Hmmm Mar 12 2012

download Hmmm Mar 12 2012

of 24

Transcript of Hmmm Mar 12 2012

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    1/24

    THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GO

    HmmmA walk around the fringes of nance

    12 March 2012 1

    o Subscribe to Tings Tat Make You Go Hmmm..... clickHERE

    ...the Spain which emerged around 1960, beginning withits economic miracle, created by the invasion o tourists,can no longer result in impassioned dedication on thepart o its intellectuals, and even less on the part o or-eign intellectuals JUaN GOYTISOLO

    In order to ully realise our aspirations, wemust create in the masses o the people thesense o sacrifce and responsibility thathas been the characteristic o the anarchistmovement throughout its historic develop-ment in Spain. Frederica Montseny

    It is we the workers who built these palaces and cieshere in Spain and in America and everywhere. We, theworkers, can build others to take their place. And beerones! We are not in the least afraid of ruins Buenaventura Durruti

    http://ethreemail.com/subscribe?g=c6128effhttp://ethreemail.com/subscribe?g=c6128eff
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    2/24

    2.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 2

    Well, I promised you whenwe lst met tt I would NOT be tlking bout

    Greece this me and, I am going to be true to

    my word. Today, we are going to discuss two

    topics that have been on my mind recently but

    that the good folks of the Hellenic Republic and

    their capve audience in Brussels have man-

    aged to shunt from the introducon of Things

    That Make You Go Hmmm....., but that remain

    sources of connual fascinaon and consterna-

    on for me; Spain and oil ahhhh NUTS! They did

    it AGAIN.... ok...the Greek restructuring. It s not

    as though I could ignore it, now, is it?

    Oil can wait unl next me.... no doubt itll be

    an issue then too.

    So Lets begin with Spain.

    Spain is a problem. A real problem.Greece today triggered the biggest sovereign

    default of all me as it reneged on its commit-

    ments to pay back investors the 210billion it

    had promised them - some 2,400 years aer 10

    Greek municipalies became the rst sovereign

    enes to default when they sed the templeof Delos, birthplace of Apollo.

    Greeces debts are ve mes those of Argen-

    na when it became the tleholder in 2001

    and Greek GDP, which stands at US$305 bil-

    lion, qualies it for 32nd place on the list of

    the worlds biggest countries - nestled nicely

    between Denmark ($310 billion) and the UAE

    ($302 billion).

    Spain is twelh.

    Spains GDP of $1.4 trillion, somewhat surpris-ingly perhaps, puts it just behind oil-rich Russia

    and Canada and people-rich India. Spain is a big

    country. Spain maers.

    When the PIIGS rst muscled their way up to

    the trough a lifeme ago, the inial diagnosis

    was that Ireland, Portugal and Greece neither

    maered in the grand scheme of things nor

    were likely to get out of hand, but that Spain

    and more importantly, Italy, would be REAL

    problems if they got sucked into the morass.

    Of course, we were all reassured that both

    countries (in fact all of Europe) were in robust

    scal health and that we shouldnt count all ourchickens with regards a cascade of defaults:

    (Reuters, Jan 19, 2009): European Economic

    Aairs Commissioner Joaquin Almunia told

    the same news conference that the markets

    and credit rang agencies would take a

    more posive view of the situaon had they

    been at the ministers talks and heard the

    extent of the commitment to stable public

    nances.

    Almunia dismissed a news conference ques-

    on about the risk of any country defaulng,

    saying conngency planning was not even

    an issue in that regard.

    But the trouble with chickens is that they have

    this annoying tendency to come home to roost

    and here we are, three years, several bailouts

    and hundreds of billions of euro in cash later

    staring down the barrel of the largest sovereign

    default of all me.

    Last year it was widely accepted that, should

    Spain and Italy be pulled into the Europeanmaelstrom, things would take a material turn

    for the worse. Conveniently, Marketwatch

    laid out ve reasons why Italy, at least, is not

    Greece:

    1. Italys average debt maturity is much lon-

    ger, meaning any rise in yields is not an im-

    mediate problem and will take some me

    to lter through into Italys debt burden.

    2. Italy collects many more taxes than its

    debt service costs, even if it hypothecallyhad to pay 7% on all its debt.

    3. Its overall debt burden combining

    private and public debt is relavely low

    compared to developed countries.

    4. More than half of Italys debt is held

    domescally, which gives the government

    a lile more say. For example, bond swaps

    can be foisted on domesc instuons.

    Domesc instuons can be required to hold

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    3/24

    3.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 3

    more government bonds in, say, pension

    porolios.

    5. Finally, Italy has other sources of

    wealth. The country has a whole lot of gold

    the fourth highest reserve in the world.

    This is generally true of Europe as a whole.

    There is great wealth. There is sucient

    wealth in Europe in general and Italy in par-

    cular to address the debt crisis.

    ...Italys problem is primarily one of con-

    dence not solvency.

    But whilst Italy may not look much like Greece,it would be dicult NOT to admit that Spain

    bears more than a passing resemblance to the

    country currently occupying Wall Street.

    Italy may have a high sovereign

    debt, but it has a low level of

    private debt. It runs a primary

    surplus and its scal decit is

    actually quite low in comparison

    with most major economies. The

    completely coincidental buy-

    ing of Italian government bondsthat occurred just aer the ECBs

    LTRO operaons has meant that

    Italian yields, while sll high in

    a relave sense, are now at a

    level that makes them at least

    manageable even if they could

    do with being lower. This is great

    news for Italy. This is terrible

    news for Spain.

    Spain is now about to become

    the country everyone caresabout all over again and, when

    the worlds focus returns to the Iberian Penin-

    sula, it will realise that the large, grey shape in

    the corner of the room was a Spanish elephant.

    When discussing Spain,much of the focus has been on its relavely low

    sovereign debt-to-GDP level, which, at roughly

    68%, is far lower than that of Italy which stood

    at 120% in 2011 (though it has already doubled

    since the crisis began in 2008). So far so good.

    However, cast your minds back to September

    2008 when the Irish government made a deci-sion that ranks as among the very worst since

    General Custer said this looks like a nice place

    to camp for the night.

    (FT.com, Sep 30, 2008): Irelands govern-

    ment on Tuesday unveiled a wide-ranging

    guarantee arrangement to safeguard the

    deposits and debts at six nancial instu-

    ons in response to turmoil in the nancial

    markets.

    The scheme, which guarantees an esmated

    400bn (315bn, $567bn) of liabilies, cov-

    ers retail, commercial and inter-bank depos-

    its as well as covered bonds, senior debt and

    dated subordinated debt.

    Most depositors were already covered by

    an exisng deposit insurance scheme for up

    to 100,000. But Tuesdays iniave was

    primarily aimed at easing the banks short-

    term funding, which had seized up in recent

    days.

    Shares in the countrys three biggest banks

    rose sharply aer the government an-

    nounced the immediate start of the scheme,

    ...

