Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide...

60
Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on cholera 3 rd International One Health Congress Amsterdam March 17, 2015 Rita R. Colwell, Ph.D., D.Sc. Distinguished University Professor University of Maryland College Park and Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health

Transcript of Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide...

Page 1: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Impact of

climate change

on water quality

and health:

a focus on cholera

3rd International One Health

Congress

Amsterdam

March 17, 2015

Rita R. Colwell, Ph.D., D.Sc. Distinguished University Professor

University of Maryland College Park

and

Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School

of Public Health

Page 2: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Water-related diseases

Amoebiasis

Arsenic

Diarrhoeal disease,

Including cholera

Dracunuliasis (guinea worm)

Fluorosis

Giardiasis

Hepatitis A

Intestinal helminths

Malaria

Schistosomiasis

Trachoma

Typhoid

48,000,000

28-35m exposed to drinking

water with elevated levels

1.5 billion

> 5000

26 million (China)

500,000

1,500,00

133,000,000

396,000,000

160,000,000

500,000,000

500,000

110,000

1,800,000

-

-

Low

-

9400

1,300,000

> 10,000

-

25,000

Cases per year Deaths per year

West Virginia University

Civil and Environmental Engineering

Page 3: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Cholera: A Global Disease

Acute water-related diarrheal disease Seventh pandemic started in 1960s Occurs in more than 50 countries affecting

approximately 7 million people Bengal Delta is known as “native

homeland” of cholera outbreaks Since cholera bacteria exist naturally in aquatic habitats evidence of new biotypes emerging,

it is highly unlikely that cholera will be eradicated but clearly can be controlled by provision of safe drinking water.

Page 4: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 5: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 6: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 7: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

G. Constantin de Magny

Page 8: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

What is reported about cholera and

macro-scale processes?

Cholera outbreaks have been linked to environmental and climate variables

precipitation (Hashizume et al. 2008)

floods (Koelle et al., 2005)

river level (Emch et al., 2008)

sea surface temperature (Colwell, 1996; Lobitz et al., 2000)

coastal salinity (Miller et al., 1982)

dissolved organic material (Worden et al., 2005)

fecal contamination (Islam et al., 2006)

chlorophyll (Lobitz et al., 2000, Magny et al., 2008)

Page 9: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Environmental Signatures Related To Cholera Epidemics

Dan Zimble, ESRI Inc.

Page 10: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Cholera and SST in the Indian Ocean

0 0.6+

R2

Six-month SST lead: R2 = 0.72

Page 11: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Environmental Signatures Related To Cholera Epidemics K

OL

KA

TA

M

AT

LA

B

Fitted model

Cross-validation model Constantin de Magny et al., 2008, PNAS

Page 12: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Results Kolkata: Significant and positive relationship between

cholera and CHL(t) and Rain(t).

Matlab: Significant and positive relationship between

cholera and Chl(t-1).

KOLKATA

+1 mg.m-3 in CHL(t) => +32.5% in number

of cholera cases (95% CI 8.3%-62.0%)

+1 mm.day-1 in Rain(t) => +6.5% in number

of cholera cases (95% CI 1.6%-11.7%)

MATLAB

+1 mg.m-3 in CHL(t-1) => +31.4% in

number of cholera cases (95% CI 13.0%-

52.7%)

Constantin de Magny et al., 2008, PNAS

Page 13: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

West Virginia University

Civil and Environmental Engineering

Page 14: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 15: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Location of areas in the Indus River Basin where cholera

outbreaks were reported from 1875-1900.

Page 16: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Relationship between cholera

outbreaks and air temperatures

Page 17: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Air

Air Temperature Rainfall

Below average for

two previous

months

Below average

Low Risk

Available

and intact

Cholera Outbreak Water and

Sanitation Access

Above average for

two previous

months

Above average

High Risk Poor or

Damaged

Theoretical framework for predicting cholera outbreaks in epidemic regions

West Virginia University

Civil and Environmental Engineering

Page 18: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Antarpreet Jutla, Elizabeth Whitcombe, Nur Hasan, Bradd Haley, Ali Akanda, Anwar Huq, Munir Alam, R. Bradley Sack and Rita Colwell. 2013. Environmental factors influencing epidemic cholera. Amer J Trop Med Hyg 89(3) 597-607

Could we have predicted the

Haiti Cholera outbreak? Recent cholera outbreak in Haiti indicated the disease remains a global threat.

