ICCA Volume 4
Transcript of ICCA Volume 4
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 1/223
Gf{n} fc{ gifc l Bifd n}nfbn if Biou~ {n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53=
Til~on ;
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 3/223
Gf{ n} fc {gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} C uulg bc{gifr =53=
Til~on ;
Gf crribgc{gif zg{a
Crribgc{gif id Rbgnf{gr{r, Kntnliun}r cfk Dcb~l{gnr !CRKD', Gfkgc
Crribgc{gif id Biou~{n} Ocbagfn}w!CBO'
Rbgnfbn $ Nfjgfnn}gfj ]nrnc}ba R~uui}{ ribgn{w !RN]RB', @i}nc
A~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif, Gfdi}oc{gif Bioo~fgbc{gif Rwr{nor
=:/23 Hcf~c}w =53=
Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc
Nkg{i}/gf/Bagnd
@& @i`~lc @}grafc Ac}g
Nkg{i}r8
N Rcg`grai}n, [ ] R}gfgtcrcf, K Lijcfc{acf,
@ Miocffc}chc cfk ] Uiff~rcow
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 4/223
U~mlgrank mw
Crribgc{gif id Rbgnf{gr{r, Kntnliun}r cfk Dcb~l{gnrCkk}nrr8 =:, 2
}kocgf }ick, @~oc}cf Fcjc} Nq{f&, Lczrun{, Uifkgban}}w/4>551
Nocgl8 ckogfEcrkd&i}j&gf || zzz&crkd&i}j&gf
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr !GBBC =53='
TIL^ON ;
Nkg{i}/gf/Bagnd8 @& @i`~lc @}grafc Ac}g Nkg{i}r8 N Rcg`grai}n, [ ] R}gfgtcrcf, K Lijcfc{acf, @ Miocffc}chc cfk ] Uiff~rcow
Biuw}gja{ § =53= GBBC =53= I}jcfgxn}r& Cll }gja{r ]nrn}tnk
[agr mii`, i} uc}{r {an}nid, ocw fi{ mn }nu}ik~bnk gf cfw di}o i} mw cfw oncfr, nlnb{}ifgb i} onbacfgbcl, gfbl~kgfj
uai{ibiuwgfj, }nbi}kgfj i} cfw gfdi}oc{gif r{i}cjn cfk }n{}gntcl rwr{no fiz `fizf i} {i mn gftnf{nk, zg{ai~{ z}g{{nf
un}ogrrgif d}io {an GBBC =53= I}jcfgxn}r i} {an U~mlgran}&
Kgrblcgon}8
Fi }nruifrgmglg{w gr crr~onk mw {an GBBC =53= I}jcfgxn}r)U~mlgran} di} cfw gfh~}w cfk) i} kcocjn {i un}rifr i}
u}iun}{w cr c oc{{n} id u}ik~b{r lgcmglg{w, fnjlgjnfbn i} i{an}zgrn, i} d}io cfw ~rn i} iun}c{gif id cfw on{aikr, u}ik~b{r
i} gkncr bif{cgfnk gf {an oc{n}gcl an}ngf& Bif{nf{r, ~rnk gf {an ucun}r cfk aiz g{ gr r~mog{{nk cfk cuu}itnk mw {an
bif{}gm~{i}r cd{n} bacfjnr gf {an di}oc{{gfj& Zaglr{ ntn}w c{{nou{ ockn {i nfr~}n {ac{ cll crunb{r id {an ucun} c}n ~fgdi}o
gf r{wln, {an GBBC =53= I}jcfgxn}r, U~mlgran} i} {an Nkg{i}!r' zgll fi{ mn }nruifrgmln zac{rintn} di} {an cbb~}cbw,
bi}}nb{fnrr i} }nu}nrnf{c{gif id cfw r{c{nonf{r i} kib~onf{r u}nrnf{nk gf {an ucun}r &
GRMF/328 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4
GRMF/358 13/7=5>:>/:/4
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 5/223
U]NDCBN
[agr u}ibnnkgfj gr c uc}{ id Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= zagba zcr
anlk gf Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc d}io =:/Knb/=53= cfk 23/Knb/=53=& [agr bifdn}nfbn zcr air{nk mw
[nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w gf crribgc{gif zg{a Crribgc{gif id
Biou~{n} Ocbagfn}w!CBO', Crribgc{gif id Rbgnf{gr{r, Kntnliun}r cfk Dcb~l{gnr !CRKD', Gfkgc,
M}g{gra Biou~{n} Ribgn{w !MBR', ^@ cfk Rbgnfbn cfk Nfjgfnn}gfj R~uui}{gfj Ribgn{w !Ribgn{w',
@i}nc&
[an zi}lk gr bacfjgfj& D}io raiuugfj ocllr {i {}cfrui}{ {n}ogfclr, cg}b}cd{ {i ucrrnfjn} ragur, {an
gfd}cr{}~b{~}n id ribgn{w acr {i biun zg{a ntn} oi}n gf{nfrn cfk bioulnq dlizr id uniuln& [ikcw,
oi}n {acf ntn}, rcdn{w, nddgbgnfbw cfk biodi}{ c}n grr~nr {ac{ o~r{ mn ckk}nrrnk mw cll knrgjfn}r& [an
Zi}lk [}ckn Bnf{}n kgrcr{n} m}i~ja{ gf{i {}cjgb dib~r {an fnnk di} znll/knrgjfnk ntcb~c{gif rwr{nor&
[an fnz }nj~lc{i}w d}conzi}` gf {an oc}gfn gfk~r{}w, cb`fizlnkjnr fi{ iflw {an goui}{cfbn id
nfr~}gfj {ac{ {an m~gl{ nftg}ifonf{ gr rcdn, m~{ clri {an bnf{}cl }iln {ac{ ntcb~c{gif rgo~lc{gif bcf
ulcw gf cbagntgfj {agr&
Cf ckkg{gifcl fnnk gr {i knrgjf rucbnr di} nddgbgnfbw ‒ nfr~}gfj {ac{ ocqgo~o {a}i~jau~{ bcf mn
cbagntnk k~}gfj fi}ocl iun}c{gifr ‒ cfk biodi}{ ‒ nfr~}gfj {ac{ {an }nr~l{gfj dlizr iddn} lg{{ln
iuui}{~fg{w di} fnnklnrr s~n~gfj i} nqbnrrgtn bifjnr{gif& [anrn bioulnq knocfkr bacllnfjn
{}ckg{gifcl u}nrb}gu{gtn knrgjf j~gknr cfk }nj~lc{gifr& Knrgjfn}r cfk }nj~lc{i}r c}n bifrns~nf{lw
{~}fgfj {i un}di}ocfbn/mcrnk cfclwrgr cfk }nj~lc{gifr dcbglg{c{nk mw {an fnz jnfn}c{gif id uniuln
oitnonf{ oiknlr&
Zanf c j}nc{n} bacfjnr c}n cbagntnk {anrn ucr{ wnc}r, r{gll oi}n gr {i mn cbagntnk zagba r{gll rnnor
{i mn ml~n r`w id 37:5‗r& M~{ di} cll {an bacllnfjnr, bcucmglg{gnr bif{gf~n {i cktcfbn c{ uanfionfcl
runnk& Ntnf {a}nn wnc}r cji g{ ocw actn mnnf bifrgkn}nk c bacllnfjn {i un}di}o c fn{zi}` knrgjf
gftiltgfj {an ntcb~c{gif id ;>,555 uniuln d}io c 3=5 r{i}w m~glkgfj, m~{ zg{a {ikcw‗r riuagr{gbc{nk
oiknllgfj {iilr cfk agja/nfk UBr, {agr gr fiz uirrgmln& [ikcw‗r bacllnfjnr c}n o~ba oi}n comg{gi~r
cfk gftiltn rgo~lc{gfj {an oitnonf{ cfk mnactgi~} id itn} ifn ogllgif uniuln gf bg{w/rgxnk
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 6/223
jnion{}gnr& [an ocfcjnonf{ id {anrn fn{zi}` gr clri ncrw cfk oi}n runbgdgbcllw cll {an ;>,555
uniuln bcf mn oifg{i}nk mw c rgfjln un}rif rg{{gfj gf agr bcmgf& [agr acr mnnf {an ntgknfbn id {an
kntnliuonf{ {anrn kcwr&
Cr r~ba, {an bifdn}nfbn }nu}nrnf{r c ~fgs~n iuui}{~fg{w di} nqun}{r cfk mnjgffn}r {i jcgf gfrgja{ gf{i
{an }cugklw&
Clri G zi~lk lg`n {i {acf` cll {an bi/iun}c{i}r di} m}gfjgfj i~{ {anrn u}ibnnkgfjr di} wi~ zagba
ochi}lw gfbl~knr ow oio O}r& @& Lc`raog cfk ow kck O}& H& @~fcrn`c}cf& Cuc}{ d}io {ano ow
mgjjnr{ zi}{aw jcfj id d}gnfkr gfbl~kgfj K}& R& U}g{agt ]chcf, Bacg}ocf id {agr bifdn}nfbn, K}& ]& R&
R~kac`c}, Uc{}if id {agr Bifdn}nfbn, K}& C& Ocfg`cfkcf cfk K}& R& Ctgfcra, Biftnfn} id {agr
bifdn}nfbn, K}& N& Rcg @grai}n, I}jcfgxgfj Rnb}n{c}w id {agr Bifdn}nfbn cfk {an nf{g}n {nco zagba
zi}`nk clifj zg{a on di} {an }cugk r~bbnrr id {an bifdn}nfbn di} ucr{ 3 wnc} d}io {an kc{n id
gfg{gc{gfj {agr Bifdn}nfbn& Clri G fnnk {i cuu}nbgc{n U}id& [& ]& R}gfgtcrcf cfk agr {nco id Tgkwcc
Tg`cr Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw di} anlugfj {i oc`n {an u~mlgbc{gif him ncrw&
Dgfcllw, G {acf` ow dcoglw, d}gnfkr, r{~knf{r cfk billncj~nr di} {ang} bifr{cf{ nfbi~}cjnonf{ cfk
r~uui}{ di} oc`gfj {agr {wun id bifdn}nfbn&
// @& @i`~lc @}grafc Ac}g Nkg{i}/gf/Bagnd
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 7/223
I}jcfgxgfj Bioog{{nn
Bagnd Uc{}if
@i`~lc @}grafc Ac}g @, Di~fkn} $ U}nrgknf{, [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc
Uc{}if
R~kac`c} ] R, Bagnd Nqnb~{gtn Iddgbn}!BNI', [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc
Bacg}ocf
U}g{agt ]chcf R, Bacg}ocf $ Cktgri}, [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc
Biftnfn}
Ocfg`cfkcf C, Bagnd A~ocf ]nri~}bnr Iddgbn}!BA]I', [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc
I}jcfgxgfj Rnb}n{c}w
Rcg @grai}n N Bagnd Gfdi}oc{gif Iddgbn}, [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
Iun}c{gifr Bacg}
J R [ioc} Kg}nb{i}, OG] Lcmr, Jzclgi}, Gfkgc
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bacg}
Occ}~d Clg Nqnb~{gtn Kg}nb{i}, !CRKD' / N~}iun, N~}iun
Airug{clg{w
O~{a~clcjcf ] Clcjcuuc Billnjn id [nbafilijw, Banffcg
Gfk~r{}w Lgcgrif Bacg}
Ocfg`cfkcf R Nqnb~{gtn Rnb}n{c}w, [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc
[nbafgbcl Ucfnlr Bacg}
Knmfc{a Mac{{cbac}wwc, Nqnb~{gtn Kg}nb{i}, !CRKD' / Znr{ Mnfjcl, Gfkgc
[nbafgbcl Bacg}
Rcog} @~oc} Mcfkwiuckawcw Di}on} ]njgr{}c}, ^fgtn}rg{w id Bclb~{{c, Gfkgc
Uiff~rcow ] U}nrgknf{, C}{gdgbgcl Gf{nllgjnfbn Crribgc{gif id Gfkgc, Gfkgc
R}gfgtcrcf [ ],Tgbn/U}gfbgucl, Tgkwcc Tg`cr Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 8/223
Zi}`raiur Ucfnl Bacg}
Lijcfc{acf K Knuc}{onf{ id Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn cfk Nfjgfnn}gfj, Uifkgban}}w
Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
OGR Bi/I}kgfc{i}
Ac}gra J [}~r{nn, [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w
Cbcknogb Bacg}
Mioocffc ]chc @, U}gfbgucl, Nqbnl Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj di} Zionf, Gfkgc
[cg/Aiif @go U}idnrri} $ Bacg}ocf, Knu{& id O~l{gonkgc, Acfoco ^fgtn}rg{w, @i}nc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 9/223
[NBAFGBCL ]NTGNZN]R
• Ckn{awc R~kc}rcfcf Bijfgxcf{ [nbafilijw Ril~{gifr, Gfkgc
• Cgf~kkgf ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
• Chcw Bac`}ctc}{aw ^fgtn}rg{w id Ri~{acou{if, ^@
• Clnrrcfk}i ]gxxg ^fgtn}rg{w id Oglcf, G{clw
• Cl/Rc`gm @acf Uc{acf Gf{n}fc{gifcl Grlcogb ^fgtn}rg{w, Oclcwrgc
• Cfjnlgfc Jnn{ac M R Cmk~} ]caocf ^fgtn}rg{w, Banffcg
• C}co~kacf O U@GN[, @c}cg`cl, Gfkgc
• C}gtcxacjcf R Onubi Rbalnf` Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• C}i`gcrcow C Cfhclcg Coocl Ocaclgfjco Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• C}~l Lcz}nfbn Rnltc`~oc} C Ckaguc}crc`{ag Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• C}~lo~}~jcf T Uifkgban}}w fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• C}~fc Knir`c} Gfr{g{~{n id Gfk~r{}gcl $ Biou~{n} Ocfcjnonf{ cfk ]nrnc}ba, U~fn
• Cragra Bac~}crgc Jwcf Jcfjc Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw $ Rbgnfbnr, Hcmclu~}, Gfkgc
• Cragra ]cr{ijg J~}~ Jacrgkcr ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Cra~{ira @~oc} K~mnw [}gfg{w Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw $ ]nrnc}ba, Gfkgc
• Ctckacfg U R Cfka}c ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Mactcfc J~u{c Cll Rcgf{r Billnjn id [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• Mgfj Rag ^fgtn}rg{w id Ri~{acou{if, ^@
• B C}~f ]& O& @& Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• Bacfk}crn`c}cf O Jitn}fonf{ Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Rclno, Gfkgc
• Bacfk}crn`c}cf R ]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Banffcg, Gfkgc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 10/223
• Bac~kac}g C L ^fgtn}rg{w id U~fn, Gfkgc
• Bagfj/Argnf Ar~ Ba~fj A~c ^fgtn}rg{w, [cgzcf
• Bag{}c @}grafcoii}{aw R{ Hirnuar Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• Ba}gr{gcf Nr{ntn ]i{anfmn}j BUsK ![nlnbio ]nrnc}ba Bnf{n}', M}cxgl
• Ba~f/Bagna A~cfj Ogfjargf ^fgtn}rg{w id Rbgnfbn cfk [nbafilijw, [cgzcf
• Kc}racf O Jillc Cfka}c ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Nltgfgc ]gbbimnfn ^fgtn}rg{w id Oglcf, G{clw
• Dcxgkca I{aocf ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
• D~ltgi D}c{g ^fgtn}rg{w id Oglcf, G{clw
• J Hnwc`~oc} Co}g{c Rbaiil id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• Jnn{ac}cocfg ] ]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Banffcg, Gfkgc
• Jnog`ifc`lg I Ogkklnrnq ^fgtn}rg{w, ^@
• Jacrrnoliiw X Fi}{a~om}gc ^fgtn}rg{w, ^@
• J}nji}gi Oc}{gfnx Un}nx ^fgtn}rg{w id O~}bgc, Rucgf
• Acogk Cmk~llc ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
• Acf~ocf{ac ]nkkw [ ]ci Mcack~} W Ocacmclnrzc}cuuc Nfjgfnn}fj Billnjn, Mnllc}w
• Ac}g Oiacf Ucfknw FOGOR ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Anljn Lcfjrn{a Fi}znjgcf ^fgtn}rg{w id Rbgnfbn cfk [nbafilijw, Fi}zcw
• Gif [~{cfnrb~ ^fgtn}rg{w id Ug{nr{g, ]iocfgc
• Hcgon Lli}n{ ^fgtn}rgkck Uilg{nbfgbc kn Tclnfbgc, Rucgf
• Hnwc Oclc K [agcjc}chc} Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• Hgfh~f Banf ^fgtn}rg{w id [nbafilijw Rwkfnw, C~r{}clgc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 11/223
• Hinl ]ik}gj~nr ^fgtn}rg{w id Mng}c Gf{n}gi}, Ui}{~jcl
• Hiaf Rcfhnnt @~oc} C [agcjc}chc} Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• Hirnua O Oi{an} [n}crc Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj $ [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• @ Jiuclcf U}idnrri}, U~}k~n ^fgtn}rg{w Bcl~on{, ^R
• @ F ]ci Cfka}c ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• @cbazclc [ FOGOR fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• @cffcf Mclcr~m}cocfgcf Onubi Rbalnf` Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• @cffcf F Hcwc}co Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw, [}gbaw, Gfkgc
• @cr{~}g Knzg Tc}c{acf ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
• @c{ag}tnl C @c}ucjc Tgfcwcjc Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj $ [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• @ctg{c Rgfja ^fgtn}rg{w id Knlag, Gfkgc
• @g}cf @~oc}g Uc{gl ]ntc Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw cfk Ocfcjnonf{, Mcfjcli}n, Gfkgc
• @}grafcocbac} R}nnfgtcrcf GG[/@J, Gfkgc
• @~oc} K Un}gwc} Ocfgcoocg fgtn}rg{w, [acfhct~}, Gfkgc
• Lchir Acfxi Bacg} id [nlnbioo~fgbc{gifr, ^fgtn}rg{w id Ri~{acou{if, ^@
• Lifjmgfj Bci ^fgtn}rg{w id [nbafilijw, Rwkfnw
• L~jocw} C}{~} [nqcr R{c{n ^fgtn}rg{w, ^fg{nk R{c{nr
• O Ac}gAc}cR~kacf Uifkgban}}w fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Ocanrzc}cf ] Onubi Rbalnf` Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• Oclo~}~jcf F @clcgjfc} @c}~fcfgkag Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• Ocfh~ Lc{c Cjc}zcl ^fgtn}rg{w id Knlag, Gfkgc
• Ocxlgxc I{aocf ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 12/223
• Oiacoock O Mcfc{ Hi}kcf ^fgtn}rg{w id Rbgnfbn cfk [nbafilijw
• Oifg R FGB / JiG, Gfkgc
• Oòfgbc Cj~glc} Gjc}{~c ^fgtn}rg{c{ Uilg{ábfgbc kn Bc{cl~fwc, Rucgf
• O~`nra K& Uc{gl Gfkgcf Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw, O~omcg, Gfkgc
• O~}{aw M @ Knuc}{onf{ id Gfdi}oc{gif cfk [nbafilijw / JiG, Gfkgc
• Fcjc}chcf R @ Cffcoclcg ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Fglcfhcf Bac{{iuckawcw R U Hcgf Gfr{g{~{n id Ocfcjnonf{ $ ]nrnc}ba, O~omcg, Gfkgc
• Fgliw Jcfj~lw GG[/@J, Gfkgc
• Fi}fcxlg{c A~rrgf ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
• Ucfbacfc{aco F Cffcoclcg ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Uc}tc{ac Tc}{agfg M R{ Hirnua‗r Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• Uc}tnnf Mnjco OCO Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw, [}gbaw
• Ucrbcl Ag{xln} Z}gja{ R{c{n ^fgtn}rg{w, Kcw{if, ^R
• Ugh~ra @cf{g Mac{{cbac}hnn Crrco fgtn}rg{w, Crrco, Gfkgc
• Uiffcoocl Fc{c}chcf ]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Banffcg, Gfkgc
• Uii}fc Mclc`}grafcf Ncrzc}g Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• Uii}fcbacfk}c R ]OK Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• U}ckgu @~oc} Mclc GG[, ]ii}`nn
• U}crcffc F [OJ Billnjn, Gfkgc
• U}no Racf`c} Jinl Bacg}ocf / ]CN, K]KI/JiG, Gfkgc
• U}gwnra @cf~fji Uc{nl J}i~u id Gfr{g{~{gifr, Gfkgc
• ]ckac R RRF Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Banffcg, Gfkgc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 13/223
• ]ckac`}grafcf T Oii`cogmgjcg Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• ]chc @ Fc}cr~*r Rc}c{aw Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• ]co Racfo~jco [nqcr R{c{n ^fgtn}rg{w, ^fg{nk R{c{nr
• ]co`~oc} H TLM Hcfc`gcoocl billnjn id C}{r $ Rbgnfbn, Gfkgc
• ]ci K A Hcgf Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• ]ctgbacfk}cf B J ] T R Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• ]ctg`cf{ Rzcog C}fg ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• ]ctg}chc R ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
• ]grack C Racdg` ^fgtn}rg{w id Ri~{acou{if, ^@
• ]~k}c U U}ckacf GG[/@JU, Gfkgc
• Rcaccwc C}~l Oc}w R C Hcwc}co Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj $ [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• Rcfhcw Bac~kac}w KC/GGB[, Gfkgc
• Rcfhcw @ Hcgf ^fgtn}rg{w id Knlag, Gfkgc
• Rc{annra @~oc} @J Crgcf Rbaiil id M~rgfnrr, [}gtcfk}~o, Gfkgc
• Rc~}cma K~{{c K} M B ]iw Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, K~}jcu~}, Gfkgc
• Rnf{acoc}cg @cffcf R [agcjc}chc} Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• Rnf{agl C}cr~ M Fc{gifcl Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw / [}gbaw, Gfkgc
• Rnf{agl @~oc} C T Agfk~r{cf Billnjn, Bigomc{i}n, Gfkgc
• Racfo~jco C Mcffc}g Coocf Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw, N}ikn, Gfkgc
• Rac}if Ucfkn FOGOR fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• Ranglc Cfcfk ]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Banffcg, Gfkgc
• Ranfmcjc}ch ] Onubi Rbalnf` Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 14/223
• Ragluc Macln}ci DBC Cb}iuilgr Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw cfk ]nrnc}ba
• Rgfjc}ctnl J @& R& ]& Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• Rgtcmclcf C RO@ Dio}c Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• Rgtc`~oc} K Cffc ^fgtn}rg{w, Banffcg
• Rgtc`~oc} T H Fc{gifcl Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw / [}gbaw, Gfkgc
• Rgtcr~m}cocfgcf C R{ Hirnuar Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• R}nnfgtcrc ]nkkw N Cbac}wc Fcjc}h~fc ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
• R}g Kntg ]ctcfc ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
• R}gfgtcrcf C OFO Hcgf Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Banffcg
• R}gfgtcrcf @ R Ncrzc}g Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Banffcg, Gfkgc
• R{ndcfir J}g{xclgr ^fgtn}rg{w id {an Cnjncf, J}nnbn
• R{nltgi Bgoc{i ^fgtn}rg{w id Oglcf, G{clw
• R~m}cocfgcf @ GJFI^, Gfkgc
• R~}nra J ] KOG Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Banffcg, Gfkgc
• [~lg`c Ucfknw Knuc}{onf{ id Gfdi}oc{gif cfk [nbafilijw / JiG, Gfkgc
• Tcr~kac Mac{fcjc} ^fgtn}rg{w id Knlag, Gfkgc
• Tnf`c{c}cocfg W Rc}cfc{acf Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Gfkgc
• Tn}oc ] R Higf{ Kg}nb{i}, Knuc}{onf{ id Gfdi}oc{gif cfk [nbafilijw / JiG, Gfkgc
• Tghcwclc`raog @ Onubi Rbalnf` Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Gfkgc
• Tghcwclc`raog R Tnlli}n Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw, Gfkgc
• Tglln L~i{ifnf An}ogc Lgog{nk, Rucgf
• Tgoclc Mclc`}grafcf ^fgtn}rg{w id Oclcwc, Oclcwrgc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 15/223
• Tgraf~u}crck Fcjckntc}c Gfkgcf Gfr{g{~{n id Ocfcjnonf{ / Mcfjcli}n, Gfkgc
• Zcfj Zng ^fgtn}rg{w id Fi{{gfjaco, Oclcwrgc
• W~lng Z~ Bagfnrn Cbcknow id Rbgnfbnr, Bagfc
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 16/223
Uc}{ ‒ G
U}ibnnkgfjr id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if
Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ =53=
GBBC ‑3=
Til~on ;
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 17/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;=53)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;=53
CMR[]CB[/ A~ocf Biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif gf {an dgnlk
id gfu~{ cfk i~{u~{ {nbafgs~nr acr kntnliunk c li{ id fnz
{nbafgs~nr itn} {an lcr{ dnz wnc}r& Zg{a {an }nbnf{lw }nlncrnk
d~ll o~l{g/{i~ba {cmln{r cfk fi{nmii`r {an zcw aiz uniuln
gf{n}cb{ zg{a {an biou~{n} gr biogfj {i c fnz kgonfrgif& Cr
a~ocfr c}n ~rnk {i acfkln {agfjr zg{a {ang} acfkr {an
{nbafilijw id o~l{g/{i~ba kgrulcwr i} {i~bauck*r m}i~ja{
o~ba oi}n biftnfgnfbn di} ~rn gf kcglw lgdn& M~{ di} r~}n {an
~rcjn id a~ocf runnba }nbijfg{gif zgll clri ulcw cf
goui}{cf{ uc}{ gf {an d~{~}n id a~ocf biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif&[agr ucun} gf{}ik~bnr {nbafgs~nr cfk kntgbnr ~rgfj {an
a~ocfr acfk jnr{~}nr di} {an ~rn zg{a o~l{g/{i~ba {cmln{r
cfk tgkni }nbijfg{gif cfk {nbafgs~nr di} tigbn gf{n}cb{gif&
[an}nmw {an jnr{~}n cfk runnba }nbijfg{gif {c`n cf
goui}{cf{ }iln cr {anrn c}n {an ocgf bioo~fgbc{gif on{aikr
mn{znnf a~ocfr cfk aiz {anw bi~lk kgr}~u{ {an `nwmic}k i}
oi~rn cr zn `fiz g{ {ikcw&
@nwzi}kr/Ogb}irid{ r~}dcbn,Kgrulcq {o,J^G n{b
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Cr onf{gifnk mndi}n, o~ba zi}` gf {an rnb{i} id a~ocf biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif, gf {an dgnlk id gfu~{ cfk
i~{u~{ {nbafgs~nr, acr mnnf ockn rgfbn {an lcr{ wnc}r&Fiz rgfbn {an }nlncrn id {an o~l{g/{i~ba {cmln{r cfk
fi{nmii`r, rion id {anrn kntnliunk o~l{g/{i~ba
{nbafgs~nr c}n biogfj gf{i u}cb{gbcl ~rcjn& [a~r g{ zgll
r~}nlw {c`n fi{ o~ba {gon {ac{ riuagr{gbc{nk {nbafgs~nr
zgll nfacfbn {anrn {nbafgs~nr di} a~ocf jnr{~}n i} tigbn
kn{nb{gif& [anrn {zi fnz on{aikr zgll di} r~}n ulcw cf
goui}{cf{ }iln id aiz {an ABG gf d~{~}n zgll bacfjn cfk
aiz uniuln bcf gf{n}cb{ oi}n ncrglw zg{a {ang} biou~{n} gf
kcglw lgdn&
Anzn{{, n{ cl kndgfnk {ac{ -A~ocf biou~{n}
gf{n}cb{gif gr c kgrbgulgfn bifbn}fnk zg{a {an knrgjf,
ntcl~c{gif cfk goulnonf{c{gif id gf{n}cb{gtn biou~{gfj
rwr{nor di} a~ocf ~rn cfk zg{a {an r{~kw id ochi}uanfionfc r~}}i~fkgfj {ano& Ri rgfbn {an gftnf{gif id
{an A~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}dcbn gf {an 37:5r c{ Qn}iq Uc}`,
zn c}n ~rnk {i actn c oi~rn cfk c `nwmic}k {i gf{n}cb{
zg{a {an biou~{n} cfk {i actn {an rb}nnf cr c rgouln
i~{u~{ kntgbn& Zg{a ~ubiogfj fnz {nbafilijgnr {anrnkntgbnr c}n oi}n cfk oi}n biftn}{gfj zg{a ncba i{an} i}
riuagr{gbc{nk on{aikr c}n }n ulcbgfj {ano& [an}ndi}n {agr
ucun} ocgflw knclr zg{a {anrn fnz kntnliuonf{r, aiz
{anw rai~lk mn goulnonf{nk gf d~{~}n cfk aiz {anw bi~lk
gfdl~nfbn cfk bacfjn {an kcglw biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif&
Di} nqcouln zg{a {an {nbafgs~nr ~rnk di} o~l{g/{i~ba
kntgbnr, knrb}gmnk gf rnb{gif =&3, {an rb}nnf }nbnf{lw
mnbionr c fnz gfu~{ cfk i~{u~{ {iil gf ifn kntgbn& Gf
kigfj ri g{ gr rnnf {ac{ {an}n gr fi fnnk di} nq{}c gfu~{
kntgbnr& [a~r ntnf {agr dcb{ gr c biouln{nlw fnz zcw, crzn c}n ~rnk {i actgfj oi}n {acf h~r{ ifn kntgbn& Gfbl~knk
gf rnb{gif =&= gr cfi{an} czc}kgfj on{aik bifbn}fgfj
a~ocf jnr{~}n gf{n}cb{gif gf {an dgnlk id kn{nb{gfj jnr{~}nr
tgc tgkni kntgbnr9 Gf rnb{gif =&2 {anf cfi{an} d~{~}n{nbafgs~n gr uigf{nk i~{ zagba gr bifbn}fnk zg{a {an
a~ocf runnba kn{nb{gif cr cf gfu~{ on{aik& Rnb{gif =&;
{anf knclr zg{a c on{aik id ~rgfj {an biomgfc{gif id
tgkni cfk runnba kn{nb{gif& Cd{n} {anrn rnb{gifr cmi~{ {ankgddn}nf{ {wunr id }nbnf{ a~ocf biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif zi}`
{an rnb{gif 2 {anf knclr zg{a {an iuui}{~fg{gnr id {anrn
fnz {nbafgs~nr cfk aiz {anw bcf mn ~rnk gf d~{~}n
nrunbgcllw aiz lgdn bcf mn bacfjnk& G{ gr {anf clri uigf{nk
i~{ gf zagba dgnlk {anrn fnz kntnliuonf{r bcf mn ckiu{nk&
GG& ]NBNF[ KNTNLIUONF[R
A~ocf jnr{~}nr cfk {an a~ocf runnba c}n {an oir{
gf{~g{gtn oi{gifr zagba a~ocfr ~rn {i bioo~fgbc{n zg{ancba i{an}& Cl {ai~ja cd{n} {an gftnf{gif id {an oi~rn cfk
{an `nwmic}k, fi d~}{an} kntgbnr zagba
bi~lk }nulcbn {agr {zi imhnb{r cr c biou~{n} gfu~{on{aik actn mnnf kntnliunk& ]nlc{gfj {i {an dcb{ {ac{ g{
c}n oi}n a~ocf lg`n on{aikr id c li{ id }nrnc}ba id aiz
{agr dcb{ bcf mn ~rnk di} bioo~fgbc{gif mn{znnf
biou~{n}r cfk a~ocf mngfjr acr mnnf kifn& Cr {an}n c}n
rion kgddn}nf{ zcwr id aiz jnr{~}nr rai~lk mn ~rnk cr
gfu~{ {agr rnb{gif gr kgtgknk gf{i o~l{g/{i~ba, tgkni,
runnba cfk o~{lg/oikcl gf{n}cb{gif Rnb{gifr& Fizckcwr
{an}n c}n cl}nckw ocfw {cmln{r zg{a {i~ba rb}nnfr ctcglcmlncfk zg{a {an fnz Cuuln gUck c fnz d~ll o~l{g/{i~ba
u}ik~b{ acr mnnf }nlncrnk& M~{ {an}n gr clri c {}nfkfi{gbncmln {ac{ {anrn on{aikr bcf clri mn ~rnk if mgjjn}
rb}nnfr lg`n {an cuu}icba id Oglln} i} Ogb}irid{*r R~}dcbn,
iflw {i onf{gif {anrn {zi& [a~r {an {}nfk gr jigfj oi}n
cfk oi}n fi{ iflw gf {an kg}nb{gif id on}jgfj gfu~{ cfki~{u~{ kntgbnr m~{ }c{an} ~rgfj ntn}w r~}dcbn cr cf gfu~{
cfk i~{u~{ dcbglg{w& Gf {agr }nlc{gif {an tgkni gr mnbiogfj
id j}nc{n} gf{n}nr{ cr g{ ~rnr {an d~ll }cfjn id a~ocf oi{gif
jnr{~}nr cfk g{ gr ~rcmln if cfw j}i~fk& Gf {an nfk {an
gfu~{ tgc runnba clri {c`nr c uc}{ gf {an ABG cr g{ gr {an
a~ocf*r ncrgnr{ zcw {i bioo~fgbc{n, m~{ di} r~}nrion{agfj biouln{nlw kgddn}nf{, biouc}nk zg{a {an i{an}
{zi {wunr id gfu~{ cfk i~{u~{ on{aikr, cr g{ gr oi}n cf
clji}g{ao {acf c kntgbn& [an biomgfc{gif id kgddn}nf{
D~{~}n A~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif zg{a runbgcl dib~r if gfu~{ cfk
i~{u~{ {nbafgs~nrU&C&Rc{agra`~oc}
Knuc}{onf{8 Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn cfk Nfjgfnn}gfj
I}jcfgxc{gif8 Bacfkw billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj [~{gbi}gf,Gfkgc
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 18/223
gfu~{ on{aikr, bcllnk o~l{g/oikcl gf{n}cb{gif, gr {anf
knrb}gmnk gf {an lcr{ Rnb{gif&
M& O~l{g/[i~ba Kntgbnr
Cr onf{gifnk mndi}n {agr rnb{gif gr knclgfj zg{a {an{nbafgs~n id {an }nbnf{lw }nlncrnk o~l{g/{i~ba kntgbnr cfkzg{a rion fnz nfacfbnk cuu}icbanr& [agr on{aik gr fiz
mnbiogfj biooif gf {an {cmln{ ub*r lg`n di} nqcouln {an
fnz Cuuln gUck gf {an rnb{i} id fi{nmii`r cfk {an AU
[i~ba Roc}{ gf {an knr`{iu rnb{i}& [an}nmw {an rb}nnf
mnbionr cf gfu~{ cfk i~{u~{ kntgbn& M~{ o~l{g/{i~ba gr
clri ~rnk {ikcw gf ocfw fi}ocl {i~ba uckr zagba c}n
iddn}gfj di~}/dgfjn} fctgjc{gif& Zg{a {agr gftnf{gif id c
fnz a~ocf biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif ocfw oi}n zi}` gf {agr
rnb{i} acr mnnf kifn cfk rai~lk riifn} i} lc{n} clri bion
gf{i u}cb{gbcl ~rn& Fizckcwr {an ~rcjn id {i~ba rb}nnfr
cfk o~l{g/{i~ba uckr rnnor {i mn }ncllw biooif cfk {ac{
{agr gr jigfj {i mn {an d~{~}n id a~ocf biou~{n}gf{n}cb{gif, m~{ {an}n gr di} r~}n oi}n nfacfbnonf{r zagba
bcf mn rnnf gf ocfw cuu}icbanr& Gf {an dgnlk id o~l{g/
{i~ba u}ik~b{r {an {}nfk {i mgjjn} {i~ba uckr gf {n}or id
o~l{g/{i~ba rb}nnfr bcf mn rnnf& [an}ndi}n {an {nbafgs~n
id c rgfjln/{i~ba {i~bauck cr g{ gr `fizf d}io di}on}
fi{nmii`r gr nfacfbnk cfk oi}n dgfjn}r iddn}gfj fc{~}cl
a~ocf acfk jnr{~}nr bcf mn ~rnk& [a~r {an ~rn} bcf ~rn
~u {i 35 dgfjn}r {i d~llw bif{}il {agfjr zg{a mi{a acfkr crzg{a {an 35)J^G rwr{no zagba ]& Blcw{if Oglln} P=_
gf{}ik~bnk gf =557& Zg{a cfi{an} ~ubiogfj {iil ntnf {an
~rcjn id cfw r~}dcbn di} r~ba c {i~ba rb}nnf bcf mn ~rnk gf
d~{~}n, lg`n di} {an nqcouln Kgrulcq[OO~l{g{i~ba
[nbafilijwd}io KGRULCQ[OGf{n}cb{gtnRwr{nor& D}io{anrn nqcoulnr g{ bcf mn blnc}lw rnnf {ac{ fnz agja
ui{nf{gcl {nbafgs~nr c}n u~ragfj gf{i {an oc}`n{ cfk c}n
jigfj {i }nulcbn {an Cuuln*r gUck cfk Ogb}irid{*r R~}dcbn&
Gf {an fnq{ dillizgfj rnb{gifr {anrn fnz {iilr cfk clri {an
}nlc{nk kntgbnr zagba c}n cl}nckw gf {an oc}`n{ c}n
knrb}gmnk gf kn{cgl&
C& gUck
[an }nbnf{lw gf{}ik~bnk gUck d}io Cuuln gr ifn id {an
ocfw goulnonf{c{gifr id d~ll o~l{g/{i~ba kgrulcwr
zan}ncr g{ gr c biouln{nlw fnz zcw aiz uniuln bcf
gf{n}cb{ zg{a {ang} biou~{n}& [a~r {an uirrgmglg{w {i ~rn {an
rb}nnf fi{ iflw cr c rgfjln/{i~ba kgrulcw gr {c`gfj {anA~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif {i {an fnq{ lntnl& Zg{a {an
gf{}ik~bnk gUck g{ gr uirrgmln {i ~rn cll {an dgfjn}oitnonf{r zagba c}n clri uirrgmln zg{a {an m~glk/gf o~l{g
{i~bauck*r gf {an Cuuln OcbMii`r {ac{ bcf mn di~fk if
{an Cuuln aionucjn& Gf kigfj ri {an ~rn} gr cmln {i ~rn ~u
{i di~} dgfjn}r c{ {an rcon {gon {i fctgjc{n {a}i~ja {an
gf{n}dcbn& Di} nqcouln {zi dgfjn}r bcf mn ~rnk {i xiio
cfk di~} dgfjn}r {i m}izrn {a}i~ja zgfkizr& Zg{a ~rgfj
{an rb}nnf cr c mgj {i~bauck {an {nbafgs~nr id {an fi}ocl
{i~bauck actn mnnf nfacfbnk& Cl{ai~ja {agr {nbafgs~n gr
h~r{ {an mnjgffgfj id {an fnz o~l{g/{i~ba kgrulcw
}ntil~{gif zagba zgll mn di} r~}n nqucfknk mw gfb}ncrgfj
{an kgrulcw rgxn&Cuuln‗r Aionucjn
a{{u8))zzz&cuuln&bio
M& Ogb}irid{ R~}dcbn
Ogb}irid{*r bcllnk {ang} nqcouln id c o~l{g/{i~ba
rb}nnf h~r{ rgoulw -R~}dcbn-& Zg{a {agr {iil {anw jnfn}c{nk
c lc}jn {i~ba rb}nnf {cmln{iu biou~{n}& [an}ndi}n {anw c}n~rgfj gfd}c}nk bcon}cr di} }nbijfg{gif id imhnb{r {ac{ c}n
~rnk if {agr rb}nnf& Cf imhnb{ bcfr {an}nmw {an a~ocf
dgfjn}r i} ntnf i{an} {cjjnk g{nor zagba bcf mn ulcbnk if
{an rb}nnf& Zg{a {agr iuui}{~fg{w {an kntgbn r~uui}{r
}nbijfg{gif id a~ocf*r fc{~}cl acfk jnr{~}nr cr znll cr
gf{n}cb{gif zg{a }ncl imhnb{r cfk racun }nbijfg{gif& Zg{a{agr iuui}{~fg{w fi nq{}c kntgbnr c}n }ns~g}nk di} c ~rcjn
id {agr {iil cfk gf{n}cb{gif bcf mn ockn kg}nb{lw zg{a {an
acfkr& Zg{a {an lc}jn 25 gfba kgrulcw ntnf oi}n uniuln
{anf iflw ifn un}rif c{ {an rcon {gon bcf gf{n}cb{ zg{a {an
rwr{no cfk zg{a ncba i{an} c{ {an rcon {gon& [an
}nbijfg{gif id {an imhnb{r ulcbnk if {an {cmln {iu ub {anf
u}itgknr oi}n gfdi}oc{gif cfk gf{n}cb{gif& Ri g{ gr un}acuruirrgmln {i m}izrn {a}i~ja kgddn}nf{ gfdi}oc{gif onf~r
cmi~{ {an ulcbnk g{no cfk im{cgf oi}n kgjg{cl gfdi}oc{gif&
If {an i{an} acfk {an rgxn id {an kgrulcw cfk {an {an}ndi}n
fnnknk gfd}c}nk bcon}cr ~fkn}fnc{a gr lnckgfj {i cf
gfb}ncrn id rgxn& [a~r {an {iil gr ocgflw knrgjfnk di}
r{c{gifc}w ~rn, lg`n di} nqcouln cr c fi}ocl {cmln zg{a
zagba g{ gr {anf uirrgmln {i gf{n}cb{ zg{a&
B& 35)J^G
[an 35)J^G rwr{no zagba Oglln} gftnf{nk gr cf
nfacfbnk {i~bauck di} knr`{iu biou~{n} u~}uirn zagba
bcf }nbijfgxn 35 dgfjn}r& Zg{a {agr iuui}{~fg{w a~ocf
mngfjr bcf gf{n}cb{ zg{a {an biou~{n} zg{a mi{a acfkr cfk
~rn g{ cr c {}cb`gfj cfk ocwmn clri cr c `nwmic}k kntgbn&[an}ndi}n Oglln} knrgjfnk {agr fnz {i~ba r~}dcbn {iil
nrunbgcllw di} ~rn gf {an knr`{iu dgnlk&
[i actn {an mnr{ n}jifiogbcllw uirg{gif an c}j~nr {ac{
g{ gr mn{{n} {i actn c d~ll o~l{g/{i~ba uck gf d}if{ id c
rb}nnf cr {an `nwmic}k cfk oi~rn }nulcbnonf{ {anf
actgfj {an zailn rb}nnf cr cf gfu~{ kntgbn, lg`n g{ gr
`fizf d}io i{an} {i~ba/rb}nnfr& [agr fitnl rwr{no gr c
zailn kgddn}nf{ on{aik id biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif cfk gr
nq{nfknk zg{a c runbgcl j}cuagbcl ~rn} gf{n}dcbn di} c d~ll
~rn id cll 35 dgfjn}r& [an oir{ }noc}`cmln {agfj cmi~{ {agr
{i~bauck nqbnu{ {an }nbijfg{gif id oi}n dgfjn}r gr clri {an
u}nrr~}n kn{nb{gif id ntn}w dgfjn}, zagba gr kg}nb{lw r{c{nk
if {an rb}nnf& [an}ndi}n ntn}w dgfjn} bcf mn ~rnk cr cuigf{gfj kntgbn lg`n {an oi~rn& Zg{a {agr dnc{~}n g{ bcf mn
clri ~rnk gf d~{~}n cr c `nwmic}k gf {an kcglw ~rnk uirg{gif
id {an acfkr, zg{ai~{ {an fnnk id rnlnb{gfj Ln{{n}r zg{a
iflw ifn dgfjn}& M~{ di} r~}n {agr dg}r{ kntnliuonf{ id {an
35) J^G gr ocgflw bifbn}fnk zg{a actgfj {an 35 dgfjn}r cb{
gfr{nck id {an oi~rn,- cr ocfw cb{gtg{gnr {ikcw fnnk iflw c
oi~rn cfk zgfkiznk gfdi}oc{gif kgrulcw if {an {iu id
{ac{&&&-
[an i{an} gffitc{gif id {agr rwr{no gr g{r runbgcl
knrgjfnk ~rn} gf{n}dcbn di} {an ~rcjn id {anrn 35 dgfjn}r&
[an}nmw Oglln} gr u}iuirgfj c zcw {i riltn {an u}imlno id
o~l{guln iunf zgfkizr& Agr ril~{gif {an}ndi}n gr c lgfnc}
c}}cfjnonf{ id {an cb{gtn zgfkizr zan}n g{ gr uirrgmln {i
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 19/223
m}izrn {a}i~
}gja{ rgkn id {
Dgj~}n 38 Kg
[i~ba r~
Cfi{an}
bionr d}io
[anw actn gf
gf{i cf gf{n}
jicl {anw c{}cfruc}nf{
Kgrulcq[OOucun} {anw c}
>5 gfba mgj
zi}` kg}nb{l
[agr bcf mn
Ogb}irid{ R~
r{c{gifc}w ulcid 34 dgfjn}r
~rn} bcf zi
zngja{ id h~
mnrgkn {an dc
if {an mcb`
i{an} kcocjn
Dgj~}n 3
r~}dcbn zan}
uirrgmln&
J}nc{ ndd
tgkni gfu~{
Rgq{aRnfrn {aOgr{}w, n
r~ba kntgbnr
gf{n}cb{gif
rb}nnfr i}}nbijfgxn a~
id ckkg{gifcl
cuu}icba id
clji}g{ao di
{ang} ucun} z
cr c uigf{gfj
P>_ actn go
kntnliuonf{
iflw cf gfu~actn cf gouc
ja {ano zg{a
an {i~ba/ucf
rulcq*r {agf {}cfr
dcbn P;_
& Kgrulcq[Odi}zc}k/lii
an D~{~}n Lc
tnf{nk c fn
cb{gtn o~l{g{
}n ~rgfj gfucun} {a
~l{g{i~ba bin {anf cmln {
{i~barb}nnf&
if c mgj rb
rnnf cr {a
}dcbn {iil z
bn& Ckkg{gifc{ {an rcon
}` if {an rb
r{ 255j g{ gr
{ {ac{ g{ gr z
d {an r~}dcbn
&
gll~r{}c{nr c
n ntnf {an ~
K&
i}{r actn mn
cfk i~{u~
c{ U}cfctcl& gftnf{nk
{a~r lgnr gf {a
g{a {an bio
/uckr& [an}ncf jnr{~}nr
acfkanlk uig
nfj, n{& cl P4
}ncl/{gon fc
g{a zagba g{ g
kntgbn lg`n {
}itnk {agr g
id c znc}cml
m~{ clri cfb{ if {an d~{
= m~{{ifr if
l&
c}nf{ o~l{g/
O~l{g{i~ba [gfj o~l{g/{
mr id {an Kg
on{aik {i {
~ba r~}dcbn&
{ang} cuu}i{ gr c{{
f{}illn}& Zg{{~}f cfw r~
Zg{a {agr u
}nnf mw h~r{
ocgf cktc
agba gr {gnk
llw {agr gf{n}{gon ri {ac{
}nnf rgo~l{c
clri c tn}w
nll k~}cmln cr
{i u}i{nb{ g{
kn{cgl id {an
rcjn if {}cf
gkni Kntgbnr
f ockn clri
{ kntgbnr l
gf =557& [a
n ui{nf{gcl i
u~{n} {anf
mw {anrn {nlg`n {an acfk
f{gfj kntgbnr
_, {anw actn c
{~}cl acfk j
r uirrgmln {i
an oi~rn& U}
u~{ uigf{gfj
jnr{~}n gf{n
i~{u~{ {iil}n a~ocf bi
{an i~{n} ln
bafilijwi~ba {nbaf
ulcq[OBio
~}f -&&&cfw r~
- [i cbagnt
ba cf tn}wcbank {i
a {agr ~l{}c}dcbn gf{i cf
irrgmglg{w wi
~rgfj wi~} a
f{cjn cjcgfr
{i c oi}n c
cbn cllizr ci}n {acf h~r
fni~rlw& Zg{
{}cfrui}{cmln
{an dglo gr u
}io rb}c{ban
{agf {i~ba/r
uc}nf{ r~}dc
gf {an rnb{g
g`n di} nq
ocgf u~}ui
actgfj ntnf
g{a fi}ocl
bafgs~nr {nfr zg{ai~{ {an
& Cbbi}kgfj {
l}nckw u}itgk
r{~}n kn{nb{g
~rn iflw {an
cfct Ogr{}w,
on{aik zg{
}dcbn zagba g
agba zgll diu~{n} gf{n}c
{ cfk
ilijw
ucfw&
}dcbn
{agr
{agf{an
{agf
~u {i
bcf
cfkr&
{ {an
lnrr
~rcjn{ ifn
a {an
{iil
lcbnk
r cfk
b}nnf
nr gr
f id
ouln
rn id
oi}n
i~ba
k {ifnnk
i {an
nk cf
if gf
acfk
n{& cl
a {an
r fi{
r~}n{gif&
Zg{
gf{n
blnc
bioG
gf{n
ABG
acf
i~{u
{agr
kg}n
{anc b
bio
{an
[an
di} r
u}ih
i~{u
{anw
i{an
g{ }n
ckkg
kg}n
acf
jnr{
jnr{
Bc}
cfi{cr c
gf {agr rnb{g
cb{gif c}n fi
gj~}n =8 Biouif
}cfct Ogr{}
lw {an mnjg
u~{n} gf{n}cb{gf {ang} cuu}
dcbn, raizf
{i {an fnq{ l
r zg{ai~{ cf
~{ id {an kntg
kntgbn& Zg{a
{lw u}ihnb{nk
cgf cktcf{c}{cgf ulcbn&
o~fgbc{gif
~rn}r gfu~{
ndi}n {an gfu
i}{gfj i} nkg{g
an}nmw {an g
b{nk itn} {a
~{ cfk gfu~{
actn clri gfb
} {agfjr {anf h
ijfgxnr {ac{
{gifcl onkgc
{lw if {an fn
an cmitn
lgfj zg{a a~
runbgcllw g{
}nr cfk ln{
}nr itn} c
njgn Onllif
an} agjalw {igfu~{ r~}dcb
f {anrn fn
nqulcgfnk&
nf{r id {an Rgq{a
=&=&3 Rgq
, n{ cl& P>_ k
ffgfj id fn
if&cba {anw c}n
gf Dgj~}n =,
ntnl zan}n b
acfkanlk {i
bn di} {agr gf
c rgouln r
{i cfw r~}dcb
n cjcgfr{ i{aRi {anw c
g{a {an bio
fk c rgouln
~{ bcf }cfjn
fj gocjnr {i
fu~{ bcf clr
rocll mnco
c{ {an rcon {
l~knk gf {an
~r{ if {an a~
{an ~rn} gr }n
{i {agr {iug
rucun}&
GGG& R@G
nf{gifnk t
cf oi{gif j
gr knclgfj
{gfj uniuln
bn}{cgf i~{u
fgtn}rg{w cf
gbcl cuu}icb, bcllnk R`gf
on{aikr i
Rnfrn kntgbn
{a Rnfrn
ntnliunk zg{
z {nbafgs~n
~rgfj c zn
zan}n {anw
ioo~fgbc{gi
ilr& H~r{ cr n
n}dcbn zagba
cll u}ihnb{i}
n wi~ lg`n, z
n} kntgbnr z}n ~rgfj di}
~{n} c rgoul
u}ihnb{i} d
d}io rgouln
oi}n runbgdg
i mn c `nwm
n} cfk ri g{ g
gon& Zg{a {a
gkni }nbijfg
ocf acfk jnr
kgfj c fnzr
mw u}ihnb{g
U^[
gkni }nbijf
r{~}nr&
g{a }nbijfgx
gf{n}cb{ zg{
~{ kntgbn&
k Ogb}irid{ a
a mw ~rgfj {au~{&
acfklgfj {a
a Rgq{a Rnfr
r di} a~oc
c}cmln jnr{~}
c}n {c`gfj {a
gr kifn zg{
crw gr clri {a
gr gfbl~knk g
{an i~{u~{ g
agba gr blnc}l
gba c}n {gnk {{ang} zail
znmbco di
} {an i~{u~
acfk jnr{~}n
{cr`r&
c}k zagba g
d~ldgllgfj {a
gr iuui}{~fg{
gif {i }ncb{ {
{~}nr& Un}acu
cun} cfk ckk
fj {an onkg
g{gif {iil g
gfj {an acf
a {ang} acf
nrnc}ban}r c
ctn kntnliun
n a~ocfr c}
n
f
n
a
n
f
r
in
}
&
r
r
n
i
r
r
c
r
{
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 20/223
g
g
g
U}ib& id {
Til~on 3& Bi
GRMF8 7:1/
mr{}cb{ ‛}{gdgbgcl m}cg
an a~ocf m
gf{n}dcbn !MB
Runbgcl u}iu}g
fnz {nbafil
zg{a c j}i~u i
@nwzi}kr/
cfi{nbafili
}cgf acb
b~}n on
bif{}ill
C m
cllnk c kg}
gf{n}dcbn, gr
~ocf i} cf
q{n}fcl kntg
ioocfkr d
qcouln, {i
zi~lk clliz
gfdi}oc{gif g
Fn~
lnb{}i banog
c}n ocfw
ogb}ifr!,55
{ang} lnfj{a t
S~c
rnogbifk~b{i
lnb{}ifgb u}
igf{ id b~log
&[ang
lnb{}iocjfn{
ntgbnr&&
GG& [an m}cgf
gfbl~kgfj fn~
rnfk cfk }nb
M
n Gf{l& Bifd&
uw}gja{ § =5
3/7=5>:>/:/4
CBO "8 kmn
agr ucun} b
bnll cfk g{r
}cgf, cfk c l
G' zagba bc}
n{w id fcfi{nb
ijw {ac{ zagb
d r~ba c}{gdgbgc
}{gdgbcl m}cgf
w&
G& G
`gfj gr h~r{ lg
f{cllw kgrcmln
k bc}r, ai~rn
}cgf/biou~{n
nb{ fn~}cl g
kg}nb{ bio
gocl m}cgf !
n& Gf ifn/zc
io {an m}cg
nr{i}n tgrgif
m}cgf cfk
mi{a kg}nb{gi
ifr cfk m}cg
cl rgjfclr {i
{wun id f
oo' {i 355
}gnr d}io ifn
{~o ki{r,
} oc{}gq z
u}gn{gnr, u}n
fc{gif id rno
g} u}iu}g{nr }
gb bnll, }nfkn
M]CGF BNL
cfk rugfcl bi
}ifr cfk jlg
gtn nlnb{}i/b
f Biou~{n}
3= [nbafi Di
88 kig8 35& :
&gon}c&35& :;
O
nuc}{onf{ iR}nn
frgr{ id mc
~fb{gif zagln
g{{ln mg{ cmi
gnr gfdi}oc{g
afilijw iunf
a bif{}il {an
l bnllr&
bnll0 M}cgf/B
F[]IK^B[GI
`n awufi{gr
un}rif, di}
n{b․
} gf{n}dcbn !
f{n}dcbn i}
~fgbc{gif u
fk m}cgf bnl
w MBGr, bio
f i} rnfk
' m~{ fi{ mi
nq{n}fcl kntg
fr&
f bnllr {ac{
}cgf d}io fn
n~}if {anw
gb}ifr!&3o
gfba {i rntn}
bian}nf{ g
agba {}~lw
nf{ {an ~{o
g bifk~b{i} u
rnomlnr {ai
}gfj uirrgmln
L CFK G[‗R D^
}k c}n ockn
l bnllr& Fn~
nogbcl rgjfcl
uulgbc{gifr
}~o J}i~u, G
=51)GRMFY5:
=51
gfk Bif{
Biou~{n} Rbgkwcfg`n{acf
gb d~fb{gifgf
g{ gr gfhnb{nk
{ m}cgf bio
f {i i~} rw
c fnz jc{n z
m}cgf id c a
fou~{n} gf{n}
zagba gr ~r
glg{c}w cfk
MBG', rion{
c m}cgf/oc
{azcw mn{zn
l b~l{~}n' cf
~{n} ng{an} c
gjfclr {i g{
{a, {zi/zcw
gbnr {i nqba
rnfk cfk }n
}ti~r rwr{no,
tc}w gf
' gf kgcon{n}
cl dnn{&
fbl~rgifr g
n}i kgonfrg
r{ bacllnfjn
awrgbr
n id c{ior g
dcrbgfc{gfj
FB[GIFGFJ
~u id ocfw
ifr c}n bnllr
r {i cfk d}i
kgc&
41
}illn} ! M
C&R~fgl Rc
gnfbn cfk RwNfjgfnn}gfj
[g}~uc{g, Gfkg
j id
gf {i
~{n}
{no&
cw {i
ocf
cbn8
k {i
gfk
gonr
agfn
nf c
k cf
bnu{
!di}
BGr
cfjn
ngtn
{anw
rgxn
cfk
c
gifcl
cfk
f cf
itnl
nllr,
{ac{
{an
m}
f
u}
f
o
[dn
&
{i
bi
!rg
bi
cq
c
}n
J
Z
-b
{c
cq
f
m}
u
{}
m
=
cgf Acb`
g
{no cfk Rwr{illnjn PC~{i
gc&
cgf cfk fn}t
~}ifr gf {an
itgkn r~uui}{
on}i~r {acf
[an}n gr o~b
gb}ifr !&55;
ng} lnfj{a tn{
Fn~}i
cfk d}io {
frgr{r id c bn
gjfcl }nbngtn}
fk~b{ {an fn}
if {n}ogfclr
rwfcurn !{an
bngtgfj bnll'&
}ocf rbgnf
clknwn}/Ac}{
a}ioirion-'
[an c
n gfdi}oc{gi
ifr c}n `fi
}ti~r rwr{no
gfj gfdi}oc{g
Ownlg
}gikgb m}nc`
frogrrgif ru
Rbazcff*r b
/25. u}i{ngf
gfj'
or Nfjgfnn}gfioi~r_
i~r rwr{no&
}cgf& [an}n c
d~fb{gifr di}
n~}ifr&
a {wun id fn~
o' {i 355
}gnr d}io c
Fn~}if !
r c}n fn}tn b
n m}cgf c{
ll mikw !i} ri
r' cfk c u}ih
tn rgjfcl& C{
{}cfrog{ {an
jcu mn{znn
[an zi}k
{gr{ Angf}gb
gf 3173
&
if, c lifj n
f czcw d}i
f cr fn}tnr
', cr fn}tn {
f {i {an bnll
bic{r cfk g
r bcllnk fi
nk clifj {an
nllr, cfk bifr
&
fj,
[an}n c}n cm
}n ocfw oi}
{an fn~}ifr,
ifr& [anw tc
gb}ifr !&3
}cb{gif id cf
}cgf bnll'
llr {ac{ {}cfr
u {i =55 o
oc' zg{a m}c
nb{gif bcllnk
{an i{an} nfk
lnb{}i/banog
{an cqif {
fn~}if- zcr
Zglanlo
!an clri bi
q{nfrgif id c
{an bnll mi
i}, zg{agf {
}cb{r i} uc{a
ikw&
r~lc{nr {an
nr id ]cft
cqif& Ownlgf
gr{r id :5/15
i~{ 355 mgllg
jlgcl bnllr0 {
cfk c}n dc} o
}w gf rgxn d}i
o' gf kgcon
gfba {i rnt
g{ fn}tn rgjf
a& [an fn~
bagfj knfk}g
cf cqif, za
id {an cqif,
cl rgjfcl cb}
}ogfcl cfk
bigfnk mw
Ji{{d}gnk
gfnk {an {n
fn}tn bnll,
kw& M~fklnr
n BFR !bnf{
zcwr& Knfk}g
qif !nqbnu{
gn}', gfb}ncrg
gr ocf~dcb{~
lgugkr !dc{'
gif
nw
}n
;
{n}&
}cl
clr
if
{nr
gba
{an
rr
{an
{an
if
}o
fk
id
}cl
{nr
di}
gfj
}nk
fk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 21/223
[an
~bln~r !zg{
Knfk}g{nr m}c
C {
rwfcurnr !{ac
n~}ifr, o~r
GGG&
[an}
c}}w nlnb{}i/
!{an f~omn}
nll mikw' cf
c&Rn
onrrnc}r,
u}ib
fn~}
nug{a
m&O
rgjf
[anr
d}io
id
fn~}
b&Gf{
d}io
actn
knfk
bi}k0
fn~}
}ii{
c&LGDN R
^flg`
cd{n} kcocDi}{~fc{nlw
m}cgf&
m&JLGCL
Jlgcl bnllr
bnllr c}n fn
tc}gi~r jlg
goui}{cf{ d
fn~}ifr, o
uawrgbcl cf
bnll mikw
a KFC cfk
ba d}io {an
ugbcl fn~}if
{ gr, g{ bioo~
ln bnllr, jlcf
GDDN]NF[
n c}n kgddn}n
anogbcl fn}t
id u}ibnrrnr,
c}n di~fk gf
ri}w fn~}if
cjnr d}io {an{b&' {i {an
rrnr& Rnfri}
fr& !Nqcoul
nlg~o bnllr&'
{ifn~}ifr i
lr d}io {an
n fn~}ifr ac
{an bnll mik
ll fn~}ifr&
fr, uw}cogkc
}fn~}ifr i}
cll {an fn~}c
{zi cqifr
}g{n'& Ifn cqi
ifn zg{a ng
fr actn {zi
jcfjlgc bnllr&'
CF ID FN^
oir{ i{an}
jn !nqbnu{ f, {an}n c}n c
NLLR
oc`n ~u 75 u
}tn bnllr {ac{
gcl !oncfgfj
~fb{gifr, gfbl
cf~dcb{~}gfj
k f~{}g{gifcl
!rioc' bif{
{wugbcl f~
nll mikw cfk
acr cmi~{
fgbc{nr zg{a 3
r, n{b&'&
WUNR ID F
{ {wunr id
n rgjfclr m~{
i} cqifr, n
kgddn}nf{ uc}{
r i} mguilc
n mikw*r rnfrBFR& [anrn
fn~}if cbbi
nr c}n }n{gf
} O~l{guilc
FR {i {an o
tn ocfw u}i
& Oi{ifn~}i
!Nqcoulnr
l fn~}ifr, U~
Urn~kiuilc
l zg}gfj zg{ag
!gfr{nck id
f bioo~fgbc
{an} {an r`gf
u}ibnrrnr& !N
IFR
bnllr, fn~}i
~}ifr d}io {i~{ 355 mgllg
n}bnf{ id {an
kif*{ bc}}w f
-jl~n-' bnll
kgfj8 kgjnr{g
ownlgf di} f
r~uui}{ di} f
gfr {an fn~
blnc} i}jcfn
}nbngtn onrrc
3,555 {i 35
,555/35,555
^]IFR
n~}ifr& [an
kgddn} gf r{}~
cfc{gfj d}i
id {an mikw&
} fn~}ifr
n }nbnu{i}r !fn~}ifr actn
~f{ di} 5&7.
l bnllr, ildc
} fn~}ifr
~rblnr cfk jl
bnrrnr i}gjgf
r cbbi~f{ di
}n rugfcl
`gfhn bnllr&'
n !Runllgfj'
f {an BFR& [
cf cqif c
{nr zg{a {an r
i} o~rbln& [
coulnr c}n k
r bcffi{ }n
an aguuibcoif fn~}ifr g
m}cgf*r bnllr&
}tn gou~lrnr&
r un}di}o
f id uc}{r id
n~}ifr, u}itg
n~}ifr, cfk
}if*r
llnr'&
jnr&
,555
{an}
cll
{~}n
{an
c}}w
wnr,{zi
d cll
{i}w
c}}w
fkr&
c{gfj
} 7.
i{i}
bnllr
anrn
k c
gfcl
anrn
i}rcl
}iz
~r'&{an
Jlgcl
[an
cfw
knck
kgfj
i}n&
bn
di
c
{i
bn
m}
id
c&
rw
z
u}
~r
bi
“
i
rg
dc
u
G{
r
[wunr id jlg
Bnllr, Ogb}i
Fn~}ijlgc !ll& [anrn bnllr
GGG& ]I
Cd{n} gfh~fb{g
} c }gja{ oit
nll zagba gr g
{an m}cgf& M
llr gf {i {an a
cgf bcf ki kg
m}cgf bnllr&
cfi{nbafili
Fcfi{nbafi
r{nor c{ {an
}` cfk bifbn
Gf g{r i}gjg
ihnb{nk cmglg{
gfj {nbafgs~n
ouln{n, agja
zcf{ {i m~
ncba i{an}
o~l{cfni~r
} cr G bcf r
rrgmglg{w id
gr fi{ cf c
on{agfj, gf
cl bnllr gfbl~
lgc, Ilgjiknf
ncfgfj “fn}tj~gkn fn~}i
N ID C][GDGB
M]
gif id c}{gdgbg
onf{ {i nfjc
f kcocjnr r{
{agr zcw zn
~ocf m}cgf m
ddn}nf{ iun}c{
GT& S^
jw
lijw gr {an
oilnb~lc} rb
u{r {ac{ c}n o
fcl rnfrn, *f
w {i bifr{}~b
r cfk {iilr m
n}di}ocfbn
glk c mgllgi
, zagba c}n
lw& & & [an u
nn, ki fi{ r
ocfn~tn}g
{nou{ {i tg
u}gfbguln,
kn Rbazcff*r
k}ijlgc, cfk
n jl~n‟' gr {r k~}gfj dn{cl
CL M]CGF BN
CGF
cl bnll gf {i {
jn zg{a {an m
{n& [anf g{ kg
c{{cba rntn}
bc~rn tc}gi~
gifr ri zn f
F[^O KI[
nfjgfnn}gfj
cln& [agr bit
i}n cktcfbnk&
cfi{nbafilij
{ g{nor d}io
gfj kntnliun
}ik~b{r&
{gfw dcb{i
ocf~dcb{~
}gfbgulnr id
unc` cjcgf
j {agfjr c{
lc{n cfw lc
{ac{ bcf mn
Bnllr, Rc{nll
r{}ijlgc&
n {wun id m}kntnliuonf{
LL GF A^OCF
an m}cgf g{ z
cgf mw }nulcbg
}nb{lw biffnb
l c}{gdgbgcl m}
r uc}{r id a~
nnk dnz f~o
id d~fb{gi
n}r mi{a b~}}
* }ndn}r {i
{an mi{{io
k {ikcw {i o
gnr, oiknlr
gfj
uawrgbr, cr
{ {an
io mw c{io
zr0 g{ gr
kifn0 m~{ g
g{n
cgf&
g{r
gfj
{nk
cgf
cf
n}
fcl
nf{
{an
~u,
`n
&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 22/223
l
}cb{gbn, g{
mgj‟
‛ ]gba
awrgbr
c&B}nc{gi
Gd z
~rgfj {iu ki
cfk b~{ g{ ki
~cf{~o ki{
S~c
gonfrgifr !
ac}cb{n}r& Z
g`n b~mn, r
c}{gdgbgcl c{io
m&S~cf{~
S~cf{~o ki{
~}}nf{lw {an
r~luagkn, lnc
airuagkn&
~cf{~o ki{rGf i}kn} {i
~cf{~o ki{
ilwon}&
S~cf{
Zn
ifbnf{}gb s~
qbnllnf{ }i{
{nbafgs~n& T
acr fi{ mnn
}k Dnwfoc
id S~cf{~o
zcf{ {i b}n
f dcm}gbc{gif
zf ~f{gl g{ m
r rocll cr !>/
{~o ki{ gr
n}i' cfk fcf
n bcf di}o {
anc} cfk uw
r&
Ki{ Oc{n}gc
r bcf mn oc
oir{ biooi
r~luagkn,
cfw id {a
zgll rnn {anctigk {iqgb
r, {anw c}n
~o ki{r zg{a g{r l
noifr{}c{n {
cf{~o ki~mln
{gifcl rwoo
c}wgfj {an j
f kifn mnb
f, Fimnl U}
fcfi ki{
{n s~cf{~o
u}ibnrr {ac{
bcon cf c{i
>5' fo gf rgx
c bifdgfnon
gf rgxn bcf
gr s~cf{~o g
}cogkr0 {agr
lr
kn d}io c }
lw ~rnk oc{
ckog~o rnl
u}iogrgfj
~rnk zg{agfoc{n}gclr l
clri bic{gfj
lcwn}r cuunc}r cr
an rnld/crrno
}gfjr zg{a ag
n{}w ~rgfj {a
}iz{a u}ibn
~rn zn c}n
gxn zgffn} g
i{ g{r uirrgml
zagba {c`n c
o& Zn oc`n
&
f{ gf cll ru
jgtn rion ru
f kgddn}nf{ ra
gr clri bclln
fjn id oc{n
}gclr gfbl~kn
fgkn cfk gf
cuulgbc{gifr
{an a~ocf mcbagfj d}io
gf c u}i{n
c }gfjr mlnk di}oc{g
ja ~fgdi}og{w
n k}iuln{ nug
r bifkg{gifr
{ii
f
n mw
rilgk
{agr
nbgcl
nbgcl
cunr
k cr
}gclr,
xgfb
g~o
di}
ikw&{an
b{gtn
f id
cfk
g{cqw
bcf
bi
d}
s
{}
{a
{a
rn
C&
ng
u
zg
ib
f
rc
zg
i
C
}n
{n
{a
}n
f
r~
id
}n
ra
f
{a
f{}il ncba }gf
o cf gfkgtg
cf{gxnk lntnl
hnb{i}gnr&Zn bcf b}n
nw c}n cr dilli
3' An{n}ih~
=' Uai{itil
2' Kntgbn}
c' Nlnb{}i
m' Cf cb{g
b' Ckhcbnf
k' Nlnb{}i
n' Ailn bi
[anrn
nw bcf }nc}}c
ld gd cfw kcoc
T&
]nckgfj {an
c&Fn~}igocj
“Fn~}igocjg
{an} kg}nb{lw i
c}ocbilijw
g{agf onkgbgf
m&Kg}nb{ Fn~
[agr gr {an o
b~}gfj gf {a
~}if gf {an m
w {ac{ {agr o
g{a }nrunb{ {
jigfj
tcfbnr gf f
clg{w&
b&Nlnb{}infbn
[agr u}ibnk~afgs~n kgrbi
n m}cgf& K~n
ril~{gif {agr
zckcwr& Ai
rbnu{gmln {i f
~rn} {}cgfgfj
bnf{ }nrnc}ba
izf {ac{ {agr
{zi}`r {i rag
n biou~{n}&
b&Ocjfn{inf
j*r rgxn& Uai{
~cl s~cf{~o
r {ac{ c}n ru
c{n kgddn}nf{ l
zr
fb{gif
{cgb
iou}nrnr
bifk~b{gtn l
n uai{i til{g
{ nlnb{}i bif
n lcwn}
fk~b{gtn lcwn
s~cf{~o ki{
jn {ang} r{}~b
jnr ibb~}&
M]CGF BI
m}cgf ‒ Fn~}
fj kndgfg{gif
j gfbl~knr {a
} gfkg}nb{lw g
d {an m}cgf& G
cfk fn~}irbg
cl Bif{cb{
ir{ cbb~}c{n
m}cgf cr g{
}cgf, n&j& mw
{aik gr agja
i~} b~}}nf{
fi{nbafilij
uaclij}cuaw
}n gr {an dg}tn}nk& G{ onc
{i g{r ncrn i
n{aik gr {an
zntn}, gf
igrn cfk {a~
gf i}kn} {i m
c{ {an D}c~fa
u}imlno bcf
d{ {an lnc}fgf
nuaclij}cua
l~ogfnrbnfb
}gfj biouln
bgdgnk mw {an
cwn}r gf c rgf
cwn}
lcwn}
~b{gtn lcwn}
c}n rnld/crrn
{~}n cfk {anw
OU^[N] GFJN
gocjgfj gf M
n ~rn id tc}gi
cjn {an r{}~b
{ gr c }nlc{gtnl
nfbn&‟ PZG@G
n{aik id }nb
acr kg}nb{ b
rgfj fcfi}im
lw gftcrgtn c
{nbafilijw&
{agr on{ai
!NNJ'
{ fif/gftcrgtr~}nr {an nlnb
~rn, bir{ cf
oir{ zgknlw
u}cb{gbn NN
}ns~g}n c rg
n iun}cmln gf
idn} Ribgn{w
mn itn}bion
itn}anck d}
!ONJ'
runb{}c nog{
q raiz unb~l
bc}}gn}r* i}mg
jln s~cf{~o
mlnk {ac{ za
bcf }nucg} {a
]DCBN
BGr
~r {nbafgs~nr
{~}n, d~fb{gif,
w fnz kgrbgul
YFG_
}kgfj ui{nf{g
if{cb{ {i nt
i{r& Fnnklnrr
k gou}cb{gbc
Aizntn}, z
ogja{ mnbi
n fn~}igocjg{}gbcl cb{gtg{w
k agja {noui
rnk ifn gf M
r c}n agj
fgdgbcf{ coi
c MBG& L~b`g
ZG@GYMBG_
mw ~rgfj fn~
o {an a~ocf
{nk
gc}
g{cl
i{
gba
no
{i
i}
gfn
clr
}w
{i
mln
g{a
on
gfjid
}cl
Gr
alw
~f{
glw,
cr
}cl
{i
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 23/223
[ai~ja rg
{nbafilijw {a
{nbafilijw& G
{an m}cgf {agrw g{& [an ocg
}ns~g}nonf{r
dgllnk zg{a r
iilgfj anlg
PFCYMBG_ M
@illi{xn` ) A
b&D~fb{gif
[agr {nbaf
!mliik dliz
cb{gtg{w gf {
]nrifcfbn G
cr Ocjfn{g
{ac{ {an}n gr
}cgf‗r acno
{iil& Gf bif{
r{}~b{~}n {agr
n{aik }ns~g
s~guonf{ cf
K&Kg}nb{ G
Ugb&
Gf {an dg
cuu}icbanr {i
Ocfw id {a
M~{ di} rion
glc} {i {an N
ONJ gr c
r{nck id on
{nbafilijw }f k}czmcb`r
gf ns~guonf{
~un}/bifk~b{g
o {cf`r r~
}cgf Biou~{
ür`n
l Ocjfn{gb ]
gs~n oncr~}n
cfk mliik
an m}cgf mw
cjgfj di}on}l
b ]nrifcfbn
bi}}nlc{gif
kwfcogbr o
}cr{ {i {an
on{aik r{~kg
}nr O]G {nb
{a~r gr s~g{n
f{n}dcbnr tgc
Gf{}
4 8 [nr{ un}ri
lk id Mikw
cf gf{n}dcbn
nrn c}n gf dcb
uniuln zai
NJ gf {ac{ g
~ba fnzn}
r~}gfj {an nl
bi}kr ocjfn{d {agr {nbafil
& “^rgfj ON
fj ocjfn{r
}}i~fknk mw
n} Gf{n}dcbnr
rifcfbn Goc
r {an acnoi
qwjnfc{gif'
{an ~rn id
w `fizf
[ioij}cuaw
n{znnf fn~}
c`nr {an dO
]G zagba r
nr {an m}cgf‗
afilijw g{ f
bir{lw&
NNJ
k~b{gif
f c{{cbank {i
/Biou~{n}/Gf
nrgjf actn n
{ acu{gb i} lg
qun}gnfbnk c
{ gr c fif/nt
fk oi}n cbb
nb{}gbcl cb{gtg
gb dgnlkr u}ikijw c}n g{r ag
}ns~g}nr c
cfk jgcf{ r
ragnlknk z
/ 4 / Mna
jgfj !dO]G'
kwfcogb }nru
}nlc{nk {i f
O]G !Ocj
O]['& [an
cl cb{gtg{w cf
G c fn~}igo
{~kgnr {an m}
d~fb{gif& Cr
nnkr tn}w ru
cf NNJ
{n}dcbnr o~l
iltnk&
j~gr{gb gf{n}d
bn}nm}cl cui
rgtn
~}c{n
{w gf
~bnka
iio
un}/
llr&‟
o )
ifrn
~}cl
fn{gb
dcb{
{an
jgfj
cgf‗r
{agr
nbgcl
{guln
cbnr&
lnqw
cf
{a
kg
m}Gf
nq
D
kg
d~
d}
bn
id
{a
k c}n “lib`n
n iun}c{gif i
ddn}nf{ {nbafg
cgf tgc cf nln{an dillizgf
coulnr c}n u}
c&Cktcf{cj
[agr gr oir{l
} nqcouln8 g
ddgb~l{ {i di~f
}{an}& Mw ~rg
o c {n}}i}gr{
k&Kgrcktcf{
Ocw mn g{ b
llr gr lnrr {ac
agr bif{}il c
Anc} G }ndn}
gr ucun} cfk
P3_ a{{u8))on~cf{~oki
P=_ a{{u8))zz:7=$gk?zg`g$u}gi{.=5zg
P2_ a{{u8))zzo/@illi{
P;_ a{{u8))zz
P>_ a{{u8))mii$ig?dfkOFxO$DR^AkJ=5ki{.=
/gf‟, {}cuunk
d {airn kntgb
s~n ‒ {an kg
b{}i/nfbnuacldi~} kgddn}n
nrnf{nk cfk b
TG& CB@F
r
w ~rnk {i bac
d uilgbn onf
k zac{ gr gf
j {agr {nbafi
{i c uilgbn o
cjnr
f {~}f c a~o
c}{gdgbgcl m}
k ki zac{nt
]NDN
ntn}cl mii`r
w j~gkn {agr g
arn&gllgfigr&nk~) {r&=5355;=>&;mk
z&jiijln&bi&gf)u h:fCSCCNMCH{rnb?cmr{}cb{"tg$d?dclrn
z&gbr&~bg&nk~)vcn`/A~nr`nYMBG
z&cxifcfi&bio)
`r&jiijln&bi&gf)muj?U]7$ks?sgj?/
5GrDGZ{2NaGfs:kndgfg{gif$d?dcl
gf {ang} izf
r gr gouirrg
}nb{ bioo~f
ij}co !NNJ'f{ {nbafgs~nr
iouc}nk r~mr
IZLNKJONF
jn {an ogfkr
bc~ja{ c {n}
gr ogfk cfk
lijw zn bac
f
f gf {i c }im
gf bnll {anf {
} {an gfu~{ gr
NFBNR
cfk oir{lw z
r {an iflw }nd
nkgc)~ulickr)bi
;b3b>mn1dn:&:2;
c{nf{r9al?nf$l}?$ig?dfk$ks?sifnucjn$s?s~c
nao)blcrrY}nui}r&ukd
}{gbln&cruq9C}{gb
ii`r9al?nf$l}?cf{~o+ki{+kndg
CWIw^`"t?ifnrn
mikw ri {i r
ln& [an}ndi}
gbc{gif zg{a
gr cuulgnk acfk cuulgbc{g
ns~nf{lw&
n{ id c un}rif
}i}gr{, g{ gr t
ac{ an gr kig
jn agr ogfk
}{, gd fi id m}
c{ un}rif gr
gtnf
nmrg{nr {i b}n
}nfbn
~}rnYznmrg{nr)ln1>=13&ukd
$tgk?^RUC[:7cf{~o+fcfi+kif{~o.=5fcfi.
{r)r{~{{jc}{)mbg)M
lnGK?313;
gk?=kbFIuG]d g{gif$i{r?;:nM
ucjn$s?s~cf{~
cw,
, c
{an
}n&gif
}w
gfj
rn{
cgf
~{
c{n
Ys
41{+=5k
a
`Bf4
.
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 24/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;=3>)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;=3>
Jijjln, FI[ Jiijln
C }nclgr{gb cuu}icba {izc}kr {an }ncl zi}lk gf{n}cb{gif
Cmagran` Hirag
Ra}g J&R Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw $ Rbgnfbn, Gfki}n
RJRG[R
Gfki}n, Gfkgc
Cli` Ucfbacl
Gfr{g{~{n id Nfjgfnn}gfj cfk [nbafilijw, Gfki}n
GN[/ KCTT
Gfki}n, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛]nrnc}ban}r actn di~fk rntn}cl oncfr id u~{{gfj {an
gknc id ]NCL ZI]LK GF[N]CB[GIF gf{i u}cb{gbcl& M~{
oir{ id {ano c}n u~}nlw cf c}{gr{gb cuu}icba zg{a fi }ncl cfk
-u}cb{gbcl- ~rn& U}ihnb{gif mcrnk {nbafilijgnr bifr~on agjan}
uizn} cfk g{ gr blnc} {ac{ ~rgfj r~ba {nbafilijgnr {i gf{n}cb{
zg{a {an }ncl zi}lk imhnb{r gr FI[ {an zcw {i c m}gja{n} zi}lk&
[i itn}bion cll {anrn mc}}gn}r zn r{c}{nk }nrnc}bagfj if
iu{gbcl {ani}w, Ml~n{ii{a, gfd}c}nk nog{{n}r cfk uai{i/kgiknr
!}nbngtn}r'& I~} }nrnc}ba zi}` kinr fi{ }ns~g}n cfw
u}ihnb{gif& G{ gr mcrnk if u~}n bg}b~g{}w cfk rnfri} mcrnk
{}cb`gfj gfr{nck id gocjn u}ibnrrgfj& Anfbn zn jn{ u}nbgrn
tcl~nr zg{a lncr{ uizn} bifr~ou{gif& Clri fi mcb`j}i~fk gr
fnnknk di} gf{n}cb{gif zg{a {an rwr{no& Zn bcon {a}i~ja rion
dcrbgfc{gfj }nr~l{r k~}gfj {ang} u}cb{gbcl goulnonf{c{gif& Zg{a
d~}{an} gou}itnonf{r, if ckkg{gif id gfd}c}nk nog{{n}r,
billnb{i} !uai{i/kgikn' r{}gur0 {an rwr{no fiz gr cmln {i {}cb`
{an dgfjn} oitnonf{r cfk zi}` cbbi}kgfjlw& Zan}n dgfjn}r
zi}` lg`n cfw i{an} gfd}c}nk }ndlnb{i}0 {an }ndlnb{nk gfd}c}nk
lgja{r c}n rnfrnk mw {an rwr{no&
@nwzi}kr/ ]ncl zi}lk Gf{n}cb{gif, {i~barb}nnf ! nw zi}kr'
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Oimgln uaifnr, lcu{iur, kgjg{cl bcon}cr c}n uc}{ id i~}kcw {i kcw lgdn& [anrn {nbafilijgnr bcf mn bifrgkn}nk cr ifnid {an oir{ u}iogrgfj gftnf{gif id {an {znf{gn{a bnf{~}w&[anw ulcw c ochi} }iln gf un}rifcl cfk u}idnrrgifcl lgdn&Bioo~fgbc{gif zg{a {anrn kntgbnr acr gou}itnkrgjfgdgbcf{lw& Di} nqcouln {i~ba/rb}nnfr actn {c`nf ulcbn id `nwuck mcrnk fctgjc{gif0 anfbn u}itgkgfj mn{{n} gf{n}cb{gifzg{a {an rwr{no !fi{ lgog{nk {i bnll uaifnr'& Coulgdgnkgf{n}cb{gif gr ifn id {an u}goc}w bifbn}fr id {anrn kntgbnr&
Biomgfc{gif id kgddn}nf{ d~fb{gifclg{gnr, rn}tgbnr cfk
cuulgbc{gifr r~ba cr bcon}c cfk kib~onf{ tgnzn} gf c bnlluaifn, ifn/blgb` ~ulick dnc{~}n id kgjg{cl bcon}cr cfk i{an}r~ba dnc{~}nr c{{}cb{ ~rn}r d}io ntn}w j}i~u&
[an s~nr{gif un}rgr{r cfk gfknnk j}izr zan{an} {anbiou~{n} zgll oc`n g{ ncrgn} i} ac}kn} di} a~ocf mngfjr {i`fiz zai {anw }ncllw c}n, {i gknf{gdw {ang} }ncl u}imlnor, {i}nruifk oi}n d~llw {i mnc~{w, {i ulcbn ckns~c{n tcl~n if lgdn,cfk {i oc`n {ang} zi}lk rcdn} {acf g{ fiz grP3_&
Oir{ ~rn}r dgfk {anrn kntgbnr !jckjn{r gf {agr bif{nq{'
kgddgb~l{ {i iun}c{n, bc}}w, cfk ~rn nddnb{gtnlw& Gf{n}cb{gifzg{a {an rwr{no gr {ai~ja nfacfbnk m~{ {an}n c}n iflw dnzcuulgbc{gifr zagba nfacfbn {an }ncl {gon knbgrgif oc`gfjbcucmglg{w, tg}{~clgxc{gif cfk un}di}ocfbn id {an ~rn}& I~}
dib~r gr u}goc}glw if biomgfc{gif id rntn}cl {nbafilijgnrcfk cuulgbc{gifr {i cbagntn jicl id }ncl zi}lk gf{n}cb{gifmngfj cr u}cb{gbcl cr uirrgmln&
GT&B^]]NF[ RBNFN]GI $ FNNK
]nrnc}ban}r actn `fizf di} wnc}r {ac{ uigf{gfj, blgb`gfjcfk k}cjjgfj c}n fi{ gkncl di}or id gf{n}cb{gif di} ocfw{cr`r& G{‗r ac}k {i k}cz c dlizn} i} rgjf fcon ~rgfj c oi~rn&Rgoglc}lw, `nwuck mcrnk fctgjc{gif gf bnll uaifn acr cl}nckwmnnf }nulcbnk mw {i~ba/rb}nnfr& Ntnf cd{n} {an gf{}ik~b{gifid {i~ba rb}nnf, bnll uaifn rgxn acr j}ck~cllw gfb}ncrnk {iu}itgkn mn{{n} gf{n}cb{gif cfk kgrulcw m~{ {anw }ns~g}n j}nc{bc}n k~n {i d}cjgln fc{~}n& ^rn}r cuuc}nf{lw oc`n r~}n {ac{{ang} dgfjn}r c}n blncf mndi}n {i~bagfj {ano, bifrbgi~rlw
bifrgkn} ntn}w oitn {anw oc`n zaglr{ ailkgfj rcgk u}nbgi~rjckjn{, rzc{a {ang} jckjn{r gf cll ocffn} id u}i{nb{gtn bcrncfk rb}nnf ril~{gifr0 aiz znll {anrn u}ik~b{r h~r{gdw {anmcrgb u}gfbguln id jiik knrgjf&
Jiik knrgjf gr cr lg{{ln cr uirrgmln& Lnrr, m~{ mn{{n} ‒mnbc~rn g{ bifbnf{}c{nr if {an nrrnf{gcl crunb{r, cfk {anu}ik~b{r c}n fi{ m~}knfnk zg{a fif/nrrnf{gclr P=_&
[ikcw gfk~r{}w‗r u}gon dib~r gr “aiz znll a~ocfgf{n}cb{r zg{a {an ocbagfn‟ cfk fi{ “aiz znll ocbagfnu}itnr g{r ~rnd~lfnrr gf }ncl zi}lk‟ i} “aiz znll {anocbagfn r~}tgtnr gf {an }ncl zi}lk bifkg{gifr‟&
Kgjg{cl {nbafilijgnr zgll bif{gf~n {i u}ilgdn}c{n, nfcmlgfjntn} oi}n zcwr id bacfjgfj aiz zn lgtn& M~{ zgll r~bakntnliuonf{r gou}itn {an s~clg{w id lgdn, nouizn} ~r, cfk
oc`n ~r dnnl rcdn}, acuugn} cfk oi}n biffnb{nk9 I} zglllgtgfj zg{a {nbafilijw oc`n g{ oi}n {g}nrion, d}~r{}c{gfj,cfjr{/ }gkknf, cfk rnb~}g{w/k}gtnf9
T&NQGR[GFJ ]NRNC]BANR CFK [ANG] GOUN]DNB[GIFR
C&[an Rgq{a Rnfrn
[an Rgq{a Rnfrn u}i{i{wun gr biou}grnk id c uib`n{u}ihnb{i}, c og}}i} cfk c bcon}c& [an ac}kzc}n biouifnf{rc}n bi~ulnk gf c unfkcf{ lg`n oimgln znc}cmln kntgbn& Mi{a{an u}ihnb{i} cfk {an bcon}c c}n biffnb{nk {i {an oimglnbiou~{gfj kntgbn gf {an ~rn}‗r uib`n{& [an u}ihnb{i} u}ihnb{rtgr~cl gfdi}oc{gif nfcmlgfj r~}dcbnr, zcllr cfk uawrgbclimhnb{r c}i~fk ~r {i mn ~rnk cr gf{n}dcbnr0 zagln {an bcon}c
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 25/223
g
g
}nbijfgxnr cmhnb{r ~rgf
rid{zc}n u}ijw {an bcon}c
!tgr~cl {}cb`g~rgfj rgoulncfk c}}cfjnnr{~}nr {ac{
cuulgbc{gif gf[an Rgq{a
anfbn bifr~{ac{ {an bnll unco }nui}{cucmglg{w& P;_
Cf imhnb{rnb~}n {acf {ar{c}{nk d}io r{i a~ocf mik
[an u}gon{ac{ ~rn} gr cl[an}n c}n c fijjlnr, oim
}nrnc}ba kntizn}d~l nfi
gfu~{, u}ibncbbi}kgfjlw& Gniuln ~rn j
gfbl~kgfj JI
lcrrnr cr bigjg{cl bcon}cLBK oi
}noitcl g{ ocd ~rgfj {}cfr
rnnonk {i mnDillizgfj
Dgj
k {}cb`r ~rbiou~{n}/
}co u}ibnrrncfk {}cb`r {aj dgk~bgclr'biou~{n}/tgrnf{r id {anr
cb{ cr gf{n}cb{{n}dcbnr&P2_
Rnfrn zi}nr agja coiaifnr zg{a uklw actn ui
GG&[AN
blirn} {i a~n imhnb{ u}nrnc}bagfj {an n0 ri {ac{ ~rn}dib~r id i~}nckw acmg{nkomn} id kntggln uaifnr,gbn rai~lk~ja {i bc}}wrr {ano u{ {ii` fi lifjjlnr& Zn m
JJLN gf{i g{&
omgfc{gif id i} cfw i{an}g{i}r ~rn c
`nr {an LBKc}nf{ [D[ gf}cb{gbcl an}n&gocjnr raiz
~}n 3& Gffn} tgn
Dgj~}n =& Jlir
}*r acfk jnrgrgif mcrnk
r {an tgkni r{libc{gifr id
c{ {an {gu id gif {nbafgs~n dgk~bgclr cgif gfr{}~b{gi
r if {an u}f{ id nfn}jw&ihnb{gif bcuci} mc{{n}w l
]NRNC]BA
ocf mikw grf{ c{ c kgr{cfqgr{gfj imhnb{bcf iun}c{n {}nrnc}ba zcrid0 ri cr {i clbnr, r~ba cr8UKC, ou2 un ui}{cmlni~{ {cr`r r~bnbgrnlw cfkj {i dgfk {ac{}icknfnk i~[an mcrgb gkn
kntgbnr r~baUKC kntgbn&{agf lcwn} iloir{ {}cfrucr{nck id }nj~l {an }nrnc}ba g
id [D[0 iunfn
rw rann{ cfk i}gjg
{~}nr cfk ua{nbafgs~nr&
}nco kc{c bc{an bili}nk o
{an ~rn}‗r d r& [an oitn}n gf{n}u}n{nr di} {an u}i
ihnb{gif {nbaG{ rai~lk mn
mglg{w lg`n Rcgdn cfk u}ih
oi}n un}rifbn& Ri i~} }nr {ac{ c}n tn}wn kntgbn ncrgl{i kntnliu cliz s~gb` lnckgjg{cl z}gr{lcwn}r& [ancfk bioucb{a cr }nckgfj
jnfn}c{nc lc}jn f~o}nrnc}ba zi
c zcr {i ~rn
cr oimgln
d jlirrw ran}nf{0 anfbn {ac} jlcrrnr gf
f cb{gif&
gf {an lcm&
gfcl {d{
wrgbcl[an
{~}nkc}`n}rgfjn}ronf{r
gf{i hnb{nk
gs~n0fi{nkr~fj
nb{gif
l cfknc}bablirnw&ntgbn}fgfj&c{ba,
cgonk0 wn{~rn}*r~{u~{n} id
}` mwijjln
aifn,
{0 ifn gkncijjln
}nj
mn{
`nwgf{
nog{aczg{~rg
c}n
If c{{cbao~lc} kgrulcw&Cl{n}fc{gtnlw{n} {}cfruc}nf
Dgj
[i gf{n}cb{ zmic}k, m~{ i}cb{ zg{a {an
g{{n}r cfk bc{ {an ~rn} kina {an Iun}c{gj oi~rn i} ` [an r{nur gftcr dillizr8
3& [kg
=& [lg
2& Z}ib
c;& B
kb
>& Obxu
gj~}n 2& [D[ c
f{ zg{a UB,
, ILNK rb}nw P>_
}n ;& Uaglgur* {}
g{a Iun}c{gfj} }nrnc}ba b}Iun}c{gfj rwr
n}c !znm/bcr fi{ }ns~g}nj rwr{no0 ~rnnwmic}k&iltnk gf gknf
n Rwr{no bi}nb{lw if {ann Gfd}c}nk na{r gf d}if{ ianf c r{wl~r,k, kndlnb{r {aon}c rnfrnr
k rnfkr {i {af{}illn} bift{c cfk rnfou~{n}&i~rn bif{}i}kgfc{nr crior, blgb`rrg{gif&
k imhnb{ tgrgmlg{
{an LBK zcr
fr bcf mn ~
cfruc}nf{ ILNK
rwr{no ~rn} }nc{nk c kgddn}{no zn ~rnk
'& [an oi{{cfw {wun id k} bcf ~rn agr
{gdgbc{gif id d
frgr{r id c d}nxnl id jijjlg{{n}r nog{ g
d {an jijjln rr~ba cr c dg
n mncor id g{an kndlnb{n
bif{}illn}&n}{r {agr kc{ckr {an bii
lln} k}gtn}f gfu~{ cfki} aitn}r
r{gll bcucmln
nk zagba jg
P4_
s~g}nr oi~rnnf{ rbnfc}gi&n}gnr id Gfd}c
i mnagfk {agrntgbn {i gf{n}gfjn}r gfr{nck
gfjn}!r' uirg{g
on {ac{ oi~&
ftgrgmln gfd}c}dcbn&jn} i} c ulcd}c}nk lgja{,
gfd}c}nk lgj
gf{i oncfgfjkgfc{nr {i
{c`nr {aitnr {an b~}r{i {an knrg
id
nr
i}[i}nk
grcb{id
gif
f{r
}nk
{gb{ana{r
d~l{an
rni},}nk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 35
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 26/223
g
[an zi}`gn}di}o {an c
rnfrnk mw {angknf{gdgnk c{ }
Dgj~}n :& [D
gj~}n >& Zi}`g
Dgj~}n 4& 2
GGG&BIFB
fj oiknl bcf{gifr cbbi}kgbcon}c c}n gff{gon di} u}i
kgrulcwgfj bif{
fj id nog{{n} cfk
K oiknl id jijj
NU[ GF[I CB[
{}cb` {an libcjlw& [an }ndl}cz di}o cfkun} gf{n}cb{gi
f{ id znmucjn c
bcon}c
ln&
GIF
{gif id dgfjn}rb{nk gfd}c}nkmlimr c}nzg{a {an rwr{
k tgrgmln i~{n}
cfk}cwr
no&
i}lk
r~bZgogl
bifnf}aicfko~bi
P3_
P=_
P2_
P;_
P>_
P4_
Dgj~
[an}n gr f f~a cr oimglg{w/Dg biffnb{gtnr{ifn gf {an
[agr }nrnc}brgkn}r fnz ` gba lgdn& Aiz
cbb~}c{n {a{ang} cb{gifr
ba b}nc{~}nr iulnq gf {ang}
Fi}ocf Bi~rgf
Kgn{n} ]cor8 [
U& Ogr{}w, U&{an U}ibnnkgfjHcucf& =557&
a{{u8))ojg{nbn{nu}ihnb{i}/uaif
a{{u8))nlnb{}ifgb
a{{u8))zzz&nfjlgja{gfj/di}/uir
}n 1& Kn{nb{nk d
TG&UIRRG
mn} id uirrgbcf mn gfb}
g{w& [an }nrgr{i}w id ]nc
TGG&BIF
a lii`r c{ {gfkr id {nbaftn}, {an r~bb
rwr{no gr gc{ c jgtnf od acmg{, {anwfnnkr cfk knr
]NDN]
r ‒ [an Uin{ cfk
nf u}gfbgulnr di}
cnr& Rgq{aRnfrnr id RGJJ]C
ba&zi}ku}nrr&bi )
r&aizr{~ddzi}`r
ckjn{&bio)=557) {/oikn}f/gknf{g{
gfjn} uirg{gif !ml
MGLG[GNR
glg{gnr zg{a {acrnk mw ckkgc}ba bcf u}
l Zi}lk Gf{n}c
BL^RGIF
an fnnk id ilijgnr {ac{ brr id }nrnc}bdn}}gfj c un
ionf{& Zaglncf clri mn agg}nr&
NFBNR
{an Biou~{n}, 3
jiik knrgjf&
‒ C Znc}cmlnA Crgc =557,
)=533)51)32)rc
&bio)ilnk;&a{o
52)54)uaglgur/{}c/ocr`)
imr'
gr }nrnc}ba zfj Ml~n{ii{aitn g{rnld crb{gif&
gffitc{gifi~lk mn ~rnk
zgll knunfkrif‗r gf{nf{guniuln c}n talw }cfkio
44
nr{~}cl Gf{n}dcbnR`n{ba& Wi`iac
r~fj/mnco/
ruc}nf{/ilnk/
}` i}c
fk{iiffr}wfk
& Gfoc,
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 33
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 27/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;===)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;===
If{ilijw Mcrnk S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj di} Cj}gb~l{~}n Kiocgf
C}ghg{ Kn[c{c Bifr~l{cfbw Rn}tgbnr
Wcf{}c Uc}`, = Ui`a}cf ]ick
[acfn !Z', O~omcg, Gfkgc, ;55453,
Cmr{}cb{‛Zg{a {an cktnf{ id {an rnocf{gb znm, if{ilijgnr cr
`fizlnkjn }nu}nrnf{c{gif r{}~b{~}nr actn jcgfnk goonfrn
uiu~lc}g{w& If{ilijgnr actn mnnf ~rnk tn}w nddnb{gtnlw gf
}nu}nrnf{gfj kiocgf `fizlnkjn di} kiocgf/runbgdgb
Gfdi}oc{gif ]n{}gntcl !G]' cfk S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj {ac{
}ns~g}n Gfdi}oc{gif Nq{}cb{gif cfk Fc{~}cl Lcfj~cjn
U}ibnrrgfj {nbafgs~nr di} s~n}w uc}rgfj cfk ~fkn}r{cfkgfj&
Gf {agr ucun} zn u}iuirn cf c~{ioc{nk s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfjrwr{no di} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf, {ac{ ~rnr j}cua clji}g{aor
{i nq{}cb{ cfrzn}r {i ~rn} s~nr{gifr r{i}nk gfrgkn c cj}i/
if{ilijw if{ilijw& Zn ntcl~c{n i~} rwr{no ~rgfj r{cfkc}k
s~nr{gifr cr`nk mw dc}on}r {i oncr~}n cbb~}cbw gf {n}or id
u}nbgrgif cfk }nbcll& Zn biouc}n {an un}di}ocfbn id i~}
rwr{no zg{a {an zgknlw uiu~lc} Cs~cLij rwr{no zanf {an
lc{{n} gr bifdgj~}nk di} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf& I~}
nqun}gonf{r knoifr{}c{n {an r~un}gi} un}di}ocfbn id i~}
rwr{no&
Rnocf{gb Rnc}ba Rwr{nor, @fizlnkjn Mcrnk Rwr{nor,If{ilijw, Gfdi}oc{gif ]n{}gntcl&
G& G F[]IK^B[GIF
[an rnocf{gb znm zcr lc}jnlw cf nddi}{ {i i}jcfgxn {anawun}{nq{ bif{nf{ id {an Zi}lk Zgkn Znm !ZZZ' gf{i clc}jn i}jcfgxnk }nuirg{i}w id kiocgf `fizlnkjn {ac{ bi~lk
mn ogfnk mw c~{ioc{nk gf{nllgjnf{ cjnf{r {i u}itgkn oi}noncfgfjd~l gfdi}oc{gif di} gfdi}oc{gif rnn`n}r& Gf i}kn} {i{}cfrdi}o {an o~l{g/onkgc cfk {nq{ }nuirg{i}w bif{cgfnkzg{agf {an ZZZ gf{i c `fizlnkjn }nuirg{i}w, rbgnf{gr{rcfk `fizlnkjn nfjgfnn}r bcon mi}}iznk {an bifbnu{ id if{ilijw i~{ id uagliriuaw& If{ilijw zagba gf uagliriuawzcr {an rbgnfbn id mngfj zcr kndgfnk cr !Bacfk}crn`ac}cfP3_' c di}ocl bifbnu{~clgxc{gif id c kiocgf i} r~mhnb{oc{{n} `fizlnkjn& [an rnocf{gb znm knoifr{}c{nk aizif{ilijgnr bi~lk mn ~rnk nddnb{gtnlw gf }nu}nrnf{gfj kiocgf
`fizlnkjn& [an ~rn id If{ilijgnr acr jifn dc} mnwifk {anrnocf{gb znm& If{ilijgnr actn mnbion c uiu~lc} baigbn crkiocgf `fizlnkjn }nu}nrnf{c{gif r{}~b{~}nr di} Gfdi}oc{gif]n{}gntcl !G]', S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj !SC', Gfdi}oc{gifNq{}cb{gif !GN' cfk c air{ id i{an} Gfdi}oc{gif Rwr{nor !GR'cuulgbc{gifr&
Gf {agr ucun} zn u}iuirn cf if{ilijw mcrnk s~nr{gifcfrzn}gfj rwr{no di} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf& Zn r{c}{ idd kgrb~rrgfj i~} u}iuirnk rwr{no cr c bifbnu{~cl kiocgf
gfknunfknf{ c~{ioc{nk s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no {ac{ ~rnrif{ilijgnr cr {an u}goc}w `fizlnkjn mcrn di} s~nr{gifcfrzn}gfj& I~} s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no {}nc{r {ankiocgf if{ilijw cr biomgfc{i}gcl kgj}cua {ac{ zi~lk mn{}ctn}rnk ~rgfj {}ckg{gifcl j}cua clji}g{aor& Zn {anfkgrb~rr {an runbgdgbr id c cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf runbgdgb
s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no {ac{ cfrzn}r s~nr{gifr u~{di}zc}k mw dc}on}r cfk cj}i/cktgri}r lntn}cjgfj cfif{ilijw cr {an riln `fizlnkjn mcrn& Zn nqun}gonf{ zg{ar{cfkc}k s~n}gnr cr`nk gf {agr kiocgf {i kn{n}ogfn {ancbb~}cbw id {an c~{ioc{nk cj}i/s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no
m~gl{& Zn clri dnnk {an rcon s~n}gnr {i {an zgknlw uiu~lc} Cs~cLij P=_ s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no zagba zn}nbifdgj~}n di} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf& Zn biouc}n cfkbif{}cr{ {an un}di}ocfbn id i~} rwr{no zg{a {ac{ id Cs~cLij&
I~} ucun} gr i}jcfgxnk cr dillizr& Gf {an fnq{ rnb{gif,zn knrb}gmn u}ntgi~r zi}` gf {agr c}nc& [agr gfbl~knr ckgrb~rrgif if `nw biouifnf{r id if{ilijgnr, if{ilijwcuulgbc{gifr gf G], GN cfk SC& [agr gfbl~knr c kn{cglnk
knrb}gu{gif id Cs~cLij cfk i~} }nbifdgj~}c{gif id Cs~cLij, cr {agr gr {an mnfbaoc}` rwr{no di} i~} nqun}gonf{r& Zn clri kgrb~rr r{cfkc}k cj}i/if{ilijgnr gf{agr rnb{gif& Gf Rnb{gif 2, zn kgrb~rr i~} u}iuirnk{ani}n{gbcl if{ilijw/mcrnk s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no&R~mrns~nf{lw Rnb{gif ; zn kgrb~rr, {an knrgjf id i~} cj}i/if{ilijw cfk i~} if{ilijw mcrnk c~{ioc{nk s~nr{gifcfrzn}gfj rwr{no di} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf& Rnb{gif > znkgrb~rrnr i~} nqun}gonf{r cfk zn bifbl~kn i~} ucun} zg{ac kgrb~rrgif if d~{~}n zi}` cfk aiz cf if{ilijw/mcrnks~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no bcf mn c r~m/rwr{no gf c m}ickn} c~{ioc{nk s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj ulc{di}o&
GG& U]NTGI^R ZI]@
Cr onf{gifnk nc}lgn}, if{ilijgnr c}n r{}~b{~}nr di} }nu}nrnf{gfj kiocgf `fizlnkjn& C dg}r{ r{nu gf if{ilijw
m~glkgfj gftiltnr gknf{gdwgfj kiocgf runbgdgb bifbnu{r cfknf{g{gnr& [anrn c}n oiknlnk gf{i m}ickn} blcrrnr, gfkgtgk~clr{ac{ mnlifj {i {anrn blcrrnr cfk blcrr cfk gfkgtgk~clc{{}gm~{nr i} u}iun}{gnr& [an }nlc{gifragu mn{znnf {anrnblcrrnr cfk gfkgtgk~clr c}n nr{cmlgrank cfk }nu}nrnf{nk crimhnb{ u}iun}{gnr& ]nlc{gifragu mn{znnf blcrrnr cfkgfkgtgk~clr c}n biffnb{nk {a}i~ja c j}cua lg`n r{}~b{~}nzan}n ncba fikn }nu}nrnf{r c blcrr i} cf gfkgtgk~cl cfk cimhnb{ u}iun}{w gr cf nkjn biffnb{gfj {zi fiknr {ac{kndgfnr c }nlc{gifragu mn{znnf {ano& If{ilijgnr {a~rbifrgr{ id !3' gfkgtgk~clr nf{g{gnr {ac{ actn runbgdgb
u}iun}{gnr& !=' blcrrnr {ac{ c}n j}i~ur id gfkgtgk~clr zg{a
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 28/223
biooif u}iun}{gnr {ac{ bac}cb{n}gxn {ano, !2' cqgior cfk}~lnr zagba kndgfn fnbnrrc}w cfk r~ddgbgnf{ bifkg{gifr di} onomn}ragu gf runbgdgb blcrrnr, !;' imhnb{ u}iun}{gnr {ac{anlu nr{cmlgra }nlc{gifragu mn{znnf kgddn}nf{ blcrrnr i} gfkgtgk~clr cfk c}n }nu}nrnf{nk cr nkjnr gf {an if{ilijwj}cua, !>' kc{c u}iun}{gnr {ac{ ntn}w nf{g{w !blcrr i} gfkgtgk~cl' uirrnrrnr, !4' cffi{c{gif U}iun}{gnr {ac{ ailkckkg{gifcl gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{ c uc}{gb~lc} blcrr {ac{ bcf fi{
mn oiknlnk i{an}zgrn& Blcrrnr cfk gfkgtgk~clr di}o fiknrgf {an if{ilijw j}cua cfk imhnb{ u}iun}{gnr di} {an nkjnr&
If{ilijgnr }ns~g}n di}ocl knrb}gu{gif lcfj~cjnr di} {ang} bifr{}~b{gif& C uiu~lc} di}ocl lcfj~cjn di} }nu}nrnf{gfj cf if{ilijw gr ]nri~}bn Knrb}gu{gifD}conzi}` !]KD' cfk g{r nq{nfrgif Znm If{ilijwLcfj~cjn !IZL'& ]KD knrb}gmnk mw @lwfn P3;_, gr cfnq{nfrgif id QOL cfk gr ~rnk {i b}nc{n c bifbnu{~cl oiknldi} }nu}nrnf{gfj {an `fizlnkjn r{}~b{~}n id c kiocgf&Mnbaaidn} P3=_ u}itgknr lc{nr{ runbgdgbc{gifr id ZnmIf{ilijw Lcfj~cjn !IZL'& IZL nq{nfknk ]KD {i ckkoi}n nqu}nrrgtg{w di} `fizlnkjn }nu}nrnf{c{gif if {anrnocf{gb znm& IZL fi{ iflw u}nrnf{r gfdi}oc{gif di} a~ocf bifr~ou{gif, m~{ bcf mn clri mn ~rnk {i u}ibnrrgfdi}oc{gif bif{nf{& Mnbaaidn} P3=_ knrb}gmn `nwbiouifnf{r id IZL& IZL if{ilijw biouifnf{r gfbl~knblcrrnr, u}iun}{gnr, kndgfgfj gfr{cfbnr cfk g{r iun}c{gifr crkgrb~rrnk nc}lgn}& U}i{çjç P32_ gr c {iil kntnliunk c{R{cfdi}k ^fgtn}rg{w {i b}nc{n if{ilijgnr ~rgfj IZL&
Liunx P=_ m~gl{ Cs~cLij cf if{ilijw mcrnk S~nr{gifCfrzn}gfj !SC'& Lnn P2_ ~rnk if{ilijgnr di} fnzrr~ooc}gxc{gif cfk Zgoclcr~}gwc P;, :_, Z~ P4, 1_
u~mlgrank {an zi}`gfjr id If{ilijw Mcrnk Gfdi}oc{gifNq{}cb{gif Rwr{nor !IMGN'& Z~ P4_ b}nc{nk cf IMGNrwr{no, @wlgf, zagba nq{}cb{r kc{c d}io Zg`gunkgcGfdimiqnr cfk i}jcfgxnr {ano gf {an di}o id cf if{ilijw&Z~ P1_ gou}itnr {an un}di}ocfbn !gf {n}or id }nbcll' id @wlgf d~}{an} gf bcrn id ruc}n blcrrnr& Zgoclcr~}gwc P7_nquli}n {an mnfndg{r id ~rgfj o~l{guln if{ilijgnr zanfkgddn}nf{ if{ilijgnr c}n cuulgnk {i kgddn}nf{ biouifnf{r id cgfdi}oc{gif nq{}cb{gif rwr{no cfk zanf o~l{guln if{ilijgnrc}n cuulgnk {i ncba gfdi}oc{gif nq{}cb{gif rwr{nobiouifnf{& Zgoclcr~}gwc P;_ m~glkr if {agr biouifnf{
mcrnk cuu}icba {i b}nc{gfj IMGN rwr{nor {ac{ bcf mn}n~rnk& [an zi}`r id Zgoclcr~}gwc P;, :_ knoifr{}c{nr {an
mnfndg{r id ~rgfj o~l{guln if{ilijgnr cfk if{ilijw }n~rn&
c&Cj}i If{ilijgnr
Rgfbn {an imhnb{gtn id {agr ucun} gr {i m~glk c if{ilijw mcrnk s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no di} {an cj}gb~l{~}nkiocgf, cfk zi~lk }ns~g}n m~glkgfj cf cj}i/if{ilijw, g{ gr
u}~knf{ {i }ntgnz u}ntgi~r nddi}{r c{ m~glkgfj cj}i/if{ilijgnr& If{ilijgnr gf {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf actn mnnfkntnliunk u}goc}glw di} rac}gfj kiocgf `fizlnkjn gf {andgnlk id cj}gb~l{~}n& [zi b}g{gbcl zi}`r gf b}nc{gfj cj}i/if{ilijgnr c}n {an CJ]ITIB u}ihnb{ P7_ cfk {anCj}iunkgc Gfkgbc u}ihnb{ P35_, kntnliunk mw GG[/@cfu~}&
CJ]ITIB P7_ zcr c ^fg{nk Fc{gifr !^F' Diik cfkCj}gb~l{~}n I}jcfgxc{gif !DCI' gfg{gc{gtn {i m~glk {anzi}lk‗r oir{ nqac~r{gtn o~l{glgfj~cl cj}gb~l{~}cltibcm~lc}w m~gl{ if c r{cfkc}kgxnk kc{c knrb}gu{gif oiknl&
CJ]ITIB gr c}}cfjnk cr rn{ id {n}or cfk {ang} gf{n}/}nlc{gifragur {ac{ }nu}nrnf{ ;5,555 cj}gb~l{~}cl bifbnu{rzi}lk/zgkn bitn}gfj fi{ iflw cj}gb~l{~}n m~{ i{an} }nlc{nk{iugbr {ac{ gfbl~kn di}nr{}w, dgran}gnr, }cfbagfj, lcfk ~rn,}~}cl lgtnlgaiikr cfk kntnliuonf{, diik rnb~}g{w&CJ]ITIB tibcm~lc}w gr gf itn} =5 oir{ uiu~lc} lcfj~cjnr zi}lk zgkn& CJ]ITIB gr clri cf gf{nj}c{nklgf`nk iunf kc{c RIC ulc{di}o di} gf{n}iun}cmglg{w,}n~rcmglg{w cfk biiun}c{gif zg{a i{an} i}jcfgxc{gifr {ac{~rn rgoglc} iunf r{cfkc}kr& TibMnfba gr c o~l{glgfj~cltibcm~lc}w nkg{i} cfk zi}`dliz ocfcjnonf{ {iil ctcglcmlnif {an CJ]ITIB znmucjn {ac{ cllizr di} uc}cllnl cfkkgr{}gm~{nk nkg{gfj id {an o~l{g/lgfj~cl tibcm~lc}w& C jlimclbioo~fg{w id lgm}c}gcfr, {n}ogfilijgr{r, gfdi}oc{gifocfcjn}r cfk rid{zc}n kntnliun}r ~rn TibMnfba di} ocgf{cgfgfj cfk ~ukc{gfj CJ]ITIB& Itn} {an wnc}r,CJ]ITCB if{ilijgnr actn mnnf kizflicknk mw ~rn}r gf ckixnf bi~f{}gnr {i gfknq cfk rnc}ba itn} lc}jn kib~onf{cfk znm billnb{gifr&
Cj}iunkgc Gfkgbc P35_ zcr c u}ihnb{ id {an GfkgcfGfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw, @cfu~} {i m~glk c ulc{di}o di} kgjg{cl `fizlnkjn ocfcjnonf{ di} cj}gb~l{~}n gf Gfkgc&Cj}iunkgc Gfkgbc acr b}nc{nk c biou}nanfrgtn, rncolnrrlwgf{nj}c{nk oiknl id kgjg{cl gfdi}oc{gif bif{nf{ di} {ancj}gb~l{~}cl kiocgf gf Gfkgc&
Cj}iunkgc Gfkgbc gr c Znm =&5 cuulgbc{gif zan}n`fizlnkjn oiknlr c}n ~rnk {i r{i}n cfk i}jcfgxn bif{nf{b}nc{nk mw tc}gi~r `fizlnkjn cb{i}r {a}i~ja {an Cld}nrbiBif{nf{ Ocfcjnonf{ Rwr{no !BOR' {ac{ cllizr {an`fizlnkjn cb{i} {i ~ulick fi{ iflw {nq{ m~{ clri o~l{gonkgcbif{nf{& Cj}iunkgc clri u}itgknr ~rn}r cfk billcmi}c{i}rzg{a cf nq{nfrgtn {cj lgm}c}w, bcllnk Cj}i{cjr u}itgknk gfNfjlgra, Agfkg cfk D}nfba& [agr b}nc{nr c biooif onkg~odi} `fizlnkjn {}cfrdn} mn{znnf `fizlnkjn cb{i}r&Cj}iunkgc `fizlnkjn oiknlr c}n oir{lw bnf{n}nk ifrunbgdgb b}iur cfk bitn} c m}ick }cfjn id {iugbr lg`ng}}gjc{gif ulcf{ kgrncrn, n{b }nlc{nk {i {an b}iu& Cj}iunkgc`fizlnkjn oiknlr u}itgkn c }gba tibcm~lc}w id b}iu }nlc{nk{n}or& [agr cllizr bif{nf{ {i mn r{i}nk, b}nc{nk, nqbacfjnk,rac}nk cfk ~rnk mw `fizlnkjn cb{i}r& G{ clri nfcmlnrrnocf{gb rnc}ba id bif{nf{ ri b}nc{nk&
c&Cs~cLij&
Cs~cLij gr c If{ilijw Mcrnk S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfjrwr{no kntnliunk mw Liunx P=_& G{ rn}tnr cr c mnfbaoc}` rwr{no mcrnk if zagba zn biouc}n {an un}di}ocfbn id i~}
u}iuirnk if{ilijw mcrnk SC rwr{no& Anfbn zn ji gf{i}nlc{gtnlw oi}n nlcmi}c{n knrb}gu{gif id Cs~cLij&
S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj !SC' rwr{nor u}itgkn cfrzn}r {is~nr{gifr cr`nk gf fc{~}cl lcfj~cjn !FL'& Cl{ai~ja rgoglc} {i `nwzi}k/mcrnk Gfdi}oc{gif ]n{}gntcl !G]' rwr{nor gfd~fb{gifclg{w, {an lc{{n} }n{~}f c rn{ id kib~onf{r {ac{ ogja{bif{cgf gfdi}oc{gif }nlntcf{ {i c s~n}w& If {an i{an} acfkSC rwr{nor }n{~}f c rai}{ cfrzn} {i c s~nr{gif& If{ilijgnrid{nf bif{cgf cf i}jcfgxnk tibcm~lc}w {ac{ gr ~rnd~l gf~fkn}r{cfkgfj ~rn} s~nr{gifr cr`nk gf FL zagba gr id{nfb}g{gbcl {i kgjjgfj ~u {an }gja{ cfrzn}& If{ilijgnr bcf clri
mn ~rnk {i }nu}nrnf{ `fizlnkjn cr c `fizlnkjn mcrn d}iozagba r~g{cmln rai}{ cfrzn}r bcf mn }n{}gntnk& Ln{ ~r
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 32
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 29/223
nquli}n aiz Cs~cLij cfrzn}r s~nr{gifr gf fc{~}cllcfj~cjn&
Liunx P=_ kntnliunk c if{ilijw mcrnk s~nr{gif/cfrzn}gfj rwr{no, Cs~cLij {ac{ cfrzn}r s~nr{gifr cr`nkgf fc{~}cl lcfj~cjn ~rgfj c kiocgf/runbgdgb if{ilijw {ac{bcf mn ul~jjnk if{i {an rwr{no& [a}i~ja Cs~cLij, LiunxP=_ knoifr{}c{nk aiz cf if{ilijw mcrnk s~nr{gifcfrzn}gfj rwr{no bcf mn rnuc}c{nk d}io {an kiocgfif{ilijw {ac{ g{ ~rnr {i cfrzn} s~nr{gifr& [an if{ilijw“ul~jr/gf‟ {i {an Cs~cLij rwr{no Cs~cLij, gfbl~knr clnc}fgfj biouifnf{, zagba nfr~}nr {ac{ {an un}di}ocfbn id {an rwr{no gou}itnr itn} {gon, gf }nruifrn {i c uc}{gb~lc} kiocgf& @nw rwr{no biouifnf{r id Cs~cLij c}n !3'Lgfj~gr{gb S~n}w Blcrrgdgn}, !=' ]nlc{gifcl Rgoglc}g{wRn}tgbnr !]RR', cfk !2' Gfdn}nfbn nfjgfn&
[an Lgfj~gr{gb Biouifnf{ ~rnr {an Jnfn}clC}bag{nb{~}n di} [nq{ Nfjgfnn}gfj !JC[N' P>_ CUG cfki{an} }nri~}bnr {i ocu {an Fc{~}cl Lcfj~cjn !FL' gfu~{s~n}w {i c s~n}w {}guln{& Di} nqcouln {an s~n}w “Zai c}n{an }nrnc}ban}r gf {an rnocf{gb znm }nrnc}ba c}nc9‟ gr{}cfrlc{nk {i <un}rif)i}jcfgxc{gif, }nrnc}ban}r, rnocf{gbznm }nrnc}ba c}nc6&
]nlc{gifcl Rgoglc}g{w Rn}tgbnr !]RR' ~rnr Zi}kFn{, ckiocgf knunfknf{ lnqgbif, cfk rgoglc}g{w oc{bagfj {i{}cfrlc{n {an s~n}w {}guln{ d}io {an Lgfj~gr{gb Biouifnf{ {icf if{ilijw biouc{gmln {}guln{& Ri {an lgfj~gr{gb {}guln{<un}rif)i}jcfgxc{gif, }nrnc}ban}r, rnocf{gb znm }nrnc}bac}nc6 jn{r biftn}{nk {i {an if{ilijw {}guln{ <}nrnc}ban},acr/}nrnc}ba/gf{n}nr{, rnocf{gb/znm/c}nc6& [an kiocgfknunfknf{ lnqgbif gr c~{ioc{gbcllw ~ukc{nk {a}i~ja {an ~rnid c Lnc}fgfj Onbacfgro&
Ifn `nw dnc{~}n id ]RR zg{agf Cs~cLij gr {ac{ g{ grgf{n}cb{gtn gf }nriltgfj comgj~g{w& Zanf {an rwr{no gr~fr~}n id aiz {i }nriltn comgj~g{gnr mn{znnf lgfj~gr{gb{n}or i} }nlc{gifr gf cf nddi}{ {i gf{n}u}n{ c s~nr{gif g{ zgllcr` {an ~rn} {i }nriltn g{ ocf~cllw& [an}n gr cf gf/m~gl{lnc}fgfj onbacfgro {ac{ c~{ioc{gbcllw ~ukc{nr {an kiocgfknunfknf{ lnqgbif mcrnk if ~rn} dnnkmcb`& Blcrr Rgoglc}g{wRn}tgbnr gr c r~m/biouifnf{ zg{agf ]RR zagba ocurlgfj~gr{gb {n}or {i if{ilijw blcrrnr& U}iun} fconr c}nocuunk {i gfkgtgk~clr gf {an if{ilijw mw oncfr id {an ~rnid r{cfkc}k r{}gfj kgr{cfbn on{}gbr clji}g{aor& Gd {agrocuugfj dcglr c uc}{gcl ril~{gif gr goulnonf{nk di} cddg}oc{gtn)fnjc{gtn {wun id s~nr{gifr, zan}n zn oc`nrnfrn id s~nr{gifr gf zagba iflw ifn id {zi gfr{cfbnr gr
}nbijfgxnk&Rgfbn ~rn}r bcf cr` s~nr{gifr ~rgfj c lc}jn tibcm~lc}wid {n}or cfk gf{n}u}n{c{gif cfk cfrzn}gfj {ano gr lgog{nk {i{an runbgdgb kiocgf if{ilijw ~rnk, kgrb}nucfbgnr id{nfibb~} mn{znnf {an fc{~}cl lcfj~cjn s~nr{gifr cfk {an rn{ id {n}or gf {an if{ilijw& ]nri~}bnr r~ba cr Zi}kFn{, {ac{
u}itgkn rwfifwor cfk }nlc{nk zi}kr, bcf anlu oc`gfjrnfrn id ~f`fizf {n}or, zagba bi~lk mn kn{nb{nk gf {an`fizlnkjn mcrn& Aizntn}, gf ocfw bcrnr, {an ]RRbiouifnf{ dgfkr g{ kgddgb~l{ {i b}nc{n jnf~gfn if{i/{}gulnd}io {an s~n}w {}guln di}onk mw {an Lgfj~gr{gb Biouifnf{&Zanf {agr acuunfr {an lnc}fgfj onbacfgro m~gl{ gf{i {an]RR lnc}fr {an fnz {n}or nouliwnk mw {an ~rn} cfk
kgrcomgj~c{nr {ano gf i}kn} {i u}ik~bn cf ckns~c{nocuugfj id {an blcrrnr id {an if{ilijw&
Gfdn}nfbn Nfjgfn di}or {an dgfcl biouifnf{ id {anCs~cLij rwr{no& G{ oc`nr rnfrn id {an if{ilijw {}guln cfkkgjr {an cfrzn} i~{ id {an `fizlnkjn mcrn&
GGG& U]IUIRNK S^NR[GIF C FRZN]GFJ RWR[NO
c&Oi{gtc{gif
Zagln Cj~cLij gr zgknlw uiu~lc} if{ilijw mcrnkS~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj rwr{no, g{ gr ac}k {i bifdgj~}n& [anbifdgj~}c{gif id Cs~cLij jinr dc} mnwifk ul~jjgfj gf cIZL if{ilijw {i {an rwr{no& [an `fizlnkjn mcrn fnnkr {i
mn b}nc{nk gf ri {ac{ {an Gfdn}nfbn Nfjgfn bcf kgj i~{gfdi}oc{gif& G{ }ns~g}nr rgjfgdgbcf{ bifdgj~}c{gif c{ {anlgfj~gr{gb biouifnf{ lntnl, rgjfgdgbcf{ bacfjnr c{ {an ]RRlntnl n{b& Clri c knnu ~fkn}r{cfkgfj id Cs~cLij rwr{nori~}bn bikn gr }ns~g}nk {i oc`n Cs~cLij zi}` u}iun}lw&
I~} oi{gtc{gif di} b}nc{gfj c S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj rwr{nozcr {i b}nc{n c rwr{no {ac{ zi~lk }ns~g}n ~rn}r {i ul~j gf cif{ilijw zagba ack {i onn{ ifn rgouln runbgdgbc{gif& [anif{ilijw zi~lk mn c rnld bif{cgfgfj `fizlnkjn mcrn d}iozagba gfdi}oc{gif zi~lk mn }n{}gntnk& [an}n zi~lk mn fi}ns~g}nonf{ di} cktcfbnk lnqgbifr n{b& Cfw kgb{gifc}w id {n}or zi~lk mn b}nc{nk d}io {nq{ bif{nf{ bif{cgfnk zg{agf{an if{ilijw&
m&J}cuagbcl Fc{~}n id If{ilijgnr
I~} u}iuirnk S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj rwr{no gr knrgjfnkif {an u}nogrn {ac{ cll gfdi}oc{gif gr bif{cgfnk zg{agf {anif{ilijw& [an}n zi~lk mn iflw ifn rgouln runbgdgbc{gif di} b}nc{gfj {an if{ilijw& [an if{ilijw zi~lk fnnk {i mn
b}nc{nk ~rgfj IZL oc}`~u zg{a ncba kiocgf nf{g{woiknlnk cr cf if{ilijw blcrr i} gfkgtgk~cl {ac{ zi~lkbif{cgf cll }nlntcf{ gfdi}oc{gif r{i}nk cr cffi{c{gifbioonf{r kndgfnk zg{agf g{& [an ~rn} cr`r s~nr{gifrrnn`gfj gfdi}oc{gif }nlc{nk {i ifn i} oi}n kiocgf nf{g{gnri} r~m/nf{g{gnr {ac{ c}n oiknlnk ~rgfj blcrrnr, r~m/blcrrnr i} gfkgtgk~clr }nrunb{gtnlw cfk {an gfdi}oc{gif zagba {an ~rn} }ns~g}nr gr r{i}nk zg{agf {an blcrr i} gfkgtgk~cl oiknlgfj{an nf{g{w ng{an} cr c kc{c u}iun}{w i} cr cf cffi{c{gif& [an{cr` id {an s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no gr {an}ndi}n {zi dilk&[an dg}r{ gr {i gknf{gdw zagba kiocgf nf{g{w i} nf{g{gnr gr {ans~n}w }nlc{nk {i& [an rnbifk {cr` gr {i }n{}gntn {an fnbnrrc}wj}cf~lnr id gfdi}oc{gif di} {ac{ nf{g{w&
Ln{ ~r bifrgkn} {an if{ilijw cr c j}cua& Ln{ ~r rcw zn
actn cf if{ilijw I ? <B, U6& Ln{ B mn c rn{ id blcrrnr cfkgfkgtgk~clr id runbgdgb blcrrnr, U gr c rn{ id imhnb{ u}iun}{gnr{ac{ b}nc{n }nlc{gifragur mn{znnf blcrrnr, gfkgtgk~clr cfkblcrrnr/gfkgtgk~clr& Ri zn bcf kndgfn c f imhnb{ !blcrrnr cfkgfkgtgk~clr' rwr{no cr B ? pbg, g, 3≫ g≫ f& Ncba blcrr bg clri acr c rn{ id baglk blcrrnr i} gfkgtgk~clr Ba crribgc{nkzg{a g{, r~ba {ac{ |Ba|≮5& Ncba blcrr bg acr cf cffi{c{nk {nq{Cg c{{cbank {i g{& Zn bcf kndgfn U ? pUgh, g, h, bg, b h&
b&U}nuc}gfj Lii`~u [cmln
[an dg}r{ `nw {cr` gf s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj gr {i gknf{gdwzagba kiocgf nf{g{w i} nf{g{gnr {an ~rn} gr s~n}wgfj cmi~{&[agr gr kifn mw b}nc{gfj lii`~u {cmlnr crribgc{nk zg{a ncba
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 30/223
kiocgf nf{g{w i} blcrr& Clji}g{ao 3 kndgfnr {an u}ibnk~}n {ib}nc{n c lii`~u {cmln di} c runbgdgb blcrr& Fi{gbn {ac{ {an
u}ibnk~}n gr }nb~}rgtn& [an cffi{c{gif crribgc{nk zg{a {anblcrr bif{cgfr {nq{~cl gfdi}oc{gif& [an {nq{ bif{nf{ gr{i`nfgxnk gf{i zi}kr cfk f/j}cor& Zi}k {i`nfr c}nrb}nnfnk di} r{iu zi}kr cfk {an dgl{n}nk bif{nf{r c}n ckknk{i {an lii`~u {cmln crribgc{nk zg{a {an blcrr& Ncba baglk id {an blcrr i} gfkgtgk~cl gr {anf u}ibnrrnk {an rcon zcw cfk`nwzi}kr crribgc{nk c}n }n{~}fnk cr c lii`~u {cmln& [anbif{nf{r id {an lii`~u {cmln id ncba baglk c}n {anf on}jnkzg{a {an lii`~u {cmln id {an uc}nf{ blcrr i} gfkgtgk~cl&Clji}g{ao 3 bcf mn }nunc{nk di} ncba blcrr)gfkgtgk~cl gf {anrn{ B kndgfnk&
m&Clji}g{ao 38 B}nc{nLii`~u[cmln
Gfu~{8IZL Blcrr)Gfkgtgk~cl bf↕ lc}jnr{ f/j}co {i`nf {i mn b}nc{nk
I~{u~{8L↕ lii`~u {cmln crribgc{nk zg{a bL bifrgr{r id f/j}co {i`nfr&
Clji}g{ao8C ↕cffi{c{nk {nq{ gf b&Ba↕rn{ id cll baglk blcrrnr cfk gfkgtgk~cl&Kndgfn ` g gr c rn{ id cll g/j}co {i`nfr b}nc{nk mw{i`nfgxc{gif` 3↕{i`nfgxn!C, 3']noitn r{iu zi}kr d}io ` 3&ckk bif{nf{r id ` 3 {i Ldi} g ? = {i f
mnjgf` g↕{i`nfgxn!C, f'ckk bif{nf{r id ` g {i L
nfk liiudi} cll baglk}nf ba Ba
mnjgfLa↕B}nc{nLii`~u[cmln!ba, f'
L↕L La
nfk liiu}n{~}f L
b&S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj
Clji}g{ao = runbgdgnk mnliz knrb}gmnr {an cb{~cl u}ibnrr id s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj gf }nruifrn {i c s~n}w& Ncba~rn} s~n}w gr {}nc{nk cr c rns~nfbn id zi}kr& [agr rns~nfbnid zi}kr gr {i`nfgxnk gf{i zi}kr, cfk f/j}cor& [an rgxn id ncba f/j}co {i`nf tc}gnr d}io = {i f zan}n f gr {an f~omn} id zi}kr gf {an s~n}w& [a~r {an lc}jnr{ f j}co gr {an zailns~n}w& F/j}co {i`nfr c}n oc{bank {i lii`~u {cmlnr& Gd c F/j}co {i`nf oc{banr c lii`~u {cmln, cll F/j}cor cfk zi}krcrribgc{nk zg{a g{ c}n {a}izf i~{ id {an rn{& Cf crribgc{gifgr b}nc{nk zg{a {ac{ uc}{gb~lc} f/j}co cfk {an lii`~u {cmln&C{ {an nfk id {agr oc{bagfj, zn im{cgf c rn{ id lii`~u{cmlnr& Lii`~u {cmlnr c}n crribgc{nk zg{a blcrrnr& D}io {agrzn bcf crbn}{cgf zac{ blcrrnr i} kiocgf nf{g{gnr ogja{ mncrribgc{nk zg{a {an s~n}w& Di} {an rn{ id blcrrnr crribgc{nk
zg{a s~n}w, gd cfw blcrr gr c r~un}/blcrr cfi{an} blcrr {anr~un}/blcrr gr nlgogfc{nk cfk {an r~m/blcrr gr }n{cgfnk gf {anrn{& Dgfcl cfrzn} {i {an s~nr{gif gr im{cgfnk mw on}jgfj {ancffi{c{nk {nq{ crribgc{nk zg{a {an blcrrnr crribgc{nk zg{a{an s~n}w&
k&Clji}g{ao =8 S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj
Gfu~{8f/blcrr if{ilijw rwr{noRn{ id Lii`~u {cmlnr L ? p lg,3≫g≫f Rn{ id Lii`~u {cmlnr B ? p bg,3≫g≫f [ ? L Q B ? p{g` , LgL,B` BS~n}w S, rns~nfbn id zi}krpz3,․&,zo&
I~{u~{8Cf ↕ Cfrzn} R{}gfj {i s~n}w S
Clji}g{ao8o↕ f~omn} id zi}kr gf {an s~n}wSo ↕ rn{ id cll {i`nfr 3 {a}i~ja o/j}cordi} h ? 3 {i o
mnjgfS h↕ rn{ id h/j}co {i`nfrS h ? [i`nfgxn/Gf{i/O/J}cor!S'
So ? So S h&
nfk liiuKndgfn LS ↕ C rn{ id Lii`~u {cmlnrKndgfn BS ↕ C rn{ id crribgc{nk Blcrrnrdi} h ? o {i 3
mnjgf
S h↕ rn{ id h/j}co {i`nfrjn{ S h d}io So&di} ncba {i`nf ` gf S h
mnjgfoc{ba ` {i {i`nfr gf lii`~u {cmlnr gf L
gd !` oc{ba {i`nfr gf cfw lii`~u {cmln l` gf L'
ckk LS ? LS l` ,
ckk BS ? BS b` &
nfk liiudi} ncba ucg} !bg, b h' gf BS
mnjgfgd ! bg gr c r~m/blcrr id b h '
]noitn b h d}io BS&nfk liiudi} ncba bg gf BS
mnjgfjn{ Cg ↕ bg )) Cffi{c{nk {nq{ Cg
Cf ? Cf Cg
Nfk liiu
GT& S^NR[GIF C FRZN]GFJ G F CJ]GB^L[^]N
Gf {an u}ntgi~r rnb{gif zn actn knrb}gmnk c {ani}n{gbclS~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj rwr{no {ac{ ~rnr if{ilijgnr {i cfrzn} ~rn} s~nr{gifr& Gf {agr rnb{gif zn m~glk if {agr {ani}n{gbcldi~fkc{gif {i goulnonf{ i~} S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj rwr{nodi} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf& [an dg}r{ r{nu zcr {i ocf~cllw
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 31/223
g
g
g
m~glk kiocgfnq{ rnb{gif
di} {an cj}gb~goulnonf{c{gnlc{nk s~n}gn
c&M~glkgfj
C{ {an anan cj}i if{ilac{ zn m~glk
dib~r id {anbi{{if n{b&b~l{gtc{gif zg
an kiocgfb~l{gtc{gif&
I~} u}iui}cb{gbnr di}
gknf{gdw {an bb}nc{nk& [anblcrr gf {an iimhnb{ u}iun}
an fnq{ r{cb~l{gtc{gif cfncba b~l{gtcb~l{gtc{gif
}nuc}c{gif, !nnk, Unr{ cf
cfk r~m/r{cjnr{cjnr zi~lkagn}c}bagbcl d
}nuc}c{gifkgddn}nf{ cuu} r~m blcrrnr {iblcrr id lcfk
g{a ncba blc mnbion gfkgtgactn rion ~fid c b}iu& Gfk
agr ogja{ ogfkgtgk~cl ag}iun}{gnr r~b}iun}{gnr& Gka}i~ja imhnb
cfk tc}gi~r b^rgfj {agr
anc{, d}ioif{ilijw b}nc
cr {an b}iub~l{gtc{gifnlc{gifragu {nu}nrnf{nk mg{}c{nr, R~lu
KCU zn}n gknu}nrnf{nk gj}ifiogbU} gnlkU}nuc}c{gi}ocl[gllcj
if{ilijw di} n knrb}gmn {
l{~}n kiocgff id {an SC
r&
If{ilijgnr
}{ id {an c~{ijw& Lg`n Cjgr b}iu bnf{}gif{ilijw gran if{ilijw
{a zanc{ mngf mngfj oiknln
rnk if{ilijw}izgfj {an
iu di} zagba}iu mnbionrf{ilijw& Cllgnr {i {agr bljn zcr gknfk kndgfgfj bl{gif cb{gtg{wi~lk gftilt
=' Rnnkgfj, !2k Kgrncrn Bizi~lk actn mn biffnb{ncragif& Di} n
i~lk gftilticbanr {i [glc [glln}gfj bl}nuc}c{gif& G
rr id ng{an} b} gk~clr& C tn}wgs~n u}iun}{gngtgk~clr zi~l
c`n g{ u}~knf{n}c}bagbcllwa cr angja{,nf{gdwgfj cfk{ u}iun}{gnr {al{gtc{gif r{cjrgouln u}ibn mnr{ u}cb{gbnk gr raizf gZanc{& D}i
n gknf{gdgnk{an zanc{ b
w c }nb{cfjla~}Uairuac{nf{gdgnk cr Gfkg
Dgj~}n 3b{gbn blcif& Tc}gi~r
cfk Xn}iOg
{an cj}gb~l{~n u}ibnrr id fk {anf u}ibrwr{no {ac{ c
oc{nk cj}i/iunkgc Gfkgbb, zagba onc
runbgdgb b} zn m~glk g
j c{ {an bnf{k gr {an}ndi}
cr m~gl{ mcrn}iu zanc{&{an if{ilijw{an bnf{}cl n
i{an} blcrrnrcrr ng{an} kg} gdwgfj tc}gi
crrnr cfk r~m& [wugbcllw
!3' Cj}if' Dn}{glgxc{gif{}il, !4' Ac} blcrr crribg
k {i {ang} uqcouln Cj} n [glln}gfj&ln}gfj zagbarr zagba zinf{gdwgfj gfkgiu i} b~l{gtc{runbgdgb tc}gr cfk ogja{ mlk actn runbg{i oiknl {agrfkn} {an b} ngja{ n{b ognr{cmlgragfj
c{ lgf` ~u mn{n blcrr&r zn m~glk cfr im{cgfnk gDgj~}n 3& [{an tc}gi~
{an r{cjnlcrr& Gf Dgjn& Runbgdgb, Uairuac{nr,gtgk~clr cr iurgfj itcl ir zcr
{wunr id go~o[gllcjn
}n kiocgf& G m~glkgfj if{nk {i knrb}gm
frzn}r cj}gb
ktgri}w rwr{nP35_ {an if{
fr {ac{ {an bn u r~ba cr zr ifn di} n id {an if{ilgog{nk {i
k if cbbnu{nkan dg}r{ r{nu
oiknl fnnkr{g{w oiknlnk
cr }nlc{nk {a} b{lw id gfkg} r r{cjnr id blcrrnr mcrnr{cjnr gf
iogbr cfk, !;' G}}gjc{ginr{gfj& Ncba{nk zg{a g{& [}nf{ r{cjnr gfiogbr cfk[an}n zi~lzi~lk bion glk gf {~}f mn
gtgk~clr crribgif cb{gtg{wf{ id c b}iunbion gfkgtggb kc{c u}iunb}iu tc}gcf{
iu& Runbgdgba{ gknf{gdw crblcrr }nlc{gifnnf {an b}iu
cj}i/if{ilijf Jgll P33_&n bnf{}cl `nw
r r{cjnr id lcrrnr cfk}n 3 ncba blcn}{glgxn}r r~b^}nc, Ui{cra
uirnk {i blcrr hnb{r& Zg{agf
{an r~m/glln}gfj r~bzn}n gknf{gdg
{anlijwn {anl{~}n
o grlijwf{}clanc{,anc{
lijw&anc{
mnr{gr {ii mncr c
i~jab{lw&b}iuk ifb}iucfk, !>'
r{cjnanrnf cf
cfk mn
gf crr~m
gc{nki~lkgja{~clr
}{gnr&r cfkc{ckc{c
ragurblcrr
w di} [an
blcrranc{{ang} rr gra crcfk
nr gf{an
blcrrcr
k cr
` m
~r~rkIagr
bli
gfcf{} r{nfbnb} blbcbb{abcf
Ccrr{~rCcf
icb}
w r~mblcrrnrimrn}tnk lii
Dgj~}
I~} u}iuirgfj {an if{ilgfj IZL Pb~onf{ P33_
L Cffi{c{gjalw r{}~b{~}ncll j}cf~lnr
n&S~nr{gif
[an cj}i/ifcrrnr {ac{ z hnb{ u}iun}{gn
di}oc{gif crrrzn}gfj ~rn} {i }n{}gntn
}nk cr cf cf{g{w& Lii`gfjf{n} id {an iiu Zanc{ crcrrnr oiknlgfllnk {anrn b~frgr{r id cl{gtc{gif r{cjgn bnf{}cl blcrf{cgfr rionfi{c{gif u}iu
I~} S~nrlji}g{ao 3 !ribgc{nk zg{a}{~u, mndi}nn} s~n}w bilji}g{ao = !Rk }n{}gntn {an
T&
Gf {an u}ntg{ilijw mcrn}gb~l{~}n kiiu bnf{}gb if
id DgnlkU}nuc`gfj c{ Dgj~}n
n 38 U}iuirnk
k mnr{ u}cb{gjw knrgjf {ii3=_& [nq{~clzcr r{i}nk crif u}iun}{w&k {nq{ kib~od gfdi}oc{gif
frzn}gfj
{ilijw {ac{ zbiffnb{nk
r& Ncba blcrr
ibgc{nk zg{as~nr{gifr {i{an oir{ cu ufi{c{gif {i {ac{ {an if{ili
f{ilijgbcl j} cf nf{g{w& [aj tc}gi~r r{cl{gtc{gif r{cjgair{ id r~mgfj blcrrnr zr oiknlgfj
gfdi}oc{gifn}{gnr&
gif CfrznRnn Rnb{gifncba blcrr !
cfw s~n}gnr bnr gf{i {ann Rnb{gif ;'cuu}iu}gc{n c
& NQUN]GON
~r rnb{gif zk s~nr{gifcgf& Zn clrilijw di} {an
}c{gif& Rgoglc3&
anc{ Cj}i/If
bnr if{ilijwl U}i{çjç P32_
bif{nf{ id {an lntnl id
[a~r {an if{f{, zg{a ncbar{i}nk&
b}nc{nk bifrw oncfr id i~lk bif{cgf
an nf{g{w {an{an cj}i/cktg}iu}gc{n ugnbn blcrr oiknjw b}nc{nk gf ua gr {an blc}n gr fnq{ lcjnr gf zanc{fj blcrrnr& [blcrrnr bif
agba c}n gf {anc{ cr cf nr{i}nk mw
gfj rwr{no;' {i b}nc{i} nf{g{w oiion gf{i {anrwr{no, {an{i kgtn gf{i {rzn}&
F[R CFK ] NR
knrb}gmnk {acfrzn}gfj r
kgrb~rrnk {Zanc{ b}iu&
} r~mblcrrnr
{ilijw
zcr bifr{}~bcfk }nu}nrnf mnr{ u}cb{g
ncba blcrr crilijw b}nc{nblcrr bif{cgfg
gr{r id c rn}gnragn}c}bagnrj}cf~lnr id {
blcrr oiknlr&ri}w rwr{no,id gfdi}oc{g
lgfj {an }nlntDgj~}n 3, c{rr oiknlgfjn} id biffnbb~l{gtc{gif&
an rnbifk lcnb{nk zg{a}f biffnb{nk{g{w& Ncba blncfr id I
zi~lk culii`~u {cmnlnk' c{ rwr{rwr{no& Zanrwr{no nouln cffi{c{nk {
L[R
n b}nc{gif id wr{no di} n b}nc{gif iI~} if{ilij
cf
{nk{nkbnrcfc
gfj
id fknq{
Gfzngifcf{{an{an{nk
nn}
{an{i
crrL
lwlnrno
cwr
nq{
~} {and c
gr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 34
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 32/223
b}nc{nk d}io mnr{ u}cb{gbnr di} j}izgfj zanc{& Nc}lgn} znack kgrb~rrnk {an zi}`gfjr id c zgknlw uiu~lc} if{ilijw
mcrnk s~nr{gif cfrzn}gfj rwr{no Cs~cLij& Zn ack clrikgrb~rrnr {an Cj}iunkgc Gfkgbc u}ihnb{ cfk {an if{ilijw
mcrnk tibcm~lc}w {ac{ g{ b}nc{nr& Cj}iunkgc Gfkgbc acr cfif{ilijw di} {an b}iu Zanc{ zagba gr b}iu bnf{}gb& Zn actndi~} bcrnr id nqun}gonf{r& [anrn c}n i~{lgfnk gf {an fnq{rnb{gif&
c&Nqun}gonf{cl Bcrnr
[an}n c}n di~} bcrnr id nqun}gonf{r cr i~{lgfnk gf [cmln3& Gf {an dg}r{ bcrn id nqun}gonf{r zn ~rn {an c IZL/}nbifr{}~b{nk tn}rgif id {an Cj}iunkgc Zanc{ If{ilijwcfk {an Cs~cLij rwr{no bifdgj~}nk di} {an cj}gb~l{~}nkiocgf& Gf {an rnbifk bcrn zn ~rn {an }nbifr{}~b{nk Cj}i/Zanc{ If{ilijw zg{a i~} u}iuirnk J}cua Mcrnk SCrwr{no& Gf {an {ag}k bcrn zn ~rn i~} Zanc{ If{ilijw zg{a{an zg{a {an }nbifdgj~}nk Cs~cLij& Gf {an di~}{a bcrn zn~rn i~} Zanc{ If{ilijw zg{a i~} u}iuirnk J}cua McrnkSC rwr{no&
[CMLN G& NQUN]GONF[CL BCRNR
Bcrnr If{ilijw SC Rwr{no
Bcrn 3
]nbifr{}~b{nk
Cj}iunkgc
Zanc{If{ilijw
]nbifdgj~}nkCs~cLij
Bcrn =
]nbifr{}~b{nk
Cj}iunkgcZanc{
If{ilijw
U}iuirnk J}cua Mcrnk
SC Rwr{no
Bcrn 2 Zanc{ If{ilijw
]nbifdgj~}nk
Cs~cLij
Bcrn ; Zanc{ If{ilijw
U}iuirnk J}cua Mcrnk
SC Rwr{no
c&]nbifdgj~}nk Cs~cLij
Gf Rnb{gif = zn kgrb~rrnk {an zi}`gfj id Cs~cLij& [i}nbifdgj~}n Cs~cLij di} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgf zn fnnk {i
ul~j gf {an if{ilijw& Gf i~} bcrn zn ul~j gf {an]nbifr{}~b{nk Zanc{ If{ilijw d}io Cj}iunkgc i} {anZanc{ If{ilijw zn b}nc{n& [an di}on} gr }nbifr{}~b{nk gfIZL zg{a ntn}w blcrr i} fikn gf {an rwr{no actgfj }nlc{nk{nq{ gfdi}oc{gif }njc}kgfj mnr{ u}cb{gbnr& [i ul~j/gf {anif{ilijw zn oikgdw rn}tgbnYu}iun}{gnr&qol dgln& [i b}nc{nlgfj~gr{gb {~ulnr di} {an cj}gb~l{~}n kiocgfs~n}wYu}iun}{gnr&qol dgln fnnkr {i mn oikgdgnk& [an lnqgbif
di} {an lnc}fgfj onbacfgro cfk {an `fizlnkjn mcrn clri}ns~g}nk oikgdgbc{gif&
m&S~nr{gif Rn{
Di} i~} nqun}gonf{r zn im{cgf c rn{ id r{cfkc}ks~nr{gifr {ac{ c}n cr`nk mw ~rn}r cmi~{ zanc{& [an s~nr{gifrn{ bif{cgfnk >55 r{cfkc}k s~nr{gifr if {an b}iu zanc{&S~nr{gifr }cfjnk d}io Kgrncrn Ocfcjnonf{, G}}gjc{gif,Lcfk U}nuc}c{gif, Dn}{glgxn}r cfk F~{}gnf{ Ocfcjnonf{,Unr{ Ocfcjnonf{, Ac}tnr{gfj, Rnnkr, Rnnkgfj cfk RnnkTc}gn{w, Znnk Ocfcjnonf{& Ncba s~nr{gif zcr u}itgknkzg{a c bi}}nb{ cfrzn}& Zn ucrrnk {anrn s~nr{gifr gf{i {anrwr{no cfk }nbngtnk cf cfrzn} d}io {an rwr{no& [cmln =
raizr {an bc{nji}w id s~nr{gifr cfk crrgjfr c lcmnl {i ncbabc{nji}w&
b&Un}di}ocfbn On{}gb Zn oncr~}nk i~} rwr{no un}di}ocfbn if {an mcrgr id
r{cfkc}k Gfdi}oc{gif ]n{}gntcl !G]' oncr~}nr, u}nbgrgif cfk}nbcll cr kndgfnk gf ]cjactcf P3>_& U}nbgrgif gr {an d}cb{gifid }n{}gntnk cfrzn}r {ac{ zn}n bi}}nb{, zagln }nbcll}nu}nrnf{nk {an d}cb{gif id {gonr {an bi}}nb{ cfrzn} zcr
u}nrnf{ cfk }n{}gntnk cbb~}c{nlw&
d&]nr~l{r
[an u}nbgrgif cfk }nbcll }nr~l{r id i~} nqun}gonf{r zg{acll di~} bcrnr c}n {cm~lc{nk gf [cmln 2 cfk ; }nrunb{gtnlw&Blnc}lw {an }nr~l{r di} Bcrn ; c}n {an mnr{ gf {n}or id mi{actn}cjn u}nbgrgif cfk }nbcll& G{ bcf mn imrn}tnk {ac{ }nbclltcl~nr c}n jnfn}cllw agjan} {acf ctn}cjn u}nbgrgif gf cll
bcrnr& [agr oncfr {ac{ zanf {an cfrzn} gr u}nrnf{ gf {an`fizlnkjn mcrn {an rwr{no gr cmln {i ugb` ~u {an cfrzn} zg{a }ncrifcmln cbb~}cbw& Bi}}nb{ cfrzn}r zn}n u}itgknkzg{a lnrr cbb~}cbw gf cll bcrnr& Blnc}lw }nr~l{r di} bcrn = cfkbcrn ; c}n {an mnr{& [agr knoifr{}c{nk {an un}di}ocfbn id i~} SC rwr{no itn} {an Cs~cLij rwr{no& Cfclwxgfj {an}nr~l{r m}nc`gfj kizf {an bc{nji}w id s~nr{gifr, zn imrn}tn{ac{ {an }nr~l{r c}n uii}nr{ di} cfrzn}gfj s~nr{gifr ifAc}tnr{gfj !A'& ]nbcll cfk u}nbgrgif c}n mi{a lizn}& [agr gr
u}goc}glw mnbc~rn {an}n zcr lnrr `fizlnkjn gf {an`fizlnkjn mcrn gf {an {iugb id ac}tnr{gfj di} zanc{&Itn}cll i~} u}iuirnk if{ilijw !U}nbgrgif ? >=&75., ]nbcll? >4&11.' kgk rlgja{lw mn{{n} {acf {an Cj}iunkgc if{ilijwzanf ~rnk gf {an ng{an} SC rwr{no !U}nbgrgif ? >5&11.,]nbcll ? >=&13.'&
[CMLN GG& S^NR[GIF BC[NJI]W
S~nr{gif Bc{nji}w Rwomil
Kgrncrn Ocfcjnonf{ KO
G}}gjc{gif G]
Lcfk U}nuc}c{gif LU
Dn}{glgxn}r F~{}gnf{ Ocfcjnonf{ DFO
Unr{ Ocfcjnonf{ UO
Ac}tnr{gfj A
Rnnkr, Rnnkgfj cfk Rnnk Tc}gn{w RRT
Znnk Ocfcjnonf{ ZO
[CMLN GGG& U]NBGRGIF !.' ID S^NR[GIF C FRZN]GFJ DI] BCRNR
U}nbgrgif Bcrn 3 Bcrn = Bcrn 2 Bcrn ;
KO ;:&42 4;&=4 >5&3= 41&2>
G] ;>&;= 45&:4 ;:&1; 4>&=2
LU ;4&72 4=&7; ;7&=> 4:&34
DFO ;=&:1 >7&>4 ;;&7: 43&2=
UO ;3&=5 >;&12 ;2&12 >1&:>
A 22&:1 ;=&74 23&1: ;=&3=
RRT ;;&>= 43&21 ;;&=4 43&:2
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 33/223
ZO ;4&;2 >1&42 ;:&=2 4=&2>
[CMLN GT& ] NBCLL !.' ID S^NR[GIF C FRZN]GFJ DI] BCRNR
]nbcll Bcrn 3 Bcrn = Bcrn 2 Bcrn ;
KO >=&:2 4:&15 >;&2> :;&=2
G] >5&=3 4=&:> >2&14 41&:5
LU >5&;> 4>&45 >4&41 :3&1=
DFO ;>&7= >:&15 ;;&44 42&=7
UO ;2&;1 >4&54 ;>&53 43&21
A 2=&14 ;3&4; 2;&44 ;>&>7
RRT ;4&>5 45&7: ;7&>2 44&:>
ZO ;:&47 4=&>= >3&37 41&;>
[CMLN T& R^OOC]W ID ] NR^L[R
U}nbgrgif !.' ]nbcll!.'
