II~ ~ ~ Xlftr ~ ~ 3tR - delhiassembly.nic.in · 3 citizens as guaranteed byArticle14and 21ofthe...
Transcript of II~ ~ ~ Xlftr ~ ~ 3tR - delhiassembly.nic.in · 3 citizens as guaranteed byArticle14and 21ofthe...
~ ~ "WtfR Pt~llcl~
"<I~~ ~ ffi ~~l *1"<4>1"<
~ 9, ~ *1R1qlcl~, ~~ 110054~ ctlxii4h1 ~ ~:- 75
mcm=rf cpJ -;:w:r:- ~ +i"'1Ri1"'G X ftrn" ~-qm \34!!{..~s:j?fl <ffi ~ ~ cpqr ~ 14>:-
~-22,03,2018
q) ~ ~ m ~ ~ qt:f 31lq'R:ct ~ ~ ~ ~ m cpl 2017-18 cf>xrfu ~ m if ~ ~ ~ xrfu cpJ ~ ~ qt:f 190 ~ ~fcl q X01 Cfm t? ~ £f\ilC 31:PfA "'<lfu RR ~
~ I ~ "C1C5 (28 ~ 2018 "C1C5)m if 99,96 ~ ~ ~xrfu~~~tl
fcl $114'11 cf> ~ ()mx m cf> ~Ri1dJG IX czrfcffi" cpJ fclq x 0 I cmr t?
fcl$114"'1 ~ m ~~ cnTi aNT ~~ ~ ~ PI C!~n cpJ fclqxol cmr t?
fcl $114 "'1 cpJ \ill {) Cf)ct f fcM-rT fcl $114"'1~ ~ cf> ~ 31lq~~Cf) ~~ 'fil+i!fl ~ Cf)xqlC1l t I ~'fil +i!fl cf> 3mlN -qx ~ '(1'<Cf)Ix~ fcl$1 I4"'1 ~ ~ ~tT~/~~qrN) cf> ~ if~T.ft~ti ~\rlrf1;q\j cf> ~ ~ fife,311\3C::;S1x ~ ~ Jl~l PI Cf) fcl $114"'1 Cf)f
~ ()mx fc)Rrr \JffC1T ~ I ~"'f1"1fflJ ~ cf> 31'j}il G"'1 cf> 6ffG~ fc)Rrr \JffC1T t I
+i1"'14)~ \3 i5qct+i ~(YI<l cf> 'fi XCf)I{)fcl$114'1'j cpl ~ m cf> 13 ~2015 3fR TfTT.f 18, 2016 cpl ~ ~f.1"uflr 1ft ~ ~-~ cpJ 3mlNtl ~ Plof;q1 ~ ~ ~ tl
~ ~ PlC!~I) cpJ 31j41<:'1""1 'tlPl~ilctm ~ cmr "CPG1l ~ ~ ~?
1
~ ~ m PI~~IIC't~ -;l \3"6i1ct+i'"""l1~1C't~ cf> ~ ~-~ ~31j4 1C't"'11 ~f1~ilct m cf> ~~-~ -qx ~ 'tlxCf)Ix cf>~~cf>~~~~~I~~~~I
j
fqOO cftrr ~ -if ~ em 3llciRct if\ilCcpr "CfffifCf II ~ ~ ~ X"lftr ~ ~Fctq,<01 CflIT t?3tR
2
~ ~ 'ti,<q)I~ ~ (~) t,\ill fcn t1~'tiI~t1 cj\if)q),<01 ~1860 ~ "d1Rf 4·\if)cpd t I
4814\S<.'11~ ~ ~ ~3/3/2013/\if)~;g)/~/~\Jfl~t) III / 1720-1731 ~'1iq) 23.04.2015 ~ aRT ~ ~ ~ em~cfr~~1
~ (nr~~I'1 ~ ~~3lj~P'1q) 1 -if ~ t I
~ em ~ 'ti,<q)I,< aRT ~if\ilC 3i Iq·red "'"11ft fcnm \JlTctT t I~3ffifi ~ -if ~ em ~'ti ,<q) I'< ~ aRT 3PJGFf ~ 50~~RR~ll<l~\illfcn~ ~ 31N ~ 'ti,<q)I,< em ~~qtf~~l{~~~l"flIT I~ ~ tGl~ct Fct$l14'1 ~(~) t, \ill fcn 3l1AT 3TT<l cpr3l\iA" ~ ~ t I ~ 3TT<l cprm Fct$II 4 'i'l ~ ~ cm_:;rr 15~RI~lct q)Sil~I'1 t I
Fct$II 4 '1 cpr "11~ q) ctf fcMTlf Fct$II 4 '1"\J1'"RT ~ ~ 3lIq~~q) ~ ~'tiIJi!ll \34C'l&:l q),<q Ict I t I ~'ti IJi!ll ~ 3TltlR "4X ~ 'ti '<q) 1'<~ Fct$l14'1 ~ ~ fife,
\ . ~ \~ Fct3l1\3c'5I'< ~ ~ ~j q)$I14'1 cpr~ ~ CfRCIT ~ I ~ ~al1l~ ~ 31j+t~G '1 ~ €fIG "\J1'"RTfcl><rr \jffifT t I
Dr, ,I/\'(/;O[V SARANGI, lAS"" Secretary (I&P,c~)'.1:2 (~fInfor,mation & Publicity
',el't. ot ~~CTof Delhi
••~ 1TI:r
~1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.10.
11.12.
13.14.15.
16.
17.18.19.20.21.22.23.24.25.26.27.28.29.
~tf1R I
~tf1R 60,000/-~tf1R 45,000/-
~tf1R 35,000/-~tf1R 30,000/-
~tf1R 30,000/-~tf1R 30,000/-
M/s ICSIL ffiRT 27,000/-tf1R)
27,000/-
27,000/-~)~)~) 17,916/-~) 17,916/-~) 16,468/-~) "~)
17,916/-17,916/-
~ ~)~ 0 it 0 1:ffl0 (W<TRf1 )
~°it°1:ffl° ~)
· , 1.~.,
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 13 OF 2003
COMMONCAUSE ...PETITIONER(S)
VERSUSUNIONOF INDIA ...RESPONDENT (S)
WITH
W.P. (C) No. 197 of 2004&
W.P. (C) No.302 of 2012
JUDGMENT
RANJAN GOGOI, J.
1. Common Cause and Centre for Public Interest Litigation,
two registered bodies, have approached this Court under
Article 32 of the Constitution seeking an appropriate writ to
restrain the Union of India and all State Governments from
using public funds on Government advertisements which are
primarily intended to project individual functionaries of the
Government or a political party. The writ petitioners have also
2 I,
prayed for laying down of appropriate guidelines by this CourtI
to regulate Government action in the matter so as to prevent
misuse/wastage of public funds in connection with such
•
advertisements.
2. In the above stated writ petitions the writ peJitioners
while conceding the beneficial effect of gov1rnment
advertisements which convey necessary information to the
citizens with regard to various welfare and· pro~ressive
measures as also their rights and entitlements, however, had
contended that in the garb of communicating with the people,I
in many instances, undue political advantage and mileage is
sought to be achieved by personifying individuals and
crediting such individuals or political leaders (who ane eitherI
from a political party or government functionaries) as being
responsible for various government achievements and
progressive plans. According to the petitioners such Ipractice
becomes rampant on the eve of the elections. Such
advertisements not only result in gross wastage ot public
funds but constitute misuse of governmental powers I besides
derogating the fundamental rights of a large section of the
3
citizens as guaranteed by Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution
of India.
3. The writ petitions, filed as public interest litigations, were
resisted by the Union of India primarily on the ground that the
issues sought to be raised pertain to governmental policies
and executive decisions in respect of which it may not be
appropriate for this Court to lay down binding guidelines
under Article 142. The decision of this Court in Manzoor Ali
Khan & Anr. Vs. Union of India & Ors.! and a
pronouncement of the Delhi High Court in Umesh Mohan
Sethi Vs. Union of India & Anr ..2 have been relied upon by
the Union in support of its above stated stand.
