Ijccr-2012-Vol-16-Special-Issue-complete3 - IJCCR 2012 Vol 16 Special Issue Complete

8/13/2019 Ijccr-2012-Vol-16-Special-Issue-complete3 - IJCCR 2012 Vol 16 Special Issue Complete

1/177


2/177


3/177

International Journal of

Community Currency ResearchVolume 16 (2012) Section D 1-4

SPECIAL ISSUE EDITORIAL

THIRTY YEARS OF COMMUNITY AND

COMPLEMENTARY CURRENCIES: A REVIEW OF

IMPACTS, POTENTIAL AND CHALLENGESJrme Blanc*

Universit Lumire Lyon 2, France; UMR Triangle

!"#$ $&'(#)* #$$+' #$ (,-&,$'. ,/ $'0'12''1 &)&'3$ ,/ 4"#(" 5#3$2 0'3$#,1$ 4'3' &3'$'12'. )2

2"' 67,1 8898,1/'3'1(' 2")2 4)$ "'*. ,1 :;9:#*#27 2")2 (,12#1+'$ 2, *')0' 2"' 5#'*. ,1 2"' &'3#&"'37 ,/ 3'$')3("A

!"' )#- ,/ 2"' #12'31)2#,1)*I -+*2#.#$(#&*#1)37 )1. 23#*#1J+)* (,1/'3'1(' ,3J)1#Q'. #1 67,1 ,1

:;9:2)#1 ) $#J1#5#()12 3,*' 4#2" 3'J)3. 2, 0)3#,+$ .#$(#&*#1'$ 2")2 )3' (,1('31'.

4#2" 2"#$ 27&' ,/ 23).#1J $("'-'$I $+(" )$ '(,1,-#($I J',J3)&"7I $,(#,*,J7I &,*#2#()* $(#'1('I

)12"3,&,*,J7I "#$2,37I *)4I '2(A

S1' &+3'*7 )().'-#( &3,>*'- ('32)#1*7 )3#$'$ /3,- 2"' /)(2 2")2 2"'7 3'*)2' 2, 5#'*.$ ,/ 3'$')3("

)2 2"' (3,$$3,).$ ,/ ) 1+->'3 ,/ .#$(#&*#1'$T .'0'*,&-'12 $2+.#'$I *,()* .'0'*,&-'12I -)3N'2

'L(")1J'I !"#3. $'(2,3 ,3 $,(#)* '(,1,-7I $+$2)#1)>*' .'0'*,&-'12I -,1'2)37 +$'$I -,1'2)37

$&)('$I $,0'3'#J127I 1'4 $&)('$ ,/ 23)1$)(2#,1 )1. $,(#)>#*#27I $,(#)* -,0'-'12$ (*)#-#1J /,3

'(,1,-#( 23)1$/,3-)2#,1$I $,(#)* (,"'$#,1I (,--+1#27 .71)-#($I 4,-'1R$ '(,1,-#( #1#2#)2#0'$

! #$%&'( )*+,$*-.'%/012/&34'5,/6-7+

!" $%&' &(%) *+&%$,'-8'%/09 :- ;6 ?@A&+B5 5*%+C ,7 0,$$2/&B5 %/D 0,$E'*$*/B%+5 02++*/0&*C( F +*3&*G ,7

&$E%0BC9 E,B*/B&%' %/D 0A%''*/H*CI JE*0&%' KCC2* #D&B,+&%' !"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'#0 .,%%$"10 2$3

4$&%15=L ;M> =4N OGGG-&)00+-/*BP KJJQ =R6S4TSNU

= @A* 0,/7*+*/0* G%C ,+H%/&V*D .5 BA* +*C*%+0A 0*/B+*C @+&%/H'* ;WXY S6 %/D Z#[K ;#F N9 C2E4

E,+B*D .5 BA* W/&3*+C&B5 Z2$&\+* Z5,/ 69 &BC ]A%&+ ,7 */B+*E+*/*2+CA&E &/ J,0&%' %/D C,'&D%+&B5 *0,/,$59 BA*

K/CB&B2B D*C C0&*/0*C D* 'IA,$$* ;KJ^> %/D BA* #QJ Z5,/9 G*+* &B G%C A*'D- [&/%/0&%' C2EE,+BC &/0'2D*( _*4

.'*/ K/CB&B2B* 7,+ #0,/,$&0 Y*7,+$C %/D [`^ ;[,/D%B&,/ ]A%+'*C Za,E,'D X%5*+ E,2+ '* `+,H+\C D*

'IA,$$*>9 K/CB&B2B ]%&CC* D*C DaEbBC *B 0,/C&H/%B&,/C E,2+ '% +*0A*+0A*9 ]'2CB*+ =6 c M5/%$&d2*C C,0&%'*C *B

B*++&B,+&%'*C e ,7 BA* YAb/*4F'E*C Y*H&,/9 YAb/*4F'E*C Y*H&,/ &BC*'79 M&+*0B&,/ Ha/a+%'* f '% '%/H2* 7+%/g%&C*

*B %2h '%/H2*C D* [+%/0* ,7 BA* X&/&CB+5 ,7 ]2'B2+* %/D ],$$2/&0%B&,/9 ],4,E*+%B&3* Y#J %/D ],/C*&' Ha/a4

+%' D2 YAb/*-
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]


4/177

!"#$ &'!(!)*(!+ "'! ,-*. #*.)!(!.#! '/0 "* 1! 234"5056#57

845./(-9 8/8!(6 )(*2 05))!(!." 056#5845.!6 :!(! :!4#*2!+ /6

:!44 /6 8/8!(6 "'/" :!(! 5."!(056#5845./(- 5. "'!5( ;!(-

6#*8!$

&'! ":*70/-6 /#/0!25# #*.)!(!.#! 5.#430!0 $ &'! ?5(6" 8/.!4 @3!6"5*.!0 "'!

5."!44!#"3/4 5.)(/6"(3#"3(! )*( AA (!6!/(#' /.0 6'*:!0 1*"'5"6 8(!6!." :!/B.!66!6 /.0 5"6 8(*C(!665;! !2!(C!.#!$ &'!

6!#*.0 8/.!4 )*#36!0 *. "'! 45.B6 "* 83145# 8*45#5!6 /.0

6'*:!0 "'! 05)?5#34"5!6 "* 2/B! AA6 / "**4 )*( 83145# 8*457

#5!6 :5"'*3" 4*65.C "'! /3"*.*2- /.0 5..*;/"5*. #/8/#5"-

/""!6"!0 1- "'!5( '56"*(-$ &'! "'5(0 0/- :/6 0!05#/"!0 "*

8(/#"5"5*.!(6$ &'56 "'(!! 0/-6 !;!." C/"'!(!0 >DE 8!(6*.6

)(*2 2*(! "'/. >F #*3."(5!6$ &'5("- -!/(6 /)"!( "'! 1!C5.7

.5.C *) "'! 8(!6!." :/;! *) AA6 5. "'! :*(40+ 8(*C(!66 56

6"544 (!@35(!0 "* B.*: /.0 3.0!(6"/.0 "'! 05;!(65"- *) !G7

56"5.C 6#'!2!6 /.0 "'!5( 6#*8!+ "'*3C' 23#' '/6 /4(!/0-

1!!. 0*.! /.0 "'! (!6!/(#' 0-./25#6 *. AA6 *1;5*364-

/##!4!(/"!$

&'! 6!;!."!!. 8/8!(6 *) "'56 68!#5/4 5663! /(! .*" (!8(!7

6!."/"5;! *) "'! !G"!." *) :'/" :/6 056#366!0 5. ,-*. 65.#!+

)*( !G/284!+ 6!;!(/4 /(!/6 /(! 25665.C *( /(! 3.0!(7

(!8(!6!."!0 H,/"5. I2!(5#/+ )(/.#*8'*.! #*3."(5!6J=$

K*:!;!(+ "'!- /4(!/0- #*;!( / :50! (/.C! *) #/6!6 /.0

"*85#6 /.0 "'!- (!4- *. ;/(5*36 (!6!/(#' /.0 /./4-"5#/4

2!"'*06$ &'! 68!#5/4 5663! 56 6"(3#"3(!0 /(*3.0 )*3( 6!#7

"5*.6$

! #$%&'($)*+ *))',-&% $- . ,/%/

K56"*(5#/4 6"305!6 #!("/5.4- 8(*;50! / 2/L*( B!- "* / 1!""!(

3.0!(6"/.05.C *) "'! 8*6651545"5!6+ )/543(!6 /.0 63##!66!6 *)

:'/" 56 '/88!.5.C "*0/-$ I44 /4*.C 5"6 '56"*(-+ "'! M$N$ '/6

1!!. / '*"68*" *) 2*.!"/(- !G8!(5!.#!6$ &'! "'(!! 8/8!(6

*) "'56 6!#"5*. #*.650!( 0!1/"!6 "'/" 0!;!4*8!0 *. 2*.!-

/.0 0!2*#(/#- )(*2 "'! !.0 *) "'! !5C'"!!."' #!."3(- /.0

6#(586 !G8!(52!."6 *) "'! O(!/" P!8(!665*.$

%012 304567489:#*."(/6"6 "'! #3((!." 2/L*( /685(/"5*. *)

83""5.C 0!2*#(/#- 5."* 2*.!- 1- AA /0;*#/"!6 :5"' ":*

2*2!."6 *) "'! MN 2*.!"/(- '56"*(- :'!(!5. 2*.!- /.0

0!2*#(/#- :!(! 45.B!0Q "'! R!0!(/456" 5284!2!."/"5*. *) /

2*.!"/(- 6-6"!2 "'/" :*340 1! #*28/"514! :5"' #/85"/4562

/.0 5.!@3/45"5!6+ /.0 "'! O(!!.1/#B!(6 :'* /0;*#/"!0 /0!2*#(/"5# #*."(*4 *;!( 2*.!"/(- 5663! "'(*3C' C*;!(.7

2!." 8/8!( 2*.!- #(!/"5*.$ K! 6'*:6 "'/" "'! .*"5*. *) /

0!2*#(/#- 56 0!!84- 05))!(!." 5. "'!6! "'(!! #/6!6Q AA6

(/"'!( /(C3! )*( S/ "-8! *) 0!2*#(/"5# 2*.!- "'/" .*

4*.C!( 6!!26 #*28/"514! :5"' #/85"/4562T$

I6 6"(!66!0 1- ,*(!. O/"#' /.0 N/(/' U4;5.6+ "'! -!/(6

/(*3.0 VW=>7== :!(! -!/(6 *) / 1**2 5. 6#(586 *) 2/.-

B5.06 5. "'! M$N$Q 1(*/04- 68!/B5.C+ #4!/(5.C'*36! #!("5?57

#/"!6+ 6#(586 *) 1/("!( /.0 6!4)7'!48 C(*386+ 6"/28 6#(586

/.0 "/G71/6!0 6#(586 )(*2 4*#/4 C*;!(.2!."6+ !"#$+ 4!/05.C

"* '3.0(!06 *) #/6!6 /44 *;!( "'! M.5"!0 N"/"!6$

%0709 .2;45


5/177

!"#$%#! %' ()# !*$%*+#$*'*,%$ #-*./(%*'01 .#23%'4 5%!)%6# (*

.%'7 )%! 2'2.8!%! (* #-*./(%*'298 #$*'*,%$!:

!"#"$% '%()%* +,- .+/"0" !%1)%23 $*'(92!( 3%;;#9#'(

!*9(! *; ,*'#8 $9#2(%*'< ;9*, $*'$#'(92(#3 =62'7'*(#! 2'3

"2"#9 ,*'#8 (8"# *; >>? (* 3%!"#9!%-# =@ABC (8"#?1 ()9*/4)

D/2!%+3%!"#9!%-# =3#"*!%( ,*'#8 $9#2(%*'?: B)#8 2'2.8E#

()# 9#.2(%-# #;F%$%#'$8 *; ()# (G* *""*!%(# $2!#!: @ABC 2"+"#29 (* 6# ,*9# #;F%$%#'( %' (#9,! *; (92'!2$(%*' 9#2.%E2(%*'

()2' 2 $*'$#'(92(#3 2'3 "9#+%!!/#3 $/99#'$81 6#$2/!# ()#

.2((#9 9#D/%9#! 2 ,*'#8 !(*$7 %' 23-2'$#: H*G#-#91 ()#

2/()*9! #,")2!%E# ()# 9%!7 *; ;9## 9%3%'4 ()9*/4) @ABC

3%!"#9!%-# ,*'#8 $9#2(%*' 2'3 2!!#!! ()# 3#6%( .%,%( (* 6#

%,".#,#'(#3 (* 2-*%3 %(:

456" 7"-1()+8/ #I(#'!%-#.8 "9#!#'(! ()# -29%#(8 *; 3#+

,/9924# ,#2'%'4!1 2""9*2$)#! 2'3 %,".#,#'(2(%*'!: H#

3%!(%'4/%!)#! ()9## !*9(! *; "9*"*!2.!< (26.# ,*'#81 !(2,"

!$9%"! 2'3 #I"%98 ,*'#8 2'3 4*#! %'(* "9*"*!2.! *; J#!#..1

K%!)#9 2'3 !*,# *()#9!: L)%.# J#!#..M! '2(%*'G%3# 2'3

"#9,2'#'( !8!(#, G2! '#-#9 %,".#,#'(#31 .*$2. #I"#9%+,#'(! )2-# (27#' ".2$#1 2.9#2381 3/9%'4 ()# NOPQ! 2'3

!%'$# ()# NOOQ!: H# !(2(#! ()2( ()# .#-#. *; 3#,/9924# )23 2

'#4.%4%6.# 9*.# %' ()# "*!!%6.# =6/( ;29 ;9*, 6#%'4 4#'#92.?

!/$$#!! *; .*$2. #I"#9%,#'(! 2'3 !)*G! ()2(1 $*'(9298 (*

()# 4#'#92. /'3#9!(2'3%'41 RC (92'!2$(%*'+62!#3 !$9%"!

2$)%#-#3 2 ,/$) )%4)#9 $%9$/.2(%*' -#.*$%(8 ()2' ()# RC

3*..29:

S' 2 !#.;+$9%(%$%!, *' ()# #29.%#9 !(24#! *; 2 9#!#29$) "9*T#$(

*' #I$)2'4# '#(G*97! 2'3 "292..#. $/99#'$%#! %' J9##$#1

9:3,3 ;"0%:"?@A>.9!7; B!C BA49DED.D!@;

V ;2%9 "29( *; ()# 2$23#,%$ .%(#92(/9# *' >>! %! 3#3%$2(#3 (*2!!#!!,#'(! *; -29%*/! !*9(! *; 3%;F%$/.(%#! ()#8 ;2$# 2'3

()#%9 "*!!%6.# !/$$#!!#!: W#8 ;2$(*9! %'$./3# ()# 9#.2(%*'

6#(G##' ()#%9 *6T#$(%-#! 2'3 ()#%9 *942'%E2(%*'1 ()# G28

()#8 29# 4*-#9'#31 ()#%9 !%E# 2'3 ()# 3%-#9!%(8 *; /!#9!1 ()#

G28 ()#8 62.2'$# ()# $*,,%(,#'( ()#8 9#D/%9# *; ()#%9

/!#9! 2'3 #;F%$2$8 9#D/%9#,#'(!1 ()# G28 ()#8 6/%.3

"9*3/$(%*'X$*'!/,"(%*' $)2%'!1 #($: V!"#$(! *; ()#!# ;2$+

(*9! 29# 3#2.( G%() %' ()%! !#$(%*':

73":6%,+ .F 7G$3# #,")2!%E#! ()# 9*.# *; >> 4*-#9'2'$#

%' ()#%9 !/!(2%'26%.%(8 ()9*/4) 2 $*,"292(%-# 2'2.8!%! *; ()#

4*-#9'2'$# ,*3# *; ()# ()9## ,2%' (9/#D/# '#(G*97! %'

V94#'(%'21 G)%$) "9*-#3 (* 9#!"*'3 3%;;#9#'(.8 (* ()# 4#'+

#92. 3*G';2.. *; >>! 2;(#9 YQQY: C)# 6/%.3! 2 (2I*'*,8 *;

V94#'(%'%2' >> '*3#! 2;(#9 ()# !".%( *; ()# ,*-#,#'( 2'3

!)*G! ()2( '*'# ,2'24#3 (* 6# !/!(2%'26.# #'*/4): C)#

$*'$./3#! *' G)2( !##,! (* 6# ()# 6#!(+!/%(#3 4*-#9'2'$#

$*'$#9'%'4 ()# !$2.# 2'3 !%E# *; !$)#,#!1 !/44#!(%'4< U*' 2

'2(%*'2.1 .294# !$2.#1 ()#9# !##,! (* 6# '* !/!(2%'26.# 4*-+

#9'2'$# !8!(#, ;*9 2 >>C0:

V!!#!!%'4 ()# Z2-29%2' >)%#,42/#9M! !/$$#!!1 A):%10%+,

@)%38 9#;#9! (* ()# ()#*9#(%$2. ;92,#G*97 *; ()# $*,,*'!G)#' 3#F%'%'4 ()# 4#'#92. *6T#$(%-#! "/9!/#3 68 [#4%*4#.3:

\*%'(%'4 */( ()# 9%!7 *; ;9## 9%3%'4 %' ()%! $*'(#I(1 )# !(2(#!)%#,42/#9+/!# G%() 2 92(%*'2.1

*""*9(/'%(8+*"(%,%E%'4 2((%(/3#0: \#*".# /!# %( 6#$2/!# %( %!

2 ,*92. ,*'#8< UV ],*92. ,*'#8M *;;#9! ()#, "*!!%6%.%(%#!

