H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States...

13
Progress Energy Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 NOV 1 12012 ,ATTN: Document Control Desk U,S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 H. B. ROBINSON STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT, UNIT NO. 2 DOCKET NO. 50-261/RENEWED LICENSE NO. DPR-23 SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION RELATED TO RELIEF REQUEST (RR)-07 FROM IMMEDIATE ASME CODE REPAIR OF REFUELING WATER STORAGE TANK DRAIN VALVE (SI-837) FOR FIFTH TEN-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM PLAN By letter to the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), dated October 25, 2012, Carolina Power and Light Company, now doing business as Progress Energy, submitted a response to a request for additional information (RAI) received from NRC staff on October 16, 2012 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System Accession No. ML 12290A25 1) related to relief request (RR)-07 for the Fifth Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Program Plan for H. B, Robinson Steam Electric Plant (HBRSEP) Unit No. 2, RR-07 was submitted to the NRC by letter dated October 5, 2012 (ADAMS Accession No. ML12292A386). RR-07 requested relief from the 2007 Edition, through the 2008 Addenda, of the ASME Section XI Code requireier'lt as stipulated in Paragraph IWC-3122.2 on the basis that compliance with the specified requirements would result in a hardship or unusual difficulty without a compensating increase in the level of quality and safety. RR-07 was submitted after discovery of a through-wall flaw in the body of the Refueling Water Storage Tank (RWST) drain * valve (SI-837). In its October 25, 2012 response to the request for additional information, Progress Energy provided the requested information for RAI items 1(1), 2, and 3(3). In its responses to RAI items 1(2), 3(1), and 3(2) Progress Energy indicated that the requested information would be provided in a separate supplemental response pending finalization of the design of the clamp or completion of a calculation of the maximum leakage flaw size that does not challenge the RWST inventory make-up capability. Enclosed, please find a supplementalresponse for items 1(2), 3(1), and 3(2) of the request for. additional information received by Progress Energy on October 16. This letter contains no new Regulatory Commitments. Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Robinson Nuclear Plant 3581 West Entrance Road Hartsville, SC 29550

Transcript of H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States...

Page 1: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

Progress Energy

Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119

NOV 1 12012,ATTN: Document Control DeskU,S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionWashington, DC 20555-0001

H. B. ROBINSON STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT, UNIT NO. 2DOCKET NO. 50-261/RENEWED LICENSE NO. DPR-23

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATIONRELATED TO RELIEF REQUEST (RR)-07 FROM IMMEDIATE ASME CODE REPAIR OFREFUELING WATER STORAGE TANK DRAIN VALVE (SI-837)FOR FIFTH TEN-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM PLAN

By letter to the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), dated October 25, 2012, CarolinaPower and Light Company, now doing business as Progress Energy, submitted a response to arequest for additional information (RAI) received from NRC staff on October 16, 2012(Agencywide Documents Access and Management System Accession No. ML 12290A25 1)related to relief request (RR)-07 for the Fifth Ten-Year Inservice Inspection Program Plan for H.B, Robinson Steam Electric Plant (HBRSEP) Unit No. 2,

RR-07 was submitted to the NRC by letter dated October 5, 2012 (ADAMS Accession No.ML12292A386). RR-07 requested relief from the 2007 Edition, through the 2008 Addenda, ofthe ASME Section XI Code requireier'lt as stipulated in Paragraph IWC-3122.2 on the basis thatcompliance with the specified requirements would result in a hardship or unusual difficultywithout a compensating increase in the level of quality and safety. RR-07 was submitted afterdiscovery of a through-wall flaw in the body of the Refueling Water Storage Tank (RWST) drain

* valve (SI-837).

In its October 25, 2012 response to the request for additional information, Progress Energyprovided the requested information for RAI items 1(1), 2, and 3(3). In its responses to RAI items1(2), 3(1), and 3(2) Progress Energy indicated that the requested information would be providedin a separate supplemental response pending finalization of the design of the clamp or completionof a calculation of the maximum leakage flaw size that does not challenge the RWST inventorymake-up capability.

