GT- CII Healthcare report
-
Upload
rishabh-kaul -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of GT- CII Healthcare report
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
1/48
Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved.
Agenda for Transforming Healthcare Delivery in the Northern Region
Bridging the Divide - for a Healthy India
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
2/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved.
03 | Foreword
04 | The Healthcare industry
09 | Healthcare delivery
17 | Healthcare infrastructure
23 | Investment Horizon
28 | Changing trends
32 | Outlook
37 | Appendices
48 | Contact us
Contents
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
3/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 3
Foreword
In a populous nation like ours, with an ever increasing need for healthcare infrastructure andservices, the private sector has remained the lynchpin of growth, accounting for more than half ofthe total healthcare spending in the country.
The healthcare delivery sector is characterised by wide regional disparities with rural India beinghighly underserved. Further, the Southern region has been a change catalyst and far ahead of itsNorthern counterpart in terms of access, technology, infrastructure and sometimes even, in the
quality of service.
Against a backdrop of changing demographics and socio economic mix in the Indian population, itis imperative to raise the bar on quality of healthcare service delivery and ensure equitable andaffordable access across social strata. Achieving this requires several factors to come together, notleast the optimal utilization of existing healthcare resources and the role the government needs toplay in the holistic development of a regional healthcare system.
In this paper, we attempt to bring out the current state of affairs in the healthcare delivery space inthe northern region of India, recent trends in the sector and challenges in executing an effective
healthcare agenda, with recommendations and actions for transforming healthcare in North India.
Mahadevan NarayanamoniPartner and Practice LeaderHealthcare and Life-sciencesAdvisoryGrant Thornton India LLP
Harpal SinghConference Chairman &Past ChairmanCII Northern Region
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
4/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 4
The Healthcare industryMarket size and segmentation
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
5/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 5
Glaring statistics
our country ranks 112th on the World Health Organisations (WHO) ranking of theworlds health systems.
doctor-to-patient ratio for rural India, as per the Health Ministry statistics, stands
at 1:30,000, well below the WHOs recommended 1:1,000.
Overall healthcare spending (public and private) accounts for a mere 4% of India'sGDP, far below the average of 9.5% across Organisation for Economic Co-operationand Development (OECD) countries. Private sector accounts for more than 70% ofthis spend, while the public sector spend has been only 1.4%.
in terms of the total health expenditure per capita (in US$), India spends the leaston public healthcare among the BRICS nations.
for FY14, the Union Budget has allocated larger funds for the health sector, Rs37,330 crore from the revised estimates of Rs 24,894 crore for FY13
merely 20% of Indias 1.2 billion population is covered by health insurance
of the 1.35 million hospital beds in the country, only 48% are functional
the private sector accounts for 65% of the total number of operational beds, andover 70% of the spending on healthcare in India.
lack of healthcare facilities in the rural areas as well as among those at thebottom of the pyramid is one of the big challenges in delivering scalablehealthcare options
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
6/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 6
While the healthcare delivery sector in Northhas been making progress with a number ofhospitals and healthcare centres gainingaccreditations from National AccreditationBoard for Hospitals & Healthcare Providers(NABH), the region still lags behind many partsof the country on several healthcare parameters.
The number of hospitals and inpatient bedsavailable relative to the total population of theregion is far lower than the national average.The states (Delhi, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh,Jammu & Kashmir, Punjab, Rajasthan,Uttarakhand and Uttar Pradesh) continue tobattle high rates of infant mortality andincidence of deaths due to dengue, cholera,diarrhea and other ailments.
The lack of requisite infrastructure in thesemi-rural and rural areas of northern India isone of the key barriers to the delivery of basichealthcare services in the region.
Market size and segmentation
The healthcare sector is the third largestcontributor to the Indian economy in terms ofrevenue and employment generation potential.The Indian healthcare sector encompasseshospitals, pharmaceuticals, medical equipmentand supplies, medical insurance anddiagnostics. Among the primary subsectors of
the healthcare sector, hospitals andpharmaceuticals account for the largestrevenue, contributing as much as 71% and13% of the total revenue, respectively. Thehospital services market, which forms one ofthe largest segments of the Indian healthcaresector, is expected to reach US$81.2 billion by2015.
Leveraging improved technology and
infrastructure of medical institutions,
northern India is witnessing a steady risein medical tourism. A number of cities
including Delhi / NCR, Chandigarh,
Amritsar, Mohali and the surrounding
areas have been attracting patients from
overseas.
Healthcare delivery in the North
71%
13%
9%
3%4%
Hospital Pharmaceuticals
Medical Devices Medical Diagnostics
Medical Insurance
Healthcaremarket in India
(% share)
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
7/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 7
What drives growth?
With the rising middle class population, theaverage real household disposable income islikely to double from 2005 to 2025 leading toan increased expenditure on healthcare. It isestimated that, by the end of 2025, the countrywill require an additional 1.8 million new beds
to fulfil the targeted 2 beds per thousandpeople. The demand for quality healthcareservices outstrips the supply from the publichealthcare system which becomes anopportunity to be a key growth driver for theprivate healthcare sector. The rise of healthconscious consumers who can afford qualityhealthcare is expected to also fuel the demandfor specialised healthcare services/delivery.This trend is already underway in Tier I cities,
including those in northern India, which hasbegun to witness the proliferation of specialtyhospitals and healthcare centres.
The growingdemand forquality care
Shift indemographicsand change inspendingpatterns
Increasingability to payfor services
Risingpenetration ofthe medicalinsurancemarket
Gaps inexisting andrequisitehealthcaredeliveryinfrastructure
1.
2 3 4 5
In a nutshell
the key challenges faced by thehealthcare delivery sector currentlyinclude the following:- access to affordable real estate- ability to leverage technology- ability to leverage existing
infrastructure (nursing homes/clinics/ excess capacity in hospitals)
- limited success under the PPProute
- the skill gap, shortage of doctorsand trained staff
deployment of technology, mobilelinkages to rural areas and efficient
utilisation of existing infrastructureholds the promise to bridge the gapbetween healthcare need and supply inseveral parts of the North
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
8/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 8
Recent policy initiatives
To increase access and utilisation of qualityhealth services by the rural population, theCentral Government launched the NationalRural Health Mission (NRHM) in April 2005.NRHM has helped upgrade healthinfrastructure, improve manpower availability
and skills of healthcare service providers andimprove accessibility of drugs and diagnosticsand service delivery in the rural areas. TheCentre is also planning to launch the NationalUrban Health Mission (NUHM), which willfocus on slums and urban poor. NUHM willcover all cities and towns with a population ofmore than 50,000. The scheme will coverover 779 Indian cities and towns, as well asseveral Tier I cities.
As a part of NRHM, Government of India'sMinistry of Health and Family Welfare(MoHFW) has instituted Accredited SocialHealth Activists (ASHAs). The initiativeentails the provision of a trained femalecommunity health activist in every village in
the country. The female community healthactivist is a representative of the village andworks as an interface between the communityand the public health system.
To-dos efficiently utilise current infrastructure, before allowing for more
link ASHAs to the nearest facilities, provide infrastructure and financial support
mobile healthcare units to form the link between the interiors and the nearest facility
rural public infrastructure must remain at the forefront of healthcare policies
preferential land allotment/ subsidies where there is infrastructure gap
cutting down the risk of deaths in maternal and perinatal conditions
increase public health spending streamline drug purchase stocking distribution arrangements
low-cost day care surgery models at government hospitals
continued focus on development of medical colleges and institutions
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
9/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 9
Healthcare deliveryKey players, operating models and recent trends
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
10/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 10
Healthcare delivery pattern
General Hospital
absence of super specialtyservices offerings
present in Tier 2, Tier 1 andMetros
patients shift to Tier 1 for advancetreatment
OT & ICU usually are present
mostly 25-100 beds
some cases up to 100 200 beds
Tertiary care
Government
TeachingInstitutions
Medical Colleges
Private
CorporateHospitals
Trust Hospitals
Specialised high-end Care, from trained manpower using high-end sophisticated technology
Secondary care
Government
District Hospital Community Health
Centre
Private
Mid-sizedSecondary care
Nursing Homes
Healthcare facilities that require constant medical attention, including short period ofhospitalisation
The basic healthcare facilities for common and minor ailments where prevention is most effective
Primary care
Government
Primary Healthcare centre
Private
Clinics
super-specialty services
mostly in Metros and Tier1
15% = > 300 beds 80% = 200 to 300 beds
5% = Avg 75 beds
mix of colleges, single andmulti-specialty facilities
primary role to treat ailments thatdo not require surgical interventionor advance care
services vary across cities
may have ICU and minor OT
up to 30 40 beds
located in smaller towns are also located in Tier I, Tier II
and Metros
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
11/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 11
Healthcare service delivery models
Health City
Brief description Illustrative examples
Integrated Healthcare Facilities of more than 1000beds spread across a few acres of land and providingmany specialties
AIMS (Kerala) Apollo (Hyderabad) Fortis (Gurgaon) Medanta Medicity (Gurgaon) Narayana Hrudayalaya (Bangalore, Jaipur, Kolkata)
Hub and Spoke / Multi chain
Tertiary care hospital functions as hub and secondarycare hospitals and clinics function as spoke. A hub is ahigh-end facility located in a metro/ tier-1 city,consisting of all the state-of-the-art equipment requiredto perform complex surgeries. A spoke is traditionallylocated in a tier-2/ tier-3 city, which have lowaffordability among patients
Apollo Hospitals Care Hospitals Columbia Asia Fortis Healthcare Manipal Hospitals Max Healthcare
Single Specialty Hospital
Hospitals focusing on single specialty care servicesare upcoming healthcare facility models.
