HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES:...

26
HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 Meeting Date Wednesday, 8 August 2012, Carson Room @ the Agonis Commencement Time: 9.17am Person Presiding: Dr G McDonald Presiding Member City Support Officer: Ms A du Boulay Heritage Coordinator Attended by: Staff: Observers: Cr J Brown Cr O Searle Mr D Corker Mrs P Morris AM JP Honorary Freeman Ms S Gurney Ms A du Boulay Mr L Gibson Mr G Ling Councillor – Council Delegate Councillor – Council Delegate Community Representative Community Representative Community Representative Manager Library & Heritage Services Heritage Coordinator Manager Planning Implementation (left at 9.30am) Project Manager - Technical Services (arrived at 9.45am and left at 10.30am) Apologies Received: Mr D Miller Mr T Newman Mrs A Rogers Community Representative Community Representative Community Representative Non Attendance: OBJECTIVE: To provide a community perspective on aspects of history and heritage within the care or control of the City of Gosnells. Endorsed by Council: 13/4/2010 Res.156 Suspend Standing Orders Moved P Morris, seconded D Corker CARRIED 4. MATTERS FOR DISCUSSION 4.1 Development application - 13 Royal Street, Kenwick (see attachment 2) Discussion: Manager Planning Implementation outlined the proposed development; the construction of a two storey building, for use as an educational facility, around the existing heritage building which would be retained. General discussion on the parking requirements. Presiding Member noted that retention of the heritage listed building is a good outcome. PROPOSED ACTION 9: That the History and Heritage Advisory Group support the retention of the existing building as outlined in the development application. Moved Cr J Brown, seconded P Morris CARRIED Manager Planning Implementation left meeting 9:30am. 1. RECEIVE PREVIOUS MINUTES: OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Transcript of HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES:...

Page 1: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012

History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012

Meeting Date Wednesday, 8 August 2012, Carson Room @ the Agonis Commencement Time: 9.17am Person Presiding: Dr G McDonald Presiding Member

City Support Officer: Ms A du Boulay Heritage Coordinator Attended by: Staff: Observers:

Cr J Brown Cr O Searle Mr D Corker Mrs P Morris AM JP Honorary Freeman Ms S Gurney Ms A du Boulay Mr L Gibson Mr G Ling

Councillor – Council Delegate Councillor – Council Delegate Community Representative Community Representative Community Representative Manager Library & Heritage Services Heritage Coordinator Manager Planning Implementation (left at 9.30am) Project Manager - Technical Services (arrived at 9.45am and left at 10.30am)

Apologies Received: Mr D Miller Mr T Newman Mrs A Rogers

Community Representative Community Representative Community Representative

Non Attendance: OBJECTIVE: To provide a community perspective on aspects of history and heritage

within the care or control of the City of Gosnells. Endorsed by Council: 13/4/2010 Res.156

Suspend Standing Orders

Moved P Morris, seconded D Corker CARRIED 4. MATTERS FOR DISCUSSION 4.1 Development application - 13 Royal Street, Kenwick (see attachment 2) Discussion:

• Manager Planning Implementation outlined the proposed development; the construction of a two storey building, for use as an educational facility, around the existing heritage building which would be retained.

• General discussion on the parking requirements. • Presiding Member noted that retention of the heritage listed building is a good

outcome.

PROPOSED ACTION 9: That the History and Heritage Advisory Group support the retention of the existing building as outlined in the development application.

Moved Cr J Brown, seconded P Morris CARRIED

Manager Planning Implementation left meeting 9:30am. 1. RECEIVE PREVIOUS MINUTES:

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 2: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012

History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012

The amended Minutes for the meeting of the History and Heritage Advisory Group held 7 June 2012 is accepted.

Moved Cr J Brown, seconded D Corker CARRIED 2. STATUS REPORT ON PREVIOUS ACTIONS PROPOSED: List actions which have been proposed by the Advisory Group and the current status. Where proposals have been approved by Council and relevant actions have been completed, they may be removed after they have been noted by the Advisory Group. Action Ref: Action Status HHAG 7/06/12 Proposed Action 8

That the History and Heritage Advisory Group congratulate Heritage Services staff on the City's nomination in the 2012 Western Australian Heritage Awards.

Acknowledged.

• Item 4.1 Presiding Member noted that he was unable to write the proposal for the

urban museum and will provide this at the next meeting. Project Manager - Technical Services arrived 9:45am.

• Proposed Action 7 - Heritage Coordinator noted that photos of the former Cowen House had been taken in the same place as in the 1998 Municipal Heritage Inventory to compare the level of deterioration. While on site Local History Librarian located the approximate position of Helms' gravesite.

• During discussion, P Morris suggested that the City writes to the owners to ascertain the intentions for the property, including Cowen House, and that historical information on the property is sent to the owners. It was also suggested that the owners are asked whether they know of any history of the property. Presiding Member noted that once the property is developed, plaques should be installed to commemorate the local history, including the house and the site of Helms' gravesite.