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    20112010200920082007200620052004

    Irish Debt-to-GDP

    (2004 - 2011)

    SOURCE: TTMYGH

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    4/24

    4.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 4

    Irish government debt soared from 24.9% in

    2007 to 41.8% in 2008 and hasnt looked back

    since - reaching 105% in 2011 and necessitat-ing the crippling austerity measures that have

    blighted Ireland since 2009.

    As manageable as Spains public debt would ap-

    pear to be at face value, herprivate debt is n

    altogether dierent story - standing at a stag-

    gering 227% of GDP and, according to McKin-

    sey, Spanish corporaons hold twice as much

    debt relave to their output as US companies

    and, in comparison to Germany, that number

    goes up to six mes (incidentally, Portugal - the

    PIIG that nobody cares about - has even worsenumbers with public debt at 93% and private

    debt at an eye-watering 249%, - sll as high as it

    was at the height of the GFC. Portugal is unsal-

    vageable - its just that nobody seems to think it

    will maer. It will.)

    As Spain reduced its decit inaccordance with the EUs Growth & Stability

    Pact, it meant an increasing reliance on private

    debt ws needed in ode to polong te eno-

    mous construcon boom that had been ongoingin Spain since the 1970s but which really picked

    up steam in the 90s and 00s. The outcome of

    that reliance? A tripling of average household

    debt.

    With the die cast, the Zapatero government

    was voted out last year and the incoming Rajoy

    administraon vowed further austerity would

    be implemented in order to bring the decits

    under control, but Januarys numbers wouldimply that austerity is anything but the magic

    bullet that the policymakers of Europe seem to

    believe it to be. When Greg Weldon, dug into

    Spains unemployment numbers last month, his

    ndings were chilling:

    Spains January Unemployment data was

    of GREAT interest, revealing the THIRD

    LARGEST EVER single-month expansion in

    the Number of Unemployed, pegged at

    +177,470 ... which represents a MASSIVE

    monthly rise equal to +4.0% ... and ... a siz-able +35.6% yr-yr increase !!!

    For reference, a populaon-equivalent rise

    in US unemployment would be akin to a (-)

    1.2 million single month LOSS in Non-Farm

    Payrolls.

    Further, the oversized January increase was

    enough to boost the rolling 12-Month

    Change in the Total Number of Unemployed

    back above +350,000, as evidenced in the

    chart on display [below, le]. Indeed, by thismeasure the Spanish labor market has been

    in a recession since the second half of 2007,

    and with a re-acceleraon to the upside, this

    gauge is back to crisis levels.

    Note the acceleraon in the year-year rate

    of increase in the Number of Unemployed,

    dang back to the spring of last

    year:

    Jan-12 ... +8.72%

    Dec-11 ... +7.86%

    Nov-11 ... +7.55%

    Oct-11 ... +6.73%

    Sep-11 ... +5.20%

    Aug-11 ... +4.06%

    Jul-11 ... +4.38%

    Jun-11 ... +3.50%

    May-11 ... +3.04%

    We also note that EVERY busi-

    ness-industry sector posted an

    increase in the Number of Unem-

    SOURCE: GREG WELDON

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    5/24

    5.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 5

    ployed, which also rose across-the-board in

    terms of BOTH sexes, and EVERY age group.

    As a result of the oversized seasonal gain in

    January, Spains Unemployment Rate seems

    set to rise further when 1Q gures are

    posted in two months.

    Already at a MULTI-DECADE HIGH as of the

    last report, for the 4Q (revealing a 22.8%

    rate, which violated the previous high of

    22.5% set in 1994) ... the gain in Januaryimplies a rise of one-full percentage point,

    which would put the Unemployment Rate at

    a newer new high of 23.8%, as evidenced in

    the chart on display [above].

    (You can head to www.weldononline.com to

    sign up for a free trial of Gregs phenomenal

    work. I cannot recommend it highly enough)

    Naturally, against this backdrop of spiralling un-

    employment, crippling debt levels in the private

    sector and rigid austerity measures, something

    had to give. That something? Well, funnily

    enough, it was the Spanish governments will-

    ingness to play ball with the EU. Ominously, it

    was couched in somewhat naonalisc terms

    which could be a harbinger of things to come:

    (UK Daily Telegraph): Spain is already plan-

    ning to breach its budgetary targets, defying

    European leaders on the day they signed

    their historic scal pact.

    Mariano Rajoy, prime minister of Spain, said

    the budget decit would be 5.8pc of GDP in

    2012 - more than 30pc higher

    than the 4.4pc target agreed by

    Brussels.

    In a move that was heralded in

    Spain as deance against the

    German-led austerity drive, Mr

    Rajoy said he had decided to

    set a new target rather than ex-

    tract 44bn (36.6bn) from the

    budget at a me of economic

    crisis. Mr Rajoy said it was now

    a sensible and reasonable

    target. This is a sovereign

    decision made by Spaniards,he said...

    Mr Rajoy insisted the slippage was just

    on an interim target and Spain would sll

    honour its commitment to bringing its decit

    down to 3pc of GDP by 2013. But the an-

    nouncement was seen as rebung other

    European leaders since the gures do not

    have to be conrmed unl April.

    Ambrose Evans-Pritchard had some thoughts

    of his own on the signicance of Rajoys boldmove:

    In the twenty years or so that I have been

    following EU aairs closely, I cannot remem-

    ber such a bold and open act of deance by

    any state. Usually such maers are fudged.

    Countries stretch the line, but do not actu-

    ally cross it.

    With condign symbolism, Mr Rajoy dropped

    his bombshell in Brussels aer the EU sum-

    mit, without rst nofying the commission

    or fellow EU leaders. Indeed, he seemed torelish the fact that he was tearing up the

    rule book and disavowing the whole EU

    machinery of budgetary control.

    Right on cue, the leader of Hollands Freedom

    Party, an important part of the ruling Dutch

    coalion, took up Rajoys baton and sprinted

    ahead in surprising fashion:

    (UK Daily Telegraph): The Dutch Freedom

    Party has called for a return to the Guilder,

    becoming the rst polical movement in the

    SOURCE: GREG WELDON

    http://www.weldononline.com/http://www.weldononline.com/
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    6/24

    6.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 6

    eurozone with a large popular base to opt

    for withdrawal from the single currency.

    The euro is not in the interests of the Dutch

    people, said Geert Wilders, the leader of

    the right-wing populist party with a sixth of

    the seats in the Dutch parliament. We want

    to be the master of our own house and our

    own country, so we say yes to the guilder.

    Bring it on.

    Mr Wilders made his decision aer receiving

    a report by London-based Lombard Street

    Research concluding that the Netherlands

    is badly handicapped by euro membership,

    and that it could cost EMUs creditor core

    more than 2.4 trillion to hold monetary

    union together over the next four years. If

    the policians in The Hague disagree with

    our report, let them show the guts to hold a

    referendum. Let the Dutch people decide,

    he said...

    The study said the eurozone cannot survive

    in its current form. The longer Europes poli-

    cians dither, the more costly it will become.

    The euro can only survive if it becomes ascal transfer union with naonal sovereign

    debt subsumed in eurozone bonds, said co-

    author Charles Dumas.

