Group - NBCRFI Framework · Management Services Quadrant House 115 Margaret Mncadi Avenue Durban...
Transcript of Group - NBCRFI Framework · Management Services Quadrant House 115 Margaret Mncadi Avenue Durban...
Management Services
Quadrant House 115 Margaret Mncadi Avenue Durban 4001
PO Box 1 Durban 4000 South Africa
Tel: +27 (0)31 304 1451 Fax: +27 (0)31 305 2848 Web: www.grindrod.co.za
Group - NBCRFI Framework
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
1
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1. Flowcharts ................................................... 2
2. Process Narratives..................................... 14
3. Control Objectives ..................................... 23
4. Control framework .................................... 24
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
2
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1. Flowcharts
1.1. Additions of new employees on the Payroll system
1.2. Terminations of employees on the Payroll system
Prevent control Detect control
P D
Authority to Appoint forms together with Contracts and supporting documents are
forwarded to Payroll for processing. Authority to Appointment forms and
contracts are approved in accordance with the
Authority Matrix.
Payroll administrators process the new
appointments on the payroll system.
Contracts captured on the payroll system are reviewed for accuracy
of information captured by an independent
person.
A report of new appointments is
extracted from the payroll system and
reviewed by the relevant line manager.
End of employment contract/termination forms
are completed and signed by employee and relevant Line Manager and forwarded to
Payroll for processing together with supporting
documents.
Payroll administrators process the terminations on
the payroll system. No further provisions made to
NBCRFI
Terminations captured on the payroll system are
reviewed by for accuracy by an independent person.
A report of new appointments is
extracted from the payroll system and
reviewed by the relevant line manager.
D
D
P
P
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
3
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.3. Payments to NBCRFI:
1.3.1. GMS – Tank Terminals
Request for payments to NBCRFI and SANLAM are prepared by Payroll Administrator. RFPs are reviewed against NBC Online Return and SANLAM D-Form Report and authorised by Payroll Specialist.
Payroll Administrator extracts a pre-numbered D Form report from SAP
reflecting amounts to be paid to NBC in respect of provisions per employee. (Leave pay, sick pay, bonus pay, admin levy, agency shop, SATAWU, TAWUAS and
wellness fees)
Payroll Administrator prepares GL Costing detailing the provisions. The GL Costing is reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
On line NBCRFI Return is completed by the Payroll Administrator based on information on the D-Form Report per employee. A Three way review is performed between the GL Costing, D Form Report and Online Return by the Payroll Specialist for accuracy. Anomalies are identified and investigated.
Monthly reconciliation of amounts paid to NBC and SANLAM is prepared by Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
Payments are then loaded on the banking system by the Payroll Administrator / Finance Clerk on Standard Bank Business Online (CATS).
Payments are then released by two authorised signatories as per the banking profiles.
GMS makes monthly provisional payments to NBCRFI on behalf of
Tank Terminals employees belonging to NBCRFI. The
provisions include: Leave pay, sick pay, bonus pay, admin levy, agency
shop, SATAWU, TAWUSA and wellness fees. In respect of provident fund payments,
payments are made to Sanlam. Payroll Administrator extracts a pre-
numbered D Form report from SAP reflecting provident fund amounts payable per employee to SANLAM.
Prior payment release, an independent review of payments loaded on the banking system is agreed to the payment amounts on the Sanlam D-Form Report and Online NBC Return/D-Form Report to ensure that the correct amounts have been loaded.
NBCRFI payments (bonus pay, admin levy, agency shop
and wellness fees,etc)
SANLAM payments (provident fund)
Monthly bank recon is prepared by Payroll Specialist and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
P
P
D D
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
4
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.3.2. Intermodal (Dry Bulk)
Request for payments to NBCRFI and SANLAM are prepared by Payroll Administrator. RFPs are reviewed against NBC Online Return and SANLAM D-Form Report and authorised by Payroll Manager.
Payroll Administrator extracts a pre-numbered D Form report from
Accpac reflecting amounts to be paid to NBC in respect of provisions per employee. (bonus pay, annual
leave, sick leave, admin levy, agency shop and wellness fees,
SATAWU, TAWUSA)
Payroll Administrator prepares GL Costing detailing the provisions. The GL Costing is reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
On line NBCRFI Return is completed by the Payroll Administrator based on information on the D-Form Report per employee. A Three way review is performed between the GL Costing, D Form Report and Online Return by the Payroll Manager for accuracy. Anomalies are identified and investigated.
Monthly reconciliation of amounts paid to NBC and SANLAM is prepared by Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
Payments are then loaded on the banking system by the Payroll Administrator / Finance Clerk on Standard Bank Business Online (CATS).
Payments are then released by two authorised signatories as per the banking profiles.
Intermodal makes monthly provisional payments to NBCRFI on behalf of employees belonging to NBCRFI. The provisions include:
bonus pay, annual leave, sick leave, admin levy, agency shop and
wellness fees, SATAWU, TAWUSA. In respect of provident fund
payments, payments are made to Sanlam.
