Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)
-
Upload
absolute-return -
Category
Documents
-
view
14.245 -
download
4
description
Transcript of Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)
![Page 1: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
!
!
November!30,!2011!
!
“Men!prefer!a!false!promise!to!a!flat!refusal.”!
!Quintus"Cicero"
Imminent!Defaults!
We!write!to!you!today!to!provide!our!thoughts!on!the!most!likely!path!of!global!debt!and!the!potential!
consequences!of!a!cluster!of!sovereign!defaults.! !We!see!an! interesting!relationship!between!the!dual!
aspects! of! the! situation! –! the! quantitative! and! the! qualitative.! ! First,! the! quantitative! data! sets! are!
simple! facts!which!are!easily!analyzable.! !Second,!and!much!more!open!to!debate,!are!the!qualitative!
thoughts!and!reactions!of!market!participants!to!that!data.!
Often!when!there!is!a!large!and!rapid!change!in!a!market!dynamic!to!a!new!paradigm!there!is!a!chorus!
of! analysts! proclaiming! that! “nothing! has! changed”,! yet! undeniably! the!market! indicates! it! has.!We!
believe!that!in!many!cases!the!quantitative!data!leads!the!qualitative!change!in!opinion!to!such!a!degree!
that!it!may!look!like!nothing!has!changed!in!the!data!to!drive!the!change!in!opinion.!In!most!cases!this!is!
merely!the!market!catching!up!with!the!fundamentals.!!!
Once!the!quantitative!data!points!get!as!bad!as!they!are!today! in!many!nations,!the!qualitative!beliefs!
and!actions!of!the!participants!can!rapidly!change!a!situation!from!benign!or!stable!to!full!crisis!(think!
Italy).!!It!is!the!beliefs!of!the!participants!that!are!most!important!in!times!like!today.!!The!data!sets!are!
large!and!slow!moving,!but! the!qualitative! interpretation!of! them! is! far!more!mercurial.! !We!operate!
under! the! assumption! that! most! participants! are! educated! and! informed,! and,! therefore! the!
quantitative!analysis!should!already!be!done.! !However,! it! is!clear! that!some!previously!unquestioned!
qualitative!beliefs!are!hard!to!shake.!!One!of!the!axioms!that!we!have!been!developing!at!Hayman!is!a!
more!precise!definition!of!debt! sustainability.! !Debt! sustainability! is!often!defined! as! the! ability!of! a!
country!to!meet!and!service! its!debt!obligations!without!requiring!debt!relief!or!accumulating!arrears.!!
The!non"linearity!of! the! relationship!between! expenses! (primarily! the!delta! in! interest! expense)! and!
revenues! is!a!concept!we! spend!a! lot!of! time!on.! !When!a!nation’s!debts!become!many!multiples!of!
central!government!revenues,!a!non"linear!relationship!develops!that!becomes!insurmountable!because!
expenses!grow!faster!than!revenues!even!in!inflationary!or!growth!environments.!We!believe!the!debts!
of! the! following! nations,! among! others,! are! not! sustainable! in! the! current! economic! environment:!!
Greece,! Italy,! Japan,! Ireland,! Iceland,! Japan,! Spain,! Belgium,! Japan,! Portugal,! France,! and,! have! we!
mentioned!Japan?!!The!United!States!is!quickly!approaching!the!zone!of!insolvency!but!can!avoid!it!with!
![Page 2: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
massive! spending! cuts! and! severe! reductions! in! entitlements! into! the! future! (but! don't! hold! your!
breath).!!!
While!there!are!many! inputs!that!are!functionally!relevant,!we! look!for!a!couple!of!warning!signs.! !We!
move! a! nation! out! of! the! risk! free! category! as! soon! as! they! spend!more! than! 10%! of! their! central!
government!revenues!on! interest!alone.!!We!also!worry!about!debt!loads!that!represent!more!than!5x!
the!revenue!of!the!responsible!government.!When!these!and!other!characteristics!are!met!or!exceeded,!
it!can!quickly!move!the!country!into!checkmate.!
!
Global!Debt!Saturation!