Framework for developing cholera prediction models in cholera endemic (ER)

and non-endemic regions (NER)

The sharp contrast in mortality rates between ER and NER exists not because

we do not know how to treat cholera patients, but because of a persistent

“knowledge barrier” between ER and NER.

We propose a pragmatic and adaptive framework which hypothesizes that

convergence of three enabling situations - Inception, Environmental

Conditions, and Transmission - are necessary for a cholera outbreak to become

an epidemic.

Page 19: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Grande Saline

Gonaives

Saint-Marc

Drouin

Chansolmes

Bassin Bleu

Carbaret

Croix-des-Bouquets

Petion Ville

Arcahaie

Tabarre

En Plein Delmas

Cite Soleil

Port-au-Prince

Léogâne

Presumed location of

original contamination

Montrouis

Patient Town Arrondissement Department

Grande Saline Dessalines Artibonite

Gonaïves Gonaïves Artibonite

Saint-Marc Saint-Marc Artibonite

Drouin Saint-Marc Artibonite

Chansolmes Port-de-Paix Nord-Ouest

Bassin Bleu Port-de-Paix Nord-Ouest

Arcahaie Arcahaie Ouest

Cabaret Arcahaie Ouest

Croix-des-Bouquets Croix-des-Bouquets Ouest

En Plein Gonaïves Ouest

Plaine Gonaïves Ouest

Léogâne Léogâne Ouest

Tabarre Port-au-Prince Ouest

Port-au-Prince Port-au-Prince Ouest

Delmas Port-au-Prince Ouest

Cite Soleil Port-au-Prince Ouest

Petion Ville Port-au-Prince Ouest

Montrouis Ouest

18 8 3

Cange

Jacmel

Source and Distribution of isolates collected from Haitian outbreak

Page 20: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Air temperature in Haiti in 2010 compared

with historical air temperature data

Monthly rainfall in Haiti in 2010 compared

with historical rainfall data

Page 21: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Source: The Institute for Genomic Research

Small Chromosome Large Chromosome

Vibrio cholerae

Page 22: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

RC9 O1 Ctx+ Kenya

2740-80 O1 ElTor Env US

NCTC8457 O1 ElTor 1910

B33 O1 ElTor Mzb

MJ-1236 O1 hybrid biotype

MO10 O139

623-39

1587 O12

VL426 albensis

O395 O1 Classical

AM-19226 O39

TMA21 non-O1 Brazil

MAK757 O1 ElTor 1937

MZO-2 O14

MZO-3 O37

RC385 O135 Csp Bay

V51 O141 US

V52 O37 Sudan

Chromosome I (2,961,149 bp, 2,742 ORFs)

Chromosome II (1,072,315 bp, 1,093 ORFs)

Missing ORFs in V. cholerae strains (Reference: N16961; cutoff = 70% DNA similarity)

Mosaic genomic structure of V. cholerae

revealed by comparative genomics

RC9 O1 Ctx+ Kenya

2740-80 O1 ElTor Env US

NCTC8457 O1 ElTor 1910

B33 O1 ElTor Mzb

MJ-1236 O1 hybrid biotype

MO10 O139

623-39

1587 O12

VL426 albensis

O395 O1 Classical

AM-19226 O39

TMA21 non-O1 Brazil

MAK757 O1 ElTor 1937

MZO-2 O14

MZO-3 O37

RC385 O135 Csp Bay

V51 O141 US

V52 O37 Sudan

Page 23: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Clinical Sample: ● 81 stool samples

V. cholerae O1 41 samples

V. cholerae Non-O1/O139 21 samples

● Both V. cholerae O1 and Non-O1/O139 have been isolated from 6 stool samples

A. From Cange in the Central Plateau: ca. 199 meters above sea level, is located near the

Artibonite River.

• From the hospital: tap water, greywater , and a latrine sample

• From the school a latrine sample was also collected.

• V. cholerae non-O1/O139 were isolated from all samples, all are ctxA negative (by PCR).

B. From Jacmel in the Sud-Est Department in southern Haiti:

• Water samples were collected from community tube well, river, and ocean

• All samples were negative for V. cholerae by toxR PCR,

• Some presumptive V. alginolyticus were isolated from these samples which showed

positive bands of different size for ctxA and the O1 rfb by Hoshino PCR.