Bcrn 3 ;2&>7 ;4&=2
Bcrn = >1&3: >7&27
Bcrn 2 ;;&7= ;1&:;
Bcrn ; 45&11 4>&52
TG& BIFBL^RGIF
Gf {agr ucun} zn actn kgrb~rrnk c {ani}n{gbcl rwr{no {ac{~rnk kiocgf if{ilijgnr {i ki kiocgf mcrnk s~nr{gif
cfrzn}gfj& Zn actn m~gl{ if {agr kgrb~rrgif {i b}nc{n cfcj}i/if{ilijw cfk cf cj}i/cktgri}w rwr{no {ac{ cfrzn}rs~nr{gifr if b~l{gtc{gif id {an b}iu zanc{ gf {an Gfkgcfbif{nq{& I~} if{ilijw gr m~glk ~rgfj mnr{ u}cb{gbnr di} zanc{ b~l{gtc{gif gf {an Gfkgcf bif{nq{& I~} rwr{no
un}di}or zg{a c agja lntnl id u}nbgrgif cfk }nbcll di} oir{bc{nji}gnr id s~nr{gifr zg{a }njc}kr {i zanc{ b~l{gtc{gif&I~} if{ilijw gr m~gl{ ocf~cllw cfk nfbcur~lc{nk mnr{
u}cb{gbnr `fizlnkjn& Zn biouc}n {an un}di}ocfbn id {anrwr{no {i {ac{ id Liunx‗r Cs~cLij rwr{no zanf {an lc{{n} gr bifdgj~}nk {i cfrzn} s~nr{gifr di} {an cj}gb~l{~}nkiocgf&
] NDN]NFBNR
P3_ M& Bacfk}crn`ac}cf, H& ]& Hirnuarif, T& ]& Mnfhcogfr& Zac{ C}n
If{ilijgnr cfk Zaw Ki Zn Fnnk [ano9& Gf GNNN Hi~}fcl id Gf{nllgjnf{ Rwr{nor, GNNN U}nrr, 3777&
P=_ T& Liunx, O& Ucrgf, cfk N& Oi{{c& Cs~cLij8 Cf If{ilijw/Ui}{cmln
S~nr{gif Cfrzn}gfj Rwr{no di} {an Rnocf{gb Znm, Gf =fkN~}iuncf Rnocf{gb Znm Bifdn}nfbn, An}c`lgif, B}n{n, =55>&
P2_ B& R& Lnn, X& Z& Hgcf, L& @& A~cfj& C D~xxw If{ilijw cfk G{r
Cuulgbc{gif {i Fnzr R~ooc}gxc{gif& Gf GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr if
Rwr{nor, Ocf, cfk Bwmn}fn{gbr, 2>!>', =55>&
P;_ K& B& Zgoclcr~}gwc, K& Ki~& Biouifnf{r di} Gfdi}oc{gif
Nq{}cb{gif8 If{ilijw/Mcrnk Gfdi}oc{gif Nq{}cb{i}r cfk Jnfn}gb
Ulc{di}or& Gf =5{a CBO Bifdn}nfbn if Gfdi}oc{gif cfk @fizlnkjnOcfcjnonf{, [i}if{i, If{c}gi, Bcfckc, =535&
P>_ A& B~ffgfjaco, K& Ocwfc}k, @& Mif{bantc, T& [cmlcf& JC[N8 C
D}conzi}` cfk J}cuagbcl Kntnliuonf{ Nftg}ifonf{ di} ]im~r{
FLU [iilr cfk Cuulgbc{gifr& Gf U}ibnnkgfjr id {an ;5{a
Cffgtn}rc}w Onn{gfj id {an Crribgc{gif di} Biou~{c{gifclLgfj~gr{gbr, Uaglcknluagc, =55=&
P4_ D& Z~, ]& Aiddocff cfk K& R& Znlk& Gfdi}oc{gif nq{}cb{gif d}io
Zg`gunkgc8 oitgfj kizf {an lifj {cgl& Gf U}ibnnkgfjr id 3;{a CBORGJ@KK Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if @fizlnkjn Kgrbitn}w cfk
Kc{c Ogfgfj, Lcr Tnjcr, FT, =551&
P:_ K& B& Zgoclcr~}gwc cfk K& Ki~& ^rgfj o~l{guln if{ilijgnr gf
gfdi}oc{gif nq{}cb{gif& Gf U}ibnnkgfjr id {an 31{a Gf{n}fc{gifcl
Bifdn}nfbn if Gfdi}oc{gif cfk @fizlnkjn Ocfcjnonf{, =557&
P1_ D& Z~ cfk K& Znlk& C~{ifioi~rlw rnocf{gdwgfj Zg`gunkgc& GfU}ibnnkgfjr id {an Rgq{nnf{a CBO Bifdn}nfbn if Gfdi}oc{gif cfk
@fizlnkjn Ocfcjnonf{, Lgrmic, Ui}{~jcl, =55:&
P7_ C& B& Lgcfj, M& Lc~rn}, O& Rgfg, H& @ngxn}, R& @c{x& D}io
CJ]ITIB {i {an Cj}gb~l{~}cl If{ilijw Rn}tgbn ) Bifbnu{ Rn}tn},
Cf IZL oiknl di} ocfcjgfj if{ilijgnr gf {an cj}gb~l{~}cl kiocgf&DCI U}nrr, =55;&
P35_ O& Rgfg, T& Wckct& M~glkgfj @fizlnkjn Oiknlr di} Cj}iunkgc
Gfkgbc / ]ns~g}nonf{r, J~gknlgfnr, R~jjnr{gifr& GG[ @cfu~} U}nrr,=557&
P33_ O& R& Jgll, A& R& Mchzc& Ucb`cjn id U}cb{gbnr di} B}iur id U~fhcm,U~fhcm Cj}gb~l{~}n ^fgtn}rg{w U}nrr, =535&
P3=_ Mnbaaidn}, R&, tcf Ac}onlnf, D&, Anfkln}, H&, Ai}}ib`r& G&,
ObJ~gffnrr, K& L&, Uc{nl/Rbafngkn},U& D&, R{ngf, L& C&,=557& IZLZnm If{ilijw Lcfj~cjn ]ndn}nfbn& Z2B Iflgfn U~mlgbc{gif&
P32_ H& A& Jnffc}g, O& C& O~rnf, ]& Z& Dn}jn}rif, Z& N& J}irri, O&B}~mçxw, A& N}g`rrif, F& D& Fiw, R& Z& [~& [an ntil~{gif id
U}i{çjç8 cf nftg}ifonf{ di} `fizlnkjn/mcrnk rwr{nor
kntnliuonf{& Gf Hi~}fcl Gf{n}fc{gifcl Hi~}fcl id A~ocf/Biou~{n} R{~kgnr, t&>1, 3, Cbcknogb U}nrr, =552&
P3;_ J& @lwfn, H& H& Bc}}ill& ]nri~}bn Knrb}gu{gif D}conzi}` !]KD'8Bifbnu{r cfk Cmr{}cb{ Rwf{cq& Z2B Iflgfn U~mlgbc{gif, =55;&
P3>_ T& T& ]cjactcf, J& R& H~fj, U& Millocff& C b}g{gbcl gftnr{gjc{gif id
}nbcll cfk u}nbgrgif cr oncr~}nr id }n{}gntcl rwr{no un}di}ocfbn& GfCBO [}cfrcb{gifr if Gfdi}oc{gif Rwr{nor, t:, uu&=5>/==7, 3717&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 31
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 34/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;==7)GRMFY5:41CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;==7
Bcf A~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif !ABG' m}gkjn {an Kgjg{cl Kgtgkn9C Bcrn id ‑C`cra‗ gf Gfkgc
Ragluc [}guc{agCrrgr{cf{ U}idnrri}, Knu{ id Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw,
R&R& Knoui Billnjn id Bioon}bn cfk Nbifiogbr,Cl{gfai, Jic&
Cmr{}cb{ / [an A~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif acr di} lifj
mnnf }njc}knk cr {ac{ ~fgs~n c}nc gf biou~{n}
cuulgbc{gifr zagba mlnfkr gfdi}oc{gif {nbafilijw zg{a
g{r a~ocf gf{n}dcbn, {an}nmw u}itgkgfj cf gfkgtgk~cl {an
ncrn id cbbnrr, ~rcmglg{w cfk i~{u~{& ABG {an}ndi}n fi{
iflw dib~rnr if {an {nbafgbcl kgonfrgif, m~{ clri
~fkn}rbi}nr {an goui}{cfbn id {an a~ocf nlnonf{ zagbagr {an `nw {i {an r~bbnrr id cfw {nbafilijw cfk g{r
cuulgbc{gif& Zagln oir{ id {an b~}}nf{ lg{n}c{~}n if ABG
dib~rnr if {an grr~nr if bacllnfjnr {ac{ nocfc{n d}io
‑cktcfbnk‗ ~rn}r, tn}w lg{{ln zi}` cr wn{ gr ntgknf{ zg{a
}njc}k {i {an ui{nf{gcl cfk bacllnfjnr di} ABG di} {an
uiu~lc{gif zagba gr if {an G[ oc}jgfr& [an u}nrnf{
ucun} {}gnr {i lii` c{ {an grr~nr cfk bacllnfjnr }nlc{gfj {i
{an ABG d}io {an u}gro id ‑Kgjg{cl Kgtgkn‗ cfk {}gnr {i
nquli}n zan{an} gffitc{gtn ABG clri acr {an ui{nf{gcl {i
}nk~bn {an ~rn} jcu mn{znnf {airn dnz !~}mcf' gf Gfkgc
zai actn cbbnrr {i {an lc{nr{ {nbafilijw cfk g{r
cuulgbc{gif cfk {airn zai c}n gf {an un}guan}w !}~}cl'
cfk ~rnr {an bcrn r{~kw id {an ‑C`cra [cmln{ UB‗ }nbnf{lwgf{}ik~bnk gf Gfkgc cr {an 2> + cfrzn} {i Gfkgc‗r tcr{
u}imlno id kgjg{cl kgtgkn& G{ {anf kndgfnr cfk nquli}nr {an
ocfgdnr{c{gifr id {an kgjg{cl kgtgkn gf c bi~f{}w lg`n
Gfkgc& [anf g{ mlnfkr {an {zi mw jgtgfj cf cbbi~f{ id {an
i}gjgf id {an ‑C`cra U}ij}co‗ g{r ui{nf{gcl cfk
lgog{c{gifr cfk r~jjnr{r rion zcwr id ckk}nrrgfj {an
ui{nf{gcl bifbn}fr&
@nwzi}kr /ABG, C`cra,kgjg{cl kgtgkn
G& GF[N]U]N[GFJ ABGA~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif gr ifn id {an
oir{ gf{n}nr{gfj crunb{ id Gfdi}oc{gifcl [nbafilijwcuulgbc{gif r{~kgnr {ac{ acr {zi biffnb{nk wn{ kgr{gfb{kgonfrgif id {an A~ocf/ biou~{n} gf{n}dcbn& Dg}r{, g{acr c kg}nb{ mnc}gfj if aiz zn cr a~ocf mngfjr }nlc{ncfk ckcu{ {i {an ntn} bioulnq c}}cw id {nbafilijgbclcktcfbnonf{ gf {an dgnlk id G[ cuulgbc{gifr& G{ nfcmlnr~r {i mnbion oi}n gffitc{gtn, nqun}gonf{gfj cfk‑{agf`gfj‗& M~{ {an}n gr c rnbifk ns~cllw goui}{cf{kgonfrgif/ {ac{ id {an {nbafilijw clri ckcu{gfj cfk
}ngftnf{gfj g{rnld {i r~g{ cfk onn{ a~ocf }ns~g}nonf{rcfk nqunb{c{gifr& [an r{c{n id }nrnc}ba cfk zi}` gf {ankiocgf id ABG {ikcw {an}ndi}n gr cf gf{n}nr{gfjgf{n}ogqnr id {anrn {zi biftn}jgfj {}nfkr&
[agr acr ack c rgjfgdgbcf{ mnc}gfj if }nrnc}ba}nlc{gfj {i ABG cr znll cfk c fnnk acr mnnf crrn}{nk {i
oitn mnwifk on}n {nbafilijgbcl kgonfrgifr id ABG{i {an a~ocf cfk uawrgbcl kgonfrgif cr znll &Cr}gja{lw uigf{nk i~{ gf ifn id {an gf{n}nr{gfj r{~kgnr}nlc{gfj {i ABG }nrnc}ba,
“]nrnc}ba gf A~ocf/Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif !ABG'acr mnnf runb{cb~lc}lw r~bbnrrd~l, cfk acrd~fkconf{cllw bacfjnk biou~{gfj& H~r{ ifn nqcoulngr {an ~mgs~g{i~r j}cuagbcl gf{n}dcbn ~rnk mw Ogb}irid{Zgfkizr 7>, zagba gr mcrnk if {an Ocbgf{ira, zagbagr mcrnk if zi}` c{ Qn}iq UC]B, zagba gf {~}f grmcrnk if nc}lw }nrnc}ba c{ {an R{cfdi}k ]nrnc}baLcmi}c{i}w !fiz R]G' cfk c{ {an Ocrrcba~rn{{rGfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw& Cfi{an} nqcouln gr {ac{tg}{~cllw cll rid{zc}n z}g{{nf {ikcw nouliwr ~rn}gf{n}dcbn {iil`g{r cfk gf{n}dcbn m~glkn}r, bifbnu{rzagba zn}n kntnliunk dg}r{ c{ ~fgtn}rg{gnr& Ntnf {anrunb{cb~lc} j}iz{a id {an Zi}lk/Zgkn Znm gr c kg}nb{}nr~l{ id ABG }nrnc}ba8 cuulwgfj awun}{nq{ {nbafilijw{i m}izrn}r cllizr ifn {i {}ctn}rn c lgf` cb}irr {anzi}lk zg{a c blgb` id {an oi~rn& Gf{n}dcbngou}itnonf{r oi}n {acf cfw{agfj nlrn acr {}gjjn}nk{agr nqulirgtn j}iz{a& D~}{an}oi}n, {an }nrnc}ba {ac{zgll lnck {i {an ~rn} gf{n}dcbnr di} {an biou~{n}r id {ioi}}iz gr acuunfgfj c{ ~fgtn}rg{gnr cfk c dnzbi}ui}c{n }nrnc}ba lcmr․․&&{an}n gr clri c fnnk {ikgrb~rr AB oi}n d}io urwbailijgbcl, n}jifiogb, cfka~ocf dcb{i}r cr znll&‟
GG& C]NCR ID ABG ]NRNC]BA CFK R[^KW
[an kiocgf id ABG }nrnc}ba acr nqucfknk cfk~fdilknk gf o~l{guln zcwr& Zagln {an gfg{gcl wnc}r id zi}` gf {an c}nc dib~rnk oi}n if {an mcrgb ~rn}{nbafgs~nr cfk cuulgbc{gifr r~ba cr {an Kg}nb{ocfgu~lc{gif id j}cuagb imhnb{r, oi~rn, zgfkizr n{b,itn} {an wnc}r, g{ nqucfknk {i gfbl~kn k}czgfju}ij}cor, ru}nckrann{r, biou~{n} cgknk knrgjf cfktgkni jconr n{b& [an oi}n }nbnf{ c}ncr actn gfbl~knktgknir, o~l{g/onkgc, znm/mcrnk cuulgbc{gifr,ui}{cmglg{w cll id zagba {c`nf {ijn{an} acr ack {an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 37
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 35/223
b~o~lc{gtn goucb{ id oc`gfj A~ocf biou~{n}gf{n}cb{gif fi{ iflw oi}n ‑gf{n}cb{gtn‗ m~{ clrikgtn}rgdgnk gf {n}or id g{r bif{nf{, cuulgbcmglg{w cfk
}ncba&[an ABG }nrnc}ba cfk gffitc{gif, zagln mngfjgfg{gc{nk cfk lnk mw {an bi}ui}c{n cfk }nrnc}babiomgfn id {an znr{, acr ack c tn}w goui}{cf{ mnc}gfjif g{r goulgbc{gifr di} {an kntnliugfj zi}lk cr znll&Kntnliugfj bi~f{}gnr, bac}cb{n}gxnk mw fcrbnf{ r{c{nid {ang} {nbafilijgbcl cfk }nrnc}ba gfr{g{~{gifr,kndgbgnf{ jitn}fcfbn cfk knlgtn}w onbacfgror cfk~fkn}/ns~guunk ‑a~ocf bcucmglg{w‗ 3 {i oc`n mnr{uirrgmln ~rn id {an {nbafilijw { ckk}nrr {an mcrgbkntnliuonf{ bifbn}fr/ c}n id{nf rnnf c{ {an }nbngtgfjnfk id G[ runb{}~o& Fntn}{anlnrr, di} {an kntnliugfjbi~f{}gnr di}ogfj {an ogkkln m}cb`n{ zagba c}n clrirnnf cr non}jgfj nbifiognr cfk ui{nf{gcl ~rn} cr znllcr ri~}bn id G[ ocfuizn}, ~rgfj ABG {i ckk}nrr {angrr~n id kgjg{cl kgtgkn mnbionr cf gf{n}nr{gfj c}nc id r{~kw cfk }nrnc}ba& [an uigf{ racll mn ckk}nrrnkd~}{an} cd{n} gknf{gdwgfj rion id {an b}g{gbclbac}cb{n}gr{gbr id {an kgjg{cl kgtgkn&
Kgjg{cl Kgtgkn8 Oncfgfj cfk Ocfgdnr{c{gifr[an {n}o kgjg{cl kgtgkn bc}}gnr o~l{guln
gf{n}u}n{c{gifr knunfkgfj d}io {an libc{gif cfk ~rcjn{an ~rn id Gfdi}oc{gif cfk Bioo~fgbc{gif[nbafilijgnr !GB[' gr mngfj }ndn}}nk {i& C{ c tn}wmcrgb lntnl, g{ }ndn}r {i {an “jcu mn{znnf gfkgtgk~clr,ai~rnailkr, m~rgfnrrnr cfk jnij}cuagb c}ncr c{kgddn}nf{ ribgi/nbifiogb lntnlr zg{a }njc}k mi{a {i
{ang} iuui}{~fg{gnr {i cbbnrr GB[ cfk {i {ang} ~rn id {anGf{n}fn{ di} c zgkn tc}gn{w id cb{gtg{gnr& G{ gfbl~knr {angomclcfbn mi{a gf uawrgbcl cbbnrr {i {nbafilijw cfk{an }nri~}bnr cfk r`gllr fnnknk {i nddnb{gtnlwuc}{gbguc{n cr c kgjg{cl bg{gxnf& @fizlnkjn kgtgkn}ndlnb{r {an cbbnrr id tc}gi~r ribgcl j}i~ugfjr {igfdi}oc{gif cfk `fizlnkjn, {wugbcllw jnfkn}, gfbion,}cbn, cfk mw libc{gif& [an {n}o jlimcl kgjg{cl kgtgkn}ndn}r {i kgddn}nfbnr gf cbbnrr mn{znnf bi~f{}gnr gf}njc}kr {i {an gf{n}fn{ cfk g{r oncfr id gfdi}oc{gifdliz‟&=
C bi~f{}w lg`n Gfkgc dgfkr g{rnld c{ c }c{an}uc}ckiqgbcl rg{~c{gif zg{a }njc}k {i {an Kgjg{cl kgtgkn&
Zagln if ifn acfk {an bi~f{}w gr aion {i ifn id {anoir{ r`gllnk ocrr id a~ocf }nri~}bn zanf g{ bionr {iG[ nqun}{grn, g{ clri gr oc}`nk mw cmwrocllw liz lntnlrid G&[ lg{n}c{n uiu~lc{gif cr biouc}nk {i g{r {i{cluiu~lc{gif cfk {an rg{~c{gif jn{r bioulgbc{nk d~}{an}cr {an itn}cll lg{n}cbw lntnlr c}n clri o~ba lnrr Gbiouc}grif {i zac{ c ui{nf{gcl G&[& R~un}uizn} o~r{actn& Mnrgknr g}}nrunb{gtn id {an ntn} j}izgfjrgjfgdgbcfbn id G[ nqui}{r gf Gfkgc‗r JKU, {an mcrgbgfd}cr{}~b{~}n di} G[ nqucfrgif cb}irr {an }~}clagf{n}lcfk }nocgfr c{ cmwrocllw kndgbgnf{ lntnlr& [anon{aikr cfk oncfr {i itn}bion {agr uc}ckiq{an}ndi}n actn {i mn dib~r if c f~omn} id dcb{i}r
mnc}gfj if a~ocf, ribgcl, cfk {nbafilijgbcl bcucbg{wnfacfbnonf{& [an}n actn gfknnk mnnf riononcfgfjd~l wn{ lgog{nk c{{nou{r mw mi{a {an r{c{n cfk
u}gtc{n rnb{i} cgonk c{ m}gkjgfj {an kgjg{cl kgtgkn mwckk}nrrgfj rion id {anrn c}ncr }nlc{gfj {i mi{a n/lg{n}cbw, jitn}fcfbn cfk gfd}cr{}~b{~}n &[anrn c}nr~ooc}gxnk cr dillizr8
n&BC]K U}ihnb{
[an Biou~{n} Cgknk Ckogfgr{}c{gif id ]njgr{}c{gif Knuc}{onf{ !BC]K' u}ihnb{ gfg{gc{nk mw{an jitn}fonf{ id Cfka}c U}cknra gll~r{}c{nr {annddnb{gtn ~rn id G[ {i gou}itn bg{gxnf‒jitn}fonf{gf{n}dcbn& ^fkn} {agr u}ihnb{, lcfk }njgr{}c{gif iddgbnr{a}i~ja i~{ Cfka}c U}cknra c}n fiz u}itgknk zg{abiou~{n}gxnk bi~f{n}r& Bg{gxnfr bcf fiz biouln{n}njgr{}c{gif di}oclg{gnr zg{ai~{ o~ba acrrln&
d& Ri~}`c}wcf cfk N‒Rntc Ifn u}ihnb{ id {an jitn}fonf{ id Cfka}c U}cknra
acr mnnf s~g{n uiu~lc} coifj {an uniuln& Ri~}`c}wcf,zagba gr fiz iun}c{gifcl gf {an ui}{ bg{w id Tgrc`acuc{fco, u}itgknr {an dcbglg{w di} c bg{gxnf {iucw u}iun}{w {cqnr iflgfn cfk clri tgnz kn{cglr id ulcfr cfk u}ihnb{r id {an jitn}fonf{ cfk libcl mikgnr&Rgoglc}lw {an N‒Rntc @nfk}cr gf {an Awk}cmck r{c{nbg{w gr cf gffitc{gtn nqun}gonf{ {izc}kr nlgogfc{gfjun}rifcl bif{cb{ mn{znnf bg{gxnf cfk {an m~}nc~b}cbw&An}n c bg{gxnf bcf ucw rclnr {cqnr, gfr~}cfbnu}nog~or, u}iun}{w {cqnr, lcfk {cqnr, n{b&Ckkg{gifcllw, {an jitn}fonf{ id Cfka}c U}cknra acrdi}o~lc{nk c u}ilifjnk r{}c{njw {i d~}{an} {an u}irunb{
id n‒jitn}fcfbn gf {an r{c{n& Gf c ochi} c{{nou{ {im}gfj }noi{n }~}cl c}ncr gf{i {an gfdi}oc{gif{nbafilijw dilk, {an dg}r{ “Bwmn} J}connf,‟ c }~}clm}ickmcfk tnf{~}n, zcr r{c}{nk& [agr u}ihnb{ acr mnnflc~fbank mw c fif‒jitn}fonf{cl i}jcfgrc{gif, “Rzc}fMac}c{ [}~r{,‟ mcrgbcllw {i rn{ ~u G[ biftn}jnfbn a~mrgf }~}cl c}ncr id {an bi~f{}w& Mw ac}fnrrgfj {an uizn}id }~}cl gf{n}fn{ m}ickmcfk {an “Bwmn} J}connf‟rnn`r {i u}itgkn c }cfjn id cuulgbc{gifr cfk rn}tgbnr {ir{go~lc{n {an }~}cl nbifiognr& [an rn}tgbnr u}itgknkgfbl~kn {nlnuaifw, {nlnonkgbgfn, kgr{cfbn lnc}fgfj, n‒ocgl, kgjg{cl nf{n}{cgfonf{, cfk knlgtn}w id jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr cfk gfdi}oc{gif&
&[an Maiiog U}ihnb{ id @c}fc{c`c r{c{n bitn}r 4&:ogllgif dc}on}r cfk ailkr ogllgifr id }nbi}kr id lcfkizfn}ragu& [an u}ihnb{ acr nc}fnk {an jiikzgll id ocfw uniuln cfk clri gf{n}fc{gifcl d~fkgfj cjnfbgnr&[agr u}ihnb{ acr }nk~bnk {an knlcwr gftiltnk gfgf{n}cb{gfj zg{a {an m~}nc~b}c{gb agn}c}baw id {an r{c{n}ntnf~n knuc}{onf{& Maiiog bnf{}nr c}n libc{nk cllitn} {an r{c{n& Cfw lcfk }nbi}k bcf mn }ntgnznk{a}i~ja c {i~ba rb}nnf c{ {anrn `gir`r0 {an u}ihnb{ bcfclri mn ~rnk cr c kc{cmcf` di} tc}gi~r u}ihnb{r id u~mlgb cfk u}gtc{n rnb{i} i}jcfgxc{gifr&
[an u}ihnb{ acr zif {an =55= Biooifzncl{aCrribgc{gif id U~mlgb Ckogfgr{}c{gif cfk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 36/223
Ocfcjnonf{ czc}k di} b}nc{gfj “rnld bif{nf{jitn}fcfbn cfk iunfgfj ~u fnz d}if{gn}r&‟ Mi{a {an^FKU cfk {an Zi}lk Mcf` actn lc~knk Maiiog di}
milk tgrgif cfk goulnonf{c{gif& Zg{a {an r~bbnrr id {an Maiiog u}ihnb{ i{an} r{c{nr id Gfkgc, tgx& [coglFcgk~, Ocac}cra{}c cfk Ockawc U}cknra actn r{c}{nkntiltgfj oiknlr mcrnk if Maiiog gf {ang} }nrunb{gtnr{c{nr&
m& [an Jwcfkii{ U}ihnb{ Jwcfkii{, zagba lg{n}cllw oncfr “@fizlnkjn
Onrrnfjn},‟ gr {an dg}r{ ntn} u}ihnb{ gf Gfkgc di} c }~}clgfdi}oc{gif fn{zi}` gf {an Kac} kgr{}gb{ id OckwcU}cknra zagba acr {an agjanr{ un}bnf{cjn id {}gmnr cfkknfrn di}nr{& Ntn}w tgllcjn acr c biou~{n} bnf{}n i}“riibafclcwcr‟ c{ u}iogfnf{ oc}`n{ ulcbnr i} ochi}}ickr& Uniuln bcf ncrglw lij gf cfk bioulcgf i} }ns~nr{gfdi}oc{gif if b}iur, di}nr{ dgnlkr, zc{n} }nri~}bnr,n{b& id {an kgr{}gb{& [znf{w‒ifn tgllcjn Ucfbacwc{r gf{an Kgr{}gb{ actn mnnf biffnb{nk zg{a biou~{n}r i}gfdi}oc{gif bnf{}nr0 rntn}cl u}gtc{n rnb{i} gfdi}oc{gifbnf{}nr bcllnk “Riibafclcwr‟ actn clri mnnf iunfnk&Ifn r~ba uiu~lc} bnf{}n gr gf “Ocfzc} Cj}gb~l{~}nOcfkg,‟ zan}n {an lc{nr{ b}iu u}gbnr c}n ocknctcglcmln {i {an dc}on}r& [an lcfk }nbi}kr id c dnz{narglr id kgr{}gb{ Kac} c}n clri ctcglcmln if {anrnbiou~{n}r& Clri, Gf{n}fn{ biffnb{gifr actn mnnfu}itgknk {i jn{ jlimcl gfdi}oc{gif mw lgf`gfj {i {anZi}lk Zgkn Znm&
[an jitn}fonf{ id Ockawc U}cknra gr c{{nou{gfj{i oc`n Jwcfkii{ U}ihnb{ c j}nc{ r~bbnrr mw
nq{nfkgfj g{ {i i{an} kgr{}gb{r& [an r{c{n gr gf {anu}ibnrr id r{c}{gfj :,155 G[ `gir`r zg{a {an anlu id {anu}gtc{n rnb{i}& [i {}cgf biooif uniuln {i mn biou~{n}lg{n}c{n, :,>55 “Hcf Rag`rac‟ u~mlgb gfr{}~b{gif bnf{}nractn clri mnnf gknf{gdgnk, cfk uilgbw gr mngfjdi}o~lc{nk {i m}gfj G[ {i {an biooif uniuln‗r fnnkcfk mnfndg{& Nddi}{r c}n clri mngfj ockn mw {anjitn}fonf{ {i gftiltn u~mlgb lgm}c}gnr gf {agr u}ihnb{&Gf dcb{, u~mlgb lgm}c}gnr bcf ulcw c tg{cl }iln gf oc`gfj{an u}ij}coon r~bbnrrd~l mw cb{gfj cr gfdi}oc{gifbnf{}nr !riibafclcwcr' di} {an Jwcfkii{ U}ihnb{& Di}{agr {i ibb~}, c U~mlgb Lgm}c}gnr cfk Gfdi}oc{gifBnf{n}r Cb{ fnnkr {i mn ucrrnk& Clri, r{}ifj zgll cfk
bioog{onf{ coifj {an u}idnrrgifclr cfk uilgbw‒oc`n}r c}n }ns~g}nk &
c&D]GNFKR U}ihnb{
[an Dcr{, ]nlgcmln, Gfr{cf{ Nddgbgnf{ Fn{zi}` di}Kgrm~}rnonf{ id Rn}tgbnr !D]GNFKR' U}ihnb{ acrmnnf lc~fbank mw {an r{c{n id @n}clc gf {an ri~{an}fuc}{ id {an bi~f{}w zg{a c tgnz {izc}k og{gjc{gfj {anac}kragu id bg{gxnfr ucwgfj {cqnr mw nlgogfc{gfjogkklnonf, knlcwr cfk lifj s~n~nr& Nrrnf{gcllw,D]GNFKR gr c bnf{}clgrnk billnb{gif bi~f{n} zagbacbbnu{r cloir{ cll {wunr id {cq cfk ~{glg{w ucwonf{r&[agr u}ihnb{ acr nqucfknk {i rn}tn 32 ogllgif uniuln
gf 3= kgr{}gb{r id @n}clc& [an mcrgb uagliriuaw id D]GNFKR gr {i {}nc{ bg{gxnfr cr tcl~nk b~r{ion}r&
Rgoglc}lw gf [cogl Fcgk~ r{c{n c u}gtc{n i~{dg{ “F
Li~jn‟ iddn}gfj liz bir{ {nln‒ril~{gifr acr zi}`nkzifkn}r gf Ock~}cg kgr{}gb{r mw ~rgfj {an libcl liiu{nbafilijw cfk oc`gfj ctcglcmln dgmn} iu{gb lgfnr}~ffgfj cb}irr {an kgr{}gb{, mw anlugfj u}gtc{nnf{}nu}nfn~}r }~f rn}tgbnr gfbl~kgfj {ac{ id n‒jitn}fcfbn&
m&Li`cog{}c)Roc}{ U}ihnb{Agocbacl U}cknra !AU', {an agll r{c{n id {an
bi~f{}w, acr gfg{gc{nk {an Li`cog{}c u}ihnb{ zg{a j}cf{rd}io FCMC]K {i u}itgkn {an jnfn}cl u~mlgb,nrunbgcllw {airn lgtgfj gf kgr{cf{ }~}cl c}ncr, ncrwcbbnrr {i jitn}fonf{ gfdi}oc{gif cfk dcbglg{gnr id n‒jitn}fcfbn {i {ang} kii} r{nur& Li`cog{}c“Riibafclcwc @nfk}cr‟ !gfdi}oc{gif bnf{}n‗r' actnmnnf rn{ ~u gf => ucfbacwc{ c}ncr }~f mw ~fnouliwnkwi~{a&
[anrn @nfk}cr u}itgkn b~}}nf{ gfdi}oc{gif}nlc{gfj {i {an kgr{}gb{ cfk jitn}fonf{ gfdi}oc{gif&[an jitn}fonf{ id AU acr clri kntnliunk G[ Tgrgif=535 gf billcmi}c{gif zg{a FCRRBIO !Fc{gifclCrribgc{gif id Rid{zc}n Bioucfgnr' {i biftn}{ {anagll r{c{n gf{i cf G[ knr{gfc{gif cfk clri oc`n Rgouln‒Oi}cl‒Cbbnrrgmln‒]nruifrgtn cfk [}cfruc}nf{!ROC][' Jitn}fonf{&2
Zagln {an cmitn bn}{cgflw c}n goui}{cf{ gfg{gc{gtnr{c`nf mw r{c{n cfk bnf{}cl jitn}fonf{r, {an}n r{gllfnnkr {i mn kifn c li{ oi}n mw zcw id itn}biogfj
mc}}gn}r {i kgjg{cl bitn}cjn cfk nqucfrgif cfk oir{goui}{cf{lw oc`gfj {an rcon }nlntcf{ di} Gfkgc‗ru}nrnf{ cfk d~{~}n kntnliuonf{cl fnnkr& Gf ifn id {anoir{ rgjfgdgbcf{ r{~kgnr if {an grr~n, {an dillizgfjactn mnnf gknf{gdgnk cr `nw mc}}gn}r {i m}gkjgfj {ankgjg{cl kgtgkn gf Gfkgc&
Gfd}cr{}~b{~}cl mc}}gn}rKnrug{n {an gfb}nkgmln j}iz{a id {an Gf{n}fn{ rgfbn
{an nc}lw 3775‗r, Gfkgc r{gll lcb`r c }im~r{{nlnbioo~fgbc{gif gfd}cr{}~b{~}n zg{a r~ddgbgnf{}nlgcmln mcfkzgk{a di} Gf{n}fn{ biffnb{gif& K~n {iagjan} bir{r {an fnbnrrc}w ~uj}ckgfj id ac}kzc}n cfkrid{zc}n gr kgddgb~l{0 anfbn, knrug{n {an }cugk ru}nck id
{an Gf{n}fn{ {an jcu gr j}izgfj zgkn} cr {an{nbafilijgbcl r{cfkc}k j}izr ntnf agjan}& Dcr{n}fn{zi}`r, agjan} lntnl ocbagfnr, oi}n bioulnqrid{zc}n cfk oi}n bcucmln u}idnrrgifclr c}n }ns~g}nk,m~{ gf ocfw fc{gifr gfbl~kgfj Gfkgc {an d~fkgfj gr fi{ctcglcmln {i r~uui}{ {anrn kntnliuonf{r&
Lgm}c}gnr cfk gfdi}oc{gif bnf{}nr, zg{a {ang}bioog{onf{ {i d}nnkio id cbbnrr {i gfdi}oc{gif cfku}ioi{gif id lgdn‒lifj lnc}fgfj gf Gfkgc, c}n wn{ {iactn c }im~r{ gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& U~mlgb lgm}c}gnr zagba bcfu}itgkn cbbnrr {i {an Gf{n}fn{ ki fi{ actn biou~{n}rcfk Gf{n}fn{ cbbnrr& Cl{ai~ja bwmn}‒bcdnr actn mnnf
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 37/223
gfb}ncrgfj, uii} uniuln bcffi{ cddi}k {i actn cbbnrrk~n {i agja bir{&
Lg{n}cbw cfk r`gll mc}}gn}r
Nk~bc{gif cfk gfdi}oc{gif lg{n}cbw zgll ulcw cfgoui}{cf{ }iln gf `nnugfj ribgn{w d}io d}cjonf{gfjgf{i gfdi}oc{gif actnr cfk actn‒fi{r& Gf {anun}runb{gtn id {an kgjg{cl kgtgkn, G[ lg{n}cbw gr tn}wgoui}{cf{ {i clliz cbbnrr {i kgjg{cl gfdi}oc{gif& Gf cbi~f{}w lg`n Gfkgc zan}n }i~jalw >5 un}bnf{ id uniulnki fi{ actn }nckgfj cfk z}g{gfj r`gllr di} d~fb{gifgfjgf ntn}wkcw lgdn, G[ lg{n}cbw gr i~{ id {an s~nr{gif&Jnfn}cllw, iflgfn bif{nf{ cfk gfdi}oc{gif actn mnnfknrgjfnk di} cf c~kgnfbn {ac{ }nckr c{ cf ctn}cjn i}cktcfbnk lg{n}cbw lntnl cfk {airn zai actnkgrb}n{gifc}w oifnw {i runfk&
Nk~bc{gif gf gfdi}oc{gif lg{n}cbw zgll ulcw cfgoui}{cf{ }iln gf `nnugfj {an ribgn{w d}io d}cjonf{gfjgf{i c uiu~lc{gif id gfdi}oc{gif actnr cfk actn‒fi{r&[an lcb` id r`gll gf ~rgfj biou~{n} cfkbioo~fgbc{gif {nbafilijw clri u}ntnf{r uniuln d}iocbbnrrgfj kgjg{cl gfdi}oc{gif&
j&Nbifiogb mc}}gn}r
Uii} cbbnrr {i biou~{n} cfk bioo~fgbc{gif{nbafilijw clri bc~rnr c kgjg{cl kgtgkn& Gf Gfkgc {ancmglg{w {i u~}bacrn i} }nf{ {an {iil di} cbbnrr {i kgjg{clgfdi}oc{gif gr lnrr coifj {an ocrrnr& [an lizn}gfbion j}i~u kinr fi{ actn kgrb}n{gifc}w oifnw {irunfk if bwmn}‒bcdnr i} {i jn{ Gf{n}fn{ biffnb{gtg{w if{ang} izf {i cbbnrr kgjg{cl gfdi}oc{gif&
a&Bif{nf{ mc}}gn}r
[an Gf{n}fn{ cllizr gkncr cfk gfdi}oc{gif {i mnrac}nk d}nnlw d}io bg{gxnf {i bg{gxnf jlimcllw& Gf ocfwzcwr {an r{}nfj{a id {an Gf{n}fn{ gr c d~fb{gif id {anf~omn} id uniuln cfk i}jcfgrc{gifr b}nc{gfj s~clg{wbif{nf{& Rgfbn fi nf{g{w bif{}ilr {an Gf{n}fn{, cfwifnzg{a Gf{n}fn{ cbbnrr acr {an ui{nf{gcl {i bif{}gm~{ngfdi}oc{gif& [an}ndi}n, {i riltn {an kgjg{cl kgtgkn,r{nur rai~lk mn {c`nf mw {an jitn}fonf{ {i nfr~}n {ac{cll bg{gxnfr c}n cmln {i }nbngtn kgtn}rn bif{nf{ }nlntcf{{i {ang} lgtnr cr znll cr {i u}ik~bn {ang} izf bif{nf{di} {ang} bioo~fg{gnr cfk di} {an Gf{n}fn{ c{ lc}jn&
g&Lcfj~cjn mc}}gn}r
Gfkgc gr c bi~f{}w actgfj c o~l{gb~l{~}cl cfk
o~l{glgfj~cl uiu~lc{gif& [ikcw c lc}jn un}bnf{cjn id gfdi}oc{gif bif{nf{ if {an Gf{n}fn{ gr gf Nfjlgra,zagba gr c mc}}gn} di} {an uniuln zairn u}goc}wlcfj~cjn gr fi{ Nfjlgra&;
h&‑C`cra‗ cr cf gffitc{i} gf m}gkjgfj kgjg{cl
kgtgkn9Zagln c f~omn} id {an cmitn onf{gifnk bifbn}fr
cfk bacllnfjnr }nocgf, [an Jitn}fonf{ id Gfkgc acrbion i~{ zg{a c ‑uc{a/m}nc`gfj‗ 2>+ [cmln{ UB fconkcr C`cra !r`w' nug{iogxgfj Gfkgc‗r dg}r{ milk di}cw gfoc`gfj biou~{n} cbbnrr , lg{n}cbw cfk ~rcjn cb}irrGfkgc‗r agf{n}lcfk& [an i}gjgfcl u}i{i{wun fconk
Rc`rac{ !Rcfr`}g{8 ऱशञशफ ॏ -Nomikgonf{-' zcr
~ftnglnk gf =557, u~}ui}{nk cr c -+35 lcu{iu-&C fnzu}i{i{wun, bir{gfj +2> cd{n} jitn}fonf{ r~mrgkw, zcr
~ftnglnk gf =535& [an kntgbn zcr di}ocllw lc~fbankif > Ib{imn} =533 cr Cc`cra, ockn mw {an ^@/mcrnkbioucfw Kc{cZgfk& Cc`cra zgll mn crrnomlnk c{Kc{cZgfk*r fnz u}ik~b{gif bnf{}n gf {an ri~{an}f bg{wid Awkn}cmck& Gfg{gcllw, {an kntgbn zgll mn rilk {i {anJitn}fonf{ id Gfkgc c{ +>5& G{ gr nqunb{nk {i mn rilkdi} +45 gf {an }n{cgl r{i}nr& > [an kntgbn acr mnnfkntnliunk cr uc}{ id {an Fc{gifcl Ogrrgif ifNk~bc{gif {a}i~ja Gfdi}oc{gif cfk Bioo~fgbc{gif[nbafilijw {ac{ cgor {i lgf` =>,555 billnjnr cfk ;55~fgtn}rg{gnr if {an r~mbif{gfnf{ gf cf n/lnc}fgfju}ij}co tgc cf nqgr{gfj Rc`rac{ ui}{cl&
Cr un} {an Jitn}fonf{ id Gfkgc‗r j~gknlgfnr, {an
dillizgfj runbgdgbc{gifr actn {i mn ckan}nk {i gf {anocf~dcb{~}gfj cfk knlgtn}w id r~ba kntgbnr8
-R~uui}{ di} tgkni znm bifdn}nfbgfj dcbglg{w0o~l{gonkgc bif{nf{ tgnzn} di} nqcouln &ukd, &kibq,&ikr, &cku, &kib, &qlr, &{q{, &hunj, &jgd, &mou, &ik{, &xgu,CTG, CB2, n{b&0 rnc}bacmln UKD }nckn}0 ~fxgu {iil {i~fxgu xgu dglnr0 uirrgmglg{w {i gfr{cll r~g{cmln dg}ozc}n~uj}cknr0 biou~{gfj cmglg{gnr r~ba cr Iunf Iddgbn,RbgLcm, b~ur !di} u}gf{gfj r~uui}{'0 onkgc ulcwn} cmln{i ulcw r{}nconk cfk r{i}nk onkgc dglnr0 Gf{n}fn{m}izrgfj, HctcRb}gu{, UKD ul~j/gf Hctc0 zg}nlnrrbioo~fgbc{gif di} c~kgi)tgkni G)I0 bli~k biou~{gfjiu{gif0 }noi{n kntgbn ocfcjnonf{ cmglg{w0 }nfkn}gfj
Wi~[~mn cfk i{an} iflgfn tgkni rn}tgbnr !iunf ri~}bnDlcra ulcwn}r, n&j&, jfcra i} rzdknb'&-I{an} u}ndn}cmln
Ulcwmcb`8 CTBAK
O~l{gonkgc G)I gf{n}dcbnr8 K[T, GU[t, K[A
Gf{n}fn{ m}izrgfj8 Dlcra ulcwn} !Ckimn'Runbgdgbc{gifr
I{an} u}ndn}cmln
AKOG ui}{Ac}kzc}n
:/gfba 155q;15 }nrgr{gtn {i~ba rb}nnf
]~jjnk bcrgfj zg{a c }~mmn}gxnk dnnl
Zg/Dg nfcmlnk !15=&33 c)m)j ZgDg'
Ogfg cfk d~ll ^RM ogfgRK bc}k rli{
R~mrb}gmn} Gknf{g{w Oik~ln !RGO bc}k' rli{
Tgkni i~{
Anckuaifn hcb`
=>4OM id ]CO
= JM id r{i}cjn onoi}w& 2= JM Nqucfkcmlnogb}iRK onoi}w bc}k&
= Zc{{r id uizn} bifr~ou{gif zg{a rilc}bac}jgfj iu{gif
244 OAx AK tgkni bi/u}ibnrri}
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ==
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 38/223
C~kgi i~{8 2&>oo hcb` ) C~kgi gf8 2&>oo hcb`
Kgrulcw cfk ]nril~{gif8 :‟ kgrulcw zg{a
155q;15 ugqnl }nril~{gifRid{zc}n
Cfk}igk =&= iun}c{gfj rwr{no
Kib~onf{ ]nfkn}gfj
R~uui}{nk Kib~onf{ di}oc{r8 KIB, KIBQ,UU[, UU[Q, QLR, QLRQ, IK[, IKU
Nk~bc{gifcl rid{zc}n kntnliunk c{ GfkgcfGfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw
Znm m}izrgfj, tgkni bifdn}nfbgfj cfk zi}ku}ibnrrgfj rid{zc}n
UKD tgnzn}, [nq{ nkg{i}
O~l{gonkgc cfk Gocjn Kgrulcw
Gocjn tgnzn} r~uui}{nk di}oc{r8 UFJ, HUJ,
MOU cfk JGD R~uui}{nk c~kgi di}oc{r8 OU2, CCB, CB2,
ZCT, ZOC
R~uui}{nk tgkni di}oc{r8 OUNJ=, OUNJ;,CTG, DLT
Bioo~fgbc{gif cfk Gf{n}fn{
Znm m}izrn} ‒ R{cfkc}kr Bioulgcfbn8qA[OL 3&3 bioulgcf{, HctcRb}gu{ 3&1 bioulgcf{
Rnuc}c{n cuulgbc{gif di} iflgfn Wi~[~mntgkni
Rcdn{w cfk i{an} r{cfkc}kr bioulgcfbn
BN bn}{gdgbc{gif ) ]iAR bn}{gdgbc{gif
3>5555 cuulgbc{gifr4
Zagln C`cra bn}{cgflw oc}`r c uc{a/m}nc`gfjkntnliuonf{ mw zcw id bifbnu{~clgxgfj cfkgoulnonf{gfj n/lg{n}cbw, jgtnf {an }nbi}k id Gfkgc‗rucr{ di}cwr gf G&[ lg{n}cbw cfk nqgr{gfj mi{{lnfnb`r, ifnfnnkr {i ki c bc}nd~l crrnrronf{ id {an u}ir cfk bifrmndi}n jgtgfj {an lc{nr{ gf{}ik~b{gif c {a~omr ~u# [an}ncrifr di} ctigkgfj u}noc{~}n cbbilcknr c}n crdillizr8
c&Zg/dg !kgr'cmglg{w/ [an {cmln{ UB ulc{di}o {imnbion ~rn} d}gnfklw cfk ~fgtn}rcllw cuulgbcmln fnnkrcf ~fgf{n}}~u{nk zg}n d}nn nftg}ifonf{ {a}i~ja zagba{an mcrgb cuulgbc{gifr cr znll cr ~rn} gf{n}dcbn/
o~l{gonkgc cuulgbc{gifr bcf oc`n c oncfgfjd~lgoucb{& Zg/dg biffnb{gtg{w cr g{ nqgr{ gf Gfkgc cuulgnron}nlw {i gfr{g{~{gifcl cfk u~mlgb rucbnr zan}n {an}n grcl}nckw c uc}cllnl oikn id biffnb{gtg{w gf rion di}oi} {an i{an} ctcglcmln& G r~ba bg}b~or{cfbnr, C`craocw c{ mnr{ mn c kntgrn zagba zi}`r mn{{n} gf c oi}nbiftnf{gifcl bcmln mcrnk zi}`gfj nftg}ifonf{ cfk{an}ndi}n ocw actn c lgog{nk }ncba&
m&R~uui}{gfj gfd}cr{}~b{~}n/ Zagln {an fn{ mcrnkzg/dg biffnb{gtg{w gr cf goui}{cf{ }ns~g}nonf{, ns~cllwgoui}{cf{ gr {an mcrgb gfd}cr{}~b{~}cl }ns~g}nonf{ mwzcw id }nj~lc} cfk ~fgf{n}}~u{nk uizn} r~uulw cfkmcb`~u zagba zi~lk mn nrrnf{gcl di} {an {cmln{ {i
}nocgf iun}c{gifcl cfk nddnb{gtn& Cjcgf zagln r~ba`gfk id uizn} mcb`~u dcbglg{gnr ocw mn oi}n }nckglwctcglcmln gf cdi}nonf{gifnk ~}mcf u~mlgb rucbnr, {ang}
cmglg{w {i r~r{cgf gf nftg}ifonf{r zan}n uizn}rai}{cjnr cfk uizn} cmrnfbnr c}n oi}n c fi}o {acfnqbnu{gif ocw rgoulw oc`n {an zailn gknc id oimglnbiou~{gfj }nk~fkcf{& Gfkgc fnnkr c ri~fk }~}cl uizn}gfd}cr{}~b{~}n cr znll {i oc`n C`cra lg`n nqun}gonf{rdncrgmln cb}irr {an o~ba fnnknk uib`n{r gf {anbi~f{}w&
b& Lg{n}cbw/mcrgb cfk nlnb{}ifgb/ Cr onf{gifnknc}lgn}, di} C`cra {i mnbion ntnf c d~fb{gifcllw tgcmlnulc{di}o gd fi{ c r~bbnrrd~llw }~ffgfj ifn, zn fnnk c{zgf u}ifj gf{n}tnf{gif c{ nfacfbgfj mi{a {an mcrgb crznll cr {an nlnb{}ifgb lg{n}cbw c{ {an u}goc}w cfk {anrnbifkc}w lntnl& Jgtnf {an }nlc{gtn un}di}ocfbn id Gfkgc‗r lg{n}cbw ogrrgifr, {agr ocw g{rnld cuunc} {i mn c{cll i}kn}, cfk ocw nfk ~u b}nc{gfj c rg{~c{gif zanf{an {cmln{ ocw fi{ actn cr ocfw {c`n}r cfkmnfndgbgc}gnr cr g{ zcr gf{nfknk {i mn&
k&[an Nbifiogb c}j~onf{ / Zagln {an cmitngfknnk c}n b}~bgcl dcb{i}r gf racugfj {an r~bbnrr i}i{an}zgrn id C`cra, {an }iln id nbifiogb dcb{i}rbcffi{ mn ~fkn}ogfnk& Dg}r{ gf c bi~f{}w zg{a cff~clun} bcug{c gfbion id ]r>;,>=: !cmi~{ +3,355', tn}wdnz ocw actn {an u}gtglnjn {i runfk +=55 if c dcfbwoimgln zg{a gf{n}fn{ dcbglg{gnr&: Rnbifklw, {an}n fnnkr{i mn c rgjfgdgbcf{ bc{baonf{ c}nc di} {an nbifiognr id rbcln c}j~onf{ {i zi}`8 goulwgfj cr {an knocfk di}{an ~rn}r id {an {cmln{ gfb}ncrnr, bir{r ocw
c~{ioc{gbcllw bion kizf {an}ndi}n oc`gfj {anuirrgmglg{w id nf{}w id mgj {nlnbio ulcwn}r oi}n}nclgr{gb& Jgtnf {an u}nrnf{ r{c{n id i~} {nlnbiobioucfgnr cfk {an jitn}fonf{ r`nu{gbgro }nlc{gfj {i{an runb{}~o gom}ijlgi, g{ gr r{gll {gon mndi}n c lnckgfjiun}c{i} zi~lk lg`n {i oc`n c mgj nf{}w gf {an rnb{i}&Lnd{ clifn, g{ zi~lk mn kgddgb~l{ di} {an jitn}fonf{ {ibc}}w {an C`cra di}zc}k if g{r izf& G{ ocw c{ mnr{b}nc{n c uilgbw, m~{ {an }ncl {a}~r{ zgll actn {i biond}io mcrgb gfd}cr{}~b{~}cl cfk ribgcl gf{n}tnf{gifr {ac{gfb}ncrn {an bc{baonf{ c}nc di} C`cra gf d~{~}n&
Bifbl~rgifZac{ ki {an cmitn c}j~onf{r goulw9 Gr C`cra {ii
~f}nclgr{gb c{ {an oionf{ {i mn rnnf cr c ucfcbnc di}Gfkgc‗r kgjg{cl kgtgkn9 Zgll g{ lnck {i j}nc{n} knnunfgfjid {an kgjg{cl kgtgkn {acf }nk~bgfj g{9
[an c~{ai}r zi~lk lg`n {i bif{nfk {an iuuirg{n&Zg{a c mcrgb gfd}cr{}~b{~}n gf ulcbn, C`cra gr gfknnk cjiik uigf{ {i mnjgf zg{a& Gfkgcfr itn} {an wnc}r actnu}itnk {anornltnr bcucmln id ckcu{gfj cfk bifdg}ogfj{i {an fnz {nbafilijw raizgfj c tn}w ~fgs~n mlnfk id {an {zi kgonfrgifcl ABG {ac{ zcr rui`nf id c{ {anmnjgffgfj id {an ucun}& Di} nqcouln, oimgln uaifn,zagba zcr bifrgkn}nk c l~q~}w {nf wnc}r mcb`, zg{a g{rlgog{nk bitn}cjn cfk cuulgbcmglg{w, gr {ikcw cfgoui}{cf{ oncfr id bioo~fgbc{gif cfk zi}` gf {an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 39/223
acfkr id ogllgifr id liz gfbion Gfkgcfr {ikcw& [anC`cra zg{a cf cuu}iu}gc{n ogq id r{c{n uilgbw cfku}gtc{n uc}{gbguc{gif gfknnk bcf ckk ifn oi}n
kgonfrgif {i {an un}nffgcl ckcu{cmglg{w {ac{ {an Gfkgcfacr raizf agornld {i mn bcucmln id& H~r{ {i jgtn cfnqcouln, c ~rn} id oimgln gf {an }~}cl agf{n}lcfk, zai{c`nr i}kn}r d}io c libcl cjnf{ di} acfkgb}cd{r {i mnraizf {i cf gf{n}nr{nk di}ngjf {i~}gr{, ocw kg}nb{lw mncmln {i j}cuagbcllw kgrulcw agr u}ik~b{ u}idgln {i {an~rn} libc{nk cm}ick, }nk~bgfj gf{n}onkgc}w cfkm}gfjgfj j}nc{n} cbb~}cbw cfk runbgclgxc{gif gf agrzi}` {an}nmw nfacfbgfj agr iun}c{gfj oc}jgfr mwtil~onr& Aizntn} {an }ncllw bacllnfjn racll }nocgf gfb}nc{gfj {an }gja{ `gfk id bifkg{gifr di} r~ba c }~}clc}{grcf {i cbs~g}n mcrgb n/lg{n}cbw cfk cf iun}c{gfjnftg}ifonf{ {i r~r{cgf agr cb{gtg{w c{ iu{go~o bir{r&Ifbn kifn, C`cra ocw mnbion ifn `nw gfr{}~onf{,m~{ fi{ {an iflw gfr{}~onf{ id m}gkjgfj {an nbifiogbcfk ribgcl kgjg{cl kgtgkn gf Gfkgc¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥3 A~ocf Bcucmglg{w gr knrb}gmnk cr {airn dcb~lg{gnr }nlc{nk {imcrgb nk~bc{gif, ancl{a, r{cfkc}k id lgtgfj zagba nfcmlnrA~ocf mngfjr {i oc`n ~rn id {an iuui}{~fg{gnr mngfjiunfnk mw r{c{n cfk nbifiogb }ndi}o& Di} d~}{an} kn{cglr rnnCoc}{wc Rnfcfk Hncf K}nxn 8 Gfkgc Nbifiogb Kntnliuonf{cfk Ribgcl Iuui}{~fg{w, Iqdi}k ^fgtn}rg{w U}nrr, FnzKnlag, 3774
= Zg`nunkgc a{{u8))nf&zg`nunkgc&i}j)Kgjg{clYkgtgkn
2 Ckcu{nk d}io Fnnfc Rgfja, M}gkjgfj {an Kgjg{cl Kgtgkn gf
Gfkgc8 Rion Bacllnfjnr cfk Iuui}{~fg{gnr
a{{u8))zzz&zi}lgm&i}j)til3:fi3)rgfjaYt3:f3&ra{ol
; Fnnfc Rgfja, M}gkjgfj {an Kgjg{cl Kgtgkn gf Gfkgc8 Rion
Bacllnfjnr cfk Iuui}{~fg{gnr
a{{u8))zzz&zi}lgm&i}j)til3:fi3)rgfjaYt3:f3&ra{ol
> Zg`nunkgc, a{{u8))nf&zg`gunkgc&i}j)C`craY{cmln{
4 Ri~}bn 8 Zg`gunkgc
: Hconr Dif{cfnllc/@acf, a{{u8))mlijr&d{&bio)mnwifk/m}gbr)=533)35)54)gfkgcr/kgjg{cl/}ntil~{gif/fnnkr/oi}n/{acf/
cc`cra)"gqxx3cNm2iM>f¥
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 40/223
U}ib& id {
Til~on 3& B
GRMF8 7:1/
J]GK
Cmr{}cb{ [
}ndn}r {i nf
o~l{guln kizf
~u i} rlizr ki
d {an nf{g}n
n}gi~r u}imln
Ri z
gf {agr ucun}
}iuirnk J}gMw ~rgfj i~}
tn}w dcr{ knu
an J}gk& Zn
agr u~}uirn&
lim~r C}bag
~}}nf{lw ~rn
actn u}iuirn
zn bifrgkn} c
}cb{gbcllw g
qun}gnfbn {a
izflickgfj
J}gk bio
rgouln wn{ l
iou~{n} i
an{n}ijnfni~
}nri~}bnr& C
r{i}cjn, cfclw
runb{}ion{n},
}nri~}bn& [an
tg}{~cl rnfrn
rac}gfj cfk b
an Gf{l& Bifd&
uw}gja{ § =5
3/7=5>:>/:/
CBO "8 kmn
IOU^
kcw zn c}n gf
hiw dcr{ cbbn
lickgfj, {an}n
zf {an un}di}
}ibnrr d}io {
or {ac{ fnnk
n actn {c`nf {
n c}n u}itgkg
Oiknl {ac{}gk zn bcf nc
fkgfj if {an
actn ~rnk {an
[an J}gk di}
{nb{~}n, zagba
zi}lkzgkn d
cf clji}g{ao
c ml~nu}gf{ d
ulnonf{nk, i
r{}nc` id lgj
~l{guln dglnr&
G& G
~{gfj gr cll
c}jn cfk ui
{ id c lc
rwr{nor ra
*}nri~}bn* o
rgr)tgr~clgxc{g
{nlnrbiun cf
J}gk cgor {i
// cllizgfj
llcmi}c{gif&
if Biou~{n}
3= [nbafi Di
88 kig8 35& :
}&gon}c&35& :
GFJ / A
{an Gf{n}fn{
r {i {an Gf{
gr c bacfbn {a
cfbn {ac{ lnc
an mnjgffgfj&
{an c{{nf{gif
agr u}imlno di
j c lcwi~{ di
cf cbbnrr {anglw kizflick
f~omn} id rw
bifbnu{ id J
~lc{nk mw ~r
gr {an iflw
} kntnliugfj
di} lcwgfj i~
} d~}{an} gou
~} J}gk u}i
a{nfgfj itn}
GF[]IK^B
mi~{ {i b}nc{
zn}d~l rnld
jn billnb{gi
c}gfj tc}gi~r
cw mn biou
if {iilr, rbgn
k ri if' i}
m}gfj cll {an
lc}jn i} ro
Cuulgbc{gifr
}~o J}i~u, G
315 )GRMFY5
315
JA LN
]RR
@clctc
i}lk cfk ntn
n}fn{& M~{ k
{ {an rwr{no a
kr {i {an }nr{c
[agr gr ifn i
id {an }nrnc}b
} i~} }nrnc}b
goulnonf{gf
Gf{n}fn{ tn}wcfw f~omn} i
r{nor nouliw
}gk Biou~{gf
~rnr {an r{cf
J}gk C}bag{n
{an J}gk& Cf
} J}gk Oiknl
lnonf{c{gif&
tgknr {an ~r
{an Gf{n}fn{
GIF
n {an gll~rgif
ocfcjgfj tg
f id biff
biomgfc{gif
{gfj uizn},
f{gdgb ac}kzc
cfw i{an} }n
rn {ijn{an} //
cll rbcln }nr
kgc&
:41
NL BI
CBGLG
gfnra, B&ChBillnjn id N
`co,Banffcg
wifn
n {i
cfjr
}{gfj
d {an
an}r&
cfk
i~}
dcr{&dglnr
k gf
j di}
kc}k
{~}n
k zn
{ac{
anf
} {i
agln
id c
}{~cl
b{nk
r id
kc{c
}n !c
i{n
gf c
~}bn
a
~
ct
n
z
z
gf
cf
{a
z
tg
gf
!u
f}n
a
t
{a
{n
i}
tg
ul
i
nf
{}
U^[GF
W
g{ Fc{c}chfjgfnn}gfj,
g,Gfkgc/452 33
[an r{cfk
{n}ijnfni~r
gdi}og{w di
cglcmglg{w id
~cllw lc}jn nt
Gf c f~{ranl
cr{nk BU^ bw
agba bcf bio
GG&
J}gk biou~
kgtgk~clr& [a
clijw {i uiz
}i~ja zcll r
an}n i} aiz {
nz id j}gk bi
kgtgk~cl ~rn
}ibnrri}r, r{
nknk zg{a lri~}bnr c}n li
}kzc}n, iun}
J}gk biou~
}gi~r {nbafil
n bif{nq{
afilijgnr {
jcfgxc{gifcl
}{~clgxc{gif
c{di}or, cfk
lw cbagntcml
tg}ifonf{ {
fruc}nf{lw c
[I CB
5
}kgxc{gif i
wr{nor b}nc{
rac}gfj
agjan} mcfk
il~{gifc}w r{
l {an j}gk bi
blnr gf {an fn
n{n zg{a r~un
JNFNRGR
{gfj bcf onc
n j}cfk tgrg
} j}gkr zan}
ib`n{r zg{a
an nlnb{}gbg{w
u~{gfj, bio
r jcgf cbb
}cjn, kc{c,
g{{ln i} fibc{nk i} zac
{gfj rwr{no&
{gfj bcf mn
ijgnr cfk ril
d kgr{}gm~{n
c{ c}n ntil
uulgbc{gif cf
tg}{~clgxc{
}jcfgxc{gifr&
{a}i~ja {a
c{ u}itgknr
bbnrr }nri~}
NRR GF
bioo~fgb
k {an Gf{n}fn
nri~}bnr, cl
gk{a, c}n k}g
u gf j}gk bio
u~{gfj gr cll
{zi}` cr ifn
}biou~{n} ru
ID J]GK BI
f kgddn}nf{ {a
if gr id{nf
~rn}r jn{ cbb
fi bc}n i} b
gr cb{~cllw j
u~{gfj mnbio
rr {i biou
cuulgbc{gifr,
`fizlnkjn{ {an ~fkn}lwg
rnnf cr c uc{
~{gifr& G{r `n
k biou~{gf
tgfj gf r~
k }nri~}bn ra
gif cb}irr
[agr `gfk id
~rn id iun
{an cmglg{w
nr cb}irr c
N]FN[
c{gifr mn{z
{ nqulirgif&
ifj zg{a
tgfj c uirrg
u~{gfj&
cmi~{ ~rgfj
tg}{~cl ocbag
nk&
OU^[GFJ
gfjr {i kgddn}
}nrnf{nk cr
nrr {i nlnb{}gb
ifrgkn}c{gif
nfn}c{nk& Gf {
nr un}tcrgtn
~{gfj }nri~}
cfk ri if'
d zan}n {afj {nbafilijg
a id gf{nj}c{g
w tcl~nr c}n
gfd}cr{}~b{
ui}{ id b}i
c}gfj gf c zi
{nbafilijg
tg}{~clgxc{gi
r{cfkc}kr&
{i rac}n
kgr{}gm~{nk
nf
an
{an
lw
{an
fn,
nf{
cf
g{w
di}
agr
fk
nr
cr
rnnr,
gfj
if
~}n
rr/
}k,
nr,
gr
Cf
fk
fk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 41/223
g
l
g
an{n}ijnfni~
{nbafilijw {
{nbafilijgnr
rnb~}g{w, cbbiou~{gfj bc
n cmln {i gk
gfdi}ogfj oc
[an J}gk
cwn} gr kndgf
gfknunfknf{lw
znll/i}jcfgxn
c&Dcm}gb8
Dcm}gb gr {
i}ocl bio}nu}nrnf{r li
}nu}nrnf{r li
n{zi}`gfj c
m& Biffnb
Biffnb{gt
gcf{ fikn id
iffnb{gifr
r~ba cr Gf{
}i{ibilr !K
nftg}ifo
i tg}{~clgxn
cfk r{cfkc}k
~f{gfj, rwr{f bion gf{i u
nf{gdw goui}{
fcjnonf{ id {
GGG& J]G
c}bag{nb{~}n a
nk gf {ang}, i
& If gf{nj}c
k j}gk oiknl&
an liznr{ lcw
~{n} c}bag{nbgb jc{nr, {an
bcl biou~{gf
k biou~{c{gi
{gtg{w8
g{w lcwn} bif
“dcm}gb‟& Bi
fk gr gouln
n}fn{ u}i{ib
R', n{b&
f{ fi{ if
bn}{cgf }nr
r gf {an c}n
nor ocfcjnlcw an}n {ii&
cf{ {}nfkr {a
airn {ac{ }ns~
I]CFGXC
cr c lcwn}nk
zf mnactgi}
{gif g{ zi}`r
} gf j}gk c}ba
{~}n zan}ncm}gb gr cf c
j }nri~}bnr
fcl }nri~}bnr&
fnb{r rntn}cl
fnb{gtg{w lcw
nf{nk ~rgfj
l ![BU)GU'
lw }ns~g}nr
~}bnr, m~{
cr id rbank~
onf{& C~{ifTc}gi~r {iilr
i~jai~{ {an
g}n c{{nf{gif&
GIF8
uu}icba cfk
l ocffn} {i
cr ifn bio
g{nb{~}n& ^flg
{an liznr{ lr{}cb{ lcwn} z
r~ba cr r{i
dcm}gbr gf{i
} u}itgknr r
fn{zi}` u}i{
cfk cuulgb
{an
clri
lgfj,
ogbocw
j}gk,
ncba
i}`
uln{n
n gf
cwn}agba
}cjn,
ifn
b~}n
bilr
c{gif
bi
u}
li
f
cf
c
kg
rn
c}
k
z
m
c&]nri~}bn8]nri~}bn l
ffnb{gtg{w lc
i{ibilr ~rnk
ck cfk ~rcj
ji{gc{n {an u
k iun}c{gifr&
m& Billnb{gt
Billnb{gtn l
ifj rntn}cl
}nb{i}w rn}tg
}tgbnr, cfk rb
b& Cuulgbc{g
Cuulgbc{gif
bag{nb{~}n& [
rg}nk cb{gifr&
c}n zi}`gfj
[an {a}nn u
liz8
cwn} knclr
wn}r& ]nri~}
{i im{cgf gfd
uilgbgnr, cf
ilgbgnr di} a
8
wn} bifrgr{ i
kgddn}nf{ }n
bnr, cbbi~f
ank~lgfj rn}tg
f8
lcwn} gr {an ag
agr lcwn} bc
Cuulgbc{gif
zg{a {i riltn
GT& J
}goc}w {wunr
g{a ocfcjn
n lcwn} bcf
}oc{gif cmi
k ocfcjnon
cfklgfj }nri~
d {an u}i{ibil
ri~}bnr& [agr
{gfj ucwonf
gbnr {i fcon
gjanr{ lcwn} gf
llr i{an} lcw
lcwn} gr rgo
i~} u}imlnor
GK‗R $ [WU
id j}gkr cfk
onf{ id o
mn gfdi}oc{g
{ bifdgj~}c{g
f{ u}i{ibil {
}bn }ns~g}no
r id gf{n}cb{g
lcwn} gfbl~
{, billcmi}c{g
dnz&
j}gk biou~{g
n}r {i un}di
lw {an u}ij}
&
R8
c}n r~ooc}g
fw
gif
f,
ac{
nf{
fr
nr
gif
gfj
}o
co
nk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 42/223
c&Biou~{c{gifcl j}gk
C biou~{c{gifcl j}gk gr dib~rnk if rn{{gfj crgkn
}nri~}bnr runbgdgbcllw di} biou~{gfj uizn}& Gf {agr {wun id
j}gk, oir{ id {an ocbagfnr c}n agja/un}di}ocfbn rn}tn}r&
m&Rbctnfjgfj j}gk
C rbctnfjgfj j}gk gr oir{ biooiflw ~rnk zg{a lc}jn
f~omn}r id knr`{iu ocbagfnr& Ocbagfnr c}n rbctnfjnk di}
ctcglcmln BU^ bwblnr cfk i{an} }nri~}bnr& Izfn}r id {an
knr`{iu ocbagfnr c}n ~r~cllw jgtnf bif{}il itn} zanf {ang}
}nri~}bnr c}n ctcglcmln {i uc}{gbguc{n gf {an j}gk&
b&Kc{c j}gk
C kc{c j}gk gr }nruifrgmln di} ai~rgfj cfk u}itgkgfj
cbbnrr {i kc{c cb}irr o~l{guln i}jcfgxc{gifr& ^rn}r c}n fi{
bifbn}fnk zg{a zan}n {agr kc{c gr libc{nk cr lifj cr {anw
actn cbbnrr {i {an kc{c&
&J]GK OIKNL U]IUIRNK8
Zn c}n ~rgfj {an Rbctnfjgfj J}gk di} i~}
goulnonf{c{gif cr lc}jn f~omn}r id knr`{iu ocbagfnr c}n
~rnk gf i~} J}gk cfk lc{n} ulcffgfj {i nq{nfk g{ mw ~rgfj
mi{a Rbctnfjgfj cfk kc{c J}gk& Dgj~}n= jgtnr cf gknc
cmi~{ {an J}gk {ac{ zn actn u}iuirnk&
n&U]IMLNOR K^N [I O^L[GULN
KIZFLICKGFJ8
Zagln cbbnrrgfj Gf{n}fn{ oir{ id ~r ogja{ actn dcbnk
{an m~}knf id o~l{guln kizflickgfj cfk gf uc}{gb~lc} zg{a
kizflickgfj a~jn dglnr g&n&, {an}n bcf mn c {i{cl cm}~u{
rwr{no dcgl~}n zagln c anctw {cr` gr crrgjfnk {i {an rwr{no&
[an rwr{no ocw acfj ~u cfk ocw mn }nmii{nk zagln rion
un}bnf{cjn id kizflickgfj ogja{ actn mnnf biouln{nk&
[agr }nmii{gfj id {an rwr{no lnckr {i kizflick id {an dgln
ifbn cjcgf d}io {an mnjgffgfj, zagba gr ifn id {an ochi}
u}imlnor ntn}wifn gr dcbgfj {ikcw&
Ln{ ~r bifrgkn} F f~omn}r id dglnr id kgddn}nf{
rgxnr !gf i}kn} id rntn}cl OMr' c}n mngfj kizflicknk if c
rgfjln rwr{no !c UB'& [agr zgll {c`n cuu}iqgoc{nlw rion
ogf~{nr i} ntnf rion ai~}r {i kizflick g{ mw ~rgfj cf
Gf{n}fn{ biffnb{gif id fi}ocl runnk zg{a c rgfjln BU^&
[agr gr ifn id {an {nkgi~r {cr`r di} {an ~rn} {i kizflick
o~l{guln dglnr c{ {an rcon {gon& I~} J}gk ulcwr c ochi} }ilnan}n&
k&NOULIWGFJ [AN JLIM^R C]BAG[NB[^]N
GF U]IUIRNK J]GK8
Zagln ulcffgfj {i goulnonf{ c J}gk u}ihnb{, zn o~r{
ckk}nrr grr~nr lg`n rnb~}g{w, ocfcjgfj cfk m}i`n}gfj {an
zi}`lick, cfk ocfcjgfj kc{c cfk }nri~}bnr gfdi}oc{gif&
Oir{ J}gk cuulgbc{gifr bif{cgf c {gja{ gf{nj}c{gif id cll
{anrn biouifnf{r&
[an Jlim~r U}ihnb{ u}itgknr iunf ri~}bn rid{zc}n
{iilr {ac{ oc`n g{ ncrgn} {i m~glk biou~{c{gifcl J}gkr cfk
J}gk/mcrnk cuulgbc{gifr& [anrn {iilr c}n billnb{gtnlw bcllnk
{an Jlim~r [iil`g{& Jlim~r [iil`g{ gr {an iunf ri~}bn J}gk
{nbafilijw di} biou~{gfj cfk kc{c J}gkr& If {an rn}tn}
rgkn, Jlim~r [iil`g{ =&= u}itgknr gf{n}dcbnr gf B& If {an
blgnf{ rgkn, g{ u}itgknr gf{n}dcbnr gf B, Hctc lcfj~cjn, cfki{an} lcfj~cjnr& If {an blgnf{ rgkn, {an Hctc gf{n}dcbnr c}n
u}itgknk mw {an Hctc Biooikg{w J}gk !BiJ' @g{& Jlim~r
}~fr if Lgf~q, CGQ, AU/^Q, Rilc}gr, cfk clri if zgfkizr
iun}c{gfj rwr{nor&
[an Jlim~r c}bag{nb{~}n }nu}nrnf{r c o~l{guln/lcwn}
oiknl& [an libcl rn}tgbnr lcwn} bif{cgfr {an iun}c{gfj
rwr{no rn}tgbnr cfk fn{zi}` rn}tgbnr lg`n [BU)GU& Gf
ckkg{gif, {an}n c}n {an rn}tgbnr u}itgknk mw bl~r{n}
rbank~lgfj rid{zc}n !lg`n GMO Lick Lntnln}' // him/
r~mogrrgif, s~n}w id s~n~nr, cfk ri di}{a& [an bl~r{n}
rbank~lgfj rid{zc}n cllizr c mn{{n} ~rn id {an nqgr{gfj
bl~r{n} }nri~}bnr& [an agjan} lcwn}r id {an Jlim~r oiknl
nfcmln {an gf{nj}c{gif id o~l{guln i} an{n}ijnfni~rbl~r{n}r&
[an Jlim~r [iil`g{ !J[' zcr kntnliunk mw Jlimcl
Cllgcfbn, c kgtgrgif id Jlimcl J}gk Di}~o& Jlimcl Cllgcfbn
biou}grnr id ]$K }nrnc}ba j}i~ur mcrnk c{ rntn}cl
~fgtn}rg{gnr r~ba cr {an ^fgtn}rg{w id Bagbcji, {an
^fgtn}rg{w id Nkgfm~}ja cfk {an ^fgtn}rg{w id Ri~{an}f
Bclgdi}fgc& J[ gr {an kn dcb{i r{cfkc}k di} j}gk biou~{gfj
P=_ cfk g{ gr biou}grnk id 2 ocgf rn}tgbnr8
[an bi}n rn}tgbnr8
Mcrgb gfd}cr{}~b{~}nr {i nfcmln j}gk biou~{gfj r~ba cr8
}nri~}bn ocfcjnonf{ di} fcogfj cfk libc{gfj
biou~{c{gifcl }nri~}bnr if }noi{n rwr{nor, rnb~}g{w cfk
rwr{no lntnl rn}tgbnr, cfk oifg{i} r{c{~r&
Rnb~}g{w rn}tgbnr8
Rnb~}g{w gr goulnonf{nk ~rgfj {an r{cfkc}k JRG !J}gk
Rnb~}g{w Gfd}cr{}~b{~}n' cfk BCR
!Bioo~fg{w C~{ai}gxc{gif Rn}tgbn'& JRG iddn}r
rn}tgbnr r~ba cr mcrgb bn}{gdgbc{gif, U@G, cfk ocfw i{an}
rnb~}g{w lgm}c}gnr&
Kc{c)]nri~}bn Ocfcjnonf{
U}i{ibilr {i nfr~}n }cugk cfk rnb~}n kc{c {}cfrdn}
coifj }nri~}bn fiknr& [an}n c}n ; u}i{ibilr8J}gkD[U, ]nlgcmln Dgln [}cfrdn} !]D[', ]nulgbc
Libc{gif Rn}tgbn !]LR', cfk Nq{nfrgmln
Gfu~{)i~{u~{ !QGI'& J]CO !Jlim~r ]nri~}bn
Cllibc{gif Ocfcjn}r' gr {an Kc{c Ocfcjnonf{ di} J[&
[n}cJ}gk P>_, [GJN], cfk [cgzcf ^fgJ}gk P4_ gr nqcoulnr
id j}gk u}ihnb{r {ac{ ~rn J[&
d&J}gk Rnb~}g{w Gfd}cr{}~b{~}n !JRG'8
JRG u}itgknr nlnonf{r di} rnb~}n c~{anf{gbc{gif cfk
bioo~fgbc{gif gf c j}gk& [an gfd}cr{}~b{~}n gr mcrnk if {an
RRL u}i{ibil !Rnb~}n Rib`n{ Lcwn}', u~mlgb `nw
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 43/223
nfb}wu{gif, cfk q&>57 bn}{gdgbc{nr& Di} c rgfjln rgjf/if,
Jlim~r ckk rion nq{nfrgifr if JRG& G{ gr mcrnk if {an
Jnfn}gb Rnb~}g{w Rn}tgbn CUG, zagba c r{cfkc}k CUG gr
u}ioi{nk mw {an Gf{n}fn{ Nfjgfnn}gfj [cr` Di}bn !GN[D'&
[anrn c}n {an ocgf d~fb{gifr goulnonf{nk mw JRG8
Rgfjln)o~{~cl c~{anf{gbc{gif
Bifdgknf{gcl bioo~fgbc{gif
C~{ai}gxc{gif
Knlnjc{gif
n&J}gk ]nri~}bn Cllibc{gif Ocfcjn} !J]CO'8
J]CO gr {an oik~ln {ac{ u}itgknr {an }noi{n
nqnb~{gif cfk r{c{~r ocfcjnonf{ id {an nqnb~{gif& Zanf c
him gr r~mog{{nk mw c blgnf{, {an }ns~nr{ gr rnf{ {i {an
}noi{n air{ cfk acfklnk mw {an jc{n`nnun} kcnoif libc{nk
gf {an }noi{n air{& [anf {an jc{n`nnun} b}nc{nr c himocfcjn} {i r{c}{ cfk oifg{i} {an him& Zanf {an him gr
dgfgrank, {an him ocfcjn} rnfkr {an r{c{~r gfdi}oc{gif mcb`
{i {an Blgnf{ cfk {n}ogfc{nr&
Jlimcl Cbbnrr {i Rnbifkc}w R{i}cjn !JCRR'
J]CO ~rnr JCRR di} u}itgkgfj {an onbacfgro {i
{}cfrdn} {an i~{u~{ dgln d}io rn}tn}r {i blgnf{r& Rion CUGr
c}n u}itgknk ~fkn} {an JRG u}i{ibil {i d~}fgra 321
Gf{}ik~b{gif {i J}gk Biou~{gfj zg{a Jlim~r
Rnb~}n {}cfrdn}r& [agr onbacfgro gr ~rnk mw {an
jlim~r}~f bioocfk, jc{n`nnun}, cfk him ocfcjn}&
d&Oifg{i}gfj cfk Kgrbitn}w Rn}tgbn !OKR'8
OKR u}itgknr cbbnrr {i r{c{gb cfk kwfcogb
gfdi}oc{gif id }nri~}bnr& Mcrgbcllw, g{ bif{cgfr {an
dillizgfj biouifnf{r8
J}gk ]nri~}bn Gfdi}oc{gif Rn}tgbn
!J]GR'
J}gk Gfknq Gfdi}oc{gif Rn}tgbn !JGGR'
Gfdi}oc{gif U}itgkn}
OKR blgnf{
a&J}gk ]nri~}bn Gfdi}oc{gif Rn}tgbn !J]GR'J]GR gr {an }nuirg{i}w id libcl }nri~}bn gfdi}oc{gif
kn}gtnk d}io gfdi}oc{gif u}itgkn}r& J]GR gr cmln {i
}njgr{n} g{r gfdi}oc{gif zg{a c JGGR, m~{ J]GR g{rnld kinr
fi{ }nbngtn }njgr{}c{gif }ns~nr{r& [an libcl gfdi}oc{gif
ocgf{cgfnk mw J]GR gr ~ukc{nk zanf }ns~nr{nk, cfk
bcbank di} c un}gik id {gon `fizf cr {an {gon/{i/lgtn
![[L'& Gd fi }ns~nr{ di} {an gfdi}oc{gif gr }nbngtnk mw
J]GR, {an gfdi}oc{gif zgll {gon i~{ cfk mn knln{nk& Gd c
lc{n} }ns~nr{ di} {an gfdi}oc{gif gr }nbngtnk, J]GR zgll bcll
{an }nlntcf{ gfdi}oc{gif u}itgkn}!r' {i }n{}gntn {an lc{nr{
gfdi}oc{gif&
g&J}gk Gfknq Gfdi}oc{gif Rn}tgbn !JGGR'8
JGGR gr {an }nuirg{i}w {ac{ bif{cgfr gfknqnr id }nri~}bn
gfdi}oc{gif }njgr{n}nk mw {an J]GR cfk i{an} JGGRr& G{ bcfmn rnnf cr c j}gk zgkn gfdi}oc{gif rn}tn}& JGGR acr c
agn}c}bagbcl onbacfgro, lg`n KFR, cfk ncba JGGR acr g{r
izf fcon& [agr oncfr blgnf{ ~rn}r bcf runbgdw {an fcon id
c JGGR fikn {i rnc}ba di}
gfdi}oc{gif&
h&Rnb~}g{w
Rnb~}g{w gr c o~ba oi}n goui}{cf{ dcb{i} gf ulcffgfj
cfk ocgf{cgfgfj c j}gk {acf gf biftnf{gifcl kgr{}gm~{nk
biou~{gfj, zan}n kc{c rac}gfj biou}grnr {an m~l` id {an
cb{gtg{w& Gf c j}gk, {an onomn} ocbagfnr c}n bifdgj~}nk {i
nqnb~{n u}ij}cor }c{an} {acf h~r{ oitn kc{c& [agr oc`nr
cf ~frnb~}nk j}gk ui{nf{gcllw dn}{gln j}i~fk di} tg}~rnr cfk[}ihcf ai}rn u}ij}cor& Di} {agr }ncrif, g{ gr goui}{cf{ {i
~fkn}r{cfk nqcb{lw zagba biouifnf{r id {an j}gk o~r{
mn }gji}i~rlw rnb~}nk {i kn{n} cfw `gfk id c{{cb`&
D~}{an}oi}n, g{ gr goui}{cf{ {i ~fkn}r{cfk {an grr~nr
gftiltnk gf c~{anf{gbc{gfj ~rn}r cfk u}iun}lw nqnb~{gfj {an
}nruifrgmglg{gnr id c Bn}{gdgbc{n C~{ai}g{w&
a&Bn}{gdgbc{n c~{ai}g{w
[an u}goc}w }nruifrgmglg{gnr id c Bn}{gdgbc{n C~{ai}g{w
c}n8
Uirg{gtnlw gknf{gdw nf{g{gnr }ns~nr{gfj
bn}{gdgbc{nr
Grr~gfj, }noitgfj, cfk c}bagtgfj
bn}{gdgbc{nr
U}i{nb{gfj {an Bn}{gdgbc{n C~{ai}g{w
rn}tn}
Ocgf{cgfgfj c fconrucbn id ~fgs~n
fconr di} bn}{gdgbc{n izfn}r
Rn}tn rgjfnk bn}{gdgbc{nr {i {airn
fnnkgfj {i c~{anf{gbc{n nf{g{gnr
Lijjgfj cb{gtg{w
M}gndlw, c Bn}{gdgbc{n C~{ai}g{w gr mcrnk if {an u~mlgb
`nw nfb}wu{gif rwr{no& Gf {agr rwr{no, `nwr c}n jnfn}c{nk
gf ucg}r, c u~mlgb `nw cfk c u}gtc{n `nw& Ng{an} ifn bcf mn~rnk {i nfb}wu{ rion kc{c r~ba {ac{ {an i{an} gr fnnknk {i
knb}wu{ g{& [an u}gtc{n `nw gr j~c}knk mw {an izfn} cfk
fntn} }ntnclnk {i cfwifn& [an u~mlgb ifn gr jgtnf {i
cfwifn fnnkgfj g{& C Bn}{gdgbc{n C~{ai}g{w gr ~rnk {i ailk
[anrn u~mlgb `nwr cfk {i j~c}cf{nn zai {anw mnlifj {i&
Zanf c ~rn} ~rnr agr u}gtc{n `nw {i nfb}wu{ rion{agfj, {an
}nbngtn} ~rnr {an bi}}nruifkgfj u~mlgb `nw {i knb}wu{ g{&
[an }nbngtn} `fizr {ac{ iflw {ac{ ~rn}‗r u~mlgb `nw bcf
knb}wu{ {an onrrcjn bi}}nb{lw& Aizntn}, cfwifn bi~lk
gf{n}bnu{ {agr onrrcjn cfk knb}wu{ g{ mnbc~rn cfwifn bcf
jn{ {an i}gjgfc{i}‗r u~mlgb `nw& Gd {an i}gjgfc{i} gfr{nck
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 44/223
ki~mlw nfb}wu{r {an onrrcjn zg{a agr u}gtc{n `nw cfk {an
gf{nfknk }nbgugnf{‗r u~mlgb `nw, c rnb~}n bioo~fgbc{gif
lgf` gr di}onk& [an }nbngtn} ~rnr agr u}gtc{n `nw {i knb}wu{
{an onrrcjn cfk {anf ~rnr {an rnfkn}‗r u~mlgb `nw di} {anrnbifk knb}wu{gif& Fiz {an }nbgugnf{ `fizr {ac{ gd {an
onrrcjn knb}wu{r u}iun}lw, {anf iflw {an rnfkn} bi~lk
actn rnf{ g{ cfk d~}{an}oi}n, {an rnfkn} `fizr {ac{ iflw
{an gf{nfknk }nbngtn} bcf knb}wu{ g{& [an mnc~{w id cll id
{agr gr {ac{ fimikw ack {i rnb~}nlw bc}}w cf nfb}wu{gif `nw
d}io {an rnfkn} {i {an }nbngtn},
`&Rbank~ln}r
Oir{ j}gk rwr{nor gfbl~kn rion ri}{ id him rbank~lgfj
rid{zc}n& [agr rid{zc}n libc{nr c ocbagfn if zagba {i }~f
c j}gk him {ac{ acr mnnf r~mog{{nk mw c ~rn}& Gf {an rgoulnr{
bcrnr, g{ ocw h~r{ mlgfklw crrgjf himr gf c }i~fk/}imgf
dcragif {i {an fnq{ ocbagfn oc{bagfj {an }nri~}bn}ns~g}nonf{r& Aizntn}, {an}n c}n cktcf{cjnr {i ~rgfj c
oi}n cktcfbnk rbank~ln}& Rion rbank~ln}r goulnonf{ c
him u}gi}g{w rwr{no& [agr gr rion{gonr kifn mw ~rgfj
rntn}cl him s~n~nr, ncba zg{a c kgddn}nf{ u}gi}g{w& Cr j}gk
ocbagfnr mnbion ctcglcmln {i nqnb~{n himr, {an himr c}n
{c`nf d}io {an agjanr{ u}gi}g{w s~n~nr dg}r{& Uilgbgnr id
tc}gi~r `gfkr c}n clri goulnonf{nk ~rgfj rbank~ln}r&
Uilgbgnr bcf gfbl~kn tc}gi~r `gfkr id bifr{}cgf{r if himr,
~rn}r, cfk }nri~}bnr& Di} nqcouln, {an}n ocw mn c uilgbw
{ac{ }nr{}gb{r j}gk himr d}io nqnb~{gfj c{ bn}{cgf {gonr id
{an kcw&
Oi}n cktcfbnk rbank~ln}r zgll oifg{i} {an u}ij}nrr id
rbank~lnk himr ocfcjgfj {an itn}cll zi}`/dliz& Gd {an himr
c}n lir{ k~n {i rwr{no i} fn{zi}` i~{cjnr, c jiik
rbank~ln} zgll c~{ioc{gbcllw }nr~mog{ {an him nlrnzan}n&
Aizntn}, gd c him cuunc}r {i mn gf cf gfdgfg{n liiu cfk
}ncbanr c ocqgo~o {goni~{, {anf r~ba himr rai~lk fi{ mn
}nrbank~lnk& [wugbcllw, himr actn kgddn}nf{ `gfkr id
biouln{gif biknr, rion id zagba c}n r~g{cmln di} }n/
r~mogrrgif cfk rion id zagba c}n fi{&
T& Oifg{i}gfj u}ij}nrr cfk
}nbitn}w
C j}gk rwr{no, gf bifh~fb{gif zg{a g{r him rbank~ln},
id{nf u}itgknr rion knj}nn id }nbitn}w di} r~m himr {ac{dcgl& C him ocw dcgl k~n {i c8
U}ij}coogfj n}}i}8 [an him r{iur uc}{
zcw zg{a rion u}ij}co dc~l{&
Ac}kzc}n i} uizn} dcgl~}n8 [an ocbagfn
i} kntgbnr mngfj ~rnk r{iu zi}`gfj gf rion zcw&
Bioo~fgbc{gifr gf{n}}~u{gif8 C
bioo~fgbc{gif uc{a {i {an ocbagfn acr dcglnk i}
gr itn}licknk zg{a i{an} kc{c {}cddgb&
Nqbnrrgtn rlizfnrr8 [an him ogja{ mn gf
cf gfdgfg{n liiu i} fi}ocl him u}ij}nrr ocw mn
lgog{nk mw cfi{an} u}ibnrr }~ffgfj c{ c agjan}
u}gi}g{w i} rion i{an} di}o id bif{nf{gif&
G{ gr fi{ clzcwr uirrgmln {i c~{ioc{gbcllw kn{n}ogfn gd
{an }ncrif di} c him‗r dcgl~}ngr k~n {i c u}imlno zg{a {an knrgjf id {an cuulgbc{gif i}
gd g{ gr k~n {i dcgl~}nr id
tc}gi~r `gfkr gf {an j}gk rwr{no gfd}cr{}~b{~}n&
Rbank~ln}r c}n id{nf knrgjfnk {i
bc{nji}gxn him dcgl~}nr gf rion zcw cfk c~{ioc{gbcllw
}nr~mog{ himr ri {ac{ {anw
c}n lg`nlw {i r~bbnnk, }~ffgfj nlrnzan}n if {an j}gk&
g&Bioo~fgbc{gifr
C j}gk rwr{no ocw gfbl~kn rid{zc}n {i anlu himr
bioo~fgbc{n zg{a ncba i{an}& [an iunf r{cfkc}k Onrrcjn
Ucrrgfj Gf{n}dcbn !OUG' cfk cfw id rntn}cl tc}gc{gifr gr
id{nf gfbl~knk cr uc}{ id {an j}gk rwr{no di} h~r{ {agr `gfkid bioo~fgbc{gif
h&CBBNRRGFJ [AN GF[]CFN[ J]GK8
Zanf cfw ~rn} zcf{r {i cbbnrr i~} u}iuirnk Gf{}cfn{
J}gk gf i}kn} {i kizflick o~l{guln dglnr itn} {an Gf{n}fn{,
{anf an rai~lk dilliz bn}{cgf u}ibnk~}nr {ac{ zn bifrgkn}
fnbnrrc}w di} {an rnb~}g{w id i~} J}gk& [an ocgf
]ns~g}nonf{r di} U}ibnrrgfj gf J}gk Nftg}ifonf{ c}n8
Rnb~}g{w8 Rgfjln rgjf/if, c~{anf{gbc{gif,
c~{ai}gxc{gif, cfk rnb~}n kc{c {}cfrdn}&
]nri~}bn Ocfcjnonf{8 ]noi{n him r~mogrrgif
cfk ocfcjnonf{&
Kc{c Ocfcjnonf{8 Rnb~}n cfk }im~r{ kc{c
oitnonf{&
Gfdi}oc{gif Rn}tgbnr8 Kg}nb{i}w rn}tgbnr id
ctcglcmln }nri~}bnr cfk {ang} r{c{~r&
Dc~l{ Kn{nb{gif8 Banb`gfj {an
gf{}cfn{&
Ui}{cmglg{w8 B mgfkgfjr !anckn} dglnr' fnnknk {i
m~glk cfk biougln u}ij}cor
&
TG& Nqgr{gfj Clji}g{ao di} Jlim~r C}bag{nb{~}n
B}nc{n rnb~}g{w u}iqw tgc JRG
rn}tgbnr
Cbbnrr c OKR/JGGR rn}tn} Rnc}ba di} }ns~g}nk ocbagfn!r'
]cf` {an ocbagfn lgr{ mcrnk if c rbank~lgfj
uilgbw
U}nuc}n {an kc{c
[}cfrdn} {an kc{c {i {an {c}jn{ ocbagfn mw
~rgfj JCRR rn}tgbnr
U}nuc}n c ]RL kib~onf{
R~mog{ {an u}ij}co ~rgfj J]CO rn}tgbnr
]ncb{ {i r{c{~r bacfjnr d}io J]CO
Jn{ }nr~l{r tgc JCRR
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 45/223
An}n, zn actn ji{ {an }nri~}bnr ctcglcmln gf {an
Fn{zi}` zagba gr c~{ioc{gbcllw kifn mw actn {an Jlim~r
[iil`g{ gf {an rn}tn}& Zanf zn zcf{ {i kizflick c dgln {agr
gfdi}oc{gif acr {i mn oc{bank zg{a {an blgnf{ oik~ln cfk{anf {an kizflickgfj acr {i mn bc}}gnk i~{ gf {an blgnf{r&
Di} {agr zn actn ckknk rion oik~lnr {i {an J}gk
C}bag{nb{~}n&
Ckknk oik~ln8
Jn{ {an Gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{ dglnr {i mn
kizflicknk&
Oc{ba {an dglnr zg{a cuu}iu}gc{n Ocbagfnr&
R{i}n dglnr gf biooif kc{cmcrn&
]n{}gntcl id kc{c d}io kc{cmcrn gr kifn cd{n}
u}iun} c~{anf{gbc{gif&
=5& UU]IUIRNK CLJI]G[AO DI]
GF[]CFN[ U]IUIRNK J]GK8R{nur {i un}di}o o~l{guln kizflickgfj gf {an J}gk, [an
air{ kn{cglr c}n ji{ d}io {an rn}tn} id {an LCF gf i}kn} {i
gknf{gdw {an tc}gi~r air{r&
[an air{ gfdi}oc{gif gr ji{ zanfntn} fnnknk if {an
u}gi}g{w s~n~n mcrgr&
))oik~ln di} kizflickgfj dglnr
R{c}{ lii`~u )) lii` di} dgln rgxn cfk
}nri~}bn gfdi}oc{gif
Knblc}n f}nr, fdgln )) fi id }nri~}bnr
ctcglcmln cfk fi id dglnr
Gfu~{ f}nr, fdglnr
Gfu~{ rgxn )) {an dgln rgxn
Gfg{gclgxn U3 }nr gfdi )) r{i}n {an
}nri~}bn gfdi}oc{gif gf u}gi}g{w s~n~n U3 zg{a agjanr{
rwr{no bifdgj~}c{gif cr u}gi}g{w
Gfg{gclgxn U= dgln rgxn )) r{i}n {an dgln
gfdi}oc{gif gf {an u}gi}g{w s~n~n U= zg{a ocqgo~o dgln
rgxn cr u}gi}g{w
Gd bifkg{gif !fdglnr ?? f}nr' )) banb`
zan{an} {an fi id }nri~}bnr gr ns~cl {i fi id dglnr
Gfg{gclgxn bi~f{n}
Di} !bi~f{n} ?30 bi~f{n} <? f}nr0
bi~f{n}++' )) gfg{gclgxn {an liiu {i crrgjf {an dglnr&
Crrgjf {an 3r{
dgln id U= {i {an 3r{
fikn gf U3& )) dg}r{ fikn zgll mn fikn zg{a agjanr{ bifdgj~}c{gif cfk
dg}r{ dgln zgll mn {an dgln zg{a ocqgo~o rgxn&
R{c}{ u}ibnrrgfj )) dglnr kg}nb{nk {i {an
cuu}iu}gc{n rwr{no di} cbbnrrgfj {ang} zcr{nk BU^
bwblnr&
Liiu
Nlrn8
R{c}{ {gon}
Knlcw 3 ogf
Billnb{ gfbiogfj dglnr )) {an dglnr {ac{ {an ~rn}
blgb`nk {i kizflick gf {agr k~}c{gif&
Crrgjf {an dglnr U=
Ji{i r{nu 1
Ji{i r{nu 3
Nfk )) zanf {an ~rn} nqg{r d}io u}iuirnkJ}gk&
=3& MNFNDG[R ID J]GK
BIOU^[GFJ8
J}gk biou~{gfj nfcmlnr i}jcfgxc{gifr {i
cjj}njc{n }nri~}bnr zg{agf cf nf{g}n G[ gfd}cr{}~b{~}n fi
oc{{n} zan}n gf {an zi}lk {anw c}n libc{nk& G{ nlgogfc{nr
rg{~c{gifr zan}n ifn rg{n gr }~ffgfj if ocqgo~o bcucbg{w,
zagln i{an}r actn bwblnr {i ruc}n&
J}gk biou~{gfj nfcmlnr bioucfgnr {i cbbnrr cfk
rac}n }noi{n kc{cmcrnr& [agr gr nrunbgcllw mnfndgbgcl {i {an
lgdn rbgnfbnr cfk }nrnc}ba bioo~fg{gnr, zan}n nfi}oi~r
til~onr id kc{c c}n jnfn}c{nk cfk cfclwxnk k~}gfj cfw
jgtnf kcw&
J}gk biou~{gfj nfcmlnr zgknlw kgrun}rnk
i}jcfgxc{gifr {i ncrglw billcmi}c{n if u}ihnb{r mw b}nc{gfj
{an cmglg{w {i rac}n ntn}w{agfj d}io rid{zc}n cuulgbc{gifr
cfk kc{c, {i nfjgfnn}gfj ml~nu}gf{r&
J}gk biou~{gfj bcf b}nc{n c oi}n }im~r{ cfk
}nrglgnf{ G[ gfd}cr{}~b{~}n mn{{n} cmln {i }nruifk {i ogfi}
i} ochi} kgrcr{n}r&
C j}gk bcf ac}fnrr {an gkln u}ibnrrgfj bwblnr {ac{
c}n ctcglcmln gf knr`{iu UBr libc{nk gf tc}gi~r libc{gifr
cb}irr o~l{guln {gon xifnr& Di} nqcouln, UBr {ac{ zi~lk{wugbcllw }nocgf gkln itn}fgja{ c{ c bioucfw*r [i`wi
ocf~dcb{~}gfj ulcf{ bi~lk mn ~{glgxnk k~}gfj {an kcw mw g{r
Fi}{a Con}gbcf iun}c{gifr&
T& BIFBL^RGIF
J}gk biou~{gfj zcr ifbn rcgk {i mn dckgfj i~{ m~{ k~n
{i {an {nbafilijgbcl biftn}jnfbn g{ gr mliiogfj ifbn cjcgf
cfk {an Gf{}cfn{ J}gk zn actn u}iuirnk ckkr c oglnr{ifn
di} {an Jlimclgxc{gif id J}gk C}bag{nb{~}n, zagba, lnckr {i
{an acr{w biou~{gfj {ac{ gr jigfj {i bifs~n} {an zi}lk gf
{an fnc}nr{ d~{~}n& Mw goulnonf{gfj i~} u}iuirnk Gf{}cfn{
J}gk g{ gr tn}w ncrw {i kizflick o~l{guln dglnr tn}w dcr{ cfk
fi fnnk {i zi}}w cmi~{ {an rnb~}g{w cr zn c}nc~{anf{gbc{gfj ncba cfk ntn}w r{nu {c`gfj ulcbn gf i~} J}gk
cfk gf uc}{gb~lc} ~rn} {i cbbnrr {an kc{cmcrn& D~}{an}
goulnonf{c{gifr bi~lk mn bc}}gnk i~{ gf {an fnc}nr{ d~{~}n&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_&U Ulcrxbxc`, ] Znllfn}, J}gk biou~{gfj, =55>, Nlrntgn})Oi}jcf
@c~docff, Rcf D}cfbgrbiP=_D}cfbnrbi Lnllg, N}gb D}gxxgn}i, Ogbanln J~logfg, Jcn{cfi Oc}if,
Rcltc{i}n I}lcfki, Cfk}nc Un{}~bbg cfk Rgltcfi Rs~gxxc{i& [an ocfw
dcbnr id {an gf{nj}c{gif id gfr{}~onf{r cfk {an j}gk& Gf{n}fc{gifcl Hi~}fcl
id Znm cfk J}gk Rn}tgbnr =55: ‒ Til& 2, Fi&2
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 25
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 46/223
P2_D}cf Mn}ocf, Jnidd}nw Diq, Cf{aifw H& J& Anw J}gk biou~{gfj, =55>,
Nlrntgn})Oi}jcf @c~docff, Rcf D}cfbgrbi
P;_Ucznl Ulcrxbxc`, ]gbac}k Znllfn}Hirç Bc}kiri B~fac, Ion} ]cfc
Lgxan Zcfj, Zng Hgn, Hgfh~f BanfD~fkconf{clr id J}gk Biou~{gfj8
[ani}w, Clji}g{aor cfk [nbafilijgnr MW D}çkç}gb
P>_Cktcfbnr gf j}gk biou~{gfj // NJB =55>8 N~}iuncf J}gk Bifdn}nfbn,
&&& Un{n} Rlii{P4_J}gk biou~{gfj8 {an fnz d}if{gn} id agja un}di}ocfbn biou~{gfj/
L~bgi J}cfkgfn{{g
P:_ Kgr{}gm~{nk kc{c ocfcjnonf{ di} j}gk biou~{gfj/Ogbacnl Kg R{ndcfi
P1_J}gk [nbafilijw cfk Cuulgbc{gifr8 ]nbnf{ Kntnliuonf{r/J& C&J}cttcfgr, A& ]& C}cmgfc,
P7_Cktcfbnr gf j}gk cfk un}tcrgtn biou~{gfj8 {ag}k gf{n}fc{gifcl/Rifj
Z~, Lc~}nfbn [gcf}~i Wcfj, [ifw Lg Q~
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 23
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 47/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;31: )GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;31:
FCFI[NBAFILIJW [AN FNZ ^UJ]CKN DI] BIOU^[N]R
C&]COWCR]NNCddglgc{nk {i Cffc ^fgtn}rg{w, Banffcg&
M&N Dgfcl Wnc} BRN,
OCGLCO NFJGFNN]GFJ BILLNJN& Ocglco&
[cogl Fck~, Gfkgc&
Cmr{}cb{‛“ [an Fnq{ Mgj [agfj Gr ]ncllw Rocll‟ / @& N}gb
K}nqln}, Di~fkn} cfk Bacg}ocf, Di}nrgja{ Gfr{g{~{n, cfk
U}nkgb{gifr, imrn}tgfj {an }grn id {an a~ocf knunfknfbn if
{an rnb{i} id Fcfi [nbafilijw& Fcfi {nbafilijw gr fi{ h~r{
r{~kwgfj ntn}w dgnlk gf c lc}jn} rbiun m~{ kn}gtgfj cf
nfi}oi~r kntnliuonf{ gf gou}itcmln c}ncr lg`n ~rcjn id
FT]CO $ lc}jn} onoi}w r{i}cjn gf g{, ^rn id {an
fcfiocjfn{gro gfg{gc{gtn zagba u}itgknr cf gf{n}kgrbgulgfc}wd}conzi}` {i anlu r{cjn {an fnq{ cktcfbn gf bioulnq
oc{n}gclr }nrnc}ba {ac{ bcf mn ~rnk gf Biou~{n} rbgnfbnr
Cuulgbc{gif id fcfib}wr{clr $ fcfibiou~{n}, Oilnb~lc} cfk
S~cf{~o cfk Fcfi Biou~{gfj cfk Fcfionbacfgbcl
biou~{gfj, ^rcjn id J}cuanfn bagur gfr{nck id rglgbif&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
C mcrgb kndgfg{gif8 Fcfi{nbafilijw gr {an nfjgfnn}gfj
id d~fb{gifcl rwr{nor c{ {an oilnb~lc} rbcln&
[agr bitn}r mi{a b~}}nf{ zi}` cfk bifbnu{r {ac{ c}n
oi}n cktcfbnk& Gf g{r i}gjgfcl rnfrn, *fcfi{nbafilijw*
}ndn}r {i {an u}ihnb{nk cmglg{w {i bifr{}~b{ g{nor d}io {an
mi{{io ~u, ~rgfj {nbafgs~nr cfk {iilr mngfj kntnliunk
{ikcw {i oc`n biouln{n, agja un}di}ocfbn u}ik~b{r&K}gtnf mw }cugk {nbafilijgbcl cktcfbnr zg{agf {an ucr{
{zi knbcknr, biou~{gfj cfk agja/runnk fn{zi}`gfjr actn
non}jnk cr uizn}d~l {iilr di} rbgnfbn cfk c}n ntnf
bacfjgfj {an zcwr gf zagba oikn}f rbgnfbn gr bifk~b{nk&
KIN gr c fc{gifcl lnckn} gf {an rbgnf{gdgb biou~{gfj dgnlk‒
r~uui}{gfj d~fkconf{cl }nrnc}ba gf cktcfbnk rbgnf{gdgb
biou~{gfj, cuulgnk oc{anoc{gbr, biou~{n} rbgnfbn, cfk
fn{zi}`gfj& [an KIN biou~{c{gifcl gfd}cr{}~b{~}n
u}itgknr zi}lk/blcrr, agja/un}di}ocfbn biou~{c{gifcl cfk
fn{zi}`gfj {iilr {ac{ nfcmln rbgnf{gdgb, nfn}jw,
nftg}ifonf{cl, cfk fc{gifcl rnb~}g{w }nrnc}ba&
Oi}n {acf =;55 rbgnf{gr{r gf ~fgtn}rg{gnr, dnkn}cl
cjnfbgnr, cfk ^&R& bioucfgnr ~rn KIN/!KNUC][ONF[ID NFN]JW/Zcragfj{if K&B' d~fknk agja/un}di}ocfbn
biou~{n}r& ]nrnc}ba bioo~fg{gnr {ac{ mnfndg{ d}io {anrn
}nri~}bnr gfbl~kn r{}~b{~}cl mgilijw0 r~un}bifk~b{i}
{nbafilijw0 onkgbcl }nrnc}ba cfk {nbafilijw kntnliuonf{0
oc{n}gclr, banogbcl cfk ulcroc rbgnfbnr0 agja nfn}jw cfk
f~blnc} uawrgbr0 cfk nftg}ifonf{cl cfk c{oiruan}gb
}nrnc}ba&
GG& FCFI BIOU^[GFJ
S~cf{~o Fcfi biou~{gfj cfk s~cf{~o biou~{n}r c}n
gf cktcfbnk r{cjnr id kntnliuonf{ k~n {i }nbnf{
fcfi{nbafilijw cktcfbnr gf {anrn c}ncr& [anrn biou~{n}r
u}iogrn {i mn ri dcr{ cfk uizn}d~l {ac{ i~} oikn}f
r~un}biou~{n}r zgll mn lg{{ln oi}n {acf {iwr gf wnc}r {ibion& [an u}imlno gr {ac{ {ang} rann} bcucbg{w di}
u}ibnrrgfj kc{c oncfr {ac{ {anw zgll lg`nlw mn cmln {i
}nckglw b}cb` ntnf {an oir{ cktcfbnk nfb}wu{gif on{aikr
{a}i~ja m}~{n di}bn&
Biou~{n}r ulcw c ugti{cl uc}{ gf fcfi{nbafilijw cr
{anw clliz ~r {i kntnliu c{iogb oiknlr cfk di}nrnn {an
Fcfi kntgbnr zn knrg}n& D~}{an}oi}n, cr fcfi{nbafilijw
ntiltnr, fnz, oi}n uizn}d~l biou~{n}r zgll non}jn,
zagba zgll lnck {i m}nc`{a}i~jar gf fcfi{nbafilijw cfk
wn{ {i oi}n uizn}d~l biou~{n}r& Anfbn zn zgll actn c
bwbln id rbgnf{gdgb kgrbitn}w ~fu}nbnknf{nk gf a~ocf
agr{i}w& G{ zgll mn {an rgfj~lc}g{w&
C& BIFRNS^NFBNR8
Mnbc~rn id {an rgfj~lc}g{w, g{ gr rai}{rgja{nk {i kgrb~rr
{an cuulgbc{gifr id fcfi{nba, m~{ an}n*r cf c{{nou{8 Gf
biou~{n} rbgnfbn, zn zi~lk actn fcfibiou~{n} {ac{
zi~lk iunf {an kii} di} cfk}igkr cfk c}{gdgbgcl
gf{nllgjnfbnr& Fcfi{nba zi~lk kntnliu cf c}ow id
oilnb~lc} }imi{r cfk fcfikntgbnr {ac{ zi~lk clliz ~r {i
biouln{nlw kiogfc{n Fc{~}n& Zn fiz kiogfc{n g{ c{ c
ocb}irbiugb lntnl0 zn zi~lk {anf kiogfc{n g{ c{ c
ogb}irbiugb lntnl, {ii& Zg{a oilnb~lc} onkgbgfn zn zi~lk
nlgogfc{n ocfw, gd fi{ cll, kgrncrnr zg{a gf{nllgjnf{
oilnb~lnr bcucmln id }nucg}gfj cfk bacfjgfj i~} bnllr& H~r{
di} b~}girg{w, ow dg}r{ gknc {izc}kr nfkgfj cjgfj, gfrug}nkmw {an lnjnfkc}w [T rn}gnr [}cfrdi}on}r zagba zn ~rnk {i
zc{ba j}izgfj ~u, zcr {i ~rn ogb}irbiugb kntgbnr bcucmln
id {~}fgfj i~} fn~}ifr gf{i on{cl ifnr zg{a c dc} j}nc{n}
r{}nfj{a cfk {an}ndi}n gouirrgmln {i `gll&
Gf rwfn}jw zg{a i{an} {nbafilijgnr r~ba cr jnfn{gb
nfjgfnn}gfj, {an bacfjnr ncba id ~r bi~lk u~}r~n zi~lk mn
r{cjjn}gfj0 d}io actgfj c r`gf gft~lfn}cmln {i m~lln{r {i
c~jonf{gfj i~} uawrgbcl cfk urwbailijgbcl bcucbg{gnr&
Gfk~r{}gcl, cj}gb~l{~}cl, cfk nftg}ifonf{cl cuulgbc{gifr c}n
cloir{ ~fgocjgfcmln c{ {agr r{cjn8 n}ckgbc{gfj a~fjn},
b}nc{gfj oilnb~lc} r~un}bifk~b{i}r c{ }iio {noun}c{~}n,
kntnliugfj fcfiocbagfnr {ac{ nlgogfc{n uill~{gif, n{b&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 2=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 48/223
g
g
Goui}{cf{lcfk bilifgxc{gcocxgfj oil
}nu}ik~bgfj&ngfj r{c}{nkgfr{}~b{gifr {{anrn oilnb~l
nagfk fcfi{}iun}lw biknd bioulnqg{
rbi~{r gf rugfan}g{nk ui
cb{n}g~o zg{ai~}r, gd clli{an zngja{ id fi~ja ocrr~{uir{r cfk
{ani}w m~{ g{nclgfj zg{a&
[an}n c}nG clri onf{g{ani}gxnk mw
cfi{nbafili}nulgbc{gfj c
giqgkn gf{i~flncrank cfitn} {an nc}{f nc}{a&cfi{nbafili
}ntgnz id {
cfi{nba c}Fcfi{nba zgll
M& DCR
ZG[A FCFI
Roclln}, lnlnb{}gbcl dcglgfcbbnrrgmln}nrnc}ba Lcm
-[gfw- o{an zgk{a id
gddn}nf{lw {a
}nrnc}ban}r a}ncb{gtn, nqag{i b}nc{n oc}nrgr{cf{ {i d}g
w, zn zi~lkgif& Ncba fcfnb~lc} nfjgf
]nonomn} {cr c {gfw bmlirrio gf
c} crrnomln}rba gr {i b}nc{k, bcf jgtn }g& [a~r fcfi
cbn nquli}c{gn} id fcfi
a c jnfn}c{gink {i j}iz,
{an nc}{a& [ag )nfn}jw acr {lgdn {a}i~jairaizr {an k
rion kcfjn}rf nlrnzan}n&]clua On}`lw& Mcrgbcllw
g}mi}fn fcfij}cuag{n&
, gf cr lg{{ln ca, mlib` {animn}{ D}ng{w, iddn}r cfn kcfjn}r
cfi{an} }ndi}ntn} bacf
N], LGJA[
NBAFILI
gja{n} biou~~}nr rnfkgfjlgomi oc}` {c{ Bagbcji icfr mgllgif{ac a~ocf acgcf {ang} lc}j
ctn lnc}fnkg{ fnz nlnb{}
{n}gclr {ac{ cb{gif cfk znc
mn bcucmlniocbagfnr zn}gfj cbagnt
ac{ ntn}w rgnll bif{cgfgf{i cf ck~l{c}n lg`n c a~n r~ba {gfw fn {i ocbagfnkntgbnr zi~lif& [i jgtn{nbafilijw,f {gon id =5}ncba c uiur oncfr {ac{an ui{nf{gcl{ {an jclcqw&gonfrgif id
gfan}g{nk {iDi} nqcoul
n cr c kiio, {an j}nwkntgbn {ac{Rai~lk r~bar c dnz kcwr,r~f, cfk ntnfr H}&, ciu{gogr{gb m~{d fcfi{nba&
crif di} run a~ocfg{w&
] BIOU^[
W&
{n}r cfk cf nfai~}r id if/ran ui{nf{gcl{gfw dn}}inln
r id c on{n},}& [anrn fcfn} m~l` bi~f
{ac{ {anw c}nifgb u}iun}{gn r{}ifjn}, {} {acf m~l` o
d rucbn bif~lk mn bcucm
nonf{r cfk
jln ck~l{ aj cll {an jnngfj& Gf c rcf njj& [an
cfikntgbnr {ar zg{a c agjak oc`n nqb
cf gknc id ~r{ {agf` {aogf~{nr bcf glc{gif ;555 {c fcfikntgbn{i b}nc{n ulcId bi~}rn {
{an uizn}r
cfi{nbafilij, {an j}nw blrkcw iddru}gfbli~k gr cbc{clwxnr bc
fcfikntgbnc rilgk zcll z{~cllw knr{}ii}lk nqun}{znll/kib~o[an kcfjn}
cbn bilifgxc
]R UIRRGML
k {i zi}}gnr}nnf zi}` gf
}nr~l{ id C}jb{}gb b}wr{clr&i} cmi~{ 3)>
ioc{n}gclr mn{n}uc}{r& C}j
oi}n banogr cfk bcf mni~jan} cfkc{n}gclr&
~nr{ln id ntnf
ocffn{gbfrn,jiclc{, gd lntnlllnf{
{anc{ cf ;1gonrzg{afn{r,gr grn*}n
w, cri~k,j id rnld/}mif
mni~lklgdnif
f{nkr id
{gif&
N
mi~{{i cfiffn
55{aactniffn
bcllw~rnk
i}n
{gGf
kgkg
ribir{zadndg
rgjrwibaoi}
cfacu
ogf
oumcfu
id
Zf
cb
dntgfbi
biid k
Dgj8 Raizrnr roclln} gbiouc}grif
con{n}, {ancon{n}&
GGG
c&]CO $ F
]CO ‒ ]onifn nf{n}rou~{n}& G{ bcfkc}k bioo
agln uizn}nktn b}nc{nk}}inlnb{}gb olk cfk }n{cgfDn}}inlnb{}gglc}lw {i dn}}
fn}cllw bif{oon{}w bc~rn i} oi}n id cfjn {agr uilnbacfgbcl {inlnb{}gbcl nfnC r{}ifj nq
k ogf~r uilnlk {ang} i}gnulgnk nlnb{}gb
noi}w, }nu}nr{an i{an}&Mnbc~rn {an
ckn zg{a {anzn} dcgl~}n&b`/~u mc{{n}gk lgja{n}& [ifnr&Cbagntgfj r
{an biou~{n}Bioucfgnr
nr{gfjai~rnf/tilc{gln ]
agntn bioonMcb` {anf,
}}inlnb{}gb rgl{cjn {i rzgan}nf{ gf {anfbnu{, ockn {[an ~rcjn i
ou~{n}r cr g{Kc{c R{i}cjn{c ogfgfj cfk
c ugb{~}n id kgcon{n} {a
{i c a~ocf a
Fcfi dgmn}r
& BIOU^[G
T]CO& !Fift
fkio Cbbnrgfdi}oc{gif
f mn z}g{{nfn}bgcl {nbafilmw nlnb{}gbg{wcfk c}n r{~{n}gclr {ac{ bcfw bacfjnr&
oc{n}gclr ‒iocjfn{gb ogf g}if ‒ bir ruif{cfni~{ang} cqnr& [
c}g{w& Dn}}inllnb{}gbcl nfn}}jw {i iu{gbcl{n}fcl nlnb{}gr id dn}}inlnb{c{gif ~f{gldgnlk& [a~r,
nf{gfj -xn}i-
b}wr{clr ki fzi~lk fi{
Lcu{iu bior, un}og{{gfjn}n zi~lk
~ba un}ocfngfk~r{}w&r~ba cr C[
Nlnb{}gb ockOr !FT]C
}bgcl ~rn&FT]COr
jln b}wr{clr{ba {ang} ui{anf }nbnf{lano gou}cb{gd FT]CO grocw lnck d~}cfk ~fnc}{arKc{c r{i}cjn
cfi dgm}glr {acf biftnf{gifcg} zagba gr b
c}n 3,555 {g
J CUULGBC
ilc{gln ]CO'
r Onoi}wi} jgtnr c b
{i cr znll crijw / ailkr& C}jiffn owgfj fcfirb
cf mn cl{n}nk
i bcllnk, mnb{n}gclr ntnf {frgr{ id b}wrr nlnb{}gbcl uan cuulgbc{gib{}gb b}wr{clrjw‒ {an ugnxnddnb{r&cl dgnlk bcf{}gb uilc}gxc{gdi}bnk {i ba{anw bcf mn
gf ifn i}gnf
{ }ntn}{ ruifmn n}crnk ra~{n}r zi~lk{ano {i mn on c rgoglc}
fbn gr c lifj
$[, Di}k, Grn}gi~r ndd
' gf {an 37
zn}n mcrnk, zagba }ns~lc}g{w& [agr,
kntgrnk }izcl&c jiik iu{gi
{an} {izc}krfnz bifbnu{
&
c{ c}n 35 {i 3cl {nq{gln dgmc& 15,555 fo
onr roclln}
GIFR
gr ~rnk zioocfk {i}nck m~{ / z
g{r bif{nf{ i{n}gclr rbgnf{gcln b}wr{clrmw cf nlnb{}g
~rn {anw mnaai~ja {anw k{clr zairn llc}gxc{gif clid til{cjn
bcf clri bacnlnb{}gb nddnb
}ntn}rn {an uif& [an b}wr{fjn mw cfi{biknk cr mgf
{c{gif cfk -i
{cfni~rlw, ]i~lk {an}n mfi lifjn} fckn r{gll roclgoucb{ if
/r{cfkgfj k}n
MO, ]BCi}{r {i kntnl5r, m~{ bi~l
if nqunfrg}nk r~mr{cfcfk b}irr {oc{}gq ckk}
f gf {an dgnlk{an kntnliuor gf {an c}nfc
55}r&gf
gf
nf{ang{alw
r{rid
bcl
tnf*{
izfjcfjn{ ‒
l~rclran}c}w
n-
Oc
nkln}nll
co
fkiuf*{
gtn{gclcl` nrr
id nf{id
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 22
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 49/223
g
l
Zi}`gfjnfrg{w ono
coi~f{ id od gfdi}oc{gicucbg{w& G{*r
ctcglcmln, m~{rion bioucf}nrnc}ba zg{ag
c&ROC][
Rbgnf{gr{rgou}itn roc}c}kr m~{ bi
r~mr{cf{gcl gfdi} ~rn mw kion}jnfbw&noi}gnr ki
zgll fi{ znc}
B~}}nf{ ronoi}w&
{an Bili}ckiagjan} bcucbgcr{gfj ono
C}jiffn rgfb
}nrnc}ba {iug}nrnc}ba bnf{
d Nfn}jw !K Fcfioc{n
[an nddi}{d}if{gn} zan
anogr{r zi{an rocllnr{rbgnf{gr{r zi{ijn{an} cr z
Oc{n}gclr355 fcfion
ilnb~lc} bl~
Dgj8f {an fcfirb}gnr zg{a dcoi}w fnnknkf' / i} ntnffi{ blnc} aibioun{g{gif
gnr blcgo {anwf lnrr {gon&BC]KR
c}n ~rgfj {a{ bc}kr& [anrnf{cgf dn}}inli}oc{gif, r~b{i}r, uac}ocflg`n ocjfn{fi{ bion gf
i~{&
Dgj8 Cc}{ bc}kr bc}
C}jiffn }nrRu}gfjr, Bil
g{w bc}k zg{a}w& Fcfioc{an 3715r&
br zi}lkzgk}r c}n mngfjN', zg{a ifn
}gclr bacllnfj
{i ~fkn}r{cf}n uawrgbr,}` zg{a c{io
uc}{gblnr {i` d}io lc}jcuu}icba {a
mnactn kgddn}{n}r !mgllgif{r{n}r c{ {agr rg
F FT]COln bacfjnr {a{n} runnkr c{i r{i}n ifnjgjcmw{n !if
z riif r~bagr anctw, r{czgll actn {a
g} nqun}{grn gc}n {an rgxnb{}gb onoia cr g{r mnc}ngr{r cfk ntngb r{}gur ifbif{cb{ zg{a
OC][ BC]w cmi~{ =>5 ` c}ban}r c}n&, Rwon{}gqc oi}n dln
{n}gclr actnanw c}n fiz
& Rntn}cl flcffnk mw {alg`nlw {i mn mn }nrnc}ban}r
~l{}c/rocllbanogr{}w cfr cfk oilnb~
lc}jn} ifnr} oc{n}gclrfcfirbcln&f{lw gf {an }r id c o
xn ocw mn kg
gr& G{ oncfr agfk onjcmw{nogllgif bac}cn mgllgif mw{bcucbg{w zgl
`nr c}n agja,dg}r{ d}~g{r i
f dn}}inlnb{}gfk racun id bw {ac{ bcf}*r onkgbcl ag
uc}conkgbr g}nkg{ bc}kr, {{ang} }nckn}r
Kglimw{nr id illcmi}c{gfji}u& {i kntnl
qgmln cfk limnnf r{~kgnifn id {an a
firbcln oc{^&R& Knuc}{
~gl{ c{ C}jiff8
c{n}gclr gr ik mgilijwlnr, oitgfj, zagln uawizf& [anw
fjn id rgxn m{n}& C{iogbdn}nf{ bili}r
jan}!{an
b{n}rnr' /l mncfk{agr
r {i}nkg{c}}w
r{i}wgf cfanrncfk
zg{aiu cjn}/
k c{{{nr{
}gclrnf{
n&
{annn{&
d}iorgbclion
nlizcfk
d}io
{aou}
cfrb~
obnF
zbi{aZg
ir~o
fFodnf{aozu}
[f
mo~r{ibi}n{i~ro
id }nid r{nm
rbbiggf
gf
n rcon nlnoi}n banogbcliun}{gnr& Imh
k {i~jan} {agnfbn {ac{ gr {kn}r{iik&Fcfirbcln
~l{glcwn} bcucll uaifnr, cucfi/nlnb{}i/o
Fc{~}n lg`nrlnc}f oi}n
fr{}~b{gif c{n fcfizi}lkn rai~lk dgcjgfn wn{&G{ gr rwfn}
gkn oc{n}gcun}bifk~b{i}cjfn{i }nrgr{g
Dn}}inlnb{}gfioc{n}gclr,cfi b}wr{cllgfnkgbcl, {}cfruc{~}nk gf lijtnl fcfirgxnn}n c}n cr on{clr, n{b․Gfan}n {zi i} oiqgog{w nddnb
n uirrgmglg{gnfi{nbafilijwm&Blirnfnrr
R~ba u}iqgbc~rn {an ocjfn{i/}nrgr{cnk gf biou~{}nck gfkgtgkuun}, g}if crgr{cfbn gf ojn{an}& GMOnk {agr {inbacfgror& [
uanfionfc&rnc}ba {ac{ K+3&= ogllgifcll bl~r{n}rafilijgnr /l` oc{n}gclr d Zn zcf{ {i
clnr cfk c}noon}bgcllwui}{cfbn d}i
{i {nbafilijgb[an fcf
{n}kgrbgulgfc}
f{r i} bioulw }ncb{gtnb{r crrnomln
cf {ang} m~lan di~fkc{gif
dn}}inlnb{}gbrbg{i}r, zagbaulgbc{gif gfnbacfgbcl rwr{i u~{ {agfj
cmi~{ fcfirb{an fcfirbclnkgddn}nf{lw cfk fnz oc{
gr{gb zg{a clr, gfbl~kgf
cfk {an}ocln oc{n}gclr&r c}n h~r{ iJgmrif rcgk&n kgcoifk dg}{c{gif, gfk~r Fcfi Rbgnnddnb{r actnfw i} oi}nckkg{gif, {a
i}n id {an cm{r, zagba bcf
r di} b}nc{gfjc}n nfklnrr&m}nnkr oc{n}
g{w nddnb{r ‒c{n}gclr c}n rfbn, c uanfin} ac}k k}gtncllw, m~{ gf{k ba}iog~ojfn{gb dgnlkrcfk {an ocjb}nc{n ~l{}cn Fcfi/bio
[an }nrnc}bIN }nbnf{lw
c wnc}& G{ gf, cfk bc}}g~ba cr rnogb}io c ogb}i/`fiz aiz u}dgfkgfj fnz
tgcmln& Fcfiaiz s~gb`l
cl cuulgbc{gifocjfn{grod}conzi}` {
i~fkr gf m~lcfk kgrulcwk d}io {ano
bi~f{n}uc}{di} {an {nbaf
clliz ~r {ibi~lk mn ~rnkoi{i}r {i ui{nor&
{ijn{an} gfgnfbn / zanf/ zn zgll mnk b}nc{n fit}gclr, {agfjr
m}ickn} r{}nf}nlc{nk
mc}}gn} bic{g
fn id {an aC}jiffn*r
glor di} ogbr{}gcl cfk cn}fbn R~oog{&mnnf di~fk ggf ocjfn{r,n}n c}n biotn c}n biomg
mn kiogfcf{
fnz ~rnd~l
gcl bacfjnr8
bacfjnr gfi blirn ‒ ranfif kgrbit
& [gfw ocjf}lnctnk fcfilraiz r~mr{cnbc~rn {an lcn{gb }nbi}kgf
rnfrg{gtno~fg{w lii`r
a gfg{gc{gtn gfuu}itnk di}bl~knr c{iorr di}zc}k
ifk~b{i}r / m{}~b{~}cl tgniun}{gnr bacfnddnb{r, rio
rbgnfbn k}czn*tn mnnf
r&-gfg{gc{gtn
i anlu r{cjn {
& [anw mnbifnz nlnb{}ibcf mn r{}if
& Aizntn},ilijw gr r{gll
kntnliu mn{gf ntnf rocl
zn} ogb}i/
n}{cgf zcwr&zn bcf bif{
cmln {i nfjgfl biomgfc{gizn bcf*{ n
j{a gf biougja/{noun}c{jr cfk bilir
{ fnz c}ncri}` zg{a ~l{i ocbagfnrrucbn ~rnrCl{ai~ja o
gf dn}}inlnb{}g~un}bifk~b{irg{n oc{n}g
fnk, gf{}ik~bgf {an fcfirb
c{n}gclr {a}i
c{n}gcl mnactiz ~u gf jg}nk gf 3711{gb mg{r c}n acwn}r id bim{gcl bacfjnr
wn}r c}n ri blj gfk~r{}w ac}k/k}gtn }c{ c zgkn }c
fcfiocjfn{g~fkgfj c{ c }, oilnb~lnrrion nqgr{g
w ~fkn}r{cfkg&n c{ {an rocl
n id zagbar rion id mln {i {~}f {a
u}itgknran fnq{ cktc
onfgbn}
{ani{
{n}ln}fk
Cr}ilnn}fr&nf
lnq~}nrcl
gf}c/di}crfwbr,}r,lr,
gfjln&
ja
gi}cf{fk
c}kcl{,gfrntnckjn
roc{nfk
gfjgfj
ln}c}ng{rrn
cfbn
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 2;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 50/223
gf bioulnq oc{n}gclr }nrnc}ba& G{ {c`nr c m}ick cuu}icba,
zi}`gfj zg{a oc{n}gclr {ac{ dcll d}io c}i~fk ifn ogb}if
!ifn ogllgif{a id c on{n}' gf rgxn {i lnrr {acf 35
fcfion{n}r& Cr {an rbcln knb}ncrnr, {an kiogfcf{ uawrgbrbacfjnr, cfk fnz oc{n}gclr, u}iun}{gnr cfk cuulgbc{gifr
non}jn&
Biou~{n} zi}lk ogja{ ifn kcw mn mcrnk gf ocjfn{gb
u}iun}{gnr gfr{nck id nlnb{}gbcl& [agr ogja{ oc`n g{ uirrgmln
{i m~glk biou~{n}r zg{a c}bag{nb{~}nr {ac{ bi~lk mn
}nr{}~b{~}nk knunfkgfj if {an {cr` id {an oionf{& [an
rcon ocbagfn bi~lk mn bifdgj~}nk lg`n c Ocbgf{ira di}
{cr`r {ac{ c Ocb iun}c{gfj rwr{no un}di}or mnr{ cfk lg`n c
UB zanf Zgfkizr IR gr u}ndn}cmln&
Clri uirrgmln bi~lk mn ocjfn{gb bifdgj~}c{gifr {ac{
zi~lk fi{ mn lgog{nk mw mgfc}w lijgb, oc`gfj {ano oi}n
lg`n {an a~ocf m}cgf& [agr gr dc} czcw, m~{ u}iogrgfj&
R{~kgnr if {an fcfirbcln bi~lk lnck {i mn{{n} m~l`
ocjfn{r cfk oi}n nddgbgnf{ oi{i}r zg{a bifrns~nf{
rctgfjr gf {an ~rn id dirrgl d~nlr& G{ ocw clri mnbion
uirrgmln {i gfbi}ui}c{n ocjfn{gb oilnb~lnr gf uilwon}r,
b}nc{gfj ulcr{gbr {ac{ bi~lk mn ~rnk zan}n {}ckg{gifcl
ocjfn{r bcffi{, di} nqcouln gf bn}{cgf bi}}irgtn
nftg}ifonf{r&
GT& OILNB^LC] BIOU^[GFJ
Oilnb~lc} biou~{gfj ~rnr rzg{banr ockn id c rgfjln
u}i{ngf oilnb~ln& U}i{ngfr -bcf rnld/crrnomln bioulnq
c}}cwr id oilnb~lnr if c r~}dcbn Pfcfion{n}/rbcln
uc{{n}fr_&&&&Ocfw u}i{ngfr ki actn bac}jn/{}cfrdn} cfk
bac}jn/rzg{bagfj u}iun}{gnr, zagba bi~lk&&&mn ac}fnrrnk {i
u}itgkn rion crunb{r id {an gfdi}oc{gif u}ibnrrgfjbcucmglg{w id c rnogbifk~b{i} kntgbn& Lifjo~g}/Mlikjn{{
dglor / {agf dglor id lgugkr / c}n `fizf {i mn cf nrrnf{gcl
uc}{ id {an nlnb{}gbcl u}iun}{gnr id fn}tn bnllr, cfk bcf mn
ockn s~g{n }nckglw gf {an lcmi}c{i}w& Fn}tn/bnll u}i{ngfr
c}n gfrn}{nk gf{i {an lgugk dglo zagba cl{n}r {an dglo*r cmglg{w
{i ln{ gifr ucrr knunfkgfj if zac{ i{an} gifr c}n u}nrnf{ i}
if {an nlnb{}gb dgnlk {i zagba {anw c}n nquirnk& [agr acr
u}ij}nrrnk {i {an r{cjn id m~glkgfj dglor, u~{{gfj u}i{ngfr
gf{i {ano, cfk knoifr{}c{gfj {an nlnb{}gbcl bac}cb{n}gr{gbr
id {an u}i{ngf, zagba gr rgoglc} {i {an uirg{gif zg{a
{}cfrgr{i}r gf 3725B& S^CF[^O BIUOU^[N]R
Rn{a Lliwk id Lir Clcoir Fc{gifcl Lcmi}c{i}wu}iuirnr biou~{n}r -ockn id znc`lw bi~ulnk s~cf{~o
rwr{nor c}}cfjnk gf ifn/, {zi/, i} {a}nn/kgonfrgifcl
c}}cwr& Biou~{c{gifr c}n un}di}onk gf }nruifrn {i
rns~nfbnr id lgja{ u~lrnr gouirnk ~uif {an nf{g}n c}}cw
rgo~l{cfni~rlw& Lliwk raizr {ac{ mw cf cuu}iu}gc{n baigbn
id oc{n}gclr cfk c}bag{nb{~}n, cfk cuu}iu}gc{n baigbnr id
u~lrnr, ncba r~m~fg{ gf {an c}}cw zgll bacfjn {i c fnz
s~cf{~o r{c{n gf c ocffn} {ac{ knunfkr mi{a if g{r
u}ntgi~r r{c{n cfk ~uif {an u~lrn rns~nfbn& An u}nrnf{r c
rgouln u}iid {ac{ r~ba cf c}}cw bi~lk bc}}w i~{ {an d~ll
}cfjn id lijgb iun}c{gifr }ns~g}nk id cfw biou~{n}&-
Di} cfw jgtnf ucg} id s~cf{~o r{c{nr gf {an rn{ id
clliznk r{c{nr id r~ba c kntgbn, {an}n c}n rns~nfbnr id
u~lrnr zagba, gd cuulgnk c{ {an u}iun} {gonr, zgll rzg{ba {an
kntgbn d}io ifn r{c{n {i {an i{an}& Rgfbn {an uawrgbclbifdi}oc{gif id cf imhnb{ gr kn{n}ogfnk mw g{r s~cf{~o
r{c{n, {an bifbl~rgif gr gfnrbcucmln {ac{ cf cuu}iu}gc{nlw
knrgjfnk s~cf{~o -biou~{n}- bcf mn ~rnk cr c s~cf{~o/
onbacfgbcl ogb}iocfgu~lc{i}&
[an s~cf{~o r{c{nr id cf nddnb{gtn ocfgu~lc{i} zi~lk
fnnk {i bi}}nruifk {i ~rnd~l bifdgj~}c{gifr id rion `gfk
id oilnb~lc} c}o& Ocfgu~lc{i}r zi~lk mn knrgjfnk
runbgdgbcllw di} {ac{ u~}uirn }c{an} {acf di} bc}}wgfj i~{
jnfn}cl biou~{c{gifr& Mi{a {wunr id kntgbnr zi~lk,
aizntn}, mn mcrnk if {an rcon jnfn}cl u}gfbgulnr cfk
zi~lk mn bif{}illnk mw rns~nfbnr id lgja{ u~lrnr&
T& FCFIONBACFGBCL BIOU^[N]R
Ntnf zg{a c mgllgif mw{nr id r{i}cjn, c Fcfionbacfgbcl
biou~{n} bi~lk dg{ gf c miq c ogb}if zgkn, cmi~{ {an rgxn
id c mcb{n}g~o& Cl{ai~ja onbacfgbcl rgjfclr oitn cmi~{
35> {gonr rlizn} {acf {an nlnb{}gbcl rgjfclr gf {ikcw*r
ocbagfnr, {anw zgll fnnk {i {}ctnl iflw 35/4 cr dc}, cfk {a~r
zgll dcbn lnrr knlcw&-
TG& FNQ[ JNFN]C[GIF FCFI[NBAFILIJW
BIOU^[N] ONOI]W OCKN ID J]CUANFN8
Bc}mif bionr gf ocfw kgddn}nf{ di}or, d}io {an
j}cuag{n di~fk gf unfbglr {i {an zi}lk*r oir{ nqunfrgtn
kgcoifkr& Gf 3715, zn `fnz id iflw {a}nn mcrgb di}or id
bc}mif, fconlw kgcoifk, j}cuag{n, cfk coi}uai~r bc}mif&Gf }nbnf{ {gonr J}cuanfn zcr clri kgrbitn}nk zagba
bc~rnk c li{ id d~xx cfk gf{n}nr{&
Nqun}gonf{r zg{a J}cuanfn actn }ntnclnk rion
dcrbgfc{gfj uanfionfc {ac{ nqbg{n fcfi{nbafilijw
}nrnc}ban}r zai c}n zi}`gfj {izc}kr oilnb~lc}
nlnb{}ifgbr& G{ zcr di~fk {ac{ J}cuanfn }nocgfr bcucmln id
bifk~b{gfj nlnb{}gbg{w ntnf c{ {an lgog{ id fiogfcllw xn}i
bc}}gn} bifbnf{}c{gif mnbc~rn {an nlnb{}ifr kif*{ rnno {i
rliz kizf i} libclgxn& [agr acr {i ki zg{a {an dcb{ {ac{ {an
nlnb{}ifr oitgfj c}i~fk bc}mif c{ior gf{n}cb{ zg{a {an
un}gikgb ui{nf{gcl id j}cuanon‗r aifnwbiom lc{{gbn, zagba
jgtnr }grn {i fnz s~crg uc}{gblnr {ac{ actn lir{ {ang} ocrr,
i} *}nr{ ocrr* !ri/bcllnk ocrr lnrr Kg}cb dn}ogifr'& [agroncfr {ac{ J}cuanfn fntn} r{iur bifk~b{gfj&
Di} biou~{n} bagur, *roclln} cfk dcr{n}* h~r{ grf*{ jiik
nfi~ja cfwoi}n& Uizn} cfk anc{ actn mnbion {an mgjjnr{
grr~nr di} bagu ocf~dcb{~}n}r cfk bioucfgnr gf{nj}c{gfj
{anrn bagur gf ntn}wkcw kntgbnr r~ba cr bnll uaifnr cfk
lcu{iur& [an biou~{gfj uizn} id {ikcw*r biou~{n} bagur gr
u}itgknk oir{lw mw iun}c{gifr rzg{bagfj c{ ntn} agjan}
d}ns~nfbw& [agr uawrgbcllw gfk~bnk uizn} kgrrguc{gif
}nu}nrnf{r {an lgog{gfj dcb{i} {i c d~}{an} gfb}ncrn id {an
bcucmglg{w id gf{nj}c{nk bg}b~g{r& Anc{ kgrrguc{gif id {an
lc{nr{ Gf{nl u}ibnrri}r acr mnbion c zgknlw kgrb~rrnk
grr~n& Mw {an nfk id {an knbckn, wi~ ogja{ cr znll mn
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 2>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 51/223
Kgcoifkig
fcfi{~mn
dnnlgfj c }ibcd{n} =535, br~}dcbn id {
if{gf~nr {intgbnr, ocfzcwr {i bi
cfcjnonf{&c}mif fcfi{ntgbnr ogja{
ANC[ griou~{n} cf
d~fkconf{cl{an}ocl kgr{}n
c' gfb}ncrnlgdn{gonr@nnugfjdcr{n} rug
m' }ns~g}nr
b' rntn}cl }
k&Knj
o~ba cru}imlnokntgbnr&
n&Gfb
bioulnqcuu}icba
[i }nk~b
dgffnk kntgbcl~ogf~o i}{i u~ll {an}o{}cfrdn} g{ gf{i
^rgfj ogbc}mif fcfi{agur actn u}ddnb{gtnlw crc{n}gcl di}
cfi{~mnr c}n{acf cfw i{an
Kgrbitn}n{agb` rann{ iifrgr{ id ran{an} {i di}o
R~un} fcfi{
n{ fixxln {aou~{n} bagurn r~f g{rnld
ba~}f i~{dcb{~}n}r acmc{ {an u
Fnz }nrnc}ba~mnr !BF[r'u}itgkn c rilmnbiogfj ifk rnogbifkzcwr {an nlnbrr8
Rai}{nfnd 35µB gf iugf acld&
kntgbnr biilfgfj dcfr, z
Bifr~oni}n biilgfj
]nk~bnkbcllr cfk u}i}cknk un}di}
75. id uizncddnb{gfj mc{{
}ncrnk m~glk
anc{ rgf`r cnr c}n k}gtgfjn agja {nou
nr ockn ibiuun} ‒ c}nl nfn}jw cz{an r~}}i~fkg
}i dgf r{}~b{~~mn c}}cwr otnf {ac{ fcfbiuun} ‒ {a
{an}ocl ocfoi}n dlnqgmlbiilgfj oc{
k iflw gf =5bc}mif& Nqg
n{r id j}cuanc rilgk oc{n
~mn Fcfi
cf {i~bagfjbi~lk dnnl lg
& Cr {an nl
oclln} cfkn mnnf bacll}rgr{nf{ u}ir~jjnr{r {accr anc{ rgf
~{gif {i {agr un id {an oirb{i} knrgjf&{}ifgbr gfk~r
u}ik~b{ lg}c{gfj {noun
Gfb}ncrnk iugfb}ncrgfjlwgba ~rn oi}n
} cbbnu{cfbncfr zagba b}}nlgcmglg{w ‛~b{ dcgl~}nr kcfbn ‛ Zg{
} gr lir{ {a}i}w lgdn if cll
bir{r ‛ Ntnk dcfr, cfk~u bir{r&
n}c{~}nr, {ik
bifk~b{gtn{{cbank {i {aw d}io {angfj cg}&
nr ockn id cli~f{nk {i {a{~mnr bcf kgrmnr{ `fizf
jnonf{ cuul, }nrglgnf{, c}gcl ctcglcmln&;, j}cuanfn{gfj di}or in, ng{an} mifgcl lg`n j}cu
{~mn ugun
c bagu& Cfk`n {an m~mmlb{}ifgbr gfk
rlgoon} ui}fjnk {i dgfklno id {an
{ {an gf{nj}c{gr gf{i nlnb{
}imlno&{ b}g{gbcl grr~
[an}n c}n{}w dcbnr j}i
dn{gonr / N}c{~}n b~{r u}n}c{gfj bir{}ns~g}nr oi}nnlnb{}gbg{w&
‛ Oi}nc{n oi}n figr[an}n actn
~n {i anc{&a ]D coulgdgnja anc{, c rn`gfkr id zg}
}/lc}jn} cfkntnf oi}n n
cw*r anc{ rgf
on{cl r~bmcb` id {an
gb}iu}ibnrri
gjfnk o~l{gzn mcb` id rglrguc{n bagu an, m~{ oir{ bgbc{gifr& Cfkk 35 {gonr lg
&gr c dlc{ ifn/d bc}mif mcrgnk if {iu id g{n, }illnk ~u
riifai{
~r{}w
{cmlnfnz}oclf id ifgb
r gfrgq
zgfj
tn}wk~b{
‛cfk
anc{n&mnnf
}r cr}gi~rnlnrr
i}nqi{gb
r ‒
cragurcfk
cllnkgbifc{ crr{lw,{an
a{n}
c{iobcllwncbagf{i
bcfm
O
id i
}mif fcfi{~fi{~mn cr cll racunk d~l
gfgr{n} D~lln}gRi J}cuanf}nulcbgfj {a
n}c{gifr id {a
TGG&
bcf mn r{iun}c{gifr&Runnk id B
gou}itnr {gfkg}nb{lwmcrn ocfc
id nlnb{}ibcucmln id fiogfcllw
kg}nb{ {anr{}~b{~}n,biugnr& Cf{nf {ai~rcfid ifn a~f
mn kntnliu
m~gl{ ~uiflnrr {gon&
u~}uirn id dgnlk gf{i clgtn oi}n b
TGGG& R[N
}nrnc}b
miiogj}nc{ bcr fcf
knnuMgi{nb
cuulgbitn}li
P3_ MB B}cf
Jlimcl Cm~fLifkif, Nfjl
mnr !{agf` J}cuanfn bwlln}nfnr&, h~r{
fnn bcf mn ~rnkrglgbif bag
n Biou~{n}&
N]G[R ID
[a}i~ja Fi}nk cfk bc
Fnz bifbniou~{n}r bcf
[an ~rn ibafgbcllw {anfk clri rn}tnonf{&
[an ^rn id gb kntgbnr&bifk~b{gfj nn}i bc}}gn} bi
C fcfibikgrcrrnomlw
fk {anf kg}cktcfbnk crrk oitgfj uc}}nk c{ior&
Cfk}igkr ck {an}nmw kn
Nqbnllnf{ri {ac{ {anw a
[a~r Fcfid~{~}n onbaclc}jn} mgirb
iodi}{cmln lg
UR DI] KN[NBAF
[an jitn}fa cfk kntnli
Ri~{a Crj nbifiognr
acfbn id mngf{nbafilijw&
R{~knf{r rrnb{i}r r~b
afilijw&
C}{gdgbgcl{gifr o~r{ mknk Rn}tn}r&
]Nkcll, “Fcfi{nbacfbn‟, [an OG
cfk& 3774&
id c rgfjlngfkn}', i} dillg`n {an Bc}
di} fi{ iflwm~{ clri di
CFI[NBA
T]CO lc}jnf mn ~rnk{r }njc}kgfjmn kntnliunk
d Oilnb~lc}c}ncr id jnfnr {an u~}uir
J}cuanfn bcG{ clri J}
lnb{}gbg{w ntnfbnf{}c{gif&
u~{n} rwr{noid cf imh
b{ {an crrnomln} bi~lk
{r, ncba bif{c
fk C}{gdgbgclnliugfj Fcf
fk o~l{gdcbncfkln oi}n b
{nbafilijwfgror cfk {aun {a}i~jan&
ILIUNONILIJW
onf{ rai~lkonf{ id Fcf
gcf Bi~f{}gr~ba cr Gfkg
j dg}r{ {i knt
i~lk raiza cr fcfi{
Gf{nllgjnfbn~rnk gfr{nck
DN]NFBNRfilijw8 Oilnb~l
U}nrr8 Bcom}g
/zcllnk bc}knk gf{i ribif B4 i} M
{an riln u~}umn{{n} cfk
ILIJW
coi~f{ id kdi} lc}jn rb{an iun}c{gi
&
fcfi{nbafil{gbcl nfjgfnn}g
id Lc}jn K
}nk~bn {an auanfn }nocc{ {an lgog{
zgll mn cmlnnb{, }nbi}kmlw id un}d
actn cr ocfwgfgfj cf ctn}
gf{nllgjnfbn}imi{gbr&
{nk rn}tn}roulnqg{w zg{
rn}tnr znll,kntnliur ntagba c ocf
[ ID FCFI
lcw nouacrgr{nbafilijw
r zagbagc Bagfc actliu c dgnlk r
i}n gf{n}nr{nbafilijw
cfk Cfk}id }nlwgfj ~
lc} Runb~lc{gifrkjn, Ocrrcba~r
ifbn}b`
rncr{
c{cclnfcl
jwgfjc{c
nc{gfrid
{ig{rnb{crjn
cf
cfagf
{an}wcf
if
c}nc
ba
iffk
gkif
if{{r0
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 24
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 52/223
P=_ Ki~jlcr O~lacll, “I~} Oilnb~lc} D~{~}n8 Aiz Fcfi{nbafilijw,]imi{gbr, Jnfn{gbr, cfk C}{gdgbgcl Gf{nllgjnfbn Zgll [}cfrdi}o I~}
Zi}lk&‟ U}ion{an~r Mii`r, Coan}r{, Fnz Wi}`, Ac}k Bitn}, 27=
ucjnr, =55=&
P2_ B}gr{gfc M~xnc, Gtcf Ucbanbi, cfk @ntgf ]immgn !=55:',-Fcfioc{n}gclr cfk Fcfiuc}{gblnr8 Ri~}bnr cfk [iqgbg{w-&Mgigf{n}uacrnr =8 O]3:&
P;_ F& [cfgj~bag !37:;', “If {an Mcrgb Bifbnu{ id Fcfi/
[nbafilijw‟& U}ib& Gf{l& Bifd& U}ik& Lifkif, Uc}{ GG M}g{gra Ribgn{w
id U}nbgrgif Nfjgfnn}gfj&
P>_ D}g{x Cllaidd, Uc{}gb` Lgf, Kcfgnl Oii}n, Zac{ gr fcfi{nbafilijw cfkzaw kinr g{ oc{{n}9 d}io rbgnfbn {i n{agbr, uu&2/>, Hiaf Zglnw cfk Rifr,
=535&
P4_ ]ikjn}r, U& !=554'& -Fcfinlnb{}ifgbr8 Rgfjln dgln-& Fc{~}n
Fcfi{nbafilijw&P:_ Rog{a, ]nmnbbc !C~j~r{ 37, =557'& -Fcfiuc}{gblnr ~rnk gf ucgf{ bi~lk
`gll, }nrnc}ba r~jjnr{r-& Lifkif8 [nlnj}cua& ]n{}gntnk Ocw 37, =535&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 2:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 53/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/488 kig8 35& :;275 )GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;275
C Mi~fknk [gon Gounfkgfj Ag{ Kn{nb{gif On{aik di} [nln/ocfgu~lc{i}r
H& @& O~`an}hnn,
BfGK, Macmac C{iogb ]nrnc}ba Bnf{}n,
O~omcg, ;5551>, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{8 Cf nddnb{gtn zi}`rucbn oiknlgfj on{aik {ac{
nfr~}nr dcr{ }imi{/uc}{ gf{n}cb{gif rnfrgfj, di} di}nzc}fgfj
iun}c{i} c{ ocr{n} nfk id ‑ocf gf liiu‗ {wun {nln/ocfgu~lc{i}
rwr{no, gf ‑{gon mi~fk‗ ocffn} acr mnnf kntnliunk& [an
{nbafgs~n ogfgogxnr }~f {gon biou~{c{gif cfk nlgogfc{nr
knunfknfbn if mi~fklnrr rnc}ba mcrnk kn{nb{gif {i nfr~}n }ncl
{gon un}di}ocfbn gf }nclgr{gb {nln/}imi{ cuulgbc{gif&
^fkn}lwgfj oiknlgfj on{aik cfk un}di}ocfbn c}n u}nrnf{nk&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
[nln/bif{}illnk ]imi{gb c}or zi}`gfj cr rlctn cjnf{r
~fkn} a~ocf iun}c{i} bif{}il, c}n tn}rc{gln }noi{n zi}`gfj
{iil gf ai{ bnllr zagba tn}w d}ns~nf{lw bif{cgf uc}{r cfk
r{}~b{~}nr i{an} {acf ocfgu~lc{nk biouifnf{r gf zi}`
nftg}ifonf{& Mglc{n}cl ocfgu~lc{i}r jgtn di}bn dnnkmcb` if
bif{cb{ iflw P3_& ^fkn} fi bif{cb{ r{c{n tnlibg{w mcrnk
kcougfj gr clri iddn}nk P=_& M~{ g{ kinr fi{ knunfk if
zi}`rucbn fngjami~}aiik& Lgog{nk un}bnu{gif id
zi}`rucbn oc`nr n}}ifni~r iun}c{gif agjalw u}imcmln& Ag{r
ocw ibb~}& Oc`gfj {an rwr{no di}nzc}f {an iun}c{i}
cmi~{ }imi{ cuu}icbagfj imr{cbln imhnb{ gr c u}iogrgfj zcw&
Oiknllgfj on{aik di} b}nc{gfj rwr{no }ncb{gif mw if lgfn
nr{goc{gif id blirnfnrr {i imr{cbln o~r{ zi}` gf }ncl {gon&Ocbagfn cb{~c{nk zc}fgfj cfk iuuirgfj cb{gif {i iun}c{i}
zagln cuu}icbagfj {izc}kr imr{cblnr c}n nddnb{gtn gf
goulnonf{gfj rcdn zi}`gfj& [nbafgs~nr di} ctigkgfj
gounfkgfj ag{ zg{a imr{cblnr c}n m~gl{ c}i~fk kn{nb{gif id
gf{n}cb{gif mn{znnf {an imhnb{ oiknlr cfk }imi{ oiknl& [an
‑kn{nb{gif u}ibnrr‗ }nm~glkr {an r{c{n id {an }noi{n }imi{gb
c}o gf {agr oiknl rucbn mw oifg{i}gfj {an {nln/}imi{‗r higf{
uc}con{n}r& [ai~ja di} tn}w rgouln imhnb{r zg{a dnz
r~}dcbnr {an on{aikr zi}`, di} rg{~c{gifr zg{a bioulnq
imhnb{r g{ dcglr& ^rn id BCK mcrnk uc}{ oiknlr gf di}ogfj
zi}`rucbn oiknl un}og{r c~{ioc{gif cfk ri gr c fc{~}cl
baigbn& [ai~ja {anrn c}n nddnb{gtn gf j}cuagb un}bnu{gif
kntnliuonf{ di} iun}c{i}P2_, uirn {an u}imlno id gfkn{n}ogfc{n {gon knocfk gf biou~{gfj gf{n}dn}nfbn zg{a
c oitgfj }imi{& [an u}nrnf{ cuu}icba c{{nou{r c{
cllntgc{gfj {agr k}czmcb`&
GG& U]IMLNO R[C[NONF[
C }imi{ c}o oitgfj gf g{r zi}`rucbn raizf cr ]
!dgj~}n 3' ocw mn cuu}icbagfj {izc}kr cf imhnb{ M& Mw
{}cb`gfj g{r kwfcogbr c oi{gif tnb{i} ‑T ‗ bcf mn
biou~{nk& [an }cfjn id rnfrg{gtg{w gr kndgfnk mw n~blgkgcf
kgr{cfbn d}io zagba {an }imi{ o~r{ mn cmln {i rnfrn {an
cuu}icbagfj imr{cbln& [an}ndi}n G T G id {an tnb{i} gr
lgog{nk {i {agr }cfjn& Fiz gd T gf{n}rnb{r cfw r~}dcbn id
imhnb{ M , {an }imi{ acr rnfrnk {an imhnb{ M& G{ o~r{ mn
uirrgmln {i dgfk {an fnc}nr{ gf{n}rnb{gif zg{agf {agr }cfjn&
Bifrgkn} c zi}`rucbn zg{a imhnb{ C, M cfk B {ac{ c}n
bwlgfkn}r id bg}b~lc} cfk uilwjif b}irr rnb{gif& R~}dcbn
mcrnk ibb~ucfbw oiknl gr ockn d}io BCK oiknlr i}
d}io }cfjn rnfrnk kc{c!2'& G{ biou}grnr {}gcfj~lc} r~}dcbn
rnjonf{r&
[an u}ibnrr }ns~g}nr ncba {}gcfj~lc} r~}dcbn {i mnbifrgkn}nk di} biou~{gfj g{r ~fg{ fi}ocl, biou~{gfj c
tnb{i} uc}cllnl {i {an fi}ocl d}io c jgtnf ] , biou~{gfj g{r
gf{n}rnb{gif zg{a r~}dcbn, dgfkgfj lnfj{a id {agr tnb{i} cfk
biouc}gfj {anrn lnfj{ar di} cll r~}dcbn uc{banr {i dgfk {an
rai}{nr{ id cll& [agr nf{g}n u}ibnrr acr {i mn }nunc{nk& Di}
rgoulgdgnk knugb{gif =K ulcf tgnz c}n raizf gf dgj 3b&
Rnjonf{r 3/=, =/2 , 2/; n{b& }nu}nrnf{ ulcfc} r~}dcbn
uc{banr id imhnb{ M& ]imi{ ‑] ‗ acr kgr{cfbnr d}io {anrn
r~}dcbnr gfkgbc{nk mw L 3 {i L ;& R~}dcbn mcrnk ibb~ucfbw
oiknl id zi}`rucbn gr di}onk cr gfkgbc{nk gf dgj~}n !='& If
lgfn }imi{ r{c{n kn{n}ogfc{gif jgtnr libc{gif ] gf
zi}`rucbn& Gf{n}cb{gif id }imi{ fiz fnnkr {i mn biou~{nk
zg{a {an zi}`rucbn oiknl& M~{ biou~{c{gif id tc}gi~r ‑L ‗fnnkr rnc}ba if cll r~}dcbnr gf {an zi}`rucbn oiknl
bif{cgfgfj {ai~rcfkr id r~}dcbnr di} dgfkgfj {an fnc}nr{
r~}dcbn& ]nk~b{gif id biou~{c{gif gr fi{ ncrw& Cf
gf{n}nr{gfj bcrn gr knugb{nk gf dgj~}n&3/b& [an fnc}nr{
r~}dcbn
Dgj~}n 3 c& Zi}`rucbn gf =K0 m& rnc}ba xifn clifj oi{gif tnb{i} 0 b&
kgr{cfbn {i imr{cbln&
uc{ba =/2 gr di}onk mw fiknr =,2 zagba c}n }nlc{gtnlw c{
lc}jn kgr{cfbn d}io ] ‗& [an r~}dcbn di}onk mw fnc}n} fikn
rn{ >/4 acr kgr{cfbn L 5 zan}n L 5 6 L= cfk L 2& C fikn
kgr{cfbn mcrnk b}g{n}gc o~r{ fi{ mn ~rnk {i knbgkn
bcfkgkc{~}n id c r~}dcbn uc{ba di} biou~{gfj fnc}nr{ imhnb{
kgr{cfbn& U}imlno id dgfkgfj ogfgo~o L nrbclc{nr zg{a
gfb}ncrn id uc}{ bi~f{ gf zi}`rucbn cfk clri zg{a dgfn
r~}dcbn kndgfg{gif id bif{i~}nk mikgnr ! dgj 2'& G{ gr ntgknf{
{ac{ imr{cbln kgr{cfbn biou~{gfj {cr` bcf fi{ mn biouln{nk
gf {gon mi~fk ocffn}& cr f~omn} id r~}dcbnr c}ngfkn{n}ogfc{n& An~}gr{gbr mcrnk rnc}ba rucbn }nk~b{gif c}n
~f}nlgcmln& ^fdi}nrnnf ag{r ibb~}&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 21
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 54/223
Dgj~}n =& Oikclg{w id r~}dcbn oiknl cuu}icba
Dgj~}n 2& BCK oiknlr ~rgfj mi~fkgfj r~}dcbnr cfk ulcfc} r~}dcbn
{}gcfjlnr if {ano di} kndgfgfj imhnb{
Dgj&;c& C {wugbcl zi}`rucbn knugb{nk gf ugb{~}n& M
raizr r~}dcbn {}gcfjlnr cfk {ang} fi}oclr di}onk d}io {an
}cfjn rcouln kc{c id zi}`rucbn gf c &
Gf i}kn} {i riltn {agr u}imlno, ulcfc} mc}}gn} r~}dcbnr
c}n c}{gdgbgcllw ulcbnk cr mi~fkc}gnr c}i~fk imhnb{ bl~r{n}r
cfk c}n ~rnk gf biou~{c{gif P;_& [an k}czmcb` gr {ac{ ~rn}
acr {i ulcbn {anrn mc}}gn}r& Gou}iun} mc}}gn} ulcbnonf{ ocw
}nr~l{ gf rntn}nlw biou}iogrnk zi}`rucbn rg{~c{gifr zan}n
d}nn rucbn di} }imi{ oitnonf{ gr {ii bifr{}cgfgfj& [an
u}nrnf{ cuu}icba c{{nou{r c{ cllntgc{gfj {agr k}czmcb`
GGG& OIKGDGNK ZI]@RUCBN OIKNLLGFJ
C& Tiqnl mcrnk oiknlgfj8
[agr cuu}icba {}nc{r {an }noi{n zi}`rucbn cr cBc}{nrgcf bi/i}kgfc{n 2K til~on& [an nf{g}n til~on gr}nu}nrnf{nk cr {a}nn kgonfrgifcl c}}cw id ns~cl rgxnk
b~mnr zg{a gf{njn} bii}kgfc{n libc{gifr !Q,W,X' P>_& [an
b~mn til~on nlnonf{ gr }ndn}}nk cr *Tiqnl* gf d~}{an}
knrb}gu{gifr& C tiqnl c{ libc{gif !Q,W,X' gr T!QWX' cfk
}nu}nrnf{r b~mn zg{a kgcjifcl fiknr Qg,W h,X` cfk Qg+3, Wg+3
Xg+3 cr raizf gf dgj~}n >c&C j}gk uirg{gif gf zi}`rucbn
zan}n fi imhnb{ nqgr{r gr }nu}nrnf{nk mw d}nn tiqnl& C tiqnl
{a}i~ja zagba c {}gcfj~lc} r~}dcbn ucrrnr gr mi~fkc}w tiqnl
!dgj~}n >M'& Tiqnlr gfrgkn imhnb{ c}n ibb~ugnk& ^rgfj onra
tn}rgif !dgj ;m' c tiqnl oiknl id zi}`rucbn gr ockn !dgj
>b'& Di} BCK oiknlr, kc{c }nu}nrnf{gfj {an 2K racun id
imhnb{ gr crribgc{nk {i zi}`rucbn jnion{}w cr un} g{r uirn
cfk uirg{gif gf zi}` rucbn& [}gcfj~lc} r~}dcbn rnjonf{r gf
BCK oiknlr cr znll cr onra biknk r~}dcbnr P;_ d}io
}cfjn mcrnk til~on ibb~ucfbw oiknlr P>_ c}n
biou~{c{gifcllw gf{n}rnb{nk mw ai}gxif{cl ulcfnr c{ angja{r
oc{bagfj X gf{n}tclr id Bc}{nrgcf bii}kgfc{n rwr{no
r{c}{gfj d}io mi{{io {i {iu id zi}`rucbn&
Dgj&>c tiqnl kndgfg{gif0 m, r~}dcbn tiqnl0 b& zi}`rucbn oiknl
M& Mnfndg{ id {an fnz cuu}icba 8
Rnfrgfj gf{n}cb{gif id ] ‗ zg{a imr{cblnr clifj T fnnkr
{i mn }nlii`nk zg{a zi}`rucbn oiknl gf tiqnl di}o& [anr~}dcbnr id jnfn}clgxnk bwlgfkn} !dgj >' cuunc} cr tiqnlr c{
bi}}nruifkgfj bii}kgfc{n libc{gifr& Di} rgoulgbg{w dgj 4c
raizr =K tgnz c{ rion X tcl~n bif{cgfgfj ] ‗ cfk {an
unf{cjif rnb{gif& Oitgfj clifj {izc}kr imhnb{, tiqnlr c}n
nfbi~f{n}nk clifj tnb{i} T & Dgj~}n 4m raizr {an bcrn
zg{a tiqnlgrnk zi}`rucbn gf 2K& [nr{ id tiqnl T!q,w,x' zg{a
!q,w,x' clifj T gfkgbc{nr u}iun}{w id rucbn cr ibb~ugnk i}
d}nn& R{c}{gfj d}io ] ‗ dg}r{ nfbi~f{n} zg{a ibb~ugnk
u}iun}{w tiqnl jgtnr rai}{nr{ kgr{cfbn id ag{ clifj {}chnb{i}w
T & [nr{ gr mi~fk clifj T di} c dgfg{n kgr{cfbn kgb{c{nk mw
ag{ u}irunb{gfj }cfjn g}}nrunb{gtn id r~}dcbnr cfk ri ctigkr
‑~fmi~fk }nruifrn {gon‗ rwfk}ion& ]ncl {gon un}di}ocfbn
rwfba}ifgxnk zg{a }imi{ gr dncrgmln
Dgj~}n 4& Ag{ kn{nb{gif gf tiqnl oiknllnk zi}`rucbn
GT& NQUN]GONF[CL GOULNONF[C[GIF
Cf nqun}gonf{cl rwr{no biou}grgfj tiqnl oiknlln}
!dgj~}n :' zi}`gfj if u}gfbgucl }ndn}}nk cmitn, c ruan}gbcl
}imi{ c}o {wugbcllw ~rnk gf {nl/ocfgu~lc{gif gf lc}jn bnllr
!dgj~}n 1c' , cf nlnb{}ifgb rwr{no !dgj~}n 7' bcucmln id
higf{ {}cb`gfj cfk {i}s~n cuulgbc{gif {i oi{i}r cfk
`gfnoc{gbr oiknl !dgj~}n 1b' mcrnk uirg{gif nr{goc{i} di}
}imi{ c}o {gu zcr rn{ ~u {i {nr{ {an cuu}icba& [an racknk
rnjonf{ `nnur c oiknl }nckw& C{ }~f {gon {an }imi{ higf{
r{c{n gr {}cb`nk cfk ~rgfj `gfnoc{gbr oiknl g{r ruc{gcl
libc{gif gf zi}`rucbn gr kn{n}ogfnk& Mw biou~{c{gif
nqulcgfnk gf nc}lgn} rnb{gif c di}bn rgjfcl gr cuulgnk {i
{i}s~n oi{i}r knunfkgfj if blirnfnrr id gounfkgfj ag{ {i
kgrr~ckn {an iun}c{i}&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 27
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 55/223
Dgj~}n :& nqun}gonf{cl rwr{no zg{a oikgdgnk oiknllgfj
C& ]imi{ C}o 8 Di} nqun}gonf{r c u}i{i{wun c}o acr
mnnf kntnliunk& Dgj~}n 1/c& raizr {an rcon gf lcmi}c{i}w&
[an `gfnoc{gbr ns~gtclnf{ gr raizf gf dgj~}n 1/m& [an higf{
rnfrgfj gr cbagntnk {a}i~ja agja }nril~{gif nfbikn} zg{a
>555uu} if oi{i} racd{& [an uirg{gif gr {}cb`nk mw agja
runnk bi~f{n}r itn} rucf id ~u {i ³=V23 bi~f{& [an c}o gr
ocf~cllw iun}c{nk gf nqun}gonf{r zg{a 3=55 oo }ncba
zg{a rgknzc}k rzgfj i cfk i}{aijifcl {gl{ +)/
25i
Dgj~}n 1 c& ]imi{ c}o gf lcmi}c{i}w0 m Ns~gtclnf{ KA
}nu}nrnf{c{gif di} {an c}o 0 b& higf{ {}cb`gfj cfk {i}s~n
bif{}il oik~ln
M& Di}bn Cb{~c{i}8 Cb{~c{i}r ~rnk gf {an c}o c}n agjau}nbgrgif cb rn}tioi{i}r !zg{a onbacfgbcl }nk~bn}r',
bcucmln id jnfn}c{gfj oikn}c{n {i}s~n !;&1 F/o'& [i}s~n
knocfk biou~{nk mw {an }ncb{gif nr{goc{gif oik~ln gr
~rnk {i kntnliur iuuirgfj di}bn mw bioocfkgfj {an oi{i}
zg{a c {i}s~n knocfk rgjfcl !}ndn} dgj~}n 1/b'&B& ]imi{ r{c{n {}cb`n}8 ]!q,w,x' gr biou~{nk ~rgfj
b~}}nf{ higf{ uc}con{n}r cfk L }nbngtnk d}io higf{rnfri}r id }imi{ &[an oik~ln ~rnr {}cfrdi}or gfkgbc{nk gf
dgj~}n 7 &
Dgj~}n 7&
T& NQUN]GONF[CL ]NR^L[
Di} {an nqun}gonf{cl }nr~l{r u}nrnf{nk an}n, tiqnl rgxn
gr 3bo Q 3bo Q 3bo, zi}`rucbn nq{nf{r c}n 3>5bo Q 355
bo Q 15bo, {an rnfrg{gtg{w id ag{ gr }nr{}gb{nk {i c
ocqgo~o kgr{cfbn id =5 bo cfk ogfgo~o id 2bo, rnc}ba
gf{n}tcl clifj
Dgj~}n 35 c& Lgfnc} d~fb{gif di} ‑K‗ mcrnk iuuirgfj
di}bn m& {}cfrdn} d~fb{gif u}ij}coonk di} {an {i}s~n
{}cfrk~bn}
T gr 5&1bo& Anfbn ocqgo~o GTG ?=5 bo, ogfgo~o
GTG ? 2 bo [an {is~n knocfk gr u}ij}coonk cr un} lgfnc}d~fb{gif gf dgj~}n 35/m
[an rwr{no gr }~f gf c oiknllnk nftg}ifonf{ zg{a
tiqnl oiknlr id imr{cbln imhnb{& !}ndn} dgj~}n 33'& [an
rwr{no
Dgj~}n 33 }gja{/tiqnl oiknllnk zi}`rucbn ns~gtclnf{ id {an BCK
oiknl raizf if lnd{& Oc}` {an u}nrnfbn id tiqnlgxnk imr{cbln ‑mlib`‗ &
bif{gf~i~rlw {}cb`r {an }imi{ c}o higf{r cfk biou~{nr
uirg{gif id tg}{~cl rnfri} c{ {an lizn} {gu id {an c}o mw
~rgfj `gfnoc{gbr oiknl cfk b~}}nf{ }imi{ higf{ r{c{~r
cfk L&
Gounfkgfj ag{ kn{nb{gif gr kifn clifj tnb{i} T cfk gr biknk cr
uc}con{n} ‑K‗& [an iuuirgfj di}bn bif{}il gr cuulgnk cr d~fb{gif id ‑K‗
raizf gf dgj~}n 35& [an uc}con{n} ‑K‗ g{rnld gr nr{goc{nk mw gf{n}cb{gif
crrnrronf{ oik~ln {ac{ zi}`r if on{aik knrb}gmnk gf dgj~}n 3= &
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 56/223
Dgj~}n 3=& On{aik di} u}irunb{gfj ag{
[an nqun}gonf{cl }nr~l{r actn mnnf }nbi}knk zg{a cqgr
crrgjfonf{r r~ba {ac{ {an oi{gif id r~runfknk c}o uc}cllnl
{i zcll cfk j}i~fk r~}dcbn gr bifrgkn}nk Q oi{gif cfk ifn
fi}ocl {i zcll gr X oi{gif& [is~n u}idgln id {an oi{i}rc}n u}ij}coonk cr un} kn{cglr gf dgj~}n 35/m&[an agja
dgknlg{w C)K biftn}rgif acr 3= mg{ }cfjn& [an agja runnk
kc{c }nbi}kgfj gr kifn c{ >5 rcoulnr un} rnbifk di} id cll
{an }imi{ cqnr, biou~{nk uirg{gif id }imi{ lizn} nfk {gu
cfk {i}s~n knocfk biou~{nk d}io nr{goc{nk uc}con{n} ‑K‗
di} {an jgtnf zi}` rucbn rbnfc}gi& Fi{n {ac{ iflw b~}}nf{
}imi{ higf{ r{c{~r cfk L c}n cbs~g}nk d}io {an }imi{
bif{}il rwr{no cfk {i}s~n }nr~l{gfj d}io {an }ncl {gongf{n}cb{gif kn{nb{gif gr rcoulnk d}io {an gfr{cf{cfni~r
{i}s~n lntnl rgjfcl u}itgknk mw {an bif{}il rwr{no cd{n} 3=
mg{ C)K biftn}rgif ]nr~l{r di} {wugbcl zi}` rucbn
rbnfc}gir !dgj~}n 33 cfk 3; ' cuunc} gf dgj~}n 32 cfk 3> &
Dgj~}n 32& Gounfkgfj ag{ kn{nb{gif }nr~l{ di} zi}`rucbn
zg{a mlib` imhnb{ if }gja{ cr knugb{nk gf dgj~}n33&
Dgj~}n 3; & Tiqnlgrnk zi}`rucbn zg{a {an r{gb` oiknl
}imi{ c}o, mlib` imhnb{ if }gja{ cfk bwlgfkn} if lnd{&
Dgj~}n3>& Tc}gc{gif id {i}s~n knocfk di} di}bndnnkmcb` b}nc{gif zg{a oitnonf{ id }imi{‗r lizn} {gu&
TG& KGRB^RRGIFR IF UN]DI]OCFBN
[an }nr~l{r raizf gf dgj~}nr 32 cfk 3> nr{cmlgra
dgknlg{w id ag{ u}irunb{gfj gf cbbi}kcfbn zg{a {an rnfri}
}cfjn cfk ifrn{ id gf{n}cb{gif }nruifrn ibb~}r c{ =5 bo
d}io {an imr{cblnr oiknllnk gf tiqnl di}o& [an oi{gif gr
nqnb~{nk ocf~cllw cr zi~lk mn kifn fc{~}cllw mw cf
iun}c{i} id {nln/ocfgu~lc{nk }imi{& [agr gr tgrgmln gf }nr~l{rcr uirg{gif jcur& [an {i}s~n dnnk/mcb` iuuirgfj oitnr
fnc}gfj imr{cblnr c}n bi}}nb{ di} mi{a rgknr id iun}c{gifr&
[an biou~{c{gif }ns~g}nonf{r mngfj mi~fknk {i lgog{nk
f~omn}r zn}n r~bbnrrd~llw biouln{nk rwfba}ifi~rlw zg{a
c}o oitnonf{ cfk i}kn}nk kc{c zn}n u}ik~bnk& [an
bl~{{n}gfj c{ tn}w blirn tgbgfg{w id imhnb{r c}grnr d}io
kgjg{grc{gif n}}i}r gf tiqnl di}oc{gif cfk iun}c{i} c}o
irbgllc{gifr cr an dcbnr agja iuuirg{gif di}bn cfk c}o
}nbngtnr ~fgf{nfknk oi{gif& Rgfbn {an ifrn{ id }ncb{gif
d}io imr{cbln gr nc}lw, {an iun}c{i} fnnk fi{ }ncba blirn
tgbgfg{w id imr{cbln cfk bl~{{n}gfj kinr fi{ acoun} fi}ocl
zi}`gfj&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 57/223
CB@FIZLNKJNONF[R
[an c~{ai} gr {acf`d~l {i Ra}g J&U& R}gtcr{ctc, Kg}nb{i},
N$G J}i~u di} nfbi~}cjnonf{& [acf`r {i Ra}g Jc~}ct
Mcl~fg di} nq{nfkgfj r~uui}{ gf nqun}gonf{r&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ A& @cxn}iifg n{& cll& “C Bif{}illn} Knrgjf D}conzi}` di} [nln}imi{gb
Rwr{no‗ GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr If Bif{}il Rwr{nor [nbafilijw‟ , Til& G ,
Fi& 3, Oc}ba 3772
P=_ Hiaf N& Rungba, @ntgf Dg{n ,Ogbacnl Jilkdc}m, “C On{aik di}
Rgo~l{cfni~rlw Gfb}ncrgfj [}cfruc}nfbw cfk R{cmglg{w ]im~r{fnrr gf
Mglc{n}cl [nlnocfgu~lc{gif‟ U}ibnnkgfjr id GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl
Bifdn}nfbn if ]imi{gbr $ C~{ioc{gif, Rcfd}cfrgrbi =555
P2_ H& @& O~`an}hnn , “Biou~{n} Cgknk ]noi{n J}cuagbr Nftg}ifonf{
di} Biou~{n} Crrgr{nk ]imi{ [}cgfgfj cfk Bif{}il !BC]N/BC['‟
U}ibnnkgfjr id Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Onbac{}ifgbr [nbafilijw
=555&Rgfjcui}n
P;_ H& @& O~`an}hnn n{ cl, “Cf Imrn}tn} Mcrnk Rcdn{w Goulnonf{c{gif gf
[nln/]imi{gbr‟ U}ibnnkgfjr id Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn [}nfkr Gf
Oncr~}nonf{r cfk C~{ioc{gif [GOC/=533 Banffcg, Gfkgc
P>_ H& @& O~`an}hnn , “ CG Mcrnk [nln/Iun}c{gif R~uui}{ [a}i~ja Tiqnl
Mcrnk zi}`rucbn Oiknlgfj cfk C~{ioc{nk 2K ]imi{ Uc{a
Kn{n}ogfc{gif ‟ U}ibnnkgfjr id GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn
[NFBIF/=552 Mcfjli}n Gfkgc
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 58/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;37;)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;37;
JNR[^]N MCRNK BIOO^FGBC[GIF C JNR[^]N A^OCFIGK
J R L @ BACFK
KNUC][ONF[ ID NLNB[]IFGBR CFK BIOO^FGBC[GIF NFJGFNN]GFJ
R[&OC]W‗R NFJGFNN]GFJ BILLNJN,BANM]IL^,J^F[^] KGR[]GB[,
CFKA]C U]CKNRA,GFKGC
Cm r { } cb { // Fizckcwr fnz gf{n}cb{gif di}or c}n fi{
lgog{nk mw J}cuagbcl ^rn} Gf{n}dcbnr !J^Gr' oc`gfj
A~ocf Biou~{n} Gf{n}cb{gif !ABG' oi}n fc{~}cl& [an
kntnliuonf{ id a~ocfigk }imi{r di} fc{~}cl
gf{n}cb{gif gr c bacllnfjgfj }nrnc}ba {iugb& Mw ~rgfj
jnr{~}n mcrnk a~ocfigk zn bcf iun}c{n cfw rwr{no
rgoulw mw jnr{~}nr& [an gf{n}/a~ocf bioo~fgbc{gif
gr tn}w bioulnq cfk iddn}r c tc}gn{w id gf{n}cb{gif
uirrgmglg{gnr& Cl{ai~ja runnba gr id {nf rnnf cr {an
u}goc}w bacffnl id gfd i}oc{gif, urwbailijgr{r blcgo
{ac{ 45. id {an gfd i}oc{gif gr {}cfrd n}}nk fif/
tn}mcllw& Mnrgknr mikw uirn, ogogbr cfk i{an}r jnr{~}nr
lg`n uigf{gfj i} acfk zctgfj c}n biooiflw ~rnk& Gf
{agr ucun} {an jnr{~}n kn{nb{gif cfk bif{}il rwr{no id
{an a~ocfigk }imi{ BAG[[G gr u}nrnf{nk ~rgfj cu}nkndgfnk kgclij rg{~c{gif& [an zailn gfd i}oc{gif
dliz d}io jnr{~}n kn{nb{gif {gll {an }ncb{gif id {an
}imi{ gr u}nrnf{nk gf kn{cgl&
@nwzi}kr‛Acfk¥ jnr{~}n,¥ biou~{n}¥ tgrgif,¥ ABG,¥ oc}`gfj¥onf~,¥^MG¥acfk¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥ ¥
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF¥mgs~g{i~r, nomnkknk biou~{gfj, n&j&, gf kionr{gb
nftg}ifonf{r }ns~g}nr fnz a~ocf/biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif
r{wlnr {ac{ c}n fc{~}cl, biftnfgnf{ cfk nddgbgnf{&@nwmic}kr cfk ogbn c}n r{gll {an oir{ biooif cfk
oir{ ~rnk gf{n}d cbnr mn{znnf a~ocfr cfk biou~{n}
rwr{nor, fi oc{{n} gd g{ gr h~r{ c knr` {iu UB, c
fi{nmii` i} c }imi{& Aizntn} {an}n gr cf gfb}ncrgfj
gf{n}nr{ gf kntnliugfj ckkg{gifcl gf{n}dcbnr r~ba cr
runnba }nbijfg{gif, acfkz}g{gfj, jnr{~}n }nbijfg{gif
cfk noi{gif kn{nb{gif, rgfbn {anrn zcwr id
gf{n}cb{gif ocw m}gfj oi}n fc{~}clfnrr gf{i {an
a~ocf/biou~{n} gf{n}d cbn& Gf ckkg{gif oir{ uniuln
{nfk {i dnnl oi}n biod i}{cmln gd {anw bcf gf{n}cb{
zg{a biou~{n}r cfk }imi{r gf {an rcon ocffn}
a~ocfr c}n bioo~fgbc{gfj zg{a ncba i{an}& [angf{n}nr{gfj {agfj gr {ac{ urwbailijgr{r blcgo {ac{
itn} 45. id gf{n}cb{gif rgjfclr c}n {}cfrd n}}nk fif/
tn}mcl P>_&[agr gr ifn id {an oi{gtc{gifr di} {an
zi}` u}nrnf{nk gf {agr ucun}& I~} ocgf jicl gr {i
nr{cmlgra c bioo~fgbc{gif gf{n}d cbn {a}i~ja jnr{~}n
}nbijfg{gif mn{znnf c a~ocf cfk {an }imi{ BAG[[G,
{ac{ r{cfkr di} ]imi{ A~ocf Gf{n}/ cb{gif Ocbagfn&
[an }imi{ o~r{ }nbijfgxn rion jnr{~}nr ockn mw c
a~ocf cfk }nruifk mw runc`gfj i} oc`gfj rion
mikw oitnonf{r&
[}ckg{gifcllw {an}n c}n rion {nbafgs~nr di}
jnr{~}n }nbijfg{gif mcrnk if {an racunid {an acfk i} mcrnk if {an oitnonf{ id {an a~ocf
c}o cfk acfk& Clri {an}n gr fi {gja{ kndgfg{gif di} c
jnr{~}n& Jnr{~}nr bcf mn tgnznk cr c fif/tn}mcl
gf{n}cb{gif cfk ocw }cfjn d}io rgouln r{c{gbrgjfclr kndgfnk mw acfk racunr, cb{gifr lg`n
uigf{gfj {i rion imhnb{r, zctgfj c acfk i} oi}n
bioulnq oitnonf{r {i nqu}nrr gkncr i} dnnlgfjrcllizgfj {an bioo~fgbc{gif coifj uniuln P1_&
[a~r di} }nbijfgxgfj jnr{~}nr g{ gr fnbnrrc}w {i
dgfk c zcw mw zagba biou~{n}r bcf kn{nb{ kwfcogbi} r{c{gb bifdgj~}c{gifr id {an a~ocf acfk, c}o,
cfk ntnf i{an} uc}{r id {an a~ocf mikw& Rion
on{aikr ~rnk onbacfgbcl kntgbnr {i nr{goc{n acfk
uirg{gifr cfk c}o higf{ cfjlnr r~ba cr {an jlitn/
mcrnk cuu}icbanr& [an ocgf k}czmcb` id {agr
gf{n}d cbn gr {ac{, mnrgknr mngfj nqunfrgtn, {an ~rn}
o~r{ znc} cf ~fbiod i}{cmln jlitn, actgfj c li{
id bcmlnr {i biffnb{ {an kntgbn {i {an rwr{no {ac{
}nr{}gb{r {an zi}`rucbn {i c rocll c}nc cfk lgog{r
{an oitnonf{r id {an ~rn}& [an}ndi}n, ifn id {an
mnr{ iu{gifr {i itn}bion {an kgrcktcf{cjnr id {an
jlitn/mcrnk on{aikr cfk {i goulnonf{ lnrr}nr{}gb{nk rwr{nor gr {an ~rcjn id biou~{n} tgrgif
{i kn{nb{ cfk {}cb` acfkr cfk c}or&
Mcrgbcllw, {an biou~{n} tgrgif cuu}icbanr
bifbnf{}c{n if }nbijfgxgfj r{c{gb acfk racunr
!uirn jnr{~}nr' i} gf{n}u}n{gfj kwfcogb jnr{~}nr
cfk oi{gif id {an acfkr !{noui}cl jnr{~}nr'& Di}
{an r{c{gb jnr{~}n cuu}icbanr {an dib~r gr {i
gknf{gd w c jnr{~}n mw {an cuunc}cfbn id {an acfk,
rglai~n{{nr, bif{i~}r, =K i} 2K oiknlr, zagln {an
on{aikr {ac{ bifrgkn} kwfcogb jnr{~}nr c}n
bifbn}fnk cmi~{ oi{gif cfclwrgr & [an}n c}n clri
zi}`r lg`n raizf mnliz {ac{ ntcl~c{
nr mi{
a uirnjnr{~}nr cfk {noui}cl jnr{~}nr&
I~} cuu}icba, lg`n ocfw i{an}r, cgor {i r~uui}{
{an gf{n}cb{gif {i c }imi{ cfk bif{}il rion
oitnonf{r& M~{ mnrgknr {ac{ zn gf{nfk {i gou}itn
{an gf/ {n}cb{gif cfk bioo~fgbc{gif zg{a c }imi{,
cllizgfj {an ~rcjn id jnr{~}nr cfk kgclijr& Cr cf
nqcouln id rion }nlc{nk zi}`, gf acfk racunr c}n
~rnk {i bif{}il c zcl`gfj }imi{ {a}i~ja jnr{~}nr
{ac{ gfkgbc{n bioocfkr cr r{iu, ji di}zc}k, n{b&
[ang} rwr{no acr di~} oik~lnr8 c acfk kn{nb{gif
~rgfj r`gf rnjonf{c{gif, acfk {}cb` gfj, c acfk/
racun }nbijfgxn} mcrnk if bif{
i~}r cfk{
an }imi{
bif{}illn}& Gf cf gf{nj}c{gif id jcxn cfk jnr{~}nr
gr ~rnk {i gfr{}~b{ c }imi{ gf cf crrnomlgfj {cr` &
Mcrgbcllw, uigf{gfj acfkr c}n kn{nb{nk {a}i~ja
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 59/223
¥
r`gf bili} cfk rulgfnr di} bif{i~} knrb}gu{gifr& Gf
P32_ cf c{{nf{gif oiknl d i} a~ocfigk }imi{r gr
kndgfnk ~rgfj jnr{~}nr cfk tn}mcl b~nr& A~ocf
oi{gif cfk jnr{~}nr c}n bcu{~}nk ~rgfj oc}`n}r
c{{cbank {i {an r~mhnb{ mikw&
Gf {agr zi}` zn dib~r if cf cuunc}cfbn mcrnk
on{aik di} }nbijfgxgfj jnr{~}nr {ac{ zgll anlu
gou}itn {an gf{n}cb{gif zg{a c }imi{ cllizgfj {an
~rcjn id jnr{~}nr cfk kgclijr& I~} cuu}icba clri
gfbl~knr c acfk {}cb` gfj oik~ln, {a~r {an ~rn} bcf
oc`n kgdd n}nf{ rns~nfbnr id jnr{~}nr zagln {an
}imi{ `nnur lii` gfj c{ {an ~rn}‗r acfk, zg{ai~{
actgfj {i u}ibnrr {an nf{g}n gocjn ntn}w {gon gf
i}kn} {i kn{nb{ c acfk cfk {anf gknf{gd w c
jnr{~}n& Fi{ iflw mw acfk m~{ clri fikkgfj id anck
n{b& [an u}nlgogfc}w }nr~l{r c}n nfbi~}cjgfj cfk
di} d ~{~}n zi}` zn nqunb{ {i {c` n {an oi{gif
agr{i}w gf{i cbbi~f{ di} }nbijfgxgfj oi}n bioulnq
cfk {noui}cl jnr{~}nr&
[agr ucun} gr i}jcfgxnk cr dillizr& [an dg}r{
ifn u}nrnf{r {an oc}`gfj onf~r cuulgnk di}
kn{nb{gfj {an acfkr id {an ~rn}& [an rnbifk ifn
knrb}gmnr
{an ugn cfk oc}`gfj onf~r cfk {an dillizgfj rnb{gif
nqulcgfr }nbijfg{gif clji}g{aor& [an gf{nj}c{gi
gf{i {an bif{}il rwr{no id {an }imi{ gr knrb}gmnk zagln
dgfcllw zn u}nrnf{nk {an bifbl~rgifr cfk d ~{~}n
zi}` & [agr clri gfbl~knr {an8
c&& Oc}`gfj onf~r di} jnr{~}n bif{}il
C d~fkconf{cl bifbn}f gf cll `gfkr id jnr{~}cl
bif{}il gr zac{ {an bioocfk rn{ rai~lk mn& Nqcb{lw
zac{ acfk uir{~}n
cfk oitnonf{r rai~lk mn ~rnk9 C uirrgmln r{}c{njw
gr {i mcrn {an bioocfk rn{ if c onf~ rwr{no& [an
“lcfj~cjn‟ gr kn{n}ogfnk mw onf~ lcwi~{ cfk
i}jcfgxc{gif, cfk bcf mn ockn b~l{~}cllw fn~{}cl cfk
rnld/nqulcfc{i}w& Jnr{~}nr bcf mn `nu{ }nlc{gtnlw
rgouln& [an crr~ou{gif an}n gr {ac{ Ugn/ cfk oc}`gfj
onf~r c}n nrunbgcllw znll r~g{nk di} {an u~}uirn,
mnbc~rn {anw iddn} c uirrgmglg{w di}~rn}r {i kntnliu
{an r`gll {i zi}` zg{a fi dnnkmcb` d}io {an onf~r&
m&& Ugn/ cfk Oc}`gfj Onf~r[anw c}n uiu/~u onf~r zg{a {an cl{n}fc{gtnr
c}}cfjnk }ckgcllw, id{nf ~rnk gf unf/mcrnk gf{n}dcbnr&
Mnbc~rn {an jnr{~}nr !“oc}`r‟' c}n kg}nb{gifcl ~rn}r
bcf lnc}f {i oc`n rnlnb{gifr zg{ai~{
lii`gfj c{ {an onf~ g{nor& Zg{a nqun}{ ~rn}r, onf~r
fnnk fi{ ntnf mn uiuunk ~u& Agn}c}bagb oc}`gfj
onf~r c}n c
kntnliuonf{ id ugn onf~r {ac{ clliz oi}n bioulnq
baigbnr& [an racun id {an uc{a, }c{an} {acf {an rn}gnr
id kgr{gfb{ onf~ baigbnr, bcf mn }nbijfgxnk cr c
rnlnb{gif& Gd {an ~rn}, n&j&, c fitgbn, zi}`r rlizlw, i}
anrg{c{nr, {an
~fkn}lwgfj onf~r bcf mn uiuunk ~u {i u}itgkn
dnnkmcb`&
b& [an U}i{i{wun
Dillizgfj zn bairn c rbnfc}gi di} {an dg}r{ u}i{i{wun
{ac{ gr znll `fizf {i oir{8 }noi{n bif{}il id cuulgcfbnrgf
c kionr{gb nftg}ifonf{ & C agn}c}bagb onf~ rwr{no
di} bif{}illgfj {an d~fb{gifr id c [T, c BK ulcwn}, c
TB], cfk c lcou gr ~fkn} kntnliuonf{ cfk rion gfg{gcl
~rn} {}gclr actn mnnf un}di}onk& [an u}i{i{wun acr mnnf
rn{ ~u rgoglc} {i c aion nftg}ifonf{ gf cf iunf lcm
)knoi rucbn c{ BGK&
Gf i}kn} {i ocqgogxn runnk cfk cbb~}cbw, jnr{~}n
}nbijfg{gif gr b~}}nf{lw {~fnk {i zi}` iflw cjcgfr{ c
~fgdi}o mcb`j}i~fk zg{agf c lgog{nk c}nc,
cuu}iqgoc{nlw 5&> mw 5&4> o gf rgxn, c{ c kgr{cfbn id
cuu}iqgoc{nlw 2 ocfk ~fkn} }nlc{gtnlw dgqnk lgja{gfj bifkg{gifr&
K& [an ]nbijfg{gif Clji}g{aor
[an biou~{n} tgrgif rwr{no di} {}cb`gfj cfk
}nbijfgxgfj {an acfk uir{~}nr {ac{ bif{}il {an onf~r
gr mcrnk if c biomgfc{gif id o~l{g/rbcln bili} dnc{~}n
kn{nb{gif, tgnz mcrnk agn}c}bagbcl acfk oiknlr cfk
uc}{gbln dgl{n}gfj& [an
acfk uir{~}nr i} r{c{nr c}n }nu}nrnf{nk gf {n}or id
agn}c}bagnr id o~l{g/rbcln bili} gocjn dnc{~}nr c{
kgddn}nf{ rbclnr, zg{a s~clg{c{gtn gf{n}/}nlc{gifr gf
{n}or id rbcln, uirg{gif cfk i}gnf{c{gif& Gf ncba
gocjn, kn{nb{gif id o~l{grbcln bili} dnc{~}nr gr
un}di}onk& [an acfk uir{~}nr c}n {anf
rgo~l{cfni~rlw kn{nb{nk cfk {}cb`nk ~rgfj uc}{gbln
dgl{n}gfj, zg{a cf nq{nfrgif id lcwn}nk rcoulgfj
}ndn}}nk {i
cr agn}c}bagbcl lcwn}nk rcoulgfj& [i gou}itn {an
un}di}ocfbn id {an rwr{no, c u}gi} if r`gf bili} gr
gfbl~knk
gf {an uc}{gbln dgl{n}gfj& zag{n nllgurnr raiz kn{nb{nk
o~l{g/rbcln dnc{~}nr gf c bioulnq rbnfn cfk {an
bi}}nb{lw }nbijfgxnk acfk uir{~}n gr r~un}gouirnk gf
j}cw&
b&& ^MG ACFK
G{ gr c zg}nlnrr bif{}il id aion cuulgbcfbnr tgc acfkjnr{~}nr mw ~rgfj a~ocfigk G{ zi}`r cr jgtnf gf
mnliz dliz bac}{
k& DLIZBAC][ ZI]@GFJ
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 60/223
¥
C& GF[NJ]C[GIF
[an nqun}gonf{r id {an u}nrnf{nk cuu}icbanr actn
mnnf un}di}onk if {an a~ocfigk }imi{ BAG[[G &[an
}imi{ bifrgr{r id c a~ocfigk ~uun}mikw cfk anck
zg{a =; knj}nnr id d}nnkio8 : di} {an oitnonf{ id
{an mikw cfk fnb`, 4 di} nwn oitnonf{ cfk 33 di}
noi{gifcl nqu}nrrgifr&
¥¥
¥Dgj& =& Rb}nnfrai{ id {an Bcon}c
j}i~u zg{a Jnr{~}nKn{nb{i} cfk
BcoRagd { oik~ln& [an gocjn raizr {an
{iil obcm}izrn} zagba bcf mn ~rnk di}}~f/{gon cfclwrgr id {an bif{}il
c}bag{nb{~}n&
¥ Iunf
Acfk
Blirn
k
Uirg{gtn
Iunf 5&73: 5&55 5&
Blirnk
Acfk
5&55 5&1>5 5&55
Uirg{gt 5&55 5&55 5&112
T 5&55 5&55 5&5>5
L 5&55 5&5>5 5&¥¥
Dgj~}n 2 raizr cf gf{n}cb{gif mn{znnf
{an }imi{ cfk c a~ocf k~}gfj {an
nqun}gonf{r&
GT& BIFBL^RGIF
D~{~}n zi}` bifbn}fgfj {an jnr{~}n mcrnk
gf{n}cb{gif zgll dib~r if {an gf/ {nj}c{gif id
tn}mcl cfk fif/tn}mcl gf{n}cb{gif rgjfclr gf{i
o~l{goikcl kgclij rg{~c{gifr&
CB@FIZLNKJNONF[
Zn {acf` ocgflw i~} uc}nf{r zai r~uui}{nk fi{iflw mw dgfcfgbgcllw m~{ clri {nbafgbcllw& Ow
rgfbn}n {acf`r {i ow rgr{n} zai anlunk on c li{
gf {agr u}ihnb{
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_& M}n{xfn}, L&, Lcu{nt, G& $ Lgfknmn}j, [& !=55=' Acfk Jnr{~}n
]nbijfg{gif ~rgfj O~l{g/Rbcln Bili~} Dnc{~}nr,
P=_& Agn}c}bagbcl Oiknlr cfk Uc}{gbln Dgl{n}gfj& R~mog{{nk {i
>{a Gf{l& Bifd& if C~{ioc{gb Dcbn cfk Jnr{~}n
P2_& ]nbijfg{gif&
P;_& Bcllcacf, H&, Aiu`gfr, K, Zngrn}, O& $ Rafngkn}ocf,
P>_& M& !3711' Cf Noug}gbcl Biouc}grgif id Ugn tr& Lgfnc}Onf~r& U}ibnnkgfjr id BAG‗11, uu& 7>/355&
P4_& D}nnocf, Z&[& $ Zngrrocf, B&K& !377;' [nlntgrgif Bif{}il mw
Acfk Jnr{~}nr& Gf 3r{ Gf{l& Bifd& if
P:_& C~{ioc{gb Dcbn cfk Jnr{~}n ]nbijfg{gif&
P1_& J~gom}n{gá}n, D& $ Zgfij}ck, [& !=555' DlizOnf~8 biomgfgfj
Bioocfk, [nq{ cfk Kc{c Nf{}w& U}ibnnkgfjr id ^GR[‗=555,
uu& =32/=34&
P7_& @~}{nfmcba, J& $ M~q{if, Z& [an Lgog{r id Nqun}{
Un}di}ocfbn ^rgfj Agn}c}bagb Oc}`gfj Onf~r& U}ibnnkgfjr id
BAG‗7;, uu& ;1=/;1:&
P35_& Hcbim D}cknf, “Acfkmii` id Oikn}f Rnfri}r8 Uawrgbr, Knrgjfr,
P33_& cfk Cuulgbc{gifr‟, Ru}gfjn} u~mlgbc{gifr =535 nkg{gif
P3=_& @& Ogcfizr`g, F& Rbaog{x, cfk @& Mn}fr&
Onbac{}ifgbr id {an a~ocfigk }imi{}iocf& Gf
Rgq{a Gf{n}fc{gifcl Zi}`raiu if ]imi{ Oi{gifcfk Bif{}il !]iOiBi', M~`izw Kzi}n`, Uilcfk,
H~fn 33/32 =55:&
P32_& T& G& Uctlitgb, ]& Rac}oc, cfk [& R& A~cfj&
Tgr~cl gf{n}u}n{c{gif id acfk jnr{~}nr di}
a~ocf/biou~{n} gf{n}cb{gif8 C }ntgnz& Gf GNNN
[}cfrcb{gifr if Uc{{n}f Cfclwrgr cfk Ocbagfn
Gf{nllgjnfbn, til~on 37, ucjnr 4::‒47>, 377:&
P3;_& D& S~n`& Jnr{~}n, runnba cfk jcxn b~nr di}
kgrbi~}rn rnjonf{c{gif& Gf GNNNBifdn}nfbn if
Biou~{n} Tgrgif cfk Uc{{n}f ]nbijfg{gif, ucjnr
=;:‒=>;, =555&
P3>_& K& H& R{~}ocf cfk K& Xnl{xn}& C r~}tnw id jlitn/
mcrnk gfu~{& Gf GNNN Biou~{n} J}cuagbr cfk
Cuulgbc{gifr, til~on 3;, ucjnr 25‒27, 377;&
P34_& 33& R& Zclkan}}, R& [a}~f, cfk ]& ]ion}i& Cjnr{~}n/mcrnk gf{n}d cbn di} a~ocf/}imi{
gf{n}cb{gif& Gf C~{ifioi~r ]imi{r, til~on 7,
ucjnr 3>3‒3:2, =555&
¥
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 61/223
Uc}{ ‒ GG
U}ibnnkgfjr id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if
Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ =53=
GBBC ‑3=
Til~on ;
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 62/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/488 kig8 35& :;27: )GRMFY5:41CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;27:
Cfclwrgr id Kc{c lirrnr gf Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r rnk gf Ac}ra Nftg}ifonf{
R~fg{c M& @ Lnb{~}n}, Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn Knuc}{onf{
Tgkawc Tc}kac`c billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj
Cmr{}cb{‛ Zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r c}n nqunb{nk
{i mn knuliwnk gf ac}ra nftg}ifonf{r bac}cb{n}gxnk
mw nq{}nonlw uii} cfk dl~b{~c{gfj bacffnl bifkg{gifr&
[}cfrogrrgif n}}i}r c}n gfan}nf{ gf zg}nlnrrbioo~fgbc{gifr mnbc~rn id {an gfr{cmglg{w id zg}nlnrr
bacffnlr }nr~l{gfj k~n {i bacffnl dckgfj, {gon/
d}ns~nfbw bian}nfbn, gf{n}/mcfk gf{n}dn}nfbn, n{b,
cfk {a~r }nbngtgfj ~f}nlgcmln onrrcjn ucb`n{r Coifj
c zgkn }cfjn id rnfri} fn{zi}` cuulgbc{gifr, ocfw id
{ano r~ba cr gf {an u}ibnrr gfk~r{}w, }ns~g}n }nlgcmln
kc{c bioo~fgbc{gifr r~ba {ac{ kc{c ucb`n{r bcf mn
knlgtn}nk {i {an knr{gfc{gif zg{ai~{ lirr ntnf ~fkn}
ac}ra bifkg{gifr& Aizntn}, nqgr{gfj }nlgcmln{}cfrogrrgif {nbafgs~nr ng{an} c}n {ii bir{lw di}
}nri~}bn/bifr{}cgfnk rnfri} fn{zi}`r i} actn lgog{nk
bcucmglg{gnr di} cbagntgfj }nlgcmln kc{c
bioo~fgbc{gif ~fkn} r~ba ac}ra bifkg{gifr&
Gf {agr ucun} zn u}nrnf{ c r~}tnw if kc{c lirr gfZRF ~rnk gf ac}ra nftg}ifonf{& Knrb}gmn {an
ri~}bnr id kc{c lirr cfk dib~r if ctcglcmln
bioo~fgbc{gif bacffnl cfk r{~kw if un}di}ocfbn id
tc}gi~r r{}c{njgnr if N}}i} Bif{}il Biknr Zn clri
u}itgkn c m}gnd r~ooc}w cfk biouc}grif id nqgr{gfj
Bioo~fgbc{gif Bacffnl@nwzi}kr / Zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`0 N}}i} Bif{}il
Bikn0 MN]0 uizn} bifr~ou{gif0 Di}zc}k N}}i}Bi}}nb{gif&
G& G F[]IK^B[GIF
Zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gifr acr rnnf c j}cfkkntnliuonf{ itn} {an lcr{ {ag}{w wnc}r& [an}n c}n lc}jnf~omn}r id tc}gi~r cuulgbc{gifr, zagba gfk~bgfj oi}n
cfk oi}n bioulgbc{nk {nbafgbcl bacllnfjnr& Rion id {anrn bacllnfjnr gfbl~kn agjan} kc{c }c{nr, ~mgs~g{w id zg}nlnrr kntgbnr, {}nfk {izc}kr dcr{n}, roclln} cfkbancun} ac}kzc}n cfk d}ns~nfbw bifjnr{gif, rnfri}ractn lgog{nk mc{{n}w uizn}, lgog{nk {}cfrogrrgif }c{n, cfko~ba }nk~bnk i{an} bcucmglg{gnr&& Ocfw cuulgbc{gif
rbnfc}gir c}n ogrrgif b}g{gbcl cfk bi}}nb{ knlgtn}w id kc{cgf c {gonlw dcragif gr uc}coi~f{ cfk {an}ndi}n ocw {c`n u}nbnknfbn itn} nfn}jw nddgbgnfbw, mcfkzgk{a ~{glgrc{gif,cfk i{an} bifrgkn}c{gifr& [i mn u}nbgrn zn bcf kndgfn un}di}ocfbn cr {an dillizgfj8
3& [an cmglg{w {i cbb~}c{nlw cfk nddnb{gtnlw rnfrn {an
knrg}nk kc{c=& [an cmglg{w {i }nlgcmlw knlgtn} {agr kc{c {i g{r
knr{gfc{gif2& [an cmglg{w {i knlgtn} kc{c zg{agf {an fnbnrrc}w
{gon mi~fkr kgddn}gfj `gfkr id n}}i}r cfk {an coi~f{ id knlcw {wugbcllw r~ddn}nk mw {ang} ~rn& Zn clri gknf{gdwrntn}cl i{an} grr~nr id goui}{cfbn zg{a }njc}k {i }ncl
{gon rwr{nor[an cmglg{w {i cbb~}c{nlw cfk nddnb{gtnlw rnfrn {an
knrg}nk kc{c gr kgb{c{nk mw {an cmglg{gnr id {an rnfri}r,{ang} oikn id iun}c{gif cfk {ang} uawrgbcl knuliwonf{}nlc{nk zg}nlnrr bacffnl &[an zg}nlnrr }ckgi bacffnl gr crac}nk, fc{~}cllw lgog{nk }nri~}bn zagba acr cbac}cb{n}gr{gb {ac{ tc}gnr zg{a {gon, d}ns~nfbw cfk rucbn&
]ckgi zctnr c}n cddnb{nk mw tc}gi~r uanfionfc zagbabcf bc~rn n}}i}r cfk cddnb{ {an s~clg{w id
bioo~fgbc{gifr& Gf {agr Ucun} zn actn kgrb~rrnkkgddn}nf{ uawrgbcl cfk r{c{gr{gbcl oiknlr {i bac}cb{n}gxn{an zg}nlnrr bacffnlr nfbi~f{n}nk gf ac}rabioo~fgbc{gif nftg}ifonf{& Clri g{ nqcogfnr {an bc~rnrid kc{c lirr gf rnfri} fn{zi}`r cfk {an r{}c{njgnr ~rnk {i
c{{cgf }nlgcmln kc{c {}cfrogrrgif& [an}n c}n rntn}cl{nbafgs~nr ctcglcmln {i gfb}ncrn kc{c }nlgcmglg{w, n&j&,n}}i} bif{}il biknr cfk }n{}cfrogrrgifr, m~{ {i rnlnb{ {an mnr{ on{aik g{ gr nrrnf{gcl {i actn rion `fizlnkjn id {anbac}cb{n}gr{gbr id {an zg}nlnrr bacffnl& Gf ckkg{gif, ocfwbioo~fgbc{gif rwr{nor c}n ntcl~c{nk ~rgfj biou~{n}
rgo~lc{gifr id Oif{n/Bc}li {wun& Gf {anrn bcrnr coc{anoc{gbcl oiknl id {an zg}nlnrr bacffnl gr fnnknk&
[an bir{ id goulnonf{gfj {anrn {nbafgs~nr acr mnnfoncr~}nk u}goc}glw gf {n}or id nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif& Cf~fkn}lwgfj u}imlno, kgr}njc}knk mw u}ntgi~r }nrnc}ba, gr{ac{ }nlgcmglg{w onbacfgror bcf b}nc{n knlcwr zagba bc~rn u}imlnor di} knlcw gf{iln}cf{ cuulgbc{gifr& R~ba c
u}imlno c}nc acr fi{ u}ntgi~rlw mnnf kndgfnk gf ZRF}nrnc}ba& Zn gf{nfk {i gftnr{gjc{n tc}gi~r }nlgcmglg{wr{}c{njgnr nouliwnk gf zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r cfkkgrb~rr {ang} cuulgbcmglg{w {i kgddn}gfj `gfkr id n}}i}r cfk{an coi~f{ id knlcw {wugbcllw r~ddn}nk mw {ang} ~rn& Znclri gknf{gdw rntn}cl i{an} grr~nr id goui}{cfbn zg{a}njc}k {i }ncl {gon rwr{nor
