Hagley Oval Attachments
-
Upload
lucas-associates-ltd -
Category
Documents
-
view
234 -
download
1
description
Transcript of Hagley Oval Attachments
attachmentsto the evidence of Di Lucas, Registered NZILA Landscape Architect
Hagley Oval, April 2013print A3, landscape, double sided, bind left
photo taken: April 2013
Hagley Oval in Central Christchurch, post-quake source: Google Earth, 26th April 2012
Hagley Park North
BEALEY AVE
MOORHOUSE AVE
WORCHESTER STRET LATIMER SQUARE
CRANMER SQUARE
VICTORIA
BOTANIC GARDENS
AVON RIVER
MON
TREA
L STR
EET
DEAN
S AVE
FITZ
GERA
LD AV
E
Hagley Park South
Riccarton Ave
Hagley Ave
Hagley Oval
attachment 1
Hagley Oval
Riccarton Ave
Polo Grounds
Netball
Hockey Ground
Hagley Oval
Christs College Grounds
Addington BrookHagley Park South
Hagley Oval - “the site” as per application
attachment 2
Hagley Park Plan 1850
source: DRAFT Maps in Conservation Plan for Hagley Park and the Christchurch Botanic Gardens, Volume One: History, Christchurch City Council 2013attachment 3
Hagley Park Plan 1867
source: DRAFT Maps in Conservation Plan for Hagley Park and the Christchurch Botanic Gardens, Volume One: History, Christchurch City Council 2013 attachment 4
Hagley Park 1955
source: DRAFT Maps in Conservation Plan for Hagley Park and the Christchurch Botanic Gardens, Volume One: History, Christchurch City Council 2013attachment 5
source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:HagleyParkAerialPhoto.jpgHagley Park aerial, 24th October 2007
attachment 6
New Zealand International Exhibition, Hagley Park, Christchurch 1882Photograph of the Cricket Pavilion, 1869 showing saw tooth detailing
source: http://christchurchcitylibraries.com/Heritage/Photos/Disc2/IMG0008.asp
VOLUME 2. SECTION 5: PAGE 94
performed in a way that cannot fail to afford satisfaction to every member of the club. Ahawthorne (sic) hedge has been planted, and a small ditch dug round the ground. The old fencehas been strengthened by the addition of two more wires, and has been properly strained andstayed. An iron gate has been put up at the corner of the fence nearest town, and by the erectionof a stile, the members are enabled to get to the ground.”108
Soon after this meeting and once the new Club's finances had been determined the pavilion fromthe Canterbury Club's former grounds was divided into sections, relocated to its present site atthe Oval and reassembled by George Blockley for the sum of £28 and 10 shillings.109
Over the following years the pavilion became the home of various cricket clubs, the last beingMarist in the 1980s.
108 The Press, 24 September 1866, p. 2109 Lowrie, G. publication quoted in NZHPT File 12009‐086
CONSERVATION PLAN: HAGLEY PARK AND CHRISTCHURCH BOTANIC GARDENS VOLUME TWO: HAGLEY PARK
Figure 1.83 Photograph taken in 1910 showing chimney in the background. Source: NZHPT File 12009‐086
Figure 1.82 Photograph of the Cricket Pavilion,1869 showing saw tooth detailing. Source: NZHPT File 12009‐086
source: NZHPT File 12009-086
VOLUME 1. SECTION 3: PAGE 78
Two main entrances were formed for carriage drive access, each half a chain in width. The first wasdescribed as being on Riccarton Road about a chain from the Riccarton Road/ Lincoln Road corner,and the second entrance was formed on Hagley Avenue opposite St Asaph Street and necessitatedthe construction of a bridge across a drain. Following the exhibition, this bridge was purchased bythe promoters of the horse ride for use on the Rotten Row. Other earthworks associated with theexhibition involved the cutting of drains and the laying of permanent drainage pipes.287
Newspaper reports documenting the development of the exhibition site describe the ceremoniallaying of a foundation stone by the Christchurch Mayor and note that “copies of the localnewspapers were placed in a sealed jar and deposited in the receptacle, together with the followinginscription on parchment:‐New Zealand International Exhibition. Promoters‐ Jules Joubert, Esq.Richard E. N. Twopeny. Esq. W. R. Mitchell, agent for New Zealand. This foundation stone was laid byJ. G. Ruddenklau, Esq., Mayor of the City of Christchurch, on the 30th day of January, 1882. T. S. Lam‐bert, Esq., architect. H. Carmichael and Son, contractors.”288 Attempts to trace both the foundationstone and the time capsule have been unsuccessful.
