Http://nodal.ercot.com 1 Cutover Update Weekly Update October 15, 2010.
-
Upload
eleanore-wilson -
Category
Documents
-
view
225 -
download
0
Transcript of Http://nodal.ercot.com 1 Cutover Update Weekly Update October 15, 2010.
http://nodal.ercot.com 1
Cutover Update
Weekly Update
October 15, 2010
http://nodal.ercot.com 2
Antitrust Admonition
ANTITRUST ADMONITION
ERCOT strictly prohibits Market Participants and their employees who are participating in ERCOT activities from using their participation in ERCOT activities as a forum for engaging in practices or communications that violate the antitrust laws. The ERCOT Board has approved guidelines for members of ERCOT Committees, Subcommittees and Working Groups to be reviewed and followed by each Market Participant attending ERCOT meetings. If you have not received a copy of these Guidelines, copies are available at the Client Relations desk. Please remember your ongoing obligation to comply with all applicable laws, including the antitrust laws.
DISCLAIMER
All presentations and materials submitted by Market Participants or any other Entity to ERCOT staff for this meeting are received and posted with the acknowledgement that the information will be considered public in accordance with the ERCOT Websites Content Management Operating Procedure.
http://nodal.ercot.com 3
Full Market Trials Agenda
• General Updates and Reminders
• Special Topics
• Nodal Cutover Update
• Question and Answers / General Discussion
ERCOT asks that Market Participants log into the WebEx session using their company name and then their name. This will allow ERCOT to take roll-
call offline
http://nodal.ercot.com 4
General Updates / Reminders
http://nodal.ercot.com 5
General Updates and Reminders
• Monday Market Call will be canceled for 10/18/2010
6
24-Hour Test Reminders
• 24-Hour Full-System Test– ERCOT will conduct the 24-Hour Test from 10/27/2010 (12pm) to 10/28/2010 (12pm)– ERCOT will send a Market Notice 2 hours prior to the test start to confirm start time– Details for the WebEx that will be held during the test will be sent to Nodal PMs shortly after
the Market Notice
• 24-Hour Full-System Test Scenarios:– Scenario #1: Switch control to the Austin facility
• During this scenario, ERCOT will switch control from Taylor to Austin for approximately two hours
– Scenario #2: Simulate EMS Failure• During this scenario, ERCOT will:
– Discontinue sending Regulation Service deployments and updated UDBPs and SCED Base Points
» To stop Reg. deployments and updated UDBPs, ERCOT will place the LFC application in “monitor” mode
» To stop updated SCED Base Points, ERCOT will activate Emergency Base Points with an incremental deployment of 0 MWs
– Request specific QSE(s) to go on Constant Frequency Control• This scenario will be initiated at an unannounced time during the 24-Hour Test window• This scenario will be conducted for approximately 15 to 30 minutes
http://nodal.ercot.com 7
Special Topics:Follow-up Items from MRS
8
MRS Follow-Up Item: SE Reports Status
EMIL_ID PRODUCT_NAME FIRST_RUN_DATENP1-116 State Estimator Standards available
NP3-363-ER State Estimator Bus Telemetry Accuracy Report 1/3/2011
NP3-578-ER State Estimator Convergence Rate Report 1/3/2011
NP3-579-ERMW Residuals - SE vs RTCA Base Case - for Congested Transmission Elements Report 1/3/2011
NP3-580-ERMW Residuals - SE vs Telemetry for Congested Transmission Elements Report 1/3/2011
NP3-581-ERMW Residuals - SE vs Telemetry for Major Transmission Elements Report 1/3/2011
NP3-582-ER KV Residuals - SE vs Telemetry - for Key Buses Report 1/3/2011
NP6-619-CD State Estimator Transmission Flows and Voltages awaiting PUCT decision
NP6-620-CD State Estimator 15-minute Average of Loads 11/30/2010
NP6-621-CD State Estimator Load Report - Individual Load on Electrical Buses available
NP6-622-CD State Estimator Transformer Information awaiting PUCT decision
NP6-623-CD State Estimator Load Report - Load by Electrical Bus by Load Zone available
NP6-624-CD State Estimator Load Report - Total System Load on Electrical Buses available
NP6-625-CD State Estimator Load Report - Total ERCOT Generation available
NP6-626-CD State Estimator Load Report - DC Ties Flows available
NP6-93-CD State Estimator Switch Status 11/30/2010NP8-365 Monthly Telemetry Point Availability Statistics Report 3/17/2011
http://nodal.ercot.com 9
Load Resources
• Question: “After Nodal Go-Live, what if I have no ability to split up my Load Resources into the Group 1 & Group 2 assignments?”