4. The issues arising in the writ petitions were considered
by this Court in an earlier round of exhaustive hearings. By
order dated 23.04.2014, this Court, on consideration of the
respective stands of the parties and by relying on the
principles laid down in the decisions specifically referred to in
the aforesaid order dated 23.04.2014, inter alia, held that
there is no dispute that "primary cause of government
1 (2014) 7 see 3212 WP (C) NO.2926 0[2012 decided on 12.12.2012
4
advertisement is to use public funds to inform the Pfblic of
their rights, obligations, and entitlements as well as to explain
•Government policies, programmes, services and initiatives." It
was further held that only such government advertisements
which do not fulfil the above requisites will fall foul of the area
of permissible advertisements. This Court aCknowledfed the
fact that the dividing line between permissible advertisements
that are a part of government messaging and adverti4ements
that are "politically motivated" may at times gets blurred. As
the materials laid before the Court by the parties were found
to be inadequate for the purpose of evolvingwhat woulf be the
best practices keeping in view the prevailing scenario in other
jurisdictions across the globe, this Court felt the nectssity of
constituting a Committee consisting of (1) Prof. (Dr.) N.R.
Madhava Menon, former Director, National Judicial Abademy,
Bhopal (2) Mr. T.K. Viswanathan, former Secretary General,
Lok Sabha and (3) Mr. Ranjit Kumar, Senior Advocale to go
into the matter and submit a report to the Court.
5. In terms of the order of this Court, the Committee was
duly constituted and after full deliberations in the nlatter, a
5
report had been submitted by the Committee suggesting a set
of guidelines for approval of this Court. It is the plea of the
petitioner that the said guidelines should be approved by this
Court and directions be issued under Article 142 of the
Constitution of India for enforcement of the said guidelines
until an appropriate legislation in this regard is brought into
effect by the Parliament.
6. The contents of the guidelines suggested by the court
appointed Committee may be usefully extracted hereinbelow:-
"GUIDELINES ON CONTENT REGULATION OFGOVERNMENT ADVERTISING
(1) These Guidelines shall be called the GovernmentAdvertisement (Content Regulation) Guidelines2014.
(2) They shall come into force with effect from......
2. APPLICATION:
(1) These Guidelines shall apply to all Governmentadvertisements other than ClassifiedAdvertisements.
(2) These Guidelines shall apply to the content ofall Government Advertising till a suitable legislationis enacted by the Government to prevent the misuseof public funds on advertisements to gain politicalmileage as distinct from legitimate GovernmentmessagIng.
6,,
(3) These Guidelines shall apply to all- •(a) institutions of Government;
(b) public sector undertakings;
(c) local bodies and other autonomousbodiesj organizations established under aStatute.
3. DEFINITIONS:
In these Guidelines unless the context ~therwiserequires: I
(a) "Classified Advertisements" include publicnotices, tenders, recruitment notices, rtatutorynotifications.
(b) "DAVPGuidelines" means the existing guidelinesof the Directorate of Advertising and VisualPublicity of the Ministry of Information andBroadcasting dealing with the eligibility andempanelment procedures and rates of paymentand such other matters;
(c) "Government" means Central Government, StateGovernments jUnion Territory Administrationsand also includes local bodies, public sectorundertakings and other autonomousbodies j organisations established under aStatute.
(d) "Government advertising" means any lessage,conveyed and paid for by the government forplacement in media such as new~papers,television, radio, internet, cinema arid suchother, media but does not include Classifiedadvertisements; and includes both copy (writtentext / audio) and creatives (visuals / vidr / multi
7
media) put out In print, electronic, outdoor ordigital media.
OBJECTS:
The objects of these Guidelines are:-
(a) to prevent arbitrary use of public funds foradvertising by public authorities to project particularpersonalities, parties or governments without anyattendant public interest.
(b) neither to belittle the need nor to deny the authorityof the Union and State Governments and its agencies todisseminate information necessary for public to know onthe policies and programmes of Government but only toexclude the possibility of any misuse of public funds onadvertisement campaigns in order to gain politicalmileage by the political establishment;
(c) to address the gap in the existing DAVPGuidelineswhich only deal with the eligibility and empanelment ofnewspapers/journals or other media, their rates ofpayment, and such like matters and not on how toregulate the content of Government advertisements;
(d) to ensure that "all government activities satisfy thetest of reasonableness and public interest, particularlywhile dealing with public funds and property";
(e) to ensure that government messaging is wellco-ordinate, effectively managed in the best democratictraditions and is responsive to the diverse informationneeds of the public.
5. GOVERNMENT ADVERTISEMENT TO INFORMCITIZENS
Subject to these Guidelines Government may placeadvertisements or purchase advertising space or
8
6.
time in any medium to inform citizens about theirrights and responsibilities, about governmentpolicies, programmes, services or initiatives, orabout dangers or risks to public health, safety orthe environment. i
THE FIVE PRINCIPLES OF CJNTENTREGULATION:
•
While placing advertisements or purchasingadvertising space in any media, the Governmentshall be guided by the following principles, namely:-
(1) Advertising Campaigns to be relt· ted toGovernment responsibilities:
!
While it is the duty of the Government toprovide the public with timely, accurate, clear,objective and complete information about itspolicies, programmes, services and initiativessince the public has a right tr· suchinformation, the content of gov rnmentadvertisements should be relevant! to thegovernments' constitutional and legalobligations as well as the citizens' rights andentitlements.
(2) Advertisement materials should bepresented in an objective, farr andaccessible manner and be designed 0 meetthe objectives of the campaign:
(i) The material shall be presented in a fairand objective manner and shall becapable of fulfilling the intendedobjectives;
I
(ii) Government shall exercise due I cautionwhile deciding the content, layout, sizeand design of the message including thetarget area and the creative requirementof the intended communication in order
9
to ensure that the maximum reach andimpact are achieved in the most costeffectivemanner;
(iii) Content of advertisement must enable therecipients of the information todistinguish between facts and analysisand where information is presented as afact, it should be accurate and verifiable;
(iv) Pre-existing policies, products, servicesand initiatives should not be presented asnew unless there has been a substantialchange or modification of such policies,products or services;
(v) Content of advertisement should provideinformation In a manner thataccommodates special needs ofdisadvantaged individuals or groupsidentified as being within the targetaudience;
(vi) Multiple formats may be used to ensureequal access;
(vii) Every effort shall be made to pre-test thematerial in case of large scale campaignwith target audiences.
(3) Advertisement materials should be objective andnot directed at promoting political interests ofruling party:
(i) Display material must be presented inobjective language and be free of politicalargument or partisan standpoint:
1 "
"(ii) Government advertising shall maintainpolitical neutrality and avoid glorification ofpolitical personalities and projecting a positiveimpression of the party in power or a pegativeimpression of parties critical of thegovernment.
