Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

57
1 4Q 2013 Global Mobile Operator Forecast: Trends and Analysis October 2014 IE Market Research Corporation Global Mobile Operator Forecast and Ranking 2Q.2014, 2003-2017

description

IEMR publishes the world’s largest database on mobile operator and mobile carrier metrics and forecasts. Our Global Mobile Operator Forecast (GMOF) provides operational and financial metrics for wireless markets across the world covering 800+ mobile operators in 200+ countries and territories. We provide five-year forecasts at the mobile operator and mobile carrier level. We also provide quarterly historical and quarterly forecast data starting in 1Q2003 and ending in eight quarters beyond the current quarter.

Transcript of Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

Page 1: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

1

4Q 2013 Global Mobile Operator

Forecast: Trends and Analysis

October 2014

IE Market Research Corporation

Global Mobile Operator Forecast and Ranking 2Q.2014, 2003-2017

Page 2: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

IEMR’s Methodology & Definitions

Global Mobile Operator Overview

Global Mobile Operator Rankings

Disclosures, Disclaimers & License Agreement

Table of Contents

Page 3: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

How IEMR Collects its Data

IEMR publishes the world’s largest database on mobile operator metrics and forecasts. Our Global Mobile Operator Forecast (GMOF)

provides operational and financial metrics for wireless markets across the world covering 800+ mobile operators in 200+ countries and

territories. The GMOF is the most extensive company-specific and country-specific forecast of its kind in the world with 1.9 million data

points.

We populate historical data in our GMOF database using proximity-based web capture technology and tracking of over 100,000 websites

including operator investor relations websites, regulatory websites, and news websites that provide information on mobile market trends at

the operator level. We complement this data with on-line executive interviews of over 3,510 executives at Communications Service

Providers (CSPs), globally, and who comprise part of IEMR’s Global Enterprise Telecommunications Panel. All historical data is vetted by

IEMR staff to ensure accuracy and consistency.

For historical data, we undertake a thorough panel-regression modeling exercise to estimate any missing data. Each historical predicted

estimate in our dataset is based on a "best fit" panel regression model that provides an estimate of that variable for a specific operator.

Unlike other Analyst firms, we do not undertake Top-down estimates based on analyst assumptions, and so the data collection exercise is

far superior to the typical analyst reports that are based mostly on analyst’s estimates, and not real data or any rigorous modeling exercise.

How IEMR Produces its Forecasts

IEMR’s forecasts are based on a combination of time-series and structural forecasting models, which are updated on a quarterly basis.

The model is a “bottom up” model that forecasts metrics at the operator-level to create country trends. For shorter term forecasts (eight

quarters), we use time-series models to forecast operator-specific metrics. Our longer-term forecasts are based on a structural-time series

panel regression model that provides a comprehensive longer term picture of operator developments at the country level. These country

level forecasts are then aggregated up to form regional and global metrics.

IEMR’s Methodology & Definitions

3

Page 4: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

How IEMR Creates its Global Mobile Operator Rankings

In producing IEMR’s Global Mobile Operator Rankings, we define mobile CSPs according to the number of subscribers on their network

(“Tiers”) as follows:

Tier 0: More than 30 million subscriber connections as of June 2014

Tier 1: 10 million - 30 million subscriber connections as of June 2014

Tier 2: 5 million - 10 million subscriber connections as of June 2014

Tier 3: 2.5 million - 5 million subscriber connections as of June 2014

Tier 4: Less than 2.5 million subscriber connections as of June 2014

Based on these Tiers, we compare a CSP to its peer group in the same Tier. Currently, our databases have the following breakdown of the

number of mobile CSPs in each Tier:

Tier 0: 47

Tier 1: 81

Tier 2: 77

Tier 3: 110

Tier 4: 534

For IEMR’s Global Mobile Operator Rankings, we calculate averages over the previous four quarters for 10 fundamental metrics that we

have found to be relevant for predicting operator developments. These are:

Subscriber Growth

Net Subscriber Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Voice ARPU Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Minutes of Use per Subscriber Growth

Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA Growth

Free Cash Flow (FCF)

(defined as EBITDA – CAPEX / Service Revenue)

IEMR’s Methodology & Definitions

4

Page 5: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

For each of the above metrics, we calculate the median level / growth rate over the last four quarters for each Tier. We choose the median

level / growth rate as our main comparator metric because it has many advantages over simple or weighted averages for this type of

ranking. Primarily it allows us to preserve a relative ranking of operators without being influenced too much by outliers.