Since!2002,!total!global!credit!market!debt!has!grown!at!more!than!an!11%!compound!annual!growth!
rate!(“CAGR”)!from!$80!trillion!to!approximately!$200!trillion.!!Over!the!same!time,!global!real!GDP!has!
only!grown!at!approximately!a!4%!CAGR.!!!
!
Total!Global!Debt!(Left!Axis)!and!Global!Debt/GDP!(Right!Axis)!
($"in"Trillions)!
!
As! it! stands! today,! total! credit! market! debt! is! 310%! of! GDP.! ! We! are! saddled! with! the! largest!
accumulation!of!peacetime!debts!without!any!playbook! for!what!happens!next.! !Throughout!history,!
whenever! total! credit!market!debt!breached!200%!of!GDP,! it!was! commonly!due! to!deficit! spending!
fueled!by!borrowing!as!nations!prepared!for!and!then!fought!wars.! !To!the!victor!went!the!spoils!(and!
240%
250%
260%
270%
280%
290%
300%
310%
320%
330%
340%
350%
$"
$20!
$40!
$60!
$80!
$100!
$120!
$140!
$160!
$180!
$200!
$220!
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Global!D
ebt!/!GDP
Total!Global!Debt!(Trillions!of!Dollars)
Public!Debt!Securities Private!Debt!Securities Bank!Assets Debt/GDP!(Right!Axis)
![Page 3: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
debt!pay"downs)!and!to!the!loser!went!defeat!and!default.!!Given!the!enormity!of!the!debt!burdens!of!
the!PIIIGSBF!(Portugal,!Italy,!Ireland,!Iceland,!Greece,!Spain,!Belgium!and!France)!coupled!with!those!of!
Japan! (and! at! some! point! the!US),! lending! schemes! designed! to! lend!more! into! an! intractable! debt!
problem!are!destined!to!fail!miserably.!!There!is!no!savior!large!enough!with!a!magical!pool!of!capital!to!
stave! off! this! unfortunate! conclusion! to! the! global! debt! super! cycle.! !We! think! hard! defaults! are!
imminent.!
For! those! of! you! that! aren’t! following! European! rates! closely,! please! see! the! charts! below.! ! After!
reviewing!the!history!of!rates!in!EMU!member!countries,!one!key!takeaway!is!that!the!markets!have!told!
participants!that!the!EMU!has!ALREADY!BROKEN!UP.!!
!
Greek!2"Year!Government!Bond!Yield!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
![Page 4: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
Portuguese!2"Year!Government!Bond!Yield!
!
!
!
Italy"Germany!10"Year!Government!Bond!Spread!
!
!
![Page 5: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
Many!absolute!levels!as!well!as!spread!levels!are!higher!and!wider!than!pre"Maastricht!extremes.!!This!
indicates!something!that!the!politicians,!bankers,!and!regulators!don’t!want!to!acknowledge:!!They!have!
already!lost!control,!and!they!will!not!be!able!to!put!this!genie!back!into!the!bottle.!!It!is!already!over!for!
the!EMU,!they!just!do!not!want!to!admit!it.!!Below!we!compare!Moody’s!official!sovereign!ratings!to!the!
implied! default! ratings! derived! from! market! trading! levels! of! sovereign! debts! –! the! “marketplace!
ratings”.!!
!
!
Needless!to!say,!a!seven"notch!differential!prompted!a!three"notch!downgrade!for!Italy.!!When!there!is!
a! 10"notch! differential! (Belgium)! or! even! a! 9"notch! differential! (France),! expect! a! multi"notch!
downgrade!in!the!very!near!future.!
!
The!Mirage!of!the!IMF!and!EFSF!(and!whatever!the!next!vehicle!is!called)!
Recently,!!rumors!circulated!in!the!press!of!a!EUR!600!billion!loan!($794!billion)!being!readied!by!the!IMF!
for!Italy,!which!would!(theoretically)!provide!the!country!with!another!12"18!months!of!runway!to!sort!
out! its! intractable!debt!problems.! !I!suppose! it!was!only!a!matter!of!time!–!another!“bazooka”!with!an!
eye"popping! headline! number! put! forth! to! calm! the!market! participants.! ! It! is! unconscionable! that!
