HSE Process
-
Upload
faress-rabi -
Category
Documents
-
view
233 -
download
1
Transcript of HSE Process
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
1/142
Basic HSE Process
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
2/142
Contents
Aims and objectives
Introduction to HSE Value
Major Disaster
HSE Management system (ILO)
Human FactorRisk Assessment
Accident Causation and investigation
Fire and Explosion Basics
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
3/142
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
4/142
Aims
To understand:
The requirements of Health and Safety Management Systems
The human factors that must be taken into account to
achieve a safe and health work environment
Risk assessment concepts for major hazards
Accidents and near misses causation and analysis to prevent
recurrence
The fire, explosion basics and the technology of fire and
explosion.
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
5/142
Introduction to HSE
Importance
Introduction to HSE
Importance
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
6/142
Introduction
What is Health and Safety?
◦ Health
Absence of disease
Physical and mental elements related to safety andhygiene at work
◦ Safety “Freedom from unacceptable risk”
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
7/142
Introduction
Welfare
◦ “Looking after people’s basic needs’”
Environmental Protection
◦ “The surroundings in which an organisation
operates, including air, water, land, natural
resources, human and their relationships”
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
8/142
Types of Accidents and Ill-health
Safety accidents include Occupational ill-health cases include
• Falls from height: death, brokenbones
• Slips trips falls: sprains, broken
bones
• Struck by vehicles: death, crush
injuries
• Struck by an object: crush injuries
• Electrical: burns, heart problems
• Crushed by a moving part of a
machine: broken bones, amputation
• Fire and explosions: burns,
asphyxiation and blast injuries
• Incorrect manual handling: backinjuries
• Exposure to chemicals: cancers
• Repeated assembly work: repetitive
strain injuries
•
Exposure to glass or sand dust:silicosis
• Working with hand held tools:
vibration white finger
• Exposure to asbestos dust / fibres:
asbestosis
• Exposure to dusts or chemicals:
asthma
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
9/142
Causes of Accidents and Ill-health
Safety Health
• Tends to affect individuals by contact
with the hazard
• Affects people by exposure to the
hazard
• Often an obvious danger • Often ‘hidden’ danger
• The results of an accident are
immediate
• Ill-health often builds up slowly
• Foreseeable or known ‘loss’ • ‘Loss’ is often difficult to assess
• Knowledge since the ‘industrial
revolution’
• Understanding lags behind, e.g. what
triggers an allergic reaction to some
substances
• Hardware or safe place solutions are
usually available, e.g. guarding,
protection of electrical systems
• Often rely on software or
behavioural safe person solutions,
e.g. use of personal protection, safe
systems of work
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
10/142
Why Manage Health and Safety?
Moral Reasonsoral Reasons
Legal Reasonsegal Reasons Financialinancial
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
11/142
1. Moral
Workplace Injuries
◦ Company work related LTI’s and injuriesstatistics
Work-related diseases
◦ Company records for illness
Graph for statistics
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
12/142
2. Legal
Law:
◦ “ a r u l e o f h u m a n b e h a v i o u r , c a r r y o u t u p o n a n d
r e q u i r e d b e t w e e n t h e m e m b e r s o f a g iv e n s t a t e”
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
13/142
3. Financial
Cost of accidents and ill-health
Insurance does not cover all losses suffered
◦ Insurance policies for employees:
–Workers’ Compensation, Employers’ Liability
◦ Other policies:–Fire, business interruption, Public Liability,
Product Liability
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
14/142
3. Financial
Uninsured or ‘hidden’ cost of failure:
◦ Lost time◦ Extra pay, overtime, temporary workers◦ Sick pay◦ Fines◦ Legal costs◦ Excess on any claim
◦ Damage or loss of product or services◦ Site cleaning◦ Investigation time◦ Plant and equipment repair◦ Delays◦ Loss of contracts
◦ Increased insurance premiums◦ Loss of business reputation
£1
£8 - £36
UK estimate (HSE)
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
15/142
Basic Aspect of Our Business
ProductionProduction
QualityQuality
CostCost
Employee
Relations
Employee
Relations
SafetySafety
Business
Success
Business
Success
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
16/142
Major DisasterMajor Disaster
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
17/142
Piper Alpha
• Summery
– The Piper Alpha was a North Sea oil production platform.
– Was operated by Occidental Petroleum (Caledonia) Ltd.
– 167 men died when an explosion and resulting fire destroyed it on July 6th, 1988.
