How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

21
Educating Entrepreneurship Educators Coneeect is an international network of universities that offers training courses for academic entrepreneurship teachers to improve the Entrepreneurship Education across Europe. www.coneeect.eu

description

What are the common challenges in entrepreneurship education and how to address them. Three case studies from the US, Mexico and Finland with different approaches to building entrepreneurship capabilities: McGuire Center for Entrepreneurship is a hub of entrepreneurship within the University of Arizona providing education, research and technical support to the students, faculty and wider community. Monterrey Tech (Itesm) is the leading private university in Mexico that was established by business leaders in 1940s and today integrates entrepreneurship in all its activities supporting hitech industry as well as social entrepreneurship. Team Academy is a 3-year entrepreneurship programme that was developed in a small Finnish town in Jyvaskyla to address the rising youth unemployment. There are no classes, not teachers, no simulations.

Transcript of How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Page 1: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Educating

Entrepreneurship

Educators Coneeect is an international network of universities that offers training courses for academic entrepreneurship teachers to improve the Entrepreneurship Education across Europe.

www.coneeect.eu

Page 2: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

This material has been produced for the Coneeect program. The content is copyright of the author. All rights reserved. Duplication and distribution of original documentation is permitted. Any changes to the original are prohibited. This copyright message shall not be removed.

Jaana PUUKKA Strategy Consultant, Founder & President of Innovation Engage, former OECD analyst

Boosting Entrepreneurial Universities: lessons from international reviews22 July 2013

Page 3: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Boosting entrepreneurial UNIVERSITIES: lessons from international reviewscontent

1. How can universities support regional growth and entrepreneurship?

2. What are the constraints and barriers?3. Three approaches to entrepreneurship

educationThree cases and the Reality

4. What are the common issues in education education?

5. Where are the gaps? And how to address them?

Page 4: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Where does the evidence come from?

[email protected] courtesy to the OECD

2005 - 2007 2010 - 2012

2008 - 2011 Kazan 2007

Between 2005 and 2013 OECD reviewed the role and impact of Higher Education in 35 cities and regions in 25 countries

Page 5: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

How were the reviews conducted?

Self-evaluation / background report owned by the Regional Steering Committee

Review visit by international experts

Review Report tailored for the city/region

Dissemination of outcomes

[email protected] courtesy to the oecd

Page 6: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

What is university’s role in regional growth & entrepreneurship?

University

Skills

Innovation

Society at large

Capacity building

[email protected]

Partnerships

Context

Global, National and Local Context

Page 7: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Wroclaw, PL• Location and first mover advantage• City investment in knowledge-based

economy• HE hub

Context

• Ageing, uneven development• Traditional HE sector• Lack of focus on equity & relevance

Challenges

• REVISIT the HE management• DEVELOP a robust evidence base • ENHANCE HE collaboration• INTEGRATE entrepreneurship, LLL,

internships in all programmes

What next

City of Wroclaw wants to mobilise HE system to build a knowledge & cultural

hub in central Europe

[email protected]

Page 8: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Victoria, Australia

[email protected] 8

The tertiary education system needs to be mobilised to contribute to more concretely to Victoria’s “healthy, sustainable and productive future.”

• Robust economy• Diverse TE sector and int’l

education hub: strongest export worth AUD 5 billion

• Investments in Science & Tech infrastructure

Context

• Rapid population growth, ageing• Impacts of global warming• Low skills & skills shortages• Dependence on int’l students

Challenges

• WIDEN access to TE, increase attainment levels

• BROADEN innovation concept, support SMEs & BOOST entrepreneurship

• ENCOURAGE TE collaboration

What next?

Page 9: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Barriers to engagement: results from OECD review

National Sub-national Institutional /HEI-level

Uncoordinated HE, STI and regional policy

Fragmented regional governance, weak leadership

Lack of management capacity and entrepreneurial culture

Limits to HEIs’ autonomy and/or suboptimal accountability schemes

Intra-regional & inter-institutional competition

Tensions between regional engagement & pursuit for world class excellence

Limited incentives to HEIs Mutual exclusion of HEIs/regions from strategy development & implementation

Lack of incentives to individuals

[email protected]

Page 10: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Entrepreneurship education – 3 cases

[email protected]

Page 11: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Create an entrepreneurial HUB: McGuire Center for entrepreneurship

A hub of entrepreneurial activity at The University of Arizona. One of the top centres in US in the field with a nearly 30-year track record and multiple on- and off campus audiences.