Payroll Administrator extracts a pre-numbered D Form report from Accpac
reflecting provident fund amounts payable per employee to SANLAM.
Prior payment release, an independent review of payments loaded on the banking system is agreed to the payment amounts on the Sanlam D-Form Report and Online NBC Return/D-Form Report to ensure that the correct amounts have been loaded.
NBCRFI payments (bonus pay, annual
leave, sick leave, admin levy, agency shop and wellness
fees, etc)
SANLAM payments (provident fund)
Monthly bank recon is prepared by Finance Clerk and reviewed by the Finance Manager.
P
P
D D
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
5
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.3.3. Fuel Logic
Request for payments to NBCRFI and SANLAM are prepared by Payroll Administrator. RFPs are reviewed against NBC Online Return and SANLAM D-Form Report and authorised by Payroll Manager.
Payroll Administrator extracts a pre-numbered D Form report from
Pastel reflecting amounts to be paid to NBC in respect of provisions per
employee. (bonus pay, annual leave, sick leave, admin levy,
agency shop and wellness fees)
Payroll Administrator prepares GL Costing detailing the provisions. The GL Costing is reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
On line NBCRFI Return is completed by the Payroll Administrator based on information on the D-Form Report per employee. A Three way review is performed between the GL Costing, D Form Report and Online Return by the Payroll Manager for accuracy. Anomalies are identified and investigated.
Monthly reconciliation of amounts paid to NBC and SANLAM is prepared by Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
Payments are then loaded on the banking system by the Payroll Administrator / Finance Clerk on Standard Bank Business Online (CATS).
Payments are then released by two authorised signatories as per the banking profiles.
Intermodal makes monthly provisional payments to NBCRFI on behalf of employees belonging to NBCRFI. The provisions include:
bonus pay, annual leave, sick leave, admin levy, agency shop and wellness fees. In respect of provident fund payments,
payments are made to Sanlam. Payroll Administrator extracts a pre-
numbered D Form report from Pastel reflecting provident fund amounts payable per employee to SANLAM.
Prior payment release, an independent review of payments loaded on the banking system is agreed to the payment amounts on the Sanlam D-Form Report and Online NBC Return/D-Form Report to ensure that the correct amounts have been loaded.
NBCRFI payments (bonus pay, annual
leave, sick leave, admin levy, agency shop and wellness
fees)
SANLAM payments (provident fund)
Monthly bank recon is prepared by Finance Clerk and reviewed by the Finance Manager.
P
P
D D
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
6
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.4. Leave processing:
1.4.1. GMS – Tank Terminals
Annual and sick leave taken during the year is
paid directly to employees by Tank Terminals.
At year end, The Payroll Administrator extracts a leave
report (annual/sick leave) from the system of NBC employees.
(report indicates all leave taken and paid to date).
The normal leave application process applies
when leave is taken (application filled out and approved by relevant line management as per the
authority matrix)
The NBC online return is completed by the Payroll
Administrator based on the information in the system leave
report.
Prior to submitting the NBC return, the return is agreed to the
leave report by the Payroll Specialist to ensure that the claim
amount is correct.
The return is then
submitted to NBC for
leave payment
recovery. (Refer to
1.6.2. – leave payment
recovery)
A reconciliation of the leave
paid/taken during the year and
the leave recovery payment
received from NBC is prepared
by the Payroll Administrator
and reviewed by the Payroll
Specialist. D
P
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
7
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.4.2. Intermodal (Dry Bulk) & Fuel Logic:
Annual and sick leave taken during the year is
paid directly to employees by NBC.
The normal leave application process applies
when leave is taken (application filled out and approved by relevant line management as per the
authority matrix)
When employee’s takes leave (annual/sick), the approved leave application forms are
submitted to NBC by the Payroll Administrator. (sick notes must
be submitted to NBC for sick leave taken)
NBC then pays employees directly for leave taken.
The leave taken is then processed as “unpaid” against the relevant employees profile by the Payroll Administrator on
SAP.
A leave report is extracted from the system by the Payroll
Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor to ensure
that all unpaid leave is accounted for.
D
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
8
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.5. Interim Movements
1.5.1. Terminations during the year
TANK TERMINALS
Signed End of contract/termination form together with supporting
documents (resignation letters, dicsiplinary outcomes,
retrenchments) forwarded to Payroll to process.
Payroll processes terminations on SAP. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll
Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on SAP.
Payroll Administrator then prepares a claim to NBCRFI for all leave days taken and paid to
employee up to point of termination. No further leave
payments are made to employees.
Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of all leave taken and paid out to the respective employee up to
the point of termination.
A review of the system leave report and the NBC Claim is
performed by the Payroll Specialist to ensure that the correct number of leave paid out to the employee is being
recorded on the NBC Claim for recovery.
