How to Handle difficult and defiant behavior

How to Handle difficult and defiant behaviorChristine Williams Mary Beth MaloneJanuary 12th, 2012ObjectivesParticipants will review FBA and BIPs and relationships between well written Behavior Intervention Plans and results. Participants will view examples and nonexamples of Behavior Intervention Plans to clearly identify Target Behaviors and utilize appropriate intervention strategies. Participants will view several case studies of students that exhibit defiant behaviors and appropriate interventions for changing those behaviors. START with dataWhat is an Antecedent?What is the BehaviorWhat is the Consequence?AntecedentsWhen identifying the antecedents, consider these questions:- Where does the behavior happen?- With whom does the behavior occur?- When does the behavior happen?- What activity is the behavior occurring during?- What are other students doing when the behavior begins?- What are other teachers/adults doing when the behavior begins?It is also helpful to consider possible contributing factors, such as:* Specific staff

Antecedents* Proximity of others* Noise level in the classroom* Number of individuals in the area* Other environmental conditions: lighting, door (open/closed), noise in hallway, etc.Additionally, it is valuable to take into account distant antecedents/setting events such as:~ Medication changes~ Family/Home Variables (e.g. visiting family members, divorce, birth of a sibling, etc.)~ Current health status of the student

BehaviorEven though you should have a clear, operationally defined target behavior with examples and non-examples, it is important to record as much information about the behavior of concern during your observations. Rather than writing, "aggressed", your notes may be enhanced by more detail, such as, "kicked peer", "hit teacher with fist", "pinched peer's arm".Operationally defined target behaviors should be described as clearly and concisely as possible. For the purposes of the example below: Aggression is defined as any instance in which Kali's hands, feet, body, or objects come in contact with another person in a forcible way out of the context of the activity. Example: Kali hurls a book toward a peer. Non-example: Kali throws a basketball toward a peer during Gym.

consequencesWhen identifying consequences, it may not be as clear as "time out", "reprimand" or "ignore". Often times when observing behavior one may find that multiple events will follow the behavior of concern. All behavior should be recorded and evaluated for its influence on the target behavior.

Functions of Problem Behavior

If we wish to gain insight into the functions of a students behavior, we need only to examine the functions of our own behavior. Efforts to resolve conflict, express anxiety, gain access to a social group, maintain friendly relationships, avoid embarrassment, and please others are all completely normal behaviors. However, we all might remember situations where we or someone else sought these outcomes through inappropriate means.At the core of functional behavioral assessment is the change of focus from the students behaviors to the functions the student is trying to meet with those behaviors. Four Categories of FunctionsHere are some examples of functions as they fall into four general categories: The function is to get: social reinforcement (e.g., a response from an adult for calling out during a social studies lecture), or tangible reinforcement (e.g., a classmates workbook or access to a preferred activity). The function is to escape or avoid: an aversive task (e.g., a difficult, boring, or lengthy assignment), or situation (e.g., interaction with adults or certain other peers). The function is both (e.g., get the attention of classmates and escape from a boring lesson). The function is to communicate something (e.g., that she does not understand the lesson or that he does not like having to answer questions in front of his peers). In addition, the student may find that engaging in a behavior to accomplish one purpose might lead to the realization of a completely different function. For example, a student who fights to try to escape teasing could discover that fighting itself can be reinforcing (e.g., the physical excitement associated with fighting). These things should be considered when developing a behavioral intervention plan.

Examples of targeted behavior for ages four to twelve include:

Not disrupting class Not picking on other children or violating their personal space Not interrupting or blurting out answers Not breaking in line Paying attention during a reading session lasting 15 minutes Remembering to bring books and homework to school Being polite to others

Examples of targeted behavior for older children include:

Completing classroom work on their own Organizing a class project Reducing impulsive behavior such as running in the halls Not drumming fingers on the desk or tapping foot repeatedly Not chewing gum in class Not pulling pranks on others Displaying social skills at meals Avoiding anger outbursts, such as shouting or cursing