Eye and Dental: Vasan Healthcare, Dr.Agarwal's EyeHospital, Centre for Sight, Axiss Dental, EyeQ
Fertility: Cocoon, Bourne hall, Nova IVI, Motherhood,Cloudnine, Fortis La Femme, Cradle, Adiva
Oncology: HCG, International Oncology
Orthopaedics: Mewar Ortho, Hosmat, Primus
Urology / Nephrology: RG Stone, Sparsh, NephroPlus, Nephro Life
Primary Healthcare
Closest to the concept of a neighborhood clinic, itforms the first point of contact for routine examination.
Express Clinics
Nationwide
Vital Healthcare
Emerging Delivery Models
New service providers are experimenting with differentdelivery models focusing on low cost, day care andother allied healthcare models
Day Surgery centres (Nova Medical Centres)
Home Health providers (IHH in Chennai)
Urgent Care
34%
19%
26%
40%
14%
11%
26%
30%
2005
2015 Government Hosp
Top Tier
Mid Tier
Nursing Home
Top Tier >100 beds Mid Tiers 30-100
beds Nursing Homes
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
12/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 12
Franchisee Model
Brief description Examples
Hospital group lends its brand, expertise, technologyto franchisee hospital or clinic.
Apollo Hospitals Max Healthcare
Public Private Partnership
Collaborative model, with funding often from the State/Centre and affordable/ accessible healthcare meantfor the masses
Apollo (tied up with public sector coal companies and in
negotiations with Indian Railways) Fortis (Rajiv Gandhi Hospital, Amethi) Seven Hills (partnered with Mumbai Municipal
Corporation)
Healthcare REIT
Global REITs such as Alexandria and Religare HealthTrust have entered in India. They are starting topromote asset-backed financing with an aim toaddress the infrastructure needs of hospitals
Germany: Vital Healthcare Property Trust, Ventas Inc,Universal Health Realty Income Trust
Singapore: Parkway UK: Primary Health Properties PLC, Target Healthcare
REIT Limited USA: LTC Properties Inc, NorthWest Healthcare
Properties Real Estate Investment Trust
Healthcare service delivery models
Top Tier >100 bedsMid Tiers 30-100beds
Nursing Homes 100 bedsMid Tiers 30-100
beds
Nursing Homes
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
13/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 13
Competition Dynamics sub 500 lead the pack!
1000 beds
Delhi
Kalawati Saran Children'sHospital (84)
Pushpawati SinghaniaResearch Institute (75)
R.G.Stone UrologicalResearch Centre (39)
Sanjeevani Medical
Research Centre (50) Shree Jeewan Hospital (40) Vinayak Hospital (39) VIMHANS (87) Sonia Hospital (65) Kukreja Hospital & Heart
Centre (70)
Holy Family Hospital(232)
Institute of Liver & BiliaryScience (180)
Jaipur Golden Hospital(256)
Kalawati Kasturba
Hospital (350) Maharaja AgrasenHospital (380)
Metro Hospital & HeartInstitute, Naraina (150)
National Heart Institute(104)
Primus Super SpecialityHospital (120)
Pushpanjali MedicalCentre (151)
Rajiv Gandhi CancerInstitute (241)
Park Hospital (170) Mata Chanan Devi
Hospital (207) Maharaja Aggarsain
Hospital (380) Kalra Hospital (P) Limited
(120) City Hospital (120) Delhi Heart & Lung
Institute (101) Dr.B.L.Kapur Memo
Hospital (300 Deepak Memorial
Hospital ( MedicalResearch Centre (100)
Max Balaji Hospital (134) Max Super Specialty,
Saket (490)
Guru Teg BahadurHospital (1000)
Paras Spring MeadowsHospital (806)
Ram Manohar LohiaHospital (984)
Rockland Hospital (664)
St. Stephens Hospital(595) Sucheta Kriplani
Hospital (877)
Lok Nayak JaiPrakash (LNJP)Hospital (1597)
Maulana AzadMedical College(2400)
Safdarjang Hospital
(1600)
Haryana
Artemis Hospital (300) Metro Hospital & Heart
Institute, Gurgaon (150) Paras Hospitals (250) Alchemist Hospital (120) Metro Hospital & Heart
Institute, Faridabad (250)
Fortis MemorialResearch Institute,Gurgaon (500-1000)
Medanta Medicity(1250)
J&K
Bone & Joint Hospital(244)
Shri Maharaja Hari SinghHospital (250)
GovernmentMedical College
Hospital (1700)
Please note that the above list of hospitals is not a comprehensive list of all hospitals in the respective regions and has been selectedbased on internet search and featured hospitals in reports and medical websites.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
14/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 14
1000 beds
Chandigarh Government Medical
Hospital and College(60)
Mukat Hospital & HeartInstitute (100)
Ivy Hospital (180)
Government SpecialtyHospital (500)
Post GraduateInstitute of MedicalEducation andResearch (1402)
Punjab
Cosmos (60) Bahri Hospital,
Gurdaspur (20) Garg Mission Hospital
(30) Jattinder GH Hospital
(50) Modern Hospital (32) Seth Hospital (30) Sibia Healthcare
Private Limited (26) Tagore Hospital &
Heart Care Centre(24)
Vidya MemorialKanwal Hospital (35)
Silver Oaks Hospital (149) Fortis Hospital (279) Ivy Hospitals (180) Apollo Hospital (350) BBC Heart Care Pruthi
Hospital (300) Fortis Escort Hospital (133) Indus Super Specialty
Hospital (115) Ivy Hospital-Multi Specialty &
Cancer Research Institute(180)
Kidney Hospital (125) Nagpal Super Speciality
Hospital (100) Nova Heart Institute and
Research Centre (200) Max Super Speciality
Hospital, Mohali (200)
Christian Medical College& Hospital (850)
Shri Guru RamdasHospital (992)
DMC Ludhiana (1326) Guru Nanak Dev
Hospital (1158)
Rajastha
n
Dr. Virendra Laser,Phaco Surgery Centre(30)
Dwarka OrthopaedicHospital (30)
Jaipur Hospital (93) Khandaka Hospital
(30) Shubh Hospital,
Vidhyut Nagar (40)
Maitri Hospital,Talwandi (50)
Fortis Escorts (210) Soni Medicare (225) Sahai Hospital (100) Fortis Life Line Hospital
(100) Fortis Escorts Hospital,
Malviya Nagar (350) Mahaveer Cancer Hospital
(250) Rukmini Devi Jaipuriya
Government Hospital (100) Rungta Hospital, Malviya
Nagar (100) Saket Hospital, Mansarovar,
Jaipur (110) Santokba Durlabhji Memorial
Hospital (375) Soni Hospital (225) Mathura Das Mathur Hospital
(493) Sudha Hospital, Talwandi
(350) Ramsnehi Chikitsalaya AvmAnusandhan Kendra (300)
Mahatma GandhiMedical Hospitals (750)
Mahatma GandhiHospital (820),Jaipur
Mahatma GandhiHospital (624),Jhodpur
Umaid Hospital (700)
NarayanaHrudayalaya Hospital(1000)
Sawai MansinghGovernment Hospital(1563)
HP
Indus Hospital (90) Delek Hospital (45)
Mahatma Gandhi MedicalServices Complex Khaneri(360)
Competition Dynamics sub 500 lead the pack!
