IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - SAFLIIIN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE...

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF

SOUTH AFRICA

IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN

SUID-AFRIKA

FINAL DRAFT ROLL

FEB/MARCH 2017

(30 November 2016)

The number of the Judge to whom in each case the judgment

has been allocated is designated by dark shading

2

JUDGES - FEB/MARCH 2017

________________________________

1 Maya AP

2 Ponnan JA

3 Cachalia JA

4 Shongwe JA

5 Leach JA

6 Tshiqi JA

7 Theron JA

8 Majiedt JA

9 Wallis JA

10 Petse JA

11 Willis JA

12 Swain JA

13 Mbha JA

14 Zondi JA

15 Dambuza JA

16 Mathopo JA

17 Van der Merwe JA

18 Mocumie JA

19 Fourie AJA

20 Molemela AJA

21 Gorven AJA

22 Nicholls AJA

23 Coppin AJA

24 Mbatha AJA

25 Schippers AJA

3

Wednesday: 15 February 2017

COURT A

1. The Director of Public Prosecutions: Gauteng Division, Pretoria v Daniel Chaka Moabi 959/2015 (GP) 1 7 15 20 21

Maya AP

Theron JA

Dambuza JA

Molemela AJA

Gorven AJA

AND

2. Director of Public Prosecutions, Gauteng Division, Pretoria v

Kingsely Jafta Moloi

1101/2015 (GP)

1 7 15 20 21

Maya AP

Theron JA

Dambuza JA

Molemela AJA

Gorven AJA

COURT B

3. Thabo Steven Mthimunye v The State 1186/2016 (GP) 2 14 15 22 23

Ponnan JA

Zondi JA

Mathopo JA

Nicholls AJA

Coppin AJA

AND

4. Donovan Mazina v The State

494/2016 (ECG) 2 14 15 22 23

Ponnan JA

Zondi JA

Mathopo JA

Nicholls AJA

Coppin AJA

4

COURT C 5. Khumbulani Collen Ndlovu v The State

925/2016 (KZD)

6 10 13 19 24

Tshiqi JA

Petse JA

Mbha JA

Fourie AJA

Mbatha AJA

AND

6. Nndwambi Mudau & another v The State 1148/2016 (LT) 6 10 13 19 24

Tshiqi JA

Petse JA

Mbha JA

Fourie AJA

Mbatha AJA

Thursday: 16 February 2017

COURT A

7. Niekara Harielall v University of KwaZulu-Natal

493/2016 (KZP)

3 12 20 21 24

Cachalia JA

Swain JA

Molemela AJA

Gorven AJA

Mbatha AJA

COURT B 8. Gert Petrus Jacobus Grobbelaar Kotze v The State 776/2016 (GP) 4 8 17 18 25

Shongwe JA

Majiedt JA

Van der Merwe JA

Mocumie JA

Schippers AJA

5

AND 9. Francois Johan Joubert v The State 642/2016 (GP) 4 8 17 18 25

Shongwe JA

Majiedt JA

Van der Merwe JA

Mocumie JA

Schippers AJA

COURT C

10. Zuluboy Zulu v The State 226/2016 (GP) 7 9 11 13 23

Theron JA

Wallis JA

Willis JA

Mbha JA

Coppin AJA

AND 11. Asanda Mpinda v The State 673/2015 (WCC) 7 9 11 13 23

Theron JA

Wallis JA

Willis JA

Mbha JA

Coppin AJA

Friday: 17 February 2017

COURT A 12. Mpumalanga Tourism and Parks Agency & another v Barberton Mines (Pty) Ltd & others 216/16 (GP) 2 6 8 15 17

Ponnan JA

Tshiqi JA

Majiedt JA

Dambuza JA

Van der Merwe JA

COURT B 13. University of the Free State v Afriforum & another 1027/2016 (FB)

6

3 12 16 19 25 Cachalia JA

Swain JA

Mathopo JA

Fourie AJA

Schippers AJA

COURT C 14. New Adventure Shelf 122 (Pty) Ltd v The Commissioner of the South African Revenue Services 310/2016 (WCC) 4 5 9 18 22