The NBC Claim application is then forwarded to NBC for
recovery of leave paid out to employees.
Monthly bank recon is prepared by Payroll Specialist and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
NBC deposits payment in to GMS bank account. The bank
statement is then printed from the banking system and
reconciled to the NBC online return by the Payroll
Administrator (GMS) to ensure that the correct amount has
been received.
Tank Terminals bank account is then credited
with the payment by Payroll (GMS)
A reconciliation of the leave
paid during the year to the
leave recovery payment
received from NBC is prepared
by the Payroll Administrator
and reviewed by the Payroll
Specialist.
Monthly bank recon is prepared by Finance Clerk and reviewed by the Finance Manager.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
9
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
INTERMODAL (DRY BULK) & FUEL LOGIC
Signed End of contract/termination form together with supporting
documents (resignation letters, dicsiplinary outcomes,
retrenchments) forwarded to Payroll to process.
Payroll processes terminations on the system. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on the system.
Should any leave payments be due to the terminated employee,
completed and approved leave application are forwarded to
NBC by the Payroll Administrator to pay employee
directly.
Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of
all leave taken and processed as “unpaid” in respect of the specific employee up to the
point of termination. The report is then reviewed by the
Payroll Supervisor to ensure accuracy and completeness.
Employee is paid directly by NBC
No further leave provisions are paid to
NBC.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
10
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.5.2. Death of employee
TANK TERMINALS
Signed End of contract/termination form together with supporting
documents (resignation letters, dicsiplinary outcomes,
retrenchments) forwarded to Payroll to process.
Payroll processes terminations on SAP. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll
Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on SAP.
Payroll Administrator then prepares a claim to NBCRFI for all leave days taken and paid to employee up to point of death. No further leave payments are
made to employees by Terminals.
Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of all leave taken and paid out to the respective employee up to
the point of death.
A review of the system leave report and the NBC Claim is
performed by the Payroll Specialist to ensure that the correct number of leave paid out to the employee is being
recorded on the NBC Claim for recovery.
The NBC Claim application is then forwarded to NBC for
recovery of leave paid out to employees.
Monthly bank recon is prepared by Finance Clerk and reviewed by the Finance Manager.
NBC deposits payment in to GMS bank account. The bank
statement is then printed from the banking system and
reconciled to the NBC online return by the Payroll
Administrator (GMS) to ensure that the correct amount has
been received.
Tank Terminals bank account is then credited
with the payment by Payroll (GMS)
Monthly bank recon is prepared by Payroll Specialist and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
A reconciliation of the leave
paid during the year to the
leave recovery payment
received from NBC is prepared
by the Payroll Administrator
and reviewed by the Payroll
Specialist.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
11
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
INTERMODAL (DRY BULK) & FUEL LOGIC
Signed End of contract/termination form together with supporting
documents (resignation letters, dicsiplinary outcomes,
retrenchments) forwarded to Payroll to process.
Payroll processes terminations on the system. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on the system.
Should any leave payments be due to the deceased employee, completed and approved leave applications are forwarded to
NBC by the Payroll Administrator to pay employee directly.
Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of
all leave taken and processed as “unpaid” in respect of the specific employee up to the point of death. The report is then reviewed by the Payroll
Supervisor to ensure accuracy and completeness.
No further leave provisions are paid to
NBC.
Beneficiaries of the deceased employee are
paid directly by NBC.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
12
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.5.3. EMPLOYEE TRANSFERS BENEFITS
TANK TERMINALS, INTERMODAL (DRY BULK), FUEL LOGIC
1
Every employee belonging to NBCRFI has a unique levy number identifying them to
the specific Business Unit where they are employed
at.
Two scenarios arise here
Employee transfered to another division within the Group
Employee joins new company
Payroll informs NBCRFI of the transfer and the provisional payments carry on as normal.
Payroll terminates employee and informs NBCRFI of the termination. The employee can be
linked to NBCRFI if the new company is also linked to NBCRFI or can be paid out by NBCRFI directly. No further provisions paid by GMS to
NBCRFI.
1
2
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
13
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.5. Application for funds from NBCRFI
1.5.1. Bonuses: Tank Terminals, Intermodal (Dry Bulk), Fuel Logic
Recon 2: Year-end reconciliation prepared by the
Payroll Administrator between total provisions paid
during the year and the online NBCRFI return at year
end. Recon reviewed by Payroll Specialist.
Yes
No
Recon 1: Year-end reconciliation prepared by the Payroll Administrator between Wage Type Report
extracted from SAP + Year End Payments and NBCFRI Schedule and reviewed by Payroll Specialist.
At year end, Payroll Administrator completes NBCFRI online return at end of
October applying for funds to pay employee bonuses. Online Return is
reviewed by Payroll Specialist prior to return being submitted to NBCRFI.
If any queries on NBC Online Return, NBC will
follow up with Payroll and resolved.
