shoots, the best combinations found to be
using of 4% sodium alginate with 1.3 mg/l BA, 4% sucrose and 1.2% agar.
1. Introduction
Sugar beet (Beta vulgaris) is an important root crop and it considers the main source
for sugar production in the moderate climate regions with five months long growing
season [1]. In Egypt, the total planted sugar beet area in 2014/2015 is about 183,000 ha,
comparing to 174,000 ha in 2013/14 as reported by Sugar Annual, 2015
(http://www.thefarmsite.com/reports/contents/EgyptSugar29April2014.pdf).
According to in vitro culture and genetic transformation, sugar beet considers as an
unruly plant species [2]. Regenerated adventitious shoot from different explants has been
effectively used for the propagation of elite sugar beet genotypes [3], although high
degree of variability in the regeneration frequencies from diverse explants of different
genotypes have been detected [4]. Additionally, the vegetative nature of the material and
the greater risks of disease transfer increase the difficultly of the distribution and replace
from gene bank field.
Artificial seed protocol extends plant biotechnology and agriculture prospect in the
plant propagation [5] as it useful for protecting the best agricultural and endangered plant
species, which are difficult to regenerate through conventional methods and natural
seeds. In addition, artificial seed is very useful way for the large-scale propagation of
superior hybrids of economically important species [6].
Encapsulated somatic embryo firstly reported by Murashige [7]. Afterward,
engineering of somatic embryo into synthetic seed has been continued by the efforts of
Kitto and Janick [8], Gray [9] and Gray and Purohit [10]. Encapsulated micro shoots or
somatic embryos were used to propagate different plant species, such as sandalwood,
mulberry, banana, cardamom, sugar beet, rice and peer [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, and 6].
28 Roba M. Ismail et al.: In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet Cultivar Frida, Through Encapsulated Different Explants
Different types of the explants have been previously used to
produce synthetic seeds such as nodeal segment from
Bacopamonnieri L [16] and Menthaarvensis [17]; or somatic
embryos and shoot tip from sugar beet [14, 18],
Begoniaxhiemalis Forch [19] and shoot tip M. arvensis [17]
and Stevia [20]. In general, the synthetic seed was used in
propagating different economically important plant species
such as vegetable crops, forage legumes, industrially
important crops, cereals, spices, plantation crops, fruit crops,
ornamental plants, orchids, medicinal plants and wood
yielding forest trees [21].
In this work, synthetic seeds were produced from inter
node, shoot tip explants and adventitious shoots from sugar
beet cv. Frida and their ability to regenerate in complete
plants was assessed. In addition, adventitious shoots
development from the internode explants was studied.
2. Materials & Methods
2.1. Materials
Seeds of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris) cultivar Frida were
kindly obtained from sugar crops institute, Agricultural
Research Center (ARC).
2.2. Methods
Seeds germination
Sugar beet seeds were surface sterilized by soaking in 70%
(v/v) ethanol for 1 min; then rinsed several times with
sterilized distilled water. Seeds were transferred to 40% (v/v)
Clorox solution for 45 min, then washed by rinsing several
times with sterile distilled water for 30 min. Thereafter, seeds
were germinated on MS medium supplemented with 0.5 mg/l
2, 3, 5-Triiodobenzoic Acid (TIBA) medium and incubated
for 45 days.
2.3. Synthetic Seeds of the Shoot Tip and
Internode Cutting Explants
2.3.1. Explants Encapsulation
I. Coating explant with alginate
Shoot tip and internode cutting as explants were coated
with six coating solutions composed 4% sodium alginate
dissolved in water or in MS basal medium with or without
benzyl adenine (BA) and sucrose (Table 1 from T1-T6).
Explants were coated by dropping the explants in sodium
alginate solutions for 20 min; the alginate-coated explants
were transferred to plates containing 1.4% CaCl2 for another
20 min. Then, coated explants were washed with liquid MS
medium for three times. All procedure steps were conducted
under aseptic condition.
