How PET and Personalized Onco-Genomic (POG) Trial are Able ... · CCNA2 [92%] TYMS [99%] 6 673 SNV...
Transcript of How PET and Personalized Onco-Genomic (POG) Trial are Able ... · CCNA2 [92%] TYMS [99%] 6 673 SNV...
Howard Lim, MD, PhD, FRCPC
Chair, Gastrointestinal Tumour Group
Program Director, Medical Oncology Residency Training Program
Clinical Associate Professor, University of British Columbia
Division of Medical Oncology, BC Cancer Agency
How PET and Personalized
Onco-Genomic (POG) Trial
are Able to Create Patient –
Centered Care
Disclosures
• Received honorariums from Eisai, Taiho,
Roche, Lilly, Amgen, and Leo for
consultant work
• Investigator on trials with Bayer, BMS,
Lilly, Roche, Astra-Zenca and Amgen
• Have investments with marijuana stocks
Objectives
• Understand the use of genomic based
testing in oncology
• Examine the use of PET for genomic
based testing
• Review the pitfalls of genomic based
testing
Genomic testing
• Many different levels of testing
• Panels:
– Look presence of known cancer genes
– Fast and relatively inexpensive
• Exome sequencing
• Whole genome sequencing (DNA & RNA)
Approaches (how much is enough?)
POG Primer 8BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
Non-coding RNAs Proteomics MetabolomicsEpigenomics
Personalized Cancer Therapy
15BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
Lung Cancer
Crizotinib
Gefitinib
Molecular profiling(genomic analysis) Adapted from: https://pct.mdanderson.org/#/home
Identify disease characteristics and predictive biomarkers
ALK fusion positive
EGFR positive
POG Primer
Population-Based Personalized
Oncology
POG Clinical
Trials
Genome
Sciences
Centre
Collaborative
Research
Innovative
Collaborative
Achievable
GSC Sequencing Capacity and Throughput
• Total data
generated to
date: 609 Tb
• Platform
upgrade in
progress →14
HiSeq 2500
1Tb model
• Annual
capacity 600Tb• 6,500 human
genomes/year
What does this entail?
• Whole genome sequencing = 6 billion bits of information
• Compare cancer to normal cells
• Patterns of RNA expression
• Analyze abnormalities and search for their function in databases
• Sift through scientific literature for evidence to link pathways to specific drugs
Types of information
• Evolution of cancer as a response to treatment
• Biological explanation of why a specific agent works in one type of cancer and not another
• Identification of pathways leading to drugs that would not have otherwise been used with excellent clinical results
• Completely changed the diagnosis of rare cancers
BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only 22
POG - Breast Cancer
AR
[100%]
ERBB4
[93%]
WNT7B
[72%]
NRAS
[80%]
MAP2K4
[0%]
MAPK3
[98%]
MAP2K2
[82%]
ELK1
[89%]
ERBB2
[59%]
ERBB3
[25%]
FGFR3
[48%]
FGFR4
[96%]
RET
[69%]
BIRC5
[95%]
WNT
Pathway
Gene Regulation
PICK3CA
[8%]GoF
BRCA1
[99%]
BRCA2
[88%]
APOBEC3B
[76%]
DNA damage
CD274
[70%]
[PD-L1]
MUC1
[31%]
TOP2A
[85%]
Inhibition of apoptosis
MAPK
Pathway
CDK1
[99%]
E2F1
[96%]
RB1
[43%]
CCNB1
[74%]
CDKN3
[82%]
MYCN
[77%]
AURKA
[90%]
AURKB
[72%]
BRD4
[80%]
TOP1
[89%]
Cell
Cycle
TGF-beta
Pathway
POG[TC=45%] TETRAPLOID
FC vs. Compendium Normal breastPercentile vs. BRCA (TCGA)
copy number loss(es)
copy number gain(s)
Tumour Sup.
Activation Inhibition Indirect
Underexpressed
Overexpressed
[%] percentile
Drug Target
Copy numbers show relative to estimated PLOIDYOne start per copy, copy gains with 5+ are in large stars
GoF activating mutationLoF inactivating mutationVUS unknown mutation
TP53
[8%]
PIK3-Akt
Pathway
VUS
CHD4
[0%]LoF
6
FGF10
[100%]
18
CCND1
[68%]
14
5
CDK6
[20%]
CDK4
[3%]
PDPK1
[47%]
5
FGF3
[88%]
14FGF4
[98%]
14FGF19
[83%]
14
FGFR2
[1%]
CCNA2
[92%]
TYMS
[99%]
6
673 SNV = hypermutated
Genomic based treatment
• Hypothesis Generating
• Each patient is their own clinical trial
• Lack power
• Need an efficient manner to evaluate
response – CT scans q 8 weeks tend to
be standard
• Use PET/CT in certain cases
POG130 – colonic adenocarcinoma
• Stage III colon cancer– toxicity with adjuvant 5FU/oxaliplatin
with neuropathy and neutropenia
• Relapsed retro-peritoneum– Resected
• Relapsed in L spine– XRT twice
• Palliative resection– Analyzed for POG
POG Primer 25BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
FFPE section
Frozen section (used for POG)
POG130 expression outlier analysis
• Outlier expression analysis in POG130 indicated the AP-1 transcriptional complex (FOS/JUN) as an upregulated axis potentially acting as a central driver to disease progression in this patient.