Enclosed, please find a supplementalresponse for items 1(2), 3(1), and 3(2) of the request for.additional information received by Progress Energy on October 16.

This letter contains no new Regulatory Commitments.

Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc.Robinson Nuclear Plant3581 West Entrance RoadHartsville, SC 29550

Page 2: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

United States Nuclear Regulatory CommissionSerial: RNP-RA/12-0119Page 2 of 2

If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact Mr. Richard Hightower,Supervisor - Licensing/Regulatory Programs at (843) 857-1329.

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed On:

Auove.14ýe- ~i tOM-

Sincerely,

Sharon A. WheelerManager - Support Services - Nuclear

SAW/sjg

Enclosure: Supplemental Response to Request for Additional Information Relief RequestNumber RR-07 Repair of Safety Injection Valve SI-837

cc: Mr. V. M. McCree, NRC, Region IIMs. A. T. Billoch-Colon, NRC Project Manager, NRRNRC Resident Inspector, HBRSEP Unit No. 2

Page 3: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,:

Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119Page 1 of 3

ENCLOSURE

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONALINFORMATION RELIEF REQUEST NUMBER RR-07

REPAIR OF SAFETY INJECTION VALVE SI-837H.B. ROBINSON STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT UNIT NO. 2

NRC REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION (RAI)

By letter dated October 5, 2012, (Agencywide Documents Access and ManagementSystem Accession No. ML12292A386) Carolina Power and Light (the licensee)requested relief from the requirements of the 2007 Edition through the 2008 Addenda ofthe American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure VesselCode, Section XI, IWC-3122.2. The licensee proposed an alternative to repair adegraded drain valve that is connected to the Refueling Water Storage Tank (RWST) asdiscussed in Relief Request Number RR-07. To complete its review, the NuclearRegulatory Commission (NRC) staff requests the following information:

1. Page 2 of the relief request states that the current leak rate does not challengethe RWST inventory make-up capabilities. (1) Provide the actual RWSTinventory make-up capabilities (e.g., in gallons per minute) and discuss thesource and delivery of the make-up coolant. (2) Provide the maximum leakageflaw size (approximation is acceptable) that would not challenge the make-upcapabilities.

2. Page 4 of the relief request discusses the allowable through wall axial andcircumferential flaw length. Submit the fracture mechanics calculation of theallowable flaw lengths.

3. (1) Provide the design drawing(s) and the stress analysis of the mechanicalclamp. The design drawing(s) should show the dimensions (including weight)and how the clamp is installed on the valve (the final installed configuration).Along with the stress analysis, provide the methodology, assumptions, andallowable stresses. Discuss if the stress analysis indicates the mechanical clampwill exert sufficient forces on the flaw to mitigate its growth and reduce leakage.(2) Discuss if sealant is or is not used with the mechanical clamp to stop the leak.(3) If after installation of the clamp assembly, the leak continues, discuss theacceptability of the weekly monitoring frequency and provide leak rate limits atwhich time corrective action would be taken. When establishing the leak ratelimits, please discuss how these limits will ensure that adequate capacity will bemaintained in the tank to ensure the design basis is maintained.

Page 4: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

United States Nuclear Regulatory CommissionEnclosure to Serial: RNP-RA!12-0119Page 2 of 3

DISCUSSION

Progress Energy provided a response to the above requested information by letter datedOctober 25, 2012 which provided the requested information for items 1(1), 2, and 3(3). Theresponse to items 1(2), 3(1), and 3(2) indicated that a separate supplemental response would besubmitted to provide requested information that was not available due to the pending completionof a calculation of the maximum leakage flaw size that does not challenge the RWST inventorymake-up capability, item 1(2) and finalization of the clamp design, items 3(1) and 3(2). Therequested information for RAI items 1(2), 3(1) and 3(2) are presented below.

Supplemental Response - RAI Item 1(2)

Progress Energy has calculated approximate maximum leakage flaw sizes that do not challengethe nominal RWST inventory make-up capability of 84 gallons per minute to be no less than2.5 inches long with a width 0.377 inches and no less than 12.9 inches long with a width of0.073 inches.