(iii) Advertisement materials must not -
(a) Mention the party in government by name;(b) directly attack the VIews or actions of
others in opposition;I
(c) include party political symbol orl logo orflag;
(d) aim to influence public supportt for apolitical party, candidate for election; or
(e) refer to link to the websites of Ipoliticalparties or politicians. I
(iv) Government advertisement materials I shouldavoid photographs of political leaders land if itis felt essential for effective Governmentmessaging, only the photographs I of thePresident/Prime Minster or Governbr/ChiefMinister should be used;
(v) • IGovernment advertisements shall not be usedat patronizing media houses or aimed atreceiving favourable reporting for the Iparty orperson In power I
(4) Advertisement Campaigns be justified andundertaken in an efficferrt andcost-effective manner:
I
(a) Since it is the responsibility of gover9ment tosafeguard the trust and confidence in theintegrity and impartiality of public services and
,< 11
hence it should be the policy of governments touse public funds in such a manner as toobtain maximum value for taxpayers' money;
(b) Advertisement Campaigns must be justifiedand undertaken In an efficient andcost-effective manner;
(c) The Government shall-
(i) decide and announce beforehand, a list ofpersonalities on whose birth or deathanniversaries, advertisements could bereleased every year and specify whichMinistryjDepartment could release thesame;
(ii) avoid the issue of multipleadvertisements by different departmentsand PSUs of the same Government inCommemorative Advertisements andshall issue a single advertisement only;
(d) Though advertising by governments shouldremain regulated all the time, it is particularlyimportant to scrupulously follow theseprinciples before and during the elections. Asfar as possible, during the period prior toelections, only those advertisements requiredby law (such as public health and safetyadvisories or job and contract advertisements)alone be released by governments;
(e) Advertisement campaigns should only be needbased; and
(f) In case of large volume advertisementcampaigns, post-campaign impact assessmentis necessary to be included in the planningprocess itself and shall identify the indicatorsto measure success when the campaign hasended.
• 1
(5) Government advertising must comply withlegal requirements and financial regulations andprocedures:
Governments shall ensure that all Advertisementscomply with:-
(i) relevant laws regarding privacy, intellectualproperty rights, election laws and consumerprotection laws apart from laws in respect ofbroadcasting and media; and '
"
•
(ii) copyright laws and ownership rightsassociated with works subject to copyright arefully respected. :
COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT:,
(1) The Government shall appoint an Ombudsman whoshall be an eminent expert independent of theGovernment to receive complaints of violations ofGuidelines and to recommend action in accordance
,
with the Guidelines.,,,
(2) Heads of government departments and agenciesshall be responsible for ensuring complianc€ withthese Guidelines and shall follow a procedure ofcertification of compliance before advertisementsare released to the media. :
(3) As part of the performanceMinistry / Departmen t / Agency -
audit of the,
(a),
there shall be separate audit bf theI
compliance of Advertisement Guidelines by theMinistry /Department/ Agency concerned; and
,,I,
(b) The annual report of, suchministry / department/ agency shall publish thefindings of such audit and the money spent onadvertising. !
I
(4) The regulatory bodies of print and electronic mediawill be within their powers to impose sanctionsagainst such media groups acting against theseGuidelines in seeking or obtaining governmentadvertisemen ts.
8. GENERAL:
(1) These Guidelines shall be in addition to andnot in derogation of the existing Guidelineswhich are in place under the existingAdvertisement Policyof Government.
(2) These Guidelines are equally applicable toState Governments and its agencies. The StateGovernments shall undertake amendments towhatever policies they have in this regard andobserve the Guidelines strictly in letter andspirit.
(3) The Ombudsman may recommend suitablechanges to the Guidelines to deal with newcircumstances and situations.
(4) The Government shall take necessary steps toinitiate necessary legislation on the subject,given its importance for democracy, humanrights and good governance."
*******
Whether the iuidelines recommended shouldcommend acceptance and if so whether thesame should be made operative and enforceableunder Article 142 of the Constitution.
7. In the earlier order dated 23rd April, 2014, this Court,
after holding that reasonableness and fairness consistent with
1
Article 14 of the Constitution would be the ultimate test of all •State activities proceeded to hold that the deployment of
public funds in any Government activity which is: notI
connected with a public purpose would justify judicialI
intervention. We would like to say something more.
I
Part IV of the Constitution is as much a guiding light forI
the Judicial organ of the State as the Executive ana theI
I
Legislative arms, all three being integral parts of the "State"II
within the meaning of Article 12 of the Conatitution.i'-" A'policyI
certainly cannot be axed for its alleged failure to complr withI
any of the provisions of Part IV. Neither can the CourtsI
I
charter a course, merely on the strength of the provisions ofI
I• I
the said Part of the Constitution, if the effect thereof would beI
to lay down a policy. However, in a situation where the: field isIII
open and uncovered by any government policy, to guide andII
I
control everyday governmental action, surely, in the exercise ofI
I
I
jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution, parametersII
can be laid down by this Court consistent with the: objectsI
I
enumerated by any of the provisions of Part IV. Such anI
3 Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar & Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors. -AIR 1967 SC 1=(1966) B SCR 744II
4 Kesavananda Bharati SripadagalvaruVs. State of Kerala & Anr. - (1973) 4 scc 225 (Para ~703)I
exercise would be naturally time bound i.e. till the Legislature
or the Executive, as the case may be, steps in to fulfill its
constitutional role and authority by framing an appropriate
policy.
8. Article 38 and 39 of the Constitution enjoin upon the
State a duty to consistently endeavour to achieve social and
economic justice to the teeming millions of the country who
even today live behind an artificially drawn poverty line. What
can be the surer way in the march forward than by ensuring
avoidance of unproductive expenditure of public funds. This
is how we view the present matter and feel the necessity of
exercise of our jurisdiction under Article 142
Constitution to proceed further.
of the
9. It is neither possible nor feasible or even necessary to try
and encompass the myriad situations where government
advertisements are issued. Indeed, the situations and
circumstances; events and occasions on which government
advertisements are issued are infinite. Nevertheless, an
attempt can be made to arrive at a broad categorization for the
purpose of an illustrative understanding.
1,
Advertisements highlighting completion of afixed period of the Government's Tenure
Governments at the Centre as well as in the States often
bring out advertisements on completion of a number of Clays,,
months and years of governance. In such advertisements, notI
I
only the 'achievements' are highlighted even the different .tasks,
which are in contemplation are enumerated. By w;ay of
example one of the points highlighted may be supply ofI
electricity to each and every village. Though the achievementsI
I
of a Government should not be a matter of publicity and really,
I
ought to be a matter of perception to be felt by the citizens on,
the results achieved, such advertisements do have the effect ofI
I
keeping the citizens informed of the government functioningI
and therefore would be permissible.
Advertisements announcing projects:
On an everyday basis both the Government at the CentreII
I
as well as in different States issue advertisements announcing,
,
events like laying of the foundation of different developmentI
projects or the inauguration of projects completed. In rnany of
such advertisements the results obtained in the particularI
1
field covered by the advertisement and the plan/targets for the
future are highlighted. Though such advertisements may look
like a report card of the Government there is an element of
informative content in such advertisements inasmuch as
information is conveyed to the citizens as regards government
programmes, policies and achievements.
Advertisements issued on the occasion ofbirth/death anniversaries and such other events:
Government advertisements are issued in the memory of
great personalities who occupy a significant place in our
history, such as, the father of the Nation, Mahatma Gandhi.
While such persons must certainly be remembered, what,
however, would not be justified is several similar, if not
identical, advertisements issued by different Departments on
the same occasion as is happening today. One single
advertisement issued by a Central Agency should be enough to
commemorate the anniversaries of the few acknowledged and
undisputed public figures whose contribution to the National
Cause cannot raise any dispute or debate.
1
Advertisement issued on certain other occasions, forI
•I
instance, to mark the centenary year of the Patna High Court
does not serve any purpose and must be avoided. InstitutionsI
I
need not be glorified. They must earn glory by contribution
and work.
Advertisements announcing policies and benefitsfor public:
I
All advertisements that fall within this category would beI
In public interest. Such advertisements, as for example inII
I
respect of the National Savings Schemes informing the .publicI
about benefits under the Scheme, are purely informational
and make people aware of their rights and entitlements.I
Similarly, advertisements issued to generate public aw~renessII
would also be justified on the touchstone of public interest.II
I
Byway of illustration, an advertisement issued by the Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare informing the public ofI
I
preventable disease, safeguards to be taken, vaccinationII
programmes for the children, etc. would be highly informativeI
and, therefore, justified.
