GOVERNMENTS GOVERNMENT CORRUPTION AFFECT QUALITY … · 2016. 5. 2. · After the country of Sudan...
Transcript of GOVERNMENTS GOVERNMENT CORRUPTION AFFECT QUALITY … · 2016. 5. 2. · After the country of Sudan...
Everywhere in the world, people count on their government to do a lot of things, from protecting their borders to providing access to safe water. Citizens pay taxes to give all levels of government the money and ability to make decisions that will improve their quality of life.
In many countries, however, governments fail to provide a good quality of life for their citizens. Why? Governments with weak economies do not have much money to work with. As well, some governments make poor choices that do not benefit their people. Sometimes government officials put their own needs and wants before those of their people. Sometimes they make choices that cause damage to the environment. As well, some governments start or fund wars or do not provide adequate help during times of conflict.
For example, by February 2014, Syria had endured civil war for three years. Fighting had completely ruined the Yarmouk neighbourhood in the capital city of Damascus. The impact of the fighting can be seen in Figure 7.14. The government had refused to allow the delivery of food aid for eight months.
HOW DO GOVERNMENTS
AFFECT QUALITY OF LIFE?
GOVERNMENT CORRUPTIONA problem that all countries around the world face is corruption. Government corruption happens when government officials use their power or authority to be dishonest with citizens or to commit illegal activities. They may use the government’s money to make themselves wealthy. When there is corruption in a country, there is less money to build infrastructure and to offer services such as healthcare and education.
Exposing corruption in a country can help to decrease it. For example, in 2004, Harvard University researchers discovered corruption was impacting an education program in Uganda. Only 13 percent of the money meant for the program was received. Evidence led to the conclusion that the missing 87 percent was taken by local politicians. After the report came out, some Ugandan government officials worked actively on ending corruption. It is still an ongoing challenge.
What other methods can be used to help fight corruption? An organization called Transparency International leads the global fight against corruption. Transparency means making information visible and easy to access. For its corruption perceptions index, the organization asks analysts and businesspeople around the world to rate countries and territories by level of public sector, or government-controlled, corruption. It combines the ratings, and scores countries and territories on a scale from 0 (highly corrupt) to 100 (very clean). Figure 7.15 is a map based on Transparency International’s findings. What patterns can you see from this map? You may notice that no country has a perfect score of 100.
What are some environmental impacts
of war?
FIGURE 7.14 In February 2014, refugees lined up for hours waiting for food at the Yarmouk refugee camp in Damascus, Syria. According to the UN, some people in this camp had nothing to eat but animal feed.
I wonder why a government would not allow food aid for its own people?
corruption dishonest or illegal actions taken by authorities in power
public sector the part of a country’s economy that is controlled by the government
ATLANTIC
OCEAN
PACIFIC
OCEANINDIAN
OCEAN
ARCTIC OCEAN
PACIFIC
OCEAN
0˚30˚W60˚W90˚W150˚W 120˚W 30˚E 60˚E 90˚E 120˚E 150˚E 180˚180˚
0˚30˚W60˚W90˚W150˚W 120˚W 30˚E 60˚E 90˚E 120˚E 150˚E 180˚180˚
60˚N
30˚N
0˚
30˚S
60˚S
60˚N
30˚N
30˚S
0˚
60˚SAntarctic Circle
Tropic of Cancer
Tropic of Capricorn
Equator
Arctic Circle
N
2000 km0
Corruption Perceptions Index, 2014
FIGURE 7.15 This map shows the public sector corruption of different countries in 2014, as estimated by the organization Transparency International. The data is based on experts’ opinions, or perceptions, of levels of corruption.
