I. Vasculitis pages 2 – 14 II. Microcrystalline arthritis ...€¦ · Metabolic Bone Disease...
Transcript of I. Vasculitis pages 2 – 14 II. Microcrystalline arthritis ...€¦ · Metabolic Bone Disease...
1
DEPARTMENT ABSTRACTS – 2005 - 2006
I. Vasculitis pages 2 – 14
II. Microcrystalline arthritis 15-17
III. Scleroderma and Raynaud's vasospasm 18
IV. Epidemiology and Outcome 19-21
V. Psoriatic arthritis 22-23
VI. Metabolic Bone Disease 24-30
2
I. Vasculitis
Wegener granulomatosis: customized treatment using cyclophosphamide and
methotrexate.
A 12 year single-practice experience.
Alexandra Villa-Forte, Tiffany M. Clark, Marcelo Gomes, John Carey, Edward Mascha,
Matthew T. Karafa, Susana Arrigain, Gerald Roberson and Gary S. Hoffman
Purpose: To assess outcomes of therapy for Wegener's granulomatosis using customized
treatment strategies that limits or completely avoids the use of cyclophosphamide.
Methods: Patients were included if they primarily received care within Cleveland Clinic
Center for Vasculitis Care and Research and met American College of Rheumatology criteria
for Wegener's granulomatosis. A primary goal was to assess methotrexate utility in limiting or
avoiding cyclophosphamide use. Patients in whom treatment primarily included cytotoxic
agents other than methotrexate and/or cyclophosphamide were excluded. In the presence of
severe disease, remission-induction was attempted with use of cyclophosphamide. For mild to
moderate disease, methotrexate was the initial treatment for all patients in whom serum
creatinine was less than 2mg/dl. Following initial improvement of severe disease after
cyclophosphamide use, patients were treated with methotrexate if serum creatinine was less
than 2mg/dl. Disease activity was measured based on the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity
Score, as modified for Wegener's granulomatosis.
Results: Eighty-three patients from among 250 referred to Center for Vasculitis Care and
Research with Wegener's granulomatosis met eligibility criteria. Seventy percent of patients
initially had severe disease and received a short course of cyclophosphamide for remission-
induction. In over half of these patients, illness was judged to be severe because of pulmonary
hemorrhage, rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis, including need for dialysis, or neurologic
abnormalities. Sixty-three percent of patients with severe illness presented with serum
creatinine values that were > 2.0 mg/dl. The two disease severity groups did not differ in time
required to achieve remission. All patients improved, remission was achieved in 50% within 6
months and 72% within 12 months. Sustained remission (> 6months) was ultimately achieved
in 77% of all patients and this end point did not differ between severity subsets. Among the 76
patients who achieved remission of any duration, 45% relapsed within 1 year and 66% relapsed
within 2 years. There were no differences in relapse rates or relapse disease activity scores
between groups. Eighty-two percent of relapsed patients achieved subsequent remissions after
additional treatment. About ¾ of relapses were mild and promptly responded to treatment.
Eighty-six percent of relapsed patients suffered disease exacerbations after methotrexate
therapy was withdrawn or in the process of being discontinued. None of the patients developed
CYC-induced cystitis or bladder cancer. Only 3.7% of patients died over a median period of
4.5 years. No deaths were due to active disease.
Conclusions: In patients with Wegener's granulomatosis, a strategy that limits or avoids
cyclophosphamide therapy has produced excellent outcomes as judged by survival and
infrequent long-term cyclophosphamide toxicity. Frequent relapses have been mild in the great
3
majority of patients. This may be related to close clinical and laboratory monitoring of disease
activity and treatment-related adverse events. While this approach has diminished mortality,
relapses still lead to incremental permanent morbidity in most patients.
4
Temporal artery gene expression profiles may predict conditions necessary for
developing giant cell arteritis. Rula Hajj-Ali, Thomas Hamilton, Michael Lee, Jianbo Li, Jose Hernandez-Rodriguez, Maria
C. Cid, Ana García-Martínez, Earl Brown, Richard Prayson, Gary S. Hoffman
Purpose: Pathogenesis of giant cell arteritis (GCA) remains incompletely understood. It is
uncertain whether abnormalities that occur during the aging process of the vessel wall and/or
the immune system play an important role in establishing disease vulnerability. We sought to
identify gene expression changes that occur in the vessel wall before overt inflammation that
may lead to GCA.
Methods: Gene expression profiling using RNA obtained from thirteen temporal artery
biopsies (5 from patients with GCA and 8 from controls) was carried out using Affymetrix
HGU133 Plus 2 GeneChips. Patients with GCA met modified 1990 ACR criteria for GCA.
Samples from patients with unequivocal GCA in which temporal artery biopsies showed no
evidence of histologic disease were compared with biopsies from patients who did not have
GCA. The data sets were analyzed using the random forests algorithm, a Classification and
Regression Tree based procedure. Gene probes exhibiting significantly increased or diminished
expression in samples from patients with GCA as compared to controls were ranked according
to the magnitude of difference and the top 50 probes were further examined for their biological
relevance.
Results: Genes showing markedly elevated expression in temporal artery biopsies from GCA
patients included those involved in transcriptional regulation (ZNF709, ZNF568, CRSP9,
ZNF131, ZNF585A) and apoptosis/anti-apoptosis (BNIP1, PAFAH2). In contrast, genes
exhibiting reduced expression included metallopeptidases (ADAMTSL3), DNA damage
response (GTSE1), anti-inflammatory activity (IL18BP) and fibroblast growth factor receptor
(FGFR1).
Conclusion: These findings suggest that the gene expression profile in temporal arteries from
GCA patients exhibits changes that precede overt inflammation and vessel injury. These
changes may set the stage in vessel substrate to “invite” the injury that is later recognized as
GCA.
5
Takayasu’s arteritis: guarded outcomes in an American cohort Kathleen Maksimowicz-McKinnon, Tiffany M. Clark, Gary S. Hoffman
Purpose: Describe clinical, laboratory, and radiographic manifestations of Takayasu’s
arteritis (TAK) in an American cohort. 2) Evaluate response to interventions, remission and
relapse rates, and disease progression. 3) Compare these observations to cohorts from the
United States, Japan, India, Italy and Mexico.
Methods: Seventy-five patients were retrospectively studied using a uniform database that
included clinical, laboratory and imaging data. Vascular imaging studies were performed at
least yearly to monitor disease progression.
Results: Ninety-two percent of patients were Caucasian; 89% female. Median age at onset
was 26 years; median duration of follow up was 3.0 years. Common manifestations
included loss or asymmetry of pulse (57%), limb blood pressure discrepancy (53%), and
bruits (53%). Eleven percent of patients were asymptomatic prior to disease diagnosis.
Angiographic studies demonstrated aortic abnormalities in 79% of patients. Subclavian
(65%) and carotid (43%) arteries were also frequently affected.
Ninety-three percent of longitudinally followed patients attained disease remission of any
duration, but only 28% attained a sustained remission of at least 6 months duration while
receiving less than 10mg of prednisone/day. Both angioplasty and vascular surgery
procedures were initially successful, but recurrent stenosis occurred in 78% of angioplasty
and 36% of bypass/reconstruction procedures.
Disease manifestations in our cohort are similar to the NIH, Italian, Japanese and Mexican
cohorts in female predominance and disease manifestations, but differed from the Indian
cohort in that the latter group had a higher frequency of males, abdominal aortic
involvement, and hypertension.
Conclusions: While symptomatic improvement usually follows glucocorticosteroid
therapy, relapses usually occur in Takayasu's arteritis with dose reduction. Attempts to
restore vascular patency are often initially successful, but restenosis occurs frequently.
Chronic morbidity and disability occurs in most patients with Takayasu arteritis in the
United States.
6
Anti-Endothelial Cell Antibodies in Patients with Wegener’s Granulomatosis:
Prevalence and Correlation with Disease Manifestations and Activity JK Sebastian, A Mahr, JH Stone, Z Romay-Penabad, JC Davis, GS Hoffman, WJ McCune,
EW St. Clair, U Specks, R Spiera, S Pierangeli, and PA Merkel, for the Wegener’s
Granulomatosis Etanercept Trial Research Group.
Purpose: In small vessel vasculitis, such as Wegener’s granulomatosis (WG), histological
examination reveals endothelial cell damage. Previous studies in small cohorts of patients with
anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA) associated vasculitis have yielded conflicting
data regarding the prevalence of AECA and its use as a measure of disease activity ranging
from 20% to 100%. This study examined a large, well characterized cohort of patients with
WG and active disease for the presence of AECA.