Supplemental Response - RAI Item 3(1)

Design drawings of the leak limiting mechanical clamping device Progress Energy plans toinstall are presented on pages 1 and 2 of the Attachment. The leak limiting mechanical clampingdevice is not designed to exert forces on the flaw in the valve body sufficient to mitigate itsgrowth and/or reduce leakage through the valve body.

The mechanical clamp consists of a Furmanite box that is to be installed to enclose the entirevalve. The Furmanite box is designed to provide a pressure boundary that prevents dischargefrom the leak through the valve body to the environment under expected pressures andtemperatures. A copy of the stress analysis for the Furmanite box is presented on pages 3through 7 of the Attachment.

The Furmanite box is designed such that all calculated stresses are less than allowable stressesfor each material and that the materials are suitable for the intended use.

Supplemental Response - RAI Item 3(2)

Sealant will not be used to seal the leak through the body of the RWST drain valve (SI-837).

The clamping device is a Furmanite injection box with sealant injected at the interface betweenthe outside diameter of the drain line and the inside diameter of the box to form an o-ring typeseal. Sealant is applied both upstream and downstream of the valve. Sealant is also injected atthe interface between the clamping surfaces of the Furmanite box to seal the box. The amount ofFurmanite material injected will be monitored and controlled to prevent introduction of sealantmaterial into the piping and/or valve.

Page 5: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

United States Nuclear Regulatory CommissionEnclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119Page 3 of 3

The installed clamping device (the Furmanite box) will provide a pressure boundary that

encloses the valve and will prevent leakage to the environment. Leakage through the valve body

may occur after installation of the clamping device (Furmanite box) into the free volume

between the valve body and inside surface of the Furmanite box. The weight of such leakage isincluded in the weight of the clamping device used in assessing the capability to meet applicable

structural requirements.

Page 6: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

United States Nuclear Regulatory CommissionAttachment to Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-01198 Pages (including cover page)

Pages 1-7 of Attachment B to EC0088526 7 pages

Page 7: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

1 2 3 42 3 4

NOTES IF IN DOUBT ASKMATERIAL SPECIFICATION: REMOVE ALL SHARP EDGES. Do Not Scale Off DrawingPLATE -SA-240 GR.-316L / 316 CLAMP IDENTIFICATION NUMBER TO BE

PIPE - SA-312 GR.-TP 316L /316 STAMPED IN 0.375" HIGH LETTERS. 3/8"INSPECTIONa REFER QAP 1316.3 45"

045.

PARTS LIST DRAWING NO. CUS1209118-DWC-01 REV. AITEM DESCRIPTION ITY. MATERIAL SPEC.

1 STUD: 5/8"-11UNC X 4 1/2" LONG 28 SA-193 GR.-B8M CL. 1

2 NUT: 5/8"-11UNC HEAVY HEX. 56 SA-194 GR.-8M

3 PACKING. 3/8" SQ. GRAPHITE ( NOTE 10.)

A

7"

B 716.3

5" PIPE 1"75" WALL THICK

----- ----- ----- ----

219/" -- I1,, 45"

2 3-/8- 4/ 5

3/8"7

m0Co

0)

(D

0C(n

0( 10

G-)

0cm

C

NOTES:1. SAFETY RELATED.2. COMPONENT DESIGNATION: S1837.3. PROCEDURE NUMBER: N-2012159.4. PACKING GROOVE ON THE BORES AND SPLIT LINE: .375" WIDE X

X .438" DEEP.5. INJECTION POINTS INTO THE PACKING GROOVE: DRILL THRU 03/16".

DRILL AND TAP FOR 3/8"-16UNC X 3/8" DEEP. ONE BETWEEN STUDSAND 4/BORE/HALF.

6. PEENING GROOVE AROUND THE BORES: 3/16" X 3/16" X 60".7. ALL DIMENSIONS ARE TYPICAL UNLESS OTHERWISE SPECIFIED.8. MEASUREMENTS WITH AN "*" ARE CRITICAL DIMENSIONS.9. MACHINE BORES AND SPLIT LINE SURFACES TO 125 RMS.10. PLANT TO PROVIDE SAFETY RELATED PACKING.