II. Synthetic seeds storage
Coated explants were placed on 3.5 cm Petri dishes either
on filter paper or without filter paper and incubated for 1, 2, 4
and 8 weeks at room temperature. To select the best coating
condition, in vitro germination of coating seeds was
performed on half SH9 medium [22]. The following
parameters were recorded: Required time for germination in
days, percentage of germination, number of shoots/explant,
shoots height and root formation.
2.3.2. Shoot Development
For producing microshoots, the inter node segments were
cut from 45-day-old in vitro seedling as explants, then
cultured on different multiplication media composed of
different media, different growth regulators and different
solidifying agent (phytagel and agar, Table 2). Each
multiplication medium had six plates on each five explants
with total number of 30 explants. Obtained micro-shoots
were isolated from their explants and were coated for
producing synthetic seeds.
2.3.3. Encapsulated Microshoots
Obtained shoots were coated with two sodium alginate
solutions (Table1, T7 and T8). Then the coated explants were
then incubated into CaCl2, and washed as mentioned before
with the shoot tip and inter-node explants.
2.3.4. In vitro Germination
To select the best germination medium encapsulated
shoots were transferred to four different media which are: G1
(hormone-free MS medium); G2 (MS with 0.5 mg/l TIBA);
G3 (MS with 40µg NAA) and G4 (half strength SH medium
with 40 µg/l NAA). All germination media were solidified
with agar at concentration of 8 g/l. Germinated sugar beet
seeds were transferred to root formation medium containing
1mg/l IBA. The rooted plantlets were acclimatized on
mixture of beet moss: sand (1:1).
Table 1. Different sodium alginate solution.
Treatments Sodium alginate agar MS BA(mg) sucrose
T1 4% +
T2 4% 1.3
T3 4% + 4%
T4 4% + 1.3
T5 4%
T6 4% 4%
T7 4% 1.2% + 4%
T8 4% 1.2% + 1.3 4%
American Journal of Agricultural Science 2016; 3(3): 27-34 29
Table 2. Different shoot development media composition.
Media medium Growth regulatorsmg/l Solidifying agentg/l
MS SH NAA mg/l TIBA BA mg/l TDZ Phytagel Agar
SD1A half 3 7
SD2A half 3 7
SD3P full 3 3
SD3A full 3 7
SD4P full 3 3
SD4A full 3 7
SD5P full 0.5 3
SD5A full 0.5 7
SD6P full 0.3 3
SD6A full 0.3 7
SD7P half 3
SD7A half 7
SD8P half 3 3
SD8A half 3 7
SD9P half 3 3
SD9A half 3 7
SD10P half 0.3 3
SD10A half 0.3 7
2.3.5. Root Formation
The obtained shoots were transferred to two different
rooting media composed of MS with different concentration
of Indole-3-butyric acid(IBA) (1 or 2 mg /l), individually.
2.3.6. Acclimatization Stage
Plantlets were transferred to greenhouse in pots containing
1:1 mixture of peat moss: sand. The pots were covered with
transparent plastic bags to keep the humidity at 90% for one
week. The plastic bags were removed gradually.
2.4. Synthetic Seeds of the Adventitious
Shoots
Synthetic seeds were also produced from adventitious
shoots that were developed from the inter-node explants.
3. Results
3.1. Synthetic Seeds of the Shoot Tip and
Internode Cutting Explants
Explants (shoot tip & internode cutting) encapsulation:
In order to select the best solution of encapsulation, the
encapsulated explants (synthetic seeds) were germinated
after different storage periods. All coated explants from
different coating treatment were germinated on half SH9
medium. Results showed that all explants incubated on a
filter paper were dried after one weak. All encapsulated
explants with T1, T2, T5 and T6 coating solutions did not
germinate. While, the encapsulated shoot tip explants with
T3 and T4 germinated easily. The internode coated explants
with T3 or T4 that stored for one week, two weeks and a
month germinated but those stored for two months did not
germinate (Table 3). It was also showed that there were
approximately no differences of the germination rate
between the coating solutions (T3 and T4). All coated
explants that were stored for one week started to germinate
after three days, whereas, the encapsulated explants that
incubated for two weeks started to germinate after four days.