Answer: Based on Nodal Protocols 6.5.9.4.2.2.a.ii.A, “QSEs shall deploy Load Resources according to the group designation and will be given some discretion to deploy additional Load Resources from Group 2 if Load Resource operational considerations require such.”In other words, if a QSE has Load Resources that are physically dependent on each other, but they are split between Group 1 and Group 2, that QSE has the option to deploy the those Load Resources at the same time.
Dashboard currently in MIS
– System Ancillary Service Capacity Monitor
– SCED Up/Down
– Day-Ahead & Real-Time LMPs• Only one LMP at a time
– LMP Ticker
– Frequency • expanding scope to include DC Tie and Other Real-Time data (similar to zonal real-time
display)
Later delivery
– LMP Contour Map (data and display issues) – for go-live
– Load Forecast vs. Actual (data alignment issue) – for go-live
– DC Ties (combine into freq and delete)
– Weather (not in current scope for go-live)
New scope
– Adding 4 new reports (similar to MOS public of pricing tables)
– Turned on links on ERCOT.com to Real-Time and Day-Ahead
http://nodal.ercot.com 10
MIS Dashboard Update
Addition of mospublic-like displays being considered
- Never in any requirements
AS Prices
15-min RTM Settlement Point (96 rows)
Day-Ahead Settlement Point (24 rows)
Real-Time LMPs (most recent 20 SCED runs)
Operation Day, IntervalEnding,
LZ_Houston, LZ_North, LZ_South, LZ_West, LZ_AEN, LZ_CPS, LZ_LCRA, LZ_RAYBN, HB_BUSAVG, HB_HUBAVG, HB_Houston, HB_North, HB_South, HB_West
“Screen Scraping” is not supported by ERCOT
All prices are available via Web Services or CDR reports
http://nodal.ercot.com 11
Additional Dashboards
DAM Failure Scenario
• DAM Failure scenario to be executed on Oct 21– Please have resources available to resubmit your Self-Arranged AS into the SASM
once it opens around 1800.
• Sequence:– DAM Operators will abort the DAM and declare an Emergency Condition. This
notice will be issued to QSEs no later than one hour before the start of the SASM. This notice will contain the target time for the start of the SASM.
– QSEs will have the opportunity to submit/change AS Offers to be used in the upcoming SASM – no caps will be in place on these offers other than SWCAP.
– No DRUC– ERCOT will open the SASM in the adjustment period to procure the entire AS Plan. – QSEs resubmit their Self-Arranged AS (the DAM submission will no longer apply)
within the 30-minute SASM submission window.– ERCOT executes the SASM and posts the results.
http://nodal.ercot.com 12
Go-live credit exposure in DAM
• Proxy prices to be used for purposes of calculating DAM credit exposure for go-live is covered in Protocol Section 4.4.10(8)
• Implementation:– DAM historical settlement point prices
• Import hourly average of zonal MCPEs over the last 30 days as a proxy
– SCED historical settlement point prices• Import 110% of zonal MCPEs over the last 30 days as a proxy for Real-Time SPPs (this
ensures the 10% Day-Ahead/Real-Time price difference called out in 4.4.10(b)).