Methods: Serum from subjects with WG who participated in a clinical therapeutic trial for
WG was collected at baseline, when all subjects had active disease. Disease activity was
measured using the BVAS/WG and clinical manifestations documented. Serum AECA (IgG)
was measured in all specimens by cyto-ELISA using unfixed human umbilical vein endothelial
cells (HUVEC). Analyses were computed by Student's t-tests and linear regression.
Results: Serum samples were evaluated for 173 patients enrolled in the trial. At baseline, 34
of 173 (19.6%) had elevated titers of AECA. Disease activity did not differ between patients
with AECA (mean BVAS/WG = 7.32 ± 3.18) or without AECA (mean BVAS/WG = 6.96 ±
3.32, p = 0.579 for difference) (Figure). Among patients positive for AECA, AECA antibody
titer did not correlate with BVAS/WG score; R = 0.09 (p = 0.57). There were no differences in
the frequency of major clinical manifestations between patients with AECA, including upper
airway, pulmonary, renal, and neurologic systems, or thrombosis.
Conclusion: AECA, as measured using HUVEC, are not highly prevalent among patients
with active WG (19.6%), are not associated with specific clinical manifestations, and do not
correlate with level of disease activity. These data question the usefulness of AECA as a
marker of disease activity in WG. Future studies should consider utilizing organ-specific adult
endothelial cells as the target for the AECA.
7
Reevaluation of the Weighting System of the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity
Score for Wegener’s Granulomatosis AD Mahr
1, T Neogi
1, H Xie
1, JC Davis
2, GS Hoffman
3, WJ McCune
4, U Specks
5, R Spiera
6, EW
St. Clair7, JH Stone
8, PA Merkel
1 for the WGET Research Group.
1Boston University, Boston, MA,
2University of California, San Francisco, CA,
3Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH,
4University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 5Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN,
6Hospital for Special Surgery, New York,
NY, 7Duke University, Durham, NC,
8Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD.
Purpose: The Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score for Wegener’s granulomatosis (BVAS/WG) is a
validated instrument that quantifies disease activity as the weighted sum of defined manifestations plus
‘other’ signs that can be added. The item weighting was originally developed based on expert opinion
and not a data-driven approach. The aim of this study was to generate and evaluate a data-driven
weighting system for the BVAS/WG.
Methods: We used data from the Wegener’s granulomatosis etanercept trial (WGET). At each trial
visit, both BVAS/WG and a 10-cm visual analog scale for physician global assessment (PGA) were
completed. Taking the PGA as the explanatory variable, we calculated weights for: i) all 34 BVAS/WG
items (rated in ≥ 5 visits); ii) ‘other’ manifestations; and iii) an additional ‘new/worse’ variable
(invoked when ≥ 1 item was rated ‘new/worse’). Construct validity of the ‘modified’ BVAS/WG (using
the data-driven weights) were assessed for the baseline visits by correlations with PGA and compared
to the ‘original’ BVAS/WG (weights of 3 for severe and 1 for non-severe manifestations) and an
‘unweighted’ BVAS/WG (all items weighted 1). Analyses used linear regression with generalized
equation estimates and Pearson’s correlations.
Results: For the 180 WGET subjects, BVAS/WG and PGA data were available for 2020 visits.
Twenty-five BVAS/WG items were reported in ≥ 5 visits; the derived weights for these 25 items plus
‘other severe’, ‘other non-severe’, and ‘new/worse’ are shown in the Table.
Correlation coefficients with PGA of the ‘modified’ vs. ‘original’ vs. ‘unweighted’ BVAS/WG
were as follows: all baseline visits (N = 177), 0.70 vs. 0.62 vs. 0.52; baseline visits with ‘severe’ disease
(N = 106), 0.72 vs, 0.67 vs. 0.56; baseline visits with ‘limited’ disease (N = 71)*, 0.51 vs. 0.28 vs. 0.28
(*P = 0.02 for comparison of ‘modified’ and ‘original’ correlation coefficients).
Data-Driven Weights for 29 Variables of BVAS/WG (original weights in parentheses)
Sign/symptom Weight Sign/symptom Weight
Alveolar hemorrhage 20 (3) Nasal discharge/crusting 6 (1)
Red blood cell casts 18 (3) Other non-severe 6 (1)
≥ 30% creatinine rise 17 (3) Motor neuropathy 5 (3)
Sensory neuropathy 16 (3) Arthralgia/arthritis 5 (1)
Pulmonary nodules or cavities 12 (1) Purpura 5 (1)
Other infiltrates 12 (1) Skin ulcers 5 (1)
Hematuria 12 (1) Retroorbital mass/proptosis 5 (1)
Other severe 11 (3) Fever 4 (1)
Cranial nerve palsy 9 (3) Conductive deafness 2 (1)
Sensorineural deafness 9 (1) Endobronchial involvement 1 (1)
Sinus involvement 8 (1) Mouth ulcers 1 (1)
Subglottic inflammation 8 (1) Conjunctivitis/episcleritis 1 (1)
Pleurisy 8 (1) Swollen salivary gland 1 (1)
Scleritis 6 (3) New/worse 11 (–)
Conclusions: This study suggests that a data-driven weighting system enhances the construct validity
of BVAS/WG, especially for patients with low-medium disease activity. The potentially greater
precision and wider range of scores of such a modified BVAS/WG may better capture the wide
spectrum of disease activity in WG, and detect more subtle therapeutic effects. These findings warrant
confirmation in an independent sample.
8
Limited versus Severe Wegener’s Granulomatosis: Outcomes and response to
therapy in the Wegener’s Granulomatosis Etanercept Trial Seo P, Min Y-I, Holbrook JT, Hoffman GS, Merkel PA, Spiera R, Davis JC, Ytterberg S, St.
Clair EW, Specks U, and Stone JH for the WGET Research Group
Purpose: In the Wegener’s Granulomatosis Etanercept Trial (WGET), all patients received
standard immunosuppressive therapy. The addition of etanercept to standard therapies had no
effect on disease outcomes. Because the experimental therapy had no discernable effect, the
WGET cohort provides a unique opportunity to compare outcomes among patients with limited
versus severe disease. This study compares the accumulation of damage and response to
therapy of patients with limited or severe Wegener’s granulomatosis enrolled in the WGET.
Methods: Patients in the WGET cohort were stratified by disease classification (i.e., limited
versus severe disease), and the frequency with which patients with limited or severe disease
experienced disease flares, remission, sustained remission, or sustained low disease activity
was calculated. Disease activity was scored at each trial visit by means of the Birmingham
Vasculitis Activity Score for Wegener’s Granulomatosis (BVAS/WG). Patients’ quality of life
was self-reported at each trial visit on the Short-Form 36 version 2 health survey (SF-36). Data
relating to the Vasculitis Damage Index (VDI) were collected at baseline and at the end of the
trial.
Results: The 180 patients in the WGET cohort experienced a total of 261 disease flares,
including 210 limited disease flares and 51 severe disease flares. Patients with limited
Wegener’s granulomatosis were at substantially higher risk for disease flare (hazard ratio (HR)
1.80; 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.29, 2.52; P<0.001), largely due to an increased risk of
limited disease flares (HR 1.89, 95% CI 1.31-2.73; P<0.001). Patients with severe disease
were significantly more likely to achieve disease remission (HR 1.49, 95% CI 1.06-2.12;
P=0.023), sustained disease remission (HR 1.49, 95% CI 1.01-2.22; P=0.047) and sustained
low disease activity (HR 1.67, 95% CI 1.16-2.38, P=0.005) than patients with limited disease.
At trial entry, patients with limited disease were more likely to report otolaryngologic damage
(53.8% versus 25.0%, P<0.01), while patients with severe disease were more likely to report
renal damage (1.9% versus 22.6%, P<0.01). The distribution of other forms of damage did not
differ significantly among patients with limited versus severe disease phenotypes. The median
VDI score at the end of the trial for patients in both groups was 1 (P=0.53). The mental and
physical component summary scales of the SF-36 did not differ between patients with limited
versus severe disease, either at trial entry or at the end of the trial.
Conclusions: Despite different phenotypes and medication exposures, patients with limited
and severe Wegener’s granulomatosis experience overlapping forms of damage and report
similar effects on their quality of life. Patients with the limited form of Wegener’s
granulomatosis, however, are at substantially higher risk of disease flare than patients with
severe Wegener’s granulomatosis.
9
Antineutrophil Cytoplasmic Antibodies Against Proteinase 3 Do Not Predict
Disease Relapses in Wegener’s Granulomatosis Javier D. Finkielman, Peter A. Merkel, Darrell Schroeder, Gary S. Hoffman, Robert Spiera, E.