Country Moody's!Rating CDS!Implied!Rating Notch!Difference
Austria Aaa/Stable Baa3 Nine
Belgium Aa1/Rvw!Dng Ba2 Ten
Cyprus Baa3/Rvw!Dng B3 Six
Estonia A1!/Stable Baa2 Four
Finland Aaa/Stable Aa3 Three
France Aaa/Stable Baa3 Nine
Germany Aaa/Stable A2 Five
Greece Ca/Developing C One
Ireland Ba1/Negative B2 Four
Italy A2/Negative Ba2 Seven
Malta A2/Negative Ba1 Five
Netherlands Aaa/Stable A3 Six
Portugal Ba2/Negative B3 Four
Slovakia A1!/Stable Ba1 Six
Slovenia Aa3/Rvw!Dng Ba2 Eight
Spain A1!/Negative Ba2 Seven
![Page 6: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
anyone! thinks! that! lending!more! into! this! debt! problem! “solves”! anything,! but! in! the! true! spirit! of!
Keynes!and!White,!Lagarde!and!Draghi!are!attempting!to!placate!the!market!with!optics.!!The!problem!is!
that!the!optics!have!now!broken!down.!!!
The!optics!of!an!EFSF! levered!CDO! idea!are! collapsing!as!one!of! the! largest!guarantors!of!early!EFSF!
bonds!–!Italy!–!!is!now!looking!to!be!a!recipient!of!aid.!!Recently,!the!EFSF!had!to!purchase!its!own!bonds!
as!there!were!no!takers!for!20%!of!a!EUR!3!billion!issue.!!Imagine!how!they!will!do!when!they!attempt!to!
issue!EUR!200!billion!more!(answer:!poorly,! if! it!happens!at!all).! !One!other!point!to!ponder! is!the!fact!
that!sovereign!bond!managers!take!career!risk!by!simply!owning!these!toxic!securities!(therefore!they!
won’t!do!it).!!Again,!there!is!a!need!to!fully!comprehend!the!enormity!of!the!circular!reference!involved!
with!the!IMF!and!EFSF!schemes!being!contemplated.!!The!EFSF!is!a!combination!of!a!handful!of!debtor!
nations!that!are!out!of!money.! !The!mechanism! is!only!as!strong!as! its!weakest! link,!and!the! links!are!
crumbling.!!How!will!EFSF!bonds!trade!in!the!marketplace!when,!in!the!first!issue,!there!are!a!group!of!
guarantors! and! a! single! recipient! while! in! the! second! issue! there! will! be! differing! guarantors! and!
recipients! (where! a! prior! guarantor! is! now! a! recipient)?! ! For! all! intents! and! purposes,! the! EFSF!
mechanism!is!dead!on!arrival.!!It!is!amazing!to!us!that!this!idea!continues!to!be!pursued!by!the!Eurocrats!
in!their!17th!emergency!summit!on!December!9th.!!
Now,! let's! discuss! the! IMF.! ! Perhaps! this!would! be! a!workable! temporary!mirage! in! the! near"term!
assuming!the!IMF!had!the!funds!at!its!disposal!to!make!such!a!promise.!!As!it!turns!out,!that!assumption!
is!way!off!the!mark.!!Currently,!IMF!resources!fall!significantly!short!of!the!rumored!Italian!loan!amount,!
and! further! increases! to! IMF! funds! exacerbate! the! circular"reference! problem! of! heavily! indebted!
nations! providing!money! –! that! they! do! not! have! –! to! bail! each! other! out.! ! Even! former! IMF! chief!
economists!agree!that! the! IMF!was!never!designed!to!make!even!a!medium"sized! loan.! !The! IMF!was!
designed! to!assist! small! third"world! countries!with!balance"of"payments!problems.! !The! IMF!was!not!
designed!to!act!as!a!lender!of!last!resort!for!profligate!debtor!nations!in!Europe!or!Japan.!!It!may!seem!
bizarre! given! some! suggested! IMF! action,! but! the! socialization! of! global! losses! run! up! by! profligate!
developed!nations!cannot!be!found!in!the!IMF!mission!statement.!!