Shongwe JA

Leach JA

Wallis JA

Mocumie JA

Nicholls AJA

Monday: 20 February 2017

COURT A 15. Neotel (Pty) Ltd v Telkom SOC Ltd & others

605/2016 (GP) 1 8 19 21 23

Maya AP

Majiedt JA

Fourie AJA

Gorven AJA

Coppin AJA

COURT B

16. Ashley Brooks & another v The National Director of Public

Prosecutions

855/2016 (NCK)

2 11 14 18 25

Ponnan JA

Willis JA

Zondi JA

Mocumie JA

Schippers AJA

COURT C

17. Ntsieni Josephine Manukha v Road Accident Fund 285/2016 (GP)

7

5 6 7 10 20

Leach JA

Tshiqi JA

Theron JA

Petse JA

Molemela AJA

Tuesday : 21 February 2017

COURT A 18. Ndivhuwo Catharine Phasha & others v Minister of Police

070/2016 (GP)

2 7 10 14 17

Ponnan JA

Theron JA

Petse JA

Zondi JA

Van der Merwe JA

COURT B

19. Riversdale Mining Limited v Johannes Jurgens Du Plessis &

another

536/2016 (GJ)

3 9 15 16 23

Cachalia JA

Wallis JA

Dambuza JA

Mathopo JA

Coppin AJA

COURT C

20. Dr David Griesel & others v Piet Haasbroek

538/2016 (NWM)

5 11 13 20 21

Leach JA

Willis JA

Mbha JA

Molemela AJA

Gorven AJA

Wednesday: 22 February 2017

8

COURT A 21. Herbal Zone (Pty) Ltd & others v Infitech Technologies (Pty) Ltd & others 204/2016 (WCC) 3 4 9 13 25

Cachalia JA

Shongwe JA

Wallis JA

Mbha JA

Schippers AJA

COURT B 22. The Premier of the Western Cape Provincial Government NO v Rochelle Madalyn Kiewitz obo Jaydin Kiewitz 158/2016 (WCC) 5 6 8 12 22

Leach JA

Tshiqi JA

Majiedt JA

Swain JA

Nicholls AJA

COURT C

Thursday: 23 February 2017

COURT A 23. Polokwane Local & Long Distance Taxi Association v Limpopo

Permissions Board & others

490/2016 (GP) 1 11 13 18 19

Maya AP

Willis JA

Mbha JA

Mocumie JA

Fourie AJA

COURT B

24. Asla Construction (Pty) Ltd v Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality

& another

894/2016 (ECG)

9

2 3 12 15 21

Ponnan JA

Cachalia JA

Swain JA

Dambuza JA

Gorven AJA

COURT C

25. Westminster Tobacco Company (Cape Town and London) (Pty) Ltd

v Philip Morris Products SA & another

925/2015 (GP)

5 9 10 14 24 Leach JA

Wallis JA

Petse JA

Zondi JA

Mbatha AJA

Friday: 24 February 2017

COURT A

26. Orica Mining Services SA (Pty) Ltd v Elbroc Mining Products (Pty)

Ltd

233/2016 (GP)

1 12 15 22 24 Maya AP

Swain JA

Dambuza JA

Nicholls AJA

Mbatha AJA

COURT B

27. Matthys Pieter Ruben De Villiers v Elspiek Boerdery (Pty) & another

1196/15 (WCC)

4 8 18 19 25

Shongwe JA

Majiedt JA

Mocumie JA

Fourie AJA

Schippers AJA

COURT C

28. Hendrik Christoffel Marais NO & others v Varicor Nineteen (Pty) Ltd

t/a BP Atlantic

10

843/2016 (WCC) 6 7 16 17 23

Tshiqi JA

Theron JA

Mathopo JA

Van der Merwe JA

Coppin AJA

Monday: 27 February 2017

COURT A

29. Moakohi Ansley Makgolo v Sandra Russel MacKenzie

207/2016 (GP)

2 9 14 20 24

Ponnan JA

Wallis JA

Zondi JA

Molemela AJA

Mbatha

COURT B 30. Media 24 Limited & another v Bekker du Plessis

127/2016 (GP)