Calls to retain the exhibition building as a “Palace of Delight” did not find favour with the DomainsBoard and, following the exhibition's closure in July 1882, all construction materials, parts of themain structure, fixtures, fittings and artworks were auctioned. By September 1882 the last vestige ofthe buildings had been removed and five of its six ornamental fountains had been razed from thesite, using charges of blasting powder. However, one fountain was left intact on the site where themain building had been located.289 This was variously described by The Star as a “memento” and“memorial” of the exhibition and was said to serve the purpose that Mr Joubert intended to befulfilled by the foundation stone.290 No information concerning the fountain's removal or relocationhas been located to date.
287 New Zealand Tablet, 3 February 1882, p. 11; The Star, 24 August 1882, p. 3288 The Star, 31 January 1882, p. 3; Exhibition Sports Committee Scrapbook 1882, CH343/75b,CCCA289 The Star, 20 September 1882, p. 3290 Ibid; The Star, 27 September 1882, p. 2
CONSERVATION PLAN: HAGLEY PARK AND CHRISTCHURCH BOTANIC GARDENS VOLUME ONE: HISTORY
Figure 3.19 Postcard view of themain exhibition building fromLincoln Road ( Hagley Avenue).Source: PhotoCD 1, IMG00013, CCL
attachment 7
VOLUME 1. SECTION 3: PAGE 96
As in previous years, sports groups were required to prepare the grounds at their own expense and pay a licence fee to the Domains Board to occupy a fixed part of the Park. This was a nominal fee,with football and hockey paying 30 shillings a year for three acres, and the Ground Committeerepresenting cricket, paying £15 pounds for the use of ten acres.358 Designs for all proposedstructures were reviewed by the Board, and the cost of erecting buildings was met by the sportsclubs who, although frequently permitted to fence off their grounds, greens and lawns, were notpermitted to debar the public from entering. It was stressed by the Domains Board that Hagley Parkbelonged to the public, and was absolutely open to everyone, without charge for admission.
New licences and structures agreed by the Board during this period are summarised as follows;• 1886. Canterbury Rugby Union Footballer's Memorial pavilion erected on North Hagley Park • 1889. Cricket Club caretaker's house built on South Park • 1891. Linwood Football Club granted a ground on North Hagley Park• 1891. The re‐formed Christchurch Golf Club held its first match on North Hagley links in September• 1892. Christchurch Polo Club granted 15 acres in South Park behind Christ's College Cricket Ground in the north‐west corner of the Park. By 1900 this had grown to 25 acres 2 roods and 25 perches
• 1892. The Christchurch Ladies’ Golf Club began to share the 18 hole layout of the Christchurch Golf Club's course
• 1893. Christchurch Polo Club pavilion erected to a design approved by the Board• 1893. Christchurch Golf Club erected a hut (on wheels) on North Park to hold their equipment• 1896. Hockey Club granted ground between the polo ground and the College Cricket club• 1899. Model Yacht Club pavilion erected near Victoria Lake• 1901. Golf Course reduced to nine holes in 1901• 1902/ 1903. Christchurch Golf club surrendered its lease and removed its hut on wheels• 1904. Hagley Golf Club formed and took over the nine‐hole course • 1905. United Bowling, Tennis and Croquet Club took up a lease of 3 acres, 3 roods and 27.2 perches in North Hagley Park in an area “bounded by the Plane Avenue Riccarton Road and the Wellingtonias.” Their two‐storey pavilion was erected in December 1905
358 The Star, 25 September 1900, p. 1
CONSERVATION PLAN: HAGLEY PARK AND CHRISTCHURCH BOTANIC GARDENS VOLUME ONE: HISTORY
Figure 3.37 Cricket Pavilion and caretaker's house, South Hagley Park, ca. 1908. Source: Part of G‐004102‐1/1, ATL
VOLUME 1. SECTION 3: PAGE 50
Hagley Oval, taking the turf from their Dilloway's pitch with them.138 (Refer Volume 2:1.9.4 for a fullaccount of the history of the pavilion). Soon after this the Albion and a newly re‐formedChristchurch Cricket Club were given permission to develop pitches near Hospital Corner.139
Challenger (1979) has noted that, by the time Barker tended his resignation in late 1867, theperimeter belts of Hagley Park were wholly in existence except for the belt adjacent to what is nowknown as Harper Avenue and a small portion in the north‐east corner of North Hagley Park oppositePark Terrace. It is possible that these areas were left unplanted to facilitate access to a workingshingle pit which operated in North Park until 1870, “when it was abolished owing to the greatinjury done to the Park by carting the gravel away.”140 In addition, tree belts had been formed onthe north side of the Avon River, opposite Christ's College and thorn hedges edged the RiccartonAvenue boundary of both North and South Hagley Parks.
