ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
-
Upload
matthew-russell-lee -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
1/8
XIDUXNG
[ J H J A ]
M ] [ B A [ [ BBU
KI]AH[
KI@B GQDMA]
(=0=) ;11-
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
2/8
/
Xumdissing ig ]aspngsa tn tja ]aquast fnr Igfnrd`ting k`tak Kahadmar 06, =501
( ]aspngsa Xumdissing )
UuMBIH
]AXUNGXAX
Fig`ghi`b `gk D`g`lari`b
I
0. Urnvika dnra kat`ib `gk ` tidabiga fnr tja igtalr`ting pb`g mayngk tja sudd`ry
`gk
luikigl prighipba d`tari`bs sumdittak witj
tja
@ppbih`ting.
[ja Darlar Igtalr`ting Ub`g wibb hngsist
nf
jraa prid`ry pj`sas3 (i) @ssassdagt, (ii)
Idpbadagt`ting `gk (iii) \igk-Knwg.
[ja @ssassdagt Uj`sa hnddaghak upng tja `ggnughadagt
nf
ja Darlar
ng
Nhtnmar 85 =501
`gk igvnbvas tjraa `htivitias3 (i) ` hurragt st`ta `ssassdagt, (ii) ` t`rlatak agvirngdagt kasilg `gk
(iii) kat`ibak igtalr`ting pb`ggigl. [ja nmcahtiva nf ja @ssassdagt Uj`sa is tn parfnrd `
kat`ibak g`bysis
nftja
sidib`ritias `gk kiffaraghas matwaag tja npar`tigl dnkabs nfOayHnrp
`gk First Gi`l`r` tn d`oa igfnrdak kahisings ral`rkigl tja prn fnrd` npar`tigl dnkab nf ja
hndmigak nrl`giz`ting, suppnrtak my kat`ibak tr`gsiting pb`gs. [ja Idpbadagt`ting Uj`sa wibb
malig upng tja hbnsigl
nf
tja Darlar `gk wibb igvnbva tja axahuting nf ja tr`gsiting pb`gs
kavabnpak ig tja @ssassdagt Uj`sa. [ja Idpbadagt`ting Uj`sa wibb ighbuka ` Hustndar K`y
0 avagt, wjihj wibb ma ` silgifih`gt dibastnga ig tja Darlar Igtalr`ting Ub`g s it is tja k`ta ng
wjihj tja prid`ry hustndar- `gk hbiagt-f`higl hj`glas kavabnpak kurigl tja @ssassdagt Uj`sa
`ra idpbadagtak. [ja Idpbadagt`ting Uj`sa wibb hnghbuka, `gk tja \igk-Knwg Uj`sa wibb
malig, upng tja hndpbating
nf
a`hj igkiviku`b tr`gsiting pb`g kavabnpak kurigl tja @ssassdagt
Uj`sa. [ja \igk-Knwg Uj`sa wibb igvnbva tja wigk-knwg
nfbal`hy
First Gi`l`r` npar`tings
fnbbnwigl hndpbating nf ja Idpbadagt`ting Uj`sa.
Fnr `kkiting`b igfnrd`ting ral`rkigl tja Darlar Igtalr`ting Ub`g, pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimit
tn tjis ]aspngsa Xumdissing.
=
Urnvika tja fnbbnwigl `htu`b `gk prn fnrd` fig`ghi`b igfnrd`ting, `s
nf
Xaptadmar 85,
=501.
`. Fnr OayHnrp3
i. @htu`b `gk prn fnrd` m`b`gha sjaat, ng ` p`ragt-ngby `gk hngsnbik`tak m`sis.
ii @htu`b `gk prn fnrd` riso-m`sak h`pit`b, hnddng aquity
tiar
0 h`pit`b ( HA[0 )
`gk bavar`la r`tins (witj rabav`gt h`bhub`tings). @bb hndpngagts nf h`pit`b sjnubk
ma hba`rby ikagtifiak. [ja gudar`tnr
`gk
kagndig`tnr
nf
a`hj h`bhub`tak r`tin
dust ma `s nf tja s`da pnigt ig tida, Xaptadmar 85, =501.