According! to!data!provided!on! the! IMF’s!official!website,! there! is!only! approximately!$385!billion!of!
remaining!firepower!currently!available!to!provide!aid!to!member!nations!(referred!to!by!the!IMF!as!its!
“forward!commitment!capacity”)1.! ! In!other!words,!a! loan! the!magnitude!of! the! rumored! Italian! loan!
would! exhaust! currently! available! IMF! resources!more! than! twice! over.! ! Including! total! committed!
capital! under! the! IMF’s! New! Arrangements! to! Borrow! (“NAB”)! (assuming! activation! could! be!
expeditiously!approved!and!funded),!total!forward!commitment!capacity!would!increase!by!$153!billion,!
to!approximately!$538!billion! (excludes! commitments! from!Greece,! Ireland!and! Italy).! !Even! still,! the!
Italian! loan!would! fully!exhaust! the! committed! (funded!and!unfunded)! resources!of! the! IMF!and! still!
leave!a!hole!of!$256!billion.!!
We!are!reaching!the!point!at!which!the!amount!of!funds!required!to!continue!delaying!the!inevitable!is!
simply!becoming!too!large.!!As!more!countries!require!aid!and!thus!are!unable!to!provide!aid,!the!burden!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1!http://www.imf.org/external/np/tre/liquid/2011/0911.htm!
![Page 7: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
on! the!remaining!contributing!nations!grows.! ! If! Italy,!currently! the!seventh! largest!contributor! to! the!
IMF!as!measured!by!both!its!quota!and!its!lending!commitments!under!NAB,!is!too!big!to!save,!what!is!
to!become!of!France!(fourth! in!terms!of!quota!and!fifth! in!terms!of!NAB!commitment)?!Or!worse!yet,!
Japan!(second!in!terms!of!both!quota!and!NAB!commitment)?!
Imagine!a!team!of!mountain!climbers!all!strapped!together!for!safety!as!they!ascend!a!treacherous!peak.!
While!they!are!all!holding!on!to!the!mountain!there! is!no!additional!strain!placed!on!each!other.!Now!
consider!what!happens! if!one!climber,! let’s!call!him!Stavros,!slips!and! loses!his!grip.!He!places!added!
strain!on!the!remaining!climbers.!One!climber!might!not!make!a!difference,!but!as!Seamus,!Pablo!and!
Jose!each! lose! their!grip! they!not!only!add!extra! total!dead!weight! to! the! team!but!also! increase! the!
amount!each!other!climber!has!to!carry,!until!finally!Francois,!Luigi!and!Takehiro!let!go!and!poor!Jurgen,!
and!Uncle!Sam!are!left!trying!to!keep!the!whole!team!on!the!mountain.!
The! IMF!has!already!made!a!mockery!of! its!own!policies!by!making!a!commitment!to!Greece!that!was!
3,200%!of!the!Greek's!SDR!quota.2!!With!the!Troika!owning!40%!of!Greek!sovereign!debt,!a!100%!write"
down! (complete! loss)! of! the! remaining! public! sector! debts! will! not! bring! Greece! into! "debt!
sustainability".!It!appears!to!us!that!the!IMF!and!the!ECB!might!have!to!take!a!loss!on!their!Greek!debt!
as!well.! ! Just! think,! the! ECB!has!been!purchasing!Greek!bonds! in! the!open!market! since!May! 2010.!!
Greek!10yr!rates!were!as!low!as!6.34%!while!the!ECB!was!initially!purchasing!bonds.!!The!ECB!and!IMF!
now!own!40%!of!the!outstanding!debt!of!Greece!and!Greek!10yr!rates!are!now!at!ALL!TIME!HIGHS!of!
31.98%.! ! If!the!ECB!can't!hold!back!Greek!rates,!what!makes!anyone!believe!they!can!do!anything! for!
Italian!rates!(where!Italy's!debts!are!$3!trillion!while!Greece!was!a!paltry!$500!billion)?!
The!bill!is!due!and!payment!time!is!now.!!The!world!sits!with!nearly!$200!trillion!of!total!credit!market!
debt!(on!balance!sheet!excluding!contingent!liabilities!arising!from!social!welfare!programs!and!the!like).!!