3 10 12 13 21

Cachalia JA

Petse JA

Swain JA

Mbha JA

Gorven AJA

COURT C

31. MTO Forestry (Pty) Ltd v AH Swart NO

420/16 (WCC) 5 11 16 18 23

Leach JA

Willis JA

Mathopo JA

Mocumie JA

Coppin AJA

Tuesday: 28 February 2017

11

COURT A 32. Tlhalefi Andries Mashamaite & others v Mogalakwena Local Municipality & others 548/2016 & 523/2016 (GP) 1 7 15 19 25

Maya AP

Theron JA

Dambuza JA

Fourie AJA

Schippers AJA

COURT B 33. Adendorffs Boerderye (Pty) Ltd v Fayindor Shabalala & others 997/2015 (LCC) 4 8 16 17 24

Shongwe JA

Majiedt JA

Mathopo JA

Van der Merwe JA

Mbatha AJA

COURT C

34. Columbia Rylaan 14 Northcliff CC & another v Absa Bank Limited 665/2015 (GJ) 6 12 18 20 22

Tshiqi JA

Swain JA

Mocumie JA

Molemela AJA

Nicholls AJA

Wednesday: 1 March 2017

COURT A 35. SA Metal Group (Pty) Ltd v The International Trade Administration

Commission & another

267/2016 (WCC)

2 5 8 11 19

Ponnan JA

Leach JA

Majiedt JA

Willis JA

Fourie AJA

COURT B

12

36. Mothuloe Incoporated Attorneys v The Law Society of the Northern Province & another 213/2016 (GP) 3 4 9 15 24

Cachalia JA

Shongwe JA

Wallis JA

Dambuza JA

Mbatha AJA

COURT C

37. Factaprops 1052 CC & another v Land and Agricultural Development Bank of South Africa t/a The Land Bank 353/2016 (GP) 6 14 17 22 23

Tshiqi JA

Zondi JA

Van der Merwe JA

Nicholls AJA

Coppin AJA

Thursday: 2 March 2017

COURT A

38. ZNK Investment CC v Luckytso Transport and Construction CC &

others

328/2016 (GP)

1 7 17 21 23

Maya AP

Theron JA

Van der Merwe JA

Gorven AJA

Coppin AJA

COURT B

39. Sentrachem Limited v A L Terblanche

237/16 (GP)

5 8 17 16 25

Leach JA

Majiedt JA

Mathopo JA

Mocumie JA

Schippers AJA

13

COURT C

40. Martinus van Rooyen Friedrich & others v Adriaan Louw Smit NO in

his capacity as the nominee of Stabilitas Board of Executors (Pty) Ltd &

others

1028/2015 (GP) 6 10 13 19 20

Tshiqi JA

Petse JA

Mbha JA

Fourie AJA

Molemela AJA

Friday: 3 March 2017

COURT A

41. Andreas Panayiotou v Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd & others

248/16 (GJ)

2 4 10 14 21

Ponnan JA

Shongwe JA

Petse JA

Zondi JA

Gorven AJA

COURT B 42. Verulam Sawmills (Pty) Ltd v Samuel December Magagula and 158

others & another

322/16 (GP)

3 9 16 20 22

Cachalia JA

Wallis JA

Mathopo JA

Molemela AJA

Nicholls AJA

COURT C 43. Richard Du Plessis Barry v Clearwater Estates NPC (Clearwater

Estates Homeowners Association) & others

187/16 (GJ)

14

5 11 12 13 25 Leach JA

Willis JA

Swain JA

Mbha JA

Schippers AJA

Monday: 6 March 2017

COURT A 44. Lucas Moila v The City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality 249/2016 (GP) 3 11 14 17 24

Cachalia JA

Willis JA

Zondi JA

Van der Merwe JA

Mbatha AJA

COURT B 45. The Body Corporate of Empire Gardens v Nobuhle Gloria Sithole & another 240/2016 (GP) 6 9 10 13 22

Tshiqi JA

Wallis JA

Petse JA

Mbha JA

Nicholls AJA

COURT C

46. Brayton Carlswald (Pty) Ltd & another v Gordon Donald Brews 245/2016 (GJ) 7 8 15 16 23

Theron JA

Majiedt JA

Dambuza JA

Mathopo JA

Coppin AJA

Tuesday: 7 March 2017

COURT A 47. The Minister of Home Affairs & others v Cishahayo Saidi & others

294/2016 (WCC)

