Immune to criticism

1
Immune to criticism Introductory Immunobiology by Huw Davies, Chapman & Hall, 1997. £24.99 (394 pages) ISBN 0 412 37240 1 Amid the recent proliferation of new ‘entry-level’ textbooks on immunology, Introductory Immunobiology is a wel- come addition. In the past, the best immunology textbooks were written with medical students in mind and followed a formula in which a brief introduction to the most up-to-date list of immunological cells and mol- ecules was followed by chapters with titles such as ‘atopy’, ‘alloreactivity’ and ‘delayed type hypersensitivity’. While these texts are essential – the dawning of a new mechanistic age in cellular and molecular immunology makes them ‘second round’ texts in building a meaningful knowledge-base for both clinical and experimental immunologists. Introductory Immuno- biology does not have a clinical bias and is suitable for students in any dis- cipline encountering immunology for the first time. It is a simple text un- encumbered by the likes of atopy and delayed type hypersensitivity. At entry level, this is an asset. What sets it apart from other, similar textbooks is that it is held together throughout by a loose theme, namely the evolution of immunity, and serves to place the mammalian immune system in its phylogenetic context wherever possible. This is well illustrated in the first three chapters (‘Protec- tion against pathogens’, ‘Recognition of pathogens’ and ‘Cells and tissues’), where parallels are drawn between the innate immune system in mammals and invertebrate immune systems. Evo- lution of the adaptive immune system is dealt with in a later, separate chap- ter (Chapter 7). This theme does not overwhelm a rigorous treatment of the molecular aspects of specific anti- gen recognition (Chapters 4 to 6), nor does it preclude some essential historical background to chapters on ‘Antigen receptors’ (Chapter 4, where I was glad to see graphic descriptions of Porter and Edelman’s and Tonegawa’s Nobel-Prize-winning experiments) and ‘The major histocompatibility com- plex’ (Chapter 6). Later chapters give a very readable introduction to the more complex processes, such as immunological control (Chapter 8: ‘Signals and control’) and thymic and peripheral tolerance of B and T cells (Chapter 9: ‘Tolerance to self’). Figures throughout are simple and informative, and there are six colour plates depicting important structures (the lysosome–Fab lysosome com- plex, epitope maps of lysosome and haemagglutinin, MHC class I molecules and a model for the interaction between the T-cell receptor and a peptide– MHC complex). These pictures were generated especially for the book from existing data. It is unfortunate that publication was not delayed a few months in order to include a real T- cell receptor–MHC–peptide complex. Given the trouble the author went to in providing the colour plates, I was dis- appointed to see such awful reproduc- tions of MHC structures elsewhere in the book (especially figure 6.9). Hope- fully, future editions will remedy this. The book is ‘user friendly’. I use ‘computerspeak’ here deliberately because the way that the book is arranged mimics features normally associated with ‘on-line’ publications. There is an impressive array of ‘hyper- text links’ in the form of margin notes (for dictionary-style definitions), boxes (for more-detailed information on sub- jects of general biological interest that are referred to in the text) and point- ers in the margin to relevant sections or boxes elsewhere in the book. The boxes are extremely informative and provide such diverse information as how to clone a new gene, and how to make a transgenic mouse, to a list of mammalian cytokines and their func- tions. Most impressive is that the author seems to have taken the trouble to ensure that this system really works and that much of the text can be read either continuously or in this modular form. Each chapter is well organized too, starting with a list of salient points, followed by an introduction and then the meat of the chapter in which most of the ‘hypertext links’ reside. Summaries are provided where they are needed (which means that, in sev- eral chapters, there is more than one) and there is often a short section point- ing to future directions for further research. References to several up-to- date reviews for further reading appear towards the end. These are normally drawn from review journals such as the ‘Annual Reviews’ series, the ‘Trendsseries and the ‘Current Opinion’ series. Each chapter then concludes with a few review questions in the form of ‘fill in the blanks’, multiple choice and even short-essay questions. Answers are provided at the end of the book – including succinct answers to the lat- ter! With a full glossary, and appen- dices listing all 130 CD antigens and the most frequently used immunological techniques, Introductory Immunobiol- ogy is a safe, informative and access- ible introduction to immunology and an essential addition to the shelf of anyone involved in teaching immu- nology to undergraduates. BOOK REVIEW trends in CELL BIOLOGY (Vol. 8) April 1998 Copyright © 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. 0962-8924/98/$19.00 173 Tim Elliott Nuffield Dept of Clinical Medicine, University of Oxford, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, UK OX3 9DU. Recent book/software reviews in other Trends journals Adhesion Molecules in Allergic Disease (edited by B. S. Bochner), Marcel Dekker, 1997. ISBN 0 8247 9836 8 Immunology Today 19, 50–51 Transgenic Animals: Generation and Use (edited by L. M. Houdebine), Harwood Academic Publishers, 1997. ISBN 90 5702 069 6 Trends in Genetics 13, 501–502 Reference Manager version 8.01, Bilany Consultants Ltd, 1997, Trends in Genetics 14, 41 Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopy (by C. J. R. Sheppard and D. M. Shotton), Bios, 1997. ISBN 1 872748 72 4 Trends in Plant Science 3, 36–37 The Oncogene and Tumour Gene FactsBook (2nd edn) (by R. Hesketh), Academic Press, 1997. ISBN 0 12 344548 5 Trends in Biochemical Sciences 23, 42 Mitochondria and Free Radicals in Neurodegenerative Diseases (edited by M. Flint Beal, N. Howell and I. Bodis-Wollner), Wiley–Liss, 1997. ISBN 0 471 14142 9, Trends in Neurosciences 21, 131–132