One!more! dollar!worth! of! global! credit!market! debt! produces! almost! no! additional! utility! via! GDP!
growth.!
Below!we!present!the!largest!contributors!to!both!the!IMF!New!Arrangements!to!Borrow!and!the!EFSF!
in!order!of!total!commitments,!largest!to!smallest.!!!
!
How!do!the!optics!of!these!schemes!look!to!you?!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!2!The!commitment!as!a!percentage!of!the!quota!fell!to!2,400%!this!year!after!IMF!raised!its!quota!for!Greece.!
IMF!New!Arrangements!to!Borrow EFSF
United!States !Germany
Japan !France
China !Italy
Germany !Spain
France !Netherlands
United!Kingdom !Belgium
Italy !Greece
![Page 8: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
IMF!Facilities!Committed!and!Outstanding!as!%!of!Countries’!Quotas!
!!
Pre"!or!Post"?!
After!perusing!about!as!many!opinions!on!the!current!debt!crisis!as!is!humanly!possible,!it!becomes!clear!
that!the!consensus!solution!involves!the!idea!that!the!ECB!takes!the!gloves!off!and!freely!prints!euros!to!
“solve”!the!debt!problems!of!Europe.! !The!consensus!argues!that!when!the!pain!becomes!most!acute!
and!unbearable!(i.e.!threatens!the!breakup!of!the!EMU),!the!ECB!will!jump!in!and!print!money!until!all!
problems! go! away.! ! The! qualitative! inputs! here! have! become! predictable! as! we! have! all! been!
programmed!to!think!that!we!will!always!be!saved!from!default!in!a!post"Lehman!world.!!The!Eurocrats!
know! full"well! that! they!don’t!have!any! spare! capital! to! recapitalize! their!entire!banking! system! in! a!
post"default!world,!nor!to!adequately!recapitalize!them!pre"default.!!Instead,!EU!member!nations!know!
that!they!will!be!required!to!print!money!in!order!to!re"capitalize!their!systems.!The!$18!trillion!dollar3!
question!for!the!EMU!periphery!is:!Should!they!(National!Central!Banks!or!the!ECB)!print!before!or!after!
a!default?! !We! think! they!print!post"default!as! they! come! to! the! realization! that!printing!pre"default!
without!addressing!the!toxic!debt!problem!would!rewind!the!clocks!back!to!the!days!of!Von!Havenstein!
and!then!you"know"who.!!
!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!3!The!total!credit!market!in!the!European!periphery!is!$18!trillion!(source:!IMF).!
"500%
0%
500%
1000%
1500%
2000%
2500%
3000%Greece
Portugal
Ireland
Mexico
Iceland
Poland
Latvia
Maldives
Ukraine
Pakistan
Bosnia!
Antigua
Macedonia
St.!Kitts
Dom.!Rep.
Colombia
Georgia
Sri!Lanka
Moldova
Jamaica
El!Salvad
or
Roman
ia
Angola
Arm
enia
Iraq
Liberia
Seychelles
Kosovo
Guinea"Bissau
Comoros
Togo
Kenya
Benin
Solomon!Is.
Tajikistan
Mauritania
Cote!d'Ivo
ire
Ghan
a
Honduras
Yemen
Djib
outi
Burkina!Faso
Grenad
a
Malawi
Burundi
Congo,!D
R
Nicaragu
a
Mali
Haiti
Zambia
Sao!Tome
Sierra!Leone
Congo,!Rep.
Afghanistan
Total!Committed
Total!Outstanding
Total!Credit!
Outstanding
7%
Total!Undrawn!
Commitments
22%
Draft!
Contribution!to!
Eurozone
35%
Total!Outstanding!and!Committed!Credit!Lines!as!%!of!
Aggregate!IMF!Funding!Capacity
Member!
Currencies,!!
$414,900!
Arrangements!
to!Borrow!
from!
Members,!!
$573,494!
IMF!Funding!Sources!($!in!millions)
![Page 9: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
The!Importance!of!Psychology!"!Self!Deception!