POG130 pathway analysis 26BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
Gene IDCopy
numberFold change
(vs. normal colon tissue)Percentile expression (within colon cancer)
RPKM value Curated cancer gene
BRI3BP 2 5 85 19.97 proto-oncogene
CCND1 2 7 79 79.26 proto-oncogene
CDT1 2 23 93 41.01 proto-oncogene
CSF1R 2 5 78 11.48 proto-oncogene
ELAC2 2 3 80 18.74 proto-oncogene
ELF4 2 4 82 22.45 proto-oncogene
FOS 2 11 98 516.74 proto-oncogene
JUN 2 4 100 383.25 proto-oncogene
MAFB 2 4 71 6.55 proto-oncogene
MDM2 2 4 92 17.02 proto-oncogene
NCKIPSD 2 2 88 15.69 proto-oncogene
PIM3 2 2 82 62.01 proto-oncogene
SPI1 2 3 84 14.09 proto-oncogene
STIL 2 4 66 4.44 proto-oncogene
TPM3 2 5 64 47.62 proto-oncogene
WHSC1 2 5 84 8.66 proto-oncogene
Table shows filtered transcriptome data from POG130 assessing the transcriptional activity of known oncogenes
Angiotensin II pathway
POG130 pathway analysis 27BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
Shown to reduce JUN levels at both RNA and Protein level
Angiotensin inhibitors (aka blood pressure meds)
Pre-treatment PET/CT (Nov 2014) Post-treatment (4 Weeks – Jan 2015)
SPINE MET
POG Primer 28BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
POG005
• 32 year old male presented with large ethmoid sinus mass
• Biopsy suggested “poorly differentiated squamous cancer”
• Received neoadjuvant cisplatin-docetaxel followed by radiation with concurrent cisplatin.
• Recurred within 6 months. Cis-doce tried again, no response.
• Biopsied for study Dec 2012.
POG Primer 29BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
POG005
POG Primer 30BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
Many chromosomes have no somatic copy number changes
Small deletions on 2,3,5,9,12,13,17 (not p53)
Larger deletions on 8,11,22 with one homozygous
deletion event on 22q SMARCB1
Diagnostic of pediatric cancer – atypical teratoid
rhabdoid tumor (ATRT); median age of this
sarcoma is 9 months.
Panel entirely normal
ch17
ch22
ch1 ch21
Pre- and Post- POG PET images
JAN 22 – 2013Baseline
FEB 25 – 2013After 1.5 cycles of
“sarcoma” directed chemo
POG Primer 31BCCA Confidential - For Research Purposes Only
Biopsies are critical
• Source material for analysis
• Biomarker analysis is dependent on the
quality of the tissue
• Need a tumor content of around 20-30%
• Treatment affects viability
• Directly related to the biopsy
• Key Factors:
– Tumor Heterogeneity
– Temporal Heterogeneity
• Evolution of the tumor
Use of functional imaging???
• Typically biopsy
the safest lesion –
not necessarily the
most biologically
relevant lesion
• Consider use of
PET/CT to
determine which
lesion to biopsy
What to biopsy?
• Metastatic CRC to
liver
• Plan – receive
chemotherapy and
consider surgical
resection
Progression???
• Patient was being
considered for POG
if evidence of
progression
• Did a PET/CT to
assess response
and viable lesion to
biopsy
Case
• Patient had complete response on
PET/CT
• Went for surgery – liver – necrotic
lesions
• So biopsy would have no yield
• PET/CT – changed treatment
management
Assessing for biopsy
• Metastatic adenoid
cystic cancer to the
lung
• Enrolled in POG
• Only accessible lesion
was a pleural lesion
that had undergone
XRT
• Is there viable tissue?
Summary
• Genomic profiling is becoming increasingly more complex – mutations, expression panels, and proteomics
• Patients should be aware of the pitfalls of testing– Does it really affect health outcomes?