G)%$) ()#8 3*'M( )2-# G%() ]'*9,2. ,*'#8M0< ()# $/99#'$8

U2!!%!(! !)*""%'4 =^? 68 2((9%6/(%'4 2 ,*92. D/2.%(8 (*

"9*3/$(! 2'3 !)*"!01 2'3 ()#8 "9*-%3# 2 ,#2'! (* #I#9( 2

"*G#9 *-#9 #2$) *'#M! "#9!*'2. #I"#'!#! 6/( 2.!* *-#9

*()#9!M:

':%103: E"8/$+,, 2'2.8E#! ()# 3%!(%'$(%-# ;#2(/9#! *;

J#9,2'+!"#27%'4 29#2 [#4%*4#.3 #I"#9%#'$#!1 3%!(%'4/%!)+%'4 ()9## !*9(! *; >>!< #/9*+62!#3 $/99#'$%#! .%7# ()#

>)%#,42/#9_ 2$(%-%(8+62!#3 $/99#'$%#! .%7# ()# R9!(9*,+

(2.#9_ 2'3 ,%I#3 $/99#'$%#! 29(%$/.2(%'4 #/9*+62!#3 2'3

@ABC+.%7# !8!(#,! .%7# ()# C(#9'(2.#9: H# .%'7! ()# 62!%$

*6T#$(%-#! *; >>! (* 2 U!*.%329%(8 #$*'*,80< U2.. #$*'*,%$

;*9,! ()2( %'$./3# 2!"#$(! *; !*.%329%(8 2'3 ;2%9'#!! %' *"+

"*!%(%*' (* "/9# "9*F%(+,2I%,%E%'40: [#4%*'2. $/99#'$%#!

()#' 2..*G U()# %'3%-%3/2. (* $)**!# ()# 3#49## (* G)%$) )#

*9 !)# G2'(! (* "29(%$%"2(# %' ()# !*.%329%(8 9#2.,0:

."88H ;("00 A+0" +,- .+:0+ ;5I:3# "9#!#'( 2' 2$$*/'(

U;9*, ()# %'!%3#0 *; ()# $9#2(%*' 2'3 #29.8 !(24#! *; ()#C(9*/3 \*/'31 %' ()# RW: B)#8 92%!# *'# ,2T*9 D/#!(%*' *'

()# 9#.#-2'$# *; >>!: @%7# *()#9!1 ()# C(9*/3 \*/'3 2%,#3

2( "9*,"(%'4 $*'!/,"(%*' *; .*$2..8 "9*3/$#3 4**3! 2'3

!#9-%$#!: H*G#-#91 29# ()#8 ()# 6#!( F%9!( !(#"1 G*/.3 %( '*(

6# ,*9# #;F%$%#'( 2'3 3%9#$( (* #'$*/924# .*$2. "9*3/$(%*'`

S'(#9#!(%'4.81 ()# 2/()*9! !(2(# ()2(1 %' ()# $2!# *; C(9*/31

U()# #I(9#,#.8 .%,%(#3 92'4# *; .*$2. "9*3/$# ()2( %! 2-2%.+

26.#1 2'3 ()# !,2.. "#9$#'(24#! *; .*$2..8 "9*3/$#3 4**3!

()2( G#9# ;*9 !2.# %' ()# .*$2. !)*"!1 923%$2..8 /'3#9$/( ()#

3#!%4' *; ()# !$)#,# 68 ,27%'4 .*$2. !/"".8 $)2%'! '#29

%,"*!!%6.# ;*9 ()# .294#!( -*./,# *; #$*'*,%$ 2$(%-%(8 %'

()# (*G':0

B)# "2"#9 *; J30: K38L,3/M N15#1+,,+ D1#03: ;#+8+H +,-

B8"%1 '",3O,P "9*-%3#! ()# 9#23#9 G%() 2 "%$(/9# *;

a%!#4923 $*/'(9%#! G)#9# >>! )2-# '*( #I"#9%#'$#3 2 49#2(

!/$$#!! (* 32(#: >*,,/'%(8 $/99#'$%#! )2-# 3#-#.*"#3 %'

\*.2'31 >E#$) [#"/6.%$1 C.*-27%2 2'3 H/'4298 6/( '#-#9

9#2$)#3 2 G%3# .#-#. 2'3 ,*!(.8 3%!2""#29#31 G%() ()# #I+

$#"(%*' *; H/'4298: C#-#92. #I".2'2(%*'! )#." /'3#9!(2'3

()%!_ 2,*'4 ()#,1 *'# $2' !(9#!! ()# $2!# *; !#.;+%'(#9#!(

$#'(9#3 2$(%-%!(!1 ()# )*,*4#'#%(8 *; ,#,6#9!1 ()# #I)2/!+

(%*' *; .#23#9!1 .%((.# #$*'*,%$ '##3 2'3 %'!%4'%F%$2'( %,+

"2$(1 #($:

4%:"$% !+/+#+0" +,- @+/31)% 4%:+$"0" ;*$/! *' ()#

G28 >>! ,28 4#'#92(# !*$%2. !/""*9( 2,*'4 2 $*,,/'%(81

()9*/4) 2 $*,"292(%-# '#(G*97 2'2.8!%! *; 2 @ABC+(8"# >>

International Journal Of Community Currency Research 2012 Volume 16 (D) 1-4 Blanc

3


6/177

!" $%&'&" ()*+$, -"' -" &./0/"&12314& 55 !" 6-4-" (7.8!2

9:;-/7" ?/38 7.8!29:;-/?-;3&;I

A1A3&0A -;& A/ '&&4B1 ./""&.3&' %!38 38& "-3!/"-B &./"2

/01K 38&1 .-""/3 ?& ./"A!'&;&' %-1A 3/ '&G!-3& C;/0 !3@ 3/

LB&& 3-S&A /; 0-;+"I',#%" -44;/4;!-3&B1 '!CC&;&"3!-3&'

.:;;&".!&A .-4-?B& /C '&"/3!"F '!CC&;&"3 314&A /C G-B:&I= +/'/ A/@ 38&1 &B-?/;-3& -" -"-B/F1 %!38 38& 3;/48!. 41;-0!'

/C &./B/F1= +8& 38&/;&3!.-B C;-0&%/;< 4;&A&"3&' !" 38&

4-4&; !A -3 38& ;//3 /C - 4;/U&.3 38-3 -!0A -3 4;/0/3!"F 3!0&

?-"

N!"-BB1@ 38& G-;!&31 /C 38&A& A&B&.3&' 4-4&;A C;/0 38& Y1/"

55 5/"C&;&".& 0-1 A&;G& -A - C-!; 4!.3:;& /C 38& 4;&A&"3

A3-3& /C 55 ;&A&-;.8= J8&;&-A 4;/4/A-BA -"' &S4&;!0&"3A

8-G& 4;/G&" 3/ ?& -:'-.!/:A@ &04!;!.-B ;&A&-;.8 A8/%A 38&

0-U/; B!0!3A -"' A8/;3./0!"FA 38-3 38!A 0/G&0&"3 &S4&;!2

&".&= J8&;&-A 38&A& ;&A&-;.8&A -;& 0/;& &04!;!.-B 38-"38&/;&3!.-B@ 38&/;&3!R-3!/" &0&;F& 38-3 ;&D:!;& -'';&AA!"F

38& 4;!0-;1 D:&A3!/" /C 38& 4/AA!?B& !;;&':.!?B& A4&.!L!.!2

3!&A /C 55 4;-.3!.&A@ 4:;4/A&A -"' &G&"3:-BB1 ./".&43:-B!R-2

3!/"= +8!;31 1&-;A -C3&; 38&!; L!;A3 &0&;F&".&@ 55A A3!BB 8-G&

3/ 4;/G& 38&1 .-" .8-"F& 38& 4;&A&"3 A3-3& /C 38!"FA@ %8!B&

;&A&-;.8 -F&"'-A -;& !".;&-A!"FB1 ./"A!'&;!"F 38&0=

International Journal Of Community Currency Research 2012 Volume 16 (D) 1-4 Blanc

4


7/177


8/177

!"#$%&'(#!%"

!"#$ &'&() (*'+#,($ -"( "#$-.)/ .0 -"( &.1#-#2'1 #3(' .0

43(+.2)'-#2 +.,(/56 7#-"#, -"( "#$-.)#2'11/ $&(2#8#2 9:;:

2'-'1#$- 3(+.2)'2/ ??@A B>CD> : E- (*&1.)($ -"(

&.1#-#2'1 2.,F()$'-#., -"'- .22G))(3 3G)#,H $(F()'1 &"'$($

#, I+()#2', "#$-.)/ -"'- 7()( 0.2G$(3 ., )($.1F#,H ' 2(,J

-)'1 -(,$#., #, I+()#2'5$ &.1#-#2'1 (2.,.+/ K ', (*&',3#,H

(2.,.+/ 3(&(,3(,- ., '3(LG'-( ',3 )(1#'M1( $G&&1#($ .0

1#LG#3#-/ ',3 -"( 3.+#,',2( .0 ' $2')2( 2.,2(&- .0 +.,(/:

!"#$ &'&() #$ ', '--(+&- -. "#H"1#H"- -"( 7'/ #, 7"#2"

+.,(/ 2)('-#.,6 ',3 21'#+$ -. M( 3(+.2)'-#N#,H #-$ 2)('J

-#.,6 ')( 3(&(,3(,- G&., -"( "#$-.)#2'11/ ',3 H(.H)'&"#J

2'11/ $&(2#8#2 2.,-(*- #, 7"#2" $G2" 21'#+$ ')( +'3(: !"(

)(1(F',2/ .0 -"#$ )($(')2" #$ -. 2"'11(,H( 2.,-(+&.)')/

21'#+$ -. M( 3(+.2)'-#N#,H +.,(/ -. 0G11/ ')-#2G1'-( -"(#)

2.,2(&- .0 3(+.2)'2/6 7"#1( )(2.H,#N#,H -"'- -"( F()/ #3('

.0 7"'- O#$P 3(+.2)'2/ "'$ $"#0-(3 .F() -#+(: !"( &'&()

+'Q($ ,. 21'#+ -. Q,.7 7"'- #$ 3(+.2)'-#2 +.,(/6 ,.)

7"'- #$ -"( +.$- 3(+.2)'-#2 0.)+ .0 +.,(/6 MG- )'-"() -.

$".7 -"'- -"( 21'#+ -. M( 3(+.2)'-#2 #$ 3(&(,3(,- ., -"(

$&(2#8#2 2.,2(&-G'1#N'-#., .0 3(+.2)'2/ (+&1./(3 M/ -".$(

-"'- 21'#+ .) '3F.2'-( ' &')-#2G1') -/&( .0 +.,(/ 2)('-#.,:

R#)$-6 #- #$ ,(2($$')/ -. 3(8#,( $&(2#8#2'11/ 7"'- #$ +(',- M/

+.,(/: !"( &')-#2G1') F#(7 -'Q(, #$ -"'- +.,(/6 '$ #- #$

2G))(,-1/ G,3()$-..36 3(F(1.&(3 M(-7((, -"( $#*-((,-"

',3 (#H"-((,-" 2(,-G)#($ ???A SBD:

;(2.,36 -. (*&1.)( -"( &.1#-#2'1 #3(' .0 3(+.2)'-#2 +.,(/ #-

#$ ,(2($$')/ -. 21')#0/ -"( $&(2#8#2 2"')'2-() .0 3(+.2)'2/

7#-"#, 7"#2" -.3'/5$ 2'-'1#$- 2)(3#-J+.,(/ 2'+( -.

3.+#,'-(: !"#$ &).2($$ #$ +.$- ('$#1/ (*'+#,(3 7#-"#, -"(

2.,-(*- .0 -"( 9,#-(3 ;-'-($ .0 I+()#2': !"( -/&( .0 3(J

+.2)'2/ -"'- (+()H(3 0).+ -"( 2.,$-#-G-#.,'1 3(M'-($ .0

>WSW 7'$ .,( -"'- (*&1#2#-1/ $G&&.)-(3 &)#F'-( &).&()-/

',3 '22(&-(3 21'$$ #,(LG'1#-/ '$ ,'-G)'1: I,36 ',/ (00.)- M/

H.F(),+(,- -. 1(F(1 -"($( #,(LG'1#-#($ .) -")('-(, -"( (*#$J

-(,2( .0 &)#F'-( &).&()-/ 7'$ F#(7(3 '$ ' -")('- -. 1#M()-/:

XG)#,H -"( &()#.3 1('3#,H G& -. -"( 7)#-#,H .0 -"( 9:;: R(3J

()'1 Y.,$-#-G-#., -"()( 7()( ' ,G+M() .0 8#,',2#'1 &.1#2#($

(,'2-(3 M/ 2.1.,#'1 $-'-( 1(H#$1'-G)($ '#+(3 '- &).+.-#,H

-"( 41(F(1#,H $)#-5B -"'- '3F.2'-($ .0 .)#H#,'1 3(+.2)'2/

0'F.)(3 C:

!"( R(3()'1#$-$ 0)'+(3 -"($( &.1#2#($ '$ ' -")('- -. 1#M()-/6

-. -"( $-'M#1#-/ .0 21'$$ )(1'-#.,$ ',3 +.$- #+&.)-',-1/6 -.-"( 0)(( 81.7 .0 2.++()2( A T@C

ZR(3()'1#$- [.: S@\D: !"()(0.)(6 7"'-(F() $/$-(+ .0 +.,(/

2)('-#., (*#$-(36 #- ,((3(3 -. M(6 8#)$- ',3 0.)(+.$-6 -"(

1('$- MG)3(,$.+( -. -"($( 21'$$($ .0 $.2#(-/: !"( M(1#(0

7'$ -"'- ' H.13 +.,(-')/ M'$( 7.G13 M( -"( +.$- 2.+&'-#J

M1( 7#-" -"( R(3()'1#$- 2.,2(&- .0 ' 2'-'1#$- 3(+.2)'2/:

*+!,-& +##-./#0 +# ($-+#!"1 0#+2,- ($-&!#

0'//,!-0

^,( .0 -"( +.$- #+&.)-',- 2.,$(LG(,2($ .0 -"( R(3()'1Y.,$-#-G-#., 7'$ ' +.F( -.7')3$ ' ,(7 +.,(-')/ )(H#+(6

7"#2" (,3(3 -"( 'M#1#-/ .0 #,3#F#3G'1 $-'-($ -. &)#,- +.,(/

.) -. 3(21')( ' 1(H'1 -(,3(): !"#$ $"#0- #, +.,(/ 2)('-#.,

'G-".)#-/ 7'$ -"( M(H#,,#,H .0 ' "#$-.)#2'1 &).2($$ #, 7"#2"

-"( 2)('-#., .0 +.,(/ 7'$ #,2)('$#,H1/ 2(,-)'1#N(3 G,3()

-"( 'G-".)#-/ .0 -"( R(3()'1 _.F(),+(,-U -"#$ "(1&(3 HG')J

',-(( -"'- ' H.F(),+(,- 0)#(,31/ -. -"( ,((3$ .0 -"( 2'J

-'1#$- (2.,.+/ (,'2-(3 +.,(/ 2)('-#., &.1#2#($: !"( )($G1-

7'$ ' 8#,',2#'1 $/$-(+ -"'- )(#,0.)2(3 -"( (*#$-(,2( .0 &)#J

F'-( &).&()-/ ',3 -"( 0)(( 81.7 .0 2.++()2#'1 (*2"',H(6

7"#1( +#,30G1 .0 -"( ,((3 -. 1#+#- ',/ 3#$)G&-#,H #,81G(,2(

-"#$ +'/ "'F( ., (*#$-#,H 21'$$ )(1'-#.,$: !"( $G22($$ .0-"#$ $/$-(+ .0 +.,(/ 2)('-#., 7'$ 2)#-#2'1 -. -"( 2.,-#,G(3

(*#$-(,2( .0 I+()#2'5$ 2'-'1#$- 3(+.2)'2/:

International Journal Of Community Currency Research 2012 Volume 16 (D) 5-13 Wainwright

6

> `:a: =..3 G$($ -"( &")'$( ',3 -"( 2.,2(&- .0 ' b2'-'1#$- 3(+.2)'2/b #, "() M..Q6 bX(+.2)'2/ IH'#,$- Y'-'1#$+P ??@A B>CD: ]()

2(,-)'1 ')HG+(,- #$ -"'- -"( 2.,2(&- .0 3(+.2)'2/ -"'- 7( '$$G+( 7'$ ' "#$-.)#2'11/ $&(2#8#2 2)('-#., .0 -"( 9:;:I: 3G)#,H -"( 7)#-#,H .0 -"(

R(3()'1 Y.,$-#-G-#.,: !"( I+()#2', 2.,2(&- .0 3(+.2)'2/ $(&')'-(3 -"( &.1#-#2'1 ',3 (2.,.+#2 $&"()($ .0 1#0(: !"#$ 7'$ '2"#(F(3 -").GH"

-"( 2)('-#., .0 ' ,(7 2.,2(&- .0 3(+.2)'2/ -"'- 2.G13 '22.++.3'-( 2'-'1#$+ M/ )(+.F#,H LG($-#.,$ .0 &).&()-/ ',3 $.2#.J(2.,.+#2

(LG'1#-/ 0).+ -"( &.1#-#2'1 $&"()(: bE, -"'- $(,$(6 &.1#-#2'1 (LG'1#-/ #, 2'-'1#$- 3(+.2)'2/ ,.- .,1/ 2.(*#$-$ 7#-" $.2#.J(2.,.+#2 #,(LG'1#-/

MG- 1('F($ #- 0G,3'+(,-'11/ #,-'2-P ??@A B>CD:

B !"( G$( .0 -"( -()+ O1(F(1#,H $)#-P 7'$ G$(3-. #3(,-#0/ (00.)-$ '- )(3G2#,H 21'$$ #,(LG'1#-/


9/177

!" $%& '(()*'%")+, )-'*)." "/ "0) 1)*)2%+ 3/-)2.()." %.*

(/&" 4'"'5).& /6 "0) .)$+, 42)%")* 7898:8 "0%" "0) );22).4, ? @)

