IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA...
Transcript of IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA...
![Page 1: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF
SOUTH AFRICA
IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN
SUID-AFRIKA
Revised FINAL ROLL
FEB/MARCH 2016
2016
The number of the Judge to whom in each case the judgment
has been allocated is designated by dark shading
Amended: 21 Jan 2016
![Page 2: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
JUDGES - FEB/MARCH 2016
________________________________
1 Maya AP
2 Navsa ADP
3 Lewis JA
4 Ponnan JA
5 Cachalia JA
6 Leach JA
7 Tshiqi JA
8 Majiedt JA
9 Seriti JA
10 Wallis JA
11 Pillay JA
12 Petse JA
13 Willis JA
14 Saldulker JA
15 Swain JA
16 Mbha JA
17 Zondi JA
18 Dambuza JA
19 Mathopo JA
20 Fourie AJA
21 Plasket AJA
22 Tsoka AJA
23 Victor AJA
24 Baartman AJA
25 Kathree-Setiloane AJA
![Page 3: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Friday: 12 February 2016
Court A
1. The Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development v The Southern African Litigation Centre
867/2015 (GNP)
3 4 JS 8 10
Lewis JA
Ponnan JA
Shongwe JA
Majiedt JA
Wallis JA
Monday : 15 February 2016
COURT A
2. Baaitse Elizabeth Nkabinde & others v The Judicial Service Commission & others 20857/2014 (GJ) 2 3 6 11 15
Navsa ADP
Lewis JA
Leach JA
Pillay JA
Swain JA
COURT B
3. Rudolph Johan du Toit v Magistrate Johanna Ntshinghila & others 733/2015 (GNP)
4 5 12 16 23
Ponnan JA
Cachalia JA
Petse JA
Mbha JA
Victor AJA
COURT C 4. Sinethemba Ntlanyeni v The State 015/2012 (SCA)
7 10 18 21 22
Tshiqi JA
Wallis JA
Dambuza JA
Plasket AJA
Tsoka AJA
![Page 4: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Tuesday : 16 February 2016
COURT A
5. Rumdel Cape/Exr Holdings / Mazcon Joint Venture v South African National Roads Agency Soc Ltd 234/2015 (KZD)
1 6 9 11 19 Maya AP
Leach JA
Seriti JA
Pillay JA
Mathopo JA
COURT B
6. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Kluh Investments (Pty) Ltd. 115/2015 (WCC)
4 6 13 17 25
Ponnan JA
Willis JA
Zondi JA
Fourie JA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT C 7. Minister of Police v Dlwathi Steve 20604/2014 (GJ)
5 8 15 14 24
Cachalia JA
Majiedt JA
Swain JA
Saldulker JA
Baartman AJA
Wednesday : 17 February 2016
COURT A 8. Antoinette Nkhesani Masuku v The State
574/2014
3 7 12 13 14
Lewis JA
Tshiqi JA
Petse JA
Willis AJA
Saldulker JA
COURT B
![Page 5: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
9. Khangale Marshall Nndanduleni & another v The State
084/2014 (LT)
6 17 21
Leach JA
Zondi JA
Plasket AJA
COURT C
10. Daniël Johannes Stephanus van der Bank v Die Staat
245/2015 (GP)
8 11 20 23 24
Majiedt JA
Pillay JA
Fourie AJA
Victor AJA
Baartman AJA
Thursday : 18 February 2016
COURT A
11. South African Municipal Workers’ Union & others v Mohau Williams
Mokgatla & others
20810/2014 (GJ)
1 10 16 18 19
Maya AP
Wallis JA
Mbha JA
Dambuza JA
Mathopo JA
COURT B
12. Tyco International (Pty) Ltd & another v Golden Mile Trading 547 CC
949/2013 (WCC)
2 15 17 22 25
Navsa ADP
Swain JA
Zondi JA
Tsoka AJA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT C
13. Cornelius Johannes Alexander Lourens v The Speaker of the National Assembly of Parliament of the Republic of South Africa & others 20827/2014 (WCC)
![Page 6: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
3 4 9 20 21
Lewis JA
Ponnan JA
Seriti JA
Fourie AJA
Plasket AJA
Friday : 19 February 2016
COURT A 14. Nicolaas Johannes Swart v Conrad Alexander Starbuck & others 20785/2014 (GP)
2 7 10 23 24
Navsa ADP
Tshiqi JA
Wallis JA
Victor AJA
Baartman A JA
COURT B
15. Feedpro Animal Nutrition (Pty) Ltd v Reada Anna Nienaber NO & another 20866/14 (FB)
3 12 13 14 25
Lewis JA
Petse JA
Willis JA
Saldulker JA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT C