TECHNICIAN SCOTTIE ARROWOOD MFG/SHOP LAPORTE, TX.

WPS NO. WPSO004 JOB NO. 101-LS-104334

WEIGHT EST. 480 LBS WO NO. 251-ML-301456

COMPOUND TYPE. FSC-N-1B,6B COMPOUND EST. 42 STICKS

r) t(GN PRESSURE:. I nr Oc~ IMAX. DESIGN TEMP: 150'FMIN. DESIGN TEMP:

E3- SCALEN.T.S

ICopyeght 0 2006. This drowing end oi1 right. therein (imcluding copyrightten rht ond 'like rights) one the property of F .... ite Worldwide I UEE ,no. ond/-r its subsidiory coneponrie. ond must not be used. dostributedto others or reproduced without the written permission or consent of:urrenite Wortdwtse Inc. MAltkIML~t~lAJt hFT LtP"UI•JtM•I•

IFurmonite Worldwide Inc. MAXIMISING ASSEr UPT1WD

CONTENTS: REFUELING WATERALL 0WE11SON I -

GEN.SRAEFGEN . MAHIMNNS lflL ~.1'SGEN FABRICATION TOL-D-8'.i00

DRAWING No.CUS1209118-DWG-O1 REV.'A ISTATUS RELEASED.ZO i

t

En

.. h -

CUSTOMER NO: PR0026 Wa'TITLE LEAK SEALING ENCLOSURE FOR 6" VALVE-- ---- - -

CUSTOMER:

PROGRESS ENERGYH.B. ROBINSON NUCLEAR ST.

>6.'(12'. *0.12y>12.-, *o.i1so'FRACTION&A BUMi +1/8- -0.0

SHEETTITTLE MANUFACTURING DETAILS SHEET 1 OF 2

9/24/2012 N/A

IdI-E

DRAWNEHIJAZI

9/24/2012 LAST MODIFIED 9/24/2012 CHECKED 09/24/2012 APPROVEDEHIJAZI IJIM STORMER APPROVER

N/AL

Page 8: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

1 2 3 42 3 4

A

B

IN DOUBT ASKDo Not Scale Off Drawing

1/8"45.

7

WELD REF. C,DoE.WELD PROCEDURE QUALIFICATION (PQR) IMPACT TESTS ARE REQUIRED

--BUT SEE GENERAL WELDING NOTE 1CHARPY V-NOTCH IMPACT TEST CRITERIA (3/8 X 3/8 IN SPECIMEN):0.0151N MINIMUM LATERAL EXPANSION AT A TEMPERATURE NOT GREATER THAN 32 *F

WELD REF. A,BGENERAL WELDING NOTE 2 APPLIES

GENERAL WELDING NOTES:

WHERE NOTE 1 APPLIES, THE INDICATED WELD PROCEDURE QUALIFICATION (PQR) IMPACTTEST REQUIREMENTS MAY BE WAIVED IF THE WELD CONSUMABLE CONFORMS TOSFA/AWS SPECIFICATION -5.4, -5.9, -5.11, -5.14, OR - 5.22

C

WHERE NOTE 2 APPLIES, THE WELD CONSUMABLE MUST CONFORM TO SFA/AWSSPECIFICATION -5.4, -5.9, -5.11, -5.14, OR - 5.22

D

S C oLCPyright 0 2006 . This drawing and oil rights therein(nldn copyogS A E design right and oil like rights) are the property of Fu ait o rdi

N aTnS~~d/or its subsidiary conmporie,n and musat not ho used distrbute poroi UR M A N ITS 0THIRD ANGLE F Frnnnarmn Worldwide Inc. MAXIMISING ASSET UPTIME