• Video
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
18/142
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
19/142
HSE Management System
(ILO)
HSE Management System
(ILO)
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
20/142
H&S ManagementSystems
Value
◦ Align business and health and safety objectives
◦ Management framework
◦ Policies, procedures and objectives◦ Continuous improvement
◦ Auditable baseline
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
21/142
ILO-OSH, 2001 (ILO)
Policy
Organising
Planning and
Implementation
Evaluation
Action forimprovement
Policy
Organising
Planning &
implementationEvaluation
Action for
improvement
Audit
Continualimprovement
Continual
improvement
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
22/142
1. Policy
Business plan for safety
◦ Health and safety aims
◦ Health and safetyobjectives
◦ Management commitment
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
23/142
2. Organising
Promoting a positive culture
◦ Competence
–Recruitment, knowledge, ability training,experience, qualifications
◦ Commitment and control
–Allocating responsibility and accountability–Securing commitment
–Information, training instruction andsupervision (ITIS)
◦ Co-operation
–Internal and external
◦ Communication
–Oral, written, visible
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
24/142
3. Planning and Implementation
Set targets
Identify hazards, assess andcontrol risks
Standard setting and monitoring
Legal compliance Safe systems of work
Purchase policy
Control of contractors
Emergency procedures
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
25/142
4. Evaluation
Measuring performance
• Active monitoring
• Reactive monitoring
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
26/142
5. Action for Improvement
Learn from experience
• Audit
• Performance review
Active and reactivemonitoring
Benchmarking
Achievement of objectives
Continual improvement
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
27/142
StandardsStandards
PlanningPlanning
ExecutionExecutionMeasureMeasure
EvaluateEvaluate
PeoplePeople
ES&H is
Value
ES&H is
Value Leadership
Commitment
Belief
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
28/142
Human FactorsHuman Factors
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
29/142
Health and Safety Culture
“The product of individual and group values,
attitudes, competencies and patterns of behaviour that determine the commitment to,
and the style and proficiency of , an
organisation's health and safety programmes.
Organisations with a positive safety culture arecharacterised by communications founded on
mutual trust, by shared perceptions of the
importance of safety, and by confidence in the
efficiency of preventive measures”
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
30/142
Positive Health and Safety Culture
Positive outputs
Increased
levels of compliance
staff morale
Reduced
staff complaints
staff turnover
absenteeism
sickness and accident rates
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
31/142
Negative Health and Safety Culture
Promoted by:
Poor example of behaviour set by management
Poor management decision-making
Inadequate supervision Poor working conditions
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
32/142
Why do we need to
understand (safety)
culture?
Why do we need to
understand (safety)
culture?
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
33/142
Traditional Management Approach
(Different Safety Cultures’ Styles)
SWAMP (Safety Without Any Management Process)
NORM (Naturally Occurring R eactive Management)
World Class Safety Culture
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
34/142
SWAMP(Safety Without Any Management Process)
Safety Responsibility: Not recognized - rejected
Accidents are accepted - a fluke Autocratic style
Task oriented - production comprised
Planning minimal - reactive short term
Communications - fear based
Make do/make fit approaches
Minimal employee involvement
Adversarial
Management Characteristics
Organizational Impacts
High Excessive Poor Statutory
Insurance Losses Employee Ignorance
Cost Relations
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
35/142
NORM(Naturally Occurring Reactive Management)
Safety Responsibility: Not understood by staff Perceived: “A cost” driven by regulatory compliance
Accidents excused away/fault based
Recognizes problem - can’t solve
Is not quite sold - go half way (what’seasy)
Highly visibility - many labels - littleresults
Significant line/staff authority conflicts
Programs/campaigns short lived
Results (only) measured
Line accountability lacking
Employees lead “the actions” - see thecredibility gap - “do nothing”
Blood Symptoms Committees Quick-fix
Cycles (Basic Causes) Programs
Management Characteristics
Organizational Impacts
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
36/142
World Class
Safety Responsibility: Owned and led by all employees at all levels
Perceived: “Good Business” - (a value)
Accidents are “intolerable”/prevented
Safety is management effectiveness
Long-term planning
Responsibilities/expectations clearlydefined
No “instant pudding” approaches
Employee centered/gain sharing
Communications - informal, open,and encouraged
Efforts measured and responded to
Zero Progressive “Walking
Accidents Employee the Talk”