William St. Clair, John C. Davis, W. Joseph McCune, Andrea K. Tibbs, Steven R. Ytterberg,
Amber M. Hummel, Margaret A. Viss, Tobias Peikert, John H. Stone, and Ulrich Specks for
the WGET Research Group
Background: The clinical utility of ANCA levels to guide the management of patients with
Wegener’s granulomatosis (WG) remains controversial. A recent study suggested that ANCA
against pro-PR3 might correlate better with disease activity than ANCA against mature-PR3.
The main objectives of this study were to determine if the levels of pro- versus mature-PR3-
ANCA correlate better with disease activity; and if increases in their levels predict relapses.
Methods: Clinical data and serum samples of 156 patients with WG collected prospectively
during a recent randomized trial were included. PR3-ANCA levels were measured by capture
ELISA, and disease activity by the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score for WG.
Results: A weak association with disease activity was found for both mature- (r2=0.030,
P=0.031) and pro-PR3-ANCA levels (r2=0.038, P=0.016) at baseline. Similar findings in
individual patients were obtained from repeated assessments over time using multiple linear
regression analysis (partial r2=0.069, P<0.001 for mature-PR3-ANCA; partial r
2=0.049,
P<0.001 for pro-PR3-ANCA).
The median time to sustained remission was 12 months among patients whose mature-PR3-
ANCA levels decreased over the initial four visits (approximately 6 months) versus 19 months
among patients whose mature-PR3-ANCA levels did not decrease (unadjusted P= 0.017,
adjusted P= 0.043). This analysis did not achieve statistical significance for pro-PR3-ANCA
levels (unadjusted P= 0.123; adjusted P= 0.284).
Cox proportional hazards regression analyses showed that neither increases in mature- (hazard
ratio: 1.0, 95% C.I.: 0.5 to 1.9, P=0.973) nor pro-PR3-ANCA levels (hazard ratio: 1.0, 95%
C.I.: 0.5 to 1.9, P=0.915) predicted relapses. The proportion of patients that relapsed within 1-
year following an increase in ANCA levels was 40% for mature-PR3 (95% C.I.: 18 to 56), and
43% for pro-PR3 (95% C.I.: 22 to 58).
Conclusion: No advantage of measuring pro- versus mature-PR3-ANCA was found in this
study. Increases in PR3-ANCA levels do not predict relapses and should not be used to guide
immunosuppressive therapy.
10
THE TREATMENT OF GIANT CELL ARTERITIS WITH BIOLOGIC
AGENTS (2005 International workshop on GCA)
Gary S. Hoffman M.D., M.S.
Giant Cell (Temporal) Arteritis (GCA)
Although the signs and symptoms of GCA are exquisitely sensitive to treatment with high
doses of glucocorticosteroids (GCS), morbidity from treatment and GCA itself is substantial.
Morbidity includes visual loss in 5-25% of patients, which although better than in the era
preceding GCS (30-60% blindness), is still a terrible handicap for the already impaired elderly
patient. In one population-based study, 17% of GCA patients developed aortic aneurysms that
were sometimes associated with dissection or vessel rupture. Aortic branch vessel stenoses
may cause extremity (upper > lower) claudication (15%). Patients may also experience
polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR) (~50%), constitutional symptoms (~50%) and stroke (0-5%).
Whereas some early reports of GCA treatment suggested that GCS may only be necessary for
6-12 months, in 1973, Beevers et al. recognized the chronic nature of this illness and noted that
in many cases GCS therapy may be required for several years. Indeed, this is now a widely
accepted observation. Relapse rates in the course of GCS tapering have been reportedly ~30 –
> 80% over 1-4 years of follow up. After 2-3 years of therapy about 50% of patients remain
GCS-dependent. The risk of fractures and cataracts are 5 and 3 times greater, respectively, in
patients with GCA compared to age-matched controls not treated with GCS. Nesher et al.
found that among 43 patients followed for a mean period of 3 years, 35% had fractures and
21% had severe infections, which in 2/3 of cases lead to death. An important role for GCS
could be implicated in 37% of all deaths. The need for prolonged GCS therapy to control
GCA, and the goal of reducing disease- and treatment-related morbidity and mortality, has lead
investigators to explore the use of adjunctive agents to improve outcomes.
Adjunctive Therapy in GCA Numerous studies have explored the utility of either methotrexate or azathioprine as a means of
achieving improved disease control and less dependence on GCS therapy. Two randomized,
double-blind, placebo-controlled studies of weekly methotrexate (MTX) have been completed.
In both, the rate of GCS taper was rapid, so that in the absence of relapse, GCS withdrawal
could be accomplished in four months or 6 months. In both studies relapses were frequent and
the first relapse occurred with equal frequency in the GCS-only and GCS + MTX groups.
However, the frequency with which more than one relapse occurred differed between groups in
one study and not the other. Jover et. al. found that MTX diminished second relapses and
cumulative GCS use, whereas Hoffman et al. did not find MTX to be beneficial. The reason
for these different conclusions is uncertain. Consequently, what role MTX or other adjunctive
therapies may play in GCA remains unsettled.
Rationale for Biologic Agents in the Treatment of GCA
Although the pathogenesis of GCA has not been completely elucidated, our understanding of
the disease has grown substantially. Biopsy specimens obtained at different stages in the
evolution of vascular lesions have revealed that inflammatory cells are initially concentrated in
the adventitia and are absent or sparse in the intima, and there being an intermediate presence
in the media. Mononuclear cells migrate into the vessel wall from the adventitia. Slow flow of
blood in the adventitial microcirculation (vasa vasorum) compared to the larger vessel lumen
favors developing initial vessel wall inflammation in this location. CD4+ T cells, and CD68+
11
macrophages are more commonly found in the adventitia and the intima than in the media.
Giant cells appear to be formed from macrophages that are recruited from the adventitia and
traverse the media, later also appearing in the intima of the large vessel lumen. CD4+ T cells
are prevalent in this infiltrate, and may play a key role in driving the inflammatory attack.
Production of IL-2, TNFα�� and IFNγ� by CD4+ T cells indicates a predominant Th1 response.
Products of activated macrophages include IL-1 and TNF� which are pro-inflammatory
cytokines that further stimulate the Th1 response. Granuloma formation depends on Th1
cytokines, and in animal models, anti-TNFα therapy has been shown to block granuloma
formation. Blockade of these cytokines could theoretically play an important role in selective
interference with disease progression.
TNFα inhibitors such as infliximab, eternacept, adalimumab and IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-
1ra) have been shown to abrogate inflammatory responses and limit tissue damage in patients
with rheumatoid arthritis and are being studied in other illnesses in which macrophage and Th1-
mediated responses may be important. Our current understanding of the pathogenesis of GCA
suggests that interfering with vascular injury due to the products of activated macrophages and
Th1 lymphocytes would be worthy of investigation. Because of their apparent important roles in
GCA pathogenesis, blockade of either IL-1, IFNγ� and TNF are particularly attractive
considerations.
The use of infliximab (IFX) as adjunctive therapy to GCS in new onset GCA has recently been
investigated in a multicenter, randomized, double-blind, controlled trial (21). Forty-four
patients were randomized in a 1:2 ratio (placebo, n=16, IFX, n=28) at 22 centers in 5 countries.
Mean age in both groups was 71.0 years (range: 50-93). After a 22 week interim analysis, the
study was terminated. There were no differences between groups in regard to: 1) proportion of
patients remaining relapse-free (50% placebo vs. 43% IFX, p=0.651), 2) cumulative doses of
GCS therapy (placebo mean ±SD = 3117 ±971 mg vs. IFX = 3051 ±770 mg, p=NS) and 3)
among patients who had 1st relapse, days to 1st relapse (placebo median = 84.5, IFX median =
96.5, p=NS). There was one case of heart failure in an IFX-treated patient. Infections were
infrequent and limited to upper respiratory tract (12.5% placebo vs. 14.3% IFX). In this elderly
population of patients with newly diagnosed GCA, IFX 5mg/kg every 8 weeks, was well-
tolerated, but during 22 weeks of treatment did not reduce number of 1st relapses or
cumulative GCS dosage.
While these results were unexpected and disappointing, they should not discourage further
exploration of blockade of other seemingly critical cytokines in the future. The morbidity of
GCA and current therapies are far too great to accept the status quo.