[an }nr{ id {an ucun} gr i}jcfgrnk cr dillizr& Rnb{gif
GG kgrb~rrnr {an bc~rnr id kc{c lirr gf rnfri} fn{zi}`r&Rnb{gif GGG kgrb~rrnr {an kgddn}nf{ oiknlr di} zg}nlnrrrnfri} fn{zi}` bacffnlr& Rnb{gif GT kgrb~rrnr }nlgcmglg{wr{}c{njgnr {i u}ntnf{ kc{c lirr cfk {an nddnb{r id goulnonf{gfj {an }nlgcmglg{w r{}c{njgnr kgrb~rrnk if kc{c
knlgtn}w knlcw& Rnb{gif T kgrb~rrnr {an Nfn}jw oiknl di} zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`& Rnb{gif TG bifbl~knr {an ucun}&
GG& BC^RNR ID KC[C LIRR
C r{}c{njw {i nfr~}n }nlgcmglg{w gf c rnfri} fn{zi}`
acr c f~omn} id imr{cblnr {i itn}bion& [anrn ri~}bnr id kc{c lirr gfbl~kn8
3& Lirrnr gf {an zg}nlnrr bacffnl k~n {i gf{n}dn}nfbn
cfk uawrgbcl nddnb{r=& OCB lcwn} lirrnr k~n {i billgrgifr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 63/223
2& Lirrnr k~n {i fikn }nlc{nk n}}i}r i} dcgl~}nr;& Lirrnr k~n {i }i~{gfj dcgl~}n[an zg}nlnrr bacffnl gr gfan}nf{lw lirrw cfk
nqun}gnfbnr mi{a mg{ cfk m~}r{ n}}i}r bc~rnk mw
gf{n}dn}nfbn d}io i{an} zg}nlnrr kntgbnr, cfk o~l{guc{anddnb{r bc~rnk mw {an nftg}ifonf{&
Gf ckkg{gif {an zg}nlnrr rgjfcl ocw mn cmri}mnk i} mlib`nk mw bn}{cgf imhnb{r& [agr u}imlno gr bioui~fknk mw {an dcb{ {ac{ {an zg}nlnrr bacffnl gr fi{ bifr{cf{ itn} {gon P2_, P;_& G{ gr id{nf crr~onk {ac{ n}}i}r gf {anzg}nlnrr bacffnl ibb~} cr c r{c{gr{gbcl kgr{}gm~{gif id mg{n}}i}r& Aizntn}, gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r g{ acr mnnf
imrn}tnk {ac{ n}}i}r bcf mn m~}r{w gf fc{~}n cfk bcfnddnb{ rgjfgdgbcf{ c}ncr id {an fn{zi}` di} c un}gik id
{gon mndi}n kgrcuunc}gfj P>_& K~}gfj {anrn un}gikr g{ grid{nf gouirrgmln {i rnfk i} }nbngtn d}io cfw id {ancddnb{nk fiknr&
Cbbnrrgfj {an OCB lcwn} ocw lnck {i n}}i}r gf rion
uc}{gb~lc} bcrnr& G{ gr id{nf crr~onk, gfbi}}nb{lw, {ac{
fikn biffnb{gtg{w gr mg/kg}nb{gifcl cfk {agr gr rion{gonrfi{ {an bcrn& Gf {anrn uc}{gb~lc} gfr{cfbnr OCB lcwn} n}}i}r bcf ui{nf{gcllw ibb~}& Bif{nf{gif mcrnk OCB u}i{ibilr, zan{an} ~rgfj billgrgif ctigkcfbn i} fi{, dcllrdi~l id {agr bifkg{gif tgc {an agkknf {n}ogfcl u}imlno&
[wugbcllw, billgrgif ctigkcfbn rbanonr crr~on mg/kg}nb{gifcl biffnb{gtg{w zagln BROC rbanonr nqulgbg{lw
gjfi}n {an u}imlno& ]nr~l{r d}io P2_, P;_ r~jjnr{ {ac{ mg/kg}nb{gifcl biffnb{gtg{w crr~ou{gifr c}n ~f}nclgr{gb&I{an} OCB u}i{ibilr zagba bii}kgfc{n zg{a i{an} fiknrgf i}kn} {i c~{ioc{gbcllw bifdgj~}n {anornltnr ocw clri mn r~rbnu{gmln {i n}}i}r bc~rnk mw crwoon{}gbclbiffnb{gtg{w& [agr gr uc}{gb~lc}lw {}~n zan}n c~{ioc{gb
bl~r{n}gfj cfk rwfba}ifgxc{gif gr gftiltnk&C fikn ocw nqun}gnfbn c dcgl~}n i} ocw rgoulw dcgl
{i di}zc}k c onrrcjn di} c f~omn} id }ncrifr& Ac}kzc}ndcgl~}n, mc{{n}w dcgl~}n, knr{}~b{gif id {an fikn, n{b&, gr fi{~fbiooif coifj rnfri} fiknr cfk {agr bcf }nr~l{ gflir{ onrrcjnr& Crgkn d}io {agr, bifr{}cgf{r if onoi}w
cfk m~ddn} rucbn bcf bc~rn c ucb`n{ {i mn k}iuunk& Di} nqcouln, bn}{cgf }ckgir actn c rgfjln m~ddn} rucbn cfk gd
cf gfbiogfj ucb`n{ gr fi{ acfklnk mndi}n {an fnq{ ucb`n{c}}gtnr ifn id {an ucb`n{r o~r{ mn k}iuunk& Gf jnfn}cl,fiknr zg{a c anctw }i~{gfj lick ocw mn cmln {i ailk cdgfg{n s~n~n id onrrcjnr gf onoi}w czcg{gfj
{}cfrogrrgif& U}imlnor c}grn zanf {}cddgb lickr zg{agf
{an fn{zi}` cfk if c uc}{gb~lc} fikn, c}n anctw cfk)i} {an fikn nqun}gnfbnr kgddgb~l{w cbbnrrgfj {an{}cfrogrrgif onkgc& [a~r k}iuunk ucb`n{r bcf ibb~}& C}i~{n ocw dcgl di} cfw id {an }ncrifr knrb}gmnk cmitn&Lgf` n}}i}r, un}gikr id bifjnr{gif cfk fikn n}}i}r bcfbc~rn c knrgjfc{nk }i~{n {i mnbion kgrbiffnb{nk& Rai~lkc fikn dgfk g{rnld ~fcmln {i di}zc}k c onrrcjn {izc}kr g{r
knr{gfc{gif g{ zgll tn}w lg`nlw k}iu {an ucb`n{ cd{n} c un}gik id {gon acr nqug}nk& Gf {agr bcrn cf cl{n}fc{gtn}i~{n gr fnbnrrc}w cfk gd c onrrcjn gr {i mn r~bbnrrd~llwknlgtn}nk, ifn o~r{ ng{an} cl}nckw mn di}onk i} b}nc{nkcr fnnknk&
GGG& OIKNLR ID ZG]NLNRR RNFRI] BACFFNLR
Zn fnnk oiknlr di} {an zg}nlnrr bacffnlr {i ntcl~c{nkgddn}nf{ bioo~fgbc{gif u}i{ibilr ~rgfj biou~{n}
rgo~lc{gifr& Di} {agr }ncrif, zn fnnk {i kntnliu on{aikr
{i knrb}gmn {ang} kgddn}nf{ u}iun}{gnr oc{anoc{gbcllw&^r~cllw, knrb}gmgfj cll uanfionfc zagba bcf bc~rnn}}i}r gr {ii c bioulnq u}imlno& Rgfbn {an }nbngtnk
rgjfcl r{}nfj{a kn{n}ogfnr {an un}di}ocfbn id c rwr{no,g{ gr tg{cl {i `fiz {an uc{a lirr cfk {an dckgfj r{c{gr{gbr&
Rgfbn {an }nbngtnk rgjfcl r{}nfj{a gr c }cfkio tc}gcmln,zn bcf fntn} mn r~}n {ac{ bioo~fgbc{gif zgll mnr~bbnrrd~l& Zn knrb}gmn {an dckgfj oc}jgf mw b~o~lc{gtnkgr{}gm~{gif d~fb{gif !bkd'& Mw g{, zn bcf bclb~lc{n {an u}imcmglg{w {ac{ {an }nbngtnk rgjfcl uizn} gr lizn} {acf cbn}{cgf tcl~n& G{ gr biooif u}cb{gbn gf bioo~fgbc{gif
{ani}w {i oiknl c bacffnl zg{a {a}nn kgddn}nf{biouifnf{r8 o~l{guc{a dckgfj, uc{a lirr cfk figrn&
[wugbcllw, {agr di}o~lc gr ~rnk {i oiknl c bacffnl8w!{' ? c!{' Ú m!k'Ú q!{' + f!{'
An}n c!{' }nu}nrnf{r dckgfj / c o~l{gulgbc{gtn }cfkiotc}gcmln, m!k' uc{a lirr, zagba bcf mn kn{n}ogfgr{gb cfk
f!{' gr figrn&2&3& Dckgfj cfk O~l{guc{a Oiknlr
If c rai}{/kgr{cfbn rbcln zn bcf fi{gbn dl~b{~c{gifrbiouc}cmln zg{a ifn zctnlnfj{a bcllnk rocll/rbclndckgfj& Rliz dckgfj bcf mn bc~rnk mw rackizgfj, zan}nlc}jn imr{}~b{gif imrb~}nr {an ocgf rgjfcl uc{a& Gd {an
imrn}tc{gif zcr ockn itn} lifj kgr{cfbnr, g{ zgll jgtn ~roi}n rlizlw tc}wgfj tgnz& R~ba lc}jn/rbcln dckgfj gr
nqulcgfnk mw {an rliz lirr id {an }nbngtnk rgjfcl uizn}&Lc}jn/rbcln u}iucjc{gif oiknlr u}nkgb{ {an oncf rgjfclr{}nfj{a, zagln {an rocll/rbcln u}iucjc{gif oiknlr u}nkgb{ {an }cugk dl~b{~c{gifr& Knunfkgfj if {an Lgfn Id Rgja{ !LIR' biouifnf{ cfk {an f~omn} id Fif Lgfn Id Rgja{ !FLIR' biouifnf{r, kgddn}nf{ oiknlr c}n ~rnk&
Ckkg{gtn Zag{n Jc~rrgcf Figrn !CZJF' }nu}nrnf{rbioo~fgbc{gif gf d}nn rucbn, zan}n iflw c r{}ifj LIRbiouifnf{ nqgr{r& Gf oir{ }nclgr{gb bcrnr, {an}n c}n clriifn i} oi}n FLIR biouifnf{r& [an ]gbgcf kgr{}gm~{gifoiknlr c LIR biouifnf{ cfk rntn}cl FLIR& [an @/dcb{i} id {an ]gbgcf kgr{}gm~{gif knrb}gmnr {an r{}nfj{a id
{an LIR biouifnf{ cr biouc}nk {i {an FLIR, n&j& zanf@ # 3, zn jn{ CZJF cfk di} @ ? 5, {an}n gr fi LIR cfk{an dckgfj acr ]cwlngja kgr{}gm~{gif& Rion goui}{cf{dckgfj oiknlr c}n i~{lgfnk mnliz&
2&=& Figrn Oiknl
Ckkg{gtn zag{n Jc~rrgcf figrn !CZJF' gr clzcwr
u}nrnf{ gf {an }ncl lgdn mnbc~rn g{ bionr d}io ocfwfc{~}cl ri~}bnr lg`n nc}{a cfk {an R~f& G{ biou}grnr Hiaf/
Fws~gr{, rai{ figrn, mlcb` mikw }ckgc{gif& G{ bcf mn ~rnkclifn di} rc{nllg{n cfk knnu rucbn bioo~fgbc{gif lgf`r,i} zg{a i{an} oiknlr, m~{ {anf g{ iflw }nbifr{}~b{r {an mcb`j}i~fk figrn !gf {n}}nr{}gcl nftg}ifonf{' i} {annlnb{}if oitnonf{r gf biouifnf{r, zagba bcf mnoiknllnk cr CZJF k~n {i {an bnf{}cl lgog{ {ani}no&
2&2 Mgfc}w N}cr~}n Bacffnl[an mgfc}w n}cr~}n bacffnl !MNB' bcf {}cfrog{ ifn
id {zi rwomilr, 5 cfk 3& [an mg{ bcf jn{ n}crnk gf {an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 64/223
bacffnl, m~{ gd {an }nbngtn} }nbngtnr {an mg{, g{ o~r{ mnbi}}nb{& {an u}imcmglg{w id n}cr~}n gr ∍, zagln {an u}imcmglg{gnr id jn{{gfj {an bi}}nb{ mg{ c}n 3/∍& Cf GUfn{zi}` bcf mn oiknllnk cr c MNB& Ng{an} c ucb`n{
c}}gtnr i} {anf g{ gr bi}}nb{, g&n& g{ ucrrnk {an n}}i} kn{nb{gif banb`, i} g{ gr z}ifj cfk {anf k}iuunk, g&n&
n}cr~}n& rocll angja{& [i{cl uc{a lirr bifrgr{r id {an d}nnrucbn uc{a lirr UL5, o~l{g rb}nnf lirr clifj {an u}iucjc{gif uc{a Lork cfk c{{nf~c{gif d}io {an lcr{}iid/nkjn {i {an oimgln r{c{gif, bcllnk }iid{iu/{i/r{}nn{kgdd}cb{gif cfk rbc{{n} lirr, L}{r, UL ? UL5 + L}{r +Lork8
GT& ]NLGCMGLG[W R[]C[NJGNR
[an}n c}n c{ u}nrnf{ c f~omn} id kgddn}nf{ }nlgcmglg{wr{}c{njgnr {ac{ bcf mn ~rnk gf biomgfc{gif i} fkgtgk~cllw&
[anrn bcf mn blcrrgdgnk mw {an uc}{gb~lc} u}imlno c}nc{ac{ {anw c{{nou{ {i ckk}nrr& Gf {agr rnb{gif zn actnbifrgkn}nk kc{c {}cfrogrrgif {nbafgs~nr }nlc{nk {i lgf`
lcwn} kc{cC f~omn} id {nbafgs~nr nqgr{ zagba ckk}nrr {an fnnk
di} }nlgcmglg{w c{ {an lgf` lcwn}& Lgf` lcwn} }nlgcmglg{w
onbacfgror bcf mn nddnb{gtn gf gfb}ncrgfj {an }nlgcmglg{wid c rgfjln lgf` m~{ dcgl {i nlgogfc{n {an nddnb{r id }i~{ndcgl~}n cfk iflw uc}{gcllw }noitn {an nddnb{r id fikn n}}i} cfk dcgl~}n& Gf {agr }njc}k ckkg{gifcl onbacfgror c}nfnnknk& Di}zc}k n}}i} bi}}nb{gif !DNB' }nlgnr if}nk~fkcf{ kc{c mngfj cuunfknk if{i {an nqgr{gfj kc{c& Mg{
n}}i}r {ac{ ibb~} bcf mn kn{nb{nk cfk bi}}nb{nk P>_, P4_&Tc}gi~r {wunr id biknr nqgr{ zg{a tc}gi~r u}iun}{gnr& Gfjnfn}cl {an r{}ifjn} {an bikn {ac{ cf DNB ~rnr {an oi}n mg{ n}}i}r g{ bcf r~bbnrrd~llw kn{nb{ cfk bi}}nb{& Gf
jnfn}cl, {an r{}ifjn} {an DNB {an oi}n }nk~fkcf{ mg{r c}nfnnknk {a~r gfb}ncrgfj {}cfrogrrgif {gon& [an ~rn id tc}gcmln DNB r{}nfj{a knunfkgfj if ucb`n{ goui}{cfbnzcr gftnr{gjc{nk gf P4_& ]nbnf{ }nrnc}ba acr raizf {ac{
{an ~rn id n}}i} bi}}nb{gfj biknr gr id lgog{nk ~rn gfrnfri} fn{zi}`r P>_ rgfbn n}}i}r c}n {wugbcllw m~}r{w gffc{~}n& Gf nrrnfbn P>_ knrb}gmnr {ac{ zan}n m~}r{ n}}i}ribb~} {an f~omn} id }nk~fkcf{ mg{r fnbnrrc}w di} bi}}nb{gif gr u}iagmg{gtnlw nqunfrgtn& Rgfbn, m~}r{ n}}i}rc}n biooif gf zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r g{ gr }ncrifcmln
{i bifbl~kn {ac{ DNBr c}n id lgog{nk tcl~n& Gd DNBr c}n~rnk {an ckkg{gifcl }nk~fkcf{ kc{c {c`nr ckkg{gifcl {gon{i nfbikn, {}cfrog{ cfk ckkg{gifcl {gon {i knbikn& Gf
jnfn}cl, {an r{}ifjn} {an DNB {an oi}n }nk~fkcf{ mg{r c}nfnnknk {a~r gfb}ncrgfj {}cfrogrrgif {gon& Aizntn} {agr{gon gr ~r~cllw }nlc{gtnlw rocll& [an {gon {c`nf {i nfbikn
cfk knbikn DNB biknr knunfk if {an cmglg{gnr id {anrnfri} fikn cfk {an bioulnqg{w id {an DNB bikn ~rnk&Rgfbn u}ibnrrgfj uizn} if rnfri} fiknr gr }nlc{gtnlw liz{agr ocw {c`n s~g{n c lifj {gon& Aizntn}, if {an Krwr=>g{ gr uirrgmln {i ckk r{cb`cmln ac}kzc}n lcwn}r, ifn id zagba gr cf DUJC zagba bcf mn ~rnk {i j}nc{lw runnk {annfbikgfj cfk knbikgfj id DNB biknr
Dgj~}n 3 DNB knlcw r~oonk itn} f~omn} id aiur
[an {gon {c`nf {i nfbikn, {}cfrog{, }nbngtn cfkknbikn cf DNB bcf mn knrb}gmnk cr dillizr8
Zan}n Nfbikn DNB cfk KnbiknDNBgr {an {gon {c`nf {infbikn cfk knbikn }nrunb{gtnlw, cfk [q)]qkc{c+anckn}+DNB
gr {an {gon {c`nf {i {}cfrog{ {an kc{c, {an anckn} cfk{an ckkg{gifcl mg{r di} {an DNB }nrunb{gtnlw {i {an
}nbngtn}& Bifrgkn} Dgj& 3& Zn ntcl~c{n {an {i{cl{}cfrogrrgif {gon di} c onrrcjn itn} c tc}gcmln f~omn} id aiur ~rgfj Ns~c{gif 3& [an {gon {c`nf {i {}cfrog{ cfk}nbngtn c ucb`n{ zg{ai~{ ckkg{gif DNB biknr gr ;ogllgrnbifkr !{wugbcl {}cfrogrrgif {gon if Krwr=> fikn'&[an ckkg{gifcl {gon {c`n {i {}cfrog{ cfk }nbngtn {an DNB
gr ;or& OCB cbbnrr gr bifrgkn}nk bifr{cf{ cfk {c`nr 34or !{wugbcl OCB cbbnrr {gon if Krwr=> fikn ~rgfj
bif{nf{gif mcrnk OCB u}i{ibil ~fkn} onkg~o {}cddgb'&[an {gonr {c`nf {i nfbikn cfk knbikn c}n knrb}gmnk gfDgj&3 cfk c}n 1or cfk 2=or }nrunb{gtnlw& Fi{n {ac{ gf {an
dillizgfj dgj~}nr !Dgj& 3 {i ;' {an tcl~n di} {an OCBcbbnrr {gon gr bifrgkn}nk {i mn bifr{cf{ cfk {an di}n {an}nr~l{cf{ j}cuar cuunc} lgfnc} zan}ncr gf c }ncl fn{zi}`
{anw zgll mn oi}n }cfkio cfk cddnb{nk mw bacfjnr gf{}cddgb bc~rn mw lifjn} ucb`n{ rgxn cfk }n{}cfrogrrgifn{b&& C]S u}i{ibilr ocw ~rn o~l{guln }nunc{{}cfrogrrgifr {i nfr~}n bi}}nb{ kc{c knlgtn}w mn{znnf{zi fiknr& Imtgi~rlw {agr zgll actn c rgjfgdgbcf{ nddnb{if {an knlcw gfb~}}nk& Aizntn} fi{n {ac{ C]S u}i{ibilr
c}n gfan}nf{lw }nrglgnf{ {i m~}r{ n}}i}r rgfbn {an }nunc{onrrcjnr c}n {noui}cllw kgrulcbnk d}io ncba i{an}&]nunc{gfj c onrrcjn bcf clri anlu {i conlgi}c{n {annddnb{r id mi{a fikn n}}i}r cfk, gf rion bcrnr, OCBn}}i}r& [an {gon {c`nf {i r~bbnrrd~llw rnfk c ucb`n{ zanf~rgfj }nunc{ lgf` lcwn} {}cfrogrrgifr gr cr {an dillizgfj
u}imcmglg{w8
zan}n uk}iu gr {an u}imcmglg{w {ac{ c ucb`n{ gr lir{ if{an zg}nlnrr lgf`, f gr {an f{a {}cfrogrrgif rnf{, cfk[gonI~{ gr {an {gon c fikn zcg{r di} cf CB@ {i mn}nbngtnk& [an rcon tcl~nr di} [ q)]q cfk POCBcbbnrr_
cr ~rnk gf Dgj& 3c}n ~rnk !; cfk 34or'&[an {goni~{ {c`nr4or& [an knlcw di} c tc}wgfj f~omn} id }n{}cfrogrrgifrgr bifrgkn}nk&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ;7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 65/223
Dgj = Agja s~clg{w i} cl{n}fc{n }i~{n knlcw
Dgj 2 Knlcw k~n {i }i~{gfj
Dgj ; Knlcw gfb~}}nk mw nfk {i nfk on{aikr ~rgfj ][[
T& NFN]JW OIKNL DI] ZG]NLNRR
RNFRI] FN[ZI]@
Nfn}jw bifr~onk c{ fikn lntnl bcf mn biou~{nk crdillizr8
Zan}nN{i{cl8 [i{cl nfn}jw bifr~onk gf {an fn{zi}` Nnfb8 Nfn}jw bifr~onk mw {an nfbikn} c{ {an dg}r{
fiknN[Q8 Nfn}jw bifr~onk gf {}cfrogrrgif mw cll fiknrN]Q8 Nfn}jw bifr~onk gf }nbngtgfj {an kc{c mw cll
fiknrnqbnu{ dg}r{ ifn
Zan}no8 F~omn} id aiur
Fm8 [i{cl f~omn} id mg{r {}cfrog{{nk
N{q8 Nfn}jw bifr~onk gf {}cfrog{{gfj c rgfjln mg{d}io cfikn
N}q8 Nfn}jw bifr~onk gf }nbngtgfj c rgfjln mg{ c{ cfikn
[an {n}o N{q bcf mn }nu}nrnf{nk cr P7_8
Zan}n, N{n gr {an uizn} bifr~ou{gif c{ {}cfrog{{n}
nlnb{}ifgbr γ gr {an uc{a lirr biouifnf{ ~r~cllw tc}gnr mn{znnf =∝; zg{a γ ? 2 mngfj c {wugbcl tcl~n zanfrbc{{n}gfj gr bifrgkn}nk P1_&
N{c gr {an uizn} bifr~ou{gif id {}cfrog{{n} coulgdgn} cfk bcf mn jgtnf cr8
Zan}n gr {an knrg}nk RF] c{ {an g{a}nbngtn}, FD]Q gr figrn dgj~}n c{ }nbngtn}, F5 gr {an{an}ocl figrn, MZ gr {an mcfkzgk{a id bacffnl figrn, ΰ
gr zctnlnfj{a, Jcf{ gr cf{nffc jcgf, κcou gr {an{}cfrog{{n} nddgbgnfbw cfk ]mg{ gr {an }cz bacffnl }c{n gf mur& Gd {an bacffnlr actn liz figrn, {agr rbanon ocwbiouln{nlw }nbitn} {an i}gjgfcl kc{c zg{a {an ckkg{gifclcktcf{cjn id liz nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif& ]nrnc}ba acr {i mn kifn if {agr c}nc mw goulnonf{gfj {anrn oiknlr gfac}ra nftg}ifonf{&
TG& BIFBL^RGIF
]nlgcmln kc{c {}cfrogrrgif gf ac}ra nftg}ifonf{
knunfkr if {an zg}nlnrr bacffnlr cfk kc{c {}cfrog{{nkd}io {an rnfri} fiknr c}n t~lfn}cmln {i bi}}~u{gif mwn}}i}r gfk~bnk mw {anrn figrw bacffnlr Anfbn g{ gr
fnbnrrc}w {i cfclwrn cfk oiknl zg}nlnrr bacffnl {i u}itgkn c u}iun} n}}i} bif{}il rbanon {i }nk~bn {an mg{n}}i} }c{n !MN]'& K~n {i {an r{}gfjnf{ nfn}jw bifr{}cgf{
gf rnfri} fn{zi}`r, g{ gr tg{cl {i ~rn nfn}jw nddgbgnf{ n}}i} bif{}il rbanon&
Gf {agr ucun}, {an zg}nlnrr bacffnl gr cfclwrnk cfk {anbac}cb{n}gr{gbr id zg}nlnrr bacffnlr bacfjn itn} {gon,rucbn, cfk d}ns~nfbw gf zcwr {ac{ c}n kgddgb~l{ {i bcu{~}nnf{g}nlw zg{a {ani}n{gbcl oiknlr G{ acr mnnf blnc}lw
raizf {ac{ {an fnnkr id rnfri} fn{zi}` cuulgbc{gifr zg{a}ncl/{gon bifr{}cgf{r cfk knocfkr c}n fi{ bifrgkn}nk mw
b~}}nf{ on{aikilijgnr& U}ntgi~r }nrnc}ba acr bifrgkn}nknfn}jw cr {an u}goc}w bir{ cfk kn dcb{i ~fg{ id b~}}nfbw
gf rnfri} fn{zi}`r }nrnc}ba& Zn mnlgntn {ac{ gd cuulgbc{gifr zg{a }ncl/{gon bifr{}cgf{r c}n {i mnkntnliunk c }ckgbcl ragd{ id dib~r gr fnnknk {ac{nfbioucrrnr {an knocfkr id {anrn cuulgbc{gifr, fconlw
}nlgcmglg{w id kc{c knlgtn}w cfk {an {gonlgfnrr id kc{cknlgtn}w&
] NDN]NFBNR
P3_ B& Gf{cfcjifzgzc{, ]& Jitgfkcf, K& Nr{}gf& Kg}nb{nk Kgdd~rgif8
C Rbclcmln cfk ]im~r{ Bioo~fgbc{gif Uc}ckgjo di} Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r&
U}ib& id {an 4{a Cff~cl Bifdn}nfbn if Oimgln Biou~{gfj cfk
Fn{zi}`r, =555
P=_ D& R{cff cfk H& Angknocff& ]OR[8 ]nlgcmln Kc{c [}cfrui}{
gf Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r& U}ib& id {an GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifc{l Zi}`raiu ifRnfri} Fn{ U}i{ibilr cfk Cuulgbc{gifr, =552
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 66/223
P2_ C& Zii, [& [ifj, K& B~lln}& [cogfj {an ~fkn}lwgfjbacllnfjnr id }nlgcmln o~l{gaiu }i~{gfj gf rnfri} fn{zi}`r& U}ib&
id CBO Rnfrwr52, Lir Cfjnlnr, BC, RC, =552P;_ K& Jcfnrcf,M& @}grafcocbac}g, C& Zii, K& B~lln}, K&
Nr{}gf, R& Zgb`n}& Bioulnq mnactgi} c{ rbcln8 Cf nqun}gonf{cl
r{~kw id liz uizn} zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r& [nba& ]nui}{^BLC)BRK/[] 5=/5532, Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn Knu{&, ^BLC,
=55=
P>_ C& Zgllgj cfk ]& Og{rba`n& ]nr~l{r id Mg{ N}}i} Oncr~}nonf{r zg{a Rnfri} Fiknr cfk Bcr~gr{gb Bifrns~nfbnr
di} Knrgjf id Nfn}jw/ Nddgbgnf{ N}}i} Bif{}il Rbanonr& U}ib& id
{an GNNN N~}iuncf Zi}`raiu if Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r,=554
P4_ N& I& Nllgi{{& Nr{goc{nr id n}}i} }c{nr di} biknr if m~}r{/figrn bacffnlr& Gf Mnll Rwr{no [nbafgbcl Hi~}fcl, til~on ;=,
ucjn 37::‒377:, 3742
P:_ N& I& Nllgi{{& Nr{goc{nr id n}}i} }c{nr di} biknr if m~}r{/figrn bacffnlr& Gf Mnll Rwr{no [nbafgbcl Hi~}fcl, til~on ;=,
ucjn 37::‒377:, 3742
P1_ U& Banf, M& IKnc cfk N& Bcllczcw, “Nfn}jw Nddgbgnf{Rwr{no Knrgjf zg{a Iu{go~o [}cfrogrrgif ]cfjn di} Zg}nlnrr
Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r,‟ GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Bioo&!GBB =55=', til& =, uu& 7;>/7>=, =1 Cu}gl / = Ocw =55=
P7_ Wcfj Lg~& Un}di}ocfbn gou}itnonf{ id zg}nlnrr
bioo~fgbc{gifr ~rgfj d}ns~nfbw aiuugfj ru}nck runb{}~o& GfGf{n}fc{gifcl Hi~}fcl id Bioo~fgbc{gifr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 67/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35&¥:21:7)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35&¥:21:7
C 2K R{cb`nk Onra FiB Di} ]nlgcmln Gf{n}/Lcwn} Bioo~fgbc{gif Cfk Bifjnr{gif
]nk~b{gif
@&C& @c}{agjnwcf
UJ Rbailc}
Knuc}{onf{ id Nlnb{}ifgbr cfk Bioo~fgbc{gif Nfjj
Tnl{nba O~l{g{nba K}&]cfjc}chcf K},Rc ~f{aclc Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn
Banffcg,Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{/ [an gfb}ncrgfj tgcmglg{w id 2K rglgbif gf{nj}c{gif
{nbafilijw acr iunfnk fnz iuui}{~fg{gnr di} bagu
c}bag{nb{~}n gffitc{gifr& Ifn kg}nb{gif gr gf {an nq{nfrgif id
=K onra mcrnk bagu o~l{gu}ibnrri} c}bag{nb{~}n gf{i {a}nn
Kgonfrgifr& Zn u}nrnf{ cf nddgbgnf{ c}bag{nb{~}n {i iu{gogxn
rwr{no un}di}ocfbn, uizn} bifr~ou{gif, cfk }nlgcmglg{w id
r{cb`nk onra 2K FiB gr u}iuirnk& R{cb`nk onra gr c dncrgmln
c}bag{nb{~}n zagba {c`nr cktcf{cjn id {an rai}{ gf{n}/lcwn}zg}gfj knlcwr, zagln r~ddn}gfj d}io gfnddgbgnf{ gf{n}onkgc{n
m~ddn}r& [i biun zg{a {agr, cf gf{n}/lcwn} bioo~fgbc{gif
onbacfgro gr kntnliunk {i nfacfbn {an m~ddn} ~{glgxc{gif,
lick mclcfbgfj, cfk rwr{no dc~l{/{iln}cfbn& [an onbacfgro
mnfndg{r d}io c bifjnr{gif/czc}n cfk m~r dcgl~}n {iln}cf{
}i~{gfj clji}g{ao di} tn}{gbcl bioo~fgbc{gif&
@nwZi}kr8 Fn{zi}`‒if/Bagu!FiB', 2K Gf{nj}c{gif, Dc~l{
[iln}cfbn, bifjnr{gif }nk~b{gif&
G GF[]IK^B[GIF
Ntn} gfb}ncrgfj }ns~g}nonf{r if nlnb{}ifgb
rwr{nor c}n ifn id {an `nw dcb{i}r di} ntil~{gif id {angf{nj}c{nk bg}b~g{ {nbafilijw& Bif{gf~i~r {nbafilijw
rbclgfj acr ockn g{ uirrgmln {i gf{nj}c{n mgllgifr id
{}cfrgr{i}r if c rgfjln baguP3_& [a~r {an nf{g}n rwr{no zg{aa~fk}nkr id biouifnf{r bcf mn gf{nj}c{nk if c rgfjln bagu,
zagba gr `fizf cr c O~l{gu}ibnrri} Rwr{no/if/Bagu P=_&
C{ r~ba gf{nj}c{gif lntnlr, bioo~fgbc{gif ulcwr c ochi} }iln gf {an knrgjf cfk
un}di}ocfbn&
Ifn i~{bion id agjan} gf{nj}c{gif lntnlr gr {ac{
gf{n}biffnb{gif ulc{di}or c}n }nulcbgfj {an rac}nk m~rnr&Fn{zi}`r/if/Bagu !FiBr' c}n u}iuirnk {i mn ~rnk
gf bioulnq RiBr di} gf{n}/bi}n bioo~fgbc{gif mnbc~rn id rbclcmglg{w, mn{{n} {a}i~jau~{ cfk }nk~bnk uizn}
bifr~ou{gif P2_&If {an i{an} acfk, gfb}ncrgfj {an f~omn} id bi}nr
itn} c =K ulcfn gr fi{ nddgbgnf{ k~n {i lifj gf{n}biffnb{r&
Zg{a {an non}jnfbn id tgcmln 2K gf{nj}c{gif {nbafilijgnr
iuui}{~fg{gnr nqgr{ di} bagu c}bag{nb{~}n gffitc{gifr {i
nfacfbn rwr{no uizn})un}di}ocfbn bac}cb{n}gr{gbr P;_& Gf 2K
gf{nj}c{gif {nbafilijgnr, o~l{guln lcwn}r id cb{gtn kntgbnr c}n
r{cb`nk cmitn ncba i{an} cfk tn}{gbcllw gf{n}biffnb{nk ~rgfj
{a}i~ja/rglgbif tgcr ![RTr' P>_& Cr biouc}nk {i =K knrgjfr,
2K GBr clliz di} un}di}ocfbn nfacfbnonf{r ntnf gf {an
cmrnfbn id rbclgfj mnbc~rn id {an }nk~bnk gf{n}biffnb{ lnfj{ar
P4_& Gf ckkg{gif {i {agr blnc} mnfndg{, ucb`cjn knfrg{w gr
gfb}ncrnk rgjfgdgbcf{lw, uizn} gr }nk~bnk k~n {i rai}{n} zg}nr,
cfk rwr{no gr oi}n goo~fn {ifigrn P:_& Ifn id {an znll/`fizf =K FiB c}bag{nb{~}nr gr
{an =K Onra& [agr c}bag{nb{~}n bifrgr{r id cf oÚf onra id rzg{banr gf{n}biffnb{gfj GU mlib`r ulcbnk clifj zg{a {ano&
[an r{}cgja{di}zc}k nq{nfrgif id {agr uiu~lc} ulcfc}
r{}~b{~}n gr 2K Rwoon{}gb FiB mw rgoulw ckkgfj {zi
ckkg{gifcl uawrgbcl ui}{r {i ncba }i~{n}0 ifn di} ^u cfk ifndi} Kizf P1_& Knrug{n rgoulgbg{w, {agr c}bag{nb{~}n acr {zi
ochi} gfan}nf{ k}czmcb`r& Dg}r{lw, g{ kinr fi{ nqulig{ {an
mnfndgbgcl c{{}gm~{n id c fnjlgjgmln gf{n}/zcdn} kgr{cfbn gf2K bagur, mnbc~rn gf {agr c}bag{nb{~}n, gf{n}/lcwn} cfk gf{}c/
lcwn} aiur c}n gfkgr{gfj~gracmln& Rnbifklw, c bifrgkn}cmlw
lc}jn} b}irrmc} gr }ns~g}nk cr c }nr~l{ id {zi nq{}c ui}{r P7_&
[an R{cb`nk !Awm}gk FiB/M~r' onra c}bag{nb{~}n
u}nrnf{nk gf P35_ gr c awm}gk c}bag{nb{~}n mn{znnf {an
ucb`n{ rzg{bank fn{zi}` cfk {an m~r c}bag{nb{~}n {iitn}bion {an onf{gifnk 2K Rwoon{}gb FiB bacllnfjnr& G{
{c`nr cktcf{cjn id {an rai}{ gf{n}/lcwn} kgr{cfbnr, c}i~fk=5μo, {ac{ c}n bac}cb{n}gr{gbr id 2K GBr P;_& G{ gf{nj}c{nr
{an o~l{guln lcwn}r id =K onra fn{zi}`r mw biffnb{gfj
{ano zg{a c m~r rucffgfj {an nf{g}n tn}{gbcl kgr{cfbn id {an
bagu&Cr {an gf{n}/lcwn} kgr{cfbn di} 2K GBr gr rocll, {an m~rlnfj{a zgll clri mn roclln}0 cuu}iqgoc{nlw !f/3' ( =5μo,
zan}n f gr {an f~omn} id lcwn}r&
[agr oc`nr {an m~r r~g{cmln di} gf{n}lcwn} bioo~fgbc{gif gf tn}{gbcl kg}nb{gif& Mw ~rgfj {an r{cb`nk
onra c}bag{nb{~}n, rgq/ui}{ }i~{n} gr }ns~g}nk gfr{nck id rntnf ui}{r di} {wugbcl 2K FiB }i~{n} cfk tn}{gbcl
bioo~fgbc{gif gr h~r{ ifn aiu czcw {i cfw knr{gfc{giflcwn}&
Gf {agr ucun}, zn ckk}nrr {an }i~{gfj grr~nr cfk
m~ddn} ~{glgxc{gif {i nfacfbn {an itn}cll rwr{no uizn} cfk
un}di}ocfbn id nqgr{gfj r{cb`nk onra & Gf ckkg{gif, {an
u}iuirnk c}bag{nb{~}n gfb}ncrnr {iln}cfbn cjcgfr{ rgfjln m~r
dcgl~}n c}bag{nb{~}nr&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 68/223
[a} ntiltnk
rbclgfj mknrb}gu{g
{an 2Kraizf {
nddgbgnf{,
bifrgkn}
2K FiBDi} ncba
ui}{r c}n
>Ú> b}irb}irrmc}
id ui}{r,
o~ba agj
[an
}i~{n} a u}iuirnk
G{r mcrgb
[gon/Kg
~rnk crtn}{gbcl
c}bag{nb{
bifr~ouc}bag{nb{
{zi m~dd
gfu~{ m~
lc{n}, {abifjnr{g
nfacfbn
bioo~fgc}bag{nb{
{}ctn}rn
oc`nr g{aiur un}
knj}cknr
c}bag{nb{
tn}{gbcl
b}irrmc} un}di}oc
knclr zg
knbgrgifbifjnr{gckkg{gif,
{iln}c{n c
}nri~}bnr
{iln}cfbn
onra c}b
gr agja/{
i{an} aconra c}b
id }nk~b
onra
GG ]N
n!2K' kgoi kncl zg{a
r{cb`gfj cb{f id {an ba
Br gr u}itgkc{ 2K GBr
m~{ zanf {
{gif, {an r{c{
c}n nq{nfrgi FiB }i~{n}
fnnknk }nr~l
mc} di} {an = uizn} gfb}nc
{an uizn} b
an} {acf c =K
ril~{gif {i {a
r mnnf u}iuc}bag{nb{~}n
u~}uirn zcr
grgif O~l{gul
c bioo~fgbioo~fgbc{gi
}n gr nddgbgn
gif cfk lc}n gr {ac{ nc
}r8 {an ri~}b
dn} cr raizf
n i~{u~{ mf/czc}n gf{n}
n gou}itn{an {a}i~ja
bc{gif }nri}n k~n {i {
cb`n{r {a}i~
lnrr uizn} n ucb`n{ di} t
rwr{no
}n knclr zg
bioo~fgbc{g
gou}itnrfbn& Ckcu{gt
{a lick mclc
oc`gfj } f gf =K FiB{an u}iuirnk
rgfjln lgf` dc
{glgxgfj {a, zn nfacfbn
di} gf{n}/lcw
ag{nb{~}n& Rw
}i~jau~{ m~
k, c}bag{nb{~ag{nb{~}nr c}n
nk {a}i~jau
c}bag{nb{~}n
C[NK ZI]
frgifcl gf{an lgog{c{gif
gtn rglgbif lcllnfjnr dcbn
nk gf P;_& [c}n uizn}
an 2K FiB
gr{gbr c}n s~g
f {i {an =Kid onra {iu
gfj c :Ú: b}
onra c}bag{rnr s~ck}c{gb
fr~ou{gif d
}i~{n} P33_&
uizn} bifr
irnk mw Lggr r{cb`nk o
cban bian}n
ln Cbbnrr !k
{gif ugllc}&f cfk 4Ú4 }
{ nfi~ja gf
nfbw& [ana ucb`n{ gr {
i~{u~{ m~dd
gf Dgj& 3& C
~ddn} agfkn} /lcwn} bioo~
{an c}bag{n u~{ mw ~rgf
}bnr& Zni ochi} cr
ja {zi r{cjn
ddgbgnf{& Rnbin}{gbcl bioo
a}i~jau~{&
{a mi{a grr
f zg{ai~{
{an rwr{ntn}{gbcl }i
bgfj& Gf P3
~{gfj clji}gc}bag{nb{~}nrkwfcogb }i~{
gl~}n&
ctcglcmlni~} cuu}icba
n} bioo~fgb
on{}gbcl 2K
fi{ uizn}
nr lg`n [}~n uizn} nddgbgn
{& Zn }ngfd
zg{ai~{
@
nj}c{nk bg}br id gf{n}bif
n}r& [an kn{c{i ocf~dcb
an c~{ai}r afk un}di}oc
gr {c`nf ~
{n kgddn}nf{&
iB c}bag{nb{ilijw, {zi n
irrmc} gfr{nc
nb{~}n& Rgfbn,llw zg{a f~
} c 2K }i~{n
ou{gif di} c
n{ cl& P35_&nra c}bag{nb{
bn& [an kwfc
KOC' m~r
K~n {i ifni~{n}r, u}iu
{n}or id ui
grr~n zg{a}ctn}rnk {a}i
} cfk knr{gfc
zn zgll kgr
r goulnonffgbc{gifr&
b{~}n {i d~} j {an ctcgl
ioulnonf{nb{r& Dg}r{ g
b}irrmc}, z
fk gr {i ~rn~fgbc{gif, z
I~} u}iu
nr& Rgfjln~rgfj {zi/r{
uizn} {gfj onbacf
=_, cf nfacf
g{ao {i czcr u}iuirnkgfj cuu}icba
bioo~fgbc{i kncl zg{a d
c{gif id r{cb
FiB c}bag{nb
nddgbgnf{& If FiB i} r{cbf{ c{ {an nqu
}bn {an r{cb
ckkgfj n
~g{rnb{
glnk~}n
ctnfbn
kn}
an
}n&{}c
id
{an mn}
} gr
2K
an}n&
ogb
cr
aiurnk
zn}
{agr~ja
gif
~rr
gfj
an} mln
{an{i
gba
{zigba
rnk
aiu
cjn
cfkgro
bnk
igk& Gfbcf
gifc~l{
`nk
~}n{an
`nkfrn
`nk
{}c
b
{
fk
{
l
} b
g
u
u
k
ioo~fgbc{gi
a}i~jau~{, dc
Gf {agr c}b
iknr c}n kg[KOC ugllc
~r{ mn u}itg
an tn}{gbcl lg
cwn}r& Cf nq
i~{n} di} {aacffnl acr
kgr{gfj~grac
Gf {an r{c{g QWX gr {an
cb`n{ {i {an k
agr uc}{gb~lcn}di}ocfbn
{glgxc{gif& [
gddn}nf{ bio
3& M~r gr m~rw
=& M~r gr d}nn
2& M~r gr m~rwgr d~ll8
}nri~}bnr
l{/{iln}cfbn,
GGG OI[G
g{nb{~}n, }i
dn}nf{, cr c!tn}{gbcl lg
knk {i nfcml
f`r zg{a {an
{}c uawrgbcl
tn}{gbcl big{r izf kn
ln d}io {an i
b QWX }i~{gfri~}bn, zagb
nr{gfc{gif ]Q
} c}bag{nb{~} nddgbgnf{ mnb
gr bcf mn
~fgbc{gif rb
m~{ gfu~{ m~d
m~{ gfu~{ m~dd
cfk clri {an g
cfk nfacf
cfk uizn} ndd
C[GIF
{n}r biffnb{
gf{n}dcbn m`' cfk {an
rncolnrr gf
=K fn{zi}`
bacffnl gr c
oo~fgbc{gif&kgbc{nk m~dd
{an} bacffnlr&
j clji}g{ao, ba fnnkr {i
WX+3 cr rai
n gr fng{an} c~rn id gfn
~r{gdgnk mw
fc}gir cr dill
dn} id ]QWX
n} id ]QWX+
fu~{ m~ddn} i
bn rwr{no
gbgnfbw&
k {i ugllc}
n{znnf {an FiB }i~{n}
{nj}c{gif id
zg{agf {an
knk {i {an
[an nq{}c}r, cfk gr
ifrgkn} {ac{nfk c kc{c
f gf Dgj& =&
uizn} fi} dgbgnf{ m~r
bifrgkn}gfj
zr&
3 gr d}nn8
3 gr d~ll8
]QWX+3
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 69/223
G{ g
tn}{gbcl mZn rai
imr{}~b{rnb{gif,
Gfg{gcllw,
}nk~bn
goulnoncf ckcu
Ckcu{gtn
di} gf{}c
clji}g{a
}i~{gfj
}i~{gfj u
{an QWgknf{gbcll
lcwn} b
clji}g{a
Crbioo~fg
zcw di} {
T U]IUIR
fi{ nddgbgnf{
~r zg{ai~{ bnk {ac{ {an
i~{gfj ckcu{gn cuu}icba {
{an m~ddn} i
uizn} bif
{gfj cf ckcugtn gf{n}/lcw
X gr cuulgnk&
i} {an rc`nlcwn} bioo
gr ~rnk& Fi{
lji}g{ao gr
ilgbw& [an}nd
}i~{gfj grw cr raizf gf
oo~fgbc{gif
gr nlcmi}c{nk
cf mn rnnfbc{gif, {an dg
an tn}{gbcl bi
K C]BAG[N
{i biffnb{ c
frgkn}gfj {annq{}c i~{u~{
g{w cfk lickn u}imlno gf
f i~{u~{ ui
r~ou{gif c
{gtn }i~{gfjn} }i~{gfj
d rgoulgbg{w, gfgbc{gif c r
n {ac{ {an u}
fi{ knunfkn
}n, gf XQW } }ihnb{nk gfDgj& 2 zg{a {
& [an Ck
gf Clji}g{ao
d}io Dgj& 2r{ m~r ugllc}
o~fgbc{gif g
B[^]N
FiB }i~{n}
g} bac}cb{n}gr m~ddn} ntnf
mclcfbgfj& Gfkgddn}nf{ uac
{ gr }noitnk
fk {i nf
clji}g{ao& [clji}g{ao bc
g{ gr crr~onkc{gb QW }i~
uirnk gf{n}/l
f{ {i gf{}c/l
i~{gfj clji}g{
kgddn}nf{ lcan ckcu{gtn gf
cu{gtnX }i~
3&
, di} gf{n}/lctcglcmln if
gr ~rnk&
i c
gbr&bcf
{agrrnr&
{i
mln
nf,llnk
{ac{gfj
wn}
wn}
ao,
n}r{n}/
gfj
wn} {an
c
{
fc
f
a
{
m
mb
c
bg
=r
b
{
u
k
{r
T
[i kncl zg}bag{nb{~}n gr
an gfu~{ m~d
agba fnnkr
ikn ] 353& ] tcglcmglg{w id
ikn ] 355& Clr
ctn {an rco
nra c}bag{nb{g{ai~{ tg}{~c
an u}iuirnk
~ddn}r cr bi
~r c}bag{nb{ioo~fgbc{gi
}bag{nb{~}n&
[an
ioo~fgbc{gir ~rnk {i }nb
B bifbnu{& [
Ú3 o~l{gulnqgjfclgfj zg
ifr~ou{gif
ctn}rcl uc{a
u{gogxc{gif kizn} bifr~o
Gf ckncklib`, m~{
an m~ddn} grwr{no uizn}
NCKLIB@
g{a kncklib`,~rnk cr raiz
n} id }i~{n}
{i mn {}cfro
~{n} ] 353 grk[KOC m~r
i, bifrgkn} {a
rg{~c{gifr& G
~}n zg{a ckcl bacffnl, {an
}bag{nb{~}n,
uc}nk {i r{c
}n P35_, znrbanon
~{u~{ m~ddn}
zcr }noitngtn {an kc{c
an}n gr tn}w r
n}, ifn 3Ú=nr& ]nk~b{g
~n {i }noit
id ucb`n{
~n {i }i~{gfj u{gif id {agr r
kg{gif, {an ckg{ clri gou}i
~rnk gf c }gcfk un}di}oc
CTIGKCFB
{wugbcl tg}{f gf Dgj& ;& B
] 553 bif{cgf
g{{nk {i {an
cl}nckw zcg{i knlgtn} c uc
c{ {an fikn
bcrn id {wu
{gtn tn}{gbcl}n zgll mn c
g{a {an rco
`nk onra zg
oikgdw {an{i r~uui}{
d}io {an }i
k& Cf nq{}c g ucb`n{r cfk
cll c}nc itn
kn/o~l{gulnqf gf kwfc
cl id {an m~d
cfk clri r
ckcu{gtg{w kocll nq{}c li
knk TB fi{nr {an {a}i~
ja{ zcw cfkbn nddgbgnf{&
cl bacffnlifrgkn} {ac{
r c ucb`n{,
fngjami}gfj
gfj di} {anb`n{ c{ {an
555 cfk ] 355
gbcl r{cb`nk
}i~{gfj cfkncklib`& Gf
f~omn} id
g{a k[KOC
gf{n}/lcwn} {an TB
{n} di} m~r
gfu~{ m~ddn} r~uui}{ {an
anck id ifn
n} cfk dnzgb uizn}
n} d}io {an
c{gb uizn}
ogfc{nr {angb&
iflw ctigkrau~{& Fiz,
oc`nr {an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 70/223
bioo~fggr c b}g{gb
uawrgbcl
[RTr bc
r{cb`nk
f~omn} [RTr gfb
}nlgcmln
bifrgkn}
nquli}n}i~{gfj c
zanf {anknr{gfc{g
Di} dc
ckcu{gtn
ckkgfj c
‑zcg{ ‗ rgbifkg{gif
‑zcg{ ‗ rg
c}mg{n} k
rgjfcl& [gf{}ik~bg
c}bag{nb{
G{ gr crrnfi~ja }
m~r lgf`
rn}tgbnr
Zanf {a
zagba gf m~r gr
{noui}c}g
‑zcg{ ‗ rg‑zcg{ ‗ rg
lcwn} cf
gf{n}/lcw
TG DC^
[a}i~ja Rg
bc{giflgf`r dicl knrgjf grr~
biouifnf{r,
dcgl& C dcgln
`fizf/jiikk
d kgnr {i mn}ncrn {an bir{
gf{n}/lcwn}
mlw og{gjc{n {
iz {an ctcglji}g{ao {i c
}n c}n i{an} f ucg}&
~l{ {iln}cfbn,
gf{n}/lcwn} b
w nq{}c zg}n
fcl cb{r crr& Gf bcrn id
fcl gr un}o
inr fi{ rn}t
a~r, }i~{gfjj {an dc
}n&
~onk {ac{ {annri~}bnr !{nr{
gr m}i`nf i}
k~n {i {an}o
n m~r c}mg{n}
gbc{n {ac{ {ani{ cmln {i
glw i} un}oc
fcl cbbi}kgffcl, g{ zgll
gf d~{~}n,
} bioo~fgb
[ [ILN]C
glgbif Tgc,
} kgnr gf {ann gf 2K gf{nj
an dcm}gbc{gi
[RT ocw b
gnr {i mn kg
r{cb`nk gfbcfk knb}ncrn
bioo~fgbc{g
anrn grr~nr& G
lcmln rgjfclrigk {anrn uc
uc{ar mn{znn
an nqgr{gfj rg
oo~fgbc{gif
& Cr nqulcgf
c bifjnr{gifcfw dc~l{ if
cfnf{lw crrn}
cfw }ns~nr{
ckcu{gtg{w grl{ {iln}cfb
k[KOC m~r~fg{r' {i rgj
{an m~r gr fi
l u}imlno i
}nbngtnr cfw
n gr c dc~l{ i u}itgkn {an
fnf{lw, g{ cr
jlw& Zanf } n}i~{n {an u
gll fi{ kn}gt
c{gif {i {a
BN
zagba u}itg
n}{gbcl kg}nb{gc{gif& Lg`n i
cfk mifkgf
c~rn c f~omn
rbc}knk& Cr
ncrnr, {an dc{an wgnlk P32
f rbanon
{agr rnb{gif,
bcf nfcmlnar !dc~l{w m~
{an ri~}bn
jfclgfj ~rnk
gr ~rnk zg{
k gf rnb{gif
dlcj gf fi} an k[KOC
{nk ‑5‗ cfk
}cgrnk mw ‑
fi{ cddnb{nkn gf nqgr
gr ns~guunkcl {ac{ ng{an}
{ cmln {i u}i
cfw i{an} d
id r~ba rgjf
{an m~r lgf` bioo~fgbc
rn}{r ‑5‗ if
i~{n} banb`rb`n{r zg{agf
n cfw {}cddgb
n bi}}nruif
knr
gif,an}
id
} id
{an
glnk_& C
bcf
zn
{anrnr'
cfk
di}
i~{
GT,
ocl~r,
m~r
ns‗
mwgfj
g{a{an
gkn
~l{&
clr,
cfkgif
{an
{an{an
di}
gfj
k
r
c
u
u
k‑
b
n}
f
n
gk
m
ur
f
uk
‑
c
}
[KOC m~r&
gll mn ~rnk nikgdgbc{gif
nb{gif GT& Mnbacfgro fn
Bifrgkn} {acucb`n{ {i f
c{ar c}n dc~l{
}iuirnk }i~{g
[KOC m~r55=‗ rai~lk
~}}nf{ rg{~c{g
g{an} id fiki~{gfj clji}g
i}ocllw cbbi
Fiz bifrg
qcb{lw mnliz
{n}/lcwn} binr{gfc{gif m~
n }n}i~{nk {i
an}n {an uc
cb`n{ zgll mng{~c{gif, zan
ikn ‑3==‗&
cb`n{ bcf ifl[KOC m~r
3==‗, zagba g
lji}g{ao }ns
i~{nk {i {an fgfgocl uc{a&
Fi}ocllw, {
nf gf bcrn igf }i~{gfj
{ {an}n c}nnkr {i mn oik
{ {an fikn ‑5ikn ‑33=‗& [
w cr rizf gf
fj clji}g{ao
iffnb{gfj {a mn {}gnk m~{
f& Ri, {an uc
nr ‑535‗ i} ao& [anf {a
kgfj {i {an u
n} cfi{an} rg
)cmitn g{r k
o~fgbc{gif,{an m~r lgf`
{an fngjami}g
b`n{ gr b~}}
knlgtn}nk {i {{an fikn ‑3
i} u}iuirnk
mn }i~{nk {aiffnb{gfj {a
r dc~l{w& Gf {
g}nr oikgdgb
iknr ‑335‗ i}
n ogfgocl u
d dc~l{w lgf`rclji}g{ao kg
dnz bcrnr, zgdgnk&
5‗ gf Dgj& 4 fan tn}{gbcl lg
Dgj& 4& Cbbi
gf rnb{gif GT,
n fiknr ‑555ac{ m~r lgf`
b`n{ zgll mn }
‑355‗ cbbi} n ucb`n{ zgl
iuirnk clji}g
g{~c{gif, gd {a
nr{gfc{gif f
g{ bcf mn knlggr m}i`nf, {an
fj fikn zg{ag
f{lw }nrgkgfj
an knr{gfc{gif=5‗ bif{cgfr
}i~{gfj clj
}i~ja {an tn} n fiknr ‑3=5
agr rg{~c{gif,
{gif& [an uc
‑5=5‗ dillizg
c{a }i~{gfj
zg{ai~{ cfwrb~rrnk gf
anf }i~{gfj
nnkr {i rnfkf`r if {zi
}kgfj {i {an
{an tn}{gbcl
‗, ‑553‗ cfkgr dc~l{w gf
i~{nk {i {an
gfj {i {anl mn }i~{nk
{ao&
n ucb`n{ gr
kn cfk mw
n}nk {i {an ucb`n{ zgll
gf {an lcwn},
& [anf {an
& [agr gr {anc ucb`n{ di}
i}g{ao, {an
gbcl‗, ‑3=3‗ cfk
{an }i~{gfj
`n{ zgll mn
gfj {an fif/
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 71/223
TGG BIFBL^RGIF
Gf {agr ucun}, cf nfacfbnk c}bag{nb{~}n di} 2K
r{cb`nk onra FiB zcr u}iuirnk {i nfacfbn rwr{no un}di}ocfbn, }nk~bn uizn} bifr~ou{gif, cfkgou}itn {an rwr{no }nlgcmglg{w& [i {agr nfk, c
bifjnr{gif czc}n ckcu{gtn gf{n}lcwn} bioo~fgbc{gif
clji}g{ao zcr gf{}ik~bnk& [i kncl zg{a kncklib`, cf
cuu}iu}gc{n TB c}bag{nb{~}n zcr ~rnk zg{a rconf~omn} id m~ddn}r cr biouc}nk {i {an nqgr{gfj
r{cb`nk onra c}bag{nb{~}nr& Gf ckkg{gif, {an
bifjnr{gif rgjfcl {}gjjn}nk mw {an m~r c}mg{n} zcr
~rnk {i kncl zg{a dc~l{ {iln}cfbn& [agr nfcmlnkctigkgfj c dc~l{w tn}{gbcl m~r gf c uirrgmln uc{a di} c
f~omn} id ri~}bn/knr{gfc{gif ucg}r gf {an ntnf{ id c
m~r dcgl~}n&
]NDN]NFBNRP3_ R& Mi}`c}, “Knrgjfgfj }nlgcmln rwr{nor d}io ~f}nlgcmlnbiouifnf{r8 [an bacllnfjnr id {}cfrgr{i} tc}gcmglg{w cfk
knj}ckc{gif,‟ GNNN Ogb}i, Til& =>, Fi& 4, =55>, uu& 35/34&
P=_ C& Hn}}cwc cfk Zcwfn Zild, “O~l{gu}ibnrri} Rwr{nor/if/Bagur,‟ Oi}jcf @c~docff, 3r{ nkg{gif, Ib{imn} 3=, =55;&
P2_ C& Hcf{rba, cfk A& [nfa~fnf, Fn{zi}` if Bagu, @l~zn}
Cbcknogb U~mlgran}r, =552&
P;_ C& Z& [iuil n{ cl&, “[a}nn/Kgonfrgifcl Gf{nj}c{nk Bg}b~g{r,‟GMO H& ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{, Til& >5, Fi& ;)>, H~lw/Rnu{&
=554, uu& ;73/>54&P>_ T& D& Uctlgkgr cfk N& J& D}gnkocf, “2/K [iuilijgnr di}
Fn{zi}`r/if/ Bagu, ‟ gf U}ib& id GNNN [}cfr& Id TLRG Rwr{nor&,
Til& 3>, Fi& 35, =55:, uu&3513/3575&
P4_ M& R& Dnn}i cfk U& U& Ucfkn, “Fn{zi}`r/if/Bagu gf c [a}nn/Kgonfrgifcl Nftg}ifonf{8 C Un}di}ocfbn Ntcl~c{gif,‟ GNNN
[}cfrcb{gifr if Biou~{n}r, Til& >1, Fi& 3, =557, uu& 2=/;>&P:_ ]& R& Uc{{g, “[a}nn/Kgonfrgifcl Gf{nj}c{nk Bg}b~g{r cfk {an
D~{~}n id Rwr{no/if/Bagu Knrgjfr‟, gf U}ib id GNNN, Til& 7;, Fi&4, =554, uu& 3=3;/3==;&
P1_ L& U& Bc}lifg n{ cl&, “Fn{zi}`r/if/Bagu gf Non}jgfj
Gf{n}biffnb{ Uc}ckgjor8 Cktcf{cjnr cfk Bacllnfjnr,‟ gf U}ib& id Gf{n}fc{gifcl Rwouirg~o if Fn{zi}`r/if/Bagu, =557, uu& 72/357&
P7_ H& @go n{ cl&, “C fitnl kgonfrgifclw/knbiouirnk }i~{n} di} if/bagu bioo~fgbc{gif gf 2K c}bag{nb{~}nr,‟ gf U}ib& id
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Rwouirg~o if Biou~{n} C}bag{nb{~}nr, =55:& uu&
321/3;7&
P35_ D& Lg n{ cl&, “Knrgjf cfk Ocfcjnonf{ id 2K BaguO~l{gu}ibnrri}r ^rgfj Fn{zi}`/gf/Onoi}w,‟ gf U}ib& id
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Rwouirg~o if Biou~{n} C}bag{nb{~}n, =554, uu&325/3;3&
P33_ ]& R& ]cocf~hco cfk M& Lgf, “C Lcwn}/O~l{gulnqnk 2K If/
Bagu Fn{zi}` C}bag{nb{~}n,‟ GNNN Nomnkknk Rwr{nor Ln{{n}r,
Til& 3, Fi& =, =557, uu& >5/>>&P3=_ U& Li{dg/@co}cf n{ cl&, “NKQW ‒ C liz bir{ bifjnr{gif/
czc}n }i~{gfj clji}g{ao di} fn{zi}`/if/bagur,‟ Hi~}fcl id Rwr{nor
C}bag{nb{~}n, Til& >4, Fi& :, =535, uu& =>4/=4;&P32_ C&/B& Argna n{ cl&, “[RT ]nk~fkcfbw8 C}bag{nb{~}n cfk
Knrgjf Grr~nr gf 2K GB,‟ gf U}ib& id Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn ifKnrgjf, C~{ioc{gif, cfk [nr{ gf N}i~un, =535, uu& 344/3:3&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 72/223
l
U}ib& id {
Til~on 3& B
GRMF8 7:1/
}
Cmr{}cb{
ioo~fgbc{gt
fk {ac{ g
ROC][UAIi nfk oimgln
tn}w ocf~dc
fk gffitc{gi
Cr c }nr
{{}cb{gtn dnc{
kcu{cmglg{w {
cb{i}r bif{}g
iouc}c{gtn
gUaifn, Rwom
iijln Cfk}i
@nwzi
Ir,Cfk}ig
[an cgo
iouc}c{gtn r
igf{ id tgn
dnc{~}nr, mw
cfk lgog{c{gi
crunb{r id {an
[an ochi
crnk rid{zc
c}`n{ mw
roc}{uaifnr&
Lgf~q/mcrnk
c~fba lg`n gOimgln, Rwo
{b&
[an mc{{l
{nbafilijgbcl
imgln IR&
an Gf{l& Bifd&
iuw}gja{ § =5
13/7=5>:>/:/
CBO "8 kmn
]craog U
OBC Knu
R]O
L~b`fi
raog3225E
/ Oimgln ua
n kntgbnr {i r
zaw {anw
NR& Roc}{uabioo~fgbc{gi
b{~}n} gr dib~
r gf {agr dgnlk&
l{ {an}n c}n
~}nr& [an r~bb
{ag}k uc}{w c
~{n gf g{r r~b
{~kw id rio
gcf, Mlcb`mn}
gk&
}k/ Cuul
k cfk Zgfkiz
G& G
id {agr }nui}
{~kw id kgddn}
& C biouc}
}gfjgfj {an
r {ijn{an}, {
rn oimgln IR
gfk~r{}w gr
}n kntnliugfj
cmi~{ >5
fk}igk, {an
lc{di}o zag
{r bioun{g{i}gcf IR, Ucl
di} oc}`n
kntnliuonf{
if Biou~{n}
3= [nbafi D
4 88 kig8 35& :
}&gon}c&35& :
imgln I
chcuc{g
c}{onf{
UB
, ^U
jocgl&bio
fnr actn n
d{zc}n gf{nfr
c}n cl{n}
fnr c}n u}itgf cb}irr {an z
rgfj if oimg
ocfw oimgl
nrr id cfw ulc
uulgbc{gifr& I
bnrr& [agr uc
id {an `nw
}w IR, Zgfk
gUaifn,
r Oimgln
[]IK^B[G
{ gr {i u}itg
f{ Oimgln I
grif mn{znnf
gddn}nf{ Oi
agr ucun} zgl
clri&
bb~ugnk mw
bioucfw z
nrunbgcllw
dlcjragu oi
a gr jn{{gfj
r lg`n {an gUIR, cfk ]
{ rac}n gr
r cfk gffitc{
Cuulgbc{gifr
}~o J}i~u, G
2114)GRMFY5
114
n}c{gfj
n}jnk d}io
gtn kntgbnr lg`
c{gtnlw bclln
gfj ril~{gif d }lk& Gf u}nrnf
ln iun}c{gfj
IR actgfj
di}o knunfkr
d bi~}rn ocfw
n} gr gf{nfkn
oimgln IR8
zr Oimgln I
Rwomgcf,Mlcb
F
n c }ntgnz
ulc{di}o d}i
cll bi}n ul
gln IR cktc
l u}itgkn {nb
womgcf, c L
agba gr lnckg
gf UKCr
gln ulc{di}o,
}nckw di} c
aifnIR, ZgGO Mlcb`mn}
c`gfj c uc{
gifr gf {an dg
‒
fkgc&
:41
wr{no8
on}n
n UBr
k cr
} nfk{ {gon
wr{no
ocfw
if g{r
oi}n
{i c
Cuuln
R cfk
mn}}w
cfk c
o i~}
{di}o
{cjnr
afgbcl
fkif
j {an
cfk
gr c
gkn}/
kizrw IR
a di}
nlk id
GG&
ulc
Cf
Gf
ulc
{i
{an
CfRn
knr
Bcl
c~
ulc
`n}
~u
dgqg
c}n
Biouc
& [AN M
&
[i ibb~uw o
wn}r lg`n Rw
k}igk c}n ~ft
}nrnf{ rbnfc}
{di}o& Ocw
c}kr c {}~lw
riuagr{gbc{gi
Cfk}igk, Gfb
kw ]~mgf !b}r !ifbn TU
gjf cfk gf{n}
gdi}fgc, ^fg{
~r{ =55>&Cd{
{di}o di} o
fnl&
Rgfbn g{r i}gj
c{nr, ncba ck
fj m~jr id u
/
c{gtn Cf
]~b
OBC
R
L~
}~bag}cra~
[[LN DI]
c}`n{ cfk {i
mgcf, ]GO M
glgfj {ang} i
gi b~r{ion} u
n c fnnkr j
unf ri~}bn
if {ang} izf
C& C
}ui}c{gif zc
/di~fkn} id c{ [/Oimgl
cbn kntnliu
k R{c{nr& G{
} {ac{ c {nc
mgln kntgbnr
gfcl }nlncrn,
gfj rion fn
ntgi~r }nlncr
clwrgrag}c Ra~`lc
Knuc}{onf{
]OJUB
`fiz, ^U
lc17Ejocg
OC]@N[ RA
ifiuilgxn {a
lcb`mn}}w, C
f cuulgbc{gif
}ndn}r c rgoul
}iz nfk ~rn
lc{di}o cfk
&
fk}igk IR
r di~fknk gf
Kcfjn}', ]g', cfk Ba}gr
nf{ c{ Znm[
zcr cbs~g}n
lnk mw ]~
actgfj {an
fk}igk acr r
z cfk gffitc
n& ]nbnf{ }nl
l&bio
C]N
n gfk~r{}w oc
uln/gUaifn,
r{i}nr itn}
n m~{ gffitc{
zgll mn {~}
{anw zgll nq{
b{imn}, =552
a Ogfn}, FZag{n !anc
', gf Ucli Cl
mw Jiijln
gf kntnliun
izn} id Lg
nnf c f~omn}
{gtn dnc{~}nr
crnr id Cfk}
hi}
fk
n{&
gtn
nk
fk
mw
gb` nk
{i,
gf
c
~q
id
fk
gk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 73/223
Çblcg} actgfj c fnz znm m}izrn} cfk r~uui}{ di}A[OL> cfk Z2B jnilibgractgfj rion roc}{ dnc{~}nr lg`nkgjg{cl Xiio, bili} nddnb{r cfk oi}n&
Çblcg} clri gfbl~knr r~uui}{ di} cfgoc{nk mcb`j}i~fkr,tigbn bif{}ilr, m~{{ifr {i iunf {an onf~, fnz znc{an}cuulgbc{gif cfk gou}itnk Nocgl cfk Uaifnmii`cuulgbc{gifr&
D}iwi gf{}ik~bnk runnk gou}itnonf{r zg{a HG[iu{gogxc{gif cfk {an Ba}ion T1 HctcRb}gu{ nfjgfn, cfkckknk Zg/Dg ai{rui{ {n{an}gfj cfk Ckimn Dlcra r~uui}{&
Aifnwbiom zcr cffi~fbnk c{ {an =533 Jiijln G)I if35 Ocw =533& / [i clliz aifnwbiom kntgbnr {i kg}nb{lw{}cfrdn} bif{nf{ d}io ^RM kntgbnr&
Aifnwbiom gr -cf gfb}nonf{cl }nlncrn {ac{ ckkr rntn}clfnz bcucmglg{gnr di} ~rn}r cfk kntnliun}r-& Agjalgja{rgfbl~kn iu{gogxc{gif di} c m}ickn} }cfjn id rb}nnf rgxnr0fnz -xiio/{i/dgll- rb}nnf biouc{gmglg{w oikn0 bcucmglg{w {ilick onkgc dglnr kg}nb{lw d}io {an RK bc}k0 cfk cf nq{nfknkrb}nnf r~uui}{ CUG, u}itgkgfj kntnliun}r zg{a oi}n u}nbgrnbif{}il itn} {an ^G&
m&Rwomgcf IR
Rwomgcf,if H~fn =;, =551 zcr cbs~g}nk mwFi`gc&U}ntgi~rlw g{ zcr izfnk mw N}gbrrif, rifwn}gbrrif,Ucfcrifgb cfk Rcor~fj& Rwomgcf
IR iddn}r c agja lntnl id gf{nj}c{gif id un}rifclgfdi}oc{gif ocfcjnonf{ zg{a bioo~fgbc{gif !UGO'&G{u}itgknr ocfw rn}tgbnr lg`n fctgjc{gif, jconr,crribgc{nlgm}c}gnr0 o~rgb ulcwmcb`r n{b&G{ acr rion ac}kzc}n}ns~g}nonf{r/
Q14 c}bag{nb{~}n Oifg{i}8 35=; q :41―ugqnl rb}nnf, Ac}k k}gtn8 =55 OM id d}nn kgr` rucbn, 34―
mg{ bili} Onoi}w8 >3=OM, BU^8 3&=JAx u}ibnrri}& Rion id {an }nlncrnr id Rwomgcf c}n/
3' Nuib ]nlncrn >8 Gf =555, g{ zcr }nlncrnk zg{aMl~n{ii{a r~bbnrri} bikn fconk bifif&G{ clrir~uui}{nk ^fgbikn&
=' Rwomgcf IR 4&5 cfk 4&3 ! N]4 '8G{ zcr}nlncrnk gf =55=&Gf {agr }nlncrn Ml~n{ii{a zcr ckknkdi} nqbacfjgfj kc{c itn} rai}{ kgr{cfbnr b}nc{gfjUn}rifcl C}nc Fn{zi}`!UCF'&G{ gr ~rnkgf Fi`gc 7=35&
2' Rwomgcf IR :&5 cfk :&5r8[agr tn}rgif ckknk NKJN r~uui}{ cfk GUT4&;' Rwomgcf IR 1&58Gf {agr tn}rgif id Rwomgcf IR, {an}n c}n fi ochi
} ntil~{gifr, acr rac}nk rion CUG‗r {i r~uui}{ 2J&>' Rwomgcf IR 7&38[an bacfjn di} {agr tn}rgif gr {an bacfjn id tn}rg
if 3&= di} {an Ml~n{ii{a acr tn}rgif =&5 zan}n {an kgddn}nfbn gr {an gf{}ik~b{gif id cf Nfacfbnk Kc{c ]c{n !NK]' di} dcr{n} kc{c {}cfrdn}& [an fiogfcl ]c{n id NK] gr cmi~{ 2 onjcmg{r un} rnbifk cl{ai~ja {an u}cb{gbcl kc{c {}cfrdn} }c{n gr =&3 onjcmg{r un} rnbifk&
cl {nlntgrgif m}ickbcr{r gf KTM―A cfk
GRKM―[ di}oc{r cfk clri libc{gif rn}tgbnr&
M& Zgfkizr Uaifn
Ogb}irid{ bcu{~}nk c j}nc{ c{{nf{gif c{ Oimgln Zi}lkBifj}nrr mw gf{}ik~bgfj Zgfkizr Uaifn : Rn}gnr, r~ba crZU:R, i} ZgfUai cfk }nu}nrnf{r c biouln{nlw fnzcuu}icba {i gf{n}cb{gfj zg{a wi~} uaifn& Gfr{nck id gbifr di}Cuur if {an ZU: rb}nnf ~rnr “a~mr‟, zagba c}n bnf{n}r di}cfw {wunid gfdi}oc{gif, cfk cll {an a~mr rnno {igf{n}biffnb{ {i ifn cfi{an}& Di} nqcouln, {an “Uniuln‟ a~mbif{cgfr wi~} bif{cb{r, rwfbnk d}io cfk lgf`nk zg{a cll wi~}ribgcl fn{zi}`r&
[an {gja{ gf{nj}c{gif id ribgcl fn{zi}`r r~ba cr [zg{{n},Dcbnmii`, cfk OwRucbn, ocw u}nrnf{ cfi{an} bacllnfjn&Ogb}irid{ ack {i b}nc{n c zailn r~mrn{ id gfr{}~b{gifr di}ncba ribgcl fn{zi}` cfk m~glk g{ gf{i Zgfkizr Uaifn :
Rn}gnr c{ {an bi}n lntnl&Zgfkizr Oimgln gr cf nqbnllnf{ o~l{g/{cr`gfj ulc{di}o
cfk g{ acr fi u}imlno zg{a {cr`r }~ffgfj gf {an mcb`j}i~fkmnbc~rn ZgfOi c~{ioc{gbcllw bacfjnr onoi}w cllibc{gifmcrnk if {an fnnkr id ncba cuulgbc{gif, cfk gd {an rwr{noonoi}w r{c}{r {i jn{ r{}n{bank {agf, {an IR ra~{r kizfmcb`j}i~fk {cr`r c~{ioc{gbcllw&
Zgfkizr Oimgln IR gr knrgjfnk d}io {an j}i~fk ~u {igf{nj}c{n zg{a mi{a Nqbacfjn Rn}tn}r gf {an bi}ui}c{nzi}lk, cfk zg{a I~{lii` nftg}ifonf{r if {an knr`{iu& Cllcrunb{r id knr`{iu I~{lii` bioogfjln acuuglw zg{a OimglnI~{lii` if {an Zgfkizr Oimgln rgkn id {agfjr&
B& Cuuln gUaifn IR8Cuuln acr b}nc{nk c UB/j}ckn Iun}c{gfj rwr{no di} c
Roc}{uaifn& B~}}nf{lw, Cuuln‗r gUaifn gr {an lifjgfj id {anoikn}f ocf& [iu/fi{ba u}ik~b{ knrgjf, cf un}bnu{gtn ~rn}/gf{n}dcbn cr znll cr dcfbw o~l{gonkgc gf{n}fn{ mcrnk rn}tgbnrocw bif{}gm~{n {i g{r ~fgs~n oc}`n{ uirg{gif&
[an dg}r{ Cuuln tn}rgif zcr gf{}ik~bnk if Hcf~c}w 7,=55:&G{r r~bbnrri}, {an gUaifn 2J zcr }ntnclnk if H~lw 33,=551& gUaifn 2J acr {an dillizgfj ac}kzc}n runbgdgbc{gifr8
Kntgbn kgonfrgifr)zngja{8 ;&> q =&; q5&;1 gfba ) ;&: i~fbnr
Kgrulcw rgxn8 2&> gfba
]nril~{gif8 ;15 q 2=5 ugqnl c{ 342 uug !g&n& crunb{ }c{gi 28=' Gfu~{ kntgbnr8 O~l{g/{i~ba nfcmlnk rb}nnf
gf{n}dcbn ul~r ; m~{{ifr !‟Aion‟, ‟Rlnnu)Zc`n‟,‟Til~on ~u)kizf‟, ‟]gfj)rglnf{‟'
Biffnb{i}r cfk gfu~{)i~{u~{8 25/ugf kib`biffnb{i}, 2&>oo r{n}ni anckuaifn
Cuuln gUaifn IR clri u}itgknr cf nqulgbg{Rnb~}g{w d}conzi}` !Rnb~}g{w& D}conzi}`'u}itgknr gf{n}dcbnr di} ocfcjgfj bn}{gdgbc{nr,u~mlgb cfk u}gtc{n `nwr, cfk {}~r{ uilgbgnr {ac{ wi~
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 74/223
bcf
cuulg
uiz
o~l{g
cfk
mn ~
c tn
g{r n
{an
iuui
uniu
M
kntn
o~l{g{ac{
acfk
{}cb`
{i~b
acfk
M
r~uu
cfk,
bio
zg{a
Ogb}
]g{r i
Cu}gl
Mlcb
=535
=533
B~}t
!713
!775
kntg
!Fi
Mlcb`mn}}
G
Mlcb
rn {i j~c}cf
bc{gif ocfcj
fi{an} `nw}nk j}cuagbr
guln rnfri}r
}iqgog{w rnf
nk, cfk g{ }cug
w u}idg{cmln
unb{nk di} {a
c}`n{ cr oi
}{~fg{gnr {i j
ln‗r ogfkr di
c&&Mlcb`M
lcb`Mn}}w
liunk mw ]n
g{cr`gfj cfk ractn mnnf c
anlkr, u}nki
mcll, cfk o
rb}nnf di} g{
anlk kntgbnr&
lcb`Mn}}w I
i}{ di} bi}u
oi}n }nbnf{lw
ln{n zg}nlnrr
Fitnll J}i~
irid{ Nqbacf
GO kntnliurun}c{gfj rwr{
=535 ]GO
Mn}}w IR
& [an rid{zc}
oc`gfj g{r c
n !72>5)72
)71>5)7145'
)7725'& ]GO
nr zi~lk fi{
Lnjcbw Kntgb
IR Ckkg{gi
u}itnk u}ik
Mn}}w cuulgb
i
i
Mlcb
Mlcb
i
Rctg
i
iunfg
{nn {an rnb~}g
nr&
runb{r id {a, {i~ba gf{n
lg`n cbbnln}i
ri}, zagba z
gklw raizf ai
cogfj ulc{di
gUaifn {i bi
}n ulcwn}r {c
{ gf, ri rai~l
c lifj {gon {
n}}w IR
oimgln i
rnc}ba Gf O
~uui}{r runbgkiu{nk mw ]
ogfcf{lw {a
r{ }nbnf{lw,
r Mlcb`Mn}}w
r mnr{ `fi
}c{n nocgl, {
, c r~mrn{ id
cb{gtc{gif c
Zgrn nocgl
n n{b&
cfk }nlncrnro {i r~uui
cffi~fbnk {
&5 tn}rgif, g
n zcr lnjcllw
uunc}cfbn if
45)72:5',
cfk
cffi~fbnk
mn ~ukc{nk {
n R~uui}{'&
cl Dnc{~}nr r
~b{gtg{w $ bi
c{gif 8
XGU
Dcr{n
Mn}}w Ro
Mn}}w Ulcwm Nfac
j C{{cbaonf Dcr{n
gfj
{w id {an kc{
gUaifn8 Iu}dcbn, cr z
n{n}, lgja{
n}n cll ctcglc
z g{ bi~lk jn{
}o& Di} {an d
f{gf~n g{r crb
`n fi{gbn di}
{an gUaifn r
bion&
n}c{gfj r
i{gif &G{ u}
clgxnk gfu~{ kGO di} ~rn
n {}cb` za
{an {}cb` uc
lgfn id Roc}{
f di} g{r
{a}i~ja OGK
GKU =&5, g{
fk rwfba}ifg
, Li{~r Kiog
~ukc{nk tn}rg{ ncba kntgb
i }nlncrn {a
gf {an 2}k s
}nlncrnk gf
{an {an Mlcb
lcb`mn}}w
lcb`mn}}w
{ac{ cfw u}
i Mlcb`Mn}}w
ba cr8
ffnb{gtg{w zg
{{cbaonf{ R
} ucg}gfj mn{
}{uaifn cf
i`
fbnk R~uui
{r
} c{{cb
wi~}
nfJLll cr
nfri}
mln {i
{i mn
~{~}n,
f{ if
{ang}
{cw gf
r{no,
tgknr
tgbnrgf g{r
nnl ,
cfk
aifn
c{gtn
U 3&5
llizr
c{gif
i i}
fr id n& If
fnz
~c}{n}
~j~r{
mn}}w
[i}ba
Milk
tgi~r
IR :
{a {an
uui}{
nnf c
k c
{ di}
onf{
GG
{an
Zg
id{
{an
cu
ct
gf{
zg
cu
{i
jio~
oc
cm
cu
knd
M~
mcb
cbb
mcb
itn
id
G& C BI
Cfk}igk bio
oc}`n{& G{r
fkizr oimgl
f mnnf b}g{gbg
Zanf zn ji
`nw dnc{~}nr
lgbc{gifr c{ {
glcmln, o~l{g{
j}c{n zg{a
kizr oimgln
m& O~l{g{cr
Cfk}igk gr
lgbc{gifr c{ {
i}nj}i~fk u}
k ~rn} nqunl{g{cr`gfj&
Zgfkizr oi
w mn c mg{ r~
~{ o~l{g/{cr
lgbc{gif blir
c~l{ zanf nqg
{ {an IR ac
`j}i~fk, g{
i}kgfj {i {an
`j}i~fk {cr`
Go
} ZNU fn{zi
Ck
lcb`mn}}w Ii
Cuu
i
Ugb{~}nr
UC]GRIF
ZGFKIZ
n tn}w znll g
oc}`n{ rac}n
acr bion
xnk di} mngfj
di} c biouc}g
{i mn biouc}
an rcon {go
r`gfj, {an ~r
biou~{n}‗r
cfk cfk}igk
`gfj
tn}w znll
n rcon {gon
ibnrrnr cr o
}gnfbn& Cfk}
mgln c}n clri
}u}grgfj mnbc
gfj& [an }
n iu{gif& C
{nk, zagba gr
fi u}imlno
c~{ioc{gbcllw
fnnk id cuulg
c~{ioc{gbcll
}itnk Zg/
}`r
g{gifcl O~l{g
8Ugfba {i
Ui}{}cg{
Cuu
N[ZNNF C
OIMGLN
f c rai}{ {go
gr j}izgfj
g{a }nbnf{ ~u
c kc{nk Roc}{
rif mn{znnf
nk c}n {an cmg
, {an f~omn
n} gf{n}dcbn c
knr`{iu n{
f {anrn dnc{~
~g{nk di} }
rncolnrrlw& G
ba {anw knrn
gk IR kinr
jiik gf o~l{g
~rn {anw act
ncrif gr {a
ulgbc{gifr k
n}w bifd~rgf
r zg{a {cr`r
bacfjnr on
c{gifr cfk {a
w&
g biffnb{gt
gonkgc Dnc{~
Xiio gf Tg
R~uui}{
FK]IGK CF
cfk unfn{}c
{ c }cugk uc
kc{nr m~{ g{
uaifn ulc{di}
imgln ulc{di}
lg{w {i }~f o
id cuulgbc{g
fk {an cmglg{w
&Ln{r biou
nr8
ffgfj o~l{g
{ jgtnr c{{nf{g
}tn {i u}itgk
c jiik him
{cr`gfj cfk {
mnnf b}g{gbg
{ g{ lcb`r
fi{ blirn
di} rion ~r
}~ffgfj gf
oi}w cllibc{g
IR ra~{r ki
g{w
}nr
ni
gf
K
{nk
bn&
cr
o&
or
fw
fr
{i
c}n
uln
gif
n c
gf
agr
nk
cf
mw
}r&
{an
gif
zf
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ >7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 75/223
Gf/dcb{ Cfk}igk IR kinr {an rcon {agfj& Zanfc ~rn} lnctnr cf cuulgbc{gif cfk r{c}{r cfi{an} {andg}r{ ifn `nnur }~ffgfj gf {an mcb`j}i~fk&
Zgfkizr oimgln acr c mgj cktcf{cjn itn}Cfk}igk gf {an c}nc id ~rn}/gfr{cllnk cuulgbc{gifr&Zgfkizr oimgln cllizr {ano {i mn gfr{cllnk gfng{an} rwr{no onoi}w zagba gr o~ba lc}jn} i} gfnq{n}fcl onoi}w bc}kr& G{ r~uui}{r c lc}jn f~omn}id cuulgbc{gifr {i mn gfr{cllnk&
m& Ctcglcmln Cuulgbc{gifr
Cfk}igk gr u}iogrgfj itn} 35,555+ cuulgbc{gifrctcglcmln cfk {ii gf c tn}w rai}{ {gon zagba grgfknnk c j}nc{ cbagntnonf{& Zagln Cfk}igk acr ctn}w dnz cuulgbc{gifr {ac{ ifn bcf dgfk if cgUaifn, wn{ {anw c}n jiik {i onn{ ~rn}‗r}ns~g}nonf{&
Zgfkizr gf rionzac{ lcb`gfj gf {agr dnc{~}nnrunbgcllw gf cuur r{i}n jconr zagba gr fi{r~}u}grgfj mnbc~rn r{i}n gr fnz {i {an oc}`n{&
Cfk}igk znm m}izrn} gr blcgonk {i mn o~bamn{{n} {acf {an lc{nr{ tn}rgif id oimgln Gf{n}fn{nquli}n} cfk g{ gr cbb~}c{n blcgo&
B& ^rn} Gf{n}dcbn
Zgfkizr oimgln gf{n}dcbn gr ilkn} {acfCfk}igk cfk di} {ac{ Cfk}igk gf{n}dcbn gr mn{{n}{acf g{& Cfk}igk gf{n}dcbn lii`r oi}n oikn}f cfkgr ncrw {i gf{n}cb{ zg{a& Mi{a gf{n}dcbnr c}n rgoulnGbif mcrnk gf zagba {an gbifr c}n i}jcfgxnk gf
‑lc~fban}r‗&[an {zi ulc{di}or bcf mn biouc}nk oi}n dcg}lwif {an mcrgr id {ag}k uc}{w cl{n}fc{gtnr& Cfk}igk gr ctn}w bcucmln gf{n}dcbn di} {ag}k uc}{w gf{n}dcbn ranllr~ba cr A[B rnfrn&A[B acr lifj u}ik~bnk g{r izfgf{n}dcbn di} Zgfkizr Oimgln uaifnr, {ii, cfk {anlc{nr{ Rnfrn gf{n}dcbn, r~ba cr di~fk if {an AK=, grcocxgfj& G{ kinr di} Zgfkizr Oimgln zac{ g{ kinrdi} Cfk}igk ‛ ckkr c agjalw b~r{iogxcmln dcbn if{an IR {ac{ oc`nr g{ zi}` {an zcw {an ~rn} u}ndn}r&
GT& BIOUC]C[GTN R[^KW ID GUAIFN IR,CFK]IGK IR CFK ZGFKIZ IR
Biouc}grif id gUaifn IR, Cfk}igk IR cfk Zgfkizr
IR bcf mn kifn if {an mcrgr id dillizgfj uigf{r8
c&& @n}fnl/
gUaifn `n}fnl gr IR Q oimgln zagba cllizr Cuuln {i}n~rn c li{ id {an oc{~}n bikn {ac{ gr cl}nckw u}itnf {i zi}`if {an Ocb& Cfk}igk `n}fnl gr Lgf~q zan}n cr Zgfkizr`n}fnl gr BN4& BN 4&5 bcf }~f cr ocfw cr 2=,555rgo~l{cfni~r u}ibnrrnr, ncba zg{a = JM id tg}{~cl onoi}wrucbn& [an d~fb{gifclg{w id cf cuulgbc{gif gr jnfn}cllw~fcddnb{nk mw bacfjnr {i {an `n}fnl&
m&& O~l{g{cr`gfj/
Cfk}igk cfk gUaifn mi{a u}itgkn o~l{g{cr`gfj m~{gUaifn clri u}itgknr u~ra fctgjc{gif rn}tgbn zg{ao~l{g{cr`gfj& O~l{g{cr`gfj gf zgfkizr IR gr lgog{nk m~{ g{
u}itgknr u~ra fctgjc{gif rn}tgbn&b&& U}iu}gn{c}w bli~k/
Rwfb rn}tgbn/gUaifn‗r rn}tgbn Oimgln On gr ucgk zaglngf Cfk}igk g{ gr Jiijln cuur zagba c}n oir{lw d}nn&Zgfkizr u}itgknr rn}tgbn Ow Uaifn =&5 zagba gr~fbifdg}onk cfk d}nn&
&k&Aion Rb}nnf/gUaifn acr lgog{nk b~r{iogxc{gif r~uui}{ zagln
Zgfkizr r{c}{r rb}nnf zg{a b~r{iogxcmln {glnr&
n& R`gf cmln IR/ gUaifn IR cfk zgfkizr IR gr fi{ r`gf cmln i} g{ gr tn}w
lgog{nk gf {agr dnc{~}n zagln Cfk}igk IR gr r`gf cmln&
[AN MLCB@MN]]W IR CFK RWOMGCF
Biouc}grif mn{znnf Mlcb`mn}}w IR cfk Rwomgcf bcfmn kifn if {anrn uigf{r8
c& Ncrn id ~rn/
[an gf{n}dcbn id mlcb`mn}}w IR gr zaillw {a~omzannlk}gtnf cfk ~rn} ocw dgfk g{ ncrw {i ~rn {ai~ja g{ ogja{ mnrliz& [an}n gr c m~gl{/gf `nwmic}k zagba cbbnln}c{nr rioniun}c{gifr r~ba cr biouirgfj N/ocglr& Mlcb`mn}}w IR ocwfi{ mn {an oir{ nddgbgnf{ ifn m~{ g{ gr ncrw {i ~rn&
Rwomgcf IR j}nc{lw knunfkr if {an uaifn di} g{r ncrn id
~rn dnc{~}n& Di} nqcouln gf Fi`gc 7255 g{ gr tn}w ncrw {ifctgjc{n m~{ if {an i{an} rgkn gf Fi`gc 441= {an gf{n}dcbn grbifd~rgfj cfk kgddgb~l{ di} kc{c nf{}w&
m& N/ocgl/
Mlcb`mn}}w nqbnlr gf {agr c}nc& G{ gr fi{ iflw {an N/ocglcuuln{ zagba gr ckkgb{gtn di} g{r r{}ncolgfnk nddgbgnfbw m~{clri {an ‑u~ra‗ on{aik id n/ocgl knlgtn}w& Gfr{nck id mngfj}n{}gntnk ocf~cllw onrrcjnr cuunc} lg`n c ocjgb if kntgbn&
Rwomgcf gr cr tn}rc{gln cr i{an} ulc{di}o actgfj figffitc{gtn dnc{~}nr& Gd wi~ zcf{ rion{agfj c lg{{ln oi}n}im~r{, wi~ bcf baiirn d}io rntn}cl u~ra n/ocgl ril~{gifr,gfbl~kgfj Mlcb`Mn}}w Biffnb{& [an iun}c{gfj rwr{no clri
r~uui}{r Li{~r Fi{nr cfk Ogb}irid{ Nqbacfjn di}ocqgo~o biouc{gmglg{w gf {an bi}ui}c{n zi}lk&
b& O~l{gonkgc/
Mlcb`mn}}w IR gfbl~knr m~gl{/gf o~rgb ulcwn}, gf{nj}c{nkbcon}cr cfk {an lc{nr{ dnc{~}gfj tgkni }nbi}kgfj dcbglg{gnr&
[an Rwomgcf iun}c{gfj rwr{no gr u}n{{w cknu{ c{o~l{gonkgc, zg{a gf{nj}c{nk r~uui}{ di} c~kgi cfk tgkniulcwmcb` cfk }nbi}kgfj, {ai~ja fi{ cll {airn bcucmglg{gnr c}n}nclgxnk if {an kntgbnr {anornltnr& [an Fi`gc 7255, di}gfr{cfbn, bionr zg{a mi{a cf OU2 ulcwn} cfk {an oimglntn}rgif id ]nclUlcwn}, zagba nfcmlnr ulcwmcb` id
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 45
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 76/223
]nclC~kgi, ]ncl Tgkni, cfk OU2 dglnr& M~{ g{ bcffi{bcu{~}n c~kgi i} tgkni&
T& BIFBL^RGIFGf Bifbl~rgif, cll oimgln iun}c{gfj rwr{nor u}nrnf{nk
g{rnld cr c agjalw biounllgfj gftnr{onf{ if {ikcw‗r oimglnoc}`n{, {anw u}itnk {an}n rnld {i mn bcucmln {i }ncba ocfwkgddn}nf{ {wun bifr~on}r gf ocfw fnz cfk gffitc{gtn zcwr,cr znll cr {i }cgrn g{r izf M~rgfnrr& Mnrgknr cll {ancktcf{cjnr id Cfk}igk itn} Zgfkizr Oimgln, {an}n c}nrion ~rn}r zai c}n biodi}{cmln zg{a Zgfkizr Oimgln k~n{i g{r r{cmglg{w cfk {ang} nf{n}u}grn ril~{gif& D~}{an},Ogb}irid{ gr jigfj {i }nlncrn g{r Zgfkizr Oimgln :, zagbabcf mn o~ba mn{{n} {acf {an u}ntgi~r tn}rgif&
I~} cfclwrgr raizr {ac{ ncba Oimgln Iun}c{gfj Rwr{no
ocw actn r{}nfj{ar cfk rai}{biogfjr0 {an oir{ rnb~}nulc{di}o di} {an M~rgfnrr ~rn gr {an Mlcb`mn}}w ulc{di}o cfk{an gUaifn acr cktcfbnk {izc}kr mngfj nf{n}u}grn/blcrr&Rwomgcf m}gfjr g{r lgog{c{gifr zanf g{ bionr {i
kntnliuonf{& Cr nc}lgn} nqulcgfnk wi~‗ll fnnk c kgddn}nf{
RK@ di} ntn}w kntgbn&Wi~ zgll clri actn c kgddn}nf{ rn{
id “{iilr‟ gf ncba RK@ {agr zgll lgog{ {an ui}{gfj id u}ij}cor wi~ }gja{ di} c Rwomgcf Roc}{uaifn&G{ zgll zi}` if cll kntgbnr zg{a {an rcon RK@ m~{ if i{a
n}r g{ zgll jgtn u}imlnor&
]gja{ fiz gd wi~ c}n lii`gfj di} rion{agfj {ac{ gr c{ {an{gu id {nbafilijw {}nfk, Cfk}igk gr zac{ wi~ fnnk& G{ acrj}nc{ d~{~}n gd {anw `nnu {ang} gffitc{gif bwbln }~ffgfjbif{gf~i~rlw
TG& ]NDN]NFBNR
P3_& Rwomgcf IR B++ di} Oimgln Uaifnr mw ]gbac}k Ac}}grif
P=_& a{{r8))nf&zg gunkgc&i}j)zg`g)OimglnYiun}c{gfjYrwr{no
P2_&a{{u8))zzz&cuulngfrgkn}&bio)c}{gblnr)35)51)3=)cfk}igkYmcrnkYroc}{uaifnYraguonf{rYlncud}ijYcuulnrYguaifn&a{ol
P;_& Cfk}igk Grr~n 2:;18 Ckk r~uui}{ di} uc}{g{gif)mlib` kntgbnnfb}wu{gif
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 43
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 77/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :2172)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :2172
Knrgjf id KCIKT OCFN[ ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil
J& Glcfbanxagcucfkgcf
]nrnc}ba Rbailc} , Knuc}{onf{ id BRN,
Rc{awcmcoc ~fgtn}rg{w,banffcg
K}&U&Rang` Cmk~l @ackn}
U}idnrri} $ AIK, Knuc}{onf{ id Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr,
M&R&Cmk~} ]caocf ^fgtn}rg{w,Banffcg
Cmr{}cb{ / Ck/aib fn{zi}`gfj gr c bifbnu{ gf biou~{n}bioo~fgbc{gifr, zagba oncfr {ac{ ~rn}r zcf{gfj {i
bioo~fgbc{n zg{a ncba i{an} di}o c {noui}c}w fn{zi}`, zg{ai~{cfw di}o id bnf{}clgxnk ckogfgr{}c{gif& Ncba fikn uc}{gbguc{gfj gf{an fn{zi}` cb{r mi{a cr c air{ cfk cr c }i~{n}& [an r{~kw id kgr{}gm~{nk fn{zi}` cfk oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` !OCFN[' c}n
b~}}nf{lw {zi ai{rui{r gf kgr{}gm~{nk biou~{gfj cfk oimgln
bioo~fgbc{gif }nrnc}bagfj kiocgf& Zn m~glk ~u c kgr{}gm~{nkitn}lcw fn{zi}` if {iu id OCFN[*r uawrgbcl gfd}cr{}~b{~}n, {inddnb{gtnlw gf{nj}c{n kgr{}gm~{nk fn{zi}`‗r cktcf{cjn if
r~r{cgfgfj agjalw kwfcogb fn{zi}` gf{i {an knrgjf id OCFN[}i~{gfj u}i{ibil& Zn knuliw ucrrgtn OCFN[ }i~{gfj clji}g{aorzg{a gffitc{gtn kgr{}gm~{nk }i~{gfj onbacfgror& Zn u}iuirn cfnz `gfk id OCFN[ }i~{gfj u}i{ibil fconk kgr{}gm~{nk
Biou~{gfj mcrnk ck/aib if knocfk }i~{gfj !KCIKT'& I~}zi}` gfkgbc{nr {ac{ KCIKT acr cf gou}itnk }i~{gfjun}di}ocfbn gf biouc}grif zg{a {an uiu~lc}lw ~rnk CIKTu}i{ibil&
@nwzi}kr/ OCFN[, KCIKT, kgr{}gm~{nk fn{zi}`&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Gf ck/aib fn{zi}`r, bioo~fgbc{gifr c}n kifn itn}
zg}nlnrr onkgc mn{znnf r{c{gifr kg}nb{lw gf c kgr{}gm~{nk
dcragif zg{ai~{ {an anlu id zg}nk mcrn r{c{gif i} cbbnrr
uigf{r& Zg{a {an uiu~lc}g{w id ck/aib fn{zi}`r, ocfw
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr actn mnnf knrgjfnk di} }i~{n kgrbitn}w
cfk }i~{n ocgf{nfcfbn& [anw c}n oir{lw knrgjfnk di} mnr{
nddi}{ {}cfrogrrgif zg{ai~{ cfw j~c}cf{nn id s~clg{w id
{}cfrogrrgifr& Rion id {an oir{ dcoi~r }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
c}n Kwfcogb Ri~}bn ]i~{gfj !KR]' Ck/aib If Knocfk
Tnb{i} !CIKT' Iu{gogxnk Lgf` R{c{n ]i~{gfj u}i{ibil
!ILR]', cfk Xifn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil !X]U'& If {an i{an}rgkn, Kgr{}gm~{nk fn{zi}` gr b~}}nf{lw c ai{rui{ gf {an
gf{n}fc{gifcl fn{zi}` }nrnc}bagfj kiocgf& Kgddn}nf{ `gfkr
id kgr{}gm~{nk fn{zi}` oiknlr r~ba cr Fcur{n}, D}nnfn{ cfk
Jf~{nllc actn cl}nckw mnnf uiu~lc}lw ~rnk& Aizntn}, ncba
id {ano acr rion iunf u}imlnor P=_, P2_& [i riltn {anrn
u}imlnor, r{}~b{~}nk KGR[]GM^[NK itn}lcw fn{zi}`r
!RIF' r~ba cr BCF, Bai}k P;_, Ucr{}w cfk [cunr{}w c}n
u}iuirnk {i u}itgkn c `gfk id onbacfgro {i gou}itn
fn{zi}` rbclcmglg{w P>_& Cll id {anrn RIF clji}g{aor actn c
biooif j}i~fk {ac{ {anw cll crrgjf `nwr {i kc{c cfk fiknr
{a}i~ja c acragfj d~fb{gif, cfk c{ {an rcon {gon {anw ~rn
{anrn `nwr {i r{i}n cfk ocgf{cgf kc{c zagba c}n rac}nk gf
{an fn{zi}` P4_&
GG&ITN]TGNZ ID OCFN[ CFK KGR[]GM^[NK
FN[ZI]@R
KGR[]GM^[NK fn{zi}`r c}n uiu~lc} Gf{n}fn{ cuulgbc{gifr
{ac{ nfcmln ~rn}r {i rac}n biou~{gfj }nri~}bnr& [ikcw,
KGR[]GM^[NK, Znm m}izrgfj, cfk nocgl bcf mn u~{
{ijn{an} gf {an rcon blcrr id goui}{cfbn& Fcur{n} gr {an
{iil u}imcmlw oir{ }nruifrgmln di} {an uiu~lc}gxc{gif id
KGR[]GM^[NK fn{zi}`r k~n {i g{r o~rgb rac}gfj r~uui}{&
Ri dc}, rntn}cl Fcur{n} blifnr cfk jnfn}cl dgln rac}gfj
rwr{nor actn mnnf b}nc{nk, r~ba cr @cXcC, Mg{[i}}nf{,
cfk nO~ln& KGR[]GM^[NK fn{zi}`r c}n biouirnk id
rid{zc}n fiknr !unn}r' gfr{cllnk if {an nkjnr id {anGf{n}fn{, ~r~cllw gf gfnqunfrgtn ~rn} air{r clifj kgtn}rn
ckogfgr{}c{gtn kiocgfr& Ncba unn} bioo~fgbc{nr zg{a
i{an} unn}r kg}nb{lw i} gfkg}nb{lw {i rac}n libcl }nri~}bnr
!n&j&, onoi}w, dglnr, u}ibnrrgfj uizn}', di}ogfj }im~r{
kgr{}gm~{nk rwr{nor itn} {an Gf{n}fn{& [an KGR[]GM^[NK
bioo~fgbc{gif oiknl blnc}lw kgddn}r d}io {an blgnf{/rn}tn}
oiknl& Gf blgnf{/rn}tn}, rn}tn}r r{i}n }nri~}bnr cbbnrrnk mw
blgnf{r, mw bif{}cr{, gf KGR[]GM^[NK ncba unn} gr g{rnld c
}nuirg{i}w {ac{ rac}nr g{r }nri~}bnr zg{a i{an} unn}r, {a~r
di}ogfj nftg}ifonf{r zan}n }nri~}bnr c}n kgr{}gm~{nk
coifj unn}r cb{gfj cr mi{a rn}tn}r cfk blgnf{r&
Blgnf{/rn}tn} ckk}nrrgfj gr mcrnk if {an Gf{n}fn{ Kiocgf
Fcon Rwr{no !KFR', zagln KGR[]GM^[NK fn{zi}`r
nouliw ckk}nrrgfj rbanonr gfknunfknf{ d}io KFR {i
gfknq unn}r, ~rn}r, cfk }nri~}bnr& Blgnf{/rn}tn} onrrcjnr
c}n }i~{nk c{ {an fn{zi}` lcwn} mw Gf{n}fn{ }i~{n}r, m~{
KGR[]GM^[NK onrrcjnr c}n }i~{nk c{ {an cuulgbc{gif
lcwn} mw }i~{gfj unn}r&
Actgfj }i~{gfj cfk ckk}nrrgfj m~gl{ if {iu id Gf{n}fn{
u}i{ibilr, KGR[]GM^[NK fn{zi}`r c}n s~g{n kwfcogb
nftg}ifonf{r zan}n fnz unn}r bcf higf {an fn{zi}` zanf
{anw c}n r{c}{nk gf ~rn} air{r, cfk lnctn zanf ~rn}r
ra~{kizf {an unn}r& [agr kwfcogb fc{~}n oc`nr
KGR[]GM^[NK fn{zi}`r mi{a ~fu}nkgb{cmln cfk rbclcmln8
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 4=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 78/223
g
l
~fu}nkgb{cmln
nn}r {ac{ a
qucfrgif i
ckkg{gif id fnK~}gfj {
gou}itnonf{
K~n {i g{r u
zg{ai~{ cfw b
cr {an c}{ id
{an }nrnc}ba
clzcwr {c`nf
rgoglc}g{gnr c
gj~}n 3'&
& Kwfcogb F
Fiknr gf
nctn {an fn{
acfjn d}ns~Cfk {an oim
cf oc`n fn{
P1_&
mnbc~rn }nri
r{ {ano c}n
{an fn{zi}
z unn}r&n lcr{ bi
c}n ockn gf
rrgmglg{w {i
nf{}cl ocfcj
n{zi}`gfj zg
d KGR[]GM^
cr {zi rnuc
n rnnf mn{zn
n{zi}` [iuil
GR[]GM^[N
i}`, zagba
f{lw zg{a {goglg{w bac}cb{n
zi}` {iuilij
!c'&
~}bnr ocw mn
kizf0 rbcl
` bcucbg{w
~uln id w
{an }nrnc}ba i
}nc{n cfk i}
onf{, OCF
g{ai~{ c fn{z
[NK fn{zi}`
}c{nk c}ncr&
nf {anrn {zi
jw
K fn{zi}`r
c~rnr {an fn
n& G{ gr {an rc} id oimgln
w bacfjnr o
}bag{nb{~}n i
~fctcglcmln g
cmln mnbc~rn
ns~g}nr iflw
nc}r {}nonf
d ck aib fn{z
jcfgxn c fn{
[ gr bac}cb{n
}` P:_& B~}}n
cfk OCFN
~{ {an dilli
{nbafilijgnr
cfkiolw higf
{zi}` {iuili
on zg{a OCiknr gf OC
ba oi}n d}n
d OCFN[
d {an
{an
{an
ki~r
i}`r&
i}`
}gxnk
f{lw,
c}n
zgfj
!rnn
cfk
w {i
N[&FN[
~nf{
bi
bi
zg
bi
{a
k
cr
gf
{i
m
}i
m&
m
bc
bc
zg
K
{a
K
u
!m'& C}ba
Dgj& 3 Rgo
C& O~l{g/
Fiknr gf m
ffnb{ zg{a nc
ffnb{gifr gf
g{a uawrgbcll
ffnb{gifr gf
n }ckgi {}cfr
M& KnbnfMi{a KGR[]
bnf{}clgxnk r{
zac{ gr rnnf
{an fn{zi}`
ncba i{an}& [
{{lnfnb` bc~r
m~r{fnrr id {a
O~l{g/Gknf{g{w
Fiknr gf K
{a cr c blgnf{
f }i~{n cfk {
f clri u}itgk
g{a ncba i{an}
GG& K
c& C}bag{nb
[an c}bag{nb
GR[]GM^[N
c{ KCIKT
GR[]GM^[N
wrgbcl fn{zi}
g{nb{~}n id KG
glc}g{gnr id OCF
iu Biffnb{g
i{a OCFN
ba i{an} tgc
GR[]GM^[N
w ~flgog{nk
OCFN[ c}n
grrgif }cfjn&
}clgxnk bif{} GM^[NK fn
}~b{~}n& [an}
gf {an Blgnf{)
c}n cll unn}r
an fn{zi}` z
k c{ {an bnf{
n fn{zi}`&
id Fiknr
GR[]GM^[N
cfk c rn}tn},
}cfrdn} onrr
n }nri~}bn k
kg}nb{lw P7_&
RGJF ID K
{~}n id KCIK
{~}n id {an
biou~{gfj
u}i{ibil
itn}lcw fn{
` id {an OC
R[]GM^[NK
N[ cfk KGR[]GM
f
cfk kgr{}g
~l{g/aiu }i~{
K fn{zi}`r c
}cfjn, z
tgc zg}nlnrr l
l{zi}` cfk
n gr fi bnf{}
Rn}tn} fn{zi
fk bcf bio
gll fi{ r~ddn} {
cl rn}tn}, zag
fn{zi}` c
cr znll cr c }
jnr gfknunfk
zflickgfj c
IKT U]I[
T Oiknl
CIKT oi
{nbafilijw&
gr gf{nj}c{
i}` zagba g
N[&
Fn{zi}`
^[NK fn{zi}`r
~{nk fn{zi
gfj& Aiu/{i/
}n tgc [BU lg
gln aiu/{i/
gf`r, lgog{nk
CFN[ act
l ckogfgr{}c{g
}` oiknl& Fi
~fgbc{n kg}nb
an uc}clwrgr
gba gou}itnr
k OCFN[
~{n}& Ncba f
nf{lw& Cfk {
k bioo~fgb
IBIL
nl gr mcrnk
gj~}n = rai
nk zg{a
r m~gl{ ~uif
}`r
iu
`r
iu
mw
c
gif
nr
{lw
fk
{an
cb{
kn
nw
c{n
if
zr
{an
{an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 42
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 79/223
Dgj& = C}bag{nb{~}n id KCIKT Oiknl
c&Mcrgb Knrgjf
KCIKT ~rnr {an fikn fcogfj onbacfgro ~rnk gf Bai}k&
G{ ckiu{r c bifrgr{nf{ acragfj clji}g{ao P35_, P33_& Ncba
fikn gr crrgjfnk cf o/mg{ fikn gknf{gdgn} !FGK', zagba gr
im{cgfnk mw acragfj {an fikn*r GU ckk}nrr& [a~r zn c}n
cmln {i runbgdw {an libc{gif id {an fikn gf {an acra }gfj&Zanf c fikn higfr {an fn{zi}` di} {an dg}r{ {gon, c fnz
FGK }cfjgfj d}io 5 {i !=o/3' gr c~{ioc{gbcllw crrgjfnk
mcrnk if {an ckiu{nk acragfj clji}g{ao& [i rgoulgdw {an
}i~{gfj clji}g{ao, zn actn ckiu{nk {an kgrbif{gf~i~r
fcogfj onbacfgro ~rnk gf Bai}k& [an fikn r{c{n gr
ocgf{cgfnk gf {an KCIKT }i~{gfj {cmln !U][' zagba gr
rgoglc} {i {an }i~{gfj {cmln id CIKT& [an kgddn}nfbn gr
{ac{, KCIKT ~rnr {an FGK di} {an knr{gfc{gif fikn cfk
{an fnq{ aiu, zan}ncr {an lc{n} ~rnr {an fikn‗r GU ckk}nrr&
C& ]i~{n kgrbitn}w Clji}g{ao
[an KCIKT }i~{n kgrbitn}w clji}g{ao kgrbitn}r {an
}i~{n d}io {an ri~}bn fikn {i {an knr{gfc{gif fikn
}ncb{gtnlw& [an }i~{n kgrbitn}w gr {}gjjn}nk mw {an oimgln
fiknr ~fkn} cfw id {an dillizgfj, cfk cf ~ukc{n gr }ns~g}nk
gf {an U][ {cmln&
g& C fikn gfg{gc{nr {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w u}ibnk~}n&
gg& Zanf c fikn }nbngtnr {an }i~{n s~n}w onrrcjn
!]]NS', g{ s~n}gnr {an U][, gd {an }i~{n gr f~ll i} i~{ kc{nk,
{an }i~{n kgrbitn}w on{aik gr gfti`nk&
ggg& Zanf c }i~{n grr~nr c }i~{n n}}i} onrrcjn !]N]]' {i
{an fikn zagba gfg{gc{nk {an kc{c {}cfrogrrgif& [an
gfg{gc{gfj fikn r{c}{r {an }i~{n s~n}w on{aik&
C knrb}gu{gif id {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w clji}g{ao gr jgtnf
mnliz83' Fikn O banb`r di} ]]NS gf bcban& Gd {an ri~}bn
gknf{gdgn} cfk {an }ns~nr{ gknf{gdgn} gr {an rcon, {an }ns~nr{
gr kgrbc}knk&
=' O banb`r gf {an ]i~{n ]nbi}k zan{an} ]]NS
onrrcjn bif{cgfr FGK!O'& Gd di~fk, {an onrrcjn gr
kgrbc}knk&
2' O banb`r zan{an} {an knr{gfc{gif fikn gr u}nrnf{ gf
{an U][ nf{}gnr& Gd di~fk ji {i r{nu >, i{an}zgrn {i r{nu 4&
;' O banb`r zan{an} {an knr{gfc{gif fikn gr O g{rnld& Gd
{}~n, ji {i r{nu >, i{an}zgrn {i r{nu 4&
>' O banb`r zan{an} {an }i~{n gr mg/kg}nb{gifcl& Gd g{ gr,
{an }i~{n }nulw onrrcjn !]]NU' gr rnfk {i {an gfg{gc{gfj
fikn R kg}nb{lw& I{an}zgrn, {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w on{aik gr
gfti`nk&4' O ckkr g{rnld {i {an }i~{n }nbi}k cfk m}ickbcr{r
]]NS onrrcjn {i {an fngjami}r&
M& U][ S~n}wgfj Clji}g{ao
[an U][ s~n}wgfj clji}g{ao s~n}gnr {an U][ cfk ugb`r
~u {an Fnq{ Aiu ]gfj Gf{n}tcl !F]G' zagba gr {an blirnr{
{i K& Cfw i~{kc{nk nf{}gnr c}n ~ukc{nk& [an clji}g{ao gr
knugb{nk cr dillizr8
3' Zanf c fikn O gfg{gc{nr i} }nbngtnr c ]]NS
onrrcjn, g{ biouc}nr {an knr{gfc{gif fikn gknf{gdgn} id {an
]]NS zg{a FGK!O'& Gd {anw c}n oc{bank, O zgll }n{~}f
]]NU {i s~n}wgfj gfg{gc{gfj fikn R&
=' O zgll rnc}ba gf{i {an U][ cfk biouc}nr {an
knr{gfc{gif fikn gknf{gdgn} !K' zg{a {an U][ nf{}gnr {i dgfk{an F]G {i zagba K mnlifjr di} onrrcjn {}cfrdn}&
2' O {}gjjn}r {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w di} {an knr{gfc{gif
fikn cfk zcg{r di} {an }nruifrn& Gd {an }nruifrn gd }nbngtnk
{an U][ gr ~ukc{nk, i{an}zgrn c dcgl~}n onrrcjn gr rnfk&
b&KCIKT ]i~{n ^ukc{n cfk Ocgf{nfcfbn
]i~{n ocgf{nfcfbn gr }ns~g}nk k~n {i {an fiknr‗
oimglg{w& Gf OCFN[r, c fikn‗r uirg{gif bacfjnr zg{a {gon,
{agr lnckr {i kwfcogb fn{zi}` {iuilijw& C knr{gfc{gif
fikn ocw mnbion i~{ id }ncba k~n {i fi}ocl i} cmfi}ocl
knuc}{~}n i} acr oitnk i~{ id {an {}cfrogrrgif }cfjn&
Zanf {agr ibb~}r, {an }i~{n ~ukc{gfj clji}g{ao gr {}gjjn}nk
}ncb{gtnlw& Zanf {an}n gr c dcgl~}n gf {an kc{c {}cfrogrrgif,
{an fikn zagba gfg{gc{nk {an ucb`n{ {}cfrdn} zgll grr~n cf
itn}k~n onrrcjn {i {an }nlc{nk fiknr& [a~r {an U][
nf{}gnr c}n i~{kc{nk cfk {an }i~{n ~ukc{n gr {}gjjn}nk& Gd {an
}i~{n kgrbitn}w u}ibnrr nfkr gf c dcgl~}n, g{ oncfr {ac{ {an
knr{gfc{gif fikn acr oitnk i~{ id }cfjn& [an}ndi}n {an
knr{gfc{gif fikn gr oc}`nk cr gftclgk&
K~n {i {an agja kwfcogb bac}cb{n}, oimgln fiknr ocw
higf cfk lnctn {an fn{zi}` c{ cfw {gon& [i rctn {an }i~{n
ocgf{nfcfbn bir{, zanf c fikn higfr {an fn{zi}`, KCIKT
zgll fi{ gfg{gclgxn g{r U][& If {an bif{}c}w, {an U][ gr
bifr{}~b{nk iflw if knocfk&
KCIKT fiknr zgll iflw itn}anc} {an ri~}bn }i~{n
}nlc{nk {i {an fnq{ aiu fikn gf g{r libcl U][& Mw kigfj {agr,KCIKT gfan}g{r cll {an cktcf{cjnr id CIKT c{ {an rcon
{gon lgog{r& Mw {an ~rn id Uanlli onrrcjnr gf KCIKT,
oimgln fiknr m}ickbcr{ uanlli onrrcjnr }ncb{gtnlw&
[an}ndi}n {an gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{ {an fngjami} fiknr c}n
billnb{nk iflw zanf {an}n gr c fnnk di} }i~{n kgrbitn}w& Gd
{an knr{gfc{gif fikn gr ifn id {an fngjami}r, {an }i~{n
kgrbitn}w u}ibnrr r{iur cfk ]]NU gr }n{~}fnk {i {an ri~}bn&
Bifrns~nf{lw, {an itn}lick id fiknr gf KCIKT gr
}nk~bnk
GGG& RGO^LC[GIF ]NR^L[R
Dgln
Kgrbitn}w
Rn}tgbn
Gfdi}oc{gif
Ckogfgr{}c{gif
Rn}tgbn
Dgln
[}cfrdn}
Rn}tgbn
Bioo~fgbc{gif
Rnb~}g{w
Rn}tgbn
KGR[]GM^[NK Biou~{gfj Mcrnk OCFN[ ]i~{gfjClji}g{ao
KGR[]GM^[NK Itn}lcw Fn{zi}` !Fikn Fcogfj cfk
Gfknqgfj'
OCFN[ Uawrgbcl Fn{zi}`
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 4;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 80/223
g
g
l
Rgo~lc{gif
rucbn& [an
rgo~lc{gif ritnonf{ k
c~rn {gon !
{an oiknl& C
r{c{gb di} c U
ikn cfk oi
c}}gtnr, {an f
c fikn cr {
}nunc{nk {gll {
tcl~nr id U[&
f KCIKT‗
d fiknr {i {}
cb`n{r c}n 3
cb`n{r un} rn
C& Ucb`
Ucb`n{ kn
r{goc{gfj c }
ckcu{r {i {an
g{ u}itgknr c
d Ucb`n{ Knl
Uc~rn [gon&
Dgj& 2
[an u}imcm
dcgl~}n knb}n
[an r~bbnrr
KCIKT gr
KCIKT acr
nlgtn}w un}
r{}~b{~}nk KG
{an bcbagfj
g{r u}imlno gf
iz ucb`n{ kn
M& Ctn}
gr kifn zg{a
fiknr c}n
iun& Cfk n}gfj {an rgo
[' gr ~rnk {i
{ {an mnjgffg
& [anf g{ zgll
tnr {izc}k g{
kn zgll `nnu
an fnq{ knr{
an rgo~lc{gif
[i rgo~lc{n
un}di}ocfbn
cfrog{ BM]
1 mw{nr ucb`
bifk
n{ Knlgtn} ]c
lgtn} }c{gi g
i~{gfj u}i{ib
acfjn id fn{
i~{n kgrbitn}
gtn} ]c{gi mn{
Biouc}grif
K
glg{w id lgf` d
rnr zanf {a
}c{n cfk r{cm
~ba mn{{n} {
gou}itnk {
di}ocfbn mw
[]GM^[NK
nbacfgro ck
u}itgkgfj i~
lgtn} }c{gi&
cjn nfk {i Nf
dgd{w fiknr g
}cfkiolw kg
cba fikn u~lc{gif un}gi
kndgfn {an
j id rgo~lc{
}cfkiolw ba
zg{a c bn}{cg
r{c{gb di} c U
gfc{gif& [agr
nfkr& Zn b
{an fn{zi}`
, zn }cfkiol
cb`n{r {i ncb
{r zg{a c {}c
{gi
r cf goui}
il‗r un}di}oc
i}` {iuilijw
w& Dgj 2 knug
znnf KCIK
id UK] mn{z
IKT
cgl~}n mn{znn
oimglg{w id
glg{w id ucb`
cf CIKT&
n fikn kgrb
{c`gfj ck
}i~{gfj onba
u{nk gf CI
{/id/{gon fn{
k Knlcw !CN
c 3555o(35
r{}gm~{nk gf
}di}or c Mk& [an {}ckg{g
imgln bac}cb{
gif, c fikn `
iirn c knr{gf
gf runnk& Za
[ cfk {anf ba
u}ibnrr zgl
iirn di} kgdd
n}tgbnr‗ gfdl~
w baiirn =5
a i{an}& [an
rogrrgif }c{n
{cf{ b}g{n}gi
fbn gf aiz z
cfk aiz nddg
{r {an biouc
cfk CIKT
nf CIKT cf
f fiknr cfk
fiknr knb}n
{ {}cfrogrrgi
an }ncrif gr
itn}w cfk u
tcf{cjnr id
cfgror& Aiz
T gr {an i}gj
i}` r{c{~r cf
'
55o
{an
izfgifcl
n} id
nnur
c{gif
nf g{
iirn
l mn
}nf{
nfbn
ucg}r
M]
id ;
gf
nll g{
bgnf{
}grif
zg{a
k
i~{n
crnr&
f gf
{ac{
b`n{
{an
ntn},
gf id
k g{r
dc
bi
K
o
}i
K
m
O
cb
b&
k
{a
o
z
Dg
kg
[
Ctn}cjn nfk
r{ }i~{n kgr
ouc}grif i
CIKT cfk C
Dgj& ; Bi
CIKT nou
nbacfgro cf
~{n zanf {an
CIKT gou}
glkgfj ~u
CFN[‗r uaw
bnln}c{n {an }
ikn R{i}cjn
Dgj~}nb}ncrnr {an }
n rcon {go
cgf{nfcfbn i
ll&
& > Biouc}g
[an bcbank
}nb{ u}iui}{gi
c{ gr, di} c O
/{i/nfk knlcw
bitn}w gr k
Ctn}cjn
IKT zg{a Uc
ouc}grif id CN
liwr m}ickbc
bifr~onr l
b~}}nf{ uc{a
tnr {an }i
KGR[]GM
rgbcl {iuili
~{n kgrbitn}
Itn}anck !F
> knugb{r~{n r{i}cjn i
g{ knb}ncr
n}anck }nlc{
grif id FRI mn{
i~{nr di} c
f {i {an f~o
CFN[ zg{a
nr{goc{nr a
ifn& Dgj~}n
fk/{i/Nfk
~rn [gon&
mn{znnf CIK
r{gfj mcrnk
ifjn} {gon {
acr dcglnk&
{n kgrbitn}w
[NK itn}lc
w cfk gf{}i
u}ibnrr&
I'
{ac{ KCItn}anck di} n
r {an }i~{n
k {i {anrn b
nnf CIKT cfk
imgln fikn g
mn} id fiknr
fiknr, {an b
z nddgbgnf{
; knugb{r
Knlcw mn{z
cfk KCIKT
}i~{n kgrbit
i }n/kgrbitn
f {an bif{}c
nddgbgnf{lw
w fn{zi}`
k~bgfj U][
KT nddnb{gtcba fikn, cfk
kgrbitn}w
cbank }i~{nr
KCIKT
f CIKT c}n
gf {an fn{zi
cbank }i~{nr
fk
{an
nf
}w
c
}w,
mw
if
{i
nlwc{
fk
cr
gf
}`&
di}
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 4>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 81/223
l
g
cba fikn gr
r{}~b{~}nk
}nlc{gifragu
zg{a {an f~KCIKT nddn
di} ncba fikn
grbitn}w cf
cbank }i~{nr
B& ]i~{
Dgj~}n 4 k
n{znnf KC
Dgj& 4 Bi
[an f~om
{an f~omn} i
}i~{n ocgf{n
cbank }i~{n
cfk knb}ncr
KCIKT gou
r{}~b{~}nk KG
cfk lgog{gfj {
KCIKT
KGR[]GM^[
ijgbcl fconr
un}c{gfj gfKCIKT a
KGR[]GM^[
agjalw kwfc
rbclcmglg{w& M
u{gogxgfj o
r{}~b{~}nk KG
}i~{gfj nddgbg
P3_ Onfj`~f
gou}itgfj rnc}b
I!F'& If {
GR[]GM^[N
d bcbank }i~
mn} id fiknb{gtnlw knb}n
, cfk c{ {an r
k ocgf{nfcf
cr znll&
gfj Itn}anck
nugb{r {an bi
KT cfk CI
uc}grif id ]
} id }i~{n uc
d bcbank }i~
cfbn cfk ~u
bifr~on o
{an un}di
}itnr {an }i~{
GR[]GM^[NK
an f~omn} id
GT& rncolnrrlw
K itn}lcw }
ucbn zg{a {ai
c uawrgbclcr gfan}g{nk
K fn{zi}`g
gb fn{zi}`
rgknr {anrn,
nbacfgror {i
R[]GM^[NK
fbw&
]ND
Wcfj cfk Xi
a nddgbgnfbw gf
an bif{}c}w,
K }i~{gfj
{nr di} ncba
r gr I!lijFrnr {an }i~{n
con {gon g{ k
n itn}anck
!]I'
uc}grif id
T zg{a Uc~r
mn{znnf C
b`n{r gf CI
{nr di} ncba
c{n u}ibnrrn
~ba id {an f
ocfbn id
gfj un}di}oc
itn}lcw fn
bcbank }i~{nr
BIFBL^RG
gf{nj}c{nr {
~{gfj u}i{ib
rn id OCFN
fconrucbn&cll {an
fj {nbafili
r cfk ocg
KCIKT gf{}
riltn {an kn{
itn}lcw fn{z
]NFBNR
fjogfo Dng, “
~fr{}~b{~}nk un
mw goulnon
onbacfgro,
fikn gf KC
'& Mw kigfjr{i}cjn itn}
nb}ncrnr {an
}nlc{nk {i {
i~{gfj Itn}
[gon&
KT cfk KC
T gr a~jn k
ikn gr a~jn&
r bc~rnk mw {
{zi}` mcfk
CIKT& Za
bn mw gf{}ik
{zi}` {nbafi
&
IF
n d~fb{gifr
lr iun}c{gfj
}i~{gfj u}i{
Mw {agr ocktcf{cjnr
w gf r~r{cg
{cgfgfj fn{
k~bnr c rn}g
~}gfj u}imln
i}` cfk gou}
fitnl cuu}ic
}/{i/unn} fn{z
{gfj
{an
KT
{agr,anck
i~{n
anrn
anck
KT
n {i
[an
anrn
gk{a
}ncr
bgfj
lijw
id
gf c
bilr
cfr,id
fgfj
i}`
r id
o id
itnr
ba {i
i}`r,‟
Hi
F
cf
[auu
fn
=5
@
un
if
mn
fn
F
ui
[n
{i
Rn
32
-Gr
d~{
Bi
di
Bi
2:
Z
Bi
go
F
Rw
~}fcl id Uc}clln
tnomn}, =557
P=_ H& Q~, -If
k fn{zi}` kgcon{
n Bifdn}nfbn if& =3::/=31:&
P2_ R& Rnf cfk
{zi}`r,- GNNN)C
5;, uu& =37/=2=&
P;_ G& R{igbc,
crain`, D& Kcmn
n} lii`~u u}i{ib
Fn{zi}`gfj, Til
P>_ H& Q~, C&
{znnf }i~{gfj
{zi}`r,- GNNN Hi
& 3, Hcf =55;, uu
P4_ R& Hcgf, ]& O
{nf{gcl id KA[/
bafilijgnr cfk R
P:_ R& Hgcfj, W&tc}gcmln {iuilijg
lnb{nk C}ncr gf
>4&
P1_ K& Bctclbcf
r~nr gf gf{nj}c{
~}gr{gb an{n}i
oo~fgbc{gifr, T
P7_ B& A& Dia
o~lc di} ifn/kg
fdn}nfbn if Bi
;=&
P35_ C& K~}cf
FB =55; /
fdn}nfbn, Til& >,
P33_ H& Ogrba`n
ulnonf{c{gif di}
OR =55; / G
ouirg~o, Til& 7,
l cfk Kgr{}gm~{n
{an d~fkconf{cl
n} gf unn}/{i/unn
Biou~{n} Bioo
& Zcfj, -Cfclw
O [}cfrcb{gifr
& Oi}}gr, K& L
`, cfk A& Mclc`
l di} gf{n}fn{ cu
& 33, Fi& 3, Dnm
~oc}, cfk Q&
{cmln rgxn cfk
~}fcl if Rnlnb{n
& 3>3/342&
cachcf, cfk K&
crnk itn}lcwr,-
wr{nor!^RG[R =5
g~, W& Hgcfj, cfknr di} }i~{gfj rba
ioo~fgbc{gifr,
{g, K& Cj}czcl,
gfj bnll~lc} fn{
nfni~r zg}nl
il& 3=, Fi& 2, H~
fk M& R& Lnn, -
nfrgifcl OCF
o~fgbc{gifr, T
cfk B&/B& Ranf,
GNNN Zg}nlnrr
Fi& 3, Oc}ba =5
cfk M& R{glln},
c agjalw rbclcml
NNN)GDGU Fn{z
Fi& 3, Cu} =55;,
k Biou~{gfj, T
{}ckniddr mn{zn
} fn{zi}`r,- GNN
~fgbc{gifr, Til&
xgfj unn}/{i/unn
if Fn{zi}`gfj,
gmnf/Fiznll, K&
}grafcf, -Bai}k8
ulgbc{gifr,- GNN
552, uu& 3:/2=&
W~, -If {an d~
fn{zi}` kgcon
k C}ncr gf Bio
n{an}cll, -C r{~k
;{a^RNFGQ Rw
52', Oc}ba =552&
S& Wgf, -U}itgrgnonr gf OCFN
Til& ==, Fi& :,
B& Bi}kng}i, M&
zi}`r, ZLCFr,
rr fn{zi}`,-
n =55>&
C blirnk di}o f
[r,- GBB =55; /
il& =:, Fi& 3, H
-Oimgln ck ai
Bioo~fgbc{gif
5;, uu& 33;/337&
-Nddgbgnf{ u}i{ib
n unn}/{i/unn} r
i}` Iun}c{gifr
uu& ;33/;=;&
il~on 47 Grr~n
f }i~{gfj {cmln
GFDIBIO , =5
==, Fi& 3, Oc} =
{}cddgb cb}irr l
Til& 3=, Fi& =,
]& @c}jn}, O&
C rbclcmln unn}
)CBO [}cfrcb{g
fkconf{cl {}ckn
{n} gf unn}/{i/
~fgbc{gifr, Til&
id {an un}di}oc
uirg~o if Gf{n
&
ifgfj id ckcu{cmgr,- GNNN Hi~}fc
Rnu =55;, uu& 32
Qgn, cfk C& @~
cfk OCFN[r8
GNNN Zg}n
n{zi}` biffnb{g
GNNN Gf{n}fc{g
fn =55;, uu& 2:
U=U dgln rac}g
r cfk Fn{zi}
il runbgdgbc{gif
c}ba gfd}cr{}~b{~
cfk Ocfcjn
33,
rgxn
2 /
52,
}jn
Cu}
D&
/{i/
ifr
ddr
nn}
==,
fbn
}fn{
glg{wl if
;:/
c},
8 C
lnrr
tg{w
fcl
27/
j,-
gfj
cfk
}n,-
nf{
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 44
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 82/223
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 4:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 83/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :2755)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :2755
Oiknlgfj Goucb{ id Tc}wgfj Kc{c ]c{nr di} Tc}gi~r Ru}nck Runb{}~o
[nbafgs~nr if Lick gf ZLCF Ck/Aib Oikn
]chcf Tia}c
Lnb{~}n}, Knuc}{onf{ id
Nlnb{}ifgbr [nbafilijwJ~}~ Fcfc` Knt ^fgtn}rg{w
Co}g{rc}, U~fhcm, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{8/&Zg}nlnrr Libcl C}nc Fn{zi}` !ZLCF' ~rnr
agja d}ns~nfbw }ckgi zctnr }c{an} {acf zg}nr {i
bioo~fgbc{n cfk {}cfrog{ kc{c& C zg}nlnrr libcl c}nc
fn{zi}` lgf`r {zi i} oi}n kntgbnr cfk jgtnr ~rn}r {an
oimglg{w {i oitn c}i~fk zg{agf c libcl bitn}cjn c}nc cfk
r{gll mn biffnb{nk {i {an fn{zi}`& Zg}nlnrr kc{c biffnb{gifractn gfan}nf{lw agja mg{ n}}i} }c{nr, liz mcfkzgk{a cfk lifj
knlcwr& Gf {agr ucun} IUFN[ Oiknln} 7&3 fn{zi}` rgo~lc{i}
acr mnnf ~rnk {i ki {an biouc}c{gtn oiknlgfj cfk
rgo~lc{gif id {an lick di} kgddn}nf{ kc{c }c{nr !3, =, >&>,33
omur' cfk tc}gi~r {nbafgs~nr !DA, KR, GD' cfk bifbl~knk
DA {nbafgs~n gr mn{{n} gf 3 Omur rbnfc}gi cfk mnr{ gf 33
Omur rbnfc}gi {acf KR cfk GD {nbafgs~nr&P:&1_
@nwzi}kr8 ZLCF, Lick, IUFN[, DA, KR, GD&
3& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Zg}nlnrr LCFr c}n mnbiogfj uiu~lc} {an zi}lk itn}
k~n {i ncrn id gfr{cllc{gif, cfk {an cmglg{w {i iddn} zg}nlnrrcbbnrr {i {ang} ~rn}r id{nf di} d}nn P3_& [an GNNN !Gfr{g{~{n
id Nlnb{}gbcl cfk Nlnb{}ifgb Nfjgfnn}r' 15=&33
runbgdgbc{gifr ~rnk {an =&; JAx d}ns~nfbw mcfk cfk
gfg{gcllw r~uui}{nk c ocqgo~o kc{c }c{n id 3 {i = Omur &
[an 15=&33m runbgdgbc{gif gfb}ncrnk {an un}di}ocfbn {i
33 Omur gf {an =&; JAx }cfjn& G{ nfbioucrrnr {an
uawrgbcl !UAW' cfk {an onkgc cbbnrr bif{}il !OCB'
lcwn}r id {an GRI rntnf/lcwn} fn{zi}` oiknl P=_& Zg}nlnrr
libcl c}nc fn{zi}`r !ZLCFr' mcrnk if {an GNNN 15=&33
r{cfkc}k c}n ifn id {an dcr{nr{ j}izgfj Zg}nlnrr cbbnrr
{nbafilijgnr gf {an zi}lk {ikcw& [anrn u}itgkn cf
nddnb{gtn oncfr id cbagntgfj zg}nlnrr kc{c biffnb{gtg{w gf
aionr, u~mlgb ulcbnr cfk iddgbn cfk clri nfcmln uniuln if
{an oitn {i bioo~fgbc{n zg{a cfwifn, cfwzan}n c{cfw{gon zg{a c }cfjn id o~l{gonkgc P3/2_& [an ZLCF
onkgc gr n}}i} u}ifn cfk {an mg{ n}}i} }c{n !MN]' gr tn}w
agja biouc}nk {i {an MN] id zg}nk fn{zi}`r& Gf ckkg{gif,
Bc}}gn} Rnfrgfj gr kgddgb~l{ gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r mnbc~rn c
r{c{gif gr gfbcucmln id lgr{nfgfj {i g{r izf {}cfrogrrgifr gf
i}kn} {i kn{nb{ c billgrgif&
[an}n c}n {zi iun}c{gif oiknr kndgfnk gf GNNN 15=&33
!c' Gfd}cr{}~b{~}n Oikn
Gf {an gfd}cr{}~b{~}n oikn cmitn, {an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` bifrgr{r id c{ lncr{ ifn CU !cbbnrr uigf{' biffnb{nk {i {an
zg}nk gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& Cll {an zg}nlnrr r{c{gifr c}n biffnb{nk {i{an CU& Cf CU bif{}ilr nfb}wu{gif if {an fn{zi}` cfk clri bcf
}i~{n {an zg}nlnrr {}cddgb {i c zg}nk fn{zi}` !rcon cr c }i~{n}'&
Zn bcf crr~on cf CU cr rgoglc} {i mcrn r{c{gif ~rnk gf
bnll~lc} fn{zi}`r&
!m' Ckaib OiknCU gr fi{ }ns~g}nk gf Ck/Aib oikn, {an zg}nlnrr r{c{gif gr
biffnb{nk {i ncba i{an} kg}nb{lw zg{ai~{ ~rgfj cf CU i} cfw
i{an} biffnb{gif& [an {iuilijw gr ~rnd~l {i rn{ ~u c zg}nlnrr
fn{zi}`r s~gb`lw& Ck/Aib oikn gr clri bcllnk unn} {i unn}
oikn i} !GMRR' Gfknunfknf{ Mcrgb Rn}tgbn Rn{&
[agr ucun} knclr zg{a {an lick iu{gogxc{gif {nbafgs~nr {ac{
bcf mn nddnb{gtnlw ~rnk di} c ZLCF mcrnk if {an fn{zi}`
rgo~lc{i}, IUFN[ Oiknln} 7&3P2_&
GG& OIKNL I^[LGFN
Gf i~} oiknl, zn ~rnk {zi zi}`r{c{gifr mn{znnf zagba,
zn {}cfrdn} gfdi}oc{gif)kc{c {a}i~ja zg}nlnrr oikn zg{a {an
anlu id kgddn}nf{ {nbafgs~nr cfk kc{c }c{nr {ac{ c}n ctcglcmln
gf IUFN[ OIKNLN] 7&3& Zn actn ockn ; rbnfc}gir cfk
gf ncba rbnfc}gi ; kgddn}nf{ kc{c }c{nr di} 2 kgddn}nf{
{nbafgs~nr !D}ns~nfbw Aiuugfj, Kg}nb{ Rns~nfbn cfk
Gfd}c}nk' actn mnnf nouliwnk di} i~} rgo~lc{gif cfk {a}i~ja
{anrn rbnfc}gir zn biouc}n lick uc}con{n} cfk ntcl~c{n {an
un}di}ocfbn c{ kgddn}nf{ kc{c }c{nr di} tc}gi~r {nbafgs~nr&[cmln G raizr {an ZLCF {}cddgb jnfn}c{gif uc}con{n}r
di} mi{a {an rbnfc}gi& Iun}c{gif Oikn ~rnk gf {an rbnfc}gi grrn}gcl !i}kn}nk', r{c}{ {gon !rnbifkr' c}n ~fgdi}o !355,335',}nun{g{gif uc{{n}f gf {an rbnfc}gir gr rn}gcl, f~omn} id }nun{g{gifr gr bifr{cf{ cfk }nr{ id {an uc}con{n}r ~rnk c}nlgr{nk gf {cmln mnliz8
[cmln GG raizr {an uc}con{n}r, zagba c}n ~rnk gfkgddn}nf{ rbnfc}gir di} rgo~lc{gif& Uc}con{n}r gfkgbc{n {ac{zn ~rn UAW bac}cb{n}gr{gbr cr Kg}nb{ rns~nfbn, D}ns~nfbwAiuugfj cfk Gfd}c}nk, m~ddn} rgxn !mg{r' 35=; ` di} cllrbnfc}gir& Mcfkzgk{a ~rnk di} {an ZLCF gf rbnfc}gi 3 cfkrbnfc}gi = gr 3 Omur cfk = Omur }nrunb{gtnlw cfk di}rbnfc}gi 2 cfk ; g{ gr >&> cfk 33 Omur }nrunb{gtnlw&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 41
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 84/223
G
Gf I~} o{}cfrdn} gfdi
{nbafgs~nr ~rg
UFN[ OI
actgfj kgddn}
n}di}ocfbn
rbnfc}gir act
355(355o Z
n}di}ocfbn ~
Omur }nrunb{g
ZLCF rbnf
[CMLN G&
]n
Iun
R{c}{
Gf{n}/}
!rn
F~omn
GG& RGO^LC[
knl, zn ~rnk}oc{gif)kc{c
fj tc}gcmln k
NLN] 7&3& A
f{ kc{c }c{n
gr ntcl~c{nk
n mnnf {nr{nk
CF oiknl dc
fkn} kgddn}nf{
nlw&
c}gi c{ kgddn}nf{ {
Zg}nlnrr LCF {}c
C{{}gm~{n
K~}c{gif
unc{cmglg{w
}c{gif Oikn
gon !rnbifkr'
nun{g{gif [gon
bifkr'
} id ]nun{g{gifr
GIF NTCL^
{zi zi}`r{c{gzg}nlnrrlw
{c }c{nr zagb
n}n zn actn
di} tc}gi~r
~fkn} {anrn
gf bcou~r
glw& Gf {agr u
kc{c }c{nr id
bafgs~nr !DA, K
ddgb jnfn}c{gif u
Tcl
Nfk id rg
Ifbn
[gon
Rn}gcl !
~fgdi}o !
bifr{cf
bifr{c
C[GIF
ifr gf zagba,i} {an tc}g
a c}n ctcglcml
ockn ; rbnfc
{nbafgs~nr&
rbnfc}gir& [
ftg}ifonf{
un}, zn tn}gdw
3, =, >&>, cfk
R, GD' cfk kc{c }
c}con{n}r
l~n
o~lc{gif
{ R{c}{
}kn}nk'
355,335'
{ !255'
{ !25'
zngi~r
gf
}gir
[an
nrn
g{a
{an
33
{nr&
}c{
imr
fi
{nb
Om
Kg}
35
kc{
c}i
{an
G]
!mg{
cf
{n}
Om
gf
rbn
mc
B
[
]nun{g{gi
Zn actn imr
r di} tc}gi~r
n}tnk {ac{ c{
nr gr bio
afgs~nr!KR,D
ur rbnfc}gi D
nb{ Rns~nfbn
,555!mg{r)rnb
Dgj~}n
c }c{n, {an}n g
~fk 2>5,555
rcon {gon D
{nbafgs~n,
r)rnb' di} DA&
Zanf zn bi
DA {nbafgs~
r id Mg{r)rnb
ur rbnfc}gi
3 Omur rbnf
fc}gi& ]ncri
kzgk{a jgtnr
fiknr ~rgfj g
Uc}con{n}
!r'
Ckk}nrr
ZLCF
mcfkzgk{a
!mur'
UAWac}cb{n}gr{gbr
Rli{ {gon
!r'
Ucb`n{
]nbnu{gif/
Uizn}
a}nrailk !Z'
Rai}{
]n{}w Lgog{!C{{nou{r'
Lifj
]n{}w Lgog{!C{{nou{r'
M~ddn}
rgxn!mg{r'
Ocq
]nbngtn
Lgdn{gon
!rnbr'
f Uc{{n}f
n}tnk {an }nr
{nbafgs~nr&
= cfk >&> Om
c}c{gtnlw r
A cfk GD' m
}ns~nfbw Ai
cfk Gfd}c}n
di} {an un}gi
> raizr {ac{
k}cr{gb gfb}
mg{r)rnb' di} {
cfk KR {nba
335,555 !mg{
uc}n rbnfc}g
nr c}n mn{{n}
gf bcrn id 33
agba raizr {
c}gi gr lnrr
di} {agr gr
lnrr lick if {
f {an rbnfc}gi
Rbnf
c}gi 3 c}g
C~{i Crrgj
3
Omur O
KR,DA,GD A
35=;555
5&>
Rn}gcl
~l{r id Lick
}io dgj~}n 2
ur Lick !mg{
on di} cll
{ dgj~}n 3 r~
ugfj {nbafgs
[nbafgs~nr
35/45 ogf~{
i} GD {nbafgs
crn gf Lick i
an un}gik 5/4
fgs~nr jgtn m
r)rnb' di}
di} 3Omur c
{acf G]& [an
Omur rbnfc}g
ac{ {an lick i
r biouc}nk
zi}`gfj id
an
&
Rbnf
i =
Rbn
c}gi 2
fnk C
=
mur
>&>
Omur
KR,D,GD
KR,A,GD
>&5 N/5>
:&22 N/3;
:
;
c{ kgddn}nf{ k
cfk ; zn a
r)rnb' c{ ZL
{an kgddn}
jjnr{r {ac{ c
~n gr mn{{n} {
mw >5,555
nr&
n zg{a 33 O
f ZLCF fi
ogf~{nr, m~
n{{n} }nr~l{r {
R cfk >5,
fk 33 Omur,
cl~n id Lick
i gr oi}n {ac
f ZLCF fi
{i {an 33 O
rbnfc}gi c{ l
f Rbnf
c}gi ;
~{i Crrgjfnk
33
Omur
D KR,DA,GD
35=;555
5&>
c{c
tn
F
nf{
{ 3
cf
fk
ur
nr
{ c{
cf
55
KR
gf
3
nr
ur
nrr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 47
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 85/223
Dgj 38 Lick
[CMLN GG8 R
Dgj =8 Lick
{ 3 Omur gf kgddn
go~lc{gif rbnfc}g
{ = Omur gf kgddn
}nf{ {nbafgs~nr
gi uc}con{n}r
}nf{ {nbafgs~nr
di}
}nrcf
{nb
mnr
zc
}ns
}nr
{nb
Dgj 28 Lick c{
Dgj ;8 Lick c{ 3
[agr ucun} g
kgddn}nf{ kc{
~l{ id {an Li; {an}n gr
afgs~nr& DA {
{ gf 33 Omur
{ {i zi}`
~g}nk lnrr L
~l{r zn zgll
afgs~nr&
&> Omur gf kgddn
3 Omur gf kgddn}
GT& BI
tnr{gjc{nr {a
}c{nr cfk {nb
k gr biouc}ck}cr{gb ba
nbafgs~n gr m
rbnfc}gi {ac
zg{a agja
ck if ZL
iu{ DA {nb
}nf{ [nbafgs~nr
f{ {nbafgs~nr
BL^RGIF
n Lick if {a
afgs~nr& Di}
{gtnlw rcon mfjn gf Lic
n{{n} gf 3 O
KR cfk GD {
cfkzgk{a n
F fiknr {a
fgs~n itn}
n ZLCF fi
rbnfc}gi = cf
~{ gf Rbnfc}gk di} kgddn}
ur rbnfc}gi
bafgs~nr& Gd
tg}ifonf{
f mw imrn}
{an KR cfk
nr
2
3nf{
fk
zn
fk
nk
GD
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 86/223
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ Zclgk Afng{g cfk Fcgo Chli~fg, “Un}di}ocfbn Nfacfbnonf{ id
Zg}nlnrr Libcl C}nc Fn{zi}`r‟,U}ibnnkgfjr id GNNN GB[[C‗54, =fkGf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Gfdi}oc{gif Bioo~fgbc{gif[nbafilijgnr8
d}io [ani}w {i Cuulgbc{gifr, Kcocrb~r, Rw}gc, til& =, uu& =;55/ =;5;,
Cu}gl =554&
P=_ L&Mififg, O& Bif{g, cfk N& J}nji}g,“]~f{gon Iu{gogxc{gif id GNNN 15=&33 Zg}nlnrr LCFr Un}di}ocfbn,‟ GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr if
Uc}cllnl Cfk Kgr{}gm~{nk Rwr{nor, til& 3>, uu& 3>7 ‒ 3:=&Hcf~c}w =55;&
P2_ Oiacoock A~rrgcf Clg cfk Ocfcl @ckago Ikca,“Rgo~lc{gifR{~kw 5d 15=&33m KBD ^rgfj IUFN[ Rgo~lc{i}‟, Nfj& $ [nba& Hi~}fcl,
Til& =:,Fi4 , uu& 3351/333:& =557&
P;_ Or& Coc}knnu @c~}3, K}& Rcfkgu Tghcw=, K}&
R&B&J~u{c2 “Un}di}ocfbn Cfclwrgr cfk Nfacfbnonf{ id GNNN15=&33 Zg}nlnrr Libcl C}nc Fn{zi}`r‟ Til& 7 Grr~n >
!Tn}=&5',uu&325&Hcf~c}w =535&
P>_ S& Fg, G& Cck, B& Mc}c`c{, cfk [& [~}ln{{g, “Oiknlgfj cfk
Cfclwrgr id Rliz BZ Knb}ncrn di} GNNN 15=&33 ZLCF‟& 3;{a GNNN
U}ibnnkgfjr if Un}rifcl, Gfkii} cfk Oimgln ]ckgiBioo~fgbc{gifr,GNNN UGO]B =552,til& =, uu& 3:3:/3:=3& Mnghgfj,
Rnu{nomn}=552&
P4_ Nlnfc Liunx/Cj~gln}c, Oc}{gf An~rrn, D}cfb` ]i~rrnc~, Cfk}nxnh K~kc cfk Hi}kg Bcrcknoif{,“ Ntcl~c{gfj
Zg}nlnrr LCF Cbnrr Oi{aikr gf U}nrnfbn id [}cfrogrrgif
N}}i}r‟&GFDIBIO =554&Mc}bnlifc, uu& 3/4, Rucgf,Cu}gl =2/=7, =554&
P:_ ]chcf Tia}c0 ]&R&Rczafnw0 Ocfh~ Rac}oc8 “
Un}di}ocfbn Nfacfbnonf{ id ZLCF mw M~ddn} Rgxn Iu{gogxc{gif ~rgfjIUFN[‟ Fc{gifcl bifdn}nfbn if Cktcfbn Biou~{gfj cfk
Bioo~fgbc{gif [nbafilijw !CBB[/35' i}jcfgxnk mw Tcgra Billnjn id
Nfjgfnn}gfj, ]ia{c`, =>/=4 H~fn,=535 uu ;7>/;77
P1_ ]chcf Tia}c0 ]&R&Rczafnw0 Rag`ac8 “ ZLCF On{}gbnr
nfacfbnonf{ ~rgfj M~ddn} Rgxn Iu{gogxc{gif‟ Gf{n}fc{gifcl Hi~}fcl id
U=U Fn{zi}` [}nfkr cfk [nbafilijw/ Til~on 3 Grr~n = /=533 Ucjn ==/
=> !GRRF8 ==;7/=43>'
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 87/223
U}ib& id {a
il~on 3& Bi
GRMF8 7:1/1
Tn}{g
Cmr{}cb{ / R
fn{zi}`r gr i
zg}nlnrr fn{z
{agr rncolnrr
Tn}{gbcl Acf
{agr bif{gf~g{
rbanonr c}n c
acfkitn} knb
zagba u}itgk
rncolnrr oimg@nwzi}kr / Tn
KTAK,B/KTA
Rnc
cfw rwr{no
mn{{n} SiR k
cfi{an}& G{
{nlnbioo~fg
u}i{ibilr zag
C onrrcj
{an rn}tgfj
gfkgbc{gif {
bioo~fgbc{g
Cll ckkg{gif
zg}nlnrr fn{fn{zi}` {i {
}nbngtnk {an
{an fngjami}
}ckgi rgjfcl
fngjami}gfj
ogfgo~o {
bioo~fgbc{g
fn{zi}` {i {a
cd{n} {an fng
zg}nlnrr bac
acfkitn} }ns
GG& TN]
Gf acf
Acfkitn} !
!TAI' cr r
u}ibnrr zan
fn{zi}` zg{aZg/Dg {i Zg/
cbbnrr uigf{
biffnb{gtg{w
fi}ocllw {i
n Gf{l& Bifd&
uw}gja{ § =53
3/7=5>:>/:/4
CBO "8 kmn}
bcl Acfk
}tgbn bif{gf
fn id {an bacl
}`r& Acfkit
imglg{w zagln
itn} acr mnn
& Gf {agr ucun
fclwxnk cfk {
grgif rbanon
n lnrr u}ibnr
glg{w itn} an{n}{gbcl Acfkitn
K&
G& GF
lnrr acfkit
g{a oimglg{w
}gfj u}ibnrr
gr c on
c{gifr rwr{n
ba c}n kgddn}n
n gr rnf{ d}i
zg}nlnrr fc{ {an oi
j zg{a {an
l gfdi}oc{gi
i}` gr clri ran oimgln r{
oimgln r{c{gi
gfj zg}nlnrr
r mn{znnf
g}nlnrr fn{z
a}nrailk {a
f {}cfrcb{gi
n fngjami}gf
ami}gfj zg}n
fnl di} {an
~nr{&
GBCL ACF
AC
kitn} {an}n c
AI' cfk c
izf gf Dgj&
{an oimgln
{an rcon {nbDg& Tn}{gbcl a
gf c fn{zi}`
g{ ~rnr {i
f Biou~{n}
= [nbafi Di
88 kig8 35& :2
&gon}c&35& :2
itn} Knb
Crrg
g{w gf an{n}
lnfjnr gf {an
} {nbafgs~n g
rzg{bagfj gf
f fi}ocllw ~
} {an tn}{gbcl
n bl~r{n}nk K
acr mnnf ntc
gfj knlcw cf
ijnfni~r fn{} knbgrgif, bl~
]IK^B[G
} gr c d~fkc
& G{ gr {an c{
ogj}c{gif d}i
aik ~rnk
{i {}cfrdn}
f{ d}io ncba
c oimgln r{
{zi}`, zag
mgln r{c{gif
ngjami}gfj
}nlc{gfj {i
nf{ d}io {anc{gif& ^rgfj
f }nbngtnr }
fn{zi}`& [a
an oimgln
}` gr oncr~}
nf c acf
f d}io {an
zg}nlnrr fn
lnrr fn{zi}`
imgln r{c{gi
ITN] CFK
KITN]
}n {zi {wunr,
fi{an} gr T
3&Ai}gxifkcl
~rn} rzg{ba
filijw cfk rcfkitn} }ndn
bacfjgfj {an
bbnrr c r~u
uulgbc{gifr
}~o J}i~u, G
75:)GRMFY5
75:
rgif Rba
Cr{cf{ U}idnrr
BOR Rbaiil
@c}~`~{{w
jnfni~r zg}
di~}{a jnfn}c
r ~rnk {i u}i
n{znnf fn{zi
rnk di} u}itg
acfkitn} knbg
gr{}gm~{nk tn}
l~c{nk cr {an
k anfbn u}it
i}`r&
{n}gfj, KTAK,
F
nf{cl bifbn}
{nou{ {i u}i
o ifn kiocg
gf c zg}n
onrrcjnr ~
i{an}&
c{gif {i c ~rn
ba gfbl~knr
gr bcucmln
g}nlnrr fn{z
{an fngjami
rn}tgfj zg}n{agr gfdi}oc
kgi rgjfclr d
n s~clg{w id
r{c{gif cfk
k& Gd {agr on
kitn} id
rn}tgfj zg}n
zi}` gr nqnb
acr nr{cmlgra
u~}r~cf{ {i
AI]GXIF[
ifn gr Ai}gxi
}{gbcl Acfk
acfkitn} gr
gfj mn{znnf
con fn{zi}` r {i c fikn i
oikn i} {wu
ui}{gfj fn{z
kgc&
41
onr gf&
}bacfc R}nnh}, Knuc}{on
l id Nfjgfnn}g
, Bibagf, @n
lnrr
{gif
tgkn
}`r&
gfj
rgif
{gbcl
ifn
gknr
[/
f gf
tgkn
f {i
lnrr
rgfj
} {i
cf
id
i}`&
}gfj
lnrr{gif
}io
{an
{an
{r c
{an
lnrr
~{nk
k c
{an
CL
f{cl
tn}
{an
{an
lg`n} cf
n id
i}`,
zg
Zg
cb
u}
{nb[a
mc
zn
~r
cf
rnl
{n}
~f
d}n
i{a
di}rzgAc
kn
ua
b}g
rnb
{i
fn{
Rn
ua
{an
zg
zabi
n{n}ijnf
g{a { id Biou~{
fj cfk [nbaf
}clc&, Gfkgc
Dgj&3 Ai
r~uui}{ fikn
nlnrr kntgbn
}nlnrr LCF
nrr& G{ gr b
tgknr mn{{n}
afilijw zagb~r {an Lcu{iu
nk if {an ct
rcw {ac{ tn}
} {i c~{ioc
{an} {i ocgf{
Zanf c
b{nk di} Bi
gfcl fnnkr {
n} mi{a rg{
~nfbw mcfk
n} goui}{cf{
oimglg{w grg{bagfj& Acffkitn} Gfg{g
grgif, Acfki
rn {an acfk
n}gc tcl~n lg`
ifk uacrn bc
knbgkn zagb
zi}` cfk n
tgbn !SIR'
rn zagba gr
fngjami} fn
a {agr ,SIR
gba fn{zi}` fnb{gif& [an
ni~r Zg}
} Rbgnfbn
ilijw
}gxif{cl tn}r~
oimglg{w& Di
lg`n lcu{iu
cfk c bnll~l
lnc} {ac{ Z
runnk }c{nr
a u}itgknr ~~rn} bcf rzg
cglcmglg{w cfk
{gbcl acfkit
gbcllw rzg{b
cgf bioo~fg
Tn}{gbcl Acf
o~fgbc{gif g
i actn c k~c
c{gifr r~ba
cfk tc}gi~r
acllnfjn zag
{an c~{ioitn} onbacc{gif, Rwr{n
tn} nqnb~{gif
itn} u}ibnr
n rgjfcl r{}nf
llnk {an Rwr{
oimgln ~r
bacfjnr gfd
u}itgknk mw
{an Acfkitn
{zi}` SIR
knbgrgif oc
{an oimglnlcr{ uacrn g
nlnrr Fn{
r Tn}{gbcl Ac
} nqcouln, c
gja{ mn cmln
c} {nbafilij
g}nlnrr LCF
biouc}nk {
gs~g{i~r fn{{ba ~rgfj {an
fnbnrrg{w& Gf
} zgll u}itg
d}io ifn
c{gif ~l{goc{
kitn} onbac
{ gr fnbnrrc}
l oikn bc}k
cr ZLCF
oik~lc{gif
ln ~rgfj c tn}
c{gif crunb{gror actno Kgrbitn}
& Gf {an Acfk
zcr oikg
j{a, lgf` s~c
o kgrbitn}w
} kgrbitn}r
}oc{gif cmi
{anrn fn{zi
} knbgrgif u
cfk {an oimg
`n} oc`nr {
~rn} acrgr {an Acfki
zi}`r
fkitn}
znll ns~guun
{i ~rn mi{a
di} gf{n}fn
biffnb{gtg{
{an bnll~lc
i}` bitn}cjn {zi kntgbn
rgouln {n}o
n i} anlu {a
{nbafilijw {
nlw&
gro acr mnn
{ac{ c oimgl
{ac{ bcf zi}
cfk ^O[
rbanonr& [a
{gbcl acfkitn
gf fn{zi}di~} uacrn
w, Acfkitn
itn} Gfg{gc{gi
gnk mw rio
lg{w n{b& Gf {a
uacrn gr ~rn
g{r fngjami}‗
~{ S~clg{w i
`r& [an {ag}
crn biouc}n
ln ~rn}r SI
n knbgrgif {
i kg}nb{ {atn} nqnb~{gi
c
{
}
&r
r
n
i
f
`
n
}
` &}
f
n
r
d
r
i
nf
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 88/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :273;)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :273;
Cf Clji}g{ao di} Kwfcogb Rnc}ba gf ^fr{}~b{~}nk Unn}/{i/Unn}
Itn}lcw Fn{zi}`
Cragra R Uir{n
Biou~{n} Nfjgfnn}gfj Knuc}{onf{
UGB[
U~fn, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛ Unn}/{i Unn} !U=U' biou~{gfj fn{zi}` acr
non}jnk cr c oiknl di} }nri~}bn rac}gfj itn} {an gf{n}fn{&
Knrgjfgfj nddgbgnf{ rnc}ba clji}g{ao gr c `nw bacllnfjn gf
~fr{}~b{~}nk unn} {i unn} fn{zi}` !U=U'&Nddgbgnf{ }nri~}bn
kgrbitn}w gr {an dg}r{ r{nu {izc}kr {an }nclgxc{gif id
~fr{}~b{~}nk U=U fn{zi}`& Gf {agr zi}`, zn u}nrnf{ c kn{cglnk
itn}tgnz id }nbnf{ cfk nqgr{gfj rnc}ba on{aikr di}~fr{}~b{~}nk Unn}/{i/Unn} fn{zi}`r& Oir{ ~fr{}~b{~}nk U=U
fn{zi}`r ~{glgxn dliikgfj mcrnk }nri~}bn kgrbitn}w zagba
crr~onr fi `fizlnkjn cmi~{ {an fn{zi}` {iuilijw, cfk {a~r
bcf lnck {i f~omn} id }nk~fkcf{ onrrcjn jnfn}c{gif& ]cfkio
Zcl` !]Z' rnc}ba jnfn}c{nr c dgqnk coi~f{ id s~n}w onrrcjnr
c{ ncba aiu m~{ zi~lk {c`n lifjn} {gon {i rnc}ba& ]nrnc}ban}r
actn u}nrnf{nk f~omn} id cl{n}fc{gtn rnc}ba clji}g{aor zagba
{c`n cktcf{cjn id {an bif{nq{ ~fkn} zagba Dliikgfj cfk ]Z
un}di}or znll& Zn u}iuirn c rnc}bagfj clji}g{ao, zagba zgll
dg}r{ bifr{}~b{ c ogfgo~o rucffgfj {}nn lg`n itn}lcw fn{zi}`
itn} {an uawrgbcl fn{zi}`& [an rnc}ba clji}g{ao zgll }nrnomln
cr dliikgfj di} rion rocll f~omn} id aiur if {an i}gjgfcl
uawrgbcl fn{zi}`, cd{n} {an gfg{gcl dliikgfj di} bn}{cgf aiur g{
zgll mnactn lg`n c }cfkio zcl` if {an bifr{}~b{nk itn}lcw
fn{zi}` cfk di}zc}k {an s~n}w {i lgog{nk rn{ id fngjami}knunfkgfj if {an `fizlnkjn jcgfnk d}io u}ntgi~r rnc}ba
c{{nou{r&U}imlno ibb~}}gfj k~n {i {an unn}r jn{{gfj
kgrbiffnb{nk gr clri acfklnk nddnb{gtnlw&
@nwzi}kr/biouifnf{0 Unn}/{i/Unn} fn{zi}`, Fn{zi}`
[iuilijw,
Rnc}bagfj [nbafgs~n&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Gf {an ucr{ dnz wnc}r, non}jnfbn id U=U cuulgbc{gifr r~ba
cr Fcur{n}, Jf~{nllc, cfk @cXcC actn raizf {ang} jiik
r~uui}{ di} bif{nf{ lii`~u cfk rac}gfj, ri {ang} uiu~lc}g{w cfk
f~omn} actn j}nc{lw nquliknk& C U=U rwr{no ~r~cllw gftiltnr
{ai~rcfkr i} ogllgifr id fiknr cfk }nri~}bnr gf {an fn{zi}`&
[an U=U rwr{no di}or c d~llw/kgr{}gm~{nk, biiun}c{gtn fn{zi}` knrgjf, zan}n fiknr ki fi{ }ns~g}n cfw r~un}tgrgif& C jiik
rnc}ba rbanon acr {i c}}gtn c{ {zi jiclr8 !3' agja rnc}ba
un}di}ocfbn, zagba {}gnr {i knlgtn} agja s~clg{w rn}tgbn !n&j&,
lc}jn f~omn} id rnc}ba }nr~l{r cfk liz s~n}w }nruifrn {gon' {i
~rn}r, cfk !=' liz bir{, zagba }nrn}tnr rwr{no }nri~}bnr {i
r~r{cgf c lc}jn f~omn} id ~rn}r& Nc}lw rwr{nor, r~ba cr Fcur{n},
~rn c bnf{}cl rn}tn} {i r{i}n gfkgbnr id uc}{gbguc{gfj unn}r& [agr
bnf{}clgxnk knrgjf cfk u}cb{gbn jgtn }grn {i {an bifbn}fr id
un}di}ocfbn mi{{lnfnb` cfk rgfjln uigf{ id dcgl~}n& Gfr{nck id
ocgf{cgfgfj c a~jn gfknq gf c bnf{}clgxnk rwr{no, c
knbnf{}clgxnk rwr{no r~ba cr Jf~{nllc kgr{}gm~{nr cll rnc}bagfj
cfk libc{gfj lickr cb}irr cll {an uc}{gbguc{gfj unn}r& [ai~ja {an
knbnf{}clgxnk cuu}icba ckk}nrrnr {an itn}lickgfj cfk
}nlgcmglg{w grr~nr, cfk gr u}iogrgfj {i m~glk c agjalw rbclcmlnU=U rwr{no, g{r r~bbnrr gr anctglw knunfknf{ if cf nddgbgnf{
rnc}bagfj r{}c{njw nouliwnk {i libc{n {an }ns~g}nk }nri~}bn&
]ncbagfj i~{ {i c lc}jn rbiun id unn}r gr c d~fkconf{cl
u}ibnk~}n gf cf ~fr{}~b{~}nk U=U fn{zi}`, mnbc~rn {an}n c}n fi
bif{}ilr cfk fi cbb~}c{n gfdi}oc{gif if fn{zi}` {iuilijgnr
cfk libc{gifr id knrg}nk dglnr& [a~r, {an rwr{no rbclcmglg{w gr
kg}nb{lw cddnb{nk mw {an nddgbgnfbw id {an m}ickbcr{gfj
onbacfgro&
Rnc}ba clji}g{aor gf ~fr{}~b{~}nk U=U fn{zi}`r bcf mn
blcrrgdgnk gf{i {zi bc{nji}gnr8 m}nc{a dg}r{ rnc}ba !MDR' on{aik,
cfk knu{a dg}r{ rnc}ba !KDR' on{aik& [anrn {zi {wunr id rnc}ba
clji}g{aor {nfk {i mn gfnddgbgnf{, cr {anw actn {an kgrcktcf{cjn
id jnfn}c{gfj {ii o~ba lick if {an rwr{no P3_, P=_, i} fi{
onn{gfj ~rn}r‗ }ns~g}nonf{r id ogfgo~o rnc}ba {gon cfkun}di}ocfbn P2_&Dliikgfj, zagba mnlifjr {i MDR/mcrnk
on{aikr, gr {an kndc~l{ rnc}ba clji}g{ao di} Jf~{nllc fn{zi}`
P;_, P>_&Gf c mlgfk rnc}ba, fiknr ki fi{ r{i}n cfw gfdi}oc{gif
}njc}kgfj dgln libc{gifr& Gf gfdi}onk cuu}icbanr, fiknr libcllw
r{i}n on{ckc{c {ac{ crrgr{ gf {an rnc}ba di} {an s~n}gnk imhnb{r&
[an rai}{biogfj id oir{ gfdi}onk on{aikr gr {an ocgf{nfcfbn
bir{ id {an gfkgbnr cd{n} unn}r higf)lnctn {an fn{zi}` i} ~ukc{n
{ang} billnb{gifr& Gf oir{ bcrnr, {anrn ntnf{r lnck {i jnfn}c{gif
id ~ukc{n onrrcjnr }nr~l{gfj gf fn{zi}` {}cddgb& B~}}nf{ U=U
rnc}ba clji}g{aor bcf mn }i~jalw kgtgknk gf {zi bc{nji}gnr8
[an ifnr {ac{ nqagmg{ jiik un}di}ocfbn c{ agja bir{ !ng{an}
k~}gfj {an rnc}ba i} {an on{ckc{c ~ukc{nr', cfk {airn {ac{ c}n
mcfkzgk{a nddgbgnf{ m~{ nqagmg{ tc}wgfj un}di}ocfbn& [an
goui}{cf{ imrn}tc{gif gr {ac{ uiu~lc} U=U fn{zi}`r kgrulcw cagjalw kwfcogb mnactgi}, zg{a oir{ ~rn}r biffnb{gfj di} rocll
un}gikr id {gon cfk {anf lnctgfj {an rwr{no&
GG& ]NLC[NK ZI]@
[i ckk}nrr {an rnc}bagfj u}imlno gf ~fr{}~b{~}nk U=U
fn{zi}` ocfw }nrnc}ban} cfk u}cb{g{gifn} actn u}iuirnk c li{
id on{aikr& [ikcw, {an oir{ uiu~lc} U=U cuulgbc{gifr iun}c{n
if ~fr{}~b{~}nk fn{zi}`r& Gf {anrn fn{zi}`r, unn}r
higfgfj)lnctgfj c fn{zi}` gr kwfcogb, {an libc{gif id {an
kib~onf{r gr fi{ bif{}illnk mw {an rwr{no cfk fi j~c}cf{nnr
di} {an r~bbnrr i} {an bioulnqg{w id c rnc}ba c}n iddn}nk&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 89/223
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYGFU^[8
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
F!~' gr {an 3 aiu fngjami} rn{ id fikn ~& G{ gr kndgfnk
cr8
F!~' ?pt ) !~, t'N &
N/6rn{ id nkjnr gf j}cua&
f/6f~omn} id fiknr)unn}r&
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Clji}g{ao8
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
3& Ncba fikn ~ billnb{r g{r 3 aiu F!~' fngjami}
gfdi}oc{gif&=& Ncba fikn ~ biou~{n {an OR[!F!~'' id cll fiknr
F!~' gfbl~kgfj ~ g{rnld&
2& Di} ncba nkjn !~,t' OR[!F!~'' , fikn ~ {nllr
fikn t cmi~{ {agr nkjn rnlnb{nk di} OR[&
;&Fikn ~ `nnur cf nkjn !~, t' gd
!~,t' OR[!F!~'' i} !~,t' OR[!F!t'' &
>&
f
g
g?3
OR[!J' OR[!F!~ ''& Jgtnr biouln{n rucffgfj
{}nn&
Dliikgfj gr cf nqcouln id mlgfk rnc}ba, c onrrcjn }nbngtnk mw
c unn} zgll mn di}zc}knk {i cll g{r fngjami} nqbnu{ {an fikn
d}io zagba {an onrrcjn c}}gtnk, m~{ dliikgfj zi~lk u}ik~bn
}nk~fkcf{ onrrcjnr zagba zgll cddnb{ mcfkzgk{a ~{glgxc{gif
cktn}rnlw &]nrnc}ban} actn oikgdgnk {an dliikgfj on{aik {i
cbagntn {an cktcf{cjnr id dliikgfj zagln }nk~bgfj {an
}nk~fkcf{ onrrcjnr j}nc{lw& ^flg`n u~}n dliikgfj rnc}bagfj
{nbafgs~nr lg`n Nqucfkgfj }gfj P4_ !i} g{n}c{gtn knnunfgfjP:_',
]cfkio un}gikgbcl dliikgfjP1_ {c`nr oi}n kwfcogb dcb{i}r gf{i
bifrgkn}c{gif {i }nk~bn {an dliikgfj ai}gxif zagln ocgf{cgfgfj
rnc}ba s~clg{w& Rnc}banr c}n
gfg{gc{nk zg{a gfb}ncrgfj [[Lr ~f{gl nfi~ja }nruifrnr c}n
}nbngtnk& Oikgdgnk MDR P:_, Kg}nb{nk MDR P7_ rnfkr s~n}w {i
fngjami} rc{grdwgfj bn}{cgf runbgdgb an~}gr{gbr& [anrn c}n rion
nqcoulnr id oikgdgnk dliikgfj {nbafgs~nr&
[i nlgogfc{n {an ~rn id dliikgfj cfk gou}itn rnc}ba
nddgbgnfbw rion }nrnc}ban} actn u}itgknk bn}{cgf Gf{n}nr{/mcrnk
libclg{w P;_,P>_,P3;_ r{c{nr {ac{ gd unn} C acr c uc}{gb~lc} ugnbn id
bif{nf{ {ac{ unn} M gr gf{n}nr{nk gf, {anf g{ gr lg`nlw {ac{ C zgll
actn i{an} ugnbnr id bif{nf{ {ac{ M gr clri gf{n}nr{nk gf& Mcrnk
if {agr crr~ou{gif, c unn} rnlnb{r i{an}r {ac{ actn u}ntgi~rlw
u}itgknk }nr~l{r {i g{r s~n}gnr cr unn}r zg{a biooif gf{n}nr{r
cfk b}nc{nr
Rai}{b~{ lgf`r {i {anrn unn}r&
R~un}/unn} mcrnk rnc}ba r{}c{njw c}n u}itgknk gf }nrnc}ba
zi}` lg`n P=3_&C r~un}/unn} gr c unn} zagba cb{r cr c
bnf{}clgxnk rn}tn} di} rion r~mrn{ id g{r blgnf{r& Ocfw r~ba
R~un}/unn}r c}n biffnb{nk {i ncba i{an} cfk di}zc}k {an s~n}w
coifj {ano gd {anw kif‗{ dgfk c oc{ba zg{agf {ang} izf blgnf{
unn}r&
Rion }nrnc}ban}r actn u}nrnf{nk on{aikr gf zagba {an unn}
zgll lnc}f cmi~{ {an libc{gif id }nri~}bn gf s~n}w {a}i~ja
`fizlnkjn ~ukc{gfj d}io u}ntgi~r rnc}ba }nr~l{r& C f~omn} id
rnc}ba on{aikr knunfkgfj if {an `fizlnkjn lnc}fnk c}n8
Ckcu{gtn u}imcmglgr{gb rnc}ba !CUR' P35_,P33_, Mgcrnk ]Z
P3=_,]i~{gfj gfknqP32_,Libcl gfkgbnrP3;_,Gf{nllgjnf{ rnc}baP3>_
]nk~fkcf{ onrrcjn jnfn}c{gif k~n {i {an liiur gf {an
fn{zi}` zgll r{gll mn c u}imlno gf oir{ id {an cmitn onf{gifnk
rnc}ba r{}c{njw& Ri bifr{}~b{gif id {}nn lg`n itn}lcw fn{zi}`
zgll mn mnfndgbgcl di} }nk~bgfj {an }nk~fkcf{ onrrcjnr k~n {i
{an liiur gf {an fn{zi}` P3:_, P31_, P37_&
I~} rbanon zgll bifr{}~b{ cf libc{gif czc}n ogfgo~o
rucffgfj {}nn lg`n itn}lcw fn{zi}` cfk {anf cuulw {an rnc}bagfj
clji}g{ao if {agr itn}lcw fn{zi}`& [}nn lg`n r{}~b{~}n gr b}nc{nk
mw blcrrgdwgfj {an fngjami} id ntn}w unn} gf{i c rn{ id
DLIIKGFJ fngjami} cfk FIFDLIIKGFJ fngjami}&
DLIIKGFJ fngjami} c}n {airn {i zaio {an unn} bcf rnfk {an
onrrcjn, zagln FIFDLIIKGFJ fngjami} c}n {airn {i zaio
onrrcjn bcffi{ mn rnf{ gf OR[& ^fr{}~b{~}nk U=U fn{zi}` c}n
ri kwfcogb {ac{ c unn} gf {an }i~{n id rnc}ba ocw jn{
kgrbiffnb{nk oc`gfj {an nf{g}n kizfr{}nco fikn ~f}ncbacmln&
Gf {agr rbnfc}gi i~} rnc}ba zgll kn{nb{ {an fikn jn{{gfj
kgrbiffnb{nk cfk gfdi}o cll 3 aiu fngjami} id {an unn}& [an 3
aiu fngjami} id {an kgrbiffnb{nk unn} zgll {anf jn{ biffnb{nk
{i ifn id {an FIFDLIIKGFJ fngjami}&
GGG& U]IUIRNK RNC]BAGFJ CLJI]G[AO
Gf {agr rnb{gif, zn u}itgkn {an kn{cglr id {an u}iuirnk
rnc}ba clji}g{ao& Rnb{gif C u}nrnf{r {an iun}c{gifr id
Bifr{}~b{gif id [}nn/lg`n Itn}lcw Fn{zi}`, rnb{gif M u}nrnf{r{an iun}c{gifr id `fizlnkjn/mcrnk rnc}bagfj clji}g{ao, cfk
rnb{gif B u}nrnf{ {an iun}c{gif if unn} jn{{gfj kgrbiffnb{nk&
C& Bifr{}~b{gif id [}nn/lg`n Itn}lcw
Fn{zi}`
Libc{gif/czc}n {iuilijw bifr{}~b{gif nquli}nr {an
{iuilijw ogroc{ba u}imlno mn{znnf {an itn}lcw fn{zi}` cfk
{an ~fkn}lwgfj uawrgbcl fn{zi}` mw bifr{}~b{gfj cf itn}lcw
ogfgo~o rucffgfj {}nn !OR[' coifj ncba unn} cfk {an unn}r
zg{agf 3 aiu kgr{cfbn d}io {ano& U}iuirnk clji}g{ao kinr fi{
fnnk {i `fiz {an gfdi}oc{gif id {an nf{g}n fn{zi}`& G{ h~r{
fnnkr {i `fiz {an unn}r mn{znnf 3 aiu kgr{cfbn cfk {an bir{ id
}i~{gfj mn{znnf {ano& Zn zgll bifr{}~b{ {an OR[ di} ntn}w
unn} cfk g{r fngjami} nlgogfc{gfj {an }nk~fkcf{ liiur mn{znnf{an fn{zi}`r& Ncba unn} zgll s~n}w g{r fngjami} cfk bifr{}~b{
{an
Fngjami} bir{ {cmln zagba zgll mn }ns~g}nk di} OR[
bifr{}~b{gif& Ifbn {an OR[ gr bifr{}~b{nk {an s~n}w onrrcjn
zgll mn di}zc}knk zg{agf {an OR[ gfr{nck id di}zc}kgfj {an
onrrcjn {i g{r nf{g}n fngjami}& K~}gfj {an bifr{}~b{gif id OR[
c rn{ id DLIIKGFJ cfk FIFDLIIKGFJ fngjami} gr
ocgf{cgfnk di} ncba unn} zai zgll kg}nb{ {an unn} {i di}zc}k {an
s~n}w onrrcjn gf OR[& Bifr{}~b{gif id OR[ gr kifn ~rgfj c
jnfn}cl clji}g{ao g&n& U]GO i} @]^R@CL&
Bifrgkn} c }cfkio j}cua J!T,N' zg{a f fiknr cfk n nkjnr,
{ac{ acr ctn}cjn knj}nn k zan}n T gr rn{ id fiknr, N gr rn{ id
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 90/223
g
YYYYYYYYY
GFU^[8
YYYYYYYYY
R/6S~n}wg
}/6s~n}gnk
[[L/6[go
O/6s~n}wg
{/6{a}nraili}gjgfcl fn{
YYYYYYYYY
Clji}g{ao8
3&Rnc}baCl
=& Gd !Un
gfdi}oc{gi
2& R }n{~}fr
;& Nlrngd !a
R{iu di}
>& nlrngd !a
a++
R di}zc}
fn{zi}`&4&nlrngd !a6
a++
Fikn ac
bairnf {i d
kjnr& Di} c jg
gr{cfbn d}io
Clji}g{ao
M& Itn}lcw F
Rnc}bagfj
Dliikgfj cfk
cktcf{cjn id
{an fiknr zg{a
}nk~fkcf{ onr
d c{ lncr{ 7>
gfg{gcl aiur
di}zc}k {an s
}nk~fkcf{ on
[L tcl~n, i
coi~f{ id unn
di}zc}kgfj {a
[L tcl~n bcf
Clji}g{ao
Biomgfgf
fizlnkjn/mc
d~}{an} gou}i
@fizlnkjn/mc
cmi~{ zan{an}
}nr~l{ gf c ag{
YYYYYYYYYYY
YYYYYYYYYYY
j fikn)unn}&
}nri~}bn&
/{i/lgtn uc}c
j onrrcjn&
rnlnb{nk di}zi}`&
YYYYYYYYYYY
i}g{ao!R, },
} ‑R‗ acr
cmi~{ {an lib
c ag{, R{iu di
[[L'
c}kgfj onrr
?{'
kr {an s~n}w {
{'
tgfj angja{
}zc}k {an on
gtnf fikn ~, ln
~&
di} bifr{}~b{g
@fizlnk
n{zi}`&
clji}g{ao zg
]cfkio zcl
itn}cjn g&n&
gf c rocll f~
rcjnr& ^r~cll
n}bnf{& Bitn}
~{ lc{n} g{ k
~n}w {i ifn
rrcjnr gfg{gcll
fbn {an onrr
}, ncba gfkgtgk
onrrcjn gf {
mn kifn mw un
di} Rnc}bagfj
{an rnc}ba
nk rnc}ba r~
n {an un}di}
rnk rnc}ba cl
di}zc}kgfj s~
r~bbnrr& Ncba
YYYYYYYYYYY
YYYYYYYYYYY
n{n}&
di}zc}kgfj {
YYYYYYYYYYY
[L, {'
{an }ns~g}nk
c{gif id }nri~
}zc}kgfj {an
jn O&
i g{r nf{g}n fn
}imcmglg{w i
rrcjn O {i&
{ F!~' mn {an
f id OR[8
n/mcrn Rnc}b
ll ~rn {an b
un}di}o znl
~n}w onrrcjn
mn} id aiur,
c [[L id : b
cjn j}iz{a }c
nj}cknr P37_&
d g{r fngjami
dliik {an
jn c}n ctcgl
~cl unn} zgll k
an OR[& Rnln
}di}ogfj nqun
gf ^fr{}~b{~}n
r{}c{njw k
a cr RU^F
cfbn id {an
i}g{ao zgll
n}w onrrcjn {
unn} zgll ocg
YYYYYYYYYYY
YYYYYYYYYYY
an onrrcjn
YYYYYYYYYYY
gfdi}oc{gi
}bn '
nrrcjn O&
gjami} if i}g
d r~bbnrr zgl
n{ id fiknr c{
agfj Clji}g{a
f{nq{ ~fkn}
l& Dliikgfj a
}ncbanr {i o
~{ jnfn}c{nr c
cf cbagntn bi
{n gr agja di}
]cfkio Zcl
} }nk~bgfj c
nrrcjnr zg{a
mln {i bifrgk
i c }cfkio z
{gfj {an cuu}
}gonf{r&
k U=U fn{zi}`
nrb}gmnk zg{
P34_, CUR P3
nc}bagfj clji
~glk {an `fi
uc}{gb~lc} un
f{cgf c u}imc
YYY
YYY
gf
YYY
i}
gfcl
l mn
g
3 aiu
if
zagba
cr {an
ir{ id
li{ id
n}cjn
n}{cgf
zgll
li{ id
rocll
n}cmln
cl` mw
u}gc{n
8
{an
_ bcf
}g{ao&
lnkjn
} zgll
glgr{gb
{cml
u}i
unn
Tc
d~f
{i
~uk
U=
on
zag
{an
cfk
Ri
Ifl
ocg
clj
unn
f~
j}i
fn{
rnc
ki
rba
lnc
FI
gf{
jn{
ocg
fik
Fi
R~
lnc
{agr
FI
YYYYYYYYYY
lji}g{ao8
3& Ntn}w fik
fdi}ogfj g{fctcglcmglg{w&
& Di} ncba un
Unn} jn{r b
IFDLIIKG
n di} ncba id g
mcmglg{w id ag{
} gr kifn za
gi~r ~ukc{n
b{gif, c lgfnc}
~ukc{n {an `
c{n d~fb{gif a
B&
gf bifr{}~b{n
Gd zn m~glk c
itn}lcw fn{
rrcjnr& Aizn
gba zgll mn ckk
OR[ gf c uc}
g{r nf{g}n 3 a
{an}n gr fi fn
w libcl gfdi}
gf{cgfgfj {an
}g{ao zgll dl
} fn{zi}` cfk
mn} id unn} g
z{a }c{n gr fi{
Dgfcllw k~n {
zi}` unn}r ln
}ba }i~{n jn{
fr{}nco fikn
non {an fikn
gfj& [an fngj
FDLIIKGF
b{& Unn}r higfg
biffnb{nk {i
gf{cgfgfj {an
Fikn R zgll b
n N, D gf g{r
n J zgll bif{
uirn fikn R
nr {an fn{zi}
bcrn fikn J
FDLIIFJ lg
]nbifr{}~b{gi
YYYYYYYYYY
~ jn{{gfj kg
r 3 aiu
n})fikn gf fng
iffnb{nk {i
GFJ rn{ id fng
{r fngjami} cf
& ^ukc{gfj id
f c ag{)ogrr
d~fb{gifr lg`n
d~fb{gif cfk c
izlnkjn {cml
cr mnnf ntcl~c
Ckk}nrrgfj {
OR[&
rucffgfj {}nn
zi}`, zn bc
n}, {an rucffg
}nrrnk gf i~}
cllnl dcragif
u kgr{cfbn fng
nk {i im{cgf {
c{gif zgll m
R[ gr {an}ndi
ikr {an s~n}
zanf {an on
{ kinr c }cfk
c u}imlno gf
i {an kwfcog
ctn)higf c{ cf
kgrbiffnb{nk
~fctcglcmln
gfdi}or g{r
ami}gfj unn}r
fngjami} {a~
fj {an fn{zi}
cfw ifn id
R[&
f{cgf fikn J
LIIKGFJ lg
cgf fikn R cf
}gjgfc{nr c s~
` oc`gfj fik
zgll jn{ biffn
r{ g&n& R i} D
D
f id OR[ cd{n
YYYYYYYYYY
rbiffnb{nk r
fngjami} F
jami} rn{ F!~
ifn id g{r
jami}&
k di} ncba }nr
{an `fizlnkj
gr }n{~}fnk d}
Dlc{ ~ukc{n
aiu bi~f{ d~f
n& [an un}di
{nk gf CUR P35
an U}imlno i
{ac{ biffnb{r
nlgogfc{n c
fj {}nn acr ri
rbanon& Cr z
an}n zn bifrg
gjami} di} ncb
an zailn fn{
n r~ddgbgnf{&
n fi{ c u}imln
w onrrcjn gf
rrcjn acr }nc
o zcl` if O
~} rbanon&
gb fc{~}n id
w {gon& Gd c
zagba zgll
~f{gl {an {}nn
f{g}n fngjami
zgll jn{ biffn
ocgf{cgfgfj {
zgll fi{ mn
{an unn} id
gf g{r FIFDL
r{ cr raizf g
D gf g{r FIF
n}w onrrcjn o
J ~fctcglcml
{nk {i ifn id
gj& 3
} c fikn jn{r kg
YYYYYYYYYY
fkr c onrrc
~' cmi~{ g
'
fngjami} d}i
i~}bn {i gfdn}
n {cmln di} nt
io g{r fngja
d~fb{gif, c r
b{gif bcf mn ~
}ocfbn id {a
_&
Unn}r lnctgf
cll {an unn}r i
ll {an }nk~fk
on kgrcktcf{
c}n bifr{}~b{
kn} iflw {an u
a cfk ntn}w u
i}` gfdi}oc{g
ifr{}~b{gfj
& Gfg{gcllw cr
i}gjgfcl unn}
ank {i r~ddgbg
R[& Ri bitn}
fr{}~b{~}nk
ikn jn{r if
oc`n {an nf
gr }nm~gl{& Gf
}gfj unn} mnd
b{nk {i ifn id
an OR[ r{}~b{
u}imlno cr {
{an fn{zi}`
IKGFJ lgr{
dgj 3& Rgogl
DLIIKGFJ l
ncfzagln fik
di} s~n}wgfj&
{an fikn d}io
grbiffnb{nk8
Y
n
g{r
o
{an
n}w
i}&
{nu
rnk
nrn
j
f c
cf{
jn
gfj
nn}
n}&
if&
fk
{an
{i/
nf{
jn
=U
{an
{g}n
~}
i}n
g{r
~}n
nw
{gll
fk
}lw
gr{&
N
& Gf
g{r
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 91/223
Ln{ R mn {an rwr{no }nu}nrnf{r Unn}/{i/Unn} fn{zi}`&g gR?pJ, C, D, r,ra, F!~',DL ,FDL
Ln{ J!T,N' mn {an j}cua }nu}nrnf{gfj {an fn{zi}`
{iuilijw&
3, =, 2&&&&& oln{ N?p zan}n o?f~omn} id nkjnr gf {an fn{n n n n
3 =, , 2&&&&& fln{ T?p zan}n f?f~omn} id tn{nq)unn}r gf {ant t t t
3 = }Ln{ D?pd ,d ,․d zan}n }?f~omn} id }nri~}bnr&
Ln{ C mn {an ckhcbnfbw oc{}gq }nu}nrnf{c{gif id {an
fn{zi}`)j}cua&
Cgh?zngja{ gd!g,h' N
? 5 i{an}zgrn&
Zan}n ‑zngja{‗ gr {an fn{zi}` knlcw mn{znnf cfw {ziunn}r g cfk h&
F!~' gr {an 3 aiu fngjami} rn{ id fikn ~& G{ gr kndgfnk cr8
F!~'?pt ) !~,t' N
Rn{ id fngjami} id tn}{nq ‑~‗ zg{agf 3 aiur&
Di} ncba tn}{nq ‑g‗ cfk fngjami} zg{agf kgr{cfbn id 3
aiur bifr{}~b{ OR[&
3 gh gD !g,C ' OR[![ '&
Zan}n [g gr {}nn }ii{nk c{ tn}{nq ‑g‗&
3D~fb{gif D {c`nr {an gfu~{ cr tn}{nq g cfk ckhcfbnw oc{}gq
}ii{nk c{ tn}{nq *g*&
g ? 3 =&&&&& d DL pt t t &gDL gr rn{ id dliikgfj tn}{nq g&n& {i zagba tn}{nq *g* gr
biffnb{nk
g 3 = fd FDL ? pT ,T &&&&T &
gFDL gr rn{ id fif dliikgfj tn}{nq g&n& {i zagba tn}{nq *g* gr
fi{ kg}nb{lw biffnb{nk
3 = fOR[!J'?OR[![ '^OR[![ '&&&&&&&&&^OR[![ '
Ln{ r?unn} s~n}wgfj di} rion }nri~}bn gf U=U fn{zi}`
d? s~n}gnk }nri~}bn&
O?s~n}w onrrcjn&
2D !r,d,O' Di}zc}kr {an onrrcjn {i g{r fngjami}& ;D !r,d,O' Di}zc}kr {an onrrcjn {i rion id g{r fngjami
itn} OR[&
D~fb{gif ;D di}zc}kr {an s~n}w onrrcjn {i ifn id g{r
fngjami} knunfkgfj if {an u}imcmglg{w {cmln {ac{ g{ zgll
}n{~}f c ag{)r~bbnrr&
a?f~omn} id aiur&
ra?Rnlnb{nk Aiu bi~f{&
2 !Kwfcogbrnc}ba?D R,D,o' gd a<?ra
? ;! , , 'D R D o gd a6ra
GT& OC[ANOC[GBCL OIKN DI] [AN RWR[NO T& BIFBL^RGIF
Gf {agr ucun}, zn actn u}iuirnk {an }nbifr{}~b{gif id
itn}lcw {iuilijw k~}gfj {an ntnf{ id unn} jn{{gfj kgrbiffnb{nk
d}io {an U=U fn{zi}`& [iuilijw bifr{}~b{gif clji}g{aou}nrnf{nk ~rnr iflw {an libcl gfdi}oc{gif ctcglcmln anfbn
gou}itgfj {an un}di}ocfbn& [an rnc}ba clji}g{ao gr c
biomgfc{gif id Dliikgfj cfk ]cfkio Zcl` r{}c{njw cfk ~rnr
{an bif{nq{ ~fkn} zagba {anw un}di}o znll& Rnlnb{gfj {an
{a}nrailk tcl~n di} dliikgfj fn{zi}` zgll j}nc{lw goucb{ {an
un}di}ocfbn id {an rwr{no& [an rnc}ba clji}g{ao gr d~}{an}
biomgfnk zg{a {an `fizlnkjn lnc}fnk d}io {an u}ntgi~r rnc}ba
c{{nou{r {a~r gou}itgfj {an u}imcmglg{w id s~n}w }n{~}fgfj c ag{
mw kg}nb{gfj {an s~n}w gf }gja{ kg}nb{gif& [an u}imlno id fikn
jn{{gfj kgrbiffnb{nk cfk oc`gfj cll kizfr{}nco fiknr
~fctcglcmln gf OR[ gr clri ckk}nrrnk gf {an rbanon&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ @& R}gucfgk`~lbacg, {an Uiu~lc}g{w id Jf~{nllc S~n}gnr cfk G{rGoulgbc{gifr if Rbclcmglg{w, zag{n ucun}, Bc}fnjgn Onllif ^fgt&Dnm&
=553&P=_ O& Hitcfitgb, D& Cffnqr{ngf, cfk @& Mn}ocf, “Rbclcmglg{w Grr~nr gf
Lc}jn Unn}/{i/Unn} Fn{zi}`r8 C Bcrn R{~kw id Jf~{nllc,‟ {nbafgbcl
}nui}{, Lcmi}c{i}w di} Fn{zi}`r cfk Cuulgnk J}cua [ani}w, ^fgt& id Bgfbgffc{g, =553&
P2_ M& Wcfj cfk A& Jc}bgc/Oilgfc, “Gou}itgfj Rnc}ba gf Unn}/{i/Unn}
Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& ==fk Gf{‗l Bifd Kgr{}gm~{nk Biou~{gfj Rwr{nor
!GBKBR ‗5=', uu& >3;, H~lw =55=&
P;_ J& @cf, “Jf~{nllc,‟ Unn}/{i/Unn} Ac}fnrrgfj {an Uizn} id Kgr}~u{gtn [nbafilijgnr, I‗]ngllw, uu& 7;3==, =553&
P>_ ]DB/Jf~{nllc 5&4, a{{u8))}db/jf~{nllc&ri~}bndi}jn&fn{)kntnliun})
{nr{gfj)gfknq&a{ol, =551&
P4_ T& @clijn}c`g, K& J~fiu~lir, cfk K& Xngfclgui~}Wcx{g, “C Libcl
Rnc}ba Onbacfgro di} Unn}/{i/Unn} Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib&CBO BG@OGf{‗l Bifd& Gfdi}oc{gif cfk @fizlnkjn Ocfcjnonf{ !BG@O ‗5=',
uu& 25525:,Fit& =55=&
P:_ M& Wcfj cfk A& Jc}bgc/Oilgfc, “Gou}itgfj Rnc}ba gf Unn}/{i/Unn}
Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& ==fk Gf{‗l Bifd&Kgr{}gm~{nk Biou~{gfj Rwr{nor!GBKBR ‗5=', uu& >3;,H~lw =55=&
P1_ X& Xa~cfj, W& Lg~, L& Qgci, cfk L&O& Fg, “Awm}gk Un}gikgbcl
Dliikgfj gf ^fr{}~b{~}nk Unn}/{i/Unn} Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& 2=fk Gf{‗l
Bifd& Uc}cllnl U}ibnrrgfj !GBUU ‗52', uu& 3:3/3:1, Ib{& =552&
P7_ T& @clijn}c`g, K& J~fiu~lir, cfk K& Xngfclgui~}Wcx{g, “C LibclRnc}ba Onbacfgro di} Unn}/{i/Unn} Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib&CBO BG@O
Gf{‗l Bifd& Gfdi}oc{gif cfk @fizlnkjn Ocfcjnonf{ !BG@O ‗5=',
uu& 25525:,Fit& =55=&
P35_ K& [ri~oc`ir cfk F& ]i~rriui~lir, “Ckcu{gtn U}imcmglgr{gb Rnc}badi} Unn}/{i/Unn} Fn{zi}`r,‟U}ib& [ag}k Gf{‗l Bifd& Unn}/{i/Unn}
Biou~{gfj !U=U‗52', uu& 35=/357, Rnu{& =552&P33_ K& [ri~oc`ir cfk F& ]i~rriui~lir, “Cfclwrgr cfk Biouc}grif id
U=U Rnc}ba On{aikr,‟ [nbafgbcl ]nui}{ BR/[]/;>27, ^OGCBR[]/
=552/35:, Knu{&id Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn, fgt& id Oc}wlcfk, =552&P3=_ W& Baczc{an, R& ]c{fcrcow, L& M}nrlc~, F& Lcfaco, cfk R& Ranf`n},
“Oc`gfj Jf~{nllc/Lg`n U=U Rwr{nor Rbclcmln,‟ U}ib&CBO
RGJBIOO ‗52, uu& ;5:/;31, C~j& =552&
P32_ C& B}nrui cfk A& Jc}bgc/Oilgfc, “]i~{gfj Gfkgbnr di} Unn}/{i/Unn}
Rwr{nor,‟ U}ib& ==fk Gf{‗l Bifd&Kgr{}gm~{nk Biou~{gfj Rwr{nor!GBKBR ‗5=', uu&=2/2=, H~lw =55=&
P3;_ M& Wcfj cfk A& Jc}bgc/Oilgfc, “Gou}itgfj Rnc}ba gf Unn}/{i/Unn}
Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& ==fk Gf{‗l Bifd& Kgr{}gm~{nk Biou~{gfj Rwr{nor
!GBKBR ‗5=', uu& >3;,H~lw =55=
P3>_ T& @clijn}c`g, K& J~fiu~lir, cfk K& Xngfclgui~}Wcx{g, “C LibclRnc}ba Onbacfgro di} Unn}/{i/Unn} Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& 33{a Gf{‗l Bifd&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 92/223
P34_ Gfdi}oc{gif cfk @fizlnkjn Ocfcjnonf{ !BG@O ‗5=', uu& 255/25:,Fit& =55=&
P3:_ K&O ]crcfhclnn Agoclg cfk R~ragl @& U}crck, ‟RU^F8 C U=U
U}imcmglgr{gb Rnc}ba Clji}g{ao mcrnk if R~bbnrrd~l Uc{ar gf
^fr{}~b{~}nk Fn{zi}`r&‟ =533 GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Uc}cllnl $Kgr{}gm~{nk U}ibnrrgfj Rwouirg~o, KIG 35&3357)GUKUR&=533&234&
P31_ W~faci Lg~, Onomn}, GNNN, Lg Qgci, Onomn}, GNNN, Qgciong Lg~,
“Libc{gif czc}nfnrr gf ~fr{}~b{~}nk unn}/{i/unn} rwr{nor,‟ GNNN
[}cfrcb{gifr if Uc}cllnl cfk Kgr{}gm~{nk Rwr{nor, TIL& 34, FI& =,
uu&342 ‒ 3:;, Dnm}~c}w =55>&
P37_ Sg~wcf A~i, Hgfjw~ Banf, Q~nxai~ Q~, Wcba~cf Xai~, Qgf Lg~ “CLibc{gif/czc}n Nddgbgnf{ Bif{nf{mcrnk Rnc}bagfj itn} ^fr{}~b{~}nk
U=U Fn{zi}`,‟ GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Fn{zi}` Biou~{gfj
cfk Gfdi}oc{gif Rnb~}g{w,uu&312 / 31:, Ocw =533&
P=5_ R& Hgcfj, L& J~i, Q& Xacfj, cfk A& Zcfj, “Lgja{Dliik8 Ogfgogxgfj]nk~fkcf{ Onrrcjnr cfk Ocqgogxgfj Rbiun id Unn}/{i/Unn} &
Rnc}ba,‟ GNNN [}cfr& Uc}cllnl cfk Kgr{}gm~{nk Rwr{nor, til& 37,fi& >,
uu& 453/43;, Ocw =551
P=3_ @cXcC Aionucjn, a{{u8))zzz&`cxcc&bio &
P==_ M& Wcfj, A& Jc}bgc/Oilgfc, “Knrgjfgfj c R~un}/unn} Fn{zi}`‟,U}ibnnkgfjr id {an 37{a Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Kc{c Nfjgfnn}gfj
,Oc}ba =552
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ ::
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 93/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :27=3)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :27=3
Oimgln Kgrcr{n} Ocfcjnonf{ Rwr{no ^rgfj Cfk}igk
[nbafilijw
Ogrr& Knnu{g M& Ranlc} Lnb{~}n} gf Raca cfk Cfbai}
@~{baag Nfjj Billnjn
O~omcg / 11, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛ Gf {ikcwr rbnfc}gi ~rn id roc}{uaifnr grjcgfgfj gf{n}nr{ gf uniuln, {an kgrcr{n} ocfcjnonf{ rwr{no zcrgoulnonf{nk cr c roc}{ uaifn cuulgbc{gif ~rgfj Jiijln‗rCfk}igk iun}c{gfj rwr{no& [an kgrcr{n} ocfcjnonf{ rwr{noCfk}igk cuulgbc{gif kn{n}ogfnr {an iu{go~o }i~{n clifjkgddn}nf{ jnij}cuagbcl libc{gifr {ac{ {an til~f{nn}r cfk
}nrb~n}r fnnk {i {c`n gf i}kn} {i rn}tn {an oir{ f~omn} id uniuln cfk u}itgkn ocqgo~o bitn}cjn id {an c}nc gf {anrai}{nr{ uirrgmln {gon& Jnfn{gb clji}g{ao zcr cuulgnk di}iu{gogxc{gif cfk kgddn}nf{ uc}con{n}r zn}n tc}gnk {i kn{n}ogfn{an oir{ iu{go~o }i~{n&
@nwzi}kr‛Cfk}igk, Kgrcr{n} ocfcjnonf{, Jnfn{gb
clji}g{ao, [}ctnllgfj rclnrocf u}imlno, Roc}{ uaifnCuulgbc{gif, Zg}nlnrr oimgln {nbafilijw
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Ocfw bi~f{}gnr cfk {n}}g{i}gnr c}n c{ }gr` id fc{~}cl
acxc}kr k~n {i nc}{as~c`nr, dliikr, {}iugbcl bwblifnr, cfk
lcfkrlgknr& K~n {i {agr oi}{clg{w }c{n gfknq !O]G' gr
gfb}ncrgfj& G{ acr blcgonk {an lgtnr id {ai~rcfkr id uniuln cfk kcocjnk mgllgifr zi}{a id u}iun}{w& [ai~ja
zn bcffi{ r{iu {anrn fc{~}cl kgrcr{n}r m~{ zn bcf
kndgfg{nlw dgfk ril~{gif {i itn}bion g{ dcr{n}& Ntnf zg{a
{an }nb~}}nf{ bclcog{gnr, {an}n gr r{gll {an cmrnfbn id cf
nddgbgnf{ kgrcr{n} ocfcjnonf{ rwr{no {ac{ zgll anlu {an
uniuln gf {gonr id bclcog{gnr&
GG& KGRCR[N] OCFCJNONF[
[an u}ibnrr id kgrcr{n} ocfcjnonf{ gftiltnr di~}
uacrnr8 og{gjc{gif, u}nuc}nkfnrr, }nruifrn, cfk }nbitn}w&
c{{nou{ {i }nk~bn kgrcr{n} }gr`r gr bcllnk cr
og{gjc{gif& kntnliuonf{ id cf cb{gif ulcf di} cf
~ubiogfj kgrcr{n} bionr ~fkn} u}nuc}nkfnrr& [an}nruifrn uacrn bifrgr{ id {an oimglgxc{gif id rn}tgbnr
cfk }nlgnd zanf kgrcr{n} r{}g`nr cfk {an }nbitn}w uacrn gr
{an }nr{i}c{gif id {an cddnb{nk c}nc {i g{r u}ntgi~r r{c{n&
C&^RN ID ROC][ UAIFNR8
C roc}{uaifn gr c agja/nfk oimgln uaifn {ac{
biomgfnr {an d~fb{gifr id c un}rifcl kgjg{cl crrgr{cf{
!UKC' cfk c oimgln uaifn& [ikcw*r oiknlr {wugbcllw clri
rn}tn cr ui}{cmln onkgc ulcwn}r cfk bcon}c uaifnr zg{a
agja/}nril~{gif {i~ba rb}nnfr, znm m}izrn}r {ac{ bcf
cbbnrr, cfk u}iun}lw kgrulcw, r{cfkc}k znm ucjnr }c{an}
{acf h~r{ oimgln/iu{gogxnk rg{nr, JUR fctgjc{gif, Zg/Dgcfk oimgln m}ickmcfk cbbnrr& [an {n}o roc}{uaifn gr
~r~cllw ~rnk {i knrb}gmn uaifnr zg{a oi}n cktcfbnk
biou~{gfj cmglg{w cfk biffnb{gtg{w {acf c bif{noui}c}w
dnc{~}n uaifn, cl{ai~ja {an kgr{gfb{gif bcf mn tcj~n cfk
{an}n gr fi iddgbgcl kndgfg{gif di} zac{ bifr{g{~{nr {an
kgddn}nfbn mn{znnf {ano& [an kndgfg{gifr clri ragd{ itn}
{gon rgfbn ocfw uaifnr {ac{ c}n bifrgkn}nk dnc{~}n uaifnr
{ikcw bcf actn bcucmglg{gnr {ac{ nqbnnk {airn id uaifnr {ac{
ack mnnf u}ioi{nk cr roc}{uaifnr gf {an ucr{&
M&CFK]IGK OIMGLN KNTNLIUONF[ NFTG]IFONF[8
Cfk}igk gr c rid{zc}n ulc{di}o cfk iun}c{gfj rwr{no di}
oimgln kntgbnr Mcrnk if {an Lgf~q `n}fnl& G{ gr kntnliunkmw Jiijln cfk lc{n} {an Iunf Acfkrn{ Cllgcfbn !IAC'&
Cllizr z}g{gfj ocfcjnk bikn gf {an Hctc lcfj~cjn&
Cfk}igk gr fi{ c rgfjln ugnbn id ac}kzc}n0 g{*r c biouln{n,
nfk/{i/nfk rid{zc}n ulc{di}o {ac{ bcf mn ckcu{nk {i zi}`
if cfw f~omn} id ac}kzc}n bifdgj~}c{gifr& Ntn}w{agfj gr
{an}n, d}io {an mii{ lickn} cll {an zcw ~u {i {an
cuulgbc{gifr& Cfk}igk ~rnr Lgf~q di} g{r kntgbn k}gtn}r,
onoi}w ocfcjnonf{, u}ibnrr ocfcjnonf{, cfk
fn{zi}`gfj& G{ r~uui}{r zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gifr ~rgfj8
JRO oimgln/uaifn {nbafilijw, 2J , 15=&33 Zg/Dg
fn{zi}`r&
Cfk}igk gr c o~l{g/u}ibnrr rwr{no, gf zagba ncba
cuulgbc{gif !cfk uc}{r id {an rwr{no' }~fr gf g{r izf
u}ibnrr& Oir{ rnb~}g{w mn{znnf cuulgbc{gifr cfk {an
rwr{no gr nfdi}bnk c{ {an u}ibnrr lntnl {a}i~ja r{cfkc}k
Lgf~q dcbglg{gnr, r~ba cr ~rn} cfk j}i~u GKr {ac{ c}n
crrgjfnk {i cuulgbc{gifr& Ckkg{gifcl dgfn}/j}cgfnk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 94/223
dnc{~}nr c
onbacfgro {
un}c{gifr {a
un}/^]G un}gdgb ugnbnr id
JNFN[GB
clji}g{ao !