Concept/Reality Involvement
Management Characteristics
Organizational Impacts
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
37/142
Evaluate this projects safety culture
Swamp Norm World-Class
A. Explain Reason for your rating:
______________________________________________________ ____
______________________________________________________
____
B. In your opinion what will it take to make your portionof the project World-Class?
______________________________________________________ ____
Safety Culture Assessment
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
38/142
Health and Safety Performance
1970’s 1980’s 1990’s 2000’s
Technicalimprovements
(Hardware)
Process andprocedural safety
(Software)
Human factors
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
39/142
The History of Safety
N u m b e r & S e v e r i t
y o f I n j u r i e s No Formal InterestNo Formal Interest
Human Factor Era (BBS)Human Factor Era (BBS)
Time
Preventive Era (Process Based)Preventive Era (Process Based)
Reactive Era (Incident Based)Reactive Era (Incident Based)
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
40/142
Behaviour:
Any act can be seen
An unsafe Act (At risk Behaviour):
An act that contravenes accepted safe practice or procedure
that could result in injury either to the person doing the task
or to others
An unsafe Condition:
An unacceptable physical state (caused by an unsafe act)
that could result in injury
Definition of Terms
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
41/142
Cause of injuries
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
42/142
TITANIC1913
Iceberg Theory
Unsafe
Behaviors
Fatality
LTI’s
Med. Case
First Aid
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
43/142
Unsafe Behaviour
Near Miss
Minor Injury
Serious Injury
Fatality
Incident triangle
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
44/142
1
10
30
600
24,000
Relationship Triangle
Fatality
Serious Injuries
Minor Injuries
Near Miss
Unsafe Behaviours
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
45/142
98% of all Accidentsare due to
Unsafe Behavior
Safe Work PracticesSafe Work Practices
Accidents
Melt the Iceberg!
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
46/142
Factors Influence Behaviour
Behaviour are Influenced by the:
◦ Organisation
◦ Job
◦ Individual
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
47/142
The Organisation
Organisational factors have thegreatest influence on individual andgroup behaviour
◦ Planning
◦ Organising
◦ Control
◦ Monitoring
◦ Review and Audit
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
48/142
The Organisation
External influences
◦ Societal expectations
◦ Political priorities
◦ Legislation and enforcement
◦ National / international agencies (Labour Office,
OSHA, ILO)
◦ Pressure groups
◦ Insurers
◦ Worker Unions
◦ Stakeholders
◦ Economic conditions
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
49/142
The Job
Physical match
◦ Work equipment, work method and workplace
Psychological match◦ Individual capabilities
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
50/142
The Job
Ergonomics
◦ Interaction of humans with their:
– work equipment, work environment and work method
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
51/142
The Job
Extent of decision making
Procedures, information and instructions
Working environment
Maintenance
Working time
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
52/142
The Individual
Physical characteristics
Psychological attributes
Social and cultural differences
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
53/142
The Individual - Attitude
Attitude
◦ The way an individual believes they will respondin a given situation
behaviour often conflicts with attitude
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
54/142
The Individual - Perception
Perception
◦ The way in which aperson interpretssensory information
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
55/142
The Individual - Perception
Ri k P i f
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
56/142
Risk Perception of getting Injured
O
100
( t )time
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
57/142
The Source of Injuriesat Worksites
Perception
Failure AccidentsOnly &Always Only &AlwaysUnsafeActs
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
58/142
The Individual - Perception
Affected by:◦ Sensory defects
◦ Mental processing
◦ Hazard nature
◦ Previous experience
◦ Being in control◦ Training
◦ Peer group influence
◦ Confidence in others
◦ Personal characteristics
Managed by:◦ Increasing awareness of
hazards
◦ Involving people
◦ Identification of poorbehaviour
◦ Improving the workingenvironment
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
59/142
The Individual
Motivation
◦ The force which stimulates anindividual to do something
people are motivated by theirperceived wants and needs
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
60/142
ABC Model
Activatorsctivators
C
onsequencesonsequences
B
ehaviour
Direct
Motivate
We Understand Behaviour
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
61/142
We Understand BehaviourBy Looking at Activators andConsequences
Activators
: Safety Meetings Goal settingRules and Regulations Pledge signingPolicies and Procedure IncentivesDirective Feedback SignsTraining Modelling
Behaviors : Driving the speed limitPutting on PPELocking out powerUsing equipment guardsGiving a safety talkCleaning up spillsCoaching others about safe work practices
Consequences :Self-approval Reprimand
Peer approval Penalty
Feedback InjuryPrize InconvenienceThank-you Time savings
Safety is
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
62/142
Safety isThe Continuous Fight
with Human Nature
Unsafe behaviours are often …◦ more comfortable
◦ more convenient
◦ more time-efficient
… than safe behaviours.