    The Dutch have always been Europeans to

    the core and staunch allies of the Germans at

    the heart of the EU. This is a troubling develop-

    ment indeed for the architects of the European

    Dream. Throw in Francois Hollandes promise

    to renegoate the scal compact if elected

    in France when elecons get under way next

    month (he is currently leading in early polling)and it becomes ever-clearer that we are a long

    way from being out of the woods.

    With 50% of Spains under-25s out of work (a

    situaon that wont improve for years), s-

    ing austerity measures in place that, in order

    to meet EU debt limits, will ensure that the

    chance of generang any growth in the Span-

    ish economy becomes about as likely as Kim

    Kardashian refusing to pose for a photograph, it

    is obvious that its only a mater of me before

    Spain becomes the new Greece. Like Greece,

    the trouble will really begin with public sector

    strikes, followed by social unrest as the Summerheat hits Southern Europe and end with poli-

    cian pandering to angry demands for an exit

    from Europe and upheaval.

    Uncannily, aer wring that previous sentence

    last night, I wake up to this arcle in the FT:

    (FT): Spains two largest unions, Comisiones

    Obreras and UGT, voted on Friday to call

    for a general strike on March 29 against

    reforms they called the most regressive in

    the history of Spanish democracy.

    The labour reforms of Mariano Rajoys gov-

    ernment grant employers greater exibility

    to pay lower compensaon when they re

    workers, a change Mr Rajoy argues is crucial

    to increase Spains economic compeve-

    ness, but one that has enraged the countrys

    unions.

    Spain is going to be the country on the front

    pages this summer so best get yourselves ac-

    quainted with the problems facing it. If it saves

    you any me, they are by and large similar tothose faced by Greece - only much, much larger.

    Lather. Rinse. Repeat.

    Speaking o Greece, Eu-ropes perennial prodigal son, managed to hold

    a gun close enough to the collecve heads of

    their investors to make them realise that volun-

    teering for a restructuring of their outstanding

    debt was an extremely smart idea. Aer the

    decision by Greece to not pay back a hundred

    billion-odd euos tt it d pomised to bond-holders was nally recognised as a default this

    week (sigh), and aer a marathon 8-hour ses-

    sion ended in the members of the ISDA commit-

    tee realising that this constuted a credit event

    (8 hours guys? Seriously?) which in turn triggers

    roughly $3bln in CDS payments, the terms of

    the restructuring will go to the EU to be raed.

    The problem is solved. That ought to allow ev-

    erybody to breathe a sigh of relief, right?

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    7/24

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    8/24

    8.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 8

    of dollars.

    Who thinks the upcoming Greek bail-out

    will be the last, drawing a line under theeurozones sovereign debt crisis? asked the

    senior Euromoney staer chairing the panel.

    Put your hands up.

    Delivered with a serious demeanour, this

    was exactly the right queson. So deadly

    was the inquiry, and so germane, that the

    mood in the room grew uneasy, barely cam-

    ouaged by an outbreak of coughing. Scan-

    ning this ultra-inuenal audience, I saw

    rows of delegates cowed, keeping their eyes

    locked forwards but staring down slightly,

    not daring to look elsewhere.

    Not a single hand was raised. Not a single

    hand among hundreds of the worlds lead-

    ing bond market praconers was srred to

    support a debt swap now presented as the

    key to the world economy shaking o

    the post sub-prime torpor and tak-

    ing us into the sun-lit uplands

    of sustainable global growth.

    But perhaps the easiest way to il-lustrate the level of condence in the

    Greek soluon is to look at the prices of the

    restructured bonds themselves, and for that, I

    will yield the oor to my friend John Mauldin

    who, in another excellent leer this week had

    this to say on the subject:

    Greek is having an orderly default. The

    taxpayers of Europe are in theory going

    to lend 130 billion to Greece to pay back

    100 billion in Greek debt that is owed to

    private lenders. Greece has to pass several

    dicult tests in order to get the money.

    100 billion of debt to private lenders will bewrien o. Thus the net eect will be that

    they owe 30 billion more. How does this

    help Greece, except that they get 30 billion

    more they cannot pay?

    The new debt is already trading in the

    market, even though it has not actually been

    issued. (Dont bother traders with messy

    details, just do the deal.) This page from

    Bloomberg [below, le] is just too delicious

    not to print, sent to me courtesy of Dan

    Greenhaus of BTIG. It shows the new Greekbonds trading at over a 71-79% discount,

    depending on the length of maturity. Note

    this is AFTER the 53% haircut already

    imposed. That reads to me like the market

    value of original Greek debt is now between

    12 and 14% of the original face value.

    ********

    So, this weekI d pomised totalk about oil, but instead I will oer you a his-

    tory lesson as well as some thoughts on taccs

    and strategy in the Straits of Hormuz courtesy

    of Louis de Sousa and Ambrose Evans-Pritchard

    SOURCE: MAULDIN/GREENHAUS

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    9/24

    9.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 9

    on the concept of plateau oil, while Japans

    nuclear power staons and the return of the

    nuclear lobby also come under the microscope.

    Former CEOs of Fannie & Freddie have the

    chutzpah to look to the government to pay their

    legal fees, margin calls sweep across Europe,

    the AIJ scandal has Japans regulator in a spin.

    John Mauldin examines the ramicaons of the

    ISDA ruling and, of course, theres Spain. Lots of

    Spain.

    In our charts secon, Je Clark takes a look

    at historical volality in the precious metals,

    chles hUg-Smit tkes im t te die stte

    of student loans in America and RIchard Ross

    picks the NASDAQ and the US 10-yr as the focus

    for his all-seeing eye.

    Jim Grant, interviewed on CNBC last week

    shows just why he is the Master, Russell Napier

    of CLSA gives a fabulous interview with Jim

    Puplava on what happens when credit dies and

    edes get to meet good fiend of mine in

    the shape of Mr. Simon Mikhailovich as he talks

    to Al Korelin.

    (incidentally, the real Simon looks nothing like

    the picture youll see on page 22).

    Tats all rom me fo noteweek aer my whirlwind trip through New York

    and Dallas, Texas.

    I had very lile sleep, ate too much good food

    and met some extraordinary people this past

    week and would like to take this opportunity to

    thank them all for their hospitality, their me

    and for sharing some ideas and views with me.

    Truly the best part of wring this leer is the

    number of smart, engaged people it brings me

    into contact with from all over the world and I

    treasure the me I get to spend with each and

    every one of them.

    I leave you with a cartoon that was sent to me

    this week by one of my very favourite readers

    and does a beer job of summing up the events

    of the past few weeks in seven words and a

    picture than I could possibly hope to do in ten

    pages.

    Until next time.

    SOURCE: UNKNOWN

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    10/24

    10.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 10

    Contents 12 March 2012

    Plateau Oil meets 125m Chinese cars

    More bailouts: $200M to defend crisis-era CEOs

    Spains sovereign thunderclap and the end of Merkels Europe

    European Banks Now Face Huge Margin Calls As ECB Collateral Crumbles

    Japan Is Now Another Spinning Plate in the Global Economy Circus

    Nuclear Lobby Pushes Ahead with New Reactors

    Why AIJ Scandal Will Be The First Of Many

    Taccs and Strategy at the Strait of Hormuz

    Te ISDa Steps Up

    Charts That Make You Go Hmmm.....

