Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ......

22
Ashtabula Municipal Court Defendant Time-in-Court Study Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of Ohio January 19, 2017

Transcript of Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ......

Page 1: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

AshtabulaMunicipalCourtDefendantTime-in-CourtStudy

GreenBeltProjectReportOutAlanOhmanSupremeCourtofOhioJanuary19,2017

Page 2: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

CourtTeam

SupremeCourtofOhio§ AlanOhman,Administrative

Officer§ TashaRuth,Manager,CMP§ ColleenRosshirt,PolicyCounsel§ NikoleHotchkiss,Statistics

Analyst

AshtabulaMunicipalCourt§ TonjaAmato,CourtAdministrator§ NickDearing,Network

Administrator/DeputyClerk

Page 3: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Background- Scope§ AshtabulaMunicipalCourtislookingtoimproveitscaseflow efficiencyviatechnology.

§ Opportunitystatement:withthefutureadditionoftheBenchProcessing program,thecourtlookstoincreasethespeedatwhichcasesareprocessedthroughthesystemanddefendantsareseen,receivetheirpaperwork,andleave.

§ FirstStep:Defendantenterscourthouse.§ LastStep:Defendantreceivesallnecessarypaperworkandleavescourthouse.

3

Page 4: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

ProjectGoals

4

• Thecourt’sownmissionstatement:TheAshtabulaMunicipalCourtshallbeeffectiveandefficient whenresolvingdisputesinordertoupholdthelawsandregulationsofthecourt’sjurisdictionandtheStateofOhio.

• Thecourtistransitioningtoanelectroniccaseflow system.Theprimarygoal–currently–iscollectingdatatosupportthetimeandeffortputintoestablishingthenewsystem.

Page 5: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Current-StateProcessMap

5

=stepwillbealtered/eliminatedbyBenchProcessing software

Page 6: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Let’sMakeitSimpler…

Page 7: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

DataCollectionPlan

7

- CompletedbyNickandTonjaasdefendantscameintocourt

Page 8: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Baselinedata

8

Page 9: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

TotalCases

9

0

50

100

150

200

250

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37

Combined

Civil Traffic Criminal

Case

MinutesinCou

rt

Page 10: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Stop!Hammer GraphTime!

Page 11: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Stat-BasicStat-GraphicalSummary

11

Page 12: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Let’sseesomemoreofthosegraphs!

Page 13: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Doesdatematter?

13

(Notreally.)

Page 14: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Wellthen…howaboutcasetype?

14

(Yep.Kindof.)

Page 15: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Isthisdataevenincontrol?!

15

(No.Butlessout-of-controlthanexpected.)

Page 16: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

SpecsDefined

16

• Followingbaselinedataanalysisofallcases,administratorsconferredregardinggoaltime-spent-in-court

• Ultimatelydetermined0-45mins.isoptimal(coversallcasetypes)

Page 17: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Okay,soisthisdatawithinspec?!

17

(No.Notevenremotelyclose.)

Page 18: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

CourtesyK.C.Green

Page 19: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Asa result…§ Wenowhavedatatocomparetothefuturedata!§ SotuneinnexttimeforAlan’sBlackBeltproject;seehisbreathtaking,action-packedanalysisofbaselinevs.implementationdata!

§ Willthedatabeinspec?WillBenchProcessing makeasignificantimpact?And,mostimportantly,willAlansavetheday?

19CourtesyNBC

Page 20: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

Implementation/FuturePlan

Task Who When Status

InitiateBenchProcessing

software

Nick BeginningOctober 2016

Ongoing– rollouttodifferentcase

typesTimestudy/collection

Tonja/Nick Beginningearly2017

Ongoing

Dataanalyzed Alan TBD Planning

Finalreportissued Alan TBD Planning

20

Page 21: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov

ProjectBenefits- Expected

§ Defendanttime-in-courtwilldecrease§ Lessfrustrationbydefendant§ Moretimebackatwork

§ Paperfilingswilldecrease§ Staffhoursreinvestedinotherprojects§ Reductionoferrorsthroughoutcaseflowprocess

21

Page 22: Green Belt Project Report Out Alan Ohman Supreme Court of ...€¦ · Supreme Court of Ohio ... Project Goals 4 •The court’s own mission statement: The Ashtabula Municipal Court

SIMPLER. FASTER. BETTER. LESS COSTLY. lean.ohio.gov22

Specialthanks to…

• TonjaAmatoandNickDearing• JudgeLauraDiGiacomo• AshtabulaMunicipalCourtemployees• SCOAdministrativeDirectorMikeBuenger• SCOITDirectorRobertStuart• SCOCaseManagementSection• Denae Kotheimer (greatmentor)and

LeanOhio team(greatingeneral)