'" '. "0) 6/2( /6 (/.), /2 42)*'"8 A0'+) "0) )4/./(,B %& '"

=2/$&B 2)C>'2)& '.42)%&'.= &>"0)2& TUUVW 1'.%.4'%+ X%(E

4")* %.* "0%" '" 2%"0)2

@)+/.=)* "/ %. %>"/./(/>& %.* .%">2%+ && 6/2 % +*

./" '&&>) (/.), J%& "0), 0%* @)). */'.= " 6/2 %**'"'/.%+ +'C>'*'", J'. "0) 6/2( /6 % 2)+'%@+)

()*'>( /6 );40%.=)PB "0) /.+, %-%'+%@+) &/+>"'/. $%& "/

'.42)%&) "0) &>E

'.= 40%2")2& =2)$ &")%*'+,8 12/( ]>&" "02)) '. T[ULB G"0)'2

.>(@)2& 2/&) "/ KO '. TOLLB TLK '. TOTLB ^K[ @, TOKL %.*

ZOM @, TO^ZBI J9,++% TUUON OZP %.* @, TOML "0)2) $)2)

/-)2 )'=0" 0>.*2)* @%.F& '&&>'.= "0)'2 /$. 6/2(& /6 @%.FE

./")& J_/>&&)%> KLLMN K^P8 `>2'.= "0) D'2&" 0%+6 /6 "0)

)'=0"))."0 4).">2, @%.F& $)2)B G'. "0) ('.*& /6 "0) %-)2E

%=) 4'"'5).& %.,$0)2)I 40%2=)* $'"0 /-)24/('.=B G"0)

&4%24'", /6 (/.),I @, (%F'.= %-%'+%@+) "0) 42)*'" .))*)* "/

).%@+) "0) 62)) D+/$ /6 4/(()24'%+ );40%.=) J7.=)2 TUVMN

MLP8 H0) *'&"'.4"'/. @)'.= "0%" "0)&) @%.F& $)2) 42)%"'.=

42)*'" %.* ./" 42)%"'.= G*)&"%@'+'5'.=I %.4) /6 42)*'"B 0/%2*'.= /6 =/+* %.* '.%@'+'", "/

'.42)%&) "0) &>+">2%+ &/>"08

H0) 4/."'.>/>& '.&"%@'+'", /6 "0'& &,&")( /6 &"%") @%.F '&E

&>)* 42)*'"B %.* "0) .)=%"'-) 2%('D'4%"'/.& "0'& 0%* 6/2 "0)

/-)2%++ )* '"& /$. 42)*'"B $/>+* +* @) %44)) @, %++ @%.F& J>.+'F) &"%") @%.F '&&>)* 42)*'"PB

@)4%>&) "0), $/>+* "2>&" "0) %@'+'", J"0) +'C>'*'",P /6 "0)

.%"'/.%+ @%.F "/ );40%.=) "0) 42)*'" 6/2 =/+* (/.),8 H0'&

$/>+* 42)%") &"%@'+'", %.* 2)*>4) "0) .)=%"'-) '(2 @%.F./") ,/> $/>+* @) ='-). %. %(/>." /6 =/+* (/.), '. 2)">2.8

Z 1/2 %. '.E*)


10/177

!"#$%#& () %*# !+,+-.$, /%$%#/ +0 %*# 12234/56 7,, #00+"%/

8#"# 0+!9/#& +- !"#$%.-: !"#&.%; 8*.,# :+,& 8+9,& !+-%.-9#

%+ 0+"< %*# /!$"!#

$-& =-$%9"$,> 0+"< +0


11/177

!"#$% '( #") '#)*'#('+,--% .*".$*)%/ 01) , !$*$ )"2$# "*

('3#/ $#4"5$4 5')6 ."5$* )" +,#+$- 4$0)(7 89-,'*/ :;?

@'36-'36)$4 '# )6'( A*,!'#3 '( )6,) 3"B$*#!$#) '( )" 6,B$ #"

*"-$ '# )6$ !"#$% +*$,)'"# .*"+$((/ ,#4 )6,) )6$ 0$() ("-1C

)'"# *$('4$( 5')6 0,#2( ,#4 )6$ +"#)'#1$4/ #,)1*,-'D$4 *"-$

"A 3"-4 ,#4 (+,*+$ !"#$% !"*$ 3$#$*,--%?

!"#$%&'( $*+',$'% -+../- 01 20'#3

E6$ .,((,3$ "A )6$ F.$+'$ G$(1!.)'"# H+) "# I,#1,*% :J/

:;


12/177

!"# %#'()*+, -# ./&,/0'1 -), 2'# )03#4 )! #5.)'40'1

!"# *233#&*0)6 #*2'237 (7 #5.)'40'1 !"# 826/3# 29

32'#7: '2! (7 0'*),0'1 !"# 826/3# 29 *(! ;)'4 !"#

),,2*0)!#4 !&)..0'1, 29 4#(! )'4 32'#7 ,*)&*0!7"0,

03.2&!)'! 40,!0'*!02' .6)*#, !"# ,.2',0(060!7 92& ,/9?0*0#'!

,/..60#, 29 */&'*7 2' !"# 128#&'3#'! )'4 '2! 2' !"#

()'+,= @3.2&!)'!67: 0! )!!#3.!#4 !2 ()+ 42-' )' 04#)

!")! *6)03#4 !"# *)!02' 29 32'#7 -), 2/!,04# 29 128#&'A3#'!B, *2'!&26= >"# %#'()*+, *#'!&)6 )&1/3#'! -), !")!:

C#*2'230* 8)6/# *2/64 )'4 ,"2/64 (# ,/(D#*! !2 *2',*02/,:

4#32*&)!0* *2'!&26E ;F)(( )'4 G)&&/!"#&, HIIJK HLMN"# O.#*0# P#,/3.!02' Q*! ,!0./6)!#4 !")! )66 .).#& 32'#7

-), !2 (# !/&'#4 92& 1264 !2 !"# >),/&7 (7 R)'/)&7 H:

HSMI= >"0, 4)!# *)3# )'4 -#'!: )'4 28#& !"# "/'4

306602' 4266)&, -2&!" 29 1#'()*+, ;), !"# .).#& 32'#7

*)3# !2 (# *)66#4< )0'#4 0' *0&*/6)!02' )'4 !)0'#4 0!,

,!)!/, ), 32'#7 0'!2 !"# !-#'!7A?0&,! *#'!/&7 ;T)80#, UVVUK

WIJ"0, 0, ) *&0!0*)667 03.2&!)'! 323#'! 0' Q3#&0*)'

"0,!2&7 (#*)/,# 0! ,/(!67 0'?6/#'*#4 )'4 1)8# ,/..2&! !2

,23# 29 !"# #3#&10'1 ;)'4 &)40*)6< !"#2&0#, 29 3)')1#4

.).#& 32'#7 ,7,!#3, (#0'1 #5.62 -0!"0' )*)4#30* *0&A

*6#, ;X)046#& HIIHK HIS"# %#'()*+, ")4 3)')1#4

!2 0'!&24/*# 04#), 0'!2 .260!0*)6 4#()!# !")! .20'!#4 !2 !"#

&26# 29 128#&'3#'! )'4 ,"2-#4 !"# .2!#'!0)6 92& )6!#&')A

!08# -)7, 29 *)!0'1 32'#7: !")! 0' 9)*! -2/64 (#: 4#,.0!#

"0,!2&0*)6 (#60#9,: *23.)!0(6# -0!" !"# #50,!0'1 *).0!)60,!

4#32*&)*7=

T#,.0!# !"# 9)*! !")! !"# %#'()*+ Y)&!7 '#8#& ,.#*0?0*)667

)&1/#4 92& !"# C4#32*&)!0Z)!02'E 29 32'#7: !"#7 404 )&1/#

92& 0!, .260!0*0Z)!02' -0!"0' !"# *2'!#5! 29 !"# *).0!)60,! 4#A

32*&)*7= >"#7 ,)- 0! ), ) .260!0*)6 *2'8#&,)!02': 4&08#' (7128#&'3#'! -"2 0, 82!#4 0'!2 .2-#& 2' !"# ),,/3.!02'

!")! !"#7 -066 .,#'! !"# 0'!#,!, 29 !"# .#2.6#= [2-A

#8#&: .6)*0'1 !"0, 0'!2 !"# (&2)4#& )&*" 29 "0,!2&7 0! 0, *6#)&

!")! !"2,# C.,#'!)!08#,E ) *62,#67 )601'#4 -0!" ) .)&A

!0*/6)& 80#- !")! )&1/#, 92& !"# ')!/&)6'#,, 29 32'#7 8)6/#

)'4 *6),, 0'#\/)60!7= X)!# !-#'!0#!" *#'!/&7 2&!"2425

#*2'230,!, *2'!0'/#4 !2 *60'1 !2 !"#0& C324#6 29 32'#7

,/..67E -"0*" -),: C)' #3.0&0*)6 1#'#&)60Z)!02' 29 ) ')!/A

&)667 *2',!&)0'#4 ,/..67 29 ) 3#!)660* 32'#!)&7 (),# .&2A

804#4 (7 ) *#'!&)6 )/!"2&0!7 ;!"# 30'!< !")! -), 2/!,04# !"#

3)&+#!E ;@'1")3 UVVWK UH"0,

0, 4&08#' (7 ) *2'*#.!/)60Z)!02' 29 4#32*&)*7 !")! 42#, '2!

)..#)& !2 (# *23.)!0(6# -0!" !"# _#4#&)60,! '2!02' 29 *).0A

!)60,! 4#32*&)*7=

`)'7 )482*)!#, 29 GG )&1/# 92& !"# 4#32*&)!0Z)!02' 29

32'#7 80) !"# *)!02' 29 )(/'4)'! ,/..60#, 29 32'#7=

`)'7 *6)03 !")! !"# ,*)&*0!7 29 32'#7 )'4 *(! 0, 4#6#!#A

&02/, !2 !"# #*2'237 )'4 !"# *)/,# 29 &0,0'1 0'#\/)60!7 )'4

#*2'230* 0',!)(060!7 ), -#66 ), #'80&2'3#'!)6 4#,!&/*!02'=

a"#!"#& !"#0& )')67,0, 29 !"# 03.)*!, 0, *2&*! 2& '2!:

-")! !"#7 ) 420'1 0, *")66#'10'1 !"# &26# )'4 #8)'*# 29

(2!" !"# _#4#&)6 %28#&'3#'! )'4 !"# ()'+, 0' !"# */&A

'*7 *)!02' .&2*#,,= >"#,# #992&!, .,#'! ) '#- )'4

/'0\/# ."),# 0' !"# "0,!2&7 29 !"# 32'#!)&7 4#()!#,=

>"#,# GG )482*)!#, 42 '2! )**#.! !"# '2!02' 29 4#32*&)*7

!")! Y,04#'! a06,2' *6)03#4 0' HIHN -"#' "# ,!)!#4 !")!

!"# *)!02' 29 !"# _#4#&)6 P#,#&8# O7,!#3 .,#'!#4 !"#

C4#32*&)!0Z)!02' 29 *(!E ;\!4= 0' a0*+-): HIHLK LH"# ()'+0'1 ,7,!#3 0,

2'# 29 !"# 32,! *#'!&)60Z#4 0',!0!/!02', 29 2/& #*2'237 )'4


10

HV c'/! a0*+,#66: )'4 2!"#& 32'#!)&7 !"#2&0,!, 29 !"# 6)!# HSSVB, )'4 HSIVB,: ")4 (#1/' !2 -2&+ ")&4 2' !"#2&0Z0'1 *(! )'4 #5.62&0'1

'2'A,.#*0# (),#4 32'#!)&7 ,7,!#3, ;X)046#& HIIHK HIS"#0& #992&!, -# 4&08#' 0' 1)! .)&! (7 !"#0& 4#,0 !2 *)!# ) ,7,!#3 !")! -),

32 ,!)(6# )'4 !")! -2/64 108# !"# *).0!)60,! #*2'237 ) 32 ?'1- 2#-1+# &! #"2 &'# .#"&+)/1H#2

-G-(I )"2 &! +#&3+" &! )" #+) !% .!(F#&1"0 (!"#G 1--3)+-

1- )/-! .!""#. &! &'# 12#) !% #"21"0 &'# F!/1&1.1H)&1!" !%

(!"#G .+#)&1!"NO> P" %).& &'# ./)1( 1- ()2# &')& 0!D#+"@

(#"& 2!#-"M& #D#" "##2 &! 701D#5 &'1- F!4#+ &! .1&1H#"-E

.1&1H#"- *3-& "##2 &! )--#+& &'#1+ !4" (!"#G .+#)&1!"

F!4#+> ?'!()- Q+#.!I )" )3&'!+ )"2 )2D!.) !% LLI -&)-

&')&I 74# ')D# .)//#2 %!+ &'# -#F)+)&1!" !% (!"#G )"2 -&)I

,3& -1".# &'# F#!F/# 2! "!& .!"&+!/ &'#1+ 0!D#+"(#"&I 4#

,#/1#D# &')& -#F)+)&1!" .)" !"/G ,# ).'1#D#2 )- &'# F#!F/#

)--#+& &'#1+ (!"#G F!4#+5 6Q+#.! ORRST NNN=> Q+#.! 0!#-

!" &! ./)1( &')& &'#I 7F!/1&1.1H)&1!" !% (!"#G ')- 1"'1,1

&'# 412#-F+#)2 )2!F&1!" !% ,#&+ )/+")&1D#-5 6Q+#.!

ORRST NNU=>

V)+& !% 4')& &'# LL )2D!.)- -## )- 3"1J3# ),!3& &'1- .3+@

+#"& (!(#"& 1" '1-&!+GI 1- &'# +1-# !% 1"%!+()&1!" )"2 "#&@4!+;1"0 .'"!/!01#-I 4'1.' !%%#+ ) +)"0# !% F!--1,/# )/@

+")&1D# 2#.#"&+)/1H#2 )FF+!).'#- &! .+#)&1"0 (!"#G> LL

)2D!.)- &')& +3" -#D#+)/ 4#,-1- )"2 ).&1D#/G 4!+; &!

F+!23.# &'# .'"!/!01.)/ -G-(- &')& #"),/# )"G!"# &!

.+#) ) .3++#".G ./)1( &')&I 701D#" '!4 (3.' 1"%!+()&1!"

.'"!/!0G ')- #D!/D#2 +#.#"&/GI &'# (#(,#+- !% ) .!(@

(3"1&G .)" ,# &'#1+ !4" )+,1+-5 6:+!.;I 7W#4 L3++#".G

B+!"&1#+-5=> ?'# .'"!/!0G 1- #--#"&1)//G %+)(#2 )- +#F/).@

1"0 &'# +!/# !% 0!D#+"(#"& !+ ,)";-E 2#.#"&+)/1H#2 7.3+@

+#".G 2#-10" 41// (#)" &'# !,-!/#-.#".#5 !% )"G -!+& !%

2#F#"2#".# 7!" )"G %!+( !% .#"&+)/ )3&'!+1&G5 6:+!.;I 7VOV

L3++#".G5=> ?'#-# )2D!.)- +#.!0"1H# &')& &'#G )+# .')/@

/#"01"0 &'# '1-&!+G !% .#"&+)/1H#2 .3++#".G .+#)&1!"I 79/@

(!-& )// .3++#".G 2#-10"- &! 2) 62!//)+- 1"./32#2= 2#F#"2

!" #1&'#+ ) -.)+.# .!((!21&G 6-3.' )- 0!/2 !+ F)F#+ "!-=

!+ ) .#"&+)/1H#2 )3&'!+1&G &! 1--3# )"2X!+ &+).; &'# .3+@

+#".G 6,)++ ./3,-I &1(#@,)";-I #&.=5 6:+!.;I 7VOV L3++#"@

.G5=NY> B!+ &'#-# )2D!.)-I 7?'# "#4 %+!"&1#+ 1- ),!3&

!F#" .3++#".1#- 4'1.' 2! "!& #A1-& ,G ()"2) !% ,)";- !+

0!D#+"(#"& &'#G )+# 21-&+1,3 )"2 3"@#"./!-),/# -G-@

(- !% 4#)/&' .+#)&1!" 4'1.' .)" ,# 2#-10"#2 &! ,#"#K1&

(!+# &')" ) F+1D1/#0#2 %#45 6:+!.;I #& )/>E 7W#4 L3++#".G

B+!"&1#+-5=>

LL )2D!.)- &GF1.)//G 2! "!& -## 0!D#+"(#"& )- +#F+#-#"@

&)&1D# !% &'#1+ 1"+#-&-I )"2 &'#+#%!+# &'#G )+# /!!;1"0 %!+

4)G- !% -!/D1"0 &'# -.)+.1&G !% (!"#G D1) "#4 (#)"-> ?'1-F#+.#1D#2 %)1/3+# !% "!& *3-& &'# 0!D#+"(#"& ,3& )/-! !% &'#

,)";-I -10")/- ) ;#G -'1%& 1" &'# '1-&!+G !% &'# K1")".1)/ 2#@

,)-> ?'# )2D!.)- !% LL )+# "!& /!!;1"0 %!+ -!/3&1!"-

&')& K1& 41&'1" &'# '1-&!+1.)/ 3"2#+-&)"21"0- !% ./)-- 1"#@

J3)/1&G )"2 +#F+#-#"&)&1D# 0!D#+"(#"&> P" #--#".# &'#

-G-( !% +#F+#-#"&)&1D# 0!D#+"(#"&I ,31/& &! #"),/# .)F1@

&)/1-(I 1- %)1/1"0 &! (##& &'# 2#()"2- !% )& /#)-& &'# LL )2@

D!.)-I 1% "!& ) /)+0# -4)&' !% -!.1#&G> ?'# F!"&1)/ 21-@

+3F&1!" &! &'# #"&1+# F!/1&1.)/ #.!"!(G 1- '30#I )"2 K103+1"0

!3& '!4 &! 2#-10" ) -G-( !% (!"#G .+#)&1!" &')& +#&3+"-

) -#"-# &')& &'# B#2#+)/ Q!D#+"(#"& ).&3)//G 1- +#F+#-#"&@

1"0 )"2 (#21)&1"0 &'# "##2- !% )// ./)--#-I ()G ,# !% .+1&1.)/

1(F!+&)".# &! &'# -3+D1D)/ !% .)F1&)/1-& 2#(!.+).1#->

Z)+0+1& [#""#2GI 4'! ')- 4+1&" )"2 /#.&3+#2 #A"-1D#/G

!" LL ')- )+03#2 &')&I 7Z!"#G .)" ,# ()2# &! -#+D# +)&'#+

&')" &! +3/#I &! ,# 3-#\+)&'#+ &')" F+!K1&@!+1#"\)"2 &!