    Words That Make You Go Hmmm.....

    And Finally.....

    The Gonnie, Gonnie Banks

    # Bank Assets ($m) Deposits ($m) Cost ($m)

    13 New City Bank, Chicago, IL 71.2 72.4 17.4

    Total Cost to FDIC Deposit Insurance Fund 17.4

  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    11/24

    11.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 11

    Oil spikes usuallymetastasizeonce energy costs reach 9pc of global GDP. The

    longer they stay there, the greater the damage.

    That proved to be the pain barrier in the 1970s

    and again in 2008, and we are just shy of that

    level right now. Oil is already capturing a higher

    level of European GDP than in 2008, said Fran-

    cisco Blanch from Bank of America.

    The rule of thumb is that a 10pc rise in crude cuts

    US growth by 0.2pc four quarters later, but the

    science is abbily so and nobody knows where

    the inexion point lies. The eect is famously

    non-linear. Nothing much seems to happenunl con-

    dence sud-

    denly snaps.

    What is

    deeply trou-

    bling is tt

    Brent crude

    should have reached fresh records in sterling

    (79) and euros (94) - with a knock-on eect

    on US petrol prices, mostly tracking Brent -

    even though the Internaonal Monetary Fundhas sharply downgraded its world growth fore-

    cast to 3.25pc this year from 4pc in September,

    and even though Internaonal Energy Agency

    (IEA) has cut its oil use forecast for this year by

    750,000 barrels per day (bpd).

    Oil is not supposed to ratchet deantly upwards

    in a downturn, which is what we have with the

    Euro zone facing a year of contracon in 2012,

    and much of the Lan bloc sliding into full de-

    pression. Japans economy shrank in the fourth

    quarter.

    Asias emerging powers of Asia - the key force

    driving the commodity boom of the last decade

    - are in various stages of so-landings aer

    hing the monetary brakes last year to check

    property bubbles and curb inaon. Chinas

    manufacturing has been bouncing along near

    contracon levels through the winter. So what

    happens when it recovers?

    The unpleasant fact we must all face is that the

    relentless supply crunch - call it `Peak Oil if you

    want, or Plateau Oil - was briey disguised dur-

    ing the Great Recession and is already back witha vengeance before the West has fully recov-

    ered.

    The IEA said non-OPEC producon stalled in

    2010 and 2011. There was no net increase. While

    there was a boost from Canadas tar sands, and

    Americas shale-oil, and Brazils oshore rigs,

    this was oset by the relentless erosion of the

    North Sea elds and Mexicos operaons, a col-

    lapse in the Sudan, and Libyas woes.

    Meanwhile OPEC spare capacity has fallen to

    2.5m barrels a day (bpd), compared to 3.7m this

    me last year during the Arab Spring, the event

    that caused a comparable spike in crude prices

    and arguably triggered the sharp global slow-

    down a few months later.

    The chain of causality is hotly disputed. A young

    professor Ben Bernanke no less wrote the deni-

    ve paper in 1997 - Systemac Monetary Policy

    and the Eects of Oil Price Shocks - arguing that

    policy-makers themselves are the villains be-

    cause they over-react.O O O AMBROSE EVANS-PRITCHARD / LINK

    Tree years ago, I put fomeFannie Mae and Freddie Mac CEOs Daniel Mudd,

    Frank Raines and Richard Syron at the top of the

    list of those responsible for the nancial crisis.

    Since then, the Securies and Exchange Com-

    mission and various class-acon groups have

    led lawsuits alleging these former execuves

    commied all sorts of accounng and securies

    fraud. Sounds great, right? We the people are -

    nally geng jusce, right?

    Wrong. Guess whos foong the roughly $200

    million in legl bills to defend tese lleged

    crooks against all those legal acons? You are.

    The taxpayers. The same is true of $400 million

    that Fannie Mae already paid to sele an SEC

    fraud suit. And thats just the tab to date; this

    will go on for years and years.

    Even worse, this shouldnt be happening. Crony

    ... What is deeply troubling is thatBrent crude should have reached reshrecords in sterling (79) and euros(94) - with a knock-on eect on USpetrol prices

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/commodities/9122311/Plateau-Oil-meets-125m-Chinese-cars.html
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    12/24

    12.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 12

    federal regulators and execuves appointed by

    those same regulators aer the ailing pseudo-

    government enes were brought under thefederal governments conservatorship are leng

    it happen instead of doing their job of protecng

    the American people.

    As is typically the case, Fannie and Freddie by-

    laws and contracts protect and indemnify com-

    pany execuves and directors against ligaon

    costs. But thats not the case if execuves or di-

    rectors breach their duciary duty -- the duty of

    loyalty to the company and its stockholders -- or

    engage in intenonal misconduct.

    And that just so happens to be what former

    execuves are being accused of: overstang in-

    come and manipulang prots over a period of

    six years to generate more than $115 million in

    improper bonuses, and misleading investors by

    understang their exposure to risky subprime

    mortgages, among other things.

    The dilemma, of course, is that as long as the

    former execuves maintain their innocence,

    neither adming nor denying they did anything

    wrong, regu-ltos nd te

    CEOs they ap-

    pointed to x

    this mess say

    theyre con-

    tractually and

    legally obli-

    gated to connue to indemnify the defendants.

    When the federal regulatory agency FHFA

    moved to put Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac un-

    der conservatorship in 2008, then FHFA directorJames Lockhart and U.S. Treasury Secretary Hen-

    ry Paulson -- both of whom took deep bows for

    this sweeping government intervenon -- had

    the chance to deny those indemnicaon agree-

    ments. The only problem is, they didnt.

    So here we are, you and me and all the other

    American taxpayers; proud owners of over $5

    trillion in quesonable mortgages and securi-

    es; prinng more and more money to cover the

    $1 trillion plus bailout and execuve bonuses for

    these remarkably dysfunconal pseudo-govern-

    ment enes.

    And the worst part about it is, when the SEC sues

    Fannie and Freddie, its essenally suing you and

    me, since thats who ends up paying all the pen-

    ales, selements, and even the legal fees to

    defend the companies and their crooked execu-

    ves. In total, thats $600 million and counng.

    Hard to believe.

    O O O CBS / LINK

    Te Spanish rebellion sbegun, sooner and more dramacally than I ex-pected.

    As many readers will already have seen, Premier

    Mariano Rajoy has refused point blank to com-

    ply with the austerity demands of the European

    Commission and the European Council (hijacked

    by Merkozy).

    Taking what he called a sovereign decision, he

    simply announced that he intends to ignore the

    EU decit target of 4.4pc of GDP for this year,

    seng his own target of 5.8pc instead (down

    from 8.5pc in 2011).

    In the twenty years or so that I have been follow-

    ing EU aairs closely, I cannot remember such a

    bold and open act of deance by any state. Usu-

    ally such maers are fudged. Countries stretch

    the line, but do not actually cross it.