Fnr tja igfnrd`ting raquastak my tjis Puasting =(`), pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimit =(`) tn tjis
]aspngsa Xumdissing.
m.
Fnr
OayM`go G`ting`b @ssnhi`ting ( OayM`go ), Hbavab`gk, Njin3
i @htu`b `gk prn fnrd` m`b`gha sjaat.
55=;8:[email protected]:88805
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
3/8
ii. @htu`b `gk prn fnrd` riso-m`sak h`pit`b, HA[0, `gk bavar`la r`tins `s raquastak
`mnva ig =.`.ii.
Fnr tja igfnrd`ting raquastak
my
tjis Puasting =(m), pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimit =(m) tn tjis
]aspngsa Xumdissing.
8. \itj raspaht tn tja kua kibilagha raviaw
nf
First Gi`l`r` hngkuhtak my OayHnrp
ig
hnggahting witj tja prnpnsak `hquisiting3
`. Kishuss oay figkigls, ighbukigl `ra`s nf wa`ogassas, if `gy, tj`t OayHnrp ikagtifiak.
Fnr tja igfnrd`ting raquastak my tjis Puasting 8(`), pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimit 8 tn tjis
]aspngsa Xumdissing.
m. Kashrima OayHnrp's pb`gs tn `kkrass `gy ikagtifiak kafihiaghias fnbbnwigl
hngsudd`ting
nf
tja prnpnsak tr`gs`hting.
nr
tja igfnrd`ting raquastak my tjis Puasting 8(m , pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimit 8 tn tjis
]aspngsa Xumdissing.
;. nr OayM`go, prnvika tja fnbbnwigl `htu`b `gk prn fnrd` `ssat qu`bity igfnrd`ting (ig
knbb`r `dnugt tnt`bs), `s nf Xaptadmar 85, =5013
`.
Ntjar
`ssats aspahi`bby dagtingak.
m. Hb`ssifiak ssats, hndprisak
nftja
sap`r`ta h`talnrias nf sumst`gk`rk, knumtfub, `gk
bnss (witj rabav`gt hndpngagts nf N]AN, sap`r`taby ikagtifiak
ig
a`hj h`talnry).
h
Gngparfnrdigl `ssats hndprisak nftja sap`r`ta h`talnrias nf tnt`b gng`hhru`b
bn`gs? N]AN `gk ntjar rapnssassak `ssats? `gk tja fnbbnwigl trnumbak kamt
rastruhturigls3 (i) ig hndpbi`gha witj tjair tards? ii) 85-:9 k`ys p`st kua? iii) 95
k`ys `gk lra`tar p`st kua? (iv) ng gng`hhru`b.
k. @hhruigl bn`gs 95 k`ys p`st kua.
Fnr tja igfnrd ting raquastak
my
tjis Puasting ;, pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimits ; 1 tn tjis
]aspngsa Xumdissing.
1. nr First Gi`l`r` M`go, G`ting`b @ssnhi ting ( First Gi`l`r` M`go ), Muff`bn, Gaw
Ynro, prnvika tja s`da (`htu`b `s nf Xaptadmar 85, =501, ngby) `ssat qu`bity
igfnrd`ting `s raquastak fnr OayM`go `mnva.
Fnr tja igfnrd`ting raquastak my tjis Puasting 1, pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimits ; 1 tn tjis
]aspngsa Xumdissing.
6. [ja `ppbih`ting st`tas tj`t _tTjraa nfOay's dnst saginr axahutivas, ighbukigl
_OayM`go HANT Dr. _HjristnpjarT Lnrd`g, wibb ma kakih`tak fubb-tida tn
tja
igtalr`ting nf First Gi`l`r` igtn OayHnrp. Kishuss OayHnrp's pb`gs tn agsura tj`t tja
axistigl rnbas
nf
tjasa axahutivas wibb ma `kaqu`taby hnvarak kurigl tja igtalr`ting
parink.