12
Evolution of the syndrome of Benign Angiopathy of the Central Nervous System
(BACNS): Retrospective review of 48 patients Swati S. Bharadwaj, Rula A. Hajj-Ali, Jeffrey P. Hammel, Leonard H. Calabrese. Cleveland
Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, OH
Purpose: The entity of BACNS was first proposed in 1993 as a subset of Primary Angiitis of
Central Nervous System (PACNS), defined by acute headache and/stroke, benign
cerebrospinal fluid, high probability cerebral angiogram and a favorable clinical outcome
without intense immunosuppression. In 2002, we described a series of 16 patients with
BACNS with rapid reversal of angiographic changes suggesting that the underlying mechanism
was reversible vasoconstriction rather than true vasculitis. Recognizing this entity is clinically
important as such patients can be spared aggressive studies such a brain biopsy and toxicities
of unnecessary immunosuppression. We now extend the clinical description of BACNS with a
larger cohort of 48 patients in an attempt to refine our diagnostic and treatment strategies.
Methods: A retrospective chart review was conducted on BACNS patients. Diagnosis was
based on prior descriptions (Hajj-Ali et al. Arth Rheum 47(6): 662-669, 2002). Information
was collected on demographics, triggers, strokes, headaches, visual symptoms, seizures,
laboratory markers, spinal taps, brain biopsies, initial and follow up neuroimaging, treatments,
outcomes and dates. The information was entered into an Oracle Database and a descriptive
analysis was conducted.
Results: 48 patients were included. Mean age was 43.8 years and 90% were females.
Associated factors were marijuana in 14.6 % and sympathomimetic amines in 8.3%. Past
history of migraine was seen in 22.9%. Headache was most common and present in 89.6%,
stroke in 14.6%, isolated visual symptoms in 20.8% and seizure in 4.2%. Of the 83.3% of
patients who had spinal taps, 82.5% had normal WBCs and 85% had normal CSF proteins
(7.5% were not reliable due to trauma/bleed, 7.5% had mild elevations). Brain biopsy was
performed in 22.9% and was normal in all except one patient with a concomitant glioma. Initial
MRI was normal in 17.1%. Subsequent MRIs revealed abnormalities in 81.4% (44.2%
ischemia, 18.6% cerebral hemorrhage, 14% subarachnoid hemorrhage). Stroke was bilateral or
multiple in 53%. All patients had high probability neurovascular imaging ¡®consistent¡¯ with
vasculitis. Follow up neurovascular imaging performed in 79.2% demonstrated reversibility of
the vascular abnormality in all, except 1 recent patient with a premature MRA. The median
time to reversibility was 92 days. Treatment was non-standardized with brief course
glucocorticoids used most frequently and more recently encountered patients receiving calcium
channel blockers. Total clinical recovery occurred in 47.9%, recovery with residual deficit in
33.3% and relapse in 3%.
Conclusions: BACNS is a common mimic of PACNS and appears to represent a syndrome of
reversible cerebral vasoconstriction and not true cerebral vasculitis. Initial neuroimaging can
be negative in many patients. Outcome appears to be limited by stroke morbidity. Studies to
define validated diagnostic criteria and optimal therapy are needed.
13
Tumor-like Mass Lesion (ML) - an Under-recognized Presentation of Primary
Angiitis of the Central Nervous System (PACNS)
Eamonn S. Molloy, Leonard H. Calabrese.
Objectives: ML is an under-recognized presentation of PACNS. The purpose of this work was
to document the occurrence of ML in PACNS and to assess the utility of diagnostic testing and
treatment.
Methods: We examined the case records of the Cleveland Clinic Foundation (CCF) and the
English language medical literature for biopsy-proven PACNS cases presenting as ML.
Relevant clinical variables were extracted and analyzed with JMP software.
Results: We identified 34 ML among 626 PACNS cases (5.4%). A higher percentage (11/42;
26%) was seen in the amyloid-related angiitis subset. Mean age was 46 years (range 6-74yrs).
18 patients were male, 16 female. Headache was the most common presenting symptom
(74%), with seizures occurring in 47%. 18/27 (67%) patients presented within 1 month of onset
of symptoms, only 3/27 (11%) had symptom duration of 6 months or more. ML were identified
by MR in 20/20 patients and by CT in 27/28 cases in which these investigations were
performed. Edema, enhancement and hemorrhage were associated with the ML in 14, 12 and 5
patients respectively. Cerebrospinal fluid was abnormal in 14 of the 19 patients in which a
lumbar puncture was performed (74%), generally elevation of protein ± cell count. Cerebral
angiography was abnormal in 8/14 patients; 7/8 showed a mass effect but no suggestion of
vasculitis. The diagnosis of PACNS was confirmed by histology in all cases, with
granulomatous vasculitis in 56% and lymphocytic vasculitis in 44%. Positive staining for
amyloid was found in 11/34 (32%). 29/33 (88%) of patients entered remission, 18 (62%) of
whom had residual deficits, most commonly hemianopia, seizures or cognitive deficits.
Patients were followed for a median of 18 months. 6/27 (22%) patients developed disease
relapse. Five patients (15%) died during the period of follow up; of these, four had amyloid-
related angiitis and one had lymphoma. Ten patients were treated with high-dose steroids for
more than three months in combination with cyclophosphamide, all of whom entered
remission. Three of these relapsed, none of whom were considered adequately treated with
cyclophosphamide. Of the 15 patients not receiving high-dose steroids and cyclophosphamide,
three died, three relapsed and two underwent surgical resection. Of the 11 patients who
underwent resection of the ML, 2 died shortly after surgery; while none of the others had a
disease relapse, 7 had residual deficits.
Conclusions: Although rare, PACNS should be considered in the differential diagnosis of ML.
There are no distinctive neuroimaging findings and angiography does not show changes
consistent with vasculitis. Biopsy evidence of angiitis is required for diagnosis and specimens
should routinely be stained for amyloid. Greater awareness of this manifestation may facilitate
more prompt diagnosis and treatment. While excision of the lesion may be curative, institution
of aggressive immunosuppressive therapy appears to be associated with favorable outcomes
and may obviate the need for surgery.
14
Pachymeningitis an under-recognised manifestation of rheumatic diseases
Molloy ES, Calabrese LH, Embi P, Carey JJ.
Department of Rheumatic and Immunologic Diseases, A50, The Cleveland Clinic Foundation,
9500 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44195, USA.
Pachymeningitis is a rare complication of several rheumatic diseases, historically associated
with a high mortality and often not diagnosed until post-mortem.
AIM: To describe the clinical features, treatment and clinical course of five cases of
pachymeningitis.
METHOD
Retrospective case series.
RESULTS
2 subjects had features of pachymeningitis at the time of diagnosis (1 rheumatoid arthritis,
1Wegener’s granulomatosis), and 3 developed this phenomenon as a late complication of their
disease (1 each of rheumatoid arthritis, Wegener’s granulomatosis and sarcoidosis). All had
pachymeningitis on imaging and negative CSF cultures. 4 had pathologic confirmation, 1 did
not have a biopsy as the clinical presentation was confirmatory. All were treated with
corticosteroids and additional DMARDs (3 cyclophosphamide). All patients improved with
treatment and remain alive at follow-up: range 5 to 31 months. 1 had recurrent disease, 1 is
finishing a course of intravenous cyclophosphamide. 3 remain in remission. Details of each
case will be presented including images of MRI scans and pathology.
CONCLUSIONS
These cases highlight the clinical features and course of pachymeningitis, a rare manifestation
of some rheumatic diseases. Presentation may occur at various stages in the disease course and
is often insidious in nature. Diagnosis is based on typical MRI, CSF and/or pathologic findings,
following the exclusion of other aetiologies such as infection and malignancy. Early and
aggressive treatment is warranted, which may ameliorate the disease and improve prognosis.
Pachymeningitis should be considered in the differential diagnosis of rheumatology patients
presenting with headache or other neurologic symptoms.
15
II. Microcrystalline arthritis
BCP crystals increase prostacyclin (PGI2) production and upregulate the PGI2
receptor in osteoarthritic synovial fibroblasts; potential effects on mPGES1 and
MMP-13 *ES Molloy
1 MB MRCPI, MP Morgan
1 PhD, B McDonnell
1 BA (Mod), J O’Byrne
2 MD
FRCSI, GM McCarthy1-3
MD FRCPI 1Department of Molecular and Cellular Therapeutics, Royal College of Surgeons of Ireland,
123 St Stephen’s Green, Dublin 2, Ireland; 2National Orthopaedic Hospital, Cappagh, Dublin
15, Ireland; 3Division of Rheumatology, Mater Misericordiae University Hospital, Eccles St,
Dublin 7, Ireland
Objective: To investigate the potential involvement of prostacyclin (PGI2) in basic calcium
phosphate (BCP) crystal-induced responses in osteoarthritic (OA) synovial fibroblasts (OASF).