If no queries on NBC Online Return
NBCRFI forwards online return together with a payout
schedule and remittance advice per employee to Payroll.
NBC deposits payment in to respective Business Units bank account. A review is performed between the NBC Online return
submitted by Payroll and the NBC Payout schedule to ensure that correct amount has been
received.
Payments made to employees by Payroll as per NBC Payout Schedule
for bonuses. Bonus pay outs are reflected on
employee salary slips in the month paid out.
NBCRFI reviews Online Return. Any queries identified.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
14
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
1.6.2. Leave payment recovery: Tank Terminals only
Yes
No
At year end, Payroll Administrator completes NBCFRI online return at end of
October for recovery of leave pay outs made to employees during the year. Online Return is reviewed by Payroll
Specialist prior to return being submitted to NBCRFI.
If any queries on NBC Online Return, NBC will
follow up with Payroll and resolved.
If no queries on NBC Online Return
Tank Terminals bank account is then credited
with the payment by Payroll (GMS)
NBC deposits payment in to GMS bank account. The bank statement is
then printed from the banking system and reconciled to the NBC
online return by the Payroll Administrator (GMS) to ensure that
the correct amount has been received.
Bank recon is prepared by Finance Clerk and reviewed by the Finance Manager
A leave report is extracted from the system
highlighting all leave taken and paid out to employees
during the year.
The NBC online return is completed by the
Administrator based on the information in the leave report extracted
from the system.
Prior to submitting the NBC return, the return is agreed
to the leave report by Payroll Specialist to ensure
that the claim is correct.
NBCRFI reviews Online Return. Any queries identified.
Bank recon is prepared by Payroll Specialist and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
A reconciliation of the leave
paid during the year to the
leave recovery payment
received from NBC is prepared
by the Payroll Administrator
and reviewed by the Payroll
Specialist.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
15
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
2. Process Narratives
2.1. Background National Bargaining Council for the Road Freight Industry (NBCRFI) is a service centred organisation whose core function is to manage
conditions of employment between road freight and logistics industry in order to ensure labour stability within the industry. NBCRFI also
provides benefits to its members through managing their annual leave, sick leave and holiday bonus. Employees of Grindrod Logistics belong to
the NBCRFI and their annual leave, sick leave and holiday bonus are managed by NBCRFI.
Grindrod Management Services makes monthly provisional payments to NBCRFI on behalf of Tank Terminal employees in respect of sick leave,
annual leave and holiday bonus. Intermodal (Dry Bulk) and Fuel Logic makes their own provisional payments directly to NBCRFI.
2.2. Additions of new employees on the payroll system - (Handover from Payroll) Contracts are signed by Line Managers of Logistics in accordance with the Authority Matrix. The approved contracts, together with signed “Authority to Appointment Forms” and supporting documents are forwarded to Payroll for capturing on the system by the Payroll Administrator. Information captured on the system is then reviewed by an Independent Payroll Administrator (other than the Administrator who captured the specific contract) against the original contract information to ensure accuracy of information captured on SAP. A SAP printout of employees belonging to NBCFRI can be extracted for audit query purposes.
2.3. Terminations of employees on the payroll system – (Hand over from Payroll)
End of Contract/Termination forms is completed and signed by the employee and relevant Line Manager and forwarded to Payroll with supporting documents (resignation letters, death certificates, disciplinary outcomes) for processing and capturing on the system by the Payroll Administrators. Terminations captured on the system is then reviewed by an Independent Payroll Administrator (other than the Administrator who captured the specific termination) to ensure accuracy of information captured on the system. A system printout of employees belonging to NBCRFI who has been terminated can be extracted for audit query purposes.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
16
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
2.4. Payments to NBCRFI & SANLAM:
2.4.1. GMS – Tank Terminals
GMS makes monthly provisional payments on behalf of Tank Terminals employees belonging to NBCFRI to NBCRFI and Sanlam. All NBCRFI
employees are entitled to 15 days annual leave and 12 days sick leave per annum.
The provisional payments include:
NBCRFI
Bonuses
Leave pay
Sick pay
OTHER PAYMENTS
Admin fees
Agency shop fess
Wellness fees
Union fees (SATAWU & TAWUSA)
SANLAM
Provident fund
On a monthly basis, the Payroll Administrator responsible for the administration of the NBCFRI Account, extracts a SAP pre-numbered “D-Form
Report” reflecting amounts to be paid over to NBCRFI in respect of the provisions and prepares a “GL Costing” based on the D Form Report.
The GL Costing and the D-Form Report is then reviewed and signed by the Payroll Specialist. With regards to the provident fund payments to
Sanlam, the D-Form report is extracted from SANLAM’s system and the payroll system and reconciled by the Payroll Administrator to ensure
that the payment amounts are correct.