• Unsafe behaviours rarely result in …– an injury
– disciplinary action
… or anything to discourage the
behaviours.
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
63/142
The Individual – UnsafeBehaviour
Lack of motivation
Unrealistic procedures
Management commitment
Over-familiarity with tasks
Boredom
Peer group pressure
Wilful disregard
Ineffective supervision
Fatigue / stress
Lack of information, training, etc.
Job insecurity
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
64/142
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
65/142
Reducing Human Failure
Skilled, competent workers
Well, motivated employees
Clear role and responsibilities
Adequate supervision
Clear information and instruction
Drugs and alcohol prevention policy
Good environmental conditions
Avoiding monotonous work
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
66/142
Human Behaviour
Influence of peers
Promoting safe behaviour
◦ Discipline
◦ Reward
◦ Inform◦ Facilitate
◦ Train
◦ Involving employees
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
67/142
INDIVIDUALCompetence, Skills
Personality, experience
Attitudes
Risk Perception
INDIVIDUALCompetence, Skills
Personality, experience
Attitudes
Risk Perception
Provide Training
Better Selection
Health monitoring
Coaching
etc
THE JOBTask, Workload
Environment,
Display & Controls
Procedures
THE JOBTask, Workload
Environment,
Display & Controls
Procedures
Improve workplace
layout
Reduce Noise
Improve Lighting
Provide proper
tools
ORGANISATIONCulture, Leadership
Resources
Work Patterns
Communications
ORGANISATIONCulture, Leadership
Resources
Work Patterns
Communications
Improve Safety
Culture via
demonstrable Safety
Leadership
HSEMS
Implementation
Look at the Big Picture !
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
68/142
Section 6
Risk Assessment
Section 6
Risk Assessment
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
69/142
Introduction
Risk assessment is a qualitative method of assessing therisks associated with a particular job, activity or taskin order
to identify the control and contingency measures thatshould be taken to manage the risks.
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
70/142
Definitions
ALARP
As Low As reasonably Practicable (ALARP), is determined
when it can be shown that no more measures can reasonably
be taken in order to reduce the risks further.
Hazard
A hazard is an article, substance or situation that has the
potential to cause harm. This can include materials,
machines, methods of work and other aspects of work
organization.
Risk
A risk is the likelihood that the harm from a particular hazard
will be realized. The product of this likelihood and the severityof the outcome determine the magnitude of risk.
A L A R bl
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
71/142
As Low As Reasonably Practicable (ALARP)
Unacceptable region
Broadly acceptable region
(No need for detailed working to
demonstrate ALARP)
ALARP or tolerability
region (Risk undertakenonly if benefit desired)
Risk can not be justified
except in extraordinary
circumstances
Tolerable only if risk reduction is
impracticable or its cost is
grossly disproportionate to the
improvement gained
Tolerable if cost of reduction
would exceed the improvement
gained
Necessary to maintain
assurances that risk remains atthis level
Negligible risk
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
72/142
Definitions
Risk =Likelihood (Probability) X Consequence
(Severity)
Likelihood (Probability)Is the description of how often an event will occur.
Usually based on historical data and statistics.
Consequence (Severity)
Is a description of how bad and how severe the eventmight be.
Risk Assessment
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
73/142
Risk AssessmentProcess
Five essential steps
Step 1 - Look for the Hazards
Step 2 - Decide who may be harmed and how
Step 3 - Evaluate the risks arising from the hazards
Step 4 - Record
Step 5 - Monitor and Review
Step 1
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
74/142
Step 1
Look for the Hazards
Look for what could reasonably be expectedto cause harm.
Ignore the trivial and concentrate only onsignificant hazards, considering:
the equipment and materials being used and
the environment where the work is being carriedout.
Manufacturer instructions or material data
sheets can also help you.
St 2
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
75/142
Step 2
Decide who may be harmed
Think about people who may not be at the work place atthe time, e.g. cleaner, visitors, contractors, and
members of the public, etc. Is there any chance that they might be harmed by your
activities?
Step 3
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
76/142
p
Evaluate the risksarising from the hazards
Risks reduction hierarchy: (ERICPD) Eliminate the hazard to remove the risk; e.g. use of intrinsically safe electrical equipment in a classified
area (elimination of sparks, which are ignition sources).