• Item 5 - Heritage Coordinator noted the items in the City's Library collections on Aboriginal culture and history, which include 628 books, website links, cds, dvds, 23 oral history interviews and 3 local studies files.

3. INFORMATION ITEMS 3.1 Manager Library and Heritage Services – Heritage Strategy Update

• Nil. 4. MATTERS FOR DISCUSSION 4.2 Proposed demolition - former Fremantle Road bridge (see attachment 3) Discussion:

• Project Manager - Technical Services outlined the state of the bridge and tabled photos. During the discussion Members raised concerns about the usage of the bridge, its current state and alternative footpaths available for pedestrians and cyclists if the bridge is removed.

• Presiding Member outlined the historical significance of the bridge as an access route for Thornlie residents travelling to Gosnells.

• P Morris noted that it may be useful to look at OCM minutes between 1986 to 1992 for a previous Council decision to retain the bridge.

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 3: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012

History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012

PROPOSED ACTION 10: That the History and Heritage Advisory Group are provided with more information at the next meeting to be held on 4 October 2012 regarding the Heritage listed bridge's usage and its heritage with regard to its early history and Indigenous heritage and culture.

Moved P Morris, seconded D Corker CARRIED

Project Manager - Technical Services left meeting 10:30am. 4. MATTERS FOR DISCUSSION 4.3 Community Projects

Thornlie Living History Group • P Morris has created a spreadsheet of Thornlie residents. People in the photo of the

original Thornlie Square shop owners are being identified. D Corker is continuing with the history of baseball. Presiding Member noted that the history of Thornlie's suburbanisation and urbanisation can be divided into periods of development which shaped the community. P Morris showed the Group the Crestwood development brochure which will be added to the collection.

5 GENERAL DISCUSSION

Matters proposed by Advisory Group members for discussion.

• Cr J Brown noted that the place on the Group vacated by P Clarke can be advertised. • Cr J Brown noted that a former City of Gosnells employee, Gerald Byrne, recently

died and his wife sent a historic photo which shows early residents of Gosnells. • Cr J Brown noted that Mayor, Cr D Griffiths, had mentioned to Councillors that a

private museum in Williams was very interesting.

Meeting Closed: 10:34am 6. NEXT MEETING

Next Meeting Date 4 October 2012, 9:15am Next Meeting Venue Scott Room, Knowledge Centre

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 4: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

Attachment 1 – Information Item: Manager Library and Heritage Services – Heritage Strategy Update Collection Developments The Thornlie Living History Group material has been catalogued. Curator made contact with Joan King of WA & J King who had some background information on the Roslyn Fruit Grader. Joan King's brother worked with Tom Robinson at Stalker Pumps and she recalled that Tom built the graders on the weekends. Curator put background information and a photo diary of the Roslyn Fruit Grader recovery on display for visitors' information. Project Progress The Historic Photograph Digitisation Project continues to progress. Further photo queries with Gosnells Primary School photos were resolved using the original attendance records which are held in the State Records Office. Activities and Publicity Heritage Coordinator assembled a pack of research resources for primary school teachers, which included Heritage Papers, heritage brochures and the Maddington and Kenwick walk trail brochure. The packs provide an introduction to the City's resources on historic topics and were handed out at the Young People's Library Services in-school program. Museum education program is now booked for half of Term 3. Volunteers and staff have worked hard this term, providing activities for two classes per visit. There has also been an increase in the bookings from Year 2 teachers as the Australian Curriculum includes local history. During May St Munchin's Primary School, Sacred Heart Primary School, Bletchley Park Primary School, Forest Crescent Primary School, Forest Crescent Primary School visited the Museum, with an incursion at John Wollaston Anglican Community School. On 4 May Kalamunda and Districts Historical Society visited the Museum. On 15 May the Curator made a short presentation to the Australian Independent Schools Early Childhood Educators when they visited the Museum. Other Museum Education Volunteers and the Curator spent a morning at Buckingham House, Wanneroo to witness their education program in action. The City of Wanneroo provides similar content to the Museum education program, but it is organised differently and the site is authentic to the time period being represented. Curator attended a workshop hosted by Museums Australia on Copyright in the Museum Environment.

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 5: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 6: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 7: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 8: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 9: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP Attachment 3 – Development application - 13 Royal Street, Kenwick

History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 10: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 11: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 12: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

Photos of the former Fremantle Road Bridge

Photo taken 2010 Photos taken 2012

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 13: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

Photos tabled at the meeting

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 14: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 15: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 16: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 17: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 18: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 19: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 20: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 21: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 22: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 23: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 24: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 25: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A

Page 26: HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 … · HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP MINUTES: 15 August 2012 . History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012 . PROPOSED ACTION

HISTORY AND HERITAGE ADVISORY GROUP Attachment 3 – Proposed demolition - former Fremantle Road bridge

History and Heritage Advisory Group 15/08/2012

OCM 11 SEPTEMBER 2012 APPENDIX 13.2.1A