Please note that the above list of hospitals is not a comprehensive list of all hospitals in the respective regions and has been selectedbased on internet search and featured hospitals in reports and medical websites.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
15/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 15
1000 beds
UttarPradesh
Sri Ram Hospital (50) Bhola Hospital (40) Heartline Cardiac Care
Hospital (50) Happy Family Hospital
(62) Jain Hospital (30) R K Devi Memorial
Hospital (45) Fortis Hospital (75)
Asopa Hospital, Sikandra(100)
District Hospital (118) Lady Lyall Hospital, Noorie
Gate (331) Pushpanjali Hospital and
Research Center, DelhiGate (350)
Jeevan Jyothi MultiSpeciality Hospital (400)
Kamla Nehru MemorialHospital (306)
Nazreth Hospital (300) Priti Hospital (108) Pushpanjali Crosslay
Hospital, Vaishali (400) Gangasheel Hospital (100) Shanti Gopal Hospital
(102) Yashoda Super Speciality
Hospital (106) District Hospital (172)
Divisional Railway Hospital(185)
Kulwanti Hospital andResearch Center (100)
Nirmal Hospital (150) Chandani Hospital (152) Mariampur Hospital (194) Regency Hospital Limited
(225) Ajanta Hospital (100) Awadh Hospital (102) Chhatrapati Shahuji
Maharaj Medical University(226)
Mayo Hospital (300) Neera Hospital (160) Kailash Hospital & Heart
Institute (325) Vinayak Hospital (150) Kailash Hospital & Heart
Institute (325) Vinayak Hospital (150)
Institute of Mental Healthand Hospital, Billochpura(838)
Sarojini Naidu MedicalCollege (976)
Moti Lal Nehru Hospital(1000)
District Deen Dayal
Upadhayay Hospital(500)
Jawaharlal NehruMedical College, A.M.U(1000)
Jeevan Jyoti Hospital(500)
MLB Medical Collegeand Hospital (700)
Command Hospital (544)
Ram Raghu Hospital(1047)
LLR Hospital (1615)
Competition Dynamics sub 500 lead the pack!
Please note that the above list of hospitals is not a comprehensive list of all hospitals in the respective regions and has been selectedbased on internet search and featured hospitals in reports and medical websites.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
16/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 16
Industry speak
We need to re-write the blueprint forHealth India
All three segments (public healthsystems, NGOs and private sector)should be aligned to make a full chainfrom ground up
We have a mass enabler already inthe form of ASHA - upgrade theirskills, provide access to technology,clearly define the functionalities, usemobile units for connectivity to B&Ccities and a national network will bein place
Dr Naresh TrehanMedanta Medicity, envisioned as ahealth city, has changed the face ofsurgery in India across multiple
specialties.
Dr Amit SachdevaAxiss Dental is currently a NorthIndia focused chain of dentalcentres providing orthodontic andimplantology solutions. Thechain has recently securedprivate equity funding from IndiaEquity Partners.
Dr Manish ChhaparwalMewar Ortho provides high quality,fast turnaround care for patients in TierII cities, where there is a dearth oforthopaedic and allied care facilities.Mewar has recently completed its firstinstitutional round of equity fundingfrom Matrix Partners.
We aim to keep our capital andoperating costs low and operate ourcentres in an environment of patientcentricityquality surgeries, quickdischarge, technology advancementand safe infrastructure
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
17/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 17
Healthcare infrastructurePublic health, disease profiles, mortality
rates
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
18/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 18
North
inadequate infrastructure and facilities as compared to South metro cities still preferred as medical tourism destination more hospitals opening up. At least 80 hospitals in Uttar Pradesh have recently applied for
NABH accreditation
East
least developed among all zones inadequate and low-end infrastructure and facilities hospital projects in Tier II towns getting funded by borrowings from banks which carry
significant amount of interest. This makes projects unviable and attracts less investments resistance from skilled staff to settle in this region high number of private nursing homes but very few multi-specialty hospitals
South
Chennai is also known as the Mecca of healthcare delivery top seven out of the ten PE healthcare deals were in South India in 2012 higher concentration of super specialties and average bed size greater than other zones better infrastructure hospitals such as Vaatsalya Healthcare, Apollo and Global are entering rural markets and
establishing secondary care hospitals in view of lower investments and higher profitability
West
good multispecialty hospitals are concentrated in Maharashtra and Gujarat wide rural-urban gap in health infrastructure facilities both in terms of quality and quantity district-wise variances (Mumbai and Pune have better population to facility ratios)
Zonal characteristics of Healthcare in India
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
19/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 19
Population: 12,548,926
Doctors: 11,200
Population served per doctor:
1120
IMR: Rural43 (M), 47 (F);
Urban28 (M), 37 (F)
MMR (2007-09): N/A
Population: 6,856,509
Doctors: 800
Population served per
doctor: 8571
IMR: N/A
MMR (2007-09): N/A
Population: 27,704,236
Doctors: 38,400
Population served per
doctor: 721
IMR: Rural36 (M), 39
(F); Urban27 (M), 29 (F)
MMR (2007-09): 172
Population: 25,353,081
Doctors: 4100Population served per doctor
6184
IMR: Rural51 (M), 52 (F);
Urban35 (M), 42 (F)
MMR (2007-09): 153
Population: 68,621,012
Doctors: 28500Population served per
doctor 2408
IMR: Rural58 (M), 64
(F); Urban29 (M), 34 (F)
MMR (2007-09): 318
Population: 16,753,235
Doctors: 46800Population served per
doctor: 358
IMR: Rural32 (M), 42
(F); Urban29 (M), 29 (F)
MMR (2007-09): N/A
Population: 10,116,752
Doctors: 3300
Population served per doctor
3066IMR: N/A
MMR (2007-09): N/A
Population: 199,581,477
Doctors: 57900
Population served per
doctor 3477IMR: Rural61 (M), 67 (F);
Urban44 (M), 45 (F)
MMR (2007-09): 359
1 2 3
4 5 6
7 8
Source: Ministry of Health & Family Welfare and National Health Profile, 2011, Medical Council of India (MCI), Press InformationBureau, Figures of Medical Practioners are related to doctors registered with State Medical Councils.
J&K
Rajasthan UP
HimachalPradesh
Punjab
Haryana
Uttarakhand
Delhi
1
23
4
5
6
7
8
The total number of doctorsregistered (allopathic) in thecountry till 31st July, 2011 is8,56,065. The currentdoctor-population ratio inIndia has been worked out to
be approximately 1:2000.Within the northern region,states such as UP,Uttarakhand, Haryana arealso lagging behind the WHOrecommended norm of onedoctor per 1000 people
A Northern Tale - Healthcare Indicators
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
20/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 20
Table 1: Number of Government hospitals and beds in rural and urban areas - North India
North Indianstates
Rural Hospitals(Government)
Urban Hospitals(Government)
Provisional/Projected
Population ason reference
period in(000)
AveragePopulationServed Per
Govt.Hospital
AveragePopulationServed Per
Govt.Hospital Bed
Number Beds Number Beds
Haryana 61 1212 93 6667 24597 159721 3122
HimachalPradesh
97 2905 53 5574 6856 45707 809
Jammu &Kashmir
61 1820 31 2125 11099 120641 2813
Punjab 78 2360 135 8063 27704 130066 2658
Rajasthan 380 13754 446 12236 68621 83076 2640
Uttar Pradesh 515 15450 346 40934 197271 229118 3499
Uttarakhand 666 3746 29 4219 9511 13685 1194
Chandigarh 1 50 3 570 1328 342000 2206
Delhi - - 126 43109 16955 134563 393
Source: National Health Profile, 2011
Although healthcare choices, healthcare spend, patient profile, disease prevalence varyacross states, it is evident that there exist significant inequities in healthcare access withinthe states of the northern region.
Densely populated areas such as Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan are ranked poorly as theaverage population served per government hospital bed is significantly higher as
compared to other northern cities such as Delhi and Punjab which have better accesshealthcare quality and infrastructure.
States such as Karnataka, Kerala and West Bengal perform far better in publicinfrastructure as compared to their Northern counterparts such as Uttar Pradesh andBihar.
The Jammu and Kashmir Government is planning an investment outlay to the tune ofRs 140 million to establish two hospitals in Kulgam and Anantnag districts.
UP Health Systems Strengthening Project has been launched by the State Governmentwith World Bank funding worth Rs 800 crore.