Methods: OASF grown in culture were stimulated with BCP crystals. PGI2 production was
measured by enzyme immunoassay. The relative dependence of PGI2 production on COX-1
and COX-2 was assessed using SC-560 (a COX-1 selective inhibitor) and SC-236 (a COX-2
selective inhibitor). Expression of mRNA transcripts was assessed by real-time polymerase
chain reaction (PCR). Protein production was measured by western blot. The effects of
iloprost, a PGI2 analogue, on expression of genes implicated in OA such as microsomal
prostaglandin E2 synthase 1 (mPGES1) and matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) was also
studied. Since it has been reported that farnesylation of the IP receptor is required for its
efficient intracellular signaling, FPT inhibitor II, a farnesyl transferase inhibitor, was used to
antagonize iloprost-induced responses.
Results: BCP crystal stimulation led to a 5-fold increase in PGI2 production in OASF
compared to untreated cells. This induction was attenuated by selective cyclooxygenase
(COX)-2 and COX-1 inhibition (with SC-236 and SC-560 respectively) at 4 and 32 hours
respectively. PGI2 synthase and PGI2 receptor transcripts were constitutively expressed in
OASF. BCP crystals upregulated PGI2 (IP) receptor expression two-fold. While iloprost
diminished BCP crystal-stimulated PGI2 receptor upregulation, this inhibitory effect of iloprost
was blocked by FPT inhibitor II. In addition, iloprost upregulated mPGES1 but downregulated
MMP-13 expression in BCP crystal-stimulated OASF, effects that were not influenced by the
FPT inhibitor II. The effects of iloprost on mPGES1 in BCP crystal-treated OASF were
confirmed by western blotting.
Conclusions: These data show for the first time that BCP crystals increase PGI2 production
and upregulate expression of the IP receptor in OASF. The potential of PGI2 to influence BCP
crystal-stimulated responses was supported by the effects of iloprost on the expression of the
IP receptor, mPGES1 and MMP-13. These data demonstrate the potential involvement of PGI2
in BCP crystal-associated OA and suggest that inhibition of PG synthesis with non-steroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs may have both deleterious and beneficial effects in BCP crystal-
associated OA.
16
Mechanism of Cyclooxygenase Induction by Basic Calcium Phosphate Crystals
in Osteoarthritic Synovial Fibroblasts ES Molloy
1,4, MP Morgan
1, G Doherty
2, J O'Byrne
3, DJ Fitzgerald
2, GM McCarthy
1,2,4.
1Department of Clinical Pharmacology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland,
2Conway
Institute, University College Dublin, 3Department of Orthopaedic Surgery and
4Department of
Rheumatology, Mater Misericordiae University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Introduction: Intraarticular basic calcium phosphate (BCP) crystal deposition has been
implicated in the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis (OA). Prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) may contribute
to cartilage degradation in OA. We have previously demonstrated that BCP crystals upregulate
mRNA expression and protein production of cyclooxygenase (COX) -1 and -2, both of which
contribute to the observed PG production in OA synovial fibroblasts (OASF). In addition, we
have previously shown that BCP crystals upregulate interleukin-1β (IL1β) expression in
human fibroblasts. The aim of this work was to explore the mechanism of COX upregulation
by BCP crystals.
Methods: OASF were obtained at joint replacement. All experiments were performed on cells
cultured in monolayer. mRNA expression was determined by quantative real-time PCR. OASF
were pre-treated with the following signal transduction pathway inhibitors: SB203580 (p38
MAP kinase inhibitor), UO126 (ERK1/2 pathway inhibitor), wortmannin (PI3 kinase
inhibitor), bisindolylmaleimide I (protein kinase C (PKC) inhibitor) and SP600125 (JNK
inhibitor). Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL1ra) was used to explore the potential
involvement of IL1 in upregulation of COX by BCP crystals. The role of intra-lysosomal
crystal dissolution was assessed using bafilomycin A1, a proton pump inhibitor. The effect of
cycloheximide, an inhibitor of protein synthesis, was also examined.
Results: BCP crystal-induced COX-1 expression was significantly inhibited by pre-treatment
with either UO126 or bisindolylmaleimide I. SP600125 had a partial inhibitory effect. The
effects on BCP crystal-induced COX-1 upregulation of a panel of PKC inhibitors suggested
that PKCµ was the PKC isoform primarily involved. BCP crystal induction of COX-1 but not
COX-2 mRNA expression was inhibited by bafilomycin A1. Inhibition of new protein
translation using cycloheximide also prevented BCP induction of COX-1 but not COX-2
mRNA expression. There was no demonstrable effect of IL1ra on BCP crystal induced COX-1
or COX-2 expression.
Conclusions: Induction of COX-1 by BCP crystals involves the PKC and ERK1/2 signal
transduction pathways. Intra-lysosomal crystal dissolution and new protein synthesis are also
necessary for BCP crystal induced COX-1 but not COX-2 upregulation, suggesting that the
induction of COX-1 and COX-2 by BCP crystals occurs via distinct and separate mechanisms.
Involvement of ΙL-1β in BCP crystal-induced COX expression could not be confirmed.
17
Basic Calcium Phosphate Crystals Upregulate MMP-13 in Human Osteoarthritic
Synovial Fibroblasts: Effect of PGE2
ES Molloy1,4
, MP Morgan1, G Doherty
2, J O'Byrne
3, DJ Fitzgerald
2,
GM McCarthy1,2,4
. 1Department of Clinical Pharmacology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland,
2Conway
Institute, University College Dublin, 3Department of Orthopaedic Surgery and
4Department of
Rheumatology, Mater Misericordiae University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Basic calcium phosphate (BCP) crystals are present in 30-60% of synovial fluids of patients
with osteoarthritis (OA). BCP crystal induction of fibroblast proliferation, and matrix
metalloproteinase (MMP), prostaglandin and nitric oxide production may contribute to the
pathogenesis of OA. The collagenase group of MMPs include MMP1, 3, and 13; MMP-13 is
particularly implicated in matrix degradation in OA. While the mechanisms of BCP crystal-
induced MMP 1 and MMP-3 production have been characterised, the induction of MMP 13
from human osteoarthritic synovial fibroblasts (OASF) stimulated by BCP crystals has been
less well studied.
Methods: OASF were obtained at joint replacement. All experiments were performed on cells
cultured in monolayer. mRNA expression was determined by quantative real-time PCR. OASF
were pre-treated with the following signal transduction pathway inhibitors: SB203580 (p38
MAPK inhibitor), UO126 (ERK1/2 pathway inhibitor), wortmannin (PI3 kinase inhibitor),
bisindolylmaleimide I (protein kinase C (PKC) inhibitor) and SP600125 (c-jun N-terminal
kinase inhibitor). Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL1ra) was used to explore the potential
involvement of IL1 in upregulation of MMPs by BCP crystals. The role of intralysosomal
crystal dissolution was assessed using bafilomycin A1, a proton pump inhibitor. The effect of
cycloheximide, an inhibitor of protein synthesis, was also examined. The potential role of
PGE2 in BCP crystal-induced MMP expression was assessed by adding PGE2, with or without
L-161982, a selective EP4 receptor antagonist.
Results: BCP crystal upregulation of MMP-13 mRNA expression was maximal at 32 hours.
This induction was abrogated by pre-treatment with SB203580, a p38 MAP kinase inhibitor or
UO126, an ERK1/2 pathway inhibitor. BCP crystal induction of MMP-13 mRNA expression
was inhibited by bafilomycin A1. Inhibition of new protein translation using cycloheximide
also prevented BCP crystal induction of MMP-13 mRNA expression. Addition of PGE2
decreased, increased and did not significantly influence BCP crystal-induced MMP-13, MMP-
3 and MMP-1 mRNA expression respectively. These effects were only partially suppressed by
pre-treatment with L-161982. There was no demonstrable effect of IL1ra on BCP crystal
induced MMP expression.
Conclusions: These data suggest that induction of MMP-13 by BCP crystals involves the p38
and ERK1/2 signal transduction pathways. Intra-lysosomal crystal dissolution and new protein
synthesis are also required. PGE2 may also differentially influence BCP crystal-induced MMP
mRNA expression. A role for ΙL1β in BCP crystal-induced MMP expression could not be
confirmed.
18
III. Scleroderma and Raynaud's vasospasm
Evaluation of Digital Microcirculation in Systemic Sclerosis and Raynaud’s
Disease using Laser Doppler Imaging Feyrouz Al-Ashkar, James Bena, Kay Stelmach, Soumya Chatterjee. Cleveland Cinic
Foundation
Purpose: Evaluation of digital microvascular flow (DMF) and assessment of therapeutic
responses in scleroderma (SSc) and in Raynaud’s disease (RD) have been largely clinical. We
lack a standardized quantifiable objective measure of DMF.