ibnrr id fc{~
nk {i jnfcfk rnc}ba u
lc}jn} blcr
nfn}c{n ril~{g
~nr gfrug}nk~{c{gif, rnlnb
gf{cgfr c uiulno c{ acflwgfj c rn{ id
gb clji}g{ao,
i} {an jnfkc{n ril~{gif
' {i cf iu{gog
r& [}ckg{gifc
jr id 5r cfk
ntil~{gif ~r~nfn}c{nk gf
Gf ncba jnf
{an uiu~l}n r{ibacr{gb
mcrnk if {
cfk uirrgmlwf& [an fnz
id {an clji}g
nf ng{an} c o
~bnk, i} c rc
n uiu~lc{gif&
go~o f~omni} ocw fi
dgfk cuulg
rbgnfbn, nfjg
, oc{anoc{gb
GT& RWR[N
{}ctnllgfj rgb clji}g{aor
nk kgrcr{n}
}igk !OKK
wKgrcr{n}K}ik Lgr{Tgnz&
mcrnk if Ji
d {an uniuln g
n u}itgknk
ac{ nfdi}bnr
c{ c uc}{gb~l
grrgifr di} jkc{c&
CLJI]G[AO
C' gr c rnc}
cl ntil~{gif&
n}c{n ~rnd~l}imlnor& Jn
id ntil~{gi
gifr {i iu{gog
w fc{~}cl nt{gif, cfk b}ir
lc{gif id bccfk oc`n
r{ibacr{gb iu
c uiu~lc{gif
{wun id {an!bcllnk gfkg
xc{gif u}imln
llw, ril~{gifr
3r, m~{ i{an}
cllw r{c}{r d}ikgtgk~clr c
n}c{gif, {an
c{gif gr ntllw rnlnb{nk
ang} dg{fnrr'
}cfkiolw ouiu~lc{gif gr
{ao& Biooi
cqgo~o f~o
{grdcb{i}w dg{f
Gd {an clji}g{
} id jnfn}c{g{ actn mnnf
gbc{gif gf
gfnn}gfj, nbi
r, uawrgbr cfk
O GOULNONF
lnrocf u}iml{i jnfn}c{n
ocfcjnonf{
' zcr goul
gk, g{ raiOcuTgnz ra
ijln Ocur z
gf fnnk, {ang}
{a}i~ja
}nr{}gb{gifr i
} u}ibnrr bc
}cf{gfj ck/ai
a an~}gr{gb {
[agr an~}gr{gb
ril~{gifrn{gb clji}g{a
fc}w clji}g{a
xc{gif u}imln
il~{gif, r~baritn}& C jnfn
kgkc{n ril~{gg{ ntiltn
n}c{i}r&
id r{}gfjr !b
jnfion', ztgk~clr, b}nc{
o, ntiltnr {i
c}n }nu}nrnf{
fbikgfjr c}n
o c uiu~lc{gk acuunfr
dg{fnrr id n
cl~c{nk, o~ld}io {an b~
, cfk oik
~{c{nk' {i di{anf ~rnk g
flw, {an clji}
mn} id jnfn}c
nrr lntnl acr
ao acr {n}og
fr, c rc{grdc}ncbank& Jn
mgigfdi}o
iogbr, banog
i{an} dgnlkr
C[GIF
no cr mcrgrc ril~{gif,
rwr{no fc
nonf{nk& ^u
r {zi tgnzr {an libc{g
gln {an Lgr{Tg
bi}}nruifkgf
c
f
f
b
ac{
gr
{ior
or
or
cr{gb
frmw
cllnk
agba~}nr,
c}k
k gf
clri
f id gf
tn}w
{guln}}nf{
gdgnk
o c{an
g{ao
{gifr
mnnf
c{nk
{i}wn{gb
{gbr,
r{}w,
fkcf
nk
if
r8gif
nz
Dgj~}n38 Mlib` Kgcj}co
Clji}g{aoGoulnonf{c{g
d {an Jnfn{gb
f
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ :7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 95/223
Dgj~}n
Dgj~}n 28 O
;8 OwKgrcr{n}
wKgrcr{n}K}ig
K}igk Lgr{Tgn
OcuTgnz
u
b
{
“
i
br
d
i
b
c{g
u
gf
~
T&![R
Kn{n}ogfgf
nij}cuagb lib
}imlno zan
ii}kgfc{nr cf
}ctnllgfj rcln [an {}ctnll
Jgtnf c dgfg{
d {}ctnl mn{z
ancunr{' zcw{c}{gfj uigf{
i}ocllw knrb
mhnb{gtn id dg
gfgo~o bir{
g{gnr i} fiknr
{ ifn fikn, tgon ncba, cf
}imlno zg{a {
b}ncrn if {~omn} id bg{g
rgfj iu{gogxc
[]CTNLLG
'
j {an oir{ i
c{gifr gr rgog
ngf jnij}cu
k {an }nrb~n}
ocf&
gfj rclnrocff~omn} id bg
nf ncba ucg}
id tgrg{gfj cll&‟ [an {}ct
}gmnk cr c u
kgfj {an uc{
' if cf ~fk
{i mn tgrg{nk&
grg{r cll i{an}dgfcllw }n{~
an {}ctnllgfj
an f~omn}gnr gfb}ncrn&
{gif {nbafgs~
FJ RCLNR
{go~o }i~{n
lc} {i {an {}ct
gb libc{gifr
r i} til~f{nn
u}imlno gr r{g{gnr cfk {an k
id {ano, dgfk
{an bg{gnr cfkllgfj rclnro
}o~{c{gif u}
id {an rai}{n
g}nb{nk j}cua
[an {}ctnllgf
fiknr r~bbn}fr {i {an r{c
rclnrocf u}i
d uirrgmln }Aizntn}, {ag
r&
NF U]IML
clifj kgddn}n
llgfj rclnro
}nu}nrnf{ bg
r }nu}nrnf{ {
c{nk cr dilligr{cfbn !i} bi
{an rai}{nr{
}n{~}fgfj {icf u}imlno
imlno zg{a
r{ lnfj{a !i}
{ac{ }nu}nrn
rclnrocf r{
rgtnlw iflw}{gfj fikn&
lno gr {an }c
~{nr zanfr bcf mn ril
NO
{
f
{w
n
r8r{'
!i}
{angr
{an
{an
f{r
}{r
fnan
gk
{annk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 15
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 96/223
TG& BIFBL^RGIF
Gf {agr ucun} zn {}gnk {i goulnonf{ }nrb~n cfk
kgrcr{n} ocfcjnonf{ iun}c{gif ~rgfjOwKgrcr{n}K}igk zcr goulnonf{nk gf cf Cfk}igk/
mcrnk oimgln uaifn& ^rgfj jnfn{gb clji}g{ao, cf
iu{go~o }i~{n clifj {an jgtnf jnij}cuagb libc{gifr
zcr kn{n}ogfnk&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ ^fg{nk Fc{gifr Gf{n}fc{gifcl R{}c{njw di}
Kgrcr{n}]nk~b{gif Rnb}c{c}gc{ !^FGRK]', Oi}{clg{w
]gr`Gfknq, 3> H~fn =557P=_ Crgc Ucbgdgb [nlnbio ]nrnc}ba
L{k&,[nlnbioo~fgbc{gifr gf {an Uaglguugfnr, 3 H~fn =557
P2_ Kcoif U& Biuuilc, Gf{}ik~b{gif {i Gf{n}fc{gifcl
Kgrcr{n} Ocfcjnonf{, Nlrntgn} Gfb&, =55:&P;_ Mc}{nl Tcf kn Zclln, Jn}k Tcf Knf Nnkn, cfk Zgllno
O~a}nf, A~ocfg{c}gcf Gfdi}oc{gif Ocfcjnonf{ cfk Rwr{nor,
Oimgln ]nruifrn8 Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Zi}`raiu if Oimgln
Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw di} Non}jnfbw ]nruifrn =551,Miff,Jn}ocfw, Ocw =7/21, =551, ]ntgrnk Rnlnb{nk Ucun}r,
Ru}gfjn}, =557
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 13
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 97/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :27=1)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :27=1
Acfkitn} [nbafgs~nr Di} ;J Fn{zi}`r
Ugwclg K~{{cUJ r{~knf{, Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn Knuc}{onf{
Kc{{c Onjan Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj& Cg}ilg
Fctg O~omcg, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{ ‛ [an fnq{ jnfn}c{gif ;J fn{zi}`r c}n }nu}nrnf{nk
mw an{n}ijnfni~r nftg}ifonf{ zg{a kgddn}nf{ cbbnrr fn{zi}`
{nbafilijgnr {ac{ tc}w gf mcfkzgk{a, lc{nfbw cfk bir{& ;J
fn{zi}`r c}n `fizf di} {ang} rncolnrr biffnb{gtg{w mn{znnf
nqgr{gfj fn{zi}`r lg`n JRO, zg}nlnrr LCF, Ml~n{ii{a cfk
i{an}r& Rncolnrr Biffnb{gtg{w gf r~ba fn{zi}`r nf{g}nlw
knunfkr if nddgbgnf{ acfkitn} onbacfgror cfk o~l{guln
oimglg{w ocfcjnonf{ onbacfgror& Gf {agr ucun}, zn kgrb~rrkgddn}nf{ bacllnfjnr dcbgfj ;J oimglg{w& Zn u}iuirn cf ~rn}
xifgfj acfkitn} {nbafgs~n mcrnk if {an GNNN15=&=3
u}i{ibil, zan}n {an cuu}icba biffnb{r ~rn}r {i c u}nrn{
fn{zi}` ~uif nf{n}gfj c xifn, j~gknk mw {an OGGR rn}tn}& Zn
clri kgrb~rr if tn}{gbcl acfkitn} di} }ncl/{gon tgkni {}cddgb&
@nwzi}kr/ acfkitn}0 ;J oimglg{w0 ~rn} xifgfj0
GNNN15=&=30 tn}{gbcl acfkitn}&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Cktcfbnk oimgln bioo~fgbc{gif rwr{nor actn ocgflw
gfb}ncrnk k~n {i {an fnnkr id {an gfb}ncrgfj ~rn}
}ns~g}nonf{r& Ocfw i}jcfgxc{gifr r~ba cr GNNN,
Nlnb{}ifgbr cfk [nlnbioo~fgbc{gifr ]nrnc}ba Gfr{g{~{nractn mnnf zi}`gfj {izc}kr ;J fn{zi}`r {i u}itgkn
rncolnrr biffnb{gtg{w cfwzan}n cfk cfw{gon& [an ;J
fn{zi}`r zagba gr an{n}ijnfni~r gf fc{~}n zan}n {an}n
zi~lk mn o~l{guln rn}tgbn u}itgkn}r, ns~guunk zg{a tc}gnk
{nbafilijgnr iddn}gfj tc}gnk rn}tgbnr di} {an mnfndg{ id {an
~rn}r& ;{ajnfn}c{gif rwr{nor c}n mngfj kntnliunk {i
r~uui}{ j}nc{n} mcfkzgk{a rn}tgbnr, agjan} kc{c }c{nr,
gou}itnk s~clg{w cfk rncolnrr jlimcl oimglg{w cr
biouc}nk {i u}ntgi~r rwr{nor&
Acfkitn} gr {an {}cfrdn} id cf if/jigfj bcll i} kc{c
rnrrgif d}io ifn bnll {i cfi{an}& Acfkitn}r ibb~} k~n {i
{an oitnonf{ id {an oimgln ~rn} d}io ifn c}nc {i cfi{an}
c}nc& Acfkitn}r c}n ~rnk {i u}ntnf{ cf if/jigfj bcll {i mn
kgrbiffnb{nk& Gd zn kif‗{ ~rn acfkitn}r {anf zanfntn} c
~rn} lnctnr {an c}nc id c uc}{gb~lc} bnll {anf g{r if/jigfj
bcll gr goonkgc{nlw kgrbiffnb{nk&
[an u}ibnrr id acfkitn} }ns~g}nr c f~omn} id
uc}con{n}r lg`n zac{ gr {an acfkitn} rbanon zn c}n ~rgfj
cfk aiz ocfw bacffnlr c}n d}nn& Gf {an acfkitn} u}ibnrr
zn rai~lk clri `nnu {an SiR ~u {i {an r{cfkc}k& Gf ;J
fn{zi}`r, zn dgfk kgddn}nf{ acfkitn} {nbafgs~nr&
Acfkitn}r mn{znnf {zi mcrn r{c{gifr !MRr' id {an rcon
rwr{no gr bcllnk Ai}gxif{cl acfkitn}& Ai}gxif{cl acfkitn}
gftiltnr c {n}ogfcl kntgbn {i bacfjn bnllr zg{agf {an rcon
{wun id fn{zi}` {i ocgf{cgf rn}tgbn bif{gf~g{w& Ai}gxif{cl
acfkitn} mn{znnf {zi MR, ~fkn} rcon di}ngjf cjnf{ !DC'
gr `fizf cr Lgf`/lcwn} acfkitn}& Gf Gf{}c/rwr{no
acfkitn}, {an ai}gxif{cl acfkitn} ibb~}r mn{znnf {zi MRr
{ac{ mnlifj {i {zi kgddn}nf{ DCr cfk mi{a DCr mnlifj {i{an rcon rwr{no cfk anfbn {i rcon jc{nzcw di}ngjf cjnf{
!JDC'& Tn}{gbcl acfkitn} ocw mn }ndn}}nk {i c u}ibnrr id
{}cfrdn}}gfj bcll biffnb{nk {i c fn{zi}`)kc{c rnrrgif d}io
ifn bacffnl biffnb{nk gf c bnll {i {an bi}n fn{zi}` id
cfi{an}& C r~g{cmlw ns~guunk kntgbn ocw mn cmln {i ~rn
mi{a {nbafilijgnr c{ c {gon, {an agja runnk Zg}nlnrr LCF
cfk bnll~lc} {nbafilijw& Tn}{gbcl acfkitn} }ndn}r {i c
fn{zi}` fikn bacfjgfj {an {wun id biffnb{gtg{w g{ ~rnr {i
cbbnrr c r~uui}{gfj gfd}cr{}~b{~}n, ~r~cllw {i r~uui}{ fikn
oimglg{w&
GNNN15=&=3 P3_ gr c r{cfkc}k {ac{ zcr b}nc{nk gf i}kn}
{i dcbglg{c{n an{n}ijnfni~r acfkitn}r mn{znnf GNNN 15=
cfk fif GNNN15= cbbnrr fn{zi}`r }njc}klnrr id {an
fn{zi}` dnc{~}nr& [an GNNN 15=&=3 r{cfkc}k kndgfnr {an
OGA !Onkgc Gfknunfknf{ Acfkitn}' onbacfgro {i nfcmln
{an iu{gogxc{gif id acfkitn}&
Gf {agr ucun}, zn u}nrnf{ c m}gnd itn}tgnz ;J jnfn}cl
c}bag{nb{~}n& Dgfcllw, zn u}iuirn c ~rn} xifgfj acfkitn}
{nbafgs~n mcrnk if {an GNNN 15=&=3 u}i{ibil cfk tn}{gbcl
acfkitn}r mn{znnf ^O[R cfk ZgOCQ fn{zi}`r&
GG& BACLLNFJNR GF OIMGLG[W OCFCJNONF[
[an}n c}n rntn}cl bacllnfjnr cfk grr~nr }njc}kgfj
oimglg{w gf ;J fn{zi}`r8
C& Libc{gif Ocfcjnonf{
Libc{gif ocfcjnonf{ anlur {i libc{n {an ~rn}‗rgfr{cf{cfni~r uigf{ id c{{cbaonf{ di} biffnb{gif knlgtn}w
u~}uirnr& Libc{gif ocfcjnonf{ gr kgtgknk gf{i {zi ocgf
d~fb{gifr8
3' Libc{gif ]njgr{}c{gif8 Libc{gif }njgr{}c{gif `nnur
{an fn{zi}` czc}n id bacfjnr c{ {an uigf{ id c{{cbaonf{ id
ncba gfkgtgk~cl ~rn} coifj {an fn{zi}`&
=' Bcll Knlgtn}w 8 Bcll knlgtn}w gr ~rnk c{ {gon id c
biffnb{gif }ns~nr{ cfk gf i}kn} {i knlgtn} {an biffnb{gif {i
{an runbgdgnk ~rn}& [an fn{zi}` gr s~n}gnk di} {an ~rn}
libc{gif u}idgln ri {an b~}}nf{ ~rn} uirg{gif gr }n{}gntnk&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 1=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 98/223
g
g
l
l
M& [an Baigb
[agr grr~
iffnb{nk u}
iffnb{nk {ic}bag{nb{~}n
~l{guln kgdd
iffnb{nk it
B& Oimglg{w
Bif{nq{ gr
{i bac}cb{n}gx
cuulgbc{gifr
gfdi}oc{gif c
rg{~c{gif& Bi
qagmg{gfj {
tcl~nr cmi~{
tcl~nr&
K& Ucjgfj
Ucjgfj gr
gfdi}oc{gif i
c{c rnrrgifr&
cjgfj gr }ns
nllr bcf mn b
N& Oitgfj J
[an oitg
}iogfnf{ bi
~rn}r di}o
agn}c}bagnr z
c bl~r{n}, zg~fgdgnk fn{zi
l~r{n} gf c
n{zi}` cfk r
Oir{ id {
f bnll di}o
nllr, }nruifrg
gog{r& [an b
awrgbcl }nri
ngfj r{}~b{~
gog{nk {i c
Itn}lcuugfj b
C ~fgtn}r
cbbnrr }ns~nr
GU fn{zi}`r
{nbafilijgnr,
}itgknk uc}
Rn}tgbn Kio
}i~{gfj cfk
iknl c}n ocg
Ocfcjnonf{
}nu}nrnf{r an
ZgOCQ, JU
Cll id {anrn
n Id [nbafil
n gr crribg
gfbguln zagba
{an mnr{ ctcgld ;J P4_ fn
}nf{ cbbnrr
}&
if{nq{ Ocfc
kndgfnk cr c
n {an rg{~c{gi
cfk fn{zi}`
mi~{ {anornlt
{nq{ gfdi}oc
oui}cl bac}
ucr{, u}nrnf
nfkgfj nrrnf
d c ~rn} gf i}
K~n {i uizn
~g}nk {i mn c
omgfnk {ijn{
}i~u Di}oc{g
fj di}oc{gif
uifnf{ id d~
{noui}c}w
agln {}ctnlgfj&
{agf zagba ~}`, d~fb{gifr
kgddn}nf{ mna
ntn} itn}anc
n zg}nlnrr bi
{gif r{}~b{~}n
gmln di} bif{c
nll‗r bcucbg{w
}bnr itn} zag
}nk itn}& C
bn}{cgf f~om
itn}cjn gr ~r
GGG&
JNFN]l biooif gf{
{r d}io tc}gi
dcbn kgddn}
rn}tgbnr cfk
{lw mw oimgl
cgf& [an Fn{
g{ ugun ocfc
gflw }nlc{nk {i
!OO' r~uui
{n}ijnfni~r
]R)^O[R, c
c}n biffnb{
jw
{nk zg{a {
goulgnr {ac{
cmln biffnb{g{zi}`r gr mc
{nbafilijw d
nonf{
w gfdi}oc{gi
id cf nf{g{w
zgll mn }n
nr, {ang} r~}}
{gif bcf mn
cb{n}gr{gbr,
{ cr znll cr
{gcl onrrcjnr
n} {i mn ~rnk
} lgog{c{gifr
r nddgbgnf{ cr
an} {i di}o i
fr
id c o~l{g/
{~}n fn{zi}`
oitgfj bl~
R~ba j}i~ur
rn}r c}n ~r~r~ba cr acfk
ctgi} {i }nr
&
oo~fgbc{gif
r& [an fn{zi
{gfj {an oim
gr kndgfnk
gba bioo~fgb
bi}kgfj {i
n} id ~rn}r {
k gf ;J rwr{
CL C]BAG[NBn}dcbn gr u}i
r {wunr id o
f{ cbbnrr
}icogfj u}i{
n kntgbnr {a
i}` Kiocgf
jnonf{& Bacl
{an SiR, Rnb
}{& [an c}bag
fn{zi}`r& G{
fk N^[]CF
k {i GU fn{
an Clzcwr
c ~rn} acr {
f c{ cll {gon&nk if biomg
} {an ~rn} {
{ac{ bcf mn
, zan}n {n}og
~g}nk {i u}
~fkgfjr cfk
{c{gb i} kwf
njc}kgfj bi
u}nkgb{nk d
{i ~ukc{n lib
{i }i~{n bcll
d oimgln knt
uirrgmln& Rn
n ucjgfj c}n
~rn} rnrrgif
& Rntn}cl fn{
{n} cfk fn{
id ~rn}r c}n b
llw higfnk gftn} zgll kncl
l{ c }nk~b{gi
rwr{nor c}n m
}` gr kgtgknk
gln ~fg{r zg{ag
w {an f~om
c{gif bacffnl
{ac{, ncba bn
i air{ c{ c
or&
[^]Ngknk {i rc{grd
imgln rwr{nor
wr{nor, {n}
ibil& Rn}tgbn
ornltnr cfk
gr }nruifrgml
lnfjnr dcbgfj
~}g{w cfk Oi
g{nb{~}n gf Dg
bif{cgfr ZL
cbbnrr fn{z
zi}` {a}i~j
Mnr{
i mn
[anfgfj
i mn
~rnk
fclr,
tgkn
{ang}
ogb,
{nq{
{~}n
c{gif
cfk
gbnr,
tn}cl
&
gr c
i}`
i}`
cllnk
{i czg{a
f gf
crnk
gf{i
gf g{r
} id
r c}n
ll gr
{gon&
{an
& Cll
gfcl
r c}n
{an
n id
{agr
glg{w
j& 3
CF,
i}`r&
cf
nt
f
a
oa
u}
}c
}n
cf
I
F
bc
lc
f
gf
rn
k
u}
f
ct
z
u}
d~
!
{a
rn!
!
dl
nt
~
li
k
id
u}
cg
c}
iltnk ucb`n{
{zi}`& [i u
fkitn} u}ib
nbacfgror8 afkitn} nqnb~
Dgj
[an acfkit
ibnk~}nr zan
kgi oncr~}n
ui}{r u}itgkn
~}jnf{ acf
{an}zgrn, g{
z lgf` kgrbi
f mn }nclgxnk
n}r& K~}gfj
{zi}`r bitn
tiltn c s~n
}tn}& Gf bcrn
tgbn o~r{ c
ibnnkgfj& Gd
{zi}`, SiR
cglcmglg{w ban
agba zcr fi{ g
ibnk~}n gr m
fb{gif !OGAD
F' cfk {an f
}nn {wunr id
}tgbn !OGNR'GBR'0 cfk !
GGR'& Ncba i
z kg}nb{gif
nf{r r~ba cr l
un} fn{zi}` l
zn} lcwn} d}i
tgbnr cfk rbc
bioocfkr
itgkgfj {an
nr {an acfk
n acfklnk mw
bi}n !NUB' z
}di}o c onk
nrr gr un}d
fkitn} gfg{gc{{gif&
}n 3 8 C An{n}ij
} gfg{gc{gif g
}n ncba kntgb
nf{ }nui}{r
gfdi}oc{gif
itn} gd run
gll rnfk un}g
tn}w gr clri
zg{a runbgdg
{an acfk
}cjn rbcffgf
}w di} gfdi}
id cbbnrr {i
~{anf{gbc{n g
{an kntgbn
if{nq{ o~r{
`& Dgfcllw, a
fbl~knk mw {a
crnk if {an
'& [an OGAD
n{zi}` fikn
rn}tgbnr8 !3
0 !=' Onkgc g' Onkgc gfk
d {an rn}tgbnr
zg{a bn}{cgf
gf` kn{n}gi}c
cwn}r& OGBR
o agjan} if
ffgfj di} ct
}kn}nk mw O
onbacfgror
tn} knbgrgif&
OGGR r~ba c
agba gr cf nt
gc gfknunfkn
i}onk gf {
gif, acfkitn
nfni~r fn{zi}`
tiltnr ilk lg
n acr {i mn bi
& [anrn on
cmi~{ {an fnn
gdgb {a}nrail
ikgb gfdi}oc{
n}di}onk gf
{}gjjn}r d}i
tn} u}nuc}c
j {c`nr ulc
c{gif d}io
fnz fn{zi}
{rnld {i {an
gr c~{anf{gbc
mn {}cfrdn}}n
cfkitn} nqnb
n GNNN 15=&=
onkgc gfknu
nqgr{r gf mi{a
u}i{ibil r{cb`
' Onkgc gf
fknunfknf{ bnunfknf{ gfd
u}itgknk mw
nruifrgmglg{gn
{gif cfk lgf`
{}cfrdn}r bif{
r& Bifdgj~}c
glcmln fn{zi}
GBR& OGGR g
{i }n{}gntn g
& R{c{gb lgf` l
bacffnl gfdi
ltnk 2JUU b
{ acfkitn},
}nn r{cjnr
u}nuc}c{gif
c}bag{nb{~}n
` bifdgj~}c{g
fdgj~}nk {i r
cr~}nonf{r
k id un}di}og
kr c}n b}irr
gifcl onrrcj
{agr r{cjn za
ctcglcmln lg
{gif, ckkg{gi
bn zagba
cf gfdi}oc{g
}nri~}bnr,
fn{zi}` mnd
{nk c{ {an f
di} c }nri~
{gif {c`nr ul
3& [an acfki
fknf{ acfki
{an oimgln f
& G{ u}itgknr
nunfknf{ nt
oocfk rn}t}oc{gif rn}t
{an OGAD ac
r& OGNR }nu
~fctcglcmglg{w
il bioocfk
{gif id fn{z
`r c}n nqcou
r }nruifrgmln
fdi}oc{gif {
cwn} uc}con{
}oc{gif cfk
}n
{an
i}
fk
gif
fk
fk
gfj
nk&
nr&
gba
gf`
fcl
cw
gif
{an
}n
nz
}bn
bn
tn}
tn}
kn
{an
nf{
gbngbn
r c
}{r
{i
{i
}`
lnr
id
ac{
n}r
{an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 12
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 99/223
nkg~o cbbn
!CU'&
GT& [an acfki
~n}w d}io
n{zi}`r gf {
ioocfkr {
ilgbgnr cfk
ifgfj cuu}i
cbbnrr fn{zi
{an dcti} id
n}di}o {an
cuulw ~rn} x
{c}jn{ xifnr
zagba {an xif
Dg
Zn r~jj
ifbn}fgfj r
c}n anlk, zan
{i nf{n} {agr
{}cddgb itn} cll
cgor {i iu{go
OGGR u}gtglnj
coi~f{ id {}c
{an {a}nn r{cj
r bif{}il !O
^RN] XIFGF
tn} u}nuc}c{g
{an OGGR
an tgbgfg{w i
zc}kr {an
fn{zi}`r u}g
cba u}iuirnr
}`r bitn}gfj
bn}{cgf fn{z
acfkitn} {iz
fgfj bifbnu{
cr {i mn u}i
n gr libc{nk&
~}n = 8 ^rn} xifg
nr{ ~ukc{gfj
nbgdgb xifnr
}n c lc}jn f~
xifn jnfn}c{
l ctcglcmln fn{
gxn {an acfki
nr, zan}n g{
ddgb if ncba
r {ac{ acfki
B' ckk}nrr
ACFKITN]
f r{cjn gfbl
n}tn} bifbn
d {an OF, c
F, gf ckkg
}g{w i}kn}&
confkgfj {a
{an r~}}i~fkg
i}`& [an OF
c}kr {agr fn{
itn} OGA,
gknk mw {an
fj acfkitn} u}ib
{an OGGR
r~ba cr r{ckg
mn} id c~kg
gfj c a~jn
zi}`r& [an ~
tn} u}ibnk~}
gll mn bcucml
tcglcmln fn{
n} u}ibnk~}n
d {an cbbnrr
CUU]ICBA
~knr8 gfdi}o
}fgfj {an c
kg{gifcl rbcf
g{gif {i bac
~} u}iuirnk
u}gi}g{w i}k
fjr id {an O
zgll mn di}b
zi}`& Gf i}k
gfdi}oc{gif
GGR rn}tn} ~
nk~}n dliz&
rn}tn} kc{
~or zanf j
fbnr c}n nqu
coi~f{ id ~
rn} xifgfj bi
mw nq{nfkgf
n id mclcfbgf
i}`& Dgj& = r
acr {i ji {a}i
igf{
c{gif
bnrr
fgfj
jgfj
~rn}
} id
F gf
k {i
} {i
mi~{
fkn}
mcrn
onr
b{nk
jnf{
bnu{
{an
{an
izr
~ja8
gf
u}
C&{i
{a
z
bi
o
!
{a
k
^
k
U
c&
gf
o
k
i{
{a
ba
Z
}n
{i
!
k
k
u}
uu}
m&
}n
tg
gf
u}
gf
b&
gf
f
d}f
{}
{a
}n
r~
ba
~
}n
!
nr
g{gc{gif, u}nu
ibnrr, goui}{
[an ~rn} xi
[an oimglnzc}kr {an f
}nrailkr gr ~
agba gr gf
ffnb{gif gr n
nrrcjn {i
GAYbifdgj~}
}nrailkr di} {
tgbn jnfn}c{
if }nbngtgf
tgbn acr {i r
R !OGAYbif
Cd{n} {ac{,
di}oc{gif
ncr~}nonf{r&
tgbn r{c{~r c{
an} rgjfgdgbcf
n zg}nlnrr k
cfjnr {i {a
anf kn{n}gi}
cba ~fcbbnu{
{an ZgOC
GAYlgf`Yjig
{cglr cmi~{ {
zf cfk {an }
nbgrgif& Fiz
}di}ogfj {annuc}c{gif r{c
C{ {agr r{cjn,
s~nr{gfj gfd
bgfg{w id {an
bl~knr gfdi}
nrnf{ c}i~fk
bl~knr8 fn{zi
[an OGGR rn}
kgbc{gfj di}bg
{zi}` gfr{nck
o& [agr r{n{zi}` ctcglc
ddgb ocfcjn
n acfkitn}
s~g}nk {i un}d
}}i~fkgfj& [
nb` if bcfkg
g{ zgll r`gu c
s~g}nk oncr
U]R gf i~
{cmlgragfj c b
c}c{gif, cfk
f{ bacfjnr gf
gfj acfkitn}
~fg{ gr u}n/bn{zi}`& [an
r~cllw rn{ m
~} bcrn {a
r{cmlgrank, {a
mn rnf{
Ylgf`Y]NS'&
an biffnb{gi
r c }nui}{ c
{an bifdgj~
fk c bifdg}o
gj~}nYlgf`YB
{an kntgbn
onrrcjnr
[an ZgOC
cll {gon& Cr
{ uc}con{n}r g
ntgbn zgll j
UiR !OGA
{gif gf bif
mln lntnlr, {a
UiR gfkgbc
jYkizfYGF
n {gon un}gi
crif id {agr
{an ZgOCQ
acfkitn} cfn r{c}{r&
c s~n}w {i {
}oc{gif }nj
oimgln kntgb
c{gif cmi~{
{an zg}nln
}` r{c{~r, ctcg
n} zgll rnfk
j {an kntgbn
id r~jjnr{gf
u cgor {i iglg{w, bir{, r
nf{ cfk zgll
u}ibnrr& [an
i}o ckkg{gif
n}n zgll mn f
c{n fn{zi}`r
ll }nj~lc} }nu
~}nonf{r }n
} nqcouln'&
ffnb{gif zg{
nqnb~{gif& G
{an lgf` s~clg
u}ibnk~}n z
fdgj~}nk {iu}n/bifdgj~
{an UiR !
ZgOCQ
n UiR grr~nr
{i {an
[agr onrr
uc}con{n}r
k rnfkr g{ m
}c{gif onrrc
c{gif onrrcj
FD'&
r{c}{r {i r
r{c{gfj rg
UiR zgll m
dc} cr SiR }
f bcrn id b}i
nfn}c{n c }n
lgf`uc}con{
nb{gif s~clg
oimgln ~fg{
{nr {an fnnk
'& [agr o
k c{ zagba {
lgf`r znc`fn
UiR gr czc}
k {agr gr za
n OGGR rn}t
c}kgfj cbbnr
n& [an OGGR
kgddn}nf{ c
r kntgbn& [
lcmglg{w, cfk r
onrrcjn {i {
{i biffnb{ {i
o~l{guln fn{
u{gogxn rn}tgcolnrr oimg
}nk~bn {an {g
zg}nlnrr ~
l rbcffgfj di
fnnk id }nri
& Gf {agr {nbaf
i}{gfj cb{gif
c}kgfj {an
[anf, go
a {an fnz }ckg
f {an gfg{gc{g
g{w c}n }nui}{n
}`r cr dilliz
nfn}c{n {}gjj}c{gif id {a
igf{/id/Rn}tg
iR& Zanf
c bifdgj~}c{g
oimgln f
cjn r{c{nr
~fkn} zagba
cb` {i {an U
n, {an zg}nl
{i {an ZgO
fk c un}gi
fcl r{}nf
n czc}n id
s~g}nonf{r
rrgfj {a}nrail
i}{ {i gfkgb
}rY}nui}{YGF
{w bif{gf~nr
rnfkr c onrr
di} c acfki
rrcjn gfbl~
an lgf` zgll
rr zg{a c bn}{
id {an fnnk
f {an acfki
} ogja{ mn r
r fn{zi}`r
rn}tn} kc{cm
bbnrr fn{zi
agr gfdi}oc{g
gjfcl r{}nfj{a
an ZgOCQ U
c bn}{cgf u}n
zi}`r {i bai
bn gf {n}orlg{w, cfk ~}j
n bifr~onk
g{ zgll fi{
fn{zi}`r gf
~}bn ctcglcmgl
gs~n, {an oi
cfk h~r{ }nu
{c}jn{ fn{z
nkgc{nlw r{
i fn{zi}`&
gif
k&
r8
n}rrn
bn'
{an
gif
kn
{an
{an
R&
nrr
Q
kgb
{a
{an
fk
kr,
c{n
K'&
{i
jn
tn}
nr
ji
cgf
id
tn}
nf{
gf
crn
}`r
gif
&
iR
rn{
rn
id nf{
gf
mn
{an
g{w
gln
i}{
}`
}{r
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 1;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 100/223
k&[an ZgOCQ UiR rnfkr cf gfdi}oc{gif }ns~nr{ !OGA/
Jn{/Gfdi}oc{gif&]NS' onrrcjn& OGGR rntn} }nbngtnr {an
}ns~nr{ cfk {anf rnfkr mcb` c runbgcl onrrcjn mcrnk if
UiC !Uigf{/id/C{{cbaonf{' libc{gif zan}n ~rn} xifgfj grcuulgnk, bif{cgfgfj {an {c}jn{ fn{zi}` clifj zg{a g{r
bac}cb{n}gr{gb& [an oimgln ~fg{ fiz zgll iflw rbcf di} {agr
runbgdgb fn{zi}` }c{an} {acf rbcffgfj di} c lgr{ id ctcglcmln
fn{zi}`r& OGGR zgll baiirn {agr fn{zi}` mcrnk if o~l{guln
crunb{r r~ba cr }nri~}bn ctcglcmglg{w, SiR, rgjfcl r{}nfj{a
zg{agf {an xifn, bcucmglg{w {i ocgf{cgf cb{gtn rnrrgifr, cfk
{an {wunr id rn}tgbnr iddn}nk&
D& C{ {agr uigf{, {an ZgOCQ UiR zgll rnfk cf i}kn} {i {an
oimgln ~fg{ {i r{c}{ rbcffgfj di} {an bifbn}fnk UiC
}nbioonfknk mw {an OGGR rn}tn}& C rgjfcl r{}nfj{a
oncr~}nonf{ onrrcjn acr {i mn rnf{ mcb` {i {an ZgOCQ
UiR&
J& [an UiR rnfkr c bifdg}oc{gif {i {an OGGR rn}tn} r{c{gfj
{an }nckgfnrr id {an zg}nlnrr kntgbn {i nqnb~{n acfkitn}&
A& [an ZgOCQ UiR bioo~fgbc{nr zg{a JU]R UiR cfk
rnfk c !OGAYF=FYAIYS~n}wY]nri~}rn' }ns~nr{ cfk
]nulw& [an JU]R UiR acr {i }nrn}tn }ns~g}nk }nri~}bnr&
]nri~}bnr actn {i mn j~c}cf{nnk gf mi{a bi}n cfk {c}jn{
fn{zi}`r& [agr gr zanf {an nqnb~{gif r{cjn mnjgfr cfk {an
ZgOCQ UiR i}kn}r {an zg}nlnrr kntgbn {i r{c}{ {an
acfkitn} mw gfkgbc{gfj {an cb{gifr itn} {an ilk cfk fnz
lgf` !OGAYFn{YAIYbioog{&]NS'& Ilk lgf` }nri~}bnr c}n
fi{ fnnknk cfwoi}n ri g{ bcf mn }nlncrnk cfk cf GU
biffnb{gif gr fiz nr{cmlgrank itn} {an JU]R fn{zi}` zagba acr {i mn }nui}{nk mcb` {i {an ZgOCQ UiR
!OGAYFn{YAIYBioog{&]RU' {anf {i {an JU]R UiR
!OGAYF=FYAIYbiouln{n&]NS'&
G& Fiz, {an ZgOCQ acr {i }nruifk
!OGAYF=FYAIYbiouln{n&]RU'& [anf, ZgOCQ }nlncrnr
}nri~}bnr gd fi{ cl}nckw kifn cfk kc{c r{c}{r dlizgfj
{a}i~ja JU]R Fn{zi}`&
T& TN][GBCL ACFKITN]R DI] ]NCL/[GON TGKNI []CDDGB
MN[ZNNF ^O[R CFK ZGOCQ FN[ZI]@R
Gf{n}fn{zi}`gfj cuu}icba id {an biftn}jnk fnq{
jnfn}c{gif o~l{g/cbbnrr fn{zi}` bcf oc`n {an mnr{ ~rn id {an cktcf{cjnr id {an kgddn}nf{ zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r cfk
nlgogfc{n {ang} znc`fnrrnr& ^O[R, ZgOCQ cfk ZLCF
fn{zi}`r bcf bioulnonf{ ncba i{an} gf {n}o id
jnij}cuagbcl bitn}cjn cfk SiR&
Ifn id {an uirrgmln rbnfc}gir zan}n {an cmitn {a}nn
an{n}ijnfni~r fn{zi}`r bcf mn ~rnk gr kndgfnk an}n& Zagln
{an tnagbln oitnr if {an }ick, {an zgkn} c}nc gr bitn}nk
iflw zg{a ^O[R& [an on{}i xifnr c}n bitn}nk
ckkg{gifcllw zg{a ZgOCQ, zagln ai{rui{r actn clri ZgDg&
Kgddn}nf{ cbbnrr fn{zi}`r ocw mn }cf`nk mw {an iun}c{i}
!gd {anw c}n izfnk mw rgfjln ifn' i} mw {an oimgln ~rn}, di}
jgtnf rn}tgbnr& Cr {an ~rn} gf {an tnagbln cuu}icbanr {an
bg{w, mnrgknr ^O[R, ZgOCQ !GNNN 15=&34n' mnbionr
ctcglcmln, ri tn}{gbcl acfkitn} mn{znnf ^O[R cfk
ZgOCQ bcf ibb~}& Tn}{gbcl acfkitn} coifj {anrn
kgddn}nf{ fn{zi}`r bcf {c`n ulcbn zanf SiR gr uii} di} {anb~}}nf{ zg}nlnrr cbbnrr fn{zi}`, i} k~n {i rn}tgbn
ocfcjnonf{ ng{an} mw {an fn{zi}` u}itgkn} i} mw {an ~rn}&
Di} {an u~}uirn id cfclwrgr id goucb{ id tn}{gbcl acfkitn}r
mn{znnf ^O[R cfk ZgOCQ di} tgkni {}cddgb, zn ~rn {an
dillizgfj {a}nn r{}ncogfj tgkni {nbafilijgnr8 AK[T
!Agja Kndgfg{gif [T', OUNJ/; cfk A&=43& Ncba id {anrn
cuulgbc{gifr }ns~g}nr kgddn}nf{ mcfkzgk{a& Ncba zg}nlnrr
{nbafilijw acr c lgog{ if {an ocqgo~o r~uui}{nk ~rn}
tnlibg{w& Clri, ~rn} oimglg{w gfdl~nfbnr {an mnactgi} id {an
zg}nlnrr cbbnrr fn{zi}` cfk {an tgkni r{}nco {}cfrog{{nk
itn} r~ba fn{zi}`&
[an cgo id {agr zi}` gr {i gftnr{gjc{n {an }ncrifr di}
mnactgi}r lg`n uii} tn}{gbcl acfkitn} lc{nfbw, cfk {i
gou}itn {an tn}{gbcl acfkitn}r gf {an bcrn id r{}ncogfj
tgkni {}cddgb, cfk anfbn {i }nk~bn {an lc{nfbw, {i }nk~bn {an
f~omn} id tn}{gbcl acfkitn}r cfk {a}i~jau~{ jcu mn{znnf
^O[R cfk ZgOCQ fn{zi}`r&
Tn}{gbcl acfkitn} u}ibnrr bcf mn kgtgknk gf {a}nn
uacrnr8 acfkitn} knbgrgif, }ckgi lgf` {}cfrdn} cfk bacffnl
crrgjfonf{& Acfkitn} knbgrgif knclr zg{a {an rnlnb{gif id
{an {c}jn{ uigf{ id c{{cbaonf{ cfk {an {gon id {an acfkitn}&
]ckgi lgf` {}cfrdn} gr {an u}ibnrr id kntnliugfj lgf`r {i {an
fnz uigf{ id c{{cbaonf{& Bacffnl crrgjfonf{ uacrn
c}}cfjnr {an cllibc{gif id bacffnl }nri~}bnr& Mnbc~rn GNNN
15=&=3 r{cfkc}k r~uui}{r {zi {wunr id tn}{gbcl acfkitn}r,
acfkitn}r gfg{gc{nk mw {an fn{zi}` cfk acfkitn}r gfg{gc{nk
mw oimgln {n}ogfclr, ntnf{r }nlc{nk {i acfkitn}r bcf mni}gjgfc{nk c{ {an OCB !Onkg~o Cbbnrr Bif{}il' i} OGAD
!Onkgc Gfknunfknf{ Acfkitn} D~fb{gif' lcwn} libc{nk gf
{an fikn i} c{ {an uigf{ id c{{cbaonf{ {i {an fn{zi}`&
Dgj~}nr 2 cfk ; }nu}nrnf{ c tn}{gbcl acfkitn} u}ibnrr
mn{znnf ^O[R cfk ZgOCQ fn{zi}`r& Zanf oimgln
fikn !OF' nf{n}r {an ZgOCQ bnll d}io ^O[R lgf` gr
kn{nb{nk ~uif }nbnu{gif id KLYOCU onrrcjn d}io MR&
OCB lcwn} goulnonf{ rwfba}ifgxc{gif onrrcjnr
KLYOCU cfk KBK onrrcjnr di} kizflgf`
rwfba}ifgxc{gif cfk ^LYOCU cfk ^BK onrrcjnr di}
~ulgf` rwfba}ifgxc{gif& Cd{n} {an rwfba}ifgxc{gif gf Dgj~}n
2 gfg{gcl }cfjgfj cfk }njgr{}c{gif ibb~}r gf {an lcwn} =
tn}{gbcl acfkitn} u}ibnrr&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 1>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 101/223
g
Dgj~}n 28 L
Lcwn} 2 t
& Zanf c lc
}nc{nk mw {a
{ac{ OGA {}g
grbitn} {an
}nulgnr {i {an
{an FK !Fng
}nbngtnr {an
c fnz ckk}nr
gf{n}dcbn, mn
ctcglcmln di}
acfkitn} u}i
Dgj~}n ; 8 Lcw
ZgOCQ&
Tn}{gbcl
~cf{g{c{gtnlw
ncr~}gfj {
cqgo~o ac
rnrrgif ocgf
cwn} = tn}{gbcl ac
Z}{gbcl acfkit
n} = biffnb{g
OCB cfk rn
jn}r c ]R !
GU u}ndgq id {
]R onrrcjn
jami} Kgrbi
C !]i~{n} C
r cfk }nkg}nb
c~rn {an Zg
cuulgbc{gif
nrr gr biouln
n} 2 tn}{gbcl a
cfkitn} u}i
oncr~}nk ~f
n f~omn}
kitn} knlcwr,
{cgfnk itn}
fkitn} u}ibnrr m
gOCQ&} u}ibnrr gr
gif gr nr{cmlgr
f{ {i {an OGA
i~{n} Rilgbg{
an fnz lgf`&
cbbi}kgfj {a
tn}w' oik~l
tn}{grnonf{'
{r {an dliz i
gOCQ gf{n}d
{}cddgb& Zg{a
{nk&
fkitn} u}ibnrr
nrr bcf mn
kn} tc}gi~r ~
d acfkitn}r
cfk {an itn}
c runbgdgb
{znnf ^O[R cf
nrb}gmnk gf Dg
ank, c Lgf`
oik~ln P4_&
c{gif' onrrc
[an cbbnrr }
}~lnr kndgfn
& Zanf {an
onrrcjn, g{ m
f {i {an Zg
bn gr bifrg
{agr {an tn
mn{znnf ^O[
s~clg{c{gtnlw
rcjn rbnfc}gi
, {an oncf
cll {a}i~jau~{
oimglg{w uc{
k
j~}n
U gr
d{n}
n {i
~{n}
k mw
OF
~glkr
CQ
n}nk
{gbcl
cfk
cfk
r mw
cfk
id c
{n}f&
D
}n
m
a{g
f
gf
bi
id
]
k
o
o
ct
k
{n
cf
tg
di
f
i
cr
~{
[
nf
gf
aZ
di
d~
bi
u}
P3_
P=_
P2_
P;_
P>_
P4_
P:_
ns~nf{ tn}{gb
ri~}bnr& Ri,
fndgbgcl di}
fkitn} gr bin, c acfkitn
nknk& [agr `g
Acfkitn} l
g{gc{gif id
ouln{gif& Ac
{an TAK
k~b{gif id {
lcw/rnfrg{gtn
ncr~}nk zg{a
imgln {n}ogfcl
cglcmln cbbnr
rg}cmln&
Gf {agr ucun
afgs~n mcrn
clwrgr if tn}{
kni r{}ncor
b~r if tn}{gb
{zi}`r& [an
n}anck cfk {g
znll cr clli
glgxc{gif mw m
gr cuu}icba
{n}gfj c xifn
di}oc{gif cm
fkitn}, rocllgOCQ fn{zi
} {an oimgln
}{an} cfclwrg
fk~b{nk {i n
iuirnk {nbafg
[an GNNN15=&
A& M}nfk{,Zglnw, Znr{ R
R& A~rrcgf,Grr~nr gf ;J
D}cfbn =554& 2JUU [R =2Rn}tgbnr cfNtil~{gif8 C2JUU [nbafgb
G&D& C`wglkgxocfcjnonf{GNNN Zg}nlnuu&34‒=1&
@& [cfg~bag,C& K~{{c, K&gfknunfknf{GNNN Bioo~
R&H& Wii, K&Onbacfgro di
l acfkitn}r
nb}ncrgfj {an
mn{{n} nddgbg
frgkn}nk ~ff} mcb` {i {an
k id acfkit
{nfbw gr {an
{an tn}{gbcl
fkitn} lc{nfb
!tn}{gbcl a
n acfkitn} l
o~l{gonkgc
{an kc{c }c{
r if {an fn{
fn{zi}` zg{
TG& B
}, zn u}nrnf
k if {an G
gbcl acfkitn}
gf an{n}ijnf
l acfkitn}r
~rn} xifgf
on bifr~on
gfj {an OGG
clcfbgfj lick
biffnb{r ~rn
j~gknk mw {a
i~{ {c}jn{ x
n} {an {a}i~j}`r di} kgddn}
rn}r zg{a tgk
r, tclgkc{gif
cl~c{n cfk b
s~nr&
]NDN
=3 R{cfkc}k, a{{u
izc}kr ;J [nb~rrnq, Nfjlcfk,
& Acogk cfk FAn{n}ijnfni~r
&;5= !=55:' 2Rwr{nor Cr
}bag{nb{~}n Nfaccl Runbgdgbc{gif
, H& Qgn, R&gf fnq{/jnfn}c{gr Bioo~fgbc{g
W& Iamc, T& Dchc`n}, O& Wchfg
acfkitn}8 dnc{~fgbc{gifr Ocjcxg
Bwuan}, cfk F} Rncolnrr Acf
cf bc~rn zc
f~omn} id a
gnfbw id {a
nbnrrc}w zani}gjgfcl uigf{
}r rai~lk mn
{gon k~}c{g
acfkitn} u
w gr }nlc{nk {
cfkitn} knb
c{nfbw gr tn
rnrrgifr& [a
n {ac{ gr {}c
i}`& Tn}{gbcl
a agjan} {a}i~
FBL^RGIF
{nk c ~rn} x
NN15=&=3 u
r kifn zg{a kg
ni~r zg}nlnrr
mn{znnf ^O
{nbafgs~n
zagln un}di
R rn}tn} {i i
r itn} {an ct
}r {i c u}nrn
n OGGR rn}tn
ifnr& Clri
au~{ jcu mn{f{ tnlibg{gnr
ni r{}ncor& C
cfk rgo~l
fdg}o {an un
NFBNR
8))zzz&gnnn15=&
afilijgnr8 Rn}tg=551&
& @ac{{c`, “OimFn{zi}`r‟, Gf
UU [nbafgbclnb{r0 2JUU Rfbnonf{r di} F=2&;5= t 3&3&5, =
Oiacf{w, “C rif cll/GU/mcrnkfr Ocjcxgfn,
}ki, R& Kcr, O&, K& Dcoilc}g, “
}nr, cuulgbcmglg{fn, Til&;:, Fi&3,
& Jilogn, “U}nkitn}r gf An{n}ij
{cjn id fn{z
cfkitn}r gr t
}nri~}bnr&
f, cd{n} c raid c{{cbaonf
gfgogxnk&
f mn{znnf
}ibnrr cfk
{an bioulnq
grgif' u}ib
w goui}{cf{
{a}i~jau~{
frog{{nk {i
acfkitn} {i
jau~{ gr ~r~
ifgfj acfki
}i{ibil cfk
gddn}nf{ }ncl {g
rbnfc}gi, z
R cfk ZgO
cgor {i }nk
}ogfj acfkit
u{gogxn fn{z
glcmln fn{zi}
{ fn{zi}` ~
zagba u}itg
gf {an Tn}{g
nnf ^O[Rn{{n} gr {an S
r c d~{~}n zi
c{gifr zgll
di}ocfbn id
}j)=3
gbnr zg{a Gfg{gc{
glg{w bacllnfjnrn}Rnfrn ‗54 , F
unbgdgbc{gif J}wr{no C}bag{nbif/2JUU Cbbnr5:&
~}tnw id oimgzg}nlnrr rwr{nil&33, Fi&;, =
[c~gl, W&/A& BaGNNN 15=&=38 o, cfk }nclgxc{g=557, uu&33=‒3
gb{gtn Lgf` [}gnfni~r Acfkitn
}`
}w
C
i}{{ gr
{an
g{r
g{w
rr&
di}
gr
{an
cf
llw
tn}
cf
on
g{a
Q
bn
n},
}`
`r&
if
nr
bcl
fkiR
}`,
mn
{an
gtn,
cfkgbn,
i~u{~}nrnr,
glg{wr‟,5;,
fj,kgcf‟,
=5 &
jn}}r‟,
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 14
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 102/223
Zglnw Zg}nlnrr Bioo~fgbc{gifr cfk Oimgln Biou~{gfj, Til& 7,Fi&>, Ocw =557&
P1_ Zg`gunkgc&bio0Jiijln&bio&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 1:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 103/223
¥
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :27;7)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :27;7
ROR Lnfj{a Nqucfrgif cfk Rnb~}g{w Cuu}icba
cf C Oimgln Kntgbn
Knnuc` R& OcfjlcfgLnb{~}n} gf J&T&Cbac}wc Nfjj&
Billnjn
Cmr{}cb{‛ Ntn} rgfbn {ang} gftnf{gif, oimgln uaifnr actn
}ntil~{gifgxnk {an }nj~lc} bioo~fgbc{gif on{aikr& [anw‗tn
ra}~f` {an zi}lk cfk actn m}i~ja{ cll id ~r blirn}&
Nqbacfjgfj c {nq{nk biftn}rc{gif mn{znnf c [q cfk c ]q tgc
oimgln uaifn {~}fnk i~{ {i mn c tn}w r~bbnrrd~l rn}tgbn&
R~ba c bioo~fgbc{gif zcr {n}onk cr Rai}{ Onrrcjn
Rn}tgbn, biooiflw cmm}ntgc{nk cfk `fizf cr ROR& [an
dlgurgkn {i {an ROR gr {an lgog{c{gif {i {an ocqgo~o f~omn}id bac}cb{n}r, g&n&, 345& Ntn}w 343
r{bac}cb{n} acuunfr {i mn c
fnz ROR& [agr gfb}ncrnr bir{ cfk bioulnqg{w& An}n, gf {agr
ucun}, zn‗tn u}iuirnk zcwr {i biou}nrr cfk nfb}wu{ {an
ROR bioo~fgbc{gif& Zn mnlgntn {agr ailkr r~mr{cf{gcl
bif{nf{ gf m}gfjgfj cmi~{ c fnz ribgcl goucb{ {i {an
kntnliuonf{ id lc}jn} bif{nf{ gf ROR onrrcjgfj&
@nwzi}kr/ [q ‒ [}cfrog{{n}, ]q ‒ ]nbngtn}, ROR ‒ Rai}{
Onrrcjn Rn}tgbn, JRO / Jlimcl Rwr{no di} Oimgln bioo~fgbc{gifr, [KOC ‒ [gon Kgtgrgif O~l{guln Cbbnrr,JU]R ‒ Jnfn}cl Ucb`n{ ]ckgi Rwr{no, BKOC ‒ Bikn Kgtgrgif
O~l{guln Cbbnrr, KNR ‒ Kc{c Nfb}wu{gif R{cfkc}k, GKNC /
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Kc{c Nfb}wu{gif Clji}g{ao, CNR ‒ Cktcfbnk Nfb}wu{gif R{cfkc}k&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Gf Oimgln Uaifn Bioo~fgbc{gif, ROR gr {an
{}nonfki~r rn}tgbn, zg{a 35 mgllgif onrrcjnr rnf{ c}i~fk
{an zi}lk kcglw& ROR oc`nr g{ uirrgmln {i rnfk cfk
}nbngtn rai}{ {nq{ onrrcjnr {i cfk d}io oimgln uaifnr&
ROR mnbcon c uiu~lc} bioo~fgbc{gif {iilr mw
gfkgtgk~clr cfk m~rgfnrr& ROR c}n ~rnk gf kcw/{i/kcw
cuulgbc{gifr lg`n mcf`gfj, oimgln ucwonf{, }nbac}jn cfk
oimgln bioon}bn, n/{gb`n{, oifnw {}cfrdn}, n{b& P3_ Gf
371>, D}gnkanlo Agllnm}cfk id Miff, Jn}ocfw cfk c
kixnf i{an}r ack mnnf lcwgfj i~{ {an ulcfr {i r{cfkc}kgxnc {nbafilijw {ac{ zi~lk clliz bnlluaifnr {i {}cfrog{ cfk
kgrulcw {nq{ onrrcjnr& Mnbc~rn id {gja{ mcfkzgk{a
bifr{}cgf{r id {an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r c{ {an {gon, ncba
onrrcjn zi~lk actn {i mn cr rai}{ cr uirrgmln& P=_
[an ocqgo~o f~omn} id bac}cb{n}r di} c rgfjln
fi}ocl ROR gr iflw 345 bac}cb{n}r& [an ROR rnb~}g{w gr
clri tn}w b}~bgcl {i u}i{nb{ {an rnfrg{gtn gfdi}oc{gif&
Uniuln rion{gonr nqbacfjn bifdgknf{gcl gfdi}oc{gif r~ba
cr ucrrzi}kr i} rnfrg{gtn kc{c& ROR {nbafilijw r~ddn}r
d}io }gr`r r~ba cr rnb~}g{w t~lfn}cmglg{gnr cfk
~fc~{ai}gxnk cbbnrr& P2_
B~}}nf{ r{cfkc}k ROR {nbafilijw gr fif/rnb~}n& G{ bcf
mn gf{n}bnu{nk clifj {an {}cfrogrrgif uc{a c{ o~l{guln
libc{gifr !cjj}njc{i}r, bc}}gn}r, gfd}cr{}~b{~}n u}itgkn}r,
i} {izn} iun}c{i}r' nrunbgcllw zanf ~rgfj Gf{n}fn{ {i
r~mog{ wi~} onrrcjnr&
I~} cuu}icba {i {agr u}imlno gf {agr ucun} gr {i
u}iuirn c on{aik {ac{ bcf mn ~rnk {i biou}nrr cfk {i
nfb}wu{ ROR onrrcjnr {ac{ c}n cmi~{ {i mn rnf{& Gf i~}
cuu}icba, {an uawrgbcl ~fkn}lwgfj JRO c}bag{nb{~}n
}nocgfr ~fbacfjnk&
[agr ucun} gr r{}~b{~}nk cr dillizr8 Rnb{gif GG
agjalgja{r JRO Rwr{no C}bag{nb{~}n& Rnb{gif GGG u}itgknr
ROR R{}~b{~}n& Rnb{gif GT nqulcgfr biou}nrrgif
{nbafgs~n gf ROR cfk Rnb{gif T raizr c on{aik rnb~}n
{an ROR& Bifbl~rgif gr u}nrnf{nk gf Rnb{gif TG&
GG& JRO RWR[NO C]BAG[NB[^]N
Gf JRO rwr{no, {an oimgln acfkrn{ gr bcllnk OimglnR{c{gif !OR'& C bnll gr di}onk mw {an bitn}cjn c}nc id c
Mcrn [}cfrbngtn} R{c{gif !M[R' zagba rn}tnr {an OR gf
g{r bitn}cjn c}nc& Rntn}cl M[R {ijn{an} c}n bif{}illnk mw
ifn Mcrn R{c{gif Bif{}illn} !MRB'& [an M[R cfk MRB
{ijn{an} di}o Mcrn R{c{gif R~mrwr{no !MRR'& [an
biomgfnk {}cddgb id {an oimgln r{c{gifr gf {ang} }nrunb{gtn
bnllr gr }i~{nk {a}i~ja c rzg{ba bcllnk Oimgln Rzg{bagfj
Bnf{n} !ORB'& Biffnb{gif i}gjgfc{gfj i} {n}ogfc{gfj
d}io nq{n}fcl {nlnuaifn !UR[F' c}n acfklnk mw c
knkgbc{nk jc{nzcw Jc{nzcw Oimgln Rzg{bagfj Bnf{n}
!JORB'& [an c}bag{nb{~}n id c JRO rwr{no gr raizf gf
dgj~}n 3&
Gf ckkg{gif {i {an cmitn nf{g{gnr rntn}cl kc{cmcrnr c}n~rnk di} {an u~}uirn id bcll bif{}il cfk fn{zi}`
ocfcjnonf{& [anrn kc{cmcrnr c}n Aion Libc{gif
]njgr{n} !AL]', Tgrg{i} Libc{gif ]njgr{n} !TL]', {an
C~{anf{gbc{gif Bnf{n} !C^B', cfk Ns~guonf{ Gknf{g{w
]njgr{n} !NG]'&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 11
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 104/223
Aion Li
!r~ba cr ~rn
~}}nf{ libc{g
zg{a {an fn{z
zai c}n mng
r{i}nk gf AL
c{c lg`n lib
c~{anf{gbc{gif
fb}wu{gif&
s~guonf{r c
s~guonf{r&Cll {an
crrgjfnk ~fg
s~guonf{ G
cf~dcb{~}n}
~omn} gr r{i
{an GORG !G
zagba gr r{i}
d {an ~rn}&
RGO gr gfrn}{
ee}ncl** {nlnua
cfk gr r{i}nk g
ROR gr c
imgln bio
}nbngtnk rgo
ROR nqgr{r
r~ba cr JRO,
[an ROR
Dgj~}n
c{gif ]njgr{
} u}idgln' cr
f' gfdi}oc{gi
i}`& C TL]
j rn}tgbnk b
di} dcr{n} c
c{gif id {an
gfdi}oc{gif
an NG] r{
k bcf mn ~rn
imgln ns~gu
~n gk bcllnk
knf{g{w' cfk
cfk }njgr{n}n
}nk gf {an NG
f{n}fc{gifcl
k gf {an R~m
oimgln r{c{g
k gf{i cf ns
fn f~omn} g
f RGO& P;_&
GGG& R
bioo~fgbc{g
~fgbc{gif r
l{cfni~rlw z
r c r~mrn{ i
[KOC, JU
Ucb`n{r gf kn
3&
} !AL]' r{i}
znll cr {n
f cmi~{ cll {a
r{i}nr {an kc{
~}}nf{lw& G{ g
bnrr cr znll
~rn}& [an
d {an ~rn} r~
}nr r{i}nr
{i u}ntnf{ b
onf{r gf J
GORG !Gf{n
gr cllibc{n
mw {an rn}tg
]& [an ~rn}r
Oik~ln R~m
rb}gmn} Gknf{g
f bcf mn ~r
~guonf{ zg{a
r kgddn}nf{ d}
R R[]^B[^]
if rn}tgbn r{
r{nor0 g{ b
g{a tigbn, kc
d {an lc}jn}
R cfk BKO
gjf c}n raiz
nr {an un}oc
ui}c}w !r~ba
n ~rn}r }njgr{
c cmi~{ {an ~
fbl~knr {an
cr {an {noui
C^B r{i}nr
a cr {an `nwr
kc{c cmi~{
cllr d}io c r{
RO rwr{no
}fc{gifcl Oi
mw ns~gu
bn u}itgkn}&
c}n gknf{gdgnk
rb}gmn} Gknf{
{w Oik~ln !R
k iflw gd c t
tclgk GORG&
o {an cmitn
N
fkc}kgxnk gf
f mn rnf{
{c cfk dcq b
g}nlnrr kio
& P>_&
gf {an Dgj~}
nf{
cr
}nk
rn}r
c{c
c}w
{an
di}
{an
lnf
c}n
mgln
nf{
agr
mw
g{w'
GO'
clgk
[an
gkr
{an
cfk
llr&
gfr
3&
{
b
b
k
g
c
{
k
}
t
!
~
b
}
b
R
R
c
d
ROR cuulg
}cfrui}{ {an
c{nzcw {ac{ b
nf{}n& G{ u}itg
nbacfgro di
ac}cb{n}r d}i
[an ROR g
g}nb{lw m~{ kn
r c fn{zi}` nl
agba ROR gr
tcglcmln& RO
an fn{zi}`&
nr{gfc{gif bnl
nbngtn i} {}cf
igbn bcll gr gf
BU)GU fn{zi
JORB'& P4_
Gf {agr rnb
rnk {i bi
iou}nrrgif n
5 un}bnf{& [
c{gi id {i{cl b
ac}cb{n}r id {
Biou}n
OR
Nddgbgn
OR
I~} cuu}i
uulgbc{gif di
cf~dcb{~}n}r
i} oimgln cu
Dgj~}n =
c{gifr c}n if
& Cf ROR r
iffnb{r {i c
gknr c uigf{/{
{}cfrog{{gfj
oimgln acf
r r{i}n cfk di
lgtn}nk tgc cf
lnonf{ gf {an
r{i}nk ~f{gl {
B j~c}cf{nn
nrrcjnr c}n
l uaifn mnb
rog{ cf ROR
u}ij}nrr i} f
`r tgc c Jc{n
GT& B
{gif, zn knr
u}nrr {an
ddgbgnfbw id {
n nddgbgnfbw
ac}cb{n}r gf
n i}gjgfcl R
rgif ? [
bw
cba {i {agr
ROR Biou
actn ckiu{nk
lgbc{gif knt
&
lw cr jiik cr
n}tgbn gr air
imgln rn}tgb
/uigf{ cfk m
rai}{ onrrcj
rn{r&
}zc}k rn}tgb
ROR Bnf{n}
oimgln {nlnu
n knr{gfc{gif
knlgtn}w id
{i}nk gf {an
onr ctcglcml
onrrcjn c{ c
i{& RORBr bi
zcw Oimgln R
IOU]NRRGIF
b}gmn {an u}i
ROR lnfj{a
n onrrcjn o
gr im{cgfnk m
biou}nrrnk
R&
i{cl bac}cb{n
[i{cl bac}
u}imlno gr
nrrgif& Rntn}
Hctc cr {ang}
liun}r& [i bn
{an fn{zi}`r
{nk if cf R
u}itgkn}r R
ickbcr{/{i/ui
r ~u {i 345 {
, cfk gr fi{ r
!RORB'& RO
ifn fn{zi}`,
kntgbn mnbi
{nq{ onrrcjn
n{zi}` ~f{gl
n, ri ~rn}r
w {gon, zan{
oo~fgbc{n z
zg{bagfj Bnf
uirnk {nbafg
& [an ctn}
~r{ mn oi}n {
w bclb~lc{gfj
ROR {i {an {
r gf Biou}nr
b{n}r gf I}gj
{i kntnliu
cl oimgln kn
ulc{di}o idd
}{cgf nq{nf{ H
¥
{an
R
R
gf{
nq{
nf{
RB
gf
nr
mw
{an
cf
an}
g{a
{n}
s~n
cjn
acf
{an
i{cl
rnk
gfcl
cf
gbn
}nk
ctc
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 17
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 105/223
g
cuulgbc{gifr
tnfki}r& Zg{
rgjfgdgbcf{lw
rnfkgfj c linrrcjn {i r
g{ cfk mw rnfk
}gjgfcl, g{ zgl
Ocfw RO
{i riltn {an
[anrn on{aik
ri/bcllnk “z
iou}nrrnk
rnfkn}r& Gf i}
{i {wun cr o~
345 bac}cb{n
[an cmm}ntgc
~rnk cfk gf{n
Zagln R
ioo~fgbc{g
~rgfj {an
ifdgknf{gclg{
Oimgln
cfk {agr on
knrgjfnk cu
rntn}cl rnb
gf{nj}g{w cfk
`nw crrn{r {a[agr rnb
di}ocl knrb
runbgdgbc{gif
cfk knb}wu{
r{c{gif gr {
c{{cb`n} bi~
{an oimgln r
Anfbn i~} c
onrrcjnr ~
}nckcmln& [
ulcgf{nq{ {i
cfk kgdd~rgi
KNR clnfb}wu{gif
cfk dgfcfbgc
rocll mw b~}
bcf mn rnc}
mlib` bguan
Ocrrnw gf
bguan}, UNR
i}gjgfcllw
kntnliunk {
ulcgf{nq{ cf
3=1/mg{ `nw&
c}n ui}{cmln
a {agr cuulg
{an f~omn} i
fj onrrcjn&fk, {an cuulg
gfj {an biou
l }nk~bn {an b
R biou}nrrgi
lgog{c{gif id
r gfbl~kn a~
}k i} ua}cr
onrrcjnr c}
kn} {i rctn {a
a gfdi}oc{gi
r un} ROR m
{gifr ~{glgxnk
u}n{nk mw {an
R gr ifn id
f, m~rgfnrrnr
ROR bacffnl
grr~nr&
G& NFB]WU
ntgbnr actn
cfr {ac{ {an
}iu}gc{nlw& D
}g{w rn}tgbnr
ctcglcmglg{w c
c{ c}n u}i{nb{{gif agjalgja
}gu{gif id c
di} g{r onrrc
gif d~fb{gifr
nd{ i} ogrul
lk jcgf cbbnr
{c{gif& [agr {
uu}icba {i {a
rgfj GKNC c
an clji}g{ao
4;/mg{ mlib`
&
i}g{ao acrlji}g{ao cfk
l cuulgbc{gifr
}nf{ r{cfkc}kr
ank gf cuu}i
} knrgjfnk m
3773& G{ gr c
!U}iuirnk Nf
cllnk GUNR
}nulcbn KN
bguan} {nq{
[an clji}g{
mn{znnf knt
c{gif, {an
d rgfjln onrr
Zanf {anc{gif bcf mn
nrrnk onrrcj
ir{&
on{aikr ac
345 bac}cb{
cf gf{n}u}n{g
cmm}ntgc{gi
ocf~cllw
n bir{, ocfw
cr uirrgmln
w ~rgfj tc}g
gf {an onrr
rnfkn}r cfk }
{an oir{ u}
cfk mcf`r c
bifrgkn}gfj
GIF $ KNB]
lgog{nk biou
rnb~}g{w onb
i} c rnb~}n R
c}n fnnknk
}n {an `nw rn
k P:_&{r i~} }nrnc}
}wu{irwr{no
jn, `nw, bgua
& [an ocgf
cbnonf{ cfk
r {i {an kc{c
}nc{ cuulgnr {
gr u}imlno a
lji}g{ao {i
nfb}wu{r c
id bguan} {nq
mnnf c uigr ~rnk gf
& Aizntn}, g
cfk g{r nf{g}
qgoc{nlw ==
w Q~nhgc L
ogfi} }ntgr
b}wu{gif R{c
!Gou}itnk
R& GKNC iu
mlib`r cfk g
o r{}~b{~}n
gbnr id kgdd
rn}r bcf }n
cjnr }ns~g}nk
~rn} acr c~rnk {i bio
n, rai}{n} {ac
n mnnf kntnl
n}r un} onrr
n biou}nrrgi
,‟ gf zagba
`nwnk/gf mw
ROR rnfkn}r
zg{agf {an lgo
~r cmm}ntgc{g
jn c}n uiu~l
bngtn}r&
dn}}nk oikn
}n bifrn}tc{gt
{an rnb~}g{w
U[GIF
~{gfj bcucmgl
acfgror o~r
OR nftg}if
& Bifdgknf{g
tgbnr cfk clr
ba zi}` jgt
{ac{ gfbl~knr
} {nq{, nfb}w
}gr` {i c o
cr c }nr~l{,
bif{nf{ r{i}n
i ROR onrr
}n gr mw nfbi
oc`n {ano
4;/mg{ mlib
{ ~rgfj bifd~
~lc} rnb}n{cfw bioon
{r `nw rgxn gr
>4 mg{ `nw r
ai~}r& GKNC
g cfk Hcon
gif id cf nc
kc}k'& GKNC
UNR' cfk
}c{nr zg{a 4
r bif{}illnk
acr mnnf ba
}nf{
~bn
di}
lifj}nrr
{an
unk
cjn&
f i}
{an
{an
{nfk
g{ id
ifr&
c}lw
r id
n gf
cfk
g{gnr
{ mn
nf{,
lg{w,
{an
r c
{an
{gif
mgln
{an
if
jnr&
kgfj
if/
id
rgif
`nw}bgcl
{ii
cbn
gr c
L&
}lgn}
zcr
zcr
/mg{
w c
rnf
n
u
m
`
u
{
r
k
`
r
~
b
n
m
`
r
k
r~ba {ac{ za
nfb}wu{gif u}
[an 4;/mg
mg{ r~m/mlib` mg{ `nw& Rgfb
}ns~g}nk di} {
id >= !? 1 q
jnfn}c{nk d}
uc}{g{gifnk gf
kg}nb{lw ~rnk
mg{ `nw gr {
uirg{gifr, cd{
uc}{g{gifnk gf
cr {an fnq{
u}ibnk~}n gr
`nw r~m/mlib
[an u}gt
r{cmlgragfj {a
c{a, rgfbn on
n knb}wu{nk
nw bcf mn
~mlgb)u}gtc{n
acf CNR rgf
~ddgbgnf{ u}ib
ntgbnr cfk R
nw zi~lk act
n}tn} cuulgb
fcbbnu{cmln t
[an biou
guan}nk {nq{
fb}wu{gif& [a
g{ `nw r~m/ml
nw r~m/mlib`
~m/mlib`r o
nb}wu{gif gf
nf kgddn}nf{
ibnrr gr gknf{g
{ ulcgf{nq{ ml
r rgq 34/mg{ ` n c d~}{an} d
an r~mrns~nf
+ ;' kgddn}n
o {an 3=1/
{i ngja{ 34/
cr {an dg}r{ n
anf bwblgbcll
} zagba {an }
{i ngja{ 34/mg
ngja{ `nw
}nunc{nk ~f{gl
r actn mnnf
Dgj~}n
{n)u~mlgb `
n di~fkc{gif
rrcjnr nfb}wu
zg{ai~{ {an u
kgr{}gm~{nk
`nw nqbacfj
n {an onrrc
nrrgfj uizn}
OR gf jnfn}
n {i mn u}ij}
c{gif& [agr
~lfn}cmglg{w {
{c{gifcl u}ib
gr nrrnf{gcll
n iflw kgddn}
b`r ~rnk di}
~rnk k~}gfj
~r{ mn ~rnk
}kn} {i }ntn}r
`nw r~m/mlib
bcl {i {an knb
b` gr uc}{g{gi
w c}n jnfn}c{i~} 34/mg{ `n
{ i~{u~{ {}cfr
{ 34/mg{ r~m/
g{ `nw& [an
g{ r~m/mlib`r
gja{ `nw r~m/
w ragd{nk {i
nr~l{gfj 3=1/
{ r~m/mlib`r {
~m/mlib`r&
cll id {an }n
nfn}c{nk&
2&
w {nbafgs~n
di} c rnb~}n
{nk zg{a {an
}gtc{n `nw& A
zg{ai~{ }gr
n bcf mn rgj
jn rgxn gr lc
, zagba gr fi{
l& [agr oncf
oonk gf{i m
rbnfc}gi zi
}ntn}rn nfjg
nrr ~rnk di}
{an rcon
fbn gr {ac{ n
nb}wu{gif gr
fb}wu{gif& Gf
gf {an }ntn
n {an nfb}wu{g
`r c}n ~rnk,
}wu{gif u}ibn
nk gf{i di~}
nk d}io {an 3w/r~m/mlib`r
i}oc{gif, c {
lib`r actn {
3=1/mg{ `nw
zagba c}n {
lib`r& [an 3
{an lnd{ mw
g{ mlib` gr c
mn kg}nb{lw ~
agr bwblgb r
s~g}nk >=, 34
gr gkncl
bioo~fgbc{g
~mlgb `nw bc
nfbn, {an u~
& Aizntn},
gdgbcf{lw rli
}jn cfk }ns~
gkncl di} oi
r {an gfg{gcl
{a {an blgnf{
~lk u}nrnf{
nn}gfj&
nb}wu{gif id
r {ac{ ~rnk
ba id {an >=
{an gftn}rn id
ckkg{gif, {an
rn i}kn} k~
if u}ibnrr& P
¥
{an
r&
34/
=1/c}n
i{cl
mn
gr
anf
=1/
=>
cgf
rnk
agd{
/mg{
di}
ifr
fi{
mlgb
c
zn}
g}nr
mgln
NR
cfk
cf
{an
di}
34/
{an
`nw
gfj
_
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 75
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 106/223
Gf {agr uc
ac}cb{n} lgog
ROR rn}tgbn,
anfionfc,
ROR R{}~b{~}
Knb}wu{gif {n
[an u}iu
rnb~}g{w gf Rd tgnz, {a
clifjzg{a rnb
Dgj~}n
T& un}, zn*tn {}g
{c{gif bifbnu
ntn} rgfbn g{
n r{~kgnk {a
n, ROR Ucb`
bafgs~nr zg{a
irnk on{aik
R bioo~fgbgr {nbafgs~n
~}g{w&
&
IFBL^RGIF
nk {i nlgogf
{ {ac{ acr mnn
gf{}ik~b{gif
n JRO Rwr{
{, Biou}nrrg
}njc}kr {i {a
clri u}itg
c{gif& D}io {nfr~}nr b
{n {an ocqg
r~}}i~fkgfj
& [i cbagntn
no C}bag{nb{
f, Nfb}wu{gi
ROR&
nr nfk {i
an nfk ~rn} ur{ nddnb{gtn
~o
{an
{agr
~}n,
$
nfk
gf{nrr
P3_ [c}n` O
Caonk O
Di} Rnb~}g
Cfk Rnb~}g
P=_ a{{u8)){nb`&giflw&a{ol P
d}nn cfk iuP2_ Hiaffw Lg/
Nfk/[i/ N Ri~{a Cd}g
P;_ a{{u8))zzzGfkgcf Gfr{g
P>_ F&H B}id{Uck [i RnBiou~{n} ^fgtn}rg{w
P4_ R~f“a{{u8))Knt
P:_ I{{i @il Nfacfbno
Bifdn}nfb
P1_ Gf{n}fc{gif
]NDN]
caoi~k, Mcajc
Ocadi~x, Awm}g
fj ROR, Gf{n}f
{w !GHBRR' =535&
f)zaw/ror/onrrRi~}bn8 “a{{u8)){n
nf ri~}bn rid{zcacfj Li, H~kgk U}i{ibil Di}
bc =551&&g{&gg{m&cb&gf)vrc{w{~{n id [nbafiliCfk O&R Ilgtgn~}n Rai}{ OnrrRnb~}g{w C}bag
Id U}n{i}gc, Ri~{
Kntnliun}nliun}&R~f&Bio)
g, [nno~un`` f{r U}ibnnkgfjrIf Rwr{no Rbgn
l Kc{c Nfb}wu{gi
FBNR
{ C& Cmknl/Lc{nd,
Biou}nrrgif
c{gifcl Hi~}fcl
cjnr/c}n/lgog{nk/{b`&gf‟ / [an {nba
n cr znll_{a Mgraiu, H&A&Rnb~}n ROR, ^
chg{)rnogfc})fiknw, Miomcw_, ^rgfj Cf Cujgfj Rn}tgbn !R{nb{~}nr !GBRC'a Cd}gbc =55>&
Fn{zi}` Oimglg{w)C}{gblnr
c Tg}{cfnf ,Id [an 2:{a
fbnr&
Clji}g{ao / C~{
Czfw C& Cao
fb}wu{gif [nbaf
d Biou~{n} Rbg
i/345/bac}cb{n}rilijw mlij u}i
Nlidd Rorrnb8gtn}rg{w Id U}n{
3;&a{ol PRi
}iqgoc{nk Ifn/R', Gfdi}oc{gif
]nrnc}ba J
ROR C}{ )Ror‟
GKU =&5 Rnb
Aczcgg Gf{n}fc{g
i}8 Aiz/Ranf B
¥
k $
gs~n
fbn
i{nr
Cfi}gc,
~}bn8
[gon Cfk i~u,
gbln,
}g{w
ifcl
cf&&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 73
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 107/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :27>4)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :27>4
Nddnb{ id {iuilijw if }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn gf uc}{gcllw oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r
Fgfj}gflc Oc}bacfj ,Fgmnkg{c Ragcl
Knuc}{onf{ id Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn cfk Nfjgfnn}gfj Fi}{a Ncr{n}f ]njgifcl Gfr{g{~{n
id Rbgnfbn cfk [nbafilijw Fg}h~lg, G{cfcjc} / :73357, C}~fcbacl U}cknra, GFKGC&
fgfj}gflcEwcaii&bi&gf, fgmnkg{c:14>Ejocgl&bio
C oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` !OCFN[' gr c fn{/ zi}` id oimgln
fiknr zagba bioo~fgbc{n zg{a ncba i{an} zg{ai~{ {an anlu
id cfw dgqnk gf/ d}cr{}~b{~}n& Lgf`r
mn{znnf fiknr c}n b}nc{nk cfk m}i`nf cr {an fiknr oitn
zg{agf {an fn{/ zi}`& [a~r oimglg{w
id {an fiknr cktn}rnlw cddnb{ }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn
uc}con{n}r r~ba cr {a}i~jau~{ cfk nfk/{i/nfk knlcw& G{ grknrg}/ cmln {i gou}itn {an un}di}ocfbn cfk tc}gi~r cu/
u}icbanr u}iuirnk {izc}k {agr jicl gfbl~kn oik/ gdwgfj {an
}i~{gfj u}i{ibil i} }ngfdi}bgfj {an fn{/ zi}` zg{a uizn}d~l
mcb`mifn fiknr& Zg{ai~{ }n/ lwgfj if r~ba nlcmi}c{n
cuu}icbanr, zagba c}n {gon/bifr~ogfj cfk bir{lw, g{ ocw mn
}ns~g}nk {i gou}itn }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn& [an bacllnfjn gr {i
gou}itn if }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn oc`gfj ~rn id iflw {an
nqgr{gfj dcbglg{gnr gf c OCFN[& Zn u}i/ uirn {ac{ ifn zcw id
cbagntgfj {agr jicl gr {iuil/ ijw knrgjf& Gf {agr ucun}, zn
gftnr{gjc{n {an nddnb{ id {iuilijw if }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn gf c
uc}{gcllw oimgln ck kaib fn{zi}`& Gf i{an} zi}kr, mw `nnu/ gfj
rion fiknr r{c{gifc}w gf rion dcragif, zn nq/ cogfn {an nddnb{ id
{an {iuilijw id {anrn fiknr if {an un}di}ocfbn& Zn actn
u}nrnf{nk i~} rgo~lc/ {gif }nr~l{r di} {an rcon&
@nwzi}kr8 Oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` !OCFN['0
[iuilijw0 ]i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn&
G GF[]IK^B[GIF
C oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` gr c fn{zi}` id zg}n/ lnrr
oimgln kntgbnr, zagba bcf mn rn{ ~u if {an dlw& [anfn{zi}` gr b}nc{nk, ocfcjnk cfk i}jc/ fgxnk u~}nlw mw {an
fiknr {anornltnr zg{ai~{ {an crrgr{cfbn id cfw bnf{}clgxnk
{ag}k uc}{w i} dgqnk gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& C fikn bcf mn c
lcu{iu, c UKC, c oimgln uaifn, i} cfw oimgln kntgbn
zg{a {an cmglg{w {i bioo~fgbc{n zg{a i{an} kntgbnr& Gf c
OCFN[, c fikn mnactnr cr c air{ cr znll cr c }i~{n}&
Rgfbn {an}n gr fi }ns~g}nonf{ id c dgqnk gfd}cr{}~b{~}n, c
OCFN[ bcf mn rn{ ~u c{ cfw ulcbn cfk c{ cfw {gon cr
fnnknk& Di} gfr{cfbn, OCFN[r bcf mn rn{ ~u gf
non}jnfbw rg{~c{gifr !n&j&, }nrb~n ogrrgif', c{ ulcbnr
zan}n zg}nk fn{/ zi}`r bcffi{ mn ~rnk !n&j&, i~{kii}
bifdn}nfbnr', i} c{ ulcbnr zan}n {an bir{ id rn{{gfj ~u zg}nk
fn{/ zi}`r gr u}iagmg{gtn !n&j&, c }noi{n agllw }nri}{'&C OCFN[ gr cf c{{}cb{gtn ril~{gif di} {an bio/
o~fgbc{gif fnnkr id c bioo~fg{w i} c}nc zan}n {an}n fi
dgqnk gfd}cr{}~b{~}nr& Cf nqcouln id r~ba c bioo~fg{w
zi~lk mn c }~}cl tgllcjn zg{ai~{ cfw oncfr id nlnb{}ifgb
bioo~fgbc{gif zg{agf {an tgllcjn& Aizntn}, di} c
OCFN[ {i r~uui}{ tigbn bioo~fgbc{gif, un}di}ocfbn
uc}con{n}r r~ba cr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 7=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 108/223
nfk/{i/nfk knlcw cfk hg{{n} rai~lk mn zg{agf cb/ bnu{cmln
lgog{r& G{ gr rnnf {ac{ knlcwr mnwifk cmi~{
=25 ogllgrnbifkr gf c tigbn bcll bc~rnr {an a~ocf nc} {i
kn{nb{ baiuugfnrr gf {an bcll&
G{ zi~lk mn gf{n}nr{gfj {i kn{n}ogfn zan{an} }i~{gfj
un}di}ocfbn bcf mn gou}itnk mw oc`gfj {an fn{zi}`
uc}{gcllw oimgln mw `nnugfj rion id {an fiknr r{c{gifc}w&
Gd g{ bi~lk mn kifn ri, zn actn di~fk c rgouln cfk bir{/nddnb{gtn ril~{gif& [an}ndi}n, ifn zi~lk fi{ fnnk {i }nlw
if i{an} nlcmi}c{n cuu}icbanr r~ba cr gftnr{gfj if oi}n
uizn}d~l fiknr cr mcb`mifn fiknr i} oikgdwgfj {an
}i~{gfj u}i{ibil& Zn r~jjnr{ {ac{ gf bn}{cgf rg{~c{gifr,
ifn ocw fi{ actn {an {gon fi} {an }n/ ri~}bn }ns~g}nk di}
r~ba nlcmi}c{n ril~{gifr& Di} gfr{cfbn, k~}gfj c }nrb~n
iun}c{gif di} zagba c OCFN[ gr rn{ ~u, gd g{ zn}n di~fk
{ac{ {an knlcw cfk hg{{n} id {an fn{zi}` c}n r~ba {ac{ fi
nddnb{gtn bioo~fgbc{gif zn}n uirrgmln, {an rgoulnr{ cfk
s~gb`nr{ ril~{gif zi~lk mn {i `nnu rion fiknr r{c{gifc}w
clmng{ gf rion c}}cfjnonf{& [agr ucun} u}nrnf{r {an
cfclw{gbcl }nr~l{r {ac{ zn}n c}}gtnk c{ cd{n} nq{nfrgtn
rgo~lc{gif d}io zagba zn bcf gf/ dn} cmi~{ {an dncrgmglg{w
id r~ba c ril~{gif&
[an dillizgfj c}n rion zi}` zagba c}n }nlc{nk gf rion
zcw {ac{ gr di~fk gf {an lg{n}c{~}n& [iuil/ ijw cfk oimglg{w
bifrgkn}c{gifr gf oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r c}n u}nrnf{nk gf
P3_& [an c~{ai}r r{~kgnk tc}gi~r bac}cb{n}gr{gbr bifbn}fgfj
{an lgf`r cfk }i~{nr {ac{ oc`n ~u c oimgln ck aib
fn{zi}`& Ifn goui}{cf{ dgfkgfj zcr {ac{ k~n {i }cugk }i~{/
gfj bacfjnr m}i~ja{ cmi~{ mw c agjalw kwfcogb {iuilijw,
ifn o~r{ rnlnb{ c }ncrifcmln oimglg{w rn{{gfj gf i}kn} {i
cbagntn rion }ncrifcmln lntnl id un}di}ocfbn& [an
goucb{ id {iuilijw gf }i/ m~r{ }i~{gfj if zg}nlnrr onra
fn{zi}`r gr gftnr/ {gjc{nk gf P=_& Gf {agr zi}`, {an c~{ai}rnquli}nk {an goucb{ id fikn kgr{}gm~{gif if }i~{gfj un}di}/
ocfbn gf c zg}nlnrr onra fn{zi}`& [anw di~fk {ac{
fn{zi}` un}di}ocfbn ~rgfj }im~r{ }i~{gfj bcf mn
gou}itnk mw ~rgfj c kgr{}gm~{gif zagba ulcbnr c j}nc{n}
knfrg{w id fiknr {izc}k {an i~{/ rgkn id c fn{zi}`& Gf P2_,
{an c~{ai}r r{~kgnk {an u}imlno id knrgjfgfj {an iu{gocl
{iuilijw
di} mcb`mifn/mcrnk awm}gk zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}`r&
[an u}imlno gr di}o~lc{nk cr c jnfn}clgxnk iu{gocl
jnion{}gb R{gnfn} fn{zi}` u}imlno zg{a ogfgo~o f~omn}
id R{ngfn} fiknr& [anw u}iuirnk c o~l{guln/r{nu ril~{gif
cuu}icba cfk biouc}nk rntn}cl an~}gr{gb clji}g{aor&
Cfi{an} zi}` gf zagba knrgjf bifrgkn}c{gifr di} c ruc}rn
fn{zi}` c}n kgrb~rrnk gr P;_& [an c~{ai}r clri kndgfnk c
on{}gb bcllnk }ncbacmglg{w {ac{ gr ~rnd~l gf ntcl~c{gfj
knrgjf {}ckn/iddr gf ruc}rn fn{zi}`r& Cll {an cmitn zi}`
c}n bifbn}fnk zg{a fn{zi}`r gf zagba ng{an} cll fiknr c}n
oimgln i} cll fiknr r{c{gifc}w& I~} u}iuirnk cuu}icba
knclr zg{a c fn{zi}` gf zagba rion fiknr c}n oimgln
zagln {an i{an}r c}n r{c{gifc}w&
[iuilijw bif{}il id ck aib fn{zi}`r !P>_/P3;_' gr
cfi{an} c}nc gf zagba {iuilijw id {an fn{zi}` gr
kn{n}ogfnk mw bif{}illgfj {an bioo~fgbc{gif }cfjn id {an
fiknr& Cl{ai~ja {iuilijw knrgjf gr clri kifn an}n, {an
ocgf cgo an}n gr {i }nk~bn {an itn}cll nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif
id {an fiknr zagln rc{grdwgfj rion bifr{}cgf{r r~ba cr
ocgf{cgfgfj biffnb{gtg{w& Mnrgknr, {iuilijw bif{}il gr
jnfn}/ cllw bc}}gnk i~{ di} r{c{gb ck aib fn{zi}`r&[an ucun} gr i}jcfgxnk cr dillizr& Gf rnb{gif G, zn
jgtn c m}gnd gf{}ik~b{gif cfk }nlc{nk zi}`& Rnb{gif GG
u}nrnf{r {an {iuilijw knrgjf& Gf rnb/ {gif GGG, zn jgtn
{an rgo~lc{gif }nr~l{r zagba gr dilliznk mw {an bifbl~rgif
gf rnb{gif GT&
GG [IUILIJW KNRGJF
Bifrgkn}gfj {ac{ {an fiknr gf c OCFN[ c}n oimgln,
{an}n rnno {i mn lg{{ln i} fi oncfgfj bif/ bn}fgfj {an
{iuilijw knrgjf id {an fn{zi}`& Aiz/ ntn}, gf i~} u}nrnf{
bif{nq{, i~} gf{n}nr{ gr gf c uc}{gcllw oimgln ck aibfn{zi}` gf zagba rion fiknr c}n `nu{ r{c{gifc}w zagln
{an }nr{ c}n oi/ mgln& [a~r, mw {iuilijw knrgjf, zn oncf
knrgjf id {an {an {iuilijw id {an fn{zi}` di}onk mw {an
rn{ id r{c{gifc}w fiknr& Di} gfr{cfbn gf Dgj& 3, zn raiz c
uc}{gcllw oimgln OCFN[& C dgllnk bg}bln knfi{nr c oimgln
fikn zan}ncr cf nou{w bg}bln knfi{nr c r{c{gifc}w fikn&
[an r{c{gifc}w fiknr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 72
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 109/223
c}n c}}cfjnk gf c j}gk zg{agf {an OCFN[‗r fn{/
zi}` c}nc }nu}nrnf{nk mw {an miq& Cf nkjn mn/
{znnf cfw {zi r{c{gifc}w fiknr knfi{nr {ac{ {an fiknr
c}n zg{agf bioo~fgbc{gif }cfjn id ncba
i{an}& [an r{c{gifc}w fiknr c}n {an rcon cr {an
oimgln fiknr gf ntn}w }nrunb{ r~ba {ac{ {anw actn {an rcon
u}ibnrrgfj bcucbg{w, {}cfrogrrgif }cfjn cfk mc{{n}w uizn}
cr {an oimgln fiknr& Oi}nitn}, c r{c{gifc}w fikn mnactnrmi{a cr air{ cfk }i~{n} lg`n cfw i{an} fikn& K~n {i {an zcw
{an r{c{gifc}w fiknr c}n ~fgdi}olw lcgk i~{, {an}nmw
u}itgkgfj jiik biffnb{gtg{w, g{ gr gf{~g{gtn {i nqunb{ c agjan}
knj}nn id }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn {acf zanf cll {an fiknr c}n
oimgln&
Cfi{an} zcw id ulcbgfj {an r{c{gifc}w fiknr
gr mw }cfkiolw rbc{{n}gfj {ano gf {an OCFN[‗r fn{zi}`
c}nc& Rgfbn, {anw c}n }cfkiolw ulcbnk, ifn bcffi{
crbn}{cgf cmi~{ {an nddnb{ {an {iuilijw knrgjf zi~lk actn
if {an fn{zi}`‗r biffnb{gt/ g{w& Zn ntcl~c{n {an goucb{ id
{iuilijw if }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn cfk zn u}nrnf{ {an
rgo~lc{gif }nr~l{r gf {an dillizgfj rnb{gif&
GGG Rgo~lc{gif cfk Un}di}ocfbn
Ntcl~c{gif
Rgo~lc{gifr zn}n kifn ~rgfj {an fr=&2= rgo/ ~lc{i}
P3>_, zan}n {an ~fkn}lwgfj OCB u}i{ibil ~rnk gr 15=&33&
[an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil zn actn ~rnk gr CIKT P34_& Zn
actn {c`nf c knuliwonf{ id
>5 fiknr gf cf c}nc oncr~}gfj 3>55o Ú 3>55o&
C un}bnf{cjn id {an >5 fiknr c}n `nu{ r{c{gifc}w cfk {an
}nr{ c}n oimgln& [an }ckgi }cfjn id ncba fikn gr =>5o&
[an rgo~lc{gif gr }~f di} tc}wgfj ocqgo~o runnkr id {an
oimgln fiknr cfk c uc~rn {gon id 5 rnbifk& Ntn}w uigf{ gf
{an j}cuar gr cf ctn}cjn id {an }nr~l{r im{cgfnk d}io
rgo~lc{gfj
=5 kgddn}nf{ {iuilijgnr ~rgfj =5 biffnb{gifr di} c un}gik
id >55 rnbifkr& Ncba kc{c ucb`n{ gr id rgxn 3=1 mw{nr cfk
{an {}cddgb {wun ~rnk gr bifr{cf{ mg{ }c{n c{ {an }c{n id ;
ucb`n{r un} rnbifk& [an oitnonf{ oiknl ~rnk di} {an
oimgln fiknr gr {an }cfkio zcwuigf{ oiknl P3:_&
[i biouc}n {an }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn id {an bcrn
Dgj~}n 3& J}gk knuliwonf{ id r{c{gifc}w
fiknr0 {an nou{w cfk dgllnk bg}blnr knfi{n
r{c{gifc}w cfk oimgln fiknr }nrunb{gtnlw
zanf cll fiknr c}n oimgln zg{a {ac{ zanf rion fiknr c}n
r{c{gifc}w, zn rgo~lc{nk CIKT gf {an rg{~c{gifr zanf
tc}wgfj f~omn} id fiknr i~{ id {an >5 fiknr c}n ockn
r{c{gifc}w& Zn bifrgk/
n}nk {an bcrnr zanf 5!5.', >!35.', 35!=5.',
3>!25.', =5!;5.' cfk =>!>5.' fiknr c}n r{c/
{gifc}w& Dg}r{ zn rgo~lc{nk di} {an bcrn zanf {an r{c{gifc}w
fiknr c}n c}}cfjnk gf c j}gk& Zn ulcbnk {an fiknr gf c j}gk
gf r~ba c zcw {ac{ {an ai}gxif/ {cl cr znll cr {an tn}{gbcl
kgr{cfbn mn{znnf cfw {zi fiknr gr =>5o& Oi}nitn}, {an
j}gk gr ulcbnk c}i~fk {an ogkkln id {an fn{zi}` c}nc&
Rnbifk, zn ulcbnk {an r{c{gifc}w fiknr }cfkiolw gf {an
fn{zi}` c}nc ~rgfj {an BO^ {iuilijw jnfn}c{gif ~{glg{w{ac{ bionr clifj zg{a fr=&2= rgo~lc{i}&
Zn actn bifrgkn}nk rgq un}di}ocfbn oncr~}n/ onf{
uc}con{n}r8
!c' Ucb`n{ Knlgtn}w ]c{gi !UK]'8 ]c{gi id {an {i/ {cl
f~omn} id kc{c ucb`n{r }nbngtnk mw {an knr{gfc{gifr
{i {an {i{cl f~omn} id kc{c ucb / n{r rnf{&
!m' Hg{{n}8 Ctn}cjn Tc}gc{gif gf {an }nbngtnk {gon id kc{c
ucb`n{r&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 7;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 110/223
H g { { n } ! o r '
U c b ` n { K n l g t n } w
N f k / { i / N f k
k n l c w
3
5&7
355
5
75
5
15
5
:5
5
455
Fi J}gk
J}gk/>J}gk/35J}gk/3>J}gk/=5J}gk/=>
5&1
5&:
>55
;55
255
5&4=55
355
5&>
5&;
Fi J}gk
J}gk/>J}gk/35J}gk/3>J}gk/=5J}gk/=>
55 = ; 4 1 35 3=
3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
5 = ; 4 1 35 3= 3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
Dgj~}n =& J}gk knuliwonf{0 Ucb`n{ knlgtn}w
}c{gi Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
5&5;
5&52>
Dgj~}n ;& J}gk knuliwonf{0 Nfk/{i/nfk
ucb`n{ knlcw Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
!b' Nfk/{i/nfk Knlcw8 Ctn}cjn id {an knlcw !}n/ bngtnk
{gon ogf~r rnf{ {gon' id ntn}w kc{c ucb`n{&
!k' ]i~{n D}ns~nfbw8 [an f~omn} id }i~{n }n/ s~nr{r
jnfn}c{nk un} rnbifk&
!n' ]i~{gfj Lick 8 [an f~omn} id bif{}il ucb`n{r
{}cfrog{{nk !gfbl~kgfj {an ifnr {ac{ c}n di}/ zc}knk'
di} ntn}w kc{c ucb`n{ }nbngtnk&
5&52
5&5=>
5&5=
5&53>
5&53
5&55>
5
Fi J}gk
J}gk/>J}gk/35
J}gk/3>J}gk/=5J}gk/=>
5 = ; 4 1 35 3= 3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
!d ' Ctn}cjn [a}i~jau~{8 [an {i{cl coi~f{ id kc{c
}nbngtnk mw cll fiknr un} rnbifk&
Dgj& = raizr {an biouc}grif id ucb`n{ knlgtn}w
}c{gi!UK]' zanf {an r{c{gifc}w fiknr c}n ulcbnk gf {an
di}o id c j}gk& [an lcmnl Fi J}gk knfi{nr {an uli{ zanf
cll {an fiknr c}n oimgln !g&n&, {an}n c}n fi r{c{gifc}w
fiknr'& Rgoglc}lw J}gk/> kn/ fi{nr {an uli{ zanf {an}n
c}n >!35.' r{c{gifc}w fiknr coifj {an >5 fiknr& [an
i{an} lcmnlr bc}}w rgoglc} oncfgfj& G{ gr rnnf {ac{ cr {an
un}bnf{cjn
Dgj~}n 2& J}gk knuliwonf{0 Hg{{n} Tr& Ocqg/
o~o runnk
id r{c{gifc}w fiknr gfb}ncrnr {an ucb`n{ knlgtn}w}c{gi gfb}ncrnr rgjfgdgbcf{lw& [agr gr cr nqunb{nk cr {an
biffnb{gtg{w gf {an fn{zi}` gfb}ncrnr zg{a {an gfb}ncrn gf
{an rgxn id {an j}gk id r{c{gifc}w fiknr& G{ gr clri fi{gbnk
{ac{ {an UK] knb}ncrnr cr {an oimglg{w gfb}ncrnr, zagba gr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 7>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 111/223
cr nqunb{nk&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 74
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 112/223
] i ~ { g f j L i c k
] i ~ { n D } n s ~ n f b w
[ a } i ~ j a
u ~ { ! O m '
5&3
2
=&>
Fi J}gk
J}gk/>J}gk/35J}gk/3>J}gk/=5
J}gk/=>
5&51
5&54
=
3&>
5&5
;
5&5=
Fi J}gk
J}gk/>J}gk/35J}gk/3>J}gk/=5J}gk/=>
3
5&>
55 = ; 4 1 35 3=
3;Ocqgo~orunnk !o)r'
55 = ; 4 1 35 3= 3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
Dgj~}n >& J}gk knuliwonf{0 ]i~{n d}ns~nfbw
Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
=
Dgj~}n :& J}gk knuliwonf{0 Ctn}cjn {a}i~ja/ u~{
!Om)rnb' Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
Dgj& 2 raizr {an hg{{n} zg{a }nrunb{ {i ocqgo~o runnk di}
tc}wgfj un}bnf{cjn id r{c{gifc}w fiknr& G{ gr rnnf {ac{ {an
hg{{n} }nk~bnr cr {an fi& id r{c/ {gifc}w fiknr gfb}ncrnr&
[agr gr nqunb{nk cr {an fn{zi}` mnbionr oi}n znll
biffnb{nk cfk r{c/ mln cr {an fi& id r{c{gifc}w fiknr
gfb}ncrnr& [an nfk/{i/nfk knlcw biouc}grif gr u}nrnf{nk
gf Dgj&
;& [an knlcw knb}ncrnr }cugklw cr {an [an nfk/{i/
3&>
3
5&>
5
Fi J}gk
J}gk/>J}gk/35J}gk/3>J}gk/=5J}gk/=>
5 = ; 4 1 35 3= 3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
nfk knlcw biouc}grif gr u}nrnf{nk gf Dgj& ;& [an knlcw
knb}ncrnr }cugklw cr {an un}bnf{cjn id r{c/ {gifc}w fiknr
gfb}ncrnr& Zanf >5. id {an fiknr c}n r{c{gifc}w, {an knlcw
mnbionr lizn} {acf ntnf
355or& Dgj& > raizr {an {an }i~{n d}ns~nfbw di}
tc}wgfj f~omn} id r{c{gifc}w fiknr& G{ gr rnnf {ac{ {an
f~omn} id }i~{n }ns~nr{r jnfn}c{nk un} rnb/ ifk
knb}ncrnr cr {an f~omn} id r{c{gifc}w fiknr gfb}ncrnr&
Zanf oi}n f~omn} id fiknr c}n r{c/ {gifc}w cfk {anw c}n
knuliwnk gf j}gk, {an f~omn} id lgf` m}nc`r }nk~bnr&Bifrns~nf{lw, {an f~o/ mn} id }i~{n }ns~nr{r un} rnbifk
}nk~bnr rgfbn c
Dgj~}n 4& J}gk knuliwonf{0 ]i~{gfj lick Tr&
Ocqgo~o runnk
lgf` m}nc` ui{nf{gcllw }nr~l{r gf nr{cmlgraonf{ id
fnz }i~{nr& Dgj& 4 gll~r{}c{nr {an biouc}grif id {an
}i~{gfj lick& Cr nqunb{nk, {an }i~{gfj lick }n/ k~bnr cr {an
f~omn} id r{c{gifc}w fiknr gfb}ncrnr& Zanf {an}n c}n oi}n
f~omn} id r{c{gifc}w fiknr di}ogfj c j}gk, {an }i~{nr c}n
oi}n r{cmln cfk ri
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 7:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 113/223
H g { {
n } ! o r '
U c b ` n { K n l g t n } w N
f k / { i / N f k k
n l c w
3555
755
3
5&7
155
:55
455
5&1
5&:
5&4
5&>
5&;
Fi]cfkio]cfkio/>
]cfkio/35]cfkio/3>]cfkio/=5
]cfkio/=>
>5
5
;5
5
25
5
=5
5
35
5
5
Fi ]cfkio
]cfkio/>]cfkio/35]cfkio/3>]cfkio/=5]cfkio/=>
5 = ; 4 1 35 3=
3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
5 = ; 4 1 35 3= 3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
Dgj~}n 1& ]cfkio knuliwonf{0 Ucb`n{ knlgt/ n}w
}c{gi Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
5&5>
Dgj~}n 35& ]cfkio knuliwonf{0 Nfk/{i/nfk
ucb`n{ knlcw Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
{an f~omn} id bif{}il ucb`n{r jnfn}c{nk cfk di}/ zc}knk gr
lnrr cr biouc}nk {i zanf {an}n c}n lnrr f~omn} id
r{c{gifc}w fiknr& Dgfcllw, {an {a}i~ja/ u~{ gfb}ncrnr cr {an
f~omn} id r{c{gifc}w fiknr gfb}ncrnr !Dgj& :'& [agr gr
nqunb{nk rgfbn {an UK] clri gfb}ncrnr cr {an f~omn} id
r{c{gifc}w fiknr gfb}ncrnr&[an rnbifk uc}{ id {an rgo~lc{gif gftiltnr {an }cfkio
knuliwonf{ id {an r{c{gifc}w fiknr gf/
5&5
;
5&5
2
5&5
=
5&5
3
5
Fi ]cfkio
]cfkio/>]cfkio/35]cfkio/3>]cfkio/=5
]cfkio/=>
5 = ; 4 1 35 3=
3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
r{nck id c}}cfjgfj {ano gf c j}gk& [an cmitn
rgq un}di}ocfbn uc}con{n}r zn}n ~rnk {i ntcl~/ c{n {agr
rbnfc}gi& Dgj& 1 {i Dgj& 3= raiz {an un}/ di}ocfbn di}
tc}wgfj f~omn} id r{c{gifc}w fiknr, zagba c}n knuliwnk
}cfkiolw& Zn imrn}tn {ac{ {an}n rnno {i mn fi fi{cmln
goucb{ if {an un}/ di}ocfbn z&}&{& cll {an un}di}ocfbn
uc}con{n}r& [a~r zn bifbl~kn {ac{ gou}itn gfun}di}ocfbn bcf blnc}lw mn cbagntnk mw knuliwgfj {an
r{c{gif/ c}w fiknr gf c j}gk zan}ncr {an}n gr oi}n i} lnrr
fi nddnb{ if {an un}di}ocfbn zanf {anw c}n kn/ uliwnk
}cfkiolw&
Dgj~}n 7& ]cfkio knuliwonf{0 Hg{{n} Tr&
Ocqgo~o runnk GT Bifbl~rgifr
Zn actn u}nrnf{nk {an goucb{ id {iuilijw id
r{c{gifc}w fiknr gf c uc}{gcllw oimgln ck aib
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 71
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 114/223
] i ~ { g f j L i c k
] i ~ { n D } n s ~ n f b w [
a } i ~ j a u ~ { ! O m '
5&3
2&> 5&51
2 5&54
=&>
=
3&>
5&5
;
5&5=
Fi ]cfkio
]cfkio/>]cfkio/35]cfkio/3>]cfkio/=5]cfkio/=>
3
5&>
Fi ]cfkio
]cfkio/>]cfkio/35]cfkio/3>]cfkio/=5]cfkio/=>
55 = ; 4 1 35 3=
3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
5 5 = ; 4 1 35 3=3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
Dgj~}n 33& ]cfkio knuliwonf{0 ]i~{n d}n/
s~nfbw Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
2&
>
2
Dgj~}n 32& ]cfkio knuliwonf{0 Ctn}cjn
{a}i~jau~{ !Om)rnb' Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
fn{zi}`& Dg}r{, zn bifrgkn}nk {an bcrn zanf {an
r{c{gifc}w fiknr c}n c}}cfjnk gf c j}gk& Rnbifk, zn
clri gftnr{gjc{nk {an rbnfc}gi zanf {an r{c{gifc}w fiknr
c}n knuliwnk }cfkiolw& Zn imrn}tnk {ac{ {an }i~{gfj
un}di}ocfbn bcf mn gfb}ncrnk rgjfgdgbcf{lw mw gfb}ncrgfj
{an f~omn} id {an r{c{gifc}w fiknr gf {an j}gk {iuilijw&
[agr zi~lk oncf {ac{ gfr{nck id ckiu{gfj nlcmi}c{n cu/
u}icbanr r~ba cr oikgdwgfj {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil
i} knuliwgfj uizn}d~l cfk nqunfrgtn mcb`mifn
=&>
=
3&>
3
5&>
5
Fi ]cfkio]cfkio/>
]cfkio/35]cfkio/3>]cfkio/=5]cfkio/=>
5 = ; 4 1 35 3= 3;
Ocqgo~o
runnk !o)r'
fiknr, {an }i~{gfj un}di}ocfbn id c OCFN[ bcf mn
nfacfbnk rgoulw mw oc`gfj rion fiknr r{c{gifc}w cfk
c}}cfjgfj {ano gf c j}gk& Aiz/ ntn}, zn di~fk {ac{
}cfkiolw kgr{}gm~{gfj {an r{c{gifc}w fiknr gf {an
fn{zi}` c}nc kinr fi{ anlu gf gou}itgfj {an }i~{gfj
un}di}ocfbn& [a~r, zn bifbl~kn {ac{ {i nfacfbn {anun}di}ocfbn, r{c{gifc}w fiknr o~r{ fi{ mn h~r{ r{c{gifc}w
m~{ o~r{ mn c}}cfjnk gr rion }nj~lc} dcragif ri {ac{
g{ anlur gf gou}itgfj {an biffnb{gtg{w id {an
Dgj~}n 3=& ]cfkio knuliwonf{0 ]i~{gfj lick
Tr& Ocqgo~o runnk
fn{zi}`&
Cb`fizlnkjonf{8 [agr zi}` gr r~uui}{nk mw ]n/
rnc}ba U}ioi{gif Rbanon id CGB[N, Gfkgc !u}ihnb{ fi&15=2)MI])]GK)]UR/=22)=551/57, 23)2)=557'&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuul gbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 77
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 115/223
]ndn}nfbnr
P3_ M& Gragmcrag cfk ]ci~d Mi~{cmc, “[iulijw cfk
oimglg{w bifrgkn}c{gifr gf oimgln ck aib
fn{zi}`r,‟ Nlrntgn} Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r, 2 !=55>'
:4=/::4&
P=_ H& Znllifr cfk W& Q~n, “[an Goucb{ id [iuil/ ijw gf
]im~r{ ]i~{gfj if Zg}nlnrr Onra Fn{zi}`r,‟
U}ib& Oimgln Biou~{gfj cfk Bioo~fgbc{gifr
]ntgnz, =535, uu& ;4/;1&
P2_ W& Qgf, [& J~tnf, O& C& Racwocf, “[iuilijw knrgjf
di} zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}`r zg{a mcb`mifn
r~uui}{,‟ U}ib& Bifdn}nfbn if Gfdi}oc{gif Rbgnfbnr
cfk Rwr{nor, =55>&
P;_ R& Un}~} cfk R& Gwn}, “Ruc}rn O~l{g/aiu zg}nlnrr di}
tigbn bioo~fgbc{gif gf }~}cl Gfkgc,‟ U}ib& 3={a
Fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Bioo~fgbc{gifr, FBB
=554, Fnz Knlag, Gfkgc0 uu& >2;/>21, Hcf~c}w =554&
P>_ O& Bc}kng, H& Z~ cfk R& Wcfj, “[iuilijw bif{}il
gf ck aib zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r ~rgfj biiun}c{gtn
bioo~fgbc{gif,‟ GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr if Oimgln
Biou~{gfj, til& >, fi& 4, H~fn =554&
P4_ C& ]caocf cfk U& Jm~}gxwfr`g, “ OCB/ crrgr{nk
{iuilijw bif{}il di} ck aib zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r,‟
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Hi~}fcl id bioo~/ fgbc{gif rwr{nor,
=55>05503/4&
P:_ R& Cjc}zcl, R& @}grafco~}{aw, ]& @c{x, cfk R& Kci,
“Kgr{}gm~{nk uizn} bif{}il gf ck/aib zg}nlnrr
fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& UGO]B, =553&
P1_ [& @zif cfk O& Jn}lc, “Bl~r{n}gfj zg{a uizn}
bif{}il,‟ U}ib& OGLBIO, til& =, uu& 3;=;/3;=1,
3777&
P7_ ]& ]cocfc{acf cfk ]& ]irclnr/Acgf, “[iuilijw
bif{}il id o~l{gaiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r ~rgfj
{}cfrog{ uizn} ckh~r{onf{,‟ U}ib& id GNNN
GFDIBIO =555, uu& ;5;/;32, [nl Ctgt, Gr}cnl,
Oc}ba =555&
P35_ L& Lg, H& W& Alcun}f, U& Mcal, W& Zcfj, cfk ]&
Zc{nfaidn}, “Cfclwrgr id c bif/ mcrnk {iuilijw
bif{}il clji}g{ao di} zg}n/ lnrr o~l{g/aiu
fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& CBO Rwo/ uirg~o if U}gfbguln id
Kgr{}gm~{nk Biou~{/ gfj !UIKB', =553&
P33_ F& Lg, H& B& Ai~, cfk L& Rac, “Knrgjf cfk cfclwrgr
id cf OR[/mcrnk {iuilijw bif{}il clji}g{ao,‟
U}ib& GFDIBIO, =552&
P3=_ T& ]ikiul~ cfk [& Onfj, “ Ogfgo~o nfn}jw oimgln
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r,‟ GNNN Hi~}fcl id Rnlnb{nk
C}ncr gf Bioo~fgbc{gifr, 3:!1', uu& 3222/32;;,
3777&
P32_ ]& Zc{{nfaidn}, L& Lg, U& Mcal, cfk W&/ O& Zcfj,
“Kgr{}gm~{nk {iuilijw bif{}il di} zg}nlnrr o~l{gaiu
ck/aib fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& GFDIBIO =553, uu& 3211/
327:, =553&
P3;_ X& A~cfj, B& Ranf, B& R}grc{acui}fuac{, cfk B&
Hcg`cni, “[iuilijw bif{}il di} ck aib fn{/ zi}`rzg{a kg}nb{gifcl cf{nffcr,‟ U}ib& GNNN Gf{&
Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Bioo~fgbc{gifr cfk
Fn{zi}`r, uu& 34/=3, =55=&
P3>_ [an Fn{zi}` Rgo~lc{i} / fr=,
zzz&grg&nk~)frfco)fr)&
P34_ B& N& Un}`gfr cfk N& O& ]iwn}, “Ck/aib If/
Knocfk Tnb{i} ]i~{gfj,‟ U}ib& =fk GNNN
Zi}`raiu if Oimgln Biou~{gfj Rwr{nor cfk
Cuulgbc{gifr, uu& 75/355, Fnz I}lncfr, LC,
Dnm}~c}w 3777&
P3:_ K& M& Hiafrif cfk K& C& Ocl{x, “Kwfcogb Ri~}bn
]i~{gfj gf Ck Aib Zg}nlnrr Fn{/ zi}`r,‟ Oimgln
Biou~{gfj ![& Gognlgfr`g cfk A& @i}{a, nkg{i}r,
@l~zn} Cbcknogb U~mlgran}r, uu& 3>2/313, 3774&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 355
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 116/223
U}ib& id {a
il~on 3& BiGRMF8 7:1/13
Cmr{
ioo~fgbc{gi
ckgfj& I}{ai
fk i}{aijif
zagba c}n o
mnbion zgknl
jcgfr{ d}ns~n
ktcf{cjnr,
}czmcb`r0 ag
i} cf ckcu{gt
an bacffnl, c
Rgfjln bc}}gn}zagba ~{glgxnr
fk d}ns~nfb
nbafgs~n {ac
con itn}cll r
c}}gn} d}ns~
oikgdgnk di}
}iogrgfj {
ioo~fgbc{gi
goglc} {a}i~
tn}cll bioul
DKOC gr {an
lizn} {acf {a
cfkgkc{n di}
n}o Ntil~{g
an 2}k Jnfn}!2JUU L[N'&
Gf {a
qulcgf aiz R
}ns~nfbw ki
fnnknk cf cl{n
Zn u}nrnf{ g
fclwxn {an nd
UCU]& Coif
zn dgfk {ac{
nunfknf{ rb
acf gf{n}lnc
n}di}ocfbn
lri nqulcgf {a
DKOC cfk I
If {an ln
c}n knugb{nk
biftn}{nk {ianf gf {an d
knrg}nk libc{g
~r{ {anf mn
Gf{l& Bifd& i
w}gja{ § =53/7=5>:>/:/4
BO "8 kmn}&g
C R
}cb{/ M}i
fr r~ddn} d}i
ifcl d}ns~nf
l d}ns~nfbw kg
~l{gbc}}gn} b
cbbnu{nk u}g
fbw rnlnb{gtn d
DKO cfk
ja unc` {i/ct
n i} biknk rba
k agja rnfrg{g
d}ns~nfbw kgtrgfjln bc}}gn
kiocgf ns
acr rgoglc}
{}~b{~}n cr {a
nfbw kgtgrgif
id I}{ai
nbafgs~n di
fr gf d~{~}n
au~{ un}di}
qg{w cr IDK
unc`/{i/ctn}c
{ id IDKOC
{an ~ulgf` o~
f id bnll~lc}
{gif Uc}{fn}r
gr ucun}, zn jg
B/DKOC ~{glg
cgf ns~clgxc
}fc{gtn id r~b
r mcrgb bifbn
nb{r id r~mbc}
{an uirrgmln
libclgxnk D
nk~lgfj !BK
nk DKOC !
d GDKOC gr
n rgoglc}g{gnr
KOC&
d{ acfk rgkn i
gf {an {gon
{an d}ns~nfbns~nfbw ki
if gf {an it
biftn}{nk mcb
Biou~{n} C
[nbafi Di} 88 kig8 35& :27
gon}c&35& :27
{~kw if
kmcfk
o~l{guc{a
w kgtgrgif o~
tgrgif o~l{gul
oo~fgbc{gif
oc}glw mnbc~r
kgfj bacffnl
DKOC r~d
}cjn uizn} }
on {i itn}bi
tg{w {i d}ns~nf
grgif o~l{gulnoik~lc{gif
~clgxc{gif c{
un}di}ocfbn
irn id cf ID
o~l{guln cb
ifcl DKOC
} agja kc
nll~lc} rwr{n
cfbn cfk nr
C& C u}gfbgu
n uizn} }c{g
& RBDKOC gr
l{guln cbbnrr r
rwr{nor ~fkn
agu U}ihnb{ Li
tn cf itn}tgn
nr rgfjln bc}}
gif {nbafgs~
cf cktcfbn
u{ if zagba
}gn} ocuugfj
r~mbc}}gn} o
OC !LDKO
' }nr~l{r gf
GDKOC'& Ai
n{{n} {acf {a
fk ocgf kgddn
d {agr Dgj~}n
kiocgf& [
kiocgf ~rgcgf {anw c}n
}cll bc}}gn} m
` {i {an {gon
uulgbc{gifr ‒
o J}i~u, Gf42)GRMFY5:
42
B/DKOB
Rgfja
g}nlnrr o
d}ns~nfbw/rnln
l{gulnqgfj !ID
cbbnrr !IDK
{nbafgs~nr,
n id g{r }im~r
&Knrug{n {an
n} c f~omn
{gi !UCU]', c
n runb{}cl f~
bw iddrn{&
cbbnrr !RB/DKc{ {an {}cfr
{an }nbngtn}
cfk nrrnf{gcll
OC rwr{no R
bnrr !RBDK
!IDKOC',
{c }c{n ~
r& RB/DKOC
rnf{gcllw {an
l cktcf{cjn i
!UCU]', zag
b~}}nf{lw c r
banon gf {an
} bifrgkn}c{gi
fj [n}o Ntil
id RB/DKO
gn} Oik~lc{gi
r rgoulw& Za
DKOC {nbaf
g{ zi}`r& Zn
if {a}i~jau~
uugfj cuu}ic
C' zg{a bac
agjan} {a}i~j
zntn}, {an U
c{ id LDKOC
}nfbnr mn{znn
an kc{c rwom
n rwomilr
j cf DD[, cocuunk {i
cfkzgk{a& [a
kiocgf gf i}
gc&1
Cktcfbacfk}c Rannrnc}ba Rba
cfgc ^fgtn}r
imgln
b{gtn
KO'
C',
actn
fnrr
cfw
} id
fnnk
llr gf
OC'g{{n}
gr c
{an
gfjln
C',c
gr c
lgf`
acr
rcon
RB/
ba gr
}ifj
Lifj
f mw
~{gif
&Zn
cfk
w zn
gs~n&
clri
cfk
banr,
ffnl/
au~{
CU]
& Zn
RB/
@ U
Gf
b
rw
{af
u
cbB
I
k
!R
b
rw
rw
D
kcbcl
z
u
j
ilr
c}n
fkan
nw
n}
n Cbbnrrac}
ilc}
g{w, ]ch&
wzi}kr8 }di}ocfbn On
G&
i}kn} {i
oo~fgbc{gif
r{nor, {an 2}
n Lifj [non}i~r kgddn
wrgbcl lcwn}
bnrr rbanonrkn Kgtgrgif
{aijifcl D}
zflgf` cfk
B/DKOC' di
RB/DKomgfnr {an li
r{nor / r~ba
omil {gon c
OC gr cf n
ocgf ns~clgbnrr& RB/DKn}fc{gtn {i
an}n lizn} U
zn} nddgbgnfb
fn}c{gif c}n r
Dgj~
{i actn {an b
Cf cl{n}fc{gt
[}cfrdi}o RuRgfjln/bc
kgtgrgif o~l{
lgfnc}lw u}nbj~c}k gf{n}t
mn{znnf mli
nlgogfc{n {g
u}iucjc{gif'
banon d
Bacffnl/Knu cr~}nr, RB/DK
RGFJLN/BC
O^L[
{}cfrg{gif d
r rwr{nor {i
Jnfn}c{gif
o Ntil~{ginfbnr mn{zn
UAW', runbg
& Zagln g{r uO~l{guln
s~nfbw Kgt
gfjln/Bc}}gn
g{r ~ulgf`&P3
OC gr cz UC] bac}c
cr {airn ~rnk
fk dlnqgmln
{nfrgif id rg
c{gif !RB)DOC acr k} DKOC, nru
U] j}nc{lw m
w& P=_P2_P;_&[
aizf gf Dgj~
n38 RB/DKO
wblgb u}ndgq g
n fcon di} R
}nck IDKO !}}gn} DKOC
guln cbbnrr r
knk IDKOClr zg{a bwb
`r id rwo
n ru}nckgf
coifj {an ml
} ;J
fknf{, GDK OC Tr& IDK
]GN] D]NS
ULN CBBNR
}io {ikcw*r
onn{ {an fnn
c}{fn}ragu U}
!L[N' ruf {anrn jnfn}
gbcllw gf {an
}nf{ jnfn}c{gbbnrr !BK
grgif O~l{gu
D}ns~nfbw/
_&
awm}gk {}cfrb{n}gr{gbr id rg
di} JRO cf
}ns~nfbw cll
jln bc}}gn} o
KN' {i cbbzf j}nc{ c{nbgcllw gf {an
nfndg{r {an o
an u}gfbgulnr
n&
C rgjfcl jnfn
frn}{nk u}gi}
B/DKOC gr
KD[/RIDK!RB/DKOC
banon& RB/D
rbanon& H~rlgb }nun{g{gif
ilr gf tgn
j !bc~rnk
ib`r& Gf IDK
OC, LDKO C&
^NFBW/KG
R !RB/DKO
2}k jnfn}
r id ;{a jnf
ihnb{ !2JUU'
bgdgbc{gif&c{gifr c}n ba
oik~lc{gif c
f }nlgnk ifC', L[N
lnqgfj !IDK
gtgrgif O~l{
ogrrgif rbagfjln/bc}}gn} {
k BKOC / z
ibc{gif id
ik~lc{gif zg{
iooikc{nnf{gif cr c~ulgf` bio
mgln {n}ogfcl
mnagfk RB D
}c{gif
{i {}cfrogrrg
Kgrb}n{n Di~
'&P>_
' gr d}ns~nf
KOC bcf c
lg`n gf IDKc}n gf{}ik~
{i nddgbgnf
mw o~l{g/u
O, Dcr{ Di~
C, UCU],
GRGIF
'
c{gif !2J'
}c{gif !;J'
acr }nlncrnk
oifj {anfjnr gf {an
fk o~l{guln
c}gc{gifr id goulnonf{r
O' di} g{r
guln Cbbnrr
on zagba}cfrogrrgif
g{a {an lifj
DKO& RB/
a d}ns~nfbw
~l{guln/~rn} c{{}cb{gtn
~fgbc{gifr
gf {n}or id
OC rgjfcl
if&
gn}
bw/
c
O,nk
{lw
c{a
gn}
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 353
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 117/223
{}cfrdi}o !DD[' gr cuulgnk if {an }nbngtn} rgkn if ncba mlib` id rwomilr, cfk gftn}rn DD[ !GDD[' if {an{}cfrog{{n} rgkn& Gf RB/DKN, mi{a DD[ cfk GDD[ c}n
cuulgnk if {an }nbngtn} rgkn, m~{ fi{ if {an {}cfrog{{n} rgkn& Gf RB/DKOC, mi{a DD[ cfk GDD[ c}n cuulgnk if{an {}cfrog{{n} rgkn, cfk clri if {an }nbngtn} rgkn& Gf RB/DKOC, o~l{guln cbbnrr gr ockn uirrgmln mw gfrn}{gfjrglnf{ di~}gn}/binddgbgnf{r if {an {}cfrog{{n} rgkn mndi}n{an GDD[, cfk }noitgfj {ano if {an }nbngtn} rgkn mndi}n{an GDD[&
Zac{ oc`nr RB/DKOC c rgfjln bc}}gn} oik~lc{gifgr {an dcb{ {ac{ {an}n gr h~r{ ifn bc}}gn}& UCU] id RB)DKOC gr =kM roclln} biouc}nk {i IDKOC&
Rgfjln Bc}}gn} D}ns~nfbw Kgtgrgif O~l{guln Cbbnrr!RB/DKOC' C fnz rgfjln bc}}gn} o~l{guln cbbnrr {nbafgs~n ^{glgxnr rgfjln bc}}gn} oik~lc{gif cfk d}ns~nfbw
kiocgf ns~clgxc{gif& Acr rgoglc} un}di}ocfbn cfk nrrnf{gcllw {an rcon
itn}cll r{}~b{~}n cr {airn id IDKOC rwr{no Acr liz UCU] mnbc~rn id g{r gfan}nf{ rgfjln
bc}}gn} {}cfrog{{n} r{}~b{~}n& Cf c{{}cb{gtn cl{n}fc{gtn {i IDKOC, nrunbgcllw gf
{an ~ulgf` bioo~fgbc{gifr zan}n lizn} UCU] j}nc{lw mnfndg{r {an oimgln {n}ogfcl gf {n}or id {}cfrog{ uizn} nddgbgnfbw&[an mcrgb ~ulgf` {}cfrogrrgif {nbafgs~n gr rgfjln/
bc}}gn} {}cfrogrrgif !RB/DKOC' zg{a bwblgb u}ndgq {icbagntn ~ulgf` gf{n}/~rn} i}{aijifclg{w cfk {i nfcmlnnddgbgnf{ d}ns~nfbw kiocgf ns~clgxc{gif c{ {an }nbngtn}
rgkn
3& Agr{i}w8
Itn} {an ucr{ dgd{nnf wnc}r, {an mg{ }c{nr cbagntnk gfbnll~lc} cfk libcl c}nc zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gif rwr{noractn gfb}ncrnk r{nckglw& [an nc}lgnr{ kgjg{cl bnll~lc} rwr{nor, Fi}{a Con}gbcf [KOC cfk JRO nouliwnk{gon kgtgrgif o~l{guln cbbnrr& Rnbifk jnfn}c{gifBKOC rwr{nor cfk {an {zi {ag}k jnfn}c{gif bnll~lc} rwr{cor cll ~rn kg}nb{ rns~nfbn ru}nck runb{}~o di} o~l{gulnqgfj cfk o~lûgul~ cbbnrr¦ [an agjanr{ mg{}c{nr gf bioon}bgcllw knuliwnk zg}nfnrr rwr{nor c}n
cbagntnk mw oncfr id I}{aijifcl Ä}ns~nfbw KgtgrgifO~l{gulnqgfj !ÉDKO' gf zgunlnrr LCFr mcr.k if {anGNNN 15=&33c cfk GNNO 15=&33j r{cfkc}kr& [an fnq{cktcfbn gf bnll~lc} rwr{nor, ~fkn} gftnr{gjc{gif mg {an[ag}k Jnfn}c{gif Uc}{fn}ragu U}ihnb{ !2JUU', clricf{gbguc{nr {an ckiu{gif id IDKÏC {i cbagntn agjan} mg{}c{nr& Fiz gf di~}{a Jnfn}c{gif zn ~rn RB/DKOc {icbagntn ocqao~o un}di}ocfbn zg{a c rgfjlnbc}}gn}&P4_&e
2& Zaw Fnnknk
[ikcw o~l{g/bc}}gnr {}cfrogrrgif Cfk IDKO c}n oncfz{i clliz di} tn}w agja itn}cll {}cfrogrrgif mcfkzgk{azagln r{gll mngfj }im~r{ {i rgjfcl bi}}~u{gif k~n {i }ckgi/
bacffnl d}ns~nfbw rnlnb{wtg{w& Aizntn}, c k}czmcb` id IDKO oik~lc{gif, cr znll cr cfw `gfk id o~l{g/bc}}gn} {}cfrogrrgif, g} {an lc}jn tc}gc{gifr gf {an gfr{cf{cfni~rUizn} id {an {}cfrog{{nk rgjfcl& R~ba uizn} tc}gc{gifrgoulw c }nk~bnk uizn}/coulgdgn} nddgbgnfbw cfk agjan} uizn}/coulgdgn} bir{& [agr gr nrunbgcllw b}g{gbcl di} {an~ulgf`, k~n {i {an agja goui}{cfbn id liz oimgln/{n}ogfcl uizn} bifr~ou{gif cfk bir{& Rntn}cl on{aikractn mnnf u}iuirnk if aiz {i }nk~bn {an lc}jn uizn} tc}gc{gifr id cf IDKO rgjfcl& Aizntn}, oir{ id {anrnon{aikr actn lgog{c{gifr gf {n}or id {i zac{ nq{nf{ {an uizn} tc}gc{gifr bcf mn }nk~bnk& D~}{an}oi}n, oir{ id {an on{aikr clri goulw c rgjfgdgbcf{ biou~{c{gifclbioulnqg{w cfk)i} c }nk~bnk lgf` un}di}ocfbn&P:_ [a~r,{an}n gr cf gf{n}nr{ {i bifrgkn} clri zgkn}/mcfk rgfjln/bc}}gn} {}cfrogrrgif cr cf cl{n}fc{gtn {i o~l{g/bc}}gn} {}cfrogrrgif, nrunbgcllw di} {an ~ulgf`, g&n& di} oimgln/{n}ogfcl {}cfrogrrgif& Ifn id r~ba rgfjln/bc}}gn} {}cfrogrrgif rbanon bcf mn goulnonf{nk ~rgfj KD[/ru}nck IDKO&
GG& RB/DKOC)KD[/ru}nck IDKO8
KD[/ru}nck IDKOKD[/Ru}nck IDKOC ‒ Ocuugfj id ru}nck rwomilr , fi{i}gjgfcl rwomilr {i r~mbc}}gn}r&
RB/DKOC bcf mn }njc}knk cr kgrb}n{n Di~}gn}
{}cfrdi}o !KD['/ru}nck IDKOC, zan}n {gon kiocgfkc{c rwomilr c}n {}cfrdi}onk {i d}ns~nfbw kiocgf mwKD[ mndi}n jigfj {a}i~ja IDKOC oik~lc{gif&
KD[/ru}nck IDKO !KD[R/IDKO' gr c{}cfrogrrgif rbanon {ac{ bcf biomgfn {an knrg}nk u}iun}{gnr di} ~ulgf` {}cfrogrrgif g&n& Rocll tc}gc{gifr gf {an gfr{cf{cfni~r uizn} id {an{}cfrog{{nk rgjfcl !‑rgfjln bc}}gn}‗ u}iun}{w'& Uirrgmglg{w di} liz/bioulnqg{w agja/s~clg{wns~clgxc{gif gf {an d}ns~nfbw kiocgf& Uirrgmglg{w di} DKOC zg{a dlnqgmln mcfkzgk{acrrgjfonf{& K~n {i {anrn u}iun}{gnr, KD[R/IDKO acr mnnf
rnlnb{nk cr {an ~ulgf` {}cfrogrrgif rbanon di} L[N,zagba gr {an lifj/{n}o 2J ntil~{gif&
>& Aiz RB/DKOC Zi}`9
[an {}cfrog{{n} id cf RB/DKOC rwr{no biftn}{r c mgfc}w gfu~{ rgjfcl {i c rns~nfbn id oik~lc{nkr~mbc}}gn}r& C{ {an gfu~{ {i {an {}cfrog{{n}, c mcrnmcfkoik~lc{i} {}cfrdi}or {an mgfc}w gfu~{ {i c o~l{glntnlrns~nfbn id bioulnq f~omn}r qf gf ifn id rntn}cl uirrgmln oik~lc{gif di}oc{r& [an {}cfrog{{n} fnq{ j}i~ur{an oik~lc{gif rwomilr p qf gf{i mlib`r ncba bif{cgfgfj
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 35=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 118/223
g
g
g
g
rwomilr& [
r~mbc}}gn}r grd}ns~nfbw k
rwomilr& G{ {aid {an O !
}cfrog{{nk& Grwomilr un
rgo~l{cfni~r
gf{n}dn}nfbn&
rwomil rns~nan rn{ l Q ɴ
coulg{~knr,
gf IDKOC,coulg{~knr {i
ɴo {anf c}
n}di}or {zi
}cfrogrrgif&
Aiznocgfgfj gfu
id {an GKD[
}iun}{gnr, g&
g{a c mcfkzcrr~ogfj c r
an fiogfcl
MZ ?O)F (gfr{cf{cfni~r
c}gnk, clli
~}{an}oi}n,
KD[ i~{u~{rragd{nk gf {an
G{ gf}ndgq !BU' g
gf{n}/mlib` }iucjc{gif&
dgl{n}gfj iun}
nk~bn i~{/id id {an lcr{ uc}
ncba mlib` d
~c}k {gon m
an BU gr lif
bacffnl, i} } nruifrn, {an
biuw id {an l
gon lgfnc} biftil~{gif&an bacffnl
mn{znnf {an
}cfrog{{nk kc uigf{/zgrn
rcoulnr& [an
KD[ id {an }
KD[ id {an
i}n riuagrnbafgs~n bc
rnk u~lrn ra
an dg}r{ r{nu g
{i un}di}o cocgf }nu}n
nf ocur ncba F ' i}{aiji
d F ? O )S
mlib`, {a
{}cfrogrrg
gr {an mcfk
fbn& [an }nr~l ? 5, 3, =․
an}n F id {a
f O /uigf{ Gc bioulnq {g
{}cfrog{{nk
i{an} rgjfcl
ntn}, gd O~{r {i {an GK
zgll mn c
& c rgjfcl zg
gk{a {ac{ knucoulgfj }c{n
cfkzgk{a id
dr& [a~r, mw mcfkzgk{a i
gfj di} dln
mw ragd{gfj {
c}n ocuunk,d}ns~nfbw ki
n}{r c rn{ id ri}kn} {i u}
gf{n}dn}nfbn[an {}cfrog
{gif }ndn}}nk
cfk rgjfcl nf{ id {an mlib`
} c bi~uln i
n{znnf r~bbn
n} {acf {an
i~jalw, {an l, {an}n gr f
r{ uc}{ id {a
iftil~{gif ga~r {}cfrog{
cf mn oiknl
bacffnl g
{c mlib`, zago~l{gulgbc{g
f, {i }noit
bngtnk rgjfcl
acffnl gou~
{gbc{nk d}nsmn goulno
ugfj dgl{n} gr
gf oik~lc{gf
f F /uigf{ Knf{c{gif Q`
id {an F KDfcl r~mbc}}g
cfk cll {n}ogn rwr{no
ifr zg{ai
gk{a nqucfrg
l{ id {an r~mb, O /3' id bi
coulg{~knr
D[ {}cfrdi} n kiocgf rg
rns~nf{gcllw&
}ibnrrgfj iu
gr roclln} {[ c}n rn{ {i
rgjfcl zg{a
{a liz uizn
fkr if O& Odr c{ {an i~{u
{an {}cfrog{{
tc}wgfj {an m{an {}cfrog{{
gmln/mcfkzg
n GKD[ gfu
{an {}cfrog{{cgf&P1_
womilr }ndn}} tgkn c j~c}k
!GMG' k~n{{n} clri un
{i cr u~lrn ra
n}jw& Gf jnfnzagba gr ckk
}ncrifr& Dg}
rgtn mlib`r&
cqgo~o knl
fj{a id {anGMG& Rnbif
mlib`, g{ bi
{i c kgrb}n{nk kc{c u}iunk cr c bg}b
ou~lrn }nru
ba gf {an d}nsif id {an
{an bacffn
bcf rgoulw m
lrn }nruifrn
nfbw kiocf{nk& Ifn i
an }cgrnk/bir
{an RB/DK
[ {i u}ik~bid {an gf
i~{u~{r {i}r {ac{ bcf
fclr {}cfrog{cf acfkln
{ bi/bacf
gif dcb{i} id
}}gn} ocuugf ulnq r~mbc}}
}n fif/xn}i&
r {an r~mbc}} fcl qɴo & N
[an {}cfrog{
n}c{gifr u}gi}
cf F cfkxn}i, {an i~{
‑rgfjln/bc}}g
tc}gc{gifr, c
i}n runbgdgbcl~{ id {an GK
k rgjfcl zgll
lib` rgxn Onk rgjfcl bcf
{a crrgjfon
{r {i zagba
k rgjfcl bcf
nk {i cr c bwb{gon {i u}nt
{i o~l{gudi}or c lgf
cugfj gf i}kn}
}cl, BU gr c bnk c{ {an r{c}{
r{, BU cb{r c
Gd {an lnfj{a
cw ru}nck id
bacffnl gou~, rgfbn BU g
tn}{r c kgrb}
n {gon bg}b~cjc{gfj {a}i~lc} biftil~{g
ifrn cfk
~nfbw kiocgfKD[ d}ns~nf
l kgr{i}{gif,
n kgtgknk mw
uigf{/zgrn i
gf ns~clgxc{g{an biooi
gfn dgl{n}&
C
c~{
fn mn F
S
nl
an
grgn}
Cr
gn} ba
{n}
{i
an~{
n}‗
fk
lw,[,
mn
an mn
f{&
an
mn
lgbnf{
c{anc}
{i
uwid
c
id
an
lrnc
n{n
lc} jaif
an
grbw
an
an
c
iflw
[an
c o~l{g/bc}}gn}nk~bnk tc}gc
goulwgfj {annddgbgnfbw&
KD[8 Kgrb}n{
GKD[8 Gftn}r
BU8 Bwblgb U} UR8 U~lrn Rac
KCB8 Kgjg{cl
]D8 ]ckgi D}
CKB8 CfclijDgj~}n=8 [}cf
DKOC)KD[R
[zi cuu}icb3 Kgr{}gm
!GDKOC'
=& Libclgxn
[an}
r~mbc}}gn}r c!LDKOC',
r~mbc}}gn}r {i
id cf LDKO
{an rwr{no mkgr{}gm~{nk R
{n}ogfcl c}n
}nclgxc{gif i
ocgf mnfndg{
} {}cfrogrrgi{gifr gf {an g
uirrgmglg{w d
Di~}gn} [}cf
Kgrb}n{n Di
ndgq ugfj
/{i/Cfclij B
s~nfbw
/{i/Kgjg{cl Brog{{n} cfk ]
/IDKO
4& Cuui}{gif
nr {i cuui}{g{nk RB/DK
k RB/DKOC
n c}n {zi
oifj {n}ogfcba {n}ogfc
{}cfrog{ g{r
{}cfrogrrgi
cfkzgk{a& [DKOC gf z
ru}nck itn}
d kgr{}gm~{nk
d KD[R/ID
f rbanon r~fr{cf{cfni~r
i} gfb}ncrnk
rdi}o
}gn} [}cfrdi}
ftn}rgif
ftn}rgifnbngtn} R{}~b{
gfj R~mbc}}gn
fgfj r~mbc}}gC i} Gf{n
!LDKOC'
cuu}icbanr
clr& Gf libclgl ~rnr c r
rwomilr& [a~
f gr bifdgfnk
n cl{n}fc{gtnagba {an r~mb
{an nf{g}n rg
RB/DKOC
O, biouc}nk
a cr IDKO,{}cfrog{ ui
uizn}/coulg
~}n id RB/
r8
n}rlnctnk DK
i cuui}{gifg
gxnk RB/DKn{ id ckhcb
r {an mcfkzg
{i c d}cb{gif
{i LDKOCc}}gn}r ~rnk m
jfcl mcfk&
gr gf{n}lnc
{i
grn},
gn}
C
gfj
Cnf{
k{a
id
grw c
fn
nk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 352
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 119/223
KOC !GD
ns~gkgr{cf{ d} Gf
cuugfj oicllibc{nk itn
an ~f~rnk rc}n ibb~ugnk
libclgxnk r~m
libclgxnk r~m
libclgxnk DKcuugfj oi
!KDKOC'& [
ikn zg{a nsbcllnk Gf{n}ln
DKOC gr c
nddgbgnf{ gf {a
r{}gb{lw gf {an
KD[&D}i
r~mbc}}gn} o
r{c{gb cfk bac
BKR crrgjfrbacffnl d}ns
rbank~lgfj
}itgknr d}nrgjfcl gr ru
kgr{}gm~{nk
n}di}ocfbn&
libclgxnk r~rgjfgdgbcf{ o
zi r~mbc}}gi{an}&
Kgr{}gm~{nCU] gf bcrn
Libclgxnk8
knunfknf{ rbDKOC m~{ rg
gj~}n28 R~m
!2 ~rn}r, 3=rn}'&
g{a }nrunb{
Rwr{no {a
OC' zan}n
o ncba i{an} {an} zcw, g
kn, KD[ i~{an nf{g}n mc
mbc}}gn}r, za mw {an KD[ i
c}}gn} ocuug
bc}}gn} ocuu
C !LDKOkn id RB/D
an bcrn id
~gkgr{cfbn mnctnk DKOC
runbgcl bcrn
c{ {an {}cfro
{gon kiocgf
c }nri~}bn
uugfj on{a
ffnl/knunfkn
r~mbc}}gn}rnfbw }nruif
n{aikr, kgr{
~nfbw kgtn} }nck itn} {
cuugfj, B
Mw bif{}cr{,
mbc}}gn} ocl{g/~rn} kgtn}
gn} ocuugfj
8 D}ns~nfbid GDKOC&
D}ns~nfbw
ank~lgfj, agjgoglc} UCU] {
c}}gn} cllibc{g
r~mbc}}gn}r, c
:& Un}di}oc
i {an {zi och
i~jau~{
ibb~ugnk
P7_&{an kgr{}gm
u~{r id {ankzgk{a zg{a
n}ncr bifrnb~{u~{r id {an
j oikn& Zn
gfj oikn i
' cfk kgr{}gOC cr kgr
? S F di
{znnf ibb~ug!GDKOC' P
id RB/DOK
g{{n} bcf oi
zg{ai~{ {an
cllibc{gif
kr c}n d~}{a
{ rbank~lgfj
{i ~rn}r cbrn id ncba
}gm~{nk r~mb
g{w mnbc~rnan nf{g}n m
R gfb}nonf
BKR gr id j
ugfj mnbc~rg{w&
actn cktcf{
kgtn}rg{w,
rnlnb{gtn jcg
an} UCU] {i {an bcrn id
if on{aikr
k ; r~mbc}}g
fbn Oncr~}nr
i} un}di}ocf
r~mbc}}gn}r
~{nk r~mbc}}
gfu~{ kc{cxn}ir ibb~uwg
{gtn r~mbc}}ggfu~{ kc{c gf
zgll }ndn} {i
RB/DKOC
~{nk r~mbc}} }gm~{nk DK
{an kgr{}gm~
nk r~mbc}}gn}r35_, P33_, P3
cfk g{ gr t
~lc{n {an rgj
~rn id KD[ c
uigf{ id tg
n} kgtgknk g
!BKR' on{ai
bi}kgfj {i~rn}& Di} m
c}}gn} ocuug
{an {}cfrog{fkzgk{a& Z
{cllw gou}i
nc{ mnfndg{ z
n g{ u}itg
cjnr itn} n
lizn}
zg{a bacf
cf {an bcrnKDKOC&
i} o~l{guln ~
n}r cllibc{nk
8
bn gfkgbc{i}r,
c}n
gn}
c}nfj
n}ran
an
cr
gn} C
nk
gr=_&
}w
cl
fk
z,
{i
kr&
an{a
fj
nkg{a
nr
g{a
nr
ba
nl
id
rn}r
un}
UCU]
:&3 Rwr{no [
Zagln UCU] gfdi}oc{gif
gfkgbc{i} id {a}i~jau~{ gf
gfdi}oc{gif r
Zg{a }nrunb{
kn{n}ogfnr {acjcgfr{ d}ns
gfdi}oc{gif g
[an}ndi}n g{If {an i{an
o~l{g/~rn} k
rnlnb{gtn dckg
ui}{gif id {a
{}cfrogrrgif~rn} kgtn}rg{
kgrun}rnk {}c
knunfknf{ r
}ns~g}nr {an rd~fb{gif id
r~mbc}}gn} c
d}ns~nfbw }nrDi}
oncr~}nr zg{
bacffnl knun
nfjgfnn}gfj rknrgjf uc}co
{an liznr{[an}ndi}n ns
~rn {ang} h~kjrunbgdgb fnnk
ocfw ~rn}r n
mn{{n} idd zg{rwr{no zg{a c
:&= UCU] cf
[an UC] gr k
mlib` !ifn Irgjfcl uizn
kgr{}gm~{gif g
gfr{cf{cfni~rkgr{}gm~{gifrtc}gc{gifr id
RB/
IDKOC, z{}cfrdi}onk {
{a}i~ja IDK
~rn}r r{norkgddn}nf{ r~m
{an bcrn id Igr c rgfjln
biouc}nk {i
o~l{gbc}}gn} rg
}i~jau~{8
gr c ochi} b{a}i~jau~{ g
rwr{no un} RB/DKOC
omilr c}n cu
{i goo~fg{w
}i~jau~{',kgr~nfbw rnln
r ru}nck cb
ddn}r {an cktacfk, LDK
gtn}rg{w gf
j gd g{ crrgjf
rgjfcl mcfk
bac}cb{n}gr{gb}nlgnr if
frog{{n}r&P32
bank~lgfj !