C. Surface water samples from the south of Haiti, Grand'Anse, Nippes, and Sud.

• V. cholerae non-O1/O139 have been isolated and are currently being investigated.

Environmental Sample:

Page 24: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

0.00002

HC61A1

HC81A1

HC41A1

HC7A1

HC80A1

HC46A1

HC17A2

HC22A1

HC32A1

HC68A1

HCUF01

HC48A1

HC20A2

2010-EL1786

2010-EL1792

HC38A1

HC49A2

HC21A1

HFU02

2010-EL1798

HC40A1

HC70A1

HC42A1

HC57A2

HC47A1

CP1038

CP1048

CP1050

CIRS 101

CP1042

CP1040

CP1041

MO10

MJ-1236

B33

CP1032

CP1033

RC9

INDRE 91/1 N16961

HC43A1

HC23A1

HC06A1

(c) 7th pandemic (c)

HC-2 (b)

NCTC8457

BX330286

M66-2

MAK757

2740-80

V52

O395

RC27

LMA3984-4

12129(1)

MZO-3

AM-19226

HE-25

TMA21

623-39

1587

MZO-2

HE-40

HE-46

HE-39

HE-48

HC-44C1

HC-46B1

HC-43B1

HC-41B1

HE-45

Amazonia

TM11079-80

V51

CT5369-93

RC385

VL426

HE-09

HE-16

0.002

(a) (b) HC-51A1

HC-02C1

HC-1A2

HC-2A1

HC-36A1

HC-50A1

HC-55B2

HC-55C2

HC-57A1

HC-59A1

HC-59B1

HC-60A1

HC-61A2

HC-78A1

HC-56A1

HC-52A1

HC-55A1

0.0000005

HC-1

Haiti, 2010

Bangladesh, 2010

Zimbabwe, 2009

Bangladesh, 2002

Thailand, 2010

Zambia, 2004

Mexico, 1991

Mexico, 2000

Ph

ylo

gen

om

ics

The Haitian V. cholerae O1 strains clustered with other 7th pandemic V. cholerae strains in a single monophyletic clade

Haitian strains branching separately from South Asian V. cholerae strains

Page 25: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

10 Haitian strains (red) form a cluster cloud, distinct and yet, distant, from CP genomes (concurrent epidemic isolates form different parts of the world) (blue) and others (green).

Interestingly, one reference strain CP 1038 (from Zambia) genome falls into the Haitian cluster.

Principal component analysis:

The three-dimensional PCA projection plots based on divergence of average nucleotide identity

Haitian Cluster Cloud

Page 26: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Conclusion:

Genomic analysis of Haitian V. cholerae O1 strains has provided evidence of:

a distinct VNTR genotype, genetic polymorphisms of rstB and ctxB, nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations in gyrA and parC gene, and a genetically similar set of MGE’s shared with isolated elsewhere

Core gene and SNP-derived phylogenies suggest, and PCA findings reinforce, that quite quickly, i.e., within a three week period early in the cholera epidemic, significant genomic diversity accumulated in the circulating population.

Genomic analysis provided evidence that two distinct Vibrio populations, V. cholerae O1 and V. cholerae non-O1/O139, contributed to the cholera epidemic in Haiti.

Comprehensive genomic analysis showed: V. cholerae O1 populations were clonal, resembling concurrent epidemic isolates

from South Asia and Africa. V. cholerae non-O1/O139 populations were not clonal but most probably serve as

a reservoir for genomic and pathogenicity islands.

V. cholerae non-O1/O139 populations in Haiti harbor a genomic backbone similar to that of toxigenic V. cholerae O1 circulating in the Western hemisphere.

Page 27: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

www.cosmosid.com

Proprietary CosmosID™

Page 28: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

GENIUS Solution

• Software suite for analyzing WGS metagenomic sequence data

– Runs on a Linux server – Remote client tool to conduct analysis, retrieve and visualize results (runs on desktop Linux,

Windows, & OS X)

• Expertly curated genome databases available for

– Bacteria – Viruses (DNA viruses and bacteriophages) – Fungi – Antibiotic Resistance – Virulence Factors – S. aureus (MRSA, MSSA) etc.