    With condign symbolism, Mr Rajoy dropped his

    bombshell in Brussels aer the EU summit, with-

    out rst nofying the commission or fellow EU

    leaders. Indeed, he seemed to relish the fact that

    he was tearing up the rule book and disavowingthe whole EU machinery of budgetary control.

    He is surely right to seize the iniave. Spains

    economy will contract by 1.7pc this year under

    his modied plans and unemployment will reach

    24pc (or 29pc under the 1990s method of count-

    ing). To compound this with manic scal ghten-

    ing and no oseng devaluaon is intellec-

    tually indefensible.

    There comes a point when a democracy can no

    ... In the twenty years or so thatI have been ollowing EU aairsclosely, I cannot remember such abold and open act o defance by anystate

    http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-500395_162-57390241/more-bailouts-$200m-to-defend-crisis-era-ceos/
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    13/24

    13.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 13

    longer sacrice its cizens to please reacon-

    ary ideologues determined to impose 1930s

    scorched-earth policies. Ya basta.

    What is striking is the wave of support for Mr Ra-

    joy from the Spanish commentariat.

    This one from Pablo Sebasn le me speech-

    less.

    My loose translaon:

    Spain isnt any old country that will allow itself

    to be humiliated by the German Chancellor.

    The behaviour of the European Commission to-

    wards Spain over recent days has been infamousand exceeds their treaty pow-

    ers these Eurocrats think

    they are the owners and mas-

    ters of Spain.

    Spain and other naons in

    the EU are sick and red of

    Chancellor Merkels meddling

    and Germanys usurpaon

    with the help of Sarkozys

    France and their pretended

    execuve presidency thatdoes not in fact exist in EU

    treaes.

    Rajoy must not retreat one

    inch. The stakes are high and

    the country is in no mood to

    suer humiliaons from a

    Chancellor who is amassing all the savings of Eu-

    rope and wont listen to anybody, as if she were

    the absolute ruler of the Union. Merkel and the

    Commission should think hard before pung

    their hand into the sovereignty of this country

    or any other because it will be burned.

    This then is the fermenng mood in the ercely

    proud and ancient naon of Spain in Year III of

    depression, probably the worst depression the

    country has seen since the 1640s or have I

    missed a worse one?

    O O O AMBROSE EVANS-PRITCHARD / LINK

    In what could prove to be the most

    crical unintended consequence of the ECBs

    LTRO program, we note that as of last Friday the

    ECB has started to make very sizable margin callson its credit-extensions to counterpares. While

    the hope was for any and every piece of lowly

    collateral to be lodged with the ECB in return for

    freshly printed money to spend on local govern-

    ment debt, perhaps the expectaon of a truly

    virtuous circle of liquidity liing all boats forever

    is crashing on the shores of reality. This De-

    posits Related to Margin Calls line item on the

    ECBs balance sheet will likely now become the

    most-watched indicator of stress as we note

    the dramac acceleraon from an average well

    under EUR200 million to well over EUR17 billion

    since the LTRO began. The rapid deterioraon in

    collateral asset quality is extremely worrisome

    (GGBs? European nancial sub debt? Papandre-

    ous Kebab Shop unsecured 2nd lien notes?) asit forces the banks who took the collateralized

    loans to come up with more precious cash or

    assets (unwind exisng protable trades such as

    sovereign carry, delever further by selling assets,

    or subordinate more of the capital structure via

    pledging more assets - to cover these collater-

    al shoralls) or pay-down the loan in part. This

    could very quickly become a self-fullling vicious

    circle - especially given the leverage in both the

    ECB and the already-insolvent banks that took

    LTRO loans that now back the main Italian, Span-

    CLICK TO ENLARGE SOURCE: BLOOMBERG/ZEROHEDGE

    http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user3303/imageroot/2012/02/20120306_ECB.pnghttp://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/finance/ambroseevans-pritchard/100015432/spains-sovereign-thunderclap-and-the-end-of-merkels-europe/
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    14/24

    14.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 14

    ish, and Portuguese sovereign bond markets.

    This huge increase in margin calls can only fur-

    ther exacerbate

    the sgma at-

    tached to LTRO-

    facing banks - and

    s we noted tis

    moning (some-

    what presciently)

    bot te LTrO-

    S t i g m a - t r a d e ,

    that we created,

    and the potenal

    fo MtM losseson the carry-

    tdes tt LTrO

    cash was put

    to work in could indeed start a vicious circle in

    European nancials, just as everyone thought it

    was safe to dip a toe back in the risk pool.

    What should also start to worry the Germans is

    the fact a 37x levered hedge-fund central bank

    with EUR3 trillion balance sheet that has ex-

    tended credit in a risk-managed approach on

    what appears to be an ever dwindling supply ofperforming collateral is starng to see dramac

    gaps in its asset-liability exposure (but rest as-

    sured Bernanke told us that our FX Swaps are

    safe as houses).

    One lst point sould be noted - te opes of

    an LTRO3 or some such are surely now out of

    the window as clearly banks have run dry of any

    and all reasonable collateral or can the sovereign

    bonds purchased using LTRO1 and LTRO2 funds

    be lodged once again in a rehypothecated mi-

    asma circling the drain?

    O O O ZEROHEDGE / LINK

    At the circus, you are somemestreated to the spinning plate act where a per-

    fome ties to keep n impobble numbe of

    plates spinning at once, racing from one plate

    to the next as their wobbles indicate the need

    for another dose of momentum. Considering the

    numbe of spinning nd wobbling pltes tt

    our central planners are managing, its easy to

    be both amazed and anxious at the same me.

    The dierence between the spinning plate anal-

    ogy and real-world economic and nancial sys-

    tems is that if a failure occurs out in the real

    world, it has a very high chance of spreading

    across and through the other elements of the

    system. Contagion is the fear, as if in nally top-

    pling, one plate will crash into its neighbor and

    set o a chain reacon of falling plates.

    To carry this metaphor, Japan is a wobbly plate.

    For those who are in a hurry today, the boom

    line is tt Jpn is in seious touble igt nowand is a top candidate to be the next black swan.

    Here are the elements of diculty that concern

    me the most, each one serving to reduce Japans

    economic and nancial stability:

    The total shutdown of all 54 nuclear plants,

    leading to an energy insuciency

    Japans trade balance is in negave territory

    for the rst me in decades, driven largely

    by energy imports

    A budget decit that is now 56% larger thanrevenues (!!)

    Total debt standing at a whopping 235% of

    GDP

    A recession shrinking Japans economy at an

    annual rate of 2.3%

    Renewed eorts underway to debase the

    yen

    As I wrote a shortly aer the earthquake in

    March 2011, Japan is facing an economic melt-down. If it is not careful, it may well face a cur-

    rency meltdown, too. These things take me to

    play out, but now almost exactly a year aer the

    devastang earthquake of 2011, the dicules

    for Japan are mounng -- as expected.

