h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq...

13
Understanding and Addressing Women’s Use of Force in Intimate Heterosexual Relationships: A Retrospective Lisa Young Larance, MSW, LCSW, LMSW Practitioner-Scholar Doctoral Candidate, University of Michigan [email protected] Leigh Goodmark, J.D. Marjorie Cook Professor of Law & Co-Director, Clinical Law Program University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law [email protected] 1 © Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020

Transcript of h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq...

Page 1: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Understanding and Addressing Women’s Use of Force in Intimate

Heterosexual Relationships: A Retrospective

Lisa Young Larance, MSW, LCSW, LMSWPractitioner-Scholar

Doctoral Candidate, University of [email protected]

Leigh Goodmark, J.D.Marjorie Cook Professor of Law & Co-Director, Clinical Law Program

University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of [email protected]

1© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020

Page 2: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Disclaimer

• The webinar series was supported by Grant No. 2015-TA-AX-K027 awarded by the Office on Violence Against Women, U.S. Department of Justice. The opinions, findings, conclusions, and recommendations expressed in this webinar are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Department of Justice, Office on Violence Against Women.

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020 2

Page 3: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Who is Lisa Young Larance?

Practitioner-Scholar

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020 3

Page 4: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Training Overview

Intervention Perspective

Common Experiences of Women Who Use Force Experiences of Women in Marginalized Communities Promising Community-Based Interventions

Legal Perspective

Common Experiences of Women Who Use Force Experiences of Women in Marginalized Communities Promising Community-Based Interventions

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020

4

Page 5: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Intervention Perspective

Common Experiences of Women Who Use Force:

Context is critical

Presentation at Intake

IPV Typically have Survivorship Histories; However, Do Not Self-Identify with Practitioner Language

SA Survivorship Histories; However, May Not Be Initially Forthcoming

Expressing Anger; However, Feeling Grief and Shame

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020

5

Page 6: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Intervention PerspectiveExperiences of Women in Marginalized Communities:

Paradigmatic Victim (Goodmark, 2008, 2012)

System’s perspective (Miller, 2005)

Disabled women (Ballan & Freye, 2012)

Black Women (Potter, 2008)

South Asian Immigrant Women (Dasgupta, 2002)

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020

6

Page 7: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Intervention Perspective

Promising Domestic Gender-Responsive, Trauma-Informed Community-Based Interventions:

RENEW, MI

Turning Points, MN

Vista, NJ

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020

7

Page 8: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Change Process

8

Larance & Rousson, 2016

Page 9: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Next Steps for Intervention Programs:

Know your program’s role and goal as a system’s partner, i.e., work alongside the criminal legal system while working diligently to not reproduce power and oppression in the women’s lives.

The role of language

Address safety & support, program documentation,& economic insecurity

Focus on the presence or absence of coercive control in the current relationship,

Rather than a sole focus on gender-responsive intervention, think “intersectionallyresponsive”

COVID-19 complicates women’s already complex circumstances

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020 9

Page 10: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Who is Leigh Goodmark?

Practitioner-scholar

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020 10

Page 11: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

Legal Perspective

Understanding the Legal Framework Mandatory arrest Self-defense Battered woman syndrome

Limitations of the Legal Response

Promising Community-Based Interventions

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020

11

Page 12: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

© Lisa Young Larance & Leigh Goodmark, 2020 12

Page 13: h v v ] v P v ] v P t } u v [ h } ( & } ] v / v ] u , } Æ ... · 1h[w 6whsv iru ,qwhuyhqwlrq 3urjudpv .qrz \rxu surjudp·v uroh dqg jrdo dv d v\vwhp·v sduwqhu l h zrun dorqjvlgh

ReferencesBallan, M. S., & Freyer, M. B. (2012). Self-defense among women with disabilities: An unexplored domain in domestic violence cases. Violence Against Women, 18, 1083-1107.

Dasgupta, S. D. (2002). A framework for understanding women’s use of nonlethalviolence in intimate heterosexual relationships. Violence Against Women, 8 (11), 1364-1389.

Goodmark, L. (2008). When is a battered woman not a battered woman? When shefights back. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism, 20 (1), 75-129.

Goodmark, L. (2012). A troubled marriage: Domestic violence and the legal system. New YorkUniversity Press: New York.

Larance, L. Y., Hoffman-Ruzicka, A., & Shivas. J. B. (2009). Vista: A program for women who use force. Morristown, NJ: Jersey Center for Nonviolence.