=
55=;8:[email protected]:88805
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
4/8
Kurigl tja igtalr`ting parink, Dr. Hjristnpjar Lnrd`g, Dr. Hr`il Muffia, `gk Dr. Mnm
Ka@glabis wibb ma kakih`tak fubb-tida tn tja igtalr`ting nf First Gi`l`r` igtn OayHnrp, wjiba
tjair pra-igtalr`ting raspahtiva rnbas nfUrasikagt, Oay Hnrpnr`ta M`go, HjiafJud`g ]asnurhas
Nffihar, `gk Kirahtnr, Agtarprisa Urnlr`d D`g`ladagt Nffiha wibb ma `kaqu`taby hnvarak kurigl
tja igtalr`ting parink ig `hhnrk`gha witj axistigl suhhassing pb`gs, `s furtjar kashrimak mabnw.
Hnrpnr`ta M`go
Ds. @glab` D`ln, OayHnrp's Ja`k nf ]a`b Ast`ta H`pit`b prinr tn tja igtalr`ting parink, `gk
Dr. ]`gky U iga, OayHnrp's Ja`k nfOayM`gh H`pit`b D`roats prinr tn tja igtalr ting parink,
wibb sarva `s hn-Ja`ks
nf
tja Hnrpnr`ta M`go kurigl tja igtalr`ting parink. Ds. D`ln wibb
hngtigua tn d`g`la `bb adpbnyaas ig tja ]a`b Ast`ta H`pit`b lrnup, wjiba Dr. U`iga wibb d`g`la
`bb adpbnyaas ig tja Hnrpnr`ta M`go ntjar tj`g tjnsa ig ]a`b Ast`ta H`pit`b. [nlatjar, Ds. D`ln
`gk Dr. U`iga wibb raprasagt `gk rapnrt
ng
tja Hnrpnr`ta M`go mafnra OayHnrp's Mn`rk nf
Kirahtnrs. Dr. Lnrd`g wibb hngtigua tn raprasagt tja Hnrpnr`ta M`go ig rab`tings witj
OayHnrp's `g`byst `gk igvastnr hnddugity gk wibb hngtigua tn sarva `s tja HAN nfOayM`go.
Jud`g ]asnurhas
Ds. O`ta [arrabb, OayHnrp's Kirahtnr nf Hndpags`ting Magafits prinr tn tja igtalr`ting, wibb
sarva `s OayHnrp's Igtarid
Hjiaf Jud`g ]asnurhas Nffihar kurigl tja igtalr`ting parink.
OayHnrp 's Jud`g ]asnurhas Ba`karsjip [a`d wibb rapnrt tn Ds. [arrabb kurigl tja igtalr`ting
parink ral`rkigl tja jud`g rasnurhas-rab`tak d`g`ladagt nfOayHnrp.
D`roatigl. Hbiagt Igsiljts @g`bytihs
Ds. [rig` Av`gs, OayHnrp's Ja`k
nf
ja Hnrpnr`ta Hagtar prinr tn tja igtalr`ting, wibb sarva `s
tja Ja`k
nf
D`roatigl, Hbiagt Igsiljts @g`bytihs kurigl tja igtalr`ting parink, ig kkiting tn
d`igt`igigl jar rnba `s tja Ja`k
nf
ja Hnrpnr`ta Hagtar. [ja Kirahtnr
nf
D`roatigl `gk a`hj
nf
tja Kirahtnrs nfbgsiljts `gk @g`bytihs wibb rapnrt tn Ds. Av`gs kurigl tja igtalr`ting parink.
Dr. Mnm Ka@glabis wibb hngtigua tn ba`k OayHnrp's Agtarprisa Urncaht D`g`ladagt Nffiha `gk
tja [r`gsiting Urncaht Nffiha.
Hngsudar Hndpbi`gha `gk Hnddugity ]aigvastdagt @ht ( H]@ )
< [n tja axtagt gnt `bra`ky prnvikak, prnvika `g upk`ta ng OayM`go's H]@ `htivitias
sigha its Nhtnmar =500 H]@ Uarfnrd`gha Av`bu`ting, `gk ng First Gi`l`r` M`go's
H]@ `htivitias sigha its D`rhj =55< H]@ Uarfnrd`gha Av`bu`ting, ig avary m`goigl
d`roat ig wjihj tja m`gos npar`ta. Ighbuka ig ynur raspngsa fnr a`hj m`go `gy
silgifih`gt H]@ igiti tivas ugkart`oag, p`rtihub`rby witj raspaht tn hrakit
`gk
kapnsit
prnkuhts `gk rat`ib m`goigl sarvihas t`rlatak tnw`rk bnw- `gk dnkar`ta-ighnda
( BDI ) lanlr`pjias
`gk
igkiviku`bs.