wr{no {i oid}ns~nfbw di
rgjfonf{r {
ifrnr id cll {ncba bifdgj~
a r{c{gb r~m
knf{ rbank~l
r{nor {an}nn{n}r cfk un}
CU] {nfkguonf{ knrgj
onf{ {i dgfk& Di} nqcoul
cba {}cfrog{{
GDKOC, zdnz agja/mg{/
lwrgr id RB/D
ndgfnk cr {an
DKO rwomi& G{ rai~lk
r fi{ {an rc
{}cfrog{ctn id{nf mnDKO&
KOC bcf
an}n {goni d}ns~nfbw
OC oik~lc{g
d}io {an d
c}}gn}r gf {an
KOC& Mnbcbc}}gn} rgjfc
{an bcrn id
jfcl&
ifbn}f gf uir cf ntnf
di}ocfbn& Cnunfkr if {a
ulgnk {i r~mbc
{i {}cfrogrrg
{}gm~{nk RB/b{gtn dckgfj
irr {an nf{g
cf{cjn id d}nsOC bcf ui{
{an u}nrnfbn
r ncba ~rn} {i
zan}n {ac{ ~r
r !agja bacffgfknunfknf{
_ G{ clri }n
KR' id r~
g{i} {an bac} ncba {n}og
i bacfjnr g
an {n}ogfclr&c{gif, zn u}
c}}gn} crrgjf
lgfj& Zn dgfk
}n bioulnq {} i}ocfbn& Bi
{i actn lin}r cfk rwr{
{an mnr{ {}cknn, zn dgfk {a
gfj c{ c oik
gln LDKOC}c{n ~rn}r&
KOC8
unc` uizn}
l' fi}oclgxnkmn fi{nk
n cr {an kgr
uizn}& Agrf ~rnk {i gll
mn }njc}knk
kiocgf kc{iocgf mw K
gif& [an i}{a
b{ {ac{ ncba
d}ns~nfbw k
rn {an itn}cll, UCU] gr
IDKOC z
{cmln {n}ogfoi}n goui}{
r gf IDKn zcw gf za
}}gn}r&
f n}}i}r !za
KOC gr }immnbc~rn
}n rgjfcl mc
~nfbw kgtn}rgnf{gcllw cbag
id d}ns~n
r~mbc}}gn}r g
n} acr dcti}c
nl jcgf'& O~dckgfj co
s~g}nr bacff
mbc}}gn}r& B
fnl s~clg{w cgfcl, cfk ck
f {an bacf
rnf{ {a}i~ja
nf{r cfk
{ac{ cr gf i{
ckniddr mn{zdgj~}c{gifr
n} {a}i~jauo iun}c{i}r
idd {i onn{ {a{ c rwr{no
n}c{n mg{ }c{n
i}`r mn{{n} g
g{agf ifn GK
mw {an ctn} {ac{ {an U
{}gm~{gif id
i}gbcllw, Ur{}c{n {an ui
cr KD[/ru}
rwomilr[ mndi}n jig
ijifclg{w id
~rn} ibb~u
ocgf, rgoglc}
l {}cfrog{ rgjgfan}nf{lw l
gba u}ik~bn
lr,cf{
C,gba
gba
~r{g{r
k&
g{w&tn
bw
f c
mln
l{g/fj
nl/
KR
r ccu{
fnl
~{
g{a
an}
nfg{a
~{&cf
ng} g{a
gr
f c
D[
jn]
{an
] n}
ck
c}ngfj
{an
gnr
{i
fcliz
c
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 35;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 120/223
Agja UCU] }ns~g}nr nqunfrgtn cfk gfnddgbgnf{ uizn} coulgdgn}r zg{a agja }ns~g}nonf{r if lgfnc}g{w,zagba gfb}ncrnr {an bir{ id {an {n}ogfcl cfk clri k}cgfr
{an mc{{n}w dcr{n}&RB/DKOC riltnr {agr u}imlno mwj}i~ugfj {ijn{an} {an }nri~}bn mlib`r gf r~ba c zcw {ac{}nk~bnr {an fnnk di} lgfnc}g{w, cfk ri uizn} bifr~ou{gif, gf {an uizn} coulgdgn}& C liz UCU] clrigou}itnr bitn}cjn cfk {an bnll/nkjn un}di}ocfbn&Gf {agr rnb{gif, zn cfclwxn {an UCU] id {an RB/DKOCrgjfcl& Zn crr~on {ac{ {an {i{cl f~omn} id r~mbc}}gn}r grO ? S º F, zan}n F gr {an f~omn} id r~mbc}}gn}r un} mlib`& [an gf{njn} S gr {an ocqgo~o f~omn} id {n}ogfclr {ac{ bcf {}cfrog{ rgo~l{cfni~rlw& Di} kgr{}gm~{nk r~mbc}}gn} ocuugfj, zn bifrgkn} {an bcrn id GDKOC zg{a r~mbc}}gn}r ns~cllw rucbnk itn} {an rwr{no mcfkzgk{a&
[an unc` uizn} id cfw rgjfcl q!{ ' gr {anocqgo~o id g{r rs~c}nk nftnliun P q!{'_V=& Aizntn}, di} c bif{gf~i~r }cfkio u}ibnrr, ocq P q!{'_V= bi~lk mn~fmi~fknk& Ntnf di} }cfkio u}ibnrr zg{a kgrb}n{ntcl~nr zan}n ocq P q!{'_V= gr mi~fknk, g{ ocw ibb~} c{tn}w liz u}imcmglg{w zagba gr fi{ tn}w ~rnd~l gf u}cb{gbn&]c{an}, {an kgr{}gm~{gif id P q!{'_V= gr oi}n ~rnd~l cfk znknrb}gmn g{ zg{a {an bioulnonf{c}w b~{/idd u}imcmglg{w&
[an UCU] gr kndgfnk cr {an }c{gi id unc` uizn} {i ctn}cjn uizn} id {an {}cfrog{{nk rgjfcl gf c jgtnf{}cfrogrrgif mlib`& Zg{ai~{ u~lrn racugfj, {ac{ gr, ~rgfj}nb{cfj~lc} u~lrn racugfj, rwomil }c{n rcoulgfj zglljgtn {an rcon UCU] cr {an bif{gf~i~r {gon kiocgf bcrnrgfbn cf RB/DKOC rgjfcl gr oik~lc{nk itn} c rgfjln
bc}}gn}&[i ntcl~c{n UCU] id gfkgtgk~cl rwr{no
bifdgj~}c{gifr, zn actn rgo~lc{nk {an {}cfrogrrgif id 35> mlib`r id rwomilr& Cd{n} bclb~lc{gfj UCU] di} ncba mlib`, zn u}nrnf{ {an kc{c cr cf noug}gbcl BBKD!Bioulnonf{c}w B~o~lc{gtn Kgr{}gm~{gif D~fb{gif'& [anBBKD gr {an u}imcmglg{w {ac{ UCU] gr agjan} {acf cbn}{cgf UCU] tcl~n UCU] ж !U} pUCU] 6 UCU] ж'&Zn clri }nlc{n {an UCU] {i ]D {}cfrog{ uizn} coulgdgn} nddgbgnfbw& Gf cf gkncl lgfnc} uizn} coulgdgn} zan}nlgfnc} coulgdgbc{gif gr cbagntnk ~u {i {an rc{~}c{gif uigf{, ocqgo~o uizn} nddgbgnfbw gr cbagntnk zanf {ancoulgdgn} gr iun}c{gfj c{ {an rc{~}c{gif uigf{& [i u}ntnf{
kgr{i}{gif gf {an u}nrnfbn id UCU], {}cfrog{ uizn} mcb`idd gr fnnknk {i iun}c{n {an uizn} coulgdgn} gf {anlgfnc} }njgif& RB/DKOC rgjfclr gfknnk actn lizn} UCU] {acf IDKOC rgjfclr& Clri, LDKOC gfb~}ragjan} UCU] biouc}nk {i GDKOC m~{, biouc}nk {iIDKOC0 g{ gr lizn}, {ai~ja fi{ rgjfgdgbcf{lw& Cfi{an} fi{gbncmln dcb{ gr {ac{ u~lrn racugfj rgjfgdgbcf{lwgfb}ncrnr {an UCU] id GDKOC& C u~lrn racugfj dgl{n} rai~lk mn knrgjfnk bc}nd~llw gf i}kn} {i lgog{ {an UCU] zg{ai~{ knj}ckgfj {an rwr{no un}di}ocfbn& Gf jnfn}cl,GDKOC gr oi}n knrg}cmln {acf LDKOC gf {n}or id UCU] cfk uizn} nddgbgnfbw&
1& Bacffnl/Knunfknf{ Rbank~lgfj !BKR' di} ^ulgf` RB/DKOC8
BKR crrgjfr r~mbc}}gn}r {i ~rn}r cbbi}kgfj {i {anbacffnl d}ns~nfbw }nruifrn id ncba ~rn}& C `nw s~nr{gifid BKR gr aiz zn rai~lk cllibc{n {gon cfk d}ns~nfbw}nri~}bnr dcg}lw coifj ~rn}r zagln cbagntgfj o~l{g/~rn} kgtn}rg{w cfk d}ns~nfbw rnlnb{gtn kgtn}rg{w& [i ki ri, zngf{}ik~bn ~{glg{w/mcrnk rbank~lgfj zan}n ~{glg{w gr cfnbifiogb bifbnu{ }nu}nrnf{gfj lntnl id rc{grdcb{gif& znbifrgkn} {zi kgddn}nf{ ~{glg{w d~fb{gifr8 cjj}njc{n ~rn} {a}i~jau~{ di} ocqgogxgfj rwr{no bcucbg{w cfkcjj}njc{n lijc}g{aogb ~rn} {a}i~jau~{ di} ocqgogxgfj u}iui}{gifcl dcg}fnrr P3;_,P3>_& [an imhnb{gtn gr {i dgfkcf iu{go~o ba~f` crrgjfonf{ di} cll ~rn}r gf i}kn} {iocqgogxn {an r~o id ~rn} ~{glg{w c{ ncba {}cfrog{ {gongf{n}tcl ![[G'& Gd {an ~rn} {a}i~jau~{ gr }njc}knk cr {an~{glg{w d~fb{gif, {an }nri~}bn cllibc{gif ocqgogxnr }c{n/r~o bcucbg{w gjfi}gfj dcg}fnrr coifj ~rn}r& [an}ndi}n,iflw {an ~rn}r fnc} {an mcrn r{c{gif zai actn {an mnr{bacffnl bifkg{gifr ibb~uw oir{ id {an }nri~}bnr& If {ani{an} acfk, rn{{gfj {an lijc}g{aogb ~rn} kc{c }c{n cr {an~{glg{w d~fb{gif u}itgknr u}iui}{gifcl dcg}fnrr&
Gf bifrgkn}gfj {an iu{gogxc{gif u}imlno id BKRdi} o~l{gbc}}gn} o~l{guln cbbnrr, g{ gr {ani}n{gbcllw uirrgmln {i crr~on {ac{ {an rbank~ln} bcf crrgjfr~mbc}}gn}r gfkgtgk~cllw& Cllibc{gfj gfkgtgk~clr~mbc}}gn}r gr, aizntn}, c u}iagmg{gtnlw bioulnqbiomgfc{i}gcl iu{gogxc{gif u}imlno gf rwr{nor zg{a =>4r~mbc}}gn}r cfk if {an i}kn} id {nf {n}ogfclr {}cfrog{{gfj
rgo~l{cfni~rlw& Oi}nitn}, crrgjfgfj r~mbc}}gn}rgfkgtgk~cllw zi~lk gf{}ik~bn ~fcbbnu{cmln bif{}ilrgjfclgfj itn}anck& Gf u}cb{gbn, {an ~fg{r id }nri~}bncllibc{gif c}n ba~f`r, zagba c}n kgrhigf{ rn{r id r~mbc}}gn}r& Cr c u}cb{gbcl oc{{n} ba~f`/mcrnk{}cfrogrrgif gr knrg}cmln rgfbn {an gfu~{ kc{c rwomilr c}nj}i~unk gf{i c mlib` di} KD[ iun}c{gif mndi}n r~mbc}}gn} ocuugfj& Zg{a }njc}kr {i ba~f` r{}~b{~}n, {an}n gr c}nr{}gb{gif if ba~f` rnlnb{gif di} GDKOC r~ba {ac{ cllcrrgjfnk r~mbc}}gn}r rai~lk mn ns~gkgr{cf{ gf i}kn} {iocgf{cgf {an liznr{ UCU] P34_&
Ntnf zg{a r~mbc}}gn}r crrgjfnk gf ba~f`r,iu{go~o rbank~lgfj gr nq{}nonlw bioulnq di} {zi
}ncrifr8 [an imhnb{gtn d~fb{gif gr bioulgbc{nk, bifrgr{gfj id fiflgfnc} cfk kgrb}n{n bifr{}cgf{r knunfknf{ if {anbiomgfnk bacffnl jcgfr id {an crrgjfnk r~mbc}}gn}r0 cfk [an}n gr c {i{cl {}cfrog{ uizn} bifr{}cgf{ di} ncba~rn}&
Gfr{nck id kg}nb{lw riltgfj {an iu{gogxc{gif u}imlno, c r~m/iu{gocl ba~f` cllibc{gif rbanon bcf mn~rnk di} mi{a GDKOC cfk LDKOC {i im{cgf oir{ id {an mnfndg{r id BKR& Di} LDKOC, c j}nnkw ba~f` rnlnb{gifon{aik bcf mn cuulgnk zan}n ncba ba~f` gr crrgjfnk {i{an ~rn} zai bcf ocqgogxn {an oc}jgfcl ~{glg{w zanfibb~uwgfj {an runbgdgb ba~f`& Di} GDKOC, {an mnfndg{ id
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 35>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 121/223
o~l{g/~rn} kgtn}rg{w bcf mn cbagntnk mw rnlnb{gfj ~rn}r gfi}kn} id {an nr{goc{nk oc}jgfcl ~{glg{w mcrnk if {anctn}cjn bacffnl bifkg{gif itn} {an nf{g}n rn{ id
r~mbc}}gn}r& [an ~rn}r zg{a agjan} bacffnl jcgfr ocwibb~uw c lc}jn} f~omn} id ba~f`r {acf ~rn}r zg{a lizn} bacffnl jcgfr P3:_&
[an cktcf{cjn id bacffnl knunfknf{ rbank~lgfjitn} }i~fk }imgf rbank~lgfj gfb}ncrnr cr {an f~omn} id ~rn}r gfb}ncrnr& [agr gr mnbc~rn {an rbank~ln} rnlnb{r {anblirn} ~rn}r zai bcf {}cfrog{ c{ agjan} kc{c }c{n& Gd {an}nc}n oi}n ~rn}r, {an uirrgmglg{w id libc{gfj ~rn}r c{ blirn} kgr{cfbn {i {an mcrn r{c{gif gfb}ncrnr& Cr c }nr~l{, {anBKR cbagntnr rgjfgdgbcf{ gou}itnonf{r di} mi{a GDKOCcfk LDKOC& Gf {an bcrn id lijc}g{aogb }c{n ~{glg{w, {anBKR jcgf r{iur gfb}ncrgfj mnwifk cuu}iqgoc{nlw 2=~rn}r& Zg{a 2= ~rn}r, ocqgogxgfj lijc}g{aogb }c{n ~{glg{wbcf gfb}ncrn rwr{no bcucbg{w mw c dcb{i} id 3&1 di} LDKOC cfk 3&=4 di} GDKOC }nlc{gtn&
[i r{c{gb rbank~lgfj& {an BKR rbanon mcrnk if{an lijc}g{ao id ~rn} {a}i~jau~{ cr c ~{glg{w d~fb{gif u}itgknr u}iui}{gifcl dcg}fnrr zairn jcgfr c}n rac}nkcoifj cll ~rn}r, zan}ncr {an BKR jcgfr c}n bifbnf{}c{nk{i {an ~rn}r fnc} {an mcrn r{c{gif zanf {an ~rn} {a}i~jau~{ gr bifrgkn}nk cr {an ~{glg{w d~fb{gif&
Di} r{c{gb r~mbc}}gn} crrgjfonf{ !}i~fk }imgfrbank~lgfj', c rwr{no zg{a ~rn}r ncba {}cfrog{{gfj c{ coikn}c{n kc{c }c{n gr mn{{n} idd zg{a GDKOC zaglnLDKOC zi}`r mn{{n} gf c rwr{no zg{a c dnz agja kc{n}c{n ~rn}r& K~n {i {an cktcf{cjnr id lizn} i~{cjn u}imcmglg{w cfk lizn} UCU], GDKOC gr cf c{{}cb{gtn
cuu}icba {i r{c{gb r~mbc}}gn} rbank~lgfj& Di} bacffnl/knunfknf{ rbank~lgfj, LDKOC acr {an ui{nf{gcl di} bifrgkn}cmlw agjan} kc{c }c{n& [an }nr~l{r raiz {ac{ BKRgfb}ncrnr rwr{no {a}i~jau~{ mw ~u {i 15. }nlc{gtn {ir{c{gb rbank~lgfj di} LDKOC m~{ {an gfb}ncrn gr iflw=4. di} GDKOC& [an rbank~lgfj jcgfr gf LDKOC bcf mn nqulig{nk {i }nk~bn uizn} bifr~ou{gif cfk UCU] mw~rgfj uizn} bif{}il {i nr{cmlgra c uizn} oc}jgf gfr{nckid gfb}ncrgfj rwr{no bcucbg{w&
7& RB/DKOC Tr& IDKOC8
Biouc}grif r{~kw mn{znnf RB/DKOC cfk IDKOC bcf mn kifn gf {zi zcwr Rgoglc}g{gnr Kgrrgoglc}g{gnr Mlib` Kgcj}co&
7&3 Rgoglc}g{gnr8 Mlib`/mcrnk oik~lc{gif& Kgtgknr {an {}cfrogrrgif mcfkzgk{a gf{i roclln} r~mbc}}gn}r& Bacffnl ns~clgxc{gif gr kifn gf {an d}ns~nfbwkiocgf&
BU gr ckknk {i itn}bion GMG !Gf{n}/Mlib` Gf{n}dn}nfbn' cfk {i biftn}{ lgfnc} biftil~{gif id {anbacffnl gou~lrn }nruifrn {i bg}b~lc} ifn&
RB/DKOC bcf mn }njc}knk cr KD[/u}nbiknk i} KD[/ru}nck IDKOC&
7&= Kgrrgoglc}g{gnr8[an iflw kgddn}nfbn gr {an u}nrnfbn id {an KD[ gf RB/DKOC& Di} {agr }ncrif RBDKOC gr rion{gonr }ndn}}nk{i cr KD[/ru}nck i} KD[/u}nbiknk IDKOC& Gf {n}or id kc{c kn{nb{gif c{ {an }nbngtn}, IDKOC un}di}or g{ if c un}/r~mbc}}gn} mcrgr zan}ncr RB/DKOC kinr g{ cd{n} ckkg{gifcl GKD[ iun}c{gif& Mnbc~rn id {agr kgddn}nfbn,IDKOC gr oi}n rnfrg{gtn {i c f~ll gf {an bacffnlrunb{}~o cfk g{ }ns~g}nr bacffnl bikgfj i} uizn})}c{nbif{}il {i itn}bion {agr kndgbgnfbw& Clri, {an k~}c{gif id {an oik~lc{nk {gon rwomilr c}n nqucfknk gf {an bcrn id IDKOC zg{a uc}cllnl {}cfrogrrgif id {an kc{c mlib` k~}gfj {an nlifjc{nk {gon un}gik zan}ncr RB/DKOCoik~lc{nk rwomilr c}n biou}nrrnk gf{i roclln} bagurzg{a rn}gcl {}cfrogrrgif id {an kc{c mlib`, o~ba lg`n ckg}nb{ rns~nfbn bikn kgtgrgif o~l{guln cbbnrr !KR/BKOC' rwr{no&
7&=&3 Bacffnl ns~clgxc{gif8 IDKOC8 Un} r~mbc}}gn} kn{nb{gif&?6C F~ll gfbacffnl runb{}~o rntn}nlw knj}cknr {an rwr{no un}di}ocfbn& 6Bacffnl bikgfj i} uizn})}c{n bif{}il gr}ns~g}nk RB/DKOC8 Kn{nb{gif cd{n} GKD[& 6RF] gr
ctn}cjnk i~{ itn} nf{g}n mcfkzgk{a&
7&=&= [gon kiocgf rwomil k~}c{gif8 IDKOC8 Oik~lc{nk rwomil k~}c{gif gr lifjn} {acfgfu~{ kc{c rwomil k~}c{gif& RB/DKOC8 Oik~lc{nk rwomil k~}c{gif gr rai}{n} {acfgfu~{ kc{c rwomil k~}c{gif&
7&=&2 UCUN]8 IDKOC8 Uc}cllnl {}cfrogrrgif id kc{c itn} o~l{gulnbc}}gn}r& Agja UCU]& RB/DKOC8 Rn}gcl {}cfrogrrgif id kc{c itn} rgfjlnbc}}gn}& ?6Liz UCU]&
7&2 Kc{c Rwomilr Kgcj}co8
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 354
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 122/223
g
g
gj~}n ;8 B
}cfrog{{gfj c
35& Ck
Rgfjln bc}}gn}
gf zagba {ankiocgf, zagb
RB/DKOC a
cl{n}fc{gtn {
bioo~fgbc{g
imgln {n}oggr b~}}nf{lw
cbbnrr rbano
tiltnk [] Liz UC
Liz rnfr
zi~lk lg` }idnrri} K}&
cfk nfbi~}cj
RB/DKOC gr ulgf` bioo
bc}}gn} DKO
rbanon {ac{ ulgf`& RB/D
d}ns~nfbw k
n}di}ocfbn
iouc}grif i
rn}gnr id SU
tcf{cjn id R
DKOC !RB/
kc{c rwomila }nr~l{r gf c
33&
cr k}czf j}
i IDKOC,
fr zan}n li
cl gf {n}or izi}`gfj cr
n gf 2JUU Li
C&]
g{gtg{w {i bc}}g
CB@FIZ
{i {acf` Oiak& A~rr
onf{&
3=& BIF
c u}iogrgfjfgbc{gif gf d
!RB/DKO
gr b~}}nf{lwOC ~{glgxnr
iocgf ns~c
fk nrrnf{gcll
d IDKOC
@ kc{c rwom
DKOC itn}
KOC' gr c t
r c}n oik~li}n uizn} n
^rcjn8
c{ c{{nf{gif
nrunbgcllw
n} UCU] j}n
{}cfrog{ ui~ou{gif di}
fj [n}o Nti
n} d}ns~nfbw
NKJNONF
w iddgbgclcgf di} cll {a
BL^RGIF8
{nbafgs~n di{~}n bnll~lc}
' gr c fnz
ngfj ckiu{nrgfjln bc}}gn}
lgxc{gif, cf
{an rcon it
cfk RB/DK
lr
IDKOC8
c}gcf{ id ID
{nk gf {an {gdgbgnf{ rbano
cr cf c{{}cb{g
gf {an ~ulg
c{lw mnfndg{r
n} nddgbgnfbw~ulgf` o~l{g
l~{gif !L[N',
iddrn{
r~un}tgri}r cng} anlu, cktg
} agja kc{c } rwr{nor& Rgf
o~l{guln cbb
gf 2JUU Loik~lc{gif c
acr rgog
n}cll bioulnq
C
O
nn&
gtn
f`
an
& G{ln
i}
fkgbn
c{nln
nrr
Nfk
lc}
g{w
cr {airn id
mnfndg{{gcl di uizn} nddgbgn
Zg{abifdgj~}c{gif
baigbnr {ac{ cgr raizf {a
UCU] biou
dib~rnk if
{a}i~jau~{ cCoifj {an u
dgfk {ac{ li
knunfknf{ rb{acf gf{n}lnct
un}di}ocfbn
id LDKOC&
Zan
{i bif{}il cfc}}izn} kgd
{n}or id UCU
{ac{ u~lrn rac
gf {an bcrnrgjfgdgbcf{ go
dgl{n} rai~lk
UCU] zg{ai~Zi}` gf u}i
bacffnl nr{go
id RB/DKOC
gfdi}oc{gifbacffnlr lgf`g
Bacffnl nr{gcfk bacfjnr
{an un}di}ocid {an oik~l
r~mbc}}gn}r {i
&
P3_& ]& tc
Bioo~fgbc{gifr
P=_& Aw~f
“Rgfjln Bc}}gn} Tnagb~lc} [nbaf
P2_& A& N
Uc}`tcll, H& [i}r
Lifj/[n}o Ntil=554, uu& 21/;>&
P;_& N& K
@c}lrrif, O&
Ntil~{gif / ]ck
GNNN Tnagb~lcOnlmi~}fn, C~r{
P>_& Lifj
znmrg{n, zzz&2j
P4_& A~h~f
C M}ickmcfk Zg
=554 !GNNN'8 uu&
P:_& Hgcfz
cfk ]cfkcll C& M
IDKOC r
{an oimglnbw cfk ocf~
gf c ru{an}n c}n
ddnb{ un}di}o{ RB/DKOC
c}nk IDKO
{an nddnb{r
k unc`/{i cirrgmln r~mbc
clgxnk DKO
nk~lgfj !BKnk DKOC !G
id GDKOC gr
f zn bifrgkn
khcbnf{ bacfn}nfbn mn{z
] un}di}ocf
ugfj gfb}ncrn
id }cgrnk/b ucb{ if UCU
n knrgjfnk b
{ knj}ckgfj {a}nrr gr cf g
c{gif n}}i} i
& Nddnb{gtn rb
mi~{ {an d}nfj {n}ogfclr
c{gif n}}i}rgf bacffnl u
bn id BKR m{gif {nbafgs~
~rn}r
]NDN
Fnn cfk ]& U}c
, C}{nba Ai~rn, =
J& Ow~fj, H~
DKOC di} ^ulijw Ocjcxgfn,
`r{}ôo, C& D~}
n}, cfk O& Zcal
l~{gif,‟ GNNN B
alocf, A& N`
~fkntcll, cfk
gi Gf{n}dcbn Bif
} [nbafilijw}clgc, Ocw =554&
[n}o Ntil~{gif
uu&i}j)Agjalgja{
Wgf cfk Rgctcr
}nlnrr Cbbnrr [n3‒;& kig835&335
ng A~cfj, Tghcw
n}}w, “Kizflgf`
wr{no&RB/DK
{n}ogfcl gf {dcb{~}gfj bir{
bgdgb RB/Dcfw knrgjf
cfbn gf c birgjfclr gfk
& Gf {agr
id r~mbc}}g
tn}cjn uizn}gn} ocuugfj
C !LDKOC'
' }nr~l{r gf agKOC'& Ai
mn{{n} mw ; {
} {an u~lrn ra
nl gf{n}dn}nnf LDKOC
bn& Cfi{an} f
UCU] cfk {
irgfn u~lrnid GDKOC&
c}nd~llw gf i}
n rwr{no un}d tnr{gjc{gif
{an {a}i~ja
ank~lgfj knu
~nfbw }nrui{i cf RB/DK
}n bc~rnk mw}iun}{gnr& [a
bc~rgfj gfbn cfk gfbi}}n
NFBNR
rck, IDKO di}
555&
fr~fj Lgo, cfk
lgf` Zg}nlnrr [til& 3, fi& 2, Rnu
~r`ë}, H& @c}lrr
stgr{,“[nbafgbcl
ioo~f& Ocj&,
{}ôo, C& D~}~
R& Uc}`tcll,“[
bnu{r cfk Un}di
Bifdn}nfbn !T
d {an 2JUU }ckg
r)L[N)L[N&a{o&
Clcoi~{g !C~j
bafilijw-& GNNN
)RC]FID&=554&
J& R~m}cocfgc
Rbank~lgfj cfk
OC gr j}n
}or id {}cfr&
KOC rwr{cfk iun}c{gi
ulnq ocffn} nk actn li
cun}, zn a
} ocuugfj
}c{gi !UCUcuu}icbanr,
zg{a bacff
gjan} {a}i~jantn}, {an UC
: kM {acf {
cugfj fnbnrr
bn, zn dgfkcfk GDKOC
i{gbncmln dcb
c{ }ill idd dcb
racugfj acrC u~lrn racug
n} {i }nk~bn
i}ocfbn&d {an goucb{
~{ un}di}oc
fkr if cbb~}
rn id {an }cC mcrn r{c{g
figrw nr{goc{gn}}i}r knj}
}}nb{ ckcu{c{gb{ crrgjfonf{
g}nlnrr O~l{go
Kctgk H& Jiik
}cfrogrrgif‟, G& =554, uu& 25/21
if, O& Onwn},
Ril~{gifr di} {an
til& ;;, fi& 2,
`ë}, W& Hckgfj
n 2J Lifj/[
ocfbn Ntcl~c{g
B' =554 Ru}
{nbafilijw,‟ 2
r{ =55:'& -IDK
Rc}fidd Rwouirg
&;>2;::2&
f, ]chnnt Cj}c
]nri~}bn Cllibc
{lw
g{
nofcl
& G{n}
tn
if
]'&zn
nl/
~{U]
ac{
c}w
cgf
gr
{i}
cgfj
{an
id
bn
c{n
kgiif&
gifkn
gifid
kgc
cf,
NN&
R&
2J
c}&
, H&
n}o
f,‟
gfj,
UU
C8
~o,
cl,
gif
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 35:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 123/223
di} IDKO Rwr{nor‟, GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr if Zg}nlnrr Bioo~fgbc{gif,Til& 1, Fi& 3,Hcf~c}w =557&P1_& Nllgfc Di~{n`itc,Uc{}gb` Cjwcuifj, cfk Ac}clk Accr“Bacffnl Crwoon{}w gf Bnll~lc} IDKOC/[KK Fn{zi}`r‟, N^]CRGU
Hi~}fcl if Zg}nlnrr Bioo~fgbc{gifr cfk Fn{zi}`gfj, Ib{imn}‗ =551&P7_& ^& Ri}jn}, G& Kn M}inb`, cfk O& Rbafnll, “Gf{n}lnctnkDKOC‛C Fnz Ru}nck/Runb{}~o O~l{guln/Cbbnrr Rbanon,‟ U}ib&
GNNN GBB ‑71, C{lcf{c, JC, uu&3532‒353:, H~fn 3771&P35_& ]& Kgfgr, K& Dclbifn}, B& [& Lco, cfk O& Rcmmcjagcf, “CO~l{guln Cbbnrr Rbanon di} {an ^ulgf` id M}ickmcfk Zg}nlnrrRwr{nor,‟ U}ib& GNNN JLIMNBIO ‗5;, til& 4, Kcllcr, [Q, Knb& =55;,
uu& 2151/213=&P33_& ^& Ri}jn}, G& Kn M}inb`, cfk O& Rbafnll, “Gf{n}lnctnkDKOC / C Fnz Ru}nck/Runb{}~o O~l{guln/Cbbnrr Rbanon,‟ U}ib&GNNN GBB ‗71, C{lcf{c, JC, H~f& 3771, uu& 3532/353:&P3=_& O& Rbafnll cfk G& Kn M}inb`, “Cuulgbc{gif id GDKOC {iOimgln ]ckgi [}cfrogrrgif,‟ U}ib& GNNN 3771 Gf{n}fc{gifclBifdn}nfbn if ^fgtn}rcl Un}rifcl Bioo~fgbc{gifr !GB^UB *71',Dli}nfbn, G{clw, Ib{& 3771, uu& 3=4:/3=:=&P32_& Lg/Ba~f Zcfj, cfk Cfkn}rif Banf, “Iu{gocl ]ckgi]nri~}bn Uc}{g{gif di} Higf{ Bif{nf{gifcfk Biffnb{gif/I}gnf{nk
O~l{gbacffnl Cbbnrr gf IDKOC Rwr{nor‟, GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr ifOimgln Biou~{gfj, Til& 1, Fi& =, Dnm}~c}w =557&P3;_& J& Rifj cfk W& Lg, “B}irr/lcwn} Iu{gogxc{gif di} IDKOCZg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`r/Uc}{GG8 Clji}g{ao Kntnliuonf{,‟ GNNN Zg}nlnrrBioo~f&, til& ;, uu& 4=>‒42;, Oc}&=55>&P3>_& X& Acf, X& Hg, cfk @& Lg~, “Dcg} O~l{g~rn} BacffnlCllibc{gif di} IDKOC Fn{zi}`r ^rgfj Fcra Mc}jcgfgfj Ril~{gifrcfk Biclg{gifr,‟ GNNN [}cfr& if Bioo~f&,uu& 3244‒32:4, C~j& =55>&P34_& ]& Kgfgr, K& Dclbifn}, B&[& Lco, cfk O& Rcmmcjagcf, “CO~l{guln Cbbnrr Rbanon di} {an ^ulgf` id M}ickmcfk Zg}nlnrrRwr{nor,‟ U}ib& GNNN JLIMNBIO ‗5;, til&4, Kcllcr, [Q, uu& 2151‒ 213=, Knb& =55;&P3:_& H& Lgo, A&J& Ow~fj, cfk K&H& Jiikocf, “U}iui}{gifcl Dcg} Rbank~lgfj id ^ulgf` Rgfjln/Bc}}gn} DKOC Rwr{nor,‟ {i mn u}nrnf{nkc{ [an 3:{a Cff~cl GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Rwouirg~o if Un}rifcl, Gfkii} cfk Oimgln ]ckgi Bioo~fgbc{gifr !UGO]B‑54', Anlrgf`g, Dgflcfk,Rnu& =554&P31_& zzz&jiijln&bioP37_& rzzz&zg`gunkgc&bio
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 351
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 124/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35&¥:21:=)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35&¥:21:=
Rgo~lc{gif id CIKT ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil
Cragra Bac~}crgc
Crr{&U}idnrri}
Jwcf Jcfjc Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw $ Rbgnfbnr , Hcmclu~}
Cmr{}cb{ / [an j}iz{a id lcu{iur cfk 15=&33)Zg/Dg zg}nlnrr
fn{zi}`gfj actn ockn OCFN[r c uiu~lc} }nrnc}ba
{iugb rgfbn {an ogk/ {i lc{n 3775r& Ocfw cbcknogb ucun}r
ntcl~c{n u}i{ibilr cfk cmglg{gnr crr~ogfj tc}wgfj knj}nnr id
oimglg{w zg{agf c mi~fknk rucbn, ~r~cllw zg{a cll fiknr
zg{agf c dnz aiur id ncba i{an} cfk ~r~cllw zg{a fiknr
rnfkgfj kc{c c{ c bifr{cf{ }c{n& Kgddn}nf{ u}i{ibilr c}n {anf
ntcl~c{nk mcrnk if {an ucb`n{ k}iu }c{n, {an itn}anck
gf{}ik~bnk mw {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil, cfk i{an} oncr~}nr& Gf {agr ucun} zn c}n oncr~}gfj {an {a}i~jau~{ id
CIKT u}i{ibil gf kgddn}nf{ rbnfc}gir&
& @nwzi}kr8 OCFN[, Zg/Dg, }i~{gfj, {a}i~jau~{, zg}nlnrr
fn{zi}`
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
C Oimgln Ck aib FN[zi}` !OCFN[',
rion{gonr bcllnk c oimgln onra fn{zi}`, gr c rnld/
bifdgj~}gfj fn{zi}` id oimgln kntgbnr biffnb{nk mw
zg}nlnrr lgf`r& Ncba kntgbn gf c OCFN[ gr d}nn {i oitn
gfknunfknf{lw gf cfw kg}nb{gif, cfk zgll {an}ndi}n
bacfjn g{r lgf`r {i i{an} kntgbnr d}ns~nf{lw& Ncba o~r{
di}zc}k {}cddgb ~f}nlc{nk {i g{r izf ~rn, cfk {an}ndi}n mnc }i~{n}& [an u}goc}w bacllnfjn gf m~glkgfj c
OCFN[ gr ns~guugfj ncba kntgbn {i bif{gf~i~rlw
ocgf{cgf {an gfdi}oc{gif }ns~g}nk {i u}iun}lw }i~{n {}cddgb&
R~ba fn{zi}`r ocw iun}c{n mw {anornltnr i} ocw mn
biffnb{nk {i {an lc}jn} Gf{n}fn{&OCFN[r c}n c `gfk id
zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}`rP3_P4_ {ac{ ~r~cllw acr c
}i~{ncmln fn{zi}`gfj nftg}ifonf{ if {iu id c Lgf` Lcwn}
ck aib fn{zi}`& [anw c}n clri c {wun id onra fn{zi}`,
m~{ ocfw onra fn{zi}`r c}n fi{ oimgln i} fi{ zg}nlnrr&
3&3 Oimgln Ck/aib Fn{zi}`
OCFN[ P=_P2_P;_ gr c `gfk id zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}`
cfk g{ gr c rnld/bifdgj~}gfj fn{zi}` id oimgln
}i~{n}r !cfk crribgc{nk air{r' biffnb{nk mw zg}nlnrr lgf`r
‒ {an ~fgif id zagba di}or cf c}mg{}c}w {iuilijw& [an
}i~{n}r, {an uc}{gbguc{gfj fiknr cb{ cr }i~{n}, c}n d}nn {i
oitn }cfkiolw cfk ocfcjn {anornltnr c}mg{}c}glw0 {a~r,
{an fn{zi}`*r zg}nlnrr {iuilijw ocw bacfjn }cugklw cfk
~fu}nkgb{cmlw& R~ba c fn{zi}` ocw iun}c{n gf c
r{cfkclifn dcragif, i} ocw mn biffnb{nk {i {an lc}jn}
Gf{n}fn{& Oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` gr c billnb{gif id
gfknunfknf{ oimgln fiknr {ac{ bcf bioo~fgbc{n {i ncba
i{an} tgc }ckgi zctnr& [an oimgln fiknr bcf kg}nb{lwbioo~fgbc{n {i {airn fiknr {ac{ c}n gf }ckgi }cfjn id
ncba i{an}, zan}ncr i{an}r fiknr fnnk {an anlu id
gf{n}onkgc{n fiknr {i }i~{n {ang} ucb`n{r& [anrn
fn{zi}`r c}n d~llw kgr{}gm~{nk, cfk bcf zi}` c{ cfw ulcbn
zg{ai~{ {an cgk id cfw gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& [agr u}iun}{w
oc`nr {anrn fn{zi}`r agjalw }im~r{&
Dgj~}n 3&3& OCFN[ id 3; Oimgln Fiknr
GG& CK/AIB IF KNOCFK KGR[CFBN
TNB[I] ]I^[GFJ !CIKT'
Ck aib If/Knocfk Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i} !CIKT'
}i~{gfj gr c }i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} OCFN[r cfk i{an}
zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}`r P2_P:_& G{ gr c }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj
u}i{ibil, oncfgfj {ac{ g{ nr{cmlgranr c }i~{n {i c
knr{gfc{gif iflw if knocfk& Gf bif{}cr{, {an oir{
biooif }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr id {an Gf{n}fn{ c}n
u}icb{gtn, oncfgfj {anw dgfk }i~{gfj uc{ar
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 357
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 125/223
Uc}con{n} Tcl~n F~omn} id fiknr :
Rgo~lc{gif [gon 3>¥rnb
Uc~rn [gon >or
Nftg}ifonf{ Rgxn 3555(3555
[}cfrogrrgif ]cfjn =>5¥o
[}cddgb Rgxn TM]¥!¥Tc}gcmln¥Mg{ ]c{n'
gfknunfknf{lw id {an ~rcjn id {an uc{ar& CIKT gr, cr
{an fcon gfkgbc{nr, c kgr{cfbn/tnb{i} }i~{gfj u}i{ibil&
CIKT ctigkr {an bi~f{gfj/{i/gfdgfg{w u}imlno id
i{an} kgr{cfbn/tnb{i} u}i{ibilr mw ~rgfj rns~nfbn
f~omn}r if }i~{n ~ukc{nr, c {nbafgs~n ugifnn}nk
mw KRKT& CIKT gr bcucmln id
mi{a ~fgbcr{ cfk o~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj&
Gf CIKTP:_P1_{an fn{zi}` gr rglnf{ ~f{gl c
biffnb{gif gr fnnknk& C{ {ac{ uigf{ {an fn{zi}` fikn
{ac{ fnnkr c biffnb{gif m}ickbcr{r c }ns~nr{ di}
biffnb{gif& I{an} CIKT fiknr di}zc}k {agr onrrcjn,
cfk }nbi}k {an fikn {ac{ {anw anc}k g{ d}io, b}nc{gfj cf
nqulirgif id {noui}c}w }i~{nr mcb` {i {an fnnkw fikn&
Zanf c fikn }nbngtnr r~ba c onrrcjn cfk cl}nckw acr
c }i~{n {i {an knrg}nk fikn, g{ rnfkr c onrrcjn
mcb`zc}kr {a}i~ja c {noui}c}w }i~{n {i {an }ns~nr{gfj
fikn& [an fnnkw fikn {anf mnjgfr ~rgfj {an }i~{n {ac{
acr {an lncr{ f~omn} id aiur {a}i~ja i{an} fiknr&
^f~rnk nf{}gnr gf {an }i~{gfj {cmlnr c}n }nbwblnk cd{n}
c {gon&
Zanf c lgf` dcglr, c }i~{gfj n}}i} gr ucrrnk mcb` {i c
{}cfrog{{gfj fikn, cfk {an u}ibnrr }nunc{r&
Dgj~}n =&3&8 Zi}`gfj id CIKT
GGG& RGO^LC[GIF $ ]NR^L[R
2&3 c Un}di}ocfbn On{}gbr
[a}i~jau~{ ‛ [an }c{gi id {an f~omn}id kc{c ucb`n{r rnf{ cfk {an f~omn} id kc{c
ucb`n{r }nbngtnk&
m&Rgo~lc{gif Uc}con{n}r
Zn actn {c`nf ifn If/knocfk !]ncb{gtn'
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr, fconlw CIKT&& Di} cll {an
rgo~lc{gifr, {an f~omn} id {}cddgb ri~}bnr zcr {c`nf
di} > cfk : fiknr, {an ocqgo~o runnk id {an fiknr
zcr rn{ {i =5o)r cfk {an rgo~lc{gif {gon zcr dgqnk cr35r&
Rbnfc}gi 3
¥
Uc}con{n} Tcl~n
F~omn} id fiknr >
Rgo~lc{gif [gon 35¥rnb
Uc~rn [gon >or
Nftg}ifonf{ Rgxn 3555(3555
[}cfrogrrgif ]cfjn =>5¥o
[}cddgb Rgxn TM]¥¥ !¥¥ Tc}gcmln¥ Mg{
]c{n'
Ucb`n{ Rgxn >3=¥mw{nr
Ucb`n{ ]c{n >¥ucb`n{r)r
Ocqgo~o¥Runnk =5¥o)r
Rgo~lc{i} fr―=&23
[cmln 2&38 Rbnfc}gi 3 di} goulnonf{c{gif id CIKT
Dgj~}n 2&38 Q J}cua id {a}i~jau~{ !CIKT' di} > fiknr
Rbnfc}gi =
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 335
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 126/223
¥
Ucb`n{¥Rgxn >3=¥mw{nr
Ucb`n{¥]c{n >¥ucb`n{r)r
Ocqgo~o¥Runnk =5¥o)r
Rgo~lc{i} fr―=&23
[cmln 2&=8 Rbnfc}gi = di} goulnonf{c{gif id CIKT
Dgj~}n 2&=8 Q J}cua id {a}i~jau~{ !CIKT' di} : fiknr
GT& BIFBL^RGIF
[a}i~jau~{ jcgf gr ocqgo~o zanf CIKT
u}i{ibil ~rnk di} lnrr fiknr cfk knb}ncrnr cr {an fikn
gfb}ncrnr&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_& Gcf K& Bac`n}nr cfk Nlgxcmn{a O& Mnlkgfj/ ]iwn}&
-CIKT ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilGoulnonf{c{gif Knrgjf&- U}ibnnkgfjr id {an Gf{n}fc{gifcl
Zi}`raiu if Zg}nlnrr Ck Aib Fn{zi}`gfj !ZZCF',
[i`wi, Hcucf, Oc}ba
P=_& Nlgxcmn{a O& Mnlkgfj/]iwn}& -]nui}{ if {an
c& CIKT Gf{n}iu&- ^BRM [nba ]nui}{ =55=/31,
H~fn =55=&
P2_& Nlgxcmn{a O& ]iwn} cfk Bac}lnr N&c& Un}`gfr& -[}cfrogrrgif ]cfjn Nddnb{r
if CIKT O~l{gbcr{Bioo~fgbc{gif&- [i Cuunc} gf CBO
Oimgln Fn{zi}`r cfk Cuulgbc{gifr
runbgcl grr~n if O~l{guigf{ Bioo~fgbc{gif gf
Zg}nlnrr Oimgln Fn{zi}`r&
P;_& Rcog} ]& Kcr, Bac}lnr N& Un}`gfr, Nlgxcmn{a O&]iwn} cfk Ocanra @& Oc}gfc&
-Un}di}ocfbn Biouc}grif id [zi If/knocfk ]i~{gfjU}i{ibilr di} Ck aib Fn{zi}`r&- GNNN Un}rifcl
Bioo~fgbc{gifr Ocjcxgfn runbgcl grr~n ifCk aib Fn{zi}`gfj, Dnm}~c}w =553, u& 34/=1&
P>_& Nlgxcmn{a O& ]iwn} cfk
Bac}lnr N&
P4_& Un}`gfr& -Cf Goulnonf{c{gif R{~kw id {anCIKT ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil&- U}ibnnkgfjr id {an GNNN
Zg}nlnrr Bioo~fgbc{gifr cfk
Fn{zi}`gfj Bifdn}nfbn, Bagbcji, GL,
Rnu{nomn} =555&
P:_& Rcog} ]& Kcr, Bac}lnr N& Un}`gfr,
cfk Nlgxcmn{a O& ]iwn}& -Un}di}ocfbn Biouc}grif id [zi If/knocfk ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr di}
Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r&-
U}ibnnkgfjr id {an GNNN Bifdn}nfbn if
Biou~{n} Bioo~fgbc{gifr !GFDIBIO', [nl Ctgt,
Gr}cnl, Oc}ba =555, u& 2/3=&P1_& Nlgxcmn{a O& ]iwn} cfk
Bac}lnr N&
P7_& Un}`gfr& -O~l{gbcr{ Iun}c{gif id {an Ck aib
P35_& If/Knocfk Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i}
]i~{gfj U}i{ibil&- U}ibnnkgfjr id
OimgBio *77, Rnc{{ln, ZC, C~j~r{ 3777, uu& =5:/=31&P33_& Bac}lnr N& Un}`gfr cfk
Nlgxcmn{a O&P3=_& ]iwn}& -Ck aib If/Knocfk Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i} ]i~{gfj&-
U}ibnnkgfjr id {an =fk GNNN Zi}`raiu if
Oimgln Biou~{gfj Rwr{nor cfk Cuulgbc{gifr, FnzI}lncfr, LC, Dnm}~c}w
P32_& 3777, uu&
75/355&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 333
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 127/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :27:5)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :27:5
C OIKGDGNK BL^R[N] MCRNK BIIUN]C[GTN RUNB[]^O RNFRGFJ
CLJI]G[AO ^RGFJ KNOUR[N]/RACDN] [ANI]W
U}id& K}& C& T& @~l`c}fg, ClgCrjn} R& Jcm~hg, Fg`agl C& Cjc}zcl, J& Uczcf @~oc}&
Knu{& id Nlnb{}ifgbr $ [nlnbioo~fgbc{gif,Uck& K}& K& W& Uc{gl Gfr{g{~{n Id Nfjgfnn}gfj $ [nbafilijw,
U~fn, Gfkgc&
Cmr{}cb{ ‛ Gf bijfg{gtn }ckgi rwr{nor, rnbifkc}w ~rn}r bcf mn
bii}kgfc{nk {i un}di}o biiun}c{gtn runb{}~o rnfrgfj ri cr {i
kn{nb{ {an u}goc}w ~rn}r oi}n cbb~}c{nlw& C tc}gn{w id dcb{i}r
r~ba cr agkknf fikn u}imlno, knnu dckgfj $ rackizgfj
kn{n}gi}c{n {an rnfrgfj un}di}ocfbn id {an bijfg{gtn ~rn}r&
Bl~r{n} mcrnk rnfrgfj on{aik ckk}nrrnr {anrn u}imlnor {i c
j}nc{ nq{nf{& Gf {agr on{aik {an libc{gifr id cll {an ~rn}r c}n
dgqnk zan}n rnbifkc}w ~rn}r c}n rnuc}c{nk gf{i c dnz bl~r{n}r
cfk {an oir{ dcti}cmln ~rn} gf ncba bl~r{n} gr rnlnb{nk {i }nui}{{i {an biooif }nbngtn}& [an knbgrgifr c}n ockn mw {an
biooif }nbngtn} biouc}gfj zg{a c rgfjln {a}nrailk tcl~n
zan}n cll {an dcti}cmln ~rn}r actn ns~cl u}gi}g{w gf knbgrgif
oc`gfj& Gf {agr ucun} zn actn u}iuirnk c zngja{ mcrnk
knbgrgif oc`gfj clji}g{ao ~rgfj ki~mln {a}nrailk {nbafgs~n
bifrgkn}gfj kwfcogb libc{gifr id {an ~rn}r& F~on}gbcl }nr~l{r
raiz {ac{ {an rnfrgfj un}di}ocfbn gr gou}itnk rgjfgdgbcf{lw cr
iuuirnk {i biftnf{gifcl on{aik&
@nwzi}kr ‒ Knour{n}/Racdn} [ani}w, Zngja{nk bl~r{n}r,Billcmi}c{gtn knbgrgif oc`gfj&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Bijfg{gtn }ckgi gr c uc}ckgjo di} Zg}nlnrr Bioo~fgbc{gifgf zagba ng{an} c fn{zi}` i} zg}nlnrr fikn bacfjnr g{r
{}cfrogrrgif i} }nbnu{gif uc}con{n}r {i bioo~fgbc{n
nddgbgnf{lw ctigkgfj gf{n}dn}nfbn zg{a lgbnfrnk i} ~flgbnfrnk
~rn}r& [agr cl{n}c{gif id uc}con{n}r gr mcrnk if {an cb{gtn
oifg{i}gfj id rntn}cl dcb{i}r gf {an nq{n}fcl cfk gf{n}fcl
}ckgi nftg}ifonf{, r~ba cr }ckgi d}ns~nfbw runb{}~o, ~rn}
mnactgi} cfk fn{zi}` r{c{n P3_&
[ikcw‗r zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r c}n bac}cb{n}gxnk mw c dgqnk
runb{}~o crrgjfonf{ uilgbw& Aizntn}, c lc}jn ui}{gif id {an
crrgjfnk runb{}~o gr ~rnk rui}ckgbcllw cfk jnij}cuagbcl
tc}gc{gifr gf {an ~{glgxc{gif id crrgjfnk runb{}~o }cfjnr
d}io 3>. {i 1>. zg{a c agja tc}gcfbn gf {gon& [an lgog{nk
ctcglcmln runb{}~o cfk {an gfnddgbgnfbw gf {an runb{}~o~rcjn fnbnrrg{c{n c fnz bioo~fgbc{gif uc}ckgjo {i nqulig{
{an nqgr{gfj zg}nlnrr runb{}~o iuui}{~fgr{gbcllw& [agr fnz
fn{zi}`gfj uc}ckgjo gr }ndn}}nk {i cr FnQ{ Jnfn}c{gif !qJ'
Fn{zi}`r cr znll cr Kwfcogb Runb{}~o Cbbnrr !KRC' cfk
bijfg{gtn }ckgi fn{zi}`r&
[an qJ fn{zi}` d~fb{gifr c}n kgtgknk cr runb{}~o
ocfcjnonf{, runb{}~o oimglg{w cfk runb{}~o rac}gfj&
D}io {an c}bag{nb{~}n knrb}gu{gif, bijfg{gtn }ckgi fn{zi}`r
bi}}nruifk {i fn{zi}`r zan}n c fikn fnnkr {i rnfrn g{r
r~}}i~fkgfjr {i kn{n}ogfn {an u}iun} d}nn runb{}~o,
uirrgmlw zg{a anlu d}io i{an} bijfg{gtn fiknr, cfk
rgo~l{cfni~rlw }nrunb{gfj {an u}gi}g{w id {an u}goc}w ~rn}r&
P33_&
[an ochi} oi{gtc{gif di} {agr gr {an anctglw ~fkn}~{glgxnk
d}ns~nfbw runb{}~o& [an kntnliuonf{ gr mngfj u~rank
di}zc}k mw {an }cugk cktcfbnr gf rid{zc}n kndgfnk }ckgi
{nbafilijw zagba nfcmln c runb{}~o cjgln cfk agjalw
bifdgj~}cmln }ckgi {}cfrog{{n})}nbngtn}&
GG& RWR[NO OIKNL
Kgr{}gm~{nk Runb{}~o Rnfrgfj !KRR'
Bc}}wgfj i~{ }nlgcmln runb{}~o rnfrgfj gr c bacllnfjgfj
{cr` di} c B]& Gf c zg}nlnrr bacffnl, rgjfcl dckgfj bcf bc~rn
}nbngtnk rgjfcl r{}nfj{a {i mn rgjfgdgbcf{lw lizn} {acf zac{
gr u}nkgb{nk mw uc{a lirr oiknlr& [an nddnb{ id dckgfj bcf
}nr~l{ gf {an “agkknf fikn u}imlno‟& P1_ [an agkknf fikn
u}imlno gf {an bif{nq{ id B] fn{zi}`r bcf mn knrb}gmnk cr
cf gfr{cfbn gf zagba c rnbifkc}w gf c B] fn{zi}` gr zg{agf
{an u}i{nb{gif }njgif id cf iun}c{gfj gfb~omnf{ m~{ dcgl {i
kn{nb{ {an nqgr{nfbn id {an gfb~omnf{& Mnrgknr {an agkknf
fikn u}imlno, g{ gr clri uirrgmln di} c rnbifkc}w {i dclrnlwkn{nb{ cf gfb~omnf{ mnbc~rn id figrn i} gf{n}dn}nfbn gf {an
zg}nlnrr nftg}ifonf{& ]nbnf{ }nrnc}ba }nr~l{r gfkgbc{n {ac{
{anrn u}imlnor bcf mn ckk}nrrnk mw }ns~g}gfj o~l{guln
rnbifkc}w‗r {i biiun}c{n zg{a ncba i{an} gf runb{}~o
rnfrgfj‛g&n&, KRR& Gf KRR, ncba rnbifkc}w cb{r cr c
rnfrgfj {n}ogfcl {ac{ bifk~b{r libcl runb{}~o rnfrgfj& [an
libcl }nr~l{r c}n }nui}{nk {i c kc{c billnb{i} !i} “d~rgif
bnf{n}‟' {ac{ nqnb~{nr kc{c d~rgif cfk kn{n}ogfnr {an dgfcl
runb{}~o rnfrgfj }nr~l{&P=_P2_ [an cuulgbc{gif id KRR
}ns~g}nr {ac{ {an kgr{cfbn mn{znnf cfw {zi rnfrgfj {n}ogfclr
gr rocll }nlc{gtn {i {ang} kgr{cfbnr d}io c u}goc}w {}cfrog{{n}
!{wugbcllw c [T {}cfrog{{n}'& Gf cf ck aib B] fn{zi}`, {agr
oncfr {ac{ zanf c fikn fnnkr {i bifk~b{ runb{}~o rnfrgfj,g{ mnbionr c kc{c billnb{i} cfk billnb{r libcl rnfrgfj }nui}{r
d}io fngjami}gfj fiknr& [an kc{c c}n nqbacfjnk gf c
bif{}il bacffnl& [an bif{}il bacffnl bcf mn ng{an} c
biooif bif{}il bacffnl rac}nk mw cll ~rn}r !r~ba cr gf {an
OCB u}i{ibil di} B] fn{zi}`r' i} c “libcl‟ j}i~u bif{}il
bacffnl {ac{ gr ~rnk iflw mw fngjami}gfj fiknr di}
bioo~fgbc{gifr&P;_
[i dcbglg{c{n i~} kgrb~rrgif, zn oiknl {an KRR u}ibnrr cr
c uc}cllnl d~rgif fn{zi}`& Gf {agr F5 gr c kc{c billnb{i},
Fg !g ? 5, 3, =, & & & ,o, zan}n o gr {an f~omn} id F 5‗r
fngjami}gfj rnfrgfj {n}ogfclr' knfi{nr ifn id F5‗r rnfrgfj
{n}ogfclr !F5 gr mi{a c kc{c billnb{i} cfk c rnfrgfj
{n}ogfcl', wg }nu}nrnf{r {an gfb~omnf{ rgjfcl }nbngtnk c{ Fg,
cfk ~g gr {an libcl runb{}~o rnfrgfj }nui}{ {ac{ Fg rnfkr {i
F5& [an i~{u~{ ~ gr {an dgfcl rnfrgfj knbgrgif, zagba gr c
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 33=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 128/223
g
g
gfc}w tc}gc
gfb~omnf{ rg
d~rgif u}iml
awui{anrgr {nw A5 cfk A3
rgoulgdw {an
{ac{ runb{}~o
cfk& P=_P2_
&Knbgrgif d~G{ }n
{a}nrailk tcl
+ 3 fnnkr {
} ns~cl {i {a
ibb~ugnk‟, g
cfk gr kn{n}
g&n&,
Knu
d~rgif bcf ac
[anrn }~ln
ftg}ifonf{r&
{a}nrailk {nb
P>_ P:_
&Knour{n}/R
An}n zn rn{
zagba oc`nr{}nfj{ar, }nb
}nlgcmln {acf
goulnonf{c{g
n{aik gf z
r{}nfj{a tcl~
[an knbgrgif
nbgrgif clji
c`gfj&
GGG
ln / c “ifn
fcl, cfk c “xn
o {an}ndi}n
{gfj u}imlno3& Bi}}nruifk
grb~rrgifr, {
rnfrgfj gr b
gif8s~g}nr {an kc{
n {ac{ gr fi l
mn runbgdgnk
n {a}nrailk, {
&n&, ~ ? 3 cf
gfnk {i mn “d
? 5 cfk A5 g
fkgfj if {an
n rntn}cl tc}g
C {a}nra
d~rgif }~l
c tcl~n
}~ln,
cfk c t
d~rgif }~l
r bcf iflw
& [an}ndi}n
afgs~n mcrn
acdn} [ani}w
~u {zi {a}nr
libcl knbgrgngtnk c{ cll
cll {an i{an}
f c Zngja{
agba liznr{
r dcllgfj mn{
r c}n ockn
g{aor mi{a, u
G& CLJI]G
‟ knfi{nr {
}i‟ knfi{nr g{
bcf mn }nj
zg{a {zi awugfjlw, ncba ~
n dillizgfj
c}}gnk i~{ gf
c billnb{i} {i
nrr {acf ifn
& Gd {an r~o i
anf {an dgfcl
k A3 gr cbbn
lliz‟,
r cbbnu{nk&
tcl~n id {an
gcf{r&
ilk tcl~n id
n,
id !o+3' gr
l~n id !o+3
n&
mn di}o~l
n actn gou
if Knou
ilkr di} nfn}
ifr knunfkg{an B]r& [ag
n{aikr& [i
crnk {nbafg
ngja{ gr crrg
nnf {an {zi
rns~nf{gcllw
iuirnk cr Bi
[AO ) DLI
n u}nrnfbn
r cmrnfbn& [a
}knk cr c
i{anrnr }nu}ng gr clri mgfc
kgrb~rrgif cr
c rgfjln run
r~o ~u cll ~
cfk fi j}nc{n
d ~g‗r gr j}nc{n
rnfrgfj knbgr
{nk0 i{an}zg
{a}nrailk, kn
ifn gr cf
cf “CFK‟
=' gr c “Och
c{nk gf fig
lnonf{nk c k
r{n}/Racdn} {
w kn{nb{gif c
fj if {angr on{aik gr
c`n g{ r~g{cm
~n gr ckknk
jfnk {i {an
{a}nrailkr P>
~rgfj ac}k
llcmi}c{gtn kn
BAC][
id cf
n kc{c
gfc}w
nf{nkw& [i
~onr
b{}~o
g‗r& C
} {acf
} {acf
gif gr
n {an
bgrgif
“I]‟
~rgif
i}g{w‟
rnlnrr
i~mln
ni}w&
{ R^r,
rgjfcloi}n
ln di}
{i {an
rgjfcl
_P3=_&
rid{
bgrgif
[
oi
k~}
cb{g
Cr
[a
gr
dcll
b&R
[
bl~
d}n
B]
an u}iuirnk
k~lnr knugb{
gfj {an rnfrg
gif cr runbgdg
~ou{gifr 8
Ocqgo
? =: k
Ocqgo
? 5 {i /
MCFK
ibb~ugn
MCFKoikn}c{
MCFKibb~ugn
jnij}cuagbc
conk cr c bl
gfj gf {an bl~
cf [nr{ 8
an mcrn r{c{gi
r{n} anckr di
~nfbw zagb
r& [an MR b
lji}g{ao gr kg
{an cb{gtg{gn
j cb{gif& [a
k mnliz&
gj 3& Dlizba
o {}cfrogrrg
o ? >55 oo }nbnu{gif
15 kMo ? 35
!nj8/ 7;2&3
k d}ns~nfbgnr&
GG !nj8/ 7;nlw ibb~ugnk
GGG !nj8/ 7;k d}ns~nfbgnr&
l }njgif gr kg
~r{n}& C kc{c
{n}r gr billnb{
f !MR' bifk~
}nrunb{gtn b
gr }nbngtnk
clb~lc{nr {an
tgknk gf{i rgq
r ~fkn}{c`nf
~r {anw }nu}n
c}{ ) Oik~lnr
if uizn} id
& P7_uizn} id c
5 uZ& P7_
Ax {i 7;;
&
&3 OAx {id}ns~nfbgnr&
5 {i 7;2& P35_
gknk gf ` rnb
crn id cll {a
nk cfk ~ukc{n
b{r c rbcf {nr
l~r{n}r& [an
$ }n/{}cfro
kgr{cfbn id
oik~lnr& [a
mw {an rwr{
rnf{ {an dliz
c bnll~lc} ua
bnll~lc} ua
Ax' cr ruc}r
7;4 OAx'
Ax' cr anct
{i}r& Ncba rnb
bijfg{gtn ~r
k&
{ di} knrgjfc{g
MR m}ickbcr{
g{{nk mw cll
ncba B] ~rg
rn
no
id
fn
fn
nlw
cr
glw
{i}
n}r
gfj
r c
{an
gfj
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 332
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 129/223
zagba g{ bclb~lc{nr {an zngja{ id ncba B] id ncba bl~r{n} mw
~rgfj {an dillizgfj di}o~lc 8
Zngja{Pg_ ? kgr{cfbnPg_ ( rgjfcl r{}nfj{aPg_
[an B] actgfj ocqgo~o zngja{ gr knrgjfc{nk cr {an
bl~r{n} anck id {an }nrunb{gtn bl~r{n}&
Zngja{r id {an gfkgtgk~cl bl~r{n}r c}n bclb~lc{nk cr dillizr 8
Ctn}cjn zngja{r id cll {an B]r gf c bl~r{n} gr bclb~lc{nk
$ {an bl~r{n} actgfj ocqgo~o ctn}cjn zngja{ gr crrgjfnk
{an agjanr{ u}gi}g{w gf knbgrgif oc`gfj&
[an runb{}~o gr rns~nf{gcllw rbcffnk mw cll {an B]r gf {an
}nrunb{gtn i}kn} mn{znnf {an }cfjnr,
MCFK G cr ruc}rnlw ibb~ugnk d}ns~nfbgnr,
MCFK GG cr oikn}c{nlw ibb~ugnk d}ns~nfbgnr,
MCFK GGG cr anctglw ibb~ugnk d}ns~nfbgnr&
Gd cll {an d}ns~nfbgnr c}n ibb~ugnk, {anf {an fn{zi}` r{cwr
bifjnr{nk zagba gr c }c}n bcrn&
^rgfj {an Knour{n}/Racdn} [ani}w $ Ac}k) Rid{ knbgrgif
bifbnu{,
Gd {an rgjfcl r{}nfj{a }nbngtnk mw {an B] <? /:5 kMo , B]
rnfkr c *5* {i g{r bl~r{n} anck
Gd {an rgjfcl r{}nfj{a }nbngtnk mw {an B] 6? /35 kMo , B]
rnfkr c *3* {i g{r bl~r{n} anck
Gd {an rgjfcl r{}nfj{a }nbngtnk mw {an B] lgnr mn{znnf /35 $
/:5 kMo, B] rnfkr {an }nbngtnk rgjfcl r{}nfj{a {i {an
bl~r{n} anck&Fiz {an bl~r{n} anck bclb~lc{nr {an . id B]r bifbl~kgfj
u}goc}w ~rn} gr u}nrnf{ i} cmrnf{&
C ? P!fi& id B]r bifbl~kgfj *5*' ( ;>_ +P!fi& id B]*r
}nbngtgfj rgjfcl r{}nfj{a mn{znnf !/:5 {i /;> kMo'' ( 35_ U ? P!fi& id B]r bifbl~kgfj *3*' ( ;>_ + P!fi& id B]*r
}nbngtgfj rgjfcl r{}nfj{a mn{znnf !/;> {i /35 kMo'' ( 35_
Knbgrgif mw Bl~r{n} Anck
U}goc}w u}nrnf{ ? PU ) !C+U'_ ( 355 .
U}goc}w cmrnf{ ? PC ) !C+U'_ ( 355 .
[anrn knbgrgifr c}n rnf{ {i {an MR di} cfclwrgr&
Fi& id bl~r{n}r 8 `
B]r gf c bl~r{n} 8 f3, f= ․ f`
Fiz, q ? 3,=,․&,`
f q
Ctj z{& id B]Pq_ ? P ∓ kPg_ ( rPg_ _ ) f q g ? 3
Ln{ {an bl~r{n}r cd{n} }nc}}cfjgfj cbbi}kgfj {i {ang} zngja{r
gf knrbnfkgfj i}kn} mn cr dillizr
Z` , Z`/3, Z`/=,&&․&, Z3
Dgfcl knbgrgif mw {an MR,
? ! knbgrgif id bl~r{n} ( zngja{ id bl~r{n} '
3∓ ]Zg ( g
g ? `
Dgfcl knbgrgif ? YYYYYYYYYYYYY
3∓ g
g ? `
zan}n ]Zg ? knbgrgif id bl~r{n} Pg_ rnf{ {i {an MR
[an d}ns~nfbw ailn rbcffnk gr cllibc{nk {i {an B] actgfj
agjanr{ u}gi}g{w cr un} g{r r~mrb}gmn} c~{ai}gxc{gif ulcf&
U}gi}g{w
Fi&
Bc{nji}w Bac}jnr un} bcll
3 !Agjanr{' Jilk Nq{}c
= !Onkg~o' Rgltn} Nq{}c
2 !Liznr{' M}ifxn Fi Nq{}c bac}jnr
GT& RGO^LC[GIF
[an dillizgfj }nu}nrnf{c{gifr knfi{n {an rgo~lc{gif
}nr~l{r id {an oik~lnr&
Dgj& = $ Dgj& > }nu}nrnf{ bl~r{n} di}oc{gif $ bl~r{n} anck
knrgjfc{gif&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 33;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 130/223
Dgj=& Bl~r{
Dgj& 2 $ Dg
R{c{gif&
Dgj 2& K
[an Itn}cll
rgfj 355 B]
Dgj& ; $ Dg
c`gfj di} kg
7¥.
KN
n} Di}oc{gif
!;
& 4 }nu}nrnf{ {
nbgrgif Oc`g
Nddgbgnfbw di
? 73 .
& : }nu}nrnf{
ddn}nf{ f~omn
BGRGIF ID
cfk Bl~r{n}
bl~r{n}r'
an knbgrgif
j Di} 355 Bi
} Rnfrgfj if
{an nddgbgnfbw
} id Bijfg{gt
73¥.[AN MCRN
nck Knrgjfc
ckn mw {an M
jfg{gtn ]ckgi
n D}ns~nfbw
gf knbgrgif
]ckgir&
R[C[GIF
KNBGRGIF !U&^&U]NRNF[)CMR
FI ]NR^L[
gif
rn
r
Ailn
&F['
Dgj ;& N
gj>& Bl~r{n}
5
=5
;5
45
15
355
35 =
=¥.
KN
dgbgnfbw Di}
i}oc{gif cf
!1 bl~
25 ;5 >
Nddgbg
GRGIF ID
355 Bijfg{gt
Bl~r{n} Anc
r{n}r'
45 :5 1
fbw
71¥.
AN MCRN R
]ckgir
k Knrgjfc{gi
5 75
[C[GIF
KNBGRGIF !U&^
U]NRNF[)CMR
FI ]NR^L[
&
NF['
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 33>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 131/223
g
Dgj 4& K
[an Itn}cll
rgfj =55 B]
Dgj :
[an nddgbgnfbw
d Bijfg{gtn
Gf {agr ucu
crnk biiufbi~}cjgfj
illcmi}c{gtn
{nbafgs~n mw
anckr& [an
gfb}ncrgfj {
cr{ dckgfj z
zi}` zan}n }
P3_ H&
o
5
=5
;5
45
15
355
3
nbgrgif Oc`g
Nddgbgnfbw di
? 71 .
& Nddgbgnfbw
id Runb{}~o
ckgir gfb}ncr
T& BI
}, zn actn
n}c{gtn rnf}nr~l{r& [an
knbgrgif o
cbs~g}gfj }n
lick if {an
n nddgbgnfbw
i~lk mn cf gf
bngtn} rnfrg{g
TG&
GGG Og{ilc cfk
c`gfj rid{zc}n
5 335 3=5 32
j Di} =55 Bi
} Rnfrgfj if
i} =55 Bijfg
Rnfrgfj gfb}n
nr&
FBL^RGIF
ikgdgnk {an b
gfj clji}g{ocgf mcrn
c`gfj ~rgfj
r~l{r d}io {a
biooif b
id rnfrgfj {i
{n}nr{gfj nq{n
tg{w bcf clri
NDN]NFBN
J& S& H}& Ocj
}ckgir oi}n
5 3;5 3>5 34
Nddgbgnfb
jfg{gtn ]ckgi
n D}ns~nfbw
{gtn ]ckgir
crnr cr {an f
iftnf{gifcl b
o $ imr{c{gif un}
ki~mln {a}
n zngja{nk b
cffnl gr }n
c bn}{cgf lg
rgif {i {an u
n gfbi}ui}c{
~g}n, “Bijfg{gtn
un}rifcl,‟ U
3:5 315 37
w
r
Ailn
omn}
l~r{n}
{cgfnkdi}or
railk
l~r{n}
~bnk,
g{P4_&
}nrnf{
k&
}ckgi8
n}rifcl
P
P
P
=55
Bioo
C~j& 3
P=_ B& R~
biiun
U}ibnBioo
P2_ C& Jadi} iu
KwRU
P;_ R& Ac
biooBioo
P>_ H& Xa
{a}nragf bi
Bijfg
!B}iz
P4_ K& Bc
Gouln
}ckgirBiou
P:_ BiiuKn{nb
Lg~ R
^fgtn
!^NRP1_ D& D&
nfn}j
gf U}i
!GNNN
2>:>P7_ Oi~l
bioo
35_ Bijfg
ClnqcNfjgf
33_ FnQ{
}ckgi
WnilM}ick
Nlnb{}[nbaf
3=_ “Bill
zg{a fM&Nfj
~fgbc{gifr, GNN
3777&
, Z& Xacfj, cfk
}c{gtn runb{}~o r
kgfjr id GNNN G ~fgbc{gifr, Jlcr
crnog cfk N& Riui}{~fgr{gb cbbnr
F, Mcl{goi}n,O
`gf& Bijfg{gtn }
~fgbc{gifr& GNNN
~fgbc{gifr, til&, X& Q~, D&Zcf
ilk nfn}jw kn{nbjfg{gtn }ckgi,‟
{gtn ]ckgi I}g
fBio', uu& 3/>,
m}gb, R& O& l\;gra
onf{c{gif grr~nr
& gf U}ib, id Crgl~{n}r, ucjnr ::=
}c{gtn Runb{}~o{gif cfk Knour{
aiil id Bioo~
}rg{w id Nlnb{}if
B' Banfjk~ 433gjaco, O&/R& Cl
kn{nb{gif id ~fb& GNNN Gf{n}fc{
GBB =552', til&
2>:7&O&, Uc~{n{ O&
~fgbc{gifr,‟ 377
{gtn ]ckgi [
fkn}, ]& Kctgknn}gfj, Gfkgcf Gf
jnfn}c{gif)kwfc
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}
Lnn, Onaon{mcfk cfk Zg}nln
gbcl cfk Biou~ilijw, C{lcf{c,
mi}c{gtn runb{}~
if/jc~rrgcf figrj&, Lc`nanck ~fg
, Til~on 4, Grr~
@& M& Ln{cgnd, “B
nfrgfj gf bijfg{g
{n}fc{gifcl Bifiz, Rbi{{lcfk, H
rc, “Billcmi}c{gtr gf dckgfj nftg}i
K, ^RC, u&u& 323
ckgi8 m}cgf/nouiHi~}fcl if Rnln
=28=53‛==5, Dn, M& A~cfj cfk
{gif id biiun}c{gf U}ib& id Gf{
f{nk Zg}nlnrr
=551&
c}, c}gk ]& Z& M}
gf runb{}~o rnfrg
oc} Bifd if Rgj::4, Fitnomn}
Rnfrgfj Mcrnk in}/Racdn} [ani}w
gbc{gif cfk Gfdi
gb Rbgnfbn cfk
3:23, Bagfcli~gfg, cfk O& @&
fizf rgjfclr itgifcl Bifdn}nfbn
>, fi& ;, Ocw 33
M&, “[an JRO
=&
bafgs~nr di}
@iglugllcg Knuc{g{~{n id [nbafil
gb runb{}~o cbb
r8 C r~}tnw Gcf
B& T~}cf (,rr Fn{zi}`gfj L
{n} Nfjgfnn}gfj,C 2522=, fg{nk
rnfrgfj gf c bi
n‟ mw [cf Dnfjtn}rg{w, =554
n ;, Ucjn!r'832 /
l~r{n}/mcrnk
tn }ckgi rwr{nor
n}nfbn if~fn =55:&
n runb{}~o rnfrgfonf{r,‟ U}i& GN
324, Fit& =55>&
zn}nk zg}nlnrr{nk C}ncr gf
}~c}w =55>M& Xacfj, “Ki
tn runb{}~o rnf}fc{gifcl Bifd&
Fn{zi}`r Bio
kn}rnf&
fj di} bijfg{gtn
fclr, Rwr{no cf=55;&
f Ki~mln [a}nrAifjw~ Banf
oc{gif Nfjgfnn}
nbafilijw id B
Rgoif, “If {an
n} dckgfj bacffnlif Bioo~fgbc{g
3>, =552, uu&
rwr{no di} oi
RO Mcfk M
}{onf{ id Nlnb{}ijw, Ock}cr&
rr)bijfg{gtn
D& C`wglkgx, Z
Racf{gknt Oiacmi}c{i}w, Rbaii
Jni}jgc Gfr{g{~{R{c{nr&
fg{gtn }ckgi Rwr
31,
, gf
fj NN
mln
gfjif
~f&
ilkgcf
gfj,
gfc
r,‟ifr
mgln
cgh~
gbcl
if/
f{wl id
id
{no
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 334
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 132/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :27::)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :27::
U}i{ibil Knrgjf di} Cktcfbnk Rnb~}g{w gf Zg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`r
]cja~tnn} Rgfja Kac`c
Knuc}{onf{ id Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn $ Nfjj&
Bnf{}cl fgtn}rg{w id ]chcr{acf
Chon}, Gfkgc
C}tgfk Kac`c
Knuc}{onf{ id Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn $ Nfjj&
Bnf{}cl ^fgtn}rg{w id ]chcr{acf
Chon}, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛[agr ucun} gr dib~rnk {i gftnr{gjc{n {an rnb~}g{w
u}i{ibilr zagba c}n ~rnk gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`& [an U}i{ibilr
lg`n ZNU, ZUC i} ZNU= c}n bifrgkn}nk ~fkn} {an GNNN
15=&33 r{cfkc}k& [a}iz {an cfclwrgr id {an u}i{ibilr zn
kn{n}ogfn {ac{ {an cktcf{cjnr cfk kgrcktcf{cjnr& Cfk di} {an
}nocgfgfj t~lfn}cmglg{gnr zn c}n u}iuirgfj cf nddnb{gtn
ril~{gif zagba gr oi}n rnb~}n cfk ~fu}nkgb{cmln&
@nwzi}kr/ ZNU0 ZUC0 OGB0CNR0NCU0GT0ZUC/=0 ORR&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
[an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` rnb~}g{w gr gf c r{c{n id bacir&Ntn}wkcw c fnz t~lfn}cmglg{w gr kgrbitn}nk gf cloir{ ntn}wnqgr{gfj u}i{ibil& [an cfrzn} {i {anrn u}imlnor lgnr gfnfacfbgfj i~} knrgjf on{aikilijw gf ckkg{gif {igoulnonf{gfj cfk {nr{gfj {an u}i{ibilr& Gf {agr ucun}, c fnzonbacfgro gr u}iuirnk cfk kgrb~rrnk& [an u}iuirnkonbacfgro zgll mn biouc}nk zg{a c f~omn} id nqg{gfjzi}`gfj onbacfgror gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r&
GG& GRR^NR CFK RNB^]G[W C[[CB@R
Gf {agr rnb{gif, grr~nr cfk rnb~}g{w c{{cb`r gf zg}nlnrrfn{zi}`r rnb~}g{w u}i{ibilr c}n kgrb~rrnk&
C& Oikgdgbc{gif
G{ gr cf cb{gtn c{{cb` zan}n {an bif{nf{ id {an i}gjgfclonrrcjn c}n oikgdgnk mw {an gf{}~kn} cfk {anf rnf{ g{ gfr{nckid {an cb{~cl onrrcjn&
M& Dcm}gbc{gif
G{ gr cf cb{gtn c{{cb` zan}n fif i}gjgfcl onrrcjn grjnfn}c{nk mw gf{}~kn} cfk {anf rnf{ {i {an }nbngtn}&
B& Gf{n}bnu{gif
G{ gr c ucrrgtn c{{cb` zan}n {an nfb}wu{nk onrrcjn gr
lgr{nfr cfk }nbi}kr mw {an gf{}~kn} cfk lc{n} if knb}wu{ mwgf{}~kn}&
K& M}~{n Di}bn
G{ gr c ucrrgtn c{{cb` zan}n {an gf{}~kn}r jnfn}c{nr ntn}wuirrgmln un}o~{c{gif gf {an `nw cfk {}w {i knb}wu{ {annfb}wu{nk onrrcjn&
N& Ocgf{cgfcmglg{w
Di} ucjnr i{an} {acf {an dg}r{ ucjn, r{c}{ c{ {an {iu id {anucjn, cfk bif{gf~n gf ki~mln/bil~of di}oc{& [an {zibil~ofr if {an lcr{ ucjn rai~lk mn cr blirn {i ns~cl lnfj{acr uirrgmln&
GGG& ZG]NLNRR RNB^]G[W U]I[IBIL
C& Zg}nk Ns~gtclnf{ U}gtcbw !ZNU'
ZNU zcr kntnliunk {i u}itgkn zg}nlnrr rnb~}g{w {i {anzg}nlnrr ~rn}r if ZLCF {ac{ gr ns~gtclnf{ {i mngfj if czg}nk fn{zi}`& ZNU, fi{ mngfj gf{nfknk {i u}itgkn c agjan}rnb~}g{w lntnl {acf c zg}nk LCF, u}itgknr ns~gtclnf{rnb~}g{w lntnl {i {ac{ mw zg}nk LCFr& ]B; R{}nco Bguan} gr~rnk {i u}itgkn bifdgknf{gclg{w cfk B]B/2= banb`r~o gr~rnk {i u}itgkn Gf{nj}g{w !aifnr{w'&ZNU ~rnr c ;5 mg{ `nwrgxn =; mg{ GT !Gfg{gclgxc{gif Tnb{i}'&
M& Zg}nk Ns~gtclnf{ U}gtcbw= !ZNU ='
G{ gr rcon cr ZNU& [an rgxn id Gfg{gclgxc{gif Tnb{i} gr
rcon oncfr =; Mg{r& M~{ {an `nw rgxn gr nqunfknk {i 35; Mg{P>_&
B& Zg/Dg U}i{nb{nk Cbbnrr !ZUC' U}i{ibil
ZUC u}i{ibil zcr knrgjfnk {i u}itgkn rnb~}g{w {i {anZg/Dg fn{zi}`r& G{ gr bifrgkn}nk ~fkn} {an GNNN 15=&33gr{cfkc}k& G{ zcr kntnliunk mw Zg/Dg Cllgcfbn& [an}n gr [@GU![noui}cl @nw Gf{nj}g{w U}i{ibil' zagba u}itgknr oi}nrnb~}g{w {i bacfjn {an kwfcogb `nw P35_& [an rgxn id Gfg{gclgxn Tnb{i} !GT' gr h~r{ ki~mln gf biouc}n {i ZNU,zagba gr ;1 Mg{& Cfk {an `nw rgxn gr 3=1 mg{&
K& ZUC/= !]im~r{ Rnb~}g{w Fn{zi}`r/ ]RFr'
OCB gr }nulcbnk mw BBOU cfk ]B; gr }nulcbnk mw CNR&[an}n c}n = oik, G oikn gr `fizf cr u}n rac}nk `nw oikncfk GG oikn gr `fizf cr d~ll Nq{nfrgtn Oik)ZUC/Nf{n}u}grn& 15=&33g {ac{ acr mnnf cuunc}nk gf =55; ~rnr {anlijgb id c ]im~r{ Rnb~}g{w Fn{zi}` !]RF'& [agr fnzr{cfkc}k cfk c}bag{nb{~}n ckiu{ {an GNNN 15=&3Q r{cfkc}kdi} cbbnrr bif{}il cfk di} nfb}wu{gif g{ ~rnr CktcfbnkNfb}wu{gif R{cfkc}k !CNR' P4_& G{ ~rnr c ucg}/zgrn `nwnqbacfjn !di~} zcw acfkrac`n' u}i{ibil ~{glgxgfj 15=&3Q di}o~{~cl c~{anf{gbc{gif cfk `nw ocfcjnonf{ u}ibnrr& 15=&33gcllizr ~rn id [@GU, m~{ mw kndc~l{ ]RF ~rnr CNR!Cktcfbnk Nfb}wu{gif R{cfkc}k' cfk BBOU !Bi~f{n} OiknBMB OCB U}i{ibil'& G{ u}itgknr c r{}ifjn}, rbclcmlnril~{gif&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 33:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 133/223
[CMLN G&
[an u}iuRwr{no !Nfb}wu{gif)K]RC, MlizdgORR ~rnr =>}cfkio gf {angddn}nf{gc{n}gjgfcl fco
ORR r{i}nr cd kgddn}nf{ rlncfr {ac{ 1=
zagba gr {}wgf
BIOUC]GRI
RNB^]G
GT& U]IU
rnk onbacfgRR'& ORb}wu{gif cla, Nllgu{gb B
4 rli{r& Ifnrn rli{r& [an}n{znnf {anrnid {an clji}g
`nw lgr{& Ncb{ clji}g{ao c
>4 uirrgmln bi{i c{{cb`&
Dgj~}n 3&
F MN[ZNNF ZNW U]I[IBILR
RNK ONBACF
ro gr `fiz~rnr
i}g{aor ]B~}tn, CNR, Ad {an ngja{ cln gr c =/mg{ bingja{ clji}g{
g{ao& Di} {anonrrcjn nfk c kgddn}nf{
omgfc{gif }n
Rli{ Rwr{no&
, ZUC CFK ZU
GR^O
cr O~l{gulifn id , Kgddgn/Anl
OCB cfk Bji}g{aor gr ~kn zagba gr ~or gf ulcbn
rn ngja{ clji}wu{r zg{a {a`nw mw ORR,~g}nr {i cfw
=
Rli{ngja{
locf,CB&
rnk c{rnk {iid {ang{aor
anluzagbacb`n}
!@OGmg{uc}=>ra~oi
C&
~rn{anCubif
Nq{c~{
=/mmg{ifzag{an
3
c}n
zgl
r{c
fi
clj`n
an
ORR anckn}' gr dg}r{ uc}{&
B ra~ddln Rnlnlifj zagba gr{ gr 1/mg{ lifj
rli{r& [an {addln {cmlnr, {atn s~gb`lw {an
Dgj
ORR Iun}c{g
Kgddn}nf{ bif}, zagba onc
~rn} gr cdd ulgbc{gif lcwndgj~}c{gif dgl
nfrgmln C~{aanf{gbc{gif rn[an bifdgj~}g{ lifj', zagbiflw& Ngja{id {an ngja{
gba gr {an ra~d OGB jnfn}c{
' Rnfkgfj U
~rnk {i baii
l mn ra~ddlnk
{gfj d}io {a
n zgll nfb}
i}g{ao di} {a& [an fikn z
kn} {i onrrc
acr kgtgknk g[an rli{ rnlnb{i} !OGBRR'~rnk {i rnlnb{zagba gr ~rng}k uc}{ gr 1/ra~ddln {cmlnOGB mg{r zg{
~}n =& ORR A
f
dgj~}c{gif dglr {ac{ {an fn{b{nk& ORR}& [an cbbnrnr& [an CU
f{gbc{gif U}i}tgbnr&{gif dgln bif{
a oncfr {ac{nw lgr{r dglnrclji}g{aor&
dln {cmln& G{rr cfk g{r lnfj
acrn8 C rli{
rn {an ~rn} i}
zg{a {an ba
dg}r{ mg{ ~f{g
u{ {an fnz
rli{ {ac{ g{gll bifbc{nfc{
n cfk {anf rn
{a}nn uc}{r&{i} !RR' gr rn{ag}k uc}{& [amn{znnf =
;1
{i rnlnb{ mn{g{ lifj {i rnl
r c}n ~rnk oca {an i}gjgfcl
ckn}r $ Ucwli
r c}n ~rnk mi}` zgll fi{
gr jigfj {iuigf{ !CU'
cb{ lg`n c bi
{ibil !NCU'
cgfr {an =>4 r{an rli{r uc}{c}n fnnknk cl
Ifn oi}n dglgk{a gr {an f~
{a gr =4;&
fk c `nw d}i
{an fikn& [a
rnf }iz gfrg
l {an lcr{ mg{ g
ucwlick zg{
zcr bairnf ~n {an RR, @R
k {an onrrcj
an `nw Rnlnbifk uc}{ cfkn dg}r{ uc}{ grnwr& [an rnbznnf ifn id nb{ mn{znnfgflw {i ra~ddlnonrrcjn&
k&
w ORR di} nn cddnb{nk ziun}c{n ifbif{cgfr cllftn}rgif rn}
~rnk {i u}it
li{r !ncba rlizgll fnnk =(ri, ifn di} n
gr clri fnnomn} id mg{r {
{an lgr{ id `
jnfn}c{nk O
kn {an onrrc
f {an OGB&
{an cuuigf
rgfj {an baicfk OGBRR c
n&
{i}{an1/fk{an>4i}
banf
{an{ann}&
gkn
{ gr>4bank
ac{
wr
GB
jn,
an
{nk
nfr c
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 331
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 134/223
g
[an rnlnb{
gr kifn rwr{n
ORR zgll }~f
nw gf {an `n
rli{ zg{a {an d
c&]nbngtgfj
rnuc}c{n {a
RR {i `fizonrrcjn& [
kc{c, {an }n
zgll ~rn {a
ra~ddln {cml
}nbngtn} zg
OGB'& [an
uc}{ cfk
}nbngtnk {i
m&Bif{}il
zgll cb{ cr
c }nd}nra i
cll fiknr&acfkln {an
bifdgj~}c{g
zgll rnfk c
CU zgll kn
bif{}il rn}
{ano {i {an
g{rnld cfk r
zgll }nbngt
ucb`n{ {i {
{an fnz tn
dglnr zg{a {a
Dgj~}n 2& Ra
gif id {an rli{
c{gbcllw, zag
g{ zgll ~rn {
lgr{ id {ac{ cl
g}r{ `nw gf agr
Uacrn8 Gf {a
RR, @R cfk
{an clji}g{aan cuuigf{nk
bngtn} zgll k
n OGBRR {i
n cfk zgll ~
ll rulg{ {an uc
}nbngtn} zgll
iouc}n {an
gfr~}n {an gf{
nrrcjnr cfk
biftn}rgif r
{an bifdgj~}
an CU o~r{biftn}rgifr&
f dglnr, `nw lg
}n/grr~n bif{
lgtn} g{ {i {a
n} zgll grr~n
CU& [an CU
nfk c biuw {
{an bifdgj~
n CU, ri {ac{
rgif {ac{ g{ a
n fnz tn}rgi
ddnlgfj Onbac
cfk {an `nw
gba oncfr {a
n dg}r{ rli{ c
ji}g{ao& Rnb
lgr{ cfk ri if
n }nbngtn} rgk
OGBRR d}i
{ac{ zgll mnnw lgr{ id {ag
b}wu{ {an on
jn{ {an ra~d
ki {an ra~d
wlick {i {zi
nfn}c{n {an
jnfn}c{nk
j}g{w id {an
bbnrr uigf{r
}tn}& G{ acr {
c{gif dglnr di
ctn c jiikORR fnnkr r
gr{r cfk ra~dd
}il ucb`n{ {i
ORR bif{}i
{an fnz dgln
zgll `nnu c b
{an cuuigf{
}c{gif dglnr
g{ zgll }nulcb
k& [an fikn
cfk }nrn{ cll
gro&
cfk {an ra~ddl
{ {an dg}r{ {g
k {an dg}r{ u
fk {gon {an r
~f{gl {an nfk&
n, {an }nbngt
{an onrrcj
~rnk {i knb}wr clji}g{ao c
rrcjn& [an }n
lgfj }iz d}i
lgfj, cd{n} {a
uc}{r !onrrc
GB di} {an o
GB zg{a {a
nrrcjn&
iun}c{gifr8 [
n c~{ai}g{w {i
} ifn fikn i
}ibnrrgfj uin}tn} {i grr~
ln {cmlnr& Cfw
{an CU, zag
l rn}tn}& [an
r fnnknk cfk
iuw id {an dgl
nk fikn& [an
fk grr~n c b
n {an ilk dgln
zgll }nulcbn {
{an bi~f{n}r&
n kc{c
n {an
gf{nk
nbifk
} zgll
& [an
u{ {ank @R
bngtn}
{an
c{ {an
n cfk
rrcjn
ifn
an CU
grr~n
ntnf
n} {ifnz
fikn
a {an
ORR
rnfk
nr di}
fikn
if{}il
r zg{a
n ilk
Rli
ifacbrlifiun}biun}mnboncuuzglORra~
[g}nd m}cfcf~rnf{an“}n“]
cb{
ORR knunfk{r cfk un}o~{
m~{ di~} cl`n} i} gf{}~kn{r bifdgj~}c{gn gf {an fn{zo~{c{gif& G{mgfnk zg{a
o~{c{gif id {ac~rn gd ifn icfr, ORR bnc}cfbn id {al znc`nf {anR acr riltnkddlgfj {an OG
[CMLN GG&
Lgr{ cfk f~onr, rgfjln/r}nfbnk gf {an
b`n{r, di} nqn!r' id nkg{imn} bg{c{gif
{nfbn u~fb{~c}ndn}nfbn f~
dn}nfbn P2_‟dn}nfbn P2_ zF~omn} dii{
~cl dii{fi{n c
T& BI
if Un}o~{cc{gif id Ra~dd
i}g{aor {i n} fnnkr {i knfr, `nw lgr{ri}`& ORR kiknunfkr if{an un}o~{
n ra~ddlgfj {cd {an clji}g{acf bi~f{n}c{ clji}g{ao gr{}nfj{a id {agr {an r{c{gbmg{r gfrgkn {
BIOUC]GRIF MN
]ND
mn} cll mgmlgicbnk, c{ {an{nq{, nfblirnouln P3_& Z}r id }ndn}nf
bifrnb~{gtn{gif dillizr {omn}, cr gf Pnqbnu{ c{ {cr {an dg}r{ & &fi{nr rnuc}c{{ {an mi{{io
FBL^RGIF
{gif id `nwr,lgfj [cmlnr& M
b}wu{ cfk kgrn c oncf {cfk ra~ddlgfr fi{ knunfk
{an un}o~{c{g{gif id {anlnr& ORR gr cr gr di~fk {
g{r nddnb{ mf {an bifdgj~n ORR& Cfi{lcbnonf{ id n i}gjgfcl on
[ZNNF ZNU =,
N]NFBNR }cuagbcl }ndnnfk id wi
{an bg{c{gif fan}n cuu}iu}gnk mii`r& [lw zg{agf m}an m}cb`n{ P=_2_‛ki fi{ ~n mnjgffgfj&‟lw gf r~un}rd {an bil~of
Un}o~{c{gifw ~rgfj fi{ i
b}wu{ zg{a,j~nrr {an nq{cmlnr di} n
iflw if {anif id {an `
rli{r cfklri ocgf{cgfc
m}i`nf mww knfwgfjc{gif rli{r& [
an} u}imlno {{an OGB mg{rrrcjn&
UC = CFK ORR
nfbnr gf 7/ui} ucun}& Z~omn} gf rs~gc{n, gfbl~knn {noulc{n
cb`n{r P3_&& ]ndn} rgoulwrn “]nd& P2_‟id c rnf{nf
}gu{r& Ulcbngf zagba g{
id lw
fwcb{banwwr
{anmlnfw{anagrac{mw
gf{nf
c}n{angllan{ii}
bn8
{ancr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 337
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 135/223
bg{nk& Ki fi{ u~{ dii{fi{nr gf {an }ndn}nfbn lgr{& ^rn ln{{n}rdi} {cmln dii{fi{nr&
^flnrr {an}n c}n rgq c~{ai}r i} oi}n jgtn cll c~{ai}r‗fconr0 ki fi{ ~rn “n{ cl&‟& Ucun}r {ac{ actn fi{ mnnfu~mlgrank, ntnf gd {anw actn mnnf r~mog{{nk di} u~mlgbc{gif,rai~lk mn bg{nk cr “~fu~mlgrank‟ P;_& Ucun}r {ac{ actn mnnfcbbnu{nk di} u~mlgbc{gif rai~lk mn bg{nk cr “gf u}nrr‟ P>_&Bcug{clgxn iflw {an dg}r{ zi}k gf c ucun} {g{ln, nqbnu{ di}u}iun} fi~fr cfk nlnonf{ rwomilr&
Di} ucun}r u~mlgrank gf {}cfrlc{gif hi~}fclr, ulncrn jgtn{an Nfjlgra bg{c{gif dg}r{, dilliznk mw {an i}gjgfcl di}ngjf/lcfj~cjn bg{c{gif P4_&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ GNNN8 GNNN 15=&338 Zg}nlnrr LCF Onkg~o Cbbnrr Bif{}il !OCB'cfk Uawrgbcl Lcwn} !UAW' Runbgdgbc{gifr !=55:',a{{u8))r{cfkc}kr&gnnn&i}j)cmi~{)jn{)15=)15=&33&a{ol&
P=_ Rnuna}kck, U&, Tc~knfcw, R&, T~cjfi~q, O&8 Kgrbitn}w cfkNqulig{c{gif id Fnz Mgcrnr gf ]B;& Gf8 Mg}w~`it, C&, Jifj, J&,R{gfrif, K&]& !nkr&' RCB =535& LFBR, til& 4>;;, uu& :;‒73&Ru}gfjn}, Angknlmn}j !=533'&
P2_ Rnuna}kck, U&, Tc~knfcw, R&, T~cjfi~q, O&8 R{c{gr{gbcl C{{cb` if]B; Kgr{gfj~gragfj ZUC& Cbbnu{nk c{ N^]IB]WU[ =533 !=533'&
P;_ T~cjfi~q, O&8 Biou~{n} Cgknk B}wu{cfclwrgr d}io Bguan}r {i Rgknbacffnlr& UaK {anrgr, Nbiln Uilw{nbafgs~n D»nk»n}cln kn Lc~rcffn ‛
NUDL !=535'&P>_ Zuc/Zuc=, a{{u8))zzz&lwlnmcb`noi}{&bio)mlij)=551)>)35) zuc/
zuc=/cr/gfrnb~}n/cr/g/nqunb{nk !cbbnrrnk if Oc}ba 3;, =535'&
P4_ C& A& K& Lcra`c}g, O&O&R& , Rcockg, M&, -C r~}tnw if zg}nlnrrrnb~}g{w u}i{ibilr !ZNU, ZUC cfk ZUC=)15=&33g',- Biou~{n}Rbgnfbn cfk Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw, =fk GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifclBifdn}nfbn if Mnghgfj, GBBRG[ =557, uu&;1/>=, =557&&
P:_ N&H&O&C& Dglai, U&F&L& Difrnbc, O&H&R& Lng{ci, cfk U&R&D& kn Mc}}ir,“Rnb~}g{w tn}r~r Mcfkzgk{a8 [an R~uui}{ id Onbacfgror ZNU $ZUC gf 15=&33j Fn{zi}`,‟ GDGU Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn ifZg}nlnrr cfk Iu{gbcl Bioo~fgbc{gifr Fn{zi}`r, ZIBF *5:, uu& 3/>, =55:&
P1_ O& Mliba n{ cl&, “Zg}nlnrr Gfdi}oc{gif/[ani}n{gb Rnb~}g{w,‟ GNNN[}cfr& Gfdi& [ani}w, til& >;, fi& 4, H~fn =551, uu& =>3>‒2;&
P7_ R& Oc{a~} n{ cl&, “]ckgi/[nlnuc{aw8 Nq{}cb{gfj c B}wu{ij}cuagb @nwd}io cf ^fc~{anf{gbc{nk Zg}nlnrr Bacffnl,‟ 3;{a CBO OimgBio,
=551&
P35_ [nb[c}jn{& !=551'& Zg/Dg U}i{nb{nk Cbbnrr& ]n{}gntnk 5> Ocw, =551,d}io a{{u8))rnc}baoimglnbiou~{gfj&{nba{c}jn{&bio)rKndgfg{gif) 5,,rgk;5Yjbg11:2=2,55&a{ol&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 136/223
g
U}ib& id {
Til~on 3& B
GRMF8 7:1/
]cja~t
Knuc}{onf{
Bnf{}cl ^fg
Ch
mr{}cb{‛ C
nbafilijw {a
gddn}nf{ rnb~
c{c c}n kgddn
actn {i jcgf c
ioo~fgbc{gi
onkg~o gr fi
bbnrrnk zg{a
nb~}g{w id zg
gfbn g{r knt
zg}nlnrr fn{z
gddn}nf{ c{{cb
nb~}g{w onba
@nwzi}kr/
G& ZL
& ZLCF Rn
ZNU gr {
goulnonf{nk&ZNU mw b}wu
U}i{nb{nk Cb
crrnk, ]RF
~fkn} {an d~ll
M& Zg}nk Ns
ZNU zcr
zg}nlnrr ~rn}
zg}nk fn{zi}
rnb~}g{w lntn
rnb~}g{w lntnl
3' Aiz
cfk ntn}w k
R{}nco bgua
Gfg{gclgxc{gif
}gjgfcl ucb`
guan} zagba
guan} r{}nco
rnfkn} bcf ba
{i {an }nbngtn
n Gf{l& Bifd&
uw}gja{ § =5
3/7=5>:>/:/
CBO "8 kmn
n} Rgfja Ka
id Biou~{n}
$ Nfjj&
tn}rg{w id ]ch
on}, Gfkgc
zg}nk cfk
w ~rn {i {}c
}g{w crunb{r&
nf{ gf mi{a {
bnrr itn} {an
f g&n& zg}nr& M
fn i{an} {acf
{an anlu id ns
}nlnrr fn{zi}
liuonf{& [a
i}`r gr gf cg
`r& [a~r g{ gr
fgror {i zg}nl
ZNU0 ZUC0
F RNB^]G[W
~}g{w gf Jnfn
n di}noir{
Rntn}cl zn{cfclwr{r, cfk
bnrr !ZUC'
!clri `fizf
GNNN 15=&33g
gtclnf{ U}gtc
ntnliunk {i
if ZLCF
& ZNU, fi{ m
l {acf c zg
{i {ac{ mw zg}
NU zi}`r8
{c ucb`n{ gr
}& [agr `n
Tnb{i} !GT'
n{ gr {anf mg{
}nr~l{r gf cf
gr ~rnk {i nf
irn c kgddn}nf
}& Zn d~}{an}
f Biou~{n}
3= [nbafi Di
88 kig8 35& :
&gon}c&35& :2
C ]n
c`c
bgnfbn
cr{acf
zg}nlnrr fn{z
rog{ kc{c, {a
nbacfgror {
bafilijgnr& Gf
awrgbcl onkg
~{ gf zg}nlnrr
cg}, {an }ckg
guonf{ ctcgl
r acr clzcwr
{}cfrogrrgif
} zagba oc`
n}w kgddgb~l{ {
nrr fn{zi}`r&
GB0GBT0GT0B
U]I[IBILR
}cl
LCF rnb~}g{
`fnrrnr zn}ZNU zcr {c
gf =552, cf
cr ZUC='
r{cfkc}k P:,
w !ZNU' On
u}itgkn zg}nl
{ac{ gr ns~gt
ngfj gf{nfknk
}nk LCF, u
nk LCFr&
anf ZNU gr
nfb}wu{nk rn
w gr jnfn}
cfk c ;5/
zgrn QI]nk
nfb}wu{nk ul
b}wu{ ncba f
{ GT un}gikgb
biou~{n ;/m
Cuulgbc{gifr
}~o J}i~u, G
71;)GRMFY5
71;
gnz id Z
ZNU,
Knuc}{o
Bnf{}cl
i}` kgddn}r g
n}nmw goulno
cbbnrr {}cfr
zg}nk fn{zi
o ~rnk di} fn
fn{zi}`r rgf
i d}ns~nfbw b
mln gf oc}`n{
mnnf c ochi
id gfdi}oc{g
nr g{ t~lfn}c
i u}itgkn ~u {
OU0[@GU0O
FK ONBACFG
w onbacfgro
gknf{gdgnk g`nf ulcbn mw
k {anf cd{n}
gr }c{gdgnk gf
_&
acfgro
nrr rnb~}g{w
lnf{ {i mngfj
{i u}itgkn c
}itgknr ns~g
nfcmlnk {anf
uc}c{nlw zg{a
{nk mw c
g{ ZNU `nw
zg{a ]B; r
cgf{nq{& C kgd
z ucb`n{ rgf
llw& GT gr {an
w{n Gf{nj}g{w
kgc&
41
g}nlnrr Rn
ZUC cf
C}tgfk Kac
nf{ id Biou~
$ Nfjj&
^fgtn}rg{w id
Chon}, Gfkg
f {an
nf{gfj
g{{nk
`r zn
{zi}`
bn {an
cf mn
r& [an
grr~n
if gf
mln {i
i kc{n
B&
ROR
{i mn
f {anZg/Dg
{gon
=55;
{i {an
if c
gjan}
tclnf{
ncba
]B;
=;/mg{
& [an
{}nco
dn}nf{
n {an
f rnf{
anb`
Tcl
clr
nfb
=
]B
nfb
}nr
r{}
r~b
Z
2=!B
-ba
r{}
kgj
mn
on
Ra
cj
Z
lnc
uir
nf
b~}g{w U}
ZUC/=
`c
{n} Rbgnfbn
]chcr{acf
c
~n !GBT' if
nfb}wu{ G
}wu{gif onba
' T~lfn}cmg
; r{}nco bgu
}wu{gif& [agr
~l{r gf {an fnn
co bcf mn
bnrrd~l c{{cb
U oc`nr g{ c
fi{an} t~lfn
onbacfgroblgb ]nk~fk
nb`r~o-& B
fj cfk {a~r f
nr{ i} acra d~
fi{nk {ac{ {a
cr~}n gf ZN
og} C{{cb`
gfr{ {an `nw
U& Clri {an g
nk mw {an d
rgmln {i }nbi
~ja ZNU/nf
i{ibilr8
O~
Knu
Bn
{an i}gjgfcl u
T zg{a {an
cfgro gr raiz
Dgj~}n 3& Zn
lg{gnr cfk dlc
n} zg{a c =;
rai}{ rgxn G
k {i }n~rn {an
nqulig{nk mw
if {an bgua
dcgl~}n {i cbag
}cmln crunb{ i
agba gr ~rnkcfbw Bikn'
B gr fi{
i{ nddgbgnf{ n
fb{gifr r~ba
n ~rn id B]
, zagba gr
nrb}gmnr c u
rbank~lgfj c
fdi}oc{gif c
g}r{ mw{n jnf
r{}~b{ {an rnb
}wu{nk ucb`n
`~l Ocfoi
}{onf{ id Bi
$ Nf
{}cl ^fgtn}rg{
Chon},
cb`n{ cfk cu
]B; bguan
f gf dillizgf
Nfb}wu{gif&
zr id ZNU8
/ mg{ Gfg{gclgx
gr c znc`fn
`nw r{}nco&
{an c{{cb`n
n} {nq{& [agr
ntn {an rnb~}g
d {an ZNU gr
di} {an gf{njgr bifrgkn}nk
bifrgkn}nk b
i~ja {i mn ~
cr OK> i} R
B/2= zcr ~r
i{ {}~n& [an
crrgtn bguan}
lji}g{ao id
i~{ gfkgtgk~
n}c{nk mw ]
}n{ `nw gf Z
{r&
cf Onjazc
ou~{n} Rbgnf
j&
w id ]chcr{ac
Gfkgc
nfk zg{a g{&
r{}nco& Z
kgcj}co&
ZNU ~rnr
c{gif Tnb{i}
rr id ZNU c
agr }n~rn id
} {i un}di}o
t~lfn}cmglg{w
{w jiclr&
{an ~rn id B]
g{w banb`& Bcr c blcrr
}wu{ij}cuagb
nk cr c onrr
C P3_& G{ rai
k cr c rnb~
Dl~a}n} Ocf
{nq{/iflw c{{
B; cr ~rnk
l `nw mw{nr j
;& G{ bi~lk
U mw cfclwxg
l
n
n
NU
{an
di}
r g{
nw
c
id
B/
Bid
llw
jn
~lk
g{w
{gf
b`
gf
n{r
mn
gfj
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 137/223
[an c~{anf{gbc{gif dlcz gf {an GNNN 15=&33 acr mnnf
raizf gf u}ntgi~r zi}`r& C rgouln r~bbnrrd~l
nctnrk}iuugfj c{{cb` cjcgfr{ GNNN 15=&33clri zcr
knoifr{}c{nk zg{a {an ZNU nfcmlnk& Mi{a ]B; cfk GTr c}n fi{ ~rnk nddgbgnf{lw gf {an r{cfkc}k
ZNU& Mnbc~rn id {anrn }ncrifr zn bifbl~kn {ac{ 15=&33
ZNU gr {i{cllw gfrnb~}n cfk {an }ncrif gr fi{agfj m~{ uii}
goulnonf{c{gif id rnb~}n {nbafilijgnr !r~ba cr ]B;'& ZNU
zcr fi{ cf{gbguc{nk {i mn c jiik ril~{gif di} cll rnb~}g{w
fnnkr&
2' [an znc`fnrrnr id ZNU
c' Kg}nb{ ~rn id Ocr{n} `nwr8 [an ^rn id ocr{n} `nwr gr
fi{ kg}nb{lw }nbioonfknk& [an i{an} {noui}c}w `nwr c}n
jnfn}c{nk mw Ocr{n} `nwr&
m' Rocll `nw rgxnr8 [an ZNU ~rnr ;5 mg{r id `nw rgxn,
zagba acr mnnf bifrgkn}nk cr ifn id {an ochi} dlcz gf {anZNU& Gf 377:, ;5/mg{ `nw rgxn zcr bifrgkn}nk {i mn
}ncrifcmln di} rion cuulgbc{gifr& C{ {ac{ {gon {an jicl zcr
{i u}itgkn u}i{nb{gif cjcgfr{ {an bcr~cl nctnrk}iuugfj, g{
zcr rnnonk jiik {i u}itgkn r~ddgbgnf{ u}i{nb{gif c{ {ac{
{gon& [an}n gr fi cfw runbgdgbc{gif id ZNU `nw rgxnr i{an}
{anf ;5 mg{r gf {an 15=&33 r{cfkc}k& M~{ oir{ kncln}r cuulw
{an `nw rgxn {i 35; i} =2= mg{r& ]B; nfb}wu{gif `nw gfbl~knr
c =;/mg{ GT gf mi{a bcrnr& 35; cfk =2=/mg{ `nwr c}n oi}n
kndnfrgtn cjcgfr{ {i m}~{n/di}bn c{{cb`r gf biouc}grif {i {an
;5/mg{ `nwr m~{ g{ gr r{gll c u}imlno zagba gr fi{ }nriltnk wn{&
b' Fi{ actn nfi~ja `nw ocfcjnonf{ 8 ZNU r{cfkc}k
kinr fi{ runbgdw `nw ocfcjnonf{& Zg{ai~{ gf{n}iun}cmln
`nw ocfcjnonf{, `nwr zgll mn id gfdn}gi} s~clg{w cfk lgtnrdi} c lifjn} {gon& [a~r {agr gr bifrgkn}nk cr g{r znc`fnrr&
Oir{ id {an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r goulnonf{gfj ZNU rac}nr c
rgfjln ZNU `nw mn{znnf ncba cfk ntn}w fikn if {an
fn{zi}`& Rcon ZNU `nw gr ~rnk {i u}ij}co {an cbbnrr
uigf{r cfk blgnf{ r{c{gifr& [an {cr` id bacfjgfj {an `nwr gr
cfifwoi~r cfk kgddgb~l{&
k' ^rn id ]B;8 Goulnonf{c{gif id ]B; acr mnnf
bifrgkn}nk {i actn znc` `nwr, gfkgbc{gfj oi}n bi}}nlc{gif
mn{znnf {an `nw cfk {an i~{u~{& G{ gr ncrw him {i kn{n}ogfn
ucb`n{r nfb}wu{nk zg{a znc` `nwr& [an dg}r{ {a}nn mw{nr id
{an `nw c}n nq{}cb{nk d}io {an GT {ac{ gr rnf{ ~fnfb}wu{nk gf
ncba ucb`n{& [agr znc`fnrr bcf mn nqulig{nk ~rgfj c ucrrgtn
c{{cb`&
n' ]n~rnk cfk rocll rgxnk GT 8 Zn di~fk {ac{ i~{ id {an
ctcglcmln 34 ogllgif GT tcl~nr 7,555 c}n gf{n}nr{gfj& [anw
raiz {an u}nrnfbn id znc` `nwr& [an c{{cb`n} bcu{~}nr
-gf{n}nr{gfj ucb`n{r- {i dgfk i~{ {an znc` `nwr, {anf
cfclwxnr {ano cfk iflw acr {i {}w c rocll f~omn} id `nwr {i
jcgf cbbnrr {i {an fn{zi}`& Mnbc~rn cll i}gjgfcl GU ucb`n{r
r{c}{ zg{a c `fizf tcl~n, g{‗r ncrw {i `fiz zanf ~rn} acr
{an }gja{ `nw& [i kn{n}ogfn c 35;/mg{ ZNU `nw, c{{cb`n} acr
{i bcu{~}n {an gf{n}nr{gfj ucb`n{r mn{znnf =,555 cfk ;,555&
If c m~rw fn{zi}` {an bcu{~}n id {an >555 gf{n}nr{gfj
ucb`n{r ogja{ fi{ bc~rn cfw kgddgb~l{w cfk {agr bcf mn kifn
gf c tn}w rai}{ {gon un}gik& Ocfw kncln}r c}n fiz
goulnonf{gfj fnz clji}g{aor {ac{ c}n rgoulw mcrnk if fi
rnlnb{gif id znc` GT& [an mnr{ ril~{gif id {agr {wun id c{{cb`
gr fi{ {i ~rn znc` GT tcl~nr&
Di} c ZNU `nw, knrug{n id {an `nw rgxn, =;/ mg{ lifj GTbcf iflw u}itgkn 34,:::,=34 kgddn}nf{ ]B; bguan} r{}ncor&
[agr f~omn} bcf mn cbagntnk if c m~rw fn{zi}` gf c dnz
ai~}r cfk zn bcf }n~rn {an rcon GT& [an ]B; r{}nco bguan}
gr QI]nk zg{a {an i}gjgfcl ucb`n{ gf {an ZNU cfk {an GT gr
rnf{ gf {an blnc} di}oc{ zg{a ncba ucb`n{ P2_& Gd {an ]B;
r{}nco bguan} di} c jgtnf GT gr di~fk, r~mrns~nf{ ucb`n{r
nfb}wu{nk zg{a {an rgoglc} GT bcf mn knb}wu{nk mw cf
c{{cb`n}& [an}n c}n ocqgo~o 34,:::,=34 GT tcl~nr&
^fl~b`glw, ZNU kinrf‗{ runbgdw r~ba dcbglg{w {ac{ aiz {i
baiirn i} aiz id{nf {i bacfjn GTr& Rion crr~onr {ac{ GT
r{c}{r c{ xn}i cfk gfb}ncrnr gfb}nonf{cllw di} ncba ucb`n{,
cfk }n{~}f mcb` {i xn}i cd{n} rnfkgfj 34 ogllgif ucb`n{r&
Cfk rion i{an} baiirnr GTr }cfkiolw& [an GT bairnf
}cfkiolw lnckr {i >5. bacfbn id }n~rn cd{n} lnrr {acf >,555
ucb`n{r&
d' Znc`fnrr id GBT clji}g{ao8 ZNU GBT gr mcrnk if
{an B]B/2= clji}g{ao ~r~cllw goulnonf{nk {i kn{nb{ figrn
clifj zg{a biooif n}}i}r gf {}cfrogrrgif& B]B/2= gr fi{
bifrgkn}nk cr c jiik baigbn di} b}wu{ij}cuagb acra& [an
B]B/2= GBT gr c lgfnc} d~fb{gif id {an onrrcjn& [agr
oncfr {ac{ c onrrcjn bcf mn nfb}wu{nk cfk {an GBT mn
ncrglw dgqnk, mw cf c{{cb`n}, oc`gfj {an onrrcjn cuunc}
c~{anf{gb& [i ki {agr cf nfb}wu{nk ucb`n{ r{}nco gr bcu{~}nk
cfk {an knr{gfc{gif ckk}nrr id ncba ucb`n{ gr bacfjnk zg{a
{an c{{cb`n}‗r zg}nk GU ckk}nrr, dgqgfj ~u {an B]B/2=&[anrn
ucb`n{r c}n {anf }n{}cfrog{{nk {i {an cbbnrr uigf{& [an
ucb`n{r zgll knb}wu{ mw {an cbbnrr uigf{ cfk cd{n} {ac{di}zc}k {ano {i {an c{{cb`n}& GT cfk GBT mcrnk c{{cb`r c}n
fi{ knunfk if {an `nw rgxn&
j' Ncrw di}jgfj id c~{anf{gbc{gif onrrcjnr8 [an}n c}n
{zi {wunr id c~{anf{gbc{gif on{aikr zagba c}n kndgfnk gf
15=&33 R{cfkc}kr& Ifn gr `fizf cr Iunf Rwr{no
c~{anf{gbc{gif cfk cfi{an} gr `fizf cr Rac}nk @nw
c~{anf{gbc{gif& Gd {an ZNU c~{anf{gbc{gif rn}tgbn gr nfcmlnk,
{anf {an gf{}~kn}r cfk c{{cb`n}r bcf j~nrr {an ZNU `nw P4,
35, 33_& Gf Rac}nk @nw c~{anf{gbc{gif {an bifbnu{ id rac}nk
ZNU `nw gr ~rnk {i nfb}wu{ {an bacllnfjn& Zg{a {agr bionr
{an uirrgmglg{w {ac{ {an bacllnfjn cfk nfb}wu{nk }nruifrn bcf
mn imrn}tnk mw cf c{{cb`n} zai gr oifg{i}gfj {an fn{zi}`
{}cddgb& Mw oifg{i}gfj {an r~bbnrrd~l c~{anf{gbc{gif, cfc{{cb`n} bcf di}jn cf c~{anf{gbc{gif& Rac}nk @nw
c~{anf{gbc{gif lgog{r {an cmglg{w id cf c{{cb`n} {i b}nc{n c
knfgcl/id/rn}tgbn c{{cb` mw rnfkgfj jc}mcjn ucb`n{r
!nfb}wu{nk zg{a {an z}ifj ZNU `nw' gf{i {an fn{zi}`&
ZNU gr dc} d}io cf gkncl rnb~}g{w ril~{gif m~{ g{ gr r{gll ~rnk&
B& Zg/Dg U}i{nb{nk Cbbnrr !ZUC' U}i{ibil
ZUC acr mnnf kntnliunk {i u}itgkn oi}n zg}nlnrrrnb~}g{w ril~{gif di} 15=&33/mcrnk fn{zi}`r& ZUC gr c}nulcbnonf{ itn} Zg}nk Ns~gtclnf{ U}gtcbw !ZNU' P=_& [angfk~r{}gnr cfk i}jcfgxc{gifr actn mnnf runfkgfj c j}nc{ knclid {gon cfk oifnw if kntnliugfj cfk knuliwgfj fnq{/
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3==
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 138/223
jnfn}c{gif ril~{gifr {ac{ ckk}nrr j}izgfj zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` rnb~}g{w u}imlnor& [an Zg/Dg !Zg}nlnrr Dgknlg{w' Cllgcfbnacr b}nc{nk {an Zg/Dg U}i{nb{nk Cbbnrr !ZUC' P;_& ZUC gr cr~mrn{ id {an 15=&33g r{cfkc}k&
Cf nfacfbnonf{r itn} ZNU8 ZUC gr cf nfacfbnonf{ itn}
u}n/nqgr{gfj u}i{ibil ZNU&ZUC {nbafilijw ocgflw
gfbl~knr {a}nn gou}itnonf{r itn} ZNU&
c' Gou}itnk kc{c nfb}wu{gif8 [noui}cl @nw Gf{nj}g{w
U}i{ibil ![@GU' gr cf gou}itnonf{ id kc{c nfb}wu{gif&
[@GU gr c [noui}cl @nw Acra D~fb{gif& [@GU gr cf
cl{n}fc{gtn {i ZNU& G{ dgqnr cll {an rnb~}g{w u}imlnor cfk
kinrf‗{ }ns~g}n fnz ac}kzc}n& [@GU ~rnr {an ]B; r{}nco
bguan} cr {an nfb}wu{gif cfk knb}wu{gif u}ibnrrnr cfk cll
gftiltnk uc}{gnr o~r{ rac}n {an rcon rnb}n{ `nw rgoglc}lw cr
lg`n gf ZNU P33_& [agr rnb}n{ `nw o~r{ mn 3=1 mg{r cfk gr
bcllnk {an -[noui}cl @nw- ![@'& [@GU clri ~rnr cf
Gfg{gclgxc{gif Tnb{i} !GT' id ;1/mg{& [an GT ~rnk cr c
bi~f{n}& Ntnf gd {an [@ gr rac}nk, cll gftiltnk uc}{gnr
jnfn}c{n c kgddn}nf{ ]B; `nw r{}nco&
m' ^rn} c~{anf{gbc{gif8 ^rn} c~{anf{gbc{gif gr ogrrgfj
gf ZNU, {a}i~ja {an nq{nfrgmln c~{anf{gbc{gif u}i{ibil
!NCU'& ZNU bif{}ilr cbbnrr {i c zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` zagba gr
mcrnk if c biou~{n}‗r ac}kzc}n/runbgdgb OCB ckk}nrr&
NCU gr m~gl{ if c oi}n rnb~}n u~mlgb/`nw nfb}wu{gif rwr{no
{i oc`n g{ bn}{cgf {i acuunf {ac{ iflw c~{ai}gxnk fn{zi}`
~rn}r bcf cbbnrr {an fn{zi}`&
b' [an s~clg{w id mngfj aifnr{ 8 Onrrcjn Gf{nj}g{w Bikn
!OGB' di} [@GU gr biou~{nk mw c fnz clji}g{ao& Onrrcjn
Gf{nj}g{w Bikn !OGB' gr biou~{nk {i kn{n}ogfn n}}i}r gf {an
kc{c bioulcbnfbw ng{an} k~n {i {}cfrdn} n}}i}r i} k~n {iu~}uirnd~l cl{n}c{gifr P>_& G{ gr c 4;/mg{ OGB {ac{ gr ckknk {i
{an Kc{c cfk {an GBT& [an GBT gr B]B id Kc{c cfk OGB&
k' Zac{ gr fnz gf ZUC gf biouc}grif {i ZNU9
Kg}nb{ ~rn id ocr{n} `nw gf ZNU8 Ocr{n} @nwr c}nfntn} ~rnk kg}nb{lw gf ZUC& C agn}c}baw id `nwr gr~rnk, cll kn}gtnk d}io {an ocr{n} `nw&
Uii} @nw Ocfcjnonf{ cfk ~ukc{gfj gf ZNU8Rnb~}n `nw ocfcjnonf{ gr c ulcffnk imrilnrbnfbndnc{~}n gf ZUC, ri `nw ocfcjnonf{ grf‗{ cf grr~nzg{a ZUC cr biouc}nk {i ZNU&
]n~rnk GT)Lnrr rgxn id GT 8 [an lnfj{a gr gfb}ncrnk id GT d}io =; mg{r {i ;1 mg{r& Ckkg{gifcllw, GTr c}n~rnk cr rns~nfbn bi~f{n}r di} {an [RB ![@GU
Rns~nfbn Bi~f{n}', u}i{nb{gfj cjcgfr{ }nulcwgfj id kc{c, zagba zcr c ochi} t~lfn}cmglg{w gf ZNU&
Znc` GT tcl~nr c}n r~rbnu{gmln {i c{{cb` 8 C kgddn}nf{rnb}n{ `nw gr ~rnk di} ncba ucb`n{, cfk {an zcw {an`nw gr oi}n s~gb`lw zg{a {an rnb}n{ `nw gr oi}nbioulnq&
Gfnddnb{gtn Onrrcjn gf{nj}g{w banb`gfj8 Gf{nj}g{wu}i{ibil B]B/2= zcr u}itnk gfnddnb{gtn di} ZNUonrrcjn ri ZUC ~rnr c Onrrcjn Gf{nj}g{w Banb` !OGB' onbacfgro bcllnk, &Ogbacnl&
b&K}czmcb` gf ZUC8 [an 15=&33g r{cfkc}k raizr {ac{
`nwr jnfn}c{nk d}io rai}{ ucrrzi}kr c}n r~mhnb{ {i
kgb{gifc}w c{{cb` cfk c `nw {ac{ gr jnfn}c{nk d}io c ucrr
ua}crn id lnrr {acf =5 bac}cb{n}r gr ~flg`nlw {i kn{n}
c{{cb`r&
K& ZUC/= !]im~r{ Rnb~}g{w Fn{zi}`r/ ]RFr'
15=&33g {ac{ acr mnnf cuunc}nk gf =55; ~rnr {an lijgb id c
]im~r{ Rnb~}g{w Fn{zi}` !]RF'& [agr fnz r{cfkc}k cfk
c}bag{nb{~}n ckiu{ {an GNNN 15=&3Q r{cfkc}k di} cbbnrr
bif{}il cfk di} nfb}wu{gif g{ ~rnr Cktcfbnk Nfb}wu{gif
R{cfkc}k !CNR'& G{ ~rnr c ucg}/zgrn `nw nqbacfjn !di~} zcw
acfkrac`n' u}i{ibil ~{glgxgfj 15=&3Q di} o~{~cl
c~{anf{gbc{gif cfk `nw ocfcjnonf{ u}ibnrr& 15=&33g cllizr
~rn id [@GU, m~{ mw kndc~l{ ]RF ~rnr CNR !Cktcfbnk
Nfb}wu{gif R{cfkc}k' cfk BBOU !Bi~f{n} Oikn BMB
OCB U}i{ibil'& G{ u}itgknr c r{}ifjn}, rbclcmln ril~{gif&
3' Zi}`gfj id ZUC/=8 ZUC/= ~rnr kwfcogb
fnji{gc{gif id c~{anf{gbc{gif cfk nfb}wu{gif clji}g{aor
mn{znnf cbbnrr uigf{r cfk oimgln kntgbnr& [an
c~{anf{gbc{gif rbanonr c}n mcrnk if 15=&3Q cfk Nq{nfrgmln
C~{anf{gbc{gif U}i{ibil !NCU'& Zn ~rn Cktcfbnk
Nfb}wu{gif R{cfkc}k !CNR' di} nfb}wu{gif P1_& ZUC/= gr
rgjfgdgbcf{lw r{}ifjn} gf biouc}grif {i ZNU cfk ZUC&
Aizntn}, {agr u}i{ibil zi~lk }~f tn}w uii}lw if lnjcbw
kntgbnr& Iflw {an lc{nr{ kntgbnr actn {an bcucmglg{w }ns~g}nk
{i cbbnln}c{n {an clji}g{aor&
GG& BIOUC]GRIF ID ZNU, ZUC CFK ZUC/=
RNB^]G[W U]I[IBILR
C& ZNU
ZNU ~rnr ]B; bguan}& [an GT gr gfrnb~}n& G{ ~rnr ;5 mg{rid nfb}wu{gif `nw& [an}n gr c bifbc{nfc{gif id `nw cfk GT
tcl~nr di} un} ucb`n{ c}n rnf{ itn} {an cg}, `nw ocfcjnonf{
onbacfgro gr fi{ nomnkknk gf g{, g{ actn fi c~{ioc{gb i}
un}gikgb nw&
M& ZUC
G{ ~rnr c r~mrn{ id 15=&33g& G{ ~rnr ]B; cfk [@GU di}
nfb}wu{gif bguan} onbacfgro& [an `nw rgxn gr 3=1 mg{r& G{
~rnr ogqnk {wun Nfb}wu{gif `nw un} ucb`n{ P4_& 15=&3q
kwfcogb `nw ocfcjnonf{ onbacfgro& [an GT rgxn gr ;1
mg{&15=&3q NCU ~rcjn di} c~{anf{gbc{gif, u}itgkgfj kc{c
gf{nj}g{w cfk anckn} gf{nj}g{w& [an [@GU cfk GT rns~nfbn
onbacfgro c}n ~rnk {i u}ntnf{ }nulcw c{{cb`r&
B& ZUC/=
Di} zg}nlnrr rnb~}g{w ZUC/= rnnor {i mn {an r{}ifjnr{
rnb~}g{w u}i{ibil& ZUC/= u}itgknr cll {an cktcf{cjnr id
ZUC gf ckkg{gif {i r{}ifjn} nfb}wu{gif {a}i~ja {an
goulnonf{c{gif id CNR, }icogfj r~uui}{ cfk BBO
onbacfgro di} kc{c cfk anckn} gf{nj}g{w P35_& ZUC
knuliwonf{r itn} b~}}nf{ ZNU gfr{cllc{gifr u}itgkn bir{
nddnb{gtn cfk acrrln d}nn ragd{r zan}n tnfki}r bcf {}cfrg{ {i
{an ZUC r{cfkc}k {a}i~ja c rid{zc}n i} dg}ozc}n ~uj}ckn&
Di} ZUC/={agr gr fi{ {an bcrn& G{ }ns~g}nr nq{}c ac}kzc}n
~uj}ckn gf i}kn} {i goulnonf{ CNR P3=_&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 139/223
[CMLN
Zg}nlnrr f
i{ ocfcjnk
ioucfgnr& R
~r{ mn gknf{
nbnrrc}w bi
n{zi}`& Cl{
ifrgkn}nk {i
{i mn c knunf
G& BIOUC
GGG& {zi}`r c}n ~
u}iun}lw og
mndi}n gfr{cl
gdgnk, ntcl~c{
f{n} oncr~}n
ai~ja fi
{cllw ~fm}nc`c
kcmln ifn& G{
GRIF ID RNB^]G
BIFBL^RGIF
rnk gf m~rgfn
a{ bc~rn tn
lgfj cfw r~b
k, cfk mcrnk
r o~r{ mn gfr
nb~}g{w rwr{
mln, 15=&33g
r~ddn}r fifn
[W U]I[IBILR
rr ZLCFr {a
}w rn}gi~r }g
fn{zi}`r, cll
if {an }nr~l{
{cllnk {i rnb~
no bcf nt
RF rnb~}g{w
id {an u}imln
c{ c}n
`r {i
}gr`r
r, {an
}n {an
} mn
rnnor
or id
ilk
15
bcf
{gornb
og
~rc
P3_
P=_
P2_
P;_
P>_
P4_
P:_
P1_
P7_
P35_
P33_
P3=_
n} onbacfgro
&33g ZUC/= g
}nlw if ~f{gl
n mngfj gf {n~}g{w u}ndn}}
go~o bir{ u
jn id ZUC gr
GNNN8 GNNN 15cfk Uawrgbca{{u8))r{cfkc}kr
Lg, L&, Xa~, L&ZUC rnb~}g{w[nlnbioo~fgb
Rnuna}kck, U&,Nqulig{c{gif id Jifj, J&, R{gfr
73& Ru}gfjn}, ARnuna}kck, U&,]B; Kgr{gfj~gr
T~cjfi~q, O&8bacffnlr& UaKNUDL !=535'&
ZgfUbcu8 Zgfa{{u8))zzz&zgfa{{u8))zzz&lwlngfrnb~}n/cr/g/n
@}grafco]ch~,@&T&R&T&F8 Di^rgfj Bcrun}gfdi}oc{gif cfGfkgc !Rnu{nom
A~fj, B&B&, Z
@nw Nfb}wu{giHi~}fcl id Bio
Agn}{x, J&, KnfM&8 [an GNNN4=‒:5 !=535'&
C&A&K& Lcra`cu}i{ibilr !ZNGfdi}oc{gif [Mnghgfj, GBBRG
N&H&O&C& Dglai,“Rnb~}g{w tn}rZUC gf 15=&Zg}nlnrr cfk I>, =55:&
C& K& Ui{i}cb c15=&33 ZLCF
Bif{}il Rwr{no
r cfk u}i{ibi
gr c zg}nlnrr
g{r t~lfn}cmg
}or id bir{ tk {anf ZU
ndn}}nk ZNU
}nbioonfkn
]NDN]
=&338 Zg}nlnrr Ll Lcwn} !U&gnnn&i}j)cmi~{)j
, H~, [&8 [an ]rwr{no& Hi~}fcl{gifr =;!3', :1‒
, Tc~knfcw, R&Fnz Mgcrnr gf ]if, K&]& !nkr&'
ngknlmn}j !=533'&Tc~knfcw, R&,
agfj ZUC& Cbbn
Biou~{n} Cgkn{anrgr, NbilnUil
ubcu8 [an zgfubcu&i}j)Zuc/mcb`noi}{&bio) unb{nk !cbbnrrnk
@&T&, Tcllg`~}ocl Tn}gdgbc{giK]& Gf8 Gf{n}fk bioo~fgbc{gin} =535'&
~, N&A&, Z~, B&
Rbanon di} {anu~{n}r 31!;' !=5
{nfnn}, K&, R{gmi}5=&33 ~fgtn}rn&
}g, O&O&R& ,Rcoc, ZUC cfk ZUbafilijw, =fk=557, uu&;1/>=
U&F&L& Difrnbc,r Mcfkzgk{a8 [33j Fn{zi}`,‟u{gbcl Bioo~fg
k K& Mclcf&“[a[a}i~jau~{‟, Bi
r, til& =, uu& ;:/
lr fconlw Z
nb~}g{w u}i{i
lg{gnr c}n m}i
n}r~r rnb~}g{C/= o~r{ m
o~r{ mn nou
k&
NFBNR
CF Onkg~o CbAW' Runbgdgb{)15=)15=&33&a{
rnc}ba id 15=&3id Fcfhgfj ^fg3 !=55;'&
&, T~cjfi~q,B;& Gf8 Mg}w~`itCB =535& LFBR
~cjfi~q, O&8
u{nk c{ N^]IB]
B}wu{cfclwrgr d {nbafgs~nD»nk»n
izr ucb`n{ bcuuc=,lij)=551)>)35) if Oc}ba 3;, =5
c}g, T&, Rcfknid GNNN15=&34
{gifcl Bifdn}nff {nbafilijgnr,
L&, Jc~, ]&L&, B
Fnq{ Jnfn}c{gi1'&
, L&, Xcfj, W&, BGNNN Bioo~fgb
kg, M&, -C r~}tnwC=)15=&33g',- BGNNN Gf{n}fc{gi
, =557&
O&H&R& Lng{ci, can R~uui}{ id GDGU Gf{n}fc{gic{gifr Fn{zi}`r
Goucb{ id Rnb~}ou~{n}
=, =557&
U cfk ZUC&
il {ac{ cfwm
ja{ i~{& Di}
iu{gifr, gd n nouliwnk,
liwnk, i{an}z
bnrr Bif{}il !O{gifr !=5l&
3 Zg}nlnrr Fn{zn}rg{w id Uir{r
&8 Kgrbitn}w, C&,, til& 4>;;, uu&
{c{gr{gbcl C{{cb` WU[ =533 !=533
}io Bguan}r {i}cln kn Lc~rcffn
{~}n lgm}c}w !=5
zuc/zuc=35'&
utc}oc, F&, ]o U@Ot2 U}i{bn if cktcfbnrGB[ =535, @n}
anf, W&B&8 C O
Zg}nlnrr Fn{z
r{c, Q&U&, Zcl`n,c{gifr Ocjcxgfn
if zg}nlnrr rnb~ou~{n} Rbgnfbnfcl Bifdn}nfbn
fk U&R&D& kn Mc}nbacfgror ZN
fcl Bifdn}nfbn, ZIBF *5:, uu
g{w Itn}anckr ifRbgnfbn
Ri
kw
{an
~llgd
grn
B':',
i}` cfk
cfk
:;‒
if'&
gkn‛
1',
/cr/
ch~,bilgf
clc,
l{g/
}`&
;1,
}g{wcfkif
}ir,U nif
& 3/
cfk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 140/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/488 kig8 35& :;;5; )GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;;5;
R~}tnw id Rnb~}g{w Grr~nr gf Oimgln Ck/Aib Fn{zi}`
U}cd~l ]&Uc}kagCrrgr{cf{ U}idnrri}
Ra}g ]coknimcmc Billnjn id
Nfjgfnn}gfj $ Ocfcjnonf{
Fcju~}, Ocac}cra{}c
Cmr{}cb{ / Cf ck/aib fn{zi}` gr c rnld/bifdgj~}gfj fn{zi}` id
zg}nlnrr lgf`r biffnb{gfj oimgln fiknr& [anrn fiknr ocw mn
}i~{n}r cfk)i} air{r& [an oimgln fiknr bioo~fgbc{n kg}nb{lw
zg{a ncba i{an} cfk zg{ai~{ {an cgk id cbbnrr uigf{r, cfk
{an}ndi}n actn fi dgqnk gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& [anw di}o cf
c}mg{}c}w {iuilijw, zan}n {an }i~{n}r c}n d}nn {i oitn
}cfkiolw cfk c}}cfjn {anornltnr cr }ns~g}nk&
Ncba fikn i} oimgln kntgbn gr ns~guunk zg{a c {}cfrog{{n}
cfk }nbngtn}& [anw c}n rcgk {i mn u~}uirn/runbgdgb,c~{ifioi~r cfk kwfcogb& [agr biouc}nr j}nc{lw zg{a dgqnk
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r, cr {an}n gr fi ocr{n} rlctn }nlc{gifragu
{ac{ nqgr{r gf c oimgln ck/aib fn{zi}`& Fiknr }nlw if ncba
i{an} {i nr{cmlgrank bioo~fgbc{gif, {a~r ncba fikn cb{r cr
c }i~{n}& [an}ndi}n, gf c oimgln ck/aib fn{zi}`, c ucb`n{
bcf {}ctnl d}io c ri~}bn {i c knr{gfc{gif ng{an} kg}nb{lw, i}
{a}i~ja rion rn{ id gf{n}onkgc{n ucb`n{ di}zc}kgfj
fiknr&Gf c zg}nlnrr zi}lk, kiogfc{nk mw Zg/Dg,
c}bag{nb{~}nr zagba ogq onra fn{zi}`gfj cfk ck/aib
biffnb{gifr c}n {an mnjgffgfj id c {nbafilijw }ntil~{gif
mcrnk if {ang} rgoulgbg{w&
Ck aib fn{zi}`r P3_ kc{n mcb` {i {an Rntnf{gnr& [anw zn}n
kntnliunk mw {an Kndnfrn Di}bnr, {i bioulw zg{a c oglg{c}w
d}conzi}`& [an cgo zcr {i }cugklw knuliw c }im~r{, oimgln
cfk }ncb{gtn fn{zi}`, ~fkn} cfw bg}b~or{cfbnr& [anrn
fn{zi}`r {anf u}itnk ~rnd~l gf bioon}bgcl cfk gfk~r{}gcl
dgnlkr, dg}r{ cgk iun}c{gifr cfk nquli}c{gif ogrrgifr& Ck aib
fn{zi}`r, clri bcllnk unn}/{i/unn} fn{zi}`r, r{gll actn c
lifj zcw {i ji gf i}kn} {i mn d~llw d~fb{gifcl cfk
bioon}bgcl, cr g{ acr g{r kndnb{r r~ba cr rnb~}g{w cfk }i~{gfj
zagba zn zgll kgrb~rr d~}{an}&
@nw Zi}kr8 Oimgln Ck Aib Fn{zi}`, Rnb~}g{w, Gf{}~rgif Kn{nb{gif, Rnb~}n ]i~{gfj
G& OCFN[ NFTG]IFONF[ TC]GC[GIFR
[an kgddn}nf{ OCFN[ nftg}ifonf{ tc}gc{gifr c}n
lgr{nk cr dillizr {c`gfj g{r kwfcogb {iuilijw gf {i
bifrgkn}c{gif8
3&3 Gf OCFN[R cll fiknr actn gknf{gbcl bcucmglg{gnr
cfk }nruifrgmglg{gnr, zagba c}n {n}onk cr d~llw
rwoon{}gb nftg}ifonf{& C oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`
!OCFN[' gr c fn{zi}` biou}grgfj zg}nlnrr oimgln fiknr
{ac{ bioo~fgbc{n zg{a ncba i{an} zg{ai~{ bnf{}clgxnk
bif{}il i} nr{cmlgrank gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& [anrn fiknr zagba
c}n zg{agf ncba i{an}‗r }ckgi }cfjn bcf bioo~fgbc{n
kg}nb{lw, zagln kgr{cfbn fiknr }nlw if {ang} fngjami}gfj
fiknr {i di}zc}k ucb`n{r& Gf OCFN[R ntn}w fikn bcf mn
c air{ i} }i~{n}& Gf OCFN[ nftg}ifonf{, fiknr c}n d}nn {i
higf i} lnctn {an fn{zi}` c{ cfw uigf{ id {gon, }nr~l{gfj gf c
agjalw kwfcogb fn{zi}` nftg}ifonf{ biouc}nk {i zg}nk
fn{zi}`&
3&= [an Crwoon{}gb Bcucmglg{gnr gf OCFN[R gfbl~kn{}cfrogrrgif }cfjnr cfk }ckgir }cfjnr zagba ocw kgddn}&
Mc{{n}w lgdn, runnk id oitnonf{ cfk u}ibnrrgfj bcucbg{w
zgll mn kgddn}nf{ c{ kgddn}nf{ fiknr&
3&2 Crwoon{}gb ]nruifrgmglg{gnr gfbl~kn {ac{ iflw
rion fiknr ocw }i~{n ucb`n{r gf {an fn{zi}` i} rion
fiknr ocw cb{ cr lnckn}r di} fnc}mw fiknr lg`n bl~r{n}
anck&
3&; [}cddgb bac}cb{n}gr{gbr ocw kgddn} gf kgddn}nf{ ck aib
fn{zi}`r lg`n mg{ }c{n, {gonlgfnrr bifr{}cgf{r, }nlgcmglg{w
}ns~g}nonf{r, ~fgbcr{ i} o~l{gbcr{ i} jnibcr{, air{/mcrnk
ckk}nrrgfj i} bif{nf{/mcrnk ckk}nrrgfj i} bcucmglg{w/mcrnk
ckk}nrrgfj&
3&> OCFN[R ocw bi/nqgr{ cfk clri bi/iun}c{n zg{a cfgfd}cr{}~b{~}n mcrnk fn{zi}` &
3&4 Oimglg{w uc{{n}fr ocw mn kgddn}nf{ lg`n uniuln
rg{{gfj c{ cf cg}ui}{ li~fjn, bg{wzgkn {cqg bcmr, oglg{c}w
oitnonf{r cfk un}rifcl c}nc fn{zi}`r& [an un}di}ocfbn
id c oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` gr knunfknf{ if {an fikn
oimglg{w uc{{n}f cr znll cr {iuilijw, kc{c {}cddgb uc{{n}fr,
cfk }ckgi gf{n}dn}nfbn&
3&: Oimglg{w bac}cb{n}gr{gbr gfbl~kn runnk,
u}nkgb{cmglg{w, kg}nb{gif id oitnonf{, uc{{n}f id
oitnonf{, ~fgdi}og{w id oimglg{w bac}cb{n}gr{gbr coifj
kgddn}nf{ fiknr&
GG& ]I^[GFJ U]I[IBILR
]i~{gfj u}i{ibilr mn{znnf cfw ucg} id fiknr zg{agf
cf ck aib fn{zi}` bcf mn kgddgb~l{ mnbc~rn {an fiknr bcf
oitn }cfkiolw cfk bcf clri higf i} lnctn {an fn{zi}`&
[agr oncfr {ac{ cf iu{gocl }i~{n c{ c bn}{cgf {gon ocw
fi{ zi}` rnbifkr lc{n}& Kgrb~rrnk mnliz c}n {a}nn
bc{nji}gnr {ac{ nqgr{gfj ck/aib fn{zi}` }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
dcll gf{i8
[cmln K}gtnf U}i{ibilr
If Knocfk U}i{ibilr
Awm}gk U}i{ibilr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 141/223
g
g
l
g
=&3 [cmln
[cmln K}
U}icb{gtn U}i
gfknunfknf{
gfdi}oc{gif {
iknr gf {an
itn kc{c c
{wun id u}i{ib
}i~{gfj liiur&
d {an fn{zi
cw }ncb{ {i
{}cddgb gr cdd
i~lk b}nc{nzg{a lg{{ln kc
gog{nk }nri~
{an}ndi}n {an
}i~{gfj ril~{g
]i~{gfj gr cf
d {an nqcoul
nliz&
=&3&3 K
!KRKT'
=&3&= Bl~r
!BJR]'
=&3&2 Zg}
=&3&; R[C=&= If Kn
If Kno
]ncb{gtn U}i{
zanf {anw c}
~ukc{gfj id n
dib~rnr if }
Zanf c }i~
nr{gfc{gif di
g{ r{c}{r c }i~
ikn {i {an i
ikn gf/mn{z
Knocfk u}i
gcj}co 38 Ck/a
K}gtnf ]i~{gf
gtnf ]i~{gf
{ibilr, zi}`
d {}cddgb kno
i r{i}n {an l
n{zi}` cfk {
ifj kgddn}nf
il gr rliz {i
[anrn u}i{i
` cfk {agr b
bacfjn gf {an
b{nk mw {an
~ffnbnrrc}w{c {}cddgb, [c
}bnr r~ba cr
w ogja{ fi{
gif di} Ck/a
nqcouln id c
nr ~fkn} {an b
r{gfc{gif R
{n}/Anck Jc{
lnrr ]i~{gfj
]
ocfk U}i{ibi
fk ]i~{gfj
ibilr, nr{cmlg
}ns~g}nk {i }
n}w uirrgmln
~{nr {ac{ c}n
{n gr }ns~g}
} zagba g{ ki
{n kgrbitn}w
{an} ~f{gl g{
nnf acr c }
{ibilr c}n j
b Oimgln ]i~{gf
j U}i{ibilr
U}i{ibilr
i~{ }i~{nr gf
cfkr& Ncba f
ibc{gif gfdi}
gr gfdi}oc{gi
{ fiknr gf {a
iftn}jn cfk
ilr `nnu c b
f mn c kgrck
fn{zi}` {iu
{iuilijw oi
tn}anck& Ntln K}gtnf U}
uizn} cfk
mn bifrgkn}
ib Fn{zi}`r
[cmln K}gtnf
c{nji}w id [
s~nfbnk K
zcw Rzg{ba
}i{ibil !Z]
lr
U}i{ibilr,
a }i~{nr mn{
i~{n kc{c ucb
}i~{n gf {an f
mngfj ~rnk
k mw c ri
r fi{ actn }i
}ibnrr zagb
}}gtnr c{ {an
i~{n {i {an
fn}cllw bif
j U}i{ibilr
clri `fizf
{an mcb`j}i~
kn ~rnr }i~{g
oc{gif id i{
f gr {anf ~rnk
n fn{zi}`& [
ocw mn u}ifn
fr{cf{ itn}tg
tcf{cjn cr {
lijw ntnf gd
gdgbc{gif zag
f gf c fn{zi{ibilr zgll
lgf` mcfkzg
nk cf nddnb{g
& Dgranwn R{
U}i{ibil& Ri
mln k}gtnf jg
gr{cfbn Tnb
i~{gfj u}i{i
U'
clri `fizf
nnf fiknr i
n{r& [an}n gr
{zi}` gfr{nc
} mngfj rn{
}bn fikn {i
~{n gfdi}oc{g
jinr d}io
knr{gfc{gif i
knr{gfc{gif&
gkn}nk nddgbg
cr
fk
gfj
an}
{i
agr
{i
nz
nw
fi
gba
}` rn
{a
gtn
c{n
on
nf
{i}
bil
cr
lw
fi
g{
~u&
c
f,
fn
} c
If
nf{
z
{}
kg
biU
cf
U
nq
jg
!
]
[
nr
}n
{a
a
c
f
gf
!X
c{
ba
o
ba
c~
ct
f
f
bi
}n
}n
c{
f
f
z
bc
rn
anf {an }i~{n
frdn} mnbc~r
rbitn}w r{n
oo~fgbc{gifi{ibilr oi}n
k liz oimg
i{ibil gr K
coulnr ~fkn
tnf mnliz&
=&=&3
=&=&= Kw
=&=
Clji}g
=&=
Tnb{i}
=&=&>
M]U'
=&=
kgrbit
=&2 Awm}gk
Awm}gk ]i
~{gfj U}i{ib
nw ~rn kgr{c
{cmlgra {an m
ui}{ }i~{gfj g
n {iuilijw i
r g{r izf }i~
xifn }ckg~r,
omn} id aiu
di}oc{gif di
]U' gr cf nqc
Ck/aib fn{
{cb`r cfk k
cllnfjnr id k
cgf }ncrifr di
cffnl, gfrnb~
{ai}g{w, lcb`
cglcmglg{w id }
knr& Jnfn}cll
{zi}`, zn nq
fdgknf{gclg{w,
u~kgc{gif&Ctcglcmglg{w
ocgf iun}c{gi
{cb`r&
Bifdgknf{gcl
tn} kgrblirnk
C~{anf{gbc{g
kn zg{a zagb
Gf{nj}g{w j~
anf {}cfrdn}}n
Fif/}nu~kg
ffi{ knfw ac
b~}g{w }ns~g}
kgrbitn}w gr
{an fn{zi}`
gr liz
mcfkzgk{a&r~g{nk {i lc}j
lg{w& Cf nq
fcogb Ri~}
{an bc{nji}
Crribgc{gtn
cogb Ri~}bn
&2 [n
ao ![I]C'
&; C
}i~{gfj u}i{i
Bl~r{n}/mcr
&4 ]
}w Ck Aib ]
i~{gfj U}i{i
{gfj U}i{ib
ilr zg{a If
fbn/tnb{i}r d
nr{ uc{ar {i
di}oc{gif if
{an fn{zi}`
{gfj xifn, {an
agba gr kndg
r& Ncba fikn
g{r izf xi
ouln id c Aw
GGG& R
i}`r c}n ag
clgfj zg{a
ntnliun}r id
} {agr kgddgb~l{
}n iun}c{gfj
id crribgc{g
ri~}bnr, cfk
w, zanf bif
cogfn g{ ~fk
c~{anf{gbc{g
}ndn}r {i {an
fcl c{ cll {go
g{w nfr~}nr
{i bn}{cgf ~rn
if gr {an cmgl
g{ gr bioo~
}cf{nnr {ac{
k&
{gif r{c{nr {a
tgfj rnf{ g{&
nonf{r bc~r
lnrr d}ns~nf{
{}cddgb bc~rn
biouc}nk
[agr oc`nrn fn{zi}`r z
ouln id cf
n ]i~{gfj&
id If Kn
Mcrnk ]i~{gf
]i~{gfj U}i{
oui}cllw I}
/aib If/Kn
bil !CIKT'
nk ]i~{gf
lc{gtn Kgr{
i~{gfj U}i{ib
ilr
lr biomgfn
Knocfk ]i~
i} oi}n u}nb
knr{gfc{gif
lw zanf {an}n
& Ncba fikn g
rgxn id zagb
nk mw c on{
`nnur c }nb
n& Xifn ]i
}gk }i~{gfj u
B^]G[W
alw t~lfn}c
{agr gr ifn
{anrn fn{zi}
w c}n rac}nk
ftg}ifonf{,
if coifj
uawrgbcl t~lf
rgkn}gfj {an
} {an anckgf
if, gf{nj}g{
dcb{ {ac{ {an
nr knrug{n kn
{ac{ bn}{cgf g
}r&
g{w id c fikn
gbc{gfj&
onrrcjn gr f
c{ {an rnfkn}
f ck/aib fn{
k mw g{r lc
{acf {an kc{
k mw {an }i~{
{i {an {i{
If Knocfg{a lgja{ {}cddg
If Knocf
Rion id {a
cfk U}i{ibil
j !CM]'
bil !KR]'
n}nk ]i~{gf
cfk Kgr{cfb
j U}i{ibi
cfbn Ogb}
il !]KOC]'
[cmln Mcrn
{gfj U}i{ibil
grn on{}gbr {
n{zi}`r, cf
gr c bacfjn g
f {an fn{zi}
gr kndgfnk m
gb r~ba cr {a
}k id }i~{gf
~{gfj U}i{ibi
i{ibil&
ln {i rnb~}g{
id {an ocg
`r {ikcw& [a
}ickbcr{ }ckg
lcb` id bnf{}
iknr, lgog{n
n}cmglg{w id {a
rnb~}g{w id
r0 ctcglcmglg{
cfk fif
fn{zi}` o~
fgcl id rn}tgb
gfdi}oc{gif g
{i gknf{gdw {a
ntn} bi}}~u{n
d {an onrrcj
i}` acr nq{}
b` id u}iun
c
n
l
b
n
r
n
l
&
n
l
w
n
l
n
c
,
/
{
n
r
n
n
c
}
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 142/223
gfd}cr{}~b{~}n cfk {an kwfcogb }nlc{gifragu mn{znnf {an
fiknr gf {an fn{zi}`& Mnbc~rn id {an lcb` id
gfd}cr{}~b{~}n, cbbi~f{cmglg{w gr tn}w kgddgb~l{ {i
kn{n}ogfn cr {an}n gr “fi bnf{}cl c~{ai}g{w zagba bcf mn}ndn}nfbnk zanf g{ bionr {i oc`gfj {}~r{ knbgrgifr cmi~{
i{an} uc}{gnr gf {an fn{zi}`&‟ [an kwfcogb }nlc{gifragu
mn{znnf {an fiknr lnctnr tn}w lg{{ln iuui}{~fg{w di} {an
fiknr {i di}o {}~r{ }nlc{gifragur zg{a ncba i{an}& Gf cf
ck/aib fn{zi}`, fiknr o~r{ cb{ cr mi{a {n}ogfclr cfk
}i~{n}r di} i{an} fiknr& Mnbc~rn {an}n c}n fi knkgbc{nk
fiknr, c rnb~}n }i~{gfj u}i{ibil gr fnnknk& O~l{g aiu
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr c}n ~r~cllw nouliwnk& [anrn bcf lnck
{i u}imlnor k~n {i fif/biiun}c{gfj fiknr cfk knfgcl id
rn}tgbn c{{cb`r&
GT& RNB^]G[W CFCLWRGR ID OCFN[
;&3 Uc}{gb~lc}g{w id OCFN[ Rnb~}g{w
OCFN[ gr kgddn}nf{ d}io {an dgqnk GU fn{zi}` cr znll
cr {an jnfn}cl zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`, zagba uirnr fnz
bacllnfjnr {i j~c}cf{nn g{r rnb~}g{w cr dillizgfj8 {an
zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gif ocffn} oc`nr {an {a}nc{ id mngfj
c{{cb`nk r~ddn}gfj d}io zg}n{cuugfj j}nc{lw gou}itnk0
o~l{g/aiu }i~{gfj on{aik ocw gfk~bn c rn}gnr id rnb~}g{w
grr~nr, r~ba cr mlcb` ailn, zi}oailn cfk n{b0 {an rnld
i}jcfgxc{gif id oimgln fiknr ml~}r {an mi~fkc}w id
fn{zi}`0 {an gfknunfknfbn id fikn oimgln oc`n {an
uawrgbcl rnb~}g{w d}cjgln&
;&= Rnb~}g{w [a}nc{r if OCFN[
[an rnb~}g{w {a}nc{r bifd}if{nk mw OCFN[ gr {an
nq{nfrgif cfk nqucfrgif id {ac{ mn bifd}if{nk mw zg}nkfn{zi}` gf {an zg}nlnrr dgnlk, zagba ocgflw bionr d}io
zg}nlnrr bacffnlr cfk fn{zi}`r& [an {a}nc{r bcf mn kgtgknk
gf{i {zi bc{nji}gnr id ucrrgtn c{{cb` cfk cb{gtn c{{cb`&
;&=&3 Ucrrgtn c{{cb`
Ucrrgtn c{{cb` P32_ gr nrrnf{gcllw {i lgr{nf i}
r~}tngllcfbn {an onrrcjn {}cfrogrrgif u}ibnrr {i im{cgf
rion rnb}n{, zagba ocgflw gfbl~knr {zi `gfkr id
zg}n{cuugfj cfk {}cddgb cfclwrgr& Zg}n{cuugfj gr {i gf{n}bnu{
ucb`n{r mngfj {}cfrog{{nk cfk cbbnrr {i bifdgknf{gcl
gfdi}oc{gif& [}cddgb cfclwrgr gr {i cfclwxn bac}cb{n}gr{gbr id
ucb`n{ d}ns~nfbw, lnfj{a cfk n{b {i awui{anrgxn {an bif{nf{
id bioo~fgbc{gif&
;&=&= Cb{gtn c{{cb` Biouc}gfj zg{a ucrrgtn c{{cb`, {an ucrrgtn c{{cb`
~r~cllw kinr fi{ bacfjn {an {}cfrogrrgif kc{c, zagln cb{gtn
c{{cb` zgll {coun} kc{c r{}nco i} b}nc{n dclrn kc{c r{}nco&
[an cb{gtn c{{cb` gfbl~knr di~} `gfkr id onrrcjn }nulcw,
d}c~k bi~f{n}dng{gfj, onrrcjn {coun}gfj cfk knfgcl id
rn}tgbn&
Onrrcjn }nulcw8 Cd{n} {an c{{cb`n} gf{n}bnu{nk
onrrcjnr, g{ zgll r{i}n {an onrrcjn cfk }n/{}cfrog{ {an
onrrcjn {i u}ik~bn cf ~fc~{ai}gxnk nddnb{& [an OCFN[
gr lg`nlw {i mn c{{cb`nk mw onrrcjn }nulcw, gf {ac{ {an
onrrcjn gr {}cfrog{{nk gf {an cg} cfk bcf ncrglw mn
gf{n}bnu{nk&
D}c~k bi~f{n}dng{gfj8 Zanf ifn nf{g{w mnactnr crcfi{an} nf{g{w {i bc}}w i~{ fn{zi}` cb{gtg{gnr, {an
bi~f{n}dng{gfj {c`nr ulcbn& Lcb` id u}i{nb{gif i} znc`
c~{anf{gbc{gif onbacfgro ocw bc~rn r~ba rnb~}g{w {a}nc{r,
r~ba cr }nulcw gknf{gdgbc{gif rns~nfbn {i oc`n mnlgntn c
u}gtglnjnk nf{g{w&
Onrrcjn {coun}gfj8 Cd{n} {an ucb`n{ i} onrrcjn
rns~nfbn mngfj gf{n}bnu{nk, {an bif{nf{ gr oikgdgnk, i}
knlgmn}c{nlw knlcwnk {}cfrogrrgif, i} c ucrrgtn bacfjn gf
{an i}kn}& [agr `gfk id c{{cb` gr c{{cb` if {an gf{nj}g{w id
onrrcjn&
Knfgcl id rn}tgbn8 Zanf cf c~{ai}gxnk nf{g{wbcffi{ cbbnrr {i rai~lk mn fn{zi}` }nri~}bnr i}
non}jnfbw iun}c{gifr mn knfgnk, {an c{{cb` id knfgcl id
rn}tgbn ibb~}r& Gf {an OCFN[, g{ gr ncrw {i cbagntn rn}tgbn
gf{n}}~u{gif, ri zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gif bcf mn ~rnk {i
ragnlk {an bioo~fgbc{gifr runb{}~o&
T& OCFN[ [A]^R[ C]NCR
[an dillizgfj lgr{ id {a}~r{ c}ncr raizr {an
gfnddgbgnfbgnr cfk lgog{c{gifr {ac{ actn {i mn itn}bion gf c
OCFN[ nftg}ifonf{8
>&3 Lgog{nk zg}nlnrr {}cfrogrrgif }cfjn8 Gf zg}nlnrr
fn{zi}`r {an }ckgi mcfk zgll mn lgog{nk cfk anfbn kc{c
}c{nr g{ bcf iddn} c}n o~ba lnrrn} {acf zac{ c zg}nk
fn{zi}` bcf iddn}& [agr }ns~g}nr {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr gf
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r {i ~rn {an mcfkzgk{a clzcwr gf cf
iu{gocl ocffn} mw `nnugfj {an itn}anck cr liz cr
uirrgmln& [an lgog{nk {}cfrogrrgif }cfjn clri gouirnr c
bifr{}cgf{ if }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr gf ocgf{cgfgfj {an
{iuilijgbcl gfdi}oc{gif& Nrunbgcllw gf OCFN[R k~n {i
d}ns~nf{ bacfjnr gf {iuilijw, ocgf{cgfgfj {an {iuilijgbcl
gfdi}oc{gif c{ cll fiknr gftiltnr oi}n bif{}il itn}anck
zagba, gf {~}f, }nr~l{r gf oi}n mcfkzgk{a zcr{cjn&
>&= [gon/tc}wgfj zg}nlnrr lgf` bac}cb{n}gr{gbr8 [an
zg}nlnrr bacffnl gr r~rbnu{gmln {i c tc}gn{w id
{}cfrogrrgif gounkgonf{r r~ba cr uc{a lirr, dckgfj,
gf{n}dn}nfbn cfk mlib`cjn& [anrn dcb{i}r }nrgr{ {an }cfjn,
kc{c }c{n, cfk {an }nlgcmglg{w id {an zg}nlnrr {}cfrogrrgif&[an nq{nf{ {i zagba {anrn dcb{i}r cddnb{ {an {}cfrogrrgif
knunfkr ~uif {an nftg}ifonf{cl bifkg{gifr cfk {an
oimglg{w id {an {}cfrog{{n} cfk }nbngtn}& Ntnf {an {zi
kgddn}nf{ `nw bifr{}cgf{r, Fws~gr{‗r cfk Racffif‗r
{ani}nor, {ac{ jitn}f {an cmglg{w {i {}cfrog{ gfdi}oc{gif
c{ kgddn}nf{ kc{c }c{nr bcf mn bifrgkn}nk&
>&2 M}ickbcr{ fc{~}n id {an zg}nlnrr onkg~o8 [an
m}ickbcr{ fc{~}n id {an }ckgi bacffnl, {ac{ gr, {}cfrogrrgifr
ockn mw c fikn c}n }nbngtnk mw cll fiknr zg{agf g{r kg}nb{
{}cfrogrrgif }cfjn& Zanf c fikn gr }nbngtgfj kc{c, fi
i{an} fikn gf g{r fngjami}aiik, cuc}{ d}io {an rnfkn},
rai~lk {}cfrog{& C fikn rai~lk jn{ cbbnrr {i {an rac}nk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 143/223
onkg~o iflw zanf g{r {}cfrogrrgifr ki fi{ cddnb{ cfw
ifjigfj rnrrgif& Rgfbn o~l{guln fiknr ocw bif{nfk di} {an
bacffnl rgo~l{cfni~rlw, {an uirrgmglg{w id ucb`n{ billgrgifr
gr s~g{n agja gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r& Ntnf {an fn{zi}` grr~rbnu{gmln {i agkknf {n}ogfcl u}imlno cfk m}ickbcr{
r{i}or& [an agkknf {n}ogfcl u}imlno }ndn}r {i {an billgrgif
id ucb`n{r c{ c }nbngtgfj fikn k~n {i {an rgo~l{cfni~r
{}cfrogrrgif id {airn fiknr {ac{ c}n fi{ zg{agf {an kg}nb{
{}cfrogrrgif }cfjn id {an rnfkn}, m~{ c}n zg{agf {an
{}cfrogrrgif }cfjn id {an }nbngtn}&
>&; Ucb`n{ lirrnr k~n {i {}cfrogrrgif n}}i}r8 Ck aib
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r nqun}gnfbnr c o~ba agjan} ucb`n{ lirr
k~n {i dcb{i}r r~ba cr agja mg{ n}}i} }c{n !MN]' gf {an
zg}nlnrr bacffnl, gfb}ncrnk billgrgifr k~n {i {an u}nrnfbn
id agkknf {n}ogfclr, u}nrnfbn id gf{n}dn}nfbn, libc{gif
knunfknf{ bif{nf{gif, ~fg/kg}nb{gifcl lgf`r, d}ns~nf{ uc{a
m}nc`r k~n {i oimglg{w id fiknr, cfk {an gfan}nf{ dckgfj
u}iun}{gnr id {an zg}nlnrr bacffnl&
>&> Oimglg{w/gfk~bnk }i~{n bacfjnr8 [an fn{zi}`
{iuilijw gf cf ck aib zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` gr agjalw
kwfcogb k~n {i {an oitnonf{ id fiknr0 anfbn cf if/
jigfj rnrrgif r~ddn}r d}ns~nf{ uc{a m}nc`r& [agr rg{~c{gif
id{nf lnckr {i d}ns~nf{ }i~{n bacfjnr& [an}ndi}n oimglg{w
ocfcjnonf{ g{rnld gr tn}w tcr{ }nrnc}ba {iugb gf ck aib
fn{zi}`r& Oimglg{w/gfk~bnk ucb`n{ lirrnr8
Bioo~fgbc{gif lgf`r gf cf ck aib fn{zi}` c}n ~fr{cmln
r~ba {ac{ }~ffgfj biftnf{gifcl u}i{ibilr di} OCFN[R
itn} c agja lirr }c{n zgll r~ddn} d}io rntn}n un}di}ocfbn
knj}ckc{gif& Aizntn}, zg{a agja n}}i} }c{n, g{ gr tn}w
o~ba kgddgb~l{ {i knlgtn} c ucb`n{ {i g{r knr{gfc{gif&
>&4 Mc{{n}w bifr{}cgf{r8 [agr gr ifn id {an lgog{nk}nri~}bnr {ac{ di}o c ochi} bifr{}cgf{ di} {an fiknr gf cf
ck aib fn{zi}`& Kntgbnr ~rnk gf {anrn fn{zi}`r actn
}nr{}gb{gifr if {an uizn} ri~}bn gf i}kn} {i ocgf{cgf
ui}{cmglg{w, rgxn cfk zngja{ id {an kntgbn& Mw gfb}ncrgfj {an
uizn} cfk u}ibnrrgfj cmglg{w oc`nr {an fiknr m~l`w cfk
lnrr ui}{cmln& Ri iflw OCFN[ fiknr acr {i iu{gocllw ~rn
{agr }nri~}bn&
>&: Ui{nf{gcllw d}ns~nf{ fn{zi}` uc}{g{gifr8 [an
}cfkiolw oitgfj fiknr gf cf ck aib fn{zi}` bcf lnck {i
fn{zi}` uc}{g{gifr& Gf ochi} bcrnr, {an gf{n}onkgc{n fiknr
c}n {an ifn zagba c}n agjalw cddnb{nk mw {agr uc}{g{gifgfj&
>&1 Ncrn id rfiiugfj if zg}nlnrr {}cfrogrrgifr
!rnb~}g{w grr~nr'8 [an }ckgi bacffnl ~rnk di} ck aibfn{zi}`r gr m}ickbcr{ gf fc{~}n cfk gr rac}nk mw cll {an
fiknr gf {an fn{zi}`& Kc{c {}cfrog{{nk mw c fikn gr
}nbngtnk mw cll {an fiknr zg{agf g{r kg}nb{ {}cfrogrrgif
}cfjn& Ri cf c{{cb`n} bcf ncrglw rfiiu {an kc{c mngfj
{}cfrog{{nk gf {an fn{zi}`& An}n {an }ns~g}nonf{ id
bifdgknf{gclg{w bcf mn tgilc{nk gd cf cktn}rc}w gr clri cmln
{i gf{n}u}n{ {an kc{c jc{an}nk {a}i~ja rfiiugfj&
TG& BIFBL^RGIF
R{~kgnk Ck/aib fn{zi}`r bifbnu{r gf knu{a, zn
mnlgntn {ac{ {anw zgll mn {an d~{~}n id zg}nlnrr
fn{zi}`gfj& G{ gr {}~n {ac{ un}di}ocfbn r~ddn}r cr {an
f~omn} id kntgbnr j}izr cfk lc}jn ck/aib fn{zi}`r
mnbion kgddgb~l{ {i }i~{n cfk ocfcjn& Aizntn}, o~ba
{gon gr mngfj knti{nk {i cbagntgfj }i~{gfj r{cmglg{w, cfk cdnz {nbafgbcl grr~nr fnnk {i mn riltnk mndi}n {anw
mnbion biooif ulcbn& [an c}nc id ck aib fn{zi}`r gr c
tn}w dcr{ j}izgfj c}nc, cfk k~n {i {an tcr{ }nrnc}ba gf
{ano, zn c}n rnngfj {anrn u}imlnor kgrcuunc} cfk {anw
c}n biogfj gf{i c zi}lk id {ang} izf&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ B& Un}`gfr cfk N ]iwn}, “Ck Aib If/Knocfk Kgr{cfbn
Tnb{i} ]i~{gfj,‟ =fk GNNN Z`ru& Oimgln Biou& Rwr&
cfk Cuur&, 3777&
P=_ K& Hiafrif cfk K& Ocl{x, “Kwfcogb Ri~}bn ]i~{gfj gf
Ck Aib Zg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`r,‟ Oimgln Biou~{gfj, [&Gognlgfr`g cfk A& @i}{a, Nk&, @l~zn}, 3774&
P2_ GNNN R{k& 15=&33, “Zg}nlnrr LCF Onkg~o Cbbnrr Bif{}il!OCB' cfk Uawrgbcl Lcwn} !UAW' Runbgdgbc{gifr,‟ 377:&
P;_ M& Rbafngn}, Rnb}n{ cfk Lgnr, Kgjg{cl Rnb~}g{w gf c Fn{zi}`nk
Zi}lk , Zglnw, =555&P>_ W& A~, C& Un}}gj, cfk K& Hiafrif, “C}gckfn8 C Rnb~}n
If/knocfk ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil di} Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r,“
CBO OIMGBIO , =55=&
P4_ O& Xcuc{c, cfk F& Cri`cf, “Rnb~}gfj Ck Aib ]i~{gfjU}i{ibilr,‟ CBO ZgRn, =55=&
P:_ M& Kcagll n{ cl&, “C Rnb~}n U}i{ibil di} Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r,“
GNNN GBFU, =55=&
P1_ W& A~, C& Un}}gj, cfk K& Hiafrif, “Ucb`n{ Lncranr8 C
Kndnfrn cjcgfr{ Zi}oailn C{{cb`r gf Zg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`r,‟
GNNN GFDIBIO , =55=&
P7_ F& Mi}grit, G& Jilkmn}j, cfk K& Zcjfn}, “Gf{n}bnu{gfj
Oimgln Bioo~fgbc{gifr8 [an Gfrnb~}g{w id 15=&33,‟
CBO OIMGBIO , =553&P35_ T& J~u{c, R& @}grafco~}{aw, cfk O& Dcli~{rir, “Knfgcl
id Rn}tgbn C{{cb`r c{ {an OCB Lcwn} gf Zg}nlnrr Ck Aib
Fn{zi}`r,‟ GNNN OGLBIO , =55=&
P33_ U& @wcrcf~}, cfk F& Tcgkwc, “Kn{nb{gif cfk Acfklgfj id
OCB Lcwn} Ogrmnactgi} gf Zg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`r,‟ KBB , =552&P3=_ B& Un}`gfr, cfk U& Macjzc{, “Agjalw Kwfcogb Knr{gfc{gif/
Rns~nfbnk Kgr{cfbn/Tnb{i} ]i~{gfj !KRKT' di}
Oimgln Biou~{n}r,‟ CBO RGJBIOO , 377;&
P32_ U& Ucuckgog{}c{ir, cfk X& Accr, “Rnb~}n ]i~{gfj di} Oimgln Ck Aib
Fn{zi}`r,‟ BFKR, =55=&¥
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 144/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :2773)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :2773
R~}tnw id ]ncb{gtn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr gf Oimgln Ckaib Fn{zi}`r
T& Hcwclc`raog
Crrgr{cf{ U}idnrri}, Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr Knuc}{onf{,R~kac}rcf Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, U~k~``i{{cg,
[coglfck~, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{ ‛ C Oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r !OCFN[r' bifrgr{ id
c billnb{gif id zg}nlnrr oimgln fiknr zagba kwfcogbcllw
nqbacfjn kc{c coifj {anornltnr zg{ai~{ {an }nlgcfbn if c
dgqnk mcrn r{c{gif i} c zg}nk mcb`mifn fn{zi}`& Gf r~ba
fn{zi}`r, {an zg}nlnrr oimgln fiknr ocw kwfcogbcllw nf{n}
{an fn{zi}` cr znll cr lnctn {an fn{zi}`& Gf {an lcr{ 3>
wnc}r, {an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`gfj bioo~fg{w knrgjfnk c
f~omn} id fnz }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr {c}jn{gfj {an tc}gi~r
rbnfc}gir id {agr knrgjf rucbn& Cfw if/knocfk }i~{gfj
u}i{ibil o~r{ ~{glgxn rion {wun id }i~{gfj bcban gf i}kn} {i
ctigk {an fnnk {i }nkgrbitn} ncba }i~{gfj knbgrgif di} ncbagfkgtgk~cl ucb`n{& Ri, bcbagfj gr cf goui}{cf{ uc}{ id if/
knocfk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr di} zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}`r [an
imhnb{gtn id {agr ucun} gr {i r~}tnw {an tc}gi~r }ncb{gtn
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr zagba ~rnr {an }i~{n bcbagfj {nbafgs~n
di} }i~{n }nuirg{i}w cfk biouc}n {ano& Zn r{}gtn {i
~fbitn} {an }ns~g}nonf{r bifrgkn}nk mw {an kgddn}nf{
u}i{ibilr, {an }nri~}bn lgog{c{gifr ~fkn} zagba {anw
iun}c{n, cfk {an knrgjf knbgrgifr ockn mw {an c~{ai}r&
@nwzi}kr‛ Ck aib 0 If knocfk, ]i~{n Bcban, ]i~{gfj
U}i{ibilr
G& G F[]IK^B[GIF
]nbnf{lw, {an}n acr mnnf c {}nonfki~r gf{n}nr{ gf m}ickmcfk zg}nlnrr cbbnrr rwr{nor, gfbl~kgfj zg}nlnrrlibcl c}nc fn{zi}`r !ZLCF', m}ickmcfk zg}nlnrr cbbnrrcfk zg}nlnrr un}rifcl c}nc fn{zi}`r !ZUCF'& [ancktnf{ id ~mgs~g{i~r biou~{gfj cfk {an u}ilgdn}c{gif id ui}{cmln biou~{gfj kntgbnr actn }cgrnk {an goui}{cfbnid oimgln cfk zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`gfj&[agr kiocgf gr c
r~mhnb{ id c a~jn }nrnc}ba cfk ocfw r{cfkc}kgxc{gifcb{gtg{gnr c}n ~fkn}{c`nf {a}i~jai~{ {an zi}lk, gf ocfw
2J);J }nlc{nk r{~kw bioog{{nnr lg`n G[^/], N[RGM]CF cfk GNNN 15=& ]nrnc}ba u}i{i{wugfj gr b~}}nf{lw~fkn}zcw c{ ocfw }nrnc}ba cbcknogb cfk gfk~r{}gclgfr{g{~{gifr P3_&
Gf {an bif{nq{ id {anrn rwr{nor, oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r!OCFN[r' actn cuunc}nk zg{a runbgdgb bifdgj~}c{gifr&
[anw u}itgkn c uizn}d~l uc}ckgjo di} oiknlgfj iunfrnld/bifdgj~}gfj zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r cfk rnno ricuu}iu}gc{n {i ~rn gf {an di~}{a jnfn}c{gif id oimglnfn{zi}`r&
C OCFN[ gr cf c~{ifioi~r billnb{gif id oimgln fiknr
di}ogfj c kwfcogb fn{zi}` cfk bioo~fgbc{gfj itn} zg}nlnrr lgf`r& ^rn}r c}n clliznk {i bioo~fgbc{n zg{ancba i{an} gf c {noui}c}w ocffn} zg{a fi bnf{}clgxnkckogfgr{}c{gif cfk gf c kwfcogb {iuilijw {ac{ bacfjnrd}ns~nf{lw& K~n {i {an lgog{nk u}iucjc{gif }cfjn id zg}nlnrr nftg}ifonf{, }i~{nr gf ck aib fn{zi}`r c}n
o~l{gaiu, cfk oimgln fiknr gf {agr fn{zi}` kwfcogbcllwnr{cmlgra }i~{gfj coifj {anornltnr {i di}o {ang} izffn{zi}` “if {an dlw‟ P=_& Ncba uc}{gbguc{gfj fikn cb{r
mi{a cr c air{ cfk c }i~{n} cfk o~r{ {an}ndi}n mn zgllgfj{i di}zc}k ucb`n{r di} i{an} fiknr& Fiknr gf r~ba cfn{zi}` oitn c}mg{}c}glw, {a~r fn{zi}` {iuilijw bacfjnr
d}ns~nf{lw,~fu}nkgb{cmlw, cfk ocw bifrgr{ id ~fgkg}nb{gifcl lgf`r crznll cr mgkg}nb{gifcl lgf`r& Oi}nitn}, zg}nlnrr bacffnl mcfkzgk{a gr lgog{nk& [an rbc}bn mcfkzgk{a knb}ncrnrntnf d~}{an} k~n {i {an nddnb{r id rgjfcl gf{n}dn}nfbn, cfkbacffnl dckgfj& Fn{zi}` air{r id ck aib fn{zi}`r r~ba
cr lcu{iur cfk un}rifcl kgjg{cl crrgr{cf{r iun}c{n ifbifr{}cgfnk mc{{n}w uizn}, zagba zgll ntnf{~cllw mn
nqac~r{nk cfk lgog{nk BU^ cfk r{i}cjn bcucbg{w&OCFN[r r{}gb{lw knunfk if }ckgi lgf`r& Cb{~cllw, c
zg}nlnrr lgf` gr {an oir{ tc}gcmln cfk ~fu}nkgb{cmlnbioo~fgbc{gif bacffnl& Gf ckkg{gif, ck aib fn{zi}`r c}nt~lfn}cmln {i c{{cb`r cfk actn lgog{nk uawrgbcl rnb~}g{w&[an gfb}ncrnk uirrgmglg{w id nctnrk}iuugfj, ruiidgfj cfk
knfgcl/id/rn}tgbn c{{cb`r rai~lk mn bc}nd~llw bifrgkn}nk&Mnbc~rn ck aib fn{zi}`r ki fi{ {wugbcllw clliz {an rconcjj}njc{gif {nbafgs~nr {ac{ c}n ctcglcmln {i r{cfkc}kGf{n}fn{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr, {anw c}n t~lfn}cmln {irbclcmglg{w u}imlnor& [anrn k}czmcb`r lnck {i kndgfn crn{ id ~fkn}lwgfj crr~ou{gifr cfk un}di}ocfbn bifbn}fr
di} u}i{ibil knrgjf&Ck aib fn{zi}`r ki fi{ }nlw if cfw u}n/nr{cmlgrankgfd}cr{}~b{~}n cfk bcf {an}ndi}n mn knuliwnk gf ulcbnr
zg{a fi gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& [agr gr ~rnd~l gf O~l{gbcr{gfj acrnon}jnk cr ifn id {an oir{ dib~rnk c}ncr gf {an dgnlk id fn{zi}`gfj& Cr {an {nbafilijw cfk uiu~lc}g{w id {an
Gf{n}fn{ actn j}izf, cuulgbc{gifr {ac{ }ns~g}no~l{gbcr{gfj !n&j&, tgkni bifdn}nfbgfj' c}n mnbiogfj
oi}n zgknru}nck& Cfi{an} gf{n}nr{gfj }nbnf{kntnliuonf{ acr mnnf {an non}jnfbn id kwfcogbcllw}nbifdgj~}cmln zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}`r {i gf{n}biffnb{oimgln ~rn}r di} cuulgbc{gifr }cfjgfj d}io kgrcr{n} }nbitn}w {i kgr{}gm~{nk billcmi}c{gtn biou~{gfj& kgrcr{n} }nbitn}w rg{~c{gifr cfk ulcbnr zg{a fif/nqgr{gfj i}
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3=7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 145/223
kcocjnk bioo~fgbc{gif gfd}cr{}~b{~}n zan}n }cugkknuliwonf{ id c bioo~fgbc{gif fn{zi}` gr fnnknk P2_&Ck aib fn{zi}`r bcf clri mn ~rnd~l gf bifdn}nfbnr zan}n uniuln uc}{gbguc{gfj gf {an bifdn}nfbn bcf di}o c
{noui}c}w fn{zi}` zg{ai~{ nfjcjgfj {an rn}tgbnr id cfw u}n/nqgr{gfj
fn{zi}` P;_&]i~{gfj gf oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r gr c rgjfgdgbcf{}nrnc}ba {iugb zan}n tc}gi~r onbacfgror actn mnnfcl}nckw u}iuirnk bifbn}fgfj {agr grr~n& Gf dcb{,biftnf{gifcl }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr c}n fi{ znll r~g{nk gf ckaib nftg}ifonf{ di} rntn}cl }ncrifr& Dg}r{lw, {anw c}n
knrgjfnk di} r{c{gb {iuilijw, zagba gr fi{ {an bcrn gf ckaib fn{zi}`& Rnbifklw, {anw c}n agjalw knunfknf{ if
un}gikgb bif{}il onrrcjnr0 {agr gr gf bif{}ckgb{gif zg{a}nri~}bn/lgog{nk ck aib nftg}ifonf{& Oi}nitn}, blcrrgbcl u}i{ibilr {}w {i ocgf{cgf }i~{nr {i cll }ncbacmlnknr{gfc{gifr, zagba zcr{nr }nri~}bnr&
Cfi{an} lgog{c{gif bionr d}io {an ~rn id mg/kg}nb{gifcl
lgf`r, zagba gr fi{ clzcwr {an bcrn gf ck aibnftg}ifonf{& Cb{~cllw, {an}n gr c fnnk di} fnz }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr, ckcu{gfj {i {an kwfcogb {iuilijw cfk {anzg}nlnrr lgf`r‗ lgog{c{gifr& ]i~{gfj u}i{ibilr gf r~bafn{zi}`r rai~lk u}itgkn c rn{ id dnc{~}nr gfbl~kgfj P;_8
kgr{}gm~{nk iun}c{gif, liiu d}nnkio, if/knocfk mcrnk iun}c{gif, ~fgkg}nb{gifcl lgf` r~uui}{, uizn}
bifrn}tc{gif, o~l{guln }i~{nr, nddgbgnfbw, rbclcmglg{w,rnb~}g{w cfk s~clg{w id rn}tgbn r~uui}{&[an }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr ocw biooiflw mn bc{nji}gxnk cr{cmln/k}gtnf cfk if/knocfk& Rntn}cl }i~{gfj u}i{ibilractn ~rnk if/knocfk onbacfgror gf ck aib fn{zi}`,cllizgfj {ano {i kwfcogbcllw ckcu{ {an lntnl id }i~{gfj
u}i{ibil cb{gtg{w }ns~g}nk {i bi}}nb{lw acfkln {an iddn}nk{}cddgb& Cfw if/knocfk }i~{gfj u}i{ibil o~r{ ~{glgxnrion {wun id }i~{gfj bcban gf i}kn} {i ctigk {an fnnk {i}nkgrbitn} ncba }i~{gfj knbgrgif di} ncba gfkgtgk~cl ucb`n{& Ri, bcbagfj gr cf goui}{cf{ uc}{ id if/knocfk}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr di} zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}`r& [agr
ucun} kgrb~rrnr {an tc}gi~r }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilrzagba ~rnr {an }i~{n bcban {nbafgs~n di} r{i}gfj {an
}i~{nr&[agr ucun} gr i}jcfgxnk cr dillizr& Rnb{gif GG jgtnr {anItn}tgnz id {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr gf OCFN[r& Rnb{gifGGG jgtnr c m}gnd r~}tnw id {an tc}gi~r }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr zagba ~rnr }i~{n bcban& Rnb{gif GT jgtnr {an
biouc}grif mn{znnf {anrn u}i{ibilr& Dgfcllw, rnb{gif T u}itgknr bifbl~rgif id i~} zi}`&
GG& ITN] TGNZ ID ]I^[GFJ U]I[IBILR
[an mcrgb }i~{gfj u}imlno gr {ac{ id dgfkgfj cf i}kn}nkrn}gnr id gf{n}onkgc{n fiknr {ac{ bcf {}cfrui}{ c ucb`n{cb}irr c fn{zi}` d}io g{r ri~}bn {i g{r knr{gfc{gif mwdi}zc}kgfj {an ucb`n{ clifj {agr rn}gnr id gf{n}onkgc{n
fiknr&[an bacllnfjn gf b}nc{gfj c }i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} ck aib
fn{zi}`r gr {i knrgjf c rgfjln u}i{ibil {ac{ bcf ckcu{ {i{an zgkn tc}gn{w id bifkg{gifr {ac{ bcf mn u}nrnf{ gf cfwck aib fn{zi}` itn} {gon& [an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil o~r{
un}di}o nddgbgnf{lw gf nftg}ifonf{r gf zagba fiknr c}nr{c{gifc}w cfk mcfkzgk{a gr fi{ c lgog{gfj dcb{i}& Wn{, {an
rcon u}i{ibil o~r{ r{gll d~fb{gif nddgbgnf{lw zanf {an mcfkzgk{a ctcglcmln mn{znnf fiknr gr liz cfk {an lntnlid oimglg{w cfk {iuilijw bacfjn gr agja& Mnbc~rn g{ grid{nf gouirrgmln {i `fiz c u}gi}g zac{ nftg}ifonf{ {an
u}i{ibil zgll dgfk g{rnld gf, cfk mnbc~rn {an nftg}ifonf{bcf bacfjn ~fu}nkgb{cmlw, {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil o~r{ mn
cmln {i ckcu{ c~{ioc{gbcllwOcfw blcrrgdgbc{gifr c}n di~fk gf {an lg{n}c{~}n& Ocfw
u}i{ibilr actn mnnf u}iuirnk di} OCFN[r& [anrn u}i{ibilr bcf mn kgtgknk gf{i {a}nn bc{nji}gnr8 u}icb{gtn,
}ncb{gtn, cfk awm}gk& U}icb{gtn on{aikr ocgf{cgf }i~{nr{i cll fiknr, gfbl~kgfj fiknr {i zagba fi ucb`n{r c}nrnf{& R~ba on{aikr }ncb{ {i {iuilijw bacfjnr, ntnf gd fi{}cddgb gr cddnb{nk mw {an bacfjnr& [anw c}n clri bcllnk{cmln/k}gtnf on{aikr& ]ncb{gtn on{aikr c}n mcrnk ifknocfk di} kc{c {}cfrogrrgif& ]i~{nr mn{znnf air{r c}nkn{n}ogfnk iflw zanf {anw c}n nqulgbg{lw fnnknk {i
di}zc}k ucb`n{r& ]ncb{gtn on{aikr c}n clri bcllnk if/knocfk on{aikr& [anw bcf rgjfgdgbcf{lw }nk~bn }i~{gfj
itn}anck zanf {an {}cddgb gr lgja{zngja{ cfk {an {iuilijwbacfjnr lnrr k}coc{gbcllw, rgfbn {anw ki fi{ fnnk {i~ukc{n }i~{n gfdi}oc{gif un}gikgbcllw cfk ki fi{ fnnk {idgfk cfk ocgf{cgf }i~{nr if zagba {an}n gr fi {}cddgb&Awm}gk on{aikr biomgfn u}icb{gtn cfk }ncb{gtn on{aikr
{i dgfk nddgbgnf{ }i~{nr, zg{ai~{ o~ba bif{}il itn}anck
GGG& ] NCB[GTN ]I^[GFJ U]I[IBILR ‒ C M]GND R^]TNW
OCFN[ gr ifn {ac{ rnc}banr di} cfk {}gnr {i kgrbitn} c}i~{n {i rion knr{gfc{gif fikn iflw zanf c rnfkgfj fiknjnfn}c{nr c kc{c ucb`n{ ckk}nrrnk {i {ac{ fikn& Gf i}kn}
{i ctigk {an fnnk di} r~ba c }i~{n kgrbitn}w {i mn un}di}onk mndi}n ncba kc{c ucb`n{ gr rnf{, r~ba }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr o~r{ bcban u}ntgi~rlw kgrbitn}nk }i~{nr
Gf {an dillizgfj zn }ntgnz rntn}cl }nu}nrnf{c{gtnnqcoulnr id }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr zagba ~rnr }i~{nbcban di} }i~{n }nuirg{i}w
C& Kwfcogb ri~}bn }i~{gfj !KR]'
Hiafrif n{ cl& u}iuirn ifn id {an oir{ zgknlw `fizf}i~{gfj clji}g{aor, bcllnk Kwfcogb Ri~}bn ]i~{gfj P>_zagba gr cf “if/knocfk‟ clji}g{ao cfk g{ acr }i~{n
kgrbitn}w cfk }i~{n ocgf{nfcfbn uacrnr&]i~{n kgrbitn}w bif{cgfr mi{a }i~{n }ns~nr{ cfk }i~{n}nulw onrrcjnr& Gf {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w uacrn, zanf c
fikn zgranr {i rnfk c onrrcjn, g{ dg}r{ m}ickbcr{r c }i~{n}ns~nr{ ucb`n{ {i g{r fngjami}r& Ntn}w fikn zg{agf c m}ickbcr{ }cfjn ckkr {ang} fikn gk {i {an }i~{n }ns~nr{
ucb`n{ cfk }nm}ickbcr{r& Ntnf{~cllw, ifn id {an m}ickbcr{onrrcjnr zgll }ncba ng{an} {an knr{gfc{gif i} c fiknzagba acr c }nbnf{ }i~{n {i {an knr{gfc{gif& Rgfbn ncbafikn ocgf{cgfr c }i~{n bcban, g{ dg}r{ banb`r g{r bcban di} c }i~{n {ac{ oc{banr {an }ns~nr{nk knr{gfc{gif&Ocgf{cgfgfj c }i~{n bcban gf ntn}w fikn }nk~bnr {anitn}anck jnfn}c{nk mw c }i~{n kgrbitn}w uacrn& Gd c }i~{ngr di~fk gf {an }i~{n bcban, {an fikn zgll }n{~}f c }i~{n
}nulw onrrcjn {i {an ri~}bn fikn }c{an} {acf di}zc}kgfj{an }i~{n }ns~nr{ onrrcjn d~}{an}& [an dg}r{ ucb`n{ {ac{
}ncbanr {an knr{gfc{gif fikn zgll actn c biouln{n }i~{n&KR] crr~onr {ac{ {an uc{a im{cgfnk gr {an rai}{nr{ rgfbn
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 325
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 146/223
g{ {c`nr gf{i bifrgkn}c{gif {an dg}r{ ucb`n{ {i c}}gtn c{ {anknr{gfc{gif fikn& C }i~{n }nulw ucb`n{ gr rnf{ {i {anri~}bn zagba bif{cgfr {an biouln{n }i~{n d}io {anri~}bn {i {an knr{gfc{gif& [a~r, {an ri~}bn fikn `fizr g{r
}i~{n {i {an knr{gfc{gif fikn cfk bcf gfg{gc{n {an }i~{gfjid {an kc{c ucb`n{r& [an ri~}bn bcbanr {agr }i~{n gf g{r
}i~{n bcban&
Gf {an }i~{n ocgf{nfcfbn uacrn, }i~{n n}}i} cfkcb`fizlnkjnonf{r ucb`n{r c}n ~rnk& KR] nfr~}nr {antclgkg{w id {an nqgr{gfj }i~{nr mcrnk if {ancb`fizlnkjnonf{r }nbngtnk d}io {an fngjami~}gfj
fiknr {ac{ kc{c ucb`n{r actn mnnf {}cfrog{{nk {i {an fnq{aiu& Cb`fizlnkjnonf{ ucb`n{r clri gfbl~kn ucrrgtn
cb`fizlnkjnonf{r cr {an fikn itn}anc}r {an fnq{ aiufngjami~} gr di}zc}kgfj {an ucb`n{ clifj {an }i~{n {i {anknr{gfc{gif& C }i~{n n}}i} ucb`n{ gr jnfn}c{nk zanf cfikn nfbi~f{n}r c {}cfrogrrgif u}imlno zagba oncfr
{ac{ c fikn acr dcglnk {i }nbngtn cf cb`fizlnkjnonf{&
[agr }i~{n n}}i} ucb`n{ gr rnf{ {i {an ri~}bn gf i}kn} {igfg{gc{n c fnz }i~{n kgrbitn}w uacrn& ^uif }nbngtgfj {an}i~{n n}}i} onrrcjn, fiknr }noitn d}io {ang} }i~{nbcbanr {an }i~{n nf{}w ~rgfj {an m}i`nf lgf`&
M& Lgf` ctcglcmglg{w/mcrnk SiR/czc}n !LMCS' }i~{gfj
W~ n{ cl& u}iuirn {an LMCS P4_ }i~{gfj u}i{ibil mcrnkif fikn oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif cfk lgf` s~clg{woncr~}nonf{& Zagln c fikn oitnr, g{ ocw nqun}gnfbntc}wgfj bcucbg{w, }nlgcmglg{w cfk mcfkzgk{a ctcglcmglg{w&Gfr{nck id {}wgfj {i u}nkgb{ {an oimglg{w uc{{n}fr id {anoimgln lgf`r, {an lgf` ctcglcmglg{w gr gfbi}ui}c{nk gf{i {an
}i~{gfj on{}gbr {i anlu baiirn {an lgf` zg{a {an agjanr{ctcglcmglg{w gf {an }i~{n& [an nqunb{nk {}cfrogrrgif bi~f{!N[Q' clifj zg{a uizn} bifr~ou{gif gr clri ~rnk cr c}i~{n on{}gb& [an }i~{n on{}gbr ~rnk c}n8
Lgf` ctcglcmglg{w8 u}imcmglg{w {ac{ {zi fiknr id c lgf` r{cw
kg}nb{lw biffnb{nk c{ c {gon {5 + { u}itgknk {ac{ {anw zn}nbiffnb{nk c{ {gon {5&
Lgf` s~clg{w8 {an f~omn} id }n{}cfrogrrgifr }ns~g}nk {irnfk c ucb`n{ if c lgf` mn{znnf {zi fiknr !N[Q'& [agr grbiou~{nk mw oncr~}gfj {an lirr }c{n id m}ickbcr{ ucb`n{r
mn{znnf {an fikn ucg}r&
Nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif8 uizn} bifr~ou{gif c{ ncba aiu&
^rgfj {an on{}gbr cmitn, c biomgfnk bir{ d~fb{gif grknrgjfnk mcrnk if zagba {an }i~{n gr bifr{}~b{nk&Kg![g'?β5!Ng'+β3!Sg'+β=!3/Lg!{'',zan}n β5, β3 cfk β= ? 3 ∝
β5 ∝ β3 c}n {an zngja{gfj binddgbgnf{r, Lg cfk Sg c}nctcglcmglg{w cfk s~clg{w id lgf` g, Ng gr {an nfn}jw
bifr~onk if lgf` g, [g gr {an {}cddgb bc}}gnk if uc{a g, cfkKg gr {an dgfcl bir{ id {an }i~{n& C ri~}bn fikn rnfkr c
]]NS ucb`n{ k~}gfj }i~{n kgrbitn}w& Zanf cfgf{n}onkgc{n fikn }nbngtnr {agr ]]NS ucb`n{, g{bclb~lc{nr g{r izf bir{ d}io {an ns~c{gif cmitn cfkdi}zc}kr {an ucb`n{ zg{a {agr fnz gfdi}oc{gif& [an {i{cl
bir{ {i {an knr{gfc{gif gr biou~{nk zanf {an ]]NS}ncbanr {an knr{gfc{gif fikn& C{ {an knr{gfc{gif, {an fikn
zcg{r di} c dgqnk f~omn} id ]]NSr mndi}n rnlnb{gfj {an}i~{n zg{a {an lncr{ bir{& Gd c lgf` m}nc`r, {anf cfcl{n}fc{n }i~{n gr rnlnb{nk di} kc{c {}cfrogrrgif&
B& Jc{an}gfj mcrnk }i~{gfj u}i{ibil !J]U'
Caf u}nrnf{r {an jc{an}gfj mcrnk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilP:_zagba billnb{r fn{zi}` gfdi}oc{gif k~}gfj }i~{n
kgrbitn}w {i mn ~rnk lc{n} mw {an ri~}bn fikn& Gfg{gcllw,{an ri~}bn fikn m}ickbcr{r c knr{gfc{gif s~n}w !KS' ucb`n{ zagba gr bif{gf~i~rlw di}zc}knk {izc}kr {anknr{gfc{gif& [agr u}ibnrr gr rgoglc} {i {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w u}ibnrr gf KR] i} CIKT ~rgfj ]]NSr& Zanf {an KS}ncbanr {an knr{gfc{gif fikn, c fn{zi}` gfdi}oc{gifjc{an}gfj !FGJ' ucb`n{ gr di}zc}knk mw {an knr{gfc{gif&[agr FGJ ucb`n{ gr {anf u}iucjc{nk itn} {an nf{g}n
fn{zi}` billnb{gfj gfdi}oc{gif& Ntn}w FGJ ucb`n{ grcrrgjfnk c rns~nfbn f~omn}& Fiknr }nbngtgfj c FGJ ucb`n{ zg{a c fnz rns~nfbn f~omn} c{{cba fn{zi}`
gfdi}oc{gif {i {agr ucb`n{ cfk di}zc}k g{ clifj nddnb{gtni~{jigfj lgf`r !NILr'& NILr c}n {airn lgf`r gf zagba {an FGJ ucb`n{r c}n fi{ }nbngtnk& Ifbn {an FGJ ucb`n{
c}}gtnr c{ {an ri~}bn fikn, {an iu{gocl uc{a gr bclb~lc{nk mw {an ri~}bn fikn mcrnk if {an billnb{nk fn{zi}` gfdi}oc{gif& Kc{c ucb`n{r c}n {anf {}cfrog{{nk {a}i~ja{agr bclb~lc{nk }i~{n&
K& Ri~}bn }i~{gfj zg{a libcl }nbitn}w !RL]'
Rnfj~l cfk @}ctn{r P1_ r{c}{ d}io {an imrn}tc{gif {ac{cl{ai~ja if/knocfk }i~{gfj }nk~bnr {an bir{ id }i~{gfjgf agja oimglg{w nftg}ifonf{r, {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w
u}ibnrr, zagba gr {wugbcllw kifn {a}i~ja fn{zi}`/zgkndliikgfj, bifr~onr c rgjfgdgbcf{ coi~f{ id mcfkzgk{a&[agr gr nrunbgcllw nqunfrgtn gd {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w o~r{ mn }nunc{nk k~n {i lgf`r m}i`nf k~n {i fikn oimglg{w& [i
cllntgc{n {agr u}imlno, {an c~{ai}r u}iuirn mwucrr}i~{gfj, c u}ibnrr zagba uc{banr c }i~{n ~rgfj libclgfdi}oc{gif cbs~g}nk if/knocfk, zg{ai~{ {an fnnk id fn{zi}`/zgkn dliikgfj& [an RL] u}i{ibil gr cfgoulnonf{c{gif nqcouln id {an mwucrr }i~{gfj cuu}icba&Mwucrr }i~{gfj gf RL] libclgxnr {an }ncb{gif {i c }i~{n
dcgl~}n cfk gfg{gc{nr iflw c libcl }nbitn}w u}ibnk~}n&^rgfj lgf` r{c{n gfdi}oc{gif d}io {an OCB lcwn}, c libcl uc{ba if {an }i~{n gr b}nc{nk mwucrrgfj {an m}i`nf lgf`&
Mw ~rgfj libcl }nbitn}w zg{a lgf` r{c{n gfdi}oc{gif, {anbacfbnr id }nbitn}gfj d}io c m}i`nf }i~{n gfb}ncrnr&Zanf c }i~{n dcglr, dg}r{ {an libcl }i~{n bcban gr rnc}bank
di} cf cl{n}fc{n }i~{n& Gd fi }i~{n gr ctcglcmln, mwucrr}nbitn}w gr gfg{gc{nk mw s~n}wgfj {an fngjami}r& Mcrnk if}nulgnr d}io {anrn fiknr, {an uc{a gr cjcgf }nbifr{}~b{nk&OCB bcbanr u}itgkn {an biffnb{gtg{w gfdi}oc{gif {igoonkgc{n ifn/aiu fngjami}r cfk {an r{c{n gr ~ukc{nk mwncba fikn zanfntn} cfw bioo~fgbc{gif gr anc}k gf {anfngjami}aiik& OCB bcbanr clri anlu kn{n}ogfn {antclgkg{w id {an }i~{nr gf {an }i~{n bcbanr& N}}i} }nbitn}w
gr gfg{gc{nk mw rcltcjgfj ~rnk }i~{n bcbanr, mwucrr}nbitn}w cfk n}}i} }nui}{gfj !rnn Dgj 3'& [an fikn lii`r
di} cl{n}fc{gtn }i~{nr {i {an knr{gfc{gif gf g{r bcban {ircltcjn c ucb`n{& Gd {an rcltcjnk ucb`n{ }ncbanr g{r
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 323
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 147/223
knr{gfc{gif, {onrrcjn d}i}i~{n gr gf dc
N& Agf{ mcrn
Mn}clkg n{
d}conzi}` ucb`n{r {izc[an on{c/gfncba fikn& C{i {an knr{gftcl~n gfkgbc{
fngjami~}aiagjan} u}imcifn/aiu fngj
Zanf c fzgll {}w rnfkgacr fi{ mnnf
{}wgfj tc}gi~
r~ba fngjamfiknr m}ick{anf ~rnk {ifngjami~}& [bclb~lc{n {an m}ickbcr{gfj mncbif onrrc{ oir{ L ai
{an u}i{ibil&tcl~n gr r~d Roclln} lii` id lizn} bif{
D& Liz itn}
W~ n{ cl& P35gfdi}oc{gifgr kizf, {andcglnk lgf`rgfg{gcl ocgfknr{gfc{gif
{}cfrog{{nk&fngjami}gfj
fiknr c}n cbfikn if {anbcfkgkc{n fi~rnk k~}gfj
an ri~}bn }nb{an knr{gfc
{ cf cl{n}fc{n
Dgj& 3& N}}i
k u}imcmglgr{g
cl& P7_ u}iu
agba ~rnr}kr {an jnfn} i}oc{gif gragf{, agk, bi
c{gif fikn kgfj {an bacf
k id fikn k&glg{w zg{a ag
ami~}r&kn di}zc}krfj {i {an fng{}gnk mndi}n d
r cl{n}fc{gtnr
~} nqgr{, {ancr{ un}gikgb
b}nc{n c tnb{agr {gon gfd
agf{ tcl~nr{an bif{}iljnr& Ntn}w fr c}i~fk g{&
[an c~{ai}rgbgnf{ di} ccanck tcl~nr}il itn}anckr
nck kwfcogb
_ }nucg} m}i` }io itn}anc
u}iuirnk u}ig{a mcb`~u lgi~{n gr bifrcg} clifj
Zagln {anfiknr itn}an
{~cllw ui{nf{ocgf }i~{n
knr c}n }nbi} {an }i~{n }nb
ngtnr cf nfa{gif r{c{gfj{i {an m}i`nf
} }nbitn}w nqco
b u}i{ibil
rn c u}imcmg
on{c/gfdi}occl kg}nb{gif i}itgknk gf u~{nk mw f
, gr }nu}nrnf{bn id fikn
lizn} agf{? 5 zanf
c ucb`n{ {i {aami~} zg{a {a} {an rcon u
gf {an i}kn}
ucb`n{ gr kanc}{mnc{ u} id {gon gfd }oc{gif tnb& Agf{r c}nnrrcjnr {a}
ikn }nbngtnragr gr {an li
raiz {ac{ cfikn {i jc{clri actn cf&
}i~{n }nucg}g
f }i~{nr kwfgfj {an fikn{ibil gf{nllgjgf`r clifj {a}~b{nk mn{zagba {an k
n ucb`n{rc} {anrn {}cf
gcl bcfkgkc{ngf bcrn id nk gf {an uc
ifr{}~b{gif g
cfbnk }i~{n nac{ {an rclt}i~{n
ln
glgr{gb di}zc}
{gif {i di} d {an knr{gfc{n}or id agf{kn g zg{a }nrnk mw c uirgg }nrgkgfj gf
cl~n ns~c{nriknr g cfk k
n knr{gfc{gifn mnr{ agf{ zcb`n{ !nddnb{g
d {an agf{'& G
grbc}knk& Cllb`n{r zagba}oc{gif di} i} gr ~{glgxnkgrrnogfc{nk~ja {an un}gagf{r d}io f`canck tcl~n
rocll lii`can} bi}}nb{ agckknk cktcf
fj
ogbcllw mw ~r& Ifbn {an } f{lw }nulcbnr
n ocgf }i~{n&nf c ri~}bnc{c ucb`n{r
c}n di}zc} rogrrgifr& [
di} }nulcbgfc dcgl~}n& [b`n{ anckn}r
{an d~{~}n&
}}i} jnk
gfj
c}kgif&r c{nb{
g{gtn{an
{i cc}n
k g{gbanlw
d fi
{anc}ncba
{i mwkgbknrdi}
nckgf{r&cjn
rgfj~{n{anCfcfkc}n
knk,nrn
j cnrncfk[an
}i ucO
c}} rnf mn{
~roczg{an
bari,biai{inf]N
ag}nc un u} ru}igfb
oi mn{{nkn
{ackn
cm
mn
[a}nrxi{an mcgf{
i}gzn
cu
{n bifr{}~b{g`n{ gfg{gcllw,NS gr dliik
gtnr c{ {an kn{ mcb`& [anznnf {an ri
k k~}gfj }i~gf }i~{n jina {an aiu bi
ocgf }i~{n
b`r {i rnn gd g{ rnfkr c } f{ tcl~n gr b
bi~f{ gr rc}kr {an knr{
mlnr fiknrUS cfk }nulw
GT& B
Ri~}bn }i~{gf
a gf{n}nr{ di} rifr di} {agr&bngtnk cr{ibilr d}iobgdgb {i ck{gfj gr mnrc}fc{gifr id {
mglg{w id {anznnf c ri~} ui}c}w gf fccfk, m~{ {an
{ {an nddgbgnfgjf bifrgkn} Ifn id {an~{ {an acfklg
cuu}icbank d
Gou}i
u}i{ikwfc
mwucr
Baiir{cmln
d~{~}n
LCMbifrgbaclln
n fitnl fc{~} nc}ban}r {in id fn{zi} i}w cfk dli`j}i~fk'&}kgrbgulgfc}w
jgfc{nk }i~{gfactn cf c
}icba&
f ~rnr c ogoglc} {i c ]
nk {a}i~jai~
{gfc{gif, {anO]]U `nn}bn cfk knr{
{n }nucg} zakizf& C }nf{ id {ac{ fdcgl~}n& C
g{ acr c rctn ucg} }nulw !iouc}nk zg{clln}, g{ u}i
gfc{gif, nlrnlirn} {i {anzg{a c tclgk
OUC]GRIF Iu}i{ibilr a
{an ck aib biDg}r{, zagln {q{nfrgifr i{an zg}nk kaib fn{zi}
{ ckcu{nkan ck aib fn{
fiknr gr rin cfk c knr~}n& Fi{ ifl u}imcmglg{w
bw id }nruif{gif&cgf gou}itnj id }nbitn}
io rntn}cl kg
tgfj {an run
ilr id {agrgb }i~{n }nu
r }i~{gfj'&
gfj uc{ar za8 LMCS P4
lgf` ctcglcmgl
P4_ nq{nfn}gfj {an Sjn&
id ri~}bn i}g}cfba i~{ d} `gfj !zagbaz iu{gogxc{C f~omncuu}icbanr
j& Gf {an ucu u}icba mcrn
cgf }i~{n }ns]NS ucb`n{ g{ {an fn{zi}
cgf }i~{n }nr {}cb` id {gfc{gif& [agr
nf c uc}{gb~l ucg} s~n}w !kn gr di}zc} ikn }nbngtg
}i~{n {i {anNU]'0 i{an}
a g{r izf ai ucjc{nr {an{an ucb`n{ grknr{gfc{gifcb`~u }i~{n&
[AN U]I[IBctn mnnf c }n
oo~fg{w& [a mln k}gtnf u}
ckcu{c{gifiocgf, }ncb{g`r& D~}{an} i {an oirzi}`r8 rg{~c{g
agja {ac{ cf{gfc{gif zgll{ac{ }i~{nrd c }i~{n dcgl
kgfj {i dcgl~
onf{ kg}nb{gw id dcglnk }i
g}nb{gifr8
k id }nm~glkg
blcrr c}n lcg} P35_ , RL
gba c}n u}nkgb_ !mcrnk if
lg{w'&
r ~uif {an~clg{w id rn}