In addition, the germination time was varied from 6-12 days
for the coated explants that incubated for one month.
Furthermore, the internode coated explants incubated for
two months did not germinate while the shoot tip coated
explants incubated for two months were germinated after 7
days. The germination percentage of synthetic seeds was
varied among the treatments from 0-100 (Table 3). Shoot
heights were ranged 8.5-13 cm among the treatments. The
highest germination percentage was in the synthetic seeds
incubated for one week, while the lowest germination
percentage was in the encapsulated explants incubated for
two month. Thus shoot tip as an explant and T3 or T4
coating solutions reveled the best condition for producing
synthetic seeds.
Not all treatments formed root on the half SH9 medium
therefore the shoots were rooted on medium containing IBA
(Fig. 1). It was observed that medium containing IBA at
concentration of 1 mg/l was better than that containing 2mg/l
(Data not shown).
30 Roba M. Ismail et al.: In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet Cultivar Frida, Through Encapsulated Different Explants
Table 3. Germination of both encapsulated explants (shoot tip-inter node) with T3 & T4 solution.
explant Coating
treatment
Storage
time
Total No.
coating seeds
Germinating
seeds
% Germinating
seeds
Time of
germination
Obtaining
shoots
Shoot heights
par cm
Shoot tip
T3
week 15 15 100 3days 7 13
Two
weeks 15 11 76 4 days 7 10
month 15 5 30 6 days 2 10
Two
moths 15 3 20 7 days 1 9
T4
week 15 15 100 3 days 6 12
Two
weeks 15 12 80 4 days 7 10
month 15 5 33.3 7 days 2 9
Two
moths 15 3 20 7 days 1 8.5
Inter node
T3
week 15 15 100 3 days 10 11
Two
weeks 15 12 80 4 days 10 12
month 15 3 20 10 days 1 8
Two
moths 15 0 0 0 0 0
T4
week 15 15 100 3 days 12 13
Two
weeks 15 15 100 4 days 10 13
month 15 3 20 10 days 3 11.5
Two
moths 15 0 0 0 0 0
Fig. 1. Germination of encapsulated shoot tip (A) & interned segments (B).
A, Encapsulated shoot tips on germination medium after 5 days (1)and after 10 days (2); germinated shoots on rooting medium after 3 weeks (3) and sugar
beet plant after 45 days under acclimatize condition.
B, Encapsulated inter-nod segments on germination medium after 5 days (1) and after 2 weeks; germinated shoots after 3 weeks incubation on rooting medium
and sugar beet plant after 45 days under acclimatize condition
3.2. Synthetic Seeds of the Adventitious
Shoots
3.2.1. Adventitious-Shoot Differentiation
Results showed that the average of developed shoots per
each explants ranged from 1-1.5 shoots. Among all media,
SD2A and SD1A revealed highest response of shoot
development. Medium SD2A containing 3mg/l TDZ revealed
higher percentage rather than SD1A that contained 3mg/l
BA. Whereas, the medium SD8P revealed highest percentage
of shoot development but it resulted in the highest
vitrification percentage as well. Media composed of half SH
media (SD7P-SD10A) had low frequency of shoot
production except SD8P medium which contained TDZ at
American Journal of Agricultural Science 2016; 3(3): 27-34 31
concentration of 3 mg/l. It was observed that the percentage
of vitrification was ranged from 7-38% in shoots that
produced on media solidified with phytagel (Table 4).
Shoots developed on medium containing MS medium and
BA was earliest than all other media as shoots started to
germinate within 4-7 days of culturing, while adventitious
shoots on other media started to differentiate after 10 days. It
was observed that shoots developed on MS medium were
greener, stronger and taller than those that developed on SH
media (Fig. 2). Thus, medium SD1A composed of half MS,
3mg/l BA and 8g/l agar was selected for developing
adventitious shoots from sugar beet internodes.