.+#) ),3"2)".#I -&),1/1&GI )"2 -3-&)1"),1/1&G5 6J&2> 1"

]&!"1"0&!"I ORR^=> ]'# -)12 &')& 4'1/# 7(!"#G 1- !"# !% &'#

(!-& 1"0#"1!3- 1"D#"&1!"- !% ()";1"25 1& ')- 7&'# F!"&1)/

&! ,# &'# (!-& 2#-&+3.&1D# !+ (!-& .+#)&1D#5 6J&2> 1" ]&!"@

1"0&!"I ORR^=> Z!"#GI .+#21& )"2 .3++#".1#- 1" 0#"#+)/I )+#

&'# F+!23.& !% ) /!"0 -#+1#- !% -!.1)/ 2#.1-1!"-> ?'#-# 2#.1@

-1!"- ')D# '1-&!+1.)//G %!.3-#2 !" 2#-10"1"0 ) -G-( !%

(!"#G .+#)&1!" &')& 1- ,!&' .!(F)&1,/# )"2 +#1"%!+.1"0 !%&'# 3"2#+/G1"0 ./)-- 1"#J3)/1&G "#.#--)+G %!+ &'# -(!!&'

!F#+)&1!" !% &'# 9(#+1.)" .)F1&)/1-& 2#(!.+).G> ?'# +1-#I

-1".# &'# NSURM-I !% ) "#4 -#& !% K1")".1)/ 2#,)-I +#F+#@

-#"&- ) 3"1J3# .')//#"0# &! ) /!"0 +3""1"0 &'#!+G !% (!"#G

)"2 .+#21& .+#)&1!"> ?'# LL )2D!.)- )+# F!1"&1"0 &! &'#

-#"-# &')& &'# .3++#"& K1")".1)/ -G-( 1- %)1/1"0E &'#1+ -!/3@

&1!"- )+# "!& %!.3-#2 !" -)D1"0 &'# .3++#"& -G-( ,3& !%

%3"2)(#"&)//G +#.!"K103+1"0 &'# #"&1+# F!/1&1.)/ #.!"!(G>

W! &'#!+G !% (!"#G .+#)&1!" ')- )&(F &! )+&1.3/) )"

)/+")&1D# F!/1&1.)/ #.!"!(G -1".# &'# %)1/#2 #%%!+&- !% &'#

.!/!"1)/ -&) /#01-/)&3+#- !% &'# N__RM-> `#(!.+)&1.

(!"#GI )..!+21"0 &! LL )2D!.)-I 1- ) &GF# !% (!"#G )"2

.+#21& &')& #"D1-1!"- ) "#4 F!/1&1.)/ #.!"!(G ,31/& !" ./)--

#J3)/1&G a 1& 1- ) D)-&/G 21%%#+#"& .!".#F&3)/1H)&1!" !% 2#@

(!.+).G &')& 3"2#+F1"- &'1- 12#)> ?'# LL (!D#(#"& 1-

+#)+&1.3/)&1"0 &'# +!/#- !% 0!D#+"(#"& )"2 ,)";-I 4'1/#

+)1-1"0 2##F#+ J3#-&1!"- ),!3& 4')& 1& (#)"- &! .+#)

(!"#G 2#(!.+)&1.)//G>


11

NO B+#2#+1.' D!" b)G#;I &'# W!,#/ F+1H# 41""1"0 %+##@()+;#& #.!"!(1-&I 4)- ) ,10 )2D!.) !% 4')& '# .)//#2I 7&'# 2#")&1!")/1H)&1!" !%

(!"#G5 )+031"0 %!+ F+1D) .!(F)"1#- &! 1--3# &'#1+ !4" .3++#".1#- )"2 )//!4 &'# ()+;#& &! 2#+(1"# &'# D)/3# !% (!"#G 6D!" b)G#;I

NS_c=> V)+& !% '1- )+03(#"& +#- !" '1- )"&1F)&'G &!4)+2- 4')& '# )/-! -)4 )- &'# F!/1&1.1H)&1!" !% (!"#G> ?'1- +#F+#-#"&- )"!&'#+ !% &'#

-#D#+)/ 4)G- 1" 4'1.' &'# LL (!D#(#"& .!(#- &! (1++!+ !+ ,31/2 !%% %+##@()+;#& .)F1&)/1-& #.!"!(1-&->

NY P& 1- 1(F!+&)"& &! F!1"& !3& &')& :+!.; #& )/I 21%%#+ %+!( ()"G !% &'# !&'#+ LL )2D!.)- 1" &')& &'#G 2! "!& -## ) +!/# %!+ ) D)/3),/# .!(@

(!21&GI )"2 ')D# ) 21%%#+#"& "!&1!" !% D)/3# %+!( &')& 4'1.' ()"G !% &'# !&'#+ )2D!.)- )2'#+# &!> P ')D# 4+1&" ),!3& &'1- 1" 0+#)+ 2#@

&)1/ 1" 8)1"4+10'&I ORNN>


14/177


15/177

!"#$%& ($)$%*+ ,-".+ /01234+ 5 ,%"$678 -9 :);%;

>)$#-"? !+(+ ,-".7%**#-")@ A-B6


16/177



SELLING SCRIP TO AMERICA: IDEOLOGY,

SELF-HELP AND THE EXPERIMENTS OF THE

GREAT DEPRESSIONSarah Elvins*

Department Of History, University Of Manitoba

!"#$%!&$

!"#$%&'$ #$)*) +,- .% -/.'") 0,##)*. #% #$) &-) %1 ,"#)*.,#/2) 3&**).34 /. !5)*/3, 6&*/.' #$)

7*),# 8)0*)--/%.9 #$) ,*'&5).#- &-)6 :4 -&00%*#)*- %1 -3*/0 %1#). 0",4)6 %. 3%55%. #$)5)-;

.%5/3 -/#&,#/%.; !"#$%&'$ #$) 8)0*)--/%. +,- , .,#/%.," ?,.6 /.#)*.,#/%.,"@ 3*/-/-9 5,.4 -3*/0

,62%3,#)- :)"/)2)6 #$,# #$)4 +%&"6 :) ,:") #% 1%3&- /50*%2)5).# +/#$/. %.) 0,*#/3&",* 3%5>

5&./#4; $)"0 ,.6 /.6/2/6&,"/-5; A2). 1,3)6 +/#$ #$)

3$,"").')- %1 #$) 8)0*)--/%.9 1)+ !5)*/3,.- +)*) +/""/.' #% )5:*,3) *,6/3," 3$,.'); !62%>

3,#)- %1 ,"#)*.,#/2) 3&**).34 $,6 #% +,"B , =/.) "/.) :)#+)). )50$,-/C/.' #$) /..%2,#/2) 0%--/>

:/"/#/)- %1 -3*/0 ,.6 *),--&*/.' #$) 0&:"/3 #$,# #$)-) 0",.- +)*) -/50"4 , 5),.- #% D0*/5) #$)

0&50E %1 ,. )--).#/,""4 -%&.6 )3%.%5/3 -4-#)5;

!&'()*+,-.,/,($#

F$) ,$%* ,3B.%+")6')- -&00%*# 1%* #$/- *)-),*3$ 1*%5 #$) NP Y+++;/Z33*;.)#[

L


17/177

!"#$%&'(#!%"

!"# %&'&(#) *+ ,"# -%#&, .#/%#))0*1 /%*2/,#3 2&14 5*26

2710,0#) &5%*)) ,"# 810,#3 9,&,#) ,* #:/#%02#1, ;0," )5%0//? @>,#%1&,0'# 57%%#154

)5"#2#) /%*>0+#%&,#3 &+,#% ,"# A&>> 9,%##, B%&)" *+ CDED4 CDGH) &13 ;&101( &) ,"# #5*6

1*205 /%*(%&2) *+ I%&1F>01 .#>&1* J**)#'#>,K) L#; .#&>

;#%# /7, 01,* />&5#? B0,0#) &13 ,*;1) &5%*)) ,"# 810,#3

9,&,#) &,,#2/,#3 ,* #15*7%&(# 5*1)72/,0*1 &13 &>>#'0&,#

71#2/>*42#1, =4 0))701( ,"#0% *;1 +*%2) *+ 2*1#4?

B*22710,0#) &) 30'#%)# &) B"05&(*< @,>&1,&< .#,%*0,< &13

,014 M&;&%3#1< N*;& ,7%1#3 ,* )5%0/ &) & )*>7,0*1 ,* ,"#

5%0)0)? N1 )*2# 5&)#) )5%0/ ;&) 010,0&,#3 =4 271050/&> (*'6

#%12#1,) *% 50,4 5*7150>)< ;"0># 01 *,"#%) /%0'&,# 50,0O#1)*4#3 ,"#2)#>'#)

+*%2#3 5**/#%&,0'#) ,* /7, 1#; ,4/#) *+ 2*1#4 01,* &5,0*1?

!"#%# ;&) 1* )01(># /&,,#%1 ,* ,"# 7)# *+ &>,#%1&,0'# 57%6

%#154 01 @2#%05&P ),&2/ )5%0/< =&%,#% )5%0/< &75,0*1 )5%0/> /7, 01,* 50%57>&,0*1

01 30++#%#1, /&%,) *+ ,"# 5*71,%4 QM&%/#%< CDRST -&,5"'01)< EHHVT A&%1#%< EHCHW?

@ 5>*)#% #:&201&,0*1 *+ ,"# 3#=&,# *'#% )5%0/ 01 ,"# 1&6

,0*1&> &13 >*5&> 2#30& =4 &5,0'0),)< /*>0,050&1)< =7)01#))

>#&3#%)< &13 *,"#% (%*7/) 5&1 /%*'03# 01)0(", 01,* ,"# /*)6

)0=0>0,0#) &13 5"&>>#1(#) +*% +7,7%# /%*/*1#1,) *+ &>,#%1&6

,0'# 57%%#154 01 ,"# 810,#3 9,&,#)? U'#1 ,"*7(" ,"# (%*7/)

&3'*5&,01( +*% ,"# 7)# *+ )5%0/ ;#%# 1*, 710+*%2< 5#%,&01

&%(72#1,) ;#%# %#/#&,#3>4 2*=0>0O#3 01 &1 #++*%, ,* (&01

)7//*%, +*% &>,#%1&,0'# 57%%#154? I0%),< )5%0/ %#X>#5,#3 ,"#

=#>0#+ ,"&, >*5&> %#)*7%5#) 5*7>3 =# 2&%)"&>#3 ,* 5*2=&,

,"# 1&,0*1&> #5*1*205 5%0)0)? @>,"*7(" ,"# .#/%#))0*1 ;&)& 1&,0*1&> Y &13 013##3 01,#%1&,0*1&> Y /%*=>#2< =&5F#%) *+

&>,#%1&,0'# 57%%#150#) =#>0#'#3 ,"&, ,"#4 ;*7>3 =# &=># ,*

5*15#1,%&,# ,"# 50%57>&,0*1 *+ 2*1#4 ,* 02/%*'# 5*130,0*1)

;0,"01 *1# /&%,057>&% 5*22710,4?

9#5*13>4< )5%0/ &>)* &//#&>#3 ,* @2#%05&1 1*,0*1) *+ )#>+6

"#>/ &13 0130'037&>0)2? N1 ,"# #&%>4 Q/%#6L#; .#&>W 4#&%)

*+ ,"# -%#&, .#/%#))0*1< @2#%05&1) %&1(01( +%*2 Z%#)03#1,

M#%=#%, M**'#% 3*;1 ,* >*5&> 5"&2=#%) *+ 5*22#%5# #:6

/%#))#3 5*15#%1 ,"&, "&13*7,) *+ %#>0#+ ,* ,"# 71#2/>*4#3

5*7>3 713#%201# ,"#0% 30(10,4 &13 )&/ ,"#2 *+ ,"#0% ;0>>6

01(1#)) ,* ;*%F? !"# 5%#&,*%) *+ )5%0/ />&1) >0F# ,"# =&%,#%

)4),#2 3#'0)#3 =4 ,"# [%(&10O#3 81#2/>*4#3 *+ \011#&6

/*>0)< \011#)*,&< #2/"&)0O#3 "*; ,"# %#>0#+ ,"&, ,"#4 *+6

+#%#3 ;&) 1*, 5"&%0,4< =7, & ;&4 ,* /%*'03# 1#; *//*%,7106

,0#) +*% ;0>>01( /#*/># ,* (#, =&5F ,* ;*%F?

I01&>>4< & ),734 *+ ,"# 30)57))0*1 *+ )5%0/ 01 1&,0*1&> &13

>*5&> 2#30&< =4 /*>0,050&1)< #5*1*20),)< &13 =7)01#)) >#&36

#%) 01 ,"# #&%>4 CDGH) %#'#&>) ,"&, &>,#%1&,0'# 57%%#154 ;&)

'0#;#3 =4 2&14 &) &1 #2#%(#154 2#&)7%#< 1*, & 2#&1) ,*

/#%2&1#1,>4 ,%&1)+*%2 ,"# #5*1*24? U'#1 +&5#3 ;0," ,"#

5%0)0) *+ ,"# .#/%#))0*1< +#; @2#%05&1) ;#%# ;0>>01( ,*

#2=%&5# %&305&> 5"&1(#? @3'*5&,#) *+ &>,#%1&,0'# 57%%#154

"&3 ,* ;&>F & X01# >01# =#,;##1 #2/"&)0O01( ,"# 011*'&,0'#/*))0=0>0,0#) *+ )5%0/ &13 %#&))7%01( ,"# /7=>05 ,"&, ,"#)#

/>&1) ;#%# )02/>4 & 2#&1) ,* ]/%02# ,"# /72/^ *+ &1 #)6

)#1,0&>>4 )*713 #5*1*205 )4),#2?

Figure 1. Scrip from Clear Lake, Iowa and from the Or-

ganized Unemployed of Minneapolis, Minnesota. The

Organized Unemployed scrip features a photo of George

Mecklenburg and the slogan Work, not Dole. (from the

collection of Dr. Hugo Godschalk)

)%)'*+$ '"&-$.#+"&!"/. %0 #1- -(%"%23

!"# ),734 *+ )5%0/ &>>*;) & 710_7# *//*%,710,4 ,* #:/>*%#

,"# &'#%&(# 5*1)72#%K) 713#%),&1301( *+ ,"# #5*1*24 &13

/7=>05 30)5*7%)#) &=*7, ,"# 5&7)#) *+ ,"# .#/%#))0*1? N1

,"# 2*1,") &13 4#&%) &+,#% ,"# A&>> 9,%##, B%&)"< & +&20>0&%

#:/>&1&,0*1 +*% ,"# #5*1*205 5%0)0) "01(#3 *1 ,"# %*># *+

/%0'&,# 5*1)72#%) ;"* ;#%# +**>0)">4 ]"*&%301(^ ,"#0%

2*1#4 ;"#1 ,"#4 1##3#3 ,* %#)72# )/#1301( &, ,"# "0("

>#'#>) *+ ,"# CDEH)? Z%#)03#1, M#%=#%, M**'#% 5**%301&,#3

&1 &1,06"*&%301( 3%0'# 01 #&%>4 CDGE ,* 015%#&)# ,"#

&2*71, *+ 57%%#154 01 50%57>&,0*1 QL#; `*%F !02#) CDGE&T

L#; `*%F !02#) CDGE=W? U30,*%0&>) &13 %#,&0> &3'#%,0)#6

2#1,) #2/"&)0O#3 ,"# %*># *+ ,"# /%0'&,# 5*1)72#% 01 ,7%16

01( #5*1*205 5*130,0*1) &%*713? @1 #30,*%0&> 01 ,"# a7++&>*

U'#101( L#;) 01 a7++&>*< L#; `*%F< &%(7#3P

!"# >&; *+ )7//>4 &13 3#2&13 0) 5*1),&1, Y

5*1)72#%< %#,&0>#%< 2&17+&5,7%#%? N,K) >*(05&>

&13 )#>+6#'03#1,? \#%5"&1,) )7//>4 ,"# 5*16

)72#%)K 1##3) Y 4*7% 1##3)? \&17+&5,7%#%)

)7//>4 ,"# 2#%5"&1,) Y 4*7% 2#%6

5"&1,)b`*7 &%# & 1#5#))&%4 /&%, *+ ,"#

=7)01#)) 545>#< &13 7/*1 4*7% X0>>01( 4*7%/>&5# 01 ,"0) 545># 3#/#13) ,"# /%*)/#%0,4

&13 ;#>+&%# *+ ,"# 1&,0*1? N+ 4*7 ),*/ =746

01(< ,"# 2#%5"&1,)K )"#>'#) %#2&01 ),*5F#3? H1 b#B N#%!2 c')*E

0,&2 *#!&0'#*% )*8&10L#, & J")-# ,)''&*K +&-A&081 01 3"0+"

!"#B *#-01,#, +)1%.-#*% !"&! 1) -&!!#* 3"#*# !"#B %A#1!

