ICT in the Teacher Training System for Academic Vocals ...
Transcript of ICT in the Teacher Training System for Academic Vocals ...
ICT in the Teacher Training System for Academic Vocals: Structured
Mentoring
S.S. Aksenova1,а*
1 Musical College named after the Gnessins of the Gnessin Russian Academy of Music, 38, building 1, Povarskaya str., 121069, Moscow, Russia
* Corresponding author
Keywords: information educational environment, teacher training system for academic vocals, ICT, non-formal education, structured mentoring, learning management systems (LMS), personal learning environments (PLE), additional education, comparative studies, advanced training of vocal teacher, ICT technologies, interactive educational environments, informatization of education, distributed education
Abstract: The subject of the research of this article is the system of advanced training of teachers in vocal of
children’s art schools and children’s music schools, the evolution of approaches (from “learning management
systems (LMS)” to “personal learning environments” (PLEs), including during the training and professional
development of teacher’s academic vocals. The article explores the approaches and methods of professional
development of teachers in vocal in the modern informational music-educational environment. On the basis of
a comparative analysis of pedagogical practice, the conditions for the development of “personal learning
environments (PLEs)” have been identified. The development of an advanced vocational education program
for teachers on academic vocals is justified.
1. Introduction
Questions about the development of the concept and practice of structured mentoring were considered in the
works of Russian and foreign scientists both in the context of consulting in education [1, 2], and in the context
of the transition from the traditions of the “old school” system of teaching academic vocals [3].
Thus, Personal Learning Environments (PLE) is an innovative new development in musical educational
practice through the introduction of information and communication technologies (ICT) and the ability to
promote the creation of “universities without walls” that can meet the needs of the knowledge society, and this
approach is effective in the conditions of advanced training of teachers on academic vocals [3].
2. Materials and Methods
The article examines some aspects of empirical research on the modification of the vocal teacher’s professional
activities conducted on the basis of various educational organizations in Russia and abroad. The results of the
experimental advanced training courses of the Gnesins Music School of the Russian State Academy of Music
named after the Gnessins are given, the development of a vocational education program for teachers on vocal
basis based on IEM RAE is justified.
Changes in the professional environment of future vocalists, modifying requirements for teacher training
and the development of ICT competence of teachers and applicable for training and raising the qualifications
of teachers for vocal “adult learners” [18], are considered in the works foreign researchers [28, 29, 19, 12].
“Online learning environment” (OLE) in the system of additional music education, in particular, when
preparing a vocal teacher, requires adaptability [9] and the formation of “special set of teaching skills”, since
the modern approach to teaching vocal integrates key features. “The master instructor” uses them in ensuring
the quality of training [4] in the system of advanced training of teachers themselves in the context of
informatization of education, including additional education [8, 9, 10].
International Conference on the Development of Education in Eurasia (ICDEE 2019)
Copyright © 2019, the Authors. Published by Atlantis Press. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/).
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 316
138
“Experimental research often begins with the fact that we formulate [our] values and ask ourselves the
question of whether we adhere to them” [22]. Some values that are important for the formation of the
personality of a vocal teacher (and teachers who train teachers) are not always preserved during musical
contacts, as a result of which we are confronted with “life contradictions” [30].
In recent years, the use of ICT in the professional activities of vocal teacher has been considered in various
aspects by both Russian and foreign researchers.
Thus, in modern studies [13], devoted to the analysis of the concepts of immersive media reality in the
context of the methodological support of teacher training in spatial interfaces and interactive 3D environment
for immersive musical performances, immersive reproduction and spatial interfaces are considered as topics
poorly studied in areas focused on developing creativity and enhancing emotional experience. A number of
works [17, 13] are devoted to modifying ICT technologies, expanding the boundaries of creating musical
works, as well as the experience of performing in digital format where the goal is to integrate sound and
interactive 3D graphics that musicians, vocalists can work with and viewers can watch.