• Database is organized as a phylogenetic tree

• Types of markers

– Unique to the organism – Shared with other neighboring organisms in the tree

• Provide identification at or near sub-species and strain level (natural concept)

4/7/2015 CosmosID Proprietary & Confidential

Uses entire genome

(tens of thousands of biomarkers)

Page 29: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Typically different strains of a species elicit different impacts, critical to human health or business.

Most E. coli are commensal, only some are pathogenic.

Pathotypes:

Serotypes:

Lineages:

Strain:

ETEC EPEC EHEC EIEC EDEC EAEC

Lineage I Lineage II Lineage I/II

EC4501

O157:H7

Pathogens Commensal

Escherichia coli

Benefits host by producing vitamin K2,

Prevents colonization of pathogenic bacteria

cause serious food poisoning,

responsible for product recalls

WHY IS STRAIN ID IMPORTANT?

Among pathogenic strains:

Severity of illness and/or

economic impacts of their

contamination varies greatly

Page 30: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

CO

SM

OS

ID G

EN

IUS

® A

NA

LY

SIS

SE

RV

ICE

Microbes Extracted DNA DNA Sequencing

GENEBOOK® Library Raw Sequence Reads GENIUS®: Probabilistic Matching

Identified Bacteria

GENEBOOK® Antibiotic

Resistance & Virulence Factor

Library

TetR

CIPR

mecA

ctxA

Pathogen detection for

health and wellness;

food safety and probiotics

biothreat and public health

surveillance;

forensic and scientific

investigation

Applications:

RE

SE

AR

CH

& T

ES

TIN

G L

AB

:

SE

QU

EN

CIN

G S

ER

VIC

E

Page 31: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

GeneBook

Library

GENIUS

Management Database

Public Sequence Databases

Private Sequence Databases

Sequence Read Archive (SRA)

Short Reads from Samples

Short Reads Samples

GENIUS

5VCE

GENIUS

NmerCE

Remote Site Server Site Server Site GENIUS GUI

Web Portals

3rd Party Tool Plugin

Metadata Sample info User info Analysis info

End Users

Bacteria Viruses Fungi etc.

Metadata Results

(a)

(b)

(c)

GEN

IUS®

SY

STEM

OV

ERV

IEW

4/7/2015 CosmosID Proprietary & Confidential

Page 32: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Post-sequencing Bioinformatics Analysis of Clinical Specimens Process:

1. Transfer sample sequence data to the CosmosID GENIUS appliance server.

2. Open GENIUS GUI for the analysis of sample sequence data: a) Load samples, b) Select sample(s), c) Run analysis

3. At the end of the analysis, a report will be generated, which includes

information on bacterial strains identified and their respective relative abundances

4/7/2015 CosmosID Proprietary & Confidential

sequencefile.fasta

Page 33: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Microbiome Analysis of Acute Diarrheal

Patients Compared with Healthy Individuals

Page 34: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

HEALTHY CONTROL

KNOWN ETIOLOGY

HMP

UNKNOWN ETIOLOGY

A SUBPOPULATION OF THE MICROBIOME IS OVER- REPRESENTED IN THE DIARRHEAL PATIENTS COMPARED TO HEALTHY INDIVIDUALS

DIA

RR

HEA

L PA

TIEN

TS

HEA

LTH

Y IN

DIV

IDU

ALS

4/7/2015 CosmosID Proprietary & Confidential

Page 35: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

PATHOGENIC

STRAINS ONLY

MULTIPLE PATHOGENS CAN READILY BE IDENTIFIED FROM

DISEASE PATIENTS

Page 36: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

|-----------HMP----------|

THE POPULATION OF KOLKATA, INDIA MAY TOLERATE A SMALL NUMBER OF PATHOGENIC

MICROORGANISMS THAT WOULD COMPRISE A DISEASE STATE IN WESTERN EUROPEANS

IDENTIFIED BACTERIAL COMMUNITIES AT STRAIN LEVEL

Known Enteric

Pathogens

Page 37: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

FDA/UVA/CosmosID Hospital Biofilm Study

• Data – NGS reads

– Biofilm samples collected from sink traps

– Single isolate samples cultured from patients

• Analysis

– Assembled isolate strains & incorporated into our database

– Ran GENIUS on all samples using both bacterial and antibiotic resistance factor (AR/V) databases

– NCBI BLAST search to check if AR/V factors are from plasmid(s)