ALLDIMW NSIN CKM DRAWING No. REV Sý ibML o~ SA FH "CUS1209118-DWG-01 "A RELEASED

GM MAWO-'ING TOL: *'O.01,-±OGEM FABRTION TOLt- TITLE-. m' o " LEAK SEALING ENCLOSURE FOR 6" VALVE

>0. SHEET SHEET OF

FRACTlON& BUM +11/ 190 TITLE MANUFACTURING DETAILS 2 2

l'J0o_,

hw

C-4

ý-.. -)C4(3) ,LJ DRAWNEHIJAZI

9/24/2012 LAST MODIFIED 9/24/2012 CHECKED 09/24/2012 APPROVEDEHIJAZI IJIM STORMER APPROVER

N/A-A

Page 9: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

EC 88526 RO Attachment B - CUS12-09-118-PACKAGE 3 of 19

No. FWI-ENG-LS-XLT-003 issue: 2.6.1U Fa M A' I E I' Work Book Template Enclosure Clamp Design

0 2005-2011 Furmanlte Worldwide Inc., 2435 North Central Expressway, Suite 700, Richardson, TEXAS 75080, USA.

This Work Book Is the property of Furmanite Worldwide Inc. It may not be copied, used or altered without the written permission of the company.

Oesign Bests FWt-ENG-LS-DS-O01 Rev.B Drocument Number CUSl20911e-XLS-"1 Revistson A 1Page

Document Type Excel Spreadsheet Document Title LEAK SEALING ENCLOSUE FOR e' VALVE

Engineering Job No. Customer PROGRESS ENERGY

Clamp Number CUS12-09-118 Site H.S. ROBINSON NUCLEAR ST.

Created 09M441210 Moditied 09A4112 Approved 090401? Document StatusEHIJAZI EHIJAZI JIM STORMER RELEASEDGeneral Calculation SAFETY RELATED -COMPONENT DESIGNATION: $1837 -PROCEDURE NUMBER: N-2012159.Notes:

Design and Operating Conditions:

Design Pressure 100 psI Void Injection Pressure 725 psi

Operating Pressure Max. 25 psi Void Pressure 109.33 psi

Design Temperature Max. 150 'F Test PressureOper•t•ig Temperature Max. 100 * DOesýgn Temperature Min.

Internal Corrosion Ailowance: Contents: REFUELING WATER

Structural Restraints Policy: Structural Restraint is not Required

Enclosure Clamp Materials:

MatedalSpec., Grade, Class I Cond. I Temper/ Special Requirements, Ruling Temp. LimiI, Design Stress, Application Delivery ConditionSection *F psi

SA.240 Grade 310L, Plate 850 1225SA-312 Grade TP310L, Stole. & wld. pipe 050 1 70.

Enclosure Clamp Bolting Materials:

Bllt Material Spec., Grade, Class I Cond. I Temper I Special Requirements, Temp. Limit, Design Stress, ,Ruling SeonApplication

SA-193 Grade SM Claw 1, Stud Boll t0S 18250

Enclosure Clamp Construction Details;

Clamp Construction Type Welded Tube Ss Completed Clamp Fabrication to be Subject to Post Weld Heat Treatment?

Joint/Component Ref: C onetomponent Material Used (Prt A) Material Used (Part )A.- Rek Lug to She# •O.0• 4t PdPn D oubl. RNQ Lug: SJ40 Gdrde3f6L, P1tr MO She A -3 f2 Gade TP316L, SWl. A .1d. pip.

a; R.L0, 0.Si.on Lug fo E/nd CAP (Perirv Pemov•Lon) Lug, "No24 Ga~d.316L, Plao End Cp: SA- 240 Gradt 31Q,• Plat#

C., RoUf E nd Ca to Shell (FuH Pmnl~fton aun~fpius FloodJ End CW 4t A.240 Grd. 316L, PLO Sh.11: &A.30• Gld, TP316L,&. Am• wid pip.