Access into Hagley Park had been improved by the construction of the College Bridge at the westernend of Armagh Street in 1859.141 In addition, as part of the subdivision of his property to the northof North Hagley Park, Joseph Helmore had erected what came to be known as Helmore's Bridge in1865.142 Access through the Park had also been addressed with a system of utilitarian footwalks thatlinked the College Bridge with stiles which had been constructed to allow access to Park Road,Fendal Town (Fendalton), Riccarton and Great South Roads (figure 3.7).
138 'Dilloway's Ground and Hagley Oval', Unsourced publication held on New Zealand Historic Places Trust Christchurch Branch File: 12009‐086 139 Reese, T. W. (1945) A short history of Hagley Park, pp. 4‐7 140 The Press, 21 November 1906, p. 12141 Lamb, R.C. (1981) From the Banks of the Avon, p. 125142 Hagley Park bridges including Carlton Mill and Helmore's. CAAR 19946 CH287/ICPW 2525/1876, ANZ
CONSERVATION PLAN: HAGLEY PARK AND CHRISTCHURCH BOTANIC GARDENS VOLUME ONE: HISTORY
Figure 3.6 Photograph of a lithograph depicting the England vs. Canterbury cricket match held at 'Dilloway's'North Hagley Park, in February 1864. Enoch Barker's perimeter plantings are depicted as a running belt to therear of the stands and tent. The pavilion (right background) was constructed for this event. Source: Exploded detail from “All England II. V 22 of Canterbury. N. Zealand 8th, 9th, 10th of Feb. 1864” 1/2‐028957‐G, ATL
Cricket Pavilion and caretaker’s house, South Hagley Park, circa 1908
Exploded detail from “All England II. V 22 of Canterbury, N. Zealand 8th, 9th, 10th Feb. 1864 source: 1/2-028957-G, ATL
source: Part of G-004102-1/1, ATL
attachment 8
Sheep grazing in Hagley Park, 1910 Hagley Park
`In the past, animals grazing on urban green spaces like Hagley Park, Christchurch, would have been a common sight. Farm animals were kept in urban areas well into the 20th century and parks were a con-venient place to house and feed them, particularly if saleyards were nearby. Owners had to get permission from the local council – but not all did, particularly in the early days of settlement when local govern-ment structures were still emerging.`
source: www.teara.govt.nz, 1910 source: Brian Brake, Te Papa online collection
attachment 9
Hagley Oval Addington Brook
embankment proposal
Christchurch EcosystemsDry Plains
Houherepiwakawaka - kohuhu, mid-age plains ecosystem
Kahikateakereru - manatu, older plains ecosystem
Totarabellbird - matai, older plains ecosystem
Pukiopukeko - karamu, peat plains ecosystem
Wet Plainssource: Lucas Associates & Ian Lynn, Landcare Research 1995
1850 Landcover of Christchurch source: Lucas Associates 2011, based on Waterways, wetlands, and vegetation cover of the Christchurch Region, as at 1856. Modified by J. Walter based on a compilation in Wilson (1989), which was based on the Black Rural Section cadastral maps of 1856.