Ig
`kkiting, prnvika igfnrd`ting fnr a`hj m`go,
`s `ppbih`mba, ng hnddugity kavabnpdagt bagkigl, igvastdagts, `gk sarvihas sigha its
b`st av`bu`ting parink, ighbukigl tja tnt`b gudmar, knbb`r `dnugt, `gk sarviha jnurs,
`gk ` mriaf kashripting nf a`hj m`go s dnst silgifih`gt hnddugity kavabnpdagt bn`gs,
igvastdagts, `gk sarvihas.
8
55=;8:[email protected]:88805
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
5/8
Fnr
igfnrd`ting ral`rkigl OayM`go's `gk First Gi`l`r`
M`go s
raspahtiva
H]@
`htivitias, pba`sa
saa U`rt IV.K. nf ja @ppbih`ting. @kkiting`b igfnrd`ting d`y ma prnvikak suppbadagt`bby.
: [ja @ppbih`ting gntas
tj`t
OayM`go rahaivak
`g
nvar`bb parfnrd`gha r`tigl
nf
Nuts t`gkigl ng its dnst rahagt H]@ ax`dig`ting my tja NHH, k`tak Nhtnmar 0,
=500. Jnwavar, st`ff gntas
tj`t
OayM`go rahaivak savar`b Gaaks tn Idprnva ( G[I )
r`tigls ig savar`b st`ta `ssassdagt `ra`s kaspita tja nvar`bb Nutst`gkigl r`tigl.
Kashrima jnw OayHnrp is `kkrassigl, nr j`s `kkrassak, tja fnbbnwigl G[I r`tigls3
`. Nvar`bb G[I r`tigl fnr tja st`ta nf Hnggahtihut (ighbukigl G[I r`tigl fnr tja
bagkigl tast)?
Xigha =50=, OayM`go gn bnglar npar`tas mr`ghjas ig Hnggahtihut.
m. Nvar`bb G[I r`tigl fnr tja st`ta
nf
Fbnrik` (ighbukigl G[I r`tigls fnr mntj tja
bagkigl `gk igvastdagt tasts)? `gk
OayM`go hurragtby npar`tas tjraa mr`ghjas ig Fbnrik` fnr priv`ta m`goigl hbiagts. @s tjasa
priv`ta nffihas wara ka gnvn nffihas ig Nhtnmar =500, OayM`go
j`k
vary biditak nppnrtugity fnr
hnddugity kavabnpdagt bagkigl gk igvastigl ig tja Fbnrik` d`roat t tja tida
nfOayM`go s
dnst rahagt
H]@
ax`dig`ting
my
tja NHH. Jnwavar, sigha tja =500
H]@
ax`dig`ting,
OayM`go j`s axtagkak `pprnxid`taby $;9 dibbing ig hnddugity kavabnpdagt bn`gs `gk j`s
prnvikak `pprnxid`taby $=8 dib bing ig hnddugity kavabnpdagt igvastdagts ig Fbnrik`.
h G[I r`tigl fnr tja igvastdagt tast fnr tja st`ta
nf
Dihjil`g.
@t tja tida nf its dnst rahagt
H]@
ax`dig`ting my tja NHH, Oay
M`go
j`k ` hngsikar`mba
hnddugity kavabnpdagt igvastdagt pnrtfnbin tjrnuljnut Dihjil`g. Jnwavar, ig tja
gg
@rmnr
Datrnpnbit`g Xt`tistih`b @ra` ( DX@ ), wjihj w`s sabahtak fnr fubb-shnpa raviaw ig tja =500
H]@
ax`dig`ting, OayM`go's hnddugity kavabnpdagt igvastdagt pnrtfnbin
nf
`pprnxid`taby
$=5; dibbing w`s
nf
hndp`r`tivaby dnkast siza kua tn OayM`go's fnhus `t tja tida
ng
kavntigl
hnddugity kavabnpdagt rasnurhas tn tja Katrnit DX@. @s ` rasubt
nf
its =500
G[I
r`tigl fnr tja
igvastdagt tast fnr Dihjil`g, OayM`go rafigak its hnddugity kavabnpdagt igvastdagt str`taly
fnr Dihjil`g gk
j s
sigha prnvikak dnra tj`g $06 dibbing ig Bnw-Ighnda Jnusigl [`x Hrakit
( BIJ[H ) igvastdagts ig tja
gg
@rmnr
DX@
`gk dnra tj`g $88.1 dibbing ig BIJ[H
igvastdagts tjrnuljnut tja st`ta.