gjgfc{nk }i~{gio {an {}ckggoulgnr }nlgcgif cr {an
id gffctn mnnf cu
n}r r~}tnwnk gif u}imc
~nr{ !O]NSf CIKT& [a` cfk ifbn g
lw !O]]U' gan aiu bi~faiu bi~f{ g
} lgf` if {aNUS' ucb`nnk gf bcrn ij {an ]NU
knr{gfc{gif& Gzgrn, {an ai
bi~f{& Gd g{]NUS ucb`nk}iuunk& [agi }nbngtn {a
ILR nc}ba {iugb i
n}n c}n rntn} i{ibilr bcf m
id nqgr{gfgtn }i~{gfj gi}n, }ncb{gt
bacllnfjgfifr zan}n {a
}i~{n di~fgfntg{cmlw m}n b}nc{nk ifgfj gr ri agj
nr gr c ochi
fr actn mnn~{nr& [agr bc
fj {an }i~{nr
iz itn}anc] P1_ !~rgf
{nk {i mn oi} u}nkgb{gif i
mcrnlgfn mtgbn Fn{zi}
j nfbi~}cjngifcl biodifbn if j}cuoc{anoc{gbtc{gtn cflgnk {i ri~}b
gf {agr rnb{gifglgr{gb }i~{gf
'ng{
r{r
n{d
d
r{rn
d
ln
rn
n
n/
}
8
n
{
l
n
,
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 32=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 148/223
[CMLN G
BIOUC]GRIF ID O^L[GBCR[ U]I[IBILR
U}i{ibil O~l{guln ]i~{nr ]i~{n On{}gb ]i~{n ]nm~glkgfjBioo~fgbc{gif
Itn} anck
KR] Wnr Rai}{nr{ uc{a i} fnq{
ctcglcmln
Fnz }i~{n
Cfk fi{gdw
Agja
W~ n{ cl Fi Rai}{nr{ Uc{a i} mcb`~u}i~{n
Libcl Mcb`~u Onkg~o
LCMS Wnr Lgf` ctcglcmglg{wS~clg{w , cfk Nfn}jw~rnk
Rcon cr KR] i} libcl }nucg}
Agja
J]U Wnr Rai}{nr{ Uc{a Mcb`~u }i~{n Agja
RL] Wnr Rai}{nr{ Uc{a i} fnq{ctcglcmln uc{a
Fnz }i~{n cfkfi{gdw ri~}bn
Agja
Mn}clkgn{ cl&
Wnr Agf{ tcl~n Libcl m}ickbcr{ Agja
T& BIFBL^RGIFR
Gf {agr ucun}, zn actn }ntgnznk cfk biouc}nk rntn}cl}nu}nrnf{c{gtn u}i{ibilr& Zagln kgddn}nf{ blcrrnr id u}i{ibiliun}c{n ~fkn} kgddn}nf{ rbnfc}gir, {anw ~r~cllw rac}n {an
biooif jicl {i }nk~bn bif{}il ucb`n{ itn}anck, ocqgogxn{a}i~jau~{, cfk ogfgogxn {an nfk/{i/nfk knlcw& [an ocgfkgddn}nf{gc{gfj dcb{i} mn{znnf {an u}i{ibilr gr {an zcwr id dgfkgfj cfk)i} ocgf{cgfgfj {an }i~{nr mn{znnf ri~}bn‒ knr{gfc{gif ucg}r& [an kntnliuonf{ id {an ck aib }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr itn} {an lcr{ 3> wnc}r gr cf nqcouln id ifn id {anoir{ rwr{noc{gb nquli}c{gifr id c knrgjf rucbn gf {an agr{i}w
id biou~{n} rbgnfbn& Cl{ai~ja, blnc}lw, fnzn} u}i{ibilr actn m~gl{ ~uif {an nc}lgn} ifnr, zn bcffi{ gknf{gdw c rgfjln “mnr{‟ u}i{ibil& Cloir{ cll {an u}i{ibilr zn kgrb~rrnk gf {agr ucun} actn {ang} izf rznn{ rui{ knuliwonf{ rbnfc}gir cfk un}di}ocfbn on{}gb biomgfc{gifr zan}n {anw i~{un}di}o {ang} bioun{g{i}r& D}io {an uigf{ id tgnz id {an u}cb{g{gifn}, {agr
b}nc{nr c rn}gi~r u}imlno& [i knuliw cf ck aib fn{zi}` zg{acf iu{gocl un}di}ocfbn, g{ }ns~g}nr c tn}w bc}nd~l cfclwrgr id {an rbnfc}gi cfk g{r }ns~g}nonf{r, cfk {an cuu}iu}gc{n baigbnid {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil d}io {an kixnfr cuulgbcmln gf {anbif{nq{
] NDN]NFBNR
P3_ a{{u8))zzz&gn{d&i}j)a{ol&bac}{n}r)ocfn{/bac}{n}&a{ol
P=_ H& M}iba, K& Ocl{x, K& Hiafrif, W& A~, H& Hn{bantc& “C un}di}ocfbn
biouc}grif id o~l{g aiu zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}` }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr“,OIMGBIO 71
& J& Ung, O& Jn}lc, Q& Aifj& “LCFOC]8 lcfkoc}` }i~{gfj di} lc}jn rbcln
zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}`r zg{a j}i~u oimglg{w“, U}ib& Id GNNN)CBOOimgAib =555, Mir{if, OC, C~j~r{ =555&
P3_ [ifw Lc}rrif, Fgb`lcr Ankocf& “]i~{gfj u}i{ibilr gf zg}nlnrr ck aib
fn{zi}`r ‒ C rgo~lc{gif r{~kw‟, Ocr{n} [anrgr, R{ib`ailo n}gbrrif
rzg{bank lcm& 3771&
P>_ K&M& Hiafrif, K&C& Ocl{x cfk H& M}iba, KR]8 {an kwfcogb ri~}bn}i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} o~l{g/aiu zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}`r, B&N& Un}`gfr,
Nkg{i}, Ck Aib Fn{zi}`gfj, Ckkgrif/Znrlnw !=553', uu& 327‒3:=
!Bacu{n} >'&P4_ O& W~, C& Ocltcf c}, Z& R~ cfk R& Dii, C lgf` ctcglcmglg{w/mcrnk
SiR/czc}n }i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} oimgln ck aib rnfri} fn{zi}`r&
Biou~{n} Bioo~fgbc{gifr, 25 31 !=55:', uu& 21=2‒2123&P:_ B& Caf, Jc{an}gfj/mcrnk }i~{gfj u}i{ibil gf oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r&
Biou~{n} Bioo~fgbc{gifr, 25 3 !=554', uu& =5=‒=54& C}{gbln
P1_ B& Rnfj~l cfk ]& @}ctn{r, Mwucrr }i~{gfj8 cf if/knocfk libcl}nbitn}w u}i{ibil di} ck aib fn{zi}`r& Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r, ; 2 !=554',
uu& 215‒27:&P7_ ]& Mn}clkg, L& S~n}xifg cfk ]& Mclkifg, C agf{/mcrnk u}imcmglgr{gb
u}i{ibil di} ~fgbcr{ bioo~fgbc{gifr gf OCFN[r& Ck Aib
Fn{zi}`r, ; > !=554', uu& >;:‒>44&
P35_ B& W~, [&/@& Z~ cfk ]& Banfj, C liz itn}anck kwfcogb }i~{n
}nucg}gfj onbacfgro di} oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r& Biou~{n} Bioo~fgbc{gifr, 25 > !=55:', uu& 33>=‒3342&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 322
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 149/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :2771)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :2771
Fikn Blcrrgdgbc{gif di} Nfn}jw Nddgbgnf{ cfk ]nlgcmln Agn}c}bagbcl ZRF U}i{ibil
Fgfj R~fKnu{& id Biou~{n} RbgnfbnBa~fjm~` Fc{gifcl fgtn}rg{w
Banifjh~, @i}nc
Rcfj/ai LnnKnu{& id Rid{zc}nBa~fjm~` Fc{gifcl fgtn}rg{w
Banifjh~, @i}nc
Cmr{}cb{‛Nfn}jw Nddgbgnfbw gr cf goui}{cf{ dcb{i} {i knrgjf c
zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}` !ZRF'& Oncfzagln, kc{c }nlgcmglg{w gr
cfi{an} goui}{cf{ grr~n di} ZRF& Mi{a id {ano bcf mn
im{cgfnk mw knrgjfgfj cf nddgbgnf{ OCB i} }i~{gfj u}i{ibil& Gf
{agr ucun}, zn u}iuirnk cf nfn}jw nddgbgnf{ cfk }nlgcmln
bl~r{n}gfj agn}c}bagbcl OCB cfk }i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} ZRFr&
Cbbi}kgfj {i {an kgddn}nf{ d~fb{gifr fiknr oc`n gf {an
fn{zi}`, zn b}nc{gtnlw blcrrgdw rnfri} fiknr gf{i dgtnbc{nji}gnr& Mw ckiu{gfj kgddn}nf{ OCB cfk }i~{gfj r{}c{njw {i
kgddn}nf{ bc{nji}w, i~} u}iuirnk onbacfgro }nk~bnr nfn}jw
bifr~ou{gif cfk u}itgknr kc{c }nlgcmglg{w gf c ocqgo~o&
@nwzi}kr/ ZRF, zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`, nfn}jw nddgbgnfbw, }nlgcmglg{w, bl~r{n}, agn}c}bagbcl, OCB, o~l{g/uc{a }i~{gfj u}i{ibil
G& G F[]IK^B[GIF
C ZRF bcf mn i}jcfgxnk mw a~fk}nkr {i {ai~rcfkr id rnfri} fiknr& [an rnfri} fiknr billnb{ kc{c {a}i~ja rnfrgfjcfk oifg{i}gfj d}io {ang} nftg}ifonf{ cfk dgfcllw rnfk {i{an mcrn r{c{gif di} d~}{an}gfj u}ibnrrgfj& ZRFr bcf mncuulgbcmln gf ocfw kiocgfr, r~ba cr oglg{c}w cb{gtg{gnr,bif{}il cfk c~{ioc{gif, nftg}ifonf{ oifg{i}gfj, ancl{abc}n,rnb~}g{w cfk r~}tngllcfbn, roc}{ aion cfk m~glkgfj, tnagbln{}cb`gfj cfk kn{nb{gif, n{b&
Cr oir{ rnfri} fiknr actn lg{{ln bir{ cfk rgxn zg{abifr{}cgfnk u}ibnrri}r, lgog{nk onoi}w rgxn, liz mg{ }c{nbioo~fgbc{gifr cfk liz nfn}jw bcucmglg{w& K~n {i {agr,nfn}jw rctgfj gr clzcwr c }noc}`cmln grr~n cfk jn{r o~bac{{nf{gif di} c ZRF u}i{ibil knrgjf& A~fk}nkr id OCB cfk}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr actn mnnf u}iuirnk cfk knuliwnk ~f{glfiz zg{a {an u~}uirn id rctgfj nfn}jw&
Oir{ nfn}jw nddgbgnf{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr cuulgnkagn}c}bagbcl r{}~b{~}n r~ba cr bl~r{n} mcrnk r{}~b{~}n cr gf P3_&Agn}c}bagbcl r{}~b{~}n bi~lk j}nc{lw }nk~bn f~omn} id kg}nb{bioo~fgbc{gifr mn{znnf rnfri} fiknr cfk mcrn r{c{gif,ntnf{~cllw imtgi~rlw knb}ncrn nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif gf {anzailn fn{zi}` cfk u}ilifj fn{zi}` lgdn{gon& Cbbi~f{gfj di} {an cktcf{cjnr id {agr on{aik, i~} ucun} ~rnk bl~r{n}gfjagn}c}bagbcl r{}~b{~}n {ii&
Gf {an tgnz id OCB u}i{ibil, nfn}jw zcr{n ocgflwbionr d}io {an dillizgfj ri~}bnr8 gkln lgr{nfgfj, kc{cbillgrgif, itn}anc}gfj cfk bif{}il ucb`n{ itn}anck, n{b&Nfn}jw nddgbgnf{ OCB u}i{ibilr cbagntn nfn}jw rctgfjr mw
bif{}illgfj {an }ckgi {i }nk~bn nfn}jw zcr{n bc~rnk mw {anrnri~}bnr& OCB u}i{ibilr di} ZRFr bcf mn bc{nji}gxnk gf{i{zi ocgf j}i~ur8 rbank~ln/mcrnk cfk bif{nf{gif/mcrnk
u}i{ibilr& Gf i~} u}iuirnk onbacfgro, cbbi}kgfj {i kgddn}nf{ uacrnr, zn ~{glgxnk kgddn}nf{ OCB u}i{ibilr {i }nk~bn {annfn}jw bifr~ou{gif dlnqgmlw&
Gf i~} ucun}, kc{c }nlgcmglg{w gr clri bifrgkn}nk, zagba gr
kndgfnk cr {an r~bbnrrd~l nfk/{i/nfk kc{c/knlgtn}w }c{gi, acr mnnf cfi{an} goui}{cf{ grr~n gf ZRFr& Ochi} ril~{gifr P4,1_di} kc{c }nlgcmglg{w id ZRF c}n mcrnk if {an o~l{g/uc{a}i~{gfj uc}ckgjo, zagba u}itgknr ncba rnfri} zg{acl{n}fc{gtn uc{ar& Gf {an uacrn id kc{c {}cfrogrrgif d}io BAr{i MR, zn un}di}or o~l{g/uc{a clji}g{ao mi{a gf }i~{gfj cfkOCB u}i{ibilr&
Gf i}kn} {i }nclgxn {an cmitn r{}c{njgnr, zn blcrrgdw rnfri} fiknr gf{i rntn}cl bc{nji}gnr, cbbi}kgfj {i {ang} kgddn}nf{ }ilngf kgddn}nf{ uacrn& Di} ncba bc{nji}w, g{ nqnb~{nr cl{n}fc{gtn}i~{gfj cfk OCB u}i{ibil cfk clri rion runbgdgb d~fb{gifr,r~ba cr kc{c cjj}njc{gif, nfn}jw clc}o, }ckgi bif{}il,rbank~ln jnfn}c{gif, n{b&
[an }nocgfkn} id {agr ucun} gr i}jcfgxnk cr dillizr8
Rnb{gif = u}nrnf{r {an }nlc{nk zi}`r& Rnb{gif 2 knrb}gmnr {anblcrrgdgbc{gif id rnfri} fiknr cfk nqulcgfr {an kn{cglnkd~fb{gif cfk clji}g{aor id ncba bc{nji}w& Rnb{gif ;gf{}ik~bnr {an u}ibnrr id i~} u}iuirnk }i~{gfj cfk OCB
u}i{ibil mcrnk if {an fikn blcrrgdgbc{gif gf rnb{gif 2& Dgfcllw,rnb{gif > k}czr bifbl~rgifr cfk raizr {an d~{~}n zi}`r&
GG& ] NLC[NK ZI]@R
Agn}c}bagbcl !bl~r{n}gfj' }i~{gfj {nbafgs~nr bcf cgk gf}nk~bgfj nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif& [an nrrnf{gcl iun}c{gif gfbl~r{n}gfj gr {i kgtgkn {an fn{zi}` gf{i rntn}cl tg}{~clbl~r{n}r, dg}r{lw rnlnb{ c rn{ id bl~r{n} anckr, cfk {anf di}ogfjbl~r{n}r zg{a {an }nocgfgfj fiknr& Bl~r{n} anckr c}n}nruifrgmln di} bii}kgfc{gif coifj {an fiknr zg{agf {ang}
bl~r{n}r cfk cjj}njc{gif id }nbngtnk kc{c, cfkbioo~fgbc{gif zg{a ncba i{an} cfk {an mcrn r{c{gif& [anrnfrnk kc{c c}n cjj}njc{nk, cfk {anf rnf{ {i {an mcrn r{c{gif
mw bl~r{n} anckr& Cr raizf gf P3_, {an bl~r{n}gfj bcfimtgi~rlw }nk~bn {an bioo~fgbc{gif itn}anck di} mi{argfjln/aiu cfk o~l{g/aiu zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r& LNCBAP3_ gr c blcrrgbcl bl~r{n}gfj agn}c}bagbcl u}i{ibil, zagbagfbi}ui}c{nr }cfkiogxnk }i{c{gif id {an agja/nfn}jw bl~r{n} anck uirg{gif coifj {an rnfri}r {i ctigk k}cgfgfj {an nfn}jwid cfw ifn rnfri} gf {an fn{zi}`& Gf {agr zcw, {an nfn}jwlick id mngfj c bl~r{n} anck gr ntnflw kgr{}gm~{nk coifj {anfiknr& Mngfj c bl~r{n} anckn} gr o~ba oi}n nfn}jw gf{nfrgtn{acf mngfj c fif/bl~r{n} anckn} fikn& LNCBA gfbi}ui}c{nr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 32;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 150/223
g
cfkiogxnkirg{gif& If
bifrgkn} {anan}ncr zn k
clji}g{ao& Rkwfcogb fn{bl~r{n}r, f~o}gi}g, m~{ gfg{a {an knu
bacfjn ntn}wlc}jn rgxn id izn} {i bioi{ }nclgr{gb d
mn{znnf BA c[an r~m
lg{n}c{~}nr P3,anck kgr{}gm~
ailn fn{zi}ilifjnk& [izntn}, cll
clji}g{ao id cjj}njc{nk kgoui}{cf{, {~c}cf{nnk&
Ri~}bnr ibillgrgifr, it
oifj {ano,itn} ifn/acld k~}gfj g{r lgdn}i{ibilr gr {
lgr{nfgfj, itnddgbgnf{ OCcfk bif{nf{g
~l{guln cbbncbagntnk mw kanf cllibc{gfikn& Fiknr {NCBA u}i{
bl~r{n}& [an {dgj~}n 2!c'&
i{c{gif id {rai}{biogf
nfn}jw dcb{inrgjfnk cf obifklw, LNi}`& G{ grn} id fiknr'}nclg{w {anrnln{gif id fi}i~fk kwfcog
RF& G{ gr crro~fgbc{n zg{i} c lc}jn rbfk MR gr o~l{rns~nf{ LN,2,;_ oir{lwgif, ri {ac{}` gr }nk~bnn r{}~b{~}n i{anrn agn}c}bbl~r{n} di}oc{c {}cfrogrrgn }nlgcmglg{w
Dgj~}n 3& Bl~r{n
d nfn}jw zcr{n}anc}gfj, nq
nfn}jw zcr{id {an {i{cl n{gon& [an oc}nk~bn nfn}j
n}anc}gfj cfB u}i{ibilr gif/mcrnk u} rr' gr c {wugbgtgkgfj {an }cj ~fgs~n {gc`n {~}fr zc` bil, g{ ~rnr [gon lgfn id ir{ bl~r{n}gf
an agja nfnid LNCBAzanf nlnb{g}n nddgbgnf{ bBA kinrf‗{nbc~rn uc}cc}n u}ij}co uc}con{n}r bnr& [anrn ubcllw& LNCBonk {ac{ ntni{an}r cfk
ln ZRF& Rig/aiu gf i~} uCBA/iu{gogxgou}itn {an{an nfn}jw bk cfk {and bl~r{n}gfj ggbcl u}i{ibil
{gif, jgtn lg{{f& Rgfbn {an
id {}cfro
}gfj r{}~b{~}n di
gf ZRFr gfbnrrgtn onrr
nk mw gkln lgrn}jw bifr~ogf imhnb{gtnw zcr{n bc~rnk nqbnrrgtngfbl~kn rbani{ibil& [Kcl ril~{gif d kgi d}ns~nfbwn rli{r {i nn ~u cfk {}cf
OC gf kc{cNCBA u}i{iZRF u}i{i
jw bl~r{n} gr {ac{ g{ k
fj bl~r{n} anl~r{n} anck nlzi}` znll gn{n}r !f~om
nk gf{i {an fif{gf~i~rlw bc}con{n}r zn
gr fi{ rbclc}w fikn acr nR kg}nb{lw, m{an bioo~fg}i{ibil&nk u}i{ibilcucmglg{w id ifr~ou{gifrwr{no lgdn{gr raizf gfr iflw bifrgkln bifrgkn}c{gcjj}njc{nk k
grrgif rai~l
ZRFr
bl~kn gkln lgr{cjn itn}anck
{nfgfj cbbi~fnk mw c rnfrid oir{ OCBk mw billgrgifitn}anck& N~ln/mcrnk u} C !{gon/kg
} {an di}on} gf{i {gon rliba bioo~fgog{)}nbngtn k{}cfrogrrgifbil gr cr raibilr ~rn [K
nckn} inrf‗{ckn}r,nb{giff {ann} id knr c
acfjn~rnk
ln di} i~ja{ g{ gr
bc{gif
r gfl~r{n} d {ann gr
gj& 3&n} {anif ifc{c grk mn
nfgfj,, n{b&
{r di} fikn/lcwn} r, gklnfn}jwi{ibiltgrgif& G{ gr{r cfkbc{gfjc{c& Gf
g{agfzf gfC cr
{anbl~
bifcfkrbcfi
u}i uigrk~{ctnfnGf
mcr mi{ ua
kgrhondli{cj
m}c{}ngroncljcobifkc{
C&
MRncb= c{an{an7 c}nsfi
m}c33/
MRMFnqa
uc{{an
h~rgrcmcfi
OCB u}i{ibr{n}&Cl{ai~jar~ou{gif im{an bifr{}cg
lcmglg{w cfk dlbii}kgfc{giftgkn oi}n rbc~lc} bif{nf{g}iuirnk {i }
w bwbln iun}cgkcfbn, itn}a}jw rctgfj o{an rcon {gonk OCB u}i{a [KOC cfkrn&Di} o~l{g/uc{igf{ uc{ar a{aik& Gf A/kgfj u}i{ibi{ang} fngjamifba {ac{ {an f
m}cfba di}obagntnk zg{a
rrcjnr& Oir{i}g{ao gf {ani~f{r id r~ou{gif& Zc {}cfrogrrgif
GGG& M}cfba Fikn
[an kndgfg{gi& Cbbi}kgfj {a MF }nu}nrnfk 2 c}n MFrfngjami} zg{kgrbitn}w id { dg}r{ rn{r ~u~nr{ onrrcjnn 33, {an }nrfba fikn 3& D7'&Cbbi}kgfj {i
, {an fikn accb{r b}g{gbcl
c~r{nk {an zaar c}n bi}}nruMF kinrf‗{ hcb{r cr c }i~
mnliz c lgogfkifr {an }iln&
il {i ocfcjn
KOC u}i{gi~rlw, g{ lgo{r id {gon cqgmglg{w& Bif
coifj {an filcmglg{w cfk dlf/mcrnk u}i{k~bn {an nfn{gif& G{ clri unc}gfj ctigkcw }nr~l{ agjn, billgrgifribilr& Gf i~} bif{nf{/mcrn
a }i~{gfj u}icr mnnf bifU]NCK P4_
l {i dgfk c rn{}r cr c baglk,ikn gr libc{nkcf cl{n}fc{gt
i~{ {an fnnk~l{g/uc{a u}
uacrn id kcnrrcjn nqb
n ~rn agn}c}b&
LCRRGDGBC[G
!MF'
id {an MF gi {an m}cfba{r ifn m}cfba
& Gd c fikn }na kgddn}nf{ Mcf cl{n}fc{gtn
c u}goc}w ud}io fikn 33l{r raiz {ac{gfcllw fikn 7
{an rgo~lc{gi
r oi}n m~}kl }iln gf {aniln m}cfba grifkgfjlw dcglnigf {an bl~r{nn} gf {an fn{zg{c{gif tcl~n,
id m}cfba f
{an cbbnrr i
ibil bcfg{r {an f~omllibc{gif ri {nf{gif/mcrnkknr cbbnrrgfjnqgmglg{w& BRbilr& Di} ZR
}jw nddgbgnfbw}itgknk rbanfbn, rwfba}ilc{nfbw cfk
bcf‗{ mn ctig u}iuirnk onk OCB u}i{
{ibil gf ZRFrgkn}nk cr {a, g{ ~rnr {aid fikn/kgrhi
rgmlgfj i} bi~& Rnfri}r di~kgrhigf{ uc{a
i gf{}ik~bn c{ibilr ~r~cllc {}cfrogrrgiacfjnr cfkgbcl r{}~b{~}n
F ID RNFRI]
{an ifn/aiuczc}n dliikgf& Cr raizf gfngtnr c }ns~n
tcl~n, g{ bc uc{a& Cr raic{a !=/;/7'& [3& Cd{n} bioufikn 33 biodgfkr cf cl{n}
}nr~l{ gf P4_,
fr if kc{c {} fn{zi}`, mn
rnuc}c{nk cfkk& Gf i}kn} {i} di}oc{gif ci}`& D~}{an}o
g{ rai~lk ckn cfk {}cfrd
fiknr zg{ag
}nk~bn nfn} id higf{ fiac{ g{‗r rai}{}i{ibilr }ns{an bacffnlC rn}gnr c}n
Fr, R/OCB Pmw ~rgfj c lnr di} billgrggxc{gif& M~{liz {a}i~jagknk gf bif{nbacfgro, znbilr gf kgddn}
r, m~glkgfj fn oir{ }nlgcn m}cfba/czgf{ uc{ar& Firgf, mcrnk ifk if c kgddn}
& [agr clji}g{fw nq{}c }i~{g~rn dlc{ }i~{g
f, zagba bc~o~ba nfn
gf {an uacrn
FIKNR
fngjami}r id j clji}g{ao Pdgj~}n =, fik
r{ onrrcjn d} mn }njc}knkgf Dgj& =, f
anf g{ anc}rc}n {an MFr d}io kgddn} c{gtn uc{a !3
{an fnc}n} {i
cfrogrrgif&bc~rn ifbn g{an kizfr{}n
bifrn}tn nfn} fk kc{c rnfrni}n, gd g{r nfnffi~fbn {ac{}or {i c fi}
c
jwnrid g}nfk{an33_izgif{an~{&f{/rn
nf{
kn mlnc}nnr
{annf{aogfjgfjrnrjwid
{an4_,n 3,iocrkn
{ang{anf{/1/
{an
ang{‗rcojw,& G{jwg{cl
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 32>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 151/223
D
Fikn g zgcbbi}kgfj {i {
N [Q gr {aan}ncr N ]B ~omn} id o
rc{grdgnk, fik
M& Bl~r{n} A
Gf i~} cu
mcrnk if {anikn& BA grnfn}c{gif,}cfrogrrgif&
s~gb`n} {acfclji}g{ao gr f
Gf i~} ucbbi}kgfj {ngjami}r id }imcmglg{w8
!Ug
N g gr {anngjami}r id ngjami}aiikgr {an iu{go
cr cmi~{ >.cfjn !5,3'&
Biouc}nknfn}jw cfk {acfkiogxnk }
Cd{n} bl~rikn rn{r ~u
gj~}n =& M}cfba
ll knbgkn zanan dillizgfj
! M}n N
n nfn}jw bifgr gf kc{c }nrrcjnr& γ grg oc}` g{rnld
ck Fikn !BA
u}icba, bl~r{
nrgk~cl nfn}jgf bac}jn ic{c u}ibnrr[an nfn}jwfi}ocl fik
nbnrrc}w& un}, BA gr
{an }nrgk~ncba fikn,
ogf' `
nrgk~cl nfn}jfikn g, zag
{cmln& F gr {acl f~omn} id d F & γ gr {an
zg{a LNCBn knfrg{w id {c{gif&n}r c}n di}on
c [KOC rba
czc}n dliikgfj c
{an} g{ rai~lk}imcmglg{w8
!( [Q N F
r~ou{gif gfnu{gif& F gran binddgbgnfcr {an MF&
'
n} anckr c}n
cfk {an f~kc{c }nbngtkc{c cjj}
bifr~ou{gifr& Ri cf n
lnb{nk gf cl nfn}jw cfA gr nlnb{n
3! N
N
{i
g
w id fikn g&gba bcf mn{i{cl f~omn}
bl~r{n}r, zagbinddgbgnf{, z
, zn bifrgkncba fikn, gf
k cr gf LNCk~ln cfk {}c
lji}g{ao
mn c m}cfba
'' ]B
kc{c {}cfrog u}iui}{gifcl& Gd {an bifkg
nlnb{nk kgr{}g
mn} id fngjam, [KOC rbnjc{gif cfk
id BA grnflw BA nl
kgr{}gm~{nk ok {an f~om
cr {an dill
3,'
F
F fngj
F fngj gr {an rn{}gntnk d}iid cll rnfri} a bcf mn bclbairn tcl~n gr
} mi{a {an }nr{nck id {an r
A, {an bl~r{nrog{r {agr rb
fikn,
rrgif,{i {angif gr
gm~{nk
i}r id nk~lnkc{c
o~banb{gif
cffn}&n} id izgfj
o id {an
iknr&~lc{nkgf {an
rgk~clgouln
ancknk~ln
{ibil
B&
r~mc~{anccfkanccuufng{}c[agrwr
{an}~fzgl
u} irbaG{ } rba{go{gocfkricj{agtn} kgd dgj
D
K&
ifl{annddgfiim
an fiknr gflgrgifr coifj
R~mr{g{~{n Bl
R~mr{g{~{n Blr{g{~{n id Bioc{gbcllw {ck gr nlnb{nk, f
f~omn} id k& [an BAigf{r c fiknjami}r& [agrrog{{nk bi}} r bi~lk gou} {no&K~}gfj {an ubl~r{n} anck
fgfj i~{ id nl mn lir{& G{‗bnrr, cll fiknnk~ln nqbnu{nbngtnr kc{cnk~ln nqug}nrn rli{ di} Bni~{, gd RF }
zcg{r di} {an u}imlnor}njc{gif cfkzcw, {an [K
w }nlgcmln cn}nfbn id i~}n 2&
gj~}n 2& c' [go
Gf{n}/onkg~o
Gf {an u}ibnrw fiknr gf {arn fiknr Gf{bgnf{lw }nk~bnr fi{ higfgfgi~r nfn}jw r
Rn{~u
Ug !{ ' CKT HIGF
Rn{~u
{an bl~r{n}& [kc{c onrrcjn
r{n} Anck F
l~r{n} Anck& Zanf B
nr itn} {aniknr rnfk g{rngjami}r gfbiouc}nr {cr c r~mr{g{~r{}c{njw j~
b{lw ntnf gd tn {an }nlgcmg
ibnrr id kc{cgr gf cfw ~n}jw, cll {anzaw zn nl
r zg{agf {an b F& RF nnurfk u}ibnnkr, kgddn}nf{ zg
{i {}cfrog{bngtnr ]BT
n fnq{ uacrn0g{a BA, ri R
{}cfrog{ {anOC rbank~lnfk dlnqgmln
OCB u}i{i
lgfn id LNCBA
Fikn !GF'
r id kc{c {}cfknlgtn}w uc{
n}/onkgc Fi{an gkln lgr{n{an kc{c {}
ctgfj&
D}con
]i~fk
[KOC
)RFRF
agr nfr~}nr {r&
kn !RF'
ikn !RF' grbcf‗{ zi}
i}`r id BA&gfdi}oc{gif iHIGF onrrcnrn uc}con{
{n zai acrc}cf{nnr {anan bl~r{n} an
glg{w cfk dc~l{
{}cfrogrrgifjnf{ rg{~c{girnfrnk kc{cb{ c r~mr{g{~
l~r{n} bioulwczc`nf k~}gfc{c cr {an Ba LNCBA, {ac ]BTYR^R^B, g{ nouI{an}zgrn g
F {c`nr itn} jj}njc{nk kcfnnkf‗{ mn cldc~l{ {iln}cf
bil zg{a LNC
m' [gon lgfn id
rogrrgif d}ia fnnk {i mnnr !GFr'& Mfgfj cfk itnfrogrrgif, r
R{nckw¥r{c{n
․
R{nckw¥r{c{n
ac{ {an}n c}n
kndgfnk crfi}ocllw,
Cd{n} {an bl~d }nrgk~cl nfnn {i {an bl~n}r cfk dgfi}n nfn}jwkc{c bi~lk
ck gr nqac~r{{iln}cfbn id
zg{agf bl~r{n} , n&j&, r~kkng{agf {an bl~
{n fikn& Gf {zg{a {an [Kj cll {an u}ib
kinr& Cd{n} n}n gr c runbg
{i RF& Gf {{gnr {an ono
oncfr {an}n{an zi}` id kc {i {an MR&n}nk c{ cll& G{‗{ rbanon&BA gr raizf
u}iuirnk u}i{ib
BA)RF {iczc`nf& Zn
{agr zcw,anc}gfj id i{{ac{ {i cbag
[}cfrog{
]BT―R^B [}cfr
fi
{anRF{n} jw{n} llwfk mnnk&{an
, gd lw
{n} agrC
rr&{angdgbagr}wgr
c{cMwr cangf
i
R,cllznan} tn
g
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 324
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 152/223
g
Dgj~}n ;& O
Mndi}n {}cacrn mndi}na`nnu czc`nfiknr ji {i rCB u}i{ibi
N& I{an} Fi
[an }nocggf bac}jn id kc{c {}cfrogrr
GT& [A
[agr u}i{irnr c awm}gk
RF gr kgrulbc{nji}gnr id
Dgj~}n
d&Uacrn if
[agr uacrnrrcjn& Aiu
nm}ickbcr{r gnrrcjn gr o
knbgknr zan{ai{cl nfn}jw
FNQ[F
F
BA
GF3
GF`
MF
Fikn
33
1
3;
CB u}i{ibil di}
frog{{gfj kc{cfk& Cd{n} {aggf {an dillilnnu ~f{gl {anl di} GF cfk i
nr
fnk fiknr c}ni}`r r~ba c
gif !zg{agf bl
U]IUIRNK ]
bil ocgflw biOCB u}i{ib
lcwnk gf dgj~} nfri} fiknr&
>& Fikn Blcrrg
n8 M}ickbcr{g
n r{c}{r d}io mw aiu, fik{ ifbn& [an r}`nk cr {an un} g{ gr c M}cffk {i{cl f~o
NQ[F
FNQ
]i~{n¥kgrbi
3
;
7
}i~{n kgrbitn}w c
, BA un}di} uacrn, GFrgfj {}cfrogrkc{c {}cfrogan} fiknr gr r
fi}ocl fiknkc{c rnfrgfjr{n}'&
I^[GFJ CFK
frgr{r id {a}nnl di} kgddn}nf
n >, zan}n
dgbc{gifgf u}iuir
fj
{an MR m}i}nbngtnr m}i
fkgfj fikn i}nf{& Cd{n} {agba Fikn, r{i}
mn} id fiknr
[F
R^B
R^B
R^
Czc`n
tn}w
․․
MR
=
4
35
32
34
fk kc{c {}cfrogrr
r c }i~{n kgrc}` {anornltgif, zan}ncrrgif gr itn}&aizf cr dgj~}
& Fi}ocl fik, bl~r{n} di}o
CB U]I[IB
uacrn& I~} r{ uacrnr& [an
n bcf rnn kg
nk onbafgro
kbcr{gfj c } ckbcr{ onrrcd g{r dg}r{lw }nr uacrn, ntn} nr {an uc}condi} {an fnq{
B
R^BKc{c
Rlnnu
Czc`n
Czc`n
Czc`n
Kc{c¥[}cfrogrrgif
/ MF
2
>
:
3=
/ BA
/ RF
/ GF
gif
itn}wr cfki{an} [an
n ;&
nr c}nc{gif,
IL
anonnf{g}n
dn}nf{
s~nr{n cfkngtnkfikn
n}r id acrn,
cfko~ckbi[a
bif
C&
cmknb
m}iOg{
mcb u}igfd
{}crccfk
M&
u}i{an{}c
zg{d}idgj{}c
knlg mn{rc
i~}
clj mi{
}nbi}kr {anl{guln uc{ar gfcf{cjn id o~fgbc{gif&{cmln id fngj
[CMLN G
Gf {agr uacrn,
{}il {an billgrg
Uacrn [zi8
Cd{n} u}ntgi~~{ {an {i{cl ngknr zan{an} Ifbn {an fickbcr{r cf ckB u}i{ibil&nlifjr, g{ {}c` {i {an ba{ibil& Gf H}oc{gif id }n[an bl~r{n}
rog{r {agr rbn {gon, cbbifngjami} f~
Uacrn [a}nn8
[agr uacrn ucjc{gif zg{a
bl~r{n} ancrogrrgif cliGf {an kc{c {a {an [KO
BA {i MR}n ;& Iflw Brogrrgif&
Gf {an ucungtn}w rbanonznnf agn}c}bn {gon, zn b[an}n c}n riu}iuirnk u}iDg}r{lw, zni}g{ao zg{aa nfn}jw nddgb
fngjami}aiikdi}oc{gif {i{an m}ickbccba fikn }n
ami} gfdi}oc{
& [CMLN I
{an fn{zi}`
gif&
l~r{n} Di}o
r uacrn, ntn} fn}jw N {i cfki mn c bl~r{n}
kn acr nlnb{nn}{grnonf{ od{n} ncba fik
frog{r c higfrnf bl~r{n} GF/]NS onrgk~cl nfn}jwnck fikn rn
ank~ln {i {a}kgfj {i {an mn}, BA rnln
Kc{c [}cfro
cgflw bifrgrgf c bl~r{n}, {k {i {anj o~l{g/uc{ar}cfrogrrgif
OCB u}i{, fiknr ~rnAr, GFr, MFr
T& BI
, zn u}iuirdi} ZRFr, zgbcl }i~{gfjfrgkn} {an On i}gjgfcl cf
{ibil8gf{nj}c{nk~l{g/uc{a }i
gnfbw cfk }nlg
gfdi}oc{gif,an MR& [agr
r{ fc{~}n i}ickbcr{r ifbgif gr cr raiz
FNGJAMI] GFDI
~rnr BROC
{gif
fikn acr jir~o id fik
anck gf c kgr{k g{rnld {i mnnrrcjn !CKTn acr knbgknk/}ns~nr{ onranck ~rgfjrrcjn, g{ clrcfk fngjami} r ~u c [KO
fiknr gf {ac}con{n}r id
b{r c fikn cr
grrgif
r id {zi r{nanf {an kc{c uR, zagba g&g{agf bl~r{n}
bil& K~}gfj{an OCB u} `nnu czc`n
BL^RGIFR
nk c bl~r{n}/agba gf{nj}c{ncfk o~l{guc{aB u}i{ibil d
k u}ij}nrrgtn
{an agn}c}b{gfj u}i{ibi
cmglg{w&
zagba u}itgnbacfgro {c
d {an zg}nln cfk iflw iff gf [cmln 3&
OC[GIF
CB u}i{ibil
{an gfdi}oc{gr F & Ncba fgm~{nk ocffbl~r{n} anck
' ~rgfj c BR{i zagba bl~cjn !Higf/]N
BROC Oi gfbl~knrf~omn}&C rbank~ln
n bl~r{n}& Gf}nrgk~cl nfnRF&
r8 dg}r{ {an k}iucjc{gif d}
r c o~l{g/a
, fiknr bioan {}cfrogrrg{ibil raizffk higf {an k
mcrnk o~l{gur {an cktcf{c
}i~{gfj& Gf} {agr rbanonbac}cb{n}gr{gb
gbcl bl~r{n}gl& [agr u}itg
nrnr
nrrbn&
l {i
gifkn}&g{C
{n} S'B
{an
fk
{anjw
c{cio ur
lwgifgf
c{c
c{anr
{an&gf
gfjnr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 32:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 153/223
Rnbifklw, zn blcrrgdw fiknr gf{i dgtn {wunr cbbi}kgfj {i{ang} }iln gf ZRF& [agr r{}c{njw j~c}cf{nnr oi}n dcg}fnrr gffikn nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif cfk u}ilifjr {an fn{zi}` lgdn{gon&
[ag}klw, mi{a id {an u}ibnrr id bl~r{n} di}oc{gif cfko~l{guln uc{a kgrbitn}w c}n gf kgr{}gm~{nk ocffn}, g{j~c}cf{nnr {an rbclcmglg{w id {an fn{zi}`&
Di~}{alw, onbacfgro id r~mr{g{~{n Bl~r{n} Anck Fikn!RF' cbbi~f{r di} {an rg{~c{gif id BA kcocjgfj& Oi}nitn},o~l{guc{a kgrbitn}w rbanon bcf riltn {an u}imlno zanf c
uc{a gr dcgl~}n& [anrn j~c}cf{nn {an }im~r{fnrr id {an rwr{no&Dgfcllw, zn ~rn {zi uc}con{n}r id {i{cl nfn}jw cfk fikn
r~o f~omn} !iu{gocl bl~r{n} f~omn}' {i gou}itn {an un}di}ocfbn id mi{a bl~r{n} di}oc{gif cfk }i~{gfj kgrbitn}w&Gf i~} rbanon, {anrn {zi uc}con{n}r c}n ~ukc{nk cd{n} ntn}w}i~fk cfk bclb~lc{nk mw {an MR& G{‗r cf nddgbgnf{ zcw {ibif{}il {an fn{zi}` s~clg{w&
^f{gl fiz, {agr zi}` gr r{gll gf {ani}n{gb r{cjn, ri i~} d~{~}n zi}`r gfbl~kn biouc}n {agr u}iuirnk onbacfgro zg{arntn}cl nqgr{gfj zi}`r, gf crunb{r id nfn}jw bifr~ou{gif,kc{c }nlgcmglg{w, fn{zi}` lgdn{gon, lc{nfbw, n{b&
TG&] NDN]NFBNR
P3_ Z& Angfxnlocf, C& Bacfk}c`crcf, cfk A& Mclc`}grafcf, “CfCuulgbc{gif/Runbgdgb U}i{ibil C}bag{nb{~}n di} Zg}nlnrr Ogb}irnfri}
Fn{zi}`r,‟ GNNN [}cfr& Zg}nlnrr Bioo&, til& 3, fi& ;, uu& 445/ 4:5,Ib{& =55=&
P=_ I& Wi~fgr cfk R& Dcaow, “ANNK8 C Awm}gk, Nfn}jw/Nddgbgnf{,Kgr{}gm~{nk Bl~r{n}gfj Cuu}icba di} Ck Aib Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r,‟GNNN [}cfrb{gif if Oimgln Biou~{gfj, til&2, fi&;, uu& 244/2:7,Ib{imi} =55;&
P2_ R& Mcfkwiuckawcw cfk N& Biwln, “Cf Nfn}jw/Nddgbgnf{ Agn}c}bagbclBl~r{n}gfj Clji}g{ao di} Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& GNNNGFDIBIO, Cu}& =552&
P;_ O Ona}cfg, H& Racfmnaxckna, C& Rc}}cdxckna, R& H& Og}cmnkgfg, cfk B&Ocfdi}k, “DNNK8 Dc~l{ [iln}cf{, Nfn}jw Nddgbgnf{, Kgr{}gm~{nkBl~r{n}gfj di} ZRF,‟ U}ib& GBCB[=535, Dnm, =535&
P>_ K& Jcfnrcf, ]& Jitgfkcf, R& Ranf`n}, cfk K& Nr{}gf& -Agjalw/}nrglgnf{, nfn}jw/nddgbgnf{ o~l{guc{a }i~{gfj gf zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r,‟ RGJOIMGLN Oim& Biou~{& Bioo~f& ]nt&, >!;'833‒=>,=553&
P4_ Z& Li~ cfk W& @zif& “A/RU]NCK8 c Awm}gk O~l{guc{a Rbanon di} Rnb~}n cfk ]nlgcmln Kc{c Billnb{gif gfZg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r,‟GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr if Tnagb~lc} [nbafilijw, >!;'832=5‒3225, =554&
P:_ B& Gf{cfcjifzgzc{, ]& Jitgfkcf, cfk K& Nr{}gf, “Kg}nb{nk Kgdd~rgif8C Rbclcmln cfk ]im~r{ Bioo~fgbc{gif Uc}ckgjo di} Rnfri}
Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& CBO)GNNN Gf{‗l Bifd& Oimgln Biou~{gfj cfk
Fn{zi}`gfj !OIMGBIO', =555&P1_ C& I~ckhci~{, W& Bacllcl, F& Lcrlc, O& Mcjcc, “RNGD8 rnb~}n cfk
nddgbgnf{ gf{}~rgif/dc~l{ {iln}cf{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r,‟ gf8 U}ibnnkgfjr id {an [ag}k Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn ifCtcglcmglg{w, ]nlgcmglg{w cfk Rnb~}g{w !C]NR' =551, Oc}ba ;‒:, =551,
uu& >52‒>51&
P7_ W& Hgfj, Q& Ocg, H& D& Q~, M& J& Q~, cfk A& L~, “ C bl~r{n}/mcrnko~l{guc{a knlgtn}w rbanon di} zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r,‟ GB/MFO[*57, Mnghgfj, uu& =14 ‒ =73, Ib{, =557&
P35_ O& R& Xcocf, cfk J& OcocO~}{aw, “Bl~r{n}nk cfk lntnlnk kgrhigf{o~l{guc{a }i~{gfj clji}g{ao di} zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r,‟ CA/GBG=557, @c{aocfk~, Fit, =557&
P33_ [&tcf Kco cfk @& Lcfjnfkinf, “Cf ckcu{gtn nfn}jw/nddgbgnf{ ocb u}i{ibil di} zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r,‟ gf CBO Rnfrwr ‗52 , =552, uu&3:3/315&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 321
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 154/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;55>)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;55>
C Kc{c Ogfgfj Cuu}icba di} Oimglg{w U}nkgb{gif ^rgfj Zg}nlnrr [}cbnr
H&Cfcf{ag, ]&Onfc`c]nrnc}ba rbailc}r, Knuc}{onf{ id NBN
Cffc ^fgtn}rg{w id [nbafilijw
Banffcg, Gfkgc
K}&T&]cfjcfc{acfU}id&, Knuc}{onf{ id TLRG
@BJ Billnjn id [nbafilijw
Banffcg, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛Zg{a tc}gi~r zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gif u}i{ibilr
non}jgfj di} ~mgs~g{i~r bioo~fgbc{gif, oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif
nfcmlnr mn{{n} ocfcjnonf{ cfk nddgbgnf{ ~rcjn id }nri~}bnr {i
u}itgkn gou}itnk rn}tgbnr {i oimgln ~rn}r& Cr oir{ ~rn}r c}n
oimgln gf {an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`, g{ gr fnbnrrc}w {i gfbl~kn
oimglg{w cr cf gfan}nf{ uc}{ id {an rwr{no& [an ~rn}‗r oimglg{w
gfdl~nfbnr {an fn{zi}` un}di}ocfbn cfk {an ~fkn}lwgfj
s~clg{w id rn}tgbn& Tc}gi~r r{~kgnr actn mnnf bifk~b{nk ~fkn}kgddn}nf{ rbnfc}gir {i gou}itn un}di}ocfbn id {an zg}nlnrr
fn{zi}` ~fkn} tc}gi~r oimglg{w oiknlr& Gf {agr ucun} g{ gr
u}iuirnk {i cuulw kc{c ogfgfj {nbafgs~nr {i u}nkgb{ {an ~rn}
mcrnk if zg}nlnrr {}cbnr&
@nwzi}kr/Oimglg{w U}nkgb{gif, Gfr{cfbn Mcrnk Lnc}fn}!GML', Cl{n}fc{gfj knbgrgif {}nn, Fcétn Mcwnr&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Zg{a {an k}cr{gb gfb}ncrn gf oimgln zg}nlnrr ~rn}r, fn{zi}`r
dcbn mcfkzgk{a cfk }nri~}bn rai}{cjnr zagba ocw bc~rn
fn{zi}` dcgl~}n P3_& [i u}itgkn j~c}cf{nnk cfk SiR {i
~rn}r, u}icb{gtn on{aikr c}n cb{gtnlw r{~kgnk& Cr oir{ ~rn}r
c}n oimgln, g{ gr fnbnrrc}w {i gfbl~kn oimglg{w cr cf gfan}nf{uc}{ id {an rwr{no P=_& Oimglg{w ocfcjnonf{ acfklnr {an
on{aikr id r{i}gfj cfk ~ukc{gfj {an libc{gif gfdi}oc{gif id
oimgln ~rn}r& Oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif gr clri uc}{ id oimglg{w
ocfcjnonf{ cr oimglg{w id {an ~rn} ulcwr cf goui}{cf{ }iln
gf nddgbgnf{ ~rcjn id }nri~}bnr& Oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif ocw mn
kndgfnk cr kn{n}ogfgfj {an fnq{ cbbnrr uigf{ !CU' {ac{ c ~rn}
zgll biffnb{ {i gf c fn{zi}`& [an oimglg{w gr jnfn}cllw
r{~kgnk mw knrgjfgfj oc{anoc{gbcl oiknlr {ac{ oiknl
a~ocf oimglg{w P2_&
[gonlw acfkiddr rai~lk mn rncolnrr di} ~fgf{n}}~u{nk cb{gtn
rnrrgifr lg`n dgln {}cfrdn}r, tigbn itn} bcllr, tgkni)c~kgi
r{}ncogfj, n{b& Zanf c ~rn} gr oimgln, {an biffnb{gif grbifr{cf{lw mngfj rzg{bank d}io ifn CU {i cfi{an}& [a~r
rncolnrr acfkiddr c}n uirrgmln iflw gd }nri~}bnr c}n
ctcglcmln c{ {an fnq{ CU& Cllibc{gfj }nri~}bnr {i cll
fngjami}gfj CUr gr fi{ dncrgmln cr g{ lnckr {i zcr{cjn id
}nri~}bnr cfk ~fkn} ~{glgxc{gif id {an fn{zi}`& Nddgbgnf{
cllibc{gifr id }nri~}bnr gou}itn }nri~}bn ~{glgxc{gif cfk
}nk~bn lc{nfbw gf cbbnrrgfj {an }nri~}bnr& U}gi} `fizlnkjn
cmi~{ {an oitnonf{r id ~rn}r gr anlud~l cr oimglg{w
u}nkgb{gif gr mcrnk if ucr{ oitnonf{r& [an oimglg{w
u}nkgb{gif goucb{r acfkitn}r cfk, anfbn, gou}itnr {an
fn{zi}` SiR& [an}n c}n rntn}cl u}imlnor cfk grr~nr
gftiltnk gf oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif gf c }ncl nftg}ifonf{& [an
oimglg{w uc{{n}f tc}gnr zg{a kgddn}nf{ uiu~lc{gif0 {an
oimglg{w uc{{n}f id c bg{w ~rn} gr kgddn}nf{ d}io {ac{ id ~rn}
gf cf nk~bc{gifcl bcou~r& ^rn} oimglg{w {}cbnr c}n ~rnk di}oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif oiknlgfj&
[an oitnonf{ agr{i}w id {an ~rn} bcf mn nq{}cb{nk d}io {an
lijr im{cgfnk d}io cll {an cbbnrr uigf{r& Zanf c oimgln
kntgbn c{{cbanr g{rnld {i cf CU, {an ~fgs~n f~omn} id {an
oimgln kntgbn gr nf{n}nk gf{i {an lijr zg{a c {gon r{cou&
^rgfj {an lijr im{cgfnk d}io cll {an CUr, {an d}ns~nf{lw
~rnk uc{a mw c uc}{gb~lc} zg}nlnrr kntgbn bcf mn {}cbnk cfk
{agr gr bcllnk {an ~rn} oimglg{w uc{{n}f !^OU' P;_& Oimglg{w
}~lnr c}n di}onk ~rgfj {an ^OUr& [an ~rn}‗r cb{~cl
oitnonf{ gr im{cgfnk,
3 =, ,&&&&,g f~ cu cu cu
zan}ng
cu gr {an CU cbbnrrnk mw {an ~rn} gf {an oitnonf{
uc{a id f cbbnrr uigf{r gf {an kndgfnk {gon& [an oimglg{w
}~lnr c}n gf {an di}o id
3 =
3 = 2 ;, ,
l l
l l l l
3 = 2, ,&&&&,fl l l l
{an lnd{ uc}{ id {an oimglg{w }~ln gr bcllnk anck id }~ln cfk
{an i{an} gr bcllnk {cgl id {an }~ln& Zanf }~lnr c}n jnfn}c{nk,
c bifdgknfbn tcl~n gr bclb~lc{nk di} ncba }~ln& [an }~ln zg{a
{an agjanr{ bifdgknfbn gr rnlnb{nk&
Gf {agr ucun} g{ gr u}iuirnk {i ~rn kc{c ogfgfj clji}g{aor di}
u}nkgb{gfj ~rn} oimglg{w ~rgfj zg}nlnrr {}cbn ctcglcmln d}io{an Kc}{oi~{a Billnjn&
GG& LG[N]C[^]N ]NTGNZ
Bifrgkn}cmln coi~f{ id }nrnc}ba if oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif gr
gf lg{n}c{~}n& Rion id {an }nlc{nk zi}`r c}n kgrb~rrnk gf {agr
rnb{gif&
U}crck, n{ cl&, P>_ u}iuirnk c jnfn}gb d}conzi}` di} oimglg{w
u}nkgb{gif id ~rn} oitnonf{ gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r& [an
u}goc}w jicl id {an u}iuirnk oiknl zcr nddnb{gtn cllibc{gif
id {an }nri~}bnr& [an d}conzi}` bifrgr{r id c u}nkgb{gif
oiknl mcrnk if Agkknf Oc}`it Oiknl !AOO' {i u}nkgb{
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 327
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 155/223
~rn}‗r fnq{ libc{gif cfk c u}nkgb{gtn oimglg{w ocfcjnonf{
mcrnk if c bif{}il {ani}n{gb cuu}icba zg{a c dnnkmcb`
bif{}il rwr{no& Bcou~r zg}nlnrr {}cbn kc{crn{ ctcglcmln
iflgfn zcr ~rnk di} {nr{gfj {an oiknl& [an kc{crn{ u}itgknkoimglg{w agr{i}w id {an ~rn} r~ba cr ~rn} crribgc{gifr zg{a
CUr, k~}c{gif id crribgc{gif cfk ri if& If rgo~lc{gif {an
nddnb{gtnfnrr id {an u}nkgb{gif oiknl cfk {an bif{}illn} zcr
u}itnf& [an u}iuirnk d}conzi}` bcf mn gfbi}ui}c{nk gf{i
nqgr{gfj zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r&
C`i~ra, n{ cl&, P4_ u}iuirnk c awm}gk Mcwnrgcf fn~}cl
fn{zi}` oiknl di} u}nkgb{gfj libc{gif& [an oiknl ~rnk
u}imcmglg{w {ani}w zg{a fn~}cl fn{zi}`r di} oitnonf{
u}nkgb{gif id {an ~rn} cfk {i m~glk c gfdn}nfbn oiknl& [an
kc{crn{ bif{cgfnk 355 Fi`gc roc}{ uaifn ~rn}r zcr
billnb{nk d}io ]nclg{w Ogfgfj U}ihnb{ c{ OG[ zcr ~rnk&
[}ckn idd cfclwrgr zcr un}di}onk di} libc{gif ~ukc{n cfk
ucjgfj di} {an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`& [i nfacfbn u}nkgb{gif
cbb~}cbw bnllr {ac{ {an ~rn}r ki fi{ ~rn zn}n j}i~unk&
]nr~l{r raiznk {ac{ {an u}nkgb{gif cbb~}cbw id {an u}iuirnk
oiknl i~{un}di}or cll i{an} r{cfkc}k fn~}cl fn{zi}`
on{aikr&
@go, n{ cl&, P:_ u}iuirnk c oimglg{w on{aik, bifr{}~b{nk
~rgfj zg}nlnrr ~rn} {}cbnr& [an u}iuirnk on{aik nq{}cb{r
~rn}‗r oimglg{w {}cb`r cfk im{cgfnk gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{
oitnonf{ runnk, uc~rn {gonr, zcwuigf{r mn{znnf
knr{gfc{gifr cfk knr{gfc{gif {}cfrg{gif u}imcmglg{w& [agr
gfdi}oc{gif zcr ~rnk {i jnfn}c{n rwf{an{gb {}cb`r cfk {an
rcon zcr tclgkc{nk mw biouc}gfj zg{a {an }ncl {}cb`r&
Nqun}gonf{r zn}n bifk~b{nk ~rgfj {}cbnr id zg}nlnrr ~rn}r
d}io Kc}{oi~{a Billnjn& ]nr~l{r raiznk {ac{ {an rwf{an{gb
{}cb`r u}ik~bnk zn}n rgoglc} {i {an }ncl {}cb`&R~, n{ cl&, P1_ u}nrnf{nk c oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif on{aik {i
nfacfbn ~fgbcr{ cfk o~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr& Gf {an
u}iuirnk on{aik, JUR uirg{gif zcr ugjjwmcb`nk if kc{c
ucb`n{r k~}gfj bioo~fgbc{gif mn{znnf {zi fiknr cfk {an
nqug}c{gif {gon id {an lgf` zcr nr{goc{nk& [an }i~{nr zn}n
}nbifdgj~}nk mndi}n {an lgf` zcr m}i`nf {a~r u}itgkgfj
rncolnrr biffnb{gif mndi}n biffnb{gif m}nc`r& [an
rgo~lc{gif zcr goulnonf{nk zg{agf JliOiRgo lgm}c}w&
Rgo~lc{gif }nr~l{r gfkgbc{nk {ac{ {an }i~{nr r{cwnk biffnb{nk
{an lifjnr{ zn}n bairnf mw {an ~rn id oimglg{w u}nkgb{gif&
GGG& ON[AIKILIJW
Kc}{oi~{a Billnjn u}itgknr oimglg{w {}cbnr cr c bioo~fg{w
rn}tgbn {i }nrnc}ban}r& Oimglg{w {}cbn billnb{nk itn} c un}gik
id {a}nn wnc}r zg{agf {an Kc}{oi~{a Billnjn bcou~r gr
ctcglcmln, aizntn} zn ~rnk ifn oif{a rwrlij kc{c gf {agr
zi}`& K~}gfj {an kc{c billnb{gif un}gik {an billnjn ai~rnk
itn} >>55 r{~knf{r cfk 3=55 dcb~l{w& Gfg{gcllw ;:4 cbbnrr
uigf{r zn}n ctcglcmln cfk itn} {an un}gik id {gon {agr
gfb}ncrnk {i >44& Cll cbbnrr uigf{r zn}n u}ij}coonk {i
rac}n {an rcon RRGK cfk anfbn oimgln ~rn}r zn}n cmln {i
rncolnrrlw ~rn {an fn{zi}` cb}irr {an bcou~r&33> r~mfn{r
bitn}nk {an 311 m~glkgfjr cfk anfbn kntgbnr zn}n di}bnk {i
im{cgf fnz GU ckk}nrrnr rion {gonr& [an lij }nbi}knk gf c
rwrlij rn}tn} gfbl~knk {an {gonr{cou {i ncba onrrcjn zg{a
ncba onrrcjn bif{cgfgfj {an CU fcon, OCB ckk}nrr id {an
bc}k cfk {an {wun id onrrcjn& [an tc}gi~r onrrcjnr ~rnk
c}n c~{anf{gbc{nk, crribgc{nk, }ncrribgc{nk, }iconk cfkkgrcrribgc{nk& Zanfntn} c kntgbn baiirnr {i ~rn {an
fn{zi}` g{ gr dg}r{ c~{anf{gbc{nk cfk {agr onrrcjn gr gjfi}nk
gf {agr zi}`& Cd{n} c~{anf{gbc{gif, {an kntgbn o~r{ crribgc{n
zg{a ifn id {an cbbnrr uigf{r nfcmlgfj cll {}cddgb mn{znnf
kntgbn cfk fn{zi}`& ]ncrribgc{gif ibb~}r zanf cfi{an} CU
zg{a mn{{n} rgjfcl r{}nfj{a gr ctcglcmln& [an {}cbn id c rgfjln
kcw d}io ~rn}r gf {an Kc}{oi~{a Billnjn gr ~rnk gf {agr
zi}`& G{ gr u}iuirnk {i bifrgkn} di~} c{{}gm~{nr zg{a {a}nn
c{{}gm~{nr jgtgfj {an u}ntgi~r libc{gif id {an ~rn} cfk {an
di~}{a c{{}gm~{n bifrgkn}gfj {an {gon&
[an Fcétn Mcwnr blcrrgdgn} gr c r{c{gr{gbcl on{aik
id blcrrgdgbc{gif ~rgfj r~un}tgrnk lnc}fgfj on{aikr& G{ gr
mcrnk if Mcwnr {ani}no& [an blcrrgdgn} bcf riltn mi{a
kgcjfir{gb cfk u}nkgb{gtn u}imlnor gftiltgfj mi{a
bc{nji}gbcl cfk bif{gf~i~r tcl~nk c{{}gm~{nr& [an Mcwnr
{ani}no gr cr dillizr8
&U M C U CU C M
U M
zan}n U C M gr uir{n}gi} u}imcmglg{w id C, U C gr u}gi}
u}imcmglg{w id C, U gr uir{n}gi} u}imcmglg{w id M cfk
U M gr u}gi} u}imcmglg{w id M&
Di} c rn{ id {~ulnr K, zg{a ‑f‗ kgonfrgifcl c{{}gm~{n tnb{i}0
3 =8 , ,&&&, f Q q q q zan}n g q gr {an tcl~n id c{{}gm~{n g C &
[an}n c}n o blcrrnr8 3 =, ,&&&&, oB B B & Mcwnrgcf blcrrgdgn}
u}nkgb{r Q mnlifjr {i c blcrr gd
g hU B Q U B Q di} 3 , h o h g
G{ mnbionr biou~{c{gifcllw kgddgb~l{ {i ntcl~c{n gU Q B gd
f~omn} id c{{}gm~{nr gr agja& Gf r~ba c bcrn Fcétn blcrr
bifkg{gifcl gfknunfknfbn gr ~rnk di} biou~{c{gif&
3
f
` g
`
U q B
Fcétn Mcwnr {ai~ja itn} rgoulgdgnk, g{ un}di}or znll gfocfw bioulnq rg{~c{gifr& Zanf {an kgonfrgifclg{w id {an
kc{c gfu~{ gr agja Fcétn Mcwnr c}n tn}w nddnb{gtn& [an
uc}con{n}r c}n nr{goc{nk zg{a tn}w rocll coi~f{ id {}cgfgfj
kc{c&
Cl{n}fc{gfj Knbgrgif [}nnr !CK[' gr jnfn}clgxc{gif
id knbgrgif {}nnr, ti{nk knbgrgif {}nn cfk knbgrgif r{~our
zg{a miir{gfj P7_& [an blcrrgdgn}r jnfn}c{nk mw CK[ c}n
ncrw {i knk~bn cfk g{ u}itgknr c oncr~}n id bifdgknfbn
bcllnk blcrrgdgbc{gif oc}jgf& Gf CK[ {an }ii{ fikn gr c
u}nkgb{gif fikn cfk bifrgr{r id c f~on}gb rbi}n& [an
u}nkgb{gif fiknr c}n dilliznk mw knbgrgif fiknr zagba c}n
rgoglc} {i knbgrgif {}nn r{~our& [an knbgrgif lcwn} gr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 156/223
l
l
g
dilliznk mw
}nkgb{gif fi
}nkgb{gif lcw
Dgj
Gf cf CK[ {a
{an uc{a }ncb
~{ if }ncbag
{an baglk}nf i
}izr& [an }~
{an }~lnr {i
{an CK[ gr ag
f {an u}nkgb{
Gfr{cfbn/m
iouc}nr fn
{}cgfgfj, gfr{n
nc}fr d}io n
g}nb{lw d}io
crnk lnc}fgf
nc}fgfj ibb~
c fnz s~n}w
gfr{cfbnr gr }
nz s~n}w
clji}g{aor gr
gr{cfbn oncrFiogfcl c{{}g
Gf {agr ucun}
lcrr c{{}gm~{n
{an Fcétn M
lcrrgdgbc{gif
m{cgfnk cfk
m{cgfnk }nr~l
Clji}g{ao
Fcétn Mcwnr
H;1
GML
u}nkgb{gif l
knr cfk knbg
n} cfk knbgrgi
38 C rgouln c
n gfr{cfbnr k
nr c knbgrgif
j c u}nkgb{i}
d {an fikn& [
lnr jnfn}c{n }
c`n }ncl tcl~
gjan} cr knbgr
gif&
rnk lnc}fgf
u}imlno g
ck id un}di}
coulnr i} gfr
{an {}cgfgfj
gr c `gfk id
}r mw rgoulw
gfr{cfbn gr u
{}gntnk d}io
gfr{cfbn& C
{an fnc}nr{
~}nr c}n ~rnk~{nr c}n acfk
GT& 25> }nbi}kr
r& C {nfdilk b
cwnr, H;1, G
cbb~}cbw cf
biouc}nk& [
{r&
Blcrrgdg
cbb~
:=&;
:=&;>
41&>=
cwn}, {a~r c
gif fiknr& c
f lcwn} gr rai
l{n}fc{gfj knb
dgfn {an uc{a
fikn g{ bif{g
fikn {an uc{
n mcrn }~lnr g
ncl f~omn}r0
nk u}nkgb{gif
gif fiknr ac
i} onoi
r{cfbnr zg{a
gfj nqulgbg{
{cfbnr cfk bi
gfr{cfbnr {a
lcxw lnc}fgfj
r{i}gfj {an u}
nrnf{nk, c rn
onoi}w cfk
f nqcouln
fngjami} cl
{i acfkln {anlnk ~rgfj itn
]NR^L[
n}n ~rnk zg{
}irr tclgkc{gi
ML clji}g{a
k }nlc{gtn c
cmln 3 cfk
bc{gif
cbw
7.
7 .
4 .
l{n}fc{gfj mn
rgouln CK[
zf gf dgj~}n 3
grgif {}nn
r gf {an {}nn&
f~nr zg{a {an
bif{gf~nr z
fb}ncrnr cr {a
{an miir{gfj
& [an }im~r{f
n lgog{nk gfdl
}w/mcrnk ln
gfr{cfbnr rn
jnfn}clgxc{gif
fr{}~b{r awui
ornltnr& Gfr
& Gf GML clji
rnf{nk kc{c&
{ id rgoglc} }
~rnk {i blcrrg
id gfr{cfbn/
i}g{ao& N~bl
f~on}gb c{{}g}lcur&
; c{{}gm~{nr
f zcr ~rnk {
r& [an }nr~
ril~{n n}}i}
gj~}n = rai
]nlc{gtn
mril~{n n}}i}
>4&;77:.
;4&7557 .
;:&3;12 .
{znnf
zg{a
P7_&
Zanf
baglk
g{a cll
n {}nn
llizr
nrr id
~nfbn
}fgfj
nf gf
& GML
{anrnr
{cfbn/
g{aor
Zanf
nlc{nk
dw {an
mcrnk
gkncf
m~{nr&
cfk 3
{}cgf
l{ di}
zn}n
r {an
Dgj
[CMLN 38 BL
=8 Blcrrgdgbc{
Gf {agr ucun
cbb~}cbw cf
H;1, GML cl
{}cbnr d}io
i~{un}di}or
}nrnc}ba fnn
oimglg{w u}n
tnb{i} ocba
P3_ U& R& U}cid oimgl
4 {a
GNN
Bifdn}n
P=_ K& Un}`g{an un
Gf{n}fc{g
til& ;, u
P2_ O& Ji“^fkn}r{
Fc{~}n,P;_ Jiacf W
Ocfiliuu}nkgb{gi
Nfjgfnn}P>_ U}c{cu
D}conz^{glgxc{g
P4_ Ran}gd OitnonFn~}cl F
P:_ Ogf`wif
c oimglgGNNN Gf
P1_ Z& R~,zg}nlnrr
5&55.
35&55.
=5&55.
25&55.
;5&55.
>5&55.
45&55.
:5&55.
15&55.
F
Mc
RRGDGBC[GIFCMRIL^
gif }c{n&
T& BI
g{ zcr u}iui
k }nlc{gtn cm
i}g{aor di}
Kc}{oi~{a B
{an Fcétn
k {i mn bc}}g
kgb{gif ~rgfj
gfn cfk Fn~}
]NDN]
rck, U& Cj}czcg{w gf agn}c}bag
Bifr~on}
bn, Hcf~c}w =5
r, A& A~janr,di}ocfbn id
ifcl Bifdn}n
& =5;1‒=5>=,
fxlnx, B&cfkgfj gfkgtg
i& ;>2, uu& ;:ctcr, Kgog{}gi
i~lir, “C kc{f gf oimgln nf
gfj >; !=55>' 3U}crck cfk
}` di} Oimgf gf Zg}nlnrr
`i~ra, Caonf{ U}nkgb{gifn{zi}`r, GZBj @go, Kctgk
{w oiknl d}iibio =554&
R&/H& Lnn, O&fn{zi}`r, gf8 G
étn
wnr
H;1 G
BB^]CBW CFN N]]I]
FBL^RGIF
rnk {i r{~kw {
ril~{n n}}i} g
imglg{w u}nkg
llnjn& ]nr~l{
Mcwnr cl
k {i gou}itn
]ckgcl mcrgr d
l fn{zi}` clj
NFBNR
l, cfk @& O& Rggbcl oimgln ck
ioo~fgbc{gifr
7, uu& 3‒>&
cfk B& Iznf,ck aib f
bn if Bioo
55=&
gkclji, cfk~cl a~ocf
‒;1=, =551&@c{rc}ir, Ixj
c ogfgfj cuu}tg}ifonf{r‟&
=3‒3;4&U}c{agoc Cj}glg{w U}nkgb{gi
n{zi}`r‟& GNN
k Rcona, =5^rgfj McwnrgB*5:, C~j~r{,
@i{x, Rifj`~`
}ncl ~rn} {}c
& Jn}lc, OimgNN OGLBIO
ML
Blc
Cbb
]nl
cmr
K ]NLC[GTN
an blcrrgdgbc{g
f Fcétn Mcw
{gifr ~rgfj k
im{cgfnk di} H
i}g{ao& D~{
nddnb{gtnfnrr
~fb{gif, R~uu
}g{ao&
clgfjco, “Ndd aib fn{zi}`r,
cfk Fn{zi}`
“Dcb{i}r cddnb{n{zi}`r,‟ G
~fgbc{gifr !GB
C&/L& Mc}cimglg{w uc{{n}
~} l~riw, Wcf
icba di} libc{c{c $ @fizln
zcl, “C Jnfcfk ]nri~
N =535&
:& Oimgln ^gcf Lnc}fgfjucjn 373/4&@go&, “Nq{}cb{
bnr‟& U}ibnnkg
lg{w u}nkgb{gif, Ib{imn} =555&
rgdgbc{gif
~}cbw
{gtn
il~{n¥n}}i}
gif
nr,
c{c
;1
~}n
id
i}{
b{rgf
gfj
gfj NN
B',
rg,r,‟
fgr
gifjn
}gb}bn
rn}di}
gfj
fjr
gf
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 157/223
P7_ W& D}n~fk cfk L& Ocrif& [an cl{n}fc{gfj knbgrgif {}nnclji}g{ao& Gf U}ibnnkgfjr id {an 34{a Gf{n}fc{gifcl
Bifdn}nfbn if Ocbagfn Lnc}fgfj, ucjnr 3=;‒322, 3777&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 158/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;53=)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;53=
Un}di}ocfbn Cfclwrgr id ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr gf Oimgln Ckaib Fn{izi}`r
[a&Gm~fjfjiocbac RgfjaKnuc}{onf{ id Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn $ Nfjgfnn}gfj, Ocfgu~} Gfr{g{~{n id [nbafilijw
Gouacl,Ocfgu~},Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛C oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` !OCFN[' gr c
knbnf{}clgxnk, unn}/{i/unn} zg}nlnrr ck aib fn{zi}` {ac{ gr
bcucmln id bifdgj~}gfj g{rnld& Rgfbn g{ gr fi{ c r{c{gb
gfd}cr{}~b{~}n fn{zi}` {}ckg{gifcl }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr dcgl {i
biun zg{a {agr {wun id fn{zi}` {iuilijw {ac{ bacfjnr zg{a
{gon& ]nbnf{lw }nrnc}ban}r actn u}iuirnk fnz OCFN[
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr cfk biouc}gfj cfk gou}itgfj nqgr{gfj
u}i{ibilr mndi}n cfw r{cfkc}kgxc{gif u}ibnrr& Aizntn}
rgo~lc{gifr }nr~l{r d}io kgddn}nf{ }nrnc}ba bioo~fg{w c}n
fi{ bifrgr{nf{ nfi~ja {i blcgo r{cfkc}k OCFN[ }i~{gfju}i{ibilr di} c runbgdgb cuulgbc{gif& [agr gr ocgflw mnbc~rn id
{an lcb` id bifrgr{nfbw gf }i~{gfj u}i{ibil oiknlr cfk
kgddn}nf{ cuulgbc{gif nftg}ifonf{r i} rbnfc}gir gfbl~kgfj
fn{zi}`gfj cfk ~rn} u}idglnr& D~}{an}oi}n {an un}di}ocfbn
on{}gbr ~rnk gf biouc}c{gtn cfclwrnr kgddn} coifj
}nrnc}ban}r& [an}ndi}n g{ gr u}noc{~}n {i jgtn c jnfn}clgxnk
bifbl~rgif gf }njc}k {i {an un}di}ocfbn id {an nqgr{gfj
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr& Gf {agr ucun} zn u}nrnf{ biouc}c{gtn
cfclwrnr id OCFN[ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr cfk ocfw uirrgmln
un}di}ocfbn on{}gbr c}n bifrgkn}nk gf {an r{~kw& [an {cr` gr
kntnliunk ~rgfj FR= rgo~lc{gif rid{zc}n cfk }nr~l{r im{cgfnk
c}n u}nrnf{nk {i jgtn c kn{cgl cfclwrnr id kgddn}nf{ {wunr
OCFN[ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr&
@nwzi}kr/ OCFN[, ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr CIKT, KR],KRKT, X]D&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Oimgln Ck Aib Fn{zi}` !OCFN[' P3_ gr c billnb{gif
id bioo~fgbc{gif kntgbnr i} fiknr {ac{ zgra {i
bioo~fgbc{n zg{ai~{ cfw dgqnk gfd}cr{}~b{~}n cfk u}n/
kn{n}ogfnk i}jcfgxc{gif id ctcglcmln lgf`r& [an fiknr gf
OCFN[ {anornltnr c}n }nruifrgmln di} kwfcogbcllw
kgrbitn}gfj i{an} fiknr {i bioo~fgbc{n& G{ gr c rnld/
bifdgj~}gfj fn{zi}` id oimgln fiknr biffnb{nk mw
zg}nlnrr lgf`r {an ~fgif id zagba di}or cf c}mg{}c}w
{iuilijw& [an fiknr c}n d}nn {i oitn }cfkiolw cfk
i}jcfgxn {anornltnr c}mg{}c}glw0 {a~r, {an fn{zi}`‗rzg}nlnrr {iuilijw ocw bacfjn }cugklw cfk ~fu}nkgb{cmlw&
]i~{gfj gr c bi}n u}imlno gf fn{zi}`r di} rnfkgfj kc{c
d}io ifn fikn {i cfi{an}& Zg}nlnrr Ck Aib fn{zi}`r c}n
clri bcllnk Oimgln Ck Aib o~l{g/aiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r gr
c billnb{gif id zg}nlnrr oimgln air{r di}ogfj c {noui}c}w
fn{zi}` zg{ai~{ {an cgk id cfw nr{cmlgrank gfd}cr{}~b{~}n i}
bnf{}clgxnk ckogfgr{}c{gif& Oimgln Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r
!OCFN[r' c}n bac}cb{n}gxnk mw c kwfcogb, o~l{g/aiu,
}cugk bacfjgfj {iuilijw& R~ba fn{zi}`r c}n cgonk {i
u}itgkn bioo~fgbc{gif bcucmglg{gnr {i c}ncr zan}n lgog{nk
i} fi bioo~fgbc{gif gfd}cr{}~b{~}nr nqgr{& OCFN[‗r bcf
clri mn knuliwnk {i clliz {an bioo~fgbc{gif kntgbnr {i
di}o c kwfcogb cfk {noui}c}w fn{zi}` coifj {ano& C
oimgln Ck Aib fn{zi}` !OCFN[' gr }nbngtgfj c{{nf{gif
k~n {i ocfw ui{nf{gcl oglg{c}w cfk bgtglgcf cuulgbc{gifr&
OCFN[r actn rntn}cl rclgnf{ bac}cb{n}gr{gbr8 3' Kwfcogb{iuilijgnr =' Mcfkzgk{a/bifr{}cgfnk 2' Nfn}jw
bifr{}cgfnk iun}c{gif ;' lgog{nk uawrgbcl rnb~}g{w&
[an}ndi}n {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr di} zg}nk fn{zi}`r bcffi{
mn kg}nb{lw ~rnk di} zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r& Rion nqcoulnr id
{an uirrgmln ~rnr id ck aib fn{zi}`gfj gfbl~kn r{~knf{r
~rgfj lcu{iu biou~{n}r {i uc}{gbguc{n gf cf gf{n}cb{gtn
lnb{~}n, m~rgfnrr crribgc{nr rac}gfj gfdi}oc{gif k~}gfj c
onn{gfj, rilkgn}r }nlcwgfj gfdi}oc{gif di} rg{~c{gifcl
czc}nfnrr if {an mc{{lndgnlk cfk non}jnfbw kgrcr{n} }nlgnd
un}riffnl bii}kgfc{gfj nddi}{r cd{n} c a~}}gbcfn i}
nc}{as~c`n& C OCFN[ ~rnr o~l{g/aiu }i~{gfj gfr{nck id c
r{c{gb fn{zi}` gfd}cr{}~b{~}n {i u}itgkn fn{zi}`
biffnb{gtg{w& Rntn}cl }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr actn mnnf u}iuirnkdi} oimgln Ck Aib fn{zi}`r& ]nbnf{ r{~kgnr if
biouc}c{gtn cfclwrnr id kgddn}nf{ OCFN[ u}i{ibilr bcf
mn di~fk gf P1/33_& Aizntn} {an }nr~l{r u}nrnf{nk gf {anrn
lg{n}c{~}nr c}n fi{ bifrgr{nf{ cfk iflw dnz un}di}ocfbn
on{}gbr c}n bifrgkn}nk& Gf {agr ucun} zn u}nrnf{ c f~omn}
id zcwr id blcrrgdgbc{gif i} bc{nji}gxc{gif id {anrn }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr cfk un}di}ocfbn biouc}grif d}io blcrrnr c}n
u}nrnf{nk&
[an dillizgfj rnb{gifr gf {an ucun} c}n c}}cfjnk crdillizr8 Kgddn}nf{ {wunr id OCFN[ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr c}nu}nrnf{nk gf Rnb{gif GG& Gf Rnb{gif GGG, on{aikilijw ~rnkcfk {an un}di}ocfbn on{}gbr c}n kndgfnk& [an rgo~lc{gif
}nr~l{r cfk kgrb~rrgif c}n jgtnf gf rnb{gif GT& Rnb{gif Tbifbl~knr {an ucun}&
GG& OCFN[ ]I^[GFJ U]I[IBILR
Mcrnk if zanf }i~{gfj cb{gtg{gnr gfg{gc{nk, }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr di} oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r ocw mn m}icklw
blcrrgdgnk gf{i {a}nn mcrgb bc{nji}gnr cr gfkgbc{nk gf dgj~}n
3&
!c' U}icb{gtn i} {cmln/k}gtnf u}i{ibilr
!m' ]ncb{gtn i} if/knocfk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
!b' Awm}gk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 159/223
Dgj~}n 3& Blcrrgdgbc{gif id ck aib }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr&
C& U}icb{gtn i} {cmln/ k}gtnf u}i{ibilr
[}ckg{gifcl kgr{cfbn/tnb{i} cfk lgf`/r{c{n }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr P3_ c}n u}icb{gtn gf {ac{ {anw ocgf{cgf }i~{nr {i
cll fiknr, gfbl~kgfj fiknr {i zagba fi ucb`n{r c}n rnf{&
Di} {ac{ }ncrif {anw }ns~g}n c un}gikgb bif{}il onrrcjn,zagba lnckr {i rbc}bn }nri~}bnr r~ba cr uizn} cfk lgf`
mcfkzgk{a mngfj ~rnk oi}n d}ns~nf{lw di} bif{}il {}cddgb cr
oimglg{w gfb}ncrnr& U}icb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr actn {ang}
}i~{gfj {cmlnr ~ukc{nk c{ cll {gonr, {a~r {an knlcw mndi}n
rnfkgfj c ucb`n{ gr ogfgocl& Aizntn}, }i~{gfj {cmlnr {ac{
c}n clzcwr ~ukc{nk }ns~g}n un}gikgb bif{}il onrrcjnr {ac{
c}n dliiknk {a}i~ja {an zailn fn{zi}`/ cf iun}c{gif {ac{
bifr~onr c li{ id {gon, mcfkzgk{a cfk nfn}jw& Ifn
nqcouln id c u}icb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibil gr nqulcgfnk gf {an
fnq{ r~mrnb{gif&
3' [an Knr{gfc{gif Rns~nfbn Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i} !KRKT'
P2_
G{ gr c u}icb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibil& KRKT clri bcllnk{cmln/k}gtnf }i~{gfj u}i{ibil mnbc~rn ncba fikn ocgf{cgfr
}i~{gfj {cmln {ac{ bif{cgfr rns~nfbn f~omn}r cfk aiu/mw/
aiu gfdi}oc{gif& KRKT gr mcrnk if Mnllocf/Di}k }i~{gfj
clji}g{ao& Rion ochi} gou}itnonf{r actn mnnf ockn gf
Mnllocf/Di}k clji}g{ao gf i}kn} {i oc`n g{ r~g{cmln di}
zg}nlnrr nftg}ifonf{ cfk biun zg{a bi~f{/{i/gfdgfg{w
u}imlno& KRKT ~rnr {an rns~nfbn f~omn} {i ctigk bi~f{/
{i/gfdgfg{w u}imlno cfk ~rgfj {agr rns~nfbn f~omn} KRKT
kgr{gfj~granr mn{znnf r{cln cfk d}nra }i~{nr& Fiknr {cl`
zg{a ncba i{an}‗r cfk ~ukc{n {ang} }i~{gfj {cmlnr& Gd bacfjn
gf {iuilijw ibb~}r, ~ukc{nr c}n {}cfrog{{nk& [an}n c}n {zi
{wunr id ~ukc{nr, {gon/k}gtnf !un}gikgb ~ukc{nr' cfk {cmln/
k}gtnf !~ukc{nr mnbc~rn id rgjfgdgbcf{ bacfjn'& Gf bcrn id
cfw bacfjn, }i~{gfj ~ukc{nr c}n {}cfrog{{nk {i cll i{an}
fiknr zagba ocw bc~rn lc}jn itn}anck& Gf i}kn} {i }nk~bn
{agr itn}anck }i~{gfj ~ukc{nr c}n rnf{ gf {zi zcwr8 c d~ll
k~ou zcw, zan}n d~ll }i~{gfj {cmln gr rnf{ {i fngjami}r m~{
g{ acuunfr iflw gf bcrn id biouln{n {iuilijw bacfjn& Cf
gfb}nonf{cl ~ukc{n8 zan}n iflw {an nf{}gnr bacfjn gf {an
}i~{n on{}gb c}n rnf{ P=, 2_&
M& ]ncb{gtn i} if/knocfk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
]ncb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr, if {an i{an} acfk, iun}c{n
iflw zanf {an}n gr c fnnk id bioo~fgbc{gif mn{znnf {zi
fiknr& [agr cuu}icba cllizr {an fiknr {i dib~r ng{an} if
}i~{nr {ac{ c}n mngfj ~rnk i} if }i~{nr {ac{ c}n gf u}ibnrr id
mngfj rn{ ~u& ]ncb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr kn{n}ogfn }i~{nr
mn{znnf fiknr iflw zanf {anw c}n nqulgbg{lw fnnknk {i
}i~{n ucb`n{r& Aizntn}, zanfntn} {an}n gr c fnnk di}rnfkgfj c ucb`n{, {an oimgln fikn o~r{ dg}r{ dgfk {an }i~{n
gd {an }i~{n gr fi{ cl}nckw `fizf& [agr }i~{n kgrbitn}w
u}ibnrr ocw }nr~l{ gf bifrgkn}cmln knlcw& Cf nqcouln id
}ncb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibil gr Ck aib If/ Knocfk Kgr{cfbn
Tnb{i} !CIKT'&
3' Ck Aib If/Knocfk Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i}
]i~{gfj U}i{ibil
G{ gr }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibil& CIKT clri bcllnk
ri~}bn/gfg{gc{nk }i~{gfj clji}g{ao, mnbc~rn CIKT iflw
kgrbitn}r {an uc{a {i {an knr{gfc{gif zanf ri~}bn zcf{r {i
rnfk kc{c& Nr{cmlgrank uc{a mn{znnf ri~}bn cfk knr{gfc{gif
}nocgfr cr lifj cr g{ gr fnnknk i} mnbionr gfcbbnrrgmln&
]i~{n kgrbitn}w onbacfgro id CIKT gr mcrnk if }i~{n
}ns~nr{ !]]NS', }i~{n }nulw !]]NU', cfk }i~{n n}}i}
!]N]]' onrrcjnr& Rgfbn CIKT gr dliikgfj gf fc{~}n,
zanf {an}n gr fnnk {i kgrbitn} uc{a, ri~}bn fikn dliikr
]]NS onrrcjn {i cll fngjami}gfj fiknr& [agr ]]NS
onrrcjn bif{cgfr knr{gfc{gif rns~nfbn f~omn}& [agr
rns~nfbn f~omn} anlur gf nfr~}gfj }i~{n tclgkg{w cfk
u}ntnf{r }i~{gfj liiur P=_& Di} nqcouln, c }i~{n zg{a
j}nc{nr{ rns~nfbn f~omn} gr clzcwr bairnf mw rnfkgfj
fikn& Cd{n} }nbngtgfj ]]NS onrrcjn ncba fngjami}gfj
fikn banb`r {an knr{gfc{gif GK& Zanf {an uc{a gr di~fk,
]]NU onrrcjn gr rnf{ mcb` {i }ns~nr{gfj fikn& [an uc{a
dilliznk mw ]]NU onrrcjn gr ~rnk {i rnfk kc{c ucb`n{& If
{an i{an} acfk, zanf {an uc{a gr fi{ di~fk, fngjami}gfjfiknr di}zc}k {an ]]NS {i {ang} fngjami}r& Gf bcrn id lgf`
m}nc`r c ]N]] onrrcjn gr rnf{ {i ri~}bn fikn gfdi}ogfj
{ac{ lgf` gr fi lifjn} tclgk fiz& [an }i~{n kgrbitn}w
onbacfgro id CIKT gr rgoglc} {i KR] cfk }i~{gfj {cmln
id CIKT zg{a knr{gfc{gif rns~nfbn f~omn}r gr rgoglc} {i
KRKT P2_&
B& Awm}gk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
Biomgfgfj {an u}icb{gtn cfk }ncb{gtn cuu}icbanr }nr~l{
gf c awm}gk }i~{gfj u}i{ibil& C awm}gk cuu}icba ogfgogxnr
{an kgrcktcf{cjnr, m~{ clri {an cktcf{cjnr id {an {zi
biomgfnk cuu}icbanr& [an Xifn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil !X]U' gr
r~ba c awm}gk }ncb{gtn )u}icb{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibil& Ncbaoimgln fikn u}icb{gtnlw ocgf{cgfr }i~{nr zg{agf c libcl
}njgif !}ndn}}nk {i cr {an }i~{gfj xifn'& Oimgln fiknr
}nrgkgfj i~{rgkn {an xifn bcf mn }ncbank zg{a }ncb{gtn
}i~{gfj& X]U gr cf nqcouln id r~ba c }i~{gfj u}i{ibil&
3' Xifn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil
X]U gr knrgjfnk {i ckk}nrr {an u}imlnor crribgc{nk
zg{a u}icb{gtn cfk }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj& Nqbnrr mcfkzgk{a
bifr~ou{gif mnbc~rn id dliikgfj id ~ukc{nr ucb`n{r cfk
lifj knlcw gf }i~{n kgrbitn}w }ns~nr{ c}n {zi ocgf
u}imlnor id u}icb{gtn cfk }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj }nrunb{gtnlw&
X]U bcon zg{a {an bifbnu{ id xifnr& Gf lgog{nk xifn, }i~{n
ocgf{nfcfbn gr ncrgn} cfk mnbc~rn id xifnr, f~omn}r id
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 160/223
}i~{gfj ~ukc{nr c}n knb}ncrnk& Fiknr i~{ id {an xifn bcf
bioo~fgbc{n tgc }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj, di} {agr u~}uirn }i~{n
}ns~nr{ gr fi{ dliiknk {i nf{g}n fn{zi}` iflw {an mi}kn}
fikn gr }nruifrgmln {i un}di}o {agr {cr`& X]U biomgfnr {andnc{~}n id mi{a u}icb{gtn cfk }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj clji}g{aor
P:_& [an c}bag{nb{~}n id X]U bifrgr{r id di~} nlnonf{r8
OCB/lntnl d~fb{gifr, Gf{}c/Xifn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil
!GC]U', Gf{n}/Xifn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil !GN]U' cfk Mi}kn}
bcr{ ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil !M]U'& [an u}icb{gtn }i~{gfj gr ~rnk
zg{agf lgog{nk runbgdgnk xifnr cfk mnwifk {an xifnr
}ncb{gtn }i~{gfj gr ~rnk& OCB/lntnl un}di}or fngjami}
kgrbitn}w cfk ocgf{nfcfbn d~fb{gifr& Di} gfr{cfbn, zanf c
fikn bionr gf }cfjn c fi{gdgbc{gif id fnz fngjami} gr rnf{
{i GC]U rgoglc}lw zanf fikn lirrnr biffnb{gtg{w, lir{
biffnb{gtg{w fi{gdgbc{gif gr rnf{ {i GC]U& Zg{agf gf c
runbgdgnk xifn, GC]U u}i{ibil }i~{nr ucb`n{r& GC]U `nnur
gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{ cll fiknr gf {an xifn gf g{r }i~{gfj {cmln&
If {an i{an} acfk, gd fikn zcf{r {i rnfk ucb`n{ {i c fikn
i~{rgkn {an xifn, gf {ac{ bcrn GN]U u}i{ibil gr ~rnk {i dgfk
mnr{ uc{a& [ac{ oncfr GN]U gr }nruifrgmln {i ocgf{cgfr
bi}}nb{ }i~{nr i~{rgkn {an xifn& Gd GN]U kinr fi{ actn cfw
}i~{n gf g{r }i~{gfj {cmln, g{ rnfkr }i~{n s~n}w {i M]U& [an
M]U gr }nruifrgmln {i bif{cb{ zg{a fiknr cb}irr Ck Aib
fn{zi}`r cfk ucrrnr }i~{n s~n}gnr& Goui}{cf{ {agfj gf
mi}kn} bcr{gfj onbacfgro id M]U gr g{ ctigkr ucb`n{r
dliik gf fn{zi}`& M]U clzcwr ucrrnr }i~{n s~n}w }ns~nr{
{i mi}kn} fiknr iflw, rgfbn iflw mi}kn} fiknr {}cfrog{ cfk
}nbngtn ucb`n{r P>, 4, :_&
GGG& ON[AIKILIJW[an rgo~lc{gif gr bifk~b{nk gf {zi kgddn}nf{ rbnfc}gir&
Gf {an dg}r{ rbnfc}gi, {an biouc}grif id {an {zi }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr gr kifn mw `nnugfj =5 biffnb{gifr dgqnk gf
tc}wgfj f~omn}r id fiknr/35, =5,25,;5,>5&
Gf {an rnbifk rbnfc}gi, {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr c}n
ntcl~c{nk gf kgddn}nf{ f~omn} id biffnb{gifr zagln {an
f~omn} id =5 fiknr gr dgqnk& [an f~omn} id biffnb{gifr gr
rn{ {i >, 35,3>,=5,=>&
[an un}di}ocfbn id {an u}i{ibilr knunfkr if tc}gi~r
gf{n}}nlc{gfj ckan}nk on{}gbr kgrb~rrnk gf {an fnq{ r~m/
rnb{gif&
C&
UN]DI]OCFBN ON[]GBR[i cfclwxn {an }nlc{gtn un}di}ocfbn id {an u}i{ibilr zn
oncr~}nk {an dillizgfj un}di}ocfbn on{}gbr d}io {an {}cbn
dglnr&
3' [a}i~jau~{8
[a}i~jau~{ gr {an coi~f{ id kc{c {}cfrdn}}nk {i {an
knr{gfc{gif {a}i~ja {an fn{zi}` gf c ~fg{ {gon nqu}nrrnk gf
`glimg{r un} rnbifk !@mur'&
`mur {gonrgo~lc{gif
k{}cfrdn}nkc{cid Coi~f{[a}i~jau~{
=' F~omn} id Ucb n{r rnf{8
G{ gr {an {i{cl f~omn} id ucb`n{r rnf{ {i {an
knr{gfc{gifr jnfn}c{nk mw {an ri~}bnr&
2' F~omn} id Ucb`n{r }nbngtnk8
G{ gr {an {i{cl f~omn} id ucb`n{r }nbngtnk mw {anknr{gfc{gifr rnf{ d}io {an ri~}bnr&
;' Ucb`n{ Knlgtn}w ]c{gi8
G{ gr {an }c{gi id {an kc{c ucb`n{r knlgtn}nk {i {an
knr{gfc{gifr {i {airn jnfn}c{nk mw {an ri~}bn&
.q355ucb`n{rrnf{[i{cl
ucb`n{r}nbngtnk[i{cl}c{giknlgtn}wUcb`n{
>' ]i~{gfj Itn}anck8
G{ gr f~omn} id }i~{gfj ucb`n{r {}cfrog{{nk un} kc{c
ucb`n{ knlgtn}nk c{ {an knr{gfc{gif&
.q355ucb`n{rgfj{}cfrog{{[i{cl
ucb`n{rrgjfcllgfj}i~{gfj[i{clitn}anck]i~{gfj
4' Ctn}cjn nfk/{i/nfk knlcw id kc{c ucb`n{r8
[an}n c}n uirrgmln knlcwr bc~rnk mw m~ddn}gfj k~}gfj
}i~{n kgrbitn}w lc{nfbw, s~n~gfj c{ {an gf{n}dcbn s~n~n,
}n{}cfrogrrgif knlcwr c{ {an OCB, cfk u}iucjc{gif cfk
{}cfrdn} {gonr& [an ucun} ~rn Ctn}cjn nfk/{i/nfk knlcw&
Ctn}cjn nfk/{i/nfk knlcw gr cf ctn}cjn nfk/{i/nfk knlcw
id kc{c ucb`n{r& G{ clri bc~rnk mw s~n~gfj di} {}cfrogrrgif
c{ {an fikn cfk m~ddn}gfj kc{c di} kn{i~}gfj& [agr on{}gb
knrb}gmnr {an ucb`n{ knlgtn}w {gon8 {an lizn} {an nfk/{i/
nfk knlcw {an mn{{n} {an cuulgbc{gif un}di}ocfbn&
f
3
f
3
{gon}nbt&[BU
{gon'}nbt&[BU/rnf{ {gon![BU
YNfkYKnlcwctjYNfkY{i
[an ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi cfk {an {a}i~jau~{ c}n oir{
goui}{cf{ di} mnr{ nddi}{ {}cddgb& Cfk {an }i~{gfj itn}anck
ntcl~c{nr {an nddgbgnfbw id {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil&
GT& RGO^LC[GIF ]NR^L[R
[an r{~kw acr mnnf bc}}gnk i~{ ~rgfj FR= rgo~lc{gif
rid{zc}n ~fkn} Lgf~q iun}c{gfj rwr{no ulc{di}o& Gf {an
rgo~lc{gif, {an un}di}ocfbn id {a}nn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
fconlw, CIKT, KRKT cfk X]U c}n cfclwxnk gf {zi
rbnfc}gir& Gf {an dg}r{ rbnfc}gi, f~omn}r id fiknr gr tc}gnk
`nnugfj =5 biffnb{gifr dgqnk cfk gf {an rnbifk rbnfc}gi,
f~omn} id biffnb{gifr gr tc}gnk zagln {an f~omn} id
fiknr, =5 gr dgqnk&
C& Rbnfc}gi 38
Gf {agr dg}r{ rbnfc}gi, {an biouc}grif id {an {a}nn
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr gr kifn mw `nnugfj =5 biffnb{gifr dgqnk
cfk tc}wgfj f~omn}r id fiknr zg{a rion uc}con{n}r zg{a
c runbgdgb tcl~n cr raizf gf {cmln G&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 161/223
[CMLN G& RBNFC]GI 3 DI] RGO^LC[GIF ID CIKT,KRKT CFK
KR]
Uc}con{n} Tcl~n
F~omn} id fiknr
35,=5,25,;5,>5
Rgo~lc{gif
[gon
355
Uc~rn [gon = r
Nftg}ifonf{
Rgxn
:55 q ;55
Ucb`n{ Rgxn >3= mw{nr
Ocqgo~o
Runnk
35 o)r
S~n~n Lnfj{a >5
Oimglg{w
Oiknl
]cfkio Zcwuigf{
Oimglg{w
[an un}di}ocfbn on{}gbr di} {an {a}nn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
c}n bclb~lc{nk cfk cll }nlntcf{ j}cuar c}n jgtnf gf dgj~}n =/
dgj~}n 2&
D}io dgj~}n =!c' g{ gr imrn}tnk {ac{ gf {an mnjgffgfj,
{an ctn}cjn nfk/{i/nfk knlcw id CIKT lnckr X]U cfk
{anf bionr KR]& Aizntn}, zg{a {an gfb}ncrn gf f~omn} id
fiknr, KRKT lnckr X]U di} c zagln m~{ CIKT bif{gf~nr
{i lnck {ano& X]U r{c}{r {i kiogfc{n itn} {ano zg{a oi}n
f~omn} id fiknr& C{ lcr{, X]U kiogfc{nr {ano cfk CIKT
lnckr KRKT& Dgj~}n =!m' jgtnr {an ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi,X]U cfk CIKT bigfbgkn& Gf {an mnjgffgfj, {an ucb`n{
knlgtn}w }c{gi id X]U cfk CIKT gr oi}n {acf KRKT&
Aizntn}, c{ {an lcr{, zg{a gfb}ncrgfj {an f~omn} id fiknr
KRKT kiogfc{nr itn} {ano& Mi{a X]U cfk CIKT
bif{gf~n {i bigfbgkn& Gf {an bcrn }i~{gfj itn}anck CIKT
lnckr itn} KRKT cfk X]U& X]U bionr c{ {an lcr{ d}io {an
mnjgffgfj {i {an nfk zg{a gfb}ncrgfj f~omn} id fiknr cr
u}nrnf{nk gf dgj~}n 2!c'&D}io dgj~}n 2!m' {an {a}i~jau~{ id
{an {a}nn u}i{ibilr bcf mn imrn}tnk& Gf {an mnjgffgfj,
CIKT lnckr itn} KRKT& X]U r{c}{ c{ {an liznr{ coifj
{ano& Cr {an f~omn} id fiknr gfb}ncrnr, KRKT r{c}{r {i
lnck CIKT cfk X]U& C{ {an nfk, KRKT lnckr CIKT
dilliznk mw X]U&
M& Rbnfc}gi =8
Gf {agr rnbifk rbnfc}gi, {an biouc}grif id {an {a}nn
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr gr kifn mw `nnugfj =5 fiknr dgqnk cfk
tc}wgfj f~omn}r id biffnb{gifr zg{a rion uc}con{n}r
zg{a c runbgdgb tcl~n c}n cr raizf gf {cmln GG&
[CMLN GG& RBNFC]GI = DI] RGO^LC[GIF ID CIKT
,KRKT CFK X]U
Uc}con{n} Tcl~n
F~omn} id
biffnb{gifr
>,35,=5,=>
Rgo~lc{gif [gon 355 rUc~rn [gon = r
Nftg}ifonf{ Rgxn :55 q ;55
Ucb`n{ Rgxn >3= mw{nr
Ocqgo~o Runnk 35 o)r
S~n~n Lnfj{a >5
Oimglg{w Oiknl ]cfkio Zcwuigf{
Oimglg{w
[an un}di}ocfbn on{}gbr di} {an {a}nn }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr
c}n bclb~lc{nk cfk }nlntcf{ j}cuar c}n raizf gf dgj~}n ;/
dgj~}n > }nrunb{gtnlw&
D}io dgj~}n ;!c' {an ctn}cjn nfk/{i/nfk knlcw id
CIKT lnckr X]U cfk X]U lnckr KRKT zg{a lnrr fi& id
fiknr& Zg{a {an gfb}ncrn gf f~omn} id biffnb{gifr, c{ {an
lcr{, CIKT bif{gf~nr {i kiogfc{n itn} X]U cfk KRKT
r{cwr cd{n} X]U& D}io dgj~}n ;!m' g{ bcf mn imrn}tnk {ac{ gf
{an mnjgffgfj, {an ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi id CIKT lnckr
KRKT cfk KRKT lnckr X]U& Zg{a {an gfb}ncrgfj f~omn}
id biffnb{gifr, ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi id CIKT k}iur&
Aizntn}, c{ {an lcr{ zg{a gfb}ncrgfj {an f~omn} id
biffnb{gifr, {an ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi id CIKT }grnr cfk
lnckr X]U m~{ KRKT kiogfc{nr {ano& Gf {an mnjgffgfj,
KRKT lnckr CIKT cfk {anf bionr X]U& Cr {an f~omn}
id biffnb{gifr gfb}ncrnr, CIKT lnckr KRKT m~{ c{ {an
lcr{, KRKT kiogfc{nr CIKT cfk X]U r{cwr c{ {an lcr{ cr
raizf gf dgj~}n >!c'&Gf dgj~}n >!m' KRKT lnckr itn}
CIKT cfk CIKT lnckr X]U& Aizntn}, zg{a {an gfb}ncrn
gf f~omn} id biffnb{gifr, CIKT lnckr KRKT m~{ c{ {an
lcr{, KRKT kiogfc{nr itn} CIKT cfk X]U }nocgfr c{ {an
lcr{&
T& BIFBL^RGIF
Gf {agr ucun} zn actn u}nrnf{nk c kn{cgl biouc}c{gtn
cfclwrnr id kgddn}nf{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr ifn ncba d}io {a}nn
kgddn}nf{ bc{nji}gnr id OCFN[ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr ~fkn}
kgddn}nf{ rbnfc}gir& Kgddn}nf{ un}di}ocfbn on{}gbr c}n
kndgfnk cfk ~rnk di} {an biouc}c{gtn cfclwrnr& [an }nr~l{r
u}nrnf{nk an}n c}n tclgk ~fkn} {an rbnfc}gir bifrgkn}nk gf
{agr ucun}& Aizntn} {an}n c}n ocfw dcb{i}r {ac{ ocw mn
d~}{an} gftnr{gjc{nk {i r{~kw g{r goucb{ if OCFN[ }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr& Zn mnlgntn {ac{ i~} zi}` u}nrnf{nk gf {agr ucun}
ocw r~g{cmlw mn id anlu {i {an }nrnc}ba bioo~fg{w gf {agr
bacllnfjgfj dgnlk&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 162/223
P3_ Bion} K&N
cfk C}bag{nP=_ Baizka~}w
id {a}nn zgr{}ncogfjid gfogb =5=55;&
P2_ Un}`gfr, B&Rns~nfbnkRGJBIOO
P;_ B& N& Un}` Tnb{i} !Ccikt/Iv&{q
P>_ Caonk, O&c{{}gm~{nr,-
!c'
]
& “Gf{n}fn{zi}`g
b{~}nr‟,di~}{a nkg, O&^&0Un}n}c, K}nlnrr o~l{g aiuunj; {}cddgb,- O
5;& 1{a gf{n}fc{gi
N& cfk Macjzc{,Kgr{cfbn/Tnb{i}Biou~{& Bioo
gfr cfk N& O&KT' ]i~{gfj&
{, Fitnomn} 377
0 Wi~rnd, R&0 , -GNNN GRGN =551 ,
Dg
DN]NFBNR
j Zg{a [BU)GU8
g{gif, =555&&0 Uaco,{&0-C unck/aib fn{zi}` ~l{g {iugb bifdn}nfcl , til&, fi&, uu
U& 377;& Agjal}i~{gfj !KRKT'~f& ]nt& =;, ; =2
iwn}& Ck AibGN[D lf{n}fn{&
nld/bifdgj~}cmlnuu&=337/=3=;, H
!c'
~}n =& !c' Ctn
8 U}gfbgulnr, U}i{
}di}ocfbn bioui~{gfj u}i{ibilrfbn, =55;& u}ibn& >34/ >=3, =;/=
kwfcogb Knr{gfdi} oimgln bio;/=;;, Ib{& 377;
If Knocfk Kg}cd{, k}cd{/gn{d/
xifn }i~{gfj u}lw =551&
cjn nfk {i knlcw
ibilr,
c}grifzanfkgfjrKnb&
c{gif/~{n}r&&
{cfbncfn{/
{ibil
P4_
P:_
P1_
P7_
P3
P33
tr fi& id fiknr !
!m
Unc}locf, Obifdgj~}c{gifRnlnb{nk C}nc
Uc{nl, M&0 R}g
u}i{ibilr gf=535 Fc{gifcl
C&Miioc}cfg[a}i~jau~{ cIunf U}imlno
Cmk~l Ackgbiouc}grgifOimgln Ck]nrnc}ba,til&
_ R&C Ckn,UCIKT,KRKTAib Fn{zi@fizlnkjno=535&
3_ [&@& Jikkn},Aib ]i~{gfj
m' Ucb`n{ knlgtn
&]& cfk Acrrdi} {an xifn
r gf Bioo~fgbc{
tcr{ctc, R&0 , -U
imgln Ck AibBifdn}nfbn if,
Oclcfw, T&]&k Knlcw Biour Bou{& Oc{a&, t
mk ]caocf,X~}gd CIKT,KRKTAib Fn{zi}`r3,fi&;,uu&>44/>
&C& [ghc}n,,ILR] cfk KR
}`r‟,Gf{& H& if{ Ocfcjnon
“Un}di}ocfbn B}i{ibilr‟,BRNGH
}w }c{gi tr fi& id
, X&H&, Kn{n}o}i~{gfj u}i{ibilgifr& t3: g1& 327
n}di}ocfbn cfcl
Fn{zi}`r,- Biotil&,uu&3/>, =7/23
Rc}oc ,]&O&}grgif id OCFNil&=,fi&2,rnu{no
gc{g Caonk X~`ccfk G/KRKT ]
‟,N~}iuncf Hi4,=557&
“Un}di}ocfbn] ]i~{gfj U}i{d Gfdi}oc{giff{,til&=,fi&= u
ouc}grgif cfk c,til3&fi&3,cu}gl =
!m'
fiknr
gfgfj {an iu{g& GNNN Hi~}fcl/3;3;&
rgr id xifn }i~
o~fgbc{gifr !FBHcf& =535&
bacfk}crn`c}cf,[ U}i{ibilr‟, Gfn} =557&
}fcgf, “Un}di}oci~{gfj U}i{ibil}fcl id Rbgnf
Biouc}grgifbilr gf Oimgln
[nbafilijwu&>;>/>;1,knbn
clwrgr id Oimgln533&
oclif
{gfj
B',
, “{& H&
fbngf
{gdgb
id Ckcfkmn}
Ck
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 163/223
!c'
!c
!
!c' ]i
' Ctn}cjn nfk {i
c'
!c' ]i~{gfj
{gfj itn}anck tr
knlcw tr fi& id b
tn}anck tr fi& i
fi& id fiknr!m'
iffnb{gifr!m' Uc
d biffnb{gif !m'
[a}i~jau~{ tr f
!m
b`n{ knlgtn}w }c{g
[a}i~jau~{ tr f
i& id fi{nr
tr fi& id biffn
i& id biffnb{gifr
b{gifr
!m'
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 164/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;537)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;537
Lg{n}c{~}n R~}tnw cfk U}iuirnk Bifbnu{ if Un}di}ocfbn Grr~n id O~l{gbcr{gfj
]i~{gfj U}i{ibil gf Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`
]ca~l Tn}oc !C~{ai}'
O& [nba& Rbailc} !BRN'
MGR[
Maiucl, Gfkgc
C`aglnra C& Zcii !C~{ai}'
Crr{& U}id& Knu{& id O& [nba& !BRN'
MGR[
Maiucl, Gfkgc
U&R& Uc{anhc !C~{ai}'
Crr{& U}id& Knu{& id O& [nba& !BRN'
MGR[
Maiucl, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛Fn{zi}`r c}n blcrrgdgnk gf {i {zi ocgf bc{nji}gnr g&n&
zg}nk fn{zi}` cfk zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`& Zn actn `fizf {ac{ {an
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` gr goui}{cf{& [i R{~kw if zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`
zn actn ~rnk Oimgln Ck/aib Fn{zi}`r !OCFN[' zagba gr {an
fnz }nrnc}ba c}nc& OCFN[ gr gfd}cr{}~b{~}n lnrr fn{zi}`zan}n }i~{gfj gr {an zcw id {}cfrdn}}gfj ucb`n{ d}io ifn fikn
{i cfi{an} fikn gf {an fn{zi}`& O~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj gr c
{nbafgs~n zan}n c ucb`n{ gr rnfk {i c j}i~u id rnlnb{nk fikn
zagba gr {an onomn} id {ac{ j}i~u, zanf o~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj gr
cuulgnk {i c OCFN[ itn}cll un}di}ocfbn id {an fn{zi}` gr
gfb}ncrnk& OCIKT cfk IKO]U }i~{gfj u}i{ibil gr {an
nqcouln id o~l{gbcr{gfj }i~{gfj& [anrn u}i{ibilr actn
uc}con{n}r lg`n Ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi, Bif{}il itn}anck,
Di}zc}kgfj nddgbgnfbw, nfk {i nfk knlgtn}w cfk ocfw i{an}r& Gf
[agr ucun} zn c}n u}iuirgfj c bifbnu{ {i riltn rion
i~{r{cfkgfj u}imlnor lg`n bcucbg{w id {an fn{zi}`, uizn}
nddgbgnfbw id {an fn{zi}` cfk oir{ goui}{cf{ {agfj iu{gocl
knrgjfgfj id {an fn{zi}` gf OCFN[r& Gf {agr ucun} i~}
u}iuirnk bifbnu{ zgll {}w {i u}itgkn ril~{gif id {an onf{gifnk
u}imlnor& An}n zn zgll u}itgkn c knrgjf {i fn{zi}` gf r~ba czcw zan}n zn bcf gfb}ncrn bcucbg{w, uizn} nddgbgnfbw cfk
i{an} uc}con{n}r zagba c}n u}nkndgfn ~rgfj gfrn}{ fnz fikn
bifbnu{ gf nqgr{gfj fn{zi}`&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
C oimgln ck aib fn{zi}` !OCFN[' gr c {wun id zg}nlnrrfn{zi}`r& [agr {wun knunfkr if {an oimgln fiknr cfk {an}ngr fi gfd}cr{}~b{~}n gf r~ba {wun& [an}n c}n fi }i~{n}r,rn}tn}r, cbbnrr uigf{r i} bcmlnr& Fiknr !oimglnr' bcf oitnd}nnlw cfk gf c}mg{}c}w zcwr, ri g{ ocw bacfjn g{r libc{gifd}io {gon {i {gon& Ncba fikn ocw mn c rnfkn} i} c }nbngtn},cfk cfw fikn ocw zi}` cr c }i~{n} cfk ki cll }i~{n}d~fb{gifr& [agr oncfr {ac{ g{ bcf di}zc}k ucb`n{r {i i{an}
fiknr& Ocfw cuulgbc{gifr id OCFN[‗r c}n goulnonf{nkcfk ~rnk ~f{gl {ikcw lg`n gf onn{gfj bifdn}nfbnr0 oglg{c}wiun}c{gifr0 rnc}ba cfk }nrb~n iun}c{gifr, cll id {ano c}nnqcoulnr id OCFN[ fn{zi}`r&
O~l{gbcr{gfj gf zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}` gr c ai{ {iugb gf}nbnf{ wnc}r& Mw o~l{gbcr{gfj, zn oncf {an {}cfrogrrgif id ucb`n{r d}io c ri~}bn i} c j}i~u id ri~}bnr {i c j}i~u id ifn i} oi}n air{r {ac{ c}n gknf{gdgnk mw c rgfjln knr{gfc{gifckk}nrr& O~l{gbcr{gfj j}nc{lw }nk~bnr {an {}cfrogrrgif bir{
zanf rnfkgfj {an rcon ucb`n{ {i o~l{guln }nbgugnf{r&Rntn}cl o~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr actn mnnf }nbnf{lw
u}iuirnk di} ck/aib fn{zi}`r& [anrn u}i{ibilr bcf mn
[}nn/mcrnk i} Onra/mcrnk&
Knunfknf{ i} Gfknunfknf{ id {an ~fkn}lwgfj~fgbcr{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibil&
If/knocfk i} [cmln/k}gtnf&
G{ bcf gou}itn {an ~rcjn id zg}nlnrr lgf`r mw rnfkgfjo~l{guln biugnr id kc{c ucb`n{r ~rgfj gfan}nf{ m}ickbcr{mnactgi} id zg}nlnrr {}cfrogrrgif {ai~ja }nk~bgfj{}cfrogrrgif itn}anck cfk uizn} bifr~ou{gif gr c tn}wbacllnfjgfj uc}{ gf o~l{gbcr{gfj& [an}n c}n ocfwcuulgbc{gifr zan}n ifn/{i/ocfw cfk ocfw/{i/ocfw{}cfrogrrgifr c}n }ns~g}nk&
[}nn/mcrnk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr actn iflw rgfjln uc{a d}iori~}bn {i knr{gfc{gifr, ri {an m}i`nf lgf`r fnnk {i mn}nucg}nk& If {an i{an} acfk, onra/mcrnk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilocgf{cgfr onra id {an biffnb{nk biouifnf{r id {an fn{zi}` cfk {an}ndi}n, acr o~l{guln uc{ar d}io ri~}bnr {i o~l{gbcr{knr{gfc{gifr& [agr }nk~bnr }nucg}gfj itn}anck k~n {iu}nrnfbn id cl{n}fc{n uc{ar ctcglcmln gf {an fn{zi}`& Onra/mcrnk }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr lnck {i bifjnr{gif ~fkn} {anbifkg{gifr id agja {}cddgb lick zagba bcf }nr~l{ gf lizucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi& [agr ucun} r~ooc}gxnr {an rgo~lc{gif{nbafgs~nr cfk cfclwrgr id rion id {an o~l{gbcr{ u}i{ibilrlg`n OCIKT P35_ cfk IKO]U P33_ gf OCFN[nftg}ifonf{&
[agr ucun} gr i}jcfgxnk cr dillizr8 gf rnb{gif GG znu}nrnf{ c m}gnd r~}tnw if tc}gi~r }nrnc}ba ucun}r ifo~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibil, rnb{gif GGG gfbl~kn u}imlnodgfkgfj gf oimgln ck/aib fn{zi}`, rnb{gif GT gfbl~knr cknrb}gu{gif id i~} u}iuirnk gknc, rnb{gif T gfbl~kgfjnqunb{nk i~{bion id u}iuirnk bifbnu{& Dgfcllw, rnb{gif TGu}itgknr bifbl~kgfj }noc}`r cfk agjalgja{r i~} u}iuirnkzi}`&
GG& LG[N]C[^]N R^]TNW
Gf P3_ ucun}, {anw actn u}nrnf{ c biouc}c{gtnun}di}ocfbn id {zi if/knocfk o~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr,fconlw OCIKT cfk IKO]U knlgtn}w }c{gi, bif{}ilitn}anck cfk di}zc}kgfj nddgbgnfbw gf kgddn}nf{ o~l{gbcr{nddnb{r r~ba cr gfb}ncrgfj f~omn} id o~l{gbcr{ ri~}bnr cfk}nbngtn}r gf {an o~l{gbcr{ j}i~u& [agr rgo~lc{gif biouirnk
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3;7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 165/223
zg{a =55 oimgln fiknr di} {agr rgfjln cb{gtn o~l{gbcr{ j}i~ugf {an fn{zi}`&
Gf Cfi{an} ucun} P2_ {anw actn u}nrnf{ rgo~lc{gif mcrnknqun}gonf{r {i cfclwxn {an un}di}ocfbn id If KnocfkO~l{gbcr{ ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil mw ntcl~c{gfj Ucb`n{ Knlgtn}w]c{gi, Nfk {i Nfk knlcw cfk ctn}cjn {a}i~jau~{& [anrn}nr~l{r c}n biouc}nk mn{znnf IKO]U zg{a CIKT cfkDR] }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr mw tc}wgfj f~omn} id fiknr cfkoimglg{w& [an biouc}grif raizr {ac{ IKO]U di} ck/aibfn{zi}`r un}di}or mn{{n} cr biouc}nk {i CIKT cfk DR]&
An}n cfi{an} kntnliunk {nbafgs~n zagba gr kndgfn gfP3=_ actn kgrb~rr, {anw actn u}nrnf{ c biouc}c{gtnun}di}ocfbn id {a}nn o~l{gbcr{ u}i{ibilr di} Oimgln Ck aibFn{zi}`r ‒ IKO]U, CO]GR cfk OCIKT dib~rgfj if {annddnb{r id bacfjnr r~ba cr {an gfb}ncrgfj f~omn} id }nbngtn}r i} ri~}bnr cfk gfb}ncrgfj {an f~omn} id fiknr&Cl{ai~ja rion rgo~lc{gif }nr~l{r id OCFN[ u}i{ibilractn mnnf u~mlgrank mndi}n, {anrn {a}nn u}i{ibilr actn fi{mnnf biouc}nk gf grilc{gif& Gf }nbnf{ wnc}r, c f~omn} id fnz o~l{gbcr{ u}i{ibilr actn mnnf u}iuirnk di} ck aibfn{zi}`r& C rwr{noc{gb un}di}ocfbn ntcl~c{gif id {anrnu}i{ibilr gr kifn mw un}di}ogfj bn}{cgf rgo~lc{gifr& [ancuulgbcmglg{w id o~l{gbcr{ u}i{ibilr {i kgtn}rn rg{~c{gif c}nclri r{~kgnk cfk kgrb~rrnk&
Gf P32_, {anw actn u}nrnf{ c biouc}c{gtn un}di}ocfbnntcl~c{gif id {a}nn jnfn}cl/u~}uirn if/knocfk o~l{gbcr{u}i{ibilr, fconlw CKO], OCIKT, cfk IKO]U,dib~rgfj if {an nddnb{r id bacfjnr r~ba cr gfb}ncrgfjf~omn} id o~l{gbcr{ }nbngtn}r i} ri~}bnr, cuulgbc{gifrnfkgfj uc{{n}f, cfk gfb}ncrgfj f~omn} id fiknr gf {anfn{zi}`& [anw actn ~rn oimgln fn{zi}`r biouirnk id 355i} =55 fiknr, zg{a mi{a c rgfjln cb{gtn o~l{gbcr{ j}i~u cfko~l{guln cb{gtn o~l{gbcr{ j}i~ur gf {an fn{zi}`, gf c zgkn}cfjn id o~l{gbcr{ rbnfc}gir& Cl{ai~ja rion rgo~lc{gif}nr~l{r di} {anrn u}i{ibilr actn mnnf u~mlgrank mndi}n, {an{a}nn u}i{ibilr actn fi{ mnnf biouc}nk, cfk u}gi} r{~kgnractn dib~rnk if roclln} fn{zi}`r ~rgfj c rocll rn{ id rgo~lc{gif rbnfc}gir, ocfw zg{a iflw c rgfjln cb{gtno~l{gbcr{ j}i~u& [anw actn dib~r an}n if {an nddnb{r id {anu}i{ibilr‗ }nlc{gtn knj}nn id if/knocfk mnactgi} cfk {ang}un}di}ocfbn gf kgddn}nf{ o~l{gbcr{ rbnfc}gir&
GGG& U]IMLNO DI]O^LC[GIF
Gd itn}anck gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` fiknr knb}ncrnr fn{zi}` bcucbg{w, }nk~bgfj {an itn}anck zgll gfb}ncrn {an bcucbg{w id
{an fn{zi}`& G{ gr uir{~lc{nk gf {agr ucun} {ac{ {angf{}ik~b{gif id cf gf{nllgjnf{lw ulcbnk fikn bcf gfb}ncrn {anbcucbg{w id c fn{zi}`& [i knb}ncrn {an itn}ancknqun}gnfbnk zg{agf {an fn{zi}`, fiknr c}n }ns~g}nk {i actn{an ogfgocl f~omn} id fngjami}r uirrgmln& [agr bcf mncbbioulgrank mw lizn}gfj {an {}cfrogrrgif uizn}r id gfkgtgk~cl fiknr {i c lntnl zan}n {an f~omn} id fngjami}r grogfgogxnk m~{ {an fn{zi}` }nocgfr biffnb{nk& [an s~nr{gif{an}ndi}n c}grnr, bcf {an gfrn}{gif id cf ckkg{gifcl fikn gf{ic OCFN[ bi~ulnk zg{a blcrrgbcl {iuilijw bif{}ilonbacfgror lnck {i cf gfb}ncrn gf fn{zi}` bcucbg{w9 Gd ri,zan}n rai~lk {agr fnz fikn gr ckknk9
GT& U]IUIRNK ZI]@
Jnfn}cllw oimgln ck/aib fn{zi}`r !OCFN[r' c}n ~rnkdi} oglg{c}w cfk bgtglgcf cuulgbc{gifr& [an}n c}n r{gll c li{ id
gf{n}nr{gfj u}imlnor gftnr{gjc{gfj {an bcucbg{w cfk {aniu{gocl knrgjf id {anrn fn{zi}`r& Gf [agr ucun} zn c}nu}iuirgfj c bifbnu{ {i riltn rion u}imlnor zagba grdgfkgfj gf OCFN[r& I~} ocgf cgo id u}iuirnk bifbnu{ gr{i gfb}ncrn {an bcucbg{w cfk uizn} nddgbgnfbw id {anOCFN[ ~rgfj o~l{gbcr{gfj u}i{ibilr lg`n IKO]U,OCIKT& An}n u}iuirnk bifbnu{ u}itgkgfj ril~{gif di} {anu}imlnor id gfb}ncrgfj {an bcucbg{w, uizn} nddgbgnfbw,gfb}ncrgfj ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi, bif{}il itn}anck,gfb}ncrgfj di}zc}k nddgbgnfbw cfk knb}ncrgfj nfk/{i/nfkknlcw id c OCFN[& Zg{a {an anlu id u}iuirnk bifbnu{ znzgll {}w {i knb}ncrn {an itn}anck id {an fn{zi}` ~rgfjo~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibil& An}n zn zgll {}w {i gfrn}{ fnzfikn gf {an nqgr{gfj fn{zi}`& [agr fnz fikn zgll gfrn}{
zanf o~l{gbcr{ }i~{gfj zgll un}di}onk& Zg{a {an anlu id {agrfnz fikn zn bcf }nk~bn itn}anck, k~n {i {agr zn bcfcbagntn {an fn{zi}` bcucbg{w gr ocqgogxnk mw ogfgogxgfjitn}anck& Mcrgb u}gfbgucl id u}iuirnk bifbnu{ gr raizf gfdgj~}n 3& an}n g{ gr blnc} {ac{ itn}anck mn{znnf {zi fiknr gr}nk~bgfj mw ckkgfj fnz fikn& K~n {i {agr f~omn} id onrrcjnr bcf mn ncrglw {}cfrog{{nk mn{znnf ri~}bnr {iknr{gfc{gif ~rgfj cl{n}fc{n uc{a&
Dgj~}n 38 C}bag{nb{~}n id U}iuirnk Bifbnu{
Dgj~}n = gr raizgfj dliz bac}{ id u}iuirnk bifbnu{& Znactn r{c}{ rnfkgfj ucb`n{r d}io ri~}bn {i rgf` cfk gd cll {anuc{a cl}nckw r~ddn} d}io itn}anck u}imlno {anf i~} }nbnf{lwucb`n{ zgll clri r~ddn} {anrn u}imlno m~{ u}iuirnk bifbnu{gr riltgfj {agr u}imlno ~rgfj gfrn}{gfj fnz fikn gf u}iun}libc{gif ri zn bcf kgtn}{ i} }nk~bn itn}anck gf fn{zi}` cfk{}cfrdn} ucb`n{r di}o ri~}bn {i rgf` gf ncrw zcw& Zn zgll{}w {i dgfk u}iun} libc{gif if {an rion imrn}tc{gif lg`n oir{itn}anck uc{a, lnrr nfn}jw uc{a, lnrr kgr{cfbn cfk ocfwoi}n&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 166/223
Dgj~}n =8 Dliz Bac}{ id U}iuirnk Bifbnu{
Cktcf{cjnr id o~l{guc{a }i~{gfj8/
Dc~l{ {iln}cfbn&
Lick mclcfbgfj&
Mcfkzgk{a ~{glgxc{gif&
Knb}ncrn Nfk/{i/Nfk knlcw&
T& NQUNB[NK I^[BION
[an o~l{gbcr{gfj }i~{gfj u}i{ibil IKO]U zgll mn
u}ik~bn mc{{n} }nr~l{r cr biouc}n i{an} o~l{gbcr{gfj }i~{gfj
u}i{ibil& I~} rgo~lc{gif zgll zn bifbnf{}c{n if IKO]U
}i~{gfj u}i{ibil& Dillizgfj uigf{r di} mc{{n} }nr~l{
IKO]U ~rnk ONRA {iuilijw d}io ncba ri~}bn
IKO]U u}itgknr cl{n}fc{gtn uc{ar cfk c lgf`
dcgl~}n fnnk fi{ {}gjjn} {an }n/biou~{c{gif id {an
onra, m}i`nf lgf`r zgll {gon i~{
IKO]U m}ickbcr{r {an }nulw mcb` {i {an ri~}bn
IKO]U cllizr di} o~l{guln uirrgmln uc{ar d}io
{an o~l{gbcr{ ri~}bn mcb` {i {an }nbngtn}
IKO]U kinr cb{gtc{n c o~l{gbcr{ }i~{n
goonkgc{nlw
TG& BIFBL^RGIF
C jnfn}cl bifbl~rgif gr {ac{, gf c oimgln rbnfc}gi, onra/mcrnk u}i{ibilr i~{ un}di}onk {}nn/mcrnk u}i{ibilr& [an
ctcglcmglg{w id cl{n}fc{n }i~{nr u}itgknk }im~r{fnrr {ioimglg{w& IKO]U gr tn}w nddnb{gtn cfk nddgbgnf{ gf oir{ id i~} u}iuirnk uc}con{n} di} rgo~lc{gif rbnfc}gir& Aizntn},zn kgk fi{ bitn} ntn}w uirrgmln rg{~c{gif& Zagln {anu}iuirnk bifbnu{ id {agr ucun} zgll u}itgkn j~gknlgfnr {igoulnonf{c{gif id fn{zi}`, {an dgfcl rnlnb{gif id c o~l{gbcr{u}i{ibil rai~lk {c`n gf{i cbbi~f{ i{an} bifrgkn}c{gifrzagba bcffi{ mn tcl~c{nk tgc rgo~lc{gif clifn&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ ]& Ucfkg Rnltco cfk T& Uclcfgrcow “ C Un}di}ocfbn Biouc}grif id OCIKT cfk IKO]U ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr gf Oimgln Ck AibFn{zi}`r‟ u~mlgrank gf Gf{n}fc{gifcl Hi~}fcl id ]nrnc}ba cfk]ntgnzr gf Ck aib Fn{zi}`r !GH]]CF' Til& 3, Fi& 2, Rnu{nomn}=533, GRRF8 =5;4/>354&
P=_ Cmaghg{ Kcr Ri~owc Rcf`c} Mcr~ cfk C{cl Bac~ka~}g C “FitnlRnb~}g{w Rbanon di} Zg}nlnrr Ckaib Fn{zi}`‟ u~tlgrank gf Zg}nlnrrBioo~fgbc{gif, Tnagb~lc} [nbafilijw, Gfdi}oc{gif [ani}w cfkCn}irucbn $ Nlnb{}ifgb Rwr{nor [nbafilijw !Zg}nlnrr TG[CN',=533 =fk GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn =533&
P2_ W~katg} Rgfja Wijnra Bacmc Oifg`c Hcgf cfk U}cmac ]cfg“Un}di}ocfbn Ntcl~c{gif id If/Knocfk O~l{gbcr{gfj ]i~{gfjU}i{ibilr gf Oimgln Ckaib Fn{zi}`r‟ u~mlgrank gf =535Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if ]nbnf{ [}nfkr gf Gfdi}oc{gif,[nlnbioo~fgbc{gif cfk Biou~{gfj&
P;_ W~katg} Rgfja cfk K}& Wijnra Bacmc “Rnb~}g{w cfk Fn{zi}` Un}di}ocfbn Ntcl~c{gif id @@* B}wu{ij}cuagb [nbafgs~n gf OimglnCkaib Fn{zi}`r‟ u~mlgrank gf GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl CktcfbnBiou~{gfj Bifdn}nfbn !GCBB =557' Uc{gclc, Gfkgc, 4/: Oc}ba =557&
P>_ N& O& ]iwn} cfk B& N& Un}`gfr, eeO~l{gbcr{ Iun}c{gifr id {an Ck/AibIf/Knocfk Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i} ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil**, U}ibnnkgfjr id
CBO)GNNN OIMGBIO*77, uu& =5:/=31, Rnc{{ln, ZC, C~j& 3777&
P4_ O& R& Bi}rif cfk R& J& Mc{rnll, eeC ]nrn}tc{gif/Mcrnk O~l{gbcr{!]MO' ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil di} Oimgln Fn{zi}`r8 Gfg{gcl ]i~{nBifr{}~b{gif Uacrn**, CBO)Mcl{xn} Zg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`r, til& 3, fi& ;,uu& ;=:/;>5, Knb& 377>&
P:_ L& Hg cfk O& R& Bi}rif, eeC Lgja{zngja{ Ckcu{gtn O~l{gbcr{Clji}g{ao**, U}ibnnkgfjr id GNNN JLIMNBIO*71, uu& 3524/35;=,Rwkfnw, C~r{}cl, Fit& 3771&
P1_ N& Mioocgca, n{ cl&, eeCO]i~{n8 Ckaib O~l{gbcr{ ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil**,Gf{n}fn{ K}cd{, C~j& 3771, Zi}` gf u}ij}nrr&
P7_ B& Z& Z~, W& B& [cw, cfk B& @& [ia, eeCk aib O~l{gbcr{ ]i~{gfjU}i{ibil ~{glgxgfj Gfb}ncrgfj gk/f~omn}R !CO]GR' D~fb{gifclRunbgdgbc{gif**, Gf{n}fn{ K}cd{, Fit& 3771, Zi}` gf u}ij}nrr&
P35_ Nlgxcmn{a O& ]iwn} cfk Bac}lnr N& Un}`gfr& O~l{gbcr{ Iun}c{gif id {an Ck/aib If/Knocfk Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i} ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil& Gf
U}ibnnkgfjr id {an Dgd{a Cff~cl CBO)GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbnif Oimgln Biou~{gfj cfk Fn{zi}`gfj, Oimgbio ‗77, ucjnr =5:‒=31, C~j~r{ 3777&
P33_ R&/H& Lnn, Z& R~, cfk O& Jn}lc, “If/Knocfk O~l{gbcr{ ]i~{gfjU}i{ibil !IKO]U' di} Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r,‟ Gf{n}fn{/K}cd{ , k}cd{/gn{d/ocfn{/iko}u/53&{q{, H~f& 3777&
P3=_ Cuc}fc @ “ Un}di}ocfbn Biouc}grif id OCFN[ !Oimgln Ck aibFn{zi}`' U}i{ibilr !IKO]U zg{a CO]GR cfk OCIKT'‟ u~mlgrankgf Gf{n}fc{gifcl Hi~}fcl id Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr !57:> ‒ 111:'Til~on 3 ‒ Fi& 35 =535&
P32_ Hi}hn{c J& Hn{bantc cfk Kctgk M& Hiafrif “C Un}di}ocfbnBiouc}grif id If/Knocfk O~l{gbcr{ ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr di} Ck AibFn{zi}`r‟ u~mlgrank gf Knbnomn} 3>, =55; BO^/BR/5;/3:4&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 167/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;5=4)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;5=4
[an Bianrgtn Bi~f{n}oncr~}n Rbanonr di} Rnb~}gfj Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r
cjcgfr{ T~lfn}cmglg{gnr cfk C{{cb`r8 ]ntgnz
]iffgn K& Bcw{glnr
Acffco fgtn}rg{w
Kcnhnif, @i}nc
Bi}}nruifkgfj C~{ai}
[cg/aiif @go
JTRC $ fgtn}rg{w id [crocfgc
C~r{}clgc
Kiogfg` Řlėxc`
^fgtn}rg{w id Zc}rcz $ Gfdim}gja{
Zc}rcz, Uilcfk
Cmr{}cb{‛ [an {n}o “Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}` !ZRF'‟,
knfi{nr c fn{zi}` id gf{nllgjnf{ rnfri} fiknr {ac{ oifg{i}r
uawrgbcl cfk nftg}ifonf{cl bifkg{gifr cfk bcf mn knuliwnk
cfwzan}n cfk cfw{gon& ZRF u}itgknr ocfw cktcf{cjnr, m~{ g{
gr clri bi~ulnk zg{a fnz rnb~}g{w {a}nc{r cfk cl{n}r {an
i}jcfgxc{gif‗r itn}cll gfdi}oc{gif rnb~}g{w }gr` u}idgln&Cl{ai~ja goulnonf{c{gif id {nbafilijgbcl ril~{gifr gr {an ~r~cl
}nruifk {i zg}nlnrr rnb~}g{w {a}nc{r cfk t~lfn}cmglg{gnr,
zg}nlnrr rnb~}g{w gr u}goc}glw c ocfcjnonf{ grr~n& Nddnb{gtn
ocfcjnonf{ id {an {a}nc{r crribgc{nk zg{a zg}nlnrr {nbafilijw
}ns~g}nr c ri~fk cfk {ai}i~ja crrnrronf{ id }gr` jgtnf {an
nftg}ifonf{ cfk kntnliuonf{ id c ulcf {i og{gjc{n gknf{gdgnk
{a}nc{r& Gf {agr ucun}, zn r{~kw {an bianrgtn bi~f{n}oncr~}n
rbanonr di} rnb~}gfj ZRFr cjcgfr{ gknf{gdgnk t~lfn}cmglg{gnr,
{a}nc{r cfk c{{cb`r& Zn u}nrnf{ cf cfclwrgr {i anlu fn{zi}`
ocfcjn}r ~fkn}r{cfk cfk crrnrr {an tc}gi~r {a}nc{r crribgc{nk
zg{a {an ~rn id zg}nlnrr {nbafilijw& C f~omn} id ctcglcmln
ril~{gifr di} bi~f{n}gfj {airn {a}nc{r c}n kgrb~rrnk&
@nwzi}k r/ ZRF, ZRF [a}nc{r, ZRF Rnb~}g{w, rnfri}
fiknr, nfb}wu{gif
G& G F[]IK^B[GIF
ZRFr bifrgr{ id o~l{gd~fb{gif rnfri} fiknr {ac{ c}nrocll gf rgxn cfk bioo~fgbc{n zg}nlnrrlw itn} rai}{kgr{cfbnr& [an rnfri} fiknr gf{nj}c{n kgddn}nf{ u}iun}{gnr di} rnfrgfj {an nftg}ifonf{, cr znll cr kc{c u}ibnrrgfj cfkbioo~fgbc{gif coifj i{an} rnfri}r& ZRFr un}di}o cfgoui}{cf{ }iln gf ocfw cuulgbc{gifr, r~ba cr mc{{lndgnlkrr~}tngllcfbn, uc{gnf{ ancl{a oifg{i}gfj, aion c~{ioc{gif,{}cddgb bif{}il, nftg}ifonf{cl imrn}tc{gif cfk m~glkgfjgf{}~rgif r~}tngllcfbn&
[an zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`gfj acr gou}itnk u}ik~b{gtg{w
{a}i~ja gfb}ncrnk cbbnrrgmglg{w {i gfdi}oc{gif }nri~}bnr cfkncrgn}, dcr{n} cfk lnrr nqunfrgtn fn{zi}` bifdgj~}c{gif&ZRFr u}itgkn biftnfgnfbn, bir{ nddgbgnfbw, cfk ncrn id gf{nj}c{gif zg{a i{an} fn{zi}`r cfk fn{zi}` biouifnf{r&Aizntn}, zg}nlnrr {nbafilijw clri b}nc{nr fnz {a}nc{r& Rgfbnbioo~fgbc{gif di} ZRFr c}n {a}i~ja }ckgi d}ns~nfbgnr, {an}gr` id gf{n}bnu{gif gr j}nc{n} {acf zg{a zg}nk fn{zi}`r&
Gd {an onrrcjn gr fi{ nfb}wu{nk, i} nfb}wu{nk zg{a c znc` clji}g{ao, {an c{{cb`n} bcf }nck g{, {an}nmw biou}iogrgfjbifdgknf{gclg{w& Rnb~}g{w imhnb{gtnr gfbl~kn8 u}nrn}tgfjbifdgknf{gclg{w, nfr~}gfj gf{nj}g{w, cfk ocgf{cgfgfjctcglcmglg{w id {an gfdi}oc{gif cfk gfdi}oc{gif rwr{nor&
ZRFr u}nrnf{ c acfkd~l id grr~nr di} fn{zi}` ocfcjn}r&^fc~{ai}gxnk cbbnrr uigf{r, ~f`fizf r{c{gifr, bcu{~}nkfiknr, ruiidnk cb`fizlnkjnonf{r c}n h~r{ c dnz id {an
u}imlnor ckk}nrrnk gf ZRF {}i~mlnraii{gfj& Oi}nitn},ifrg{n ocgf{nfcfbn di} }noi{nlw knuliwnk rnfri} fiknr grgfdncrgmln, {a~r c {ai}i~ja bifrgkn}c{gif id rnb~}g{w ril~{gifrcfk {}i~mlnraii{gfj {iilr o~r{ mn ctcglcmln&
Gf {agr ucun}, zn gknf{gdw {an bianrgtn bi~f{n}oncr~}nrbanonr {ac{ bcf ckk}nrr {an }gr`r iddn}nk mw {an {a}nc{r cfkc{{cb`r }nlc{nk {i ZRFr& Cl{ai~ja {anrn {a}nc{r bcffi{ mn{i{cllw nlgogfc{nk, c knrg}nk lntnl id rnb~}g{w bcf mn cbagntnk
mw ckiu{gfj r~ba bi~f{n}oncr~}n& [an imhnb{gtn id {agr ucun} gr {i crrgr{ ocfcjn}r gf oc gfj knbgrgifr mw u}itgkgfj{ano zg{a c mcrgb ~fkn}r{cfkgfj id {an fc{~}n id {an tc}gi~r
{a}nc{r crribgc{nk zg{a zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`gfj cfk ctcglcmlnbi~f{n}oncr~}nr&
GG& ZRF RNB^]G[W [A]NC[R
[agr rnb{gif bitn}r {an kgddn}nf{ c{{cb`r cfk {a}nc{r {ac{}nlc{n {i ZRFr& Oir{ id {anrn c{{cb`r c}n rgoglc} {i {airn{ac{ cuulw {i {}ckg{gifcl fn{zi}`r& Aizntn} c fikn bcu{~}nc{{cb` gr c {i{cllw fnz cfk kgr{gfb{ uanfionfif zagba kinrfi{ cuulw {i {}ckg{gifcl fn{zi}`r&
C& Fikn Bcu{~}n C{{cb`
Ifn id {an kgr{gfb{ c{{cb`r gf ZRFr gr c fikn bcu{~}n& Gf{agr c{{cb`, cf c{{cb`n} jcgfr d~ll bif{}il itn} c rnfri} fikn{a}i~ja c kg}nb{ uawrgbcl cbbnrr& [anf {an c{{cb`n} bcf ncrglw
nq{}cb{ b}wu{ij}cuagb u}gog{gtnr cfk im{cgf ~flgog{nk cbbnrr{i {an gfdi}oc{gif r{i}nk if {an onoi}w bagu id {an bcu{~}nkfikn {a}i~ja c }ntn}rn nfjgfnn}gfj u}ibnrr zg{a {an ui{nf{gcl{i bc~rn r~mr{cf{gcl kcocjn {i {an nf{g}n ZRF&
[a}nn ocgf dcb{i}r {ac{ bcf cgk {an c{{cb`n}r k~}gfj cfikn bcu{~}n c{{cb`8
• Gd rnfri} fiknr zg{agf {an ZRF rac}n c `nw i} `nwrzg{a fngjami}gfj fiknr {ac{ gr ~rnk {i nfb}wu{ i} knb}wu{ kc{c&
• C fikn bcu{~}n c{{cb` acr c j}nc{ goucb{ if {anr{}~b{~}n i} {iuilijw id c ZRF&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 168/223
• [an knfrg{w id {an ZRF acr c kg}nb{ gfdl~nfbn iffikn bcu{~}n c{{cb`r, actgfj c rgoglc} cddnb{ {i {anfn{zi}` r{}~b{~}n&
M& Rgkn Bacffnl C{{cb` C rgkn bacffnl c{{cb` }ndn}r {i cfw c{{cb` {ac{ gr mcrnk if
gfdi}oc{gif jc{an}nk d}io {an uawrgbcl goulnonf{c{gif id cb}wu{irwr{no, gf bif{}cr{ {i t~lfn}cmglg{gnr gf {an clji}g{aog{rnld P7_& Di} nqcouln {an c{{cb`n} oifg{i}r {an uizn} bifr~ou{gif i} {an nlnb{}iocjfn{gb !NO' nocfc{gif d}ior~ba b}wu{ij}cuagb kntgbnr, cfk {anf cfclwxnr {an billnb{nkkc{c {i nq{}cb{ {an crribgc{nk b}wu{i `nw&
Rgkn bacffnl c{{cb`r gfbl~kn8• Rgouln uizn} cfclwrgr !RUC' gr c {nbafgs~n {ac{
gftiltnr kg}nb{lw gf{n}u}n{gfj uizn} bifr~ou{gifoncr~}nonf{r billnb{nk k~}gfj b}wu{ij}cuagbiun}c{gifr& Fi r{c{gr{gbcl cfclwrgr gr }ns~g}nk gf r~bacf c{{cb` P>_&
• Rgouln nlnb{}iocjfn{gb cfclwrgr !RNOC' cfcktn}rc}w gr cmln {i nq{}cb{ biou}iogrgfjgfdi}oc{gif d}io c rgfjln nlnb{}iocjfn{gb rcoulnP;_&
• Gf kgddn}nf{gcl uizn} cfclwrgr !KUC' cf cktn}rc}woifg{i}r {an uizn} bifr~onk mw b}wu{ij}cuagbkntgbnr, cfk {anf r{c{gr{gbcllw cfclwxnr {an billnb{nkkc{c {i nq{}cb{ c `nw gf bif{}cr{ {i {an rgouln uizn} cfclwrgr P>_&
• Gf kgddn}nf{gcl nlnb{}iocjfn{gb cfclwrgr !KNOC',gfr{nck id oifg{i}gfj {an uizn} bifr~ou{gif, cfc{{cb`n} oifg{i}r nlnb{}iocjfn{gb nocfc{gifr d}iob}wu{ij}cuagb kntgbnr, cfk {anf {an rcon r{c{gr{gbclcfclwrgr cr {ac{ di} {an kgddn}nf{gcl uizn} cfclwrgr gr
un}di}onk if {an billnb{nk nlnb{}iocjfn{gb kc{c {inq{}cb{ rnb}n{ uc}con{n}r P;_&
B& Knfgcl id Rn}tgbnr !KiR'
C Knfgcl/id/Rn}tgbn c{{cb` !KiR' ibb~}r zanf cfc{{cb`n} bif{gf~cllw miomc}kr c {c}jn{nk CU !Cbbnrr Uigf{'i} fn{zi}` zg{a mij~r }ns~nr{r, u}noc{~}n r~bbnrrd~lbiffnb{gif onrrcjnr, dcgl~}n onrrcjnr, cfk)i} i{an} bioocfkr& KiR gr cf ntnf{ {ac{ kgogfgranr i} nlgogfc{nr cfn{zi}`‗r bcucbg{w {i un}di}o g{r nqunb{nk d~fb{gif {a}i~jaac}kzc}n dcgl~}nr, rid{zc}n m~jr, }nri~}bn nqac~r{gif,oclgbgi~r m}ickbcr{gfj id agja nfn}jw rgjfclr,nftg}ifonf{cl bifkg{gifr, i} cfw bioulgbc{nk gf{n}cb{gif
mn{znnf {anrn dcb{i}r P33_&
Bioo~fgbc{gif rwr{nor bi~lk mn hcoonk biouln{nlw gd r~ba c{{cb`r r~bbnnk& I{an} knfgcl id rn}tgbn c{{cb`r c}n clri
uirrgmln, n&j&, gfagmg{gfj bioo~fgbc{gif mw tgilc{gfj {anOCB u}i{ibil& [anrn bc~rn lnjg{goc{n ~rn}r {i fi{ mn cmln {ijn{ if {an fn{zi}` cfk ocw ntnf bc~rn {an fn{zi}` {i b}cra&[anrn c{{cb`r }nlw if {an cm~rn id u}i{ibilr r~ba cr {anNq{nfrgmln C~{anf{gbc{gif U}i{ibil !NCU'&
K& Rid{zc}n C{{cb`r
Gf Rid{zc}n/mcrnk c{{cb`r if ZRFr, cf c{{cb`n} ocw {}w{i oikgdw {an rid{zc}n bikn gf onoi}w i} nqulig{ `fizft~lfn}cmglg{gnr gf {an rid{zc}n bikn& C znll/`fizf nqcoulnid r~ba cf c{{cb` gr c m~ddn} itn}dliz c{{cb` zan}n c u}ibnrr
c{{nou{r {i r{i}n kc{c mnwifk {an mi~fkc}gnr id c dgqnklnfj{a m~ddn}, {a~r, }nr~l{gfj gf {an nq{}c kc{c itn}z}g{gfj {anckhcbnf{ onoi}w libc{gifr&
N& ]i~{gfj C{{cb`rCr knrb}gmnk nc}lgn}, ntn}w fikn cb{r cr c }i~{n} gf c
ZRF& ]i~{gfj cfk kc{c di}zc}kgfj c}n cf goui}{cf{ {cr` di} rnfri} fiknr& ]i~{gfj u}i{ibilr actn {i mn nfn}jw cfkonoi}w nddgbgnf{, m~{ c{ {an rcon {gon {anw actn {i mn }im~r{cjcgfr{ c{{cb`r cfk fikn dcgl~}nr& [an}n actn mnnf ocfw
uizn}/nddgbgnf{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr u}iuirnk di} ZRFr&Aizntn}, oir{ id {ano r~ddn} d}io rnb~}g{w t~lfn}cmglg{gnrid ifn ri}{ i} cfi{an}& Gf {an }ncl zi}lk, c rnb~}n }i~{gfj
u}i{ibil rai~lk j~c}cf{nn {an gf{nj}g{w, c~{anf{gbg{w cfkctcglcmglg{w id onrrcjnr gf {an nqgr{nfbn id cktn}rc}gnr id c}mg{}c}w uizn}& Ntn}w c~{ai}gxnk }nbngtn} rai~lk }nbngtn cllonrrcjnr u}iuirnk di} g{ cfk rai~lk mn bcucmln id u}itgfj{an gf{nj}g{w id ntn}w onrrcjn cfk clri {an gknf{g{w id {anrnfkn}&
Rion id {an }i~{gfj u}i{ibil c{{cb`r c}n {an dillizgfjP35_8
• Mlcb` ailn c{{cb`r i} ucb`n{ k}iu c{{cb`0• Ruiidnk, cl{n}nk, i} }nulcwnk c{{cb`0• Zi}oailnr c{{cb`0• Rnlnb{gtn di}zc}kgfj c{{cb`0• Rgf`ailn c{{cb`0• ANLLI dliik c{{cb`0• Cb`fizlnkjnonf{ ruiidgfj&
D& [}cddgb Cfclwrgr C{{cb`r
Cll bioo~fgbc{gif gr ZRFr gr oitgfj {izc}k c mcrnr{c{gif gf ocfw/{i/ifn i} ocfw/{i/dnz uc{{n}fr& Cf c{{cb`n}
gr cmln {i jc{an} o~ba gfdi}oc{gif if {an {iuilijw id {anfn{zi}` cr znll cr {an libc{gif id {an mcrn r{c{gif cfk i{an} r{}c{njgb fiknr mw imrn}tgfj {}cddgb til~onr cfk uc{{n}f&
[an}n c}n {zi {wunr id {}cddgb cfclwrgr c{{cb`r gf ZRFr8 c}c{n oifg{i}gfj c{{cb` cfk c {gon bi}}nlc{gif c{{cb`& Gf c }c{noifg{i}gfj c{{cb` cf c{{cb`n} oifg{i}r {an ucb`n{ rnfkgfj}c{n id fiknr fnc} {an c{{cb`n} cfk oitnr blirn} {i {an fiknr{ac{ actn c agjan} ucb`n{ rnfkgfj }c{n& Gf c {gon bi}}nlc{gifc{{cb` cf c{{cb`n} imrn}tnr {an bi}}nlc{gif gf rnfkgfj {gon
mn{znnf c fikn cfk g{r fngjami} fikn {ac{ gr crr~onk {i mndi}zc}kgfj {an rcon ucb`n{ cfk knk~bnr {an uc{a mwdillizgfj {an ri~fk di} ncba di}zc}kgfj iun}c{gif cr {an
ucb`n{ u}iucjc{nr {izc}kr {an mcrn r{c{gif P2_&
J& Rwmgl C{{cb`r[an Rwmgl c{{cb` gr kndgfnk cr c oclgbgi~r kntgbn
gllnjg{goc{nlw {c`gfj if o~l{guln gknf{g{gnr& Di} nqcouln, coclgbgi~r fikn bcf blcgo dclrn gknf{g{gnr, i} goun}rifc{ni{an} lnjg{goc{n fiknr gf {an fn{zi}` P3_P=_& [an Rwmgl c{{cb` bcf cddnb{ c f~omn} id kgddn}nf{ u}i{ibilr r~ba cr {andillizgfj8
• Kgr{}gm~{nk r{i}cjn u}i{ibilr0• ]i~{gfj u}i{ibilr0• Kc{c cjj}njc{gif !~rnk gf s~n}w u}i{ibilr'0• Ti{gfj !~rnk gf ocfw {}~r{ rbanonr'0• Dcg} }nri~}bn cllibc{gif u}i{ibilr0• Ogrmnactgi} kn{nb{gif u}i{ibilr&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 169/223
[i c{{cb` }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr c Rwmgl c{{cb` zi~lk }nlw if coclgbgi~r fikn {c`gfj if {an gknf{g{w id o~l{guln fiknr, {a~r}i~{gfj o~l{guln uc{ar {a}i~ja c rgfjln oclgbgi~r fikn&Aizntn} {an Rwmgl c{{cb` bcf iun}c{n gf kgddn}nf{ zcwr {ic{{cb` {an u}i{ibilr lgr{nk cmitn&
A& C{{cb`r if Gf/Fn{zi}` U}ibnrrgfj
Kc{c cjj}njc{gif i} gf/fn{zi}` u}ibnrrgfj gr tn}w ~rnd~lgf {n}or id }nk~bgfj {an bioo~fgbc{gif itn}anck& Aizntn} {an}n bcf mn kgddn}nf{ {wunr id c{{cb` if gf/fn{zi}`
u}ibnrrgfj8• Biou}iogrn c fikn uawrgbcllw {i cddnb{ cjj}njc{nk
}nr~l{r P3=_0• C{{cb` cjj}njc{i} fiknr ~rgfj kgddn}nf{ c{{cb`r0• Rnfk dclrn gfdi}oc{gif {i cddnb{ {an cjj}njc{gif
}nr~l{r&
G& C{{cb`r if [gon Rwfba}ifgxc{gif U}i{ibilr
[gon rwfba}ifgxc{gif u}i{ibilr u}itgkn c onbacfgro di} rwfba}ifgxgfj {an libcl blib`r id fiknr gf c rnfri} fn{zi}`&[a}nn id {an oir{ u}iogfnf{ u}i{ibilr c}n {an }ndn}nfbn
m}ickbcr{ rwfba}ifgxc{gif !]MR' u}i{ibil, [gogfj/rwfbU}i{ibil di} Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r ![URF' cfk Dliikgfj [gonRwfba}ifgxc{gif U}i{ibil !D[RU'&
Rgfbn oir{ id {an {gon rwfba}ifgxc{gif u}i{ibilr ki fi{bifrgkn} rnb~}g{w, cf c{{cb`n} bcf uawrgbcllw bcu{~}n cd}cb{gif id {an fiknr cfk gfhnb{gfj {ano zg{a dc~l{w {gonrwfba}ifgxc{gif onrrcjn ~ukc{nr ncrglw& [agr ntnf{ bcfoc`n {an fiknr gf {an nf{g}n fn{zi}` i~{/id/rwfb zg{a ncbai{an}&
H& ]nulgbc{gif C{{cb`r
[an}n c}n {zi zcwr {i lc~fba }nulgbc{gif c{{cb`r gfZRFr& Dg}r{, cf c{{cb`n} bcf nctnrk}iu if bioo~fgbc{gifrcfk }nrnfk ilk ucb`n{r cjcgf o~l{guln {gonr gf i}kn} {i zcr{ng{r fngjami}gfj rnfri} fiknr‗ nfn}jw& [anf, cf c{{cb`n} bcfgfrn}{ ckkg{gifcl }nulgbc{nk air{gln rnfri} fiknr gf{i {anZRF cd{n} im{cgfgfj rion rnb}n{ gfdi}oc{gif d}io bcu{~}nkrnfri} fiknr i} {a}i~ja gfdgl{}c{gif&
GGG& ZRF RNB^]G[W [A]NC[R BI^F[N]ONCR^]N
RBANONR
C& Rnb~}gfj {an Bifdgknf{gclg{w id ZRF Kc{c [}cfrogrrgif
Rntn}cl {wunr id bi~f{n}oncr~}nr nqgr{ di} }nk~bgfj {an}gr` id nctnrk}iuugfj if zg}nlnrr {}cfrogrrgifr& [an dg}r{
gftiltnr on{aikr di} oc`gfj g{ oi}n kgddgb~l{ {i libc{n cfkgf{n}bnu{ {an zg}nlnrr rgjfclr& [an rnbifk gftiltnr {an ~rn id nfb}wu{gif {i u}nrn}tn bifdgknf{gclg{w ntnf gd {an zg}nlnrrrgjfcl gr gf{n}bnu{nk& [an }nr{ c}n c{{cb` runbgdgbbi~f{n}oncr~}nr&
3' Rgjfcl Agkgfj [nbafgs~nr8 Gf i}kn} {i gf{n}bnu{
zg}nlnrr {}cfrogrrgifr, c{{cb`n}r dg}r{ fnnk {i gknf{gdw cfk
libc{n zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r& [an}n c}n, aizntn}, c f~omn} id
r{nur {ac{ i}jcfgxc{gifr bcf {c`n {i oc`n g{ oi}n kgddgb~l{ {i
libc{n {ang} zg}nlnrr cbbnrr uigf{r& [an ncrgnr{ cfk lncr{
bir{lw gfbl~kn {an dillizgfj8 [~}fgfj idd {an rn}tgbn rn{
gknf{gdgn} !RRGK' m}ickbcr{gfj mw zg}nlnrr cbbnrr uigf{r,
Crrgjf b}wu{gb fconr {i RRGKr, ]nk~bgfj rgjfcl r{}nfj{a {i
{an liznr{ lntnl {ac{ r{gll u}itgknr }ns~grg{n bitn}cjn i}
Libc{gfj zg}nlnrr cbbnrr uigf{r gf {an gf{n}gi} id {an
m~glkgfj, czcw d}io zgfkizr cfk nq{n}gi} zcllr& Oi}nnddnb{gtn, m~{ clri oi}n bir{lw on{aikr di} }nk~bgfj i}
agkgfj rgjfclr gfbl~kn8 ^rgfj kg}nb{gifcl cf{nffcr {i
bifr{}cgf rgjfcl nocfc{gifr zg{agf knrg}nk c}ncr id bitn}cjn
i} ^rgfj id rgjfcl nocfc{gif/ragnlkgfj {nbafgs~nr,
rion{gonr }ndn}}nk {i cr [NOUNR[, 3 {i mlib` nocfc{gif
id zg}nlnrr rgjfclr&
=' [an ^rn id Nfb}wu{gif8 [an mnr{ on{aik di}
u}i{nb{gfj {an bifdgknf{gclg{w id gfdi}oc{gif {}cfrog{{nk
itn} zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r gr {i nfb}wu{ i} rb}comln cll zg}nlnrr
{}cddgb cfk bioo~fgbc{gifr itn} {an fn{zi}`& [agr gr
nrunbgcllw goui}{cf{ di} i}jcfgxc{gifr r~mhnb{ {i }nj~lc{gifr&
[zi {wunr id bi~f{n}oncr~}nr bcf rgjfgdgbcf{lw }nk~bn
{an }gr` id r~ba c{{cb`r8 r{}ifj nfb}wu{gif cfk r{}ifjc~{anf{gbc{gif id mi{a kntgbnr cfk ~rn}r&
2' Bi~f{n}oncr~}nr cjcgfr{ Knfgcl id Rn}tgbn C{{cb`r8
Zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gifr c}n clri t~lfn}cmln {i knfgcl/id/
rn}tgbn !KiR' c{{cb`r& I}jcfgxc{gifr bcf {c`n rntn}cl r{nur
{i }nk~bn {an }gr` id r~ba ~fgf{nf{gifcl KiR c{{cb`r& Bc}nd~l
rg{n r~}tnwr bcf gknf{gdw libc{gifr zan}n rgjfclr d}io i{an}
kntgbnr nqgr{0 {an }nr~l{r id r~ba r~}tnwr rai~lk mn ~rnk
zanf knbgkgfj zan}n {i libc{n zg}nlnrr cbbnrr uigf{r&
]nj~lc} un}gikgb c~kg{r id zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`gfj cb{gtg{w cfk
un}di}ocfbn bcf gknf{gdw u}imlno c}ncr0 cuu}iu}gc{n
}nonkgcl cb{gifr ocw gfbl~kn }noitcl id {an iddnfkgfj
kntgbnr i} oncr~}nr {i gfb}ncrn rgjfcl r{}nfj{a cfk bitn}cjn
zg{agf {an u}imlno c}nc& [an r~ooc}w id bi~f{n}oncr~}nr
di} kgddn}nf{ KiR c{{cb`r c}n knugb{nk gf [cmln 3&
[CMLN G& ZRF LCWN]R CFK KIR KNDNFRNR
Rnfri} fn{zi}` lcwn}r cfk knfgcl/id/rn}tgbnr kndnfrn
Fn{zi}` lcwn}
C{{cb`r Kndnfrnr
Uawrgbcl Hcoogfj
[coun}gfj
Ru}nck/runb{}~o, u}gi}g{w
onrrcjn, lizn} K~{w
bwbln,}njgif ocuugfj,
oikn bacfjn[coun}/u}iidgfj,
agkgfj
Lgf` Billgrgif
Nqac~r{gif
^fdcg}fnrr
N}}i}/bi}}nb{gif
bikn
]c{n lgog{c{gif
Rocll d}conr
Fn{zi}` cfk]i~{gfj
Fnjlnb{ cfkj}nnk
Aiogfj
Ogrkg}nb{gif
]nk~fkcfbw, u}imgfj
Nfb}wu{gif
Nj}nrr dgl{n}gfj,
c~{anf{gbc{gif,
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 170/223
Mlcb` Ailnr oifg{i}gfj
C~{ai}gxc{gif,
oifg{i}gfj,
}nk~fkcfbw[}cfrui}{ Dliikgfj
Kn/
rwfba}ifgxc{gif
Blgnf{ u~xxlnr
C~{anf{gbc{gif
;' Bi~f{n}oncr~}nr cjcgfr{ Rid{zc}n C{{cb`r8 [an
dillizgfj bi~f{n}oncr~}n bcf mn bifrgkn}nk {i rnb~}n {an
ZRF rid{zc}n cfk mn u}i{nb{nk d}io mngfj nqulig{nk mw
oclgbgi~r ~rn}r8
• Rid{zc}n c~{anf{gbc{gif cfk tclgkc{gif, n&j&, }noi{n
rid{zc}n/mcrnk c{{nr{c{gif di} rnfri} fn{zi}`r0
• Kndgfgfj cbb~}c{n {}~r{ mi~fkc}gnr di} kgddn}nf{
biouifnf{r cfk ~rn}r0
• ^rgfj c }nr{}gb{nk nftg}ifonf{ r~ba cr {an HctcTg}{~cl Ocbagfn0
• Kwfcogb }~f/{gon nfb}wu{gif)knb}wu{gif di}
rid{zc}n& [agr gr rgoglc} {i nfb}wu{gif)knb}wu{gif id
kc{c nqbnu{ {ac{ {an bikn }~ffgfj if {an kntgbn gr
nfb}wu{nk& [agr bcf u}ntnf{r c oclgbgi~r ~rn} d}io
nqulig{gfj {an rid{zc}n0
• Ac}kzc}n c{{nr{c{gif& [an {}~r{nk biou~{gfj j}i~u
ulc{di}o cfk fnq{ jnfn}c{gif rnb~}n biou~{gfj mcrn
u}itgkn {agr {wun id c{{nr{c{gif& C rgoglc} oiknl
bi~lk mn ~rnk gf rnfri} fn{zi}`r&
>' Bi~f{n}oncr~}nr cjcgfr{ Rwmgl C{{cb`r8 U}iuirnk
ril~{gifr {i {an Rwmgl c{{cb` gfbl~kn {an dillizgfj8
• }ckgi }nri~}bn {nr{gfj zagba }nlgnr if {an crr~ou{gif
{ac{ ncba uawrgbcl kntgbn acr iflw ifn }ckgi0
• }cfkio `nw u}n/kgr{}gm~{gif zagba crribgc{nr {an
gknf{g{w id ncba fikn {i {an `nwr crrgjfnk {i g{ cfk
tclgkc{nr {an `nwr {i nr{cmlgra zan{an} {an fikn gr
}ncllw zai g{ blcgor {i mn0
• }njgr{}c{gif id {an fikn gknf{g{gnr c{ c bnf{}cl mcrn
r{c{gif0 cfk
• Uirg{gif tn}gdgbc{gif zagba oc`nr {an crr~ou{gif
{ac{ {an ZRF {iuilijw gr r{c{gb&
M& Rnb~}gfj {an ZRF Cbbnrr Uigf{
Gfrnb~}n, uii}lw bifdgj~}nk zg}nlnrr cbbnrr uigf{r bcf
biou}iogrn bifdgknf{gclg{w mw cllizgfj ~fc~{ai}gxnk cbbnrr{i {an fn{zi}`& I}jcfgxc{gifr bcf }nk~bn {an }gr` id ~fc~{ai}gxnk cbbnrr {i zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r mw {c`gfj {anrn{a}nn r{nur8
3& Nlgogfc{gfj }ij~n cbbnrr uigf{r& [an mnr{ on{aik di} knclgfj zg{a {an {a}nc{ id }ij~n cbbnrr uigf{r gr {i~rn 15=&3q if {an zg}nk fn{zi}` {i c~{anf{gbc{n cllkntgbnr {ac{ c}n ul~jjnk gf{i {an fn{zi}`& ^rgfj15=&3q zgll u}ntnf{ cfw ~fc~{ai}gxnk kntgbnr d}iobiffnb{gfj {i {an fn{zi}`0
=& U}iun}lw bifdgj~}gfj cll c~{ai}gxnk cbbnrr uigf{r&I}jcfgxc{gifr clri fnnk {i nfr~}n {ac{ cll c~{ai}gxnkzg}nlnrr cbbnrr uigf{r c}n rnb~}nlw bifdgj~}nk& G{ gr
nrunbgcllw goui}{cf{ {i bacfjn cll kndc~l{ rn{{gfjr mnbc~rn {anw c}n znll `fizf cfk bcf mn nqulig{nk mwc{{cb`n}r0 cfk
2& ^rgfj 15=&3q {i c~{anf{gbc{n cll kntgbnr& R{}ifjc~{anf{gbc{gif id cll kntgbnr c{{nou{gfj {i biffnb{ {i{an fn{zi}` bcf u}ntnf{ }ij~n cbbnrr uigf{r cfki{an} ~fc~{ai}gxnk kntgbnr d}io mnbiogfj gfrnb~}n
mcb`kii}r& [an 15=&3q u}i{ibil kgrb~rrnk nc}lgn} u}itgknr c oncfr di} r{}ifjlw c~{anf{gbc{gfj kntgbnr u}gi} {i crrgjfgfj {ano GU ckk}nrrnr&
B& I{an} Bi~f{n}oncr~}nr
[an dillizgfj c}n rntn}cl {gur di} bi~f{n}gfj c{{cb`r cfknfr~}gfj rnb~}g{w di} ZRFr8
• ^rn cf{g/tg}~r cfk cf{g/ruwzc}n rid{zc}n, cfk cdg}nzcll& Biou~{n}r if c zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` fnnk {anrcon u}i{nb{gifr cr cfw biou~{n} biffnb{nk {i {anGf{n}fn{& Gfr{cll cf{g/tg}~r cfk cf{g/ruwzc}n rid{zc}n,cfk `nnu {ano ~u/{i/kc{n& Gd wi~} dg}nzcll zcrraguunk gf {an “idd‟ oikn, {~}f g{ if0
• [~}f idd gknf{gdgn} m}ickbcr{gfj& Oir{ zg}nlnrr}i~{n}r actn c onbacfgro bcllnk gknf{gdgn}
m}ickbcr{gfj& G{ rnfkr i~{ c rgjfcl {i cfw kntgbn gf{an tgbgfg{w cffi~fbgfj g{r u}nrnfbn& Wi~ kif‗{ fnnk{i m}ickbcr{ {agr gfdi}oc{gif gd {an un}rif ~rgfj {anfn{zi}` cl}nckw `fizr g{ gr {an}n& Acb`n}r bcf ~rngknf{gdgn} m}ickbcr{gfj {i aion gf if t~lfn}cmlnzg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r& Kgrcmln {an gknf{gdgn} m}ickbcr{gfjonbacfgro gd wi~} zg}nlnrr }i~{n} cllizr g{0
• Bacfjn {an gknf{gdgn} if wi~} }i~{n} d}io {an kndc~l{&[an gknf{gdgn} di} wi~} }i~{n} gr lg`nlw {i mn cr{cfkc}k, kndc~l{ GK crrgjfnk mw {an ocf~dcb{~}n} {icll ac}kzc}n id {ac{ oiknl& Ntnf gd wi~} }i~{n} gr fi{
m}ickbcr{gfj g{r gknf{gdgn} {i {an zi}lk, acb`n}r `fiz{an kndc~l{ GKr cfk bcf ~rn {ano {i {}w {i cbbnrr wi~} fn{zi}`& Bacfjn wi~} gknf{gdgn} {i rion{agfj iflwwi~ `fiz, cfk }nonomn} {i bifdgj~}n {an rcon~fgs~n GK gf{i wi~} zg}nlnrr }i~{n} cfk wi~} biou~{n} ri {anw bcf bioo~fgbc{n& ^rn c ucrrzi}k{ac{‗r c{ lncr{ 35 bac}cb{n}r lifj8 [an lifjn} wi~}
ucrrzi}k, {an ac}kn} g{ gr di} acb`n}r {i m}nc`0• Bacfjn wi~} }i~{n}‗r u}n/rn{ ucrrzi}k di}
ckogfgr{}c{gif& [an ocf~dcb{~}n} id wi~} zg}nlnrr}i~{n} u}imcmlw crrgjfnk g{ c r{cfkc}k kndc~l{
ucrrzi}k {ac{ cllizr wi~ {i rn{ ~u cfk iun}c{n {an}i~{n}& Acb`n}r `fiz {anrn kndc~l{ ucrrzi}kr, ribacfjn g{ {i rion{agfj iflw wi~ `fiz& [an lifjn} {an ucrrzi}k, {an {i~jan} g{ gr {i b}cb`0
• Clliz iflw runbgdgb biou~{n}r {i cbbnrr wi~} zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`& Ntn}w biou~{n} {ac{ gr cmln {ibioo~fgbc{n zg{a c fn{zi}` gr crrgjfnk g{r izf~fgs~n Onkgc Cbbnrr Bif{}il !OCB' ckk}nrr&Zg}nlnrr }i~{n}r ~r~cllw actn c onbacfgro {i clliziflw kntgbnr zg{a uc}{gb~lc} OCB ckk}nrrnr cbbnrr{i {an fn{zi}`& Rion acb`n}r actn ogogb`nk OCBckk}nrrnr, ri kif‗{ }nlw if {agr r{nu clifn0
• [~}f idd wi~} zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` zanf wi~ `fiz wi~zif‗{ ~rn g{& Acb`n}r bcffi{ cbbnrr c zg}nlnrr }i~{n} zanf g{ gr ra~{ kizf& Gd wi~ {~}f {an }i~{n} idd zanf
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 171/223
wi~‗}n fi{ ~rgfj g{, wi~ lgog{ {an coi~f{ id {gon {ac{g{ gr r~rbnu{gmln {i c acb`0
• Kif‗{ crr~on {ac{ u~mlgb “ai{ rui{r‟ c}n rnb~}n&Ocfw bcdçr, ai{nlr, cg}ui}{r, cfk i{an} u~mlgbnr{cmlgraonf{r iddn} zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r di} {ang} b~r{ion}r‗ ~rn&
[an cmitn onf{gifnk bi~f{n}oncr~}n {gur c}n cuulgbcmln{i zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r, wn{, rion id {ano ocw cuulw {i ZRFrkg}nb{lw&
GT& BIFBL^RGIF
ZRFr uiu~lc}g{w gr k~n gf uc}{ {i {ang} rocll rgxn cfkliz bir{ id rnfri}r, {ang} iun}c{gifr cfk {ang} fn{zi}`gfj
mnactgi}, nfcmlgfj {ano {i u}itgkn rgjfgdgbcf{ cktcf{cjnr di} ocfw cuulgbc{gifr {ac{ zi~lk fi{ actn mnnf uirrgmln gf {an
ucr{& [anw bcf u}itgkn c f~on}i~r iuui}{~fg{gnr {i gfb}ncrn u}ik~b{gtg{w cfk ogfgogxn bir{r&
Gf {agr ucun} zn actn gknf{gdgnk cfk knrb}gmnk {ankgddn}nf{ t~lfn}cmglg{gnr, {a}nc{r cfk c{{cb`r {ac{ bi~lk uirrgmlw u~{ ZRFr gf c tg{cl i} b}g{gbcl rg{~c{gif& [anrn{a}nc{r c}n cfclwxnk cfk bc{nji}gxnk {i dgfk cfk blcrrgdw {anbi~f{n}oncr~}n rbanonr cuulgbcmln {i og{gjc{n {an }gr`r di} ncba bc{nji}w& C }ncrifcmln cfk u}cb{gbcl lntnl id rnb~}g{w gr
uirrgmlw cbagntnk mw ckiu{gfj c rwr{noc{gb cuu}icba {icrrnrrgfj cfk ocfcjgfj }gr` }njc}klnrr id cll {an {a}nc{r cfkc{{cb`r&
C }nj~lc} r{~kw if {an non}jgfj {a}nc{r rai~lk mnbifrgkn}nk {i nfr~}n {an rnb~}g{w {i mn ocgf{cgfnk c{ cknrg}nk lntnl& Ocfw }nrnc}ba bacllnfjnr o~r{ mn ckk}nrrnk gfi}kn} di} ZRFr {i mn }nclgr{gbcllw goulnonf{nk cfk di} {ano{i mnbion uc}{ id ntn}wkcw lgdn&
] NDN]NFBNR
P3_ [& ]iir{c, R& Ragna, R& Rcr{}w8 [cqifiow id Rnb~}g{w C{{cb`r gfRnfri} Fn{zi}`r, 3r{ GNNN Gf{& Bifdn}nfbn if Rwr{no Gf{nj}c{gifcfk ]nlgcmglg{w Gou}itnonf{r =554, Acfig !=554' uu& 32‒3>&
P=_ C& Un}}gj, H& Fnzrion, N& Rag, K& Rifj8 [an Rwmgl C{{cb` gf Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r8 Cfclwrgr cfk Kndnfbnr, 2}k Gf{& Rwouirg~o ifGfdi}oc{gif U}ibnrrgfj gf Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r =55; !CBO U}nrr, FnzWi}`, RC =55;' uu& =>7‒=41&
P2_ H& Knfj, ]& Acf, R& Ogra}c8 Bi~f{n}oncr~}nr Cjcgfr{ [}cddgbCfclwrgr C{{cb`r gf Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r, Dg}r{ GNNN)Bn}c{n Fn{Bifdn}nfbn if Rnb~}g{w cfk U}gtcbw gf Bioo~fgbc{gif Fn{zi}`r!Rnb~}nBioo' =55>, C{anfr !=55>' uu& 332‒3=;&
P;_ @& Jcfkil, B& Oi~}{nl, D& Ilgtgn}, “Nlnb{}iocjfn{gb Cfclwrgr8Bifb}n{n ]nr~l{r‟, U~mlgrank gf BY &@& @iYb, K& Fcbbcban, cfk B&Ucc}, Nkr&, B}wu{ij}cuagb Ac}kzc}n cfk Nomnkknk Rwr{nor p BANR=553, til& =34= id Lnb{~}n Fi{nr gf Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn, uu& =>3p=43,Ru}gfjn}/Tn}lcj, =553&
P>_ “Uizn} Cfclwrgr‟, a{{u8))nf&zg`gunkgc&i}j)zg`g)Uizn}Ycfclwrgr,Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn}, =533&
P4_ “Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r‟, a{{u8))nf&zg`gunkgc&i}j)zg`g)Zg}nlnrrYrnfri}Yfn{zi}`, Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn} =533&
P:_ H&F& Cl/@c}c`g, C&N& @cocl8 ]i~{gfj {nbafgs~nr gf zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r8 C r~}tnw, GNNN Zg}nl& Bioo~f& 33!4', 4‒=1 !=55;'&
P1_ D& Wn, A& L~i, H& Banfj, R& L~, L& Xacfj8 C [zi/[gn} Kc{cKgrrnogfc{gif Oiknl di} Lc}jn/Rbcln Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`r,CBO)GNNN OIMGBIO =55= !=55=' uu& 3;1‒3>7&
P7_ [& ]iir{c, R& Ragna, R& Rcr{}w8 [cqifiow id Rnb~}g{w C{{cb`r gfRnfri} Fn{zi}`r, 3r{ GNNN Gf{& Bifdn}nfbn if Rwr{no Gf{nj}c{gifcfk ]nlgcmglg{w Gou}itnonf{r =554, Acfig !=554' uu& 32‒3>&
P35_ W&/B& A~, C& Un}}gj, K&M& Hiafrif8 Ck}gcfn8 C Rnb~}n If/Knocfk]i~{gfj U}i{ibil di} Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r, Cff~cl CBO Gf{&Bifdn}nfbn if Oimgln Biou~{gfj cfk Fn{zi}`gfj !OimgBio' =55=!=55='&
P33_ “Knfgcl/id/Rn}tgbn C{{cb`‟, a{{u8))nf&zg`gunkgc&i}j)zg`g)Knfgcl/id/rn}tgbnYc{{cb`, Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn}, =533&
P3=_ @& @gdcwc{, O& On}cm{g, S& Rag, K& Llnznllwf/Hifnr8 J}i~u/mcrnkrnb~}n bioo~fgbc{gif di} lc}jn rbcln zg}nlnrr rnfri} fn{zi}`r, H&Gfdi}oc{gif Crr~}cfbn Rnb~}g{w& =!=', 327‒3;: !=55:'&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 172/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;522)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;522
C ]im~r{ Knrgjf id ][^ Rnfri} Fiknr Bioo~fgbc{gif di} RBCKC Rwr{nor
Rcmca Oiacoonk
Knuc}{onf{ id Biou~{n} Rbgnfbn,
Lc`nanck fgtn}rg{w,
BCFCKC
]iffgn K& Bcw{glnr
Knuc}{onf{ id O~l{gonkgc
Nfjgfnn}gfj, Acffco fgtn}rg{w
Kcnhnif, @i}nc
[cg/aiif @go
JTRC cfk ^fgtn}rg{w id [crocfgc
C~r{}clgc
Cmr{}cb{‛ RBCKC Bioo~fgbc{gif ulcwr c tg{cl }iln di}
R~un}tgri}w Bif{}il cfk Kc{c Cbs~grg{gif !RBCKC'
Oifg{i}gfj Rwr{nor& [an nc}lw RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gif {ii`
ulcbn itn} }ckgi, oikno, i} knkgbc{nk rn}gcl lgfnr& [ikcw, g{ gr
o~ba oi}n biooif di} RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gifr {i {}ctnl
itn} LCF i} ZLCF& [agr u}ibnrr id bioo~fgbc{gif itn} c
RBCKC rwr{no gftiltnr rntn}cl kgddn}nf{ RBCKC rwr{no
biouifnf{r {ac{ gfbl~kn {an rnfri}r cfk bif{}il }nlcwr,
]noi{n [n}ogfcl ^fg{r !][^r', RBCKC ocr{n} ~fg{r, cfk {an
itn}cll bioo~fgbc{gif fn{zi}`& Cktcfbnk ][^r zan}n oir{
RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gif gr jc{an}nk zg{agf {an rwr{no, c}n
knuliwnk di} c oi}n biouln{n oifg{i}gfj& [an kgddn}nf{ tcl~nr
d}io gfu~{r cfk i~{u~{r, }ndn}}nk {i cr RBCKC uigf{r, c}n
rnf{ d}io gfkgtgk~cl rnfri}r {i {an ][^ zagba gr }nruifrgmln
di} di}zc}kgfj {anrn RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gifr {i {an ocr{n}
r{c{gif, i} A~ocf/Ocbagfn Gf{n}dcbn !AOG'& [agr ucun}
u}iuirnr cf ]D‒JRO Nfcmlnk RBCKC ][^ Bioo~fgbc{gif
di} Rnfri} Fiknr {ac{ ~{glgxnr {an ctcglcmln bioo~fgbc{gif
fn{zi}`r r~ba cr bnll~lc} uaifn fn{zi}` cfk }ckgi d}ns~nfbw
di} nqbacfjgfj kc{c {i ogfgogxn bir{ cfk a~ocf nddi}{& [an
cuu}icba oc`nr ~rn id {an JRO fn{zi}`, c b~r{io ]D
ril~{gif, c liz/bir{ ogb}ibif{}illn}, cfk rid{zc}n nomnkknk {iogb}ibif{}illn}r gr kntnliunk {i }~f {an itn}cll u}ibnrr&
@nwzi}kr/ ]D, JRO, ][^, RBCKC rwr{nor, Rnfri} Fiknr G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
[an {}ckg{gifcl R~un}tgri}w Bif{}il cfk Kc{c Cbs~grg{gif!RBCKC' bioo~fgbc{gif ~rnk {an biomgfc{gif id }ckgi cfkkg}nb{ rn}gcl i} oikno biffnb{gifr& [ikcw, g{ gr o~ba oi}nbiooif di} RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gifr {i {}ctnl itn} LCF i}ZLCF& [agr u}ibnrr id bioo~fgbc{gif itn} c RBCKCrwr{no gftiltnr rntn}cl kgddn}nf{ RBCKC rwr{nobiouifnf{r {ac{ gfbl~kn {an rnfri}r cfk bif{}il }nlcwr,]noi{n [n}ogfcl ^fg{r !][^r', RBCKC ocr{n} ~fg{r, cfk
{an itn}cll bioo~fgbc{gif fn{zi}`& Cktcfbnk ][^r zan}noir{ RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gif gr jc{an}nk zg{agf {an rwr{no,c}n knuliwnk di} c oi}n biouln{n oifg{i}gfj& [an kgddn}nf{tcl~nr d}io gfu~{r cfk i~{u~{r, }ndn}}nk {i cr RBCKCuigf{r, c}n rnf{ d}io gfkgtgk~cl rnfri}r {i {an ][^ zagba gr}nruifrgmln di} di}zc}kgfj {anrn RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gifr {i{an ocr{n} r{c{gif, i} A~ocf/Ocbagfn Gf{n}dcbn !AOG'&
RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gifr ibb~} mn{znnf Ocr{n} R{c{gifcfk {an ][^r, cfk mn{znnf {an ][^r cfk {an }noi{nlwknuliwnk rnfri} fiknr& Cr RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gifrmn{znnf {an Ocr{n} r{c{gif cfk {an ][^r fizckcwr ~{glgxnr{an LCF, ZLCF, cfk {an Gf{n}fn{, {an lgf` mn{znnf rnfri}fiknr cfk ][^r bcffi{ gfbi}ui}c{n {anrn {nbafilijgnr&
Rnfri} fiknr bif{cgf RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gif kc{c {ac{ c}nrnfrg{gtn cfk fnnkr {i mn rnb~}nlw {}cfrog{{nk {i ][^r& [an~{glgxc{gif id LCF di} rnfri} fiknr bcf mn nqunfrgtn {igfr{cll c{ }noi{n rg{nr, cfk g{ ocw fi{ mn dncrgmln di} cfi}jcfgxc{gif {i goonkgc{nlw gfbi}ui}c{n cll id {ang} }noi{nrg{nr gf{i {an LCF fn{zi}`&
[agr ucun} gr bifbn}fnk zg{a {an u}i{i{wun knrgjf cfkkntnliuonf{ id c bioo~fgbc{gif rbanon {ac{ zi~lk u}itgkn}noi{n cbbnrr {i {an rnfri} fiknr, {a}i~ja {an biomgfc{gifid ]ckgi D}ns~nfbw cfk Jlimcl Rwr{no di} Oimglnbioo~fgbc{gifr fn{zi}`& [agr u}iuirnk bioo~fgbc{gifrbanon gf{}ik~bnr {an {zi kgddn}nf{ zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gif{nbafilijgnr {i clliz kc{c bioo~fgbc{n mn{znnf {an rnfri}fiknr cfk ][^r id RBCKC rwr{nor& ^fkn}r{cfkgfj {an
bac}cb{n}gr{gbr, u}iun}{gnr, cfk mnactgi} id JRO, ]D cfkkgddn}nf{ ac}kzc}n biouifnf{r c}n tg{cl {i {agr bifbnu{& [anzg}nlnrr u}ibnrrnr zgll mn bif{}illnk tgc c liz/bir{ogb}ibif{}illn}& [an JRO cfk ]D bioo~fgbc{gif onkgc c}nd~llw ~{glgxnk mw gf{}ik~bgfj fnz fn{zi}` u}i{ibilr&
[an }nr{ id {agr ucun} c}n i}jcfgxnk cr dillizr8 Rnb{gif GGkgrb~rr cmi~{ ][^ gf RBCKC rwr{nor0 {an u}iuirnkrbanon di} bioo~fgbc{gif coifj rnfri} fiknr id ][^ gri~{lgfnk gf Rnb{gif GGG0 cfk {an bifbl~kgfj }noc}`r gfRnb{gif GT&
GG& ][^ GF RBCKC RWR[NOR
C }noi{n {n}ogfcl ~fg{ !][^' gr c ogb}iu}ibnrri}/bif{}illnk nlnb{}ifgb kntgbn {ac{ gf{n}dcbnr imhnb{r gf {an
uawrgbcl zi}lk {i c kgr{}gm~{nk bif{}il rwr{no i} RBCKC!r~un}tgri}w bif{}il cfk kc{c cbs~grg{gif rwr{no' mw{}cfrog{{gfj {nlnon{}w kc{c {i {an rwr{no cfk)i} cl{n}gfj {anr{c{n id biffnb{nk imhnb{r mcrnk if bif{}il onrrcjnr}nbngtnk d}io {an rwr{no& Cfi{an} {n}o {ac{ ocw mn ~rnk di}][^ gr }noi{n {nlnon{}w ~fg{0 {an biooif ~rcjn {n}o tc}gnrzg{a {an cuulgbc{gif c}nc jnfn}cllw P7_&
][^r, GNKr, ULBr cfk KBR c}n gfb}ncrgfjlw mnjgffgfj{i itn}lcu gf }nruifrgmglg{gnr, cfk ocfw tnfki}r rnll ][^rzg{a ULB/lg`n dnc{~}nr cfk tgbn tn}rc& [an gfk~r{}w acrr{cfkc}kgxnk if {an GNB 43323/2 d~fb{gifcl mlib` lcfj~cjndi} b}nc{gfj u}ij}cor {i }~f if ][^r cfk ULBr, cl{ai~ja
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 173/223
fnc}lw cll tnfki}r clri iddn} u}iu}gn{c}w cl{n}fc{gtnr cfkcrribgc{nk kntnliuonf{ nftg}ifonf{r&
GGG& ]D CFK JRO NFCMLNK RNFRI] FIKNR
BIOO^FGBC[GIF
[agr rnb{gif i~{lgfnr {an u}iuirnk rbanon di}nr{cmlgragfj c lgf` mn{znnf {an }noi{nlw knuliwnk rnfri}fiknr gf jnij}cuagbcl c}nc cfk {an ][^r& [anbioo~fgbc{gif lgf` ~{glgxnr {an f~on}i~r bcucmglg{gnr id {an]ckgi D}ns~nfbw !]D' cfk Jlimcl Rwr{no di} OimglnBioo~fgbc{gifr !JRO' {i u}itgkn di} kc{c {}cfrogrrgif di}RBCKC rwr{nor& Dgj& 3 gll~r{}c{nr {an bifbnu{ di} {an ocgfr{}~b{~}n id {an bioo~fgbc{gif lgf`&
Dgj~}n 3& ]D/JRO Nfcmlnk Bioo~fgbc{gif Lgf` R{}~b{~}n di} Rnfri}
Fiknr cfk ][^r&
[an bioo~fgbc{gif lgf` r{}~b{~}n gr biouirgfj id {a}nnbiouifnf{r {ac{ gfbl~kn8
• Rnfri} Fiknr• Oimgln Fn{zi}` Bif{}illn} !FB'
• Bnf{}cl Rn}tn} !BR' di} ][^r[an Rnfri} Fikn gr bcucmln id un}di}ogfj rion
u}ibnrrgfj, jc{an}gfj rnfri}w gfdi}oc{gif cfkbioo~fgbc{gfj zg{a i{an} biffnb{nk fiknr gf {an fn{zi}`& G{u}ik~bnr c oncr~}cmln }nruifrn {i rnfri}w nftg}ifonf{,u}ibnrrnr kc{c di} c tc}gn{w id cuulgbc{gif, r{i}nr kc{c{noui}c}glw cfk {}cfrui}{r {an kc{c {i {an Bnf{}cl Rn}tn} di}][^r gd fnbnrrc}w {a}i~ja {an Fn{zi}` Bif{}illn}&
[an Oimgln Fn{zi}` Bif{}illn} !FB' rn}tnr cr }i~{n}kntgbn {ac{ gr gfr{cllnk if agja uigf{r lg`n uizn} uilnr& [anu}gfbgucl u~}uirn id FB gr kc{c {}cfrdn} cfk gfdi}oc{gif}i~{gfj mn{znnf Rnfri} Fiknr cfk Bnf{}cl Rn}tn} di} ][^r&
[an Bnf{}cl Rn}tn} !BR' di} ][^r ocfcjnr {anbillnb{gif id kc{c d}io fn{zi}` kntgbnr& G{ clri {}cfrdn}r {an
kc{c {i {an kc{cmcrn di} r{i}cjn cfk }n{}gntcl&
Dgj~}n =& C oi}n kn{cglnk bifbnu{ di} {an bioo~fgbc{gif lgf` mn{znnf
][^r cfk Rnfri} Fiknr&
D~}{an}oi}n, {i gll~r{}c{n {an kn{cgl bifbnu{, Dgj~}n =raizr aiz {an kc{c {}ctn}rn d}io ncba id {an kntgbnr&
Bifbgrnlw, cf cb{gtn rnfrgfj kntgbn }nbngtnr rgjfclr
u}iui}{gifcl {i {an rnfri}w nftg}ifonf{ }ndn}}nk {i crRBCKC uigf{r& [agr RBCKC uigf{r c}n un}gikgbcllw }nck,cbb~o~lc{nk cfk r{i}nk c{ c liz bir{ m~{ agja/un}di}ocfbnogb}ibif{}illn}& [an ]D {}cfrog{{n} cfk }nbngtn} u}itgkn {anzgfkiz di} {an rnfri} fiknr {i bioo~fgbc{n zg{a FB&Ogb}ibif{}illn}, ]D [q\]q, cfk {an rnfrgfj kntgbn di}o cfikn& [an fikn bcf gfbl~kn oi}n biouifnf{r knunfkgfj if{an ckkg{gifcl d~fb{gifr ckknk {i {an rwr{no& [i nfacfbn {anrwr{no }nlgcmglg{w0 c fif/tilc{gln NNU]IO gr ~rnk {i r{i}n{an on{n} }nckgfj cfk i{an} goui}{cf{ kc{c c{ c fikn i} FB0cfk }nlick {an r{i}nk kc{c c{ r{c}{~u&C{ {an Oimgln Fn{zi}` Bif{}illn}, {an ~{glg{w‗r i}kn}r {i {anrwr{no c}n }nbngtnk cr Rai}{/Onrrcjgfj/Rn}tgbn !ROR'onrrcjnr {a}i~ja c JRO oikno& C ogb}ibif{}illn}
cfclwxnr {an onrrcjn cfk rnfkr {an u}iun} bioocfkr {i cllfiknr gf g{r c}nc i} {i c runbgdgb fikn iflw& Cfw }nckgfjr,cln}{r i} }nui}{r rnf{ mw {an fiknr c}n }nbngtnk gf {an FB,}nracunk {i cf ROR onrrcjn di}o cfk rnf{ cjcgf {i {anbnf{}cl rn}tn} id {an ][^&
C& Ogb}ibif{}illn}
C ogb}ibif{}illn} gr c rocll biou~{n} if c rgfjlngf{nj}c{nk bg}b~g{ bifrgr{gfj id c }nlc{gtnlw rgouln BU^biomgfnk zg{a r~uui}{ d~fb{gifr r~ba cr c b}wr{cl irbgllc{i},{gon}r, zc{bakij {gon}, cfk rn}gcl cfk cfclij G)I n{b&
[an ogb}ibif{}illn} zgll ulcw cr c u}ibnrri} gf c Fikncfk FB, g{ bif{}ilr cfk dcbglg{c{nr {an kc{c {}cfrogrrgifmn{znnf {an fikn cfk fn{zi}` bif{}illn}&
[an}n c}n {zi `gfkr id Ogb}ibif{}illn} ~rn gf {an knrgjf&Rgfbn FB }ns~g}nr oi}n ^RC][ di} gf{n}dcbgfj zg{a JROcfk ]D oik~ln, c ogb}ibif{}illn} zg{a {zi i} oi}n ^RC][gr {an baigbn& Gf {agr bcrn {an liz/bir{ m~{ uizn}d~l C}k~gfiOnjc Kntnliuonf{ Mic}k gr {an iu{gif, g{ rc{grdgnk {an}ns~g}nonf{ di} {an fnnk id oi}n ^RC][& C}k~gfi Onjc grcf iunf/ri~}bn ogb}ibif{}illn} mcrnk gf C[onjc3=15 P35_&[an r~ooc}w id {an uc}con{n}r di} C}k~gfi Onjc gr lgr{nkif [cmln 3&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 174/223
[CMLN G& R^OOC]W ID [AN C]K^GFI ONJC
Ogb}ibif{}illn} C[onjc 3=15
Iun}c{gfj Til{cjn > T Gfu~{ Til{cjn
!]nbioonfknk'
: ‒ 3= T
Gfu~{ Til{cjn !Lgog{r' 4 ‒ =5 T
Kgjg{cl G)I Ugfr >; !id zagba 3; u}itgkn
UZO i~{u~{'
Cfclij Gfu~{ Ugfr 34
KB B~}}nf{ un} G)I Ugf ;5 oC
KB B~}}nf{ di} 2&2T Ugf >5 oC
Dlcra Onoi}w 3=1 @M !id zagba ;@M
~rnk mw mii{lickn}'
R]CO 1 @M
NNU]IO ; @M
Blib` Ruunk 34 OAx
Rn}gcl ^RC][r ;
[an Fikn }ns~g}nr iflw lnrr f~omn} id ugfr di} gfu~{r cfki~{u~{r, ifn ^RC][ di} gf{n}dcbgfj zg{a ]D oik~ln, cfklnrr onoi}w rgxn ogb}ibif{}illn}& [an C}k~gfi Kgnbgoglc gr{an cuu}iu}gc{n ogb}ibif{}illn} di} {agr kntgbn, C}k~gfiKgnbgoglc gr c ogb}ibif{}illn} mic}k mcrnk if {anC[onjc341, g{ gr clri cf iunf ri~}bn ogb}ibif{}illn} zagba{an u}nknbnrri} id C}k~gfi Onjc& Mnliz gr {an r~ooc}w id {an Kgnbgoglc raizf gf [cmln =&
[CMLN GG& R^OOC]W ID [AN C]K^GFI KGNBGOGLC
Ogb}ibif{}illn} C[onjc 2=1
Iun}c{gfj Til{cjn > T
Gfu~{ Til{cjn
!]nbioonfknk'
: ‒ 3= T
Gfu~{ Til{cjn !Lgog{r' 4 ‒ =5 T
Kgjg{cl G)I Ugfr 3; !id zagba 4 u}itgkn
UZO i~{u~{'
Cfclij Gfu~{ Ugfr 1
KB B~}}nf{ un} G)I Ugf ;5 oC
KB B~}}nf{ di} 2&2T Ugf >5 oC
Dlcra Onoi}w 2= @M !id zagba =@M
~rnk mw mii{lickn}'
R]CO = @MNNU]IO 3 @M
Blib` Ruunk 34 OAx
Rn}gcl ^RC][r 3
M& Jlimcl Rwr{no di} Oimgln Bioo~fgbc{gifr
[an mcrgb gknc gf ~rgfj JRO bioo~fgbc{gifr gf FBr gr{i }nbngtn i}kn} onrrcjnr d}io {an ~{glg{w gf ROR di}o!Bnf{}cl Rn}tn} di} ][^r'& [an Ogb}ibif{}illn} nqnb~{nr {anu}iun} }i~{gfn }nlc{nk {i {an onrrcjn bif{nf{ cfk ucrrnr g{rbioocfkr {i {an Fiknr& ]ntn}rnlw, {an rwr{no rnfkr g{r}nulgnr, zan{an} {anw c}n }nckgfjr, }nui}{r i} cln}{r, {i {an
~{glg{w‗r bnf{}cl rn}tn} cjcgf gf ROR di}o tgc {an JROfn{zi}`& [an Ogb}ibif{}illn} agjalw mnfndg{r d}io {an JROOik~ln dnc{~}n {ac{ g{ cln}{r di} cfw cb{gif zg{agf {an JROfn{zi}`, ri {an Ogb}ibif{}illn} bcf clzcwr oifg{i} zac{ grknlgtn}nk {i {an JRO oik~ln d}io fn{zi}`&
Gf {agr u}iuirnk bioo~fgbc{gif lgf` rbanon, di} {anu}iid id bifbnu{ cf ilk Rifw N}gbrrif [=25 gr ~rnk crcl{n}fc{gtn {i JRO oik~ln0 g{ gr o~ba bancun} cfk ctcglcmln{i {an libcl oc}`n{& Dgj~}n 2 raizr {an mlib` kgcj}co id JRO gf{n}dcbgfj zg{a Ogb}ibif{}illn} gf FB&
Dgj~}n 2& Mlib` Kgcj}co di} JRO gf{n}dcbgfj zg{a {an Ogb}ibif{}illn} gf
c Fn{zi}` Bif{}illn}&
[an iun}c{gfj d~fb{gifr id {an JRO oik~ln !RN/[=25'c}n cbbnrrnk {a}i~ja {an ~rn id C[ bioocfkr0 {anrn C[bioocfkr c}n bifdi}ogfj {i JRO 52&5; r{cfkc}kr& C[bioocfkr c}n ctcglcmln tgc {an rn}gcl gf{n}dcbn id {an [=25di} d~fb{gif goulnonf{c{gif& [an C[ r{cfkc}k gr c lgfn/i}gnf{nk bioocfk lcfj~cjn& Ncba bioocfk gr ockn ~u id {a}nn nlnonf{r8 {an u}ndgq, {an mikw, cfk {an {n}ogfc{gifbac}cb{n}&
• [an u}ndgq bifrgr{r id {an ln{{n}r “C[‟• [an mikw gr ockn ~u id gfkgtgk~cl bac}cb{n}r0 g{
bifrgr{r id c fcon cfk !gd cuulgbcmln' crribgc{nk
tcl~nr• [an kndc~l{ {n}ogfc{gif bac}cb{n} gr “<B]6‟!?