    Exacerbated by the earthquake and tsunami, Ja-

    pans current predicament has been developing

    over many years and represents the aermath of

    a burst nancial bubble (involving stocks and real

    estate), an inability to let failed instuons actu-

    ... What should also start to worrythe Germans is the act a 37xlevered hedge-und central bank

    with EUR3 trillion balance sheetthat has extended credit in arisk-managed approach on whatappears to be an ever dwindlingsupply o perorming collateral is

    starting to see dramatic gaps inits asset-liability exposure

    http://www.zerohedge.com/news/european-banks-now-face-huge-margin-calls-ecb-collateral-crumbles
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    15/24

    15.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 15

    ally fail, and repeated and stubborn aempts to

    preserve what ulmately could not be sustained.

    Where many analysts predicted that the tsunami

    would be GDP posive because of the re-build-

    ing that would follow, I predicted economic dif-

    cules would be the main result due to broken

    supply chains, reduced factory output, and in-

    creased drag due to rising energy imports.

    Japan is like the worlds largest petri dish, and

    the experiment at hand is about what happens

    to an advanced, industrialized economy when

    its electricity producon is cut. As always, our

    view is that energy is the master resource. Our

    observaon is that complex systems behave in

    unpredictable ways when starved for energy, but

    direconally, they tend to shrink and simplify.

    Electricity is a crical form of energy, and thus

    the amount of electricity produced and a coun-

    trys GDP are very highly correlated. Sure, there

    is always some easy conservaon that can be

    done that would allow an electricity shorall to

    be met without any serious economic impacts.

    Street lights can be turned o, air condioning

    and heang can be moderated, and other low-impact conservaon eorts can reduce electric-

    ity consumpon without doing much more than

    lowering ulity revenues.

    However, there is a certain point beyond which

    conservaon can do no more and electricity re-

    stricons begin to bite into economic acvity.

    Plants end up running slower or even shungdown, producvity declines, and work can stag-

    nate.

    Before the Fukushima disaster, Japan relied on

    nuclear power for 30% of its total electricity pro-

    ducon. As of March 26, 2012, that number is

    going to be 0%.

    O O O CHRIS MARTENSON / LINK

    Te road to the construcon site isanked by ruins. At one point, theres a churchthat looks like its steeple has been shaved right

    o. An icy wind whistles through empty farm-

    lands.

    The buildings, which are slowly decaying at

    the foot of a small hill, are relics of the former

    German province of East Prussia. Now they

    are located in the eastern part of the Russian

    exclave of Kaliningrad, located between Poland

    and Lithuania.

    At the top of the knoll, three cranes are pivong.

    A massive construcon pit comes into view, 20

    meters (66 feet) deep and 500 meters long. Visi-

    tors can walk down a ramp to reach its boom of

    sand-brown dirt.

    CLICK TO ENLARGE SOURCE: DER SPEIEGEL

    http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/bild-819452-325754.htmlhttp://%20http//www.chrismartenson.com/blog/japan-another-spinning-plate-global-economy-circus/72033
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    16/24

    16.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 16

    Yevgeniy Vlasenko, the director of the nuclear

    power plant that will be built on the site, slips

    on his hardhat. With Vyacheslav Machonin, hisconstrucon supervisor, trailing close behind,

    Vlasenko heads for a mass of freshly poured con-

    crete blocks. All around, workers are bending the

    iron rods that will be used in the buildings ring-

    shaped foundaon.

    The reactor with its fuel rods will rest on top of

    this, Vlasenko explains. His construcon super-

    visor proudly reports to him that his workers are

    mixing 2,000 cubic meters (70,000 cubic feet)

    of concrete per hour for the structure. Should

    there be a core melt-down, the extremely

    ot unium will

    dip down nd be

    tpped in tis b-

    sin. But, of course,

    Vlasenko insists that

    things will never get

    to that point.

    Vlasenko doesnt

    wnt to spoil te

    good mood on the construcon site. Everythingis reportedly going according to plan: In four or

    ve years, at most, the rst block of the new Ka-

    liningrad Nuclear Power Plant will begin generat-

    ing 1,200 megawas of electricity. Then well

    sell the energy to Europe, Vlasenko says. In-

    cluding Germany.

    The gaunt director and his more rotund con-

    strucon supervisor cant help but laugh a bit

    about the irony of selling nuclear power to Ger-

    many, now that it has decided to phase out its

    own nuclear power plants by 2022. You used tobuild fantasc nuclear power plants, elegant and

    solid, says Machonin, who is now working on

    his ninth such construcon project.

    Before this project, Machnonin was in the south-

    western Iranian city of Bushehr. There, we took

    over and nished the Siemens building project,

    he says. And we adopted some things from you

    there. Both of them shake their heads. How

    could the Germans just throw everything away,

    asks Vlasenko. Nuclear energy isnt on its way

    out; its at the beginning of a renaissance.

    O O O DER SPIEGEL / LINK

    Japans investment man-agement sector expects more scandalsto emerge as regulatory scruny of the countrys

    domesc fund managers intensies.

    Last month, Japans Financial Services Agency

    (FSA) suspended the operaons of money man-

    agement rm, AIJ Investment Advisors, aer it

    was unable to account for the bulk of $2.6 billion

    in pension funds it managed on behalf of 123 cli-

    ents.The suspension follows the $1.7 billion account-

    ing scandal at the Japanese camera maker Olym-

    pus, which raised quesons about the preva-

    lence of white-collar crime in Japan and the

    ability of Japanese nancial regulators to moni-

    tor oenders.

    Japans nancial services minister, Shozaburo

    Jimi, last week described the situaon as deplor-

    able and ordered a sweeping invesgaon into

    the nances of 263 other money management

    companies in Japan.

    As part of these invesgaons fund management

    companies will be required to disclose more in-

    formaon on their operaons including whether

    they had set up investment trust funds overseas

    and whether they use external auditors.

    One Tokyo-based fund manager told IFLR the AIJ

    incident had revealed the fundamental weak-

    nesses at the ground level of Japans pension

    fund system.

    It has, for instance, become commonplace for

    the countrys mid- and small-sized pension funds

    to hire only one or two dedicated managers, of-

    ten without the necessary skills or professional

    background to manage pension funds.

    Such hires were oen former employees of Ja-

    pans scandal-hit Social Insurance Agency which,

    before being abolished and replaced by the Ja-

    pan Pension Scheme in 2010, monitored Japans

    pension fund policy at the naonal level.

    ... Japans fnancial servicesminister, Shozaburo Jimi, last

    week described the situationas deplorable and ordered asweeping investigation into thefnances o 263 other moneymanagement companies in

    Japan

    http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,819452,00.htmlhttp://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,819452,00.html
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    17/24

    17.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 17

    For smaller funds, without the means

    to hire from big names such as Goldman

    Sachs, exemployees of the Social Insur-ance Agency seemed the best opon,

    the fund manager said. It was assumed

    they would be well qualied to do a good

    job.

    The regulaons didnt eecvely take

    those facts into account, he said. And

    the gaps that developed between indus-

    try assumpons and the regulatory reali-

    ty created room for the AIJ to manipulate

    those systemac weaknesses.