10. A connected facet of the matter which cannot be ignored
is the power of the Government to give/award advertisements
to selected media houses and the concomitant issue of
freedom of press. Award of advertisements, naturally, brings
financial benefit to the particular media house/newspaper
group. Patronization of any particular media house(s) must be
avoided and award of advertisements must be on an equal
basis to all newspapers who may, however, be categorized
depending upon their circulation. The D.A.V.P. guidelines do
not deal with the said aspect of the matter and hence the
necessity of incorporating the same in the present directions
to ensure the independence, impartiality and the neutrality of
the fourth estate which is vital to the growth and sustenance
of democracy will have to be weighed and considered by us.
11. An analysis of the Draft Guidelines as prepared by the
Committee set up by this Court in the case may now be made.
The applicability of these Guidelines is to all Government
advertisements other than classifieds and in all mediums of;
communication, thereby including internet advertising. The
objective of these Guidelines emphasize the Government's
2 •responsibility to disseminate information necessary for the
public to know about the policies and programmes ofI
Government. It principally spells out five principles to re~late
the contents of advertisements, namely,
i) advertising campaigns are to be related to
government res ponsi bilities,
I
ii) materials should be presented In an objectiye, fair
and accessible and designedI
manner to meet
objectives of the campaign,
iii) not directed at promoting political interests of a
Party,
iv) campaigns must be justified and undertaken in an
efficient and cost-effective manner and
v) advertisemen ts must complyI
I
with: legal
requiremen tsI
and financial regulationsI
and
procedures.
The five broad Content Regulations contained in the draftI
guidelines framed by the Committee are similar I to theI
provisions found in the Australian guidelines. IHowever,
2
under each broad head specific regulatory parameters have
been indicated which seem to embody what would be good
practices in the Indian context.
12. While under the first head the requirement of conformity
of Government advertisements with dissemination of
information relating to Government's constitutional and legal
obligations and the corresponding rights and entitlements of
citizens is being stressed upon, under the second head
objective presentation of the materials contained in an
advertisement bearing in mind the target audience has been
emphasized. Under the third head, the Guidelines state that
advertisement materials must not: (a) mention the party In
government by its name, (b) attack the views or actions of
other parties in opposition, (c) include any party symbol or
logo, (d) aim to influence public support for a political party or
a candidate for election or (e) refer or link to the websites of
political parties or politicians. It is also stated in the
Guidelines that photographs of leaders should be avoided and
only the photographs of the President/ Prime Minister or
Governor j Chief Minister shall be used for effective
2
government messaging.I
The fourth head deals with I cost •effectiveness of an advertisement campaign and measures to
cut down avoidable expenses. A somewhat restricted range of
advertising activity on the eve of the electionsI
is I alsoI
recommended. Appointment of an Ombudsman to: hear
complaints of violation of the norms and toI
suggestI
amendments thereto from time to time beside specialI
performance audit by the concerned Ministries is also
recommended.
13. The Union Government and the State of Bihar have filed
their responses to the guidelines suggested by the Committee.I
I
The State of Bihar suggests that some of the recommen<!lationsI
of the Committee, details of which need not be noticed, areI
somewhat vague and require a more precise definition orI
meaning. The only aspect of the suggestions where the State
has responded emphatically 1S with regard to theI
recommendation to confine the publication of photographs ofI
the President and the Prime Minister of the country and the
Governor and the Chief Minister of the State. According to theI
State of Bihar such a restriction should not be imposed.I
2
14. The Union in its response to the guidelines of the
Committee has been more categorical in suggesting certain
changes as well as deletion of some of the recommendations.
It will, therefore, be necessary to specifically notice the said
objections raised by the Union.
Content of the Response of the UnionRecommendations
(1) Object of Guidelines
(a) To prevent arbitrary use The meanmg of the wordof public funds for advertising "arbitrary" according to theby public authorities. Union needs to be more
specifically defined.
(b) To exclude the possibility According to the Union theof any misuse of public funds expression "politicalon advertisement campaign in mileage" IS inappropriateorder to gain political mileage and should be deleted.by the politicalestablishments.
(2) 5 Princigles of Content Regulation
(a) Clause (vii) under the 2nd According to the Union thispoint of the 5 principles should be done only whenrecommended by the the same IS feasible and,Committee - Every effort whenever public interest soshould be made to pre-test the demands.material in case of large scalecampaign with targetaudiences.
(3) Ombudsman
(b) Clause (c)(i)under the 4th
point of the 5 principles ofContent Regulation states that"The Government shall decideand announce beforehand, alist of personalities on whosebirth or death anniversaries,advertisements could bereleased every year andspecify whichMinistry/Department couldrelease the same.
(c)Clause (d) of the 4th point ofthe 5 principles of ContentRegulation states that "as faras possible, during the periodprior to elections, only thoseadvertisements required bylaw (such as public health andsafety advisories or job andcontract advertisements) alonebe released by thegovernments.
The suggestion of theCommittee with regard toappointment of theOmbudsman IS In thefollowing terms: "TheGovernment shall appoint anOmbudsman who shall be aneminent expert independent ofthe Government to receivecomplaints of violations ofGuidelines and to recommendaction in accordance with theGuidelines. "
2 •According to the Unimh.thewords "decide and announcebeforehand" may be deletedas the same is not feasible
I
SInce Issuance I ofadvertisement depends: on ahost of factors I like
I
availability of funds, lastminute changes and thepriorities of the government.
According to the :UnionI
advertisement that I serveI
public interest may beI
issued at any point of time,
The Union 0bjects :to thesame and seeks deletion ofthe said recommendation asalso the recommendationwith regard to separateperformance audit of eachMinistry and publication ofthe result of such audit.
I
According to the Union theI
Government has I inbuiltI
machinery for redressal andfor audit purposes. :
I
2
15. A consideration of the objections filed by the Union would
go to show that the Union seriously disagrees with the
recommendations of the Committee in respect of the following
matters:
(1) restricted publication of photographs of the
Government functionaries and political leaders
alongwith the advertisement etc.
(2) appointment of an Ombudsman
(3) the recommendation with regard to performance
audit by each Ministry.
(4) embargo on advertisements on the eve of the
elections.
16. The rest of the objections are really in the nature of
suggestions which having been considered we are of the view
that incorporation of the said suggestions made by the Union
or otherwise would not make any substantial difference to the
impact and effect of the said recommendations. It is the
recommendations with regard to the publication of
photographs; appointment of Ombudsman; carrying out
independent audit and embargo on advertisements during
2
election time that will have to be specifically dealt with in someI
details.I
17. The rernammg recommendations of the CommitteeI
appear to be comprehensive and based on an analytical
approach of the best practices prevailing in other jurisdictions.II
The said recommendations, in our considered view, wouldIII
serve public interest by enabling dissemination of information,
II
and spreading awareness amongst the citizens not only :ofthe
government policies; achievements made and targets ito be
reached but also the rights and entitlements of the citizensIII
including the availability of a host of welfare measures.: TheI
said recommendations, therefore, commend to the Court for
acceptance and are accordingly accepted.
18. At this juncture we may very briefly deal with the withIII
the situation prevailing in other jurisdictions across the globe.III
While, undoubtedly there can be no blind adherence to theIII
practices followed in other jurisdictions as what may beI
appropriate to another country may not be ideal in the Indian
context, the correct approach will be to discern some of theI,
I
best practices prevailing in such jurisdictions and thereafter toIII
test the relevance of the same to our own country. Though theI
2
recitals contained in the Report of the Committee do mention a
consideration of such good practices prevailing in other
jurisdictions there is however no discussion or even an
indication of the precise contents of the practices that were
found by the Committee to be in existence in other countries.
It has therefore become necessary for us to deal with the
matter though very briefly. In this regard we may usefully,
though illustratively, make a reference to certain practices
prevailing in Canada, United Kingdom, New Zealand and
Australia.