– As nodal data is created, the zonal data will roll off, so that 30 days after go-live, all prices used for credit exposure calculations will be nodal prices.
http://nodal.ercot.com 13
http://nodal.ercot.com 14
Special Topics:Recap of Cutover Activities
Market Readiness Seminar
Cut-Over Monthly Outlook – Go-Live Sequence of Events
Date Action Comments
11/15/2010 – 11/29/2010ERCOT Initiates “Soft Start” to Nodal Market Go-Live
ERCOT will run non-binding DAM, RUC daily per Nodal protocol timelines. RTM will remain Open Loop, but continue to publish base points and LMPs. Note that credit will be set high on 11/15
11/15/2010Credit posts ACLs and TPEs for non-binding DAM
First Credit Operating Day 11/16/2010
11/17/2010
Market now able to submit transactions for first Nodal Operating Day (T-14d)
12/01/2010 Operating now available for Market submissions
11/23/2010QSEs with Resources required to submit 7 days of rolling COPs
12/01/2010 required on 11/23/2010
11/28/2010 2:00 PM – 11/28/2010 3:00 PM
Generation and Frequency Control switched to Nodal systems
QSEs will begin following Nodal base pointsSettlements will continue to be Zonal
11/28/2010 2:00 PM – 11/30/2010 11:59:59
QSEs remain on Nodal Control while settling Zonaly
11/29/2010Last Non- Binding DAM for operating day 11/30/2010
01 October 2010
Market Readiness Seminar
Cut-Over Monthly Outlook – Go-Live Sequence of Events
01 October 2010
Time Action Comments
up to 10:00 Bids and Offer submission QSE submit bids and offers
10:00 Close DAM
10:00 Execute Dam Clearing Process
13:30 Approve DAM results Day Ahead results posted to MIS
1330-1430 Submit COP updates
14:30 Close for RUC
14:30 Begin Execution of DRUC
16:00 Approve DRUC Results
16:00 Post DRUC Results
18:00 HRUC Begins Hourly Runs
11/30/2010 Go-Live Sequencing
Market Readiness Seminar
Cut-Over Monthly Outlook – Go-Live Sequence of Events
01 October 2010
• Key Zonal Notes for 11/30/2010 and 12/01/2010– QSEs will maintain:
• Balancing Energy Offers through Operating Day 12/01/2010– Submitted on 11/30 for OD 12/1
• Resource Plans through Operating Day 12/01/2010– Maintained continuously through 12/01 to reflect actual Resource Plan
• Zonal Outages effective on Operating Day 12/01/2010– Examples: Actual Start / End, Forced Outages, etc
– On 11/30/2010 ERCOT will run:• Zonal Ancillary Service Market
– Zonal awards will be published• Zonal RPRS
– Run as a study only– Zonal commitments will not be published
– Zonal prices will not be generated for 12/01/2010– No Zonal Submissions or Markets for Operating Day 12/02/2010
or later
http://nodal.ercot.com 18
Special Topics:Credit
Topics
• TCR and CRR Credit Limits
– Unsecured credit
– TCR collateral disposition
• December 2010 TCR and CRR Auction Overlap
• December 2010 CRR Auction Specifics
• Preliminary Credit Cutover Timeline
• Soft start – credit approach
– First Priority Security Interest
• Approach for estimating initial exposure in CMM
• Counter-Party Authorized Reps
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
TCR and CRR Credit Limits
• Unsecured credit for TCR Auction– Total unsecured credit limit was set as of Oct 1– EAL calculated from the October 21st Zonal Invoice will be used to determine Zonal
exposure– ERCOT will notify TCR Account Holders of how much unsecured credit is available
for TCR auction by October 25th (Total unsecured less QSE exposure)
• Unsecured credit for CRR Auction– Total unsecured credit limit was set as of Oct 1– EAL calculated from the October 28st Zonal Invoice will be used to determine Zonal
exposure– ERCOT will notify CRR Account Holders of how much unsecured credit is available
for TCR auction by November 1st (Total unsecured less QSE exposure)
Market Readiness Seminar
October 14, 2010
