Impact Investment - Sustainability is a better predictor than Return On Investment
-
Upload
miguel-reynolds-brandao -
Category
Economy & Finance
-
view
47 -
download
0
Transcript of Impact Investment - Sustainability is a better predictor than Return On Investment
THE SORG INDEXto
Internal & external Impact • Usefulness, Meaning • Non-speculative • Sustainability
COMPETITION
AUTHORITY
UNFAIR WAGES
MARKET CAP
COOPERATION
RECOGNITION
FAIR REWARDING
SORG INDEX
VALUES
IMPACT
RELATIONSHIPS
METRICS
TO CREATE AN INDEX, USING ONLY PUBLIC DATA, THAT ALLOW COMPARISONOF ANY ORGANISATION REGARDLESS OF SIZE, INDUSTRY OR PURPOSE
CH
ALL
EEN
GE
SUSTAINABLE ORGANISATION INDEX (SORG)
SORG = SORGI x SORGII x SORGIII
THE PRODUCT OF THE THREE INDEX INDICATES A CUMULATIVE EFFECT AND HOW BALANCED THE ORGANISATION IS - INTERNALLY AND EXTERNALLY
SORGI MEASURES THE BALANCE OF THE ORGANISATION WITH THE COMMUNITY; SORGII INSIDE THE ORGANISATION BALANCE; HARMONY THE INTERNAL COHESION.
COMMUNITY2xTEAM MEDIAN2
OWNERS2xTEAM AVERAGExCEOSORG =
SUSTAINABLE ORGANISATION INDEX I (SORGI)
COMMUNITY(3)= (REVENUES-COGS(1)-INTERESTS(1)+TAXES(2)+IMPACT)
OWNERS= NET INCOME-TEQUITY(4)
TEQUITY=NET INCOME x TEAMOWNERSHIP
TEAMOWNERSHIP=TOTAL SHARES OWNED BY TEAM / TOTAL SHARES
COMMUNITY (5)
OWNERS
(1) COGS AND INTEREST WILL BENEFIT OTHER ENTITIES. AS ITS EXPLAINED IN THE ECONOMIC FLOW MODEL(2)TAXES COME BACK TO COMMUNITY(3)ORGANISATIONS WITH NO REVENUES CALCULATE USING ONLY IMPACT.(4)FOR NET INCOME >= 1 (5)TO DO A HISTORIC ANALYSIS DO SUMMATION OF BOTH FACTORS FOR THE YEARS OF ANALYSIS
ESSENTIALLY IT ANALYSES THE OWNERS’ INVESTMENT EFFECT ON THE COMMUNITY
SORG I =
HARMONY INDEXCEO=CEO SALARY+ALL BENEFITS
TEAM=TEAM SALARY+ALL BENEFITS
COHESION FACTOR IMPLIES THATCEO <= MEDIAN TEAM x 12
TEAM MEDIAN2 TEAM AVERAGE x CEO (1)
FIRST PART ASSURES THAT THE DISTRIBUTION IS CLOSE TO A NORMAL OR SKEWED NEGATIVELY ( TO HIGHER VALUES) CURVE
SECOND ENSURES COHESION IN TOP (CEO) RETRIBUTION
(1)FOR CEO GREATER THAN TEAM MEDIAN. OTHERWISE CEO= TEAM MEDIAN.