-)1#B 01 b#B N#%!2 ')+&' /.%01#%%#% +)1!*0/.!#, !) +070+

0-A*)7#-#1!%2 A&0, 3&8#% !) A#)A'# 01 !"# &*#&2 &1,

"#'A#, !) 0-A*)7# +)1,0!0)1% ()* &''? S)1%.-#*% 3#*# !)',2

J@"# ,)''&* B). %A#1, &! ")-# ^ %!&B% "#*# &1, 3)*D%? ? ?

X#-#-/#* B).* 1#08"/)* 30'' !&D# /#!!#* +&*# )( B). !"&1

& %!*&18#*K 4b#B N#%! S0!0L#12 :;?

H! 3&% 1)! -.+" )( & '#&A ()* -#*+"&1!% !) -)7# (*)- #1E

+).*&8018 +)1%.-A!0)1 &! ")-# !) ,#70%018 ()*-% )( &'!#*E

1&!07# +.**#1+B !"&! +).', )1'B /# %A#1! 30!"01 )1# +)-E

-.10!B? H1 !"# #&*'B :; &1, +).', /# *#,##-#, 01 +&%"? @"#

A*)-01#1! Y&'# #+)1)-0%! H*7018 c0%"#* /#+&-# #G+0!#, /B

!"# A)%%0/0'0!0#% )( !"# Z&3&*,#1 A'&12 &'!").8" "# +&.E

!0)1#, !"&! !"# *#P.0*#-#1! )( & A.*+"&%# )( %!&-A ()*

#7#*B !*&1%&+!0)1 3).', /# '#%% #((#+!07# !"&1 & ,&!#, A'&12

3"#*# %+*0A +).', +0*+.'&!# (*##'B .1!0'2 &(!#* & A#*0), )(

)1# )* !3) 3##D%2 & %!&-A 3).', /# "&7# !) /# A.*+"&%#,

!) #G!#1, 0!% .%#? c0%"#* %&3 %!&-A %+*0A &% & ,0*#+! +"&'E

'#18# !) +)1%.-#*% 3") 3#*# ")&*,018 +.**#1+BU 0! 3&% J&

I'##!E())!#, +.**#1+B 3"0+" 1)/),B +&1 ")&*,K /#+&.%# !"#

+)%! )( &(I0G018 & %!&-A )1 #&+" +#*!0I0+&!# 3).', A#1&'0L#

&1B +)1%.-#* ())'0%" #1).8" !) ")', )1!) %+*0A 30!").!

%A#1,018 0! 4c0%"#*2 :;


19/177

!"#$%& !()*+ +,& -&%,!.$%/ )0 !1+&2.!+$#& %*22&.%3 41!./ +)

$.+&2&/+&" %)--*.$+$&/5 !." /&.+ ,$/ 2&/&!2%, !//$/+!.+

6!./ 7),2//&. +) %)11&%+ -!+&2$!1 !()*+ /%2$4 &84&2$-&.+/

$. 9&2-!.3 !." :*/+2$!;

)2 42)-)+&2 )0 $+/ */& $. +,& ?.$+&" @+!+&/; 6& /!= *.A

&-41)3-&.+ !/ ! %)--*.$+3 42)(1&-5 !." !2B*&" +,!+ >*/+!/ %$+$C&./ "*2$.B D)21" D!2 E ,!" 2!11$&" +) /*44)2+ +,&

F$(&2+3 !." G$%+)23 ()." "2$#&/5 HDI :JI :K D:J LMD5

!+ =!2 =$+, &!%, )+,&2; D& !2& +23$.B +) ,!.B ).+) -).&3

!." 42)4&2+3 =$+, ! "&!+,B2$45 (*+ =& ") .)+ /&&- +) 2&!1A

$C& +,!+ $+ $/ )*2 02$&."N/ +,2)!+ )0 =,$%, =& ,!#& ,)1" !."

+,& ,!2"&2 =& /O*&&C& +,& -)2& "$0P$%*1+ $+ (&%)-&/ 0)2 +,$/

02$&." +) /*4413 */ =$+, +,& .&%&//!23 0))" !." -!.*0!%A

+*2&" !2+$%1&/Q R


20/177

!"#$%"& ()*+%,"&& -."/% %)"% %).$+ ("&"+$.( 0.+. 1*$/1 2/3

#"$45 6). (%*+. 4$4 /*% +.72$+. %."!).+( %* -"8. " #2+3

!)"(.9 :2% ($-#&; .

!"()5 >.%0../ ?@AB "/4 ?@AC9 D%&"/%" $((2.4 -*+. %)"/

EFBB9BBB $/ (!+$# %* -2/$!$#"& 0*+8.+(9 0)$!) G$!)H( ":3

(*+:.4 IJ*+1"/9 /545K G*:.+4(9 ?@@B9 L&M$/(9 NB?BO5 G$!)H(

+."#.4 %). :./.=$% *, $/!+."(.4 &*;"&%; ,+*- D%&"/%" %."!)3

.+(9 "/4 (%*+. #+.($4./% P"&%.+ G$!) 0"( #+.(./%.4 "( %).("M$*+ *, %). !$%; */ %). ,+*/% #"1. *, %). D%&"/%" Q*/(%$%23

%$*/ ID%&"/%" Q*/(%$%2%$*/9 ?@ABO5 R/ *%).+ $/(%"/!.(9 )*03

.M.+9 (!+$# $((2.( =&*2/4.+.4 "( :2($/.((.( +.,2(.4 %* #"+3

%$!$#"%.9 "( 0"( %). !"(. 0)./ Q)$!"1*H( S%"%. S%+..% 4.3

#"+%-./% (%*+.( +.,2(.4 %* "!!.#% %). (!+$# 0)$!) )"4 :../

#"$4 %* !$%; %."!).+(5 T/. (%*+. .

%). ,*+- *, !*--*4$%; (!+$# I0).+. 0"+.)*2(. +.!.$#%(

:"!8.4 2# %). -.4$2- *, .

U)*2+V (!+$# 0"( $((2.4 0)$!) 2(.4 )*2+( *, 0*+8 "( %).

(%"/4"+45 D 1+*2# *, _"+&.- :2($/.((-./ *#./.4 %). _"+3&.- J2%2"& L

?@AA"O5

R/ J$//."#*&$(9 " 1+*2# !"&&.4 %). T+1"/$X.4 \/.-#&*;.4

+"/ " 0"+.)*2(. "/4 (%*+. 0).+. %). */&; !$+!2&"%$/1 -.3

4$2- *, !2++./!; 0"( (!+$#5 G.M.+./4 ^.*+1. J.!8&./3

:2+19 4$+.!%*+ *, %). #+*1+"-9 "+12.4 %)"% (!+$# 0"( !+2!$"&

$/ :+$41$/1 %). 1"# :.%0../ 2/.-#&*;.4 &":*+ "/4 (2+#&2(

#+*42!%(5 _. +.!"&&.4 ;."+( &"%.+9 UT2+ &"!8 0"( /*% ,**4

"/4 !&*%).(K *2+ &"!8 0"( -*/.;5 b.*#&. !*2&4 /*% :2;

%)$/1( 0$%)*2% -*/.;V IJ.!8&./:2+19 ?@cC9 ##5 [A3CO5

\/.-#&*;.4 0*+8.+( +.!.$M.4 E?5FB " 4"; $/ (!+$# %* 0*+8!)*##$/1 0**49 0*+8$/1 */ " #&*% *, &"/4 1+*0$/1 M.1.%"3

:&.(9 -"8$/1 #+.(.+M.( *+ !"//$/1 ("2.+8+"2%5 6). *+1"/$3

X"%$*/ +"/ " U0)$%.3!*&&"+V +.(%"2+"/% ,*+ %). 2/.-#&*;.49

0).+. )*% &2/!).( 0.+. (*&4 ,*+ ?B !./%(9 "/4 " 4*+-$%*+;

0).+. */. !*2&4 #"; ,*+ " :.4 %* (&..# $/ 0$%) ?F !./%( *,

(!+$# " /$1)%5 6). 1+*2#H( (%*+. (%*!8.4 "/ "-"X$/1 "++";

*, $%.-( d /*% */&; 2(.4 1**4( :+*21)% $/ ,*+ :"+%.+ :2%

0**49 #+*42!. "/4 " )*(% *, #+*42!%( -"4. :; 0*+8.+( ,*+

%). !**#.+"%$M.5 D% $%( ).$1)%9 *M.+ ?9FBB #.*#&. M$($%.4 %).

,"!$&$%; 4"$&; IY2+%X9 ?@AAO5

Y.; %* %). (2!!.(( *, %). #+*1+"-9 $/ J.!8&./:2+1H( M$.09

0"( %). #(;!)*&*1$!"& :./.=$% $% *,,.+.4 %* 2/.-#&*;.4

J$//.(*%"/(5 R/ )$( -.-*$+(9 J.!8&./:2+1 4.(!+$:.4 U6).

:.(% (.+M$!. %). T+1"/$X.4 \/.-#&*;.4 )"4 +./4.+.4 0"(

%* ("M. %). (.&,3+.(#.!% *, %). #.*#&.5 6).; "&& ,.&% %)"% %).;

0.+. /*% +.!.$M$/1 !)"+$%;5 6).; 0.+. 0*+8$/1 !**#.+"3

%$M.&; 0$%) ."!) *%).+ "/4 ,*+ ."!) *%).+9 2/4.+ !"+.,2&&;

&"$4 #&"/(5V IJ.!8&./:2+19 ?@cC9 #5 [ZO D #2:&$!$%; =&;.+ ,*+

%). *+1"/$X"%$*/ :*"(%.4 *, %). (#$+$% *, !*-+"4.()$# %)"%

$/,2(.4 ,*+-.+&; 2/.-#&*;.4 0*+8.+(9 /*0 ./1"1.4 $/

!)*##$/1 0**4 *+ 0*+8$/1 "% %). ("2.+8+"2% ,"!%*+;e

U6).(. #.*#&. ,..& %).; "+. 0*+8$/1 ,*+ %).-(.&M.(9 /*% ,*+

(*-.:*4; .&(.5 6). .


21/177

!"#$%&' )*+,'&-. $)&/, %* ' $*&% *0 ,&-$$1&- 2'#2- %3'%

)*1#. &-#/-2- %-4$/*4$ 53/)3 +/63% *%3-&5/$- &-$1#% *0 '4

*2-&%3&*5 *0 %3- -7/$%/46 $"$%-+8 9/$3-&: /4 %1&4: 14.-&;

$)*&-. %3- $-4$- *0 $)&/, '$ ' &-#/-0 ,#'4 %3'% *00-&$ 5*&-#/-0

'.+/4/$%&'%/*48 ?- 4*%-. %3'% 14#/


22/177

!"# %#&'#()'* +, ("# -.)/%(+/ 0112/+2% 3#()21 4#'&")/(%5

6%%+&2)(2+/ %2721)'1* #78")%29#: ("# ;)* 2/ ;"2&" %&'28

&+&+/%&2+


23/177

!"#$%&''("#)* ,&-"%. /012234 5"6'& "7 ,&8%&')9(:&'4 ;&>?

@*:(#'4 A? />BBC3 A)*&' )#. !&*&BBQ3 RA-%(8 S"#&= )#. A*6T8 !6%&'D E"H)U' @V8&%(K

T' H(9M L*9&%#)9(:& !6%%-= .6%(#$ 9M& W%&)9 X&8%&''("#Y?ZM& L##)*' "7 E"H)4 ["*? \C #"? 2 /A6TT&%34 88? >>0K>CQ?

@*:(#'4 A? />B0B3 RA-%(84 A9"%&'4 )#. !)'MKA9%)88&. !(9(&'D LT&%(K

-)# ,&9)(*&%' )#. L*9&%#)9(:& !6%%-= .6%(#$ 9M& W%&)9 X&8%&'K

'("#Y? ]"6%#)* "7 5('9"%(-)* ,&'&)%-M (# S)%J&9(#$4 ["*? > #"? 0 88?

^\K0B_?

@V&-69(:& !"TT(99&& "7 9M& N%$)#(`&. O#&T8*"=&. "7 S(##&)8"*('

/01223 R!)**(#$ (# A-%(8Y? P)T8M*&9 (# W&"%$& Z'&*"' !"**&-9("#4

S(##&'"9) 5('9"%(-)* A"-(&9=?

;('M&%4 E? /#?.?3 RS&T"%)#.6TY? E%:(#$ ;('M&% P)8&%'4 G&H I"%J

P6 #"? > /A6TT&%34 88? 0\^K011

W)9-M4 a? />BB^3 Ra"-)* S"#&= (# 9M& O#(9&. A9)9&' X6%(#$ 9M&

W%&)9 X&8%&''("#Y? @'')=' (# @-"#"T(- d c6'(#&'' 5('9"%=4 ["*?

eeE[4 88? C_K\0?

W)6*94 @?5? /01223 RL A"6#. S"#&= P*)# 7"% !"TT6#(9= c)%9&%Y?

S)%-M 024 c6%9"# 5('9"%(-)* !"**&-9("#4 X&9%"(9 P6?

])#'4 P?G? /01223 P%"8"')* 7"% #)9("#)* '-%(8 8*)#4 E%:(#$ ;('M&%P)8&%'4 G&H I"%J P63 Ra""Jh I"6 g&&8 ) A9%(#$ N# @:&%= X"**)%

I"6 A8. L9 5"T&Y? L8%(* 014 8? \?

g6%9`4 ,? /01223 R,&'6T& "7 A96.= "7 9M& N%$)#(`&. O#&T8*"=&.4

E#-?4 "7 S(##&)8"*('4 S(##?Y? ,6''&** A)$& ;"6#.)9("#4 O#(9&. F)=

"7 S(##&)8"*(' ,&-"%.'4 ;"*.&% 0Q2D C4 A"-()* F&*7)%& 5('9"%=

L%-M(:&'4 O#(:&%'(9= "7 S(##&'"9)?

S&-J*)3 R56T_?

N%$)#(`&. O#&T8*"=&. E#-? "7 S(##&)8"*(' /#?.?3? Z=8&'-%(89 *&)7K

*&94 W&"%$& Z'&*"' 8)8&%'4 S(##&'"9) 5('9"%(-)* A"-(&9=?

,"B0B3 RA9)T8 A-%(8 (# 9M& W%&)9 X&8%&''("#D a&''"#'

7"% !"TT6#(9= !6%%-= Z".)=kY E#9&%#)9("#)* ]"6%#)* "7 !"TK

T6#(9= !6%%-= ,&'&)%-M? ["*? 0C 88? >1KCQ?

F)%#&%4 ]? />BB^3 RZM& L#)M&(T A-%(8 P*)#Y? A"69M&%# !)*(7"%#()

l6)%9&%*= ["*? 1B #"? 24 88? 2B_K2>Q?

F&('M))%4 F? )#. P)%%('M4 F? F? /012234 S F(9M"69 S"#&=D ZM&!M)**$& "7 c)%9&% )#. A-%(8? /G&H I"%JD W?P? P69#)TU' A"#'3?

m=*'9%)4 !? /012>)3 R;(%'9 ,&*&)'&Y? P%&'' %&*&)'&4 #"9 .)9&. -3 a&99&% 9" E%:(#$ ;('M&%? N-9"^4 E%:(#$ ;('M&%

P)8&%'4 G&H I"%J P6


24/177



TAX ANTICIPATION SCRIP AS A FORM OF LOCAL

CURRENCY IN THE USA DURING THE 1930S

Loren Gatch*

Department Of Political Science, University Of Central Oklahoma

!"#$%!&$

!"#$%& ()* +,#-. */,%,0$/ /#$1$1 ,2 ()* 345617 ()* 8%$(*. 9(:(*1 *;1/#$


25/177

!"#$%&'(#!%"

!"#$%& ()* +,#-. */,%,0$/ /#$1$1 ,2 ()* 345617 ()* 8%$(*.