19. Insofar as Canada(Ontario) is concerned, it appears that
the object of issuing a government advertisement is : (i) to
inform the public of current or proposed government policies,
programs or services available to them; (ii) to inform the public
of their rights and responsibilities under the law and (iii) to
encourage or discourage specific social behaviour in public
interest. Such advertisements are not to include the name,
voice or image of any functionary of the State and the primary
objective of an advertisement ought not to be to foster a
positive impression of the ruling government or a negative
2 • .r
impression of any person, group or party critical of the
government.
20. In some of the foreignjurisdictions there is a mechtnism
for review of advertisements on fixed parameters even before
they are published and publication/issuance thereof only
upon passing of the required test. In Australia and UnitedI
Kingdom,there is an added emphasis on the cost effecti~eness
of advertising campaigns. In Australia, advertising caJpaigns
of more than a particular pecuniary value i.e. Imillion
Australian dollars require to undergo a cost benefit analysisI
wherein the best options to achieve the intended obj+tiVe of
the campaign has to be determined before launching the
same.i
21. The good practices adopted in other jUrisdict10ns as
noticed above do find adequate reflection .n the
recommendations of the Committee which further fortify our
conviction to adopt the same.
22. This will require the Court to consider the ~ifferent
aspects of a government advertisement campaign hi~lighted
earlier on which we have reserved our comments. The first is
2
with regard to publication of photographs of functionaries of
the State and political leaders alonwith the advertisement
issued. There can be no manner of doubt that one
government advertisement or the other coinciding with some
event or occasion IS published practically every day.
Publication of the photograph of an individual be a State or
party functionary not only has the tendency of associating that
particular individual with either the achievement(s) sought to
be highlighted or being the architect of the benefits in respect
of which information IS sought to be percolated.
Alternatively, programmes/targets for the future as advertised
carry the impression of being associated with the particular
individual(s). Photographs, therefore, have the potential of
developing the personality cult and the image of a one or a few
individuals which is a direct antithesis of democratic
functioning.
23. The legitimate and permissible object of an
advertisement, as earlier discussed, can always be achieved
without publication of the photograph of any particular
functionary either in the State of a political party. We are,
3 "
, .therefore, of the VIew that in departure to the VIews of the
"
Committee which recommended permissibility of publication,
,
of the photographs of the President and Prime Minister of the,
II
country and Governor or Chief Minister of the State alongwith,,
the advertisements, there should be an exception only in the,,
I
case of the President, Prime Minister and Chief Justice of the,
country who may themselves decide the question,,
Advertisements issued to commemorate the anniversaries of,
acknowledged personalities like the father of the nation: wouldI,
of course carry the photograph of the departed leader.
24. Insofar as the recommendation with regard to theI
appointment of Ombudsman is concerned, we are of the view,
II
that for ironing out the creases that are bound to show from,
I
time to time in the implementation of the present directions,
I
and to oversee such implementation the government i shouldIII
constitute a three member body consisting of persohs withI,,
unimpeachable neutrality and impartiality and who have
excelled in their respective fields.,
We could have: but weI,,
refrain from naming the specific persons and leave the said
exercise to be performed by the Union Government.
"3
25. Insofar as performance/special audit is concerned, we do
not feel the necessity of any such special audit inasmuch as
the machinery available IS adequate to ensure due
performance as well as accountability and proper utilization of
public money.
26. If Government advertisements adhere to the objects and
parameters mentioned above we do not feel the necessity of
imposing a special curb on government advertisements on the
eve of the elections, as suggested by the Committee.
27. In an earlier part of the present order we had indicated
the power of the purse that Government advertisements
invariably involve. Needless to say the concepts of fairness
and even dispensation to all media/publishing houses will
have to be maintained by the Government be it at the Centre
or the States.
28. We close the matters on the aforesaid note by approving
and adopting the recommendations of the Committee except
what has been specifically indicated above with regard to
3
(1) publication of photographs of the Government
functionaries and political leaders alongwith the
advertisement(s).
(2) appointment of an Ombudsman
(3) the recommendation with regard to performanceI
audit by each Ministry.
(4) embargo on advertisements on the eve of theI
elections.
29. We also make it clear that the present directions issued
under Article 142 of the Constitution cannot be comprehensive,
I
and there are several aspects of the matter which may haveI,
escaped our attention at this stage. In this regard, we would,
I
like to clarify that it is not the intention of the Court toII
attempt to lay down infallibleand all comprehensive directions,
I,
to cover the issue at hand. The gaps, if any, we are confident
would be filled up by the executive arm of the governmentI
itself inasmuch as the attainment of constitutional goals and,
values enshrined in Part IVof the Constitution is the :conjoint,
., 3
responsibility of the three organs of the State i.e. legislative,
executive and the judiciary, as earlier discussed .
.......................••••................... ".[RANJAN GOGOI]
.......•..••••••........................•••.•. ".[PINAKI CHANDRA GHOSE]
NEW DELHI,MAY 13, 2015.
1
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
REVIEW PETITION (e) NOS.1879-1881/2015
IN
WRIT PETITION (e) NOS.13/2003, 197/2004 & 302/2012
STATE OF KARNATAKA ... PETITIONER
VERSUS
COMMON CAUSE AND ORS.ETC. ETC. ...RESPONDENTS
WITH
R.p.(e) NO.1876-1877/2015 IN w.p.(e)NO.197/2004, R.p.(e) NO.1834/2015 IN w.p.(eLNO.197/2004, R.p.(e) NOS.2703-2705/2015 INw.p.(e) NOS.13/2003, 197/2004 _& 302/2012, R.P.(e) NOS.3191-3193/2015 IN W.P. (e) NOS.13/2003,197/2004 & 302/2012, R.p.(e) NOS.3275-3277/2015 IN W.P. (e). NOS.13/2003, 197/2004 &.302/2012, R.p.(e) NO.3259/2015 IN w.p.(e)NO.197/2004, R.p.(e) NOS.3674-3676/2015 INW.P. (e) NOS.13/2003, 197/2004 & 302/2012, R.P.(e) NOS.123-125/2016 IN w.p.(e) NOS.13/2003,197/2004 & 302/2012.
ORDER
1. We have heard the learned counsels for all the
contesting parties. Upon due consideration, we review our
judgment dated 13th May, 2015 passed in Writ Petition
(Civil) No.13 of 2003, Writ Petition (Civil) No.197 of 2~M 1
and Writ Petition (Civil) No.302 of 2012 to the extent,I
2 "•indicated below:
(i) The exception carved out in paragraph 23 of :
the aforesaid judgment dated 13th May, i
,
2015 permitting the publication of the i
photographs of the President, Prime i,,,
Minister and Chief Justice of the country..I
,
subject to the said authorities themselves:I
deciding the question, is now extended to,
Ithe Governors and the Chief Ministers of the
,,,I
States.
(ii) In lieu of the photograph of the Prime
Minister, the photograph of the
Departmental (Cabinet) Minister /MinisterIIII
In-charge of the concerned Ministry may tie,,
published, if so desired.II
(iii) In the States, similarly, the photograph of
the Departmental [Cabinet],III
Minister / Minister In-charge In lieu of the,,
photograph of the Chief Minister may 'be
published, if so desired.
(iv) All other observations/directions In the
aforesaid judgment dated 13th May, 2~15: Page 2
, ,. . 3
shall continue to remain in force subject to
the above modification.
2. The review petitions are disposed of In the above
terms.
........••........••..........•......... ,~.(RAN~AN GOGOI)
.•.•.......................•........... ,~.(PINAKI CHANDRA GHOSE)
NEW DELHI;MARCH 18, 2016.