Please note that we force “Maximum” and “Minimum” criteria on all indicators. If, for a given operator, a metric is greater than 100% of the

Tier median, we assign a “Maximum” score of 200 for that metric to that operator. If, on the other hand, a metric is less than 100% of the Tier

median, we assign a “Minimum” score of 0 for that metric to that operator.

We weigh each of the 10 metrics differently according to their predictive power in forecasting the future overall ranking of an operator. For

2Q 2014, the weighting used for the overall score was: Subscriber Growth (11.65%), Net Subscriber Adds (0.35%), Monthly Churn

(26.88%), Data ARPU Growth (2.59%), Voice ARPU Growth (1.55%), Voice Revenue Per Minute Growth (0.01%), MOU per Subscriber

Growth (8.29%), Service Revenue Growth (17.71%), EBITDA Growth (5.31%), Free Cash Flow (25.65%).

The example below shows our methodology as it applies to Djezzy GSM, a mobile operator in Algeria.

Djezzy GSM had a subscriber base of 17.587 million in June 2014. It is, therefore, a Tier 1 operator by our definition and it makes

sense to compare it with other global Tier 1 operators (as opposed to, say, Tier 4 operators, either in Algeria or Africa).

The average service revenue growth rate for Djezzy GSM between 3Q 2013 to 2Q 2014 (last four quarters) was -0.7% according to

our 2Q 2014 Global Mobile Operator Forecast. For the 81 Tier 1 operators in our GMOF database, the median service revenue

growth rate for the last four quarters was -1%. Djezzy GSM was, therefore, a GROWTH PLAYER compared to its Tier 1 peers on

this metric. Given that Djezzy’s service revenue growth was 30% greater than its peer-group median, Djezzy’s Service Revenue

Growth Score was 130 (= (1+0.3) x 100).

We weigh service revenue growth with a weighting of 17.71%. For Djezzy GSM’s overall score, the service revenue growth

component is 23.0 (= 17.71% x 130).

We use the same methodology described above for each of the 10 metrics we track for our Global Mobile Operator Ranking. We then add

up the contributions of each score to provide an overall score for Djezzy GSM compared to its Tier 1 peer group.

IEMR’s Methodology & Definitions

5

Page 6: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

Based on the above methodology, we classify operators as “GROWTH PLAYERS”, “TIER PERFORMERS”, or “UNDERPERFORMERS”

using the following criteria:

Operator Overall Score > 110 – We classify the operator as “GROWTH PLAYER”

90 ≤ Operator Overall Score ≤ 110 – We classify the operator as “SECTOR PERFORMER”

Operator Overall Score < 90 – We classify the operator as “UNDERPERFORMER”

How to interpret IEMR’s Global Mobile Operator Rankings

IEMR’s Global Mobile Operator Rankings provide a transparent, objective and comprehensive global ranking of operator performance.

Analysts and strategy planners at investment banks, consulting firms, hedge funds, operators, and telecom vendors and service providers

can use these rankings to benchmark operator performance based on a wide range of metrics and compare them to their peers globally.

In terms of the predictive power of our model, we ran an ex-ante analysis of operator scores for the period 4Q 2012 – 3Q 2013 and

compared it to the 3Q 2013 – 2Q 2014 period. As shown in the chart below, with an adjusted R-Squared of 0.6146, IEMR’s overall historical

ranking accounted for approximately 61% of the variation of the latest 4-quarter period. This makes our Global Mobile Operator Ranking

methodology a highly predictive ranking of future operator performance. The adjusted R-Squared is higher for Tier 0, 1, 2, and 3 operators.

y = 0.7052x + 15.995R² = 0.6146

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

IEMR’s Methodology & Definitions

6

Page 7: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

7

Global Mobile Operator Overview (June 2014)