Whether!it!is!Kahneman’s!“availability!heuristic”!(wherein!participants!asses!the!probability!of!an!event!
based! on! whether! relevant! examples! are! cognitively! “available”),! the! Pavlovian! pro"cyclicality! of!
thought,!or!the!extraordinary!delusions!of!groupthink,!investors!in!today’s!sovereign!debt!markets!can't!
seem! to! envision! the! consequences! of! a! default.! ! The! psychology! of! the! situation! is! crucial! to!
understanding!why! and! how! the! gap! between! perception! and! reality! can! be! so! large.! ! Participants!
haven’t!contemplated!hard!defaults!(until!most!recently)!because!they!have!been!conditioned!to!believe!
they!cannot!occur!because! it! is!against!the! interests!of!too!many!powerful!parties.! ! !They!believe!that!
there!is!no!upside!to!thinking!this!scenario!all!the!way!down!through!the!logical!steps!due!to!the!fact!the!
last! few! steps! are! so! painful! for! everyone! (both! financial! and! non"financial).! ! Developed!Western!
sovereigns! haven't! defaulted! since!WWII! and! current! generations! have! not! experienced! a! cluster! of!
defaults!or!any!developed!default!in!their!lifetime.!!However!financial!history!has!shown!repeatedly!that!
waves!of!default!are!commonplace!across!a!longer!time!horizon.!!As!events!transpire,!investors!will!be!
forced!to!accept!developed!defaults!with!enormous!loss!severities.!!The!risk"free!rate!won't!be!risk"free!
any! longer.!The!very!foundation!of!the!collective!financial!education!will!be!proven!to!be!flawed.! !The!
Value"at"Risk! (VAR)!models! that!Wall! Street! continues! to!use! today!will!blow! apart!once! again.! !The!
models!that!currently!provide!us!with!some!of!the!most!mispriced!anomalies! in!the!history!of!finance!
because! of! their! reliance! on! historical! implied! volatility! as! substitute! for! true! risk!will! be! rendered!
useless.!!It!is!analogous!to!driving!a!racecar!using!the!rear"view!mirrors.!!
!
Japan!Will!Soon!Be!on!the!Front!Page!
Madoff's! scheme! collapsed! for!one!primary! reason!–!he!had!more! investors!exiting!his! scheme! than!
entering.! !As!soon!as! this!happened,! it!was!over.! !According! to! the!most! recent!census,! the! Japanese!
population!peaked!within!the! last!few!years!at!127.9!million!and!has!since! lost!almost!3!million.!Japan!
has! one! of! the! most! homogeneous! –! and! some! might! even! call! it! xenophobic! –! societies! of! any!
developed!nation!in!the!world.!!!It!is!no!secret!that!there!is!no!love!lost!between!the!Japanese!and!their!
neighbors,! and! therefore,! immigration! is! an! unlikely! answer! to! a! dwindling! populace.! Even! if!
immigration!was!encouraged,!such!an!influx!would!depress!carefully!balanced!wages!and!would!further!
disrupt!the!three!jewels!of!Japanese!corporate!culture!(seniority!based!wages,!employment!for!life,!and!
company!unionism).! ! It! is! indisputable! that! Japan!has! the!worst!on!balance! sheet!debt!burden! in! the!
world!(roughly!229%!of!GDP).!!Japan!has!the!worst!debt!dynamic!(total!debt!outstanding!as!a!multiple!of!
central!government!revenues)!of!any!country! in!the!world!(at!a!staggering!20X).! !They!now!have!more!
people! leaving! the!workforce! than!entering.! !Soon! they!will!have!more!people!dis"saving! than!saving.!
Without! re"hashing!our!entire! thesis!here,! the! funding!mechanism! (including! Japan's! current!account!
surplus)!is!dwindling!and!in!fact,!we!forecast!the!trade!component!of!the!current!account!to!be!negative!
for!FY2011.! !Personal!savings!of!the!Japanese!population! is!forecast!to!be!below!zero!by!the!middle!of!
2012.!!Their!ability!to!fund!themselves!internally!is!coming!to!an!end.!!We!believe!that!Japan!would!have!
a! bond! crisis! of! its! own!within! the! next! two! years!without! the! current! European! debt! crisis.! ! The!