TCR and CRR Credit Limits
• TCR Collateral Disposition– IMPORTANT REMINDER – TCR collateral “goes away” after the last TCR
Auction Invoice is paid since TCRs are not referenced in the Nodal Protocols• Guarantees or LCs currently in place for TCR auctions cannot be used for
Nodal activity, including CRR auctions– Language in those documents is specific to TCRs and retires with
TCRs– CPs should plan to replace (if they are not already) these collateral
documents with collateral valid for Nodal (including CRRs)» ERCOT will notify those that have these forms of collateral;
however, each CP should double check internally about what is needed
– Note: Guarantees and LCs held for QSE activity ARE valid for Nodal activity, including CRRs, as well as QSE activity
• Cash collateral can be refunded or transferred to the Nodal collateral pool upon request
– Send requests to [email protected]
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
December 2010 TCR and CRR Auction Overlap
• ERCOT will offer a December 2010 TCR Auction in addition to the December 2010 CRR Auction
– The TCR Auction will occur prior to the CRR Auction– Collateral requirements for Auctions
• TCR collateral will be posted as it has historically been• CRR collateral will be posted separately (similar to TCR collateral) for the
December 2010 CRR auction (see later slides)– The calendar activities for the Auctions overlap such that TCR Auction invoices are
• published prior to collateral being required for the CRR Auction but • due to be paid after the CRR Auction lock date
Note: There are 3 business days between when TCR Auction invoices are published and the CRR Auction lock date
– The overlap in activities is unavoidable given time constraints. Of course, participation is not required in either Auction.
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
December 2010 TCR and CRR Auction Overlap
– Counter-Parties(CPs) who desire to participate in both auctions have several options for managing their collateral during this period
• Post collateral for the TCR auction and separately for the CRR auction– Disadvantage – may have to post higher levels of collateral for a period
of days to accommodate both auctions• Prepay their TCR invoice before the CRR Auction lock date and roll cash
collateral to the CRR auction– Advantage – avoid “doubling up” on collateral requirements for TCR
and CRR auctions– Reminder: Only TCR cash collateral can be “rolled over”
• Reduce collateral held for TCR invoice to invoice amount and roll collateral to the CRR auction
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
December 2010 CRR Auction Specifics
• As discussed in August and September, the initial CRR Auction (for December 2010) held in early November, will be handled as follows:
1. Treated similarly to the current Zonal TCR Auctions
1. Separate collateral posted
2. If participating in both the TCR and CRR Auction, CP will need to coordinate collateral between the two auctions
2. Process
1. CPs will be notified of the unsecured credit available by November 1
2. To the extend additional credit is desired, CP must send collateral specifically earmarked for the December 2010 CRR Auction to ERCOT via wire transfer between October 28 and November 8
3. The combination of posted collateral and unsecured credit allocated by the CRRAH will be the ACL provided for the CRR Auction
3. Available Credit Limits (ACL) viewable in CRR, not MIS• ACLs will be viewable in the CRR Application beginning October 29, 2010 • ACLs will be viewable only by CRR Account Holders and Counter-Parties
and only in the CRR Application leading up to the December CRR Auction (e.g. CMM is in cutover and Credit Reports will not be available on MIS).
