Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. ·...

27
Michela Maschietto Dep of Education and Human Sciences University of Modena e Reggio Emilia Italy DIDACTIC INTERACTIONS BETWEEN FRANCE AND ITALY. A PERSONAL JOURNEY

Transcript of Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. ·...

Page 1: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto(Dep(of(Education(and(Human(Sciences(University(of(Modena(e(Reggio(Emilia(Italy(

DIDACTIC(INTERACTIONS(BETWEEN(FRANCE(AND(ITALY.(A(PERSONAL(JOURNEY((

Page 2: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

SFIDA(Séminaire(

FrancoKItalien(sur(la(Didactique(de(

l’Algèbre(

https://sites.google.com/site/seminairesfida/Home(

"SFIDA-0” Turin, October 1992

SFIDA-38 Nice, November 2012

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Nice(J.P.Drouhard(

Turin,(F.Arzarello(

Genoa(P.Boero(

Page 3: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Collaborations(and(projects(•  French(summer(schools(in(mathematics(education(

•  Participation(to(scientific(activities,(as(seminars,(workshops(•  Participation(to(scientific(committees(

(•  Meeting(of(Statistical(Implicative(Analysis(

•  Participation(to(scientific(committees(•  Organisation(of(some(meetings(at(the(University(of(Palermo(

•  Espace(mathématique(francophone(•  Participation(to(scientific(activities,(as(seminars,(workshops,(team(

members(of(working(groups(•  Participation(to(scientific(committees(

Page 4: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Collaborations(and(projects(• European(projects(“TELMA”(and(“ReMath”(

Representing(Mathematics(with(Digital(Media(

((Focus(on(the(semiotic(dimension.(

(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Page 5: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

But(also(a(critical(regard…(•  Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(

•  Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the(relationships(between(innovative(didactical(proposals(and(their(development(in(classes(than(modelling(didactical(phenomena(

•  Aim(of(the(experimental(parts(in(classes:(not(a(situation(to(study(as(external(observer,(but(an(opportunity(to(precise(and(test(the(hypotheses(about(“research(for(innovation”.((•  TeachersKresearchers(

•  Some(difficulties(to(establish(collaboration(between(communities(

Reasons:(•  The$difficulties$do$not$derive$only$from$researchers’$characteristics$but$also$from$ecological$conditions$under$which$research$in$mathematics$education$develops$•  Features(of(the(school(systems(•  Economical(constraints(of(research(•  The(weight(of(the(cultural(environment(

Boero((1994)(

Boero((2016)(Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Page 6: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Grenoble(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

PhD(students(and(postKdoc((

Page 7: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

MY(PERSONAL(JOURNEY(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Page 8: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Fellowship(by(the(University(of(Turin((

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Torino(

Page 9: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Bordeaux(• LADIST(with(G.Brousseau(

((

Passion(Enthusiasm(

Discussions(during(lunch(Sketches(on(paper(little(table(

cloths(

First(learning(for(a(young(researcher(

Theory(of(Didactical(Situations((TDS)(

Observations(of(primary(school(classes(at(Ecole(Michelet(

(COREM)((in(Talence((

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Comparing(to(the(contingence(

Page 10: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Page 11: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Torino(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Page 12: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Thesis(between(Paris(and(Turin((• Doctoral(dissertation(

• With(two(supervisors…(

Thesis(

Research(in(Paris((Artigue)((

(

Research(in(Turin((Arzarello)((

((

Italian(paradigm(“Reseach(for(innovation”(

Theoretical((frameworks(

Page 13: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Thesis(between(Paris(and(Turin((• Doctoral(dissertation(

• With(two(supervisors…(

Introduction(of(calculus(at(secondary(school(level(by(graphical(and(symbolic(

calculators(

Research(in(Paris((Artigue)(Didactical(engineering(

Instrumental(approach(Graphical(calculators(

Research(in(Turin((Arzarello)(Embodied(cognition(

Gestures(and(metaphors(

Geometry(and(cognition(

Page 14: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Thesis(between(Paris(and(Turin((• Doctoral(dissertation(