Now What?Obviously, as you can see from these examples, changeable behaviors can occur in all age groups and are not just related to a childs age. Even adults display a lot of these behaviors and can self monitor their own reports cards or progress cards if they wish. The key to a successful target behavior modification program is consistency. So, once you have a behavior system in place, what do you do with it?Table 4.1. Popular models and techniques for dealing with discipline referrals ModelTechniques emphasizedFocusing on PreventionPreventative classroom managementEffective teaching practices, frequent monitoring, clear rules and procedures, social praise, and so forth Prosocial behaviorSystematic reinforcement, modeling of prosocial behavior, verbal instruction, role playingMoral educationClassroom moral discussions of real-life dilemmas, hypothetical situations, and literature; role playing; student participation in school governmentSocial problem solving (SPS)Direct teaching of SPS skills (e.g. alternative thinking, means-ends thinking), self- instruction training, dialoguingEffective communication modelsValues clarification activities, active listening, communication and interpersonal skills training for students and teachersFocusing on Correction and Control of MisbehaviorBehavior modificationDirect instruction; reinforcement techniques, including social praise, material reinforcers, and tokens; punishment-oriented techniques, including verbal reprimand, response cost, and time-out; group contingency techniques such as the Good Behavior Game; behavioral contractingAssertive disciplineTeacher assertion, systematic use of behavior modification techniques, continuous monitoringReality therapyConfrontation questioning, classroom meetings, classroom moral discussions, social problem solving, behavioral contracting, logical consequences, time-out, preventative techniques such as democratic governanceFocus on TreatmentSocial skills trainingDirect instruction, modeling and rehearsal, coaching, self-instruction, manipulation of antecedents and consequencesAggression replacement trainingSocial skills training techniques, self- instruction (e.g. anger control training), moral discussionsParent management trainingParent training in application of behavioral techniquesFamily therapyVariety of therapeutic and educational techniques, depending on the particular modelBehavior therapyVariety of cognitive, behavioral, and operant techniquesFrom Bear, G.G. (1990). Modeks and techniques that focus on prevention. In A. Thomas & J. Grimes (Eds.), Best practices in school psychology (p. 652). Silver Spring, MID: National Association of School Psychologists; Copyright 1990 by the National Association of School Psychologists. Reprinted by permission of publisher.Table 4.2. Technique, behavior, consequence, and probable effect ClassificationExhibited behaviorConsequencesProbable future effect on behaviorPositive reinforcementJane cleans her room.Jane's parents praise her.Jane will continue to clean her room.Positive reinforcementCarmen brushes her teeth after meals. Carmen receives a nickel each time.Carmen will continue to brush her teeth after meals.Positive reinforcementRob works quietly at his seat.The teacher praises and rewards Rob.Rob will continue to work quietly at his seat.Negative reinforcementJason complains that older boys consistently beat him up, and he refuses to attend school.Jason's parents allow him to remain at home because of his complaints.Jason will continue to miss school.Negative reinforcement Balin complains of headaches when it is time to do homework.Balin is allowed to go to bed without doing his homework. Balin will have headaches whenever there is homework to do.ExtinctionJim washes his father's car.Jim's car washing behavior is ignored.Jim will stop washing his father's car.ExtinctionCarmen puts glue on Joe's seat.Carmen is ignored.Carmen will stop putting glue on Joe's seat.PunishmentMarta sits on the arm of the chair.Marta is spanked each time she sits on the arm of the chair.Marta will not sit on the arm of the chair.PunishmentTakeo puts Gwen's pigtails in the paint.The teacher administers the paddle to Takeo's posterior.Takeo will not put Gwen's pigtail in the paint.From Walker, J.E., & Shea, T.M. (1991). Behavior management: A practical approach for educators (5th ed.). New York: Macmillan; adapted by permission.Reinforcement Menu: KindergartenReinforcement Menu: Third GradeReinforcement Menu: Tenth-Grade GeometryMain CoursesPlay the pianoPaintLook out of the windowUse the toys at the back of the roomWork with puzzlesUse model clayMove a chair to another placeChoose a carpet piece to sit onUse the computerCut and pasteTalk to a classmateDrinkHugUse colored chalkSwing feetWalk around in the back of the roomWatch a science videoSingMain CoursesGo to the library to work on a special project related to a study unitArrange the game shelf and pick a game to playListen to a story with earphonesWork in the art cornerRead and record a favorite story with expression and clarityWork on scrapbook for history project using magazines in the roomLeave 5 minutes early for lunchBe line captainBe in charge of taking attendanceGet a drink at any time without asking permissionBe in charge of passing out papers and other class materialsBe excused 15 minutes early to clean erasers and chalkboardMain CoursesChallenge someone to a game of chessUse the computerDo extra credit problems to raise gradeMake up a quiz and give it to the classSit at the teacher's desk while doing homeworkPrepare the bulletin board using display of student's choiceWrite a letterReadPlay charadesDiscuss past or forthcoming athletic or social eventsHave a creative exhibit period (i.e. show-and-tell for older students)Be excused 15 minutes early to clean erasers and chalkboardDaily SpecialsMonday: Visit first gradeTuesday: Finger paintWednesday: Play a game with teacherThursday: Make a muralFriday: Use the computerDaily SpecialsMonday: Watch a videoTuesday: Use the computerWednesday: Be a group leaderThursday: Add another piece to class muralFriday: Help plan the Friday group activityDaily SpecialsMonday: Appear as a guest lecturer in another math classTuesday: Do a special crossword puzzle involving geometry conceptsWednesday: Play a math game with another studentThursday: Construct a special paper model using geometrical figuresFriday: Solve mysteries involving mathematical solutionspunishmentAll students are aware of which behaviors are punished and how they are punished.Appropriate models for acceptable behavior are provided.Punishments are offered immediately, consistently, and fairly.Punishments are offered impersonally.A natural or logical consequence should be used as often as possible.The student being punished must understand the relationship between his or her behavior and the punishment.Reinforcement or PunishmentAlthough reinforcement and punishment can be equally effective in reducing specific target behaviors in the classroom, reinforcement is by far more effective in helping children develop alternative, more functional behaviors. When Jeremy was in third grade, his teacher instituted a procedure in which he would receive a tally mark if she looked over and saw that he was tipping back in his chair. She placed 4 Xs under each chair leg to remind him not to lean back. A more positive approach would be to let Jeremy earn a tally mark each time she looked over and saw that all four legs were down. This would reinforce the desired behavior. It is important to always begin with a number of reinforcing strategies before resorting to punishment as a means of reducing unwanted or aversive classroom behaviors.