    O O O IFLR / LINK

    About a month ago,when Iranian ocials started venng

    the idea of closing the Strait of Hormuz

    to commercial trac, Western media

    was prompt in reviewing the events of

    1981. At that me, Iranian forces mined

    the Strait and engaged commercial ves-

    sels with rubber speedboats in what was largely

    seen as a pathec aempt to control the area.

    The media seems to think that Iranian ocialsare talking about using similar taccs today. In

    reality, the military technology deployed by Iran

    in the region is completely dierent today, cre-

    ang a strategic scenario totally dierent from

    that of 30 years ago.

    According to the EIA, 17 million barrels of pe-

    troleum crossed the Strait of Hormuz each day

    during 2011. This makes up almost 40% of the in-

    ternaonal petroleum market, clearly the most

    important choke-point of the world for this com-

    modity; on average 28 oil tankers cross the Strait

    every day, half of them empty and inbound, the

    other half outbound. Adding to petroleum is

    liquied natural gas (LNG), exported by Qatar

    and the UAE ; over 6 million tones of LNG cross

    the Strait every month, about 25% of the inter-

    naonal market. All of this trac takes place

    very close to Iranian waters and shores.

    Iran is a very large country, with an area of almost

    1 700 000 km2, more than Spain, France, Italy,

    and Germany combined. To its south, Iran has a

    coast almost 1700 km long, which makes up all

    the north shores of the Persian Gulf (hence thename) and the Gulf of Oman. Along this coast lie

    numerous islands of assorted sizes, including Le-

    van, Hendorabi, Kish, Forur, Sirri, Abu Masa, the

    Tunb twins, Qeshm, Hengrn, Lark, and of course,

    Hormuz. All these islands are found west of the

    Strait, Hormuz being eecvely the eastern most

    of them all. Qeshm is by far the largest of these

    islands, with 1490 km2, larger than all the other

    islands together. Contrary to what its name sug-

    gests, the narrowest secon of the Strait is along

    the southeastern shores of Qeshm, between the

    smaller islands of Hengrn and Lark. BetweenLark and the smaller isles of Oman, there are

    less than 40 km of water. Sovereignty over the

    Strait waters is divided by Iran and Oman. The

    noten lf is sllowe nd less suitble fo

    large vessel navigaon. Being deeper, the Omani

    half provides for the narrow naval corridors that

    make up what has been for centuries one of the

    worlds most important commercial routes.

    O O O THE OIL DRUM / LINK

    SOURCE: WIKIPEDIA

    http://www.theoildrum.com/node/8956#morehttp://www.iflr.com/Article/2991926/Corporate/Why-AIJ-scandal-will-be-the-first-of-many.html
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    18/24

    18.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    12 March 2012 18

    Te ISDA (the InternaonalSwaps and Derivaves Associaon) declared

    today that Greece is in ocial default. This is a

    derivaves-industry commiee of 15 members,

    represenng the largest banks and derivave

    buyers all the usual suspects. I started to write

    last week about their hesitancy, but it was very

    technical and I thought it likely they would issue

    the ruling they did this week. There are a few

    things we should note about this decision.

    First, there is a widespread misunderstanding

    that the ISDA is the nal answer to whether

    a naon is in default. The correct answer is, itdepends. Credit default swaps are contracts be-

    tween two private pares . The actual original

    contract is the governing document. While most

    contracts named the ISDA as the nal arbiter of

    default, there are many that did not. Some ex-

    pets told tei

    clients there

    ws poblem

    with choosing a

    self-inteested

    industry group

    to be the naljudge, and were very specic in their contracts

    as to what constuted a default. (Thanks to

    Janet Tavakoli, who spent an hour late one night

    paently explaining the arcana and minuae

    of credit default swaps. She literally wrote the

    book and not just one but three of them on

    swaps.)

    It does not take a nance major to understand

    that if you do not get your money paid back to

    you, there was a default of some kind. If the

    ISDA had not conrmed a default by

    Greece, they would have ceased to be relevant

    in any future contracts that were wrien. It will

    be interesng to see how contracts are struc-

    tured in future.

    Secondly, the number that keeps showing up

    in the press is that there are only $3 billion

    of credit default swaps on Greek debt. That is

    only half true. The reality is that there is a NET

    $3.2 billion of CDS on Greek debt. The total or

    GROSS amount of swaps wrien is esmated to

    be about $60-70 billion (Dan Greenhaus, Chief

    Global Strategist, BTIG). This is in the 4,323 con-tracts that are known about.

    Of the net exposure, the loss is likely to be less

    than the $3.2 billion, unless Greek debt goes

    to absolute zero. But that does not tell the

    whole story. For instance, just one Austrian

    state- owned bad bank, KA Finanz, faces a hit

    of up to 1 billion euros ($1.31 billion) for the

    hole Greeces debt restructuring punches in its

    balance sheet. That loss, which will be borne by

    Austrian taxpayers, is someone elses gain. The

    net number means nothing to them they loseit all, over a third of the expected total loss.

    Every bank and hedge fund, insurance company,

    and pension fund has its own situaon. Care to

    wager that the larger banks wont win on this

    trade? My bet is that there will be $30 billion in

    losses, out of which maybe someone will make

    $27 billion in gains.

    Will the counterparty that holds your oseng

    CDS be able to pay? Will all taxpayers be so ac-

    commodang as Austrias? Does anyone thinkthat taxpayers will bail out a hedge fund that

    cannot pay its debt, if it sold protecon and has

    to default?

    Would that it was only a $3 billion loss spread

    among the largest losers. That would be trivial

    in the grand scheme of things. Will Greece real-

    ly stress the system, as it was stressed in 2008?

    The answer is, not likely, since European taxpay-

    ers have found 100 billion to cover the debt

    and the ECB has printed over 1 trillion, which

    has postponed any debt crisis for the immedi-ate future. But the queson that we must ask in

    a few paragraphs is, how many more countries

    will have to restructure their debt?

    O O O JOHN MAULDIN / LINK

    ... It does not take a fnance majorto understand that i you do not getyour money paid back to you, there

    was a deault o some kind.

    http://www.johnmauldin.com/images/uploads/pdf/mwo031012.pdf
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    19/24

    19.CHARTS THAT MAKE YOU GO Hmmm...

    12 March 2012 19

    Based on our experi-ence, weve been saying for some

    me that volality will increase as

    the markets ght their way to the

    mania phase of this cycle and

    that once there, the gyraons will

    jump even higher. This call doesnt

    exactly require one to go out on a

    limb; it makes sense since more

    investors will be crowding in and

    volality was high in the 1979-80

    mania.

    First, lets put last Wednesdaysbig plunge in perspecve. Heres

    a picture of the daily changes in

    the gold price since 2003, based

    on London x prices. (This chart is

    very busy, but I want to show the

    bulk of the bull market in one vi-

    sual.)

    A 4.8% decline is one of golds bigger one-day movements over the past nine-plus years. But as you

    can see, there have been a number of days where gold rose or fell more than 5%. And it exceeded 6%

    on ve occasions.