80–89
90–99
100
no data
0–9
10–19
20–29
30–39
40–49
50–59
60–69
70–79
Corruption Score
CHAPTER 7: Challenges to Improving Quality of Life 213NEL212 UNIT 2: Global Inequalities: Economic Development and Quality of Life NEL
HEROES IN ACTION
JIWO DAMAR ANARKIE: ANTI-CORRUPTION LEADER
Indonesia is a country that has a high
level of corruption. In 2013, more than
one in three people reported that they
or someone in their family had paid a
bribe over the past year. The Indonesian
government and legal system are part of
the corruption. It was reported that two in
three people were forced
to pay bribes in court.
Three in four people were
forced to pay bribes to
the police.
Jiwo Damar Anarkie
(Figure 7.17) is a young
Indonesian man who
speaks up against
corruption in his country.
He co-founded Future
Leaders for Anti-Corruption (FLAC)
Indonesia. FLAC is a youth organization
that runs an anti-corruption education
campaign. Anarkie feels that young people
can change the future of corruption in
Indonesia. Using storytelling, singing,
and puppets, he brings his anti-corruption
message to elementary school students.
He says, “They’re very young, at the stage
where character building is still possible.
Storytelling is one of the most effective
ways to do so.” He believes that teaching
the next generation to have integrity and
respect for one another
will decrease future
corruption in the country.
FLAC also engages older
students through anti-
corruption contests, music,
and mini-conferences.
FLAC began by working
with four schools in
Jakarta, the capital of
Indonesia. The program
became very successful. FLAC has
received funding and support from local
and international anti-corruption groups.
This funding has allowed Anarkie and
his FLAC team to reach more schools
by hiring more staff and purchasing
more supplies.
Anarkie hopes to inspire students to
be caring and responsible citizens as they
grow older and to live free from corruption.
A CALL TO ACTION 1. FLAC uses storytelling as a learning
tool. With a partner, write a story about
the negative effects of corruption.
Use creative storytelling to present your
story to the class.
2. What would you do if you were
asked for a bribe to get something
you needed? Write a journal entry
describing how you would feel and
how you would handle the situation.
“THEY’RE VERY YOUNG, AT THE STAGE WHERE CHARACTER
BUILDING IS STILL POSSIBLE. STORYTELLING IS ONE OF THE
MOST EFFECTIVE WAYS TO DO SO.”
THE EFFECTS OF CORRUPTION ON THE ECONOMYCorruption decreases quality of life and discourages positive economic activity. The World Bank has estimated that US$1.1 trillion is spent worldwide on bribes, or illegal payments and favours, every year. Corruption occurs in a variety of ways. Some government officials steal money. Some officials give job contracts only to businesses that offer bribes. In this case, the company that gets the contract may not be the most qualified company. For example, in 2012, several mayors and other politicians in Québec were investigated for corruption. They were accused of taking bribes from a construction company in exchange for government job contracts. Will exposing this case help to end similar types of corruption in Québec?
Many people, particularly in developing countries, have to pay bribes to start a new business or pay the police to allow them to sell goods. This negatively affects people’s job opportunities and incomes, which affects their quality of life. To create change, many citizens protest against government corruption (Figure 7.16). As well, the growing attendance of officials from developing countries at Transparency International conferences is showing that these countries are determined to fight corruption.
How can individuals work toward decreasing government corruption?
FIGURE 7.16 These people in Ankara, Turkey, are protesting against corruption, the prime minister, and his government in June 2014.
I wonder why many protests are initiated by the younger population rather than people from other levels of society?
FIGURE 7.17 Jiwo Damar Anarkie with some of the puppets he uses to teach his anti-corruption message to children
214 UNIT 2: Global Inequalities: Economic Development and Quality of Life CHAPTER 7: Challenges to Improving Quality of Life 215NEL NEL
MAKING CONNECTIONS 1. Work in pairs to list skills you think an advocate
should have.
2. Think of a change that would help people or the
environment. What actions could you take to create
this change?
LASTING PROBLEMSAs mentioned, not all transitions to independence have been peaceful. When former colonies are forced together to create a new country, conflicts may arise, particularly when there are differences in religion and culture.