16. The Salem Party Club & others v The Salem Community & others
20626/2014 (LCC)
5 9 11 16 18
Cachalia JA
SeritiJA
Pillay JA
Mbha JA
Dambuza JA
Monday: 22 February 2016
COURT A 17. MV “Shark Team” & others v Sarah Tallman
190/2015 (WCC)
5 13 17 21 25
Cachalia JA
![Page 7: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Willis JA
Zondi JA
Plasket AJA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT B 18. Dines Chandra Manilal Gihwala & others v Grancy Property Limited & others 20760/14 (WCC) 3 6 9 10 22
Lewis JA
Leach JA
Seriti JA
Wallis JA
Tsoka AJA
COURT C 19. Renasa Insurance Company v Christopher Brian Watson & another
32/2015 (WCC)
4 7 14 16 20
Ponnan JA
Tshiqi JA
Saldulker JA
Mbha JA
Fourie AJA
Tuesday: 23 February 2016
COURT A
20. Roviana Property (Pty) Ltd & another v Ismail Suliman Dadabhay &
others
20606/2014 and 20607/2014 (GP)
2 8 11 15 23
Navsa ADP
Majiedt JA
Pillay JA
Swain JA
Victor AJA
COURT B
[21]. Dines Chandra Manilal Gihwala & others v Grancy Property Limited & others 20760/14 (WCC) 3 6 9 10 22
Lewis JA
Leach JA
Seriti JA
Wallis JA
Tsoka AJA
![Page 8: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
COURT C
22. The Body Corporate of Riverview Sectional Title Scheme v The City
of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality
30/2015 (GP)
4 12 17 18 19
Ponnan JA
Petse JA
Zondi JA
Dambuza JA
Mathopo JA
Wednesday: 24 February 2016
COURT A
23. Mzwanele Lubando v The State 347/2015 (ECM)
1 15 18
Maya AP
Swain JA
Dambuza JA
COURT B 24. Ronson Pillay v The State
453/2015 (KZP)
7 12 17
Tshiqi JA
Petse JA
Zondi JA
COURT C
25. Director of Public Prosecutions v Molefe Joseph Mphaphama
20450/2014 (GP) 8 13 24
Majiedt JA
Willis JA
Baartman AJA
AND 26. Zenzele Clerence Mndebele v The State 173/2015 (GP)
8 13 24
Majiedt JA
Willis JA
Baartman AJA
![Page 9: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
Thursday: 25 February 2016
COURT A 27. Adcock Ingram Intellectual Property (Pty) Ltd & another v Actor
Holdings (Pty) Ltd
20625/2014 (GP)
1 7 10 14 16
Maya AP
Tshiqi JA
Wallis JA
Saldulker JA
Mbha JA
COURT B
28. Riaan Anton Swart v Charlene Heine & others 192/2015 (GP)
3 11 13 19 21
Lewis JA
Pillay JA
Willis JA
Mathopo JA
Plasket AJA
COURT C
29. Mine2Market SARL v Benoryn Investment Holdings (Pty) Ltd
126/2015 (GJ)
5 9 12 18 20
Cachalia JA
Seriti JA
Petse JA
Dambuza JA
Fourie AJA
Friday: 26 February 2016
COURT A 30. A C Brookstein v J Brookstein 20808/2014 (GJ)
1 15 22 24 25
Maya AP
Swain JA
Tsoka AJA
Baartman AJA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
![Page 10: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
COURT B
31. Linah Ntombi Madalane obo Clericia Masuku v Izak Daniel van Wyk
87/2015 (GP)
4 17 21
Ponnan JA
Zondi JA
Plasket AJA
COURT C
32. Navin Naidoo v The Standard Bank of South Africa 20595/2014 (GP)
8 16 19 20 23
Majiedt JA
Mbha JA
Mathopo JA
Fourie AJA
Victor AJA
Monday: 29 February 2016
COURT A 33. The CADAC Pension Fund & others v The Executive Officer of the Financial Services Board 20106/2014 (GJ)
2 9 12 18 20
Navsa ADP
Seriti JA
Petse JA
Dambuza JA
Fourie AJA
COURT B
34. Sino West Shipping Co. Limited v Nyk-Hinode Line Limited 16/2015 (KZD)
4 10 13 19 24
Ponnan JA
Wallis JA
Willis JA
Mathopo JA
Baartman AJA
COURT C
35. Mervyn Mohapi v De Beers Pension Fund & another
64/2015 (GP)
5 7 11 15 23
Cachalia JA
Tshiqi JA
Pillay JA
Swain JA
Victor AJA
![Page 11: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Tuesday: 1 March 2016
COURT A 36. Nova Property Group Holdings Ltd & others v Julius Peter Cobbett & another (MandG Centre for Investigative Journalism as amicus curiae) 20815/2014 (GP)
1 8 16 21 25
Maya AP
Majiedt JA
Mbha JA
Plasket AJA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT B 37. Distell Limited v KZN Wines and Spirits CC
20291/2014 (KZD)
3 5 10 14 17
Lewis JA
Cachalia JA
Wallis JA
Saldulker JA
Zondi JA
COURT C
