Grass without roots

38
GRASS WITHOUT ROOTS? Foreign Funding and Accountability in Nicaraguan Civil Society Dean Chahim ([email protected] ) 2009 Beyond Good Intentions Fellow Development Studies & Civil and Environmental Engineering

description

4-30-2010Dean Chahim

Transcript of Grass without roots

Page 1: Grass without roots

GRASS WITHOUT ROOTS?Foreign Funding and Accountability in Nicaraguan Civil Society

Dean Chahim ([email protected])

2009 Beyond Good Intentions Fellow

Development Studies & Civil and Environmental Engineering

Page 2: Grass without roots

“Constructing civil society cannot be essentially about building up

intermediary development organisations to represent the

'poor': it must be about empowering the poor and

enabling them to fight for their own rights as citizens.”

(Pearce 1993, emphasis added)

FROM AGENTS TO FACILITATORS

Page 3: Grass without roots

CIVIL SOCIETY FOR HEALTH

Resistance against neoliberal policies

Pressure for improvement of social services

Reduce corruption via watchdog groups

Enhance democracy? Youth at rally in Managua

Page 4: Grass without roots

MOTIVATION

Increasing donor funding for “civil society”

Apathy and demobilization

Structural inequalities (economic, ethnic, gender, orientation, etc.)

Highly organized society in 1980s

Farmer & NGO aid recipient

Page 5: Grass without roots

KEY QUESTIONS & OUTLINE

How does foreign funding affect the accountability of NGOs to the grassroots?

Does conflicting accountability affect the ability of NGOs to catalyze social change?

How does the presence of NGOs affect the viability and vitality of the grassroots?

What are the alternatives?

Page 6: Grass without roots

NICARAGUAN CONTEXT

High poverty & inequality GDP/capita: $1160 Top 10% own 41% Bottom 10% own

1.4% Weak social

movements, unions, cooperatives, etc.

Rampant corruption

Poor quality social services

Data source: World Bank, www.data.worldbank.org

Page 7: Grass without roots

NGOS IN NICARAGUA

Explosion after 1990 Neoliberal reforms

2009: 60% of foreign aid goes to NGOs (Hidalgo 2009)

Assumed to be: Closer to “people” More innovative Apolitical Check to state

power

NGO administrator at press conference

Page 8: Grass without roots

PARADOX: WHY SO DEMOBILIZED?

Highly unfavorable conditions for poor – stagnant or declining.

BUT: 20+ years of “civil society” building NGOs

(and 20 years of neoliberal policies)

Coffee farmers & NGO aid recipients

Page 9: Grass without roots

“Civil society”?

Page 10: Grass without roots

HYPOTHESIS: “GRASS WITHOUT ROOTS”

Weak & disconnected civil society

Reduces downward

accountability

Emphasizes social service

over social change

Decreases viability of

locally-funded grassroots

organizations

Increasing Foreign Funding…

Page 11: Grass without roots

POINTS OF DEPARTURE

“Civil society” as purchasable and quantifiable

NGOs as strictly normative actors

NGOs as “apolitical” actors

NGOs able to “empower” the grassroots

NGOs able to advocate on behalf of the grassroots

Page 12: Grass without roots

SAMPLE

17 NGOs Advocacy networks (4) Organizing (1) Human Rights (3) Democracy (1) Environmental (1) Rural Development (5) Health (2)

16 locally run 11 national Most visible NGOs in

media included

NGO educator at workshop in León

Page 13: Grass without roots

METHODOLOGY

Two month field study (July & August, 2009)

Semi-structured interviews with: Administrators Field staff Volunteer “Promoters” Recipients

Observation & field visits

Analysis of NGO literature & local media

Volunteers and field staff of local NGO

Page 14: Grass without roots

CHARACTERISTICS OF FUNDING

Volatile & whimsical Short-term cycles Aimed at

quantitative results Politicized and

depoliticizing Tied to donor foreign

policy

USAID funded NGO compound

Page 15: Grass without roots

ACCOUNTABLE TO WHO?The struggle for downward accountability

Page 16: Grass without roots

STRAINED ACCOUNTABILITIES

Donors

Recipients?

NGOs Other NGOs, Staff

Page 17: Grass without roots

COORDINADORA CIVIL (CC) :THE “VOICE” OF CIVIL SOCIETY?

Advocacy network Foreign funded Dominated by NGOs Representatives elect

“spokesperson” Extremely prominent

in media Claims to be “the

voice” of civil society

“apolitical” Headline: “Civil Coordinator condemns Mel Zelaya”

Page 18: Grass without roots

THE “APOLITICAL” PARADOX

How can advocacy for any group be “apolitical” – let alone the

disempowered?

Does this notion of “apolitical” restrict the impact of advocacy?

Page 19: Grass without roots

ACCOUNTABLE TO WHO?