    You might think this kind of volality is high and its true. Worse or beer, depending on how yousee things the volality in the underlying commodity is magnied in the related company stocks.

    This is why Doug Casey calls mining stocks, especially the juniors, the most volale stocks on earth.

    But the thing is, metals volality

    has been higher in the past, par-

    cularly during a mania.

    Heres what I mean.

    The following chart documents

    golds daily price changes from

    1976 through the end of 1980.

    Take a look at the jump in volal-ity in 1979-80...

    O O O JEFF CLARK / LINK

    CLICK TO ENLARGE SOURCE: CASEY RESEARCH

    SOURCE: CASEY RESEARCHCLICK TO ENLARGE

    http://www.caseyresearch.com/articles/face-volatility?ppref=GRA442ED0312Ahttp://www.caseyresearch.com/sites/default/files/DailyGoldPriceVolatility1976to1980_0.pnghttp://www.caseyresearch.com/sites/default/files/DailyGoldPriceVolatilitySince2003_0.png
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    20/24

    20.CHARTS THAT MAKE YOU GO Hmmm...

    12 March 2012 20

    Richard Ross on the NASDAQ & the US 10-yr Treasury [email protected]

    SOURCE: RICHARD ROSS

    SOURCE: RICHARD ROSS

    mailto:rross%40agco.com?subject=Things%20That%20Make%20You%20Go%20Hmmm.....%20mailto:rross%40agco.com?subject=Things%20That%20Make%20You%20Go%20Hmmm.....%20
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    21/24

    21.CHARTS THAT MAKE YOU GO Hmmm...

    12 March 2012 21

    We have a letspretend economy: lets pre-

    tend the unemployment rate

    actually reects the number

    of people with full-me jobs

    nd te numbe of people

    seeking jobs, lets pretend

    the Federal government bor-

    rowing 10% of the GDP every

    year is sustainable without

    any consequences, lets pre-

    tend the stock market actu-

    ally reects the economy

    rather than Federal Reservemonetary intervenon, and

    so on.

    We also have a lets pretend

    educat ion/s tudent- loan

    game running: lets pretend

    college is worth the invest-

    ment, and lets pretend stu-

    dent loans are about educa-

    on. There are three dirty

    lile secrets buried under

    the educaon/student-loancomplexs high-gloss sheen:

    1. Student loans have lile

    to do with educaon and

    everything to do with creat-

    ing a new prot center for

    subprime-type lenders guar-

    anteed by the Savior State.

    2. A college diplomas value

    in the real world of geng a

    job and earning a good sal-ary in a post-nancializaon

    economy has been grossly

    oversold.

    3. Many people are taking out student loans just to live; the loans are essenally a form of State

    funding a.k.a. welfare that must be paid back.

    Weve got a lot of charts that reect reality rather than hype, so lets get started.

    o o o CHARLES HUGH-SMITH / LINK

    SOURCE: NY FED/BEA

    SOURCE: ZEROHEDGE

    http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/2012/03/our-lets-pretend-economy-lets-pretend.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+google%2FRzFQ+%28oftwominds%29http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/2012/03/our-lets-pretend-economy-lets-pretend.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+google%2FRzFQ+%28oftwominds%29
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    22/24

    22.

    12 March 2012 22

    WORDS TH AT MAKE YOU GO Hmmm...

    My very good friend Simon Mikhailovich isone of the smartest guys in any room and, mark my words,

    the work he is doing at Eidesis Capital is set to make him

    one of the most-recognized names in the precious metals

    world.

    For those of you not fortunate enough to be familiar with

    Simon, this interview with another of my good friends, Al

    Korelin, will give you an insight into the clarity of his think-

    ing. Simon is someone you denitely want to listen to on

    this, and for that maer, any subject.

    It just so happens that Simon is also a prince of a man.

    The photo (le) is the result of a Google search for Si-mons name and will hopefully hasten him sending me a

    photo I can use going forward...

    Jim Grant is temaster.

    That is all there is to to say.

    Watch and be educated byone of the nest minds we

    have in nance..

    (Via zerohedge)

    Jim Puplava welcomes Russell Napier, Consultant at CLSAAsia-Pacic Markets. Russell discusses China dumping US treasuries and growing

    signs of a private-sector liquidity squeeze in the US. Russell notes that when credit

    dies, deaon follows, leading to greater nancial repression.

    CLICK TO WATCH

    CLICK TO LISTEN

    CLICK TO LISTEN

    http://www.financialsense.com/financial-sense-newshour/guest-expert/2012/03/09/russell-napier/when-credit-dies-european-liquidity-situation-getting-worsehttp://www.zerohedge.com/news/jim-grant-must-watch-capitalism-alternative-what-we-have-nowhttp://www.kereport.com/wp-content/uploads/0225-2-4.mp3
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    23/24

    SUBSCRIBE UNSUBSCRIBE COMMENTS

    and fnally

    12 March 2012 23

    Hmmm

    Regular readers othese pages will be well aware of my love for photographyand todays And Finally..... contains some magnicent lt/sh eect footage from a country

    geng a LOT of press out here in Asia.

    Ladies and gentlemen, I give you The Next Mongolia - Myanmar.

    CLICK TO WATCH

    THING S THAT MAKE YOU GO HMMM..... 2012

    http://ethreemail.com/subscribe?g=bdc736behttp://ethreemail.com/unsubscribe?g=bdc736bemailto:TTMYGH%40me.com?subject=Hmmm.....%20Feedbackhttp://www.theatlantic.com/video/index/253991/mailto:TTMYGH%40me.com?subject=Hmmm.....%20Feedbackhttp://ethreemail.com/unsubscribe?g=bdc736behttp://ethreemail.com/subscribe?g=bdc736be
  • 8/2/2019 Hmmm Mar 12 2012

    24/24

    24.THINGS THAT MAKE YOU GOHmmm...

    As a result of my role at Vulpes Investment Management, it falls upon me to disclose that, from me-to-me,

    the views I express and/or the commentary I write in the pages of Things That Make You Go Hmmm..... may

    reect the posioning of one or all of the Vulpes funds - though I will not be making any specic recommenda-

    ons in this publicaon.

    Grant

    www.vulpesinvest.com

    Grant Williams

    Grant Williams is a porolio and strategy

    advisor to Vulpes Investment Manage-

    ment in Singpoe - edge fund unning

    $200million of largely partners capital

    across mulple strategies.

    In 2012, all Vulpes funds will be opened to

    outside investors.

    Grant has 26 years of experience in nanceon the Asian, Australian, European and US

    markets and has held senior posions at several internaonal investment houses. He

    has been wring Things That Make You Go Hmmm..... since 2009

    For more informaon on Vulpes please visit www.vulpesinvest.com

    http://users/Grant/Library/Caches/Adobe%20InDesign/Version%207.0/en_GB/InDesign%20ClipboardScrap1.pdfhttp://www.vulpesinvest.com/http://www.vulpesinvest.com/http://users/Grant/Library/Caches/Adobe%20InDesign/Version%207.0/en_GB/InDesign%20ClipboardScrap1.pdf