9(:(*1 *;


26/177

!"# %&'!(!)* +&, "-'-,,&.* )/ 0&"- 01"!'!2&( -32-"4!5

)1.-,6 7" "/.0&( )!0-,8 )9!, '/1(4 :- 4/"- -!)9-. :* ,9/.)5

)-.0 ;!"&"'!"# %./0 (/'&( :&"-) )9- 2/(!)!'&( &"4 (-#&( !02(!'&)!/", /% )9!, ;!"&"'!"#+-.- "/) 1"2./:(-0&)!'6 ?1"!'!2&( #/=-."0-"), 4!,:1.,-4

%1"4, 1,!"# @+&..&"),A8 01'9 &, !"4!=!41&(, 0!#9) +.!)-

'9-'

(&)- IJKV &"4 -&.(* IJKK )/ )9- 4-'(&.&)!/" /% ,)&)-5(-=-(

:&"< h9/(!4&*,N )/ 2.-=-") 4-2/,!)/.,N .1", )9&) +/1(4 21,9

!((!c1!4 !",)!)1)!/", !")/ !",/(=-"'*6 F1(0!"&)!"# !" )9- "&5

)!/"&( h9/(!4&*N 4-'(&.-4 :* f.-,!4-") P//,-=-() !" ?&.'9

IJKK8 )9-,- '(/,1.-, "/) /"(* 4-2.!=-4 01"!'!2&(!)!-, /% &

,/1.'- /% ;!"&"'!"#8 :1) '1) )9-0 /%% %./0 +9&)-=-. %1"4,

)9-* )9-0,-(=-, 9&4 /" 4-2/,!)6

]9!(- )9- -32-.!-"'-, /% F9!'/ &"4 _-)./!) +-.- ,2-'5

)&'1(&. -3&02(-, /% )9- 4!%;!'1()!-, 01"!'!2&(!)!-, %&'-48 )9-;!,'&( 2.-,,1.-, +-.- +!4-,2.-&46 H* IJKK ,/0- )+/ )9/15

,&"4 01"!'!2&( #/=-."0-"), 9&4 4-%&1()-4 /" 2&*0-"), /%

!")-.-,) /. 2.!"'!2&( /" )9-!. 4-:),8 &"4 /"(* )9- (&.#-,)

International Journal Of Community Currency Research 2012 Volume 16 (D) 22-35 Gatch

24


27/177

!"#"$% '$#(")$* (# +$(%# %,-$ (!!$%% #, %.,'#/#$'- 0")()!")1

#.',21. #.$ )(#",)3% !(4"#(+ -('5$#%67 8, '$+"$9$ #.$%$

4'$%%2'$%: ( )2-;$' ,< %#(#$ +$1"%+(#2'$% (2#.,'"=$* #.$ 2%$

,< #(> ()#"!"4(#",) 0")()!")1 ") #.$ $%7

8.$ 4+"!"#+D +(;$+$* G%!.,,+ %!'"4H: "%%2$* #, 4(D

#$(!.$'%3 %(+('"$% ()* (!!$4#(;+$ ()#"!"4(#",) ),#$%: %$##")1 24 ( GW,()

I,('*H (# #.$ %#(#$ !(4"#(+ #.(# A,2+* (44',9$ #.$ (44+"!(/

#",)% ,< +,!(+ %!.,,+ ;,('*% #, "%%2$ %!'"4 BX2'#, NOEOC7 F)

Y$A Z$'%$D: $9$) (% #.$ X,2)#D ,< @#+()#"! "%%2$* G%!.,,+

%!'"4H ,) ;$.(+< ,< %!.,,+ *"%#'"!#% ") @#+()#"! X"#D ()*

[$)#),': #.$%$ !,--2)"#"$% ") #2') 42# ,2# #.$"' ,A) %$4(/

'(#$ -2)"!"4(+ %!'"4% #.(# !"'!2+(#$* !,)!2''$)#+D BV"#!.$++()* \.("%#")1 (2#.,'"#D ,< -2)"!"4(+"#"$% #, 2%$ #(> ()#"!"4(#",)

),#$% %, #.(# %2!. *$;# !,2+* ;$ "%%2$* (% !"'!2+(#")1 %!'"47

J."+$ (9("+(;+$ #, (++ !,2)#"$% ()* -2)"!"4(+"#"$% ") #.$

%#(#$: #.$ ;"++ A(% ")#$)*$* 4'"-('"+D #, -$$# #.$ 0"%!(+

$-$'1$)!D ") L$#',"# BX,--$'!"(+ ()* U")()!"(+ X.',)"!+$

NO??C7 I$#A$$) @4'"+ NO?? ()* @4'"+ NO?E: #.'$$ %$4('(#$

"%%2$% ,< %!'"4 #,#(+")1 aEN7O -"++",) $% Bf)"#$* \#(#$% X,)!+2*")1 0+,(#")1 *$;# +"5$ #(> ()#"!"4(#",) 0")()!")1: #.$ ())2(+ #,#(+ ,< )$A -2)"!"4(+ *$;# "%%2$* ") #.$ f)"#$* \#(#$% .(* *',44$* (%7 F) (**"#",): $9$) "< #.$D *"* ),# (2#.,'"=$ #.$ (!#2(+ "%%2$ ,< %!'"4: () $K2(+ )2-;$' ,< %#(#$%

4(%%$* %#(#2#$% (++,A")1 ;,)*%: ),#$% ,' A(''()#% #, ;$ '$!$"9$*


28/177

!"#$%&'() (+%( ,'$-&) %,,.#/0 '(, .,/#, (+%( ,1#'- 2%, 3"(

,"$/ 4'30 "! .3!.30/0 0/5( "! '30/6'3'(/ 0.#%('"37 8"#/9

":/#; (+/ &//2 F/#,/) &//2 c"#4 \'$/, ADEG[ X#"23 ADGA; :"&7

KN AWD9A]AQ7

J/(%'&, !#"$ 8"3$".(+ H".3() '&&.,(#%(/ +"2 >/2 F/#,/)S,

,1#'- ,),(/$ 2"#4/07 X/(2//3 C/-(/$5/# ADEE %30 C/-9

(/$5/# ADEZ; (+/ H".3()S, X"%#0 "! H+",/3 T#//+"&0/#,

%.(+"#'`/0 AG ',,./, /%1+ "! @PBB;BBB '3 ,1#'-; 5/%#'3< Za

'3(/#/,(; -%)%5&/ %( $%(.#'() '3 ADE]7 \+/ H".3() \#/%,9

.#/#S, "!6'1/ '3,(%&&/0 % ,-/1'%& (/&&/# 2'30"2 (" +%30&/ %&&

,1#'- (#%3,%1('"3,7 C1#'- (.#3":/# 2%, #%-'07 X) F%3.%#)

ADEG; "! @WBB;BBB ',,./0; ,"$/ @EGB;BBB +%0 5//3 -%'0 '3

(%=/,; &/%:'3< % ,1#'- &'%5'&'() "! @PWB;BBB %, (+/ )/%# 5/


29/177

!"#$%&'() +,-./-&0 "&/ 12"& 32$!"&-%( '224 '5% (36-! 726

$26'0"0% !"#$%&'(8 "( /-/ ,'-.-'-%( 726 '5%-6 7%%() 95"-&

('26%( :%6% .%(( 2;.-0-&0) 2?%6/,% ;-..() @'5%6

$%635"&'( "33%!'%/ (36-! 2&.# ,! '2 '5% "$2,&' 27 '5%-6

2:& '"A .-";-.-'-%() 95"&0% 726 '5% (36-! :"( 27'%& $"/% -&

('26% 36%/-'8 &2' 3"(5 B@3%"& 9-'# C%&'-&%.D1%/0%6 EFGGH(

&%:(!"!%6 32&(-/%6%/ -'( ,(% (#$!'2$"'-3 27 32,&'# 02?D

%6&$%&' $-($"&"0%$%&' "&/ =-(3". %A'6"?"0"&3%8 [,/0-&0(36-! '2 ;% M"& -.. :-&/8 ;,' -' $"# ;.2: (2$% 022/R) Q5%

!"!%6 ".(2 :266-%/ '5"' '5% %A'%&/%/ ,(% 27 (36-! 2&.# %&D

32,6"0%/ !62!%6'# 2:&%6( '2 !6%7%6 -' '2 ('"&/"6/ 7,&/(

:5%& $"4-&0 '"A !"#$%&'(8 '5,( "006"?"'-&0 '5% ?%6#

;,/0%'"6# (526'7"..( '5"' (36-! :"( (,!!2(%/ '2 6%$%/#

BP%/ +"&4 P%0-('%6 EFGGH C%!'%$;%6 IW8 T,2'%\ @3'2;%6 J\

EFGVH ]!6-. IVK)

Z-'5 '5% !"(("0% 27 ",'526-^-&0 .%0-(."'-2& -& ( ,(%7,.&%(( "( " 3"(5 (,;('-','% #%' 3",'-2&%/ '5"' -'

:"( M'5% ("$% "( " 5-05D!2:%6%/ ('-$,."&' -& '5% 5"&/( 27

"& ,&(4-..%/ !5#(-3-"&R) ] (36-! !6206"$ :"( $2(' %77%3D

'-?%8 5% "?%66%/8 -7 -$!.%$%&'%/ ;%726% -' ;%3"$% " /%(!%6D

"'% =-(3". ."(' 6%(26') _2 $26% '5"& 5".7 27 " $,&-3-!".-'#>(

!"#62.. (52,./ ;% $%' :-'5 (36-!8 5% 32,&(%.%/) Q5% $"',6-D

'-%( 27 (36-! (52,./ ;% &2 $26% '5"& (-A $2&'5(8 "&/ :2,./

-/%"..# ;% $"'35%/ '2 '5% 3#3.% 27 '"A !"#$%&'() L& '5-( :"#8

M;# 6%('6-3'-&0 '5% !62!26'-2& 27 '5% (36-! '2 ;% ,(%/8 "&/

'5% '%6$ '2 '56%% 26 72,6 $2&'5(8 !6"3'-3"..# '5% %&'-6%

-((,% :2,./ =-&/ -'( :"# ;"34 -& '5% $,&-3-!". '6%"(,6# -&

'5% !"#$%&' 27 '"A%( ;%726% -'( /,% /"'%R) L& 32&'6"('8 d-%6D

(2& :"6&%/8 (36-! '5"' .-&0%6%/ "( " .2&0D'%6$8 ,&7,&/%/

/%;' :"( (,6% '2 7".. '2 " /-(32,&' Bd-%6(2& EFGJH IVK)

9"6. e) 95"''%6(8 " !62$-&%&' &"'-2&". $,&-3-!". =-&"&3%

%A!%6'8 :"( $26% ("&0,-&% '5"& d-%6(2& "&/ (": (2$% 62.%

726 '"A "&'-3-!"'-2& (36-! -& .23". =-&"&3%() C4%!'-3". 27('"$! (36-!8 95"''%6( &2&%'5%.%(( '52,05' '5"' '"AD;"34%/

$,&-3-!". (36-! :"( M&2 /-77%6%&' '5"& " ;"&4 .2"& %A3%!'

'5"' $%635"&'(8 %$!.2#%%(8 "&/ 2'5%6 3-'-^%&( .%&/ '5%-6

36%/-' '2 '5% 3-'# /-6%3'.# -&('%"/ 27 '562,05 '5%-6 ;"&4(R)

M9-'-%( (52,./ /%?-(% "' 2&3% (2$% $%"&( 27 ;2662:-&0 2&

(526' '%6$ ($".. /%&2$-&"'-2& &2'%() Q5% (%3,6-'# "&/

!.%/0% $"/% 726 '5%-6 !"#$%&' (52,./ ;% "$!.%) C$"..

&2'%( (52,./ ;% '6"&(7%6";.% ;# /%.-?%6# "&/ ."60%6 /%D

&2$-&"'-2&( ;# %&/26(%$%&') L' :-.. ;% &%3%(("6# '2 5"?%

&%: $%/-" 27 %A35"&0% 726 " (526' !%6-2/ "' .%"('8 "&/ $,D

&-3-!".-'-%( 5"?-&0 '5% 32&=-/%&3% 27 '5%-6 3-'-^%&( (52,./

!62?-/% '5%(% $%/-"R B95"''%6( EFGG"H fgK) L&/%%/8 95"'D

'%6( (": -& (36-! " !2'%&'-". 726 %&32,6"0-&0 3-?-3 %&0"0%D

$%&'H MQ5% -((,"&3% 27 (36-! "&/ :"66"&'( -& (2$% 726$ -(

[,(' "&2'5%6 :"# 27 ;2662:-&0 762$ $%635"&'(8 3-'-^%&(8

"&/ 2'5%6( -& '5% .23". 32$$,&-'-%() L7 %?%6# 3-'-^%& -& "

32$$,&-'# 5"/ " ($".. /-6%3' -&'%6%(' -& '5% =-&"&3-". 2;.-D

0"'-2&( 27 5-( 3-'#8 $,35 .%(( '62,;.% -& 3-?-3 $"''%6( $-05'

;% %A!%3'%/R B95"''%6( EFGG;H EEfK)

h%(!-'% '5%(% !62(!%3'( 726 " .23".8 '"AD;"(%/ 3,66%&3#8

$,&-3-!". 27=-3-".( /,6-&0 '5% EFGW( :%6% &2' ,&$-&/7,.

'5"' '5%-6 (36-! -((,%( 5"/ .%0". -$!.-3"'-2&(8 "&/ '5% 72.D

.2:-&0 (%3'-2& 6%?-%:( '5% [,6-(!6,/%&3% 2& &2&D&"'-2&".

3,66%&3-%( -&(27"6 "( -' $-05' 5"?% "77%3'%/ '5% ,(% 27 $,D&-3-!". (36-!)


27


30/177

!"# %#&'%(!) *+ !', '-!(.(/'!(*- 0.1(/

!"#$#%&'"#%( *+,,-#*'-. /-,- % *"00"# 1-%&+,- "1 -*"$

#"0'* ('1- '# &2- 3#'&-4 5&%&-. 1", &2- 6',.& 2%(1 "1 &2- 78&2

*-#&+,9: ;2- 1-4-,%( *"#.&'&+&'"# '&.-(1 '0-,#0-#&

*"+(4 '&.-(1 '..+- %&- =%#G #"&-.: M,"+#4-4 +-,#0-#&. &" '..+- -,- ('0'&. +- "#- 4"((%,B &2+. .'-/B &2- ('0'&-4 %&- .*,'"(>-4 %&&-0-. 2%4 '-/ "1 0"#-9 &2%& 0%4- '&. 4-6'#'&'"# % 0%&&-, "1

4-?,--: l1 &2- ;-]%. /%,,%#&.B h-*G2%0 /,"&-B A'& 0+.& #"&

"#(9 =- &2%& &2-9 %,- *%


31/177

!"#$" !&' ()*()')+,)- ./ ,") !&((&+,'0 1 233 4565 778 9:;

6?@?A?+ 2 #+ $?+,(&',; A&V#+F '$(#* &$$)*,&.@) E?( *&/IA)+, ?E ',&,) &+- @?$&@ ,&M)' &(FD&.@/ ')(G)- ,? E&$#@#,&,)

,") '$(#*H' ()-)A*,#?+; &+- +?, ,? *(?A?,) #,' $#($D@&,#?+

&' A?+)/5 [&+-&,#+F #,' $&+$)@@&,#?+ D*?+ *&/A)+, #+,?

AD+#$#*&@ ,()&'D(#)' 1(&,")( ,"&+ &@@?!#+F #, ,? .) ()#'I

'D)-B ',()'')- '$(#*H' *D(*?') &' & A)&+' ?E *&/#+F ADI

+#$#*&@ -).,'; (&,")( ,"&+ &' & $#($D@&,#+F A)-#DA5 6)$D(#+F

'$(#* !#," ,") F??- E," &+- $()-#, ?E & ',&,) #A*@#)- ,")

'$(#* !&' &+ ?.@#F&,#?+ ?E ,") ',&,) &' & '?G)()#F+ )+,#,/>

.),,)(; ',&,)' !)() &-G#')-; ,? A&V) '$(#* ,") ?.@#F&,#?+ ?E

& '*)$#U#$ ',&,) &F)+$/ &+- ')$D()- ./ ,") *@)-F) ?E '*)$#U#$

()G)+D) ',()&A'; &''),' ?( *(?*)(,#)'5 O#+&@@/; A&V#+F '$(#*

#+,)()',I.)&(#+F; &+- '*)$#E/#+F & -&,) ?E A&,D(#,/; D+-)(I'$?()- #,' $"&(&$,)( &' &+ )G#-)+$) ?E -).,; &+- +?, &+ #@@)I

F&@ #''D) ?E $D(()+$/ 1[?,, 2 &+- ,"?') A)($"&+,' !"? -#- &$$)*, '$(#* -#'I

$?D+,)- #, 'D.',&+,#&@@/5 R") E)!)( ,") +DA.)( ?E ?D,@),'

E?( '*)+-#+F ,") '$(#*; ,") A?() -#EU#$D@, #, .)$&A) ,? '*)+-

,") @&(F) -)+?A#+&,#?+ +?,)' 1E(?A ^2K &@@ ,") !&/ ,?^LKKB ?( ,? F#G) $"&+F) E?( ,")A #+ @)F&@ ,)+-)( ED+-'5 R")

@?$&@ D,#@#,/; !"#$" !&' D+D'D&@@/ F)+)(?D' #+ &$$)*,#+F ,")

'$(#* E?( 'A&@@ *&/A)+,'; E?D+- #,')@E #+D+-&,)- ./ ,)&$"I

)(' -)'*)(&,) ,? F), $&'" #+ $"&+F) 1\@G#+' =K2KB5

W+ $?+,(&', ,? Q"#$&F?H' -#'A&@ )M*)(#)+$); _),(?#, A&+I

&F)- ,") '#+F@) @&(F)', #''D) ?E AD+#$#*&@ '$(#* #+ ,")

4+#,)- 6,&,)' !#,"?D, '#A#@&( *(?.@)A' !#," -#'$?D+,#+F

&+- &$$)*,&.#@#,/5 _)'*#,) & -)'*)(&,) U#'$&@ '#,D&,#?+ $?AI


29

L O?( & $?+,)A*?(&(/ @)F&@ ?*#+#?+ E(?A ,") E)-)(&@ F?G)(+A)+,H' *)('*)$,#G); ')) `)(A&+ a@#*"&+, 1b)+)(&@ Q?D+')@; R()&'D(/ _)*&(,I

A)+,B ,? c)(+?+ X5 Z(?!+; d&+D&(/ 23; 2


32/177

!"#"$%& () *+,-".)/0 (+"( -1%2,3"(&4 ,3 )1(#,.+( 4&5"1%( $6

7&$#1"#6 89::; ?@ 2,%%,)3 ,3 0-#,! 5)# (+& 3&A( 6&"# "34 " +"%5B C#)3,-"%%6;

,( D"0 (+& -%)0,3. )5 8P () 5"-,%,("(& #&(",% (#"30H

"-(,)30; "34 ,3 +,.+ 4&3)2,3"(,)30 O1! () >8@@@P () !#)H

=,4& %"#.& +)%4 )5 0-#,! 01-+ "0 #&(",% (+& )!!)#(13,(6

)5 &A-+"3.,3. 2"36 %)D 4&3)2,3"(,)3 3)(&0 5)# (+& -)3H

=&3,&3-& )5 " 02"%% 312$ )5 (+& +,.+H4&3)2,3"(,)3

="#,&(6B Q+&0& -)1%4 $& (+&3 +&%4 &,(+ "0 ,3(&0(H$&"#,3.