Addington Brook
HagleyOval
Underlying Ecosystems of ‘the site’
attachment 10
Hagley Oval
Hagley Oval
LiDAR image (DRAFT March 2011) LiDAR image (DRAFT March 2011) with embankment proposal
Addington Brook Addington Brook
Riccarton AveRiccarton Ave
Avon RiverAvon River
attachment 11
HAGLEY PARK MANAGEMENT PLAN 2007
27
Hagley Park Landscape Zones
source: Hagley Park Management Plan 2007, Christchurch City Council attachment 12
CO
LO
MB
O S
TC
OL
OM
BO
ST
RO
LL
ES
TO
N A
VE
DE
AN
S A
VE
MO
NT
RE
AL
ST
MO
NT
RE
AL
ST
DU
RH
AM
ST
DU
RH
AM
ST
CO
LO
MB
O S
TPA
RK
TC
E
T U A M S T
A R M A G H S T
K I L M O R E S T
S A L I S B U R Y S T
VI C
TO
RI A
ST
H E R E F O R D S T H E R E F O R D S T
C A S H E L S T
C A M B R I D G E T C E
M O O R H O U S E A V E
B E A L E Y A V E
O X F O R D T C E
R I C C A R T O N A V E
H A G L E Y AV E
H A R P E R A V E
S T A S A P H S T
Convention Centre
Papa o Ōtākaro Avon River Precinct
Te Puna AhureaCultural Centre (indicative)
Cricket Oval
Metro Sports Facility
Justice & Emergency Services Precinct
Health Precinct
The Frame
Retail Precinct
Botanic Gardens New Visitor CentreNew Visitor Centre including inter pretation and information facilities, a new café and greenhouses
Christchurch Hospital
Antigua Boatsheds and FootbridgeHistoric riverside recreation since 1882
Cambridge TerraceLocal tra�c and buses only along part of Cambridge Terrace to provide widened river corridor
Bridge of RemembranceWar memorial and gathering space at the end of City Mall. Design improved to remove visual barriers and improve access
Addington Brook
Riccarton Stream
Canterbury Provincial Council BuildingsHeritage buildings that housed the early provincial government
Additional islands provide habitat for birds
Deciduous canopy trees to provide shade in summer
Commuter cyclists on true left bank
Christchurch Central Blueprint Summary (pp 5-6) overlain with Avon River Precinct Te Papa o Ōtākaro (pp 55-56)
source: Christchurch Central Recovery Plan, 2012
attachment 13
Hagley Park on a winters day without the maintenance fence Cricket in Hagley Parksource: Save Hagley Park’s Facebook page source: Save Hagley Park’s Facebook page
attachment 14
St Albans Pavilion and Umpires Pavilion source: Athfield Architects Ltd Hagley Cricket Oval Perspectives, View 4 Existing p.10
10-22Hagley Oval 23.01.13
P.10
hagley cricket oval / perspective images
View Four: Existing
attachment 15
Photo Locations
DEAN
S AVE
RICCARTON AVE
HAGLEY AVE
source: Google Earth, 26th April 2013
view 7
view 3
view 2
view 4
view 5
view 6
view 1view 8
view 11
view 9view 10
view 12view 13
view 20
view 22
view 23
view 21
view 14view 16
view 17 view 18 & 19
view 15Hagley
Oval
temporary carpark
MOORHOUSE AVE
attachment 16
VIEW 1: Existing entry into the Horticultural Hall carpark from Riccarton Ave. Photo taken: 29th April 2013
attachment 17
VIEW 2: Looking south along Addington Brook toward Horticultural Hall Photo taken: 29th April 2013
attachment 18
VIEW 2: Looking north along Addington Brook to Riccarton Ave. Photo taken: 29th April 2013
attachment 19
VIEW 3: Looking north along Addington Brook, Horticultural Hall access on left Photo taken: 29th April 2013
attachment 20
VIEW 4: Looking north along Addington Brook, Old Boys Collegians Pavilion on right to be demolished Photo taken: 29th April 2013
attachment 21
VIEW 5: Addington Brook (Old Boys Collegians Pavilion on left to be demolished) VIEW 6 : Addington Brook by Horticultural HallPhoto taken: 29th April 2013 Photo taken: 29th April 2013
attachment 22
VIEW 7a: Looking south over Hagley Oval from second floor of Umpires Building
VIEW 7b: Looking south over Hagley Oval from second floor of Umpires Building (panorama stitched)
Photo taken: 23rd April 2013
Photo taken: 5th May 2013
Horticultural Hall
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished) Store Shed (to be demolished)
attachment 23
VIEW 8: Looking south over Hagley Oval from beside Umpires Pavilion Photo taken: 23rd April 2013
Horticultural Hall
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)Umpires Pavilion Store Shed (to be demolished)
attachment 24
VIEW 9: Looking south over Hagley Oval from carpark on Riccarton Ave. Photo taken: 23rd April 2013
Horticultural Hall
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)Umpires Pavilion
St Albans Pavilion
Groundsmans House
attachment 25
VIEW 10: Looking south over Hagley Oval from Line Walk Photo taken: 29th April 2013Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)