Page 3
I~
DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITYGOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
BLOCK NO. IX, OLD SECRETARIAT, DELHI-10054
No. F.16 (54)/AdvtlDIP/2016-17! h96 3- 70
CIRCULAR
Dated: )'~ I j b
With reference to Hon'ble Supreme Court's judgement dated 135.2015 inWrit petition (civil) No. 13 of 2003 with W.P.(C) No. 197 of 2004 & WP. (C) No. 302of 2012 and order dated 18.3.2016 in Review petition (C) N879-1881/2015 In writpetition (civil) No. 13 of 2003, 197 of 2004 & 302 of 2012 (copies of the both areavailable on the official website of the Directorate), all Principal SecretariesSecretaries and HODs are hereby informed that the Hon'ble Supreme Court hasapproved the Guidelines on content regulation of Government advertising exceptwith regard to
(1) Publication of photographs of the Government functionaries andpolitical leaders along with the advertisement(s)
(2) Appointment of an Ombudsman(3) The recommendation with regard to performance audit by each Ministry(4) Embargo on advertisements on the eve of the elections
An excerpt of the guidelines on content regulation of Government advertisinqfrom the above mentioned judgement is attached herewith for ready reference FullJudgement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is also available at DIP's website
This issues with the prior approval of the Competent Autnority
.~~~(Nalin Chauhan)
Deputy Director (Advt)
No. F.16 (54)/AdvtlDIP/2016-17 Dated
Copy for compliance to:
1 PS to ProSecretary to Lt. Governor2. PS to PL Secretary to Chief Minister3. PS to Secretary to Dy Chief Minister4. PS to Chief Secretary GNCTD5. All Secretaries to Minister. GNCTD6. All Principal Secretaries/Secretaries/Head of Deptt, GNCT of Delhi7 All Head of Autonomous Bodies/Commissioners/Corporations of GNCTD8. All Deputy CommiSsioners, GNCTD
(Nalin Chauhan)Deputy Director (Advt)
vI \! •
6. The contents of the guidelines suggested by the court appointed Committee ma~ be usefullyextracted hereinbelow:- I
I
"GUIDELINES ON CONTENT REGULATION OF!GOVERNMENT ADVERTISINq".' I
These Guidelines shall be called the Government Advertisem~nt (ContentRegulation) Guidelines 2014. I
1
(1)
(2) They shall come into force with effect from .
2, APPLICATION:
3
(1) These Guidelines shall apply to all Goverrir'nent advertisements other th~n Classified~~ise~~ I
II
(2) These Guidelines shall a,pply to the conten, of all Government Advertisingl till a suitablelegislation is enacted by the Government to prevent the misuse of p~blic funds on .advertis~ments to gain political mileag~ as distinct from legitimat~ Governmentmessaging. I
IIIIIII
autonomous bodies! organizations establishedunderIII
IIIIIIII
"Classified Advertisements" include publiCnotices, tenders, recruitment ryoticeS,statutory '.notifications. I e.·~
I -I
"DAVP Guidelines" means the existing guidelines of the Directorate Of/Advertising amfVisual Publicity of the Ministry of Informfltion and Broadcasting dealing 'tVith the eligibilityand empanelment proceoures and rates of payment and such other matt~rs; .
"Government" means Central Government, State GovernmentJunion TerritoryAdministrations and also includes local bodies, public sector und~kiAgs and otherautonomous boc:tieslorganisations estabtished under a Statute. / .
I(d) "Government advertising- means any messag,. conveyed and paid for by thf government forplacement in media such as newspapers, television, radio, internet, cinema and uch other, mediabut does not include classified advertisements; and includes both copy (written text/audio) andcreatives (visuals/video/multi media) put out in print, electronic, outdoor or digita media..
IIIII
III
(a) to prevent arbitrary use of public funds for advertising by pubtic a4thorities to projectparticular personalities, parties or governments withou( any attendant public interest. I
II
(b) neither to belittle the need nor to deny the authority of the Union and State Gpvemments and itsagencies to disseminate information necessary for ~blic to know on the policies ~nd programmes of
I
III
(3) These Guidelines shall apply to all(a) institutions of Government;(b) public sector undertaking.s;(c) local bodies and other
a Statute.
DEFINITIONS:
In these Guidelines unless the context otherNise requires:
(a)
(b)
(c)
OBJECTS:
The objects of these Guidelines are:-
2I~ Government but only to exclude the possibility of any misuse of public funds on advertisement campaigns
in order to gain political mileage by the political establishment;
(c) to address the gap in the existing DAVP Guidelines which only deal with the eligibility andempanelment of newspapers/joumals or other media, their rates of payment, and such like matters andnot on how to regulate the content of Government advertisements;
(d) to ensure that "all government activities satisfy the test of reasonableness and public interestparticularlywhile dealing with public funds and property";
(e) to ensure that government messaging is well co-ordinate, effectively managed in the bestdemocratic traditions and is responsive to the diverse information needs of the public.
5. GOVERNMENT ADVERTISEMENT TO INFORMCITIZENS
Subject to these Guidelines Government may place advertisements or purchase advertising spaceor time in any medium to inform citizens about their rights and responsibilities, about government policies.programmes, services or initiatives, or about dangers or risks to public health, safety or theenvironment.
6. THE FIVE PRINCIPLES OF CONTENTREGULATION:
While placing advertisements or purchasing advertising space in any media, the Government shall beguided by the following principles, namely:-
(1) Advertising Campaigns to be related to Government responsibilities:
While it is the duty of the Government to provide the public with timely, accurate, clear, objectiveand complete information about its policies, programmes, services and initiatives since the publichas a right to such information, the content of government advertisements should be relevant tothe governments' constitutional and legal obligations as well as the citizens' rights andentitlements.
(2) Advertisement materials should be presented in an objective, fair and accessiblemanner and be designed to meet the objectives of the campaign:
(i) The material shall be presented in a fair and objective manner and shall becapable of fulfilling the intended objectives;
(ii) Government shall exercise due caution while deciding the content, layout, size anddesign of the message including the target area and the creative requirement of theintended communication in order to ensure that the maximum reach and impact areachieved in the most cost effective manner;
(iii) Content of advertisement must enable the recipients of the information to distinguishbetween facts and analysis and where information is presented as a fact. it should beaccurate and verifiable;
(iv) Pre-existing policies, products, services and initiatives should not be presented asnew unless there has been a substantial change or modification of such policiesproducts or services;
(v) Content of advertisement should provide information in a manner that accommodatesspecial needs of disadvantaged individuals or groups identified as being within the targetaudience;
3\•
(vii)
Multiple formats may be used to en~ure equal access;
Every effort shall be made to pre-test ,the material in case of large ~Ie campaign withtarget audiences. ' I
(vi)
(3) Advertisement materials should be objective and not directed at prclmloting politicalinterests of ruling party: I
(i) Display material must be presented in objective languaie and be free ofpolitical argument or partisan standpoint
(ii) Government advertising shall maintain political neutrality and a old glorificationofpolitical personalities and projecting a positive impression of the p rty in power or anegative impression of parties critical of the government. I
I
(iii) Advertisement materials must not -
(a)
~~~~n ::c:~~:g:i~,:m:t:~ti::,e~f others in OPpoSitiOf;include party political symbol or logo or flagaim to influence public support for a polltlca,rparty, ca dkltatefor election;or
(e) refer to link to the websites of political parties or POliticianr-
Government aavertisement.materials, should avoid photographs of ~Iitical leaders andif it is felt essential for effective Government messaging. only Ithe photographsofthe President/Prime Minster or Governor/Chief Minister should be use1;
(v) Government advertisements shall not be used at patronizing media [housesor aimed atreceiving favourable reporting for the party or person in power ~
Advertisement Campaigns be justified and undertaken in an efficient nd cost-effectIVe,1manner: ",
Since it is the responsibility of government to safeguard the trust and confid+noe in the jnteg,~and impartiality of public services and hence it should be the policy of 90verntents to use public'funds In such a manner as to obtain maximum value for taxpayers' money "
Advertisement campaigns must be justified and undertaken in an and cost-eff tive manner;
(c) TheGovernmentshall- .