An “Online NBCFRI Return” detailing the provisions per employee is then completed by the Payroll Administrator based on the information of
the D Form Report. A three way match between the GL Costing, SAP D-Form Report and Online NBCRFI Return is then performed by the Payroll
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
17
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
Specialist to ensure accuracy. Any anomalies identified are investigated. A request for payment (RFP) is then prepared by the Payroll
Administrator for NBCRFI and SANLAM payments and signed off by the Payroll Specialist as evidence of review prior to processing.
The payment is then loaded onto the online banking system by the Payroll Administrator/Finance Clerk and released by any two of the four
authorised signatories as per the banking profiles. Prior to releasing the payment, a review is performed of the payments loaded on the banking
system to the RFP and D-Form reports to ensure that the correct payment amounts have been loaded on the banking system. A monthly
reconciliation of amounts paid to NBCRFI and SANLAM is prepared by the Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
A monthly bank recon is prepared by the Payroll Specialist and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
2.4.2. Intermodal (Dry Bulk) & Fuel Logic:
Intermodal and Fuel Logic makes monthly provisions to NBCRFI on behalf of employees belonging to NBCRFI (50% employee contribution and
50% employer contribution).
The provisional payments include:
NBCRFI
Bonuses
Annual and sick leave
Admin levies
Agency shop fees
Wellness fees
Union fees (SATAWU & TAWUSA)
SANLAM
Provident fund
On a monthly basis, the Payroll Administrator responsible for the administration of the NBCFRI Account, extracts a SAP pre-numbered “D-Form
Report” reflecting amounts to be paid over to NBCRFI in respect of the provisions and prepares a “GL Costing” based on the D Form Report.
The GL Costing and the D-Form Report is then reviewed and signed by the Payroll Specialist. With regards to the provident fund payments to
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
18
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
Sanlam, the D-Form report is extracted from SANLAM’s system and the payroll system and reconciled by the Payroll Administrator to ensure
that the payment amounts are correct.
An “Online NBCFRI Return” detailing the provisions per employee is then completed by the Payroll Administrator based on the information of
the D Form Report. A three way match between the GL Costing, SAP D-Form Report and Online NBCRFI Return is then performed by the Payroll
Specialist to ensure accuracy. Any anomalies identified are investigated. A request for payment (RFP) is then prepared by the Payroll
Administrator for NBCRFI and SANLAM payments and signed off by the Payroll Specialist as evidence of review prior to processing.
The payment is then loaded onto the online banking system by the Payroll Administrator/Finance Clerk and released by any two of the four
authorised signatories as per the banking profiles. Prior to releasing the payment, a review is performed of the payments loaded on the banking
system to the RFP and D-Form reports to ensure that the correct payment amounts have been loaded on the banking system. A monthly
reconciliation of amounts paid to NBCRFI and SANLAM is prepared by the Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
A monthly bank recon is prepared by the Finance Clerk and reviewed by the Finance Manager.
2.5. Leave processing:
2.5.1. GMS – Tank Terminals:
Annual and sick leave taken during the year is paid directly to employees by GMS on behalf of Tank Terminals and recovered from NBCRFI at
year end. The normal leave application process applies when leave is taken (leave applications are filled out and approved by the relevant line
manager as per the authority matrix).
At year end, the Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report (annual/sick leave) from the system of NBCRFI employees (report indicates all
leave taken and paid to date). The NBCRFI online return is completed by the Payroll Administrator based on the information in the system leave
report. Prior to submitting the NBCRFI, the return is agreed to the leave report by the Payroll Specialist to ensure that the claim amount is
correct. The return is then submitted to NBC for the leave payment recovery (refer to the leave payment recovery process narratives).
A reconciliation of the leave paid/taken during the year and the leave recovery payment received from NBC is prepared by the Payroll
Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
19
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
2.5.2. Intermodal (Dry Bulk) & Fuel Logic:
Annual and sick leave taken during the year is paid directly to employees by NBC. The normal leave application process applies when leave is
taken (leave applications are filled out and approved by the relevant line manager as per the authority matrix). When employees takes leave
(annual/sick leave), the approved leave application forms are submitted to NBC by the Payroll Administrator (all sick leave must be supported
by sick notes). A leave report is extracted from the system by the Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist to ensure that all
unpaid leave is accounted for.
2.6. Interim movements During the year, employees may be terminated by Payroll as a result of resignations, disciplinary outcomes or death. These movements are
dealt with as follows:
1. Terminations during the year
GMS – Tank Terminals:
An end of employment/termination form is completed and signed by the relevant line manager as per the authority matrix and forwarded to
payroll together with supporting documents (resignation letter, disciplinary outcome) for processing. Payroll processes terminations on the
payroll system. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on the system.
The Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of al leave taken and paid out to the respective employee up to the point of
termination. The Payroll Administrator then prepares a claim to NBCRFI for all leave days taken and paid to the employee up to the point of
termination. No further leave payments are made to the employee. A review of the system leave report and the NBC Claim is performed by the
Payroll Specialist to ensure that the correct number of leave paid out to the employee is being recorded on the NBC Claim for recovery.