38. Nurcha Finance Company (Pty) Ltd v Oudtshoorn Municipality 20821/2014 (WCC)
4 11 12 20 22
Ponnan JA
Pillay JA
Petse JA
Fourie AJA
Tsoka AJA
Wednesday: 2 March 2016
COURT A 39. Thembani Mabaso v The State
200/2015 (KZP)
6 17 20
Leach JA
Zondi JA
Fourie AJA
![Page 12: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
COURT B
40. Shamduth Singh & others v The State 862/2015 (KZD)
7 15 16 22 23
Tshiqi JA
Swain JA
Mbha JA
Tsoka AJA
Victor AJA
COURT C
41. Ernest Vusi Majazi Zwane v The State 700/2015 (KZD)
8 9 21
Majiedt JA
Seriti JA
Plasket AJA
Thursday: 3 March 2016
COURT A 42. Elizabeth Aletta Magdalena van Niekerk v Gert Abraham Kruger & others 20632/2014 (GJ) 2 6 14 22 24
Navsa ADP
Leach JA
Saldulker JA
Tsoka AJA
Baartman AJA
COURT B 43. Kosmos X6 Homeowners Association v Leopont 64 Properties (Pty)
Ltd & another
20546/2014 (GP)
3 13 18 19 21
Lewis JA
Willis JA
Dambuza JA
Mathopo JA
Plasket AJA
COURT C
44. BSB International Link CC v Readam South Africa (Pty) Ltd &
another
279/2015 (GJ)
![Page 13: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
4 8 15 23 25
Ponnan JA
Majiedt JA
Swain JA
Victor AJA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
Friday: 4 March 2016
COURT A
45. Compensation Solutions (Pty) Ltd v The Compensation Commissioner & others 072/2015 (GP)
1 5 11 12 18
Maya AP
Cachalia JA
Pillay JA
Petse JA
Dambuza JA
COURT B 46. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Coltrade International CC 054/2015 (GP)
2 6 7 17 25
Navsa ADP
Leach JA
Tshiqi JA
Zondi JA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT C 47. Bernard Geoffrey Fisher v Natal Rubber Compounders (Pty) Ltd 20640/2014 (KZD)
3 10 13 14 19
Lewis JA
Wallis JA
Willis JA
Saldulker JA
Mathopo JA
Monday: 7 March 2016
COURT A 48. Christian Herodemus Botha NO v The Governing Body of Eljada
Institute
20530/2014 (WCC)
5 8 13 20 24
Cachalia JA
![Page 14: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Majiedt JA
Willis JA
Fourie AJA
Baartman AJA
COURT B 49. Ian David Mitchell NO v Sandra Jane Wren & others 153/2015 (ECP) 6 9 12 16 25
Leach JA
Seriti JA
Petse JA
Mbha JA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT C
50. Nomvula Effie Chaliza v Ashendran Govender & another 20837/2014 (KZD) 7 11 15 18 22
Tshiqi JA
Pillay JA
Swain JA
Dambuza JA
Tsoka AJA
Tuesday: 8 March 2016
COURT A 51. Viking Inshore Fishing (Pty) Ltd v Mutual & Federal Insurance
Company Ltd
041/2015 (WCC)
1 10 14 15 23
Maya AP
Wallis JA
Saldulker JA
Swain JA
Victor AJA
COURT B 52. Merial & others v Cipla Vet (Pty) Ltd 20772/2014 (Court of the Commissioner of Patents)
2 6 12 18 25
Navsa ADP
Leach JA
Petse JA
Dambuza JA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT C
53. The Road Accident Fund v Francois Petrus Kotze
![Page 15: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
20587/2014 (WCC)
3 4 17 19 22
Lewis JA
Ponnan JA
Zondi JA
Mathopo JA
Tsoka AJA
Wednesday: 9 March 2016
COURT A 54. Muzi Gonya v The State 891/2015 (GP) 3 6 11 13 23
Lewis JA
Leach JA
PillayJA
Willis JA
Victor AJA
COURT B
55. Raymond Daniel de Villiers v The State & another
20732/2014 (FB)
8 20 24
Majiedt JA
Fourie AJA
Baartman AJA
COURT C
56. Cornelius Marthinus Jansen v The State
236/2015
9 14 19
Seriti JA
Saldulker JA
Mathopo JA
Thursday: 10 March 2016
COURT A 57. Umso Construction (Pty) Ltd v MEC of the Government of the
Province of the Eastern Cape responsible for Roads and Transport &
others
20800/2014 (ECB)
1 5 11 16 23 Maya AP
![Page 16: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Cachalia JA
PillayJA
Mbha JA
Victor AJA
COURT B 58. Pro Tempo Academy CC v CS van der Merwe obo Hercules van der
Merwe
20853/2014 (GP)
2 10 14 17 25
Navsa ADP
Wallis JA
Saldulker JA
Zondi JA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT C
59. Jacobus van Schalkwyk v The State
680/2015 (NCK)
3 7 13 21 24
Lewis JA
Tshiqi JA