Reduce or substitute the hazard with an alternative; e.g. use of sodium hypochlorite solution in stead of free chlorine
gas for disinfection purposes.
Isolate the hazard from people; e.g. fencing of excavations.
Control the hazard by introducing suitable measures; e.g. Permit-to-Work system.
Personal protective equipment; e.g. use of safety harness when working at height.
Discipline - personal discipline which is competencebased (e.g. well trained staff) and organizational discipline which is rule
based (e.g. adherence to work procedures).
Step 4
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
77/142
Step 4
Record
Record the findings, write down the more significanthazards e.g. above ground power cables.
Step 5
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
78/142
Step 5
Monitor and Review
Review your assessment from time to time and reviseif necessary.
If there is any significant change, you should add to
the assessment to take account of the new hazards.
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
79/142
Severity
Slight Injury
First Aid
Minor/
Serious Injury
Major/
Lost Time
> 3 days
Single Fatality
/Permanent
Disability
Multiple
Fatalities
Likelihood 2 4 6 8 10
Certain 10 20 40 60 80 100
Very Likely 8 16 32 48 64 80
Likely 6 12 24 36 48 60
May Happen 4 8 16 24 32 40
Unlikely 2 4 8 12 16 20
The matrix shown can provide a breakdown of the Risk into categories:-
Risk Evaluation
Ri k E l ti
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
80/142
201612842Unlikely
4032241684May Happen
60483624126Likely
80644832168Very Likely
1008060402010Certain
108642Likelihood
Multiple
Fatalities
Single Fatality
/Permanent
Disability
Major/
Lost Time
> 3 days
Minor/
Serious Injury
Slight Injury
First Aid
Severity
201612842Unlikely
4032241684May Happen
60483624126Likely
80644832168Very Likely
1008060402010Certain
108642Likelihood
Multiple
Fatalities
Single Fatality
/Permanent
Disability
Major/
Lost Time
> 3 days
Minor/
Serious Injury
Slight Injury
First Aid
Severity
4 - 8
12 - 24
32 - 48
60 - 100
Trivial Risk; No further improvements. Necessary control measures are provided and maintained.
Adequately Controlled Risk; Risk is tolerable when control measures are implemented.
Moderately Controlled Risk; Further Risk Reduction Measures should be considered.
Intolerable Risk; Seek specialist advice / support.
Risk Evaluation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
81/142
Section 7
Accident causation and
Investigation
Section 7
Accident causation and
Investigation
Wh I i ?
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
82/142
Why Investigate?
Prevent future accidents
Demonstrate concern
Identify management system weaknesses
Prevent business loss
Best practice compliance
Collate data and establish trends
Defend civil claims
Defend a criminal case
D fi iti
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
83/142
Definitions
Accident
“ An unplanned, unwanted event whichresults in loss”
Incident / near-miss
“ An unplanned, unwanted event that hasthe potential to result in loss”
Occupational ill-health
Any acute or chronic ill-health (disease)caused by physical, chemical, biological,ergonomic or psychological hazards
D i Th
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
84/142
E
DCB
A
A = Root causes - Lack of management control
B = Basic causes - Individual and job factorsC = Immediate causes - Unsafe acts and conditionsD = AccidentE = Loss
Domino Theory
Active And Latent
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
85/142
Active And LatentFailures
Active
Failures
Controls
SupervisionRoles & ResponsibilitiesDesignCommunication / Info.Risk Assessment
Procedures / methodsTrainingEquipmentInspection / maintenanceAudit
Skil ls based
behaviour
Wilful violationErrorAt-risk behaviour
Guards
PPE
Rules
Methods
etc
Local management
create these Then it only takes oneof these...
IncidentLatent
failures
Decisions
OrganisationStaffingBudgetTiming
Work FlowDesignPriority conflicts
The Swiss cheese model of
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
86/142
accident causation
Some holes dueto active failures
Other holes due tolatent conditions
(resident ‘pathogens’)
Hazards
Losses
Managementdecisions
Latentfailures
Activefailures
How and why defences
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
87/142
yfail?
Unsafe acts
Local workplace factors
Organisational factors
Hazards
Defences/ Barriers/ Controls
Latentconditionpathways
Causes
Investigation
HOW?
WHY?