(i) decide and announce beforehand. a list of personalities on whJe birth or death ,advertisements could be released every year and specify which~inistry/Departmentcould release the same; I
avoid the issue of multiple advertisementsj by diffe,rnt departments andPSUs of the same Government in Commemorative Advertisemen and shall issue asingle advertisement only;
Though advertiSing by governments should remain regulated all the tife. it is particularlyimpo,rtant to ,scrupulous,ly fOIl?w these ~rinc""iPlesbefore and ~uring the el~~tions. As far as,possible, dUring the penod pnor to electtons. only those advertisements re~Ulred by law (suchas public health and safety adV,iSOrieSorjob and contract advertisementf) alone be releasedby governments;" .
I
I
I
(a)(b)(c)(d)
(iv)
(4)
(b)
(ji)
(d)
(e) Advertisement campaigns should only be need based; and
4
(f) In case of large volume advertisement campaigns. post-campaign impact assessment isnecessary to be included in the planning process itself and shall identify the indicators to measuresuccess when the campaign has ended.
(5) Government advertising must comply With legal requirements and financial regulationsand procedures:
Governments shall ensure that all Advertisements comply with:-
(i) Relevant laws regarding privacy, intellectual property rights, election laws and consumerprotection laws apart from laws in respect of broadcasting and media and(ii) Copyright laws and ownership rights associated with works subject tocopyright are fully respected.
COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT:
(1) The Government shall appoint an Ombudsman who shall be an eminent expert independent ofthe Government to receive complaints of violations of Guidelines and to recommend action Inaccordance with the Guidelines.
(2) Heads of government departments and agencies shall be responsible for ensuring compliancewith these Guidelines and shall follow a procedure of certification of compliance beforeadvertisements are released to the media.
(3) As part of the performance audit of the Ministry/DepartmentiAgency -
(a) there shall be separate audit of the compliance of Advertisement Guidelines bythe Ministry/DepartmentiAgency concerned; and
(b) The annual report of such ministry/departmentl agency shall publishthe findings of such audit and the money spent on advertising.
(4) The regulatory bodies of print and electronic media will be within their powers toimpose sanctions ~gainst such media groups acting against these Guidelines in seekingor obtaining government advertisements.
8. GENERAL:
(1) These Guidelines shall be in addition to and not in derogation of the existing Guidelineswhich are in place under the existing Advertisement Policy of Government.
(2) These Guidelines are equally applicable to State Governments and its agencies. The StateGovernments shall undertake amendments to whatever policies they have in this regard andobserve the Guidelines strictly in letter and spirit.
(3) The Ombudsman may recommend suitable changes to the Guidelines to deal with newcircumstances and situations.
(4) The Government shall take necessary steps to initiate necessary legislation on the subject,given its importance for democracy, human rights and good governance."
... ****
DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITYGOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
BLOCK NO. IX. OLD SECRETARIAT. DELHI-10054
No. F.16 (54)/AdvtlDIP/2016-171 "~7 )"
CIRCULAR
Dated: l ~ 110 j'"YO Ib
This is in continuation to the circular No. F.16 (54)/AdvtlDIP/2016-17/6896-6903dated 13.10.2016 regarding compliance on content regulations of Governmentadvertisement by HOD in accordance with the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court ofIndia dated 13th May 2015.
A copy of the draft of the certificate to be issued by concerned HOD withadvertisements is hereby attached. The soft copy of draft is also uploaded on theofficial website of DIP (http://delhi.gov.inlwpslwcm/connectlOOIT_publicity/information+and+ publicity/ home) for reference.
This issues with the prior approval of Secretary (PR)/Director (I&P).
I~~j.'il'
(Nalin Chauhan)Deputy Director (Advt)
No. F.16 (54)/AdvtlDIP/2016-17 Dated:
Copy for compliance to:
1. PS to ProSecretary to Lt. Governor2. PS to ProSecretary to Chief Minister3. PS to Secretary to Dy. Chief Minister4. PS to Chief Secretary, GNCTD5. All Secretaries to Minister, GNCTD6. All Principal Secretaries/Secretaries/Head of Deptt, GNCT of Delhi7. All Head of Autonomous Bodies/Commissioners/Corporations of GNCTD8. All Deputy Commissioners, GNCTD
~uJ_ ..(Nalin Chauhan)
Deputy Director (Advt)
• DRAFT
Dated: :File No.
I
Certificate for Compliance on content regulations of Government Advertisements bV .ill>D
This is to certify that the proposed advertisement is in accordance with theguidelines prescribed by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India vide its judgem:entI
dated 13.05.2015and 18.03.2016on the Guidelineson Content RegulationsofI
GovernmentAdvertisements.I
The content/spellings/photographs of the Government functionaries: andpolitical leadersalongwith the advertisement are verified and in order.
,
SignatureofI
I
(Headof Department)I
Seal/Stampof the HODI
DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITYGOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
BLOCK NO. IX, OLD SECRETARIAT, DELHI·10054
No. F.16 (54)/AdvtJDIP/2016-17! :::to!))CIRCULAR
Dated: :<.5/10/ :lc7/6
The Directorate of Information and Publicity had issued an Office memorandumvide letter No, 16(32)/Advt/DIP/2009-10/Pt.File/130-137 dated 12,01.2016 containinginstructions for strict compliance for releasing of advertisements to all the Head ofDepartments of Govt. of NCT of Delhi. (copy at 1/C), As per point 5 of the O.M""Essentially the concerned department will be responsible for the contents of theadvertisements besides it shall also be ensured that the same is free from anygrammatical or spelling mistake, omission or commission."
Further, a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) was circulated vide circulardated 2.6.2016 and 1,7.2016 to all departments of Govt. of NCT of Delhi.
In pursuance to Hon'ble Supreme Court Order dated 13.5.2015 and 18.5.2016,another circular was issued by the directorate on 19.10.2016 regarding issuance ofcertificate of compliance of content regulation of government advertisement by HOD.
All Head of departments are once again requested to ensure the compliance ofabove two circulars along with the latest one regarding issuance of certificate ofcompliance of content regulation of government advertisement by HOD before the fileof proposal of advertisement is forwarded to DIP for publication/release. The circularsand the draft certificate are available on the official website of DIP for ready reference.
No,'F.16 (54)/AdvtlDIP/2016-17 ) thS)Copy for compliance to: /
1. PS to ProSecretary to Lt. Governor2. PS to ProSecretary to Chief Minister3. PS to Secretary to Dy. Chief Minister4, PS to Chief Secretary, GNCTD5. All Secretaries to Minister, GNCTD6. All Principal Secretaries/Secretaries/Head of Deptt, GNCT of Delhi7. All Head of Autonomous Bodies/Commissioners/Corporations of GNCTD8. All Deputy Commissioners, GNCTD
cPwcH '(Dr. Jayadev Sarangi)
Secretary (PR)/Director (I&P)
Dated: 2.5/10I:J.o/6
(Dr.Jaya;t:;a~g'iSecretary (PR)lDirector (I&P)
DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITYGOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
BLOCK NO. IX, OLD SECRETARIAT, DELHI-10054
No. F.16 (32)/AdvtJDIP/2009_10
CIRCULARDated:
In continuation to Office Memorandum issued by the Directoratevide No. 16/321AdvVD IP12009-1 0/5936-42 daled 30.3.2015. 10 simplify.standardize and streamline the process of releasing of advertisements, aStandard Operating Procedure (SOP) has been prepared for approval of alladvertisements. It is to be followed by all departments of Government ofNCT of Delhi, before submitting any advertisement (Print, Electronic andOutdoor) for pub/ication/ release.
