How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ......

23
How ESG drives business performance Benjamin McCarron Managing Director, Asia Research and Engagement Specialist Consultant, Asian Corporate Governance AssociaBon Sustainable Development Forum October 8, 2015

Transcript of How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ......

Page 1: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

How  ESG  drives  business  performance  Benjamin  McCarron  Managing  Director,  Asia  Research  and  Engagement  Specialist  Consultant,  Asian  Corporate  Governance  AssociaBon    

Sustainable  Development  Forum  October  8,  2015  

Page 2: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

How  ESG  drives  business  performance  Benjamin  McCarron  Managing  Director,  Asia  Research  and  Engagement  Specialist  Consultant,  Asian  Corporate  Governance  AssociaBon    

Sustainable  Development  Forum  October  8,  2015  

Page 3: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Making  money  and  sustainability  Benjamin  McCarron  Managing  Director,  Asia  Research  and  Engagement  Specialist  Consultant,  Asian  Corporate  Governance  AssociaBon    

Sustainable  Development  Forum  October  8,  2015  

Page 4: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

•  Studies  on  the  business  benefits  •  What  is  ‘corporate  sustainability’  •  Company  case  studies  by  value  driver  

– Turnover  growth  and  innovaBon  – Risk  management  – ProducBvity  improvement  

 

Making  money  and  sustainability  

Page 5: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

MulBple  studies  find  ESG  adds  value  

Source: Arrabesque Partners and Oxford University, From the Stockholder to the Stakeholder, March 2015

Type  of  study  ProporBon  where  ESG  adds  value  

Cost  of  capital   90%  

OperaBng  performance   88%  

Stock  price   80%  

Review  of  190  studies  on  economic  relevance  of  ESG  

Page 6: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

What  is  corporate  sustainability?  

Page 7: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

A  sustainable  business  roadmap  

Philanthropy  

Community  Investment  

Corporate  Responsibility  

Sustainable  Business  

Level 0

Level 1

Level 2

Level 3

Page 8: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

The  M&S  Journey  

Philanthropy

Community  Investment  

Corporate  Responsibility  

M&S  Plan  A  2007  -­‐  100  commitments  2010  -­‐      80  commitments  2015  -­‐  100  commitments  

Sustainable  Business  

Zero  Carbon,  zero  waste,  fair  and  healthy    

1980 1990 2000 2010 2015 2030

Level 0

Level 1

Level 2

Level 3

Source: Marks and Spencer (adapted)

Page 9: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Turnover  growth  and  innovaBon  

Page 10: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Old  companies,  new  growth    • GE  –  ecomaginaBon  sales  of  USD  200  billion  in  10  years  • Philips  –  EUR  11.1  billion    green  product  sales  in  2014  • Toyota  –  hybrids  >40%  of  Japan  unit  sales  • Dow  –  USD  13  billion  sustainable  advantaged  sales  in  2014  • BRI  –  microcredit  is  32%  of  loans  

Turnover  growth  and  innovaBon  

Page 11: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Toyota  -­‐  hybrids  go  mainstream  

Source: Toyota 2014 Annual Report, page 11

Page 12: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Dow  –  boosBng  sustainable  sales  

Source: Dow Chemical Sustainability Summary 2014, page 8

Page 13: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

ProducBvity  improvement  

Page 14: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Resource  efficiency  • M&S  –  GBP  160  million  savings  from  Plan  A  • GE  –  USD  350  million  savings  from  environmental  efficiency  

Human  capital  management  • Gender  balance  • Employee  engagement  • OccupaBonal  health  and  safety  

ProducBvity  improvement  

Page 15: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

M&S  –  growing  net  benefits  

Source: Marks and Spenceer various reports

-­‐50  

0  

50  

100  

150  

200  

2007/8   2008/9   2009/10   2010/11   2011/12   2012/13   2013/14   2014/15  

GBP  million  

Page 16: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Risk  management  

Page 17: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

ReputaBon/  license  to  operate  and  grow  • Vedanta  • Volkswagen  • Lynas  • Palm  oil  

Safety  (operaBonal  and  product)  • Oil  spill,  BP,  2010  • Nuclear  incident,  TEPCO,  2011  • Food  safety  scare,  Nestle  India’s  Maggi  noodles,  2015  • Malaysia  airlines  

 

Risk  management  

Page 18: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Picking  the  wrong  fight  

Source: Survival International

Page 19: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Vedanta  –  loses  the  bajle  

Source: yahoo finance

0.4  

0.5  

0.6  

0.7  

0.8  

0.9  

1  

1.1  

1.2  

4-­‐Jan-­‐10   4-­‐Feb-­‐10   4-­‐Mar-­‐10   4-­‐Apr-­‐10   4-­‐May-­‐10   4-­‐Jun-­‐10   4-­‐Jul-­‐10   4-­‐Aug-­‐10   4-­‐Sep-­‐10   4-­‐Oct-­‐10   4-­‐Nov-­‐10   4-­‐Dec-­‐10  

FTSE  100  (rebased)   Vendata  Resources  (rebased)  

Page 20: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

Thank  you  

   Please  ask  or  send  me  quesBons      [email protected]          

Page 21: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

How  investors  use  the  informaBon  

Screening

Engagement

Integration

Source: Asia Research and Engagement

Page 22: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

BNI  –  responsible  lending  

Source: BNI Sustainability Report 2013, page 14

Page 23: How$ESG$drives$business$ performance - Bursa … · • Company$case$studies$by$value$driver$ ... Type$of$study$ Proporon$where ... •Food$safety$scare,$Nestle$India’s$Maggi$noodles,$2015$

To  conclude  

Corporate  sustainability  and  reporBng  helps    •  idenBfy  new  growth  areas  •  improve  risk  management  •  idenBfy  cost/  efficiency  savings  •  have  more  talented,  more  producBve  staff  •  ajract  longer  term  investors