Larance, L. Y., Goodmark, L., Miller, S. L., & Dasgupta, S. D. (2019). Violence AgainstWomen’s 25th Anniversary Edition: Understanding and Addressing Women’s Use of Force: A Retrospective, 24(1), 56-80.

Larance, L. Y. & Rousson, A. (2016). Facilitating change: A process of renewal for women who have used force in their intimate heterosexual relationships. Violence Against Women, 22 (7), 876-891.

Miller, S. L. (2005). Victims as offenders: The paradox of women’s violence in relationships.New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

Potter, H. (2008). Battle cries: Black women and intimate partner abuse. New York, NY: University Press.

13


W } } Z v P } Z Á Ç µ } l h v P } µ v / v i ] } v } v } o ... · W } } Z v P } Z Á Ç µ } l h v P } µ v / v i ] } v } v } o ~h/ ( W u ] } µ u v

W } } Z v P } Z Á Ç µ } l h v P } µ v / v i ] } v } v } o ... · W } } Z v P } Z Á Ç µ } l h v P } µ v / v i ] } v } v } o ~h/ ( W u ] } µ u v

V Jadransko more V - Milnaopcinamilna.hr/.../article/108/UPU-BIJAKA_4-a_Uvjeti-gradnje_1-1000_… · Jadransko more Jadransko more V V V V V V V V V H V H V V H R3-2-BS T2-1-BS R3-1-BS

V Jadransko more V - Milnaopcinamilna.hr/.../article/108/UPU-BIJAKA_4-a_Uvjeti-gradnje_1-1000_… · Jadransko more Jadransko more V V V V V V V V V H V H V V H R3-2-BS T2-1-BS R3-1-BS

V h-polymers

V h-polymers

H V H W V H G H H H H H K H Q G G - STS · 6ht '%7deoh1dph h 6kruw1dph v h w v h g h h h h h k h q g g 32&3&,,q$gxowgdwd 32&$gxowgdwd 32&,qw $gxowgdwd 32&,qw $gxowgdwd 32&,qw $gxowgdwd

H V H W V H G H H H H H K H Q G G - STS · 6ht '%7deoh1dph h 6kruw1dph v h w v h g h h h h h k h q g g 32&3&,,q$gxowgdwd 32&$gxowgdwd 32&,qw $gxowgdwd 32&,qw $gxowgdwd 32&,qw $gxowgdwd

D /v v }vsfxolg.org/sites/default/files/images/bulletin/10-13-2019.pdf · Kh Z > zK &' h >h W îðí -îðôñ zE h ^dZ^ H KZ ' h >hW D /v v }v W ]} v oD ] ^ µ Ç UK } íî îô

D /v v }vsfxolg.org/sites/default/files/images/bulletin/10-13-2019.pdf · Kh Z > zK &' h >h W îðí -îðôñ zE h ^dZ^ H KZ ' h >hW D /v v }v W ]} v oD ] ^ µ Ç UK } íî îô

Why PBL? h?v=LMCZvGesRz8 h?v=LMCZvGesRz8.

Why PBL? h?v=LMCZvGesRz8 h?v=LMCZvGesRz8.

ˇ ˆ174299/FULLTEXT01.pdf · h 2 V h such that a h;˛ h.u h;v/D ` h.v h/; 8v h 2 V h; (2.3) where u h, v h, a h, and ` h are the discretized counterparts to u, v, a, and ` respectively,

ˇ ˆ174299/FULLTEXT01.pdf · h 2 V h such that a h;˛ h.u h;v/D ` h.v h/; 8v h 2 V h; (2.3) where u h, v h, a h, and ` h are the discretized counterparts to u, v, a, and ` respectively,

F D P H IUR P WK H V H D V 2 Q V R P H WUD LWV R I WK H ... · : k h q ly r u\ f d p h iur p wk h v h d v 2 q v r p h wud lwv r i wk h wud g h r i ud z d q g f d uy h g v h d p d

F D P H IUR P WK H V H D V 2 Q V R P H WUD LWV R I WK H ... · : k h q ly r u\ f d p h iur p wk h v h d v 2 q v r p h wud lwv r i wk h wud g h r i ud z d q g f d uy h g v h d p d

V V H D H % UD V V LF D F H D H R F F X UULQ J LQ % X OJ D …7 ulf k r ph pr us k r or j \ r i h oh y h q j h q h ud r i wk h wule h $ o\ v v h d h % ud v v lf d f h d h r f f x uulq