The aims of the study were to determine whether measurement of DMF by laser Doppler
perfusion imaging (LDI) can: (1) estimate the reproducibility of mean responses within SSc,
RD and healthy controls (HC) at basal conditions (25°C), and then after 'cold challenge (CC)'
(10°C, 2 min), and after 'warm challenge (WC)' (43°C, 2 min), (2) distinguish between the 3
groups by evaluating the differences in mean response, and (3) estimate the variability within
each group.
Methods: 15 subjects in each group had measurements by LDI at baseline and then after CC
and WC. Participants were asked to refrain from vasoactive agents prior to testing. The
dorsums of the 2nd to 5th fingers were scanned and regions of interest at the fingertips were
identified. The geometric mean perfusion level was used to summarize each finger region,
since it better reflected the central tendency of the data. Repeated measure linear models were
used to estimate the variability in mean measurements within subjects and to identify
differences between groups under basal conditions, and then after CC and WC. F-tests were
used to compare groups overall, and t-tests were used to make paired comparisons. A P-value
of 0.05 was considered significant.
Results: Data on 43 subjects were analyzed. Two SSc patients were excluded due to image
artifacts. The standard deviation of overall mean perfusion values in all 4 fingertips was 0.12
(volt) under basal conditions, and ranged between 0.27 and 0.35 for single fingers. The table
shows the observed mean perfusion levels and changes by group. RD patients had the lowest
perfusion levels under all conditions, while HC had the highest levels. A borderline difference
was observed among groups under basal conditions (p = 0.055). RD patients had a significantly
larger difference between WC and CC mean perfusion levels than HC subjects (p = 0.009). No
differences were observed between SSc and the other groups.
Conclusion: RD patients had lower basal perfusion levels, and showed more change with CC
and WC than the control subjects. Differences between SSc and HC subjects were not
significant, possibly due to the small number of subjects. Thus, Laser Doppler imaging may
provide an objective measurement of DMF at baseline in patients with SSc and RD. In
planning future research, we can use the results from this pilot study to estimate group
differences and variability. Further research with a larger patient population is necessary for
evaluation of DMF in SSc patients.
19
IV. Epidemiology and Outcome
US Rheumatologist Supply and Demand : 2005-2006 Workforce Study Chad Deal
1, Walter G. Barr
2, Tim Harrington
3, Roderick Hooker
4, Paul Hogan
5, Ellen
Bouchery5, Neal Birnbaum
6, for the ACR Workforce Subcommittee COTW
7.
1Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, OH;
2Northwestern University, Chicago, IL;
3University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI;
4University of Texas Southwestern, Dallas, TX;
5Lewin Group, Falls Church, VA;
6Pacific Rheumatology, San Francisco, CA;
7ACR, Atlanta
Purpose: A decline in US rheumatologists is anticipated when retirement rates will exceed
completed fellowships. Demand for rheumatology services is increasing due to an expanding
and aging US population, new technologies and treatments.
A workforce (WF) study by the Lewin Group in 2005-06 investigated this supply and demand
interface, the ACR Subcommittee on Workforce (Committee on Training and Workforce)
served an advisory role.
Methods: The WF study included a literature review, analyses of national databases, and a
survey sent to a random sample of 4946 adult rheumatologists (n=1683) and all 218 pediatric
rheumatologists. Survey components included work efforts, productivity, measures of excess
demand, retirement plans, sources of income, job satisfaction, and conditions treated. Pediatric,
age <40, academic, and rural rheumatologists were over-sampled. Results were used to develop
a computer model of supply and demand (S/D) that provides sensitivity analyses of key
components including number of fellows trained, retirement rates, physician assistant/nurse
practitioners (NP/PA's), hours worked, gender/age effects, lifestyle changes and changes in
GDP. A logistical regression identifying statistical differences between the groups was set at
the 95% confidence level.
Results: 1,683 rheumatologists were surveyed, 627 responded (return = 37%). 70% were male
(median age 53), median age of adult and pediatric physicians was 51 and 47. Overall there are
17.7 and 0.7 adult and pediatric rheumatologists per million people. There were 179 first-year
fellowships offered in 2005, with an occupancy rate of 91% and 95% completion rate. At least
35% were filled by international medical graduates of whom 80% remain in the US. The
number of annual visits averaged 2,624 for female and 3,548 for male rheumatologists. The
model predicts a shortfall of supply to demand (assuming S=D in 2005) of 8, 21, 27, and 56%
in 2010, 2015, 2020, and 2025.
Conclusions: At the time of this survey in 2005, the majority of rheumatologists were in their
most productive years. As a younger, increasingly female cohort follows, we predict a decline
in annual visit productivity based on the model and a shortfall of 2,600 rheumatologists by the
year 2025. Solutions could include:1) increasing fellowship positions, 2) increasing NP/PA's,
3) improving practice efficiency. The incremental addition of 188 first year fellow positions
(n=367 total first year positions) by 2021 would be required to equalize supply and demand.
The committee recommends that the ACR develop strategies that address the predicted
imbalance and use the computer model in evaluating the impact of proposed solutions.
20
A Practical Quality Reporting System for Hip and Knee Arthroplasty Procedures
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
Elaine Husni, Mary Lograsso, Dawn M Gerz, Charles Emmerich, Julie Thornton, Sarah
Worley, George F Muschler,
Background: This effective system for quality assessment following arthroplasty procedures
imposes no change in practice and eliminates provider bias and burden. Institutions are
increasingly obligated to implement proactive continuous quality assessment (QA) programs.
Addition of personnel or adding burden to busy providers is impractical, particularly in large
institutions with multiple providers and locations. This paper describes an effective institution-
wide arthroplasty QA system.
Methods: Between 12/2000 and 3/2004, 2,362 patients were scheduled for unilateral hip or
knee arthroplasty (16 surgeons, 3 locations). One month before and 10 months after surgery,
patients were mailed 8 demographic questions, the Charlson co-morbidity index, the SF-36
instrument, a cover letter and a stamped return envelope.
Results: 1,021 returned pre-op forms (43%). 679 returned post-op forms (29%). 619 patients
(26%) returned both, including 257 hips, 232 primary knees, 71 revision hips and 59 revision
knees. No differences were found between providers or treatment centers with respect to
change in Physical Composite Score (PCS). Improvement in PCS was associated with THA,
primary procedures, lower pre-op physical function, role function, bodily pain, Charlson score
and PCS, and with higher pre-op general health, role emotional and mental composite scores.
No association was found with respect to body mass index or gender,
Conclusion: This system is effective in comparing provider and care centers at acceptable cost.
It imposes no change on practice patterns, eliminates provider bias and burden, and allows
assessment of practice variation and clinical predictors of outcome. It can be implemented in
large institutions with multiple delivery sites and even on a national scale across IT systems.
21
Early Outcome Assessment Comparison of Unilateral
And Bilateral Primary Total Knee Arthroplasty
George F Muschler, Elaine Husni, Mary Lograsso, Viktor Erik Krebs, Lester Stuart Borden,
Julie Thornton, Sarah Worley
Objective: Bilateral total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is an option available to patients and
surgeons in the seeing of severe degenerative arthritis of the knee. This decision balances the
desire for a single procedure against the potential for increased short term risk and discomfort.
Disease severity, functional limitations, and the burden of co-morbid disease are expected to
influence this decision.
Methods: A prospective arthroplasty outcomes registry was used to test the hypothesis that
patients undergoing bilateral vs. unilateral TKA differ with respect to pre-operative health
perception and co-morbidity.
Results: Baseline and one year outcome was assessed in 232 unilateral and 129 bilateral TKAs
performed between 12/1/2000 and 3/24/2004. Patients reported co-morbidity, and SF-36
scores pre-op and one year post-op were compared. Patients undergoing bilateral TKA
reported: significantly higher pre-op general health perception (p<0.-001) but no difference in
pre-op physical function, role function, pain, vitality, social or role function mental health,
physical composite score, Charlson co-morbidity index, body mass index, or gender. Bilateral
patients also reported a greater change in physical composite score one year following surgery
(median change 12 vs. 9, p<0.001).
Conclusion: Perception of general health appears to be a significant factor in the decision to
undergo bilateral TKA, independent of objective co-morbidity. Patients with this perception
may be more likely to seek out and accept the increased short term risk associated with
bilateral TKA. This pre-operative perception may also predict a higher level of expectation
contributing to the improved overall outcome.
22
V. Psoriatic arthritis
Development and evaluation of PASE: A self-administered Psoriatic Arthritis
Screening and Evaluation tool Abrar A. Qureshi, MD, MPH, Darel S. Cohen, MD, MPH, Elinor Mody, MD, and
M. Elaine Husni, MD, MPH
The incidence and prevalence of psoriatic arthritis is largely unknown at the population level.