As for the modification of the educational process and its methodological support in the conditions of the
development of ICT technologies, vocal teacher activities, the works devoted to the assessment of skill using
the supporting vocal training system based on the visualization of the acoustic properties of the student’s
singing voice [23] substantiate the development of a vocal support system, which is based on the visualization
of the acoustic properties of the student’s singing voice, as well as methods for assessing the level of the
student’s singing skill using this system. As a result of the study, the high convergence of the training results
in both methods was revealed, and the differences between owning a singing voice of students who used the
vocal support system based on the visualization of the acoustic properties of the trainee's vocal voice, and the
students who listened to the performance by a live vocalist, were not found.
The study on the teaching of music teachers and non-formal education in the concept of the Freire model
of the dialogical model [20] on the example of distance education programs (Brazil) [26] notes that the
specifics of teaching consist of three areas that were emphasized during teacher training. Namely, they include
the area of practical musical skill, the area of their authority and theoretical knowledge and the area of their
relationship with the musical world of students. These areas were identified as a result of attempts to find a
dialogical relationship between teachers and students. In the study, an attempt was made to improve practical
work and bring it in line with the values that are necessary for the process of professional self-improvement.
The informal learning model applicable to the vocal teacher’s vocational activity [21] motivates the methods
of teaching music, vocal and the position that it proposes the teacher and student to play in [14, 31, 16]. In
recent studies [26], the results of a pilot research project are presented, in which the Green model was integrated
into a mixed model of distance education teacher training program in Brazil.
Personal Learning Environment (PLE) has become a promising new way of responding to the needs of the
knowledge society and represents a significant change in understanding the role of ICT in education (see Adell
& Castañeda, 2010). Many higher education institutions have implemented the institutional PLE (iPLE) in
their programs (refer to Casquero, Portillo, Ovelar, Romo & Benito, 2010). The iPLE is a digital environment
created by institutions that allow students to create and organize their own networks of learning resources,
applications and tools in accordance with their interests and tasks, as well as communicate with people
participating in specific learning events. These environments provide students with the opportunity to integrate
work areas and individual and group training, which can be divided to a greater or lesser extent, and link
learning acquired in formal or informal settings. From a constructivist and sociocultural point of view, learning
is understood as a process of building knowledge, which is social and general.
As part of the implementation of the PLE concept, the author developed and tested the additional
professional development program “Academic vocals and ICT in the modern musical and educational
environment” for teachers of musical educational organizations of different levels (additional, vocational and
higher education), methodologists and heads of relevant departments in the field of music, art, culture, and
education. The program was tested on the basis of the Institute of Education Management of the Russian
Academy of Education. In this program, the planned learning outcomes include developing the ICT
competence of teachers on academic vocals (knowledge in the application of teaching methods and ICT tools,
information educational resources in the vocalist’s professional activities); skills in collecting, analyzing, and
adapting information related to academic vocals; networking skills between participants in the educational
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 316
139
process. In this program, the planned learning outcomes include: improving hearing skills and intonation; ideas
about modern technologies of teaching academic vocals; expanding the possibilities of professional activity in
music education, mastering, and professional testing of the technique and technology of vocal art education,
developed by domestic and foreign masters of vocal art.
Thus, the analysis of the practice of ICT implementation in the musical and pedagogical process, including
the formation of vocal skills (in the process of teaching vocals), made it possible to identify the main directions
of the development of pedagogical technologies:
• Introducing electronic educational resources, allowing to provide free access to the database of vocal
and educational environment, where any concept or term used in the context of the studied topic is
associated with multimedia images (texts, pictures, sounds);
• Creating a Web-portfolio of students (work in the classroom, independent work, work in projects, at
competitions);
• Using social media to enhance the interaction between the participants of the music-vocal educational
environment by placing audio and video recordings with comments;
• Organizing international projects between students to create joint musical compositions in real time
(intercontinental integration of musical cultures);
• Modification of students’ composers, arranging and sound engineering activities with the help of
optimal software corresponding to pedagogical tasks [1, 2].