Transcript of Immune to criticism

Immune to criticism

Introductory Immunobiology

by Huw Davies, Chapman & Hall,1997. £24.99 (394 pages)

ISBN 0 412 37240 1

Amid the recent proliferation of new‘entry-level’ textbooks on immunology,Introductory Immunobiology is a wel-come addition. In the past, the bestimmunology textbooks were writtenwith medical students in mind andfollowed a formula in which a briefintroduction to the most up-to-datelist of immunological cells and mol-ecules was followed by chapters withtitles such as ‘atopy’, ‘alloreactivity’and ‘delayed type hypersensitivity’.While these texts are essential – thedawning of a new mechanistic age incellular and molecular immunologymakes them ‘second round’ texts inbuilding a meaningful knowledge-basefor both clinical and experimentalimmunologists. Introductory Immuno-biology does not have a clinical biasand is suitable for students in any dis-cipline encountering immunology forthe first time. It is a simple text un-encumbered by the likes of atopy anddelayed type hypersensitivity. At entrylevel, this is an asset.

What sets it apart from other, similartextbooks is that it is held togetherthroughout by a loose theme, namelythe evolution of immunity, and servesto place the mammalian immune system in its phylogenetic contextwherever possible. This is well illustratedin the first three chapters (‘Protec-tion against pathogens’, ‘Recognitionof pathogens’ and ‘Cells and tissues’),where parallels are drawn between theinnate immune system in mammalsand invertebrate immune systems. Evo-lution of the adaptive immune systemis dealt with in a later, separate chap-ter (Chapter 7). This theme does notoverwhelm a rigorous treatment ofthe molecular aspects of specific anti-gen recognition (Chapters 4 to 6),nor does it preclude some essentialhistorical background to chapters on‘Antigen receptors’ (Chapter 4, whereI was glad to see graphic descriptions ofPorter and Edelman’s and Tonegawa’sNobel-Prize-winning experiments) and‘The major histocompatibility com-plex’ (Chapter 6). Later chapters give

a very readable introduction to themore complex processes, such asimmunological control (Chapter 8:‘Signals and control’) and thymic andperipheral tolerance of B and T cells(Chapter 9: ‘Tolerance to self’).