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
December 2010 CRR Auction Specifics
Release of CRR collateral / Ongoing collateral requirement for CRR obligations• The CRR Auction will be complete at the same time as the “soft start” of the Nodal
market• Once the CRR Auction is complete,
– CRR inventory will be transferred to CMM (in conjunction with soft start)– CRR Auction invoices will be reflected in TPE in the Credit Reports until paid– Once the CRR Auction Invoice is paid, excess CRR collateral may be refunded,
upon request, with the following consideration• CRR Obligations will be collateralized in CMM (in conjunction with soft start)
as required per Nodal Protocols
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Preliminary Credit Cutover Timeline
Credit Assumptions • For the soft start, ERCOT will calculate Total Potential Exposure (TPE) using a)
Zonal data and b) binding Nodal data. No non-binding Nodal data will be included in the soft start TPE calculations. Collateral included will be actual collateral held. (details to follow in coming slides)
– At this point in the process, CPs should be working within real credit constraints preparatory to Go Live
• Given that the data used in the soft start TPE calculations is binding, ERCOT will use CMM exposures published beginning November 18th for BOTH a) the “soft start” period of Nodal and b) as the bases for binding Zonal collateral requirements
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Preliminary Credit Cutover Timeline
• ERCOT came to this decision based on the following:– The calculations in CMM using Zonal data produce substantially similar results to
what is currently experienced in Zonal– Exposure for binding Nodal activity prior to December 1, 2010 should be
collateralized. CMM is the most efficient way to accomplish this– Making the change for credit effective November 18th will allow both ERCOT and
Counter-Parties time to work through any issues before the remainder of the market starts up
– Making the change for credit effective November 18th will reduce the confusion as to which set of reports (Zonal vs Nodal) to use between November 15th and November 30th
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Preliminary Credit Cutover timeline
• Thursday, November 11th – Zonal invoice published – NOTE - last Zonal EAL credit calculation from which a collateral call will be made
(system will be maintained through Go Live and will be available for a period beyond Go Live)
• The Zonal Invoice published on November 18th will be captured in CMM and Zonal collateral calls will be made based on exposure calculated in CMM using a) Zonal and b) binding Nodal data
• Monday, November 15th – Initial DAM run in “soft start” - without CMM credit constraints
• “e” factors set at 1/0/1
– Initial “soft start” TPE published• TPEs in the “soft start” reflect real exposure and collateral only – no non-binding data
will be included
• Non-binding - No collateral calls sent based on these calculations. However, TPE will be binding on November 18th , so CPs should plan to cover any deficit quickly
– Initial “soft start” ACL sent to CRR and DAM
• Tuesday, November 16th
– Initial DAM run in “soft start” – with CMM credit constraints
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Preliminary Credit Cutover timeline
• Thursday, November 18th – Zonal invoice published – NOTE: CMM calculation of TPE will be used as a) the basis for the soft start
Nodal ACL and b) the binding Zonal credit calculation from which a collateral call will be made
• The Zonal Invoice published on November 18th will be captured in CMM and Zonal collateral calls will be made based on exposure calculated in CMM using a) Zonal and b) binding Nodal data
• From this point forward, ERCOT will use the CMM calculation of TPE as the basis for determining credit exposure for both Zonal and Nodal
• Saturday/Sunday, November 20th – 21st
– CMM calculations will run, Credit Reports will be published and ACLs will be sent to CRR and DAM on non-business days
• Thursday - Sunday, November 25th - 28th – Thanksgiving holiday– CMM calculations will run, Credit Reports will be published and ACLs will be sent
to CRR and DAM on non-business days
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Preliminary Credit Cutover timeline
• Monday, November 29th – Zonal invoice published– Send ACL for initial binding DAM (afternoon)
• Tuesday, November 30th – Initial binding DAM
• “e” factors set at 1/0/1
• Wednesday, December 1st – “Go Live”
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Approach for establishing the initial exposures in CMM
• Nodal Soft start beginning November 15th
• Zonal binding collateral requirements beginning November 18th During this period – ERCOT will publish Credit Reports and send ACLs daily based
on data that
Includes– Actual collateral held (including CRR collateral, excludes TCR collateral)– Zonal data to establish TPE’s (see next slides for details)
– Binding Nodal activity• CRR inventory from December 2010 auction will impact FCE component
– (e.g. Obligations will be collateralized at the greater of the ACPE component of the FCE calculation and the Auction Clearing Price (ACP))
• CRR Auction invoices will be reflected in CMM until paid– First Priority Security Interest to the extent executed and perfected
Excludes– Non-binding Nodal activity resulting from soft start (e.g. DAM results, RT activity,
etc)
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Approach for establishing the initial exposure in CMM
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Key Components For "Soft Start" and Go Live
A Estimated Aggregate Liability (EAL)- "Core" collateral calculation
Highest ADTE - estimate of historical and projected RT activity (See Note)
Soft start - At least nine (9) Zonal invoices will be uploaded into CMM for soft start and ADTE calculations will be based on those Zonal invoices. Go Live - Zonal invoices will continue to be uploaded and will continue to drive this component while Nodal invoices roll in. Zonal invoices will "roll off" over time.