Consider the case of Sudan. In 1956, Sudan became a country. This brought together people from the two British colonies of North Sudan and South Sudan. There was already a bitter and violent history between these two groups of people. After the country of Sudan was formed, a civil war began that lasted from 1956 to 1977, and again from 1983 to 2005. According to the UN, the conflict in Sudan killed as many as 300 000 people and displaced 2 million more. South Sudan eventually became its own nation in 2011.
Quality of life is very poor in Sudan and South Sudan. In 2013, Sudan’s HDI score ranked 166 out of 187 countries; South Sudan ranked last at 187. Sudan also has a high level of gender inequality. Only 12.8 percent of adult women reach a secondary or higher level of education. The country allows teen marriage and enforces strict separation of females from males. Discrimination and violence against women often occur.
IMPACTS OF COLONIALISMToday, most countries are independent or mainly independent. This was not always the case. At one time, most countries were colonies, regions ruled by major world powers. For example, Russia ruled Alaska until 1867, when it was sold to the United States. Portugal ruled Macau until 1999, when Macau was returned to China.
Most colonial powers, countries that control colonies, sought to conquer more lands to gain more power and control. They sought lands that could provide them with goods and resources to serve their own interests, not those of their colonies. Lands and resources were taken and people were exploited or killed. This led to very low quality of life in the colonies.
After World War II, the period of colonialism began to end. The colonial powers had healthy economies with major industries. Figure 7.18 shows major European colonial powers and their colonies in Africa and Asia in 1945. Between 1945 and 1960, 36 new countries in Africa and Asia achieved partial or full independence from their European colonial rulers.
The transition from colony to independent country was often difficult and sometimes violent. Many former colonies were left with weak economies and social and political problems. For example, in 1962, Algeria won independence from France. However, when the French left, Algeria’s economy suffered. This was partly because few Algerians had received technical or management training. Some former colonies have made a peaceful transition to independence. Canada, which was a British colony, is one example of a peaceful transition.
colony a country, territory, or region that is controlled by another country
colonial power a country that controls one or more colonies
Why are some former colonies at
a different economic stage than their old
colonial powers?
Major European Colonial Powers and Their Colonies in 1945
FIGURE 7.18 This map shows major European colonial powers and their colonies in Africa and Asia in 1945. Many independent countries in 1945 were former colonies; for example, Afghanistan and Syria. They had achieved independence much earlier.
FIGURE 7.19 Sylvia McAdam speaking at a Canadian Union of Public Employees convention
An advocate is someone who acts publicly in
support of a person or cause. An advocate may
meet with politicians, speak publicly, write reports,
or help individual citizens.
Sylvia McAdam (Figure 7.19) is a lecturer, author,
law school graduate, and human rights advocate
from the Cree nation. She works at the University
of Saskatchewan teaching Aboriginal culture and
history, with the goal of ending discrimination.
As a law student, she felt outraged when she
learned about new Canadian laws that would
allow oil sands mining to expand. This expansion
was happening on land that was supposed to be
protected by treaties between First Nations peoples
and the government. McAdam discovered the
word acquiescence. It means that if you are silent
in relation to a new law, your silence is taken as
approval of the law.
In response, McAdam co-founded a movement
with three others called Idle No More. The word idle
means “do nothing,” and the goal of the movement
is to protect Aboriginal communities and the
environment. The four founders speak publicly,
organize protests to fight unfair laws, and use social
media to spread news. The movement continues
to grow and is supported by many Aboriginal and
non-Aboriginal people. McAdam says, “History has
shown that movements like Idle No More have the
power to change and stop governments … and the
power to change laws.”