Figures throughout are simple andinformative, and there are six colourplates depicting important structures(the lysosome–Fab lysosome com-plex, epitope maps of lysosome andhaemagglutinin, MHC class I moleculesand a model for the interaction betweenthe T-cell receptor and a peptide–MHC complex). These pictures weregenerated especially for the book fromexisting data. It is unfortunate thatpublication was not delayed a fewmonths in order to include a real T-cell receptor–MHC–peptide complex.Given the trouble the author went toin providing the colour plates, I was dis-appointed to see such awful reproduc-tions of MHC structures elsewhere inthe book (especially figure 6.9). Hope-fully, future editions will remedy this.

The book is ‘user friendly’. I use‘computerspeak’ here deliberatelybecause the way that the book isarranged mimics features normallyassociated with ‘on-line’ publications.There is an impressive array of ‘hyper-text links’ in the form of margin notes(for dictionary-style definitions), boxes(for more-detailed information on sub-jects of general biological interest thatare referred to in the text) and point-ers in the margin to relevant sectionsor boxes elsewhere in the book. Theboxes are extremely informative and

provide such diverse information ashow to clone a new gene, and how tomake a transgenic mouse, to a list ofmammalian cytokines and their func-tions. Most impressive is that the authorseems to have taken the trouble toensure that this system really works andthat much of the text can be read eithercontinuously or in this modular form.

Each chapter is well organized too,starting with a list of salient points,followed by an introduction and thenthe meat of the chapter in whichmost of the ‘hypertext links’ reside.Summaries are provided where theyare needed (which means that, in sev-eral chapters, there is more than one)and there is often a short section point-ing to future directions for furtherresearch. References to several up-to-date reviews for further reading appeartowards the end. These are normallydrawn from review journals such asthe ‘Annual Reviews’ series, the ‘Trends’series and the ‘Current Opinion’ series.Each chapter then concludes with afew review questions in the form of‘fill in the blanks’, multiple choice andeven short-essay questions. Answersare provided at the end of the book –including succinct answers to the lat-ter! With a full glossary, and appen-dices listing all 130 CD antigens and themost frequently used immunologicaltechniques, Introductory Immunobiol-ogy is a safe, informative and access-ible introduction to immunology andan essential addition to the shelf ofanyone involved in teaching immu-nology to undergraduates.

BO

OK

R

EVIE

W

trends in CELL BIOLOGY (Vol. 8) April 1998 Copyright © 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. 0962-8924/98/$19.00 173

Tim ElliottNuffield Dept ofClinical Medicine,University ofOxford, JohnRadcliffe Hospital,Oxford,UK OX3 9DU.

Recent book/software reviews in other Trends journals

Adhesion Molecules in Allergic Disease (edited by B. S. Bochner), Marcel Dekker, 1997. ISBN 0 8247 9836 8 Immunology Today 19, 50–51

Transgenic Animals: Generation and Use (edited by L. M. Houdebine),Harwood Academic Publishers, 1997. ISBN 90 5702 069 6

Trends in Genetics 13, 501–502

Reference Manager version 8.01, Bilany Consultants Ltd, 1997, Trends in Genetics 14, 41

Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopy (by C. J. R. Sheppard and D. M. Shotton), Bios, 1997. ISBN 1 872748 72 4

Trends in Plant Science 3, 36–37

The Oncogene and Tumour Gene FactsBook (2nd edn) (by R. Hesketh),Academic Press, 1997. ISBN 0 12 344548 5

Trends in Biochemical Sciences 23, 42

Mitochondria and Free Radicals in Neurodegenerative Diseases (edited by M. Flint Beal, N. Howell and I. Bodis-Wollner),

Wiley–Liss, 1997. ISBN 0 471 14142 9, Trends in Neurosciences 21, 131–132