Groundsmans House
Umpires’ PavilionSt Albans PavilionRiccarton Pavilion
attachment 26
VIEW 11: Looking south-east over Hagley Oval to the Port Hills
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished) Horticultural Hall
Photo taken: 23rd April 2013
attachment 27
VIEW 12: Looking south through Line Walk and over Hagley Oval Photo taken: 29th April 2013
Umpires’ PavilionSt Albans Pavilion Groundsmans House Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)
attachment 28
VIEW 13a: Looking south through the line walk and over Hagley Oval
VIEW 13b: Looking south through the line walk over Hagley Oval with dashed green line as indicative embankment height
Photo taken: 29th April 2013
Horticultural HallOld Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)
Groundsmans HouseUmpires PavilionSt Albans Pavilion
attachment 29
Photo taken: 23rd April 2013VIEW 14: Looking north-east over Hagley Oval from Line Walk
Photo taken: 23rd April 2013VIEW 15: Looking north-west over Hagley Park South over Christs College grounds
Umpires’ PavilionSt Albans PavilionRiccarton Pavilion
Groundsmans House
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)
Horticultural Hall
attachment 30
Photo taken: 29th April 2013VIEW 16: The Line Walk entrance from Riccarton Avenue and carpark
attachment 31
Photo taken: 29th April 2013VIEW 17a: Looking north-east over Hagley Oval from near Christs College facilities
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)Groundsmans HouseUmpires PavilionSt Albans Pavilion
attachment 32
Photo taken: 29th April 2013VIEW 17b: Looking north-east over Hagley Oval with dashed green line as indicative embankment height
attachment 33
Photo taken: 29th April 2013VIEW 18: Looking north-east over Hagley Oval with dashed green line as indicative embankment height
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)Groundsmans HouseUmpires PavilionUmpires Pavilion
attachment 34
Photo taken: 29th April 2013
Photo taken: 29th April 2013
VIEW 19b: Looking north-east over Hagley Oval with dashed green line as indicative embankment height
VIEW 19a: Looking north-east over Hagley Oval
Old Boys Collegians Pavilion (to be demolished)Groundsmans HouseUmpires PavilionSt Albans Pavilion
attachment 35
Photo taken: 23rd April 2013VIEW 20a: Looking east from Deans Ave over Hagley Park South to Hagley Oval & Umpire´s Pavilion
Store shed (to be demolished)Umpires Pavilion Groundsmans House, grandstand & sheds
attachment 36
Photo taken: 23rd April 2013
Umpires Pavilion
Groundsmans House Groundsmans House, grandstand & shedsSt Albans Pavilion
VIEW 20b: Looking east from Deans Ave over Hagley Park South to Hagley Oval & Umpire´s Pavilion
attachment 37
VIEW 21: Hagley Avenue and Netball Association building (Atrium in the Park) Photo taken: 5th May 2013
attachment 38
VIEW 22a: From Hagley Ave over Netball court mound Photo taken: 5th May 2013
attachment 39
VIEW 22b: From Hagley Ave over Netball courts, across temporary carpark to Hagley Oval Photo taken: 5th May 2013
attachment 40
VIEW 23: Hagley Avenue’s Avenue Photo taken: 5th May 2013
attachment 41
Photo taken: 29th April 2013Looking east from Riccarton Ave over Hagley Park North
attachment 42
Photo taken: 29th April 2013Hagley Park North from Riccarton Ave looking over Rugby Fields through to Tennis Club
attachment 43
20
98
15
18
11
12
21
10
20
19
13
16
22
17
14
1565000
1565000
1570000
1570000
1575000
1575000
1580000
1580000
5175
000
5175
000
5180
000
5180
000
Info
rmat
ion
cont
aine
d in
this
dra
win
g is
the
copy
right
of G
olde
r Ass
ocia
tes
(NZ)
Ltd
. Una
utho
rised
use
or r
epro
duct
ion
of th
is p
lan
eith
er w
holly
or i
n pa
rt w
ithou
t writ
ten
perm
issi
on in
fring
es c
opyr
ight
.
© G
olde
r Ass
ocia
tes
(NZ)
Ltd
.
CHRISTCHURCH CITY COPPER, LEAD AND ZINC CONCENTRATIONS COMPARED TO ANZECC SEDIMENT QUALITY GUIDELINES
1. Map image: Land Information New Zealand NZ Topo50 Series, Crown Copyright Reserved.2. Schematic only, not to be interpreted as an engineering design or construction drawing.
25DECEMBER 20111078105525PROJECT
0 1 2 3 4 5
KilometresDatum: NZGD 2000Projection: Transverse Mercator
S:\GIS\Projects-Numbered\2010\10781x\05xxx\1078105_525_ECanSedimentQualitySurvey\MapDocuments\SedimentSampling\Fig25_ChristchurchCopperLeadZincConcentrations_GIS.mxd
¯
Copper
!( < 65
!( 65 - 270
!( > 270
Lead
!( < 50
!( 50 - 220
!( > 220
Zinc
!( < 200
!( 200 - 410
!( > 410
Concentration (g/m³)
Legend:
Site no.