,3=&0(2&3(0 O"0 $)340P; )# 10&4 ,3 !"62&3( )5 -,(6 ("A&0B

R+,%& ,3 (+& &"#%6 4"60 )5 (+& M@;@@@ ,3 [H2)3(+ 0-#,!

#"3.,3. ,3 ="%1& 5#)2 T -&3(0 () T 4)%%"#0B R,(+ $"#&%6 "

(+,#4 )5 ,(0 "00&00&4 0-+))% ("A&0 !",4 ,3 "34 >M@;@@@ 0(1-E

,3 (+& $"3E; (+& \D)00) I)"#4 )5 `41-"(,)3 5"-&4 2"00

%"6)550 )5 (&"-+ "34 "3 &"#%6 &34 () (+& 0-+))% 6&"#B C(

=)(&4 () ,001& >:@;@@@ ,3 " #"3.& )5 4&3)2,3"(,)30 1! ()

M@ 4)%%"#0 OQ+& \D)00) U#.10Ha#&00 89::G _"#-+ ?; 8@; 8TH

8SPB R+,%& 3&,(+ ,001& &A!,&3-&4 4,0-)13(,3.; (+& !#)$H

%&2 )5 2"E,3. -+"3.& 5)# (+& %"#.H="%1& 0-#,! %&4 () "

#&$"%"3-,3. )5 (+& 4&3)2,3"(,)30; "0 (+& -,(6 ,3-#&"0&4 (+&

312$ )5 TH-&3( 3)(&0 "34 #&(,#&4 (+& &b1,="%&3( ="%1& )5

T@H-&3( 3)(&0B _"3".&2&3( )5 (+& -,#-1%"(,)3 D"0 +"34%&4

$6 (+& *,(6 Q#&"01#/0 )5X,-&; D+,-+ 513-(,)3&4 "0 " $"3E

5)# (+& 0-#,!B I6 %"(& U!#,%; &A-&00,=& -,(6 "34 0-+))% 0-#,!

$"%"3-&0 D,(+ -(",3 2-+"3(0 D& "%%&=,"(&4 $6 (+&

*+"2$ )5 *)22-&; D+,-+ "-(&4 "0 " -%&"#,3. +)10& ()

#&4,#&-( 0-#,! () !&)!%& 3&&4,3. ,( () !"6 ("A&0B ^-#,! +)%4H

+"4 (+& )!(,)3 )5 -)3=(,3. 02"%% 3)(&0 ,3() (+& M@H

4)%%"# 4&3)2,3"(,)3; D+,-+ 13%,E& (+& )(+ D"0 ,3(&0(H

$&"#,3. OQ+& \D)00) U#.10Ha#&00 89::G _"#-+ MZK U!#,% T;

8M; M8; M?K _"6 8PB

Q+& \D)00) 0-+))% 6&"# &34&4 ,3 _"6 89:: D,(+ (&"-+#&-&,=,3. (+&,# X,3"% !"6 !"#(%6 ,3 0-#,!; !"#(%6 ,3 -"0+; "34

(+& I)"#4 )5 `41-"(,)3 D"0 "$%& () #&4&&2 (+& %"0( >9;@@@

)1(0("34,3. "( ,(0 ^&!(&2$ :@ 2"(1#,(6 4"(&B _&"3D+,%&;

(+& #&2",3,3. >8T;@@@ )5 \D)00)/0 -,(6 0-#,! D"0 #&(,#&4

)1( )5 ,3-)2,3. ("A #&-&,!(0 $6 ,(0 U1.10( 8T 4&"4%,3&B

c)3&(+&%&00; -)3(,31&4 %"..,3. ("A #&-&,!(0 41#,3. (+&

0122 2"4& " 0&-)34 ,001& )5 -,(6 0-#,! 3&-&00"#6; "34

>:@;@@@ 2)#& D"0 "1(+)#,J&4 $6 (+& &34 )5 (+& 6&"# )3

0,2,%"# ( () (+& X,#0( ,001&B OQ+& \D)00) U#.10Ha#&00

89::G _"6 M[K W1%6 M[HMSK ^&!(&2$ M9K c)=&2$ MZPB

\(+ %"#. 0-#,! ,001&0 &%0&D+& 2"4& 10& )5 0,2,%"#

"##"3.&2&3(0B Q) 010(",3 ,(0 -,#-1%"(,)3 )5 >ZZ@;@@@ ,3213,-,!"% "34 $)"#4 )5 &41-"(,)3 0-#,!; d#"34 e"!,40

O_,-+,."3P -#&"(&4 " fe&=)%=,3. 7134g )5 >8T@;@@@ ,3 -"0+

D+,-+ ,( 10&4 () !1#-+"0& 0-#,! 5#)2 0)1#-&0 (+"( +"4 "-H

-121%"(&4 &A-&00 01!!%,&0B Q+& 7134/0 4,#&-()# -"3="00&4

(+& -,(6/0 #&(",% &0("$%,0+2&3(0 () 4&(,3& D+& (+&0&

&A-&00&0 D& $1,%4,3.B U%(+)1.+ (+&6 D& 0&!"#"(& ("A,3.

"1(+)#,(,&0; (+& -,(6 "34 (+& $)"#4 )5 &41-"(,)3 ".#&&4 ()

"--&!( &"-+ )(+/0 0-#,! 5)# -,(6 "34 0-+))% ("A&0 O" 0,2,%"#

"##"3.&2&3( ,3=)%=,3. (+& D"( 1(,%,(6 !#&=",%&4 ,3 7%,3(;

_,-+,."3PB d#"34 e"!,40 2-+"3(0 "34 2"315"-(1#&0 "%0)

&3-)1#".&4 (+& -,#-1%"(,)3 )5 0-#,! $6 !"6,3. (+&,# )D3

&2!%)6&&0 M@N )5 (+&,# D".&0 ,3 0-#,!B C3 h)#",3 O\+,)P;,3410(#,&0 !1#-+"0&4 0-#,! 5)# (+&,# )D3 !"6#)%%0 4,#&-(%6

5#)2 (+& -,(6B OU2,-"3 _13,-,!"% U00)-,"(,)3 89:?K

_,(-+&%% "34 ^+"5 89Z?G M@@PB

_)$,%,J"(,)3 )5 !1$%,- "34 $10,3&00 01!!)#( "%0) $)%0(&4

(+& "--&!("$,%,(6 )5 0-#,! -,#-1%"(,)30B 7)# &A"2!%&; ,3 I,#H

2,3.+"2 O_,-+,."3P; (+& 0-+))% $)"#4 )#."3,J&4 -"2H

!",.30 () &3-)1#".& (+& 10& )5 0-+))% 0-#,! "0 2&"01#& )5

01!!)#( 5)# %)-"% 0-+))%0; "34 (&"-+/ -%1$0 2"#E&(&4 ,( "0

"3 ,3=&0(2&3( O*1#() 89?9PB Q+& R&0( a"%2 I&"-+ O7%)#H

,4"P *+"2$ )5 *)22-& "$"34)3&4 ,(0 )D3 !%"3 () ,0H

01& 0("2! 0-#,! ,3 5"=)# )5 !#)2)(,3. (+& -,(6/0 ("A "3(,-,H

!"(,)3 ="#,&(6 5)# (+& !"62&3( )5 $"-E ("A&0B C3 a,3&%%"0

*)13(6 O7%)#,4"P; D+& (&"-+ +"4 $&&3 !",4 ,3 0-#,!;

(+& 2-+"3(0/ "00)-,"(,)3 )5 ^(B a&($1#. 0)1.+( D"60 )5

E&&!,3. (+& 0-#,! %,b1,4 OQ+& a"%2 I&"-+ a)0( 89::G U!#,%

88; MMK ^(B a&($1#. Q,2&0 89::G W13& ZPB _,%D"1E&&/0

OR,0-)30,3P f$"$6 $)340g )=-"2& &"#%6 !#)$%&20 (+"3E0

() X,#2 %&"4+,! $6 (+& -,(6/0 5&,0(6 0)-,"%,0( 2"6)#;


33/177

!"#$"% '()*+, -.+/ '()01 234 ''54 62"+/ 7$89 :;"% 8"= '())1 P"?8"@B"= SU54

NE>$/">>">V >E??.=8 F.= >2=$? 2.EGA +G>. C$#" 83"@ >.@"

G"#"=+C" .#"= @E/$2$?+G W$/+/2"4 X8G+/8+V> >2=$? F+2"A +

>3+L9 >8+=8 $/ '()SI %3"/ 83" B+/L> %.EGA /.8 +22"?8 $8I

E/8$G 83" 2$89V> @"=2+/8$G" ">8+BG$>3@"/8I G"A B9 Y+G8"= -4

!$23I Z=">$A"/8 .F !$23V> ["?+=8@"/8 P8.="I E/$8"A +=.E/A +

?G+/ 8. +22"?8 >2=$? ?+=8G9 $/ "H23+/C" F.= 2+>3I ?+=8G9 $/

"H23+/C" F.= C..A>4 -"/2"F.=83 83" @"=23+/8> 3"GA +/ "FO

F"28$#" #"8. .#"= 83" E>" .F >2=$? $/ 2$89 W$/+/2">I %$833.GAO

$/C F.= "H+@?G" 83"$= >E??.=8 F.= + >"2./A >2=$? $>>E" $/

'())I %3$23 83" 2$89 C.#"=/@"/8 +88"@?8"A "#"/ +> ="O

A"@?8$./ .F 83" '()S $>>E" ="@+$/"A $/2.@?G"8" :N=.%/

'(\'I #.G4 ]1 )0, !.B"=A> '((K, ^G#$/> SK'K54

]/ @.>8 "H+@?G">I @E/$2$?+G$8$"> ?+$A .E8 G">> 83+/ 'KKD

.F 83"$= %+C"> +/A >+G+=$"> $/ >2=$?I %3$23 ?=.#$A"A ?=+28$O

2+G >E??.=8 8. $8> #+GE"4 M3" ?=.?.=8$./> .F >2=$? #+=O

$"A_`KD $/ ["8=.$8I *\D $/ Z+8"=>./ :;"% ""@"A 8.

B" @.=" + FE/28$./ .F 83" +#+$G+BG" 2+>3 =+83"= 83+/ +/9

.83"= 2./>$A"=+8$./4 X8G+/8$2 7$89 :;"% V %+C"> $/ 2+>3, +GG %+C"> +B.#"

83+8 %"=" ?+$A `*D $/ >2=$?4 N9 '()*I X8G+/8$2 7$89 ="AE2"A

>2=$? ?.=8$./ .F %+C"> 8. *KDI +/A ./G9 F.= ?+9A+9> $/ 83"

>"2./A 3+GF .F 83" @./834 !.9+G 6+L :R$23$C+/5 %3$23 3+A

+ 2.@?+=+8$#"G9 G./C =E/ .F >2=$? :'()'O'()05I #+=$"A 83"

?"=2"/8+C" .F >2=$? $>>E"A $/ "@?G.9"" %+C"> +/A >+G+=$">

F=.@ S*D 8. U*DI A"?"/A$/C E?./ 83" [email protected]/8 .F 2+>3 ./

3+/A4 aE$GF.=A 7.E/89I ;.=83 7+=.G$/+ E>"A >2=$? F.= 'KKD

.F %+C">I BE8 ./G9 B"2+E>" G.2+G B+/L> ="@+$/"A 2G.>"A

83=.EC3 @.>8 .F '()) +/A 2.@@E/$8$"> 83"=" %"=" A">?"=O

+8" F.= +/9 L$/A .F 2$=2EG+8$/C @"A$E@4 Q$L" 83" 2$89 .F

6%.>>. :R$23$C+/5I %3$23 +G>. ?+$A +GG %+C"> $/ >2=$?I aE$GO

F.=A 7.E/89 $>>E"A F=+28$./+G A"/.@$/+8$./> 83+8 @$/$O

@$c"A 83" ?=+28$2+G ?=.BG"@> .F @+L$/C >@+GG 23+/C"4 683O

"=%$>"I 3+#$/C +8 G"+>8 >.@" %+C" ?+9@"/8> @+A" $/ 2+>3

A$A G">>"/ 83" ?=.BG"@ .F ?".?G" >?"/A$/C >2=$? >$@?G9 $/

.=A"= 8. ="2"$#" 23+/C" $/ 2+>3I +/A ="AE2"A 83" /""A 8.

?=.AE2" G+=C" >E??G$"> .F 83" G.%">8OA"/.@$/+8$./ B$GG>

:d/$8"A P8+8"> 7./F"="/2" .F R+9.=> '()), X@"=$2+/ REO

/$2$?+G X>>.2$+8$./ '()\, ;+8$./+G RE/$2$?+G !"#$"%

'()*B1 \K*, -.+/ '()01 234 '', N=.%/ '(\'I #.G4 ]1 'US,

7E=8. '(\(54

d/G$L" >2=$? $>>E"A B9 B+=8"= +/A >"GFO3"G? C=.E?>I 8+H +/O

8$2$?+8$./ >2=$? $>>E"A B9 @E/$2$?+G$8$"> >EFF"="A +8 @.>8="G+8$#"G9 @.A">8 A$>2.E/8> +C+$/>8 >8+/A+=A FE/A>4 ]/

2.E/8 %3$23I ./ 8.? .F "eE+GG9OG+=C" 2E8> $/ 83"$=

/.@$/+G %+C" =+8">I ="?=">"/8"A + >EB>8+/8$+G BG.% 8. 83"

G$#$/C >8+/A+=A> .F @E/$2$?+G "@?G.9""> :73+88"=> '())A1

'U`O(54 M3" A$>2.E/8 ./ ["8=.$8V> >2=$? %+> $/$8$+GG9 G+=C"I

BE8 @.@"/8+=94 ]/ 3$> >E=#"9 .F U\ $>>E"> .F @E/$2$?+G

>2=$?I 2.E/8> .F E? 8. 'KD4 Y3$G" -+=?"= C$#"> /.>?"2$W$2 ="+>./> F.= 83">" A$>2.E/8>I >2+88"="A +/"2A.8+G

"#$A"/2" >ECC">8> >.@" 23+=+28"=$>8$2 2+E>"> .F A$>2.E/8O

$/C4

R$G%+EL""V> >2=$? ?G+/ %+> ?E>3"A 83=.EC3 $/ + 3.>8$G"

"/#$=./@"/8 :>"" +B.#"54 ]/ X8G+/8$2 7$89 :;"% @+GG ="8+$G"=> 2+E>"A 83" A$>2.E/8 ./ >2=$? 8.

%$A"/ 8. +> @E23 +> SKDI +G83.EC3 83" G+=C"= =">.=8 3.8"G>

>8"??"A $/ 8. "H?G.$8 83$> A$>2.E/8 $/ .=A"= 8. @""8 83"$=

.%/ 8+H BE=A"/>4 X> 83" A+8" .F ="A"@?8$./ F.=I +/A ?+9O

@"/8 .F $/8"=">8 ./I X8G+/8$2 7$89 >2=$? /"+="AI $8> /.8">

8=+A"A +> 3$C3 +> J'4KU :;+8$./+G RE/$2$?+G !"#$"% '()*+1

\K*, N=.%/ '(\'I f.G4 ]1 \\54 X> R./@.E83 7.E/89 $>>E"A

JSKKIKKK $/ >2=$? @./83 +F8"= @./83 F.= 8%. 9"+=>I B9

'()* 83" "@"=C"/2" .F + *D A$>2.E/8 >ECC">8"A >.@" A"O

C="" .F ?.?EG+= F+8$CE" %$83 83" A"#$2" :!"A N+/L !"C$>8"=

'()*1 X?=$G S*54 Z+8"=>./V> :;"% 2=$? F"GG 8. + A$>O

2.E/8 +F8"= G.2+G B+/L> ="FE>"A 8. 3+/AG" $8 :;.BG" '(U`1

(KO('54 M3" >23..G >2=$? .F Y$GA%..A :;"%

B.92.88"A B9 G.2+G @"=23+/8> E/8$G 83" 2$89 @+A" $8 +22"?8O

+BG" F.= $8> .%/ 8+H"> :62"+/ 7$89 P"/8$/"GOQ"AC"= '())1

R+9 S054 XG83.EC3 >E??.=8"A B9 $8> @"=2+/8$G" 2.@@E/$89I

X8G+/8+V> >2=$? A$A 8=+A" +8 + A$>2.E/8 .F +8 G"+>8 *D .E8>$A"

.F 83" @+g.= ="8+$G"=>I +22.=A$/C 8. .=+G 3$>8.=$"> :!.B"=A>

'((K54 73$2+C. %+> 83" G+=C">8 "H+@?G" .F +/ E/>+8$>F+2O8.=9 "H?"=$"/2"I %3"=" G$88G" 83.EC38 .= "FF.=8 >""@"A 8.