Fig. 2. Adventitious shoots differentiation on different media: obtained adventitious-shoots on half SH based medium (A), MS based medium (B). Difference on
normal and vitrified shoots on medium solidified by phytagel (C).
Table 4. Effect of different media on shoot differentiation.
Media Total n of
explants
No of explants
producing shoots
% explants
producing shoots
Total No of
shoots
Means of
shoot/explants
Number of Vitrified
plants(v) %(v)
SD1A 30 30 100 39 1.3 0 0
SD2A 30 30 100 42 1.4 0 0
SD3P 30 30 100 37 1.2 13 35%
SD3A 30 30 100 30 1.0 0 0
SD4P 30 30 100 42 1.4 15 36%
SD4A 30 25 83 25 1 0 0
SD5P 30 30 100 30 1 9 30%
SD5A 30 30 100 31 1 0 0
SD6P 30 30 100 30 1 6 20%
SD6A 30 30 100 30 1 0 0
SD7P 30 28 93 28 1 10 36
SD7A 30 10 33 10 1.0 0 0
SD8P 30 30 100 45 1.5 17 38
SD8A 30 30 100 32 1.06 0 0
SD9P 30 30 100 30 1 2 7
SD9A 30 30 100 30 1 0 0
SD10P 30 20 66.6 20 1 3 15
SD10A 30 30 100 35 1.16 0 0
3.2.2. Explants Encapsulation
Obtained adventitious shoots were coated with two coating
solutions composed of 4% sodium alginate, 1.2% agar and
4% sucrose (T7) or 4% sodium alienate, 1.2% agar, 4%
sucrose and 1.3 mg/l BA (T8) dissolved into liquid MS
medium. After one-week incubation at 25°C, the
encapsulated explants were germinated on four different
media. Seeds started to germinate after 3-4 days on all media;
shoots reach 2-11 cm height during 3-4 weeks. From the data
in Table (5), the best conditions for germination were at
hormone free MS medium and T8 coating solution, because
it counted the height seed germination, shoots and root
formation (Fig. 2). The germinated shoots that did not form
roots were transferred to root formation medium containing
1mg/l IBA (Fig. 3).
32 Roba M. Ismail et al.: In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet Cultivar Frida, Through Encapsulated Different Explants
Table 5. Encapsulation adventitious shoot explant germination on different media.
Germination
media
Coating
treatment
Total No.
coating seeds
Germinating
seeds
% Germinating
seeds
Obtaining
shoots
Shoot heights
par cm Root formation
G1 T7 15 8 53.3 8 11 0
T8 15 15 100 30 4 1
G2 T7 15 8 53.3 8 2 0
T8 15 6 66.7 10 2.5 0
G3 T7 15 6 40 9 6.3 1
T8 15 10 66.7 20 3.2 0
G4 T7 15 8 53.3 8 3.5 1
T8 15 8 53.3 18 3.1 0
Fig. 3. Adventitious shoot explant before coating: Adventitious shoot used for coating (A); coated adventitious shoots with alginate/agar (B); coating shoots
after one week incubation (C); germinated of synthetic seeds after 2 weeks on MS medium (D); Shoots after 3 weeks on rooting medium (E); acclimatized
plants after 45 days (F) and after 100 days (G) and produced sugar beet tap-root after 100 days (H).
4. Discussion
The artificial seed technology has opened a new scope for
handling, transplantations and maintenance of rare and
attractive genotypes [23]. In this investigation the production
of the synthetic seed from in vitro materials of sugar beet cv
Freda was studied. Three sugar beet explants were used, i.e.,
shoot tip, internode cutting and adventitious shoots that were
developed from the internode cutting explants. Several
explants were used previously to produce synthetic seeds
such as: the nodal segment in Bacopamonnieri L [16];
Cannabis sativa L. [24] and M. arvensis[17]; shoot tip of M.
arvensis[17]; Stevia [20].Synthetic seeds of sugar beet were
produced previously from somatic embryos [14] and shoot
tip [17].