Cu PbZn
TITLE
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(20
19
18
15
1312
11
1566000
1566000
1568000
1568000
1570000
1570000
5176
000
5176
000
5178
000
5178
000
5180
000
5180
000
5182
000
5182
000
Info
rmat
ion
cont
aine
d in
this
dra
win
g is
the
copy
right
of G
olde
r Ass
ocia
tes
(NZ)
Ltd
. Una
utho
rised
use
or r
epro
duct
ion
of th
is p
lan
eith
er w
holly
or i
n pa
rt w
ithou
t writ
ten
perm
issi
on in
fring
es c
opyr
ight
.
© G
olde
r Ass
ocia
tes
(NZ)
Ltd
.
S:\GIS\Projects-Numbered\2010\10781x\05xxx\1078105_525_ECanSedimentQualitySurvey\MapDocuments\SedimentSampling\Fig06_SedimentSamplingChristchurchAreaE_GIS.mxd
1. Aerial: Google Earth, Copyright Reserved. Image Date 15/02/2011 2. Schematic only, not to be interpreted as an engineering design or construction drawing.
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
KilometresDatum: NZGD 2000Projection: Transverse Mercator
¯
Legend
!( Sediment sample site
Waterways
SAMPLING SITES - CHRISTCHURCH (AREA E) 6DECEMBER 20111078105525PROJECT
TITLE
Okeover Stream
Heathcote River
Wa imairi Stream
Avon RiverIlam
Stream
Addi
ngto
nCr
eek
Cashmere Stream
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(20
19
18
15
1312
11
1566000
1566000
1568000
1568000
1570000
1570000
5176
000
5176
000
5178
000
5178
000
5180
000
5180
000
5182
000
5182
000
Info
rmat
ion
cont
aine
d in
this
dra
win
g is
the
copy
right
of G
olde
r Ass
ocia
tes
(NZ)
Ltd
. Una
utho
rised
use
or r
epro
duct
ion
of th
is p
lan
eith
er w
holly
or i
n pa
rt w
ithou
t writ
ten
perm
issi
on in
fring
es c
opyr
ight
.
© G
olde
r Ass
ocia
tes
(NZ)
Ltd
.
S:\GIS\Projects-Numbered\2010\10781x\05xxx\1078105_525_ECanSedimentQualitySurvey\MapDocuments\SedimentSampling\Fig06_SedimentSamplingChristchurchAreaE_GIS.mxd
1. Aerial: Google Earth, Copyright Reserved. Image Date 15/02/2011 2. Schematic only, not to be interpreted as an engineering design or construction drawing.
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
KilometresDatum: NZGD 2000Projection: Transverse Mercator
¯
Legend
!( Sediment sample site
Waterways
SAMPLING SITES - CHRISTCHURCH (AREA E) 6DECEMBER 20111078105525PROJECT
TITLE
Okeover Stream
Heathcote River
Wa imairi Stream
Avon RiverIlamStream
Addi
ngto
nCr
eek
Cashmere Stream
source: Canterbury regional urban stream sediment and biofilm quality survey p 67, report prepared for ECAN by Golder Associates, January 2012
source: clipped from Canterbury regional urban stream sediment and biofilm quality survey p 27, report prepared for ECAN by Golder Associates, January 2012
CANTERBURY REGIONAL URBAN STREAM SEDIMENT AND BIOFILM QUALITY SURVEY
January 2012Report No. 1078105525 65
6.6 Implications of Changes in Metal Concentrations in Sediments The ANZECC (2000) sediment quality guidelines are used in this section to assess the potential effects that sediment quality may have on biological communities inhabiting the stream. Increased concentrations of metals in stream sediments have the potential to adversely affect stream biota that inhabit these sediments. Toxicity arises through the exposure of organisms to pore water within the sediments. Metals adsorbed to sediment particles are in equilibrium with the metals in the pore water. The concentration in the pore water is a function of many factors including the redox state of the sediment (how much oxygen is present) and the rate of diffusion between the pore water and the overlying stream waters. Concentrations can in some situations become high enough to exert toxic effects on biota. It should be noted however, that toxicity may arise from constituents other than metals. Ammoniacal nitrogen is common in stream-bed sediments especially if organic matter builds up and the sediments become anaerobic. A number of studies have shown that ammoniacal nitrogen in sediments is often implicated as the prime causal agent of toxicity.
In Figure 25 and Figure 26 the concentration of copper, lead and zinc has been presented graphically in a traffic light system, where green denotes sediment metal concentrations were below the ISQG-Low, yellow denotes concentrations above the ISQG-Low, but below the ISQG-High, and red denotes concentrations above the ISQG-High. Table 9 provides a summary of the ANZECC (2000) ISQG exceedences.