All Principal Secretaries, Secretaries and HODs are hereby advisedto ensure strict compliance of the prescribed SOP•.
This issues with the prior approval of Hon'ble Deputy Chief Minister.
~-_--_.--(Sandeep Mishra)
Special Director (I&P)
No. F.16 (32)/AdVtJDIP/2009-10(41-0~-~ 2-1 :;Copy for compliance to:
1. All Principal Secretaries/Secretaries/Head of Deptt, GNCT of Delhi2. All Head of Autonomous BOdies/Commissioners/Corporations of
GNCTD
Dated: 2.(b ( 1(,
3. All Secretaries to Minister, GNCTD...4. PS to Chief Secretary. GNCTD5. PS to ProSecretary to Lt. Governor6. PS to ProSecretary to Chief Minister7. PS to Secretary to Dy. Chief Minister8. All Deputy Commissioners, GNCTD
~ ----
Encl: A copy SOP with checklist(Sandeep Mishra)
Special Director (I&P)
REMINDER-I
DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITYGOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
BLOCK NO. IX, OLD SECRETARIAT, DELHI-100S4
No. F.16 (32)/AdvtlDIP/2009-1 01
CIRCULAR
Dated:
This is in continuation of Circular issued by the Directorate videNo.16/32/AdvUDIP/2009-1 0/4208-4215 dated 02.06.2016, regarding StandardOperating Procedure (SOP) for releasing of advertisements.
It has been observed that the Departments are not following theprocedure prescribed in the SOP, The Office of the Principal AccountantGeneral (Audit), Delhi has also observed that the government advertisementsare being released without assessing estimated expenditure or expendituresanction which is violation of GFR. Therefore, it is requested that the estimatedcost of each advertisement with the size to be published may be worked outand included in the proposal for administrative approval as per SOP.
In view of the above all Principal Secretaries, Secretaries and HODsare hereby once again requested to ensure strict compliance of the above SOPlest it shall not be possible for DIP to accept the advertisements for release.
(Sandeep Mishra)Special Director (I&P)
No. F.16 (32)/AdvtlDIP/2009-10 / I1t 8' - 46 qoCopy for compliance to:
Dated:
1. All Principal Secretaries/Secretaries/Head of Deptt, GNCT of Delhi2. All Head of Autonomous Bodies/Commissioners/Corpo:'ations of GNCTD3. All Secretaries to Minister, GNCTD4. PS to Chief Secretary, GNCTD5. PS to ProSecretary to Lt. Governor6. PS to ProSecretary to Chief Minister7. PS to Secretary to Dy. Chief Minister8. All Deputy Commissioners GNCTD
(Sandeep Mishra)Special Director (I&P)
Encl: A copy Circular dated 02.6.2016 with SOP with checklist
I
DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITYGOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI :
BLOCK NO. IX, OLD SECRETARIAT, DELHI-10054I
No. F.16 (32)/AdvtlDIP/2009-10
CIRCULAR
Dated: II
I
In continuation to Office Memorandum issued by the Directoratevide No.16/32/AdvtlDJP/2009-10/5936-44 dated 30.3.2015, to: simplify,standardize and streamline the process of releasing of advertisements, aStandard Operating Procedure (SOP) has been prepared for approval of alladvertisements. It is to be followed by all departments of Government ofNCT of Delhi, before submitting any advertisement (Print, Electronic andOutdoor) for publication/ release.
I
IAll Principal Secretaries, Secretaries and HODs are herebr advisedto ensure strict compliance of the prescribed SOP.. I
This issues with the prior approval of Hon'ble Deputy Chief ~inister.
I
~--(Sandeep Mishra)
Special Director (I&P)I
No. F.16 (32)/AdVtlDIP/2009-10(~ 1-0~-~2-1 )Copy for compliance to:
Dated: i2( b ( 1(,I
I
1. All Principal Secretaries/Secretaries/Head of Deptt, GNCT of DelhiI2. All Head of Autonomous Bodies/Commissioners/Corporations of
GNCTD I
3. All Secretaries to Minister, GNCTD4. PS to Chief Secretary. GNCTD5. PS to ProSecretary to Lt. Governor6. PS to ProSecretary to Chief Minister7. PS to Secretary to Dy. Chief Minister8. All Deputy Commissioners, GNCTD
Encl: A copy SOP with checklist
(Sandeep Mishra)Special Director (I&P)
I
._
SOP TO BE FOLLOWED BY HODs FOR APPROVAL OF ADVERTISEMENTS
Officer Procedure to be followed before submitting I Remarks, if any ·1the advertisement. t-' ~(Put tick mark in box after completing the .--------- ....;process) !
Ir.-:-=:-=:---t----:-.--- __. J • • ._.
HOD 0 Preparation of content (information facts &Tfigures) needed to be published. i
o Brief note on the necessity and theimportance of the advertisement
o Size of the a::vertisement
o Media plan including approximate cost foreach advertisement
o Proper translation of the text, if required.
o Hindi to English
o English to Hindi
o Design, idea and layout to the extentpossible
--.-- __ --1, .._ .__.
The HOD, with all the above details, will first get the approval of the Honble Ministerconcerned and then follow the below mentioned flow for processing in DIP.
Hon'ble Minister to the HOD --. HOD to DIP __. DIP to Shabdarth
Shabdarth will finalize the layout and design and submit it to Dy. Chief Minister for finalapproval.
After approval of the Deputy Chief Minister, Shabdarth will send back the advertisementto DIP for publication Irelease.
..
MOST IMMEDIATESUP,8_EMECOURT MATTER
DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITYI
GOVERNMENT OF NeT OF DElHIBLOCI~ NO. IX. OLD SEeTT:. OELHI-II0054
No. 16(22lJOIP!Advt/201S-16! ~~'1.t Dated: ~~) J 6/ , r-"('~-~---".-
ToAll HODs,Government (jf'-,\ICTof Delhi
Su.b: HgnJb1e Supreme Court Judgement dated 13.5.2015 in the matter of Guidelines forGovernment funded advertisements in the .matter .ofWPC No. 13 of 20.03and 194 of 2004 byCommon Cause and Centre for Pllblic Ihterestlitigatlon
Sir,In the matter of WPC No. 13 of 2003 and 194 of 2004 by Cq,mmon Cause and Centre for Public
Interest Litigation, the Hcn'ble Supreme Court had appointed a three member committee to suggestGuidelines for Government funded advertisements. Hon'ble Supreme Court h~s delivered its judgementon the above matter on 13.5.2015. Full text of the judgement is available and same may be visited inthe website of Han'ble Supreme Court Of India.
Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that ONLY thl' photograph of the President, PrimeMinister and Chief Justice of the country should be displayed in Government advertisements. TheHon'ble Supreme Court has, inter-alia, also directed that "Advertisement issued to commem,orate theanniversaries of acknowledgedpersonalities like the father of the nation would of course carry the
photograph of the departed leader",
The judgement is binding on the Union of India, State Governments and Union TerritoryAdministrations and it) agencies, This implies that tbe judgement is applicable to al! local bodies, publicsector undertakings and other autonomous bodies/organization established under a Statue. These'C;uide!inesare applicable to all Governments advertisements other than classifieds and in all mediumsof communications, such as print, electronic, outdoor and digital, including internet advertising.
It is necessary to take note of all aspects of the judgement of Hon'ble Supreme Court forcompliance ill letter and spirit. It is therefore aov.seble to download the full text of the judgement for
necessarv compliance.\ /
~Additional Director (I&P)
Copy to
LY" Secretary tc Lt. Governor of Oelill ,.2. Secretary to Chief Minister, Delhi3. Secretary to Deputv CI1iefMinister, Delhi4. Secretary to all Cabinet of Ministe(S, Delhiuv. OSDto Ctlief Secretary. Gove.of NCTof Oelhiif. Deputy DirectoriPress)/AclvtjFleld Publicity, DIP