Kitto and Janick [25] used many encapsulating agents such
as agar, agarose, alginate, carrageenan, gelrite and
polyacrylamide. Alginate is one of the most commonly used
polymers for immobilization of plant cells and production of
synthetic seeds because it is available in large quantities,
inert, non-toxic, cheap and can be easily handled [26, 27].
Sodium alginate is recommended as most suitable
encapsulating agent due to its solubility at room temperature
and its ability to form completely permeable gel with calcium
chloride forming a hydrogel in the presence of calcium ions
[28, 29]. In this study, sodium alginate has been used as an
encapsulating agent for coating explants in different matrix
solutions. It was found that the presence of MS, sucrose and
BA in encapsulating solutions is important in the artificial
seed germination. Results showed that all explants coated
with sodium alginate solution did not germinate. Moreover,
the synthetic seeds that coated with solution of sodium
alginate and sucrose dissolved in water did not germinate.
While, the synthetic seeds that coated with sodium alginate
with sucrose dissolved in MS germinated. Explants coated
with encapsulation solution containing 4% sodium alginate
dissolved in MS medium with either 1.3 mg/l BA or 40 g/l
sucrose revealed the same germination frequency. This
indicates the importance of sucrose, BA or MS for synthetic
seed germination. Furthermore, the adventitious shoot
explants were coated with matrix solution that containing BA
and sucrose revealed higher germination rate than those
coated with solution contained only sucrose. This result
indicates that the combination of BA and sucrose in coating
solution affected positively on seed germination as well as
the shoot development frequencies from the synthetic seeds.
We concluded that the best coating (encapsulating) matrix
solution was 4% sodium alginate, 1.2% agar as a solidified
agent, 1.3 mg/l BA and 3% sucrose. The enhancement effect
American Journal of Agricultural Science 2016; 3(3): 27-34 33
of sucrose in producing synthetic seeds was previously
reported by Rizkalla et al., [18] while conducting the
synthetic seeds production of sugar beet cvs Francesca and
Toro by encapsulating shoot tip with matrix solution
composed of 4% sodium alginate and 30 g/l sucrose. They
found that the addition of sucrose at 30 g/l to encapsulation
matrix solution gave high germination rate of synthetic seeds
than addition of 40, 50 or 60 g/l sucrose. Tsvetkov et al. [30]
and Maqsood et al. [31] reported that supplying 3% sucrose
to the alginate solution was very important in the starting
stage of the re-growth and synthetic seeds germination of
hybrid aspen and Catharanthusroseus L, respectively.
Murthy et al. [32] found that the shoot developing
percentage, a high number of shoots obtained of each
encapsulated explant and maximum shoot length were
achieved with the encapsulation matrix prepared with MS
supplemented with 3 mg/l BA, 3% sucrose and 3% sodium
alginate in Ceropegiaspiralis. Our results showed also that
the coating solution containing both sucrose and BA has also
influenced positively on producing synthetic seeds from
adventitious shoot explants as it reveled higher shoot
development than the explants coated by solution without
BA. Tsvetkov et al. [30] reported the positive effect of
combining BA and sucrose in the coating solution. They
observed that the highest fresh mass was shown when using
MS media with either BA and sucrose or MS with only
sucrose. They also demonstrated that BA increases the mass
weight twenty fold. Contrarily, Nower [20] encapsulated
stevia explants in MS liquid supplemented with only 4%
sodium alginate. It was indicated that the encapsulation
solution optimization is species-dependent and there is no
general encapsulation solution for every plant.
Nature of explants was found to be an important factor in
producing synthetic seed. The synthetic seeds from shoot tip
explants were earlier in germination than those produced
from internode. In addition, shoot tip synthetic seeds could
be stored viable for two months while, the synthetic seed
from inter node lost its germination ability after two months.