5q5K'i Nqcouln8 C[+BOJ]?-3=-
[agr bioocfk }nckr {an onrrcjn zg{a gfknq 3= r{i}nk gf{an kndc~l{ RGO bc}k ulcbn& Bioocfkr di} {an RN/[=25 bcfmn bc{nji}gxnk gf {zi bc{nji}gnr8
• Rn{~u bioocfkr8 ~rnk {i rn{ {an kgddn}nf{ uc}con{n}rid {an RN/[=25 !n&j& Mc~k }c{n, }nruifrn {wun․'
• Bioo~fgbc{gif Bioocfkr8 ~rnk {i nr{cmlgrabioo~fgbc{gif ~rgfj {an RN/[=25 !n&j& ]nck $Rnfk ROR'
B& ]D Oik~ln
Cf goui}{cf{ jicl id {an knrgjf gr {i oc`n {an rwr{nobir{ nddnb{gtn0 gfr{nck id u~{{gfj JRO oik~ln if ntn}w fikngf {an rwr{no {ac{ zgra {i jn{ }nckgfjr, {an ]D oik~lnr {ilgf` {an FB zg{a {an r~}}i~fkgfj Fiknr& [agr zgll }nk~bnbir{ cfk zgll u}ik~bn c fgbn bacllnfjn {i r{cfk di}&
]D oik~lnr c}n runbgdgnk mw {ang} iun}c{gfj d}ns~nfbw,oik~lc{gif {wun, ocqgo~o kc{c }c{n cfk ocqgo~o kgr{cfbnid iun}c{gif !gf mi{a iunf dgnlkr cfk gf m~glkgfjr'&
Cbbi}kgfj {i {an bioo~fgbc{gif {ani}w, {an cf{nffclnfj{a id {an oik~lnr rai~lk mn cmi~{ 3: bo& Fi runbgclcf{nffcr zan}n ~rnk {i {agr knrgjf mnbc~rn {an {}cfrog{{n}cfk {an }nbngtn} zn}n {ii blirn {i ncba i{an} di} {an knoiu~}uirnr, m~{ gd {anw c}n {ii rucbnk cfk lc}jn} kgr{cfbn {an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3>7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 175/223
bifrgkn}c{gif id ~rgfj {an runbgcl cf{nffc gr agjalw}nbioonfknk&
Di} {an u}iid id bifbnu{ u~}uirnr, c liz/bir{ ;22 OAx]D cfk {an {}cfrog{{n} }cfjn gr cmi~{ 355 on{n}r mn{znnfm~glkgfjr!cb{~cllw cmi~{ :> on{n}r cbb~}cbw'& [an ~rn id riuagr{gbc{nk ]D ril~{gif zagba acr c }cfjn id c}i~fk =`ogr znll r~jjnr{nk gf cb{~cl goulnonf{c{gif&
K& ]nlcw
[an Nlnb{}ifgb m}gb` />T ]nlcw oik~ln ~rnr ALR1L}nlcw oik~ln {i bif{}il agja/til{cjn nlnb{}gbcl kntgbnr!ocqgo~o =>5T'& [agr }nlcw gr bif{}illnk mwogb}ibif{}illn} zg{a ]D {i nfcmln }noi{n biffnb{ cfkkgrbiffnb{gif& Di} knoi u~}uirnr {agr knrgjf zgll ~rn c}nlcw zg{a ocqgo~o =>5T cfk :C&
N& LBK Oik~ln
[an Rn}LBK t=&> gr c rgouln cfk bir{ nddnb{gtn ril~{gif
di} gf{n}dcbgfj {i LBK mcrnk if {an AK;;:15 bif{}illn}&[an Rn}LBK oik~ln {c`nr gfbiogfj 7455 mur [[L lntnlrgjfcl cfk kgrulcwr {airn bac}cb{n}r if {an LBK rb}nnf&
[an bifrgkn}c{gif id baiirgfj Rn}LBK gr {an f~omn} id ugfr fnbnrrc}w {i gf{n}dcbn {i ogb}ibif{}illn}& [an {wugbclLBK ~rnk 33 ugfr {i gf{n}dcbn zg{a ogb}ibif{}illn}, zaglnRn}LBK acr iflw {a}nn zg}nr / >T, JFK, cfk Rgjfcl c}nfnnknk {i gf{n}dcbn {i {an LBK&
[an AK;;:15 ki{/oc{}gq lgs~gk b}wr{cl kgrulcw bif{}illn}cfk k}gtn} LRG kgrulcwr cluacf~on}gb& G{ bcf mn bifdgj~}nk {ik}gtn c ki{/oc{}gq lgs~gk b}wr{cl kgrulcw ~fkn} {an bif{}il id c ;/ i} 1/mg{ ogb}iu}ibnrri}& Rgfbn cll {an d~fb{gifr r~ba crkgrulcw ]CO, bac}cb{n} jnfn}c{i}, cfk lgs~gk b}wr{cl k}gtn},}ns~g}nk di} k}gtgfj c ki{/oc{}gq lgs~gk b}wr{cl kgrulcw c}n
gf{n}fcllw u}itgknk if ifn bagu, c ogfgocl rwr{no bcf mngf{n}dcbnk zg{a {agr bif{}illn})k}gtn}&
D& Bioo~fgbc{gif Lgf` Rid{zc}n)U}ij}co
Cr onf{gifnk cmitn, cf nomnkknk rid{zc}n i} u}ij}cozgll }~f {an itn}cll u}ibnrr gf {an Bnf{}cl Rn}tn} r~barnfkgfj bioocfk cfk }nbngtgfj }nruifrn d}io {an Fn{zi}` Bif{}illn}& [i kntnliu {agr rid{zc}n c runbgdgb u}ij}coogfjlcfj~cjn zgll mn ~rnk bifrgkn}gfj {an biouc{gmglg{w grr~nrdi} {an ][^, ogb}ibif{}illn}, cfk rnfrgfj kntgbnr&
[an Bnf{}cl Rn}tn} di} ][^r gr {an ocgf ac}tnr{gfjbiouifnf{ {ac{ billnb{r kc{c d}io cll FBr !cfk Fiknr' gf {anrwr{no cfk ocfcjnr u}ibnrr bif{}illgfj {ii& [an c~{ioc{gifid {an rwr{no rai~lk ocgflw mn goulnonf{nk gf {an Bnf{}cl
Rn}tn}& G{ rai~lk mn biffnb{nk {i c kc{cmcrn {i r{i}n tc}gi~rkc{c cfk {}cfrcb{gifr d}io kgddn}nf{ fiknr gf {an rwr{no&
GT& BIFBL^RGIF
Gf RBCKC rwr{nor, kc{c bioo~fgbc{gif ulcwr c tg{cl}iln di} oifg{i}gfj cfk bif{}illgfj {an u}ibnrrnr id {an
nf{g}n rwr{nor& [an}n c}n {zi ocgf bioo~fgbc{gif c}ncr di}RBCKC rwr{nor, {ac{ gr, mn{znnf RBCKC Ocr{n} R{c{gifrcfk ][^r0 cfk mn{znnf {an }noi{nlw knuliwnk rnfri} fiknrcfk {an ][^r& Cktcfbnk ][^r zan}n oir{ RBCKCbioo~fgbc{gif gr jc{an}nk zg{agf {an rwr{no, c}n knuliwnkdi} c oi}n biouln{n oifg{i}gfj& [an kgddn}nf{ tcl~nr d}iogfu~{r cfk i~{u~{r, }ndn}}nk {i cr RBCKC uigf{r, c}n rnf{d}io gfkgtgk~cl rnfri}r {i {an ][^ zagba gr }nruifrgmln di}di}zc}kgfj {anrn RBCKC bioo~fgbc{gifr {i {an ocr{n}r{c{gif, i} A~ocf/Ocbagfn Gf{n}dcbn !AOG'&
[agr ucun} actn u}iuirnk cf ]D‒JRO Nfcmlnk RBCKCBioo~fgbc{gif lgf` mn{znnf {an ][^r cfk Rnfri} Fiknr{ac{ ~{glgxnr {an ctcglcmln bioo~fgbc{gif fn{zi}`r r~ba crbnll~lc} uaifn fn{zi}` cfk }ckgi d}ns~nfbw di} nqbacfjgfjkc{c {i ogfgogxn bir{ cfk a~ocf nddi}{& [an cuu}icba oc`nr~rn id {an JRO fn{zi}`, c b~r{io ]D ril~{gif, c liz/bir{ogb}ibif{}illn}, cfk nomnkknk rid{zc}n di} ogb}ibif{}illn}rgr kntnliunk {i }~f {an itn}cll u}ibnrr&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ O& Baig, ]& ]imlnr, N& Bai, MH Uc}`, RR @go, JB Uc}`, cfk [A @go,“C U}iuirnk C}bag{nb{~}n di} RBCKC Rwr{no zg{a Oimgln Rnfri}r‟,[an Hi~}fcl id @i}ncf Gfr{g{~{n id Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw, a{{u8))`g/g{&i}&`})ucun})ucun}Y51Y5>)1.NC.M4.1B>.NK.71.M1)C.=5U}iuirnk.=5C}bag{nb{~}n.=5di}.=5RBCKC.=5Rwr{no.=5zg{a.=5Oimgln.=5Rnfri}r&ukd, Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn}, =533
P=_ ]& ]imlnr, O& Baig, [A @go, “[an D~fb{gif id RBCKC gf B}g{gbclGfd}cr{}~b{~}n‟, [an Hi~}fcl id @i}ncf Gfr{g{~{n id Gfdi}oc{gif[nbafilijw, =557&
P2_ GRI)GNB =;:25/3 Gfdi}oc{gif {nbafilijw // ]ncl/{gon libc{gfjrwr{nor !][LR' // Uc}{ 38 Cuulgbc{gif u}ij}co gf{n}dcbn !CUG'&
P;_ “Gf{}ik~b{gif {i ULB cfk RBCKC‟, a{{u8)){nrlc/
oi{i}r&biffwm}ii`~r&bio)=533)3=)3>) gf{}ik~b{gifY{iYulbYcfkYrbckc) Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn}, =533
P>_ K& Mcglnw cfk N& Z}gja{, -U}cb{gbcl RBCKC di} Gfk~r{}w-, Nlrntgn},=552&
P4_ GRI)GNB 37:4=/> Gfdi}oc{gif {nbafilijw / C~{ioc{gb gknf{gdgbc{gifcfk kc{c bcu{~}n !CGKB' {nbafgs~nr / Ac}oifgxnk tibcm~lc}w / Uc}{>8 Libc{gfj rwr{nor&
P:_ JCI/5;/4=1[& B}g{gbcl gfd}cr{}~b{~}n u}i{nb{gif0 Bacllnfjnr cfknddi}{r {i rnb~}n bif{}il rwr{nor& [nr{goifw Mndi}n {anR~mbioog{{nn if [nbafilijw Gfdi}oc{gif Uilgbw, Gf{n}jitn}fonf{cl]nlc{gifr cfk {an Bnfr~r, Ai~rn Bioog{{nn if Jitn}fonf{ ]ndi}o&Oc}ba 25, =55;& a{{u8))zzz&jci&jit&fnz&g{nor)k5;4=1{&ukd,Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn}, =533&
P1_ “Zg}nlnrr Rnfri} Fn{zi}`‟, a{{u8))nf&zg`gunkgc&i}j)zg`g) Zg}nlnrrYrnfri}Yfn{zi}`, Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn}, =533&
P7_
“]noi{n [n}ogfcl ^fg{‟, a{{u8))nf&zg`gunkgc&i}j)zg`g) ]noi{nY[n}ogfclY^fg{, Cbbnrrnk8 Knbnomn}, =533&
P35_ “C}k~gfi‟, a{{u8))nf&zg`gunkgc&i}j)zg`g)C}k~gfi, Cbbnrrnk8Knbnomn}, =533&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 345
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 176/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;5;5)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;5;5
Rnb~}nk RBCKC Rwr{no gf Roc}{ J}gk Knuliwonf{
Wtn{{n N& Jnliji [cg/aiif
O~l{gonkgc Nfjgfnn}gfj Knuc}{onf{, Acffco ^fgtn}rg{w @goB~l{~}n Knrgjf Nfjgfnn}gfj ]nrnc}ba Bnf{n},322 Ihnifj/kifj, Kcnk~`/j~, Kcnhnif, @i}nc Acffco ^fgtn}rg{w,
Cmr{}cb{/R~un}tgri}w Bif{}il cfk Kc{c Cbs~grg{gif
!RBCKC'gr c rwr{no {ac{ acrmnnf c r{clzc}{ id nlnb{}gb ~{glg{w
iun}c{gifr& G{ mnbiogfj gfb}ncrgfjlw bioulnq cr fnz
{nbafilijgnr c}}gtnr cfk fnz grr~nr non}jn if {an }ick {i c
oikn}f nlnb{}gb j}gk&G{ gr tn}w goui}{cf{ {i `nnu {}cb{ {an
rnb~}g{w grr~nr {ac{ c}grn {ijn{an} zg{a g{r gou}itnonf{& [agr
ucun} kgrb~rrnr {an RBCKC rwr{no t~lfn}cmglg{gnr cfk
di}o~lc{nr {an uirrgmln rnb~}g{w oncr~}nr {i og{gjc{n {anrn
t~lfn}cmglg{gnr cr RBCKC rwr{no mnbionr c mgj uc}{ id Roc}{
J}gk&
@nwzi}kr8RBCKC, Roc}{ J}gk, B}wu{ij}cuaw, Rnb~}g{w
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
C roc}{ j}gk gr c kgjg{cllw nfcmlnk nlnb{}gbcl j}gk {ac{
jc{an}r, kgr{}gm~{nr, cfk cb{r if gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{ {an
mnactgi} id cll uc}{gbgucf{r !r~uulgn}r cfk bifr~on}r' gf
i}kn} {i gou}itn {an nddgbgnfbw, goui}{cfbn, }nlgcmglg{w,
nbifiogbr, cfk r~r{cgfcmglg{w id nlnb{}gbg{w rn}tgbnr&
Uizn} j}gk gr ocfcjnk {a}i~ja bif{}il bnf{n}r,nlnb{}ifgb oifg{i}gfj)bif{}il ns~guonf{ c{ r~mr{c{gifr, cfk
cf nq{nfrgtn bioo~fgbc{gif fn{zi}`& R~un}tgri}w Bif{}il
cfk Kc{c Cbs~grg{gif !RBCKC' rwr{nor c}n ~rnk
nq{nfrgtnlw {i bif{}il cfk oifg{i} {an fc{gifcl uizn}& Ocfw
{nr{r actn mnnf kifn cfk o~ba t~lfn}cmglg{w zcr kgrbitn}nk,
{agr t~lfn}cmglg{gnr acr fi{ mnnf u~mlgbcllw kgrblirnk, m~{
bi~lk mn nqulig{nk mw c `fizlnkjncmln c{{cb`n} P3_&
Cr c uc}{ id Roc}{ j}gk, RBCKC rwr{no ulcw c tg{cl
}iln gf fc{gifr‗ b}g{gbcl gfd}cr{}~b{~}nr cfk {c`gfj g{ {i {an
fnq{ lntnl id nfacfbn iun}c{gifr, RBCKC rwr{no acr mnnf
gf{nj}c{nk {i GU/mcrnk fn{zi}` zagba oc`n {an RBCKC
rwr{no {c`n }gr` gf {n}or id rnb~}g{w& [ai~ja {an}n actn
mnnf c li{ id }nrnc}banr cfk r{~kgnr ockn {i og{gjc{n {anrn
t~lfn}cmglg{gnr, {agr gr fi{ nfi~ja cfk {an r{~kw gr r{gll jigfj
if&
[agr ucun} u}iuirnr c on{aikilijw di} rnb~}gfj RBCKC
rwr{no gf Roc}{ J}gk nftg}ifonf{&[an {zi dib~rnk gr di}
{an fn{zi}` rnb~}g{w {i nfr~}n {ac{ {an ucb`n{r rnf{actn}ncbank di} g{r gf{nfknk }nbngu{r& Cfk {an i{an} ifn gr
{an {wugbcl c{{cb`r {ac{ c}n mngfj lc~fba {a}i~ja oclgbgi~r
rid{zc}n& [anrn {zi zcwr id c{{cb`r ~rnr kgddn}nf{
onbacfgror {i lc~fba cf c{{cb` {i air{& G{ gr mn{{n} {i r{~kw
mi{a {i actn c oi}n rnb~}n RBCKC rwr{no&
Di} ucb`n{ rnb~}g{w, {an}n gr c li{ id bguan} rbanon
mngfj ~rnk {i oc`n r~}n {an gf{nj}g{w id {an onrrcjn&[an
c{{cb`r {ac{ bcf uirrgmlw lc~fba zg{a ~frnb~}nk fn{zi}` gr
{an c{{cb`n} bcf gf{n}bnu{ {an ucb`n{ gf{nfknk di} cfi{an}
RBCKC biouifnf{r {ac{ gr mngfj oikgdgnk mw {an c{{cb`n}
cfk }nulcbn g{ oclgbgi~r u}ij}cor {ac{ bcf knr{}iw {an
gf{nfknk }nbgugnf{r i} air{& [ai~ja {agr `gfk id c{{cb` zgll
bc~rn c mgj kcocjn, {an}n gr fi bifb}n{n rnb~}g{w
onbacfgro {i biomc{ r~ba c{{cb` u}idi~fklw& Cfi{an} gr
zanf {an c{{cb` gr mngfj lc~fba {a}i~ja kizflicknk cfk
gfr{cllnk rid{zc}n zagba c}n oclzc}n, [}ihcf tg}~rnr cfk
i{an} tg}~r u}ij}cor {ac{ {an air{ gr fi{ czc}n id g{r
nqgr{nfbn mnbc~rn clri id {an agja b}wu{ij}cuaw ~rnk {ac{
{an GKR i} FGGRK , dg}nzcll bcffi{ kn{nb{& [agr zgll bc~rn c
li{ id kcocjn mndi}n g{ bcf mn kn{nb{nk& [agr ucun} kgrb~rrnr
{an onbacfgro {i og{gjc{n {anrn c{{cb`r&
GG& MCB@J]I^FK
[an dillizgfj c}n {an RBCKC Rwr{no Biouifnf{r8
3& Iun}c{i}8 A~ocf iun}c{i} zai oifg{i}r {an
RBCKC rwr{no cfk un}di}or r~un}tgri}w bif{}il
d~fb{gifr di} {an }noi{n ulcf{ iun}c{gifr&
=& A~ocf ocbagfn gf{n}dcbn !AOG'8 U}nrnf{r kc{c {i
{an iun}c{i} cfk u}itgknr di} bif{}il gfu~{r gf c
tc}gn{w id di}oc{r, gfbl~kgfj j}cuagbr, rbanoc{gbr,
zgfkizr, u~ll kizf onf~r, {i~ba/rb}nnfr, cfk ri
if&
2& Ocr{n} {n}ogfcl ~fg{ !O[^'8 [an O[^ u}nrnf{r
kc{c {i {an iun}c{i} {a}i~ja {an AOG, jc{an}r kc{c
d}io {an kgr{cf{ rg{n, cfk {}cfrog{r bif{}il rgjfclr
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 343
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 177/223
{i {a
mn{z
liz
mnbcgf{n}
;& Bio
mn{z
Bio
zg}nl
{nlnu
>& ]no
gf {
rgjf
d}io
O[
mn{z
}nlc{g
blir
ogb}
gf{n}
kgr{}g
bif{
{}cfr
cl{n}g
bif{
Cfi{
[nln
zg{a
oifg
cfk {
R{c{g
Dg
RBCKC
{wugbcl bif{}
{n}ogfcl ~fg{r
cb{~c{i}r, cfk
i} {an oir
n}di}onk m
}ndn}}nk {i
ifrgr{r id c
~r~cllw rn{ {
n }noi{n rg{
nnf {an O[^
cfk {an bif{
~rn id uirrg}~u{gifr&
o~fgbc{gifr
nnf {an O
o~fgbc{gif
nrr i} zg}nk
aifn fn{zi}`
{n {n}ogfcl
n ocr{n})rlc
lr {i {an knt
{anrn kntgbn
& Cf ][^
nnf {an ]
tnlw agja cf
k liiu& C ]
u}ibnrri}/bi
dcbnr imhnb{r
m~{nk bif{}il
il cfk k
og{{gfj {nlno
fj {an r{c{n
il onrrcjnr
an} {n}o {ac{
n{}w ^fg{, {
{an cuulgbc
{i}r {an dgnl
}cfrog{r cll {
f&
~}n 3&[wugbcl R
rwr{nor c}n
l rwr{no bi
!][^' biff
}nlcwgfj gfd
{ uc}{, {an m
{an ]noi
r {an ][^'
u}ij}coocml
runbgdgb }ns
& [an {}cfro
cfk {an }no
il on{aik gr
mln {gon knl
ncfr8 Bio
[^ cfk }
cf mn {a}i
fn{zi}`r, i}
&
fg{ !][^'8 D
tn c}bag{nb{
gbn ~fkn} bi
r, cfk {}cfr
ocw mn c U
^ cfk bi
k {an bif{}il
oi{n [n}ogf
f{}illnk nlnb
gf {an ua
rwr{no i} R
{c cbs~grg{
n{}w kc{c {i
id biffnb{n
}nbngtnk
ocw mn ~rnk
an biooif
{gif c}nc j
kgjg{cl cfk
n kc{c {i {an
CKC Rwr{no c}
u}goc}glw b
frgr{r id if
b{nk {i c tc
}oc{gif {i c
}cgfr id c R
{n [n}ogfcl
& [an ]noi
n lijgb bift
~g}nonf{r, a
grrgif }c{n i
{n rg{n gr }nlc
~r~cllw iunf
cwr i} kc{c
~fgbc{gif o
oi{n bif{}
~ja {an Gf{
{an rzg{bank
~fb{gifr cr c
}n& Rnfkr b
{}il, cbs~g}n
g{r {an kc{c
LB& [an kc{
{}illnk kntg
on{aik gr ~
cl ^fg{ !][^
{}ifgb kntgb
rgbcl zi}lk
CKC !r~un}
gif rwr{no'
{an rwr{no
imhnb{r mcr
}io {an r
di} ][^ gr ]
~rcjn {n}o
fn}cllw& Cf
cfclij uc}c
Bnf{}cl Oifg
bag{nb{~}n
if{}il rwr{n
i} oi}n }
gn{w id rnfri
ocr{n} r{c{gi
CKC rwr{n
^fg{r !rio
{n [n}ogfcl
}{n}& [an ][
zntn}, oir{
d kc{c
{gtnlw
liiu
dliz
n{aik
lln}r&
n}fn{,
~mlgb
rlctn
if{}il
r kc{c
{i {an
}c{n
n gr
r~cllw
' gr c
{ac{
{i c
gri}w
mw
fk)i}
k if
r{no&
oi{n
tc}gnr
][^
n{n}r
{i}gfj
r& C
noi{n
r cfk
f P=_&
c}n
{gonr
^fg{r
^ c}n
][^
cll
{an
{an
a~~r~
id{
ba
bi
a~
}nc
oi
un}
mn
cf
bi
i~{
RB
kgj
g{r
{go
bli
jn
gfr
{i
{nb
cf
gf{
u}i
c mg
r{c
f~
fn{
c{{
rwr
cr
c{{
fn{
nq
{ac
go
nru
zi
rn{
clg
z a~ocf gf{
][^ ogja{
runnk bcf m
cf gf{n}tnf{gcllw c~{ioc{g
f, c RBCK
fjnr {i d~
rgkn}nk blirn
cf gf{n}tnf{g
l/{gon kc{c i
}n nddgbgnf{
riffnl rcdn{w
ndg{r c}n ock
rid{zc}n gf
o~fgbc{gif
rgkn fn{zi}
CKC c}bag{nb
g{cl kc{c {}cfr
GGG&
R~un}tgri}w
bioo~fgbc{g
n rnb~}g{w z
rnk fc{~}n i
n}cl oiknl
{cllnk gf c u}g
c{{cb` {an r
afilijw oik
actn r{c}{nk
}dcbnr cfk
{ibilr P4_& Mn
gjjn} grr~n&
[an {}cfrg{g
kc}kgxnk cfk
mn} id biffn
zi}`r cfk {an
b`r& Bifrn
{nor acr bio
nq{}nonlw t
b`r P:_P1_&
RBCKC rw
zi}` biffnb
irnk RBCK
{ cbbioucfw
lgbc{gifr }n
nbgcllw rgfbn
}lk‗r b}g{gbcl g
id fn{zi}` d
fonf{ id fn{
}tnf{gif, di}
bif{}il {an r
n bacfjnk i
gif& Gf ckkg{ggbcllw lijjnk
rwr{no zg
b{gif iu{go
liiu rwr{no
if P=_& RBC
f u}ik~b{gif,
bif{}il uc}c
, cfk }nk~b
n uirrgmln mw
RBCKC rwr{
u}i{ibilr cf
r, gfbl~kgfj
{~}nr }nlw anc
grrgif&
RBCKC T^L
Bif{}il cfk
if u}i{ibilr
r fi{ {an u}g
d {an bioo
d {}~r{gfj {a
c{n fn{zi}`&
wr{no mnbc~
}fgxnk, {anw
}~ffgfj oi}n
actn gouln
bc~rn id {agr
f d}io u}iu
iunf ril~{gi
b{gifr mn{zn
Gf{n}fn{ acr
~nf{lw, {an
n gf{i s~nr{gi
~lfn}cmln {i
{nor c}n mng
{gtg{w& [agr
fn{zi}`r {i
{ikcw‗r [B
r~l{gfj d}io
ocfw id {anr
gfd}cr{}~b{~}n&
b{r bcf i}jcf
i}` kndnfrnr
gfr{cfbn, gf
{{gfj id c bi
} itn}}gkknf
f, cfw bacfdi} cfk)i}
ll oifg{i} c
cllw0 RBCK
r cfk }~f zg{
C u}itgknr
iun}c{gifr,
kgjor, gou}
r bir{r id i
{an ~rn id r{
or biomgfn
k gfb}ncrnk
{an Gf{n}fn
tglw if r{cfkc
FN]CMGLG[
c{c Cbs~grg{
knrgjfnk kn
oc}w bifbn}f
fgbc{gifr fn
kc{c if {a
I~{rgkn}r zgl
rn id g{r bl
actn mnbio
oikn}f rn}tg
nf{nk }noi{
uj}cknr, rnb
}gn{c}w {nbaf
r {ijn{an} zg
f RBCKC rw
ckn {ano o
rnb~}g{w id
cr {anw c}n g
bwmn}zc}dc}
fj oikn}fgx
kntnliuonf{
{an rgjfgdgbc
)GU fn{zi}`
{agr nqui
rwr{nor bif
& Iflw zg{a
gxc{gifr d~llw
cfk rnb~}g{w
dcb{i}w rn{{g
tnwn} mnl{,
c{ cfw {gon
nr i} n}}i}rgrulcwnk& O
fk oc`n rlg
rwr{nor
a }nlc{gtnlw lg
cfcjnonf{ z
goulnonf{c{g
tnr ulcf{
un}c{gif& [a
fkc}k ac}kz
zg{a gou}i
biffnb{gtg{w
{& P;_& Oik
}k u}i{ibilr
GNR
gif Rwr{nor
bcknr cji, {
mnbc~rn id
{zi}`r cfk
o rgfbn g{
l dgfk g{ kgddgb
irn fc{~}n&
gf{n}biffnb
bnr r~ba cr
n bifdgj~}c{g
}g{w acr mnbi
ilijgnr {i o
g{a {an gfb}nc
r{nor cfk idd
}n t~lfn}cml
RBCKC/mc
fb}ncrgfjlw r
n)bwmn}{n}}i}g
k zg{a [BU
, aizntn},
f{ rnb~}g{w }g
& [an ui{nf
~}n c}n ag
{}il o~ba id
biou}nanfr
knoifr{}c{n
uilgbw&
fj,
fk
mw
c}nir{
a{
c}n
{{ln
g{a
fr
fk
rn
c}n
nk
{i
}f
fk
fk
ac{
{an
{an
cr
~l{
Cr
{nk
nm
gif
on
}n
nk
gbn
{i
nk
nf
ro
)GU
cr
r`r
{gcl
ja,
{an
gtn
{an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 34=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 178/223
g
l
g
G
[wugbcl
awrgbcllw rn
cfk nouliwg
crrzi}k u}i
rnb~}g{w oncr
acb`n}r bcf
nbikn u}iu
c{nzcwr& Nf
n{aikr {i }
ioo~fgbc{g
&3 Rnb~}gfj G
G{ gr tn}w
RBCKC gr fi
gf gf{n}fn{ m
c~fba gf [B
nnk {i rnb~}
zn u}iuirn
!BJC'& BJ
gknf{gdgn} gr
zcw acra d~f
[an mgfkgfj
tn}gdgnk mw }n
{an acra zg{a
GUt4 ckk}nrr
cfk c~qglgc}w
{an bi}}nruifc bn}{gdgbc{gif
&= @nw Ocfc
C~{anf{g
RBCKC rwr{
RBCKC kntg
ioocfk {i
acllnfjn {an
n }ns~g}nk {i
zai actn nf
S~clg{w rwr{n
gddn}nfbn gf
& RNB^]G[
gj~}n =& Rnb~}n
RBCKC r
~}gfj {an ac
j biooif
{nb{gif cfk cf
~}nr c}n ac}k
ncrglw gknf{g
gn{c}w u}i{ib
}wu{gif cfk c
k~bn rion i
fr&
U Rgjfclgfj
goui}{cf{ {i
z }~f gf GU/m
i~ja{ rnb~}g
U)GU lcwn}& [i
{an bioo~f
c B}wu{ij}
gr GUt4 ckk
nfn}c{nk mw
{gif d}io u~
n{znnf {an u
/biou~{gfj {
{an gf{n}dcbn g
bcf mn u}i{n
uc}con{n}r c
gfj u}gtc{n ` c~{ai}g{w i}
jnonf{
c{gif gr {an
o u}itnr g{r g
gbn }nbngtgfj
un}di}o bif
rnfkgfj kntg
cbbnrr {an k
i~ja un}ogrr
ckogfgr{}c{
rnb~}g{w u}nt
ON[AIK
BCKC Bioo~
b~}g{w onc
}kzc}n cfk {
wmn} rnb~}g{
{g/tg}~r ~{glg{g
n} {i nfdi}bn
w bifdgknf{g
ilr, cfk mw
~{anf{gbc{gif
d {anrn bwmn}
rnb~}n GU rgj
crnk fn{zi}`&
{w t~lfn}cmglg
biomc{ {anr
gbc{gif gf Lgf
uagbcllw Jn
}nrrnr di} z
biou~{gfj c
lgb `nw cfk c
~mlgb `nw cfk
n acra tcl~n
gknf{gdgn}& On
{nk mw c{{cb
fk mw rgjfgf
nw& [an u}i{nfw rnb~}g{w gf
}ibnrr mw z
knf{g{w {i cfi
c b}g{gbcl o
{}ilr i} }nru
n‗r gknf{g{w&
{c cfk }nui}{
gif bcf cbbn
gif {nbafgs~
f{gif& RBCK
LIJW
gbc{gif
r~}nr bifrg
}cfrogrrgif
kndnfrnr r~
nr& Bioo~fg
rgfbn oikn}
l uaifn f~
crr dg}nzcll
c}n agjalw ndd
{a}nc{r {i RB
clgfj rgfbn o
& Nquirgfj RB
{gnr& Rion c
c{{cb`r, {an
` lcwn}& Gf {ag
fn}c{nk Ckk
agba {an gf{
b}wu{ij}cuagb
~qglgc}w uc}c
{an ckk}nrr b
cfk mw bio
rrcjnr rnf{ d}
gfj {an u~mlg
{an onrrcj
{gif zi}`r zd}cr{}~b{~}n&
agba ifn uc}
{an}& C
nrrcjn, r~ba
fk zg{a kc{
C~{anf{gbc{gi
r ri {ac{ iflw
rr {an gfdi}o
r bcf oc`n
C znm rn}tn
{ id
nkgc,
ba cr
c{gif
f kcw
mn}r,
cfk
nb{gtn
CKC
ikn}f
CKC
{{cb`r
n gr c
r bcrn,
}nrrnr
}dcbn
ifn/
n{n}r&
cf mn
c}gfj
o cf
b `nw
zg{a
g{ai~{
{ id c
cr c
, bcf
f zgll
~rn}r
c{gif&
ll {an
o~r{
clz
rn}
d}i
{an}ns
rnf
gfd
nfb
oc
;&2
ua
Rnb
uir
lib
bc
oi
zc
^R
rid
c{{
d}i
RB
`gf
rn}gRB
Ro
zc
RB
d~ll
{an
ac}
lnc
P3_
P=_
P2_
P;_
P>_
P4_B
P:_
cwr mn rnb~}
tn} rnb~}g{w r
{an b~r{io
ocr{n} rn}tn~nr{ zgll mn
k mcb` {an
}oc{gif zgl
}wu{gif {ac{ g
r{n} cfk {an }n
Rnb~}gfj Ac
G{ gr tn}w go
rgbcllw& [an
~}gfj ac}kz
rgmln gfrgkn h
c{gif rnb~}g{w
n}c cfk i{
fg{i} {an c}n
r{an oclgbgi~
M k}gtn gf{i
{zc}n mnbco
b`n} zcr ulc
cll id agr
CKC rwr{no
k id c{{cb`&
G{ gr tn}w
gi~rfnrr, cfkCKC rwr{no
c}{ J}gk nftg
r&[agr ucun
CKC rwr{no
w rnb~}nk RB
rn crunb{8 Rn
kzc}n rnb~}g{
{i oi}n t~l
R{~kw id Rnb~}g{Rnb~}g{w
a{{u8))zzz&gfl&
}nf{Ygrr~nr&ukd ifclk L& @}~{x,
KNULIW GUt4a{{u8))zzz&4kn
fk.=5Rnfri}
[cg/aiif @go, “
Roc}{ J}gkCuulgbc{gifr, N
i}nc Roc}{ J}gk
FF Gf{n}cb{gtn,
3711,a{{u8))zzz h~tnfgln&acb`n})g
{{u8))zzz&{rbo&
rgfbn {an kc
d{zc}n bcf c
} i} blgnf{ zg
& [an blgnf{biouln{nk& [
}ns~nr{nk gf
l clri mn
r u}iuirnk {i
oi{n crrn{r&
kzc}n
ui}{cf{ {i rnb
n c}n {an {
}n d}io cfw
im {ac{ ocw
oncr~}n o
n} rnfri} k
& Ifn id {an
r rid{zc}n {
cf nquirnk
cf gfr{}~o
ffgfj c -ocr
if{}illnk oc
o~r{ mn rnb
T& BIFB
goui}{cf{ {i
goui}{cfbn, {an bacllnf
ifonf{ gf ri
nqcogfnr {
cr c uc}{ id
CKC rwr{no
~}gfj GU Rgj
w& Di} fnjln
n}cmln RBC
]NDN]
C{{}gm~{nr id R
it)rbckc)u~mlgb
-Rnb~}gfj RBCK
}cgfgfj, C{anfr,uliw&n~)zi}`rai
=5Fn{zi}`r&ukd
Rnb~}gfj Bioo
Nftg}ifonf{ Gfjgfnn}gfj $ Kn
Gfr{g{~{n, a{{u8))
“[nnf Acb`n}
&bff&bio)[NBA) fknq&a{ol POcw
io)i~{rgknulcf{
{c gf g{ c}n t
lri mn ckknk&
ll r{c}{ zg{a c
gll mn c~{anf{gan RBCKC
i}oc{gif {i
nfb}wu{nk ~
mn ~rnk mn{z
~}n RBCKC a
cfjgmln uc}{
kgrcr{n}r i}
ibb~}& Gf {ag
r{ mn knuliw
tgbnr o~r{
}nbnf{ RBC
c{ zcr knlg
^RM ui}{&
nf{ di} mi{f
rgtn- knfgcl
bagfnr& [agr
~}nk uawrgbcl
L^RGIF
~fkn}r{cfk
d {anrn fnzljnr crribgc{n
on kgddn}nf{
an rnb~}g{w }
roc}{ j}gk& G
zn o~r{ bif
clgfj, @nw
b{gfj {agr rnb
C rwr{no&
FBNR
oc}{ J}gk Rwr{n
c{gifr)k)rnb~}gfj
C Rwr{nor- Zgl
==)54)=53,ur)=53554=3Yc{a
~fgbc{gif id RB
{n}fc{gifcl Hi~tnliuonf{, Grr~n
zz&roc}{j}gk&i}
Dcbnr Dnkn}cl B
biou~{gfj)7152) 533_
&a{ol
}w b}g{gbcl&
Bioo~fgbc{g
f a{{u }ns~nr{
gbc{nk mndi}ncr{n} zgll {
{an blgnf{&
rgfj {an rc
nnf {an RBC
c}kzc}n kntg
id {an rwr{
bclcog{gnr
r bcrn, uawrg
nk& R~}tngllc
mn gfr{cllnk
C c{{cb`r P
n}nk {a}i~j
[agr oclgbg
{ c{{cb`cfk
d rn}tgbn c{{
iflw raizr {
lw {i ctigk {
{an bioulnqg
gf{n}biffnbk zg{a {an f
cfk oi}n ~}j
ns~g}nonf{r
f i}kn} {i a
rgkn} rnb~}g{w
cfcjnonf{
~}g{w c}ncr
or ‒ B~}}nf{ BGrr
{anYroc}{Yj}gk
w U~mlgragfj, Gfb
nfr)1.=5GUt4.
KC Biouifnf{
}fcl id Rwr{n=, Til~on >, =53
&`})35nfj4/3&uau
ac}jnr‟, Oc}ba
31)
nm
gif
{i
{annf
an
on
C
nr
o&
fk
bcl
bn
{i
35_
c
~r
{an
b`
ac{
agr
g{w,
{nknz
nf{
di}
tn
gf
fk
gll
mn}~nr,
b~}
&
=5c
r gf
r‟33&
31,
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 342
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 179/223
P1_ Zcragfj{if Uir{& Kgrrn}{c{gif bi~lk mn rnb~}g{w {a}nc{&a{{u8))zzz&zcragfj{ifuir{&bio)cb=)zu/kwf) C=2417/=552H~l:
P7_ On{gfIx{~}`, Uaglgu C~mgf, -RBCKC Rnb~}g{w8 Bacllnfjnr cfk
Ril~{gifr- H~fn =533 ) Zag{n ucun}
P35_ Roc}{ J}gk fnzr, “Roc}{n} J}gk&& R{}~jjlgfj RBCKC9‟a{{u8))zzz&roc}{j}gkfnzr&bio)c}{ocf)u~mlgra)[nbafilijgnrYRBCKC)Roc}{n}/J}gk/R{}~jjlgfj/RBCKC/3>43&a{ol
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 34;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 180/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :;5;:)GRMFY5:41CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;5;:
[nln/Iun}c{gtn Iua{acloirbiun
C&F&Fg{awcc
]&U}no`~oc}Knuc}{onf{ id Mgionkgbcl Nfjgfnn}gfj Knuc}{onf{ id Mgionkgbcl Nfjgfnn}gfj
]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn ]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn[acfkclco,Banffcg,Gfkgc [acfkclco, Banffcg,Gfkgc&
C&]&Cf~u}crcf
Mac}c{a`~oc}&TKnuc}{onf{ id Mgionkgbcl Nfjgfnn}gfj Knuc}{onf{ id Mgionkgbcl Nfjgfnn}gfj
]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn ]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn[acfkclco,Banffcg,Gfkgc [acfkclco,Banffcg,Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{ / [an rlg{ lcou gr cf gfr{}~onf{ bifrgr{gfj id cagja/gf{nfrg{w id lgja{ ri~}bn {ac{ bcf mn dib~rnk {i ragfn c{agf rann{ id lgja{ gf{i {an nwn& Gf oir{ kntnliugfj cfkocfw c}ncr id kntnliunkbi~f{}gnr, cbbnrr {i s~clg{w nwn bc}n c}n gfckns~c{n zagbalnckr {i mlgfkfnrr& Gf {ikcw‗r oikn}f anc{a {nbafilijw {an
iua{acloilijgr{ fnnkr kgjg{cl uai{ij}cuaw di} blgfgbclnqcogfc{gif cfk di} kgcjfirgfj {~oi~}r gf {an nwn& [anu}gbn id c rlg{ lcou gfb}ncrnr zg{a g{r s~clg{w di} cbb~}c{ngknf{gdgbc{gif id nwn {~oi~}r& [nln/Iun}c{gtnIua{acloirbiun iddn}r j}nc{ aiun {i itn}bion u~mlgbancl{a u}imlno cfk bcf mn ~rnk di} {ncbagfj onkgbclu}idnrrgifclr zg{a liz bir{& ]nrnc}ba cb{gtg{gnr bcf mnbc}}gnk i~{ ~rgfj {agr rwr{no& [agr rwr{no u}itgknr c }ncl{gon tgkni id {an nwn {i {an r{~knf{r zg{ai~{ cfwkgrbiodi}{ cfk gfbiftnfgnfbn {i {an uc{gnf{r& Zagln{ncbagfj {an r{~knf{r {an bifbn}f r{cdd acr {i rctn {angocjnr id {an nwn {i u}itgkn c blnc} gknc cmi~{ {ac{ gocjn&Gf bcrn id kg}nb{ tgr~clgrc{gif {an iua{acloilijgr{ acr {iki {an ckh~r{onf{r di} ncba cfk ntn}w r{~knf{, rgfbn {anuirg{gif id {an tgr~clgxc{gif zgll bacfjn gd {an}n gr cfw
kgr{~}mcfbn& [i }nk~bn {an bacfjnr cfk {i u}itgkn kg}nb{tgr~clgxc{gif, c bi~uln} zg{a bcon}c gr dg{{nk {i {an tgnzgfjrwr{no cfk gr biffnb{nk {i c ub& [an ucun} nftgrcjnrknrgjfgfj cfk {nr{gfj c fnz [nln/Iun}c{gtnIua{acloirbiun, zagba jgtnr {an kg}nb{ tgr~clgxc{gif id {an nwn if c oifg{i} i} if c rb}nnf, ri {ac{ cll {an r{~knf{rbcf tgnz {an gocjn c{ {an rcon {gon gf c blcrr }iio& Di}{an u~}uirn id nqun}gonf{c{gif Znmbco gr ~rnk&
@NW ZI]KR Iua{acloirbiun, [nlnon{}w
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
[agf rlg{ lgja{ mnco nfcmlnr cf iu{gbcl rnb{gif di} gftgti gfrunb{gif id kgddn}nf{ lcwn}r id {an nwn& Rgfbn g{rgftnf{gif gf 3733, {an rlg{/lcou acr mnbion cf
gfkgrunfrcmln {iil di} nwn nqcogfc{gif& P3_Iua{acloilijw gr gkncl di} {nlnonkgbgfn& Oir{ nwnuc{ailijw gr tgrgmln {i gfrunb{gif& Zagln mlgfkfnrr grkntcr{c{gfj, ocfw nwn kgrncrnr kntnliu rlizlw& [a~r, gd {an kgrncrn gr kn{nb{nk nc}lw gf g{r bi~}rn cfk grcuu}iu}gc{nlw {}nc{nk, zn bcf rctn ocfw uniuln d}io
fnnklnrr r~ddn}gfj d}io tgr~cl kgrcmglg{w& Gf oir{kntnliugfj cfk ocfw c}ncr id kntnliunk bi~f{}gnr,
cbbnrr {i s~clg{w nwn bc}n gr gfckns~c{n lnckgfj {i {anu}ntnf{cmln mlgfkfnrr& Ucrrgtn {nln/iua{acloilijw‒zan}n uc{gnf{r‗ blgfgbcl kc{c !r~ba cr d~fk~ruai{ij}cuar' c}n billnb{nk, {}cfrog{{nk, cfk lc{n}gf{n}u}n{nk mw iua{acloilijgr{r‒ c}n znll kntnliunk&
P=/2_ Aizntn}, k~n {i g{r kwfcogb fc{~}n cfk}ns~g}nonf{ id runbgcl r`gllr onf{gifnk cmitn, rlg{/lcou
nqcogfc{gif }ns~g}nr cb{gtn {nln/iua{acloilijwril~{gifr& [i ckk}nrr {agr u}nrrgfj u~mlgb ancl{au}imlno, zn actn kntnliunk c [nln/Iun}c{gtnIua{acloirbiun, zagba jgtnr {an kg}nb{ tgr~clgxc{gif id {an nwn if c oifg{i} i} if c rb}nnf, ri {ac{ r`gllnk
iua{acloilijgr{ bcf {ncba {an r{~knf{r zg{ai~{kgr{~}mgfj {an uc{gnf{ cfk bcf u}itgkn lgtnlw {an nwngocjnr& U}ik~bgfj lgtnlw gf {an blcrr}iio gr czifkn}d~l zcw {i ruc}` {an r{~knf{‗r gocjgfc{gifr cfkk}cz i~{ {ang} b}nc{gtg{w&
GG& [NLNIUN]C[GTN RLG[LCOUOGB]IRBIUN
Di} iua{acloilijgb nqcogfc{gif, c rlg{ lcouogb}irbiun gr jnfn}cllw ~rnk cr c d~fkconf{clkgcjfir{gb kntgbn, cr raizf gf Dgj& 3& Zg{a {an rlg{ lcouogb}irbiun, {an nwn runbgclgr{*r mcrgb {cr`r gfbl~knckh~r{onf{ id {an ogb}irbiun uirg{gif ~rgfj {an hiwr{gb` {i dgfk c dibcl uirg{gif cfk {i rzg{ba rlg{ {wunr ~rgfj {an`fimr if {an rlg{ lcou ~fg{ {i rn{ cf cuu}iu}gc{nkgcjfir{gb bifkg{gif& [an nwn runbgclgr{ ogja{ ~rn cd}if{gfj lnfr cfk c ml~n dgl{n} {ijn{an} zg{a {anogb}irbiun {i bifk~b{ ckkg{gifcl
nqcogfc{gifr& [an i}jcfgxc{gif id {anrn runbgcl
kntgbnr }ns~g}nr j}nc{ r`gll cfk nqun}gnfbn di}ogb}irbiun bif{}il gf ckkg{gif {i `fizlnkjn id blgfgbclonkgbgfn&
Dgj 3& Nqcogfc{gif id c Rlg{ Lcou
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 34>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 181/223
Gf u}ntgi~r zi}`r, c runbgclgr{ / cf nqun}{ }noi{nu}nrnf{n}/bif{}ilr c rlg{ lcou ogb}irbiun c{ {an uc{gnf{rg{n& [an bcu{~}nk agja/s~clg{w r{gll i} oitgfj gocjnr id nwnr c}n rnf{ {i c blcrr}iio&
Iua{acloilijgr{r ulcw c }nlc{gtnlw un}guan}cl }iln gf{ncbagfj {an onkgbcl r{~knf{& Gf bif{}cr{, i~} cuu}icba
gf{}ik~bnr c {nln/iun}c{gtn rlg{ lcou ogb}irbiun bcfu}itgkn c }ncl {gon {nbafilijw {i bcu{~}n agja/s~clg{wr{gll i} oitgfj gocjnr {a}i~ja {an fn{zi}`, cfkbifk~b{ c blcrrnr cfk kgcjfirgr gf c {gonlw ocffn}&[agr rn{{gfj ogja{ }ns~g}n cf crrgr{cf{ c{ {an uc{gnf{ rg{nzg{a lgog{nk `fizlnkjn }nlc{nk {i {an iua{aclogbun}guan}clr, ac}kzc}n cfk rid{zc}n& [an crrgr{cf{ ogja{mn c jnfn}cl kib{i} zai gr fi{ cf iua{acloilijgr{, i}un}acur c f~}rn zai zi~lk r~uui}{ {aniua{acloilijgr{*r rlg{ lcou iun}c{gif&
Dgj =& Dib~rnk cfk rlgja{lw ml~}}nk c}nc
A~ocf nwn acr c ruan}gbcl r~}dcbn& Iflw dnc{~}nr{ac{ c}n libc{nk gf {an ulcfn kndgfnk mw {an un}dnb{imhnb{ kgr{cfbn cuunc} un}dnb{lw dib~rnk& Cll i{an}dnc{~}nr c}n ml~}}nk& Gf ckkg{gif, c{{cbagfj {an bcon}c c{ifn rgkn id {an rlg{ lcou ogb}irbiuw bcf bc~rn {anfc}}iz tgrgif gocjn, rnn Dgj&=&
GGG& JNFN]CL MLIB@ KGCJ]CO
Dgj 2&3 Jnfn}cl Mlib` Kgcj}co
2&3 Knrb}gu{gif id Mlib` Kgcj}co
2&3&3&3 Rlg{ Lcou
[ikcw {an rlg{ lcou gr {an iua{acloilijgr{‗r oir{d}ns~nf{lw ~rnk cfk oir{ ~fgtn}rcllw cuulgbcmlngfr{}~onf{& Mgiogb}irbiuw id {an lgtgfj nwn gr c }i~{gfniua{acloilijgb nqcogfc{gif& [an rlg{ lcou nfcmlnr {an~rn} {i gfrunb{ gfkgtgk~cl nwn rnjonf{r gf s~gb`
r~bbnrrgif {i im{cgf c jnfn}cl gou}nrrgif id { a nnwn cfk oc`n c kgcjfirgr&
G f c rlg{ lcou, {an oi r { goui}{cf{ {wun id gll~ogfc{gif gr {an iu{gbcl rnb{gif& Cl l i{an}{nbafgs~nr c}n tc}gc{gifr& Di} r~}tnw nqcogfc{gif id {an cf{n}gi} rnjonf{ {an rlg{ gr ckh~r{nk {i d~ll cun}{~}n&[agr }nr~l{r gf c bg}b~lc}, tn}w m}gja{ cfk ntnflwgll~ogfc{nk dgnlk { a c { gr rlgja{lw roclln} {acf {an
ogb}irbiun*r dgnlk id tgnz& Mw ulcbgfj c j}i~fk jlcrrgf{i {an iu{gbcl uc{a {an nf{g}n dgnlk id tgnz grgll~ogfc{nk& G { gr znll `fizf { a c { {an r{}~b{~}n id {}cfruc}nf{ imhnb{r r~ba cr {an bi}fnc, cf{n}gi}bacomn}, nwn lnfr, cfk mikw bcf iflw mn rnnf uii}lwgf {}cfrog{{nk i} }ndlnb{nk lgja{, cr {an }nlc{gtncoulg{~kn oik~lc{gif i d lgja{ gr {ii znc` c f k{an uacrn oik~lc{gif gr fi{ un}bngtnk mw {an nwn&Aizntn}, r~ba imhnb{r bcf jnfn}cllw mn imrn}tnk znllgf rbc{{n}nk i} dl~i}nrbnf{ lgja{&
Dgj 2&= [an itn}cll rwr{no
C rlg{ lcou nqco ocw mn kifn8
Cr uc}{ id c }i~{gfn nwn nqco clifjzg{a i{an} u}ibnk~}nr {i ntcl~c{n {an nwn, r~bacr iua{acloirbiuw, tgrgif {nr{gfj, i} {ifion{}w!{i oncr~}n u}nrr~}n gf {an nwn'&
[i lii` c{ r{}~b{~}nr gf {an mcb` id {annwn, r~ba cr {an iu{gb fn}tn i} }n{gfc&
[i anlu kn{nb{ kgri}kn}r gf {anr{}~b{~}nr gf {an d}if{ id {an nwn, r~ba crgfdnb{gif i} gfh~}w {i {an bi}fnc, bc{c}cb{r,bifh~fb{gtg{gr, i} g}g{gr&
[i anlu kn{nb{ cfk oifg{i} jlc~bioci} ocb~lc} knjnfn}c{gif&
[i banb` di} c di}ngjf mikw, r~ba cr con{cl d}cjonf{, if i} gf {an nwn&
[i kn{nb{ nwn u}imlnor {ac{ ocw mnbc~rnk mw i{an} kgrncrnr, r~ba cr kgcmn{nr i}}an~oc{igk c}{a}g{gr& ]i~{gfn rlg{ lcou nqcor c}ngoui}{cf{ {i kn{nb{ nwn u}imlnor c{ cf nc}lwr{cjn cfk {i j~gkn {}nc{onf{ gd nwn u}imlnorkntnliu&
[i oifg{i} bioulgbc{gifr r~ba crmlnnkgfj cd{n} cf nwn gfh~}w&
[i oifg{i} bioulgbc{gifr r~ba crbc{c}cb{ di}oc{gif {ac{ ibb~}r mnbc~rn id banoi{an}cuw, }ckgc{gif {}nc{onf{, i} cd{n} cmifn oc}}iz {}cfrulcf{&
2&3&3&= Bi~uln}
C bi~uln} gr c kntgbn {ac{ biffnb{r {zi nfkr zg{ai~{ cfw lirr id nfn}jw& [an bi~uln} gr {zi ugnbn [ndlif
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 344
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 182/223
bi~ulgfj& [an bcon}c gr dg{{nk gfrgkn {an bi~uln} c{ {anbi}}nb{ lnfj{a cfk {an {zi ugnbnr c}n {gja{nfnk& [anoikgdgnk rlg{ lcou r~uui}{r tgkni bcon}c gfr{cllc{gifdi} tgnzgfj gocjnr id {an uc{gnf{‗r nwn if rb}nnf& [angocjn biogfj d}io ifn nfk id {an rlg{ lcou gr dib~rnkif {i {an znmbco di} agja dgknlg{w& [an znmbco ~rnk
ugb`r ~u {an gocjn kg}nb{lw cfk knlgtn}r {i {an UB& [anbi~uln} gr ockn ~u id UTB, gf i}kn} {i actn jiikdib~rgfj& [agr k~ulgbc{gif id {an fc{~}n‗r agja dgknlg{wrwr{no gr cbagntnk cd{n} ocfw {}gcl cfk n}}i}r&
2&3&3&2 Bi~uln} Knrgjf
Dgj 2&2[iu Tgnz id Dg}r{ Uc}{
Dgj 2&; [iu Tgnz id Rnbifk Uc}{
Dgj 2&>[iu Tgnz id [ag}k Uc}{
Dgj 2&4Rgkn Tgnz id Dg}r{ Uc}{
Dgj 2&: Rgkn Tgnz Id Rnbifk Uc}{
Dgj 2&1 Rgkn Tgnz Id [ag}k Uc}{
Dgj 2&7[i{cl Bi~uln}
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 34:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 183/223
Dgj 2&35 R{cfkc}k Uai{ij}cua d}io {an nwn
GT& BIFBL^RGIFR
Di} {an u~}uirn id nqun}gonf{c{gif znmbco gr~rnk, zagba jgtnr {an kg}nb{ tgr~clgxc{gif id {an nwn if coifg{i} i} if c rb}nnf, ri {ac{ cll {an r{~knf{r bcf tgnz{an nwn c{ {an rcon {gon gf c blcrr }iio& Rgfbn {an nwn grtn}w rnfrg{gtn cfk goui}{cfbn {i a~ocf lgdn, {an s~clg{w id {an gocjn {ac{ ~rnk di} kib{i}r* kgcjfirn ulcwr cfgoui}{cf{ }iln gf nqcogfgfj {an uc{gnf{*r gllfnrr&D~}{an}oi}n, rlg{ lcou nqcogfc{gif bcf r~ddn} {an uc{gnf{
mnbc~rn id agja l~ogfcfbn, ri lnrr ~rnk {gon zi~lk mnmn{{n}& [nln/Iun}c{gtn Iua{acloirbiun rwr{no acrrunbgdgbg{w cuu}icbagfj {airn id {an biftnf{gifcl rlg{/
lcou& [an }nocgfgfj bacllnfjnr c}n {i ogfgc{~}gxn {anu}i{i{wun, {i kntnliu c liz bir{ ocrr u}ik~b{gif id {an
~fg{r, cfk {i iu{gogxn {an ~{glgxc{gif id gf{n}fn{mcfkzgk{a&
T& CB@FIZLNKJNONF[R[an c~{ai}r zgra {i {acf` {an Bacg}ocf cfk
Bacg}un}rif id ]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn,Banffcg di} u}itgkgfj cll {an dcbglg{gnr }ns~g}nk di}bc}}wgfj i~{ {agr zi}`& [anw clri {acf` {an U}gfbgucl,]chclc`raog Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn, Banffcg di} agrbifr{cf{ nfbi~}cjnonf{ cfk j~gkcfbn&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_& H&@& Lnkdi}k, “[an Rlg{ Lcou U}gon},‟ Rlcb` Gfbi}ui}c{nk,[ai}idc}n, F&H&, =554&
P=_& R& @~oc}, O&L& [cw/@nc}fnw, G&H& Bifr{cmln, @&Wijnrcf&, “Gf{n}fn{mcrnk iua{acloilijw rn}tgbn8goucb{ crrnrronf{‟ M} H Iua{acloil178 321=/12, =55>&
P2_& H&J& Bcoc}c, ]N ]ik}gj~nx&, “]ncl/{gon{nlnonf{i}gfj gf Iua{acloilijw‟ [nlnonk H ;8 2:>/2::, 3771
P;_& ]gbac}k h& Hcoc}c, Ik, dcci, d}cfr tcf kn tnlkn, ok,cfk nlg unlg, orb, ik, dcci “Rbcffgfj NwnOitnonf{r gf Aioifwoi~r AnogcfiugcKib~onf{nk mw Rbcffgfj Lcrn} Iua{acloirbiun]n{gfcl Un}gon{}w‟ 35;5/>;11)52)155:/5;7>)5 TIL&15, FI& :, UU& ;7>‒>5; Iu{ion{}w Tgrgif RbgnfbnBiuw}gja{ § =552 Con}gbcfCbcknow id Iu{ion{}w
P>_& H&J& Bcoc}c, ]N ]ik}gj~nx&, “]ncl/{gon {nlnonf{i}gfj gfIua{acloilijw‟ [nlnonk H ;8 2:>/2::,3771&
P4_& C~r{gf ]ii}kc, Kctgk On}gfi, @cbbgn W& Lg, cfk W~a~c Xacfj“Ogfgc{~}gxc{gif id Ckcu{gtn Iu{gbr Rbcffgfj Lcrn}Iua{acloirbiun‟ gf D}if{gn}r gf Iu{gbr, IRC [nbafgbcl Kgjnr{!BK' !Iu{gbcl Ribgn{w id Con}gbc, =557', ucun} DZQ3&
P:_& Un}nkfgc K& C&, Cllnf, C&, -[nlnonkgbgfn {nbafilijw cfkblgfgbccuulgbc{gifr- HCOC, >2, =:2, 377>&
P1_&
A& Lg, -[nlnonkgbgfn cfk iua{acloilijw,- R~}tnw id Iua{acloilijw, til& ;;, 3777, u& 43/:=&P7_& O& Oii}n, -[an ntil~{gif id {nlnonkgbgfn,- D~{~}n Jnfn}c{gif
Biou~{n} Rwr{nor, til& 3>, 3777, uu& =;>/=>;&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 341
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 184/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :27;=)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :27;=
Cmr{}cb{/ ]i~{gfj u}i{ibilr di} oimgln ck aib fn{zi}`r
!OCFN[r' actn mnnf nquli}nk nq{nfrgtnlw gf lcr{ dnzwnc}r& O~ba id {agr zi}` gr {c}jn{nk c{ dgfkgfj c dncrgmln
}i~{n d}io c ri~}bn {i c knr{gfc{gif zg{ai~{ bifrgkn}gfjb~}}nf{ fn{zi}` {}cddgb i} cuulgbc{gif }ns~g}nonf{r&
]i~{gfj ocw ln{ c bifjnr{gif acuunf zagba gr kn{nb{nk mwbifjnr{gif bif{}il, m~{ knclgfj zg{a bifjnr{gif gf }ncb{gtnocffn} }nr~l{r gf lifjn} knlcw, cfk ~ffnbnrrc}w ucb`n{ lirr
cfk }ns~g}nr rgjfgdgbcf{ itn}anck gd c fnz }i~{n gr fnnknk&]i~{gfj rai~lk fi{ mn czc}n id, m~{ clri mn ckcu{gtn {i,
fn{zi}` bifjnr{gif& Ckcu{c{gif {i {an bifjnr{gif anlur {igfb}ncrn mi{a {an nddnb{gtnfnrr cfk nddgbgnfbw id }i~{gfj&[anrn u}imlnor c}n riltnk mw {an bifjnr{gif/czc}n }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr gf bn}{cgf knj}nn& [anrn u}i{ibilr zagba c}nckcu{gtn {i bifjnr{gif r{c{~r id oimgln ck/aib fn{zi}` bcf
j}nc{lw gou}itn {an fn{zi}` un}di}ocfbn& Gf {agr ucun},zn u}nrnf{ {an r~}tnw id bifjnr{gif ckcu{gtn }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr di} oimgln ck/aib fn{zi}`& Dgfcllw, {an d~{~}nkg}nb{gif id bifjnr{gif/czc}n }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr grknrb}gmnk&
@nwzi}kr8 Ck aib fn{zi}`r, bifjnr{gif czc}n }i~{gfj,
Bifjnr{gif on{}gb, bifjnr{gif ckcu{cmglg{w
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}` gr ~r~cllw kndgfnk cr c rn{id zg}nlnrr oimgln fiknr kwfcogbcllw rnld/i}jcfgxgfj c
{noui}c}w fn{zi}` zg{ai~{ cfw bnf{}cl ckogfgr{}c{gif i}nqgr{gfj fn{zi}` gfd}cr{}~b{~}n& [an fikn gf {an zg}nlnrr
ck/aib fn{zi}` bcf rn}tn cr }i~{n}r cfk air{r& Ri, {anw
bcf di}zc}k ucb`n{r di} i{an} fiknr gd {anw c}n if }i~{n
d}io ri~}bn {i knr{gfc{gif& ]i~{gfj gr goui}{cf{ u}imlno
gf zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}`& [}ckg{gifcl zi}`gfju}i{ibilr bcffi{ zi}` znll gf zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}`
mnbc~rn id {an bac}cb{n}gr{gbr id {an zg}nlnrr ck/aib
fn{zi}`r& Rgfbn, oimgln fiknr actn lgog{nk {}cfrogrrgifbcucbg{w {anw oir{lw gf{n}bioo~fgbc{n mw o~l{gaiu
}nlcw& O~l{gaiu }i~{gfj gr bacllnfjnk mw lgog{nk zg}nlnrr
mcfkzgk{a, liz kntgbn uizn}, kwfcogbcllw bacfjgfj
fn{zi}` {iuilijw, agja t~lfn}cmglg{w {i dcgl~}n& [icfrzn} {anrn bacllnfjnr, ocfw }i~{gfj clji}g{aor gf
OCFN[r zn}n u}iuirnk& [an}n c}n kgddn}nf{ kgonfrgifr{i bc{nji}gxn {ano8 u}icb{gtn }i~{gfj Tr }ncb{gtn }i~{gfj
i} rgfjln uc{a }i~{gfj Tr o~l{guc{a }i~{gfj& Gf u}icb{gtn
u}i{ibilr, }i~{n mn{znnf ntn}w {zi fiknr c}n nr{cmlgrankgf cktcfbn ntnf {ai~ja fi {}cfrogrrgif gr gf knocfk& Gf
}ncb{gtn u}i{ibilr, }i~{n gr kgrbitn}nk zanf fnnknk{}cfrogrrgif cfk }nlncrnk zanf {}cfrogrrgif fi lifjn}
{c`nr ulcbn& Bifjnr{gif gr ifn id {an oir{ goui}{cf{
}nr{}gb{gifr id zg}nlnrr ck/aib fn{zi}`& G{ ocw
kn{n}gi}c{n {an un}di}ocfbn id zailn fn{zi}`& Gf {anb~}}nf{ knrgjf }i~{gfj gr fi{ bifjnr{gif/ckcu{gtn&]i~{gfj ocw ln{ {an
bifjnr{gif acuunf zagba gr kn{nb{nk mw bifjnr{gifbif{}il& M~{ knclgfj zg{a bifjnr{gif gf }ncb{gtn ocffn}
}nr~l{r gf lifjn} knlcw cfk cf ~ffnbnrrc}w ucb`n{ lirrcfk }ns~g}nr rgjfgdgbcf{ itn}anck gd {an fnz }i~{n grfnnknk& M~{, fiz {an}n gr cfi{an} kgonfrgif di}
bc{nji}gxgfj di} }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr8 bifjnr{gif ckcu{gtnTr& bifjnr{gif ~f/ckcu{gtn }i~{gfj& I~} oi{gtc{gif gr
{ac{ bifjnr{gif gr kiogfcf{ bc~rn di} ucb`n{ lirr, lifjknlcw, cfk agja itn}anck gf OCFN[r&
[anrn u}imlnor mnbion tgrgmln gf lc}jn rbcln
{}cfrogrrgif id {}cddgb gf{nfrgtn kc{c r~ba cr o~l{gonkgckc{c zan}n bifjnr{gif gr oi}n u}imcmln cfk fnjc{gtn
goucb{ id ucb`n{ lirr if {an rn}tgbn s~clg{w gr id oi}nrgjfgdgbcfbn& Gf {agr ucun} zn r{~kgnk bifjnr{gif }i~{gfju}i{ibilr lg`n B]U!Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj
U}i{ibil'P:_,NBC]U !Nddgbgnf{ Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn]i~{gfj U}i{ibil 'P33_,BC]U!Bifjnr{gif Czc}n
]i~{gfj U}i{ibil',BCKT!Bifjnr{gif Czc}n Kgr{cfbnTnb{i}'P3=_,BC]C!Bifjnr{gif Czc}n ]i~{gfj ul~r }c{n
Ckcu{c{gif'P3=_,BC]O!Bifjnr{gif Czc}n ]i~{gfjU}i{ibil di} Oimgln Ck/aib Fn{zi}`'P3=_&
[an }nocgfgfj uc}{ id {an ucun} gr i}jcfgxnk cr
dillizr8 Gf rnb{gif GG zn u}itgkn {an r{~kgnk bifjnr{gif
czc}n }i~{gfj u}i{ibilr& Gf rnb{gif GGG biouc}grif
mn{znnf {anrn clji}g{aor gr u}nrnf{nk& Gf rnb{gif GT znbifbl~knk {an ucun}&
CLJI]G[AOR
[an}n c}n ocfw }i~{gfj clji}g{aor gf oimgln ck/aib
fn{zi}`r di} }i~{gfj cfk bifjnr{gif d}nn fn{zi}`r&Rion id {ano c}n nqulcgfnk mnliz8
C& Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil !B]U'8
Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj gr c bifjnr{gifckcu{gtn ~fgbcr{ }i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} oimgln ck/aib
fn{zi}`& B]U u}i{ibil {}gnr {i u}ntnf{ bifjnr{gif d}ioibb~}}gfj gf {an dg}r{ ulcbn& Gf B]U, ntn}w fikncuunc}gfj if c }i~{n zc}fr g{r u}ntgi~r fikn zanf u}ifn
{i mn bifjnr{nk& Ri, B]U ~rnr {an ckkg{gifcl uc{ar bcllnk
cr “mwucrr‟ di} mwucrrgfj {an ui{nf{gcl bifjnr{gif c}nc
{i {an dg}r{ fif/bifjnr{nk fikn if {an u}goc}w }i~{n& G{}nk~bnr ucb`n{ knlcw& M~{, c{ {an rcon {gon B]U {}gnr {i
ogfgogxn mwucrr {i }nk~bn u}i{ibil itn}anck& Anfbn,{an {}cddgb gr rulg{ itn} mwucrr cfk u}goc}w cfk
ckcu{gtnlw {i fn{zi}` bifjnr{gif& Anfbn, 3' uizn}
bifr~ou{gif gr nddgbgnf{&=' Bifjnr{gif gr }nriltnk
U}i{ibilr C R{~kw id Bifjnr{gif Czc}n
Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj gf OCFN[
O}&R&C&Hcgf O}&R&]&@i`c{n]nrnc}ba Rbailc} ]nrnc}ba Crribgc{nr
OCN, Clcfkg !K' OCN, Clcfkg !K'U~fn ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc U~fn ^fgtn}rg{w, Gfkgc
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 347
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 185/223
mndi}nacfk cfk c{ {an rcon {gon {an}n gr rocll ucb`n{
lirr }c{n&
]U gr if/knocfk cfk bifrgr{r id {an dillizgfj
biouifnf{r&c& Bifjnr{gif Oifg{i}gfj8 Zanf fi& id ucb`n{r
biogfj {i {an fikn nqbnnkr g{r bc}}wgfj bcucbg{w, fiknmnbionr bifjnr{nk cfk g{r r{c}{r lirgfj ucb`n{r& Tc}gi~r
on{}gbr c}n ~rnk di} fikn {i oifg{i} bifjnr{gif r{c{~r&Ocgf uc}con{n}r c}n un}bnf{cjn id cll ucb`n{r kgrbc}knk
di} lcb` id m~ddn} rucbn, {an ctn}cjn s~n~n lnfj{a, {an
fi& id {an ucb`n{r {gonk i~{ cfk }n{}cfrog{{nk, ctn}cjn
ucb`n{ knlcw& Gf cll {anrn uc}con{n}r, }grgfj f~omn}
gfkgbc{nr j}izgfj bifjnr{gif&=' U}goc}w ]i~{n Kgrbitn}w8 Rnfkn} kgrbitn}r {an
}i~{n {i {an }nbngtn} mw m}ickbcr{gfj {an ]NS ucb`n{{izc}k }nbngtn}& [an }nbngtn} }nruifkr ]NS mw rnfkgfj{an ]NU ucb`n{ if rcon uc{a {ac{ {an ]NS u}ntgi~rlw
dilliznk& [agr gr bcllnk u}goc}w }i~{n cfk fiknr if {agrc}n bcllnk u}goc}w fiknr& [i }nk~bn {}cddgb k~n {i {an
u}goc}w }i~{n kgrbitn}w cfk mn{{n} kncl zg{aBifjnr{gif gf {an fn{zi}`, = r{}c{njgnr c}n ckiu{nk
3' ]NS gr k}iuunk gd c}}gtgfj c{ c fikn zagba gr actgfjbifjnr{gif r{c{~r cr “}nk‟ =' ]NS gr k}iuunk G c}}gtgfj
c{ fikn cl}nckw actgfj c }i~{n {i knr{gfc{gif &
m& Mwucrr Kgrbitn}w8 C u}goc}w fikn un}gikgbcllwm}ickbcr{r c ^K[ g&n& ~ukc{n ucb`n{& [agr ucb`n{
bif{cgfr {an fiknr bifjnr{gif r{c{~r cfk rn{ id {~ulnrPknr{gfc{gif K, fnq{ j}nnf fikn J, kgr{cfbn {i j}nnf
fikn, f_ di} ncba fikn cuunc}gfj cr c knr{gfc{gif gf
u}goc}w {cmln& Di} {agr }ncrif gr zanf fikn U }nbngtnr cf~ukc{n ucb`n{ d}io fnq{ u}goc}w fikn Ufnq{, cmi~{ {an
knr{gfc{gif K, U zgll mn czc}n id bifjnr{gif r{c{~r id
fnq{& [agr bc~rnr {an bifjnr{gif {i `fiz cmi~{ {an fnq{j}nnf fikn id U zagba gr f aiur czcw d}io u}goc}w}i~{n& M~{ gd {an fnq{ aiu gr wnlliz i} }nk, bifjnr{gifzgll mn {an}n gd kc{c ucb`n{r bif{gf~n {i mn di}zc}knk if
UUfnq{& M~{, B]U {}gnr {i `nnu bifjnr{gif d}ioibb~}}gfj gf {an dg}r{ ulcbn, U fikn r{c}{r {i rnlnb{ mwucrr
}i~{n {izc}k J/{an fnq{ j}nnf fikn id U `fizf d}io {an
^K[ ucb`n{& [agr mwucrr rnc}ba gr rgoglc} {i u}goc}w
}i~{n rnc}ba, nqbnu{ {ac{ 3'{an mwucrr }ns~nr{ ucb`n{‗r[[L gr rn{ {i =(o cfk ='mwucrr }ns~nr{ gr k}iuunk gd
c}}gtgfj c{ fikn cl}nckw u}nrnf{ if u}goc}w }i~{n& G{bcf mn clri uirrgmln {ac{ fi mwucrr gr di~fk& Ri, gf r~ba
rg{~c{gif ucb`n{r c}n knlgtn}nk {i knr{gfc{gif mwdillizgfj u}goc}w }i~{n&
B& [}cddgb Rulg{{gfj cfk Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{cmglg{w8
Zanf {an mwucrr c{ c fikn gr di~fk, kc{c ucb`n{r biogfj
{i {agr fikn c}n fi{ fnbnrrc}glw ru}nck itn} mwucrr cfk
u}goc}w }i~{n& [i ctigk {an mwucrr d}io mngfj
bifjnr{nk fi ucb`n{ gr di}zc}knk if mwucrr ~flnrr cfw
u}goc}w fikn gr }nk g&n& bifjnr{nk& [an mcrgb gknc mnagfk{}cddgb rulg{{gfj gr {ac{ zanf u}goc}w lgf` bifrgr{r id lnrr
bifjnr{nk fikn, {}cddgb if u}goc}w lgf` rai~lk mngfb}ncrnk, i{an}zgrn g{ rai~lk mn }nk~bnk& Mwucrr cfk
u}goc}w }i~{nr bcffi{ gfbl~kn oi}n {acf = biooiffiknr, m~{ kgddn}nf{ mwucrr uc{ar bcf rac}n biooif
fikn& [agr gfb}ncrnr bacfbn {i kgrbitn} c mwucrr& M~{,
mnbc~rn id {agr mwucrr fikn ocw mnbion bifjnr{nk gd g{
acr {i bc}}w lc}jn lickr id mwucrr {}cddgb& M~{, {agr bcf mn
riltnk, mw rulg{{gfj u}imcmglg{w ckh~r{onf{ di} bifjnr{gifckcu{c{gif& [an u}imcmglg{w ckh~r{onf{ gr cr raizf gf
[CMLN G&m& O~l{guc{a Ogfgogxc{gif8 [i }nk~bn {an u}i{ibil
itn}anck, B]U {}gnr {i ogfgogxn ~rgfj o~l{guln uc{ar& Gd
{an u}imcmglg{w u {i di}zc}k kc{c if c u}goc}w lgf` cuu}icbanr 3&5, {agr oncfr {an fnq{ u}goc}w fikn gr dc}
d}io bifjnr{nk i} {an mwucrr }i~{n gr agjalw bifjnr{nk&Gf {agr bcrn, {an mwucrr c{ {an b~}}nf{ fikn gr }noitnk&
Rgoglc}lw, gd {an fnq{ u}goc}w fikn gr tn}w bifjnr{nk !u
cuu}icbanr 5', {an u}goc}w lgf` gr kgrbiffnb{nk cfk {anmwucrr }i~{n mnbionr u}goc}w& [i oc`n
{an u}i{ibil oi}n lgja{zngja{, B]U kinr fi{ clliz cfikn {i actn oi}n {acf ifn mwucrr& [an u}i{ibil
itn}anck k~n {i ~rgfj mwucrr gr clri }nk~bnk uc}{lwmnbc~rn id rai}{ mwucrr lnfj{ar& Ncba mwucrr biffnb{r {i
{an dg}r{ fif/bifjnr{nk fikn cd{n} {an bifjnr{gif rui{,
zagba rai~lk mn h~r{ c dnz aiur kizfr{}nco&
b&Dcgl~}n ]nbitn}w8 B]U gr cmln {i s~gb`lw }nr~onbiffnb{gtg{w cd{n} c lgf` m}nc`cjn mw ~rgfj mwucrr }i~{nr
b~}}nf{lw ctcglcmln& [an}n c}n 2 ogf bcrnr id dcgl~}nU}goc}w lgf` dcgl~}n8 Zanf ifn id lgf` if u}goc}w
}i~{n dcglr, {an gfg{gcl fikn rnfkr c KGRB ucb`n{ {izc}kr
rnfkn} clifj }i~{n& [agr KGRB jinr if }nbi}kgfj fiknrcfk g{ r{iur c{ fikn actgfj mwucrr& [agr fikn gd dgfkr
{ac{ g{r mwucrr knr{gfc{gif gr {an}n gf KGRB, {ac{ mwucrr grfi{ ~rnk cfk KGRB gr di}zc}knk ~ur{}nco {izc}krrnfkn} {gll g{ dgfkr c fikn zg{a mwucrr cfk fi{ actgfj
dcglnk fikn cr g{r knr{gfc{gif& Gd mi{a {anrn bcrnr c}n fi{
Bifjnr{gif Mwucrr
r{c{~r?j}nnf
Mwucrr r{c{~r?wnlliz Mwucrr r{c{~r?}nk
Fnq{ u}goc}w fikn gr j}nnf U8?u+!3/u'); U8?u+!3/u')2 U8?u+!3/u')=
Fnq{ u}goc}w fikn gr wnlliz U ~fbacfjnk U ~fbacfjnk U8?u+!3/u');
Fnq{ u}goc}w fikn gr }nk U8?u/!3/u')= U8?u/!3/u'); Dgfk cfi{an} mwucrr
[CMLN G
RULG[[GFJ U]IMCMGLG[W CKH^R[ONF[
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:5
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 186/223
{an}n KGRB gr rnf{ {i {an rnfkn} cfk g{ zgll dgfk fnz
u}goc}w }i~{n& k&Mwucrr lgf` i} fikn dcglr8 Gf {agr bcrn mwucrr fikn
zagba dgfkr {agr dcgl~}n rnfkr c MURYKGRB ucb`n{{a}i~ja mwucrr }i~{n {i u}goc}w fikn cfk {ac{ mwucrr gr
}noitnk&
n&U}goc}w fikn dcglr8 Gd fikn if {an u}goc}w }i~{n
dcglr, g{r u}ntgi~r fikn rnfkr KGRB ucb`n{ clifj u}goc}w}i~{n& Gd {an mwucrr fikn kn{nb{r rion dcgl~}n, g{ zgll clrirnfk MURYKGRB ucb`n{ clifj mwucrr ~f{gl }ncbagfj c
u}goc}w fikn& Zanf u}goc}w fikn }nbngtnk mi{a {anrn
ucb`n{, g{ }noitnr mwucrr cfk KGRB ucb`n{ gr di}zc}knkclifj u}goc}w }i~{n& [anf {agr gr acfklnk rcon cr dg}r{
bcrn& Gd MURYKGRB ucb`n{ kinrf‗{ c}}gtn c{ {an u}goc}w
fikn if {gon {ac{ mwucrr gr ~rnk cr u}goc}w }i~{n& M~{, gd
g{ bionr lc{n, g{ gr gjfi}nk& M~{, }i~{n }nocgfr m}i`nf m~{g{ zgll }nbitn} riif mnbc~rn cfi{an} KGRB ucb`n{ zgll mn
rnf{ mcb`&
[i ntcl~c{n {an un}di}ocfbn id {an B]U dillizgfj
uc}con{n}r c}n ~rnk8 c&Ucb`n{ knlgtn}w }c{gi8 Un}bnf{cjn id kc{c ucb`n{r
}nbngtnk c{ {an knr{gfc{gif i~{ id {an f~omn} id kc{c
ucb`n{r jnfn}c{nk mw {an BM] {}cddgb ri~}bnr&
m&Nfk/{i/Nfk knlcw8 G{ gr {an cbb~o~lc{gtn knlcw gf
kc{c ucb`n{ k~n {i m~ddn}gfj id ucb`n{r, fnz }i~{nkgrbitn}gnr, s~n~gfj knlcw, OCB/lcwn} }n/{}cfrogrrgif,
cfk {}cfrogrrgif cfk u}iucjc{gif knlcwr&
b&]i~{gfj Itn}anck8 [an }c{gif id {an coi~f{ gfmw{nr id bif{}il ucb`n{r {}cfrog{{nk {i {an coi~f{ gf
mw{nr id kc{c }nbngtnk&
k&Fi}oclgxnk uizn} bifr~ou{gif8 [an }c{gi id {an
coi~f{ gf mw{nr id mi{a bif{}il cfk kc{c ucb`n{r
{}cfrog{{nk {i {an coi~f{ gf mw{nr id kc{c }nbngtnk&
M& Cf Nddgbgnf{ Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj
U}i{ibil di} Oimgln Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r !NBC]U'8
Cf nddgbgnf{ bifjnr{gif ckcu{gtn }i~{gfj u}i{ibil grmn{{n} {acf ntn}w i{an} }i~{gfj u}i{ibil k~}gfj anctw
{}cddgb lickr& [an NBC]U, }i~{gfj u}i{ibil nfr~}nr agjactcglcmglg{w id cl{n}fc{gtn }i~{nr cfk }nk~bn {an }c{n id
r{cln }i~{nr& NBC]U gr actgfj ocgflw CIKT cr g{r mcrn&
[agr bcf mn cbagntnk mw gfb}ncrgfj {an uc}con{n}r id
}i~{gfj u}i{ibilr !nrunbgcllw gf CIKT' {ac{ fi}ocllw{c`n oi}n {gon di} lgf` }nbitn}w& [anrn uc}con{n}r c}n
cb{gtnY}i~{nY{gon/i~{, }i~{nY}nulwYzcg{Y{gon,
}ntn}rnY}i~{nYlgdn, [[LYr{c}{, [[LYgfb}nonf{,[[LY{a}nrailk cfk knln{nYun}gik&
NBC]U Bifjnr{gif Bif{}il Clji}g{ao[agr clji}g{ao u}itgknr ril~{gif {i gou}itn }i~{gfj
u}i{ibilr k~n {i bifr{}cgfnk nftg}ifonf{&
R{nu 38 Banb` {an ibb~ucfbw id lgf` lcwn} m~ddn} id fikn un}gikgbcllw& Ln{ Fb mn {an bifjnr{gif r{c{~r
nr{goc{nk&
R{nu =8 Biou~{n F b ?F~omn} id ucb`n{ m~ddn}nk gf
m~ddn})M~ddn} RgxnR{nu 28 Rn{ {an r{c{~r di} bifjnr{gif& G{ bcf mn
gfkgbc{nk mw {a}nn r{c{~rnr “Ji‟, “bc}nd~l‟, cfk “R{iu‟&
P “Ji‟ gfkgbc{nr {an}n gr fi bifjnr{gif zg{a F b ≫ ¿ _,
“bc}nd~ll‟ gfkgbc{nr {an r{c{~r lg`nlw {i mn bifjnr{nk zg{a¿ ≫ F b ≫ ¶ cfk “R{iu‟ gfkgbc{nr {an r{c{~r cl}nckw
bifjnr{nk, ¶ ≫ F b ≫ 3&_R{nu ;8 Gfti`n bifjnr{gif bif{}il }i~{gfn zanf lgf`
dcglnk ntnf{ acr ibb~}}nk gf kc{c {}cfrdn} zg{a ~rgfj
cb{gtn }i~{n i} ¶ ≫ F b ≫ 3&
R{nu >8 Crr~on {ac{ fngjami}gfj zgll actn cl{n}fc{n}i~{n i} fif/bifjnr{nk }i~{n {i {an knr{gfc{gif&R{nu 4 8 Oc`n S~n}w {i fif/bifjnr{nk fngjami}r di}
}i~{n {i knr{gfc{gifR{nu : 8 cd{n} im{cgfgfj {an }i~{nr d}io {an fngjami}r,
rnlnb{ }i~{n zg{a ogfgo~o aiur&R{nu 18 Ifbn }i~{n gr dgfclgxnk r{c}{ rnfkgfj {an kc{c
ucb`n{r {a}i~ja fif/bifjnr{nk }i~{n&R{nu 78 Gd {an}n gr fi cl{n}fc{gtn }i~{n {i knr{gfc{gif
{anf r{c}{ rulg{{gfj {an {}cddgb {i {an lnrr bifjnr{nk }i~{n&R{nu 358 [}cddgb rulg{{gfj nddnb{gtnlw }nk~bnr {an
bifjnr{gif r{c{~r c{ {an fnq{ ocgf fikn&
k& Bifjnr{gif czc}n }i~{gfj ul~r ]c{n Ckcu{c{gif
!BC]C'8
[an mcrn ~rn id BC]C u}i{ibil gr KR]& [an }i~{n
kgrbitn}w onbacfgro id KR] gr oikgdgnk& [agr u}i{ibil
ocgflw cgor {i dgfk {an mwucrr }i~{n di} bifjnr{nk xifnri} fiknr& [agr bcf mn cbagntnk mw biomgfgfj {an ctn}cjn
OCB ~{glgxc{gif cfk {an gfr{cf{cfni~r {}cfrogrrgifs~n~n lnfj{a {i gfkgbc{n {an bifjnr{gif lntnl id fiknr gf{an fn{zi}`& Zanf ri~}bn zcf{r {i {}cfrog{ kc{c {i {an
knr{gfc{gif fikn, g{ m}ickbcr{r ]]NS ucb`n{r& Zanfgf{n}onkgc{n bikn }nbngtnr ]]NS, g{ banb`r g{r
bifjnr{gif lntnl& Gd {an bifjnr{gif lntnl gr agjan} {anf g{kgrbc}kr {an ]]NS& Zanf ]]NS c}}gtnr c{ {an
knr{gfc{gif fikn, {ai~ja knr{gfc{gif fikn gr bifjnr{nk i}fi{ g{ acfklnr {an ]]NS cfk }nulgnr ]]NU& Ri, }i~{n
zg{ai~{ bifjnr{nk fikn gr nr{cmlgrank&
BC]C ~rnr {zi on{}gbr {i oncr~}n bifjnr{gif
gfdi}oc{gif dg}r{ gr ctn}cjn OCB lcwn} ~{glgxc{gif& [an
gfr{cf{cfni~r OCB lcwn} ~{glgxc{gif gr bifrgkn}nk cr 5iflw zanf {an onkg~o c}i~fk {an fikn gr ctcglcmln c{{an mnjgffgfj id c {}cfrogrrgif cfk cr 3 zanf {an fikn
gr fi{ gkln& !n&j& kn{nb{gfj uawrgbcl bc}}gn} i} kn{nb{gfj i}mcb` idd k~n {i tg}{~cl bc}}gn} rnfrgfj&' Cr, {an
gfr{cf{cfni~r OCB lcwn} ~{glgxc{gif gr ng{an} 3 i} 5 {anctn}cjn tcl~n zg{a gf {an un}gik gfkgbc{nr {an ~rn id
zg}nlnrr onkg~o c}i~fk {an fikn&Rnbifk on{}gb ~rnk gr gfr{cf{cfni~r {}cfrogrrgif
s~n~n lnfj{a& Gd {an fikn acr ocfw ucb`n{r zcg{gfj gf{an s~n~n, g{ bc~rnr lifj ucb`n{ lc{nfbw i} ntnf k}iuugfj
id ucb`n{r& Ri zn bcf rcw {ac{ fikn gr bifjnr{nk fiz&[an cmitn onf{gifnk on{}gb bcf tn}cbgi~rlw }ndlnb{
{an bifjnr{gif bifkg{gifr c}i~fk {an fikn& [agr u}i{ibil
{}gnr {i ogfgogxn {an bifjnr{gif gf {zi zcwr8 3' G{
di}mgkr {an ]]NS ucb`n{r {i u}iucjc{n gf {an bifjnr{nk
c}nc& =' G{ j~gknr {an }i~{n c}i~fk {an bifjnr{nk c}nc i}
fiknr gfr{nck id cb}irr {ano& Cr c }nr~l{ id {agr fibifkg{gifcl {}cfrogrrgif m~}knf jnfn}c{n gf {anrn c}ncr&
n&Bifjnr{gif Czc}n ]i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} Oimgln ck
aib fn{zi}`r !BC]O'8
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:3
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 187/223
C bifjnr{gif czc}n }i~{gfj u}i{ibil di} oimgln ck
aib fn{zi}`r ~rnr c on{}gb gfbi}ui}c{gfj kc{c }c{nr,
OCB itn}anck cfk m~ddn} knlcw {i bif{}il {an
bifjnr{gif& [an BC]O u}i{ibil gf{}ik~bnr c fnz
uc}con{n} bcllnk ZBK !Zngja{nk Bacffnl Knlcw' {ioncr~}n bifjnr{gif lntnl cfk ckiu{r c }i~{n
NLKB!Nddnb{gtn lgf` Kc{c/}c{n Bc{nji}w' {i ctigk {anOK]]!Ogroc{bank kc{c/}c{n }i~{n' u}imlno& [an
OK]] u}imlno gr raizf gf dillizgfj dgj&2
Dgj& 2 Cf nqcouln id OKK] u}imlno
[an kc{c }c{n id }i~{n raizf mw kcrank !C/M/K/J' gr
lgog{nk mw {ncogfj dcr{ lgf` !M/K' zg{a rliz lgf` !C/M
cfk K/J'&
Cr onf{gifnk nc}lgn}, {an BC]O u}i{ibil gf{}ik~bnr
c fnz uc}con{n} bcllnk ZBK !zngja{nk bacffnl knlcw'
{i oncr~}n bifjnr{gif cfk g{ gr jgtnf cr 8
ZBK?c ϋ S +
!3+m'[ OCBCLL+[ kc{c
zan}n S gr {an f~omn} id m~ddn}nk ucb`n{r di} {agr
lgf`& [ kc{c?Lkc{c ) ] gr {an kc{c {}cfrogrrgif {gon, Lkc{c gr
{an lnfj{a id kc{c gf mw{nr i} mg{r cfk ] gr {an kc{c }c{n id
{an lgf`& [ OCBCLL gr {i{cl {gon runf{ c{ {an OCB lcwn}&
[an bifr{cf{r c cfk m c}n uc}con{n}r zg{a tcl~nr
mn{znnf 5 cfk 3 zagba c}n ~rnk {i zngja{ [ OCBCLL& Mw
zngja{gfj [ OCBCLL bcf ctigk ogrh~kjonf{ id bifjnr{gifcr raizf gf dgj&=
Dgj& = [zi rbnfc}gir zg{a {an rcon itn}cll knlcw m~{ kgddn}nf{
OCB cfk {}cfrogrrgif knlcw k~n {i kgddn}nf{ kc{c/}c{nr cfk bifjnr{gif
lntnlr&
Gf BC]O, ri~}bn fikn m}ickbcr{r ]]NS ucb`n{r
zg{a NLKB cfk ZBK gfdi}oc{gif zanf g{ c{{nou{r {i
{}cfrog{ kc{c {i {an knr{gfc{gif& Gf{n}onkgc{n fiknr
biouc}n ri~}bn GK, ri~}bn rns~nfbn, cfk NLKB id {an
]]NS ucb`n{r {anw }nbngtn d}io fngjami}r, cfk k}iu {an
]]NS ucb`n{r zairn ri~}bn GK cfk ri~}bn rns~nfbnf~omn} c}n {an rcon zg{a {ac{ id i{an} ]]NS ucb`n{r
}nbngtnk nc}lgn} cfk NLKB gr lizn} {acf {an nc}lgn}
]]NS ucb`n{r‗& Iflw {an knr{gfc{gif fikn bcf }nruifkr
{i {an ]]NS ucb`n{r mw rnfkgfj ]]NU ucb`n{r mcb` {i
{an ri~}bn clifj {an }i~{n d}io zagba {anw bcon& [an
}i~{n gr nr{cmlgrank zanf {an dg}r{ ]]NU c}}gtnr c{ {an
ri~}bn& [an r~mrns~nf{ ]]NU ucb`n{r c}n bcbank di} {an
ruc}n }i~{nr& [an ~{glgxc{gif id {an bifjnr{gif on{}gb,
ZBK, gr tn}w runbgcl gf BC]O u}i{ibil& Mnbc~rn {an
u}gi}g{w id }i~{n ucb`n{r gr agjan} {acf kc{c ucb`n{r, {an
}i~{n ucb`n{r bcf mn di}zc}knk zg{ai~{ s~n~gfj& [ac{ gr,
{an bifjnr{gif lntnl gfdi}oc{gif gfan}nf{ gf s~n~gfj
knlcwr gr lir{& [an c~{ai} u}iuirnk c ]]NS/knlcw
rbanon& Cf ]]NS gr di}zc}knk zg{a c knlcw id {anZBK {ac{ gr bclb~lc{nk cbbi}kgfj {i {an ZBK
gfdi}oc{gif gf {an ]]NS c{ {an gf{n}onkgc{n fiknr& [an
lizn} {an bifjnr{gif lntnl id lgf` gr, {an roclln} {an
knlcw id ]]NS ucb`n{r c}n, {an nc}lgn} {an ]]NS
ucb`n{r c}}gtn c{ {an knr{gfc{gifr& [agr rbanon nfr~}nr
{ac{ {an ]]NS ucb`n{r id }i~{nr zg{a lizn} bifjnr{gif
lntnl c}}gtn c{ {an knr{gfc{gif dg}r{ cfk bifjnr{nk lgf`r
c}n nlgogfc{nk gf {an }i~{nr& [agr cll bc~rnr agja
itn}anck& Ri, itn}anck gf bcrn id BC]O gr tn}w agja&
N& Bifjnr{gif/Czc}n Kgr{cfbn Tnb{i} !BCKT'8
[an BCKT u}i{ibil gr mcrnk if u}icb{gtn u}i{ibil,
KRKT& Gf c kgr{cfbn tnb{i} }i~{gfj u}i{ibil, ntn}w air{ocgf{cgfr c }i~{gfj {cmln bif{cgfr c kgr{cfbnr d}io g{rnld
{i uirrgmln knr{gfc{gifr& C oimgln air{ gf ck /aib
fn{zi}` cb{r lg`n c rgfjln rn}tn} s~n~gfj rwr{no& Knlcw
gf rnfkgfj ucb`n{ gr }nlc{nk zg{a bifjnr{gif& Gf BCKT,
ncba nf{}w gr }nlc{nk zg{a knlcw nqunb{nk& [agr anlur {i
oncr~}n bifjnr{gif c{ {an fnq{ aiu& [an nqunb{nk knlcwgr biou~{nk dillizr8
∓
!3'Zan}n f gr {an f~omn} id rnf{ ucb`n{r $ L gr {an
lnfj{a id OCB lcwn} ucb`n{ s~n~n& N PK_ nr{goc{nr {an
{gon& C fnzlw c}}gtnk ucb`n{ acr {i zcg{ mndi}n g{ gr rnfki~{&Gf BCKT, }i~{gfj knbgrgif gr ockn mcrnk if
kgr{cfbn {i {an knr{gfc{gif cr znll cr {an nqunb{nk knlcw
c{ {an fnq{ aiu raiznk gf !3' BCKT jgtnr {an }i~{nr
zg{a liz nqunb{nk knlcw, agjan} u}gi}g{w& BCKT {}gnr {i
ctigk bifjnr{gif cfk {}gnr {i mclcfbn {}cddgb mw jgtgfj
u}gi}g{w {i c }i~{n actgfj liz nqunb{nk knlcw&
BCKT }i~{gfj u}i{ibil bifrgr{ id {a}nn biouifnf{r8
3' [}cddgb Oifg{i}8 G{ oifg{i}r {}cddgb jigfj i~{
{a}i~ja {an lgf` lcwn}& B~}}nf{lw g{ `nnur {}cb` id
ctn}cjn knlcw di} rnfkgfj ifn kc{c ucb`n{ gf }nbngu{
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 188/223
un}gik id {gon& [gon un}gik gr runbgdgnk mw }i~{n
ocgf{cgfcfbn biouifnf{&=' [}cddgb Bif{}il8 G{ kn{n}ogfnr zagba ucb`n{ gr {an
fnq{ {i rnfk i} k}iu& G{ }nrbank~lnr ucb`n{r gd fnnknk& G{r~uui}{r c k}iu {cgl DGDI s~n~n cfk u}itgknr
d~fb{gifclg{w {i s~n~n ucb`n{r&
2' ]i~{n ocgf{cgfcfbn8 G{ gr {an ocgf biouifnf{& G{
un}di}or {an zi}` id nqbacfjgfj gfdi}oc{gif zg{afngjami}r, ntcl~c{gif cfk ocgf{cgfgfj }i~{nr& G{ ocfcjnr{an {}cddgb oifg{i} cfk {}cddgb bif{}il biouifnf{& BCKT
mn{{n} r~uui}{ di} SiR& [an }ncl {gon un}di}ocfbn id
BCKT gr jiik, cfk nfk {i nfk knlcw zcr rai}{& [anitn}anck id BCKT gr ~fcbbnu{cmln zanf {an fn{zi}` gr
lc}jn& [a}i~ja u~{ clri knb}ncrnr {an un}di}ocfbn id
BCKT gr ocw mn znll gf {an rocll $ r{nckw zg}nlnrr ck/
aib fn{zi}`&
D& Bifjnr{gif Czc}n }i~{gfj U}i{ibil !BC]U'
BC]U gr cf if/knocfk }i~{gfj u}i{ibil& G{ ~rnr
gfdi}oc{gif jc{an}nk d}io OCB lcwn} {i kgrbitn}bifjnr{gif d}nn }i~{nr& BC]U ~rnr biomgfnk zngja{
oc{}gq gf g{r r{cfkc}k bir{ d~fb{gif {i banb` di} {anbifjnr{gif lntnl& [an o~l{guln uc{ar c}n biou~{nk
k~}gfj {an }i~{n kgrbitn}w& Bclb~lc{n fikn zngja{ oc{}gq FO zagba crrgjf c bir{ {i ncba lgf` gf {an fn{zi}` cfkrnlnb{ ocqgo~o {a}i~jau~{ uc{ar&
FO ? !Ls ( K}c{n')!IA ocb ( Kctj'
3' ]i~{n }ns~nr{ 8 Bifrgkn} {an }i~{n
R/U3/U=/U2/K
[i gfg{gc{n bifjnr{gif/czc}n }i~{gfj kgrbitn}w, {an
ri~}bn fikn R rnfkr c ]]NS& Zanf {an gf{n}onkgc{n
fikn U3 }nbngtnr {an ]]NS ucb`n{, g{ dg}r{ nr{goc{nr cll{an fikn zngja{ on{}gbr&
[an fikn U3 {anf bclb~lc{nr g{r fikn zngja{ FOU3
]]NSU3 U=U= bclb~lc{nr FOU= cfk di}zc}k {an ]]NS ucb`n{
]]NSU= U2 Dgfcllw {an ]]NS }ncbanr {an knr{gfc{gif fikn K
zg{a {an r~o id fikn zngja{r ]]NSU2 K
=' ]i~{n ]nulw8 [an knr{gfc{gif fikn K
rnfkr {an }i~{n }nulw ucb`n{ ]]NU clifj zg{a {i{cl
fikn zngja{ {i {an goonkgc{n ~ur{}nco fikn U2
]]NSKU2
Fiz U2 bclb~lc{nr g{r bir{ B mcrnk if {angfdi}oc{gif d}io ]]NU cr
BU2? !FO u3+FO u=+FO u2'/!FO u3+FO u='
Mw u}ibnnkgfj gf {an rcon zcw, cll {an gf{n}onkgc{nair{r bclb~lc{n g{r bir{ &If }nbngtgfj {an ]]NU d}io cll{an }i~{nr, {an ri~}bn rnlnb{r {an }i~{n zg{a ogfgo~o
bir{ tcl~n&
GG& BIOUC]GRIFR
Bifjnr{gif gr c kiogfcf{ }ncrif di} ucb`n{ k}iur gfck aib fn{zi}`r&B]U rnfkr ucb`n{r if mi{a mwucrr
uc{ar cfk u}goc}w }i~{nr rgo~l{cfni~rlw& Ri, gfbiogfj
{}cddgb gr kgr{}gm~{nk if u}goc}w cfk mwucrr }i~{n
knunfkgfj if b~}}nf{ bifjnr{gif r{c{~r id fn{zi}`&Bifjnr{gif gr r~mrns~nf{lw mn{{n} }nriltnk &Gf NBC]U
rion uc}con{n}r id CIKT r~ba cr [[LYr{c}{,[[LYgfb}nonf{ c}n gfb}ncrnk& Ri, g{ nfr~}nr {an agja
ctcglcmglg{w id cl{n}fc{gtn }i~{nr cfk }nk~bnr {an }c{n id
m}i`nf }~{ }noitcl u}ibnrr& BCKT gr fi{ bifjnr{gif
ckcu{gtn& G{ iddn}r fi }nonkw zanf {an nqgr{gfj }i~{nmnbionr anctglw bifjnr{nk& Ri, BCKT gou}itnr CIKTgf knlgtn}w }c{gi iflw& [an }ncl {gon un}di}ocfbn id {an
BCKT gr jiik cfk {an Nfk/{i/Nfk knlcw gr rai}{& [an
kgrcktcf{cjn id {an BCKT gr {ac{ rgfbn, ncba fiknocgf{cgfr cll {an }i~{nr {i {an fiknr gf {an fn{zi}` cfk
bacfjnr {an }i~{n gfdi}oc{gif un}gikgbcllw, {an itn}anck
di} ocgf{cgfgfj {an }i~{gfj {cmlnr gr a~jn& [an itn}anck
id {an BCKT gr ~fcbbnu{cmln zanf {an fn{zi}` gr lc}jni} {an {iuilijw bacfjnr d}ns~nf{lw& [an {a}i~jau~{
knb}ncrnr rac}ulw c{ {an rcon {gon& Ri, BCKT ocwun}di}o znll gf {an rocll, r{nckw zg}nlnrr ck /aibfn{zi}`& Mw r{~kwgfj {an clji}g{aor id BC]O, BC]C
cfk BCKT g{ gr bifbl~kn {ac{ itn}anck id {an BC]Ocfk BCKT c}n agjan} {acf BC]C, {an knlcw id BCKT
gr rai}{n} {acf {an i{an} {zi&
GGG& BIFBL^RGIF
G{ gr blnc} d}io clji}g{aor ctcglcmln di} actgfj
ckcu{gtn ril~{gif di} bifjnr{gif gf {an fn{zi}` cr k~n {i
tcr{ ucw lick if fn{zi}`r, zagba ocw mn k~n {i dliikgfjid ucb`n{r i} ocw mn k~n {i }nunc{ }ns~nr{r if {an mcrgr
id n}}i} bi}}nb{gif {nbafgs~nr& Bifjnr{gif on{}gbr r{gll}nocgfr c j}nc{ bacllnfjn di} {an d~{~}n zi}`& G{ gr s~g{n
goui}{cf{ {i im{cgf cf iu{gocl cuu}icba {ac{ biomgfnr}nlc{nk uc}con{n}r billnb{nk d}io uawrgbcl lcwn}, OCB
lcwn} {i oncr~}n bifjnr{gif& Dgfcllw zn bcf bifbl~kn{ac{ bifjnr{gif gr {an u}imlno crribgc{nk zg{a {anfn{zi}` cfk acr {i mn bi~f{n}nk mw actgfj biou}iogrnk
ril~{gif }c{an} {acf nlgogfc{gif&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ K& M& Hiafrif, K& C& Ocl{x, “Kwfcogb ri~}bn }i~{gfj gf ck aib
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r,‟ Oimgln Biou~{gfj, uu& 3>2‒313, 3774&
P=_ Hira M}iba, Kctgk C& Ocl{x, Kctgk M& Hiafrif, Wga/Ba~f A~,
Hi}hn{c Hn{bantc& “C Un}di}ocfbn Biouc}grif id O~l{g/Aiu Zg}nlnrr
Ck Aib Fn{zi}` ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr,‟ [an Di~}{a Cff~cl CBO)GNNN
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Oimgln Biou~{gfj cfk Fn{zi}`gfj, uu& 3/32, 3771
P2_Banf, Q&, A& O& Hifnr, C &K &R& Hcwclc{a, “Bifjnr{gif/Czc}n
]i~{gfj U}i{ibil di} Oimgln Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r,‟ Tnagb~lc}[nbafilijw Bifdn}nfbn =55:, uu& =3/=>, =55:
P;_ R& ]cocfc{acf, O& N& R{nnfr{}~u, “C r~}tnw id }i~{gfj {nbafgs~nr
di} oimgln bioo~fgbc{gifr fn{zi}`r, oimgln fn{zi}`r cfk
cuulgbc{gifr,‟ Til& 3, uu& 71‒35;, 3774&P>_ B& N& Un}`gfr, “Ck aib if knocfk kgr{cfbn tnb{i} !CIKT'
}i~{gfj,‟ GND[ Gf{n}fn{ K}cd{, Fitnomn} 3771,
P4_ A& ]cjactnfk}c cfk K&C& [}cf, “Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj gfCk Aib Fn{zi}`r !Rai}{ Tn}rgif',‟ U}ib& CBO Gf{‗l Bifd& Oimgln
Biou~{gfj cfk Fn{zi}`gfj !OIMGBIO', Ib{& =55;&
P:_ A& ]cjactnfk}c cfk K&C& [}cf, “Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj gfCk Aib Fn{zi}`r‟ GNNN [}cfrcb{gifr if Uc}cllnl cfk Kgr{}gm~{nk
Rwr{nor, Til& 3:, Fi& 33, Fitnomn} =554&
P1_ K&C& [}cf cfk A& ]cjactnfk}c, “]i~{gfj zg{a Bifjnr{gif
Czc}nfnrr cfk Ckcu{gtg{w gf Oimgln Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ib& GNNN
Zg}nlnrr Bioo& cfk Fn{zi}`gfj Bifd& !ZBFB', Oc}& =55>&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:2
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 189/223
P7_ Qgcisgf Banf, Aclnw O& Hifnr cfk Hcwclc{a, -Bifjnr{gif/Czc}n
]i~{gfj U}i{ibil di} Oimgln Ck Aib Fn{zi}`r- GNNN 44{a
bifdn}nfbn
if Tnagbln [nbafilijw, uu&=3/=>, Ib{imn} =55>&P35_ R& H& Lnn cfk O& Jn}lc, “Kwfcogb lick/czc}n }i~{gfj gf ck aib
fn{zi}`r,‟ U}ibnnkgfjr GNNN Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if
Bioo~fgbc{gifr, uu& 2=54‒2=35, H~fn =553&P33_ [&J&Mcrct}ch~, R&@&Rc}`c}, B&U~{{cockcuuc, O&C&Jc~{aco,
“NBC]U8 Cf Nddgbgnf{ Bifjnr{gif Ckcu{gtn ]i~{gfj U}i{ibil di}
Oimgln Ck/aib Fn{zi}`r‟, G[R [nlnbioo~fgbc{gif U}ibbnkgfjr,
uu&:3>/:31, =554&P3=_ Z~ Zng, Xacfj Xaifjxaci, Rac Q~nh~f, Sgf Kcfwcfj “C R{~kw
id Bifjnr{gif/Czc}n ]i~{gfj U}i{ibilr Di} Zg}nlnrr Ck/Aib
Fn{zi}`‟&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 190/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :272>)GRMFY5:41CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :272>
Nqulig{gfj {an Mg{ N}}i} Kgtn}rg{w di} Nddgbgnf{ N}}i} Kn{nb{gif gf O~l{gaiu
Zg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`
Wcf{a~fjmnfg A~o{rin
UJ R{~knf{ ON Biou~{n} Knuc}{onf{
U~fn Gfr{g{~{n id Biou~{n} [nbafilijwU~fn, Gfkgc&
Cmr{}cb{‛ N}}i}r c}n gfan}nf{lw u}nrnf{ gf zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`,nqulig{gfj {an mg{ n}}i} kgtn}rg{w cfk bi}}nb{gfj {an n}}i} di}ucb`n{ {}cfrogrrgif gr fnbnrrc}w di} gou}itgfj {an{a}i~jau~{& Gf o~l{gaiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` zanf {}cfrogrrgif
jinr itn} o~l{guln aiur, n}}i} gfb}ncrnr zagba knj}cknr {anun}di}ocfbn id {an fn{zi}`& Tc}gi~r on{aikr cl}nckw nqgr{di} bif{}illgfj {an n}}i} {i gou}itn {an {a}i~jau~{& Rbc{{n}nk]cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj nqulig{ {an ~rnd~lfnrr id }cfkiofn{zi}` bikgfj cfk blcrrgdw {an mlib` gf{i jiik !liz n}}i}u}imcmglg{w' cfk mck mlib` !agja n}}i} u}imcmglg{w'& Gf {agrucun} zn u}iuirnk c fnz cuu}icba di} bif{}illgfj {an n}}i}&U}iuirnk zi}` ~rnr {an bifbnu{ id di}zc}k n}}i} bi}}nb{gifdi} bi}}nb{gfj cfk bif{}illgfj {an n}}i} if {an mck mg{r,
34SCO gr ~rnk di} oik~lc{gif rwomil cfk rai}{nr{}nocgfgfj clji}g{ao gr ~rnk di} jgtgfj u}gi}g{w {i onrrcjnr&
@nwzi}kr/ O~l{gaiu, [a}i~jau~{, N}}i} bif{}il, mg{ n}}i}, N}}i} kn{nb{gif&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Gf o~l{g/aiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r, bioo~fgbc{gif
mn{znnf rnfkn} cfk }nbngtn} gr bc}}gnk i~{ {a}i~ja c rn}gnr
id gf{n}onkgc{n fiknr zairn d~fb{gif gr {i }nlcwgfdi}oc{gif d}io ifn fikn {i cfi{an}& Gf ~f}nlgcmln
zg}nlnrr bacffnl, n}}i}r c}n fc{~}cllw u}nrnf{& O~l{gaiu
zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` r~ddn} d}io liz {a}i~jau~{ cr n}}i}
gfb}ncrnr itn} o~l{guln aiur& G{ gr goui}{cf{ {i knrgjf cf
nddgbgnf{ {}cfrogrrgif cfk n}}i} bif{}il rbanonr {i
gou}itn {an {a}i~jau~{ gf o~l{gaiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`&Fn{zi}` bikgfj gr gf{}ik~bnk gf P3_ {i gou}itn {an
{a}i~jau~{ un}di}ocfbn& Gf fn{zi}` rwr{no, {an
gf{n}onkgc{n fikn rgoulw }nulgbc{n cfk di}zc}k {an
}nbngtnk gfdi}oc{gif {i {an knr{gfnk fikn ,zagln gf
fn{zi}` bikgfj ,{an gf{n}onkgc{n fikn biomgfn {an
gfdi}oc{gif }nbngtnk d}io kgddn}nf{ ri~}bnr cfk di}zc}k {i{an i~{u~{ fikn& Gf P=_ c fn{zi}` bikgfj cuu}icba {i
biiun}c{gtn kgtn}rg{w gr u}iuirnk, c rbnfc}gi gr bifrgkn}nk
gf zagba {zi uc}{fn}r biiun}c{n {i {}cfrog{ gfdi}oc{gif {ic rgfjln knr{gfc{gif& Mi{a {an uc}{fn} {}cfrog{ {ang} libcllw
jnfn}c{nk gfdi}oc{gif cfk {an uc}{fn} }nlcw gfdi}oc{gifzagba lnck {i cf nfbikgfj rbanon gf zagba {an cljnm}cgb
r~un}gouirg{gif id g{r libcl cfk }nlcw gfdi}oc{gif gr
{}cfrog{{nk mw ncba uc}{fn}& C{ {an knr{gfc{gif knbikgfj gr
kifn mw }nunc{gfj {an u}ibnrr mn{znnf {an biknzi}k d}io
{an {zi uc}{fn}r& Gf c bioo~fgbc{gif fn{zi}`, tc}gi~r
`gfk id n}}i} nqgr{r k~}gfj {an ucb`n{ {}cfrogrrgif& N}}i}rgfbl~kn ucb`n{ n}}i}, }cfkio n}}i} cfk ri if& Fn{zi}`
n}}i} bi}}nb{gif bikgfj !FNB' gr gf{}ik~bnk gf P2_ {i knclzg{a {anrn n}}i}r& Nc}lgn} zi}` if fn{zi}` bikgfj ocgflw
dib~r if o~l{gbcr{, gf P;_ Fn{zi}` bikgfj acr mnnf cuulgnk
gf o~l{gaiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` {i {c`n cktcf{cjn id {ano~l{guln }i~{nr d}io rnfkn} {i }nbngtn} gf ~fgbcr{ dlizr&
[an =F/SCO !S~ck}c{~}n Coulg{~kn Oik~lc{gif'
oik~lc{nk rwomil bifrgr{r id F/mg{r& Di} {an =F/SCO
zg{a F lc}jn} {acf =!nj&1SCO !UR@', 34SCO, 4;SCO,
=>4SCO․' {an }nlgcmglg{gnr id {an mg{r J}cw/ocuunk if{i
{an oik~lc{nk rwomil gr kgddn}nf{&34SCO bif{cgfr ;mg{rcfk 4;SCO bif{cgfr 4mg{r&
GG& ]NLC[NK ZI]@
]cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj P>_ gr c {nbafgs~n di}
rbc{{n}gfj gfdi}oc{gif gf c bioo~fgbc{gif fn{zi}`, g{ gr
u}ifn {i n}}i}r& [an c{{cbaonf{ id ntnf c rgfjln bi}}~u{nk
ucb`n{ zgll cddnb{ cll {an gfdi}oc{gif }nbngtnr0 {an}ndi}nn}}i} bif{}il gr id j}nc{ gf{n}nr{ gf }cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj&
Cr ocfw u}imlno ibb~} di} n}}i} bif{}il gf }cfkio
fn{zi}` bikgfj, gf P4_ {an u}imlno id n}}i} bif{}il gr
bifrgkn}nk cfk {an nqu}nrrgif id {an n}}i} bif{}il u}imlno
gr jgtnf gf {n}or id }cf` on{}gb biknr& Nddgbgnf{ Fn{zi}`
bikgfj mcrnk }nlgcmln o~l{gbcr{ gr gf{}ik~bnk gf P:_& Gf P1_{an c~{ai} nqcogfnr {an n}}i} bif{}il u}imlno gf
fifbian}nf{ }cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj& Gf fn{zi}` bikgfj,
n}}i} bif{}il gr cf goui}{cf{ u}imlno rgfbn {anw c}n agjalw
gou}nrrgifcmln {i ucb`n{ n}}i}& Gf P7_ cf n}}i} bif{}il bikn
gf ]cfkio Fn{zi}` bikgfj acr mnnf gf{}ik~bnk& [an]cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj acr c u}iun}{w bcllnk }c{nlnrr gf
zagba {an ucb`n{ c}n nfbiknk cr c lgfnc} biomgfc{gif id {an i}gjgfcl ucb`n{ cfk cll {an gfknunfknf{ ucb`n{ c}n
~rnd~l& C }nbngtn} billnb{ ntn}w kc{c !bi}}nb{ mlib`' {ac{ g{
}nbngtn zg{ai~{ knrb}gmgfj zagba mlib` gr d}io zagba
ri~}bn, ifbn g{ }nbngtn cll {an mlib`r, {an i}gjgfcl kc{c
mlib`r bcf mn bi}}nb{lw }nbifr{}~b{nk& Gf {agr rnfrn,}cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj bcf mn bifrgkn}nk cr c }c{nlnrr
bikn& Zanf }cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 191/223
gr cuulgnk {i o~l{gaiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r, {an rnfkn}
nfbiknr {an kc{c cfk {}cfrog{r {an biknk mlib`r {i {an
}nlcw, zagba zgll di}zc}k {an kc{c {i {an nfk }nbngtn}&
GfP35_K}gxxln gr u}iuirnk {i rnn zan{an} fn{zi}` bikgfj
zgll mn r{gll ~rnk gf o~l{gbacffnl zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`r cfk g{
gr c fnz ril~{gif {i ocqgogxn {an {a}i~jau~{ gf {anu}nrnfbn id n}}i}r& Gf P33_ c rgjfcl bifr{nllc{gif
}nc}}cfjnonf{ di} AC]S gr u}nrnf{nk zan}n di}
}n{}cfrogrrgif rwomil ocuugfj gr ~rnk cfk c{ {an }nbngtn}
mndi}n knoik~lc{gif rgjfcl biomgfc{gif gr goulnonf{nk
cfk {anf {an biomgfnk rgjfcl gr knoik~lc{nk& Gf P3=_ cfitnl clji}g{ao di} rnc}bagfj AC]S zg{a bifr{nllc{gif
}nc}}cfjnonf{ gr u}iuirnk& Gf zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gif k~n
{i ~f}nlgcmln zg}nlnrr bacffnlr }n{}cfrogrrgif gr kifn {i
}noitn {an n}}i}r& Rbc{{n}nk ]cfkio Fn{zi}` bikgfj !R/
]FB' gr gf{}ik~bnk gf P32_ {i gou}itn {an {a}i~jau~{, g{ gr
knrgjfnk {i nqcogfn {an mnfndg{ u}itgknk mw {an }cfkio
fn{zi}` bikgfj&
GGG& U]IUIRNK ZI]@ P32_ Gf{}ik~bnr mg{ n}}i} kgtn}rg{w cfk u}iuirnr
Rbc{{n}nk ]cfkio Fn{zi}` Bikgfj !R/]FB' {i nqulig{
{agr kgtn}rg{w {i gou}itn {an {a}i~jau~{ di} o~l{gaiu
zg}nlnrr bioo~fgbc{gif& Aizntn}, R/]FB }nlgnr if
}cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj cfk mlib` kgddn}nf{gc{gif !ncba
mlib` o~r{ actn c u}gi}g{w'& R/]FB bcf mn nq{nfknk cfk
jnfn}clgxnk {i }noitn {anrn {zi }nr{}gb{gifr& Zn u}iuirn{i ki ri ~fkn} {zi kgddn}nf{ anckr/
3& R{}ifjn} N}}i} Bi}}nb{gif di} emck* mg{r&=& Knbgkgfj zagba mg{r ji {i {an ejiik* mg{r&
[i gou}itn {an {a}i~jau~{ zn bifrgkn} c fnz cuu}icba
di} bif{}illgfj {an n}}i}r& Gf {agr cuu}icba, R{}ifj n}}i}
bi}}nb{gif zgll mn u}itgknk {i {an mck mg{r cr {anw actn cagja u}imcmglg{w id n}}i}& [agr zgll nfr~}n fi{ iflw n}}i}
}nrglgnfbn, m~{ clri }nk~bnk bikgfj itn}anck& DNB
!di}zc}k n}}i} bi}}nb{gif' gr cuulgnk if {an mck mg{ di}
bif{}illgfj {an n}}i}r& C rbank~lgfj clji}g{ao gr u}iuirnk
{ac{ rbank~lnr {an mlib` ri cr {i ocqgogxn {an {a}i~jau~{id {an rwr{no& Zn baiirn {an rai}{nr{ }nocgfgfj onrrcjn
!R]O' clji}g{ao ri {an onrrcjn zg{a {an rai}{nr{ lnfj{a
zgll actn {an agjanr{ u}gi}g{w&[an onrrcjn zg{a rai}{nr{lnfj{a zgll mn u~{ if {an jiik mlib` cfk lifjnr{ lnfj{a c}n
u~{ if mck mlib` &Gf i}kn} {i ctigk gfkndgfg{n zcg{gfj di}
lifj onrrcjnr R]O zg{a cjngfj gr ckiu{nk cr {an ucb`n{
j}izr ilkn} {ang} u}gi}g{w gfb}ncrnr cfk di} {agr cf cjn ‑c‗
gr cuunfknk {i cll {an onrrcjnr !cjn gr ~rnk iflw mwrbank~ln} cfk gr fntn} {}cfrog{{nk'&Gfg{gcllw cjn c}n rn{ {i 3,
ri !O ? p!o3, c3 ? 3', !o=, c= ? 3',!o2, c2 ? 3', ․&' cfk g{
gr gfb}nonf{nk ntn}w {gon zanf {an u}gi}g{w d~fb{gif gr
bcllnk& Clri, Rai}{nr{ ]nocgfgfj onrrcjn clji}g{ao gr~rnk zagba jgtnr u}gi}g{w {i {an onrrcjn zg{a {an rai}{nr{
lnfj{a zg{a {an aiun {ac{ onrrcjn bcf mn rnf{ {i {an}nbngtn} s~gb`lw zg{a lnrr f~omn} id n}}i}r&
O gr c rn{ id onrrcjnr {ac{ gr
O ? pog | og ∁ O, ∅g&
Ncba onrrcjn !og' bifrgr{r id ifn i} oi}n mg{r& Zn bcf
}nu}nrnf{ og cr c }nj~lc} nqu}nrrgif cr,
og ? !5|3'di} cll g&
Ncba onrrcjn gr biouirnk id rntn}cl mlib`r& Gd {an}n
c}n fg mlib`r gf onrrcjn og {anf
og ? Pmg3 mg= mg2․․ mgf_&Ulcbn {anrn mlib`r gf mlib` s~n~n !MS'&[a~r,
MS?MS ∨ mgh ∅ g, 3≫ h≫ fgh
Di}zc}k n}}i} bi}}nb{gif !DNB' gr ~rnk {i bif{}il n}}i}if mck mg{r& Rgfbn zn c}n ~rgfj 34SCO, {an }nulgbc{gif
DNB
di} 34SCO gr, !Pmg․&m h _ biftn}{nk {i Pmg․&&m=h_'&
Gf 34SCO ncba mlib` gr biouirnk id ;mg{r,
m` ?P m`3 m`= m`2 m`;_,
{an bikn zi}k zgll mn/
B?33 3= 32 3;
=3 == =2 =;
b b b b
b b b b
?3 = 3 =
2 ; 2 ;
` ` ` `
` ` ` `
m m m m
m m m m
[i ulcbn {an jiik i} mck mg{r gf {ang} cuu}iu}gc{nuirg{gif
Jiik oc{}gq !JO' cfk mck oc{}gq !MO'c}n ~rnk& [an
jiik mg{r cfk mck mg{r c}n ogqnk {ijn{an} di} {}cfrogrrgif&
Cr
#4SCO gr ~rnk ;mg{r un} rwomil bcf mn rnfk c{ c {gon
cfk {an jiik cfk mck mg{r c}n ogqnk {ijn{an} gf {anrn;mg{r&[an bikn zi}k zgll mn/
B? !mj' JO + ! mm' MO
[an clji}g{ao mnjgfr zanf g{ }nbngtnr c rn{ id
onrrcjnr O {ac{ c}n {i mn {}cfrog{{nk d}io {an fn{zi}`
lcwn}& Ncba onrrcjn gf O gr uc}{g{gifnk gf{i ;/mg{ mlib`rrgfbn 34SCO gr ~rnk cr oik~lc{gif rwomil& [anrn mlib`r
c}n cuunfknk {i MS& oj!lizn} tcl~n gfkgbc{n agjan}
u}gi}g{w' cfk om!agjan} tcl~n gfkgbc{n lizn} u}gi}g{w' c}nrnlnb{nk d}io coifj {an onrrcjnr gf O & G{ gr uirrgmln {ac{
{an}n gr iflw ifn onrrcjn gf O i} cll onrrcjnr actn {an
rcon u}gi}g{w !lnfj{a'& Gf i}kn} {i nqulig{ mg{ n}}i}
kgtn}rg{w {i gfb}ncrn {a}i~jau~{, zn fnnk c{ lncr{ {zionrrcjn zg{a kgddn}nf{ u}gi}g{gnr &Anfbn, gd oj ? om , zn
{}cfrog{ {an }nocgfgfj mlib`r zg{ai~{ cfw d~}{an}
u}ibnrrgfj& Gf {an i{an} bcrn, zn oitn {i {an fnq{ r{nu& Gf
{an fnq{ r{nu, zn jnfn}c{n {an rn{r JM !jiik mlib`' cfk
MM !mck mlib`'&DNB gr c dlcj {ac{ gfkgbc{nk zan{an} {an]nulgbc{gif DNB gr {i mn cuulgnk& Zn gfg{gclgxn g{ {i e{}~n*&
Gf u}nuc}c{gif di} ulcbgfj {an jiik)mck mlib`r gf {an
jiik)mck uirg{gif, zn rnlnb{ {an dg}r{ mlib` d}io JM cfk
knfi{n g{ mw mj& [an fnq{ r{nu gr {an ]nulgbc{gif DNB!di}zc}k n}}i} bi}}nb{gif'& Zn rnlnb{ {an dg}r{ mlib` d}io
MM !knfi{nk cr mm'& Dgfcllw, zn c}n }nckw {i ulcbn {an
mlib`r gf {an }gja{ uirg{gif& Cr mj acr mnnf {}cfrog{{nk, znbcf fiz }noitn g{ d}io MS& Cd{n} }noitcl id cfw mlib`
d}io MS, zn o~r{ banb` zan{an} MS gr nou{w !r{iuugfj
bifkg{gif' i} gd {an}n gr iflw ifn mlib` gf MS !{}gtgcl
bcrn'&Zn clri }noitn mj d}io JM& Cr JM bif{cgfr cll {anmlib`r id {an onrrcjn oj, cf nou{w JM gfkgbc{nr {ac{ {an
nf{g}n onrrcjn acr mnnf {}cfrog{{nk& Anfbn, zn }noitn oj
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:4
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 192/223
d}io O& Cr MS gr fi{ nou{w, m~{ JM gr nou{w, zn fnnk {i
dgll {an fnq{ onrrcjn gf oj& Zn ki {agr gf {an fnq{ {zi r~m
r{nur& Cr mndi}n, zn banb` gd {an}n gr iflw ifn onrrcjn i}
{an u}gi}g{w id cll {an onrrcjnr c}n {an rcon& Fiz zn
u}ibnnk {i mm& Gd DNB gr {}~n zn rai~lk fi{ un}di}o DNB gf
{an fnq{ g{n}c{gif !gfr{nck zn rai~lk ~rn m='& Gd DNB gr dclrn,zn actn {}cfrog{{nk mi{a m3 cfk m=& Anfbn, zn }noitn mm
d}io MS cfk MM& [an }ncrifgfj gr rcon cr {ac{ ~rnk di}
}noitgfj mj d}io MS cfk JM& [an u}ibnrr zgll bif{gf~n
~f{gl {an nf{g}n onrrcjnr c}n mngfj {}cfrog{{nk&
Clji}g{ao8 Gfu~{8 Rn{ id onrrcjnr !O'
I~{u~{8 [}cfrogrrgif id onrrcjn&
3& Uc}{g{gif {an onrrcjn gf O gf{i mlib`r&
=& Cuunfk ncba mlib` {i MS
2&!c'Rnlnb{ oj r~ba {ac{ u}gi}g{w!oj' ?
ogfpu}gi}g{w!og' ∅g
!m'Rnlnb{ om r~ba {ac{ u}gi}g{w !om' ? ocq pu}gi}g{w
!og'∅g
;& gd !oj ?? om' p{}cfrog{!MS' cfk }n{~}f
>& !c' JM ? pm | !m ∁ MS' cfk !m Ͼ oj'
!m' MM ? pm | !m ∁ MS' cfk !m Ͼ om'
4& DNB ? {}~n:& Rnlnb{ dg}r{ mlib` gf JM8 mj !rcw'
1& gd !DNB ?? {}~n'
!c' Rnlnb{ dg}r{ mlib` gf MM8 mm !rcw'!m' Kndgfn m3 cfk m= cr dillizr/
3
=
m
m
?3 = 3 =
2 ; 2 ;
` ` ` `
` ` ` `
m m m m
m m m m
7& B ? mj Ú JO + m3 Ú MO
35& [}cfrog{ B
33& ]noitn mj d}io MS
3=& &!c'gd !lnfj{a!MS??5'p}n{~}f
!m'nlrn gd !lnfj{a!MS'??3'p[}cfrog{!MS' cfk
}n{~}f32& ]noitn mj d}io JM
3;& gd !lnfj{a!JM??5'
!c' ]noitn oj d}io O
!m' Rnlnb{ oj r~ba {ac{ u}gi}g{w !oj' ?ogfpu}gi}g{w!og'
∅g
!b' JM?pm |!m ∁ MS' cfk !m ∁ oj'!k' Gd !oj ?? om' p{}cfrog{ !MS' cfk }n{~}f
3>& gd !DNB ?? {}~n'!c' DNB ? dclrn!m' m3 ? m=
34& nlrn
!c' DNB ? {}~n
!m' ]noitn mm d}io MS
!b' Gd !lnfj{a !MS' ?? 5' p}n{~}f
!k'Nlrn gd!lnfj{a!MS'??3'p{}cfrog{ !MS' cfk
}n{~}f
!n' ]noitn mm d}io MM
!d' Gd !lnfj{a!MM'?? 5'
g& }noitn om d}io Ogg& Rnlnb{ om r~ba {ac{ u}gi}g{w !om' ? ocq
pu}gi}g{w
!og' ∅g
ggg& MM ? pm | !m ∁ MS' cfk !m ∁ om'
3:& ji {i :
GT & BIFBL^RGIF
Gf {agr ucun}, zn actn u}itgknk c }ntgnz di} {an }ncrifrid uii} {a}i~jau~{ gf o~l{gaiu zg}nlnrr fn{zi}`& N}}i}bif{}il rbanon acr mnnf gf{}ik~bnk di} }cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj& Rbc{{n}nk }cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj }nlgnr if }cfkiofn{zi}` bikgfj cfk {anw u~{ {an mg{r id ikk f~omn} mlib`rgf jiik mg{ uirg{gif cfk ntnf f~omn} mlib`r gf mck mg{
uirg{gif& Zanf {}cfrogrrgif jinr itn} o~l{guln aiur {anikk f~omn} mlib`r c}n u}i{nb{nk d}io jn{{gfj n}}i} zagln{an ntnf f~omn} mlib`r zgll jn{ kg}{gn}& Zn bcf gou}itn {anun}di}ocfbn if {an nqgr{gfj rwr{no mw goulnonf{gfj cr{}ifj n}}i} bif{}il rbanon& [i gou}itn {an {a}i~jau~{,Zn actn u}iuirnk c fnz cuu}icba mw u}itgkgfj r{}ifjn}}i} bi}}nb{gif if {an mck mg{r cr {anw actn c agjau}imcmglg{w id n}}i}&DNB !di}zc}k n}}i} bi}}nb{gif' grcuulgnk if {an mck mg{r di} n}}i} bi}}nb{gif cfk rai}{nr{}nocgfgfj onrrcjn !R]O' clji}g{ao gr clri ~rnk {i jgtnu}gi}g{w {i {an onrrcjn zg{a {an rai}{nr{ lnfj{a zg{a {anaiun {ac{ onrrcjn zgll mn knlgtn}nk {i {an }nbngtn} s~gb`lwcfk {i ctigk gfkndgfg{n zcg{gfj {gon R]O zg{a cjngfj grclri ckiu{nk&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ ]& Calrznkn, F& Bcg, R& ]& Lg, cfk ]& Z& Wn~fj, “Fn{zi}`
gfdi}oc{gif dliz,‟ GNNN [}cfr& Gfd& [ani}w, til& ;4, fi& ;, uu&3=5;‒3=34,H~l& =555&
P=_ L& Qgci, [& D~hc, H& @lgnzn}, cfk K& Bir{nlli, “C fn{zi}` bikgfj
cuu}icba {i biiun}c{gtn kgtn}rg{w,‟ GNNN [}cfr& Gfd& [ani}w, til& >2,fi& 35,uu& 2:3;‒2:==, Ib{& =55:&
P2_ X&Xacfj,‟[ani}w cfk cuulgbc{gif id fn{zi}` n}}i} bi}}nb{gif
bikgfj,‟ u}ibnnkgfj id {an GNNN, til&77, uu&;54/;=5, =533&
P;_ R& @c{{g, A& ]ca~l, Z& A~, K& @c{cmg, O& Onkc}k, cfk H& B}izb}id{,
“QI]r gf {an cg}8 U}cb{gbcl zg}nlnrr fn{zi}` bikgfj,‟ gf U}ib& CBO
RGJBIOO , =554&
P>_ [& Ai, O& Onkc}k, ]& @in{{n}, K& @c}jn}, O& Ndd}ir, H& Rag, cfk M&
Lnifj,“C }cfkio lgfnc} fn{zi}` bikgfj cuu}icba {i o~l{gbcr{,‟ GNNN [}cfr& Gfd&[ani}w , til& >=, fi& 35, uu& ;;32‒;;25, Ib{& =554&
P4_ K& Rgltc, D& @rbagrbacfj, cfk ]& @in{{n}, “C }cf`/on{}gb cuu}icba
{i n}}i} bif{}il gf }cfkio fn{zi}` bikgfj,‟ GNNN [}cfr& Gfd&
[ani}w, til& >;,fi& 7, uu& 27>3‒274:,Rnu =551&
P:_ @&Bag, Q&Hgcfj, M&Wn, A&W&Razn, cfk R&Ai}gj~bag, “Nddgbgnf{
Fn{zi}` bikgfj/Mcrnk Nfk/{i/Nfk ]nlgcmln O~l{gbcr{ gf O~l{g/aiuZg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`,‟U}ibnnkgfj id {an 3>
{aCrgc/Ucbgdgb Bifdn}nfbn
if bioo~fgbc{gif!CUBB=557', =557
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3::
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 193/223
P1_ ]& @in{{n}, D& ]& @rbagrbacfj,‟Bikgfj di} n}}i}r cfk n}cr~}nr gf
]cfkio Fn{zi}` Bikgfj,‟ GNNN [}cfr& Gfd& [ani}w, til& >;,fi&1,uu& 2>:7‒2>73, C~j& =551&
P7_ ]&Calrznkn cfk A&Cwkgfgcf,‟If n}}i} bif{}il biknr di} ]cfkioFn{zi}` bikgfj,‟ Zi}`raiu if Fn{zi}` Bikgfj, {ani}w cfk
Cuulgbc{gifr , =557&
P35_ ]&W&@go,H&Hgf cfk M&Lg,‟K}gxxln8Biiun}c{gtn rwomil/lntnl Fn{zi}` Bikgfj gf ZgOCQ,‟ GNNN [}cfr&tna&[nbafil&,til&>7,
fi&2,uu&3;3>/ 3;2=,Oc}&=535&
P33_ X& Xaci, L& Xai~, Q& Xanfj, cfk R&/N& Uc}`, “Nfacfbnkbifr{nllc{gif }nc}}cfjnonf{ di} ac}s zg{a rwomil biomgfgfj,‟ gf
U}ib& GNNN OZR, H~l& =557, uu& 33‒3>&
P3=_ O&L& Hgc, H&O& @~cfj, cfk X&Z& An, “Nfacfbnk AC]S nouliwgfjLKUB biknk bifr{nllc{gif }nc}}cfjnonf{ zg{a 4;SCO,‟ gf
U}ib&Gf{&Bifd&Bioo~f&[nbafil&,=554, uu& 3‒;&
P32_ ]&W& @go, H& Hgf, M& Lg,‟ Rbc{{n}nk ]cfkio Fn{zi}` Bikgfj di}Nddgbgnf{ [}cfrogrrgif gf O~l{gaiuZg}nlnrr Fn{zi}`,‟GNNN
[}cfr&if Tnagb~lc} [nba&, til&45, =533&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:1
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 194/223
Uc}{ ‒ GGG
U}ibnnkgfjr id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if
Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ =53=
GBBC ‑3=
Til~on ;
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 3:7
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 195/223
Nr{cmlgragfj {an ]nlc{gifragu mn{znnf B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragu
Ocfcjnonf{ cfk N/ M~rgfnrr
Ocf~ Baiu}c]nrnc}ba Rbailc}
Rgfjacfgc fgtn}rg{w, ]chcr{acf
Cmr{}cb{/ B~r{ion} }nlc{gifragu ocfcjnonf{ !B]O' gr
clri `fizf cr }nlc{gifragu oc}`n{gfj i} b~r{ion}
ocfcjnonf{& [an jicl id B]O gr {i cgk i}jcfgxc{gifr
gf mn{{n} ~fkn}r{cfkgfj ncba b~r{ion}‗r tcl~n {i {an
bioucfw& B]O gr c tn}w goui}{cf{ m~rgfnrr gfg{gc{gtn
mnbc~rn k~}gfj {gonr id nbifiogb kgrlibc{gif, b~r{ion}
}n{nf{gif }nunc{cmln }ntnf~n gr c oc{{n} id r~}tgtcl&
B]O gr {an on{aik {ac{ m~rgfnrrnr actn {i kncl zg{a
{an fnzlw ogf{nk b~r{ion} nbifiow&Fiz/c/kcwr, B]O gr non}jgfj cr B]O n/M~rgfnrr& N/
M~rgfnrr gr c {n}o {ac{ gr mcrgbcllw ~rnk {i knrb}gmn c
m~rgfnrr {ac{ }~fr if {an gf{n}fn{ cfk {ac{ oc`nr ~rn id
{an nqgr{gfj gf{n}fn{ {nbafilijgnr {i gfb}ncrn {an
u}idg{cmglg{w cfk nddgbgnfbw id {an m~rgfnrr& [an fnnk di}
B]O n/M~rgfnrr ril~{gif acr mnnf d~nllnk cr u}ik~b{r
actn mnbion oi}n biooikg{gxnk cfk {an f~omn} id
bioun{g{i}r acr ric}nk zg{a u}gbgfj kgddn}nfbnr jn{{gfj
fc}}izn}& Cll {agr acr ulcbnk goonfrn u}nrr~}n if {an
bioucfw cfk i}jcfgxc{gifr c}n dcr{ }nclgxgfj {ac{ {anw
fnnk {i cbagntn b~r{ion} rc{grdcb{gif gd {anw zcf{ {ang}
u}idg{r {i }grn&
Gf {agr ucun} zn zgll {}w {i nr{cmlgra c }nlc{gifragu
mn{znnf {an B]O cfk {an N/ulc{di}o& B]O, knrug{n
mngfj ifn id {an oir{ u}idg{cmln b~r{ion} r{}c{njgnr,r{gll g{ acr rion dcgl~}nr& [an oir{ goui}{cf{ crunb{ id
B]O u}imlnor gr g{r nqbnllnf{ cmglg{w {i cbagntn
b~r{ion} }n{nf{gif m~{ g{r dcgl~}n {i ki ri& [agr gr
gfkg}nb{lw }nruifrgmln di} B]O billcurn& Zac{ cb{~cllw
gr B]O dcgl~}n cfk zaw kinr g{ ibb~}9 Jnfn}cllw ifn id
{an }ncrifr di} {agr dcgl~}n gr mnbc~rn oir{
i}jcfgxc{gifr {ac{ cb{~cllw nouliw B]O, nqun}gnfbn c
li{ id bifd~rgif cmi~{ g{r c{{}gm~{nr cfk zac{ g{ }ncllw gr&
Rion zi~lk kndgfn g{ cr c m~rgfnrr r{}c{njw zagln i{an}r
tgnz g{ cr rion{agfj {i ki zg{a {nbafilijw&
@nwzi}kr8 B]O, N/Bioon}bn, N/ulc{di}o&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIFCr zn cll `fiz {agr gr {an zi}lk zan}n ntn}wgfk~r{}gnr mi~fkc}w c}n fi{ bifdgfnk {i {an mi~fkc}wid {an gfk~r{}gnr& [anrn c}n nq{nfknk knnu gf {anb~r{ion}& [agr ln{ {i {an }grgfj id {an bifbnu{ bcllnkB~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{0 Mcrgbcllw {an
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u,
Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/488 kig8 35&
:25:;)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :25:;
fnnk {i `nnu gf {i~ba zg{a {an b~r{ion} gfb}ncrnr{an rgjfgdgbcf{ id {an B]O rid{zc}n& Fiz c kcw {an}ngr fi bioucfgnr zagba lg`n {i b}nc{n c j}nc{}nlc{gifragu zg{a {an b~r{ion}& [an fnnk id {anbioucfw di} r~ba {wun id }nlc{gifragu gfb}ncrnr {anb~r{ion} rc{grdcb{gif {ac{ gfk~r{}w i} bioucfw gr
{agf`gfj di} {ano&
GG& B^R[ION] ]NLC[GIFRAGUOCFCJNONF[
[an ri bcllnk {wugbcl b~r{ion} fi lifjn} nqgr{r,cfk bioucfgnr actn mnnf lnc}fgfj {agr lnrrif {anac}k zcw& ^f{gl tn}w }nbnf{lw, m~rgfnrr zcr oi}nbifbn}fnk cmi~{ {an “zac{‗r‟ {anf cmi~{ {an“zai‗r‟& Gf i{an} zi}kr, bioucfgnr zn}n di~fk crrnllgfj cr ocfw u}ik~b{r cfk rn}tgbnr cr uirrgmln,zg{ai~{ }njc}k {i zai zcr m~wgfj {ano& Oir{bi}ui}c{gifr blgfj {i {agr u}ik~b{ bnf{}gb tgnz ntnf{ikcw, mcrgfj {ang} i}jcfgxc{gifcl r{}~b{~}n cfk
biounfrc{gif ulcfr if {an u}ik~b{r {anw rnll, fi{ {anb~r{ion} zai m~w& Fizckcwr {an bioun{g{gif gr h~r{ c oi~rn blgb`
czcw& Nomc{{lnk bioucfgnr c}n rli~bagfj {izc}kr{an }nclgxc{gif {ac{ zg{ai~{ b~r{ion}r, u}ik~b{r kif‗{rnll cfk rn}tgbnr kif‗{ oc{n}gclgxn& [anw actn mnnfdi}bnk {i mnbion roc}{n} cmi~{ rnllgfj, cfk {agroncfr mnbiogfj roc}{n} cmi~{ zai‗r m~wgfj,bioucfgnr c}n }nckgfj {an bioun{g{gtn z}g{gfj if {anzcll lii`gfj {an {nbafilijw di} c lnj ~u& [agr,biomgfnk zg{a {an id{ s~i{nk dcb{igk {ac{ g{ bir{r cbioucfw rgq {gonr oi}n {i rnll c u}ik~b{ {i c fnzb~r{ion} {anf g{ kinr {i rnll {i cf nqgr{gfj ifn ‒ {anilk “mg}k gf {an acfk‟ {a~r biogfj {i }iir{ acroi{gtc{nk m~rgfnrr {i {}w {i ocqgogxn nqgr{gfjb~r{ion} }nlc{gifragu cfk {an ocgf zcw {i rs~nnxnntn}w k}iu id tcl~n d}io nqgr{gfj b~r{ion} gr {i`fiz zai {an mnr{ b~r{ion}r c}n oi{gtc{n {ano {ir{cw {ac{ zcw& Gfknnk c jiik r{c}{n} kndgfg{gif id b~r{ion} }nlc{gifragu ocfcjnonf{ gr8
“[an gfd}cr{}~b{~}n {ac{ nfcmlnr {an knlgfnc{gif id cfk gfb}ncrn gf b~r{ion} tcl~n, cfk {an bi}}nb{ oncfr
mw zagba {i oi{gtc{n tcl~cmln b~r{ion}r {i }nocgfliwcl/gfknnk, {i m~w cjcgf‟&
B]O gr {an rncolnrr bi/i}kgfc{gif mn{znnf rclnrb~r{ion} rn}tgbn, oc}`n{gfj dgnlk r~uui}{ cfk i{an}
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 315
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 196/223
b~r{ion} {i~bagfj d~fb{gifr& G{ gf{nj}c{nr uniuln, u}ibnrr cfk {nbafilijw {i ocqgogxn }nlc{gifraguzg{a cll b~r{ion}r cfk r~uulgn}r& B]O }nr~l{r gf c
f~omn} id mnfndg{r {i cf i}jcfgxc{gif lg`n gfb}ncrnkoc}jgfr gou}itnk b~r{ion} rc{grdcb{gif }c{gfjr cfkknb}ncrnk ckogfgr{}c{gtn bir{r& [an jicl id B]O gr{i cgk i}jcfgxc{gifr gf mn{{n} ~fkn}r{cfkgfj ncbab~r{ion}‗r tcl~n {i {an bioucfw, zagln gou}itgfj{an nddgbgnfbw cfk nddnb{gtnfnrr id bioo~fgbc{gif&B]O bcu{~}nr, cfclwrgr, cfk kgr{}gm~{nr cll }nlntcf{kc{c d}io b~r{ion}r cfk u}irunb{ gf{n}cb{gifr {intn}wifn gf {an i}jcfgxc{gifr& B]O nouacrgxnkb~r{ion} cbs~grg{gif cfk gr }nbijfgxnk cr ifn id {anoir{ tgcmln {iilr ~rnk {i d~{~}n c bioucfw‗r r~bbnrrgf {an agjalw bioun{g{gtn m~rgfnrr zi}lk&
[an}n c}n {a}nn ochi} c}ncr {ac{ dib~r ifb~r{ion} rc{grdcb{gif, rclnr, oc}`n{gfj cfk rn}tgbnr&[an d~fb{gifclg{w id cfk mn{znnf {anrn {a}nn dgnlkr grnrrnf{gcl {i r~bbnrrd~llw biffnb{gfj c bioucfw‗rd}if{ cfk mcb` iddgbnr {i dcbglg{c{n nddnb{gtn,nf{n}u}grn zgkn bii}kgfc{gif& [an u}idnrrgifcl rclnrdi}bn u}nkgb{r cfk u}iuirnr {an }ncl {gon cfclwrgr id gfdi}oc{gif cfk kgr{}gm~{nr {agr gfdi}oc{gif {i {anbioucfw cfk m~rgfnrr uc}{fn}r& Oc}`n{gfjbifbnf{}c{nr if un}rifclgxgfj b~r{ion} u}ndn}nfbnrcfk iddn}gfj {ano rc{grdwgfj nqun}gnfbnr rn}tgbn grcrribgc{nk zg{a {an bioucfgnr bcll bnf{n}r cfkbii}kgfc{n gf{n}cb{gif mn{znnf znm nocgl cfk i{an} bioo~fgbc{gif Onkgcr& [anrn dgnlkr c}n kntnliunkd~}{an} zg{a {an anlu id B]O c~{ioc{gif&
GGG& B]O BACLLNFJNRB]O knrug{n mngfj ifn id {an oir{ u}idg{cmln
b~r{ion} r{}c{njgnr, r{gll g{ acr rion dcgl~}nr& [anoir{ goui}{cf{ crunb{ id B]O u}imlnor gr g{rnqbnllnf{ cmglg{w {i cbagntn b~r{ion} }n{nf{gif m~{ g{rdcgl~}n {i ki ri&
Tc}gi~r u}imlnor zg{a B]O c}n8c& Nqi}mg{cf{ bir{r
m& Gfckns~c{n dib~r if imhnb{gtnrb& Gfnddgbgnf{ ]nri~}bnr
k& Gfcuu}iu}gc{n oc{}gbnrn& Bioulnq Rwr{nor&
d& Fi b~r{ion} dib~rj& Rliz }n{~}frB]O kinr dcgl gf rion gfr{cfbnr& [ac{ bcffi{ mn
kgru~{nk& B]O }ntgnzr rain {ac{ {an dcgl~}n }c{nr id B]O bi~lk }ncba c agja id cf cocxgfj 15. gf c dnzwnc}r {gon& [ac{‗r nf{g}nlw gf bif{}ctnf{gif id cll {anagjar {ac{ actn mnnf u}nkgb{nk }gja{9 G{ h~r{ ntgknfbnr{an dcb{ {ac{ gd B]O gr {i mn nouliwnk g{ acr {i mnkifn zg{a {an ~{oir{ bc~{gif nqn}bgrnk cfk zg{a d~llc{{nf{gif {i goulnonf{c{gif&
Rion rid{zc}n bioucfgnr clri dcglr gfgoulnonf{gfj B]O, if {agr d}if{ {an bagnd ogr{c`nbi~lk mn {an zcw {anw acfkln RDC cr c biouifnf{&
Zac{ acuunfr gr {ac{ knrug{n {an dcb{ {ac{ {annfkncti} {i anlu rclnr un}rifr cb{~cllw jcgf j}i~fkgf {ang} rclnr nddi}{r {anw zgfk ~u kigfj {an iuuirg{n&
Rgfbn {an rwr{nor c}n kntgrnk bagndlw mw uniuln zaic}n fi{ c{ {an di}n d}if{ cfk zai `fiz tn}w lg{{lncmi~{ rclnr cb{gtg{gnr un}rifcllw, {agr acr cf goucb{if g{r ~rn} d}gnfklw c{{}gm~{nr& Rclnr un}riffnl{an}ndi}n dgfk {ano s~g{n kgddgb~l{ {i acfkln cfk oi}nid{nf {anf fi{ fif u}ik~b{gtn cr znll&
B]O ucb`cjnr {nfk {i dcgl clri if cbbi~f{ id {ang} gfdlnqgmglg{w i} racll zn rcw {ang} }gjgkg{w& CB]O ril~{gif {nfkr tgnz {an b~r{ion} cr wn{ cfi{an} {}cfrcb{gif& M~{ b~r{ion}r c}n dc} d}io {ac{& Rnngfj{ano cr dgj~}nr cfk f~omn}r gr ifn id {an liiu ailnrgf {an B]O gfk~r{}w& [an a~ocf nlnonf{ gr lir{ gf{an nf{g}n runb{}~o id cb{gtg{w& Knbgrgifr c}n }ns~g}nk{i mn ockn if c kcglw mcrgr {ac{ bcf fi{ mngfbi}ui}c{nk gf {an B]O ucb`cjn g{rnld& G{ acrntn}w{agfj {i ki zg{a ruif{cfni~r, knbgrgtn baigbnr
mngfj ockn mw {an nouliwnnr zai c}n dcbn {i dcbn {ib~r{ion}r&
Ifn }ncrif B]O rwr{no id{nf dcgl gr mnbc~rn {annouliwnnr {anornltnr c}n }nl~b{cf{ {i ~rn {ano i} ~fcmln {i ~rn {ano gf {an cuu}iu}gc{n ocffn}& C}onkzg{a gfr~ddgbgnf{ `fizlnkjn cfk ogrbifbnu{gifr {anwc}n anrg{cf{ cfk gll ns~guunk {i kncl zg{a {an B]Onddi}{r& Kgrcuuigf{nk zg{a {an gfg{gcl goulnonf{c{gif}nr~l{r nouliwr r{c}{ {i j}~omln& ]nl~b{cf{ {i jgtn g{c bacfbn {anw r{iu jgtgfj idd {ang} mnr{ nddi}{r iflw {icgk B]O dcgl~}n& [an awun cmi~{ B]O gr id{nf {i
mlcon ‒ lnctgfj nouliwr mnlgntgfj gf {an ocjgbzcfk rznnugfj czcw cll {ang} kgddgb~l{gnr zanf {ancb{~cl ug{dcllr c}n dnl{, {anw r{iu zi}`gfj {izc}krB]O jiclr& ]nr~l{ ‒ B]O dcgl~}nr&
B]O clri dcglr mnbc~rn m~rgfnrrnr rnlkio mi{an} {i oc`n {an }gja{ baigbn id B]O rid{zc}n cfk id{nfki ri cd{n} lg{{ln i} fi knlgmn}c{gif& Nfr~}gfj {ac{ {anbairnf ril~{gif bcf cfk zgll r~uui}{ cll {ang}
m~rgfnrr u}ibnrrnr, gr nrrnf{gcl cfk o~r{ mn bc}}gnki~{, m~{ g{ gr rion{agfj m~rgfnrrnr rnlkio ki}nr~l{gfj gf B]O billcurn&
Ri Zai‗r ]nruifrgmln Di} B]O Dcgl~}n9Cb{~cllw g{‗r c biomgfc{gif id mi{a ‒
I}jcfgxc{gifr nouliwgfj B]O cr znll cr {airnrnllgfj {ano& I}jcfgxc{gifr actnf‗{ lnc}f{ aiz {inouliw g{r m~rgfnrr u}ibnrrnr gf {an }gja{ ocffn} ricr {i jn{ {an oir{ i~{ id g{r B]O goulnonf{c{gifzagln B]O rnlln}r fnnk {i oc`n r~}n {ac{ {ang} rwr{nor c}n ~rn} d}gnfklw cfk ncrglw ckcu{cmln cfkoir{ goui}{cf{lw {c`n gf{i cbbi~f{ {an tc}gi~r dcb{i}r{ac{ actn mnnf ri dc} itn}lii`nk& Bioucfgnr fnnk {ilnc}f {an jilknf }~ln& On}nlw gfr{cllgfj B]O
ucb`cjnr kinr fi{ nfr~}n r~bbnrr& G{ gr mw fi oncfr cr~}n{w id uirg{gtn }nr~l{r& ^fkn}r{cfkgfj {an dcb{ {ac{{an r{}c{njw kinr actn g{r k}czmcb`r, zi}`gfj if{anrn k}czmcb`r cfk kigfj {ang} mnr{ {i jn{ {an oir{
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 313
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 197/223
i~{ id {ang} B]O goulnonf{c{gif clifn zgllimlg{n}c{n B]O dcgl~}nr cfk wgnlk r~bbnrr& Zac{ greagjalw }ns~g}nk gr {an cmglg{w {i dib~r if {an m~rgfnrr
fnnkr, baiirn c B]O ucb`cjn {ac{ zi}`r {izc}kr g{,nouliw {an }gja{ }nri~}bnr cfk crr~on {an }gja{on{}gbr& Ckiu{gfj {anrn oncr~}nr zi~lk ji c lifjzcw gf cllntgc{gfj B]O u}imlnor&
GT& B^R[ION] ]NLC[GIFRAGUOCFCJNONF[ CFK N/M^RGFNRR
[an uanfionfif id m~glkgfj c }nlc{gifragu zg{ab~r{ion}r tgc gf{n}fn{ gr `fizf cr nlnb{}ifgb B]O!n/B]O'& [an imhnb{gtn id B]O cfk n/B]O c}n {anrcon ‒ {an kgddn}nfbn gr {an onkg~o ~rnk di}
u}itgkgfj rn}tgbnr {i {an b~r{ion}& N/B]O gr co~l{gdcbn{nk r{}c{njw {ac{ anlur bioucfgnr~fkn}r{cfk, cf{gbguc{n cfk ocfcjn b~r{ion} fnnkr& Cochi} {a}~r{ id g{ gftiltnr rnjonf{gfj b~r{ion}r cfkiddn}gfj cuu}iu}gc{n cfk kgddn}nf{gc{nk rn}tgbnr di} ncba id {anrn lntnlr& G{ ocgflw ~rnr {an nlnb{}ifgbonkgc {i gf{nj}c{n cfk rgoulgdw b~r{ion}/ }nlc{nk
m~rgfnrr u}ibnrrnr, k}cr{gbcllw }nk~bgfj bir{r id b~r{ion}/ dcbgfj iun}c{gifr zagln cbagntgfj B]O‗r
u}goc}w jicl {i nfacfbn {an b~r{ion} nqun}gnfbn& N/M~rgfnrr kinr actn g{r izf kgddgb~l{gnr {ai~ja& G{ gr cli{ oi}n bioulnq {acf {ac{ zac{ uniuln {agf` g{ gr& Gfi}kn} {i r~bbnnk c{ n/M~rgfnrr cf i}jcfgxc{gif fnnkr{i mcrgbcllw dgj~}n i~{ h~r{ ain g{ zcf{r {iu ki g{r
m~rgfnrr, zac{ u}ik~b{r g{ zcf{r {i rnll, zac{ c}n g{r`nw imhnb{gtnr cfk zai c}n g{r {c}jn{nk b~r{ion}r&
N/M~rgfnrr {}cfrcb{gifr actn b}irrnk {an mgllgifoc}`r cfk c}n rbank~lnk {i ag{ +3 {}gllgif gf {an wnc} =554& Zg{a r~ba cr{i~fkgfj r{c{gr{gbr, g{ gr m~{ blnc} {ac{ {an cktcf{cjnr {ac{ g{ iddn}r actn dc} r~}ucrrnkbioucfw nqunb{c{gifr cfk actn }iunk gf ~rn}r}cugklw& Gjfi}gfj {an uanfionfcl j}iz{a id n/M~rgfnrr gr d~{gln& Bioucfgnr u}ndn}}gfj {i r{gb` {i{}ckg{gifcl on{aikr cfk u}ibnrrnr zgll zg{ai~{ cki~m{ c}n lnd{ mnagfk gf {an }c{ }cbn& Rgfbn {an gf{n}fn{nqulirgif jlimcllw, bifr~on}r u}ndn} n/ M~rgfnrr cr g{rocb`r id ncrn id ~rcjn& N/ M~rgfnrr gr c {n}o {ac{ gr
mcrgbcllw ~rnk {i knrb}gmn c m~rgfnrr {ac{ }~fr if {angf{n}fn{ cfk {ac{ oc`nr ~rn id {an nqgr{gfj gf{n}fn{
{nbafilijgnr {i gfb}ncrn {an u}idg{cmglg{w cfknddgbgnfbw id {an m~rgfnrr&
T& ]NCRIFR DI] [AN J]IZ[A ID B]ON/M^RGFNRR
>&3& [an }ncrifr di} B]O n/M~rgfnrr j}izgfj {ir~ba nfi}oi~r angja{r gr gf{n}fn{ {nbafilijw,
mnfndg{r id nlnb{}ifgb {nbafilijw cfk {an ncrglwctcglcmln ril~{gifr {ac{ nqgr{& Bioucfgnr dgfk {ac{ctcglgfj id B]O n/ M~rgfnrr dcbglg{gnr miir{r {annddgbgnfbw {i c j}nc{ nq{nf{& [an }ncrif n/ M~rgfnrracr r~bbnnknk gr if cbbi~f{ id g{r cmglg{w {i u}itgkn
bir{ nddnb{gtn ril~{gifr {ac{ }ns~g}n tn}w lg{{ln {gon {igoulnonf{&
>&=& [}ckg{gifcl m~rgfnrr on{aikr actn u}itnk{g}nrion, bir{lw cfk tn}w {gon bifr~ogfj& Cr c }nr~l{ m~rgfnrrnr actn mnnf lii`gfj c}i~fk di} c mn{{n} ril~{gif& B]O n/ M~rgfnrr ril~{gifr u}itnk {i mn h~r{{an r{}c{njw {ac{ zcr }ns~g}nk& G{ bc{n}nk {i nqgr{gfj
m~rgfnrr u}imlnor cfk u}itnk {ac{ g{ ack {an ui{nf{gcl{i kncl zg{a ui{nf{gcl kgddgb~l{gnr cr znll& Dlnqgmglg{wcfk {an cmglg{w {i ckcu{ {i c bacfjgfj nftg}ifonf{ grrion{agfj {ac{ B]O n/M~rgfnrr dgfkr ncrw {i ki&
>&2& B]O n ‒ M~rgfnrr gfbl~knr bioucfgnr {ac{~rn {an gf{n}fn{ {i cbs~g}n u}ik~b{r i} r~uulgnr di} gfai~rn u}ik~b{gif& [agr gr `fizf cr n/u}ib~}nonf{& G{car {an ui{nf{gcl {i cb{~cllw b~{ kizf bir{bifrgkn}cmlw oc`gfj g{ c jiik mn{ di} bioucfgnrlii`gfj c{ cbagntgfj bir{ nddnb{gtnfnrr&
>&;& G{ clri acr {an ckknk cktcf{cjn id mngfj cmln{i {}cb` u~}bacrnr cfk ocfcjn {an u~}bacrgfj nddi}{rnddgbgnf{lw& G{ anlur gf {an m~wgfj cfk rnllgfj id
u}ik~b{r& G{ clri anlur {an i}jcfgxc{gif {i ~rnnlnb{}ifgb bac{ cr c oncfr id {nbafgbcl r~uui}{ cfkb~r{ion} r~uui}{& [agr anlur cfw bioucfw {i rctn{gon cfk nddi}{ cfk c{ {an rcon {gon u}itgkniuui}{~fg{gnr {ac{ {an {}ckg{gifcl rwr{no bi~lk fi{&Zac{‗r cktcf{cjni~r an}n gr {ac{ c tg}{~cl biou~{n} rwr{no bcf mn ~rnk cfk zg{a {an kizflick id c
u}ij}co, cll {an }nlntcf{ gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{ ac}kzc}ncfk rid{zc}n runbgdgbc{gifr bcf mn ckns~c{nlw rnf{ {i
{an r~uui}{ {nco kg}nb{lw&>&>& Gf ckkg{gif g{ ocfcjnr {i ocgf{cgf c bnf{}cl
rn}tn} i} nocgl lgr{ cr c on{aik id kgr{}gm~{gfjgfdi}oc{gif, }c{an} {acf actgfj bir{lw cfk {gonbifr~ogfj gfkgtgk~cl ifnr& Gf {an uc{r dnz wnc}rcloir{ cll bioucfgnr actn mnbion {i rion lntnl i} {an i{an} cf n/ M~rgfnrr& B]O n/ M~rgfnrr gr }gja{fiz gfb}ncrgfj {an bacfbn id m~glkgfj rclnr cfkgfb}ncrgfj {an rclnr }ntnf~n mw gfb}ncrgfj {an c}nc id iun}c{gif, }nk~bgfj iun}c{gfj bir{r, gfb}ncrgfj
u}ik~b{gtg{w cfk {an}nmw ag`gfj {an nddgbgnfbw id {anr~uulw bacgf cfk {an B]O cuulgbc{gif cr znll&
>&4&B]O n/ M~rgfnrr ril~{gifr jgtn bioucfgnr c
znll ulcffnk cfk ncrglw gf{nj}c{nk n/ M~rgfnrrr{}c{njw {ac{ bc{n}r {i mi{a {an b~r{ion} fnnkr cr znllcr {an bi}ui}c{n fnnkr& Mi{a {anrn fnnk {i mnckns~c{nlw bc{n}nk {i gf i}kn} {ac{ bioucfwimhnb{gtnr kn d~ldgllnk& [an fn{ }nr~l{ id goulnonf{gfj B]O n ‒ M~rgfnrr r{}c{njgnr grrc{grdgnk b~r{ion}r cfk itn}cll u}ik~b{gtg{w&
TG& BIFBL^RGIFB~r{ion} }nlc{gifragu ocfcjnonf{ clri `fizf cr
}nlc{gifragu oc}`n{gfj i} b~r{ion} ocfcjnonf{, ulcwr c tg{cl }iln gf {ikcw‗r bioun{g{gtn zi}lk cfk gd goulnonf{nk u}iun}lw, bcf wgnlk tn}w uirg{gtn }nr~l{r
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 31=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 198/223
gf }n{cgfgfj {an nqgr{gfj b~r{ion}r cfk c{{}cb{gfj {anfnz ifnr& B]O‗r jicl gr {i cgk i}jcfgxc{gifr gf
mn{{n} ~fkn}r{cfkgfj ncba b~r{ion}‗r tcl~n {i {an
bioucfw&B]O gfrug{n id mngfj ri d}~g{d~l, r{gll dcbnr rionbacllnfjnr i} dcglr rion{gonr k~n {i {an gou}iun} goulcf{c{gif id g{ i} ocw mn k~n {i {an i}jcfgxc{gif{airn rnllgfj g{& [i itn}bion {anrn bacllnfjnr zac{ gragjalw }ns~g}nk gr {an cmglg{w {i dib~r if m~rgfnrrfnnkr, baiirn c B]O ucb`cjn {ac{ zi}`r {izc}kr g{,nouliw {an }gja{ }nri~}bnr cfk crr~on {an }gja{on{}gbr& [agr cll bcf anlu i}jcfgxc{gif {i cbagntnagja u}idg{r cfk gf }n{cgfgfj b~r{ion}r&
Gf {an rcon ocffn} n/B]O gr {an }gja{ {iil di} {an u}nrnf{ rbnfc}gi cr g{ rctnr {gon cfk }nri~}bnr id cf i}jcfgxc{gif cfk u}itgknr jiik nfi~ja i~{biongf {n}or id b~r{ion}&
CB@FIZLNKJNONF[G zi~lk lg`n {i {acf` ow iddgbgcl r~un}tgri}r cfk
Crrgr{cf{ U}idnrri} K}& Cragra F& Hcfg di} cll {ang} anlu, cktgbn cfk nfbi~}cjnonf{&
]NDN]NFBNRP3_& Hgll KwbaẰ, “[an B]O Acfkmii`‟, C m~rgfnrr j~gkn {i
b~r{ion} }nlc{gifragu ocfcjnonf{0 :{a Nkf&=55:8 =1/;=&P=_& U}id& T&R~kac`c}, Gfkgcf Hi~}fcl Id Oc}`n{gfj‟, n/B]O0 Knb
=5570 22/27&P2_& Hgll KwbaẰ, “[an B]O Acfkmii`‟, C m~rgfnrr j~gkn {i b~r{ion}
}nlc{gifragu ocfcjnonf{0 :{a Nkf&=55:8 3=1/3;3&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 312
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 199/223
R~bbnrr cfk Dcgl~}n Dcb{i}r id n/Jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ goulnonf{c{gif gf Wnonf8
C rwr{noc{gb Lg{n}c{~}n }ntgnz
Ocakg Cmk~llca ClrnmcngGf{n}fc{gifcl G[ Uilgbw U}ij}co
[nbafilijw Ocfcjnonf{, Nbifiogbr cfk Uilgbw U}ij}coBillnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj, Rni~l Fc{gifcl ^fgtn}rg{w
Rni~l, Ri~{a @i}nc
Cmr{}cb{ / [an cgo id {agr ucun} gr {i nquli}n {an b~}}nf{rg{~c{gif id n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{‗r goulnonf{c{gif gfWnonf cfk ~fkn}r{cfk {an r~bbnrr cfk dcgl~}n dcb{i}r d}io {anun}bnu{gif id {an Wnonfg n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ {nco& [anon{aikilijw gr nquli}c{i}w on{aik zagba gr {i gftnr{gjc{n {an
cbcknogb lg{n}c{~}n cmi~{ n/jitn}fonf{ goulnonf{c{gif gfkntnliugfj bi~f{}gnr dib~rgfj if {an r~bbnrr cfk dcgl~}n dcb{i}rid goulnonf{c{gif& Clri {an r{}~b{~}nk {nlnuaifn gf{n}tgnzrzn}n kifn zg{a {an {iu knbgrgif oc`n}r id {an n/jitn}fonf{ gfWnonf& [an rg{~c{gif id Wnonf gf {an c}nc id bioo~fgbc{gifcfk {nbafilijgnr zgll mn u}nrnf{nk& [an dgfkgfjr raiz {ac{Wnonf r{c}{nk {i nr{cmlgra c jiik ulcf di} n/jitn}fonf{u}ihnb{r cfk {an goulnonf{c{gif bifbnu{ r{c}{nk {i mn znlli}jcfgxnk mw {an n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{‗r {nco& [an }nrnc}ban}cr c onomn} id {agr {nco acr gknf{gdgnk ocfw cb{gtg{gnr gfi}kn} {i kn{n}ogfn {an oir{ rgjfgdgbcf{ dcb{i}r {ac{ anlu {anjitn}fonf{ di} c u}iun} goulnonf{c{gif di} {an rwr{no id n/jitn}fonf{& Aizntn}, Wnonf‗r jitn}fonf{ r{gll fnnk {izi}` ac}k }njc}kgfj {an Gf{n}fn{ s~clg{w cfk {an lntnl id nk~bc{gif di} bg{gxnfr gf {n}or id biou~{n} {nbafilijgnr cfk G[
r`gllr& Wnonf clri fnnkr {i itn}bion {an grr~n id {an jcumn{znnf jnfkn}r cr znll cr mn{znnf ~}mcf cfk }~}cl c}ncr&
[an r{~kw zgll ckk}nrr goui}{cf{ cfk rgjfgdgbcf{ dcb{i}r
u}ntnf{gfj {an goulnonf{c{gif id n/jitn}fonf{ cfk
nr{cmlgragfj id n/rn}tgbnr gf Wnonf& Dgfcllw0 {an }ns~g}nonf{r
di} r~bbnrrnr N/jitn}fonf{ goulnonf{c{gif zgll mn nlcmi}c{nk&
Cfk {an r{~kw nfkr ~u zg{a }nbioonfkc{gifr cr ril~{gifr di}
mn{{n} N/jitn}fonf{ goulnonf{c{gif gf {an d~{~}n di} {an
]nu~mlgb id Wnonf&
@nwzi}kr8 N/jitn}fonf{, R~bbnrr dcb{i}r, dcgl~}n dcb{i}r,
N/jitn}fonf{ gf Wnonf, Wnonf&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Nlnb{}ifgb jitn}fonf{ i} n/jitn}fonf{ r~jjnr{r {an ~rn id
gfdi}oc{gif {nbafilijw {i nfcmln cfk gou}itn {an nddgbgnfbwzg{a zagba jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr c}n u}itgknk {i bg{gxnfr,nouliwnnr, m~rgfnrrnr cfk cjnfbgnr0 g{ gfb}ncrnr {anbiftnfgnfbn cfk cbbnrrgmglg{w id jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr cfkgfdi}oc{gif {i bg{gxnfr, !Bc}{n} cfk Mnlcfjn}, =55>'&N/jitn}fonf{ biou}grnr {an ~rn id GB[ gf i}kn} {i knlgtn}
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ Til~on
3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :2513)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :2513
u~mlgb rn}tgbnr {i bg{gxnfr cfk m~rgfnrrnr& G{ nf{cglr {an{}cfrdi}oc{gif id u~mlgb rn}tgbnr ctcglcmln {i bg{gxnfr ~rgfjfnz i}jcfgxc{gifcl u}ibnrrnr cr znll cr fnz {nbafilijgbcl{}nfkr !J~f{n}, =554'&
N/jitn}fonf{ gr knrgjfnk {i dcbglg{c{n c oi}n gf{nj}c{nkoikn id jitn}fcfbn& G{ nfbcur~lc{nr {an }nlc{gifragurmn{znnf jitn}fonf{r, {ang} bg{gxnfr cr znll cr {ang} r~uulgn}rmw {an ~rn id nlnb{}ifgb oncfr !Oncfr cfk Rbafngkn}, =555'&Gf m}gnd, {an jicl id n/jitn}fonf{ gr {i cbagntn gf oc`gfjjitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr oi}n cbbnrrgmln, oi}n bg{gxnf dib~rnk,oi}n }nlntcf{ {i bg{gxnfr cr znll cr oi}n }nruifrgtn {i {ang}fnnkr cfk nqunb{c{gifr&
Gf {agr un}runb{gtn, n/jitn}fonf{ gr {an ~rn id {nbafilijw, nrunbgcllw znm/mcrnk Gf{n}fn{ cuulgbc{gifr gfi}kn} {i nfacfbn cbbnrr {i cfk nddgbgnf{lw knlgtn} jitn}fonf{gfdi}oc{gif cfk rn}tgbnr !M}izf cfk M}~kfnw, =553'&!Ann`r, =552' crrn}{r {ac{ {an ~rn id gfdi}oc{gif cfk
bioo~fgbc{gif {nbafilijgnr cr c oncfr {i gou}itn {ancb{gtg{gnr id u~mlgb rnb{i} i}jcfgxc{gifr gr {an kndgfg{gif id n/jitn}fonf{& Cbbi}kgfj {i {an Zi}lk Mcf` !=55;', n/jitn}fonf{ }ndn}r {i {an ~rn id gfdi}oc{gif {nbafilijgnr mwjitn}fonf{ cjnfbgnr {ac{ actn {an cmglg{w {i {}cfrdi}o}nlc{gifr zg{a bg{gxnfr, m~rgfnrrnr, cfk i{an} c}or id jitn}fonf{& Lcr{ m~{ fi{ lncr{, cbbi}kgfj {i {an Bnf{}n di}Knoib}cbw cfk [nbafilijw !=55=', “n/jitn}fonf{ gr {an ~rn id gfdi}oc{gif cfk bioo~fgbc{gifr{nbafilijgnr gf i}kn} {i {}cfrdi}o jitn}fonf{ mw oc`gfj g{oi}n cbbnrrgmln, nddnb{gtn cfk cbbi~f{cmln‟&
[an }nrnc}ban} bifk~b{nk {agr r{~kw {i }ntgnz {anrg{~c{gif id n/jitn}fonf{ gf Wnonf cfk cfclwrgr g{r }nlc{nkbifbnu{r zagba gr coifj {an nc}lw r{cjn id N/jitn}fonf{u}ihnb{& [an r{~kw zgll cfclwxn rntn}cl dcb{i}r {ac{ bif{}gm~{n{i {an r~bbnrr goulnonf{c{gif id N/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ gflibcl jitn}fonf{ id Rcfc‗c bg{w/ {an bcug{cl id Wnonf&
GG& N/JITN]FONF[ BIFBNU[R C& Ocgf imhnb{gtnr id n/jitn}fonf{
Oc`n g{ ncrgn} {i dgfk gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr&
Gou}itgfj cbbnrr {i jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr mwoc`gfj {ano iflgfn =;):&
Anlugfj {i gou}itn {an s~clg{w id rn}tgbnr&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 31;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 200/223
Anlugfj {i gf{n}cb{ oi}n nddnb{gtnlw zg{ajitn}fonf{ i}jcfgxc{gifr cfk }nlc{nk cjnfbgnr ri {ac{oi}n rn}tgbnr bcf mn u}itgknk&
Anlugfj {i m~glk {}~r{ mn{znnf jitn}fonf{ Bacllnfjgfj {an nqgr{gfj zcwr id zi}`gfj&
M& N/jitn}fonf{ Cuulgbc{gifr
Jitn}fonf{/{i/Jitn}fonf{ !J=J'8J=J gr {an gf{n}biffnb{gif mn{znnf {an jitn}fonf{
cjnfbgnr& [agr d~fb{gif i} cuulgbc{gif rn}tnr mi{a gf{n}fclu}ibnrrnr cfk cb{gtg{gnr !mn{znnf u~mlgb i}jcfgxc{gifr{anornltnr' cfk nq{n}fcl ifnr clri !mn{znnf jitn}fonf{i}jcfgxc{gifr, bg{gxnfr cfk m~rgfnrrnr'& [an ~l{goc{n cgo id {an !J=J' d~fb{gif gr {i nfacfbn gf{n}/jitn}fonf{i}jcfgxc{gifr* u}ibnrrnr mw r{}ncolgfgfj billcmi}c{gif cfkbii}kgfc{gif&
Gf i}kn} {i }nclgxn c rgfjln cbbnrr uigf{, billcmi}c{gif cfk
biiun}c{gif coifj kgddn}nf{ jitn}fonf{cl knuc}{onf{r cfkcjnfbgnr gr biou~lri}w& Iflgfn bioo~fgbc{gif cfkbiiun}c{gif cllizr jitn}fonf{ cjnfbgnr cfk knuc}{onf{r {irac}n kc{cmcrnr, }nri~}bnr, uiil r`gllr cfk bcucmglg{gnr,nfacfbgfj {an nddgbgnfbw cfk nddnb{gtnlw id u}ibnrrnr!Tclcf{gfc, =55;'&
Jitn}fonf{/{i/Bg{gxnfr !J=B'8J=B gr {an gf{n}biffnb{gif mn{znnf {an jitn}fonf{
cjnfbgnr cfk {an u~mlgb bg{gxnfr& Zg{a {agr d~fb{gif i}cuulgbc{gif, {an u~mlgb i}jcfgxc{gifr u~mlgra gfdi}oc{gif cfkbif{cb{ kn{cglr, cfk iddn} }nj~lc} rn}tgbnr iflgfn& [an~l{goc{n cgo id {agr cuulgbc{gif gr {i jgtn ~rn}r kgddn}nf{iu{gifr cfk bioo~fgbc{gif bacffnlr di} jitn}fonf{{}cfrcb{gifr&
J=B cllizr b~r{ion}r {i cbbnrr jitn}fonf{ gfdi}oc{gifcfk rn}tgbnr gfr{cf{lw, biftnfgnf{lw, d}io ntn}wzan}n, mw~rn id o~l{guln bacffnlr !UB, Znm [T, oimgln uaifn i}zg}nlnrr kntgbn'& G{ clri nfcmlnr cfk }ngfdi}bnr {ang}uc}{gbguc{gif gf libcl bioo~fg{w lgdn “rnfk cf nocgl i}bif{}gm~{n {i cf iflgfn kgrb~rrgif di}~o‟ !Tclcf{gfc, =55;'&
Jitn}fonf{/{i/M~rgfnrrnr !J=M'8J=B gr {an jitn}fonf{ bioo~fgbc{gif zg{a {an u}gtc{n
m~rgfnrr rnb{i}& J=M cllizr m~rgfnrrnr cr znll cr gfkgtgk~clr{i actn {}cfrcb{gifr zg{a {an jitn}fonf{, nqcoulnr mngfj8}nfnzgfj }njgr{}c{gifr, likjgfj {cqnr, kizflickgfj {nfkn}r‗gfdi}oc{gif, cfk ocfw i{an}r& [an jitn}fonf{/{i/m~rgfnrr!J=M' cuulgbc{gif gr cr ~rnd~l cr {an J=B rwr{no, nfacfbgfj
{an nddgbgnfbw cfk s~clg{w id bioo~fgbc{gif cfk {}cfrcb{gifrzg{a m~rgfnrr& [an}ndi}n, {agr rai~lk mn bifrgkn}nk mw {anjitn}fonf{r&
Bioucfgnr ntn}wzan}n c}n bifk~b{gfj m~rgfnrr/{i/m~rgfnrr n/bioon}bn gf i}kn} {i lizn} {ang} bir{r cfkgou}itn gftnf{i}w bif{}il& [an iuui}{~fg{w {i bifk~b{iflgfn {}cfrcb{gifr zg{a jitn}fonf{ }nk~bnr }nk {cun cfkrgoulgdgnr }nj~lc{i}w u}ibnrrnr, {an}ndi}n anlugfj m~rgfnrrnr{i mnbion oi}n bioun{g{gtn& [an knlgtn}w id gf{nj}c{nk,rgfjln/ri~}bn u~mlgb rn}tgbnr b}nc{nr iuui}{~fg{gnr di}m~rgfnrrnr cfk jitn}fonf{ {i uc}{fn} {ijn{an} di}
nr{cmlgragfj c znm u}nrnfbn dcr{n} cfk bancun} !Tclcf{gfc,=55;'&
Jitn}fonf{/{i/Nouliwnnr !J=N'8
J=N gr {an gf{n}biffnb{gif mn{znnf {an jitn}fonf{cjnfbgnr cfk {an nouliwnnr d}io kgddn}nf{ rnb{i}r !u~mlgbcfk u}gtc{n J=N gr un}acur {an lncr{ ckiu{nk cuulgbc{gif id n/jitn}fonf{& Rbailc}r cfk bi~f{}gnr c}i~fk {an zi}lk ~r~cllwdib~r if {an dg}r{ {a}nn cuulgbc{gifr iflw&
J=N gr cf nddnb{gtn zcw {i u}itgkn n/lnc}fgfj, m}gfjnouliwnnr {ijn{an} cfk {i u}ioi{n `fizlnkjn rac}gfjcoifj {ano& G{ jgtnr nouliwnnr {an uirrgmglg{w id cbbnrrgfj}nlntcf{ gfdi}oc{gif }njc}kgfj8 biounfrc{gif cfk mnfndg{uilgbgnr, {}cgfgfj cfk lnc}fgfj iuui}{~fg{gnr, bgtgl }gja{r lczr,n{b !Tclcf{gfc, =55;'&
Aizntn}, Wnonf gr r{gll gf {an dg}r{ d~fb{gif J=J zagbagr {an gf{n}biffnb{gif mn{znnf {an jitn}fonf{ cjnfbgnr&[an}n gr fi d~ll gf{n}cb{gif zg{a bg{gxnfr mnbc~rn {anw bcfiflw m}izr {an gfdi}oc{gif cmi~{ jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr d}io{an kgddn}nf{ jitn}fonf{ cjnfbgnr {a}i~ja {an jitn}fonf{iddgbgcl ui}{cl zagba gr cffi~fbnk gf =557& Oi}nitn}, {an}ngr fi nlnb{}ifgb gf{n}cb{gif zg{a {an Wnonfg jitn}fonf{zg{a {an u}gtc{n m~rgfnrr rnb{i} wn{ cr znll cr {an nouliwnnrd}io mi{a u~mlgb cfk u}gtc{n rnb{i}r, {anrn ocwmn {c}jn{nk {imn nr{cmlgrank cd{n} biouln{gfj cll {an r{cjnr }ns~g}nk {i mngoulnonf{nk di} {an n/jitn}fonf{ rwr{no gf Wnonf&
B& Mnfndg{r id N/jitn}fonf{
INBK !=552' {ai}i~jalw nqcogfnk n/jitn}fonf{gfg{gc{gtnr gf g{r onomn}r‗ bi~f{}gnr !C~r{}clgc, C~r{}gc,Mnljg~o, Bcfckc, Bxnba ]nu~mlgb, Knfoc}`, Dgflcfk,D}cfbn, Jn}ocfw, J}nnbn, A~fjc}w, Gbnlcfk, G}nlcfk, G{clw,
Hcucf, @i}nc, L~qnom~}j, Onqgbi, Fn{an}lcfkr, FnzXnclcfk, Fi}zcw, Uilcfk, Ui}{~jcl, Rlitc` ]nu~mlgb, Rucgf,Rznknf, Rzg{xn}lcfk, [~}`nw, ^@, ^RC', cfk lgr{nk {ancktcf{cjnr id n/jitn}fonf{ cr dillizr8
/ Gou}itnr nddgbgnfbw gf u}ibnrrgfj lc}jn s~cf{g{gnr id kc{c
/ Gou}itnr rn}tgbnr {a}i~ja mn{{n} ~fkn}r{cfkgfj id ~rn}r‗ }ns~g}nonf{r, {a~r cgogfj di} rncolnrr iflgfnrn}tgbnr&
/ Anlur cbagntn runbgdgb uilgbw i~{bionr mw nfcmlgfjr{c`nailkn}r {i rac}n gfdi}oc{gif cfk gkncr&
/ Crrgr{r c jitn}fonf{‗r nbifiogb uilgbw imhnb{gtnr mwu}ioi{gfj u}ik~b{gtg{w jcgfr gfan}nf{ gf GB[ cfk
n/bioon}bn&/ Bif{}gm~{nr {i jitn}fonf{r‗ }ndi}o mw gou}itgfj
{}cfruc}nfbw, dcbglg{c{gfj gfdi}oc{gif rac}gfj cfkagjalgja{gfj gf{n}fcl gfbifrgr{nfbgnr&
/ Anlur gf m~glkgfj {}~r{ mn{znnf jitn}fonf{r cfk {ang}bg{gxnfr, cf nrrnf{gcl dcb{i} gf jiik jitn}fcfbn mw ~rgfjgf{n}fn{/mcrnk r{}c{njgnr {i gftiltn bg{gxnfr gf {an uilgbwu}ibnrr, gll~r{}c{gfj jitn}fonf{ {}cfruc}nfbw cfkcbbi~f{cmglg{w&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 31>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 201/223
GGG& U^]UIRN ID [AN R[^KW [AN OCGF U^]UIRNR ID [AGR R[^KW C]N CR DILLIZR8
[i ~fkn}r{cfk {an b~}}nf{ lntnl id n/jitn}fonf{
u}ihnb{ goulnonf{c{gif gf Wnonf& [i kn{n}ogfn {an b}g{gbcl r~bbnrr cfk dcgl~}n dcb{i}r
id n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ gf Wnonf cr mngfj un}bngtnk mw {iuknbgrgif oc`n}r cfk u}ihnb{‗r {nco&
[i bion ~u zg{a rion }nbioonfkc{gifr {ac{rai~lk m}gfj gf{i c{{nf{gif di} {an n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{goulnonf{c{gif gf Rcfc‗c bg{w {an bcug{cl id Wnonf&
GT& N/JITN]FONF[ OIKNLR Rntn}cl n/jitn}fonf{ oiknlr actn mnnf u}iuirnk mw
}nrnc}ban}r cfk Gf{n}fc{gifcl i}jcfgxc{gifr r~ba cr !^F=551, Lcwfn $ Lnn =553' cfk rion i{an}r& Zn m}gndlwkgrb~rr {anrn oiknlr gf {an dillizgfj r~mrnb{gifr8
C&
^F n/jitn}fonf{ oc{~}g{w oiknl =5518 C Dgtnr{cjnr oiknl8
^fg{nk Fc{gifr acr gknf{gdgnk r{cjnr id n/jitn}fonf{d}io kgddn}nf{ un}runb{gtn& ^F kntnliunk c dgtn r{cjn n/jitn}fonf{ oiknl zagba m~glkr ~uif {an riuagr{gbc{gif id iflgfn u}nrnfbn& Cr c bi~f{}w ogj}c{nr ~uzc}kr {a}i~ja {antc}gi~r r{cjnr cr raizf gf {an dgj~}n, g{ gr }cf`nk agjan} gf{an znm oncr~}n gfknq !^F, =551'&
Dgj~}n 38 ^F N/jitn}fonf{ Oc{~}g{w OiknlRi~}bn8 ^F N/jitn}fonf{ Gfknq =551&
R{cjn G / Non}jgfj8 C jitn}fonf{‗r iflgfn u}nrnfbn gr
ocgflw biou}grnk id c znm ucjn cfk)i} cf iddgbgcl znmrg{n0lgf`r {i ogfgr{}gnr i} knuc}{onf{r id nk~bc{gif, ancl{a, ribgclznldc}n, lcmi} cfk dgfcfbn ocw)ocw fi{ nqgr{&
R{cjn GG / Nfacfbnk8 Jitn}fonf{r u}itgkn oi}ngfdi}oc{gif if u~mlgb uilgbw cfk jitn}fcfbn& [anw actnb}nc{nk lgf`r {i c}bagtnk gfdi}oc{gif {ac{ gr ncrglw cbbnrrgmln{i bg{gxnfr, cr di} gfr{cfbn, kib~onf{r, di}or, }nui}{r, lczrcfk }nj~lc{gifr, cfk fnzrln{{n}r&
R{cjn GGG / Gf{n}cb{gtn8 Jitn}fonf{r knlgtn} iflgfnrn}tgbnr r~ba cr kizflickcmln di}or di} {cq ucwonf{r cfkcuulgbc{gifr di} lgbnfrn }nfnzclr&
R{cjn GT / [}cfrcb{gifcl8 Jitn}fonf{r mnjgf {i{}cfrdi}o {anornltnr mw gf{}ik~bgfj {zi/zcw gf{n}cb{gifr
mn{znnf ‑bg{gxnf cfk jitn}fonf{‗& G{ gfbl~knr iu{gifr di}ucwgfj {cqnr, cuulwgfj di} GK bc}kr, mg}{a bn}{gdgbc{nr,ucrrui}{r cfk lgbnfrn }nfnzclr, cr znll cr i{an} rgoglc} J {iB gf{n}cb{gifr, cfk cllizr {an bg{gxnf {i cbbnrr {anrn rn}tgbnriflgfn=;):& Cll {}cfrcb{gifr c}n bifk~b{nk iflgfn&
R{cjn T / Biffnb{nk8 Jitn}fonf{r {}cfrdi}o {anornltnrgf{i c biffnb{nk nf{g{w {ac{ }nruifkr {i {an fnnkr id g{rbg{gxnfr mw kntnliugfj cf gf{nj}c{nk mcb` iddgbngfd}cr{}~b{~}n& [agr gr {an oir{ riuagr{gbc{nk lntnl id iflgfnn/jitn}fonf{ gfg{gc{gtnr cfk gr bac}cb{n}gxnk mw8
3& Ai}gxif{cl biffnb{gifr !coifj jitn}fonf{ cjnfbgnr'=&Tn}{gbcl biffnb{gifr !bnf{}cl cfk libcl
jitn}fonf{ cjnfbgnr'2& Gfd}cr{}~b{~}n biffnb{gifr !gf{n}iun}cmglg{w grr~nr';& Biffnb{gifr mn{znnf jitn}fonf{r cfk bg{gxnfr>& Biffnb{gifr coifj r{c`nailkn}r !jitn}fonf{, u}gtc{n
rnb{i}, cbcknogb gfr{g{~{gifr, FJIr cfk bgtgl ribgn{w'
M& Kntnliugfj d~llw d~fb{gifcllw N/jitn}fonf{8 C di~} r{cjn oiknl Mw Lcwfn $ Lnn =5538
Mcrnk if {nbafgbcl cfk ocfcjn}gcl dncrgmglg{w, Lcwfn cfkLnn !=553' u}iuirnk c di~}/r{cjn n/jitn}fonf{ oiknl&[anrn di~} r{cjnr c}n8
R{cjn 3/ Bc{clij~gfj8 jitn}fonf{ iflgfnu}nrnfbn
R{cjn =/ [}cfrcb{gif8 bg{gxnfr {}cfrcb{zg{a jitn}fonf{ nlnb{}ifgbcllw&
R{cjn 2/ Tn}{gbcl gf{nj}c{gif8 Libcljitn}fonf{ biffnb{nk {i kgddn}nf{ d~fb{gifri} rn}tgbn id {an jitn}fonf{&
R{cjn ;/ Ai}gxif{cl Gf{nj}c{gif8
Gf{nj}c{gif cb}irr kgddn}nf{ d~fb{gifr cfk rn}tgbnr id jitn}fonf{&
Dgj~}n =8 Lcwfn cfk Lnn !=553', Njitn}fonf{ R{cjnr Oiknl Ri~}bn8 Kntnliugfj d~llw d~fb{gifcllw N/jitn}fonf{8
C di~} r{cjn oiknl mw Lcwfn $ Lnn =553&
Cbbi}kgfj {i {an oiknl, {an dg}r{ r{cjn gr {an bc{clij~gfjid gfdi}oc{gif if c Znm rg{n& [agr gftiltnr {an gfg{gcl nddi}{r
B8 Biffnb{nk
[}cfrcb{8 [}cfrcb{gif
/Ai}gxif{cl
Gf{nj}c{gif/Rwr{norgf{nj}c{nk cb}irrkgddn}nf{d~fb{gifr//]ncl ifn r{iuraiuugfj di}bg{gxnfr
/Tn}{gbcl
Gf{nj}c{gif
/Libcl Rwr{norlgf`nk {i agjan}
lntnl rwr{or/zg{agfrgoglc}
d~fb{gifclg{gn
[}cfrcb{gif/Rn}tgbnr cfk
Di}or c}niflgfn
/Zi}`gfj K&M
r~uui}{gfjiflgfnBc{clij~n
Iflgfn u}nrnfbn/Bc{clij~nu}nrnf{c{gif/KizflickcmlnDi}or
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 314
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 202/223
id jitn}fonf{ {i mn u}nrnf{ iflgfn& Gf {agr r{cjn, {angfdi}oc{gif gr fi{ c {}cfrcb{gifcl iun}c{gif& Iflgfn u}nrnfbnid {an jitn}fonf{ rctnr g{r {gon cfk oifnw mnbc~rn {ac{zgll }nk~bn {an zi}`lick if d}if{lgfn iddgbnr& [an rnbifkr{cjn gr, [}cfrcb{gif, cgor {i nq{nfk {an bcucmglg{w id bc{clij~n r{cjn cfk nfcmlnr {i un}di}o c rgouln iflgfn{}cfrcb{gif& [an Tn}{gbcl Gf{nj}c{gif r{cjn {}cfrdi}orjitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr cfk gf{nj}c{gfj {ano c{ kgddn}nf{ lntnlr&[an ai}gxif{cl Gf{nj}c{gif r{cjn gr {an oc{~}g{w r{cjn zg{a~fgdgnk cfk rncolnrr rn}tgbnr&
[an {zi oiknlr kgddn} mnbc~rn {anw c}n kntnliunk d}iokgddn}nf{ un}runb{gtnr& ^F !=551' dgtn/r{cjn oiknl dib~r ifc znm/mcrnk u~mlgb rn}tgbn& Lcwfn $ Lnn‗r !=553' di~}/r{cjnoiknl gr kntnliunk mcrnk if c jnfn}cl i} cf gf{nj}c{nkun}runb{gtn biomgfgfj {nbafgbcl, i}jcfgxc{gifcl, cfkocfcjn}gcl dncrgmglg{w& Aizntn}, {an oiknl u}iuirnk mwLcwfn $ Lnn !=553', di~}/r{cjn oiknl ogrrnr i~{ if {an
uilg{gbcl uc}{gbguc{gif biouifnf{ cfk kinr fi{ ckk}nrr {anuirrgmln bacfjnr gf {an zcw knbgrgifr c}n ockn gfjitn}fonf{& Wnonf jitn}fonf{ gr oir{ lg`nlw kncl zg{a {ankgddn}nf{ r{cjnr id n/jitn}fonf{ mw dillizgfj mi{a id {anrnoiknlr& !N/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ {nco Kib~onf{c{gif, =551'&
T& GB[ CFK N/JITN]FONF[ GF WNONF Gf {agr uc}{ {an }nrnc}ban} gr {}wgfj {i u}nrnf{ {an b~}}nf{
rg{~c{gif id Wnonf‗r GB[ cfk n/jitn}fonf{& [an}ndi}n {agruc}{ zgll mn nqulcgfnk gf dgtn r~mrnb{gifr cr dillizr8 C& Wnonf itn}tgnz8
Wnonf gr ifn id {an kntnliugfj bi~f{}gnr zagba libc{nkgf {an ri~{an}f uc}{ id {an C}cmgcf Unfgfr~lc& G{ gr mi~fknk
if {an fi}{a mw Rc~kg C}cmgc cfk mw {an C}cm Rnc& Iocf lgnrgf {an znr{ id {an ]nu~mlgb id Wnonf cfk {an ]nk Rnc lgnr gf{an znr{ id {an ]nu~mlgb id Wnonf& [an {i{cl c}nc id {an]nu~mlgb id Wnonf gr cmi~{ >>>,555 rs~c}n @glion{n}, cfk{an uiu~lc{gif id Wnonf gr =2 ogllgif !FGB, =535'& [aniddgbgcl lcfj~cjn id {an bi~f{}w gr C}cmgb cfk Grlco gr {aniddgbgcl }nlgjgif id {an bi~f{}w& [an Wnonfg ]gcl !W]' gr {aniddgbgcl b~}}nfbw ~fg{& [an ]nu~mlgb id Wnonf acr {a}nnfc{gifcl gfknunfknfbn kcwr8 Rnu{nomn} =4, 374= zanf {an`gfj id Fi}{a {an ]nu~mlgb id Wnonf, c{ {ac{ {gon, zcritn}{a}izf cfk oc`gfj {an bi~f{}w c }nu~mlgb gfr{nck id c`gfjkio, Fitnomn} 25, 374: zanf Ri~{a {an ]nu~mlgb id Wnonf, c{ {ac{ {gon, ack mnbion gfknunfknf{ d}io ^fg{nk@gfjkio& [an ^fgdgbc{gif Kcw if Ocw ==, 3775, zanf {an
]nu~mlgb id Wnonf zcr nr{cmlgrank mw {an on}jn} id Ri~{acfk Fi}{a id Wnonf&
Dgj~}n 28 Ocu id {an ]nu~mlgb id Wnonf&
M&
GB[ Rnb{i} gf WnonfGfdi}oc{gif cfk Bioo~fgbc{gif [nbafilijw !GB[' grbifrgkn}nk fizckcwr cf nddgbgnf{ {iil rn}tgfj {an u}ij}nrrcfk kntnliuonf{ id bi~f{}gnr !NRBZC, =55:'& Lg`n i{an}lnrr kntnliunk bi~f{}gnr, {an }nu~mlgb id Wnonf gr rnn`gfj {ikntnliu {agr tg{cl rnb{i} {i bc}}w if g{r kntnliuonf{ u}ibnrr!NRBZC, =55:'& Wnonf gr gf liznr{ lntnl id GB[gfd}cr{}~b{~}n gf zi}lk, {agr lntnl gr bac}cb{n}gxnk mw {andillizgfj8 !c' liz unfn{}c{gif }c{nr id dgqnk cfk oimgln{nlnuaifn lgfnr0 !m' lcb` id cf nftg}ifonf{ bifk~bgtn {izgknru}nck ~rn id {nlnbioo~fgbc{gif rn}tgbnr mw m~rgfnrrnrcfk gfkgtgk~clr0 cfk !b' gfr~ddgbgnf{ fc{gifcl mcfkzgk{a,gfckns~c{n mcb`mifn di} tigbn cfk kc{c {nlnbioo~fgbc{gifcfk gfr~ddgbgnf{ f~omn} id Gf{n}fn{ ulcwn}r gf {an oc}`n{!NRBZC, =557'&
[an dillizgfj {cmln 3/ raizr {ac{ Wnonf bi~f{}w gfknqgf {n}o id ~rgfj biou~{n}r cfk Gf{n}fn{, {nlnuaifn ~rcjn&
[cmln 38 [nlnbioo~fgbc{gif Gfd}cr{}~b{~}n gfknq cfk g{r biouifnf{r
Bi~f{}wGfknqtcl~n
Nr{goc{nkGf{n}fn{ ~rn}r
un} 355gfacmg{cf{r
Ocgf dgqnk{nlnuaifn
lgfnr un} 355gfacmg{cf{r
Oimglnr~mrb}gmn}r
un} 355gfacmg{cf{r
Un}rifclbiou~{n}r
un} 355gfacmg{cf{r
[i{cl dgqnkm}ickmcfk
un} 355gfacmg{cf{r
Wnonf 5&5=71 3&;; ;&;1 32&:4 =&:: 5&55
Ri~}bn8 ^fg{nk Fc{gifr N/jitn}fonf{ R~}tnw =535&
Cbbi}kgfj {i !NRBZC, =55:', Wnonf‗r nddi}{ {izc}krm~glkgfj cf Gfdi}oc{gif Ribgn{w bcf mn r~ooc}gxnk crdillizr8
[an Fc{gifcl Gfdi}oc{gif Bnf{n} !FGB' zcr nr{cmlgrankk~}gfj {an rnbifk acld id 377>&
[an ogfgr{}w id [nlnbioo~fgbc{gif cfk Gfdi}oc{gif[nbafilijw !O[G[' gf =552, g{ zcr nf{}~r{nk zg{a G[ocfcjnonf{ gf ckkg{gif {i kntnliuonf{ cfk i}jcfgxc{gifid bioo~fgbc{gif uilgbgnr& G{ acr ocfw bcou~rnr knclzg{a {an G[ r~ba cr83& [nlnbioo~fgbc{gif cfk Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw bg{w=& Nlnb{}ifgb Lgm}c}w2& Jnfn}cl [nlnbio Bi~fbgl
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 31:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 203/223
;& Kc{c bioo~fgbc{gif>& Wnonf Nlnb{}ifgb Jitn}fonf{ Ui}{cl&
[an bnf{}cl r{c{gr{gbr Knuc}{onf{, cddglgc{nk {i {an
Ogfgr{}w id Ulcffgfj cfk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Biiun}c{gif,ckiu{nk c fc{gifcl r{}c{njw if r{c{gr{gbcl zi}`&B& [nlnuaifnBcucbg{w
Cbbi}kgfj {i !NRBZC, =55:', Wnonf gr r{gll coifj {anbi~f{}gnr {ac{ mnfndg{ lg{{ln d}io bioo~fgbc{gif rn}tgbnr&[an ocgf bacllnfjnr cfk imr{cblnr c}n {an bi~f{}w‗rkgddgb~l{ {iuij}cuaw, rbc{{n}nk uiu~lc{gif j}i~ur cfk lizknfrg{w, znc` gfd}cr{}~b{~}n rn}tgbnr cfk liz lntnl id kgr{}gm~{gif fn{zi}`r gf {an bg{gnr cr znll cr gf }~}cl c}ncr&[an dillizgfj {cmln raizr {an ochi}g{w gfkgbc{i}r di}Wnonf {nlnuaifn bioo~fgbc{gifr&
[CMLN=8 [NLNUAIFN BIOO^FGBC[GIF GFKGBC[I]R !^]MCF CFK ]^]CL'
K^]GFJ =552/=55>GFKGBC[I] ) WNC] =552 =55; =55> =554 =55:
^]MCF BIOO^FGBC[GIF [I[CL BCUCBG[W ID
BIOO^FGBC[GIF
FN[ZI]@
3,>5>,37= 3,>4;,2;7 3>:>,347 3,>15,744 3,>:2,;:4
CUCBG[W DG[[NK!LGFN' 3,343,5;3 3,=;2,121 3,=:1,23> 3,255,5;= 3,2=4,3=>
Uiu~lc{gif !Uniuln' 37,323,7:: 37,:=3,423 =5,25>,=47 =5,755,>2= =3,>21,77>
nlnuaifn knfrg{w!{nlnuaifn) un} 355gfacmg{cfbnr'
2&> ;&3 ;&; ;&42 ;&:;
Lgfnr Tcbcfbgnr !lgfn' ;:4,3>: ;;>,:5= 2:4,725 223,:3; 25;,32:
F~omn} id zi}`gfj
{nlnuaifn lgfnr !lgfn'41;,11; :71,324 753,21> 741,2=1 3,5=3,711
an gfb}ncrn gf {anzi}`gfj {nlnuaifn lgfnr
3;=,415 332,=>= 352,=;7 44,7;2 >2,445
an f~omn} id ocgfnqbacfjnr !f~omn}'
;: >= >; ;7 ;7
an f~omn} id r~mnqbacfjnr !f~omn}'
=51 === ==2 ==7 ==7
]~}cl Bioo~fgbc{gif((
]~}cl Bioo~fgbc{gifBcucbg{gnr dg{{nk !Lgfn' 353,2;; 3=1,21> =;5,=;> 375,>:> 372,>:1
Lgfnr iun}c{gfj !lgfn' 4=,>72 74,5=: 3=;,7=3 3>4,375 341,:31
Un}bnf{cjn id lgfnriun}c{gfj {i ns~guunkbcucbg{gnr !.'