HARMONY =
COMMUNITY(3)= (REVENUES-COGS(1)-INTERESTS(1)+TAXES(2)+IMPACT)
OWNERS= NET INCOME-TEQUITY(4)
TEAM=TEAM SALARY+ALL BENEFITS
TEQUITY=NET INCOME x TEAMOWNERSHIP
TEAMOWNERSHIP=TOTAL SHARES OWNED BY TEAM / TOTAL SHARES
IT ANALYSES BALANCE BETWEEN OWNERS AND TEAM, SHARING FLOW
TEAM x HARMONY (5) OWNERS
(1) COGS AND INTEREST WILL BENEFIT OTHER ENTITIES. AS ITS EXPLAINED IN THE ECONOMIC FLOW MODEL(2)TAXES COME BACK TO COMMUNITY(3)ORGANISATIONS WITH NO REVENUES CALCULATE USING ONLY IMPACT.(4)FOR NET INCOME >= 1(5)TO DO A HISTORIC ANALYSIS DO SUMMATION OF BOTH FACTORS FOR THE YEARS OF ANALYSIS
SUSTAINABLE ORGANISATION INDEX II (SORGII)
=SORG II
SUSTAINABLE ORGANISATION INDEX I (SORGIII)
COMMUNITY(3)= (REVENUES-COGS(1)-INTERESTS(1)+TAXES(2)+IMPACT)
OWNERS= NET INCOME-TEQUITY(4)
TEQUITY=NET INCOME x TEAMOWNERSHIP
TEAMOWNERSHIP=TOTAL SHARES OWNED BY TEAM / TOTAL SHARES
COMMUNITY (5)
TEAM
(1) COGS AND INTEREST WILL BENEFIT OTHER ENTITIES. AS ITS EXPLAINED IN THE ECONOMIC FLOW MODEL(2)TAXES COME BACK TO COMMUNITY(3)ORGANISATIONS WITH NO REVENUES CALCULATE USING ONLY IMPACT.(4)FOR NET INCOME >= 1 (5)TO DO A HISTORIC ANALYSIS DO SUMMATION OF BOTH FACTORS FOR THE YEARS OF ANALYSIS
ESSENTIALLY IT ANALYSES THE TEAM LEVERAGE EFFECT ON THE COMMUNITY
=SORG III
SUSTAINABLE ORGANISATION INDEX (SORG)
SORG = SORGI x SORGII x SORGIII
THE PRODUCT OF THE THREE INDEX INDICATES A CUMULATIVE EFFECT AND HOW BALANCED THE ORGANISATION IS - INTERNALLY AND EXTERNALLY
SORGI MEASURES THE BALANCE OF THE ORGANISATION WITH THE COMMUNITY; SORGII INSIDE THE ORGANISATION BALANCE; HARMONY THE INTERNAL COHESION.
SORG = COMMUNITY TEAM
COMMUNITY OWNERS
TEAM x TEAMEDIAN2 OWNERS x TEAMAVERAGE x CEO
XX
SORG I SORG II SORG III
SUSTAINABLE ORGANISATION INDEX
THE INDEX SYNTHESIZES THE ECONOMIC IMPACT AN ORGANISATION HAS ON THE GROUPS IT RELATES, INDEPENDENTLY OF ITS SIZE, LOCATION, ACTIVITY OR PURPOSE.
IT USES ONLY DATA PUBLICLY AVAILABLE
OWNERS
Financial data fromWolfram Alpha (2013 filling data)Median PayScale Dez 2014 Team was calculated by average salary x employees
SUSTAINABLE ORGANISATION INDEX
SORGI= COMMUNITY/OWNERS
SORGII=TEAM*HARMONY/OWNERS
SORG=SORGI x SORGII x HARMONY
COMMUNITY= REVENUES - COGS - INTEREST +TAXES + IMPACT*
OWNERS= NET INCOME-TEQUITY
TEAM(1)= AVERAGE SALARY x EMPLOYEES
*IMPACT WAS NOT CONSIDERED IN THIS EXAMPLE
THIS PROPOSAL OF CALCULATION SORG HAS THE ADVANTAGE TO BE VALID TO ANY ORGANIZATION SIZE
(1)WITH DATA DISCLOSE TEAM = SALARIES + ALL BENEFITS
OWNERS
INDUSTRYTYPE OF IMPACT
ECOLOGICAL HEALTH SECURITY DEVELOPMENT
OIL ITS EASY TO RELATE BARREL WITH REVENUES
- $96x BarrelTHIS IS AN OFFICIAL VALUE
-0,2x Revenues
JUNK FOOD - 2x Revenues
COMPUTERS -0,5 Revenues +2 x Revenues
LEARNING +3 x Revenues
HUMANITARIAN NGO +500xPeopleHelped +100xPeopleHelped
ARMAMENT - FxRevenues
WE SHOULD MEASURE THE IMPACT OF EACH INDUSTRY. IT SHOULD BE A FACTOR, POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE, OF REVENUES - SO IT WILL BE EASY COMPARABLE.
IMPACT CALCULATION - IDEAS
IMPACT EXAMPLE, CONSIDERING US$96 COST OF CO2
Market Cap (bn USD)
Revenue (bn USD)
Employees
Net Income (bn USD)
Cost of goods sold
Taxes Interest Average Salary
Median salary (USD per year)
CEO x MEDIAN
ExxonMobil 421,7 436,5 75.000 5,82 283,6 22,03 0,066 $44.000 $ 96.900 936
Impact (bn USD)
SORG I SORG II SORG
-437 - 44,98 0,00133 - 0,000141
30,05 0,00133 0,000094
Obs: WIKIPEDIA revenues, cogs and net income are in thousands
Financial data: Wolfram Alpha (2013 filling data)Median Salary: PayScale.com Dez 2014Average Salary: Carrerbliss,com WIKIPEDIA data from WIKIPEDIA financial report 2013