The NBC Claim application is then forwarded to NBC for recovery of leave paid out to employees.
NBC deposits payment into GMS bank account. The bank statement is then printed from the banking system and reconciled to the NBC Online
Claim return by the Payroll Administrator (GMS) to ensure that the correct amount has been received. Tank Terminals bank account is then
credited with the payment by Payroll (GMS).
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
20
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
Intermodal (Dry Bulk) & Fuel Logic:
An end of employment/termination form is completed and signed by the relevant line manager as per the authority matrix and forwarded to
payroll together with supporting documents (resignation letter, disciplinary outcome) for processing. Payroll processes terminations on the
payroll system. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on the system.
The Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of al leave taken and processed as “unpaid” up to the point of termination in
respect of the specific employee. The report is reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor to ensure accuracy and completeness. Should any leave
payments be due to the terminated employee, completed and approved leave forms are forwarded to NBC by the Payroll Administrator to pay
employee directly. No further leave provisions are paid to NBC.
2. Death of employee during the year
GMS – Tank Terminals:
An end of employment/termination form is completed and signed by the relevant line manager as per the authority matrix and forwarded to
payroll together with supporting documents (resignation letter, disciplinary outcome) for processing. Payroll processes terminations on the
payroll system. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on the system.
The Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of al leave taken and paid out to the respective employee up to the point of
termination. The Payroll Administrator then prepares a claim to NBCRFI for all leave days taken and paid to the employee up to the point of
termination. No further leave payments are made to the employee. A review of the system leave report and the NBC Claim is performed by the
Payroll Specialist to ensure that the correct number of leave paid out to the employee is being recorded on the NBC Claim for recovery.
The NBC Claim application is then forwarded to NBC for recovery of leave paid out to employees.
NBC deposits payment into GMS bank account. The bank statement is then printed from the banking system and reconciled to the NBC Online
Claim return by the Payroll Administrator (GMS) to ensure that the correct amount has been received. Tank Terminals bank account is then
credited with the payment by Payroll (GMS).
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
21
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
Intermodal (Dry Bulk) & Fuel Logic:
An end of employment/termination form is completed and signed by the relevant line manager as per the authority matrix and forwarded to
payroll together with supporting documents (resignation letter, disciplinary outcome) for processing. Payroll processes terminations on the
payroll system. Terminations are reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor for accuracy of capturing on the system.
The Payroll Administrator extracts a leave report from the system of al leave taken and processed as “unpaid” up to the point of termination in
respect of the specific employee. The report is reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor to ensure accuracy and completeness. Should any leave
payments be due to the terminated employee, completed and approved leave forms are forwarded to NBC by the Payroll Administrator to pay
employee directly. No further leave provisions are paid to NBC.
3. Employee transfers benefits
GMS – Tank Terminals, Intermodal (Dry Bulk) & Fuel Logic:
Every employee belonging to NBCRFI has a Levy number used to uniquely identify a specific employee. Two scenarios arise here :
● If the employee is transferred to another division within the Group, Payroll informs NBCFRI of the transfer and the transfer has no impact on
the flow of the NBCRFI process involved. Provisional payments carries on as normal.
● If employee exits the business (resigns, terminates), and joins another company that belongs to the NBCRFI, the employee is then transferred
to the new company. The employee will be terminated as normal as in one above and no further provisions are made to NBCRFI in respect of
the terminated employee.
2.7. Application for funds from NBCRFI
2.7.1. Bonus application:
GMS – Tank Terminals, Intermodal (Dry Bulk) & Fuel Logic:
At year end, 31 October, being the Financial Year End for NBCRFI, Payroll applies for funds to pay employees in respect of the provisions paid
during the course of the year.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
22
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
Payroll Administrator prepares an NBCRFI Online Return Application applying for funds to pay employee bonuses. The Online Return is then
reviewed by the Payroll Specialist prior to the application being submitted to NBCRFI.
NBCRFI reviews the Online Return and forwards the Online Return together with a detailed Payout Schedule and attached remittance advices
per employee on the Online Return to Payroll. Amounts as per the Online Return is deposited into the respective BUs bank account.
A review is performed between the NBC online return submitted by Payroll and the NBC Pay out schedule to ensure that the correct amounts
has been received.
Payroll makes payments to employees in December based on the Payout Schedule received from NBCRFI. Payout amounts are reflected on
December employee salary slips.
The following reconciliations are prepared by the Payroll Administrator at year end :
Recon 1: reconciliation is performed as follows by the Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist : Wage Type Report
extracted from SAP plus manual payments made to employees is reconciled to the NBCRFI Online Return Application.
Note : Should the year end reconciliation between the SAP Wage Type Report plus the manual payments made to employees and the NBCRFI
Online Return not agree, the difference will equal to the interim movements which may have occurred during the year. These items will be
reconciled on the reconciliation.