9 Igkih`ta wjatjar tja hngsudar hndpbi`gha, f`ir bagkigl hndpbi`gha, `gk H]@
prnlr`ds nf tja darlak
m`go
wibb ma OayHnrp 's hurragt prnlr`ds, First Gi`l`r`'s
hurragt
prnlr`ds, snda hndmig`ting
nf
tja hurragt prnlr`ds
nf
OayHnrp
`gk
First
Gi`l`r`, nr prnlr`ds kavabnpak frnd ntjar snurhas. Kishuss jnw tjasa da`suras
wnubk ma idpbadagtak `t tja darlak igstituting.
Ng hngsudd`ting
nf
ja prnpnsak tr`gs`hting, OayM`go 's
H]@
hndpbi`gha prnlr`d, pnbihias
`gk igiti`tivas wibb ma idpbadagtak fnr tja darlak m`go. OayM`go's hurragt
H]@
hndpbi`gha
;
55=;8:[email protected]:88805
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
6/8
prnlr`d is kasilgak tn ma sh`b`mba
`gk
wibb affahtivaby k`pt tn ighbuka First Gi`l`r` M`go s
`ssassdagt `ra`s.
OayM`go's kakih`tak
H]@ ta`d
j`s malug hngkuhtigl `g`bysas nf First Gi`l`r`'s hnddugity
bagkigl parfnrd`gha usigl pumbihby v`ib`mba Jnda Dnrtl`la Kishbnsura
@ht
( JDK@ ) `gk
Xd`bb Musigass @ht k`t` frnd =50=, =508, `gk =50;. OayM`go j`s `bsn agl`lak Hrnwa Jnrw`tj
BBU, ` tjirk-pru?ty hngsubt`gt, tn prnvika
`g
`kkiting`b parspahtiva ng tja H]@ `gk F`ir Bagkigl
parfnrd`ghas
nfOayM`go `gk
First Gi`l`r` M`go mntj igkiviku`bby
`gk
prnspahtivaby `s `
hndmigak nrl`giz`ting. Fnbbnwigl tja hbnsigl nf ja Darlar, OayM`go wibb parfnrd ` fubb k`t`
igtalrity raviaw nfFirst Gi`l`r` M`go s igtarg`b JDK@ `gk H]@ k`t`. M`sak ng tja rasubts nf
tj`t k`t` igtalrity raviaw, OayM`go wibb upk`ta rabav`gt prnhakuras gk hbnsaby dngitnr tja
hndmigak nrl`giz`ting's nvar`bb
k`t`
igtalrity.
@kkiting`bby, iddaki`taby fnbbnwigl tja hbnsigl
nf
ja Darlar, OayM`go wibb darla `bb ntjar
`spahts
nf
First Gi`l`r`
M`go s H]@
prnlr`d igtn OayM`go's
H]@
prnlr`d. [ja prid`ry
raspngsimibitias nfOayM`go s
H]@
prnlr`d ighbuka3
H]@
k`t` igtalrity?
H]@
`g`bysis (ighbukigl m`sak
ng
tja Bagkigl, Igvastdagt, Xarvihas tasts
nftja
NHH s
H]@
ax`dig`ting)?
Biga-nf-musigass
H]@
parfnrd`gha nvarsiljt `gk dngitnrigl?
@shart`igdagt nf hnddugity gaaks `ssassdagts?
Kavabnpdagt `gk idpbadagt`ting nf hnddugity agl`ladagt str`talias?