4/7/2015 CosmosID Proprietary & Confidential

Page 38: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Identification Resistant Bacterial Strains from Biofilms

4/7/2015 38

3183_S1 3184_S2 3185_S3 3186_S4 3187_S5 3189_S6 3192_S7 3193_S8 3197_S9

Serr

atia

_mar

cesc

en

s_1

60

5

Cit

rob

acte

r_yo

un

gae

_17

20

En

tero

bac

ter_

clo

acae

_16

97

A

ero

mo

nas

_hyd

rop

hila

_17

60

Se

rrat

ia_m

arce

sce

ns_

16

02

Se

rrat

ia_m

arce

sce

ns_

17

02

A

ceto

bac

ter_

acet

i_N

BR

C_

14

81

8

Ach

rom

ob

acte

r_xy

loso

xid

ans_

78

No

de

A

chro

mo

bac

ter_

xylo

soxi

dan

s_A

8

Ach

rom

ob

acte

r_xy

loso

xid

ans_

C5

4

Aci

do

vora

x_sp

_JS4

2

Aer

om

on

as_h

ydro

ph

ila_s

ub

sp_h

ydro

ph

ila_A

TCC

_79

66

A

gro

bac

teri

um

_tu

mef

acie

ns_

F2

Alic

yclip

hilu

s_d

enit

rifi

can

s_K

60

1

Azo

rhiz

ob

ium

_cau

lino

dan

s_O

RS_

57

1

Bac

tero

ides

_fae

cis_

MA

J27

B

rad

yrh

izo

bia

ceae

_b

acte

riu

m_S

G-6

C

Bra

dyr

hiz

ob

ium

_sp

_17

2 N

od

e

Bu

rkh

old

eria

_sp

_JV

3

Bu

rkh

old

eria

_vie

tnam

ien

sis_

G4

C

hry

seo

bac

teri

um

_gle

um

_ATC

C_

35

91

0

Cit

rob

acte

r_am

alo

uti

cus_

16

98

C

itro

bac

ter_

freu

nd

ii_4

_7_4

7C

FAA

C

itro

bac

ter_

sp_3

0_2

C

lost

rid

ium

_bo

tulin

um

_N

CTC

_2

91

6

Co

mam

on

as_t

esto

ste

ron

i_A

TCC

_1

19

96

C

om

amo

nas

_tes

tost

ero

ni_

KF-

1

Co

mam

on

as_t

esto

ste

ron

i_N

BR

C_

10

09

89

C

om

amo

nas

_tes

tost

ero

ni_

S44

C

up

riav

idu

s_m

etal

lidu

ran

s_C

H3

4

Dec

hlo

roso

ma_

suill

um

_PS

Del

ftia

_aci

do

vora

ns_

SPH

-1

Del

ftia

_sp

_Cs1

-4

Dys

gon

om

on

as_g

adei

_ATC

C_

BA

A-2

86

Dys

gon

om

on

as_m

oss

ii_D

SM_2

28

36

El

izab

eth

kin

gia_

ano

ph

elis

_Ag1

En

tero

bac

ter_

asb

uri

ae_

LF7

a En

tero

bac

ter_

clo

acae

_su

bsp

_clo

acae

_A

TCC

_1

30

47

En

tero

bac

teri

acea

e_b

acte

riu

m_9

_2_

54

FAA

Es

cher

ich

ia_c

oli

MS_

115

_1/2

_41

68

/TW

11

68

1

Esch

eric

hia

_co

li X

H0

01

Es

cher

ich

ia_c

oli_

4_0

96

7

Flav

ob

acte

riu

m_j

oh

nso

nia

e_U

W1

01

H

afn

ia_a

lvei

_ATC

C_

51

87

3

Kle

bsi

ella

_pn

eum

on

iae_

11

62

28

1

Lact

ob

acill

us_

bre

vis_

ATC

C_

36

7

Lact

ob

acill

us_

case

i_5

6 N

od

e

Lact

ob

acill

us_

case

i_A

TCC

_3

34

La

cto

bac

illu

s_ca

sei_

B_5

8 N

od

e

Lact

ob

acill

us_

case

i_st

r_Zh

ang

Lact

ob

acill

us_

par

acas

ei_s

ub

sp_p

arac

asei

_8