• Most genomic testing should be done in the context of trials and informed consent
• The results are complex for both patient and physician – should be tests that physician directed versus consumer driven
Summary
• How do we assess success? Does a metabolic response translate into clinically meaningful benefit such as survival
• The acquisition of tissue is key for analysis
• Therefore biopsies are a critical component for genomic based testing
• PET/CT can help in ensuring quality of biopsy samples and in some cases spare patients from procedures
• Given the heterogeneous nature of cancer –PET/CT may also determine which lesion is the biologically relevant sample versus obtaining from the safest site
Acknowledgements
43All patients & their families
Medical Oncologist Janessa Laskin Deepa Wadhwa Anna Lee Pinaki Bose Gregg MorinAbdul Al-Tourah Lyly Le Tamana Walia Lawrence Lee Simon Chan Ryan Morin
Helen Anderson Christopher Lee HuiLi Wong Hector Li Chang Carolyn Ch'ng Andy MungallVanessa Bernstein Ursula Lee Muhammad Zulfigar Pedro Farinha Richard Corbett Brad Nelson
Sylvie Bourque Jenny Ko Ann Tan Malcolm Hayes Eric Chuah Cydney Nielsen
Barbara Campling Christian Kollmannsberger Sara Taylor Tadaaki Hiruki An He Julie NielsenAngela Chan Caroline Lohrisch Anna Tinker Hugo Horlings Martin Jones Jacquie ScheinTheresa Chan Nicol Macpherson Dorothy Uhlman David Huntsman Steven Jones Colin SchlosserSylvia Cheng Barb Melosky Neurologist Diana Ionescu Katayoon Kasaian Sohrab Shah
Winson Cheung John Paul McGhie Brian Thiessen Hoang Lien Ji-Young Kim Liz StarksKim Chi Corey Metcalf Medical Geneticist Nikita Makretsov Sreeja Leelakumari Yongjun Zhao
Stephen Chia Deepu Mirchandani Linlea Armstrong Nissreen Mohammad Jake Lever Social ScientistJoseph Connors Nevin Murray Ian Bosdet Greg Naus Yvonne Li Anita ChartersJanine Davies Sujaatha Narayanan Gillian Mitchell Tony Ng William Long Peter Chow-White
Rebecca Deyell Thao Nguyen Sean Young Torsten Nielsen Yussanne Ma Dung HaThuan Do Conrad Oja Intan Schrader Tomo Osako Karen Mungall Dean Regier
Bernhard Eigl Gary Pansegrau Clinical Ethicist Amir Rahemtulla Brandon Pierce Deirdre Weymann
Susan Ellard Maryse Power Alice Virani David Schaeffer Erin Pleasance Project Coordinator/ ManagerXiaolan Feng Bradley Proctor Radiologist Brandon Sheffield Cara Reisle Leslie AlfaroDavid Fenton Sanjay Rao Francois Bernard Sona Sihra Yaoqing Shen Charlene Appleby
Daygen Finch Rod Rassekh Colin Mar Brian Skinnider Greg Taylor Balvir Deol
Paul Galbraith Daniel Renouf Montgomery Martin Graham Slack Nina Thiessen Nancy FergusonKaren Gelmon Paul Rogers John Myo Peyman Tavassoli Tina Wong Colleen Fitzgerald
Alina Gerrie David Sanford Pharmacist Basile Tessier-Cloutier Wei Zhang Cathy Fitzpatrick
Sharlene Gill Delia Sauciuc Shirin Abadi Tom Thomson Eric Zhao Alexandra FokKarmjit Gill Kerry Savage Pathologist Tracy Tucker Amir Zadeh Colleen JantzenAnagha Gurjal Ravinder Sawhney Yazeed Alwalaie Emilija Todorovic Kelsey Zhu Jas Kandola
Edward Hardy Asif Shaikh Daiana Becker-Santos Dirk van Niekerk Genome Scientist Julie Lorette
Jason Hart Wen Wen Shan Ian Bosdet Suzanne Vercauteren Sam Aparicio Katherine MuiCheryl Ho Tamara Shenkier Kathy Ceballos Carlos Vilamil Scott Brown Jessica Nelson
Donna Hogge Christine Simmons Andy Churg Joanne Wright Robin Coope Robyn RoscoePaul Hoskins Kevin Song Bakul Dalal Stephen Yip Peter Eirew Payal Sipahimalani
Michael Humphreys Caron Strahlendorf Christopher Dunham Chen Zhou Bruno Grande June Song
Bal Johal Sophie Sun John English Bioinfomatician Martin Hirst Isabel TrapagaAvancena
Hagen Kennecke Isabella Tai Patrice Eydoux Jianghong An Rob Holt Peggy Tsang
Koo Khoo Joanna Vergidis Anthony Karnezis Dustin Bleile Christopher Hughes
Meg Knowling Diego Villa Aly Karsan Melika Bonakdar Marco MarraDoran Ksienski Helga Klein-Parker Morgan Bye Richard Moore