GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1,...

34
GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1 , Nelson Pulido 2 , Anibal Ojeda 3 , Kuvvet Atakan 1 , Mustafa Erdik 4 1 Department of Earth Science, University of Bergen, Norway, 2 Earthquake Disaster Mitigation Research Center EDM, NIED, Kobe, Japan, 3 INGEOMINAS, Bogota, Colombia, 4 Kandilli Observatory and Earthquake Research Institute, Bogazici

description

This study Hybrid method for simulating ground motions due to finite-extent earthquake source in Marmara Sea Pulido and Kubo (2004): Deterministic at low frequencies, semi-stochastic at high frequencies Simulation on irregular grid of Istanbul Earthquake Rapid Response and Early Warning System stations

Transcript of GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1,...

Page 1: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN

ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen1, Nelson Pulido2,

Anibal Ojeda3, Kuvvet Atakan1, Mustafa Erdik4

1Department of Earth Science, University of Bergen, Norway, 2Earthquake Disaster Mitigation Research Center EDM, NIED, Kobe, Japan, 3INGEOMINAS, Bogota, Colombia, 4Kandilli Observatory and Earthquake Research Institute, Bogazici University, Istanbul, Turkey.

Page 2: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Westward migration of earthquakes on the NAF

after Barka et. al. (2002)

Page 3: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

This study• Hybrid method for simulating ground motions

due to finite-extent earthquake source in Marmara Sea

• Pulido and Kubo (2004): Deterministic at low frequencies, semi-stochastic at high frequencies

• Simulation on irregular grid of Istanbul Earthquake Rapid Response and Early Warning System stations

Page 4: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Istanbul Earthquake Rapid Response and Early

Warning System

Page 5: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Rapid Response system• 100 accelerometer stations• When triggered, station produces spectral

acceleration at a number of frequencies, 12 Hz filtered PGA and PGV

• Data sent pr SMS every 20 s• Main data center produces shake, damage

and casualty maps, which are available to the end-users within 5 min

Page 6: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Istanbul Earthquake Rapid Response and Early

Warning System

Page 7: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Early Warning system• 10 accelerometer stations close to the

Marmara fault • When several stations triggers an

alarm is declared • Alarm level is sent to critical facilities,

which can then shut down before the earthquake strikes

Page 8: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Use of simulation results

• Calibration of Rapid Response system parameters

• Calibration of Early Warning system parameters • Realistic scenario input for producing shake,

damage and casualty maps• Comparison to recorded earthquakes

Page 9: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Ground motion evaluation from asperity model

Page 10: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Ground motion simulation technique

• Low frequency: Deterministic wave propagation from an asperity model in a flat layered velocity structure (Discrete Wave Number Method, Bouchon 1981)

• High Frequency: Semi-Stochastic Simulation based on an asperity model . The model combines the stochastic methodology of Boore (1986) with the empirical Green’s function method of Irikura (1986), and a high frequency radiation pattern model (Pulido et. al 2002).

Page 11: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Scenario earthquake

Active tectonic map of the Marmara Sea (Okay et. al 2000)

Page 12: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Source parametersTotal seismic moment M0 = 2.0·1020 Nm

Asperity area Sa/S = 0.22

Average stress drop 5 MPa

Asperity stress drop 10 Mpa

Rise time Random, average 3.0 s

Rupture velocity Random between 2.8 – 3.2 km/s

fmax 10 Hz

Q 100 · f1.5

Page 13: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Velocity model

Page 14: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

PGV results

Page 15: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

PGA results

Page 16: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

PGV

Page 17: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

PGA

Page 18: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Waveform exampleAvcilar district

Page 19: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

GM3D

Page 20: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.
Page 21: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Tectonic Setting Marmara Sea Region

Okay et. al 2000

Page 22: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Scenario Earthquake

Active tectonic map of the Marmara Sea (Okay et. al 2000)

Page 23: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Scenario Earthquake 1b

Active tectonic map of the Marmara Sea (Okay et. al 2000)

Page 24: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Scenario Earthquake 2

Active tectonic map of the Marmara Sea (Okay et. al 2000)

Page 25: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Scenario Earthquake 3

Active tectonic map of the Marmara Sea (Okay et. al 2000)

Page 26: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

High Frequency Radiation Pattern Model

P-wave SH-wave SV-waveLow

Frequency

< 1HzNon-spherical

HighFrequencySpherical

> 3 HzThe region between 1 to 3 Hz is a transition between the theoretical radiation of a double couple to a completely stochastic radiation

Page 27: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Asperities and Seismicity

After Gurbuz et. al. (2000), Tectonic fault model from Okay (2000)

Page 28: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Fault Segments Parameters

Hypocenter located at a depth of 10 km

The depth seismogenic zone is 20 km

Page 29: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Variability of the Simulated Ground Motion

Page 30: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Simulated Spectra and Turkish Seismic Code

Turkish Seismic Code, Aydinoglu (1998)

Page 31: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Deterministic vs Probabilistic PGA Distribution

PGA values for a 10% of excedance in 50 years (Atakan et. al. 2002)

PGA from scenario earthquake 1a

Page 32: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Avcilar district

Page 33: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.

Sultanahmet district

Page 34: GROUND MOTION SIMULATIONS AT RAPID RESPONSE SITES IN ISTANBUL, TURKEY Mathilde Bøttger Sørensen 1, Nelson Pulido 2, Anibal Ojeda 3, Kuvvet Atakan 1, Mustafa.