OUT - outstanding historical activity (invoiced and estimated)
Nodal invoices - Soft start - Non-binding invoices WILL NOT be included. Binding invoices WILL be included. Go Live - Binding invoices WILL be included.
Zonal invoice Soft start - Zonal invoices will be included. Go Live - Zonal invoices will be included.
Payments Soft start and Go Live - Payments of Zonal invoices that include Initial statements will be reflected the day after they are received as an OIA adjustment. Payments of Zonal invoices that include only Final, Resettlement or True Up statements will be posted the day after the due date. Payments of Nodal invoices will be reflected the day after they are received.
Approach for establishing the initial exposure in CMM
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Key Components For "Soft Start" and Go Live
UDAA - Unbilled Day Ahead (an estimate of DAM activity prior to an invocie being generated).
Soft start - Non-binding DAM activity (including UDAA) WILL NOT be included in TPE. Go Live - Binding DAM activity WILL be included in TPE beginning with the binding DAM run on November 30. UDAA will be updated daily thereafter. NOTE: ERCOT will "ramp up" for DALE using UDAA as it did in the 168-hour test (so DALE won't hit as a "lump sum" with the first invoice). To "ramp up,", ERCOT will multiply the UDAA by a factor of 5 each day (for the first three days - December 1-3) until the first DAM invoice is published.
DALE - projected forward DAM activity Soft start - Non-binding DAM activity WILL NOT be included. Go Live - No DALE calculation December 1-3 since no DAM invoices have been published. DALE will be calculated using the first DAM invoice and will appear on Credit Reports beginning Saturday, December 4, 2010. Note: Since the first DALE impact will occur on a Saturday, ERCOT will discount the DALE by 25% for Saturday and Sunday, December 4 and 5, 2010. DALE will be calculated at 100% beginning with Credit Reports posted Monday, December 6, 2010 and ACLs sent Monday evening for Tuesday, December 7, 2010.
IEL - Initial Estimated Liability Used as needed for CPs not active in the Zonal market or for new sub-QSEs
Approach for establishing the initial exposure in CMM
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010
Key Components For "Soft Start" and Go Live
B Aggregate Incremental Liability (AIL)- Reasonableness test for ADTE for RT activity Soft start - Zonal BES data will be uploaded and used as a proxy
for RT activity. Zonal bilaterals will be used as a proxy for Energy Trades. Go Live - Zonal data will be used through operating day November 30, 2010. Nodal data will roll in as it occurs. Zonal data will roll off over time.
C Future Credit Exposure (FCE)- Forward value of CRRs held Soft start - CRR Obligations - CMM calculation will use the
higher of the ACPE or ACP. CRR Options - No collateral requirements.
Go Live - CRR Obligations - CMM calculation will use the higher of the ACPE or ACP initially. Calculation will use DAM and RT prices as they become available. CRR Options - No collateral requirements. Credits available per Protocols.
Note: If a Counter-Party believes that their Zonal ADTE is not representative of their anticipated Nodal RT activity, they can provide an estimate of anticipated RT activity and ERCOT will consider revising ADTE appropriately.
Counter-Party Contact information
• Reminder – If you haven’t already, please complete the Notice of Change of Information (NCI) form to designate an a) Authorized Representative and also a b) Backup Authorized Representative for your Counter-Party (overall rather than for a specific QSE or CRRAH)
– Market Notice went out on September 13, 2010– ERCOT will contact these designated individuals along with the credit contacts for
credit purposes such as collateral calls, late payment notices and breach or default notices.
Market Readiness SeminarOctober 14, 2010