70

0:2

La

cto

bac

illu

s_p

arac

asei

_su

bsp

_par

acas

ei_A

TCC

_25

30

2

Lact

ob

acill

us_

pla

nta

rum

_su

bsp

_pla

nta

rum

_ATC

C_

14

91

7

Lact

ob

acill

us_

pla

nta

rum

_su

bsp

_pla

nta

rum

_ST

-III

La

cto

bac

illu

s_p

lan

taru

m_

WC

FS1

La

cto

bac

illu

s_rh

amn

osu

s_LM

S2-1

La

cto

cocc

us_

lact

is_s

ub

sp_

lact

is_

3 N

od

e

Lact

oco

ccu

s_la

ctis

_su

bsp

_la

ctis

_5

No

de

Le

uco

no

sto

c_ci

treu

m_2

78

No

de

Le

uco

no

sto

c_ci

treu

m_

LBA

E_C

11

M

eth

ylo

bac

teri

um

_ch

loro

me

than

icu

m_C

M4

M

eth

ylo

bac

teri

um

_ext

orq

uen

s_A

M1

M

eth

ylo

bac

teri

um

_ext

orq

uen

s_D

M4

M

eth

ylo

bac

teri

um

_po

pu

li_B

J00

1

Met

hyl

ob

acte

riu

m_

rad

ioto

lera

ns_

JCM

_28

31

M

eth

ylo

vers

atili

s_u

niv

ers

alis

_FA

M5

N

ovo

sph

ingo

biu

m_p

enta

rom

ativ

ora

ns_

US6

-1

Och

rob

actr

um

_an

thro

pi_

ATC

C_

49

18

8

Och

rob

actr

um

_in

term

ediu

m_

LMG

_33

01

P

seu

do

mo

nas

_aer

ugi

no

sa_3

90

16

P

seu

do

mo

nas

_flu

ore

scen

s_2

60

No

de

P

seu

do

mo

nas

_pu

tid

a_G

B-1

P

seu

do

mo

nas

_sp

_2_1

_26

P

seu

do

mo

nas

_stu

tze

ri_1

_18

6 N

od

e

Pse

ud

om

on

as_s

tutz

eri

_18

7 N

od

e

Ral

sto

nia

_pic

kett

ii_1

2J

Rh

izo

biu

m_l

egu

min

osa

rum

_bv_

35

8 N

od

e

Rh

od

op

seu

do

mo

nas

_pal

ust

ris_

58

No

de

R

ho

do

pse

ud

om

on

as_p

alu

stri

s_6

0 N

od

e

Sph

ingo

bac

teri

um

_sp

irit

ivo

rum

_ATC

C_

33

_98

No

de

Sp

hin

gob

acte

riu

m_s

pir

itiv

oru

m_A

TCC

_3

38

61

Sp

hin

gob

ium

_ch

loro

ph

eno

licu

m_

L-1

Sph

ingo

biu

m_y

ano

iku

yae_

XLD

N2

-5

Sph

ingo

mo

nas

_ech

ino

ides

_ATC

C_1

48

20

Sp

hin

gom

on

as_e

lod

ea_A

TCC

_3

14

61

Sp

hin

gom

on

as_s

p_K

C8

Sp

hin

gom

on

as_s

p_S

17

Sp

hin

gop

yxis

_ala

sken

sis_

RB

22

56

St

eno

tro

ph

om

on

as_m

alto

ph

ilia_

K27

9a

St

eno

tro

ph

om

on

as_m

alto

ph

ilia_

RR

-10

Sten

otr

op

ho

mo

nas

_sp

_SK

A1

4

Syn

ergi

stes

_sp

_3_1

_syn

1

Var

iovo

rax_

par

ado

xus_

17

6 N

od

e

Var

iovo

rax_

par

ado

xus_

EPS

Var

iovo

rax_

par

ado

xus_

S11

0

Xan

tho

bac

ter_

auto

tro

ph

icu

s_P

y2

Zym

om

on

as_m

ob

ilis_

sub

sp_

10

7 N

od

e

Strains

Bio

film

0

10

20

30

Relative Abundance (%)

CosmosID Proprietary & Confidential

Page 39: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Biofilms AR/V Factor Results – Biofilms & Isolates