Losses
Accident Categories /
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
88/142
Accident Categories /Types
Slips / trips / falls onsame level
Falls from height
Falling objects
Collision with objects
Trapping / crushing
Manual handling
Machinery contact
Electricity
Transport
Chemical contact
Asphyxiation /drowning
Fire and explosion
Animals
Violence
Actions Following An
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
89/142
Actions Following AnIncident
Emergency response
Initial report
Initial assessment and investigation
Gather information
Accident Investigation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
90/142
Accident Investigation
What should be investigated?
Do not only consider severity of loss
Also consider the potentialconsequences and likelihood of recurrence
Accident Investigation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
91/142
Accident Investigation
Four steps
1. Gather the information
2. Analyse the information3. Identify the risk control measures
4. Take action
Accident Investigation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
92/142
Accident Investigation
1. Gather the information Questionnaire
Interviews
Documents, Records
Accident Investigation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
93/142
Accident Investigation
2. Analyse the information Determine:
The type of accident
The immediate causes (unsafe actsand conditions)
The basic causes (individual and jobfactors)
The root causes (lack of managementcontrol
Accident Investigation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
94/142
Accident Investigation
3. Identify the risk control measures Measures which eliminate risk
Measures which combat risks at source
Measures that minimise the risk byrelying on human behaviour
Accident Investigation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
95/142
Accident Investigation
4. Take action Action plan
Apply control measures
Investigation report
Records Review
Risk Assessment. Were the risks identifiedbefore the accident?
Risk control. Why did management systemsfail?
How effective were the emergencyprocedures?
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
96/142
Section 9
Fire and Explosion
Basics
Section 9
Fire and Explosion
Basics
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
97/142
Introductionntroduction
• Fire kills over 1.000 people every year and injuries many more.
• Fire destroys jobs and property and costs millions of pounds in
the payment of insurance claims .• Every fire, no matter how large the end result, starts from small
beginnings,
But certain fundamentals are common to every incident.
Knowledge of these will help to prevent or control a fire.
Fire and ExplosionFire and Explosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
98/142
TechnologyTechnology
To understand how to avoid creating the conditionsleading to a fire or explosion, it will help if we
explore how these chemical reactions take place atthe molecular level.
For a Fire or Explosion to occur, molecules of fuel andoxidizer must meet and electrons must be changed
A fuel is any substance that can donate electron to theoxidizer, which is any substance that can accept thedonated electron.
This reaction releases heat and is self-sustaining.
Fire and ExplosionFire and Explosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
99/142
TechnologyTechnology
To have these electrons exchanged, there must be amotive force to push molecules sufficiently close for thereaction (exchange of electrons)
This motive force is called the “Activation energy” .
In case of the fire or explosion reaction, the activationenergy is called the “Source of Ignition”
Fire and ExplosionFire and Explosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
100/142
TechnologyTechnology
Once the fuel and oxidizer meet and react, they form newcompound, such as water vapor and carbon dioxide, andalso release great amount of heat.
This energy is greater than the amount needed for initialreaction.
That excess energy is then available to cause the nextmolecules in line to come together to react.
This continues in what is known as “chain reaction”.
Chain reaction will not stop until either fuel or oxidizer isused up, or something else is put into the mix that siphons
off the energy until there is too little lift to initiate any morereaction.
Fire and ExplosionFire and Explosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
101/142
TechnologyTechnology
The difference between the reaction we call a fire and onewe call an explosion is the speed at which the reaction frontmoves through the mixture of fuel and oxidizer molecules.
Fire moves at subsonic speed, while the explosion flame frontmoves at supersonic speed.
Some times is five to six times the sound speed
”The sound speed is 1220 km/H or 339 m/sec”
The relationship of the elements needed for a fire or an
explosion is most often represented by the Fire Triangle
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
102/142
Chemistry Of Combustionhemistry Of Combustion
Atomic structure
Combustion of Methane
CH 4 + 2O2 CO2 + 2H 2O - 890kJ
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
103/142
Fire Triangleire Triangle
• Oxidizer A substance that will accept an electron from a fuelmolecule as part of chain reaction called fire orexplosion.Oxygen is typically an oxidizer, either in theatmosphere or introduced by oxyacetylene set.
• Fuel Any substance that can donate an electron to anoxidizer. In practical terms, any material that can burn.
• Ignition source Any source of energy capable to of
producing an incendiary spark, heat, or flame.
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
104/142
Heat Sourceseat Sources
To reach ignitionTemperature
Open flame – The Sun - Hotsurfaces - Sparks and Arcs
Friction – Chemical ActionElectrical Energy -
Compression of Gases
Fire Triangleire Triangle
xygen Sourcesxygen Sources
Approximately 16%required
Normal air contain 21% O2.