Public Healthcare Infrastructure
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
21/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 21
Some recent activities in the healthcare
sector in the northern region
News bytes
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
22/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 22
Fortis Healthcare (India)plans to launch four
hospitals including one inHimachal Pradesh to beoperational by 2013, as
part of its plans tostrengthen its nationwide
presence.
Immediate expansion plansfor Mewar Ortho include
setting up a 100bedcentre of excellence in
Udaipur while alsoincreasing its footprint inCentral India with centres
in Sirohi, Mandsaur,Chittorgarh and several
more.
ASG Eye Hospitals, aRajasthan based group of
super specialty eyehospitals has recently
raised Rs 50 crore fromSequoia Capital. The fund
will support the expansionplan of the hospital
Metropolis Healthcare hasmade investments of Rsone crore each in Tier II
and Tier III cities such asLucknow, Bareilly, and
Jalandhar and has recentlyacquired two brownfieldventures in Chandigarh
and Jodhpur.
Apollo Hospitals Grouplaunched its first ApolloCosmetic Clinic in North
India.
As a part of its expansionplans over the next coupleof years, Rockland Group
will open a multi-specialty505 beds hospital in
Manesar, Haryana as wellas a 500 beds hospital in
Greater Noida (UttarPradesh)
Rajasthan based group ofsuper specialty eyehospitals, ASG Eye
Hospitals has raised Rs 50crore from Sequoia Capitalto support expansion incentral and north Indianstates including MadhyaPradesh, Uttar Pradesh,
Jharkhand, Chhattisgarhand Bihar
Besides undertaking theconstruction of a new 300-bed hospital at its Medcity
campus, MoolchandHealthcare has also
earmarked Rs 100 crorefor acquisitions in the
pathology and diagnostic
segment
News bytes
Some recent activities in the healthcare sector in the northern region
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
23/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 23
Investment HorizonDeal trends, optionspublic and private route
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
24/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 24
Private Funding Options
Establishing and growing a hospital business requires intensive planning and large capital outlay,which makes it imperative for players to pursue new avenues to meet their capital needs.
2CapitalMarkets
Dependsentirely onmarketconditions,not easy formid-capcompanies
Mezz/ Debt
High fixedcost,restrictionson dealstructuresdue to FDIregulations,limitednumber ofproviders
PrivateEquity
GrowthCapitalMost activein today'smarket
OverseasListing
Depends onmarketconditions
REIT
Limitednumber ofoperators,restrictionson dealstructuresdue to FDIregulations
1 3 4 5Angel
Investors
For veryearly stagedeals, thereis usually noother option
6
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
25/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 25
Deal Street
The healthcare delivery market is very interesting and active from a transaction point of view. Inmulti-specialty hospitals, we are seeing consolidation, which is driving increasing corporatisation ofthat market. This is enabled by a few players with access to significant amounts of capital and withambitions/ plans to expand rapidly without going through the typical 3 year + maturity period forgreenfield projects.Fortis has been an active player, having made several acquisitions in India and Overseas (andinterestingly, some divestments as well already).
Chains of single specialty hospitals and diagnostics businesses are to continue attracting significantinterest from PE funds as well as strategic players, given their attractive unit economics and capitalefficiency metrics. Eye care, dental care, maternity, paediatrics, orthopaedic surgery, pathology,low-end imaging, etc. are areas we expect to see significant transaction activity in 2013, andbeyond.
Investor InvesteeAmount
(US$ million)
SONG InvestmentAdvisors
Eye Q -
Temasek Holdings Max India ~ 26.3
Helion VenturePartners, NexusVenture Partners
Eye Q -
Sequoia CapitalMoolchandHealthcare
20
India EquityPartners
Axiss Dental -
Matrix PartnersIndia
MewarOrthopedic
5.4
Source: Grant Thornton Deal TrackerThe data includes deals till March 2013
Table 4: PE deals in the hospitalssector in north India (2010-2013)
SectorAmount
(US$ million)
Hospital and diagnosticcentres
1,542.35
Drugs and Pharmaceuticals 9,783Medical and surgicalappliances
584.14
Table 3: FDI inflows in healthcaresector (April 2000 to December 2012)
Source: Department Of Industrial Policy & Promotion(DIPP), Government of India
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
26/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 26
Policy Initiatives
National Health Mission (NHM)
Creation of a new integrated NHMwith an allocation of Rs 21,239crores National Program for Healthcare of Elderly
Allocation of Rs 150 Crores to NationalProgramme for the Health Care of Elderly(implemented in 100 selected districts of 21States)
Rashtriya Swasthiya Bima Yojana
Health insurance covers under extendedto include rickshaw pullers, taxi drivers,sanitation workers, rag pickers and mineworkers
Infrastructure Development
Intends to enhance its investment
outlay in the infrastructure developmentto over Rs 46.74 trillion during the nextfive years
Medical Education
To improve medical education, training andresearch Rs 4,727 Crores has beenallocated. Additional funding of Rs 1,650
Crores provided to AIIMS-like institutionscommissioned in September 2012 fordevelopmental activities
Tax Initiatives
Subsection (11C) in Section 80-IB, theGovernment is granting Tax Holiday tohospitals starting their operations in ruralbelts between 01 April 2008 to 31 March
2013
Union Budget 2013-2014
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
27/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 27
Fostering Partnerships
As per estimates, debt financing/bank loans from nationalised bankscontribute over 50% of long-termfinancing for hospitals
With the Planning Commission intending toaugment the public health spending up tothree times during the 12th Five Year Plan,there exists huge opportunities for fosteringpartnerships between the public and privatesectors as well as the various private sector
players in the healthcare space to deliverquality healthcare to the Indian population
During 2012, healthcare and lifesciences sector became the secondmost preferred investment destinationamong the venture capital investors
The healthcare and life sciences sectorattracted 18 investments worth US$98million during the year
The development of industrialcorridors across Delhi, UP, Haryana
and Rajasthan is expected to boostinvestment to the pharmaceuticalsand healthcare sector of the region
A large number of biotech andpharmaceutical players are partneringwith domestic players in Haryana,
Delhi, Rajasthan, Uttarakhand tostrengthen their market standing
Demand-supply mismatch is likely tocreate enormous investment potentialacross specialities such as cardiology,neurology and joint replacements,
especially in tier I and tier II cities in theNorth
Public/ Private Boost
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
28/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 28
Changing trendsImproving healthcare delivery
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
29/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 29
The technology impediment
Lack of data of outcome is key cons Technology progression is set to change the face ofhealthcare delivery in the country, by controlling costs, standardising quality of service delivery,and improving the experience of care for patients and families. IT enables the development ofnew models of care delivery and payment reform by bringing in better billing transparency andbuilding capacity in line with the demand. Spending on Information Technology (IT) products andservices by the healthcare providers in India will increase by 7% between 2012 and 2013, from
US$53 billion to US$57 billion. (Source: Gartner).
Technology inhealthcare
Brief description Advantages/ Uses
Digital HealthKnowledgeResources
Archived medical and scientific information, these aremainly set up in hospitals, healthcare centres,medical colleges, healthcare sector firms, researchinstitutes, etc.
relatively lower storage space requirement low cost of maintenance over the traditional medical
libraries
E-learning platforms This non-traditional collection of tutorials andinformation in the form of text, images, audio or video
is currently being deployed to provide frequenttraining programmes to doctors, basic training andvarious intricacies of in-patient care to nurses,training to medical personnel in the use of newdiagnostic and surgical equipment, etc.
training patients who use self-diagnostic kits training the users of device implants
training the various stakeholders in the use of new ITapplications in healthcare such as EMR, HER, etc. educating the general public about the various
essentials of healthcare advocating a shift from curative to preventive
healthcare
The ElectronicMedical Record(EMR)
Signifying the digital format of a patient medicalrecord, the EMR is, essentially, a tool to capturebasic patient data such as patient medical history,history of various drug allergies, prescriptions,previous consultation records, etc.
enables hospitals to ameliorate the inconveniencies ofusing existing paper records
ensures efficient data storage, data backup, datarecovery, data portability and data maintenance, atcompetitive costs
aids in better retrieval of information by doctorsresulting in informed and swift decision making
Mobile healthcare(m-health)
Use of mobile phones to improve the real-timecollaboration between healthcare service providersand patients
relatively lower storage space requirement low cost of maintenance over the traditional medical
libraries
The ElectronicHealth Record(EHR)
EHR serves to overcome the limitation of EMR; thatpatient medical records cannot be sent electronicallyto any other sources such as laboratories, practicesor specialists outside the home provider practice.