Average EBITDA/Service Revenue

Growth

Operator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

9.0%

58.2%

Voice Revenue per

Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Average Voice ARPU

Growth

Net Subscribers Adds

Growth

Monthly Churn

Service Revenue

Growth

0.1%

$11.82-2.2%

2.3%

134.9 million

3.3%

-3.3%

0.21%MOU per Subscriber Growth

Subscriber Connections

Growth (YoY) 6.5%7.129 billion

22.38%

43% $ 254.6 billion

Page 8: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

6,649 6,693

6,816

6,973

7,114 7,1307,198

7,328

7,457

7,736

8.9%

7.1%

5.4%

6.3%

7.0%6.5%

5.6%5.1%

4.8%

7.3%

6,000

6,200

6,400

6,600

6,800

7,000

7,200

7,400

7,600

7,800

8,000

1Q.2013 2Q.2013 3Q.2013 4Q.2013 1Q.2014 2Q.2014 3Q.2014 F 4Q.2014 F 1Q.2015 F 2Q.2015 F

0.0%

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

8.0%

9.0%

10.0%

Figure 1: Industry-wide Subscribers (in Millions) and YoY Growth Rates, 2Q.2013 – 2Q.2015F

Source: IE Market Research Corporation

Global Mobile Operator Overview

As of 2Q 2014, the Global mobile subscriber connection base was 7.130 billion-- a YoY increase of +6.5%. We expect this slowing trend to continue over the next two quarters due to a general slowdown in emerging market countries, particularly India.

Nevertheless, we expect a bounce-back in subscriber growth starting in 2Q.2015F. Our longer-term forecast shows that subscriber growth in emerging markets will come back to trend starting in the second half of 2015.

8

Page 9: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

9 9

$14.57

$14.42

$14.52

$14.14

$14.31

$14.63

$14.58 $14.56

$14.58

-4.2%

-5.0% -4.6%-4.3%

-1.7%

1.5% 0.5%

2.9%

1.8%

13.9

14.0

14.1

14.2

14.3

14.4

14.5

14.6

14.7

-6.0%

-5.0%

-4.0%

-3.0%

-2.0%

-1.0%

0.0%

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

Source: IE Market Research Corporation

Global Mobile Operator Overview

2Q13 1Q15F4Q14F3Q14F2Q141Q144Q13 2Q15F3Q13

Figure 2: Industry-wide ARPU (in US$) and YoY Growth Rates, 2Q.2013 – 2Q.2015F

Average ARPU across all operators covered was $14.31 in 2Q.2014 with a negative growth rate of -1.7% YoY.

Overall, we think that ARPU growth rates will show a cumulative recovery into 3Q.2014 of approximately 1.5%. The Growth Rate will reach its maximum in 1Q.2015 and won’t be negative again over the next four quarters as operators continue to see the fruits of network transformation projects result in increased use of data services by consumers globally.

Average Revenue per User is $38.40 in Northern America, $25.96 in Western Europe, $15.08 in Latin America, $ 12.15 in Asia Pacific, $11.41 in Eastern Europe, and $8.57 in Africa as of June 2014.

Page 10: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

10 10

246.5247.4

251.5

255.6254.5

253.4

255.2

256.8

260.4

1.9%

0.7% 0.7%

5.7%

3.2%

2.4%

1.4%

0.5%

2.3%

235

240

245

250

255

260

265

0%

1%

2%

3%

4%

5%

6%

7%

Source: IE Market Research Corporation

Global Mobile Operator Overview

2Q13 1Q15F4Q14F3Q14F2Q141Q144Q13 2Q15F3Q13

Figure 3: Industry-wide Service Revenue (in US$ billions) and YoY Growth Trend, 2Q.2013 – 2Q.2015

Global Service Revenue in 2Q 2014 was $254.5 billion, a growth rate of 3.2% YoY. As subscriber growth continues to fall in the

next two quarters, we are forecasting a declining growth trend in service revenue over the next three quarters, with a bounce-back

in service revenue in 2Q.2015.

Page 11: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

11 11

39.2% 39.8% 40.0% 41.4% 42.8% 41.8% 42.8% 44.0%45.…

4.0%

-1.1%

1.4%

9.2% 9.0%

5.1%

6.9% 6.5%6.7%

0

0

0

1

1

1

-2%

0%

2%

4%

6%

8%

10%

Source: IE Market Research Corporation

Global Mobile Operator Overview

2Q13 1Q15F4Q14F3Q14F2Q141Q144Q13 2Q15F3Q13

Figure 4: Industry-wide EBITDA Margins and YoY Growth Rate, 2Q.2013 - 2Q.2015

The average industry-wide EBITDA margin (EBITDA / Service Revenue) was 42.8% in 2Q.2014. We forecast constantly increasing EBITDA Margins over the next four quarters reaching up to 45.7% in 2Q.2015.