Some fuel material materialcontain sufficient oxygen
within their make-up tosupport burning
Solidsolids
Coal – Wood – Paper – Cloth – Wax –Grease – Plastic –
Surge – Grain – Hay – Cork, and Others
Gasesases
Natural Gas –Propane – Butane –
Hydrogen – Acetylene Carbon
Monoxide, andOthers
Liquidsiquids
Gasoline – Kerosene – Turpentine –
Alcohol – Paint – Varnish – Benzene –Olive oil, and Others
Fuel Physical State
Fire
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
105/142
• Flash Point The temperature to which a combustible orflammable liquid must be raised so that enough vapor formsabove the surface of the liquid to enter the flammablerange. A liquid below its flash point temperature does not
produce enough vapor to burn.• Note: This concept does not apply when the liquid is
atomized into a fine mist, such as when in an airliner crashesor paint solvent is applied using a sprayer, creating a mist.Liquids at temperatures below their flash point can igniteunder such circumstances.
Flash Pointlash Point
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
106/142
Fire point
• The minimum temperature where sufficient flammablevapour is produced to support continuous combustiononce ignited by an outside source of heat
Auto-ignition
• The temperature where a flammable vapour will ignitewithout an external source of ignition
Definitionsefinitions
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
107/142
• Combustible Refers to material with a flash pointat or above 100 F ( 37.8 C.)
• Flammable A material with a flash point less than
100 F ( 37.8 C.)
• Flammable Range The range of ratios of fuel tooxidizer in a mix that can be ignited by an energysource; between LFL and UFL. A concentration of fuel vapor or gas outside of this range will not burnor explode.
Definitionsefinitions
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
108/142
0% 100%
Flammable Rangelammable Range
LFLLFL UFLUFL
1.4% 7.6%
Too reach
Too lean
Flammable Range
(Percent Gasoline Fuel Vapor)
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
109/142
100%
Oxygen
100%
Fuel
0%
Oxygen
0%
Fuel
UFLUFL
LFLLFL
Flash pointFlash point
F u e l /
A i r c o n
c e n t r a t i o n
F u e l /
A i r c o n
c e n t r a t i o n
Temperature oCTemperature oC
Auto-ignitionAuto-ignition
Flammable Rangelammable Range
Flammable range
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
110/142
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
111/142
Fire Spreadire Spread
1.
Direct contact
2. Conduction
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
112/142
Fire Spreadire Spread
3. Convection
4. Radiation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
113/142
Fire Spreadire Spread
Open burning fires Enclosed fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
114/142
Fire Spreadire Spread
Enclosed fires
• Thermal layering
• Flash-over
• Back draught
Fire damage
Explosionxplosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
115/142
Deflagration
• Subsonic velocity
• Relatively slow pressure build up
• Fireball
Detonation
• Supersonic velocity• Rapid pressure build up
• Destructive
Explosionxplosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
116/142
Classification
• Physical explosions
• Chemical explosions
• Escape of flammable fluids• Electrical explosions
Explosionxplosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
117/142
AtmosphericPressure
AtmosphericPressure
PressurePressure
Over Pressure Zone
Under Pressure
Zone
TimeTime
MEPMEP
Explosionxplosion
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
118/142
Explosive limits
• LEL• UEL
BLEVELEVE
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
119/142
Overpressure caused by external
fire
• Worst case flame impinging onvapour space
Relief valve operates liberating
fuel
• Containment fails as internaltemperature rises above criticaltemperature
• Results in secondary explosion andfireball (radiation hazard),fragmentation and blast pressurewave (destructive)
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
120/142
Flash Fireslash Fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
121/142
Fire in premixed region
Rapid flame propagation
Thermal radiation
Flame decay
Pool Firesool Fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
122/142
Ignition of evaporatingliquid
Heat produced causesliberation of vapour and
steady burning Less dangerous to human
life than flash fires
Structural and equipment
damage
Pool Firesool Fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
123/142
Sources
• Spillage
Onto water
Onto land
Into a bund
Pool Firesool Fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
124/142
Sources
• Tanks which have losttheir roof after an
explosion
Pool Firesool Fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
125/142
Duration
• Depends on depth of fuel
Thermal energy release
• Incomplete combustion(smoke)
• (W/m3)
Fireballireball
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
126/142
A fire that risesinto the air as aball or sphere
Jet Fireset Fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
127/142
Pressurised release of flammable liquid or gas
Gravity release frompunctured vessel or pipe
Jet Fireset Fires
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
128/142
Produces a long flame
Diffusion flame
• fuel and air not initially mixed
Liquid ‘rain’ causes pool fire Flame length proportional to flow rate
• A pressurised release of 8 kg/s wouldhave a length of 35 m
Fire Hazards To Plantire Hazards To Plant
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
129/142
Radiation Smoke (products of
combustion)
Loss of mechanical
strength• Tanks, pipework,
supporting structures,Building may fail
Fire Hazards To Plantire Hazards To Plant
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
130/142
Bunds• Confines and limits areaof spillage
• Reduces
Pool size, therefore surface
area for evaporation Extent of flammable cloud
Probability of ignition
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
131/142
Natural Gas, IntroductionNatural Gas, Introduction
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
132/142
What is Natural Gas?