Recon 2: reconciliation between total provisions made during the year and the year-end online NBCRFI return.
2.7.2. Leave payment recovery application:
GMS – Tank Terminals only:
At year end, the Payroll Administrator completes the NBCRFI online return at the end of October for recovery of leave pay outs made to
employees during the year. Online return is reviewed by the Payroll Specialist prior to the return being submitted to NBCRFI.
A leave report is extracted from the system highlighting all leave taken and paid out to employees during the year. The NBC online return is
completed by the Payroll Administrator based on the information in the leave report extracted from the system. Prior to submitting the NBC
return, the return is agreed to the leave report by the Payroll Specialist to ensure that the claim is correct. The return is then submitted to NBC.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
23
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
NBC deposits payment in to GMS bank account. The bank statement is then printed from the banking system and reconciled to the NBC online
return by the Payroll Administrator (GMS) to ensure that the correct amount has been received. GMS then credits Tank Terminals with the
payment received.
A reconciliation of the leave paid during the year to the leave recovery payment received from NBC is prepared by the Payroll Administrator
and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
24
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
3. Control Objectives
1. Only valid contracts are processed and captured on the system.
2. Only valid terminations are processed and captured on the system.
3. Valid and correct amounts are paid to NBCRFI/SANLAM and accounted for accurately.
4. Valid and correct amounts are paid to employees belonging to NBCRFI at year end and accounted for.
5. All unpaid leave of employees belonging to NBCRFI is correctly processed and accounted for.
6. All paid leave of employees belonging to NBCRFI is correctly processed and accounted for.
7. All leave paid out to employees belonging to NBCRFI during the year is recovered from NBCRFI.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
25
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
4. Control framework
1. Only valid contracts are processed and captured on the system.
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
1.1 An Authority to appoint Form is prepared by Talent and forwarded to the respective relevant Line Managers for approval as per the Approved Authority Matrix. Contracts of employment is produced and signed in accordance with the Approved Authority Matrix and forwarded to Payroll with supporting documents for processing on the payroll system.
Payroll Manager Payroll Supervisor
Per Contract Signed Authority to Appoint Forms Contracts with supporting documents Approved Authority Matrix.
1.2 An independent review is performed of contracts captured on the system to ensure accuracy of information processed.
Payroll Manager Payroll Supervisor
Per contract
Signed new appointments report
2. Only valid terminations are processed and captured on the system.
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
2.1 An End of Employment Contract / Termination form is completed and signed by the employee and relevant Line Manager. End of Employment Contract forms together with supporting documents are forwarded to Payroll for processing on payroll system.
Payroll Manager Payroll Supervisor
Per Contract Signed End of Employment Contract/Termination Forms Supporting documents( resignation letters, etc)
2.2 An independent review is performed by the Payroll Supervisor of terminations captured on the system to ensure accuracy of information processed. No further payments are processed in respect of terminated employees.
Payroll Manager Payroll Supervisor
Per
termination
Signed SAP terminations report
2.3 The termination date is captured by the Payroll Administrator based on the details per the authorised end of contract employee form.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Ongoing Signed End of Employment Contract/Termination Forms
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
26
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
3. Valid and correct amounts are paid to NBCRFI/SANLAM and accounted for accurately.
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
NBC Provisions: 3.1 A pre-numbered D-Form report is extracted
from the payroll system detailing the provisions (bonus pay, admin levy, agency shop and wellness fees). A detailed GL Costing is prepared by the Payroll Administrator based on the D-Form report and an online NBCRFI return is completed. A reconciliation of the D-Form report, GL Costing and the online NBC return is prepared by Payroll administrator and reviewed by Payroll specialist.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Monthly Signed reconciliation with supporting documents
NBC Provisions: 3.2 A pre-numbered D-Form report is extracted
from the payroll system detailing provisions (sick leave, annual leave, bonus pay, admin levy, agency shop and wellness fees). A detailed GL Costing is prepared by the Payroll Administrator based on the D-Form report and an online NBCRFI return is completed. A reconciliation of the D-Form report, GL Costing and the online NBC return is prepared by Payroll administrator and reviewed by Payroll specialist.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Monthly Signed reconciliation with supporting documents
SANLAM Provident fund provision: 3.3 A reconciliation of the Sanlam D-Form report
and the online NBC return is prepared by Payroll administrator and reviewed by Payroll specialist
Payroll Manager Finance Clerk Monthly
Signed reconciliation with supporting documents.
NBC/SANLAM Payments: 3.4 A request for payment (RFP) is prepared by the
Payroll Administrator, signed off by the Payroll Specialist and forwarded to Finance to process payment.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Monthly
Signed RFP with supporting documents
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
27
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
Payment release: NBC/SANLAM 3.5 RFP is uploaded onto the banking system by the
Payroll Administrator/Finance Clerk and is released by two authorised signatories as per the LOA’s.