![Page 10: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
European! debt! crisis!will! simply! act! as! an! accelerant! to! the! Japanese! situation! as! it!will!most! likely!
change!the!qualitative!thoughts!of!JGB!investors.!!We!believe!that!this!sequence!of!events!is!set!to!begin!
in!the!next!few!months!(beginning!with!defaults!in!Europe).!!Attached,!please!find!several!recent!articles!
showing!the!initial!stresses!beginning!to!show!in!the!JGB!and!swaps!marketplace.!
!
The!Problems!Between!Kaiserville!and!Medland!
Recently,!Larry!Lindsey,!former!Director!of!the!US!National!Economic!Council!at!the!White!House!and!a!
trusted!friend,!penned!a!satirical!piece!that!warrants!inclusion!into!this!letter.!!With!Larry's!permission,!
we!are!pleased!to!share!it!with!you.!
Kaiser!on!the!Hill!
The"European"Finance"Ministers’"meeting"hardly"qualified"as"King"of"the"Hill,"maybe"Earl"of"the"
Hill,"and"had" it"not"been" for"the"actions"of"the"world’s"central"banks,"equity"markets"would"be"
headed"south"today.""The"central"bank"action"certainly"qualifies"as"doing"the"urgent.""Odds"were"
we"were"days"from"a"major"European"bank"collapse"and"heading"that"off"was"both"urgent"and"
important.""But"the"underlying"sovereign"debt"crisis"remains.""Hopes"now"focus"on"a"deal"in"which"
centralized"fiscal"control" is"a"quid"pro"quo"for" increased"ECB"purchases"of"peripheral"debt." "We"
consider" the" underlying" dynamics" of" this" by" examining" what" happened" in" Medland" and"
Kaiserville,"who"were"locked"in"a"currency"union"known"as"the"Uberalles."""
Medland’s" economy" was" 60" percent" private" sector," 40" percent" public" sector." " It" financed" its"
public"sector"with"a"25"percent" income" tax"on"all"workers"and"a"20"percent"VAT" levied"on" the"
private"sector.""The"VAT"left"the"private"sector"with"only"48"percent"of"GDP"to"pay"its"workers"and"
investors,"so"total"income"tax"collections"were"22"percent"of"GDP.""Coupled"with"VAT"collections"
of"12"percent"of"GDP," revenues"were"6"percent"of"GDP" short"of" the"40"percent"of"GDP"being"
spent.""In"addition,"the"accumulated"debt"of"Medland"was"up"to"100"percent"of"GDP,"on"which"it"
had"been"paying"a"4"percent" interest"rate," just"equal"to" its"nominal"growth"rate." "That" interest"
was" being" paid" to" the" banks" in" Kaiserville" who" owned" Medland’s" bonds." " Recently" they" got"
nervous" and" demanded" a" higher" interest" rate"which"would" put"Medland’s" debt" position" in" a"
clearly" unsustainable" position" and" provoke" both" a" sovereign" crisis" and" a" banking" crisis." " The"
Prime"Ministers"of"Medland"and"Kaiserville"and" the"head"of" the"Uberalles"Central"Bank" (UCB)"
agreed"on"a"Grand"Plan"to"fix"the"problem." "The"Medland"VAT"would"be"raised"by"10"points"to"
generate"the"6"percent"of"GDP"needed"to"fix"the"primary"budget"deficit.""In"return"the"UCB"would"
buy"enough"Medland"debt"to"stabilize"the"Medland"interest"rate"at"4"percent."""
The"sovereign"bond"crisis"was"averted"and"markets"rallied"as"the"banks" in"Kaiserville"would"no"
longer" take" losses" on" their" bond" holdings" and" it" looked" like" Medville’s" fiscal" problems" were"
solved." "But"the"higher"VAT"posed"a"problem." " In"many"countries"higher"VATs"are"passed"on"to"
consumers" in" the" form" of" higher" prices." " But" the" UCB" favored" price" stability" and" there" was"
sufficient"slack" in" the"Medland"economy" that" firms" lacked"pricing"power." "Medland"companies"
![Page 11: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
could"only"respond"by"cutting"costs"(in"this"case"wages)"from"the"old"rate"of"48"to"the"new"rate"of"
42,"which" is"what" they"had" left"after" the"higher"VAT." " Income" tax"collections"on"private"sector"
workers"immediately"dropped"from"12"to"10.5,"so"state"revenues"declined"and"the"primary"deficit"
reappeared." "With" after!tax"wages" now" down," demand" for" private" sector" goods" and" services"
dropped"by"7"½"percent.""Layoffs"rose.""Both"VAT"and"income"tax"receipts"began"to"drop.""Worse"
for" the" long" run,"Medland’s"most"productive"private" sector"workers"and" entrepreneurs"began"
leaving"as" their"current" compensation"was"now"unattractive" relative" to"both" the"public" sector"
and"to"Kaiserville’s"private"sector"and"their"prospects"were"bleak."
