Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure...

41
Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach Good, Better, Best Practice Brian J Cross DO Broward Health Medical Center Ft Lauderdale, FL

Transcript of Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure...

Page 1: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Ilioinguinal vs AIP ApproachGood, Better, Best Practice

Brian J Cross DOBroward Health Medical Center

Ft Lauderdale, FL

Page 2: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Disclosures

Depuy Synthes – consultant/ speaker bureauOrbis Medical – design consultantCitieffe- design consultant

Page 3: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Thanks

• AO Trauma• Claude Sagi MD• Pierre Guy MD

Page 4: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Case

• 48 y/o male • Avid cyclist (100 miles/week)• Struck by motor vehicle• Isolated injury to left hip

Page 5: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first
Page 6: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first
Page 7: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first
Page 8: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Objectives

• Discuss which fracture patterns will benefit from an anterior exposure

• Discuss the ilioinguinal and AIP approaches• Similarities• Differences• Tips for maximizing your exposure

• How do I choose?

Page 9: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

What Patterns?

• 30% of acetabular fractures require anterior fixation• Anterior wall• Anterior column• High (transtectal) transverse• T-type*• Anterior column posterior hemitransverse*• Associated both column*

• *May require sequential/ simultaneous approaches

Page 10: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first
Page 11: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Ilioinguinal Approach

• Developed by Emile Letournel• Exposure of the inner innominate bone from the SI joint to the

symphysis• Indirect access to the quadrilateral plate and posterior column

Page 12: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Ilioinguinal

• Requires development of 3 wound intervals• Mobilization of the femoral vessels and nerve and the spermatic cord (round

ligament)• Articular reductions are indirect• Femoral and inguinal hernias

Page 13: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Ilioinguinal

Page 14: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Ilioinguinal

• Must understand the anatomy of the femoral canal and the iliopectineal fascia

Page 15: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - II

• First window• Iliac fossa from SI to iliopectineal

eminence• Hip flexion relaxes iliopsoas• Exposure can be increased by

osteotomy of ASIS to access medial eminence• PAO ( Bern CH)• Useful in avoiding second window

exposure

Page 16: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Courtesy of Claude Sagi MD

Page 17: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - II

• Second window• Access to pelvic brim and

quadrilateral surface from SI joint to the lateral third of the ramus• Flexion and external rotation of the

ipsilateral hip will maximize exposure• Complete release of the iliopectineal

fascia

Page 18: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - II

• Third window• Release the ipsilateral rectus

insertion• Will expose entire medial ramus to

the quadrilateral plate

Page 19: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - II

• Third window• Incise vertically along the linea

alba• Can be extended into the AIP

approach• Operate from the opposite side of

the table

Page 20: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

AIP

• First described for hernia repair by Rene Stoppa in 1975.• Revised for pelvic and acetabular surgery by Hirvensalo et al in 1993• “Modified Stoppa” was described in 1994 by Cole et al.• Access to the entire anterior column when supplemented with a

lateral window• Unlike ilioinguinal allows direct instrumentation of the quadrilateral plate• Limited access to anterior wall• Operate from the opposite side of the table ( limits utility for simultaneous

approaches)

Page 21: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

AIP

Page 22: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - AIP

• Complete release of the iliopectineal fascia is mandatory

Page 23: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - AIP

VS

Courtesy of Pierre Guy MD

Page 24: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - AIP

VS

Courtesy of Pierre Guy MD

Page 25: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - AIP

• Skeletonize and mobilize obturator neurovascular bundle• Operate around it rather

than retracting it

Page 26: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - AIP

• Specialized retractors can be useful but are not mandatory

Page 27: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Tips for Exposure - AIP

Addition of first window• Exposure of entire ilium• ASIS osteotomy can extend lateral

exposure to medial aspect of iliopectineal eminence• Pre drill osteotomy and repair with

lag screw to minimize nonunion

Page 28: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

What’s the evidence?

Page 29: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

What’s the evidence?

• Level 2 evidence (prospective comparative)• 60 consecutive patients randomized to either a AIP (modified Stoppa)

or ilioinguinal approach• Assessed multiple preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative

parameters

• AIP decreased intraoperative blood loss and operative time

Page 30: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

• Direct (AIP) vs indirect (II) exposure of the retropubic anastomosis

Page 31: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

What’s the evidence?

J Orthop Trauma. 2014 Jun;28(6):313-9

Page 32: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

What’s the evidence?

• Level 3 evidence (retrospective review)• 122 patients (1993-2006)• Assessed fracture type, fracture reduction quality, surgical time, and

postoperative complications

• AIP 82.5% anatomic• II 68.9% anatomic• Fracture type, surgical time, and complications similar in both groups

Page 33: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

VS

Direct (AIP) vs indirect (II) access to the posterior column segment

Page 34: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first
Page 35: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Post Op

Page 36: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

2 years

Page 37: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Summary

• 30% of acetabular fractures will need an anterior approach• Anterior wall• Anterior column• High (transtectal) transverse• T-Type*• Anterior column posterior hemitransverse*• Associated both column*

• *may require sequential/simultaneous approaches

Page 38: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Summary

• Simultaneous approach ( “floppy lateral” position ) only possible with ilioinguinal approach (KL + II)

• Sequential approach ( KL + II or AIP) requires meticulous attention to screw placement and intraoperative repositioning

Page 39: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Summary

• AIP approach • Direct visual access to quadrilateral plate and posterior column• Indirect access to anterior wall

• Ilioinguinal approach• Direct visual access to anterior wall• Indirect access to quadrilateral plate and posterior column

Page 40: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Summary

• The use of the AIP has gained significant popularity since its development

• Addition of the lateral window +/- ASIS osteotomy increases utility

• Access to the anterior wall is still limited

Page 41: Ilioinguinal vs AIP Approach · • Operate around it rather than retracting it. Tips for Exposure -AIP ... useful but are not mandatory. Tips for Exposure -AIP Addition of first

Summary

• THE PATIENT AND THE FRACTURE PATTERN ARE THE DECIDING FACTORS IN THE APPROACH

• THE SURGEON SHOULD BE FAMILIAR AND FACILE WITH BOTH!!!