[ahjgih`b hndpbi`gha witj tja
H]@
raquiradagts?
]iso @ssassdagt `gk Lnvarg`gha, ]iso, `gk Hndpbi`gha rapnrtigl?
]aspngsas tn ralub`tnry, hnddugity `gk H]@-rab`tak hnddagts gk hndpb`igts? `gk
Idpbadagt`ting
nf
fnrw`rk-tjigoigl hnrpnr`ta str`taly tn `kkrass tja gaaks nf
hnddugitias.
05. [n tja axtagt gnt `bra`ky prnvikak, kashrima OayHnrp's kua kibilagha raviaw
spahifih`bby rab`tigl tn First Gi`l`r`'s hngsudar hndpbi`gha prnlr`d, f`ir bagkigl,
`gk
tja H]@. Igkih`ta tja k`tas nf tja raviaw, tja igkiviku`bs `gk nrl`giz`tings igvnbvak,
`gk d`cnr
`ra`s raviawak. Kishuss tja nvar`bb figkigls, `gy silgifih`gt kafihiaghias nr
issuas gntak, `gk `gy `htings pb`ggak tn `kkrass tja kafihiaghias.
Fnr
tja igfnrd`ting raquastak my tjis Puasting 05, pba`sa saa Hngfikagti`b Axjimit 05 tn tjis
]aspngsa Xumdissing.
00. Hngfird,
if
suhj is tja h`sa, tj`t fnbbnwigl hngsudd`ting
nf tja
prnpnsak tr`gs`hting,
tja First Gi`l`r` Fnugk`ting wibb ma hngtiguak ig tja hndmigak nrl`giz`ting. Kashrima
`gy prnpnsak hj`glas tn tja prid`ry dissing nf tja fnugk`ting.
Fnbbnwigl hngsudd`ting nf ja prnpnsak tr`gs`hting, tja First Gi`l`r` Fnugk`ting (tja
Fnugk`ting ) wibb ma hngtiguak ig tja hndmigak nrl`giz`ting. OayHnrp hurragtby knas gnt
prnpnsa gy hj`glas tn tja prid`ry dissing nf ja Fnugk`ting. @s OayHnrp hngtiguas tn rafiga
tja str`talih prinritias nftja hndmigak nrl`giz`ting, it wibb hngsikar `kcustdagts tn tja
1
55=;8:.()()[email protected]:88805
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
7/8
Fnugk`ting's dissing tj`t suppnrt d`oigl snugk igvastdagts ig tja rabav`gt hnddugitias.
0=. [ja @ppbih`ting st`tas tj`t tja prnpns`b w bb ag`mba OayHnrp tn `hjiava jiljar
a`rgigls tjrnulj hnst s`vigls `gk
tj`t
OayHnrp axpahts hnst s`vigls tn rasubt frnd,
`dngl ntjar tjigls, "nptidizigl nvarb`ppigl mr`ghjas." Kishuss jnw OayHnrp pb`gs
tn nptidiza nvarb`ppigl mr`ghjas, ighbukigl wjatjar OayHnrp `gtihip`tas hbnsigl
mr`ghjas. Fnr `gy `gtihip`tak mr`ghj hbnsuras, kishuss wjatjar suhj hbnsuras wibb ma
hndpbatasf ig `hhnrk`gha witj OayM`go's mr`ghj hbnsigl pnbihias `gk prnhakuras, tja
Igtar`laghy Unbihy Xt`tadagt ng Mr`ghj Hbnsuras,
`gk
0=
Q.X.H.
0:80r-0.
OayHnrp pb`gs tn nptidiza tja mr`ghj gatwnro tjrnulj mr`ghj hngsnbik`tings kua tn tja
da`giglfub mr`ghj nvarb`p matwaag tja axistigl mr`ghj gatwnros nf ja twn fr`ghjisas.
Xpahifih`bby, `s
nfKahadmar
==,=501,=9 nfFirst Gi`l`r`
M`go's
mr`ghjas `ra bnh`tak witjig
0.1 dibas nf `g axistigl OayM`go mr`ghj.