Only two ISQG-High trigger values were exceeded across the entire survey:
Zinc in Addington Brook at Riccarton Ave (Christchurch)
Lead in Taitarakihi Creek at SH1 (Timaru)
All sites recorded cadmium, chromium and nickel concentrations below the ISQG-Low trigger value. This indicates that concentrations of these parameters would be unlikely to cause adverse effects on aquatic biota.
Arsenic concentrations were below the ISQG-Low trigger value at all sites except for Addington Brook at Riccarton Ave (Christchurch). Copper concentrations exceeded the ISQG-Low trigger value at one site (Heathcote River/Ōpāwaho at Annex Road).
Lead and mercury concentrations were below the ISQG-Low trigger value at the majority of sites. Dock Creek at Chamberlains Park (Amberley) and Avon River/Ōtakāro at Fitzgerald Ave (Christchurch) reported lead and mercury concentrations above the ISQG-Low trigger but as noted above, lead exceeded the ISQG-High trigger in Taitarakihi Creek at SH1 (Timaru).
Zinc concentrations exceeded the ISQG-Low trigger value at 10 sites and as noted above, zinc exceeded the ISQG-High trigger value in Addington Brook.
Table 9: Summary of sites where exceedences of ANZECC (2000) sediment quality guidelines were found in this study. Site No. Location Arsenic Copper Lead Mercury Zinc
3 Dock Creek4 Dock Creek10 Avon River/Ōtakāro13 Avon River/Ōtakāro15 Addington Brook
16 Heathcote River/Ōpāwaho
18 Heathcote River/Ōpāwaho
19 Heathcote River/Ōpāwaho
source: Canterbury regional urban stream sediment and biofilm quality survey p 65, report prepared for ECAN by Golder Associates, January 2012
Hagley Oval
Addington Brook sampling site 15
attachment 44
CANTERBURY REGIONAL URBAN STREAM SEDIMENT AND BIOFILM QUALITY SURVEY
January 2012Report No. 1078105525 49
Table 8: Metal/metalloid concentrations in sediment samples collected from Canterbury streams. Site Number Waterway Arsenic Cadmium Chromium Copper Lead Mercury Nickel Zinc
1 Lyell Creek 6.4 0.32 17 27 27 0.094 16 160
2 Lyell Creek 5.4 0.12 14 14 17 0.065 13 81
3 Dock Creek 4.8 0.45 20 32 150 0.17 10 260
4 Dock Creek 2.8 0.21 12 11 17 0.078 9.1 220
5 South Brook 2.4 0.056 11 7.6 14 0.044 7.5 57
6 Middle Brook 3.4 0.12 12 27 48 0.071 8.6 140
7 North Brook 2.0 0.062 11 8.2 19 0.080 8.7 79
8 Avon River/Ōtakāro 7.7 0.15 30 20 32 0.11 15 150
9 Avon River/Ōtakāro 3.7 0.11 17 14 25 0.060 14 110
10 Avon River/Ōtakāro 4.4 0.52 19 40 110 0.17 14 380
11 Avon River/Ōtakāro 1.9 0.074 12 10 20 0.051 11 81
12 Avon River/Ōtakāro 1.0 0.12 11 8.9 27 0.047 8.9 120
13a1 Avon River/Ōtakāro 3.6 0.28 15 35 70 0.083 9.4 250
13b Avon River/Ōtakāro 4.0 0.30 15 38 70 0.077 9.4 250
13c Avon River/Ōtakāro 4.0 0.29 16 41 72 0.086 10 270
14 Dudley Creek 2.1 0.052 10 4.6 14 0.038 8.4 61
15 Addington Brook 21 0.24 16 16 39 0.047 14 500
16 Heathcote River/Ōpāwaho
4.6 0.30 28 25 36 0.078 13 250
17 Heathcote River/Ōpāwaho
2.1 0.040 11 6.0 10 0.043 8.6 71
18 Heathcote 7.3 0.45 21 54 50 0.087 14 410
CANTERBURY REGIONAL URBAN STREAM SEDIMENT AND BIOFILM QUALITY SURVEY
January 2012Report No. 1078105525 75
Table 15: Trace element concentrations in biofilms from urban streams in Canterbury. Site Number Waterway Arsenic Cadmium Chromium Copper Lead Mercury Nickel Zinc
1 Lyell Creek – Information Centre 9.2 0.2 35 85 16.5 0.21 27 115
2 Lyell Creek – u/s SH1 11.4 0.25 29 92 10.9 0.26 27 92
3 Dock Creek – Chamberlains Park 9 0.42 53 124 121 0.23 48 450
4 Dock Creek – d/s Lawcocks Rd 6 0.32 68 73 21 0.29 35 200
5 South Brook - u/s Railway Rd 7 0.25 68 96 23 0.34 35 2406 Middle Brook- Denchs Rd 12.5 0.27 42 74 108 0.19 28 390