facilitates bidirectional electronic sharing of patientdata between external laboratories, external providerand the home provider practice
Hospital InformationSystem (HIS)
HIS is an electronic platform, encompassing variousmodules associated with the innumerabledepartments and functions in a hospital, which isused to seamlessly manage the whole process ofhealthcare delivery right from the entry of the patientto his discharge.
rooting out inefficacies in the system reducing costs offering a higher quality of patient care improving patient medical data integrity avoiding duplication of data minimising transcription errors ensuring real time data access for doctors and other
healthcare service providers
PRACTO An online practice management software thatfacilitates storage of healthcare records such aspatient demographics, billing data, insurance detailsetc.
used to capture billing data including patientdemographics, information of insurance payers, etc.
help in scheduling of appointment and reportgeneration
Table 5: Technology in healthcare
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
30/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 30
Tele-docs and Tele-medicine
A novel idea implemented byHaryana Jiva International, ahealthcare venture on the outskirtsof Delhi. It deploys a GPRS enabledJava application to enhance thereach of medical care to rural partsof the region. The project, known asthe Teledoc project, has won
widespread acclaim globally,including the World Summit Awardfor eHealth.
Grameen Foundation has rolledout an m-health service for AIDSpatients in India. The applicationis used to send healthy livingtips, messages and remindersregarding consultations andmedications to AIDS patients.
In a recent report for the 12th Five Year Plan, the steering committee on health hasrecommended connecting all the district hospitals to tertiary care centres by telemedicineusing applications such as Skype which facilitate audio-visual interactions. The committeealso advocates adoption of mobile health solutions to enhance real-time collaborationbetween patients and providers and between providers, improvement in the rate oftransmission of data and information between the various stakeholders and promotion forthe adoption of preventive healthcare across the various Indian states.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
31/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 31
Non Conventional Delivery Models
In addition to Narayana Hrudayalaya, which plans to establish low cost hospitals in Mysore,Siliguri and Bhubaneshwar in the near future, the Apollo Hospitals group has also adopted thismodel to set up 250 low cost Apollo Reach Hospitals hospitals in Tier II and III cities.
Model Brief description
Low cost, no-frillshospitals
Enable cutting back the extraneous costs associated with healthcare and diagnostics for the middle andlower-middle classes
Specialist hospitalsfocus on a single target patient group or disciplinecomparatively lesser capital expenditure and operating costs than multi-specialty hospitalsspecialised training ensures higher success rates and efficiency
Day care surgery
these centres focus mainly on minimally invasive surgical proceduresafter recovering from a surgery, a patient is fit to be discharged within 24 hourslow cost of surgery owing to lower capital cost and reduced time required to break-evenhigher incentives for doctors and healthcare professionalsuse of modern anaesthesia and painkillers enables the patient to recover consciousness quickly aftersurgery and recuperate at home
Ambulatory Surgeryovernight stay in the hospital is not required by the patienta patient recovers from surgery and is deemed fit to be discharged within a couple of hours of surgery
Primary care networksintegrates primary care, diagnostic, pharmacy and wellness services to coordinate management of accessto appropriate primary healthcareassists in broadening the market reach
Senior Living Centres/
Hospitals
given that the senior living sector in the country comprises of nearly 100 million people, most of whom areindependent and financially stable, it is a largely untapped sectoras per Association Senior Living India (ASLI), by 2025, the senior living sector will grow to nearly 173millionin such centres, elderly people are offered various facilities including full time/ visiting professionalpersonnel, as well as medical and entertainment facilities
Wellness Centres
increased discretionary spending, rising income levels and changing lifestyles are driving the focus towards
wellness and preventive healthcarethese centres encompass Ayurveda treatment centres, dietary counselling facilities, medi-spas, alternativemedicine centres, etc.
Health cities
refers to a single campus having wellness centres, multiple single speciality hospitals, educational andtraining institutes, centres of excellence (COEs), etc.facilities such as blood banks, imaging centres, clinical laboratories, as well as functions such as financeand management are often shared between the different speciality hospitalsmostly, health cities are located on the outskirts of cities
Table 6: Non-conventional healthcare delivery models
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
32/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 32
OutlookStrategic recommendations
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
33/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 33
Transforming Healthcare - Agenda
for action
Challenges (s) Recommendations Success stories
lack of requisiteinfrastructure
Adopt PPP model to permitprivate sector to expand thecoverage of healthcaredelivery and provide diversityof services, and the publicsector to ensure equitableaccess to quality healthcare
Undertake pilot programs firstto assess effectiveness andacceptance of this model.
Do not build additionalcapacity until the existing bedcapacity is not efficientlyutilised.
GVK Emergency Management and Research Institute (EMRI) a not-for-profit professional healthcare services organisation
B. Braun has signed a MoU with the Government of Andhra Pradesh to buildand operate 11 dialysis centres in the state
Government of Karnataka partnered with the Indian Space ResearchOrganisation (ISRO) and Narayana Hrudayalaya to launch the KarnatakaTelemedicine Programme in the states underserved areas
A three-way partnership among the Government of Uttarakhand,
Technology Information, Forecasting and Assessment Council (TIFAC) andBirla Institute of Scientific Research (BISR), the Uttarakhand Mobile Hospitaland Research Center (UMHRC) to offer healthcare services diagnosticfacilities to poor and rural people residing in the hilly terrains of the state
UP State Government considering adoption of PPP to launch districthospitals, CHCs and super specialty clinics/hospitals
Ayush Graham Bhawali Project, operating on Build -Operate-Transfer (BOT)mode, established in Nainitial
A joint venture of the Apollo Hospitals group and the Government ofKarnataka, the Rajiv Gandhi Super-Specialty Hospital in Raichur, Karnataka
Gujarat Government has signed a MoU with GE Healthcare for upgradingthe existing medical technology in the state and for setting up diagnosticimaging centres in five medical colleges and hospitals in the regions ofRajkot, Ahmedabad, Baroda, Bhavnagar and Jamangar
skill gap,especially inrural areas
improve the outlay forestablishing Governmentmedical institutes
improve the training methods train the district head in ASHA
Tamil Nadu State Government has undertaken a pilot project to train andcertify the practitioners of indigenous medicines such as Ayurveda, Unaniand Siddha medicine to serve as independent care providers in a rural
setting
inefficiencies inpublic healthcaresystem in semi-urban and ruralareas
launching secondary carehospitals in less developed TierII tier III belts of the country
link the deeper regions throughmobile vans.
Fortis healthcare, which already has presence in Tier II cities, is coming upwith 5 hospitals in Tier III cities. The chain also plans to open 25 morehospitals in Tier II and Tier III cities within the next 2-3 years
besides 10 centres in Delhi/ NCR, Eye Q also operates a customised modelin rural areas
Apollo Hospitals group has set up 250 low cost Apollo Reach Hospitals
hospitals in Tier II and III cities
the UP State Government has sectioned 150 medical mobile units underNRHM to improve the accessibility to medical services in the remote places
Narayana Hrudayalaya plans to establish low cost hospitals in Mysore,Siliguri and Bhubaneshwar
It is imperative for the sector to not only raise the quality of service delivery, but also ensure equitableaccess of basic healthcare to the dramatically increasing population and gear up its capabilities to tacklethe changing disease incidence profiles. Inspiration and learning from southern states such as Keralaand Tamil Nadu which have successfully brought about effective changes to their healthcare regime, byundertaking strong action on social determinants and making comprehensive efforts to enhance theefficiency of public health system respectively, can go a long way in assisting the northern regions of thecountry in devising a robust healthcare structure. Going forward, the ability of the healthcare sector to
institute an effective healthcare policy will be critical to define the manner in which the nationshealthcare resources, funds and services are equitably allocated, utilised, developed, distributed andaccessed.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
34/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 34
Challenges (s) Recommendations Success stories
lack ofinfrastructure,technology andpractical toolsfor effectivemonitoring ofpatient outcomes
oiutcomes could be clinical(assessing therapeutic resultssuch as blood pressure andinvolving extensive use oftechnology), human (effect ofmedication on human life) oreconomic (in terms of the costof care). Increasing quality of
healthcare delivery in the longterm can be achieved onlythrough a robust mechanism totrack outcomes and takecorrective actions whereveroutcomes are not in line withdesired levels
International Players
Novartis is investing innovative technologies which involve the use ofsensor-based and digital packaging technologies which serve as tele-monitoring applications
GE patient monitors help manage Clinical Information Logistics by capturingand presenting accurate information to help improve decision-making,patient outcomes and provider performance
Domestic India has put in place 22 monitoring centres to combat adverse drug
reactions (ADR) -- unintended side effects, some of which could prove fatal.These centers have been put under the country's new pharmaco vigilanceprogramme.