INDIAN
OCEAN
ATLANTIC
OCEAN
PACIFIC
OCEAN
FRANCE
BELGIUMNETHERLANDS
PORTUGAL SPAIN
UNITEDKINGDOM
ASIA
AFRICA
EUROPE
N
1250 km0
Belgium
France
Netherlands
Portugal
Spain
United Kingdom
Colonial Powers
HUMAN RIGHTS ADVOCATEGEOGRAPHY AT WORK
216 UNIT 2: Global Inequalities: Economic Development and Quality of Life CHAPTER 7: Challenges to Improving Quality of Life 217NEL NEL
1. PATTERNS AND TRENDS Analyze the European
colonial powers map (Figure 7.18). In your analysis,
• identify patterns in the map
• suggest consequences of the patterns
2. GEOGRAPHIC PERSPECTIVE Suppose that you belong
to an anti-corruption group in a country where
there is widespread corruption. Your group is
to deliver a speech to the UN about fighting
corruption. Write a speech listing actions that
could be taken to reduce corruption. For each
action, describe what you hope it will accomplish.
3. INTERPRET AND ANALYZE Explain how a large
foreign debt prevents improvements in quality of
life in developing countries. Show your ideas in a
flow chart.
4. INTERRELATIONSHIPS Create a Causes and Effects
organizer that shows how a country’s colonial
history, government corruption, and foreign debt
are connected to quality of life.
CHECK-IN
By 2010, Greece owed so much money that it could not keep up with its foreign debt payments. Greece is a European Union (EU) country, so the EU decided to help Greece, which in turn helps the EU economy. The EU promised to eliminate half of Greece’s debts (US$333 billion) if Greece cut government spending. This involved reducing government jobs, salaries, and services, and raising the retirement age. The plan sparked massive, and sometimes violent, public protests (Figure 7.21). The Greek people felt these changes would negatively impact their quality of life. In 2014, more than 1 million Greek citizens lost their healthcare coverage. This lack of access to healthcare led to higher rates of infant mortality and illness.
FOREIGN DEBTWhen governments do not have enough money to operate, they borrow money from other countries. The money that one country owes to another country is called foreign debt.
In 2013, developing countries owed more than US$7 trillion in foreign debt. More developed countries also have foreign debt. In 2014, the debt of the United States government was nearly US$18 trillion. The United States has such a large economy that it can continuously work at paying back its debts. Developing countries may not have the wealth to pay back their debts. Some of the reasons why developing countries have large debts include• recovery from major natural disasters• corrupt government spending• costs of war or post-war rebuilding• high interest rates (a charge made for borrowing money) on loans
Figure 7.20 shows how the debt of developing countries has been increasing over time.
THE EFFECTS OF FOREIGN DEBT ON QUALITY OF LIFEWhen a country cannot pay its debt, it has to borrow even more money. The country may then have no money left to spend on developing its economy or improving quality of life.
For example, Pakistan borrows money just to make debt payments of US$6 billion a year. Since it must make these payments, Pakistan does not use its money to reduce poverty. In an effort to raise funds, the government raised taxes. However, now even the poorest people have to pay 7 percent more in taxes every year. This increase in taxes for the poor continues their cycle of poverty.
In some countries, citizens indirectly contribute to foreign debt. For example, in recent decades, Greece was increasing its foreign debt. During this time, many people’s salaries were high, the retirement age was low, and government services were plentiful. Yet many people and businesses avoided paying taxes whenever they could. So the government had to keep borrowing more money to pay off its foreign debt.
foreign debt the money that a country owes to individuals, corporations, and governments in other countries
Year
Total Foreign Debt of Developing Countries,2004 to 2013
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
3000
4000
0
5000
6000
7000
8000
Deb
t (U
S$
bil
lio
ns)
FIGURE 7.20 The total debt owed by developing countries on foreign loans between 2004 and 2013
Does the trend shown in this graph seem sustainable? Why or why not?
FIGURE 7.21 This mass protest occurred in Athens, Greece, in 2011. It was just one of many that expressed the people’s anger at the government’s decisions on how to pay back foreign debt.
I wonder if it’s fair to cut government services to reduce foreign debt?
218 UNIT 2: Global Inequalities: Economic Development and Quality of Life CHAPTER 7: Challenges to Improving Quality of Life 219NEL NEL