Analysis of the existing teaching practice in the process of experimental work revealed an insufficient
amount of ICT use in the formation of vocal skills of students. The establishing experiment was conducted on
the basis of advanced training courses of the Gnessins Music College of the Russian Academy of Music named
after the Gnesins in 2014-2015. With the method of questioning and interviewing, readiness was revealed by
vocal teachers to expand the use of ICT in the process of developing vocal skills of students, 237 people took
part in the experiment [2].
Among the trainees of advanced training courses, a survey was conducted regarding the goals of using ICT
in the process of developing singing skills (Fig. 1):
• For practicing skills between students – 15%;
• For collegial projects between teachers – 19%;
• Operational exchange of information – 24%;
• Structured storage of information, portfolio – 23%;
• Not currently used – 49%;
• Do not plan to apply – 25%.
Fig. 1. The results of a survey of students of advanced training courses on the purpose of using ICT in the process of
developing vocal skills.
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 316
140
Further, the survey was conducted regarding the reasons hindering the introduction of ICT in the musical and
pedagogical process by the teacher:
• Underestimation of the artistic possibilities of digital tools – 87%;
• There is no material and technical base for the introduction of technology – 64%;
• Negative attitude to the process of introducing ICT – 56%;
• Lack of trust from colleagues – 47%;
• No user skills – 35%;
• There is no understanding of the prospects for implementation – 36%.
Fig. 2. The results of the survey of students of the advanced training system.
4. Conclusion
Analysis of the problem of continuity of the tradition in the process of vocal training allowed to consider it in
the context of a factor constraining the introduction of ICT by the teacher in the process of formation of singing
skills. The question arises of translating the “new” and “old school” conflict into a constructive dialogue,
developed and supported by introducing into the educational process modern pedagogical technologies for
designing a musical educational environment. Analysis of the existing teaching practice led to the conclusion
that there is no contradiction in the “inheritance of the positive aspects of the traditions of various vocal schools
in organizing the process of teaching the singer, mastering certain vocal-pedagogical principles of teachers of
the past”, where new information and communication technologies contribute to the improvement of the
modern system of the formation of singing skills and improving the quality of students’ performing skills.
References
[1] Arinushkina, A. A. (2017). Strategic planning of attracting students as an element of management
consulting in the educational sector. In X International Scientific and Practical Conference “Higher
School: Experience, Problems, Prospects”. Moscow, Russia: RUDN.
[2] Arinushkina, A. A. (2016). The evolution of consulting practice in the educational sector: foreign and
Russian experience in management consulting in the education system. Education Management: Theory
and Practice, 4(24).
[3] Aksenova, S. S. (2018). Corrective aspects of ICT in the development of musical hearing in children
with hearing disabilities. Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, 288.
[4] Aksenova, S. S. (2014). Development of the program of advanced training of vocal teachers in the
Children's Music School and Children's Art School. Innovation and Investment, 5, 289-291.
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 316
141
[5] Dalskaya, V. A. (2014). The method of visual modeling in vocal lesson in an interdisciplinary aspect.
Historical, Philosophical, Political and Legal Sciences, Cultural Studies and Art History. Questions of
Theory and Practice, 5-3, 44-47
[6] Neustroev, S. S., Fedorchuk, Yu. M., & Polyaninova, Yu. V. (2017). Quality management of general
education and the problem of evaluating its performance. Man and Education, 2(51).
[7] Pudenko, T. I., Potemkina, T. V., & Mindzaeva, E. V. (2016). Development of regional education
quality assessment systems: conceptual ideas of renewal. Education Management: Theory and Practice,
1 (21).
[8] Robert, I. V., Panyukova, S. V., Kuznetsov, A. A., & Kravtsova, A. Yu. (2008). Information and
communication technologies in education: teaching aid. Moscow, Russia: Drofa.
[9] Robert, I. V. (2012). Informatization of education as a new field of pedagogical knowledge. Man and
Education, 1.