Mobiles for Disease Surveillance
standard Mobile enterprise services used by healthcare workers, suchas remote access to e-mail and health information systems;
Mobile Applications to meet a specific need of medical workers, such asmobile prescriptions and remote diagnoses;
applications that play a direct role in the provision of care, such asmobile data collection and wireless transmission of health data; and
consumer-targeted applications to encourage health and help preventillness
poor reach ofhealthcareservices tounderserved/unservedareas
inadequateaccessibilityto specialtycare for ruraland semi-urban patients
scope fortimelydiagnosis and
treatment
set up a national task force topromote the adoption ofTelemedicine, as well as todefine the standards ofimplementing telemedicinesolutions to healthcaredelivery
Sir Ganga Ram Hospital operates a telemedicine unit across threecentres in the underserved areas of North India - Gohana in Haryana,Dasmal in Himachal Pradesh and Kaithun in Rajasthan
Online Telemedicine Research Institute (OTRI) tapped this technology forproviding telemedicine links for tele-consultation in Bhuj, Gujarat after theearthquake in January 2001
OTRI also transferred cardiology and radiology-related data of over 200ailing pilgrims during the Kumbh Mela festival in Uttar Pradesh. As a partof this initiative, OTRI also transferred microscopic images for monitoringthe levels of cholera-causing bacteria in the river
Government of Karnataka partnered with the Indian Space ResearchOrganisation (ISRO) and Narayana Hrudayalaya to launch the KarnatakaTelemedicine Programme in the states underserved areas such as
Chamrajanagar
availability ofoverallhealthcarefacilities at asingle location
strategies toboost medicaltourism
set up health cities which canact as the hub for smallerspokes/ nursing homes/clinics.
Apollo Health City, established in Hyderabad, offers varied medicalservices and facilities including preventive care, wellness services,integrated multi specialiy healthcare service, education and research andlife sciences under a single roof
Chettinad Health City in Chennai, spread over an area of 100 acres,provides comprehensive healthcare services to patients
Narayana Health City, estimated to be operational by 2013, will beestablished as 5,000-bed health cities across the North Indian cities suchas Delhi, Jaipur, etc
affordability ofhealthcareservices inrural areas
set up health insuranceprograms in rural areas
with a coverage value of Rs 30,000 to each below poverty line categoryhousehold in the country, Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) hastoday become one of the worlds largest medical insurance programmes.
The scheme has also been chosen by the United Nations DevelopmentProgramme (UNDP) and International Labour Organisation (ILO) as oneof the top 18 social security schemes in the world
Community Health Insurance Scheme, launched in Karnataka, inpartnership between Karuna Trust with the National Health InsuranceCompany and Government of Karnataka
Transforming Healthcare - Agenda
for action
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
35/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 35
Transforming Healthcare - Agenda
for action
Role theGovernment
can play
PrivateSectorFocus
Strengthening the PPP model
Establish StructuredFramework
Ensure multi stakeholderparticipation
Run a pilot to testefficacy
Financially viableproposition for all
stakeholders
Improving paymentmechanism and cycles
Priority redressal ofmedico legal issues
Viable exit options forstakeholders
Continued financial andoperating support
work towards creating a regional focus rather than focusing only on toptier cities.
link existing infrastructure through technology and mobile units to Tier IIand Tier III regions
integrate healthcare delivery with technology that will redefine healthcareand reduce costs
refrain from mere additions in bed capacity and focus on efficientutilization of current infrastructure
focus on emerging healthcare delivery models that provide affordableand quality healthcare in Tier II and Tier III Cities.
build more health cities that provide ease of access, promote medicaltourism with real estate support from the government.
encourage usage of re-furbished equipment in district and tier II hospitalswhich significantly reduce the cost burden of the private sector withoutcompromising on quality.
granting Healthcare an Industry Status expand the scale and scope of Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana encourage health programs that focus on preventive health care ease visa norms to boost medical tourism empower the ASHA representative and grant resources, technology and
establish linkages to hospital infrastructure in larger cities/ towns
pilot programs to test the PPP model to establish effectiveness before aroll out preferential allotment of land to private sector players to overcome the
rising real estate costs preferential allotment of land to private sector players to overcome the
rising real estate costs ease of norms for setting up medical and institutional infrastructure by
relaxing minimum requirements, mandatory affiliations with existinggovernment district hospitals and other private players.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
36/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 36
A regional health strategy
A regional approach for developing sustainable health systems is the only means to address theballooning healthcare need of the Northern Region. Combined with innovative delivery modelsand technological interface to bring regions together, Healthcare continues to remain one of themost promising sectors for the Indian Economy for the coming decade and thereafter.
A regional focus can be maintained either through the current state wise institutionalframework or by channelizing the existing ecosystem of district/ civil hospitals, smallerhospitals/ nursing care to larger hospitals in Tier I and Tier II cities. Spreading outdelivery models on the basis of the population profile of regions and doctor availabilitywill ensure equitable allocation of healthcare resources across all regions
Reach
Integration
Keeping the drivers in mind
Developing a clinical pathway
Skill enhancement
Integration of primary care and hospital based infrastructure to provide seamless,uniform and pro-active care, keeping in mind the level of clinician support (doctoravailability and referral channels) that are available in and around such regions.
Ageing population profile, disease prevalence and general medical technology are keydrivers fueling the demand for healthcare in the Northern Region.
Depending on the need and complexity of surgical intervention, every doctor/representative at the bottom of the clinical ecocystem shall decide on what activities canbe done at the primary centre level, what needs to be referred to relatively largerhospitals/ nursing homes and finally acute needs which may need to be referred to
specialty hospitals with skilled professionals. A clear, well defined policy framework ofthis clinical pathway is critical for the creation of a holistic and interlinked regionalhealthcare system.
Overcome resistance of skilled medical professionals in moving to Tier II, Tier III citiesby creating a timetable of periodic mobility of professionals across deeper regions.Develop adequate infrastructure and provide institutional support by regular andcontinuous training of medical doctors and other skilled manpower to service the sector
Infrastructure support
Reducing the real estate burden and providing support for setting up infrastructureacross the entire spectrum of this regional ecosystem.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
37/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 37
AppendicesHealthcare Indicators, Deal summary
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
38/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 38
Maternal Mortality Rate
North Indian states 2004-06 2007-09
Haryana 186 153
Punjab 192 172
Rajasthan 388 318
Uttar Pradesh 440 359
Note: Per1,00,000 Live BirthsSource: National Health Profile, 2011
Projected Levels of Expectation of Life at Birth
North Indian states 2011-15 2016-20
Male Female Male Female
Haryana 68.9 71.3 69.9 72.5
Punjab 69.7 72.8 70.7 73.8
Rajasthan 67.6 70.7 68.6 71.9
Uttar Pradesh 66 66.9 67.5 69.2
Source: National Health Profile, 2011
Infant Mortality Rates
North Indian states Rural Urban
Male Female Male Female
Haryana 51 52 35 42
Himachal Pradesh - - - -
Jammu & Kashmir 43 47 28 37
Punjab 36 39 27 29
Rajasthan 58 64 29 34
Uttar Pradesh 61 67 44 45
Uttarakhand - - - -
Chandigarh - - - -
Delhi 32 42 29 29
Note: Per 1000 live birthsSource: National Health Profile, 2011
Appendix 1: Health IndicatorsNorth India
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
39/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 39
Number of registered allopathic doctors and dental surgeons in North India
Source: Ministry of Health & Family WelfareFigures of Medical Practioners are related to doctors registered with State Medical Councils.Figures of Dental Surgeons are related to doctors registered with Central/State Councils.