This was agreed with Islam and Bari [17] as they reported
that the artificial seed of shoot tip of M. arvensis exhibited
highest percentage of multiple shoot formation than nodal
segment explants.
The storage time of the synthetic seeds was also found to
be affecting the required germination time. The required
germination time was prolonged when the storage time was
increased. It was three or four days in case of seeds stored for
one or two weeks, respectively, and varied from 6-10 days in
seeds that stored for month or two months. In our result only
4 days required to germinate the one week stored synthetic
seeds on hormone free MS. Whereas, Sionget al. [6] reported
that the artificial seeds produced from adventitious shoots of
cauliflower, Brassica oleracea var. botrytis required 12 days
(after 7 days storage) and 14 days (after 30 days storage) to
germinate on MS basal medium.
Artificial seeds of sugar beet in current study were stored
at empty Petri dishes, while Rizkalla et al. [18] stored their
seeds on MS medium with sorbitol or mannitol.
5. Conclusion
In this study, synthetic seeds of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris)
cv Frida from different explants were produced. Our
established protocol showed efficient germination rate and
storage time. We also concluded the importance of sucrose in
the encapsulation by alginate.
References
[1] Trifonova, A. and A. Atanassov (1995). Genetic Transformation of Sugar Beet by AgrobacteriumRhizogenes. Biotechnology &Biotechnological Eq., 9:23-26.
[2] Krens, F. A.; A. Trifonova; L. C. P. Keizer and R. D. Hall (1996). The effect of exogenously-applied phytohormones on gene transfer efficiency in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.). Plant Sci., 116:97-106.
[3] Grieve, T. M.; K. M. A. Gartland and M. C. Elliott (1997). Micropropagation of commercially important sugar beet cultivars. Plant Growth Regul, 21:5-18.
[4] Saunders, J. W. and C. J. Tsai, (1999). Production of somatic embryos and shoots from sugar beet callus: Effects of abscisic acid, other growth regulators, nitrogen source, sucrose concentration and genotype. In Vitro Cell. Dev. Biol. Plant, 35:18-24.
[5] Kinoshita I. (1992). The Production and Use of Artificial Seed, Research Journal of Food and Agriculture, 15(3):6-11.
[6] Siong, P. K.; Sadegh M. and Rosna M. T. (2012). Production of Artificial seeds derived from encapsulated in vitro microshoots of cauliflower, Brassica oleracea var. botrytis Romanian, Biotechnological Letters, 17:4 (7549-7556).
[7] Murashige T. (1977). Plant cell and organ culture as horticultural practice. ActaHortic, 78:17-30.
[8] Kitto, S. L. and J. Janick, (1982). Polyox as an artificial seed coat for asexual embryos. Horticultural Science, 17:448.
[9] Gray, D. J. (1987). Synthetic seed technology for the mass cloning of crop plants: problems and prospects. Horti. Sci., 22:795-814.
[10] Gray, D. J. and A, Purohit. (1991). Somatic embryogenesis and development of synthetic seed technology. Crit Rev Plant Sci., 10:33-61.
[11] Bapat, B. A. and P. S. Rao (1998). Sandalwood plantlets from synthetic seeds. Plant Cell Rep., 7:434-436.
[12] Ganapathi, T. R.; P. Suprasanna; V. A. Bapat and P. S. Rao (1992). Propagation of Banana through enhanced shoot tips .Plant Cell Rep, 11:571-575.
[13] Ballester, A.; L. V. Janeiro and A. M. Vieitez (1997). Cold storage of shoot cultures and alginate encapsulation of shoot tips of Camellia japonica L. and Camellia reticulate Lindly. SciHortic, 7:67-78.
[14] Tsai, C. J. and J. W. Saunders (1999). Encapsulation, germination and conversion of somatic embryos in sugar beet. Journal of Sugar Beet Research, 36(4):11-32.
[15] Nower, A. A.; E A. Ali and A. A. Rizkalla (2007). Synthetic seeds of Pear (Pyruscommunis L.) Rootstock storage In vitro, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 1(3):262-270.