V V H D H % UD V V LF D F H D H R F F X UULQ J LQ % X OJ D …7 ulf k r ph pr us k r or j \ r i h oh y h q j h q h ud r i wk h wule h $ o\ v v h d h % ud v v lf d f h d h r f f x uulq

M C J I = V F ; L M C J @ K L I H ; F W H V H V P

M C J I = V F ; L M C J @ K L I H ; F W H V H V P

Epok H & V Tamari H & V - Purmo

Epok H & V Tamari H & V - Purmo

D V S S T A R T - U P R E P O R T · page 8 dvs ir v w h u v s x u s r v h g u ly h q oly h v ir u a/ / nh z yr u n clw \ v h u y lf h p h p e h u v , y h w h u d q v , d q g w k

D V S S T A R T - U P R E P O R T · page 8 dvs ir v w h u v s x u s r v h g u ly h q oly h v ir u a/ / nh z yr u n clw \ v h u y lf h p h p e h u v , y h w h u d q v , d q g w k

H OMESTEAD V PLATINUMSERIES · H OMESTEAD V PLATINUMSERIES 315.462.2921 1 TheArtist’srenderingshowncontainsoptionalandsuggestedfeatures. HOMESTEAD V …

H OMESTEAD V PLATINUMSERIES · H OMESTEAD V PLATINUMSERIES 315.462.2921 1 TheArtist’srenderingshowncontainsoptionalandsuggestedfeatures. HOMESTEAD V …

h v v ] v P Z ( ] v v ] o } ( v µ

h v v ] v P Z ( ] v v ] o } ( v µ

LQ S ULP LS D UR X V P R R V H $ OF H V D OF H V - BioOne€¦ · % ld v h g d g x ow v h [ ud wlr f d q d iih f w ih f x q g lw\ lq s ulp ls d ur x v p r r v h $ of h v d of h v

LQ S ULP LS D UR X V P R R V H $ OF H V D OF H V - BioOne€¦ · % ld v h g d g x ow v h [ ud wlr f d q d iih f w ih f x q g lw\ lq s ulp ls d ur x v p r r v h $ of h v d of h v

u ] o ^ Ç u } ] µ u > v } v ( v v U > v h v ] À ] Ç U h v ... · > v } v ( v v U > v h v ] À ] Ç U h v ] < ] v P } u U í í r í î l î l î ì í õ ^ Ç u

u ] o ^ Ç u } ] µ u > v } v ( v v U > v h v ] À ] Ç U h v ... · > v } v ( v v U > v h v ] À ] Ç U h v ] < ] v P } u U í í r í î l î l î ì í õ ^ Ç u

) R V V LO & H Q R ]R LF & UD V V D WH OOLQ H % LY D OY H ... · 6 s h f lh v d q g * h q h ulf ,q v lj k wv $ x wk r u ' h yulh v 7 k r p d v - 6 r x ufh $ fwd 3 d od h r q wr or

) R V V LO & H Q R ]R LF & UD V V D WH OOLQ H % LY D OY H ... · 6 s h f lh v d q g * h q h ulf ,q v lj k wv $ x wk r u ' h yulh v 7 k r p d v - 6 r x ufh $ fwd 3 d od h r q wr or

h } µ v í X í } ( h } µ v - ITU€¦ · h^ Z 'h/ t ,Kt dK h^ Z KhEd^ E h^ Z D E ' D Ed d Z ] P µ ] Æ o ] v Z } Á Z µ u v P u v ] ] u o u v ] v Z r^ µ u ] ] } v } (

h } µ v í X í } ( h } µ v - ITU€¦ · h^ Z 'h/ t ,Kt dK h^ Z KhEd^ E h^ Z D E ' D Ed d Z ] P µ ] Æ o ] v Z } Á Z µ u v P u v ] ] u o u v ] v Z r^ µ u ] ] } v } (

V WH P V % D V H G R Q 0 D V V % D OD Q F H

V WH P V % D V H G R Q 0 D V V % D OD Q F H

K H P B : E V G H L ? H E H = B Q ? K D B C V L ? L D Z n ... · n ? > ? j : e v g h = h k m > : j k l < ? g g h : < l h g h f g h h ; j : a h < : l ? e v g h m q j

K H P B : E V G H L ? H E H = B Q ? K D B C V L ? L D Z n ... · n ? > ? j : e v g h = h k m > : j k l < ? g g h : < l h g h f g h h ; j : a h < : l ? e v g h m q j