North Indian statesAllopathic doctors Dental surgeons
2010 2011 2010 2011
Haryana 4100 - 1740 1740
Himachal Pradesh 800 - 772 772
Jammu & Kashmir 11200 - 1090 1090
Punjab 38400 - 6996 6996
Rajasthan 28500 - 364 364
Uttar Pradesh 57900 - 8152 9441
Uttarakhand 3300 - 451 451
Chandigarh - - 675 675
MCI Delhi 37000 - - -
Appendix 2: Healthcare Indicators
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
40/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 40
Malaria cases during 2011 NorthIndia
Source: National Health Profile, 2011
Appendix 3: Disease profilesNorth India
North Indian states 2011 (Provisional)
Haryana 33345
Himachal Pradesh 247
J&K 1031
Punjab 2693
Rajasthan 46457
Uttarakhand 1162
Uttar Pradesh 56438
Chandigarh 582
Delhi 413
Acute Diarrhoeal Diseases casesduring 2011 North India
North Indian states 2011
Haryana 224223
Himachal Pradesh 310227
Jammu division 342670
Kashmir division 202041
Punjab 190022
Rajasthan 227571
Uttarakhand 79643
Uttar Pradesh 554770
Chandigarh 42615
Delhi 102983
Source: National Health Profile, 2011
Enteric Fever (Typhoid) casesduring 2011 North India
Source: National Health Profile, 2011
Acute Respiratory Infection casesduring 2011 North India
North Indian states 2011
Haryana 1275035
Himachal Pradesh 1484149
Jammu division 185551
Kashmir division 342858
Punjab 656544
Rajasthan 1089640
Uttarakhand 130283
Uttar Pradesh 1183992
Chandigarh 49649
Delhi 198541
Source: National Health Profile, 2011
North Indian states 2011
Haryana 25469
Himachal Pradesh 28074
Jammu division 59465
Kashmir division 22882
Punjab 36263
Rajasthan 7902
Uttarakhand 13760
Uttar Pradesh 117537
Chandigarh 3190
Delhi 42976
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
41/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 41
Appendix 4: Deal summary (Diagnostic chainsand hospitals)North India
Year Acquirer TargetValue (US$
million)
2010 Fortis Healthcare Ltd Parkway Holdings Ltd 685.30
2010 Fortis Healthcare Ltd OP Jindal Hospital -
2010 Fortis Healthcare Ltd Vivekanand Hospital and Research Centre -
2010 Fortis Global Healthcare Holdings Pte Ltd Dental Corporation Holdings Limited 95.74
2010 Fortis Global Healthcare Holdings Pte Ltd Dental Corporation Holdings Limited 95.74
2011 Shalby Hospitals Vrundavan Hospital -2011 Fortis Healthcare Ltd Super Religare Laboratories 174.57
2011 Fortis Healthcare Fortis Healthcare International 665.00
2011 Life Healthcare Group Holdings Max Healthcare Institute Ltd 112.28
2011 Fortis Global Healthcare Lanka Hospitals Corporation Plc 36.30
2011 Max India Ltd Max Healthcare Institute Ltd 30.43
2011Surya Healthcare, majority owned by SuryaPharmaceuticals
Medimart Pharmacy 2.39
2011 Halcyon Finance and Capital Advisors Pvt. Ltd BLK Super Speciality Hospital 44.4
2012 BUPA Care Services Ltd Dental Corporation Holdings Ltd- Subsidary of Fortis Healthcare 286.00
2012 Radiant Life Care Pvt Ltd Guru Harkishan Hospital-management rights 77.00
2012 Fortis Healthcare RadLink-Asia Pte Ltd 50.00
2012 Radiant Life Care Pvt Ltd Guru Harkishan Hospital-management rights 77.00
2012 Fortis Healthcare RadLink-Asia Pte Ltd 50.00
2012 Centre for Sight New Vision Laser Centre 10.00
2012 Shalby Ltd Yogeshwar Healthcare Ltd -Krishna Heart Institute 13.64
2013 Moolchand Healthcare Pankaj Apollo Hospital -
M&A deals (2010-13)
Source: Grant Thornton Dealtracker -the data includes deals till March 2013
Year Investee InvestorValue (US$
million)
2010 Asian Healthcare Fund Diwan Chand Medical Services Pvt Ltd 20.00
2010 SONG Investment Advisors Eye Q -
2010 Matrix Partners India Investment Holdings,LLC Centre for Sight 10.64
2010 Temasek Holdings Max India 25.532010 Aureos Capital India BSR Super Specialty Hospitals Ltd 10.00
2011 Intel Capital Sudhir Srivastava Advanced Robotic Surgery Centre -
2011 Helion Venture Partners, Nexus Venture Partners Eye-Q -
2011 Avigo Capital Partners Super Religare Laboratories Ltd 21.74
2011 Sabre Capital Super Religare Laboratories Ltd 10.87
2011 Franklin Templeton Symbiotec Pharmalab 9.78
2012 NYLIM Jacob Ballas Super Religare Laboratories 50.00
2012 International Finance Corporation Super Religare Laboratories 24.00
2012 Sequoia Capital Moolchand Healthcare 20.00
2012 India Equity Partners Axiss Dental -
2012 Matrix Partners India Mewar Orthopaedic Hospital 5.45
2012 Rajasthan Venture Capital International Oncology Services Pvt Ltd 4.002012 India Innovation Fund, Indian Angel Network Consure Medical -
2013 Sequoia Capital ASG Eye Hospitals 9.09
2013 WestBridge Capital Partners Dr Lal PathLabs 36.00
2013 TA Associates Dr Lal PathLabs 9.00
2013 Artiman Ventures Core Diagnostics 4.91
PE deals (2010-13)
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
42/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 42
IMR: Infant Mortality Rate MMR: Maternal Mortality Rate GDP: Gross Domestic Product OECD: Organisation for Economic Co-
operation and Development BRICS: Brazil, Russia, India, China and
South Africa FDI: Foreign Direct Investment PE: Private Equity FVCI: Foreign Venture Capital Funds FIIs: Foreign Institutional Investors ADR: American Depositary Receipt GDR: Global Depository Receipt M&A: Mergers and Acquisitions NRI: Non-resident Indian Pvt: Private Ltd: Limited
MoU: Memorandum of Understanding IT: Information Technology HIS: Hospital Information System EHR: Electronic Health Record EMR: Electronic Medical Record RGI: Registrar General Of India SRS: Sample Registration System RSBY: Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana ASHAs:Accredited Social Health Activists OT: Operation Theatre
ICU: Intensive Care Unit US: United States of America UK: United Kingdom UT: Union Territory MIOT: Madras Institute of Orthopaedics
and Traumatology GPRS: General Packet Radio Service AYUSH: Department of Ayurveda, Yoga &
Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha andHomoeopathy, Government of India
AHM:Ahmedabad CHD: Chandigarh DEL: Delhi GUR: Gurgaon GZB: Ghaziabad LUD: Ludhiana RAJ: Rajasthan UP: Uttar Pradesh J&K: Jammu and Kashmir WHO:World Health Organisation PPP: Public-Private Partnership ANC:Ante-Natal Care CAGR: Compounded Annual Growth Rate NRHM: National Rural Health Mission NABH: National Accreditation Board for
Hospitals & Healthcare Providers MoHFW: Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare NUHM: Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare OTRI: Online Telemedicine Research
Institute TIFAC: Forecasting and Assessment
Council BISR: Birla Institute of Scientific Research UMHRC: Uttarakhand Mobile Hospital
and Research Centre
BOT: BuildOperateTransfer AIIMS:All India Institute of Medical
Sciences AIDS:Acquired Immunodeficiency
Syndrome ISRO: Indian Space Research Organisation ILO: International Labour Organisation UNDP: United Nations Development
Programme
Appendix 5:Abbreviations
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
43/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 43
References
http://www.gartner.com/newsroom/id/2344215
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.PCAP/countries
Health at a Glance 2011: OECD indicators http://www.business-
standard.com/article/economy-policy/doing-less-with-more-india-s-health-care-system-113033000209_1.html
http://www.changemakers.com/changeshop/primary-healthcare-rural-indian-populations
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3283025/
http://www.business-standard.com/article/management/improving-the-picture-of-india-s-healthcare-
112061800066_1.html http://www.photius.com/rankings/healthra
nks.html http://www.ibef.org/download/Healthcare
50112.pdf http://ehealth.eletsonline.com/2013/02/he
alth-gets-over-28-hikes-in-budget/ http://www.photius.com/rankings/world_h
ealth_systems.html
Indian Healthcare sector reportMegStratConsulting
http://www.indianmirror.com/indian-industries/2012/health-2012.html
http://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/indian-pharma-market-to-grow-at-15-cagr-by-fy14-112060300047_1.html
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD
http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-11-01/jaipur/34856928_1_imr-infant-mortality-rate-sample-registration-survey
National Health Profile2011 and 2010 http://www.businessinsider.com/inside-
indias-no-frills-hospitals-where-heart-surgery-costs-just-800-2013-4
http://www.livemint.com/Politics/D0gBgwCn3huK72S06p8K5H/The-dark-underbelly-of-Indias-clinical-trials-business.html
http://www.photius.com/rankings/world_health_systems.html
Grant Thornton Healthcare Sector Budgetreport 2013-14
Research on IndiaHospital Market inIndia (March 2012)
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
44/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 44
About CII
The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) works to create and sustain an environment conduciveto the development of India, partnering industry, Government, and civil society, through advisoryand consultative processes. CII is a non-government, not-for-profit, industry led and industrymanaged organization, playing a proactive role in India's development process. Founded over 118years ago, India's premier business association has over 7100 member organizations, from the privateas well as public sectors, including SMEs and MNCs, and an indirect membership of over 90,000companies from around 257 national and regional sectoral associations.