• With(two(supervisors…(

Introduction(of(calculus(at(secondary(school(level(by(graphical(and(symbolic(

calculators(

Research(in(Paris((Artigue)(Didactical(engineering(

Instrumental(approach(Graphical(calculators(

Research(in(Turin((Arzarello)(Embodied(cognition(

Gestures(and(metaphors(

Geometry(and(cognition(

The$influence$of$embodied$cognition$is$visible$in$the$sensitivity$she$develops$about$the$students’$gestures$and$discourse,$as$they$zoom$in$and$zoom$out$with$the$calculator,$and$about$the$personal$and$collective$development$of$the$metaphor$of$microlinearity.$But$what$is$added$to$these$perspective$is$a$carefil$attention$to$the$mathematical$limits$of$visualization$(it$shows$closeness,$but$not$the$order$of$the$approximation$that$is$essential$here),$a$careful$attention$to$the$way$the$microlinearity$metaphor$can$become$an$operational$tool,$and$to$the$difficulties$met$by$students$in$that$operatioalization.$

Page 15: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Thesis(between(Paris(and(Turin((

Introduction(of(calculus(at(secondary(school(level(by(graphical(and(symbolic(

calculators(

Research(in(Paris((Artigue)(Didactical(engineering(

Instrumental(approach(Graphical(calculators(

Research(in(Turin((Arzarello)(Embodied(cognition(

Gestures(and(metaphors(

Geometry(and(cognition(

Teaching(experiments(in(Italian(classes(with(teachers(of(Turin(team.(

A$priori$analysis(as(mediation(tool(with(the(teachers(

A$priori$analysis(

Page 16: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Torino(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Modena(

Page 17: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Modena((( (Mathematical(machines(

• Theory(of(Semiotic(Mediation((TSM)((Bartolini(Bussi)(((((((((( (((((( ( ( ( ( (Mathematics(laboratory(

( ( ( ( ( (sessions(at(MMLab(( ( ( ( ( ((mmlab.unimore.it)(

• Regional(project(on(teacher(education(within(mathematics(laboratory(methodology(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

R.Falcade(PhD(

Page 18: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Visiting(researcher(at(EducTICE(–(INRP(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Modena(

Page 19: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Lyon(• EducTICE((L.Trouche)(at(INRP((now(IféKENS)((

Page 20: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Lyon(• EducTICE((L.Trouche)(at(INRP((now(IféKENS)((

Page 21: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Lyon(• EducTICE((L.Trouche)(

Different(perspectives(on(sciences(education(and(use(of(digital(

tecnologies.(

For(a(limited(time,(work(without(our(institutional(contraints.((

(Living(in(a(foreing(institution(gives(the(possibility(to(capture(les(differences(

of(the(systems(

Very(nice(team(

Page 22: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Lyon(

Page 23: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

S.(SouryKLavergne(Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Modena(

Page 24: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

!

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Page 25: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Teaching(experiments(in((Modena(and(Reggio(Emilia(

Teaching(experiments(in(Dijon,(Lyon(and(ClermontKFerrand(

Page 26: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

Teaching(experiments(in((Modena(and(Reggio(Emilia(

Michela(Maschietto.(A(personal(journey(

Teaching(experiments(in(Dijon,(Lyon(and(ClermontKFerrand(

•  Thinking((the(relationships(between(material(and(digital(tools(

•  Use(of(technology(at(primary(school(

•  Cultural(differences((•  Conditions(and(contraints(

Page 27: Home | International Mathematical Union (IMU) - … · 2016. 10. 31. · But(also(a(critical(regard…(• Differences(between(French(and(Italian(research(works:(• Italian(researchers(have(been(more(interested(in(studying(the

A(VERY(NICE(JOURNEY((