Positive reinforcementPositive reinforcement should follow immediately after good behavior. It should be specific and initially continuous, slowly moving to an intermittent schedule. Material reinforcers provide the child with something tangible. Social reinforcers are more versatile, and, even if material reinforcers are used, a kind word from the teacher should always accompany them. It is also easier to increase behavior than decrease it. Thus, when choosing a target behavior, it is preferable to focus on behaviors to be increased rather than on those to be decreased. Shea and Bauer (1987) described the following process to apply positive reinforcement effectively:Select a target behavior to increase, define the behavior, and choose a reinforcer.Observe the child and watch for the behavior.Reinforce the target behavior every time it is exhibited.Comment in a positive way about the behavior when providing reinforcement.Be enthusiastic -and interested.Offer assistance.Vary the reinforcer.

Avoid power struggles! Loss of the privilege during which the inappropriate behavior is exhibited is fair. Warning, nagging, threatening, and debating, however, should be avoided. In other words, act, don't yak. Punishment can exert a complex, negative effect in the classroom and on teacher-student relationships. Furthermore, when less punishing interventions are combined with positive reinforcers, they tend to be effective in the long run.

Focus on Behaviors That Need to Be Changed

Students who are referred to as having "conduct disorders" and students who are referred to as having "emotional disabilities," "behavioral disorders," "serious emotional disturbances," or "emotional and behavioral disorders" have two common elements that are instructionally relevant: (1) they demonstrate behavior that is noticeably different from that expected in school or the community and (2) they are in need of remediation.

The best way to approach a student with a "conduct disorder" and a student with a "behavioral disorder" is to operationally define exactly what it is that each student does that is discrepant with the expected standard. The most effective and efficient approach is to pinpoint the specific behavioral problem and apply data-based instruction to remediate it. (Lewis, Heflin, & DiGangi, 1991, p.9)

Identify New Behaviors to Be Developed

Two questions need to be addressed in developing any behavior change procedure regardless of the student's current behavioral difficulty: "What do I want the student to do instead?" and "What is the most effective and efficient means to help the student reach his or her goals?" We may want the student to play with peers on the playground instead of playing alone. We may want the student to play appropriately with peers on the playground instead of hitting peers during games.

Dont forget to laugh! Above all else, have fun with students! Humor in the classroom lets students view school and learning as fun. Humor can also be used to avoid escalating behaviors by removing the negative focus from the problem. (Lewis, Heflin, & DiGangi, 1991, p.26).

Provide Opportunities to Practice New Behaviors

If we expect students to learn appropriate social skills we must structure the learning environment so that these skills can be addressed and practiced. We need to increase the opportunity for students to interact within the school environment so that prosocial skills can be learned. If all a student does is perform as a passive participant in the classroom, then little growth in social skill acquisition can be expected. Just as students improve in reading when they are given the opportunity to read, they get better at interacting when given the opportunity to initiate or respond to others' interactions.