1 8 12 21 24

15

Maya AP

Majiedt JA

Swain JA

Gorven AJA

Mbatha AJA

COURT B 48. Catherine Claris Cilliers NO & others v Edward Ellis & another 200/2016 (WCC) 2 14 16 19 22

Ponnan JA

Zondi JA

Mathopo JA

Fourie AJA

Nicholls AJA

COURT C 49. Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality v Amber Mountain Investments 3 (Pty) Ltd 576/2016 (ECP) 3 7 15 18 20

Cachalia JA

Theron JA

Dambuza JA

Mocumie JA

Molemela AJA


COURT A COURT B

COURT C


COURT A 50. Cathay Pacific Airway Ltd & another v Hai Lin (In re: Hai Lin &

another v Minister of Home Affairs & others)

16

260/2016 (GJ)

1 8 17 20 21

Maya AP

Majiedt JA

Van der Merwe JA

Molemela AJA

Gorven AJA

COURT B

51. The National Head of the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation

v Major General Johann Wessel Booysen & another

062/2016 (KZD)

2 4 18 23 25

Ponnan JA

Shongwe JA

Mocumie JA

Coppin AJA

Schippers AJA

COURT C

52. Steyn Lyell Maeyane Attorneys v Johan Oelofse

271/2016 (GP)

5 6 9 13 19

Leach JA

Tshiqi JA

Wallis JA

Mbha JA

Fourie AJA


COURT A

53. NO Oelofse Attorneys v Thakeli Thubaka Sidwell NO IN RE: Thakeli

Thubaka Sidwell NO v Phillipus Marthinus Du Buisson NO & others

506/2016 (FB)

2 4 9 17 25 Ponnan JA

Shongwe JA

Wallis JA

Van der Merwe JA

Schippers AJA

17

COURT B 54. Mount Amanzi Share Block Limited v The Body Corporate of

Windsor Heights Sectional Title Scheme

537/2016 (GP)

3 12 22 23 24 Cachalia JA

Swain JA

Nicholls AJA

Coppin AJA

Mbatha AJA

COURT C

55. Afgri Operations Limited v Hamba Fleet (Pty) Ltd

542/2016 (GP) 5 7 10 11 15

Leach JA

Theron JA

Petse JA

Willis JA

Dambuza JA


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

56. Home Talk Development (Pty) Ltd & others v Ekurhuleni

Metropolitan Municipality

255/2016 (GJ)

2 3 8 11 25

Ponnan JA

Cachalia JA

Majiedt JA

Willis JA

Schippers AJA

18

COURT B

57. Auction Alliance (Pty) Ltd v Wade Park (Pty) Ltd 342/2016 (KZP) 4 12 14 16 21

Shongwe JA

Swain JA

Zondi JA

Mathopo JA

Gorven AJA

COURT C

58. Saamwerk Soutwerke (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Mineral Resources &

another

1098/2015 and 206/2016 (NCK)

5 7 17 19 22 Leach JA

Theron JA

Van der Merwe JA

Fourie AJA

Nicholls AJA


COURT A

59. Director Public Prosecutions, Gauteng Division Pretoria v Ferhat

Benbelkacem

831/2016 (GP)

6 16 17 18 22

Tshiqi JA

Mathopo JA

Van der Merwe JA

Mocumie JA

Nicholls AJA

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A 60. P A Pearson (Pty) Ltd v eThekwini Municipality & others

19

241/2016 (KZD) 1 10 12 13 22

Maya AP

Petse JA

Swain JA

Mbha JA

Nicholls AJA

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C


PUBLIC HOLIDAY


COURT A

61. Mahaeeane Mahaeeane & another v Angogold Ashanti Limited 085/2016 (GJ)

1 19 20 21 24

Maya AP

Fourie AJA

Molemela AJA

Gorven AJA

20

Mbatha AJA

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

62. Serengeti Rise Industries (Pty) Ltd & another v Taybo Nazeer Aboobaker NO & others 845/2015 (KZD) 4 15 17 23 25

Shongwe JA

Dambuza JA

Van der Merwe JA

Coppin AJA

Schippers AJA

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

21

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C


COURT A

COURT B

COURT C

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - SAFLIIIN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE...

Documents

Transcript of IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF - SAFLIIIN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE...