Holding a Job;Having a Life
Transcript of Holding a Job;Having a Life
8/6/2019 Holding a Job;Having a Life
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holding-a-jobhaving-a-life 1/7
A Work in America Institute National Policy Study
Holding a Job, Having a Life: Strategies for Change
By Jill Casner-Lotto
Executive Summary
Holding satisfying jobs, living full, meaningful lives-for many working Americans, balancing
work and life represents difficult terrain to navigate. Despite the wide range of work/life policies
and programs available today, the existing policies still do not meet the need and, in many cases,
do not achieve their potential value. Policies are rarely rooted in business strategies and may
clash with corporate cultures. Excessive workloads and job demands require long hours and
frequent travel. Access to flexible work schedules, while offered by a growing number of companies, is often limited by the nature of the job and level in the organization. And while there
has been growing corporate support for child care, the reality is that only a relatively small
portion of the workforce today enjoys such benefits as on-site child care or even child care
resource and referral services.
While many U.S. employers have implemented work/life programs and policies such as child
care, elder care, family leave, or flexible work schedules, research has shown that such
initiatives-by themselves--often have limited impact.
This report presents the findings of a two-year study by Work in America Institute that
investigated how some companies have moved beyond simply adding a work/life program or policy. Instead, the employers in this study have adopted a strategic work/life-approach designed
to accomplish a "dual agenda": to simultaneously improve business results and employees´
work/life integration.
To achieve this goal, these companies have made systemic changes in their organizations--for
example, through redesigning work processes, changing the organizational culture, or integrating
work/life initiatives with core business strategies and human resource systems--rather than
simply adding on programs.
What Makes This Research Important
This research-based on detailed case studies of ten companies and three related discussion
papers-builds on two earlier and important work/life studies that highlighted the importance of
work design and workplace culture:
8/6/2019 Holding a Job;Having a Life
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holding-a-jobhaving-a-life 2/7
y The Ford Foundation´s Relinking Life and Work: Toward a Better Future (1996) was based on dual-agenda
interventions at three companies. The study found that by engaging employees in restructuring work
processes, the companies could simultaneously improve business results and employees´ ability to manage
work and personal life.
y The Families and Work Institute´s 1997 National Study of the Changing Workforce surveyed employees toinvestigate how work, family, and personal life fit together. Among the study´s conclusions: high-quality jobs
and supportive workplaces are the best predictors of job satisfaction, commitment, performance, and
retention. Both factors must be present, the study found.
The present study, conducted by Work in America Institute and funded by the Ford Foundation
and 15 sponsoring organizations was designed to:
- Analyze the in-depth experiences and learning of a larger and more diverse group of
companies, moving toward a strategic work/life approach;
- Define a framework for understanding the key elements of such an approach;
- Document work/life initiatives that address the needs of salaried employees as well as
hourly workers--a group whose needs have received less attention, and whose work/life
resources are often more limited than those of salaried staff;
- Describe in detail the change processes companies have used to develop innovative
approaches, build support, and move from pilot projects to mature strategies that are diffused to
other parts of the organization;
- Provide business, labor, and public policy leaders with practical guidelines for creating
work environments that support both work/life balance and business; and
- Report the results-both for businesses and employees-that these initiatives have achieved.
Featured Organizations
The ten organizations whose work/life initiatives are profiled in the case studies include: Bank of
America, Baxter Healthcare, Eli Lilly & Company, Ernst & Young, First Tennessee Bank,
Hewlett-Packard/Agilent, Kraft Foods, Merck & Company, Fleet Financial, and Statistics
Canada. They represent a broad range of industries and many different kinds of work and
workers-- from white-collar
8/6/2019 Holding a Job;Having a Life
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holding-a-jobhaving-a-life 3/7
professionals to assembly-line pizza packers, from call-center customer service representatives to
government employees.
In addition to the ten case study companies, the three discussion papers also included in the
report substantially broaden the kinds of work and workers whose experiences are reflected in
the report´s findings. Two papers address labor-management initiatives in the work/family arena.Among the unions profiled in successful labor/management initiatives are: Communications
Workers of America; Local 1199 National Health and Human Services Employees Union, New
York City; Local 2, Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees International Union, San
Francisco; and the Harvard Union of Clerical and Technical Workers, AFSCME. The third paper
explores some of the critical issues regarding the measurement of work/life practices and offers
preliminary findings of a national cross-industry work/life measurement project.
Highlights
- Business results. Companies that have taken a strategic, systemic approach to addressing
work/life issues report significant business gains, such as greater retention, productivity, and
customer service and reduced absenteeism.
For example:
At Fleet Financial, a work/life redesign project increased flexibility in scheduling and reduced
the work load for underwriters by redistributing administrative tasks and changing other work processes. The intervention enabled underwriters to increase the time spent on "real
underwriting," as opposed to administrative tasks, and to significantly reduce seasonal loan
backlog.
At Statistics Canada, work/life and other human resource strategies have paid off in turnover
rates that are about half those of other agencies and the lowest grievance rate of any government
department.
At First Tennessee Bank, 93 percent of managers felt their employees were more productive, and
88 percent of employees said they were more committed to remaining at the bank following a
massive cultural change program with a significant work/life component. In one bank division, business doubled over a six-year period, while in another key operations department,
productivity improved by 50 percent.
At Ernst & Young, in parts of the firm where the Office for Retention implemented life balance
prototypes or pilots, turnover dropped dramatically and client satisfaction increased. Ernst &
Young estimates that the OFR´s efforts have contributed to the increased retention of employees,
responsible for savings of $14 to $17 million in turnover costs.
8/6/2019 Holding a Job;Having a Life
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holding-a-jobhaving-a-life 4/7
- Benefits to employees. As a result of such innovative approaches to work/life issues,
employees are able to integrate their work and personal life more satisfactorily-- for example,
through increased flexibility; reduced work loads, overtime, and stress levels; and more free time
for family, community, and recreational activities.
At Hewlett Packard/Agilent, field technicians were required to meet customer requests within atwo-hour turn-around time while operating on a 24x7 schedule. Together, they redesigned the
work schedule to meet the service standard and also to give everyone real time off--days when
they could turn off their beepers and keep their personal commitments.
At Merck & Company, after a work redesign process was implemented in the payroll
department, overtime was cut in half and the number of employees on flexible work schedules
doubled.
At Ernst & Young, employees and their managers negotiate life-balance agreements every six
months to address such issues as how many days they will travel. Meanwhile, "solution teams"
redesigned travel schedules overall to allow more time at home, and "utilization committees"meet regularly to oversee employees´ work-loads, evenly distribute the work, and balance client
expectations with employees´ personal needs. The new rule: no one is required to check e-mail
or voice mail on weekends or vacations.
At Fleet Financial, the change initiative dramatically increased employee satisfaction with the
new work system, enabled employees to spend more time with their families and in leisure
activities, and significantly reduced sleeplessness, which had become a chronic problem
affecting many employees in the work unit.
- Innovation through employee involvement and the dual agenda. The work/life redesigns
described in the report differ from management-driven, top-down reengineering, because they
encourage strong employee involvement and encompass both work/life needs and strategic
business objectives.
Addressing both dimensions creates a synergy that improves employees´ lives and unleashes
individual and team creativity.
At Kraft Foods´ Sussex, Wisconsin, pizza plant, workers who took part in a high-performance
work redesign developed a schedule and a new team system that not only boosted production but
also reduced huge overhead costs and assembly down-time and made it easier to recruit and
retain people. It gave employees greater flexibility and predictability in their work hours, makingit easier to arrange child care and transportation. It also provided employees-many of them first-
time job holders out of welfare-to-work programs- with increased pay and training in business
and team decision making.
- The challenge of getting managers on board. When work/life initiatives are integrated with
work redesign and cultural change--as they were at companies such as Merck and Bank of
America--their success depends on managers´ willingness to listen to,and act on, employee
8/6/2019 Holding a Job;Having a Life
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holding-a-jobhaving-a-life 5/7
feedback. However, managers may feel threatened by such a participative change process, which
they perceive as a loss of control rather than an opportunity to improve work effectiveness.
- Systems to support managerial change. Given managers´ crucial role in creating a
supportive work environment and the natural resistance they may feel toward changing old
practices, companies need to find ways to encourage desired behaviors. For example, Bank of America, Merck & Company, and First Tennessee Bank found that managers needed extensive
coaching to deal effectively with employee feedback and involvement. At Statistics Canada, line
managers´ support of such practices as flexible working hours, training, and career development
is assured through performance reviews and a highly mobile internal job market that permits
employees to move to a different job in the organization if their present manager is not
supportive.
- Measurement matters. Despite a growing body of evidence that strategic work/life
initiatives contribute to the bottom line, more work needs to be done on the measurement front.
Among the recommended strategies:
1. Underlying cultural and work environment factors that impact usage of work/life programs
should be studied and incorporated into the measurement process.
2. In addition to quantitative results, the qualitative, hard-to-measure outcomes should also be
documented as part of the evaluation process. For example, managerial effectiveness may be an
important outcome of work/life redesign initiatives-in terms of freeing up managers´ time,
requiring less oversight and control over employees, and allowing more time for strategic
business planning.
3. Employers should hold managers accountable for promoting a supportive work
environment. Although companies are incorporating support for work/life balance into
managerial performance reviews, companies need to develop better ways to measure such
support. In addition, more explicit rewards/recognition programs for supportive leaders should
be developed.
- Use of data to leverage change. Data gathering and analysis can serve as a powerful
stimulus to change. Using internal benchmarking and surveys, Baxter Healthcare was able to
build managerial support for work/life initiatives and reshape organizational culture to place a
higher value on treating employees with respect. Survey findings led to the addition of a new
work/life standard into the company´s statement of Shared Values and into key human resource
systems-an important step toward a uniform standard for a highly decentralized company.
Other Approaches
In addition to the work redesign and cultural changes companies in our study have made to
simultaneously address work/life and business issues, the report also captures three other
8/6/2019 Holding a Job;Having a Life
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holding-a-jobhaving-a-life 6/7
approaches: public-private partnerships, joint labor-management partnerships, and collective
bargaining agreements.
- Public-private partnerships. Public-private partnerships, implemented at state and
community levels, represent an important strategy for addressing child care problems. Such
partnerships can be highly effective in leveraging federal, state, and private funds and mobilizingdiverse resources. Eli Lilly & Company partnered with state, community, and business
stakeholders to improve child care throughout Indiana. The results led to much more effective
and systemic solutions than any one partner could achieve working alone. As the state´s largest
private employer, the company not only improved the child care resources available to its
workers. Employee loyalty, morale, commitment and retention also improved as a result of the
company´s leadership role.
- Union-management partnerships. Joint labor-management partnerships can develop
innovative work/family solutions, as they have for unionized hotel and restaurant workers in San
Francisco, health and human services employees in New York City, and clerical workers at
Harvard University. When the partnership is part of the collective bargaining agreement andthere is a joint committee to plan and carry out initiatives, unionized organizations can be ideal
places to model genuine employee participation in work/family issues. Such partnerships are not
easy to accomplish or sustain, however. They require mutual trust, joint leadership commitment
to work/life as a priority, and adequate financial resources and training to enable the parties to
move from an adversarial to a collaborative relationship.
- Collective bargaining to limit mandatory overtime. Mandatory overtime has emerged as a
critical work/family issue, causing serious disruptions in employees´ lives and impacting
customer service, as demonstrated in the telecommunications industry. The Communications
Workers of America´s successful efforts to curb mandatory overtime through bargaining haveled to new provisions in bargaining contracts with employers that limit mandatory overtime and
require a joint committee to oversee and monitor overtime issues.
Critical Challenges
The report concludes by highlighting critical challenges organizations face when they link
work/life initiatives with a strategic focus. Key among these challenges is the task of diffusing
and sustaining these change initiatives throughout the corporation. The ultimate success and
staying power of innovative work/life strategies will depend on:
y building a broader understanding of how work/life strategies can address both business and personal needs;
y developing a chain of support and participation emanating from the top, middle, and grass-roots levels of the
organization; and
y creating tools and practices to help other parts of the organization replicate the change process.
8/6/2019 Holding a Job;Having a Life
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holding-a-jobhaving-a-life 7/7
In this regard, there are promising signs of success. All of the work/life redesign initiatives have
gone beyond the pilot stage, and corporate strategies and resources are in place to replicate
change processes. And even in organizations with the most mature cultural change processes,
steps are being taken to expand upon or revitalize existing efforts. Despite the diversity of
approaches to work/life integration, the cases presented in this report share a common theme: the
commitment to continuously learn, evolve, and improve upon strategies that address both business and work/life needs.