Page 12: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

12

#1Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 0

30 million+ subscribers

Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

MTN Nigeria Communications Limited

Overall Score 177/200

8.6%

Not available

-4.9%

2.8%

-2.3%

-78.5%

4.5%

Not available

-1.9%

51.5%

MOU per Subscriber Growth

Page 13: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

13

#2Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Bharti Airtel Limited

Overall Score 157/200

7.6%

-9.8%

4.2%

27.7%

-60.4%

-0.7% -6.6%

31.3%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 1.1%

-10.7%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 030 million+ subscribers

Page 14: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

14

#3Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 0

30 million+ subscribers

Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Mobile TeleSystems OJSC (MTS)

Overall Score 156/200

6.8%

-6.5%

3.2%

2.1%

174.3%

2.2% 13.0%

25.6%

MOU per Subscriber Growth -8.1%

1.8%

Page 15: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

15

Tier 0 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

1 MTN Nigeria Communications Limited 1772 Bharti Airtel Limited 1573 Mobile TeleSystems OJSC (MTS) 1564 Grameenphone Limited 1525 Globe Telecom, Inc. 1506 Verizon Wireless 1487 Idea Cellular Limited 1478 AT&T Mobility LLC 1449 PT Telekomunikasi Selular (Telkomsel) 138

10 Viettel Group 13411 Telekom Deutschland GmbH (T-Mobile) (Deutsche Telekom AG) 13212 T-Mobile USA, Inc. 12313 Telecom Italia Mobile (TIM) 12314 SOFTBANK MOBILE Corp. 12215 MegaFon OJSC (MegaFon) 11916 Mobinil (The Egyptian Company for Mobile Services) 11917 China Mobile Ltd. 11818 Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company (PLDT) (Smart Communications, Inc.) 11719 China Telecom Corporation Limited 11620 China Unicom Ltd. 11421 3 Indonesia (PT Hutchison CP Telecommunications) 11422 PT XL Axiata Tbk (PT Excelcomindo Pratama Tbk) 113

Page 16: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

16

Tier 0 Telecom Carriers: Sector Performers

Operator ScoreRanking

23 MTN Irancell (MTN Group) 11024 AIS (Advanced Info Service Public Company Limited) 10925 Vodafone Egypt Telecommunications Company S.A.E. 10526 MobiFon (Vietnam Mobile Telecom Services) 10527 Claro S.A. (America Movil S.A.B. DE C.V.) 10428 KDDI Corporation (au) 10429 Vodacom Group (Pty) Ltd 10130 Telenor Pakistan (Telenor ASA) 10031 Reliance Communications Ltd. 9932 Aircel Limited 9633 Vodafone Italy (Vodafone Group Plc) 9534 TCI (Telecommunication Company of Iran) 93

Page 17: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

17

Tier 0 Telecom Carriers: Underperformers

Operator ScoreRanking

35 Vimpel-Communications (VimpelCom) 8836 NTT DOCOMO, Inc. 8737 Vivo Participacoes SA 8538 Turkcell Iletisim Hizmetleri A.S. (Turkcell) 8539 Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL) 8440 Tele Norte Leste Participacoes (Oi, Telemar) 8341 Sprint Nextel Corporation 7942 Vodafone Essar Limited (Hutchison) 7043 Mobilink (Pakistan Mobile Communications Limited) 5944 Telcel (Radiomovil Dipsa S.A. de C.V.) 5045 Tata Teleservices Limited (TTSL) 4746 TIM Participacoes SA 4647 PT Indosat Tbk (PT Satelit Palapa Indonesia (Satelindo)) 40

Page 18: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

18

#1Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 1

10 million – 30 million subscribers

Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Orange Mali

Overall Score 184/200

17.1%

10.4%

1.8%

34.5%

-27.5%

11.5% 131.0%

37.4%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 1.9%

8.4%

Page 19: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

19

#2Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Unitel Uzbekistan (Beeline)

Overall Score 172/200

1.8%

12.5%

5.6%

3.8%

Not available

-825%

7.2%

-6.1%

5.9%

Not available

MOU per Subscriber Growth

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 110 million – 30 million subscribers