D.- Ret.34 franch to $1ftU (SIt.Or No R•Jnfor~mww Pr-nM Shel1,"12tf G~d. TP~f6L, .. $m6• pip. Man Shell: SA417 Grade TP36 rftt & w)d pipe

:E. Ret.24, File He~d to ShVl (Wuf + R11it Weld) =letHead SA-240 G-=.kSt LPW.t Shell: SA-31 2 Grde 1PfLSfAL. A r d opip

Cylindrical and Obround Shells and Shelf Sections:

Cylindrical Shell Reference: A B C D E F

Shell External Diameter D, in 16

Shell Internal Diameter D, In 15.25

Component Shol

Material Spec. 6A,312

Part B Material Type I Grade TP316LSize I Thickness In Unliited

Design Stress S. psi 16700

Design Stress S psi 16700

Welded Joint Effldenecy Factor E I

Min. Required Shell Thlckness I.,-, In 0,078ACtual Shell Thick. less Corrosion Ailtw.) 1-c In 0,375

is Actuat Corroded Thickness S Required Thickness? Yea. OK

Opeanings In Cylindrical Shells:

Shell Opening Reference A B C D

Main $hell MotoriatSize I Thickness InDesign Stress S, psi 16700

Material Spec. 5A-312

Type I GradeBranch Shell MaterilI Size i Thickness

Design Stress

TP31SL

Unltnitred

16700

7.5250.0732

0.375

0.0732

0.375

______ .1 1. .1

[netIUG-45 Branch (Nozzle Neck) Thickness Check:

[U-4().Reure TiknssuCorrosion Allowance ton 0,0732Iain Reale riq., bul nou leass hu In lol,, In 0.0732

JUG-45(b)(4), Min. Thick. o1 Sid. Wall Pipe - C.A. In

Page 10: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

EC 88526 RO Attachment B - CUS12-09-118-PACKAGE 4 of 19

FLJFt EVI~.EI rr~Clamp Number CUS12-09-f11 3. ROBINSON NUCLEAR ST.

Openings In Cylindricl Shelas (Continued):

Limits of Relnforcreenrt.

Umits of Relnrrent parallel to Shell Wall L, In 9Urn. of Reint. normal to Shell outwards L, In 0.375UW-16(c) and (d) Weld Dinension Check;

Leg Length of Outer Branch Fillet Weld In 0.375Are Weld Dimensions Acceptable? Yes -OK

UG-37 Required Reinforcement Area:

Joint Efficiency Factor for Main Shell E

Angle Between Branch and Main Shell P goRequired Reinforcement Area A Inf 1f116Area Available in Shell A, In 0.83Anea Available in Branch (Outwards) A, In- 0.5659

Area Available in Outer Branch Fillet Wid A,, In' 0.1406Total Available Reintefcement Area Inr 1.537Is Total Available Reinforcement Area z Required Area? Yes -OK

Appendix 1-7 Requirerents tor Large Openings:

UG-36(b) Maximum Opening Size In 7.625

Additional Large Opening Requlrements Apply? Yes2J3 or Required Reinforcement Area A' inW 0744

Within 1-7ýa)()) Limit:

Area Available In Shell A', inn 0.83Area Available within Appendix 1-7(a) Limits In- 1.537

2/3 of Required Reinforcement within Appendix 1-7(a) Limils? Yes-OK

UG-41 Loads to be Carried by The WeAY$:Total Weld Load a U(Do wrelds meet the U

End Cape:

End Cap Reference A B C E FSMonreal Spec. gA-240Type C Greds 316L

End Cap Mate[al Size / Thickness In Urdltad

Design Stress S, pSI 15450

Shell Internal Dlarmeter (- 2 x Positive Contrallne Offset) in 15.25End Cap Bore Diameter In &615End Cap Radius Ratio 0438

Minimum Required End Cap Thickness in 0.902

Actual End Cap ThicknessEnd Cap Thickness less Corrosion Allowa

Is Actual Corroded Thickness ? Required

Flat Heads:

Flat Head Reference

as -CO

A

Imatedal Spec. 84240

Flat Head Material i,.^ r^d316L

ass

d InD I

Minimum Required Flat Head Thickness I-u InActual Flat Head ThicknessFlat Head Thick. less Corrosion Allowance -uc In IIs Actual Corroded Thickness k Required Thickness? Yes:

Page 11: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

EC 88526 RO Attachment B - CUS12-09-118-PACKAGE 5 of 19

uocument Numoer CUS12091U 0-XL--1 ,Revision A iPege 3=ngmeenng

Joe r•o,

,Engineering uotbNO. Customer 'L~u.JP:U$12-09-118 Isite H.B. F

a,

Bolt Area Caluleallons:

Sector Type (Primary / Secondary)Projected Area of Void In Half-Joint Plane

type

Seal Segment 1 Contact Pressure

Projected Area on Half-Joint

PrimaryA nIr

psi

In,'

134.07

12.563Sector Parting Force F, Ibf 35934.4531

Soil Thread and Form ot. UNG

Minor Diameter Area A a In- 0,2071

inBolt Materlol Specification, Grade, (Class / Cond. I SA-193 BM

Solt Size 1 Temper/ Special Requirements) and Ruling Section (clma 1)

Design Strew PSI 18250Number of Bolts 14

Tofrque (Coeft. of Friction 0.12) ft,lbf (N.m) 37(50)Minimum Soft Design Stress S. psi 18250

Required Boll Minor Root Area A In- 1.969Recommended Bolt Minor Area In'Total Sector Bolt Area A In- 2.899

Is Actual Root Area Z Required I Recommeeded Root Area? Yes - OK

oitted Lug Calcolationo (at Design Condiion);

Component LugMaterial Spec. SA-240

Part A Material Type I Grade 316.Kizo / Thickness in Unlrrnted

Design Strens SA psi 15450

Component ShellMatedal Spec. SA.312

Part B Matedal Type I Grade TP316LSlze I Thnickness In Unflnrlted

Design Sirens Sa psi 16700Design Stress for Lug Thickness S psi 1i4e0

Welded Joint Efficiency Factor E, 0.55

Bot Pre-Stress to be Applied? o,, psi 20000

Sector Bolt Pre.Load F, Ibf 57988Lug Length Lu In 30.828Effective Lug Length L', In 21

Bolt Offset from Shell Mid Plane / 0I o. in 1.188Recommended Lug Edge Offset (from Bolt CIL) In 1,94

Log Edge offSet from Bolt Centmllne ura in 0,825Lugr Edge Of seal from Bolt Centrellne Ins 10 2

Minimum Required Lug Thickness _H_. in 0.731 1Minimum Recommended Lug Thickness in 0.8573Lug Thickness IHL In I

Is Actual Lug Thickness Z Required I Recommended Thickness? Yes -OK

Lug Afachmonent Weld Calcolttlons (at Design Corditlon):

Lug is Attached to Shell (Calculation Reference for Smallest): ALength of Weld In 26

Fillet Weld I (Top) Leg Length In 0,375BuSt Weld 1 (top) Preparatlon Depth In 0.375Fillet Weld 2 (Bottom) Leg Length In 0.375

Seal Groove Depth (if located In weld) In 0.4375

Neld Equiv. Sire. ndlnc

Are the Lug Attachment Weld Stress within Allowable Limits? Yes - OK

Page 12: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

EC 88526 RO Attachment B - CUS12-09-118-PACKAGE 6 of 19

Eng Dnumeeing J N .mber1= IVIM ^1M I ~ nineern lob No.

-0-~~ag -.- eura. )Clamp Number

CUSa120118-XLS-01 lReviseon A Page 4

ostomer PROGRESSENERGYCUgS12-0U-118 Ito H.B. RtOBINSON NUCULERi ST.

Low Temperature Impact Test, Post Weld Heat Treatment and NDT Requirements:

Joint I Component Ref. A 5 C D EJoint / Component Description Lw Iw (lSel {n. s1., L4 l E.WCUp EýtCaauo•aLO L a gn h.IlOS..On. Pl F 0lhl ,d loh0(&lu.

pnP.t i. 0. """•F (P.rw IP....k) P-WlI• *.l PJ No Re•wmc•and) FRe, W.4

DImenslon e2, In

LgTle• L •m nCprk

Bc h•Te ~ ed[k

Fee

Dimension 03. In

eg 4E UoFuD~~mens~~on ada______

Bnoocn c Sell I Noazde O~stide DIameter Dl, in

f

0,5Dimension e2, In

SWC Tftw EmUP,,6 •thdI

ESze I Thickness, in Uolnllred Untemhed ln~lau • Udrted Uolrndl nmlied _______ ______ ______

A ,dditional Impost Tests Reotuired? so No No No ha

We ld zeqdo Te3est, In E rnlt t Eepansiod.