7 North Brook – d/s stormwater pond 8.8 0.31 46 90 55 0.32 47 174
8 Avon River/Ōtakāro – Pages Rd 18 0.19 40 28 49 0.2 20 157
9 Avon River/Ōtakāro – Kerrs Reach 15.9 0.23 35 54 57 0.21 32 320
11 Avon Rivew – Antigua Boatsheds 10.3 0.41 38 92 79 0.33 30 460
12 Avon River/Ōtakāro – Carlton Corner 16.4 0.43 33 98 93 0.36 34 410
13 Avon River/Ōtakāro – Mona Vale 10 0.36 67 128 130 0.3 49 260
14 Dudley Creek – Banks Ave 24 0.61 41 62 129 0.21 29 780
15 Addington Brook – Riccarton Ave 90 6.0 39 121 80 0.23 91 7,100
16 Heathcote River/Ōpāwaho –d/s the cut 10.6 0.32 56 43 59 0.16 21 300
source: Canterbury regional urban stream sediment and biofilm quality survey p 49, report prepared for ECAN by Golder Associates, January 2012
source: Canterbury regional urban stream sediment and biofilm quality survey p 75, report prepared for ECAN by Golder Associates, January 2012
Addington Brook sampling site 15
Addington Brook sampling site 15attachment 45
CANTERBURY REGIONAL URBAN STREAM SEDIMENT AND BIOFILM QUALITY SURVEY
January 2012Report No. 1078105525 77
a) Arsenic b) Cadmium
c) Chromium d) Copper
Figure 27: Concentrations (mg/kg) of (a) arsenic, (b) cadmium, (c) chromium and (d) copper recorded in biofilms and sediments at stream sites sampled in 2011. ANZECC recommended sediment quality trigger values for ISQG "high" and "low" are shown. Site names and corresponding site number are listed in Table 2.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31Ar
seni
c (m
g/kg
)Site Number
Biofilm Sediment
ISQG - High 70 mg/kg
ISQG - Low 20 mg/kg
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Cadm
ium (m
g/kg
)
Site Number
Biofilm
Sediment
ISQG - Low 1.5 mg/kg
*ISQG - High 10 mg/kg
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Chro
miu
m (m
g/kg
)
Site Number
Biofilm
Sediment
ISQG - Low (80 mg/kg)
*ISQG - High 370 mg/kg
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Copp
er (m
g/kg
)
Site Number
Biofilm
Sediment
ISQG - Low 65 mg/kg
ISQG - High 270 mg/kg
CANTERBURY REGIONAL URBAN STREAM SEDIMENT AND BIOFILM QUALITY SURVEY
January 2012Report No. 1078105525 78
a) Lead b) Mercury
c) Nickel d) Zinc
Figure 28: Concentrations (mg/kg) of lead (a), mercury (b), nickel (c) and zinc (d) recorded in biofilms and sediments at stream sites sampled in 2011. ANZECC recommended sediment quality trigger values for ISQG "high" and "low" are shown. Site names and corresponding site number are listed in Table 2.
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Lead
(mg/
kg)
Site Number
Biofilm
Sediment
ISQG - Low 50 mg/kg
ISQG - High 220 mg/kg
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Mer
cury
(mg/
kg)
Site Number
Biofilm
Sediment
ISQG - Low 0.15 mg/kg
*ISQG - High 1.0 mg/kg
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Nick
el (m
g/kg
)
Site Number
Biofilm
Sediment
ISQG - Low (21 mg/kg)
ISQG - High (52 mg/kg)
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Zinc (
mg/
kg)
Site Number
Biofilm
Sediment
ISQG - High 410 mg/kg
ISQG - Low 200 mg/kg
*Biofilm Zinc Concentration at Site 15 continues to 7100 mg/kg
source: Canterbury regional urban stream sediment and biofilm quality survey p 77, report prepared for ECAN by Golder Associates, January 2012
source: Canterbury regional urban stream sediment and biofilm quality survey p 78, report prepared for ECAN by Golder Associates, January 2012
Addington Brook sampling site 15
attachment 46
attachment P39
View from Titirangi Road over Melville Cove
Gannet Point
Sanford Pool Head mussel farm
Port Gore Saddle
Mt FurneauxMelville Cove
Tinui
Hagley Park South sign on Deans Ave. Photo taken: 29th April 2013
attachment 47