Percent.Unique.Hits

0

25

50

75

100

Plasmid.Hit

Y

N

4/7/2015 CosmosID Proprietary & Confidential 39

Aeromonas_caviae_JHU

Aeromonas_hydrophila_1695

Aeromonas_hydrophila_1719

Aeromonas_hydrophila_1721

Aeromonas_hydrophila_1761

Klebsiella_pneumoniae_1762

Klebsiella_pneumoniae_1699

Serratia_marcescens_1605

Serratia_marcescens_1606

Citrobacter_youngae_1720

Citrobacter_amalonaticus_1698

Enterobacter_cloacae_1697

Aeromonas_hydrophila_1760

Serratia_marcescens_1602

Aeromonas_hydrophila_1700

Serratia_marcescens_1702

biofilm3183_S1

biofilm3184_S2

biofilm3185_S3

biofilm3186_S4

biofilm3187_S5

biofilm3189_S6

biofilm3192_S7

biofilm3193_S8

biofilm3197_S9

AR/V Factors

Sam

ple

s

Plasmid associated

Page 40: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Milestone Technologies

Year Algorithm Approach Algorithm Relative Speed

1981 Smith-Waterman

Global Sequence Alignment

Exact matches and complete alignments. Hashes the query.

1.0

1988 FASTA Local Sequence Alignment

Focuses on common sub-sequences (words) shared between query and database sequences. Hashes the query.

50x SWA

1990 BLAST Local Sequence Alignment

Focuses on high-scoring sub-sequences (words) shared between query and database sequences. Hashes the query.

50x SWA

2002 BLAT Local Sequence Alignment

Hashes the database. 50x WUBLAST

2006 ScalaBLAST Local Sequence Alignment

Utilizes parallel processing

4x BLAST using 50

processors

2013 GENIUS®

5VCE Probabilistic

Matching Hashes the database.

10,000X BLAST

Page 41: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

A Simple, Sustainable Method for Reducing Cholera

Page 42: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 43: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 44: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 45: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Full Study

0.00

0.20

0.40

0.60

0.80

1.00

1.20

1.40

Control Sari Nylon

Test Group

Cases o

f C

ho

lera

Per

1000

Po

pu

lati

on

Full Study

Control Nylon Sari

Test Group

Cases o

f C

hole

ra P

er

1000 P

opula

tion

1.40

1.20

1.00

0.80

0.60

0.40

0.20

0.00

Page 46: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations
Page 47: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

From Response to Coordinated Research Established 2011

www.gulfresearchinitiative.org

www.gomri.org

gulfresearchinitiative.org

Page 48: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Credit: US Chemical Safety Board

Page 49: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Credit: SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images

Credit: AP Photo/Charlie Riedel

GoMRI is not part of the

National Academy of Science or

National Fish and Wildlife Foundation

GoMRI is not part of

National Resource Damage

Assessment or

Clean Water Act

gulfresearchinitiative.org

Page 50: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Credit: SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images

Credit: AP Photo/Charlie Riedel

GoMRI is not part of the

National Academy of Science or

National Fish and Wildlife Foundation

GoMRI is not part of

National Resource Damage

Assessment or

Clean Water Act

gulfresearchinitiative.org

Page 51: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

1 - ESP

1 - DEU

2 - NLD

1 - NOR

• Dispersion by physics and plankton,

• Behavior and hydrocarbon transformation of deep oil spills,

• Influences on fate and transport,

• Environmental consequences,

• Ecosystem impacts,

• Oil plume fate,

• Ecotoxicology,

• Improved dispersants,

• Modeling of fate,

• Transport, and

• Ecosystems

Page 52: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Year One Block Grants - $45M, 149 Projects (completed)

Summer 2011 Bridge Grants (RFP III) - $1.5M, 17 Projects (completed)

2012 - 15 Eight Consortia Grants (RFP I) - $110 M, 8 RC (NCEs)

2013 -16 Investigator Grants (RFP II) - $18.6 M, 19 projects

2015 – 17 Consortia Grants (RPFIV) @ $140 M, 12 projects

2016-18 Individual Grants (RFP V) release- Nov 14 @ $30 M

2018 – 2020 last RFP(s) and wrap up.