U ngtb. Foed 0.01510

Uni0e litiieg

Umtten __Lg

S ,dtoa l m pa Re Tetolns onPRu uetured? oWade No No NOl ON o NoK ______ ___ReoaloWed Deg t re ate nt RT qid or UTpEcifnitd? Nxe Noe Cor Non Non

P~-N3-alfSaEMns 0 Esamtrle on ClAss4 t6g

61,".1,¢ 2 e te te te e

Wd ld, Toit Ettnolercy pasor

0.05 5 si3 0.075

0.075 0.15n

Dimesio ice RIndtin

PP. PatalPnertonWldO

O N

0.5.l~

.I1

~ o•c• ,,,59 .•1.6 1.O .52

e •

leemtEnlo -eNCam -VLameM: 03Eais~n

ls

iiN

Cyllndalal Shells;

A BC '' D S E

Incemel Diameter

I0 15,25C e ntrali ne O tt set (Ceotreilne to C u ntreilee)

in

Copernal Centr4line Length

In 43N umber Ott

f

Internul VoSume

inA 7004

Gross/ nternol Clamp Volume

inN 7004E:NCLOSED

PIPING COMPONENTS VOLUME;

Cylindrieal Compoenets;

A B C 0

External Diameter

in " 7.&A0Centre[lne Leegth

In 10Number Ott

Enclosed Volume

inG 6e8.2Total Enrdoned V olume

lea 000.2

Clamp Vast Volume (Grass inte sl ClaInpi Volume.o Total oseead Compoeent ina 7100Volume)

In' 7100

Additional Ihepast Tet Reurd No ND No NoN

Enclosure Clamp Mass:

Postna W eldte Hos Tr a m n1eu rd rSp cfe ?N ON

oNinternall~isuabe t FA64,9 4e.1.n

Length.- 22 403 YeYs

Yse

Namber sOfpl)f t

Component Moes

Ib 232,2

M ess 0n Bolts0.015

S er ic R es ridion on P a ta1 .nt

a io8eds KO

O3KOLuglaioa Thickness

to 1F-.,141,51,r-52 e e

R equire D egre ofrs Off T Ex m n lo N o eN neN n

ComponentEMS00 Exaissio Clas

I II.I I

MWs 7od J o in t E f i ie c F a t r0 5 51 1.

1 - .

Page 13: H.B. Robinson, Unit 2, Supplemental Response to Request for … · 2012-12-13 · United States Nuclear Regulatory Commissidn ,: Enclosure to Serial: RNP-RA/12-0119 Page 1 of 3 ENCLOSURE

EC 88526 RO Attachment B - CUS12-09-118-PACKAGE 7 of 19

I* I u M I I I; 11ý,Tnb!_

I clamp Number

CUS129118-YlXLS-01 Revision A Page 5

Customer PROGRESS ENERGY

CUS12-J9-118 Site H.S. ROBINSON NUCLEAR ST.Enclosure Clamp Mass (Continued):

End Caps: A B CE FEnd Cap IShell External Diameter In IBEnd Cap Bore in 6.675

End Cap Thickness In INumber (of Pairs) Off 2

Component Mass lb 94.8

Flat Heads., A B CFlat Head I Shell xtmeral Diameter In Is

Flat Head Thickness In 1NumberOff 1Component Mass lb 57.4

Total Mass of Clamp as Calculated lb 453Percentage Mass Allowance (uncalculated components, welds, etc.) 6.0%

Estimated Total Mass of Clamp as Supplied ib 410

Estimated Total Mass of Clamp as Installed lb 480END OF REPORT