Prosocial behaviorIt is necessary to target specific prosocial behaviors for appropriate instruction and assessment to occur. Prosocial behavior includes such things as Taking turns, working with partner, following directions. Working in group or with others. Displaying appropriate behavior toward peers and adults. Increasing positive relationships. Demonstrating positive verbal and nonverbal relationships. Showing interest and caring. Settling conflicts without fighting. Displaying appropriate affect. (Algozzine, Ruhl, & Ramsey, 1991, pp. 22-23)

Treat Social Skills Deficits as Errors in Learning

Social skills deficits or problems can be viewed as errors in learning; therefore, the appropriate skills need to be taught directly and actively. It is important to base all social skill instructional decisions on individual student needs. In developing a social skill curriculum it is important to follow a systematic behavior change plan. During assessment of a student's present level of functioning, two factors should be addressed. First, the teacher must determine whether the social skill problem is due to a skill deficit or a performance deficit. The teacher can test the student by directly asking what he or she would do or can have the student role play responses in several social situations (e.g., "A peer on the bus calls you a name. What should you do?"). If the student can give the correct response but does not display the behavior outside the testing situation, the social skill problem is probably due to a performance deficit If the student cannot produce the socially correct response, the social skill problem may be due to a skill deficit. More direct instruction may be required to overcome the skill deficits, while a performance deficit may simply require increasing positive contingencies to increase the rate of displaying the appropriate social response. During assessment, it is important to identify critical skill areas in which the student is having problems. Teaching replacement behaviorsOnce assessment is complete, the student should be provided with direct social skill instruction. At this point, the teacher has the option of using a prepared social skill curriculum or developing one independently. It is important to remember that since no single published curriculum will meet the needs of all students, it should be supplemented with teacher-developed or teacher-modified lessons. This is the Key to Changing Behaviors! If you taught a student that struggled in reading only comprehension skills, but they did not know how to sound out words, the success would be very limited! You must target SPECIFIC behaviors! We have tons of programs! Call if you need one for a specific behavior!

How to teach social skillsSocial skill lessons are best implemented in groups of 3 to 5 students and optimally should include socially competent peers to serve as models. The first social skill group lesson should focus on three things: an explanation of why the group is meeting, a definition of what social skills are, and an explanation of what is expected of each student during the group. It may also be helpful to implement behavior management procedures for the group (i.e., contingencies for compliance and non-compliance). It is important to prompt the students to use newly learned skills throughout the day and across settings to promote maintenance and generalization. It is also important to reinforce the students when they use new skills. (Lewis, Heflin, & DiGangi, 1991, pp.17-18)

Teach Students to Take Responsibility for Their Own Learning

Often overlooked is the need to increase student independence in learning. Students with BD may be particularly uninvolved in their learning due to problems with self-concept, lack of a feeling of belonging to the school, and repeated failures in school. Instructional strategies involving self-control, self-reinforcement, self-monitoring, self-management, problem solving, cognitive behavior modification, and metacognitive skills focus primarily on teaching students the skills necessary for taking responsibility and showing initiative in making decisions regarding their own instruction. These strategies, typically used in combination or in a "package format" that incorporates extrinsic reinforcement, have shown promise for enhancing student learning and independence. (Gable, Laycock, Maroney, & Smith, 1991, p.24)

Focus on Functional Skills That Will Have Broad Applications

Essential in a curriculum for students with behavioral problems are skills that can directly improve the ultimate functioning of the student and the quality of his or her life. The concept of functional skills is not limited to the areas of self-help or community mobility, but also include skills such as those required to seek and access assistance, be life-long independent learners, respond to changes in the environment, succeed in employment, be adequately functioning adults and parents, and achieve satisfying and productive lives. The concepts of the functional curriculum approach, the criterion of ultimate functioning, and participation to the highest degree possible in life must be extended to students with BD, many of whom will otherwise fail to fulfill their potential. (Gable, Laycock, Maroney, & Smith, 1991, p.28)

referencesAlgozzine, B., Ruhl, K., & Ramsey, R. (1991). "Behaviorally disordered? Assessment for identification and instruction." Reston, VA: The Council for Exceptional Children. (ED No. 333660). Stock No. P339. Gable, R. A., Laycock, V. K., Maroney, S. A., & Smith, C. R. (1991). "Preparing to integrate students with behavioral disorders." Reston, VA: The Council for Exceptional Children. (ED No. 333658). Stock No. P340. Lewis, T. J., Heflin, J., & DiGangi, S. A. (1991). "Teaching students with behavioral disorders: Basic questions and answers." Reston, VA: The Council for Exceptional Children. (ED No. 333659). Stock No. P337.