Psoriatic arthritis can result in disability and deformity if not diagnosed and treated
appropriately. However, the diagnosis of psoriatic arthritis is difficult as there are no well-
accepted diagnostic criteria and evaluation available. We have developed a self-administered
questionnaire that dermatologists can use to screen psoriasis patients for evidence of psoriatic
arthritis. This will expedite and optimize a rheumatology referral.
The PASE questionnaire (PASE – Psoriatic Arthritis Screening and Evaluation) contains a total
of 15 five-choice items and two subscales for symptoms and function. PASE minimum score
was 15 and maximum score 75. Forty participants were screened with PASE after institutional
IRB approval. All participants responded to the questionnaire prior to intervention or systemic
therapy. Seventeen participants were diagnosed with psoriatic arthritis plus psoriasis and 23
with psoriasis alone by a dermatologist and rheumatologist working in collaboration. Average
age was 59 years and 19 were female. In the psoriatic arthritis group, total median score was
51 (25th
, 75th
percentiles = 47, 63). In the psoriasis alone group, total median score was 37
(25th
, 75th
percentiles = 30, 47), p = 0.003. Sensitivity was 0.76 and specificity was 0.70 for
the total score. Similarly, median function score for psoriatic arthritis was 26 (25th
, 75th
percentiles = 23, 31) and median function score for psoriasis alone was 18 (25th
, 75th
percentiles = 16, 22), p = 0.001; sensitivity was 0.88 and specificity was 0.78. Median
symptom score for psoriatic arthritis was 24 (25th
, 75th
percentiles = 23, 30) and median
symptom score for psoriasis alone was 21 (25th
, 75th
percentiles = 14, 24), p = 0.001;
sensitivity was 0.76 and specificity was 0.65.
The PASE questionnaire is a valid screening tool for detection of psoriatic arthritis among
patients with psoriasis. There is a need to identify patients with PsA so that timely therapy can
be initiated and long term disability avoided. Further work is on-going to test PASE for
internal consistency and test-retest reliability in a larger sample of patients with psoriasis and
psoriatic arthritis.
23
Diagnosis of arthritis in psoriasis patients presenting with joint pain to a
dermatology-rheumatology clinic Elinor A. Mody, MD, M. Elaine Husni, MD, MPH and Abrar A. Qureshi, MD, MPH
Psoriatic arthritis (PsA) is an inflammatory spondyloarthropathy associated with psoriasis. The
epidemiology of psoriatic arthritis is largely unknown as the diagnosis is difficult to make.
Currently there are no formally accepted diagnostic criteria for PsA in adults. When untreated,
PsA can be progressive in some patients leading to permanent joint destruction and disability.
Consecutive patients presenting to the Center for Skin and Related Musculoskeletal Diseases at
Brigham and Women’s Hospital with psoriasis and joint pain were included in this study. All
71 patients were simultaneously evaluated by dermatology and rheumatology and all had a
diagnosis of psoriasis. The average age was 55 years and 52% were female. About 41%
(29/71) of patients were diagnosed with PsA alone on the basis of clinical history, physical
examination and radiographs. A further 27% (19/71) were diagnosed with PsA and
osteoarthritis (diagnosis based on radiographs). Hence, about 55% (39/71) were diagnosed with
PsA overall in this population. A total of 14% patients reporting joint pain could not be
diagnosed with any form of arthritis. The mean age of patients in the PsA group was 49 years
and non-PsA group was 57 years (P=0.01). Family history of psoriasis or PsA in a first- or
second-degree relative was reported by 7% of participants. Radiograph data was available for
51 participants and 39% (20/51) had erosions present. Data on Schober’s test was available for
52 participants, was abnormal in 24% (16/52) and 88% with an abnormal Schober’s were
diagnosed with PsA (p=0.001). About 40% (28/70) of participants reported morning stiffness
of greater than 1 hour and 82% with morning stiffness were diagnosed with PsA (p=0.001).
Psoriatic arthritis may be more common among psoriasis patients than previously reported. A
large proportion of patients may have concomitant PsA and osteoarthritis making it more
difficult to diagnosis and treat joint symptoms in psoriasis patients. Care for patients with
psoriasis and PsA can be optimized in a multi-disciplinary environment.
24
VI. Metabolic Bone Disease Equivalence of Technology Generated T-scores and Z-scores in Young Adult Bone
Densitometry.
J.J.Carey1, M.F. Delaney
1, B. Richmond
1,3, B.A. Cromer
4, T.E. Love
5, S. Lewis
5, C.A.
Thomas5, P.D. Miller
6, A.A. Licata
1,2,
Affiliations: 1The Center for Osteoporosis and Metabolic Bone Disease, A50,
2Department of Endocrinology,
3Department of Radiology
The Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, Ohio 44195. 4Department of Pediatrics, Division of Adolescent Medicine, BG 4,
5Center for Health Care Research & Policy, Rammelkamp Research & Educ. Bldg.,
MetroHealth Medical Center, Cleveland, OH 44109-1998 6Colorado Center for Bone Research, 3190 South Wadsworth, #250, Lakewood, CO 80227..
ASBMR 2006 Meeting Abstract The purpose of this study was to assess T-score and Z-score equivalence of central dual-energy
x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) generated in Young Adults (ages 20-50 years). Recently Z-scores
have been recommended for diagnosis of low bone mass in young men and premenopausal
women. Little difference between T-scores and Z-scores is expected in this population,
particularly young Caucasian women. Unlike T-scores, rigorous scientific publications to
support such recommendations are lacking. Additionally consensus Z-score definitions vary,
and methods for Z-score calculation differ within and between technologies. A cross-sectional
design was used for this study using a convenience sample of young adults scanned (Hologic
or Lunar) at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation (CCF) between 2000 and 2006. Paired
comparison tests and simple linear regression models were used for preliminary analyses;
because of their limitations in assessing reliability, more complex analyses including Deming
regression, graphical plots including Altman-Bland and mountain were also used to assess
differences, and bias, between T-scores and Z-scores. 4275 predominantly female Caucasians
subjects had ≥1 scans available for analysis. Overall, significant differences were seen between
DXA-generated T-scores and Z-scores at the spine and hip with both technologies: maximum
range: 3.5 (standard deviations), p-value <0.001. Stratification by gender, ethnicity, skeletal
site and age did not significantly alter the results. Caucasian women aged 20-30 years differed
significantly at the spine and hip: p-value <0.05, maximum range 2.5. Using Z-scores instead
of T-scores resulted in significant alterations in DXA diagnosis using either 1994 W.H.O. or
2005 I.S.C.D. criteria; kappa ranged from 0.573-0.808, McNemar’s p-value <0.001.
Considerable differences exist between Z-scores and T-scores in young adults which may
result in significant ascertainment bias if Z-scores are used for DXA diagnosis of osteoporosis.
Altman-Bland Plot of 20-30 year-old Caucasian Women Lumbar Spine T-scores and Z-scores:
difference V Mean.
25
-4 -2 0 2 4
AVERAGE of hipt and hipz
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
hip
t -
hip
z
Mean
-0.06
-1.96 SD
-0.76
+1.96 SD
0.65
26
Inappropriate PTH Response to Severe Vitamin D Deficiency in Patients with Chronic
Liver Disease. M. E. Schulte*
1, A. A. Licata
2, J. J. Carey
3, M. F. Delaney
3.
1Medicine, Cleveland Clinic
Foundation, Cleveland, OH, USA, 2Endocrinology, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland,
OH, USA, 3Rheumatology, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, OH, USA.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the calcium-vitamin D-PTH axis in patients with
chronic liver disease.
Vitamin D (VitD) deficiency is associated with a compensatory increase in parathyroid
hormone release to maintain serum calcium homeostasis. This secondary
hyperparathyroidism is associated with decreased calcium absorption, increased efflux of
calcium from bone, and increased risk for low bone mass. Reduced bone formation in
chronic liver disease has been ascribed to several factors including vitamin D deficiency,
osteomalacia, hypogonadism and excessive alcohol consumption. We noted an impaired PTH
response to VitD deficiency in patients with chronic liver disease.
To evaluate this we performed a cross-sectional study. A cohort of subjects undergoing
evaluation for liver transplantation seen at the Center for Osteoporosis at the Cleveland
Clinic Foundation from 2004 to 2006 were age-matched to 49 controls with vitamin D
deficiency (<20ng/ml) but without clinical or biochemical evidence of liver disease during
the same time period. Subjects with known primary hyperparathyroidism, renal insufficiency
(serum creatinine >1.4mg/dl) or other disorders of calcium metabolism were excluded. 2
sample t-tests were used to compare serum creatinine, corrected serum calcium, vitamin D
levels and serum parathyroid hormone levels.