@+A" 8. 8E=/ @E/$2$?+G %+==+/8> $/8. + 2./#"/$"/8 @"O

A$E@ .F "H23+/C" F.= 83" G./CO>EFF"=$/C 8"+23"=>4 M3" ./G9

.E8=$C38 F+$GE=" .F 8+HOB+2L"A >2=$? >""@> 8. 3+#" .22E=="A

$/ ^=$" :Z"//>9G#+/$+5I %3"=" 83" BEGL .F + J)KKIKKK $>>E"

%+> ="?EA$+8"A E/A"= E/2"=8+$/ 2$=2E@>8+/2"> :R$823"GG

+/A P3+F"= '(`\1 SSU54

!"##$%# $' ()* )%(+,+-)(+$% #,.+-

X> -+=?"= :'(\`5 2./2GEA"A $/ 3$> >E=#"9 .F @E/$2$?+G

>2=$? "H?"=$"/2">I %3"83"= >2=$? %+> $/8"=">8OB"+=$/CI 2+GGO

+BG"I .= B+2L"A $/ + ?+=8$2EG+= %+9 %+> G">> $@?.=8+/8 8. $8>

>E22">> 83+/ 83" 2="A$B$G$89 .F $8> @+/+C"@"/84 X?+=8 F=.@

83" >3""= >$c" .F + C$#"/ >2=$? $>>E" ="G+8$#" 8. 83" +B$G$89 .F

G.2+G ="8+$G"=> 8. +B>.=B $8I 83" @.>8 $@?.=8+/8 F+28.= $/

>2=$?V> >E22">> %+> h83" "FW$2$"/29 .F +==+/C"@"/8> F.=

+#.$A$/C 83" 2G.CC$/C .F 23+//"G> $/ %3$23 $8 8"/A"A 8. +2O

2E@EG+8"i, $/ 8E=/I hj8k3" A"C="" .F 2..?"=+8$./ $/ ="2$=2EO

G+8$/C >2=$?lA"?"/A"A G+=C"G9 E?./ 83" 2./W$A"/2" .F @"=O

23+/8> $/ 83" W$/+/2$+G ?G+/> .F 83" G.2+G C.#"=/@"/8 +/A

83" [email protected]/8 .F $/8"GG$C"/8 +A#+/2"A ?G+//$/C +/A ?EBG$2$89

./ 83" ?+=8 .F ?EBG$2 .FW$2$+G>i :'S0O'SU54

M3" hW$/+/2$+G ?G+/>i -+=?"= +GGEA"A 8. ">>"/8$+GG9 "/#$>O+C"A 83" FE8E=" ="8$="@"/8 .F >2=$?I +> ="2.#"=$/C 8+H ="#"O

/E"> +/A >E22">>FEG A"B8 ="FE/A$/C ?G+/> :+> $/ ["8=.$8V>

"H+@?G"5 ="8E=/"A @E/$2$?+G W$/+/2"> 8. + 2+>3 B+>$>4


31


34/177

!"#$% '()' *$+),-'. /% $0".'"%1 *$2'. ()* 34$5"3"')'$* '($

',4% '/ .54"3 "% '($ $)4-6 789:.; "' F"#$ 6$)4 2/%* )'

)% "%'$4$.' 4)'$ -/

4)2-$ 2)%C F"%)%5"%1 H)%* $%'"4$-6 )2.$%'; "+ '($ .54"3 "%'$4$.' 2$)4"%1RK =/4$/#$4; .54"3 1)#$ =,%"5"3)-"'"$.

) F-$0"2"-"'6 '()' .')%*)4* ')0>)%'"5"3)'"/% F"%)%5"%1 -)5C$*?

M)%C -/)%. /4 ')0 %/'$. ()* '/ 2$ $%1)1$* "% -)41$; -,=3.,=. "% )*#)%5$ /+ ')0 4$5$"3'.? S% 5/%'4).'; .54"3 5/,-* 2$

"..,$* *"4$5'-6 +/4

'"#$ 5)3)5"'6 /+ -/5)- 1/#$4%=$%'.; 2).$* .54"3? S% '($ U=$4"5)% $03$4"$%5$

2).$*

.54"3 ". .,+F"5"$%' 3,2-"5

5/4*$* '/ .54"3 ) =$)%"%1+,- 4/-$ "% )%6 +,',4$ $5/%/="5

4$5/#$46? S%*$$*; '($ *$34$.."/% 6$)4.

#$4.$-6; '($ )2.$%5$ /+ .,5( -$)*$4.("3 H). "% B("5)1/R

5/,-* .)2/')1$ '($ ,.$ /+ .54"3? P/4 '($"4 3)4'; =,%"5"3)-

F"%)%5$ $03$4'. $#"%5$* )=2"#)-$%5$ '/'$4= 2/44/

"%1 34)5'"5$. '()' .C"4'$* '($ $*1$ /+ F".5)- 4$.3/%."2"-"'6?

^$.3"'$ .54"3G. .,55$..$.; "'. ."1%"F"5)%5$ ). ) =/%$')46=$*",=


35/177

!"#$%&'() +,$#"!$#"# -,./, -"012 2.3&++$&' "#/$

,$&1%,.$' %&4 '$/$.+%3 -"012 &11"- 5"6$'#!$#%3 %" '$%0'#

%" & /&3, 7&3.3 8902-.5 :; ?,$ @!$'./ A.%( :; Q&3%'"!&%%$" W$#%0'& UVVX> 70% 3$$

Y"127$'5 UV:VHI Z6$# .# %,$ Y$'! /,&'%&1.3% %'&2.%."#) "M

-,./, [#&++ -&3 %,$ !&\"' $4&!+1$) %,$ '"1$ "M %,$ 3%&%$S3

%&4.#5 +"-$' -&3 &//"'2$2 "#1( & !.#"' '"1$ 8Z11.3 :; _$/]0$% ?,.$3

UVVXHI Y$"MM'$( O#5,&!S3 +'"!.#$#% '$3%&%$!$#% "M %,$

/,&'%&1.3% +$'3+$/%.6$ %'&/$3 %,$ "'.5.#3 "M !"#$( %" .%3

M0#/%."# &3 & 0#.% "M &//"0#% M"' %,$ /&1/01&%."# "M 2$7%3

-.%, %,$ +'$6&.1.#5 !&%'.4 "M 3"/.&1 .#$]0&1.%.$3 !$2.&%$2

7( 3%&%$ +"-$'I @//"'2.#5 %" O#5,&!) J7"%, %,$ 1"5./

%,$ ,.3%"'./&1 "'.5.#3 "M !"#$( &'$ %" 7$ M"0#2 .# %,$ 3%&%$`Q"#$%&'( 3+&/$ .3 3"6$'$.5# 3+&/$> .% 2"$3 #"% /"#3.3% 3.!G

+1( .# %,$ 3(!7"1./ '$+'$3$#%&%."#3 "M !&'L$% %'&/%."#3)

&3 .% 2"$3 .# "'%,"2"4 $/"#"!./ %,$"'(K 8O#5,&! UVV=D FX>

3$$ &13" P'&( UVV=HI

P,&% %,$ /,&'%&1.3% &1(3.3 .110!.#&%$3 &7"0% %,$ @!$'.G

/ $4+$'.$#/$ "M %&4 %./.+&%."# 3/'.+ .3 2.MR./01% %" 3+$/G

.M(I O#5,&! ,.!3$1M .3 3L$+%./&1 &7"0% %,$ +"%$#%.&1 M"' 1"/&1

/0''$#/.$3 .#3"M&' &3 %,$( J2" #"% 5.6$ '.3$ %" %,$ /'$&%."#

"M +0'$ &73%'&/% 6&10$ .# %,$ M"'! "M %,$ 3"/.&1 '$1&%."# "M

/'$2.%G2$7%) ) /"#3$]0$#%1() #" !"#$( .# %,.3 3$#3$ .3

/'$&%$2 $#2"5$#"031( %,'"05, %,$ $4%$#3."# "M 7L 1$#2G

.#5KI @% 7$3%) 1"/&1 /0''$#/.$3 / M0#/%."# &3 1.!.%$2 +0'G

+"3$ !"#.$3) /"#R.#$2 %" 3+,$'$3 "M J.#%$'+$'3"#&1 %'03%

/"#R.2$#/$K> &% -"'3%) J%,$( %$#2 %" !&'5.#&1.B$ %,$

.#M"'!&1 $/"#"!( '$.#M"'/$ %,$ M'&5!$#%&%."#

.#$]0&1.%( "M %,$ -.2$' $/"#"!(K 8O#5,&! UVV=D :EC) :EXHI

T"' 3.!.1&' '$&3"#3 O#5,&! .3 207."03 &7"0% %,$ +'"3+$/%3

"M %,$ Z0'") 3.#/$ .%3 %$/,#"/'&%./ &2!.#.3%'&%."# 7(

.#2$+$#2$#% /$#%'&1 7L .3 #"% !&%/,$2 7( $]0.6&1$#%

Z0'"+$ 3"6$'$.5# &0%,"'.%(I

OM %,$ !"#$(G3"6$'$.5#%( #$403 .3 /"#3%.%0%.6$ "M J!"#$G

%&'( 3+&/$K) %,$# %,$ .!+1.$2 1$33"#3 "M %,$ ,.3%"'./&1 $4+$G

'.$#/$ -.%, %&4 %./.+&%."# 3/'.+ -.11 /"!$ M'"! -$'3%" +"1.%./&1 ]0$3%."#3 &7"0% %,$ +"-$'3 &0%"#"!( "M

1"/&1 5"6$'#!$#%3) #"% %" $/"#"!./ ]0$3%."#3 &7"0%

%,$ +0%&%.6$ 7$#$R.%3 "M 1"/&1 /0''$#/.$3I P,&% &'$ %,$ '$G

3+"#3.7.1.%.$3 +'"+$' 3/"+$ "M 1"/&1 5"6$'#!$#%3a N"-

&'$ %,$3$ %" 7$ &3/$'%&.#$2 &33$'%$2 &5&.#3% %,$ +"-$'3

+'$%$#%."#3 "M %,$ /$#%'&1 3%&%$a

^$6$#%( ($&'3 &5") %,$3$ ]0$3%."#3 -$'$ -$'$2 %" %,$

2$%'.!$#% "M 1"/&1 +"-$'I _"1./( '$3+"#3$3 %" %,$ Y'$&%

b$+'$33."# .# %,$ c#.%$2 ^%&%$3 ,&2 %,$ /0!01&%.6$ $MM$/% "M

2'&-.#5 +"-$' &-&( M'"! 1"/&1 /"!!0#.%.$3 %" %,$ 3%&%$3) M'"! 3%&%$3 %" %,$ /$#%'&1 5"6$'#!$#%I O#2$$2) M&' M'"!

'$5'$%%.#5 %,.3 %'M$' "M +"-$') !0#./.+&1 R.#/$ $4+$'%3

&26"/&%$2 -$1/"!$2 %,$ /$#%'&1.B&%."# "M %&4.#5

+"-$' %,$ 3073$]0$#% '$1./$ "M 1"/&1 5"6$'#!$#%3

"# M$2$'&1 3%&%$ 5'%3G.#G&.2 8N.11,"03$ :;


36/177

!!! #$%&&'( )*+,-.-/01 2-,0,.3 456378 9+'1-. *0,0:3;3,6 /?-1(@ $$A!$$BC

!!! #$%&&.( )*+,-.-/01 2-,0,.3 456378 9+'1-. *0,0:3;3,6 -H L5? J,3;/15E;3,6 M31-3LC BG,H

K5,:CN G,H 7377CN O D0,+0?EC

!!! #$%&P( )*+,-.-/01 2-,0,.3 456378 9+'1-. *0,0:3;3,6 1'3?6 *C S-11R5+73 #$%&%( T5.01 U5V3?,;3,6

W3'6 >H;-,-76?06-5, #4X@ 9?3,6-.3!S011(C

K5;;3?.-01 0,H 2-,0,.-01 KR?5,-.13 #$%&&( )I6063 0,H K-6E W3!

/0?6;3,68 #>/?-1 GG(@ GFGA!B

K+?65N DCDC #$%P%( *-.R-:0, W3/?377-5, I.?-/ 5L 6R3 $%&Y7 #>;3?-!

.0, 4+;-7;06-. >775.-06-5,(C

W3 X5+,:N KR?-7 #$%&A( Z+H:36-,: -, 9+'1-. I.R5517 #U0?H3, K-6EN

4X@ W5+'13H0EN W5?0,(C

W+,'0?N KR0?137 2C #$%A% [$F%B\( T0]7 5L 6R3 J,-63H I60637 M3106!

-,: 65 K+??3,.EN 2-,0,.3N 0,H Z0,^-,: L?5; $BF% 65 $F%A #4X@

>+:+76+7 *C _3113E(C

W+,,3N U3?01H `C #$%AY( *5,360?E W3.-7-5,7 5L 6R3 I+/?3;3 K5+?6

#M+6:3?7 J,-V3?7-6E 9?377(C

a11-7N S5]0?H IC #$%&P( U3?;0, *5,360?E `R35?E $%YO!$%&&C

#S0?V0?H J,-V3?7-6E 9?377(C

a1V-,7N I0?0R #GYYO( )90,0.30 5? W+H@ M360-13?7 M30.6 65 I.?-/ -,

6R3 U?306 W3/?377-5,8 Z+7-,377 0,H a.5,5;-. S-765?E b,1-,3 &@ $!

$BC

R66/@cc]]]CR!,36C5?:cd'+7-,377c'R.]3'c/+'1-.06-5,7cZaS5,1-,

3cGYYOc31V-,7C/HL

!!! #GY$Y( )I.?-/N I65?37N 0,H K07R!I6?0//3H K-6-37@ >;3?-.0, M3!

60-13?7 0,H >163?,06-V3 K+??3,.E H+?-,: 6R3 U?306 W3/?377-5,8

D5+?,01 5L S-765?-.01 M3730?.R -, *0?^36-,: G@ FA!$YBC

25?76063?N *06R3] #GYYA( )`0e!W?-V3, *5,3E@ >HH-6-5,01 aV-!

H3,.3 L?5; 6R3 S-765?E 5L a.5,5;-. `R5+:R6N a.5,5;-. S-765?E

0,H a.5,5;-. 951-.E8N -, K5;/13e-6EN a,H5:3,5+7 *5,3EN 0,H

*0.?53.5,5;-. `R35?EN 3HC *0?^ I3663?f-31HC #aH]0?H a1:0?(@ GYG!

GGYC

U06.RN T5?3, #GYYF(8T5.01 *5,3E -, 6R3 J,-63H I60637 W+?-,: 6R3

U?306 W3/?377-5,8 a770E7 -, a.5,5;-. 0,H Z+7-,377 S-765?E ;3?-.0,

T3:-71065?7h >775.-06-5,(C

406-5,01 *+,-.-/01 M3V-3] #$%&O0( )Z0'E Z5,H7 0,H Q,.?3073H

`0e K5113.6-5,7 I0V3 *-1]0+^338 =51C +:+76G%C

43] X5?^ `-;37C $%&&C )b.30, K-6E Q77+37 I.?-/8 #*0?.R $F(@ OC

!!! #$%&P( )43] D3?73E `0e37 X-31H jA&NF$YN%$FC &B 93? K3,6 5L

T3VE K5113.63HN Q,.5;/1363 M3/5?6 L5? I-e *5,6R7 W-7.157378

#>+:+76 O(@ $FC

!!! #$%&O( )*5,;5+6R K5+,6E 910,7 M3f-,0,.-,:8 #D+1E P(@ GOC

!!! #$%&A( )>610,6-. K5+,6E >.67 5, W3'6 910,8 #*0E G(@ G&C

45'13N M-.R0?H >C #$%BF( )9063?75,h7 M37/5,73 65 6R3 U?306 W3!

/?377-5,8 43] D3?73E S-765?E %A #23'?+0?E(@ FB!%FC

4+77'0+;N >?6R+? #$%&B( )`R3 T0] 5L 6R3 W5110?8 K51+;'-0 T0]

M3V-3] &B #45V3;'3?(@ $YOB!$Y%$C

!!! #$%OY( *5,3E -, 6R3 T0] #Z?55^1E,N 4X@ `R3 25+,H06-5,

9?377(C

!!! #$%OB( > S-765?E 5L 6R3 W5110? #K51+;'-0 J,-V3?7-6E 9?377(C

b.30, K-6E [43] D3?73E\ I3,6-,31!T3H:3? $%&&@ V0?-5+7 H0637C

93.k+36N U0?E *CN 0,H K1-LL5?H 2C `R-37 #GYYB( )`3e07 `?307+?E

45637 0,H *0?^36 *0,-/+106-5,N $F&B!$FPG8 ae/15?06-5,7 -, a.5!

,5;-. S-765?E PP@ F$!%%C

9-3?75,N >?6R+? 4C #$%&P( )`R3 J73 5L I.?-/ 5? Z0'E Z5,H78 43]

D3?73E *+,-.-/01-6-37


37/177

!"#$%&'()* ,-.- /0122 3014056 789(:$"; Q:$ 7&&":(?6-

!'>9()?* R:QQ:"8 /011T6 UV9;)9(? '& #%9 @9W#K#'KV"?# !9?'(#B 6 U789(:$"; S'Q';:"Q C';9#"(H !9I:89?B ]%9 [":QN(9 '&

#%9 `N";#:#H ]%9'(H ";) '(* C:$%:I";5 @9F?KD"QQ"):N8 /01JJ6B M"(:'N?

)"#9?-

]%9 \F'??' 7(IN?KD(9?? /01JJ6B M"(:'N? )"#9?-

]%9 D"Q8 ,9"$% D'?# /01JJ6B M"(:'N? )"#9?-

]%9 ]'Q9)' S:#H G'N(;"Q /01JJ6 U]%9 C"(?%"QQ ,:QQ PWOQ":;9)Z ecXX

/7O(:Q bb6B 0JLK^-

]:9)98";* S%(:?#'O%9( Y- /0^1^6 7 ](9"#:?9 '; #%9 V"F '& ,:QQ? ";)

@'#9? /Q98? '& #%9 S:#H '& =9#(':#

:; #%9 =9O(9??:';- !9O'(# @'- 0a0- =9#(':# ,N(9"N '& Y'M9(;89;#"Q

!9?9"($%* X;$- /9(6-

R:$E9(* PQ8N? /01^a6 UC';9#"(H


38/177


Community Currency ResearchVolume 16 (2012) Section

Ijccr-2012-Vol-16-Special-Issue-complete3 - IJCCR 2012 Vol 16 Special Issue Complete

Documents

Transcript of Ijccr-2012-Vol-16-Special-Issue-complete3 - IJCCR 2012 Vol 16 Special Issue Complete