CC

NGOs w/o Promoters

Recipients

NGOs w/Promoters

Promoters

Public

Downward accountability?

Page 20: Grass without roots

WEAK DOWNWARD TIES Legitimacy from NGO

“experts” Urban elite NGO staff NGOs not strongly

accountable to volunteer promoters

Volunteer promoters and victim of abuse NGO representative checking on

project

Page 21: Grass without roots

STRUCTURAL IMPEDIMENTS

Completely dependent on foreign aid

No institutionalized downward accountability to constituency

Can it be responsive?

Can it mobilize?

Page 22: Grass without roots

NET RESULT

Self-admitted minimal policy impact

Marginal success at NGO coordination

Springboard to politics for NGO staff

Façade of active civil society

Representative speaking at CC assembly

Page 23: Grass without roots

MISSION DRIFTSocial service or social change?

Page 24: Grass without roots

EXAMPLE: IXCHEN

Promote and defend women’s rights

“empowerment” “we incite the

autonomy, participation, equality, and decision power of women”

Create a movement for women’s rights

More funding for: Vertical healthcare delivery

Less funding for: Women’s rights education via volunteer promoters

Mission Practice

Pre-natal care

Page 25: Grass without roots

EMPOWERMENT?

Ixchen workshop

Page 26: Grass without roots

PUSHED TO SERVE THE STATUS QUO

Short-term “project” focus ignores structures

Depoliticized, token popular education

Services reduce pressure on state for policy change

Campesino child

Page 27: Grass without roots

NO ROOM FOR THE GRASSROOTS?

Page 28: Grass without roots

1979-1983: MOBILIZATION & INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE Tens of thousands of

volunteers mobilized +37% Literacy -50% Malaria Elimination of Polio -75% Infant Diarrhea +4 years life expectancy

Literacy crusade trucks Teaching literacyPhotos and statistics from Walker, 2003

Page 29: Grass without roots

CONTEXTUAL EFFECTS OF NEOLIBERALISM, WAR, AND POVERTY

Fatigue from war

Distrust in corrupt institutions

Neoliberal reforms crushed unions, cooperatives

Increasing poverty: eat or organize?

Rural community leaders in Somoto

Page 30: Grass without roots

IMPACT OF NGOS ON GRASSROOTS

NGOs have disproportionate voice

Overshadowed by NGO elites

“Funding culture”

Depoliticized & demobilized

Overly localized and project-focused Community organizer in León

Page 31: Grass without roots

POLICY IMPLICATIONS & EMERGING SOLUTIONS

Page 32: Grass without roots

SUMMARY: “GRASS WITHOUT ROOTS” Funding restricts downward accountability

Structural inequality stagnant

Dominated by NGO elites

Limited “empowerment”

Limited potential for grassroots growth

Minimal policy impact

Depoliticized, localized, and demobilized

Undermining of social contract?

Page 33: Grass without roots

“ILLUSION OF PROGRESS”

Foreign funding to NGOs does not resolve but actually may distract from the structural issues underlying inequality while demobilizing those best capable of challenging them.

Campesino children

Page 34: Grass without roots

EMERGING SOLUTIONS Long-term donor funding?

Does not eliminate donor politicization

Social audits?

Accountability clubs?

Democratic NGO structures?

NGO technical support without co-optation? Ex. Zapatistas, Sandinistas

Return to member funding for advocacy? Difficult - and not perfect - but great potential

Page 35: Grass without roots

WORKING TOWARDS OBSOLESCENCE?

“The greatest achievement of any NGO is the ability to renew

society and then be replaced by movements from that renewed

society.” -Marchetti 1997 (emphasis added)

Page 36: Grass without roots

THANK YOU!

Page 37: Grass without roots

QUESTIONS?

Page 38: Grass without roots

SOURCES Gugerty, Mary Kay, and Aseem Prakash. Advocacy Organizations and Collective Action.

Cambridge, UK:: Cambridge University Press, 2010.

Hidalgo, Wendy Álvarez. "Ipade: Obtener fondos internacionales fue dificìl en 2009." La Prensa, 12 18, 2009.

Marchetti, Peter E. "NGOs: Rethinking Strategy." Envío, no. 195 (October 1997).

Pearce, Jenny. "NGOs and Social Change: Agents or Facilitators?" Development in Practice 3, no. 3 (October 1993): 222-227.

Polakoff, Erica, and Pierre La Ramée. "Grass-Roots Organizations." In Nicaragua without Illusions: Regime Transition and Structural Adjustment in the 1990s, by Thomas W. Walker, 185-201. Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources Inc., 1997.

Walker, Thomas W. Nicaragua: Living in the Shadow of the Eagle. Boulder: Westview Press, 2003.

Vázquez, Luis Serra. "La Sociedad Civil en Nicaragua." Centro de Análisis Socio Cultural, Universidad Centroamericana, Managua, 2008.