A limited-enrolment undergraduate degree stream, an enterpreneurship initiative to all business students; an entrepreneurship-focused MBA and + electives and support services.

McGuire identifies and helps transfer technology and innovations to the market place. It teaches entrepreneurship to early-career business people, schools etc. and provides technical assistance on entrepreneurship activities.

Images credits: [email protected]

Page 12: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

McGuire Center for entrepreneurship, UArizona

MENTORS-IN- RESIDENCE

TECHNOLOGY MENTORS

ALTERNATIVE VALUATION

COMMUNICATION MENTORS MOCK LAW FIRM

Page 13: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Create an entrepreneurial INSTITUTION: Monterrey Tech MX

A private university founded by business leaders (1943): 33 campuses+ 6 academic centres in Latin America. Supports both high-tech spin offs and social entrepreneurship.

Mandatory entrepreneurship training since 1985. Programa Emprendedor, Entrepreneurial diploma, Bachelor program in business creation and development, 3 Masters programs through virtual and class room delivery

Interdisciplinary open innovation spaces in most study fields. All campuses have business incubators for for-profit enterprises and ventures that support social and community development.

Images credits: [email protected]

Page 14: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Promote resilience, self-reliance, innovation and ingenuity: team academy, FI

Developed in 1993 in a small town in Finland by a marketing lecturer of Jyvaskyla University of Applied Sciences. Worldwide interest: TAs in 8 countries, 6000 users of methodology, 1800 adult learners, 800 TA alumni, 850 team entrepreneurs

A 3 year program: no classrooms, no lectures, no exams. In first 2 weeks teams of 20 students start developing real businesses. Students learn finance, marketing, leadership & strategy in projects. Half of the students launch their own business.

Coaching programs for entrepreneurs, team leaders, managers and teachers. Over 1000 adult learners graduated with vocational qualifications accredited by the Finnish National Board of Education.

Images credits: [email protected]

Page 15: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Compelling examples but a different reality in many universities

[email protected]

Page 16: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Gap btw labour market needs & competencies acquired in HEIS – Graduates’ views (Scale 1-7)

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Use computers and the internet

Use time efficiently

Assert your authority

Come up with new ideas and solutions

Negotiate effectively

Write and speak in a foreign language

Alertness to new opportunities

Coordinate activities

Perform well under pressure Present products, ideas or

reportsKnowledge of other fields

Make your meaning clear to others

Mastery of your own field

Question your own and others' ideas

Mobilize the capacities of others

Write reports, memos or documents

Work productively with others

Rapidly acquire new knowledge

Analytical thinking

Required Acquired

Page 17: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

What are the common issues?

[email protected]

Page 18: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

Gaps

Lack of strategic anchoring within

HEIs and HE policy; limited legitimacy

within HEIs

A lack of system coherence and a

co-ordination deficit within and

among HEIs

Weak evidence base and supply-driven delivery

Disconnect between graduate

enterprise, knowledge

transfer & regional growth

[email protected]

Page 19: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

How to reform education so that its

supports entrepreneurship and

regional growth?

[email protected]

Page 20: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

20

reforming education

• Courses with the local/global needs; ALIGN graduate enterprise/entrepreneurship training with regional industry developmentAlign

• Employability skills, work-based learning, internship, entrepreneurialism in all curriculaEmbed

• Learning pathways from schools to LLL to ensure flexible learning, up-skilling, re-training and entrepreneurshipCreate

• Data about labour market needs. DEVELOP student/graduate tracking and USE the data strategically.Develop

• With employers in course design & delivery; CREATE links between support for graduate enterprise development and business support in the local areaCo-operate

[email protected]

Page 21: How to boost Entrepreneurial UNIVERSITY: lessons from international reviews

JAANA PUUKKATel: +33 6 18 33 26 12 (m)[email protected]: puukka.jaanawww.linkedin.com/in/puukkaFollow my tweets on: @jaanapuukka www.innovationengage.com