34 Roba M. Ismail et al.: In Vitro Propagation of Sugar Beet Cultivar Frida, Through Encapsulated Different Explants
[16] Ramesh, M.; R. Marx; G. Mathan; S. K. Pandian (2009). Effect of bavistin on in vitro plant conversion from encapsulated uninodeal micro-cuttings of micro-propagated Bacopamonnieri (L) An Ayurvedic Herb. J. Environ. Biol., 30:441-444.
[17] Islam, M. S. and M. A. Bari (2012). In vitro regeneration protocol for artificial seed production in an important medical plant Menthaarvensis L. 20:99-108.
[18] Rizkalla, A. A.; A. M. Badr-Elden; M. E. Ottai; M. I. Nasr and M. N. M. Esmail (2012). Development of artificial seed technology and preservation in sugar beet. Sugar Tech., 14(3):312-320.
[19] Awal, A.; R. M. Taha and N. A. Hasbullah (2007). In vitro formation of synthetic seeds of Begoniaxhiemalis Fotch. Indian J. Environ. Sci. 2:189-192.
[20] Nower, A. A. (2014). In Vitro Propagation and Synthetic Seeds Production: An Efficient Methods for Stevia rebaudiana Bertoni, Sugar Tech, 16(1):100-108.
[21] Reddy, M. C.; K. S. R. Murthy and T. Pullaiah (2012). Synthetic seeds: A review in agriculture and forestry, African J. of Bio. 11(78), 14254-14275.
[22] Trinh, T. H.; P. Ratet; E. Kondorosi; P. Durand; K. Kamaté; P. Bauer and A. Kondorosi (1998). Rapid and efficient transformation of diploid Medicago truncatula and Medicago sativa ssp. falcata lines improved in somatic embryogenesis. Plant Cell Rep., 17:345-355.
[23] Zhang, Y. F., S. Yan and Y. Zhang (2011). Factors affecting germination and propagators of artificial seeds of Dendrobium Candidum. International Conference on Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering. Advances in Biomedical Engineering, (1-2):404-410.
[24] Lata, H.; S. Chandra; T. Natascha; I. A. Khan and M. A. ElSohly (2011). Molecular analysis of genetic fidelity in Cannabis sativa L. plants grown from synthetic (encapsulated) seeds following in vitro storage. Biotechnol. Lett. 33:2503-2508.
[25] Kitto, S. L. and J. Janick (1985). Production of synthetic seeds by encapsulating asexual embryos of carrot. J Am Soc Hortic Sci, 110:277-282.
[26] Endress R. (1994). Plant Cell Biotechnology. Springer-verlag, Berlin. 256-269.
[27] Jaiswal, V. S.; A. Hussain and U. Jaiwal (2001). Synthetic seed: Prospects and limitations. Current Science, 78(12):1438-1444.
[28] Bapat, V. A.; M Mhatre and P.S. Rao (1987). Propagation of Morusindica L. (Mulberry) by encapsulated shoot buds. Plant Cell Rep., 6, 393-395.
[29] Kikowska, M. and B. Thiem (2011). Alginate-encapsulated shoot tips and nodeal segments in micropropagation of medicinal plants. A review 57 (4).
[30] Tsvetkov, I; L. Jouve and J. F. Hausman (2006). Effect of alginate matrix composition on re-growth of in vitro-derived encapsulated apical microcuttings of hybrid aspen, Biologia Plantarum, 50 (4):722-724.
[31] Maqsood, M.; A. Mujib and Z. H. Siddiqui (2012). Synthetic seed development and conversion to plantlet in Catharanthusroseus (L.) G. Don. Biotechnology, 11:37-43.
[32] Murthy, K. S. R.; M. C. Reddy and R. Kondamudi (2013). Synthetic seeds – A novel approach for the conservation of endangered C. spiralis wt. and C. pusilla Bangladesh J. Sci. Ind. Res. 48(1), 39-42.