Of 114 liver disease subjects screened, 12 were excluded due to abnormal creatinine. Of the
remaining 102 subjects, 73 had low vitamin D (<20) and 30 had very low vitamin D (<10).
3 controls were excluded, 2 primary hyperparathyroidism,1 hypocalcemia. We found no
significant difference in corrected serum calcium, creatinine or age between groups.
Although controls had higher mean serum vitamin D levels, they also had significantly
higher serum PTH levels - see table. In patients with chronic liver disease there was no
significant difference in serum PTH levels in those with low Vit D compared with those with
normal Vit D levels. Subjects with advanced chronic liver disease appear to have a
subnormal rise in PTH in the setting of Vit D deficiency. Further studies to evaluate this
phenomenon are needed.
<0.001 -46.53, -22.8971.40 (36.50)36.69 (21.26)Serum PTH
0.004-3.7, -0.714.53 (3.56)12.30 (3.78)Serum 25 vitamin D
0.89-0.22, 0.269.60 (0.48)9.61 (0.68)Corrected Calcium
0.92-0.08, 0.090.80 (0.24)0.80 (0.20)Serum Creatinine
0.80-4.69, 3.6356.7 (14.6)56.2 (8.3)Age
ControlsCirrhotics
p-value95% C.I.Mean (SD)Variable
<0.001 -46.53, -22.8971.40 (36.50)36.69 (21.26)Serum PTH
0.004-3.7, -0.714.53 (3.56)12.30 (3.78)Serum 25 vitamin D
0.89-0.22, 0.269.60 (0.48)9.61 (0.68)Corrected Calcium
0.92-0.08, 0.090.80 (0.24)0.80 (0.20)Serum Creatinine
0.80-4.69, 3.6356.7 (14.6)56.2 (8.3)Age
ControlsCirrhotics
p-value95% C.I.Mean (SD)Variable
27
The impact of body weight on DXA generated Z-scores in Young Adults
Brad Richmond1,2
, John J Carey2,3
, Miriam F Delaney2,3
, Angelo A Licata2,4
, Martha Manilich1
McIntosh, Paul D Miller4,
1Department of Radiology,
2The Center for Osteoporosis and Metabolic Bone Disease,
3Department of Rheumatology &
4Department of Endocrinology, All at The Cleveland Clinic
Foundation, 9500 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio 44195, U.S.A. 4Colorado Center for Bone
Research, 3190 South Wadsworth, #250, Lakewood, CO 80227-4800
Background:
We have previously shown significant differences exist between DXA-generated Z-scores and
T-scores at the spine, total hip, femoral neck and trochanter in young adults. Stratifying the
analyses by technology, gender, race and age did not alter the results; differences were seen
even in White women aged 20-29 years. Z-scores are sometimes adjusted for body weight, an
important predictor of fracture risk.
Purpose:
To assess the impact of body weight on weight-adjusted DXA-generated Z-scores in young
adults.
Methods
A cross-sectional design using a convenience sample of subjects aged 20-49 years from The
Cleveland Clinic Foundation between 1999 and 2000 was used. All subjects had a DXA scan
on one of two technologies: Hologic or Lunar. Linear Regression models and stratified
bivariate analyses were used to indirectly assess the impact of body weight on DXA-generated
Z-scores at 4 skeletal sites.
Results:
Heavier individuals’ Z-scores were significantly lower than lighter individuals after adjusting
for T-score, though considerable overlap was seen between groups. Univariate linear
regression showed weight was a weak predictor of Z-score (r2
<0.023), but when coupled with
T-scores r2
was >0.99 for all 4 sites.
Conclusions:
Subject’s body weight may account for some of the difference seen between DXA generated
Z-scores and T-scores. However adjustment for weight does not fully explain the difference
between these values in this population.
28
Diagnostic Agreement between DXA generated T-scores and Z-scores in
Young Adults
John J Carey MB2,3
, Miriam F Delaney MD2,3
, Angelo A Licata MD, PhD2,4
,
Martha L Manilla-McIntosh RT1,
,3, Paul D Miller
4, Bradford J Richmond MD
1,2
1Department of Radiology,
2The Center for Osteoporosis and Metabolic Bone Disease,
3Department of Rheumatology &
4Department of Endocrinology at The Cleveland Clinic
Foundation, 9500 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio 44195, U.S.A. 4Colorado Center for Bone
Research, 3190 South Wadsworth, #250, Lakewood, CO 80227-4800
Purpose:
To assess diagnostic agreement between DXA-generated T-scores and Z-scores in young
adults.
Methods:
This study used a cross-sectional design performed on a cohort on young adults extracted from
a convenience sample of all DXA subjects who had a BMD scan at The Cleveland Clinic
Foundation between 1999 and 2000. All subjects were scanned using one of two technologies:
Hologic or Lunar. Evaluations comparing diagnostic agreement using 1994 W.H.O. and 2005
I.S.C.D. diagnostic criteria were undertaken using McNemar’s test of proportions and Kappa
Statistics using SAS version 9.1.
Results:
4,275 unique subjects met study criteria and were available for analysis. Effective percentage
agreement was good (those with concordant T-score and Z-score diagnosis) range: 80-97%.
Kappa coefficients for agreement between groups (also assesses chance agreement) were good
to excellent: range 0.533-0.808. However significant differences in DXA diagnosis of low
bone mass or osteoporosis were seen using W.H.O. or I.S.C.D. diagnostic criteria for both
technologies when Z-scores were used instead of T-scores, all p values <0.001.
Conclusions:
Using Z-scores instead of T-scores for DXA diagnosis of osteoporosis or low bone mass in
young adults may result in significant ascertainment bias. This is an important consideration
when using DXA in such individuals.
29
Rheumatologists Order Less Testing for Secondary Causes of Osteoporosis than other
Specialties.
John J Carey, Miriam F. Delaney, Anton Mandrov, Angelo A Licata, Lisabeth V. Scalzi,
Holly L Thacker, Andrea Sikon, Chad L Deal.
Background: Prior study shows that physicians’ response to the results of bone mineral
density (BMD) testing is influenced by the format of the report. A more detailed report may
increase physician use and understanding of BMD testing, patient treatment, and testing for
secondary causes of osteoporosis (1). Secondary causes of osteoporosis or low bone mass are
prevalent, but often go unrecognized, and may require specific therapy (3,4,5). At our
institution, a statement in the BMD report to evaluate for secondary causes of osteoporosis is
recommended for all individuals with Z-scores of <-1.5. Few studies have evaluated the effect
of such recommendations, and how response varies by physician specialty.
Methods:
• Retrospective cohort study between August 1st 2002 and July 31
st 2003.
• All patients with a Z-score of <-1.5 at any site scanned on our DXA machine (G.E.
Lunar Prodigy DF 60004) between August 1st 2002 and January 31
st 2003 were
screened using BMD report and Electronic Medical Record (EMR) review.
• Subjects were eligible for study inclusion if:
1. There was such a recommendation on their BMD report;
2. EMR available for review;
3. Such a work-up had not been performed previously.
• I.R.B. approval was obtained for our study.
• All statistical analysis performed using S-Plus version 6.2, Insightful Inc. U.S.A., and
SAS Version 9.1, Cary, N. Carolina, U.S.A.
Results:
• 752 BMD reports were identified which had a Z score of <-1.5 at one site or more.
• 148 met study inclusion criteria
• 48 referred by their Rheumatologist, 47 by their internist and 53 by 13 other specialties.
• Physicians’ responses varied widely, some ordering no investigations, while others
performed limited or extensive laboratory and imaging studies (range 1-17).
• 88 of 148 (59%) subjects had at least 1 investigation performed.
• Rheumatologists were less likely to order further testing that other specialties, P = 0.004.
• The median number of investigations ordered was 7 and did not differ between specialties,
p=0.37.
• The most frequently ordered tests were serum calcium (77), 25 hydroxy vitamin D (68),
phosphorous (67), and intact parathyroid hormone (61).
• 45 patients had abnormal investigations leading to a diagnosis of secondary osteoporosis:
12 Rheumatology, 13 Internist, 20 other.
• The tests with the highest yield were 25 hydroxy vitamin D (47%), 24 hour urine calcium
(22%) and serum PTH levels (13%).
30
Conclusions:
• Physicians’ response to a recommendation to evaluate secondary causes of low bone
mass/osteoporosis on the BMD report varied.
• Secondary causes of low bone mass/osteoporosis are common.
• Rheumatologists were less likely to order ancillary testing than non-rheumatologists.
• Given the prevalence of secondary osteoporosis, such testing may be warranted