Willis JA
Plasket JA
Baartman AJA
Friday: 11 March 2016
COURT A 60. Windor Trade and Invest 129 CC v Unit 14 Dijon CC & others 20660/2014 (GP) 1 8 16 21 23
Maya AP
Majiedt JA
Mbha JA
Plasket JA
Victor AJA
COURT B 61. Hannes Geldenhuys NO & others v Susan Romao-Duarte Daniels 20848/2014 (KZP)
4 10 12 18 22
Ponnan JA
Wallis JA
Petse JA
Dambuza JA
Tsoka AJA
COURT C
![Page 17: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
62. The MEC for the Department of Public Works, Road and Transport v
Loretta Botha
20811/2014 (ECP)
6 15 20
Leach JA
Swain JA
Fourie AJA
Monday: 14 March 2016
COURT A
63. Estee Bunton & another v W A Coetzee & another
20794/2014 (GP)
2 7 9 15 20
Navsa ADP
Tshiqi JA
Seriti JA
Swain JA
Fourie AJA
COURT B
64. Nedbank Limited v Gordon Ndzimande Radebe & another
20776/2014 (GJ)
3 10 12 18 19
Lewis JA
Wallis JA
Petse JA
Dambuza JA
Mathopo JA
COURT C
65. Christos Koukoudis & another v Abrina 1772 (Pty) Ltd & another
20747/2014 (GP)
6 8 11 23 24
Leach JA
Majiedt JA
Pillay JA
Victor AJA
Baartman AJA
Tuesday: 15 March 2016
COURT A
![Page 18: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
66. First National Bank (A Division of First Rand Bank Limited) & another
v Scenematic One (Pty) Ltd
20832/2014 (GP)
2 8 16 17 22 Navsa ADP
Majiedt JA
Mbha JA
Zondi JA
Tsoka AJA
COURT B
67. Eravin Construction CC v Jacobus Nicolaas Bekker NO & others
20736/2014 (NWM)
3 7 15 18 21
Lewis JA
Tshiqi JA
Swain JA
Dambuza JA
Plasket AJA
COURT C
68. Gary Itzikowitz v Absa Bank Limited
20729/2014 (GJ)
4 5 13 14 20
Ponnan JA
Cachalia JA
Willis JA
Saldulker JA
Fourie AJA
Wednesday: 16 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 17 March 2016
COURT A
69. Foxlake Investments (Pty) Ltd t/a Foxway Developments (Pty) Ltd v
Ultimate Raft Foundation Design Solutions CC t/a Ultimate Raft Design &
another
![Page 19: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
144/2015 (GP)
1 9 11 13 23
Maya AP
Seriti JA
Pillay JA
Willis JA
Victor AJA
COURT B
70. Grainco (Pty) Ltd v Jacobus Alewyn van der Merwe & others
20693/2014 (WCC)
4 10 16 19 21
Ponnan JA
Wallis JA
Mbha JA
Mathopo JA
Plasket AJA
COURT C
71. Khomoeng Jane Mothupi v MEC, Department of Health Free State
Province
20598/2014 (FB)
5 6 8 17 25
Cachalia JA
Leach JA
Majiedt JA
Zondi JA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
Friday: 18 March 2016
COURT A
72. Trustco Group International (Pty) Ltd v Vodacom (Pty) Ltd & another
82/2015 (GP)
2 10 12 22 25
Navsa ADP
Wallis JA
Petse JA
Tsoka AJA
Kathree-Setiloane AJA
COURT B
73. Suzette Deacon v Planet Fitness Holdings (Pty) Ltd
028/2015 (GP)
3 11 13 21 23
![Page 20: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Lewis JA
Pillay JA
Willis JA
Plasket AJA
Victor AJA
COURT C
74. The Minister of Safety and Security & another v Tembop Recovery
CC & others
006/2015 (GJ)
6 14 18 19 24
Leach JA
Saldulker JA
Dambuza JA
Mathopo JA
Baartman AJA
Monday: 21 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 22 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Wednesday: 23 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
![Page 21: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
COURT C
Thursday: 24 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Friday: 25 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Monday: 28 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 29 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
![Page 22: IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - Justice … · IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL FEB/MARCH 2016 2016](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022022609/5b8f7f1209d3f28c298c89d6/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Wednesday: 30 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 31 March 2016
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C