In mediation, the questions are open; In politics, they are closed! The de Borda Institute .

In mediation, the questions are open;

In politics, they are closed!

The de Borda Institute

www.deborda.org

Initials of candidates in order of preference

1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 7th 8th 9th 10th

Cabinet:

Taoiseach

Department of Finance

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade

Department of Education and Skills

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation

Department of Defence

Department of Justice and Equality

Department of Health

Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt

Department of Arts Heritage and the Gaeltacht

THE BALLOT PAPER

SHORT LIST OF POTENTIAL MINISTERS

FINE GAEL (12) FIANNA FÁIL (3) SINN FÉIN (2)Richard Bruton RB Micheál Martin MM Gerry Adams GA

Simon Coveney SC Éamon Ó Cuiv EOC Mary Lou McDonald MMD

Lucinda Creighton LC Willie O’Dea WODJimmy Deenihan JDFrances Fitzgerald FF ‘INDEPENDENTS’ (3)Phil Hogan PH LABOUR Joan Collins JC

Enda Kenny EK Joan Burton JB Joe Higgins JH

Nicky McFadden NMF Eamon Gilmore EG Maureen O’Sullivan MOS

Michael Noonan MN Brendan Howlin BHJames Reilly JR Kathleen Lynch KLAlan Shatter AS Ruairí Quinn RQLeo Varadkar LV Pat Rabbitte PR

THE SHORT LIST OF CANDIDATES



Cabinet:JEAN

JI

M

JANE

JOE

Taoiseach

Department of Finance

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade


Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation

Department of Defence



Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt

Department of Arts Heritage and the Gaeltacht

A PARTIAL BALLOT - ONE EXAMPLE



Cabinet:JEAN

JI

M

JANE

JOE

JOAN

JAN

JAMES

JOHN

JO

JILL

Taoiseach A

Department of Finance A

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade A


Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation A

Department of Defence A



Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt A

Department of Arts Heritage and the Gaeltacht A

A PARTIAL BALLOT - ANOTHER EXAMPLE



Cabinet:JEAN

JI

M

JANE

JOE

JOAN

JAN

JAMES

JOHN

JO

JILL

Taoiseach A

Department of Finance A

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade A

Department of Education and Skills A

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation A


Department of Justice and Equality A

Department of Health A

Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt A

Department of Arts Heritage and the Gaeltacht A

A FULL BALLOT - ONE EXAMPLE

Names of candidates in order of preference


Cabinet:JEAN

JI

M

JANE

JOE

JOAN

JAN

JAMES

JOHN

JO

JILL

Taoiseach A

Department of Finance C A

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade B A

Department of Education and Skills C B A

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation B C B A


Department of Justice and Equality B A

Department of Health C A

Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt B C B A

Department of Arts Heritage and the Gaeltacht A C

A FULL BALLOT - ANOTHER EXAMPLE

Names of successful candidates in order of popularity.

1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th = 5th = 7th 8th =

8th =

10th

Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

QBS RESULTS 1st 2nd =

2nd =

4th 5th 6th 7th 8th =

8th =

10th

MBC TOTALS 108 48 26 67 65 65 52 43 43 38

THE CHOSEN CABINETThe results of the QBS election.

Names of successful candidates .


Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

Taoiseach 30 20 20 10 23 9

Department of Finance 55 6 8 7 7 33

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade 8 15 25 10

Department of Education and Skills 11 13 40 13 7 1

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation 10 7 8 25 4

Department of Defence 4 3 1 21 3

Department of Justice and Equality 13 9

Department of Health 9 3 8 4 11 3

Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt 3 4 2 3 2

Department of Arts Heritage and the Gaeltacht 6 2 7 1 1

THE MATRIX COUNT

Names of successful candidates.


Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

Taoiseach 30 20 20 10 23 9







Department of Health 9 3 8 4 11 3



THE MBC ELECTION – appointing the cabinet: the As



Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

Taoiseach 30 20 20 10 23 9







Department of Health 9 3 8 4 11 3 9



Blue = appointment; yellow = redundant sum; green = B’s.



Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

Taoiseach 30 20 20 10 23 9


Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade 8 10 15 25 10








A tie, 20 each, Kenny and Martin for Taoiseach.



Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

Taoiseach 30 20 20 10 23 9




Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation 10 10 7 8 25 4


Department of Justice and Equality 13 6 9


Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt 3 4 2 3 2 9


Bruton’s Bs redundant: go to Cs.



Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

Taoiseach 30 20 20 10 23 9




Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation 10 10 7 8 25 4




Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt 3 4 2 3 2 9


MBC count, final stages.



Cabinet:BURTON

KENNY

MARTIN

RABBIT

GILMOR

QUINN

LYNCH

McDONAL

HIGGIN

BRUTON

Taoiseach 20

Department of Finance 55

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade 25

Department of Education and Skills 40

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation 25

Department of Defence 21

Department of Justice and Equality 6

Department of Health 11

Department of Environment, Community, Local Govt 9

Department of Arts Heritage and the Gaeltacht 6

THE FINAL RESULT

In mediation, the questions are open; In politics, they are closed! The de Borda Institute .

Documents

Transcript of In mediation, the questions are open; In politics, they are closed! The de Borda Institute .