OayM`go j`s ast`mbisjak ` "Mr`ghj @hting Unbihy `gk Urnhakuras," sattigl fnrtj OayM`go's
nmbil`tings
tn
hndpby witj ppbih`mba fakar`b st`tutas, ralub`tings gk pnbihy st`tadagts rab`tak
tn mr`ghj npagigls, hbnsuras, rabnh`tings gk hngsnbik`tings, ighbukigl ugkar tja Cnigt Unbihy
Xt`tadagt Hnghargigl Mr`ghj Hbnsigl Gntihas `gk Unbihias. OayM`go wibb fnbbnw tja Mr`ghj
@hting Unbihy `gk Urnhakuras ig hnggahting witj futura mr`ghj hbnsuras
nr
hngsnbik`tings,
ighbukigl
my
nmt`igigl `bb raquirak `pprnv`bs (suhj `s `pprnv`bs
my
OayM`go's mn`rk
nf
kirahtnrs, axahutiva d`g`ladagt `gk hnddugity kavabnpdagt m`goigl ta`d) fnr suhj mr`ghj
hbnsuras nr hngsnbik`tings. OayM`go wibb sumdit ` gntiha nfmr`ghj hbnsigl tn tja NHH gn b`tar
tj`g 95 k`ys ig `kv`gha nf`gy mr`ghj hbnsura, `s raquirak my Xahting ;= nf tja Fakar`b Kapnsit
Igsur`gha @ht (0= Q.X.H. 0:80r-0). OayM`go wibb bsn prnvika raquirak gntifih`tings tn
hustndars
nf
`gy mr`ghj sumcaht tn ` prnpnsak hbnsura
my mntj
d`ibigl gntiha nf ja hbnsura tn
`ffahtak hngsudars `gk pnstigl tja gntiha ig tja mr`ghj.
08.
bfOayHnrp
`gtihip`tas `gy mr`ghj hbnsuras3
`. Urnvika ` bist
nf
mr`ghjas npar`tak my OayM`go
`gk
First Gi`l`r`
M`go tj`t
d`y
ma hbnsak, hngsnbik`tak, nr rabnh`tak ig tja hndmigak nrl`giz`ting's d`roats
fnbbnwigl hngsudd`ting
nf
tja prnpns`b, tn tja axtagt
tja
igfnrd`ting is `v`ib`mba.
@kkiting`b igfnrd`ting wibb ma prnvikak suppbadagt bby.
m. Kashrima tja prnhass OayHnrp is usigl tn katardiga tja gudmar
`gk
bnh`ting
nf
mr`ghj hbnsuras,
`gk
igkih`ta wjatjar `gy mr`ghjas
`ra
ig BDI tr`hts nr ig
ugkarsarvak nr kistrassak `ra`s.
@kkiting`b igfnrd`ting wibb ma prnvikak suppbadagt`bby.
h Kashrima `gy `htivitias tj`t OayHnrp pb`gs tn ugkart`oa tn ditil`ta tja pntagti`b
idp`ht
nf
tja mr`ghj hbnsuras ig tjnsa hnddugitias. f suhj igfnrd`ting is gnt yat
`v`ib`mba, prnvika `g astid`tak tidafr`da fnr its `v`ib`mibity `gk prnvika
it
iddaki`taby upng its mahndigl `v`ib`mba.
6
55=;8:[email protected]:888 5
-
7/24/2019 ICP Protested Key - First Niagara, Now FOIAs Withheld Answers
8/8
@kkiting`b igfnrd`ting wibb ma prnvikak suppbadagt`bby.
0;. @ hnddagtar nmcahtak tn
tja
prnpns`b ng tja m`sis nf tja pntagti`b idp`ht gk cnm
bnssas nftja hngtadpb`tak hbnsigl nf m`goigl f`hibitias ig _Gaw YnroT `ssnhi`tak witj
tja prnpnsak hquisiting... Uba`sa raspngk tn tjis hnddagt.