CII charts change by working closely with Government on policy issues, interfacing with thoughtleaders, and enhancing efficiency, competitiveness and business opportunities for industry through arange of specialised services and global linkages. It also provides a platform for consensus-buildingand networking on diverse issues. Extending its agenda beyond business, CII assists industry toidentify and execute corporate citizenship programmes. Partnerships with over 120 NGOs across thecountry carry forward our initiatives for integrated and inclusive development, in affirmative action,healthcare, education, livelihood, diversity management, skill development, empowerment of women,and water, to name a few.
The CII Theme for 2013-14 isAccelerating Economic Growth through Innovation,Transformation, Inclusion and Governance.Towards this, CII advocacy will accord top priorityto stepping up the growth trajectory of the nation, while retaining a strong focus on accountability,transparency and measurement in both the corporate and social eco-system, building a knowledgeeconomy, and broad-basing development to help deliver the fruits of progress to many.
With 63 offices including 10 Centres of Excellence in India, and 7 overseas offices in Australia,China, France, Singapore, South Africa, UK, and USA, as well as institutional partnerships with 224counterpart organizations in 90 countries, CII serves as a reference point for Indian industry and theinternational business community.
Confederation of Indian IndustryThe Mantosh Sondhi Centre23, Institutional Area, Lodi Road, New Delhi 110 003 (India)
T: 91 11 45771000 / 24629994-7 F: 91 11 24626149E: [email protected] W: www.cii.in
Reach us via our Membership Helpline: 00-91-11-435 46244 / 00-91-99104 46244CII Helpline Toll free No: 1800-103-1244
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
45/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 45
Grant Thornton InternationalGrant Thornton International is one of the worlds leading organisations of independently ownedand managed accounting and consulting firms. These firms provide assurance, tax and specialistadvisory services to privately held businesses and public interest entities.
Clients of member and correspondent firms can access the knowledge and experience of morethan 2500 partners in over 100 countries in order to consistently receive a distinctive, high quality
and personalised service wherever they choose to do business. Grant Thornton Internationalstrives to speak out on issues that matter to business and which are in the wider public interest.Its aim is to emerge as a bold and positive leader in its chosen markets and within the globalaccounting profession.
About Grant Thornton India LLPGrant Thornton in India is a member firm within Grant Thornton International Ltd. The firmhas today grown to be one of the largest accountancy and advisory firms in India with over 1,500staff in New Delhi, Bangalore, Chandigarh, Chennai, Gurgaon, Hyderabad, Kolkata, Mumbai andPune, and affiliate arrangements in most of the major towns and cities across the country. Thefirm specialises in providing assurance, tax and advisory services to growth-oriented,entrepreneurial companies.
About Grant Thornton
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
46/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 46
Our services: Unlocking the potential for growth in dynamic healthcareorganisationsGrant Thorntons assurance, tax and advisory professionals have extensive experience serving a
broad spectrum of growth-oriented organisations. The Firm seamlessly combines theinternational reach, depth and expertise with personal attention and a relationship approach,which has made us the leading firm in each of our chosen markets. With shorter decision makingchains, more senior personnel involvement and distinctive client services, we are able to take a
wider view and operate in a coordinated way thats as fast and agile as our clients.
We have a dedicated healthcare & lifesciences practice in India with extensive experience, havingworked across over 100 clients in the sector. Building successful organisations requiresmanagement to work on many fronts simultaneously. Organic growth, capacity building, mergersand acquisitions, joint ventures, managing business risk and putting in place the right capitalstructure are all equally important in dynamic organisations looking to realise their full potential.To help healthcare organisations unlock their potential for growth, we provide robust advice inthe areas below:
Healthcare &Life sciences
Advisory
Tax andRegulatory
Business Risk &Process
Improvement
Due Diligence& Valuation
StrategicServices
JV &InternationalExpansion
Assurance& Compliance
M&A and CapitalRaising
To know more about our solutions for healthcare businesses, please contact:
Mahadevan Narayanamoni
PartnerHealthcare and Life Sciences [email protected]+91 40 66308200
Vrinda Mathur
Associate DirectorHealthcare and Life [email protected]+91 124 462 8000
About Grant Thornton
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
47/48 Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved. 47
Insights for healthcare in India
Grant Thornton India LLP strives to speak out on matters that relate to the success andsustenance of your business. Through our publications, we seek to share our knowledge derivedfrom our expertise and experience. The firm publishes a variety of monthly and quarterlypublications designed to keep dynamic business leaders apprised of issues affecting theircompanies.
Visit our Blog atwww.grantthornton.in/insights to know more about our Thought Leadershipinitiatives.
-
7/28/2019 GT- CII Healthcare report
48/48
Contact us
NEW DELHINational OfficeOuter CircleL 41 Connaught Circus
New Delhi 110 001T +91 11 4278 7070
CHENNAIArihant Nitco Park, 6th floorNo.90, Dr. Radhakrishnan SalaiMylaporeChennai 600 004T +91 44 4294 0000
KOLKATA10C Hungerford Street5th floor
Kolkata 700 017T +91 33 4050 8000
CHANDIGARHSCO 172nd floor
Sector 17 EChandigarh 160 017T +91 172 4338 000
GURGAON21st floor, DLF SquareJacaranda MargDLF Phase IIGurgaon 122 002T +91 124 462 8000
HYDERABAD7th floor, Block IIIWhite HouseKundan Bagh, Begumpet
Hyderabad 500 016T +91 40 6630 8200
MUMBAI16th floor, Tower IIIndiabulls Finance Centre
SB Marg, Elphinstone (W)Mumbai 400 013T +91 22 6626 2600
PUNE401 Century ArcadeNarangi Baug RoadOff Boat Club RoadPune 411 001T +91 20 4105 7000
BENGALURUWings, 1st floor16/1 Cambridge RoadUlsoor
Bengaluru 560 008T +91 80 4243 0700
Grant Thornton India LLP. All rights reserved.
Grant Thornton India LLP (formerly Grant Thornton India) is registered with limited liability with identity number AAA-7677 and its registered office at L-41 Connaught Circus, New Delhi, 110001Grant Thornton India LLP is a member firm within Grant Thornton International Ltd (Grant Thornton International).
Grant Thornton International and the member firms are not a worldwide partnership. Services are delivered by themember firms independently.
For more information or for any queries, write to us at [email protected]
Disclaimer:
The information contained in this document has been compiled or arrived at from other sources believed to be reliable,but no representation or warranty is made to its accuracy, completeness or correctness. The information contained in thisdocument is published for the knowledge of the recipient but is not to be relied upon as authoritative or taken insubstitution for the exercise of judgment by any recipient. This document is not intended to be a substitute forprofessional, technical or legal advice or opinion and the contents in this document are subject to change without notice.
Whil d h b k i h i f hi d i f i i d h i G Th d
Editorial team:Vrinda Mathur, Misbah Hussain, Sanjana ShankarDesign and production: Rakshit Dubey, Sushant Hivale
Abhishek Puri
Deputy Director
Confederation of Indian IndustryNorthern Region Headquarters
Sector 31A
Chandigarh 160 030T: +91 172 502 2522
F: +91 172 260 6259, 261 4974
Pankaj Jain
Executive
Confederation of Indian IndustryNorthern Region Headquarters
Sector 31A
Chandigarh 160 030
T: +91 172 502 2522F: +91 172 260 6259, 261 4974
Jasdeep Kaur
Executive
Confederation of Indian Industry INorthern Region Headquarters
Sector 31A
Chandigarh 160 030
T: +91 172 502 2522F: +91 172 260 6259, 261 4974
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]