[10] Robert I. V. (2005). The main directions of informatization of education in the national school. Vestnik
of the Moscow City Pedagogical University (Series: Informatics and Informatization of Education), 5,
106-114.
[11] Shikhnabieva, T. Sh. (2016). Adaptive semantic models of automated knowledge control. Pedagogical
Education in Russia, 7, 14-20.
[12] Belair, M. (2012). The investigation of virtual school communications. Tech Trends, 56(4), 26-33.
[13] Berthaut, F., & Hachet, M. (2016). Spatial interfaces and interactive 3d environments for immersive
musical performances. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, 36(5), 82-87.
[14] Burlin Sr., T. B. (2015). High school contemporary a cappella: A descriptive phenomenology. Denton,
TX: University of North Texas.
[15] Cabedo Mas A., & Narita F. (2011). Music education and the construction of musical knowledge in
Spain and Brazil. International Journal of the Arts in Society, 6(4), 159-166.
[16] Carroll, C. L. (2017). Playing the field: An Australian case study of student popular musicians’ informal
learning in senior secondary classroom music education. Sydney, Australia: Sydney Conservatorium
of Music, Sydney University.
[17] Cadoz C. (1999). Les nouveaux gestes de la musique, chapter Musique, geste, technologie (pp. 47-92).
Editions Parenth`eses.
[18] De Gagne J., & Walters K. (2009). Online teaching experience: A qualitative metasynthesis (QMS).
Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 5(4), 577.
[19] Dipietro, M. (2010). Virtual school pedagogy: The instructional practices of K-12 virtual school
teachers. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 42(3), 327-354.
[20] Freire, P. (1974). Conscientisation. CrossCurrents, 24(1), 23-31
[21] Green, L. (2008). Group cooperation, inclusion and disaffected pupils: some responses to informal
learning in the music classroom. Music Education Research, 10(2), 177-192.
[22] Hernández-Bravo, J. R., Cardona-Moltó, M. C., & Hernández-Bravo, J. A. The effects of an
individualized ICT-based music education program on primary school students’ musical competence
and grades. Music Education Research, 18(2), 176-194.
[23] Ikeda K., Haga, T., Kayama, M., Itoh, K., Yatsuka, M., & Higashibara, Y. (2015). The Mastery
Evaluation Using Singing Learning Support System based on the visualization of acoustic features of
learners’ singing voice. In E-Learn: World Conference on E-Learning in Corporate, Government,
Healthcare, and Higher Education (1981-1985). Waynesville, NC: Association for the Advancement of
Computing in Education (AACE).
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 316
142
[24] McNiff, J., & Whitehead, J. (2011). All you need to know about action research. Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage Publications.
[25] Narita, F. M. (2017). Informal learning in action: the domains of music teaching and their pedagogic
modes. Music Education Research, 19(1), 29-41.
[26] Narita, F. M. (2014). Music, informal learning, and the distance education of teachers in Brazil: a self-
study action research project in search of concretization. London, UK: Institute of Education,
University of London.
[27] Narita, F. M., & Green, L. (2015). Informal learning as a catalyst for social justice in music education.
In C. Benedict, P. Schmidt, G. Spruce, & P. Woodford (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of social justice in
music education. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
[28] Savery, J. R. (2005). BE VOCAL: Characteristics of successful online instructors. Journal of Interactive
Online Learning, 4(2), 141-152.
[29] West, R. E., Waddoups, G., & Graham, C. R. (2007). Understanding the experiences of instructors as
they adopt a course management system. Educational Technology Research and Development, 55(1),
1-26.
[30] Whitehead, J. (1989). Creating a living educational theory from questions of the kind, “How do I
improve my practice?” Cambridge Journal of Education, 19(1), 41-52.
[31] Wright, R. (2016). Informal learning in general music education. In Carlos R Abril & Brent M Gault
(Eds.), Teaching General Music: Approaches, Issues, and Viewpoints. Oxford, UK: Oxford University
Press.
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 316
143