Natural gas is a highly efficient form of energy.
It's a colorless, odorless gas that is lighter thanair.
Its most abundant component is methane (about95% by volume.) The remaining 5% consists of ethane, nitrogen, propane, other heavierhydrocarbons, and trace contaminants such as sulfurcompounds and water.
and Overviewand Overview
Natural Gas, IntroductionNatural Gas, Introduction
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
133/142
Natural gas facts
Natural gas is lighter than air, it dissipates quickly inwell-ventilated areas – unless it becomes trapped in an
enclosed space.Given the right concentrations of natural gas and air, natural
gas can ignite from sparks from electrical switches or
appliances and from open flames such as matches,cigarettesand hot works. Fire or explosions can result.
Natural gas is not poisonous, but it can causeunconsciousness in high concentrations when it displaces air.
Natural gas is odorless
and Overviewand Overview
Natural Gas Hazardsatural Gas Hazards
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
134/142
Health Hazard
Eye and Skin Contact; It is documented that is notan eye or skin irritant.
Inhalation (Breathing); Asphyxiant – High
concentration may limit oxygen available for breathing.
Signs and Symptoms; Drowsiness, Confusion,Visual disturbance, Vomiting, Unconsciousness, and canlead to Death.
Natural Gas Hazardsatural Gas Hazards
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
135/142
Fire Explosion Hazard
Flammable gas;Can cause flash fire;Keep away from Heat, Sparks, Flames, or other
lit sources; e.g Static electricity,Hot work operation,cigarettes, mobile phone and mechanical/electrical
equipment.
Vapors may travel considerable distance;Has the potential to create vapor/air explosion
hazard (indoor and out door)Closed containers, like pipes, exposed to
extreme heat can rupture due to pressure build up
Control Measuresontrol Measures
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
136/142
Risk control:• Maintain high levels of inherent safety
• Manage hazards effectively during production andmaintenance activities
Objectives:
• Minimise the likelihood of hazard release events(inventory control)
• Minimise the risk of fires and explosions occurring(ignition source control)
Control Measuresontrol Measures
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
137/142
Safe operating procedures
Maintenance activities
Reduce potential hydrocarbon leak sources
Control of other flammable hazards Control of ignition sources (for minor and
major releases
Ignition Source Controlgnition Source Control
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
138/142
Identification and assessment
Area classification and environmental control
Segregation
Access control
Control Measures
–
Access Limitation
Control Measures
–
Access Limitation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
139/142
Access Limitation
Personnel Access
Designated Areas
Competent persons
Area Pass
Permit to Work (PTW)
Personal Properties
(Lighters, Matches and Heaters)
Non-intrinsic equipment
(Mobile phone, Laptop, Camera, Pagers and Non-intrinsic Radio,,…etc.)
Control Measures
–
Access Limitation
Control Measures
–
Access Limitation
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
140/142
Access Limitation
Vehicles and Equipment
Inspection and Certification by Authorized Person
Diesel motor vehicles ONLY ! –No petrol motorGas proof – Spark Arrestor
STOP
Control Measures
–
Tools and Equipment
Control Measures
–
Tools and Equipment
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
141/142
Tools and Equipment
Inspection and Maintenance by Authorized Person
Gas Proof
Color Code
(Hand Power Tools –Rigging Hard Ware)
أص
YELLOW
GREENأخض
أحم
RED
أز ق
BLUE
First Quarter(January, February and March)
Second Quarter(April, May and June)
Third Quarter(July, August and September)
Fourth Quarter(October, November and December)
-
8/9/2019 HSE Process
142/142