Payroll Manager Finance Clerk Monthly
Signed RFP Signed business online audit report LOA’s
Bank recon: 3.6. The bank reconciliation is prepared by the Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Manager.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Monthly
Signed and dated bank recon
Bank recon: 3.6. The bank reconciliation is prepared by the Finance Clerk and reviewed by the Finance Manager.
Finance Manager Finance Clerk Monthly
Signed and dated bank recon
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
28
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
4. Valid and correct amounts are paid to employees belonging to NBCRFI at year end and accounted for.
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
Bonus application: 4.1 An Online NBCFRI Return Application is
completed by the Payroll Administrator for the bonus application and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist prior to being submitted to NBCRFI.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Annually Signed Online NBCRFI Return Application
Pre Bonus pay-outs: 4.2 Payments loaded on the banking system by the
Payroll Administrator/Finance Clerk are reviewed by Payroll Manager for evidence of accuracy prior to release f the payments. (Hand over to Payroll)
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Annually
Authorised NBCRFI Payout Schedule Signed provisional online payment release report Dummy employee payslips
Post bonus pay-outs: 4.3 Pay-outs are released on the banking system by
authorised signatories as per the authority matrix. (Hand over to Payroll)
Payroll Manager Payroll Manager Annually Banking profiles Signed business online audit report.
4.4 Year-end reconciliation is prepared by the Payroll Administrator of amounts received from NBCRFI and paid to employees. The recon is reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Annually
Signed reconciliation with supporting documents ( Wage type report, manual payments, NBCRFI Payout Schedule)
4.5 Year-end reconciliation between total provisions made during the year to NBC and the online NBCRFI return is prepared by the Payroll administrator and reviewed by the Payroll specialist.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Annually
Signed reconciliation with supporting documents
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
29
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
5. All unpaid leave of employees belonging to NBCRFI is correctly processed and accounted for.
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner
Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
Leave form approval: 5.1 All leave forms of employees belonging to
NBCRFI are approved by the respective line managers as per the approved authority matrix and submitted to Payroll for processing 7 days prior to employees going on leave.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Per leave
application
Authorised leave application Approved authority matrix
Sick leave: 5.2 All sick leave forms submitted to NBC are
supported by a medical certificate.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Per leave
application
Authorised sick leave application Supporting medical certificate
Unpaid leave processing: 5.3 Leave applications of NBCRFI employees are
processed as unpaid on the system by Payroll. Payroll deducts amounts as per number of days on the leave forms from the employee’s salary .Deductions captured on SAP are reviewed by independent administrators.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrators
Ongoing Authorised leave application Signed dummy employee payslips
System leave report: 5.4 A leave report is extracted from the system and
reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor to ensure that all unpaid leave is accounted for.
Payroll Supervisor Payroll Supervisor
Monthly Signed leave report
Manual leave form file: 5.5 A manual file of leave forms of all NBCRFI
employees is maintained by the Payroll administrator. All leave forms are future dated.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrators
Ongoing Manual file of leave application forms future dated.
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
30
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
6. All paid leave of employees belonging to NBCRFI is correctly processed and accounted for.
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner
Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
Leave form approval: 6.1 All leave forms of employees belonging to
NBCRFI are approved by the respective line managers as per the approved authority matrix and submitted to Payroll for processing 7 days prior to employees going on leave.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Per leave
application
Authorised leave application Approved authority matrix
System leave report: 6.2 A leave report is extracted from the system and
reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor to ensure that all paid leave is accounted for.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrators
Monthly Signed leave report
NBCRFI – CONTROL FRAMEWORKS
31
Confidential Grindrod Internal Audit
7. All leave paid out to employees belonging to NBCRFI during the year is recovered from NBCRFI.
Key Controls Process Owner Control Owner
Frequency Evidence GMS-Tank Terminals
Intermodal Fuel Logic
System Leave report: 7.1 A leave report is extracted from the system and
reviewed by the Payroll Supervisor to ensure that all paid leave is accounted for.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Monthly Signed leave report
NBCRFI Online claim return: 7.2 The NBC Online leave claim return is reconciled
to the system leave report by the Payroll Specialist to ensure that the leave claim days are correct.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrators
Annual Signed leave report Signed NBC leave claim return
Receipts: 7.3 The bank statement is printed off the banking
system and reconciled to the NBC Online leave claim return by the Payroll Administrator to ensure that the correct leave payment amount has been recovered.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Annual Signed bank statements Signed NBCRFI online leave claim return
Recon: 7.4 A recon of the leave paid to employees during
the year and the NBCRFI leave claim return is prepared by the Payroll Administrator and reviewed by the Payroll Specialist.
Payroll Specialist Payroll Administrator
Annual Signed recon with supporting documents
Tank Terminals credit: 7.5 Leave payments received from NBCRFI is paid over to Tank Terminals by GMS.
Payroll Manager Payroll Administrator
Annual Signed bank statements with supporting NBCRFI leave payment proof