The"banks" in"Kaiserville"quickly" sensed"something"was"wrong"and"began" to" sell" their"Medland"
bonds"to"the"UCB.""Their"rationale"was"simple.""If"Medland"should"default"or"be"restructured,"the"
UCB"would"not"take"a"haircut.""This"meant"that"the"more"bonds"the"UCB"bought,"the"greater"the"
haircut" would" be" on" private" sector" bond" holders." " The" rush" for" the" exit" quickly" became" a"
stampede"as"more"banks"caught"on"and"sensed"that"the"UCB’s" interest"rate"stabilization"policy"
was"their"best"chance"to"head"for"the"exits.""The"Grand"Plan"was"coming"apart"and"UCB"money"
creation" through" the" purchase" of" Medland" debt" did" not" solve" the" problem." " Medland’s"
fundamental"problem"was"that"its"unproductive"public"sector"was"too"large"and"its"tax"wedge"on"
its"private"sector"to"onerous." "Restructuring"a"country’s"or"a"company’s"finances"buys"time,"but"
unless"its"fundamentals"are"also"restructured,"it"returns"to"the"same"problem.!
!
If!we!are! correct! regarding!our!hypothesis!on! the!outcome!of! the!debt! crisis,! the!world!will!have! its!
social!fabric!ruffled!or!even!torn!for!a!period!of!time.!!Be!mindful!that!we!are!not!talking!about!the!end!
of! the!world!as!we!know! it;!we!are!simply!saying! that! it!will!be!a!different!and!slightly!more!difficult!
place!to! live! in! for!those!of!us! in!the!developed!and! indebted!West.! !We!will!all!wake!up! in!the!days,!
weeks,! and!months! afterward! and! go! to!work,! continue! to! invest,! and! live! our! lives.! ! I! am! eagerly!
awaiting!the!day!to!finally!arrive!when!our!fiduciary!duty!compels!us!to!worry!less!and!invest!more.!!It!is!
our! job! as! a! fiduciary! to! avoid! nursing! 50%+! losses! because! we! failed! to! believe! that! a! cluster! of!
sovereign!defaults!was!even!possible!(let!alone!probable).!!We!urge!you!to!consider!the!ramifications!of!
our!thesis!being!correct,!preparing!yourself!for!the!worst!while!hoping!for!the!best.!!As!one!of!my!closest!
friends!advises!me;!"Trade!as!you!like,!divest!accordingly."!
!
Sincerely,!
!
!
J.!Kyle!Bass!
Managing!Partner!
![Page 12: Hayman Capital Management Letter to Investors (Nov 2011)](https://reader031.fdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022020306/547f6edb5806b5ea5e8b4866/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12!©!Hayman!Capital!Management,!L.P.!2011!
!
The information set forth herein is being furnished on a confidential basis to the recipient and does not constitute an
offer, solicitation or recommendation to sell or an offer to buy any securities, investment products or investment
advisory services. Such an offer may only be made to eligible investors by means of delivery of a confidential
private placement memorandum or other similar materials that contain a description of material terms relating to
such investment. The information and opinions expressed herein are provided for informational purposes only. An
investment in the Hayman Funds is speculative due to a variety of risks and considerations as detailed in the
confidential private placement memorandum of the particular fund and this summary is qualified in its entirety by
the more complete information contained therein and in the related subscription materials. This may not be
reproduced, distributed or used for any other purpose. Reproduction and distribution of this summary may
constitute a violation of federal or state securities laws.!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!