4= :> >= 1= 1:
Ri~}bn8 FC[GIFCL U]IDGLN ID [AN GFDI]OC[GIF RIBGN[W GF WNONF, NRBZC =557&
K& Gf{n}fn{ cfk oimgln rn}tgbnr gf Wnonf
Cbbi}kgfj {i !Cl/N}wcfg, =557', Gf{n}fn{ rn}tgbnr gf Wnonfr{c}{nk gf 3774 zg{a ifn rgfjln u}itgkn}& Rnbifk u}itgkn}
acr mnnf r{c}{nk zi}`gfj gf Cu}gl =55=& Zg}nlnrr cbbnrr {ifn{zi}` zcr l~fbank c{ {an nfk id Knbnomn} =554&Mn{znnf=55;/=554, Wnonf gou}itnk g{r oimglnbioo~fgbc{gif rn}tgbnr cr {an f~omn} id oimgln {nlnuaifnr~mrb}gmn}r h~ounk d}io 3&;12 ogllgif gf =55; {i 2&=53ogllgif =554 !NRBZC, =55:'& [an dillizgfj {cmln raizr{an ochi}g{w gfkgbc{i}r di} Wnonf gf{n}fn{ cfk oimglnrn}tgbnr&
[cmln 28 Gf{n}fn{ cfk Oimgln Uaifn Gfkgbc{i}r gf WnonfRi~}bn8 FC[GIFCL U]IDGLN ID [AN GFDI]OC[GIF RIBGN[W GF WNONF,
NRBZC =55:
N& N/jitn}fonf{ kntnliuonf{ gf Wnonf
[an Wnonf jitn}fonf{, lg`n oir{ i{an} kntnliugfjbi~f{}gnr, gr r{gll {}wgfj {i goulnonf{ G[ gf jitn}fonf{i}jcfgxc{gif, cfk {}w nr{cmlgragfj rion u}ihnb{r cr gfg{gcl
r{nu {i oc`n n/jitn}fonf{ r~ba cr {an Fc{gifcl U}ij}co di}Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw, {ac{ `fizf cr Wnonfn/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ =552& [an dillizgfj [cmln/; raizr{ac{ Wnonf gr r{gll ifn id {an liznr{ bi~f{}gnr gf {n}or id N/jitn}fonf{ kntnliuonf{ mn{znnf =551/cfk =535&[cmln ;8 N/jitn}fonf{ kntnliuonf{r gf znr{n}f Crgc !gfbl~kgfj Wnonf'
mn{znnf =551 cfk =535&
Bi~f{}wN/jitn}fonf{ kntnliuonf
gfknq tcl~nZi}lk n/jitn}fonf{kntnliuonf{ }cf`gfj
=535 =551 =535 =551
Mca}cgf 5&:242 5&>:=2 32 ;=
Bwu}~r 5&>:5> 5&4537 ;= 2>
^fg{nk C}cm Nog}c{nr 5&>2;7 5&4253 ;7 2=
@~zcg{ 5&>=75 5&>=5= >5 >:
Hi}kcf 5&>=:1 5&>;15 >3 =5
Rc~kg C}cmgc 5&>3;= 5&;72> >1 :5
Sc{c} 5&;7=1 5&>23; 4= >2
[~}`nw 5&;:15 5&;12; 47 :4
Iocf 5&;>:4 5&;473 1= 1;
Cxn}mcghcf 5&;>:3 5&;457 12 17
Lnmcfif 5&;211 5&;1;5 72 :;
Jni}jgc 5&;=;1 5&;>71 355 75
C}onfgc 5&;5=> 5&;31= 335 352
Rw}gcf C}cm ]nu~mlgb 5&2352 5&243; 322 337
G}cs 5&=774 5&=475 324 3>3
Wnonf 5&=3>; 5&=3;= 34; 34;
Ri~}bn8 fg{nk Fc{gifr N/Jitn}fonf{ R~}tnw =535&
TG& N/JITN]FONF[ U]IHNB[R GF WNONF
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 311
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 204/223
Gfdi}oc{gif Bioo~fgbc{gif [nbafilijw !GB[' grbifrgkn}nk fizckcwr cf nddgbgnf{ {iil rn}tgfj {an u}ij}nrrcfk kntnliuonf{ id bi~f{}gnr !NRBZC, =55:'& [an Wnonfjitn}fonf{, lg`n oir{ i{an} kntnliugfj bi~f{}gnr, gr {}wgfj{i goulnonf{ GB[ gf jitn}fonf{ i}jcfgxc{gif, cfk {}wnr{cmlgragfj rion u}ihnb{r cr gfg{gcl r{nu {i oc`nn/jitn}fonf{ rwr{no r~ba cr {an Fc{gifcl U}ij}co di}Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw, {ac{ `fizf cr Wnonf n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ !OBG[, =552', cfk {an iddgbgcljitn}fonf{ ui}{cl zagba acr mnnf cffi~fbnk gf =557& Cr{an u}ntgi~r [cmln ; biouc}n Wnonf {i i{an} bi~f{}gnrc}i~fk {an zi}lk cfk raiz {ac{ Wnonf gr r{gll ifn id {anliznr{ bi~f{}gnr gf {n}o id N/jitn}fonf{ kntnliuonf{mn{znnf “=551/=535‟&
C& Dg}r{ N/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ gf Wnonf !=552 '8
[an dg}r{ c{{nou{ {i m~glk n/jitn}fonf{ gf Wnonf zcr
cffi~fbnk gf =552 cfk g{r znmrg{nr zcr lc~fbank c{ {anrcon wnc} m~{ zg{a dcgl~}n& Aizntn}, {an u}ihnb{ zcrkn}cglnk gf {an cmrnfbn id bacfjn/gfk~bgfj nftg}ifonf{!NRBZC, =55:'& Oi}nitn}, oir{ id {an ctcglcmlngfdi}oc{gif rwr{nor lcb` id {nbafgbcl biouc{gmglg{w cfk~ukc{nk gfdi}oc{gif !FGB, =55>'& [agr dg}r{ n/jitn}fonf{u}ihnb{ dcbnk rion u}imlnor zagba lnck {i {an dcgl~}n id {anu}ihnb{0 {anrn u}imlnor bcf mn r~ooc}gxnk cr dillizr83& Cmrnfbn id blnc} tgrgif cfk r{}c{njw di} {an u~}uirn id
{an n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{& =& Cmrnfbn id bii}kgfc{gif cfk gf{nj}c{gif mn{znnf {an
n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ {nco cfk kgddn}nf{ r{ib`ailkn}rd}io {an jitn}fonf{ ogfgr{}gnr cfk }nlc{nk cjnfbgnr&
2& Cmrnfbn id uilg{gbcl lnckn}ragu&
;&
Bifdlgb{gfj u}gi}g{gnr cmi~{ {an }nruifrgmglg{gnr coifjgftiltnk i}jcfgxc{gifr {izc}k {an n/jitn}fonf{u}ihnb{&
>& Bc}nd~lfnrr d}io rion i}jcfgxc{gif {i kgdd~rgif {ang}gfdi}oc{gif&
4& Lcb` id {nbafgbcl `fizlnkjn cfk biooif {nbafgbclb~l{~}n&
:& Lcb` id rnfrn cfk ribgcl czc}nfnrr id {an goui}{cfbnid n/jitn}fonf{ rwr{no&
1& Lcb` id blnc} on{aikilijgnr cfk oiknlr& 7& Lcb` id n/}nckgfnrr coifj {an jitn}fonf{
i}jcfgxc{gifr nouliwnnr gfbl~kgfj {an {iuocfcjnonf{ cfk lnckn}r&
35& [an jcu mn{znnf {an u}ihnb{ tgrgif cfk {an }ncl
rg{~c{gif&
Mnbc~rn id {an cmitn dcb{i}r, {an u}ihnb{ zcr dcglnk& [andcgl~}n id {an dg}r{ n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ zcr rnnf d}io i{an}{iu ocfcjnonf{ uigf{ id tgnz cr ckhi~}fonf{ fi{ dcgl~}n
k~n {i {an jitn}fonf{ u}gi} u}ihnb{r r~ba cr gou}itgfjnk~bc{gif rnb{i}r cfk ancl{a rnb{i}r& M& Rnbifk N/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ gf Wnonf !=551 '8
[agr u}ihnb{ zcr nr{cmlgrank gf Rnu{nomn} =551&[anocgf cgo zcr {i goulnonf{ cfk biouln{nlw knrgjf {anWnonf iddgbgcl nlnb{}ifgb ui}{cl& [an dg}r{ r{cjn zcr {iknrgjf {an nlnb{}ifgb gfdi}oc{gif bif{nf{ id cll jitn}fonf{i}jcfgxc{gifr, {c`gfj gf{i cbbi~f{ {an kcglw ~ukc{gfj& Gf {agrr{cjn {an bg{gxnf zgll mnfndg{ d}io n/jitn}fonf{ znmrg{n gf{zi kgddn}nf{ zcwr& Dg}r{ zcw gr dgfkgfj gfdi}oc{gif d}io{an ui}{cl tgc {an gf{n}fn{& Rnbifk zcw, gr gfs~g}gfj cmi~{{an jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr tgc {an nocglr cfk bif{cb{rctcglcmln if {an jitn}fonf{ ui}{cl&
D}io {an fnz n/jitn}fonf{ ulcf, {an}n zgll mn u}ihnb{rzi}`gfj gf uc}cllnl zg{a {an ocgf u}ihnb{ cgo {i kntnliu {an{nbafgbcl b~l{~}n& I{an} u}ihnb{r zgll cgo {i kgdd~rgif {an{nbafgbcl r`gllr mw kigfj ocfw {nbafgbcl r`gllr mw kigfjocfw {nbafgbcl bi~}rnr gf ocfw libc{gifr gf Wnonf r~ba crr~oon} bcour !Cl/N}wcfg, =557'&
[an rnbifk r{cjn gf {an fnz n/jitn}fonf{ ulcf zgll mnbifrgkn}gfj {an bifbnu{ id gf{n}cb{gif mn{znnf n/jitn}fonf{ cfk bg{gxnfr gf ifn kg}nb{gif !rnog/gf{n}cb{gif'&[an {ag}k r{cjn id {agr ulcf zgll mn dib~rgfj if n/ucwonf{&[agr r{cjn zgll cgo di} d~ll gf{n}cb{gif gf {zi kg}nb{gifr&
Aizntn}, {an Wnonf n/jitn}fonf{ ui}{cl c{zzz&wnonf&jit&wn gr {an dg}r{ r{nu {izc}k {an d~llgoulnonf{c{gif id {an n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{& [an ocgf cgo
id {agr jitn}fonf{ ui}{cl gr {i oc`n c ~fgdgnk bif{cgfn} di}cll jitn}fonf{ ogfgr{}gnr cfk cjnfbgnr gf ifn rg{n& [agrnlnb{}ifgb ui}{cl o~r{ mn {an iddgbgcl ri~}bn id cll {anjitn}fonf{ gfdi}oc{gif& [agr ui}{cl bcf mn bifrgkn}nk cr{an dg}r{ {}cb` {i {an n/rn}tgbnr cfk {an dg}r{ r{nu {izc}k {and~ll n/jitn}fonf{&
Cbbi}kgfj {i !Cl/N}wcfg, =557' {agr ui}{cl acr ocfwmnfndg{r r~ba cr8 }nk~bn bir{ id rnc}bagfj gfdi}oc{gif,}nk~bn {gon cfk nddi}{ id rnc}bagfj gfdi}oc{gif, cfk u}nuc}n{an ribgn{w di} {an fnq{ r{nu zagba {izc}k {an rnoggf{n}cb{gif zg{a {an jitn}fonf{ znmrg{nr&
Ifn id {an ocgf }ncrifr mnagfk {an r~bbnrr id knrgjfgfjcfk lc~fbagfj {an jitn}fonf{ ui}{cl zg{a cll ogfgr{}gnr id
Wnonf jitn}fonf{ gr {an biomgfc{gif id rnlnb{gfj {anu}ihnb{ {nco zagba bifrgr{r id {nf onomn}r dgtn id {ano c}nd }io {an ogfgr{}w id {nlnbioo~fgbc{gif cfk gfdi}oc{gif{nbafilijw di} {an {nbafgbcl cfk air{gfj grr~nr cfk {an i{an}dgtn c}n d}io {an Gfdi}oc{gif bnf{n} id {an Rnb}n{c}w id {anbcmgfn{ c{ {an U}gon ogfgr{n} iddgbn di} {an ckogfgr{}c{gifcfk uilgbw grr~nr& [agr lnckr {i jn{ c jiik }nruifrn d}io {ankgddn}nf{ ogfgr{}gnr cfk }nlc{nk cjnfbgnr {i ~ulick {ang}gfdi}oc{gif cr }ns~g}nk d}io {an u}ihnb{ {nco {i {an iddgbgclui}{cl gf c uc}{gb~lc} {gon cfk ncba id {ano {c`n {an}nruifrgmglg{w id ~uj}ckgfj {ang} gfdi}oc{gif& [agr bi~lk fi{mn acuunf zg{ai~{ {an gf{n}dn}n id {an rnb}n{c}w id {anbcmgfn{ gf {an U}gon ogfgr{n} iddgbn zagba jgtnr kg}nb{gifr
Gfkgbc{i})Wnc}r =552 =55> =554
Itn}cll gf{n}fn{ r~mrb}gmn}r !r~mrb}gmn}' :;43> 3573=: 3>1;:4
Itn}cll gf{n}fn{ r~mrb}gmn}r !un} 355 gfacmg{cf{r' 5&21 5&>; 5&:4
Gf{n}fn{ ~rn}r !~rn}' ==3555 225555 ;>5555
Itn}cll f~omn} id oimgln uaifn r~mrb}gmn}r 3;12=22 ==::>>2 2=53:74
Oimgln uaifn r~mrb}gmn}r un} 355 gfacmg{cf{r :> 33&= 3>&2
F~omn} id biou~{n}r gf {an bi~f{}w !biou~{n}' =35555 =:5555 225555
Biou~{n} kgrrnogfc{gif knfrg{w
!ifn kntgbn un} 355 gfacmg{cf{r'
3&3 3&2 3&4
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 317
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 205/223
cfk gfr{}~b{gif {i {an kgddn}nf{ ogfgr{}gnr cfk cjnfbgnr {i mnif {gon {i ki {ang} }nruifrgmglg{gnr zg{a {an }nrunb{ {i {anrbank~lgfj {gon runbgdgnk mw {an u}ihnb{ {nco&
TGG& BIFBL^RGIF CFK ]NBIOONFKC[GIFR
[an INBK !=552' kndgfnr n/jitn}fonf{ cr “{an ~rn id gfdi}oc{gif cfk bioo~fgbc{gif {nbafilijgnr, cfkuc}{gb~lc}lw {an gf{n}fn{, cr c {iil {i cbagntn mn{{n}jitn}fonf{‟& Gf {agr knrb}gu{gif, {an gf{n}fn{ gr kndgfnk cr c}ns~g}nonf{ cfk c uirrgmln onkg~o di} n/jitn}fonf{& [a~r,{an dg}r{ r{nu, bi~f{}gnr fnnk {i kndgfn {ang} blnc} tgrgif cfkr{}c{njw di} n/jitn}fonf{ rwr{no& [agr m}ick tgrgif id n/jitn}fonf{ rai~lk mn rac}nk zg{a {an cll kgddn}nf{r{c`nailkn}r !jitn}fonf{ cjnfbgnr, Bg{gxnfr, M~rgfnrrnr,cfk i{an}r'& D}io {an n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{‗r {ncogfdi}oc{gif cfk uaifn bcll gf{n}tgnzr cfk clri }nrnc}ban}uigf{ id tgnz cr ifn onomn} id {an {nco, g{ acr mnnf blnc}{ac{ {an}n c}n dcgl~}n cfk r~bbnrr dcb{i}r id goulnonf{gfj n/jitn}fonf{ rwr{no gf {an on{}iuilg{cf bg{w “Rcfc‗c‟/{anbcug{cl bg{w id {an }nu~mlgb id Wnonf& [anrn dcb{i}r bcf mnr~ooc}gxnk cr dillizr8
R~bbnrr dcb{i}r8
3& Oc`n {an jitn}fonf{ nouliwnnr n/}nckw& [ac{oncfr {}cgf {ano di} {an }ns~g}nk GB[ r`gllr cfk `fizlnkjncr znll cr oc`n {ano czc}nfnrr id {an mnfndg{r cfkgoui}{cfbn id {an n/jitn}fonf{ rwr{no&
=& Oc`n {an bg{gxnfr n/}nckw& [ac{ oncfr {i }nk~bn{an jcu mn{znnf {an bg{gxnfr gf {an {nbafilijw b~l{~}n cfkr`gllr&
Dcgl~}n dcb{i}r8
3& [an comgj~i~r tgrgif id {an bifbnu{~cl id {ann/jitn}fonf{&
=& [an cmrnfbn id {an }nckgfnrr cfk czc}nfnrr coifj{an nouliwnnr cfk {an bg{gxnfr&
2& [an kgjg{cl kgtgkn mn{znnf {an bioo~fg{gnr& ]nbioonfkc{gifr8
D}io {an }nrnc}ban} uigf{ id tgnz, rion}nbioonfkc{gif {ac{ Wnonfg jitn}fonf{ rai~lk r{}ifjlwbifrgkn} {izc}kr n/jitn}fonf{ goulnonf{c{gif zagba bi~lkmn fi {nbafilijgbcl dcb{i}r cr znll& [anrn }nbioonfkc{gifrbcf mn r~ooc}gxnk gf {zi r{cjnr8
R{cjn38 N/}nckgfnrr Gfd}cr{}~b{~}n8 [agr acr {i gfbl~kn{an dillizgfj8
3& Nk~bc{gif8 gou}itn {an s~clg{w id nk~bc{gif cfk iddn} nk~bc{gif di} cll&
=& Jnfkn}8 }nk~bn {an jcu mn{znnf oclnrcfk dnoclnr cfk iddn} {ano ns~cl nk~bc{gif cfkbacfbnr&
2& Gfbion8 rgfbn {an JKU un} bcug{c grc}i~fk +3555 ^RK, {an jitn}fonf{ rai~lk }nk~bn {anbir{ id biou~{n}r, {}cgfgfj, cfk gf{n}fn{ cbbnrr cfkoc`n {ano ctcglcmln di} {an cll lcwn}r id bg{gxnfr zg{abancun} u}gbnr&
;& ]~}cl cfk ^}mcf8 }nk~bn {an jcu mn{znnf{an bg{gxnfr gf {an }~}cl cfk ~}mcf c}ncr mw iddn}gfj{ano&
R{cjn=8 N/}nckgfnrr Kgdd~rgif8 [agr acr {i gfbl~kn {andillizgfj8
3& Kgdd~rgif id biou~{n}r cfk gf{n}fn{ b~l{~}n
=&
Blc}gdw {an {ai~ja{ {ac{ “Biou~{n} gr iflw di}runbgclgr{‟&2& Blc}gdw {an ogr~fkn}r{cfkgfj id kcfjn}r id {an
gf{n}fn{ znmrg{nr&;& Blc}gdw {an bifbnu{~cl id n/jitn}fonf{ mnfndg{r
cfk goui}{cfbn di} bg{gxnfr cfk nouliwnnr&Dgfcllw, g{ bcf mn rcgk {ac{ Wnonf u~mlgrank g{r iddgbgcl
ui}{cl gf =557 {izc}kr u}nuc}gfj di} {an zailn n/jitn}fonf{ u}ihnb{ goulnonf{c{gif& [an tgrgif gr fiz blnc}cfk {an u}ibnrrnr c}n rionaiz gknf{gdgnr cfk nr{cmlgrank&Ifn id {an ocgf }ncrifr mnagfk {an r~bbnrr id knrgjfgfjcfk lc~fbagfj {an jitn}fonf{ ui}{cl zg{a cll ogfgr{}gnr id Wnonf jitn}fonf{ gr {an biomgfc{gif id rnlnb{gfj {anu}ihnb{ {nco zagba bifrgr{r id {nf onomn}r, dgtn id {anoc}n d}io {an ogfgr{}w id {nlnbioo~fgbc{gif cfk gfdi}oc{gif{nbafilijw di} {an {nbafgbcl cfk air{gfj grr~nr, cfk {ani{an} dgtn c}n d}io {an Gfdi}oc{gif bnf{n} id {an Rnb}n{c}wid {an bcmgfn{ c{ {an U}gon ogfgr{n} iddgbn di} {anckogfgr{}c{gif cfk uilgbw grr~nr& [agr lnckr {i jn{ c jiik}nruifrn d}io {an kgddn}nf{ ogfgr{}gnr cfk }nlc{nk cjnfbgnr{i ~ulick {ang} gfdi}oc{gif cr }ns~g}nk d}io {an u}ihnb{{nco {i {an iddgbgcl ui}{cl gf c }nrunb{nk {gon, {an}ndi}n ncbaid {ano {c`n {an }nruifrgmglg{w id ~uj}ckgfj {ang} izfgfdi}oc{gif& [agr bi~lk fi{ mn acuunf zg{ai~{ {an gf{n}dn}nid {an rnb}n{c}w id {an bcmgfn{ gf {an U}gon ogfgr{n} iddgbnzagba jgtnr kg}nb{gifr cfk gfr{}~b{gif {i kgddn}nf{ ogfgr{}gnrcfk cjnfbgnr {i mn if {gon {i ki {ang} }nruifrgmglg{gnr zg{a
{an }nrunb{ {i {an rbank~lgfj {gon runbgdgnk mw {an u}ihnb{{nco&
CB@FIZLNKJONF[ [agr zi}` zcr r~uui}{nk mw {an Ogfgr{}w id @fizlnkjn
Nbifiow !O@N', Ri~{a @i}nc, ~fkn} {an Gf{n}fc{gifcl G[Uilgbw U}ij}co !G[UU' c{ Rni~l Fc{gifcl ^fgtn}rg{w&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ ^fg{nk Fc{gifr !=551'& ^F N/Jitn}fonf{ R~}tnw =5518 D}io n/jitn}fonf{ {i Biffnb{nk Jitn}fcfbn, Knuc}{onf{ id Nbifiogb cfkRibgcl Cddcg}r, Kgtgrgif di} U~mlgb Ckogfgr{}c{gif cfk Kntnliuonf{Ocfcjnonf{, ctcglcmln c{8a{{u8))~fucf3&~f&i}j)gf{}ckib)j}i~ur)u~mlgb)kib~onf{r)~f)~fucf5=145:&ukd
P=_ Lcwfn, @& cfk Lnn, H&Z& !=553'&Kntnliugfj d~llw d~fb{gifcl N/jitn}fonf{8 C di~} r{cjn Oiknl, Jitn}fonf{ Gfdi}oc{gif S~c}{n}lw31!=', 3==/324&
P2_ Bc}{n}, L& cfk Mnlcfjn}, D& !=55>'& [an ~{glgxc{gif id n/jitn}fonf{ rn}tgbnr8 bg{gxnf {}~r{, gffitc{gif cfk cbbnu{cfbn dcb{i}r,Gfdi}oc{gif rwr{no H 3>, >/=>&
P;_ Tclnf{gfc !=55;'& N ‒ jitn}fonf{ di} Kntnliugfj Bi~f{}gn0Iuui}{gf~{gnr cfk Bacllnfjnr& [an Nlnb{}ifgb Hi~}fcl if Gfdi}oc{gifRwr{nor gf Kntnliugfj Bi~f{}gnr, NHGRKB !=55;' 31, 3, uu& 3/=;&
P>_ Ann`r, ]& !=552' N/jitn}fonf{ di} Kntnliuonf{ U}ihnb{r Dcgl8 Aizbcf ]gr`r mn ]nk~bn9 gJitn}fonf{ zi}`gfj ucun} rn}gnr, Ucun} fi&3;& Ctcglcmln c{ a{{u8)) a{{u8))~fucf3&~f&i}j)gf{}ckib)j}i~ur)u~mlgb)kib~onf{r)FGRUCbnn)^FUCF53>;11&ukd
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 375
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 206/223
P4_ INBK,=552 “INBK n/Jitn}fonf{ R{~kgnr8 [an n/Jitn}fonf{Goun}c{gtn,‟ INBK U~mlgbc{gifr, D}cfbn, =552
P:_ NRBZC !Nbifiogb cfk Ribgcl Bioogrrgif di} znr{n}f Crgc',!=55:' Fc{gifcl U}idgln id {an gfdi}oc{gif ribgn{w gf Wnonf, ^fg{nk
Fc{gif ctcglcmln c{8a{{u8))zzz&nrbzc&~f&i}j)zrgr)}nui}{r)kibr)WnonfY=55>/N&ukd
P1_ [an Wnonfg n/jitn}fonf{ ui}{cl u}ihnb{ kib~onf{c{gif, !=551,=557'&
P7_ Kckc, K& !=554'& “[an Dcgl~}n id N/jitn}fonf{ gf KntnliugfjBi~{~}gn}r8 C Lg{n}c{~}n ]ntgnz‟& [an Nlnb{}ifgb Hi~}fcl ifGfdi}oc{gif Rwr{nor gf Kntnliugfj Bi~f{}gnr, NHGRKB !=554' =4, :,3/35&
P35_ ^fg{nk Fc{gifr !=535'& ^F N/Jitn}fonf{ R~}tnw =5358 Lntn}cjgfjn/jitn}fonf{ c{ c {gon id dgfcfbgcl cfk nbifiogb b}grgr, ^fg{nkFc{gifr, Fnz Wi}`, =535& Ctcglcmln c{8a{{u8))~fucf3&~f&i}j)gf{}ckib)j}i~ur)u~mlgb)kib~onf{r)~f)~fucf5211>3&ukd
P33_ Zi}lk Mcf` !=557'& Zi}lk Kntnliuonf{ ]nui}{, ctcglcmln c{a{{u8))nbif&zi}lkmcf`&i}j) cbbnrrnk if Rnu{nomn} 3>, =535&
P3=_ FGB !Fc{gifcl Gfdi}oc{gif Bnf{n}' !=55>', N/jitn}fonf{ “Wnonf‗ruc}{gb~lc}g{gnr cfk on{aikilijw di} cbagntgfj comg{gif‟& Ucun}r~mog{{nk {i Wnonf‗r Rai~}c bi~fbgl onn{gfj&
P32_ Mcr~, R& !=55;', “N/Jitn}fonf{ cfk Kntnliugfj Bi~f{}gnr8 CfItn}tgnz‟, Gf{n}fc{gifcl ]ntgnz id Lcz Biou~{n}r $ [nbafilijw,Til 31, Fi& 3, uu& 357‒32=&
P3;_ Rac}gdg, A& cfk Xc}ng M, !=55;'& Cf ckcu{gtn cuu}icba di}goulnonf{gfj n/jitn}fonf{ gf G&]& G}cf, Hi~}fcl id Jitn}fonf{Gfdi}oc{gif 25 !=55;' 455‒437, kig835&3534)h&hjg&=55;&35&55>
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 373
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 207/223
C Knrgjf Oiknl id Mcf`gfj Znmrg{n gf Un}runb{gtn id Mnactgi}cl Dncrgmglg{w R{~kw
O}& Rc}ctcfcf&B O}& Tgfcw ]
Crrgr{cf{ U}idnrri}, Knuc}{onf{ id OBC, R{~knf{, 2}k Rnonr{n}, Knuc}{onf{ id Onbacfgbcl Nfjgfnn}gfj]&T&Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj ]&T&Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj
Mcfjcli}n, Gfkgc Mcfjcli}n, Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{‛Gf [ikcw‗r fn{zi}` zi}lk, rnb~}g{w gr {an ochi}
bifbn}f cll itn} {an zi}lk& Zanf fnz rnb~}g{w oncr~}nr actn
kntnliunk {i riltn {an nqgr{gfj {a}nc{, c fnz c{{cb` gr u}ik~bnk
mw {an oclgbgi~r ~rn}r& [agr ucun} knclr zg{a u}imlnor }nlc{nk
{i ogkkln cjnk j}i~u uniuln cfk cjnk uniuln zagln ~rgfj mcf`
znmrg{nr di} {}cfrcb{gifr cfk i{an} zi}`r& Uagragfj gr ifn id
{an }ncrif zan}n uniuln ctigk ~rgfj n/mcf`gfj& Gf {agr ucun}
zn c}n jgtgfj r~jjnr{gifr {i nfacfbn {an dnc{~}n id mcf`gfj
znmrg{nr mcrnk if mnactgi}cl dncrgmglg{w r{~kw mw ~rgfj
rgo~lc{gif
@nwzi}kr/Rnb~}g{w,Uagragfj,n/mcf`gfj,mnactgi}cl dncrgmglg{w&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
Uagragfj gr {an zi}k zagba gr {iugfj {an lgr{ id bwmn}b}gonr cr {agr gr {an r{c}{gfj b}gon zagba lnckr {i cll i{an}bwmn} b}gonr& Uagragfj gr {an cb{ id cbs~g}gfj u}gtc{n i}rnfrg{gtn kc{c d}io un}rifcl biou~{n}r di} ~rn gf d}c~k~lnf{cb{gtg{gnr& [ikcw Uagragfj znmrg{nr c}n gfb}ncrgfj c{ cfclc}ogfj }c{n kcw mw kcw& Cbbi}kgfj {i Gfkgcf Biou~{n}Non}jnfbw ]nruifrn {nco PBN][/ Gf_ gf {an r~}tnwbifk~b{nk mw {ano, i~{ id 357 rnb~}g{w gfbgknf{r }nui}{nk gf
{an oif{a id Rnu{nomn} =533, =1. gfbgknf{r zn}n }nlc{nk {iUagragfj P3_&
Ocfw uniuln ctigk n/mcf`gfj r{c{gfj Uagragfj cr ifn id {an }ncrif& Cjnk uniuln clri dgfk kgddgb~l{gnr mnbc~rn id {ang}tgrgif u}imlno {ac{ gfb}ncrnr zg{a {ang} cjn& Knb}ncrgfjcmglg{w {i dib~r if fnc} {cr`r }nlc{nk {i biou~{n} rb}nnf,Lcb` id bifdgknfbn cfk {}~r{ zi}{aw gf ~rgfj mcf`gfjznmrg{n oc`n uniuln {i gjfi}n ~rgfj iflgfn mcf`gfj{}cfrcb{gifr& Gf {n}or id rnb~}g{w, uniuln c}n clri zi}}gnkcmi~{ {ang} fn{ mcf` lijgf kn{cglr {i mn acb`nk mw~fc~{ai}grnk oclgbgi~r ~rn}r& B~r{ion}r c}n bn}{cgflwbifbn}fnk id jgtgfj {ang} mcf` cbbi~f{ f~omn} iflgfn&F~on}i~r r{~kgnr actn gknf{gdgnk lcb` id {}~r{ cr ifn id {anocgf }ncrifr {ac{ bifr~on}r c}n r{gll }nl~b{cf{ {i bifk~b{
{ang} dgfcfbgcl {}cfrcb{gifr iflgfnGf bcrn id non}jnfbw, ~rn}r kif‗{ jn{ cuu}iu}gc{n }nruifrnr
d}io {an rn}tn} cr {an di}o id Cbbi~f{ r{c{nonf{r cfk i{an}
iflgfn {}cfrcb{gif kn{cglr& Oir{ id {agr ibb~}r k~n {i
{nbafgbcl u}imlnor& ^rn}r clri dnnl {ac{ gf{n}fn{ mcf`gfj
gftiltnr gf c ucun}lnrr m~rgfnrr nftg}ifonf{& [anw dnc} {ac{
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ Til~on
3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35& :2511)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :2511
gd {anw ki fi{ actn z}g{{nf u}iid id {}cfrcb{gifr, {anw zglllirn {an cmglg{w {i u}itn cfw{agfj& [anw zcf{ {an bif{}il cugnbn id ucun} rnnor {i jgtn {ano& Nk~bc{nk ~rn}r c}n clrir{gll ~rgfj {an mcf` ucrrmii` di} {ang} mcf`gfj {}cfrcb{gifrcfk fi{ ~rgfj {an dcbglg{gnr id {an fn{ mcf`gfj di} {an{}cfrcb{gifr& [an grr~n id b~r{ion} ~fdcoglgc}g{w zg{a {angf{n}fn{, zagba gr u}iogfnf{ coifj rnfgi} bg{gxnfr, acr}nbnf{lw bc~ja{ rion c{{nf{gif, mnbc~rn {anrn b~r{ion}rmnlgntn {ac{ {anw c}n lnd{ c{ c kgrcktcf{cjni~r uirg{gif cfkmnbion tn}w }nl~b{cf{ gf kigfj m~rgfnrr iflgfn& OcfwU}ibnk~}nr c}n gftiltnk gf ~rgfj fn{ mcf`gfj cr biouc}nk {iC[Or& Mcf`gfj {a}i~ja iflgfn acr non}jnk cr cf goui}{cf{}nri~}bn di} bif{}illgfj {an {}cfrcb{gifr, }nk~bgfj {an bir{ mw}nulcbgfj ucun} zi}`r zagba gf {~}f lnckr {i nddgbgnf{u}ik~b{gtg{w cfk u}idg{cmglg{w P=_&Dgj 3 }nu}nrnf{r {an r{c{gr{gbr id uagragfj }c{n di} {an wnc}=533, d}io Hcf~c}w {gll Rnu{nomn}& Gf {an oif{a id Cu}gl=533, {an}n zcr agja }c{n id uagragfj gfbgknf{r&Dgj =}nu}nrnf{r {an jnf~gfn znmrg{n id mcf`gfj znmrg{n cfk Dgj 2}nu}nrnf{r uagragfj znmrg{n zagba kgddn}r iflw gf {an ^]L&
Dgj 3& Uagragfj R{c{gr{gbr gf {an wnc} =533
!Hcf~c}w {i Rnu{nomn{'
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 37=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 208/223
Dgj =& Jnf~gfn Mcf`gfj Znmrg{n
Dgj 2& Uagragfj Znmrg{n zagba kgddn}r gf ]L
GG& NQGR[GFJ U]IMLNOR ZG[A MCF@GFJ ZNMRG[NR
[nq{ bili} cfk Dif{ rgxn grr~n
[an {nq{r c{ {an rg{n c}n {wunk zg{a c tn}w rocll dif{ cfk
{an dif{ bili} gr u}cb{gbcllw gknf{gbcl {i {an mcb`j}i~fk bili}&
G{ u}ntnf{r {an tgrg{i}r d}io r{~kwgfj {an gfdi}oc{gif c{ {an
rg{n cr r~ba dif{r c}n tn}w {g}gfj di} {an nwnr& [an
mcb`j}i~fk bili} id rion id {an znmrg{nr gr {ii m}gja{ cfk
oi{lnw& [an {nq{ jn{r lir{ if r~ba mcb`j}i~fk cfk g{ gr ac}k
di} tgrg{i}r {i }nck cfw{agfj&
Rliz Rn}tn} ]nruifrn [gonrRion mcf` znmrg{nr bif{cgfr oi}n j}cuagbr {acf {an
knrg}nk lntnl zagba }nr~l{r gf knlcw gf lickgfj {an ucjn&
Rion{gonr m~glkgfj c ucjn clri gftiltnr biffnb{gifr {i
kc{cmcrn rn}tn}r, rlizgfj kizf {an u}ibnrr ntnf d~}{an}& C
~rn} kinr fi{ mi{an} zaw }nruifrn {gonr c}n rliz& Cll {anw
`fiz gr {ac{ {an rg{n kinr fi{ iddn} jiik rn}tgbn& [an lntnl id
{}~r{ j}ck~cllw }nk~bnr k~n {i liz }nruifrn {gonr Cffiwgfj imhnb{r gf {an znmrg{nr
Cjnk ^rn}r dgfk Dlcragfj cfk mlgf`gfj gf {an znmrg{n {i
mn g}}g{c{gfj di} {ano &[anw clri dgfk ucjnr zg{a g}}nlntcf{
oc{n}gcl r~ba cr cktn}{grnonf{r kgr{}cb{gfj {i {ano& Cb{gifr
Rb}illgfj cfk i{an} oi~rn cb{gtg{gnr c}n c lnc}fnk
mnactgi~} cfk mnbion oi}n kgddgb~l{ zg{a cjn& ^rgfj u~ll/
kizf onf~r, rb}illgfj lgr{r cfk rb}illgfj ucjnr gr kgddgb~l{ {i
~fkn}r{cfk, cbbnrrgfj {an g{nor zac{ gr blgb`cmln gru}imlnoc{gb di} rion nlkn}lw ~rn}r&Rnb~}g{w grr~nr
Rnb~}g{w cfk kc{c bifdgknf{gclg{w grr~nr actn mnnf c
ochi} mc}}gn} gf {an mcf`gfj gfk~r{}w gf {an b~}}nf{ un}gik
P2_& Rion b~r{ion}r ctigk iflgfn mcf`gfj cr {anw un}bngtn g{
cr mngfj {ii t~lfn}cmln {i d}c~k& [an rnb~}g{w oncr~}nr
nouliwnk mw oir{ mcf`r bcf fntn} mn biouln{nlw rcdn m~{ g{
mnbionr lnrr rnb~}n gd ~rn}r c}n bc}nlnrr i} biou~{n}
gllg{n}c{n& Cf gfb}ncrgfjlw uiu~lc} b}gogfcl u}cb{gbn {i jcgf
cbbnrr {i c ~rn}*r dgfcfbnr gr Uagragfj, zan}nmw {an ~rn} gr gf
rion zcw un}r~cknk {i acfk itn} {ang} ucrrzi}k!r' {i c
d}c~kr{n}&
[cmln 3 }nu}nrnf{r {an jnfn}cl u}imlnor dcbnk mw nlkn} ~rn}rgf ~rgfj mcf`gfj znmrg{n iflgfn& Nlkn} ~rn}r r~jjnr{ 2 ochi}dcb{i}r lg`n rnb~}g{w, rgouln knrgjf id znmrg{n cfk {}cgfgfj gfknbgkgfj {an ~rcmglg{w id mcf`gfj }nlc{nk znmrg{nr&Mcf`gfj i}jcfgxc{gifr bcf bifbnf{}c{n oi}n if {anrn dcb{i}rri cr {i gfb}ncrn {an f~omn} id nlkn}lw iflgfn ~rn}r&Dgj ;}nu}nrnf{r {an {iu u}gi}g{w dcb{i}r r~jjnr{nk mw {ano {infacfbn {an mcf`gfj znmrg{n dnc{~}nr&
[cmln 3& Un}bnf{cjn kgtgrgif id u}imlnor dcbnk mw nlkn} ^rn}r
Rl&Fi U}imlnor dcbnk mw nlkn} ~rn}rUn}bnf{cjn
3 Di}oc{{gfj== .
= Rliz Rn}tn} ]nruifrn {gon=;.
2 Cffiwgfj imhnb{r31 .
; Rnb~}g{w grr~nr== .
> Lcb` id Biou~{n} Czc}nfnrr3; .
Dgj ;& Ochi} dcb{i}r r~jjnr{nk mw nlkn}lw ~rn}r
GGG& KNRGJF OIKNL ID [AN ZNMRG[N
Mcf`r bcf {c`n {an dillizgfj oncr~}nr {i gfb}ncrn {andncrgmglg{w id {an nlkn}lw ~rn}rKnrgjf ^rn} D}gnfklw znmrg{n
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 372
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 209/223
[an mcf` znmrg{n rai~lk mn di}oc{{nk gf c ~rn} d}gnfklw
ocffn}& Biou~{n} hc}jif cfk ocfw {nbafgbcl {n}or ~rnk if
rg{nr {ac{ bifd~rn {an ~rn}r rai~lk mn ctigknk &[an znmrg{n
rai~lk mn knrgjfnk gf c r~ba c zcw {ac{ nlkn} b~r{ion}rrai~lk mn dcoglgc} {i iun}c{n&Tgr~cl Knrgjf di} znmrg{n
Nqun}gnfbnk ilkn} ~rn}r bcf rbcf ucjnr cr znll cr
wi~fjn} ~rn}r, m~{ ilkn} ~rn}r zg{a tgrgif kndgbg{r fnnk {i mn
cbbiooikc{nk zg{a r~g{cmln bif{}cr{ clifj zg{a anckgfjr {i
anlu {ano fc}}iz {ang} tgr~cl rnc}ba Cjnk ~rn}r jnfn}cllw
u}ndn} lc}jn} {nq{&Znmrg{n ~rcmglg{w
^rn}r rai~lk mn cmln {i cbagntn runbgdgnk jiclr zg{a
nddnb{gtnfnrr, nddgbgnfbw cfk rc{grdcb{gif& Jiik biftnf{gifr,
Blnc} knrb}gu{gif id {an ~{glg{gnr cfk bifbgrn bif{nf{ gf {an
znmrg{n rai~lk mn ocgf{cgfnk
Gf{n}cb{gtn Znmucjn
Knrgjf biftnf{gif r~ba cr ~fkn}lgfnk lgf`r rai~lk mn
dilliznk Mcf` Znmrg{nr rai~lk actn oi}n anlu iu{gifr cfk
rai~lk mn oi}n gf{n}cb{gtn zg{a J^G lg`n C[O&
GT& JNFN]CL R[NUR [I MN BIFRGKN]NK MW MCF@R
Mcf`r rai~lk u}itgkn r~jjnr{gifr cfk fnbnrrc}w cktgbnr
if {an goui}{cfbn id rnb~}g{w u}nbc~{gifr {i g{r nlkn}
b~r{ion}r P;_&]~}cl c}nc }nrgknf{ uniuln c}n fi{ czc}n id
iflgfn mcf`gfj cfk i{an} dnc{~}nr id mcf`gfj znm rg{n
P>_&Mcf`r cfk dgfcfbgcl i}jcfgxc{gifr bcf {c`n {an dillizgfj
r{nur {i gfb}ncrn f~omn} id nlkn}lw ~rn}r {i ~rn iflgfn
mcf`gfj& Mcf`r rai~lk nk~bc{n {ang} b~r{ion}r cfk ocfcjn
jnfn}cl bifr~on}r‗ un}bnu{gif id {an }gr`r gf{}cfrcb{gfj if {an gf{n}fn{&
Gf i}kn} {i ocgf{cgf rnb~}g{w cfk u}gtcbw id {annlkn}lw b~r{ion}r, zanf ~rgfj iflgfn mcf`gfj,Mcf`r bcf i}jcfgxn rnogfc} cfk zi}`raiur di}{ano&
Rion Nlkn} b~r{ion}r u}ntnf{ iflgfn mcf`gfj k~n {ilcb` id biou~{n} r`gllr& [anw bcf mn nk~bc{nk ifRion Mcrgb biou~{n} r`gllr fnnknk {i bifk~b{iflgfn mcf`gfj&
Mcf`r rai~lk gfrgr{ if {an biftnfgnfbn {ac{ iflgfnmcf`gfj bcf u}itgkn {i nlkn} uniuln, r~ba cr
ctigkgfj lifj s~n~n, gf i}kn} {i oi{gtc{n {ano {i~rn g{&
Mcf`r bcf clri oi{gtc{n {an nlkn}lw ~rn}r if bir{rctgfj {ac{ iflgfn bcf u}itgkn, r~ba cr }nk~b{gif gf{}cfrcb{gif bir{ mw ~rn id iflgfn mcf`gfj
Mcf`r rai~lk gfb}ncrn czc}nfnrr coifj nlkn}b~r{ion}r mw bifk~b{gfj czc}nfnrr u}ij}cor cfkoc`n {ano dnnl iflgfn mcf`gfj gr clri rnb~}n di}bifk~b{gfj dgfcfbgcl {}cfrcb{gifr lg`n {}ckg{gifclmcf`gfj&
T& BIFBL^RGIF
Mcf`gfj {a}i~ja iflgfn acr c tn}w m}gja{ cfk u}iogrgfj
d~{~}n gf {an nwnr id Nlkn} b~r{ion}r& Gd Mcf`r u}itgkn {ano
zg{a fnbnrrc}w r~uui}{ cfk r~jjnr{gifr, ochi}g{w id {an
nlkn}lw b~r{ion}r zgll {}w {i nqun}gnfbn iflgfn mcf`gfj&
Nlkn} b~r{ion}r actn r{}ifj bifdgknfbn gf {ang} mcf`r m~{
{ang} bifdgknfbn lntnl gf {an {nbafilijw gr c{ liz lntnl&
Mcf`r rai~lk gfb}ncrn {an lntnl id czc}nfnrr [anw c}n }nckw
{i ckiu{ iflgfn mcf`gfj gd mcf`r bcf {c`n fnbnrrc}w cb{gifr&
Mcrnk if {an r~jjnr{gifr d}io {an nlkn}lw ~rn}r, mcf`r bcfoikgdw {an knrgjf uc{{n}f cfk ~rn} gf{n}dcbn id {an znmrg{n&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_ BN][/gf Oif{alw Rnb~}g{w M~lln{gf, Gfkgcf Biou~{n} Non}jnfbw]nruifrn {nco, Knuc}{onf{ id Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw, Ogfgr{}w id Bioo~fgbc{gifr cfk Gfdi}oc{gif [nbafilijw
P=_ Uiihc oclai{}c, Mclzgfkn} rgfja, “[an Goucb{ id Gf{n}fn{ Mcf`gfj ifMcf` Un}di}ocfbn cfk ]gr`8 [an Gfkgcf Nqun}gnfbn‟, N~}crgcfHi~}fcl id M~rgfnrr cfk Nbifiogbr =557, = !;', uu ;2/4=&
P2_ Fnac Kgqg{, K}& Rc}ih @& Kc{{c “Cbbnu{cfbn id N/mcf`gfj coifjCk~l{ B~r{ion}r8 Cf Noug}gbcl Gftnr{gjc{gif gf Gfkgc‟ Hi~}fcl id Gf{n}fn{ Mcf`gfj cfk Bioon}bn, C~j~r{ =535, til& 3>, uu&=&
P;_ Cfk}nc Rbacnba{n}, “Grr~nr gf Nlnb{}ifgb Mcf`gfj8 Cf itn}tgnz‟,
GOD Uilgbw Kgrb~rrgif Ucun}, Gf{n}fc{gifcl Oifn{c}w D~fk =55=&
P>_ Hgcsgf Wcfj, Og`n Zag{ndgnlk cfk @c{hc Minaon * Fnz grr~nr cfkbacllnfjnr dcbgfj n/mcf`gfj gf }~}cl c}ncr8 cf noug}gbcl r{~kw* Gf{& H&Nlnb{}ifgb Dgfcfbn, Til& 3, Fi& 2, =55: uu& 224 / 2>;
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 37;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 210/223
Rnocf{gb Znm [nbafgs~n Cuulw N/O~rn~o Kiocgf ^rgfj {an U}i{çjç [iil di}If{ilijw Mcrnk Rnocf{gb Rnc}ba
@&Uclcfgcoocl,]nrnc}ba Rbailc}, G[ Knuc}{onf{ ,
[agcjc}chc} Billnjn id Nfjgfnn}gfj,
Ock~}cg/4=>53>, [coglfck~, Gfkgc&
Cmr{}cb{ 8 [an Rnocf{gb Znm gr cf nq{nfrgif id {an b~}}nf{znm gf zagba }nlntcf{ gfdi}oc{gif gr jgtnf {i {an }ns~g}nkuniuln mw {c`gfj gf{i cbbi~f{ {an oncfgfj id {an zi}kr&
[agr ucun} u}nrnf{r rnocf{gb znm {nbafgs~n cuulw N/o~rn~o kiocgf ~rgfj {an U}i{çjç {iil di} if{ilijw mcrnk
gfdi}oc{gif }n{}gntcl& G{ gftiltnr QOL, ]KD cfk If{ilijwzagln rnc}bagfj {an gfdi}oc{gif& [an if{ilijw gr mngfjb}nc{nk zg{a U}i{çjç zagba gr {an {iil ~rnk cr cf if{ilijw
nkg{i}& ]nr~l{r raiz {ac{ oi}n }nlntcf{ gfdi}oc{gif gr}n{}gntnk ~rgfj {an u}iuirnk cuu}icba&
@nwzi}kr8 If{ilijw, ]KD, Rnocf{gb Znm, Gfdi}oc{gif
]n{}gntcl, N/o~rn~o, U}i{çjç [iil&
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF Oir{ id {an rnc}ba nfjgfnr rnc}ba di} `nwzi}kr {i
cfrzn} {an s~n}gnr d}io ~rn}r& [an rnc}ba nfjgfnr
~r~cllw rnc}ba znm ucjnr di} {an }ns~g}nk gfdi}oc{gif&
Aizntn} {anw dgl{n} {an ucjnr d}io rnc}bagfj
~ffnbnrrc}w ucjnr mw ~rgfj cktcfbnk clji}g{aor& [anrn
rnc}ba nfjgfnr bcf cfrzn} {iugb zgrn s~n}gnr nddgbgnf{lw
cfk nddnb{gtnlw mw kntnliugfj r{c{n/id c}{ clji}g{aor&
Aizntn} {anw c}n t~lfn}cmln gf cfrzn}gfj gf{nllgjnf{
s~n}gnr d}io {an ~rn} k~n {i {an knunfknfbn id {ang}
}nr~l{r if gfdi}oc{gif ctcglcmln gf znm ucjnr& [an ocgf
dib~r id {anrn rnc}ba nfjgfnr gr riltgfj {anrn s~n}gnrzg{a blirn {i cbb~}c{n }nr~l{r gf rocll {gon ~rgfj o~ba
}nrnc}bank clji}g{aor& Aizntn}, g{ raizr {ac{ r~ba
rnc}ba nfjgfnr c}n t~lfn}cmln gf cfrzn}gfj gf{nllgjnf{
s~n}gnr ~rgfj {agr cuu}icba& [anw ng{an} raiz gfcbb~}c{n
}nr~l{r zg{a {agr cuu}icba i} raiz cbb~}c{n m~{ !bi~lk
mn' ~f}nlgcmln }nr~l{r zg{a {an `nwzi}kr mcrnk rnc}banr{anw ~r~cllw u}itgkn }nr~l{r d}io mlijr !gd ctcglcmln' i}
i{an} kgrb~rrgif mic}kr& [an ~rn} bcffi{ actn c
rc{grdcb{gif zg{a {anrn }nr~l{r k~n {i lcb` id {}~r{r if
mlijr n{b& [i jn{ {an {}~r{nk }nr~l{r rnc}ba nfjgfnr
}ns~g}n rnc}bagfj di} ucjnr {ac{ ocgf{cgf r~ba
gfdi}oc{gif c{ rion ulcbn& [agr }ns~g}nr gfbl~kgfj
kiocgf `fizlnkjn gf {an znm ucjnr {i anlu rnc}banfjgfnr gf cfrzn}gfj gf{nllgjnf{ s~n}gnr& [an lcwn}nk
oiknl id Rnocf{gb Znm u}itgknr ril~{gif {i {agr
u}imlno mw u}itgkgfj {iilr cfk {nbafilijgnr {i nfcmln
ocbagfn }nckcmln rnocf{gbr gf b~}}nf{ znm bif{nf{r&
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u,
Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/4 88 kig8 35&
:257>)GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :257>
Znm rnc}ba gr c `nw {nbafilijw id {an Znm, zagba gr
nrrnf{gcllw mcrnk if c biomgfc{gif id {nq{~cl `nwzi}k
rnc}ba zg{a cf goui}{cfbn }cf`gfj id {an kib~onf{r
knunfkgfj if {an lgf` r{}~b{~}n id {an Znm& Di} {agr
}ncrif, g{ acr ocfw lgog{c{gifr, cfk {an}n c}n c uln{ai}c
id }nrnc}ba cb{gtg{gnr {izc}kr oi}n gf{nllgjnf{ Znm
rnc}ba, bcllnk rnocf{gb rnc}ba if {an Znm, i} clri
Rnocf{gb Znm rnc}ba, zagba gr b~}}nf{lw ifn id {an
ai{{nr{ }nrnc}ba {iugbr gf mi{a {an Rnocf{gb Znm cfk
Znm rnc}ba !rnn P1_ cfk P:_, }nrunb{gtnlw'&
[an rnocf{gb znm gr c oncfgfjd~l znm& G{ gr c onra
id gfdi}oc{gif lgf`nk ~u gf r~ba c zcw cr {i mn ncrglwu}ibnrrcmln mw ocbagfnr, if c jlimcl rbcln P=_& [an
rnocf{gb znm mcb`mifn {nbafilijw gr if{ilijw&
If{ilijw gr cmi~{ {an nqcb{ knrb}gu{gif id {agfjr cfk
{ang} }nlc{gifragur& Di} {an znm, if{ilijw gr cmi~{ {an
nqcb{ knrb}gu{gif id znm gfdi}oc{gif cfk {an }nlc{gifragu
mn{znnf znm gfdi}oc{gif P3_ P2_& [an rnocf{gb znm grmcrnk if c lcfj~cjn r~ba cr QOL, ]KD, IZL cfk {iil
{ac{ oc`n ~rn id {anrn lcfj~cjnr& [an rnocf{gb znm gr
jnfn}cllw m~gl{ if rwf{cqnr zagba ~rn ^]Gr {i }nu}nrnf{
kc{c, ~r~cllw gf {}gulnr !r~mhnb{, u}nkgbc{n, cfk imhnb{'
mcrnk r{}~b{~}nr8 g&n& ocfw {}gulnr id ^]G kc{c {ac{ bcf mn
anlk gf kc{cmcrn i} gf{n}bacfjnk if {an Zi}lk Zgkn Znm
~rgfj c rn{ id uc}{gb~lc} rwf{cqnr kntnliunk nrunbgcllw
di} {an {cr`& [anrn rwf{cqnr c}n bcllnk “]nri~}bn
Knrb}gu{gif D}conzi}`‟ rwf{cqnr&
Gf {agr ucun}, zn u}iuirn {an rnocf{gb znm mcrnk
rnc}ba nfjgfn di} o~rn~o kiocgf zg{a cffi{c{gifr
b}nc{nk di} ntn}w billnb{gifr& Zn cuulw {an uizn} id
QOL on{c/{cjr knuliwnk if {an znm ucjn {i rnc}ba {an
s~n}gnk gfdi}oc{gif& [an QOL ucjn zgll mn bifrgr{nk id
m~gl{/gf cfk ~rn} kndgfnk {cjr& [an on{ckc{c gfdi}oc{gif
gr nq{}cb{nk d}io {agr QOL gf{i ]KD& [an ]KD {}gulnr
c}n uiu~lc{nk mw gfu~{{gfj {a}i~ja QDi}or P34_& [anrn
{cjr zgll anlu {an rwr{no gf jn{{gfj cfrzn} d}io }nlgcmln
ri~}bnr& Gf {agr zi}` zn dib~rnk if {an o~rn~o
kiocgf& RSL gr ~rnk di} }n{}gntgfj }nr~l{r di} i~} rcoulns~n}gnr& Rnocf{gb gf{n}iun}cmglg{w gr cbagntnk mw ~rgfj
if{ilijgnr zagln {an ~rn id QOL)]KD nfr~}nr ocbagfn
~fkn}r{cfkcmglg{w&
[an goulnonf{c{gif id {an rnocf{gb znm knunfkr if
{nbafilijgnr r~ba cr QOL, ]KD, cfk IF[ILIJW
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 37>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 211/223
zagba c}n cll Z2B }nbioonfkc{gifr& Gf {agr ucun} zn
knrb}gmnk gf {an fnq{ rnb{gif lg{n}c{~}n r~}tnw, rnb{gif 2
u}nrnf{r zac{ gr o~rn~o, o~rn~or cfk {an rnocf{gb
znm, rnb{gif ; u}nrnf{r goulnonf{c{gifr, rnb{gif > di}
bifbl~rgifr cfk dgfcllw raizr }ndn}nfbnr&
GG& LG[N]C[^]N R^]TNW[an RB^LU[N^] P3;_ u}ihnb{ gr cf if{ilijgbcl
mcrnk ril~{gif di} fctgjc{gfj, rnc}bagfj cfk }n{}gntgfj
kgjg{cl b~l{~}cl an}g{cjn gfdi}oc{gif d}io o~l{guln
kgr{}gm~{nk kgjg{cl o~rn~or& [an fc{~}n id {an zi}` d}io
{agr tgnz uigf{ gr jlimcl if{ilijw mcrnk rnocf{gb
gf{nj}c{gif di} o~l{guln an{n}ijnfni~r kc{cmcrnr P3>_&
Ac`gc P35_ gr c jnfn}cl u~}uirn rnocf{gb rnc}ba
nfjgfn {ac{ rnc}ba r{}~b{~}nk {nq{ lg`n Zg`gunkgc& Ac`gc
bcllr g{rnld c “oncfgfj/mcrnk !rnocf{gb' rnc}ba nfjgfn‟
P33_& [anw‗}n {}wgfj {i u}itgkn rnc}ba }nr~l{r mcrnk if
oncfgfj oc{ba, }c{an} {acf mw {an uiu~lc}g{w id rnc}ba
{n}or& [an u}nrnf{nk fnzr, Mlijr, B}nkgmln, cfk jclln}gnr
c}n u}ibnrrnk mw ac`gc*r u}iu}gn{c}w bi}n rnocf{gb{nbafilijw bcllnk SKNQgfj P35_& G{ bcf u}ibnrr cfw `gfk
id kgjg{cl c}{ndcb{ mw g{r Rnocf{gb]cf` {nbafilijw ~rgfj
{ag}k uc}{w CUG dnnkr P3=_& C rgfjln s~n}w mw {an ~rn}
m}gfjr }nr~l{r d}io cfw }nuirg{i}w gfbl~kgfj Znm, Fnzr,
Mlijr, Tgkni, Gocjnr, Ac`gc Jclln}gnr cfk clri d}io
B}nkgmln Ri~}bnr P3=_& Di} rai}{ s~n}gnr {an rg{n kgrulcwr
}nr~l{r gf bc{nji}gnr, gfr{nck id c r{cfkc}k lgr{ cr raizf
gf b~}}nf{ rnc}ba nfjgfnr& Di} lifjn} s~n}gnr, Ac`gcagjalgja{r }nlntcf{ ua}crnr i} rnf{nfbnr& [an }nr~l{r c}n
rionaiz }nlntcf{ cfk }nlgcmln m~{ Ac`gc kinr fi{ }ntncl
g{‗r gfrgkn {nbafilijw& Ac`gc {c`n {an rnc}bank s~n}w cfk
dgfk {an }nr~l{r gf ocfw bc{nji}gnr di} nqcouln d}io
jclln}gnr, tgknir n{b& ri g{ {ii` oi}n {gon {acf {an ~r~clrnc}ba nfjgfnr gf {an }n{}gntcl id }nr~l{r P35_&
KnnuKwtn P32_ gr c uizn}d~l, u}idnrrgifcl }nrnc}ba
nfjgfn {ac{ ln{r ~rn}‗r cbbnrr nqun}{ bif{nf{ d}io {an
“Knnu Znm‟ {an uc}{ id {an gf{n}fn{ {ac{ gr fi{ gfknqnk
mw {}ckg{gifcl rnc}ba nfjgfnr& G{ gfknqnr ntn}w zi}k gf c
kib~onf{, m~{ clri biou~{nr {an dcb{i}gcl biomgfc{gif id
zi}kr cfk ua}crnr gf {an kib~onf{ cfk ~rnr rion
gfk~r{}gcl r{}nfj{a r{c{gr{gbcl {nbafgs~nr {i crrnrr {an
“gfdi}oc{gifcl goucb{‟ id {anrn biomgfc{gifr P33_& [an
u}nrnf{c{gif id rnc}ba }nr~l{r gr tn}w bioulnq& G{ u}nrnf{r
{an ~rn}r zg{a ocfw cktcfbnk iu{gifr di} }ndgfgfj,
ri}{gfj i} rctgfj {an rnc}ba& [an rnc}ba }nr~l{r c}n
aizntn} }nlc{gtnlw ncrw {i fctgjc{n& [an }nr~l{ru}nrnf{nk c}n iflw di} {an ucgk b~r{ion}r, {anw c}n fi{
ctcglcmln di} {an jnfn}cl u~mlgb&
GGG& O^RN^OR CFK [AN RNOCF[GB ZNM
C& O~rn~o
C o~rn~o gr c fif/u}idg{ oc`gfj, un}ocfnf{
gfr{g{~{gif gf {an rn}tgbn id ribgn{w cfk id g{r
kntnliuonf{, cfk iunf {i {an u~mlgb, zagba cbs~g}nr,
bifrn}tnr, }nrnc}banr, bioo~fgbc{nr cfk nqagmg{r, di}
u~}uirnr id r{~kw, nk~bc{gif cfk nfhiwonf{, oc{n}gcl
ntgknfbn id uniuln cfk {ang} nftg}ifonf{&
C runbgcl bac}cb{n}gr{gb id b~l{~}cl billnb{gif bif{nf{r
gr rnocf{gb }gbafnrr& Billnb{gif G{nor actn c agr{i}w cfkc}n }nlc{nk gf ocfw zcwr {i i~} nftg}ifonf{, {i {an
ribgn{w, cfk {i i{an} billnb{gif g{nor ;_& [agr rnocf{gb
fn{zi}` gr fi{ lgog{nk {i c rgfjln billnb{gif, m~{ rucfr
itn} i{an} }nlc{nk billnb{gifr gf i{an} o~rn~or& [an
fn{zi}` id rnocf{gb crribgc{gifr bcf mn nq{nfknk {i
bif{nf{r id i{an} {wunr gf i{an} i}jcfgxc{gif, cr znll&
O~ba id {an rnocf{gb znm bif{nf{ zgll mn
u~mlgrank ~rgfj rnocf{gb ui}{clr& R~ba ui}{clr{wugbcllw u}itgkn {an nfk/~rn} zg{a {zi mcrgb
rn}tgbnr8 c rnc}ba nfjgfn mcrnk if {an rnocf{gbr id
{an bif{nf{ cfk kwfcogb lgf`gfj mn{znnf ucjnr
mcrnk if {an rnocf{gb }nlc{gifr gf {an ~fkn}lwgfj
`fizlnkjn mcrn& Rnocf{gb znm {nbafilijw nfcmlnr
fnz uirrgmglg{gnr zanf znm rnc}bagfj o~rn~obillnb{gifr if {an rnocf{gb znm
M& ^rgfj rnocf{gb znm {nbafilijgnr di} N/
O~rn~or
O~rn~or uirrnrr lc}jn coi~f{r id kgjg{gxnk kc{c cfk
On{c kc{c gf {ang} billnb{gif kc{cmcrn& C runbgcl
bac}cb{n}gr{gb id b~l{~}cl billnb{gif bif{nf{r grrnocf{gbcllw }gbafnrr zg{a cf gf{n}biffnb{nk fc{~}n&
Billnb{gif g{nor actn c agr{i}w cfk c}n }nlc{nk gf ocfw
zcwr {i i~} nftg}ifonf{, {i {an ribgn{w, cfk {i i{an}
billnb{gif g{nor& Rnocf{gb znm On{c kc{c cfk if{ilijw
r{cfkc}kr cfk {iilr, r~ba cr ]KD cfk ]KD rbanoc bcf
mn ~rnk di} ocfcjgfj tn}rc{glg{w id bifbnu{r cfk
crribgc{gif gf c fitnl zcw cfk di} oc`gfj g{ nqulgbg{ di}
{an o~rn~o tgrg{i}r cfk }nrnc}ban}r P4_& [an znm oc`nr
g{ uirrgmln {i bifrilgkc{nk kc{c d}io kgr{}gm~{nk
an{n}ijnfni~r billnb{gif cfk u~mlgranr g{ di} cfwmikw
zai acr cf Gf{n}fn{ cbbnrr&
[i }nclgxn {anrn gkncr, zn actn kntnliunk c
knoifr{}c{gifcl u}i{i{wun id c rnocf{gb znm ui}{clbcllnk “Cffi{c{gif di} O~rn~o billnb{gifr‟& [agr rwr{no
bif{cgfr billnb{gif id b~l{~}cl cfk c}{gdcb{r& [an u}ihnb{
acr fgfn oik~lnr cr dillizgfj
C}bacnilijw
C}{
Cf{a}iuilijw
F~ogroc{gbr
Mi{cfw
Jnilijw
Xiilijw
Banogbcl bifrn}tc{gif
Baglk}nf‗r O~rn~or[an billnb{gifr gfbl~kn ocfw oi}n r~m bif{nf{r& [an
bif{nf{r bion d}io {an billnb{gif id {an Fc{gifcl
O~rn~o, [cfhi}n O~rn~o, Banffcg O~rn~o, Ock~}cg
o~rn~o n{b&&&
B& Imhnb{gtnr
[an ocgf jiclr id kntnliugfj {an rwr{no c}n {an
dillizgfj
Jlimcl tgnz {i kgr{}gm~{nk billnb{gifr
G{ gr uirrgmln {i ~rn {an an{n}ijnfni~r kgr{}gm~{nk
billnb{gifr id {an o~rn~or uc}{gbguc{gfj gf {an rwr{no cr
gd {an billnb{gifr zn}n gf c rgfjln ~fgdi}o }nuirg{i}w&
O~rn~or gfdi}oc{gif }n{}gntcl
[an rwr{no r~uui}{r gf{nllgjnf{ gfdi}oc{gif }n{}gntclmcrnk if if{ilijgbcl bifbnu{r, fi{ if rgouln `nwzi}k
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 374
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 212/223
r{}gfj oc{bagfj cr gr b~r{ioc}w zg{a b~}}nf{ rnc}ba
nfjgfnr P7_&
Rnocf{gbcllw gf{n}iun}cmglg{w
C oir{ gf{n}nr{gfj crunb{ id {an billnb{gif g{nor {i
{an nfk/~rn} gr {an goulgbg{ rnocf{gb }nlc{gifr {ac{ }nlc{n
billnb{gif kc{c zg{a {ang} bif{nq{ cfk {i ncba i{an}& Gf
o~rn~o billnb{gifr, r~ba crribgc{gifr c}n nquirnkkwfcogbcllw {i {an nfk/~rn} mw kndgfgfj {ano gf {n}or id lijgbcl u}nkgbc{n }~lnr {ac{ oc`n ~rn id {an ~fkn}lwgfj
if{ilijgnr cfk billnb{gif on{ckc{c&
Ncrw libcl bif{nf{ u~mlgbc{gif
[an ui}{cl rai~lk u}itgkn {an o~rn~or zg{a c
bir{/nddnb{gtn u~mlgbc{gif bacffnl& [an r~bbnrr id {an
zzz gr {an ncrw id bif{nf{ u~mlgbc{gif&
GT& GOULNONF[C[GIFR
C& If{ilijw di} Kib~onf{ {wun cfk Bif{nf{r8
If{ilijw biou}grnr {an tibcm~lc}w& G{ gr ockn ~u id
{zi uc}{r fconlw, kib~onf{ cfk kib~onf{ {wun&
Kib~onf{ gr b}nc{nk di} O~rn~o billnb{gifr cfkkib~onf{ {wun bifrgr{r id bif{nf{r di} g{& If{ilijw gr
b}nc{nk di} ]KD& ]KD acr dgtn dgnlkr fconlw, blcrr,
r~mblcrr, u}iun}{gnr, kiocgf cfk }cfjn&
Blcrr8 Blcrrnr c}n cmr{}cb{ j}i~ur, rn{r, i} billnb{gifr
id imhnb{r& G{ ocw bif{cgf gfkgtgk~clr, i{an} blcrrnr, i} c
biomgfc{gif id mi{a&
]nlc{gifragur !r~mblcrr'8 Cf goui}{cf{ ~rn id
c{{}gm~{nr gr {i knrb}gmn {an }nlc{gifragur !clri `fizf cr}nlc{gifr' mn{znnf imhnb{r gf {an if{ilijw& [wugbcllw c
}nlc{gif gr cf c{{}gm~{n zairn tcl~n gr cfi{an} imhnb{ gf
{an if{ilijw&
C{{}gm~{nr8 Imhnb{r gf {an if{ilijw bcf mn knrb}gmnk
mw crrgjfgfj c{{}gm~{nr {i {ano& Ncba c{{}gm~{n acr c{ lncr{c fcon cfk c tcl~n, cfk gr ~rnk {i r{i}n gfdi}oc{gif {ac{
gr runbgdgb {i {an imhnb{ g{ gr c{{cbank {i& Gf {agr kib~onf{,
O~rn~o billnb{gif gr goulnonf{nk& [an ~rn} bcf tgnz
{an bifbnu{r d}io bif{nf{r cfk clri d}io {an u}iun}{gnr
id bif{nf{r cr c kcw/{i/kcw u}ibnrr {a}i~ja {agr o~rn~o
billnb{gif& [agr u}iun}{w bif{cgfr {an C}bacnilijw, C}{,
Cf{a}iuilijw, F~ogroc{gbr, Xiilijw, Jnilijw,
Baglk}nf‗r o~rn~or, Banogbcl bifrn}tc{gif, cfk
Mi{cfw& [an ~rn} bcf tgnz oi}n, ~rgfj {an u}iun}{gnr id
lgf`r gf {an di}o id r{nu/mw/r{nu u}ibnrr {a}i~ja {anrn
o~rn~o billnb{gifr& [an ~rn} bcf ~ukc{n cfw }nlc{nk
bifbnu{r c{ cfw{gon ~rgfj {an u}iun}{gnr id lgf`r&
M& M~glkgfj If{ilijwIf{ilijgnr c}n {an bi}n {nbafilijw di} {an
Rnocf{gb Znm& If{ilijw kndgfnr {an {n}or ~rnk {iu}nrnf{ c kiocgf id `fizlnkjn {ac{ gr rac}nk mw uniuln,
kc{cmcrnr, cfk cuulgbc{gifr& [an Rnocf{gb Znm {a~r
u}itgknr nqulgbg{ oncfgfj {i {an gfdi}oc{gif cfk rn}tgbnr
ctcglcmln if {an Znm di} c~{ioc{nk u}ibnrrgfj cfk
gfdi}oc{gif gf{nj}c{gif mcrnk if {an ~fkn}lwgfj
if{ilijw& If{ilijw gr cf nqulgbg{ cfk di}ocl
runbgdgbc{gif id c bifbnu{~clgxc{gif& [an If{ilijgnr c}n
~rnd~l di} gou}itgfj {an cbb~}cbw id Znm rnc}banr&[a~r
rnc}ba nfjgfnr bcf lii` di} ucjnr {ac{ }ndn} {i c u}nbgrn
bifbnu{ gf if{ilijw& Znm rnc}banr bcf nqulig{
jnfn}clgxc{gif) runbgclgxc{gif gfdi}oc{gif &[a~r, gd cs~n}w dcglr {i dgfk cfw }nlntcf{ kib~onf{r, {an rnc}ba
nfjgfn ocw r~jjnr{ {i {an ~rn} c oi}n jnfn}cl s~n}w cfk
gd {ii ocfw cfrzn}r c}n }n{}gntnk, {an rnc}ba nfjgfn ocw
r~jjnr{ {i {an ~rn} rion runbgclgxc{gifr& O~rn~o
if{ilijw gr kntnliunk {i rac}n biooif ~fkn}r{cfkgfj id
{an r{}~b{~}n id knrb}gu{gtn gfdi}oc{gif coifj uniuln,
coifj rid{zc}n cjnf{r cfk mn{znnf uniuln cfk rid{zc}n
cfk {i nfcmln }n~rn id kiocgf `fizlnkjn zagba ctigkr“}n/gftnf{gfj {an zannl‟ cfk {i gf{}ik~bn r{cfkc}kr {i
clliz gf{n}iun}cmglg{w& [an }ncrifr di} b}nc{gfj cf
if{ilijw gr {i oc`n kiocgf crr~ou{gifr nqulgbg{ g&n&,
ncrgn} {i bacfjn kiocgf crr~ou{gifr cfk ncrgn} {i
~fkn}r{cfk cfk ~ukc{n lnjcbw kc{c cfk {i rnuc}c{n
kiocgf `fizlnkjn d}io {an iun}c{gifcl `fizlnkjn&Gf {agr ucun} ~rn c f~omn} id r{cfkc}k oc}`~u
lcfj~cjnr, r~ba cr ]KD, {i di}ocllw oiknl gfdi}oc{gif
}nu}nrnf{nk gf znm }nri~}bnr& [an Rnocf{gb Znm gr c
znm id ocbagfn u}ibnrrcmln oncfgfjr ~fkn}ugffnk mw
rac}nk cfk di}ocllw kndgfnk if{ilijgnr& Gf i}kn} {i
bii}kgfc{n kgddn}nf{ rnocf{gb znm cb{gtg{gnr, o~rn~o
if{ilijw gr nqulgbg{lw kndgfnk {i rac}n c bif{nq{~clbifbnu{~clgxc{gif id {an o~rn~o kiocgf& [agr cllizr
{an ~rn}r {i oc`n {ang} }nri~}bnr oi}n ocbagfnr
u}ibnrrcmln mw billcmi}c{gtnlw bifr{}~b{gfj cf nf}gbank
lcwn} id {an rnocf{gb znm {ac{ lgf`r o~rn~o c}{gdcb{r
zg{a di}ocl rnocf{gbr {i r~uui}{ i{an} rnocf{gb
cb{gtg{gnr r~ba cr rnocf{gb s~n}w, cjj}njc{gif cfk
gfdi}oc{gif }n{}gntcl&
Dgj& 3 IZL Blcrrnr [an Dgj& 3 raizr {an if{ilijw di} o~rn~o rn}tgbnr&
[an If{ilijw gr b}nc{nk mw actgfj {an }ii{ fikn cr
“{agfj‟ {anf dillizr {an tc}gi~r bc{nji}gnr lg`nC}bacnilijw, C}{, Cf{a}iuilijw, F~ogroc{gbr, Mi{cfw,
Jnilijw, Xiilijw, banogbcl bifrn}tc{gif, cfk baglk}nf‗r
o~rn~o& Ncba r~m bc{nji}w acr ocfw i{an} fiknr
}nlc{nk {i g{& G{ bifrgr{gfj IZL blcrrnr, }nlc{gifragur id
IZL blcrrnr cfk gfkgtgk~clr di} o~rn~o if{ilijw& [an
o~rn~o if{ilijw gr b}nc{nk ~rgfj u}i{çjç 2&;&:& B& If{ilijw di} Tc}gi~r Oik~lnr Crribgc{nk Zg{a
Bif{nf{r
[an bif{nf{ zcr cffi{c{nk ~rgfj ]KD cfk
}ndn}nfbn {i tc}gi~r if{ilijgnr& [an kc{crn{ gr on{ckc{c
id itn} 25555 billnb{gifr id imhnb{r, n&j& C}bacnilijw,
C}{, Cf{a}iuilijw, F~ogroc{gbr, Mi{cfw, Jnilijw,
Xiilijw, banogbcl bifrn}tc{gif, cfk baglk}nf‗r o~rn~ogf ]KD {}gulnr di}oc{ }nr~l{r cr mnliz&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 37:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 213/223
Dgj&3 Rnocf{gb znm rnc}ba nfjgfnr
Dgj&= ]KD [}gulnr di} o~rn~or billnb{gifr
K& J}cua id {an Kc{c Oiknl
An}n {an kc{c oiknl di} aion ucjn cfk
f~ogroc{gbr c}n b}nc{nk& [an lcfj~cjn ~rnk di} b}nc{gfj
kc{c oiknl gr QOL cfk ]KD&
Dgj&2 Kc{c Oiknl
;&> D}conzi}` di} {an rnocf{gb znm o~rn~or
]KD bcf mn ~rnk cr c jnfn}cl d}conzi}` di} kc{c
nqbacfjn if {an znm& [an ]KD kc{c oiknl kgr{gfj~granr
mn{znnf }nri~}bnr, zagba c}n imhnb{ gknf{gdgn}r}nu}nrnf{nk mw ^]Gr, cfk lg{n}clr, zagba c}n h~r{ r{}gfjr&
[an r~mhnb{ cfk {an u}nkgbc{n id c r{c{nonf{ c}n clzcwr
}nri~}bnr, zagln {an imhnb{ bcf mn c }nri~}bn i} c lg{n}cl&
Gf ]KD }nr~l{r, }nri~}bnr c}n clzcwr k}czf cr itclr, cfk
lg{n}clr c}n k}czf cr miqnr&
Dgj&; Gocjn Cffi{c{gifr ]KD zcr ~rnk gf cffi{c{gfj agr{i}gbcl b~l{~}cl bif{nf{r&
T& BIFBL^RGIFRGf {agr ucun} u}nrnf{nk {an knrgjf cfk goulnonf{c{gif
id rnocf{gb znm {nbafgs~n {i gou}itn znm rnc}ba gf
o~rn~o billnb{gifr& Rnocf{gb Znm rnc}ba nfjgfn zcr
b}nc{nk, If{ilijw cfk ]KD zn}n kntnliunk& [agr zi}`
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 371
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 214/223
u}nrnf{nk {an fi{gif id rnocf{gb i}gjgfcl on{c/kc{c
oiknl cllizgfj if{ilijw mcrnk fconk/nf{g{w, gfknqgfj,
cfk }n{}gntcl& F~omn} id grr~nr }nlc{nk {i {an
}nu}nrnf{c{gif cfk {an ~rcjn id {an rnocf{gb cffi{c{gif
zn}n ckk}nrrnk& [an dgnlkr kgrb~rrnk gfbl~kn {an
rnocf{gb znm, gfdi}oc{gif nq{}cb{gif, n/o~rn~or,
if{ilijw }nlc{nk {iugbr, bifbnu{~cl oiknlgfj, ]KDd}conzi}` oiknlgfj cfk znm rn}tgbnr& [an rwr{no ocwclri nq{nfk {i r~uui}{ i{an} kiocgfr lg`n nk~bc{gif,
{i~}gro, cfk cfw gfdi}oc{gif }n{}gntcl rwr{no
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_& U~mlgragfj cfk ^rgfj If{ilijgnr cr Ocra/^u Rn}tgbnr8 @goTglhcfnf, Hi~fg [~iogfnf, cfk Nn}i Awt ifnf Rnocf{gb
Biou~{gfj ]nrnc}ba J}i~u !RnBi' Anlrgf`g ^fgtn}rg{w id
[nbafilijw cfk ^fgtn}rg{w id Anlrgf`g&
P=_& Gf{}ik~b{gif {i Rnocf{gb Znm [nbafilijgnr Gtcf An}ocf,
=535 Rnocf{gb [nbafilijw Bifdn}nfbn gf Rcf D}cfbgrbi,
BC, ^RC&
P2_& `fizlnkjn }nu}nrnf{c{gif zg{a if{ilijw8 B&m}nzr{n}, {an
u}nrnf{ cfk d~{~}n, gf{nllgjnf{ rwr{nor , GNNN til37!3'/=55;
P;_& Un}rifclgxnk Bif{nq{/czc}n }nbioonfkc{gifr gf
ROC][O^RN^O8 biomgfgfj Rnocf{gbr zg{a
R{c{gr{gbr&Gffc} Lggt, [cfnl [coon{, [~~``c ]~i{rcli cfk
Clc} @~~rg`8 U}ibnnkgfjr id {an [an [ag}k Gf{n}fc{gifcl
Bifdn}nfbn if Cktcfbnr gf Rnocf{gb U}ibnrrgfj
!RNOCU]I =557', GNNN Biou~{n} Ribgn{w, Ib{imn}, =557
P>_& O~rn~oDgflcfk / Dgffgra O~rn~or if {an Rnocf{gb Znm&
Nn}i Awtôfnf, Nn{~ Oë`nlë, Og}tc Rclogfnf, C}{{~ Tcli,
@go Tglhcfnf,8 Hi~}fcl id Znm Rnocf{gbr, til& 2, fi& =, uu&
=>, =55>&
P4_& ROC][O^RN^O @fizlnkjn Nqbacfjn ulc{di}o di}
B}irr/N~}iuncf B~l{~}cl Bif{nf{ Gf{nj}c{gif cfk Oimgln
U~mlgbc{gif8 {iog `c~uugfnf n{ cl/=557&
P:_& [an kczf id rnocf{gb rnc}ba& Biou~{n}, H& Anfkln}& Znm
2&58 ;2!3'8::‒15, =535&
P1_& Fnq{ jnfn}c{gif Znm rnc}ba&
]& C& Mcnxc/Wc{nr cfk U& ]cjactcf& Gf R& Bn}g cfk O&
M}comgllc, nkg{i}r, Rnc}ba Biou~{gfj, LFBR >7>5, uu& 33‒=2& Ru}gfjn}, =535
P7_& Gf{nllgjnf{ Rnocf{gb Znm Rnc}ba Nfjgfnr8 Gf{n}fc{gifcl
hi~}fcl id Znm $ Rnocf{gb [nbafilijw !GHZnr[' Til&=,
Fi&3, Hcf~c}w =533 KIG8 35&>3=3)ghznr{&=533&=352 2; C
M}gnd R~}tnw J&Ocka~3 cfk K}&C&Jitc}kacf=
K}&[&T&]chgfg`cf{a2
P35_& Cf Noug}gbcl Ntcl~c{gif if Rnocf{gb Rnc}ba
Un}di}ocfbn id @nwzi}k/Mcrnk cfk Rnocf{gb Rnc}ba
Nfjgfnr8K& [üon}, O& C& Raca, cfk W& Mg{g}go, Jiijln,
Wcaii, Orf cfk Ac`gc, =557 ;{a Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn
if Gf{n}fn{ Oifg{i}gfj cfk U}i{nb{gif !GBGOU ‗57' =557&
P33_& -[iu > Rnocf{gb Rnc}ba
Nfjgfnr-&a{{u8))zzz&ucfkgc&bio)
P3=_& JiZnm8 c rnocf{gb rnc}ba nfjgfn di} {an lgdn rbgnfbn
znm& MOB mgigfdi}oc{gbr,A& Kgn{xn cfk O& Rba}inkn}, Til&
35, Fi& R~uul 35, uu& R:, =557&
P32_& -KnnuKwtn8 [an lc}jnr{ iflgfn }nf{cl rn}tgbn di}
rbgnf{gdgb, {nbafgbcl cfk onkgbcl }nrnc}ba
a{{u8))zzz&knnukwtn&bio)
P3;_& Fnz zcw {i rnc}ba, fctgjc{n cfk ~rn o~l{gonkgc
o~rn~o billnb{gifr itn} {an znm, o~rn~or cfk {an znm,
Bcfckc/=55>& Oc{anz ckkgr, `g}` oc}{gfnx n{ cl&
P3>_& Jlimcl If{ilijw bifr{}~b{gif di} an{n}ijnfni~r kgjg{cl
o~rn~or8 aifj/Xan Lg~,GNNN/=55:
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ 377
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 215/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒
Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/488 kig8 35& :;;33 )GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;;33
B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{ Gf Mcf`r
K]&U&CFM^ILG3, [&]&[AG]^TNF @C[ ]CH
=
Dcb~l{w, Knuc}{onf{ id Ocfcjnonf{ R{~kgnr, Crrgr{cf{U}idnrri},Cffc ^fgtn}rg{w id [nbafilijw Ock~}cg, Mac}c{a Fg`n{cf Nfjgfnn}gfj Billnjn,
Ock~}cg, [cogl Fck~ [anfg, [coglfck~
Cmr{}cb{ / Gf {ikcw‗r rbnfc}gi, bioucfgnr a~f{ di}
b~r{ion}r {i ulncrn {ano gf ntn}w }nrunb{ cfk iddn} {ano {an
mnr{ kncl& “B~r{ion} gr ntn}w{agfj, zai gr {an fnz
}nclgxc{gif id ntn}w u}idg{/oc`gfj bioucfw‟ mnbc~rn {anw
c}n {an }ntnf~n cfk u}idg{r& [an lgmn}clgxc{gif cfk
jlimclgxc{gif id Gfkgcf nbifiow acr {c`nf ulcbn cloir{ c
knbckn cji, {an dib~r uigf{ gf cfw rn}tgbn i}jcfgxc{gif gr
b~r{ion} rn}tgbn& G{ gr oi}n ri gf {an mcf`gfj gfk~r{}w&
B~r{ion} rn}tgbn gr {an mcrn di} m~rgfnrr nqucfrgif mnbc~rn
id {an r{gdd bioun{g{gif u}ntclnf{ gf {an mcf`gfj gfk~r{}w&
[an r~}tgtcl id mcf`gfj m~rgfnrr gr knunfknf{ if b~r{ion}rn}tgbnr&
@nwzi}k8B]O,MCF@,B^R[ION]
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{ !B]O' gf {an
Gfkgcf mcf`gfj rwr{no gr d~fkconf{cl {i m~glkgfj c
b~r{ion}/bnf{}gb i}jcfgxc{gif& B]O rwr{nor lgf`
b~r{ion} kc{c gf{i c rgfjln cfk lijgbcl b~r{ion}
}nuirg{i}w& B]O gf mcf`gfj gr c `nw nlnonf{ {ac{ cllizr c
mcf` {i kntnliu g{r b~r{ion} mcrn cfk rclnr bcucbg{w& [an
jicl id B]O gr {i ocfcjn cll crunb{r id b~r{ion}
gf{n}cb{gifr gf c ocffn} {ac{ nfcmlnr mcf`r {i ocqgogxn
u}idg{cmglg{w d}io ntn}w b~r{ion}& Gfb}ncrgfj bioun{g{gif,kn}nj~lc{gif, cfk {an gf{n}fn{ actn cll bif{}gm~{nk {i {an
gfb}ncrn gf b~r{ion} uizn}&
“Mw nf{n}gfj gf{i wi~} u}nogrnr, {an b~r{ion} gr
jgtgfj cf iuui}{~fg{w {i rn}tn ago, m~{ wi~ c}n fi{ kigfj
cfw dcti~} mw rn}tgfj
Gf lg{n}c{~}n, ocfw kndgfg{gifr zn}n jgtnf {i knrb}gmn
B]O& [an ocgf kgddn}nfbn coifj {anrn kndgfg{gifr gr
{nbafilijgbcl cfk }nlc{gifragu crunb{r id B]O& Rion
c~{ai}r d}io oc}`n{gfj mcb`j}i~fk nouacrgxn
{nbafilijgbcl rgkn id B]O zagln {an i{an}r bifrgkn} G[
un}runb{gtn id B]O& D}io oc}`n{gfj crunb{, B]O gr
kndgfnk mw PBi~lkznll 3771_ cr “c biomgfc{gif id
m~rgfnrr u}ibnrr cfk {nbafilijw {ac{ rnn`r {i ~fkn}r{cfkc bioucfw‗r b~r{ion}r d}io {an un}runb{gtn id zai {anw
c}n, zac{ {anw ki, cfk zac{ {anw c}n lg`n‟& [nbafilijgbcl
kndgfg{gif id B]O zcr jgtnf cr “{an oc}`n{ ulcbn id {an
d~{~}n gr ~fkn}jigfj c {nbafilijw/k}gtnf on{coi}uairgr‟
PUnuun}r cfk ]ijn}r 377>_& Bifrns~nf{lw, G[ cfk
oc}`n{gfj knuc}{onf{r o~r{ zi}` blirnlw {i goulnonf{
B]O nddgbgnf{lw& Oncfzagln, goulnonf{c{gif id B]O gf
mcf`gfj rnb{i} zcr bifrgkn}nk mw POganlgr n{ cl& =553_&
[anw dib~rnk if {an }ntcl~c{gif id {an b}g{gbcl rc{grdcb{gif
kgonfrgifr cfk {an kn{n}ogfc{gif id b~r{ion} j}i~ur
zg{a kgr{gfb{gtn u}ndn}nfbnr cfk nqunb{c{gifr gf {an
u}gtc{n mcf` rnb{i}& [an on{aikilijgbcl cuu}icba gr
mcrnk if {an u}gfbgulnr id o~l{g/b}g{n}gc oiknlgfj cfk
u}ndn}nfbn kgrcjj}njc{gif oiknlgfj ~rnk di} kc{c cfclwrgr
cfk gf{n}u}n{c{gif& PWlg ]nf`i n{ cl& =553_ actn dib~rnk
if {an ocfcjnonf{ id {an nqbacfjn }nlc{gifragur cfk {an
goulgbc{gifr id r~ba ocfcjnonf{ di} {an un}di}ocfbn cfkkntnliuonf{ id {nbafilijw/mcrnk dg}or cfk {ang}
b~r{ion}r& Runrgdgbcllw {an b~r{ion} }nlc{gifragur id fnz
{nbafilijw/mcrnk dg}or acr mnnf r{~kgnk& PBii` cfk
Acmcmi~, =553_ zcr gf{n}nr{nk gf {i{cl rclnr cb{gtg{gnr,
mi{a til~on/}nlc{nk cfk fif/til~on }nlc{nk& [anw clri
kntnliunk c oikgdgbc{gif id {an r{cfkc}k kc{c nftnliun
cfclwrgr !KNC' r{}~b{~}n ~rgfj jicl u}ij}coogfj
bifbnu{r {ac{ wgnlkr mi{a c rclnr cfk rn}tgbn oncr~}nr&
PMnb`n{{/Bcoc}c{c n{ cl& 3771_ actn fi{nk {ac{ ocfcjgfj
}nlc{gifragur zg{a {ang} b~r{ion}r !nrunbgcllw zg{a
nouliwnnr, bacffnl uc}{fn}r cfk r{}c{njgb cllgcfbn
uc}{fn}r' zcr b}g{gbcl {i {an dg}o‗r lifj/{n}o r~bbnrr& G{
zcr clri nouacrgxnk {ac{ b~r{ion} }nlc{gifragu
ocfcjnonf{ mcrnk if ribgcl nqbacfjn cfk ns~g{w
rgjfgdgbcf{lw crrgr{r {an dg}o gf kntnliugfj billcmi}c{gtn,
biiun}c{gtn cfk u}idg{cmln lifj/{n}o }nlc{gifragur&
Goui}{cfbn id B~r{ion} Rc{grdcb{gif
[an goui}{cfbn id b~r{ion} rn}tgbn di}
bcu{~}gfj m~rgfnrr gf mcf`r acr mnbion c dib~r uigf{ gf
cll r{cjnr id oc}`n{gfj id mcf`gfj rn}tgbnr, rgfbn cloir{
cll mcf`r c}n iddn}gfj oi}n i} lnrr {an rcon u}ik~b{r zg{a
lg{{ln bacfjnr gf fionfblc{~}n& An}n, {an bifbnu{ id
nfacfbgfj {an b~r{ion} rc{grdcb{gif gr c ugti{cl uigf{ {i
c{{}cb{ oi}n cfk oi}n uniuln {i mcf`gfj mw c uc}{gb~lc}
mcf`& Gf {an u}nrnf{ kcw rg{~c{gif, b~r{ion}r mnbiogfj
oi}n cfk oi}n knocfkgfj, mcf`n}r fnnk {i ntiltn fnz
cuu}icbanr, fnz cfk gffitc{gtn u}ik~b{r {i `nnu ucbnzg{a j}izgfj nqunb{c{gifr& Zg{a {an iunfgfj ~u id {an
nbifiow, b~r{ion} rc{grdcb{gifr “acr cbs~g}nk fnz
oncfgfj cfk kgddn}nf{ kgonfrgifr‟ cr mcf`r c}n
kgrbitn}gfj oi}n cfk oi}n gffitc{gtn u}ik~b{r {i onn{
gfb}ncrgfj bioun{g{gif coifj {anornltnr& Gf i}kn} {i
rn}tgbn {an b~r{ion} oi}n nddgbgnf{lw {i {an agjanr{ lntnl
id rc{grdcb{gif, {nbafilijw ~u j}ckc{gif gr cf goui}{cf{
crunb{ {i runnk ~u {an rn}tgbgfj gf cll ruan}nr id mcf`gfj
cfk {i d~ldgll {an b~r{ion} fnnkr&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =55
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 216/223
[nbafilijw
[nbafilijw gr anlud~l gf ~uj}ckgfj {an rn}tgbnr {i
onn{ {an bioun{g{gif, g{ zgll mnbion c dclli~{ gd fi{
iun}c{n nddnb{gtnlw cfk nddgbgnf{lw& [nbafilijw/k}gtnfu}ik~b{r r~ba cr knmg{ bc}kr, b}nkg{ bc}kr, {nln/mcf`gfj,
oimgln uaifn mcf`gfj, gf{n}fn{ mcf`gfj, dcq, n/ocgl, anlu
knr` rn}tgbnr, n{b& actn jgtnf oi}n cbbnrr {i b~r{ion}r {i
bioo~fgbc{n {ang} fnnkr gfr{cf{lw cfk {}cfrcb{ {ang}
m~rgfnrr u}iou{lw
B~r{ion} Nqunb{c{gifr
B~r{ion} rn}tgbn gr }ns~g}nk {i mn ~uj}cknk {i rc{grdw
{an b~r{ion} nqunb{c{gifr& [i }nfkn} nddgbgnf{ b~r{ion}
rn}tgbn, {an mcf`n}r actn {i dg}r{ ~fkn}r{cfk, zac{ }ncllw
{an b~r{ion} zcf{r& [an}ndi}n, {an mcf` ocfcjnonf{r
actn {i bif{gf~i~rlw gffitc{n cfk oc`n r{}c{njgnr cfk
ntiltn fnz u}ik~b{r {i c{{}cb{ {an b~r{ion}r& Gf i}kn} {i
cbagntn {agr {cr`, mcf`r actn {i u}nuc}n u}ihnb{r, `nnugfj
gf tgnz, {an u}gi}g{gnr id ncba rnjonf{ id b~r{ion}r
blcrrgdgnk gf{i ogkkln tcl~n b~r{ion}r cfk agja fn{ zi}{a
b~r{ion}r& [agr zgll nfcmln mcf`r {i gffitc{n u}ik~b{r {i
b~r{ion} fnnkr
Bioo~fgbc{gif
Gf{n}cb{gif zg{a b~r{ion}r gr cf goui}{cf{ crunb{ gf
u}itgkgfj mn{{n} rn}tgbn {i {an b~r{ion}r {i {ang} d~llnr{
rc{grdcb{gif& Bioo~fgbc{gif zg{a b~r{ion}r c{ d}if{
iddgbn lntnl zgll anlu mcf`n}r {i }ncllw gknf{gdw {an fnnkr
cfk u}gi}g{gnr id b~r{ion}r& [an}ndi}n, {an }iln id A~ocf
]nri~}bnr Knuc}{onf{ id {an mcf` gr {i u}itgkn nddgbgnf{
r{cdd c{ cll lntnlr, zan}ntn} {an}n gr cf gf{n}cb{gif zg{a
b~r{ion} ng{an} kg}nb{lw i} gfkg}nb{lw& U}iun}
bioo~fgbc{gif r`gllr c}n }ns~g}nk di} {an r{cdd {i knclzg{a {an b~r{ion}r& G{ gr ifn id {an {iu u}gi}g{gnr id mcf`r
{i u}itgkn jiik rn}tgbn&
]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{
]nlc{gifragu ocfcjn}‗r }iln gf u}itgkgfj c mn{{n}
Rn}tgbn {i {an b~r{ion}r gr ugti{cl {i {an nqucfrgif id
mcf`gfj m~rgfnrr& [agr ]Or ocgf{cgfr }cuui}{,
uc}{gb~lc}lw zg{a agja fn{ zi}{a b~r{ion}r cfk u}itgknr
{ano zg{a cll {an rn}tgbnr {anw fnnk& [agr zgll anlu gf fi{
iflw }n{cgfgfj {an nqgr{gfj b~r{ion} mcrn, m~{ clri {i
bcu{~}n {an fnz blgnf{nln& ]nlc{gifragur c}n oi}n
goui}{cf{ {i u}itgkn jiik b~r{ion} rn}tgbnr&
Cl{n}fc{gtnlw, jiik rn}tgbn zgll anlu {an mcf`n}r {i m~glk
~u }nlc{gifragur& ^flnrr {an rn}tgbn gr u}itgknk {i {and~llnr{ rc{grdcb{gif id {an b~r{ion}r, {c`gfj d~}{an}
}ndn}nfbnr d}io {an nqgr{gfj b~r{ion}r {i nr{cmlgra fnz
}nlc{gifragur gr kgddgb~l{& Cjcgf {agr }ns~g}nr {an rn}tgbn {i
{an nqgr{gfj b~r{ion}r cfk {ang} uc{}ifcjn {i mcf`&
Ocuugfj {an B~r{ion} Fnnkr
Gf {an u}nrnf{ kcw mcf`gfj, {ai~ja{ {an mcf`gfj
rn}tgbnr c}n {nbafilijw/k}gtnf cfk ochi} }iln gr ulcwnk
mw {nbafilijw gf cll knbgrgifr if b~r{ion} rn}tgbnr, {an
}nr{nk on{aikr lg`n b~r{ion} r~}tnwr bif{gf~n {i anlu {an
ocfcjnonf{r gf gknf{gdwgfj {an b~r{ion} fnnkr&
Gknf{gdwgfj {an b~r{ion} fnnkr gr goui}{cf{ mndi}n
u}itgkgfj {an rn}tgbn, ri {ac{ {an cb{~cl }ns~g}nonf{ id {an
uc}{gb~lc} rnjonf{ id b~r{ion} gr on{ zg{a& [agr zgll anlu
ocfcjnonf{r {i actn cf gfrgja{ gf{i b~r{ion} fnnkr cfk
c{{g{~knr& Aiz {i u}nrnf{ {an rn}tgbn
Mcf`gfj gr c rn}tgbn gfk~r{}w cfk mcf`n}r actn {i mngknf{gdgnk mw {an b~r{ion} di} zaio {an rn}tgbn gr
nq{nfknk& G{ gr {an r{c}{gfj uigf{, zan}n {an mcf`n} bionr
gf{i bif{cb{ zg{a {an b~r{ion}& [an}ndi}n, mcf`n} rai~lk
actn jiik c{{g{~kn, cuuncl cfk jiik cuunc}cfbn& Mcf`n}r
actn {i b~l{gtc{n c jiik }nlc{gifragu zg{a {an b~r{ion}&
[anrn dcb{i}r actn c j}nc{ goucb{ if b~r{ion} rn}tgbn& Gf
r~ba rg{~c{gifr, b~r{ion}r zgll mnbion liwcl {i {an
rn}tgbnr u}itgknk mw mcf`n} cfk uc{}ifgrn {an mcf`n}&
Mcf`n} rai~lk ~fkn}r{cfk {an b~r{ion} fnnkr cfk
gknf{gdw {an biooif c}ncr id gf{n}nr{& ]nlc{gifragu
m~glkgfj gr cf gf{nj}cl uc}{ id mcf`gfj m~rgfnrr&
B~r{ion} J}gntcfbnr
]nbngtgfj b~r{ion} bioulcgf{r, lgr{nfgfj {i {an
j}gntcfbnr uc{gnf{lw cfk riltgfj {an u}imlnor gr ifn id
{an goui}{cf{ c}ncr id b~r{ion} rn}tgbn& Di} {agr, c
rnuc}c{n onbacfgro gr u}itgknk mw mcf`r, r~ba cr
“b~r{ion} j}gntcfbn bnllr‟ gf gfkgtgk~cl mcf`r cfk
iom~krocf c{ ncba r{c{n& B~r{ion}r c}n d}nn {i bif{cb{
{an j}gntcfbn bnllr gf mcf`r {i oc`n bioulcgf{r, cmi~{ {an
rn}tgbn, u}imlnor n{b& Mcf`r zgll goonkgc{nlw c{{nfk {i
r~ba j}gntcfbnr cfk rn{{ln {an grr~nr&
Bacfjn id I}jcfgxc{gifcl R{}~b{~}n di} Mn{{n}
Rn}tgbgfj
[an dgfcfbgcl rnb{i} }ndi}or actn m}i~ja{ cmi~{ c
fnnk di} }nr{}~b{~}gfj id mcf`r gf u}itgkgfj jiik
b~r{ion} rn}tgbn& [an f~omn} id gffitc{gtn dgfcfbgcl
u}ik~b{r iddn}nk mw mcf`r gr gfb}ncrgfj r{nckglw& [anu~mlgb rnb{i} mcf`r c}n r{gll bif{gf~gfj zg{a ilk uc{{n}fr
gf {ang} r{}~b{~}n& [anw c}n itn}r{cddnk rnllgfj kgddn}nf{
rbanonr cfk cll {wunr id u}ik~b{r& [agr r{}~b{~}n gr
acoun}gfj b~r{ion} rn}tgbn& Gf {anrn kcwr id r~un}
runbgclgxc{gif, u~mlgb rnb{i} mcf`r actn {i rnj}njc{n {ang}
r{}~b{~}n mw blcrrgdwgfj {an mcf`gfj cr }~}cl mcf`gfj cfk
bioon}bgcl mcf`gfj& Gf r~ba bcrn, {anw bcf bioun{n
nddnb{gtnlw zg{a fnz m}nnk id u}gtc{n rnb{i} mcf`r&
GG& BIFBL^RGIF
B~r{ion} rn}tgbn rai~lk mn {an ocgf oi{{i di}
gou}itnonf{ id m~rgfnrr& [nbafilijw goulnonf{c{gifrai~lk mn runnknk ~u, r~ba cr biou~{n}gxc{gif, nlnb{}ifgb
mcf`gfj& [an mcf`gfj gfk~r{}w gr tgm}cf{ cfk cb{gtn gf
Gfkgc, k~n {i {nbafilijgbcl }ntil~{gif, Mcf`r actn {i
~{glgxn {agr iuui}{~fg{w {i mnbion oi}n cfk oi}n r{}ifj
i}jcfgxc{gifr u}itgkgfj nrrnf{gcl rn}tgbnr&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_& Clgr, I&D&, @c}c`~}{, N&, $ Onllg, U&, =555, Kc{c Ogfgfj di}
Kc{cmcrn Oc}`n{gfj c{ Jc}cf{g Mcf`, U}ibnnkgfj id {an
Gf{n}fc{gifcl Rnogfc} -Kc{c Ogfgfj =555-, ZG[
U~mlgbc{gifr&
P=_& Mnb`n{{/Bcoc}c{c, N&H&, Bcoc}c{c, O&]&, Mc}`n}, ]&[&, 3771,Gf{nj}c{gfj Gf{n}fcl cfk Nq{n}fcl B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragur
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =53
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 217/223
[a}i~ja ]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{8 C R{}c{njgb ]nruifrn {ic Bacfjgfj Jlimcl Nftg}ifonf{, Hi~}fcl id M~rgfnrr
]nrnc}ba, ;3, :3/13&
P2_& Mn}}w, O&H&C& $ Lgfidd J&R&, =555, Ocr{n}gfj Kc{c Ogfgfj8
[an C}{ cfk Rbgnfbn id B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{,Hiaf Zglnw $ Rifr, Gfb&
P;_& Bcmnfc, U&, Baig A&A&, @go G&R&, I{r~`c R&, ]ngfrbaogk{ H& $
Rcc}nftg}{c J&, 3777, Gf{nllgjnf{ Ogfn} di} Kc{c Cuulgbc{gifr
J~gkn, GMO ]nkmii`r, RJ=;/>=>=/55&
P>_& >&Bii`, Z&K&, $ Acmcmi~, O&, =553, Rclnr Un}di}ocfbn
Oncr~}nonf{ gf Mcf` M}cfbanr, Ionjc, =7, =77 ‒25:&P4_& Bi~lkznll, B&, 3771, C Kc{c Kcw Mc{{ln, Biou~{gfj, =3
Ocw, 4;‒44&
P:_& Air`gfj, H&]&O&, Unkfc~l{, N& U& K& $ R~kcf, O&, 377:, C
r{c{gr{gbcl un}runb{gtn if kc{c ogfgfj, D~{~}n Jnfn}c{gifBiou~{n} Rwr{nor, 32, 3:/32;&
P1_& Oganlgr, J&, J}gji}i~kgr, N&, Rgr`ir, W&, Uilg{gr, W&, $
Oclcfk}c`gr, W&, =553,
P7_& B~r{ion} Rc{grdcb{gif Oncr~}nonf{ gf {an U}gtc{n Mcf` Rnb{i}, N~}iuncf Hi~}fcl id Iun}c{gifcl ]nrnc}ba, 2;:/245&
P35_& Unuuc}k, H&, =555, B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{
!B]O' gf Dgfcfbgcl Rn}tgbnr,
P33_&
N~}iuncf Ocfcjnonf{ Hi~}fcl, Til& 31, Fi& 2, uu& 23=‒2=:,P3=_& Unuun}r,K&, $ ]ijn}r,O&, 377>, C Fnz Oc}`n{gfj Uc}ckgjo,
Ulcffgfj ]ntgnz, =2!=', 3;‒31&
P32_& ]wclr, L&, $ @fiq, R&, =553, B}irr/D~fb{gifcl Grr~nr gf {an
Goulnonf{c{gif id ]nlc{gifragu Oc}`n{gfj [a}i~ja
B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragu Ocfcjnonf{, N~}iuncf Ocfcjnonf{
Hi~}fcl, Til& 37, Fi& >, uu& >2;‒>;=&P3;_& Wlg/]nf`i, A&, Rcugnfxc, A&H&, Acw, O&, =553, [an ]iln id
Bif{}cb{~cl Jitn}fcfbn Dlnqgmglg{w gf ]nclgxgfj {an
I~{bionr id @nw B~r{ion} ]nlc{gifragur, Hi~}fcl id
M~rgfnrr Tnf{~}gfj, 34, >=7‒>>>&P3>_& 32&W~cf, R&[&, $ Bacfj, Z&L&, =553, Ogqnk/Gfg{gc{gtn
Rwf{anrgxnk Lnc}fgfj Cuu}icba
P34_& Di} Znm/Mcrnk B]O, Nqun}{ Rwr{nor zg{a
Cuulgbc{gifr,=5,31:/=55&
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =5=
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 218/223
U}ib& id {an Gf{l& Bifd& if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr ‒ Til~on 3& Biuw}gja{ § =53= [nbafi Di}~o J}i~u, Gfkgc&
GRMF8 7:1/13/7=5>:>/:/488 kig8 35& :;;31 )GRMFY5:41
CBO "8 kmn}&gon}c&35& :;;31
CFCLWRGR ID DI]NGJF KG]NB[ GFTNR[ONF[ GF RN]TGBN RNB[I]8 C R[^KW ZG[A ]NDN]NFBN [I GFKGC
K}& @& Oc}cf,Kg}nb{i} / Rcg}co Gfr{g{~{n id
Ocfcjnonf{ R{~kgnr, Banffcg ‒ Gfkgc
]& Cfg{ac]nrnc}ba Rbailc}, Mac}c{agc}
^fgtn}rg{w, Bigomc{i}n ‒ Gfkgc
]& ^kacwcrcf`c} Dcb~l{w, Ocfcjnonf{ R{~kgnr,
Rcg}co Gfr{& id [nba& Banffcg /Gfkgc
Cmr{}cb{ / K~}gfj 3775, {an}n zcr c j}nc{ rn{mcb` gf{an Gfkgcf nbifiow k~n {i {an nbifiogb b}grgr& [anGfkgcf nbifiow r~ddn}nk d}io liz un} bcug{c gfbion,ba}ifgb ~fnouliwonf{, liz bcug{cl di}oc{gif,gfb}ncrnk {}ckn kndgbg{, liz r{cfkc}k id lgtgfj, lizj}iz{a gf JKU, liz gfd}cr{}~b{~}cl kntnliuonf{ n{b& Gftgnz id {an nbifiogb b}grgr cfk {an rai}{cjn id bcug{cl,
{an Jitn}fonf{ id Gfkgc }nclgxnk {an goui}{cfbn id di}ngjf bcug{cl di} {an kntnliuonf{ id {an bi~f{}w&D}io {an un}gik 3773 ifzc}kr {an}n acr mnnfbif{gf~i~r nddi}{ {c`nf mw {an Jitn}fonf{ gfc{{}cb{gfj di}ngjf bcug{cl cfk anfbn {agr un}gik gr{n}onk cr {an uir{ lgmn}clgxc{gif un}gik& [an gfg{gc{gtnr{c`nf mw {an Jitn}fonf{ gfbl~kn gfb}ncrgfj {angftnr{onf{ bcu, u}itgkgfj bifbnrrgifr gf {cqnr cfkiddn}gfj {cq ailgkcwr& Gfkgc zcr {anf c{{}cb{nk {idi}ngjf gftnr{i}r0 cr c }nr~l{ {an}n zcr c ocrrgtngfb}ncrn id di}ngjf gftnr{onf{ dliz gf{i {an bi~f{}w&[an bif{}gm~{gif id DKG gfdliz gf{i {an bi~f{}w zcr ^R+ 3=7 ogllgif gf 3773/7= {i ^R + 2:,31= gf =557/35&K~}gfj =554, {an rac}n id DKG gf {agr rnb{i} zcrgfb}ncrnk k}cr{gbcllw d}io 25&:= un}bnf{ gf =55> {i
43&7; un}bnf{ gf =554& D}io =554 ifzc}kr, cf ~uzc}k{}nfk id DKG gf {agr rnb{i} zcr imrn}tnk& [an}n gr crgjfgdgbcf{ bacfjn d}io ocf~dcb{~}gfj {i rn}tgbn rnb{i}d}io =554 ifzc}kr&
@nwzi}kr8 DKG, Nbifiow, Rn}tgbn Rnb{i}, Nr{goc{nk,
U}n cfk Uir{ Lgmn}clgxc{gif n{b&,
G& GF[]IK^B[GIF
[an Gfkgcf nbifiow acr ockn }noc}`cmln u}ij}nrr k~}gfj {an u}n/lgmn}clgxc{gif un}gik& [ancj}gb~l{~}cl rnb{i} k~}gfj {an un}gik acr u}ij}nrrnk
{a}i~ja j}nnf, wnlliz, zag{n cfk ml~n }ntil~{gifr&[an gfk~r{}gcl rnb{i} acr j}izf cff~cllw mw 4 {i :.cfk {an {n}{gc}w rnb{i} acr bif{}gm~{nk {i {an j}iz{aid {an Gfkgcf nbifiow& K~}gfj 3775, {an}n zcr cj}nc{ rn{mcb` gf {an Gfkgcf nbifiow k~n {i {annbifiogb b}grgr& [an Gfkgcf nbifiow r~ddn}nk d}ioliz un} bcug{c gfbion, ba}ifgb ~fnouliwonf{, lizbcug{cl di}oc{gif, gfb}ncrnk {}ckn kndgbg{, lizr{cfkc}k id lgtgfj, liz j}iz{a gf JKU, liz
gfd}cr{}~b{~}cl kntnliuonf{ n{b& Gf tgnz id {annbifiogb b}grgr cfk {an rai}{cjn id bcug{cl, {anJitn}fonf{ id Gfkgc }nclgxnk {an goui}{cfbn id di}ngjf bcug{cl di} {an kntnliuonf{ id {an bi~f{}w&D}io {an un}gik 3773 ifzc}kr {an}n acr mnnfbif{gf~i~r nddi}{ {c`nf mw {an Jitn}fonf{ gf
c{{}cb{gfj di}ngjf bcug{cl cfk anfbn {agr un}gik gr{n}onk cr {an uir{ lgmn}clgxc{gif un}gik& [angfg{gc{gtnr {c`nf mw {an Jitn}fonf{ gfbl~kngfb}ncrgfj {an gftnr{onf{ bcu, u}itgkgfj bifbnrrgifrgf {cqnr cfk iddn}gfj {cq ailgkcwr&
Di} {an dg}r{ di~} knbcknr cd{n} gfknunfknfbn gf37;:, {an nbifiogb uilgbgnr id {an Gfkgcfjitn}fonf{ zn}n bac}cb{n}gxnk mw ulcffgfj, bif{}ilcfk }nj~lc{gif& ^f{gl {an 3715r, Gfkgc‗r kntnliuonf{r{}c{njw zcr dib~rnk if rnld/}nlgcfbn cfk goui}{r~mr{g{~{gif& [an}n zn}n un}gikgb c{{nou{r c{ oc}`n{/i}gnf{nk }ndi}o, ~r~cllw dillizgfj mclcfbn id
ucwonf{r u}nrr~}nr, zagba gfk~bnk uilgbw }nruifrnr{ac{ biomgfnk nqbacfjn }c{n knu}nbgc{gif cfk cfncrgfj id }nr{}gb{gifr if di}ngjf bcug{cl gfdlizr&Aizntn}, {anrn bif{}ilr zn}n }nlc{gtnlw fc}}iz gfrbiun cfk ack lg{{ln goucb{ if cb{~cl gfdlizr, zagba}nocgfnk rocll& [an rg{~c{gif bacfjnk k}coc{gbcllwzg{a {an ifrn{ id }ndi}o u}ij}coonr gf{}ik~bnk gf{an nc}lw 3775r gf {an cd{n}oc{a id {an mclcfbn id
ucwonf{r b}grgr id 3773&M}icklw runc`gfj, Gfkgc‗r cuu}icba {izc}kr
nq{n}fcl bcug{cl dlizr bcf mn kgtgknk gf{i {a}nn ocgf uacrnr& Gf {an dg}r{ uacrn, r{c}{gfj c{ {an {gon id gfknunfknfbn cfk rucffgfj ~u {i {an nc}lw 3715r,Gfkgc‗r }nlgcfbn if nq{n}fcl dlizr zcr ocgflw}nr{}gb{nk {i o~l{glc{n}cl cfk mglc{n}cl bifbnrrgifcl
dgfcfbn& R~mrns~nf{lw, gf {an bif{nq{ id c zgknfgfjb~}}nf{ cbbi~f{ kndgbg{ k~}gfj {an 3715r, Gfkgcr~uulnonf{nk {agr {}ckg{gifcl nq{n}fcl ri~}bn id dgfcfbgfj zg{a }nbi~}rn {i nq{n}fcl bioon}bgcl licfr,gfbl~kgfj rai}{/{n}o mi}}izgfjr cfk knuirg{r d}iofif/}nrgknf{ Gfkgcfr !F]Gr'& Cr c }nr~l{, {an
u}iui}{gif id rai}{/{n}o knm{ gf Gfkgc‗r {i{cl nq{n}fclknm{ ack gfb}ncrnk rgjfgdgbcf{lw mw {an lc{n 3715r&[an {ag}k uacrn zcr oc}`nk mw {an mclcfbn id
ucwonf{r b}grgr id 3773 cfk {an gfg{gc{gif id {an}ndi}o u}ibnrr&
[an m}ick cuu}icba {i }ndi}o gf {an nq{n}fclrnb{i} zcr ockn gf {an ]nui}{ id {an Agja Lntnl
Bioog{{nn if Mclcfbn id Ucwonf{r mcrnk if {an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =52
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 219/223
}nbioonfkc{gifr ockn mw B& ]cfjc}chcf, Bacg}ocf,Nbifiogb Cktgri}w Bi~fbgl gf 3773& [an imhnb{gtnrid }ndi}o gf {an nq{n}fcl rnb{i} zn}n bifkg{gifnk mw{an fnnk {i bi}}nb{ {an kndgbgnfbgnr {ac{ ack lnk {i
ucwonf{ gomclcfbnr gf 3773& ]nbijfgxgfj cfgfcuu}iu}gc{n nqbacfjn }c{n }njgon, ~fr~r{cgfcmlnb~}}nf{ cbbi~f{ kndgbg{ cfk c }grn gf rai}{/{n}o knm{ gf}nlc{gif {i iddgbgcl }nrn}tnr zn}n coifjr{ {an `nwbif{}gm~{gfj dcb{i}r {i {an b}grgr& C rn}gnr id }ndi}ooncr~}nr zn}n u~{ gf ulcbn& [anw gfbl~knk c rzgd{{}cfrg{gif {i c oc}`n{/kn{n}ogfnk nqbacfjn }c{n}njgon, kgrocf{lgfj id {}ckn }nr{}gb{gifr, c oitn{izc}kr b~}}nf{ cbbi~f{ biftn}{gmglg{w cfk c j}ck~cliunfgfj/~u id {an bcug{cl cbbi~f{& Zagln lgmn}clgxgfj
u}gtc{n bcug{cl gfdlizr, {an Bioog{{nn }nbioonfknk,gf{n}/clgc8 c biouirg{gifcl ragd{ czcw d}io knm{ {ifif/knm{/b}nc{gfj dlizr0 r{}gb{ }nj~lc{gif id nq{n}fcl
bioon}bgcl mi}}izgfjr, nrunbgcllw rai}{/{n}o knm{0kgrbi~}cjnonf{ id {an tilc{gln nlnonf{ id dlizr d}io
F]Gr0 cfk c j}ck~cl lgmn}clgxc{gif id i~{dlizr&Rn}tgbn rnb{i} zcr {an rnbifk c{{}cb{nk rnb{i} di}
di}ngjf gftnr{i}r k~}gfj {an un}gik d}io 3773 {i=55>& M~{ d}io =554 ifzc}kr, {agr rnb{i} mnbcon {anoir{ u}ndn}}nk rnb{i} di} di}ngjf gftnr{i}r zanf g{ grbiouc}nk {i ocf~dcb{~}gfj cfk u}goc}w rnb{i}&K~}gfj =554, {an rac}n id DKG gf {agr rnb{i} zcrgfb}ncrnk k}cr{gbcllw d}io 25&:= un}bnf{ gf =55> {i43&7; un}bnf{ gf =554& D}io =554 ifzc}kr, cf~uzc}k {}nfk id DKG gf {agr rnb{i} zcr imrn}tnk&[cmln ;&1 cfk Bac}{ ;&> nlcmi}c{nr {an dcb{ {ac{ {an
rnb{i}cl biouirg{gif id DKG acr ~fkn}jifn crgjfgdgbcf{ bacfjn d}io ocf~dcb{~}gfj {i rn}tgbnrnb{i} d}io =554 ifzc}kr& [an ochi} ragd{ gf {anbiouirg{gif id DKG gr k~n {i {an uilgbw lgmn}clgxc{gifcfk {an bacfjnr gf rnb{i}cl uilgbgnr id DKG d}io {gon{i {gon& Nc}lgn}, ocfw rnb{i}r zagba zn}n fi{ iunf {iDKG zn}n {a}izf iunf cfk lgog{r id ocfw i{an}ractn mnnf }cgrnk gf {an uir{ lgmn}clgxc{gif un}gik&K~}gfj 3773/=55>, iflw ;2 gfk~r{}gnr zn}n iunfnk {idi}ngjf kg}nb{ gftnr{onf{ m~{ d}io =554 ifzc}kr,k~n {i d~}{an} lgmn}clgxc{gif id DKG uilgbgnr, {anf~omn} id gfk~r{}gnr acr gfb}ncrnk {i 4;&
D~}{an}, {an uanfionfcl ragd{ id DKG gf Gfkgcd}io ocf~dcb{~}gfj {i rn}tgbn rnb{i} acr bc~rnk {anfnnk {i biouc}n rnb{i}cl biouirg{gif id DKG dliz gfGfkgc zg{a {ac{ id {an kntnliunk cfk kntnliugfjbi~f{}gnr gf {an zi}lk&
GG& R[C[NONF[ ID [AN U]IMLNO
K~}gfj 3775, Gfkgc zcr dcbgfj zg{a c rn}gi~rnbifiogb cfk Mclcfbn id Ucwonf{ b}grgr& G{ zcr {an{gon zanf Jitn}fonf{ dnl{ {an fnnk di} di}ngjfbcug{cl {i r~uulnonf{ kionr{gb bcug{cl {i itn}bion{an b}grgr cfk {i r{go~lc{n nbifiogb j}iz{a& Gf 3773,{an Jitn}fonf{ lgmn}clgxnk {an nbifiow mw iunfgfj{an kii}r {i di}ngjf gftnr{i}r ri cr {i m}gfj Gfkgc gf{~fn zg{a {an jlimcl nbifiow& Gfkgc zcr {anf
c{{}cb{nk {i di}ngjf gftnr{i}r0 cr c }nr~l{ {an}n zcr cocrrgtn gfb}ncrn id di}ngjf gftnr{onf{ dliz gf{i {anbi~f{}w& [an di}ngjf gftnr{onf{ gfbl~rgtn id mi{aDKG cfk DUG zagba zcr ^R+322 ogllgif gf 3773/7=
gfb}ncrnk {i ^R + 47,>>: ogllgif gf =557/35& [anbif{}gm~{gif id DKG gfdliz gf{i {an bi~f{}w zcr ^R +3=7 ogllgif gf 3773/7= {i ^R + 2:,31= gf =557/35&K~}gfj =554, {an rac}n id DKG gf {agr rnb{i} zcrgfb}ncrnk k}cr{gbcllw d}io 25&:= un}bnf{ gf =55> {i43&7; un}bnf{ gf =554& D}io =554 ifzc}kr, cf~uzc}k {}nfk id DKG gf {agr rnb{i} zcr imrn}tnk&[an}n gr c rgjfgdgbcf{ bacfjn d}io ocf~dcb{~}gfj {irn}tgbn rnb{i} d}io =554 ifzc}kr&
IMHNB[GTNR ID [AN R[^KW
[i cfclwxn {an di}nbcr{gfj id DKGGfdlizr gf{i Gfkgc
[i gknf{gdw {an {}nfkr cfk r{c{~r id DKG
Gfdlizr gf{i Rn}tgbn Rnb{i}
GGG& ]NTGNZ ID LG[N]C[^]N
Mclcr~fkc}co Ocfgco cfk Cog{gctc Bac{{n}hnn!3771' cfclwrnk if {an kn{n}ogfcf{r id ^R di}ngjfgftnr{onf{ gf Gfkgc0 {}cbgfj {an j}iz{a id ^R DKG gfGfkgc cfk {an bacfjgfj c{{g{~kn id {an GfkgcfJitn}fonf{ {izc}kr g{ cr c uc}{ id {an lgmn}clgxc{gif
u}ij}co& [anw dgfk {ac{ iflw {an }nlc{gtnlw znc` nqbacfjn }c{n cuunc}r {i mn c rgjfgdgbcf{ dcb{i} cfk{ac{ {an ^R DKG acr mnnf gfb}ncrgfj gf killc} coi~f{r cfk }nlc{gtn un}bnf{cjn j}iz{a& [anw bclldi} cf gou}itnonf{ gf gfd}cr{}~b{~}n cfk }nk~b{gifr
gf }nk {cun cfk u}i{nb{gifgro {i nfbi~}cjn d~}{an} j}iz{a&
Fcjnra @~oc} !=555' acr ockn cf nquli}c{i}wc{{nou{ {i nqcogfn {an uc{{n}fr id OFB }nlc{nkon}jn}r cfk cbs~grg{gifr gf Gfkgc k~}gfj {an fgfn{gnrzg{a {an anlu id cf nqbl~rgtn kc{c mcrn& An dgfkr {ac{{an lgmn}clgxc{gif id uilgbw d}conzi}` rgfbn {an nc}lwfgfn{gnr acr lnk {an OFBr {i gfb}ncrgfjlw ~rn {anOn}jn} cfk Cbs~grg{gif }i~{n {i nf{n} cfk r{}nfj{anf{ang} u}nrnfbn gf {an bi~f{}w& Gf {an }nbnf{ wnc}r, {zidgd{ar id cll DKG gfdlizr {ii` {an di}o id O$C rbiouc}nk {i tg}{~cllw cll id DKG gfdlizr biogfj d}ioJ}nnfdgnlk tnf{~}nr nc}lgn}& [an knclr }nlc{gfj {i
OFBr c}n u}nkiogfcf{lw ai}gxif{cl }c{an} {acftn}{gbcl gf fc{~}n& Gf {n}or id kntnliuonf{goulgbc{gifr, an dgfkr {ac{ DKG gfdlizr gf {an di}o id O$C r c}n id cf gfdn}gi} s~clg{w biouc}nk {iJ}nnfdgnlk gftnr{onf{r& [anrn dgfkgfjr, {an}ndi}n,nouacrgxn {an fnnk di} ckiu{gfj c biou}nanfrgtnbioun{g{gif uilgbw d}conzi}` gf Gfkgc&
Bifr{cf{gfc @i{{c}gkg cfk [acfcrgr R{nfjir!=535' oc`n c bif{}gm~{gif {i {an nqgr{gfj lg{n}c{~}nif {an di}ngjf kg}nb{ gftnr{onf{ cfk nbifiogbj}iz{a fnq~r mw bif{}cr{gfj ucr{ noug}gbcl ntgknfbncfk biftnf{gifcl zgrkio cfk c}}gtgfj c{ riongf{n}nr{gfj fnz }nr~l{r& Mw cuulwgfj fif/uc}con{}gbon{aikr cfk {c`gfj gf{i cbbi~f{ fif/lgfnc} nddnb{r id
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =5;
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 220/223
gfg{gcl gfbion cfk a~ocf bcug{cl if nbifiogbj}iz{a& [anw nquli}n {an DKG nddnb{ if j}iz{a gfo~ba j}nc{n} kn{cgl {acf u}ntgi~r r{~kgnr& [ang} dgfkgfjr fi{ iflw bifdg}o {an fif/lgfnc} nddnb{ id
a~ocf bcug{cl gf {an u}nrnfbn id DKG gfdlizr m~{ clrir~jjnr{ {ac{ DKG gfdlizr c}n j}iz{a nfacfbgfj gf {anogkkln/gfbion bi~f{}gnr zagln {an}n gr c ‑{zi/}njgon‗ DKG nddnb{ di} agja/gfbion bi~f{}gnr& [agrfnz dgfkgfj cuunc}r {i mn gfknunfknf{ id INBKbi~f{}w onomn}ragu&
Nlgxcmn{a Crgnk~ cfk Kifclk Lgnf !=533', gf{ang} noug}gbcl r{~kgnr nqcogfn {an goucb{ id knoib}cbw if di}ngjf kg}nb{ gftnr{onf{ crr~on {ac{{an }nlc{gifragu mn{znnf knoib}cbw cfk DKG gr {anrcon di} }nri~}bn nqui}{gfj cfk fif/}nri~}bnnqui}{gfj bi~f{}gnr& [agr ucun} nqcogfnr zan{an} fc{~}cl }nri~}bnr gf air{ bi~f{}gnr cl{n} {agr
}nlc{gifragu& Zn nr{goc{n c lgfnc} kwfcogb ucfnl/kc{coiknl ~rgfj kc{c d}io 33= kntnliugfj bi~f{}gnr itn} {an un}gik 371=‒=55:& Zn dgfk {ac{ knoib}cbw
u}ioi{nr DKG gd cfk iflw gd {an tcl~n id {an rac}n id ogfn}clr cfk igl gf {i{cl nqui}{r gr lnrr {acf rionb}g{gbcl tcl~n& Zn gknf{gdw 75 bi~f{}gnr zan}n cfnqucfrgif id knoib}cbw ocw nfacfbn DKG cfk ==bi~f{}gnr zan}n cf gfb}ncrn gf knoib}c{gxc{gif ocw}nk~bn DKG& Zn clri dgfk {ac{ {an nddnb{ id knoib}cbw if DKG knunfkr if {an rgxn cfk fi{ {an{wun id fc{~}cl }nri~}bnr&
GT& ON[AIKILIJW
]nrnc}ba Knrgjf[an knrgjf ckiu{nk di} {an r{~kw gr Knrb}gu{gtn
]nrnc}ba Knrgjf, cr {an r{~kw gr bifbn}fnk zg{aknrb}gmgfj {an bac}cb{n}gr{gbr cfk runbgdgb u}nkgb{gifrcmi~{ Di}ngjf Kg}nb{ Gftnr{onf{r gf Gfkgc k~}gfj c
uc}{gb~lc} un}gik&
T& UN]GIK ID R[^KW
[an ocgf u~}uirn id {an r{~kw gr {i cfclwxn {anocjfg{~kn, bc~rnr cfk nddnb{r id Di}ngjf Kg}nb{Gftnr{onf{ gfdliz gf{i {an bi~f{}w& Anfbn DKGgfdlizr gf{i {an bi~f{}w gr cfclwxnk di} c un}gik id 25wnc}r d}io 3715/13 {i =557/35& Di} mn{{n} cfclwrgr,{an un}gik gr blcrrgdgnk gf{i {zi uacrnr8 {an dg}r{ uacrngr {an un}gik id U}n/Lgmn}clgxc{gif g&n&, un}gik d}io3715/13 {i 3775/73 cfk {an rnbifk uacrn gr {an Uir{Lgmn}clgxc{gif un}gik d}io 3773/7= {i =557/35& [an}nr{ id {an cfclwrgr, {ac{ gr, {an bi~f{}w zgrn ri~}bn,rnb{i}cl cfclwrgr, }nlc{gifragu mn{znnf DKG cfk DUG,dcb{i}r zagba kn{n}ogfn DKG dliz cfk g{r goucb{ if{an nbifiow c}n cfclwxnk di} c un}gik id 37 wnc}rd}io 3773/7= {i =557/35&
[an un}gik ~fkn} r{~kw gr goui}{cf{ di} c tc}gn{wid }ncrifr& Dg}r{ id cll, g{ zcr k~}gfj H~lw 3773 {ac{Gfkgc iunfnk g{r kii}r {i u}gtc{n rnb{i} cfk {i di}ngjfgftnr{i}r mw lgmn}clgxgfj cfk jlimclgxgfj {annbifiow& Rnbifklw, {an nqun}gnfbnr id Ri~{a/Ncr{
Crgcf bi~f{}gnr mw lgmn}clgxgfj {ang} nbifiognr gf3715r mnbcon {an r{c}r id nbifiogb j}iz{a cfkkntnliuonf{ gf nc}lw 3775r& [ag}klw, Gfkgc‗rnqun}gnfbn zg{a g{r dg}r{ jnfn}c{gif nbifiogb }ndi}or
cfk {an bi~f{}w‗r nbifiogb j}iz{a un}di}ocfbn zcrbifrgkn}nk cr rcdn actnfr di} DKG zagba lnk {irnbifk jnfn}c{gif id nbifiogb }ndi}or gf Gfkgc gfdg}r{ knbckn id {agr bnf{~}w& Di~}{alw, {an}n gr cbifrgkn}cmln bacfjn gf {an c{{g{~kn id mi{a {ankntnliugfj cfk kntnliunk bi~f{}gnr {izc}kr DKG&[anw mi{a bifrgkn} DKG cr {an oir{ r~g{cmln di}o id nq{n}fcl dgfcfbn& Dgd{alw, {an}n gr cf gfb}ncrn gfbioun{g{gif di} DKG gfdlizr uc}{gb~lc}lw coifj {ankntnliugfj fc{gifr&
TG& RI^]BNR ID KC[C
[an r{~kw gr mcrnk if rnbifkc}w kc{c zagba gr
u~mlgrank ri~}bnr id kc{c billnb{nk d}io tc}gi~rri~}bnr& [an kc{c zcr nq{}cb{nk d}io {an dillizgfjri~}bnr0 Acfkmii` id R{c{gr{gbr if {an Gfkgcfnbifiow, ]MG, tc}gi~r grr~nr, ^FB[CK, ZG] rn}gnr, tc}gi~r grr~nr, Nbifiogb R~}tnw, Jitn}fonf{id Gfkgc, tc}gi~r grr~nr, Zi}lk Kntnliuonf{Gfkgbc{i}r, Zi}lk Mcf`, Knuc}{onf{ id Gfk~r{}gclUilgbw cfk U}ioi{gif !KGUU', Rnb}n{c}gc{ id Gfk~r{}gcl Crrgr{cfbn !RGC', Bnf{}cl R{c{gr{gbclI}jcfgxc{gif !BRI'&
AWUI[ANRGR[an awui{anrnr di} {an r{~kw c}n {i {nr{
zan{an} DKG gfdliz raizr c uirg{gtn {}nfk itn} {an
r{~kw un}gik&
TGG& ]NR^L[ CFK KGRB^RRGIFR
[}nfkr gf DKG Gfdlizr k~}gfj =535/33 {i =53;/3>
Cd{n} cfclwxgfj {an til~on id DKG Gfdlizrgf Gfkgc, k~}gfj {an U}n cfk Uir{ Lgmn}clgxc{gif un}gik{an {}nfk gf DKG gfdlizr di} fnq{ dgtn wnc}r g&n&, d}io=535/33 {i =53;/3> gr mngfj u}ihnb{nk& [an
u}ihnb{gif id DKG gfdliz {i {an bi~f{}w gr nr{goc{nk mw ~rgfj C~{i ]nj}nrrgif Oitgfj Ctn}cjn!C]GOC' oiknl& [an }nr~l{r id {an oiknl c}nr~ooc}gxnk gf {cmln 3&3 cfk {an nr{goc{nk DKGgfdlizr d}io =535/33 {i =53;/3> gr {cm~lc{nk gf {cmln3&=&
[cmln 3&38 ]nr~l{ id C]GOC oiknl id DKG Gfdlizr
Oiknl
Bindd gbgnf{
R{k&N}}i} id Binddgbg
nf{
{tcl~n
utcl~n
C]3 3&;;7 5&317
:&4;7
5&555((
C]= /&4>= 5&=31
=&711
5&557((
Wnc} 1;57&4>3
=>3:&=42
2&2;5
5&55;((
Bif / >52 2& 5&55
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =5>
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 221/223
r{cf{ 34:15=;1&;27
:54:&=5 223 ;((
(( knfi{nr rgjfgdgbcfbn c{ 3. lntnlLij Lg`nlgaiik 8 /
=54&7:2Cl`clgfn‗r Gfdi}oc{gif B}g{n}gif !CGB'8
;=3&7;4Rbazc}x‗r Mcwnrgcf B}g{n}gif !RMB' 8
;=>&:=;D}io {an cmitn }nr~l{, {an u/tcl~n id {an bifr{cf{,
dg}r{ cfk rnbifk lcj gr tn}w lnrr& [agr gfkgbc{nr {ac{{an dg{ gr jiik& D~}{an}, {an Cl`clgfn‗r Gfdi}oc{gifB}g{n}gif !CGB' cfk Rbazc}x‗r Mcwnrgcf B}g{n}gif!RMB' mi{a oncr~}n jiikfnrr id dg{ cfk cbbi~f{ di} oiknl bioulnqg{w& [an C]GOC oiknl ns~c{gif gr
dg{{nk cr ,!DKG'{ ? /34:15=;1&;27 3&;;7 !DKG'{/3 /
5&4>= !DKG'{/= ξ{ Zan}n, !DKG'{ ? dg}r{ i}kn} kgddn}nfbn gf DKG ?
!DKG'{ / !DKG'{/3
[cmln 3&=8 Nr{goc{nk DKG Gfdlizr gf Gfkgc k~}gfj =535/33{i =53;/3>
!Coi~f{ ]r& Gf B}&'
Wnc}
Nr{goc{nk
Coi~f{
. id J}iz{agf DKGitn}
U}ntgi~rwnc}
7>. BifdgknfbnLgog{
Lizn} BL
^uun} BL
=53
5/33
3:1,
335 3
3;4,
353
=35,3
=5=533/3=
3:=,155 /2
333,>=1
=2;,5:3
=53=/32
34>,4== /;
:7,=:7
=>3,744
=532/3;
345,215 /2
>>,344
=4>,>7>
=53;/3>
3>7,343 /3
;3,315
=::,3;=
Dgj& 3&3 8 U}ihnb{gif id DKG Gfdlizr gf Gfkgc d}io =535/33{i =53;/3>
[cmln 3&= raizr c oc}jgfcl gfb}ncrn id ifn
un}bnf{ gf DKG gfdliz cr zanf biouc}nk {i {an
un}gik =557/35& [anf d}io {an un}gik =533/3= {i=53;/3> c kizf{}nfk id DKG gfdliz gr imrn}tnk& DKGgfdliz gf{i Gfkgc gr nr{goc{nk {i mn ]r&3:=155 b}i}ngf =533/3= cr cjcgfr{ ]r&3:1335 b}i}n gf =535/33,
{ac{ gr, {an j}iz{a {}nfk id DKG gfdliz gf{i {anbi~f{}w raizr c knblgfn id 2 un}bnf{ gf =533/3= crzanf biouc}nk {i =535/33& [agr dcll gf DKG gfdlizgf{i {an bi~f{}w gr nqunb{nk {i d~}{an} knblgfn k~}gfj=53=/32, {ac{ gr, c ; un} bnf{ knblgfn zgll mncf{gbguc{nk cr cjcgfr{ {an u}ntgi~r wnc}& K~}gfj=532/3; cfk =53;/3>, {an dcll gf j}iz{a }c{n id DKGgfdliz gr di~fk {i mn }nk~bnk {i 2 un}bnf{ cfk ifn
un} bnf{ cr cjcgfr{ {an u}ntgi~r wnc}r& [an u}ihnb{gifid DKG gfdliz gf Gfkgc di} {an fnq{ dgtn wnc} un}gikd}io =535/33 {i =53;/3>, raizr {ac{ DKG gf{i {anbi~f{}w zgll actn c kizfzc}k {}nfk d}io =533/3=ifzc}kr& [an}ndi}n, Jitn}fonf{ rai~lk {c`n r~g{cmln
r{nur {i itn}bion {agr rg{~c{gif&[}nfkr gf Rn}tgbn Rnb{i}
Dg}r{ id cll zn imrn}tn {ac{ {an DKG gfdliz gfrn}tgbnr acr mnnf uanfionfcl gf {an lcr{ {ziknbcknr& Rgfbn {an ifrn{ id lgmn}clgxc{gif, {an bi~f{}w}nbngtnk c a~jn coi~f{ id DKG gf rn}tgbn rnb{i}
mnbc~rn id {an {}nonfki~r j}iz{a ui{nf{gcl {ac{ g{ uirrnrrnr& [agr rnb{i} acr }cf`nk coifj {an {iu {nfrnb{i}r c{{}cb{gfj DKG rgfbn 3773& Rn}tgbnr zagbabiou}grn id dgfcfbgcl cfk fif dgfcfbgcl rn}tgbnr,
mcf`gfj rn}tgbnr cfk gfr~}cfbn, i~{ri~}bgfj cfk}nrnc}ba cfk kntnliuonf{ rn}tgbnr }nbi}knk {ag}k
ulcbn k~}gfj 3773/77 cfk =555/5> mw c{{}cb{gfj 7&:3
cfk 7&43 un}bnf{ id {i{cl DKG gfdlizr k~}gfj {an {zi un}gikr& Aizntn}, g{ oitnk {i }cf` ifn mw ckkgfj==&74 un}bnf{ rac}n {i {an b~o~lc{gtn DKG di} {an
un}gik d}io =554 {i =535&Coifj {an r~m rnb{i}r id rn}tgbnr rnb{i}r,
dgfcfbgcl rn}tgbnr c{{}cb{ 7&32 un}bnf{ id {i{cl DKGgfdlizr& G{ gr dilliznk mw mcf`gfj rn}tgbnr =&33
un}bnf{, gfr~}cfbn 3&>= un}bnf{, fif/dgfcfbgclrn}tgbnr =&57 un}bnf{, i~{ri~}bgfj 5&:= un}bnf{,}nrnc}ba cfk kntnliuonf{ =&22 un}bnf{, bi~}gn} 5&2=
un}bnf{ cfk i{an} rn}tgbnr 2&21 un}bnf{ }nrunb{gtnlw&Oc~}g{g~r zcr ulcbnk {an {iu id {an bac}{ mw gftnr{gfj;2&57 un}bnf{ gf rn}tgbn rnb{i} dilliznk mw Rgfjcui}n32&11 un}bnf{, ^@ mw 33&=3 un}bnf{ cfk ^RC mw 1&>=
un}bnf{& DKG gfdlizr gf rn}tgbn rnb{i} c}n anctglwbifbnf{}c{nk c}i~fk {zi ochi} bg{gnr gf Gfkgc {ac{ gr,O~omcg mw 4=&75 un}bnf{ cfk Knlag 3=&;1 un}bnf{&
D~}{an} ~rgfj C~{i ]nj}nrrgif Oitgfj Ctn}cjn!C]GOC' oiknl DKG gfdliz gf Rn}tgbn Rnb{i} gr
u}ihnb{nk di} fnq{ dgtn wnc}r& [an }nr~l{r id {an oiknlc}n r~ooc}gxnk mnliz /
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =54
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 222/223
[cmln 3&28 ]nr~l{ id C]GOC oiknl id DKG Gfdlizr {i Rn}tgbnRnb{i}
C& O
iknl
Binddgbgnf{
R{k&N}}i} id
Binddgbgnf{
{tcl~
n
utcl~n
C]35&252 5&2=5
5&7;4
5&2:=
Wnc} =1:>3&;12 171;&==7
2&=55
5&532(
Bifr{cf{
>:>34>2:&4;:
3155;;=3&>>1
2&37>
5&532(
(( knfi{nr rgjfgdgbcfbn c{ 3. lntnl
Lij Lg`nlgaiik 8 /32:&;5>
Cl`clgfn‗r Gfdi}oc{gif B}g{n}gif !CGB' 8=15&135
Rbazc}x‗r Mcwnrgcf B}g{n}gif !RMB' 8=1=&55;
[an cmitn }nr~l{ raizr {ac{ {an u/tcl~n id {anbifr{cf{ cfk dg}r{ lcj gr tn}w lnrr& G{ gfkgbc{nr {ac{ {an{nr{ gr dg{& D~}{an}, {an Cl`clgfn‗r fdi}oc{gif B}g{n}gif!CGB' cfkRbazc}x‗r Mcwnrgcf B}g{n}gif !RMB' mi{a
oncr~}n iikfnrr id dg{ cfk cbbi~f{ di} oiknlbioulnqg{w& [an C]GOC oiknl ns~c{gif gr dg{{nk cr,
!DKG'{ ? />:>34>2:&4;: 5&252 !DKG'{/3 ξ{
zan}n, !DKG'{ ? dg}r{ i}kn} kgddn}nfbn gf DKG ?!DKG'{ / !DKG'{/3
M& [cmln 3&; 8 Cb{~cl cfk nr{goc{nk tcl~nr id
DKG Gfdlizr {i Rn}tgbn Rnb{i}
!Coi~f{ ]r& gf Ogllgif'
B
nc}
Cb{~cl
Tcl~nr
Nr{goc{nkTcl~nr
7>.Bifdgknfbn
Lgog{
.id
J}iz{agf
DKGitn} U}ntgi~r
Wnc}
K&
izn
} BL
^ uun}
BL
3773/77
;5,2:4&1=
/
;=,2=3&;7
/
=45,5=5&3;
3:>,2
::&34 /
=555
3,143&>5
33,>53&;1
/3:=,;2>
&12
37>,;21&:
7 /
=553
1,=5=&=;
37,1>7&1=
/345,>:3
&=5
=55,=75&1
22
;3
=55=
3>,
;23&27
;3,
13:&51
/324,=3=
&:3
=37,1;4&1
:
1
1=552
32,752&>7
4;,5;2&41
/33=,:2>
&55
=;5,1==&2
4/
35
=55;
33,;>>&12
12,43>&;>
/72,514&
44
=45,23:&>
4/
31
=55>
23,;>>&3;
35=,751&2
=
/:;,172&
=:
=15,:57&7
33
:>
=55 3:1 3=7 / 2 ;
4 ,>1;&:;
,554&;2
>3,5;7&3:
57,54=&5
=
41
=55: 3;>
,577&>=
372,4;4&2
:35,=
=;&1=
2::,54:&7
=/
37
=551 227
,;:>&3=
=52,>=7&4
13>,4
17&71
273,247&2
13
2;
=55
7 =:7,31=&>
;
=1=,;72&3
517,=
>>&==
;
:>,:25&7
1/
31
=535 =1;
,=;7&=:
1;,:3=&:5
;12,:1>&1
; =
=533 25>
,1=5&=7
:2,471&>>
>2:,7;=&5
2 1
=53= 22=
,27;&17 13,4=>&73
>12,3
42&1: 7
=532 245
,;14&;3
72,77>&45
4=4,7::&=
= 1
=53; 217
,52:&1=
35:,3:3&=:
4:5,75;&2
4 1
=53> ;3:
,:=1&4;
3=5,3;7&35
:3>,251&3
1 :
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =5:
zzz&crkd&i}j&gf § =53= 88 [nbafi Di}~o ]nrnc}ba cfk Kntnliuonf{ Bnf{}n, Uifkgban}}w, Gfkgc zzz&gbbc&i}j&gf
7/21/2019 ICCA Volume 4
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/icca-volume-4 223/223
Fi{n8 Cb{~cl tcl~nr biouglnk d}io RGC, Fnzrln{{n},=557&
Dgj& 3&=8 [}nfkr gf Rn}tgbn Rnb{i}
rn}tgbn rnb{i} {i nfacfbn g{r un}di}ocfbn cfk clri {ibif{}gm~{n oi}n gf Gfkgcf nbifiow&
]NDN]NFBNR
P3_& Ckg{wc @] Mchch cfk Rzcr{g` Fgjco “Jlimclgxc{gif gf{an Gfkgcf Uac}ocbn~{gbcl Gfk~r{}w ‒ Di}ngjf Kg}nb{ Gftnr{onf{rugllitn}r cfk goulgbc{gifr if Kionr{gb U}ik~b{gtg{w8 3773/=55:‟,gr c }nrnc}ba u}ihnb{ kifn ~fkn} GGO Caonkcmck, =55:&
P=_& Cff~cl R~}tnw id Gfk~r{}gnr, Ogfgr{}w id R{c{grg{gbr cfkU}ij}coon Goulnonf{c{gif, Jitn}fonf{ id Gfkgc, tc}gi~r grr~nr
P2_& Ctg` Bac`}cmc}{g !=552', “C [ani}w id {an ruc{gclkgr{}gm~{gif id Di}ngjf Kg}nb{ Gftnr{onf{,‟ Gf{n}fc{gifcl ]ntgnz id Nbifiogbr $ Dgfcfbn, Til~on 3=, Grr~n =, =552, uu& 3;7/347&
P;_& Mclcr~m}cocfwco&T&F cfk Kctgk Rucrdi}k, “KinrGfkgc fnnk c li{ oi}n DKG9‟ Nbifiogb cfk Uilg{gbcllw Znn`lw,Cu}gl =1, =55:&
P>_ Mclcr~fkc}co Ocfgco cfk Cog{gctc Bac{{n}hnn “[an
U}ib& id {an Rnbifk Gf{n}fc{gifcl Bifdn}nfbn if Biou~{n} Cuulgbc{gifr =53= PGBBC =53=_ =51