Metrics as of Jan 31, 2015 • About 480 scientific peer-reviewed publications/book chapters

• Over 1930 presentations and poster sessions at conferences/scientific meetings

• Over 688 graduate students

gulfresearchinitiative.org

Page 53: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

41 states

240 academic institutions

16 countries

Page 54: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

“When one tugs at a single thing in

nature, he finds it hitched to the rest

of the universe.” John Muir

(1838-1914)

Page 55: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Collaborators and Colleagues ICDDR,B

• Dr. Munir Alam

• Dr. David Sack

• Dr. M. A. Salam

• Dr. A.S.G. Faruque

• Dr. Peter Kim Streatfield

• Dr. Carel van Mels

• Mr. Sarker M. Nazmul Sohel

• Dr. Mohammad Yunus

• A.K. Ashraful Aziz

• Dr. M. Imadadul Huq

• Dr. Sirajul M. Islam

• Huda Khan

• Rezaur Rahman

NICED, Kolkata, India

• Dr. Balakrish Nair

• Dr. T. Ramamurthy

University of Maryland • Sittipan Chayanan

• Nipa Choopun

• Jafrul Hasan

• Anwarul Huq

• Christopher Grim

• Shameem Huq

• Guillaume Constantin de Magny

• Chenyang Jiang

• James Kaper

• Erin Lipp

• Valerie Louis

• David Maneval

• Tonya Rawlings

• Janie Robinson

• Estelle Russek-Cohen

• Paul West

• Young Gun Zo

• Norma Brinkley

• Jennifer Papp Newlin

• Victoria Lord

Page 56: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Collaborators and Colleagues • Richard Atwell, England

• Brad Lobitz, NASA Ames

• Louisa Beck, NASA Ames

• Byron Wood, NASA Ames

• Phyllis Brayton, NIAID, NIH

• Jongsik Chun, Seoul, Korea

• Ana Gil, Lima, Peru

• Jay Grimes, Univ. of Southern Mississippi

• Sunny Jiang, Univ. of California

• Tatsuo Kaneko, San Diego

• L. Lizaragga-Partida, Mexico

• Huai-shu Xu, China

• Norma Binsztein, Argentina

• Crystal Johnson, Louisiana State University

• Carla Pruzzo, University of Genoa, Italy

• Tom Brettin, Los Alamos National Laboratory

• Nell Roberts, Louisiana State University

• Betty Lovelace, NCI/NIH

• Minnie Sochard, Catholic University, Washington, DC, USA

• Irma Rivera, Univ. of Sao Paolo, Brazil

• R. Bradley Sack, Johns Hopkins University, School of Public Health

• Fred Singleton, Gainesville, Florida

• Miguel Talledo, Lima, Peru

• Jack Dangermond, ESRI, Redlands, CA

• William Davenport, ESRI, Redlands, CA

• John Calkins, ESRI,, Redlands, CA

• Glenn Morris, Florida State University

• Ron Taylor, Darmouth, College, NH

• Matt Luck, ISciences, Burlington, VT

• Thomas Parris, ISciences, Burlington, VT

• Ric Ciccone, ISciences, Burlington, VT

• Fred Zimmerman, ISciences, Burlington, VT

• Linda Zall, Office of the Chief Scientist

Page 57: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Special Acknowledgement

• Dr. Bruce Budowle, University of North Texas

• Dr. Jack A. Gilbert, Argonne National Laboratory

• Dr. Christopher J. Grim, FDA

• Dr. Terry C. Hazen, University of Tennessee

• Dr. G. Balakrish Nair, Minister of Translational Biotechnology,

Government of India

• Dr. Thomas A. Cebula, CSO, CosmosID Inc.

• Dr. Huai Li, Director, Product Development, CosmosID Inc.

• Dr. Seon Young Choi, Bioinformatic Scientist, CosmosID Inc.

• Dr. Poorani Subramanian, Bioinfromatician, CosmosID Inc.

Page 58: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Collaborators and Colleagues

Anwar Huq,

Professor

University of Maryland,

College Park, MD

Nur Hasan

Vice-President,

Research and

Development

CosmosID, Inc.

College Park, MD

Antarpreet Jutla,

Assistant

Professor,

West Virginia

University

Morgantown, WV

Dr. Seon Young

Choi,

Bioinformatic

Scientist,

CosmosID Inc.

College Park, MD

Page 59: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations

Courtesy of GB Nair, NICED, Kolkata, India

Page 60: Impact of climate change on water quality and health: a focus on … · 2020. 4. 8. · nucleotide (GTA) deletions in rstB, an increased number (five) of ToxR binding repeats, mutations