OayM`go j`s ` bngl-st`gkigl rahnrk `s `g adpbnyar witjig tja Xt`ta
nfGaw
Ynro. Dnra tj`g
=,655 OayM`go prnfassing`bs, raprasagtigl dnra tj`g =5%
nfOayM`go's
agtira wnrofnrha, biva
`gk wnro ig ;5 hnugtias tjrnuljnut Gaw Ynro Xt`ta. OayM`go's
Gaw
Ynro Xt`ta wnrofnrha
raprasagts ` $=55 dibbing p`yrnbb, `gk dnra tj`g =5% nfOayM`go's musigass is hngkuhtak
witjig tja Xt`ta nfGaw Ynro.
[ja prnpnsak Darlar
s
`g nppnrtugity fnr OayM`go tn sabaht adpbnyaas frnd mntj OayM`go
`gk First Gi`l`r` M`go wjnsa t`bagt, ta`dwnro `gk ba`karsjip h`g jabp tja hndmigak
nrl`giz`ting ra`hj its fubb pntagti`b.
Mabnw `ra twn ax`dpbas nfOayM`go's hndditdagt tn digidiza cnm bnss rasubtigl frnd tja
prnpnsak Darlar3
OayM`go j`s pb`gs tn kavabnp its nwg ig-jnusa rasikagti`b dnrtl`la bn`g nrilig`ting
h`p`mibitias, `gk igtagks tn ighnrpnr`ta First Gi`l`r`'s axistigl bn`g sarvihigl ugit tn
sarva `s OayM`go's ugkarwritigl, fubfibbdagt `gk pnrtfnbin d`g`ladagt pb`tfnrds ig
suppnrt
nfOayM`go's
ig-jnusa dnrtl`la bn`g nrilig`ting prnhassas. @s ` kiraht rasubt nf
suhj ngmn`rkigl, OayM`go `gtihip`tas rat`igigl `pprnxid`taby 855 First Gi`l`r`
adpbnyaas ig rnbas hnggahtak witj rasikagti`b dnrtl`la ugkarwritigl, fubfibbdagt `gk
pnrtfnbin d`g`ladagt. Ig p`rtihub`r,
my
d`igt igigl First Gi`l`r`'s dnrtl`la fubfibbdagt
lrnup, OayM`go wibb rat`ig ` silgifih`gt gudmar nf nms ig Gaw J`vag, Hnggahtihut.
OayM`go j`s igstitutak `g agtarprisa-wika jirigl fraaza ig nrkar tn d`xidiza ratagting
nf
First Gi`l`r` adpbnyaas (witj h`sa-my-h`sa axhaptings fnr hritih`b `gk tida-sagsitiva
pnsitings nr pnsitings fnr wjihj First Gi`l`r` knas gnt hurragtby j`va adpbnyaa
rasnurhas).
01. OayHnrp j`s raprasagtak
tj`t
OayM`go j`s mal`g affnrts tn
mattar
ugkarst`gk
tja
gaaks nftja hnddugitias sarvak my Firs t Gi`l`r` M`go. Igkih`ta OayHnrp's figkigls
frnd tjasa affnrts. Ig `kkiting, prnvika ` tidat`mba fnr hndpbating nf tjis rasa`rhj `gk
wj`t staps OayM`go pb`gs tn t`oa tn kkrass tjasa figkigls.
OayHnrp j`s kavabnpak `gk b`ughjak ` hnddugity agl`ladagt pb`g rab`tak tn OayHnrp's
`hquisiting nf First Gi l`r . [ja pb`g w`s igiti`tak ng Nhtnmar 85, =501, tja k`y nf ja Darlar's
pumbih `ggnughadagt, `gk wibb hngtigua tjrnulj tja hbnsigl nf ja Darlar. [ja hnddugity
agl`ladagt pb`g hngtadpb`tas daatigls witj bnh`b `gk g`ting`b nrl`giz`tings tj`t d`y ma
idp`htak my tja prnpnsak tr`gs`hting, `s wabb s ig-kaptj `g`bysis `gk rasa`rhj nf mntj
OayHnrp's `gk First Gi`l`r`'s igvastdagts ig tja `ffahtak hnddugitias. Ig-parsng hnddugity
daatigls `ra `bsn maigl hngkuhtak tn igfnrd tja kavabnpdagt
nfOayHnrp's
hnddugity magafits
pb`g tn ma sumdittak tn tja Fakar`b ]asarva ig hnggahting witj tja @ppbih`ting.