Page 20: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

20

#3Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Spice Nepal Private Ltd. (Ncell)

Overall Score 167/200

13.6%

0%

2.3%

23.8%

-55.8%

10.7% 0%

134.1%

MOU per Subscriber Growth -5.4%

5.9%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 110 million – 30 million subscribers

Page 21: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

21

#3Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Movistar Venezuela

Overall Score 167/200

0%

9.3%

2.38%

7.4%

-3221%

-4.2% 10.0%

38.9%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 1.6%

7.5%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 110 million – 30 million subscribers

Page 22: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

22

Tier 1 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

1 Orange Mali SA 1842 Unitel Uzbekistan (Beeline) 1723 Spice Nepal Private Ltd. (Ncell) 1674 Movistar Venezuela (Telefonica S.A.) 1675 DiGi Telecommunications Sdn. Bhd. 1576 Mobilis (Algérie Télécom) 1527 Safaricom Limited 1478 Play (Novator) 1479 Movistar Perú (Telefonica, S.A.) 144

10 Claro S.A. (America Movil S.A.B. DE C.V.) 14411 Viettel (Cambodia) Pte. Ltd. (Metfone) 14312 Zain Iraq (Zain Group) 14113 Meditel (Medi Telecom) 13914 E-Plus Mobilfunk GmbH & Co. KG 13815 MTS-Ukraine (UMC) 13716 Movistar Colombia (Telefonica S.A.) 13617 Etisalat Nigeria (Emerging Markets Telecommunication Services (EMTS)) 13418 True Move (True Corporation Public Company Limited) 13219 Ethio Telecom (Ethiopian Telecommunications Corporation) 13020 Mobily (Etihad Etisalat Company) 12921 Chunghwa Telecom Co., Ltd. 128

Page 23: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

23

Tier 1 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

22 KT Corp. (Korea Telecom Freetel) 12723 Vodacom Tanzania Limited 12624 LG Uplus Corp. (LG Telecom) 12525 SK Telecom Co., Ltd. 12226 Telstra Corporation Limited 12227 Saudi Telecom Company (STC) 12028 3 Italy (Hutchison Telecommunications International Limited) 11729 Vodafone D2 GmbH 11630 Tele2 11531 Wind Telecomunicazioni SpA 11532 Telecom Argentina S.A. 11533 Kcell (GSM Kazakhstan OJSC Kazakhtelecom LLP) 11534 Kyivstar GSM 11435 Rogers Wireless Inc. 11436 Telefónica O2 Germany GmbH & Co OHG 11337 MTN Ghana (MTN Group) 112

Page 24: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

24

Tier 1 Telecom Carriers: Sector Performers

Operator ScoreRanking

38 China Mobile Ltd. (Paktel) 11039 Djezzy GSM (Orascom Télécoms Algérie) 11040 Robi Axiata Limited (Telekom Malaysia) 10941 SFR (Vodafone Group Plc) 10942 Vodafone Limited 10843 Telefónica O2 UK Limited 10744 Orange España (France Telecom España S.A.) 10745 Cell C (Pty) Ltd 10746 Celcom (Malaysia) Berhad 10747 Movistar (Telefónica Móviles España, S.A.U.) 10548 Movilnet (CA Nacional Telefonos de Venezuela (CANTV)) 10549 Orange (France Télécom S.A.) (Everything Everywhere Ltd.) 10350 Maroc Telecom SA (Itissalatt Al Maghreb) 10351 PTC (T-Mobile International AG) (Era) 10252 Banglalink/Sheba (Orascom Telecom Holding S.A.E) 10153 Airtel Nigeria (Bharti Airtel Limited) 10154 DTAC (Total Access Communication Public Company Limited) 10055 Orange (France Telecom S.A.) 10056 Zain Sudan (Zain Group) 10057 Ufone GSM 9758 Asiacell Telecommunication LLC 9659 Conecel S.A. (Porta) 9560 Smart Telecom Indonesia 94

Page 25: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

25

Tier 1 Telecom Carriers: Underperformers

Operator ScoreRanking

61 VinaPhone (Vietnam Posts and Telecommunications Group) 8962 Orange Romania (France Télécom S.A.) 8963 Comcel (America Movil S.A.B de C.V.) 8764 MTN Group Limited 8765 Polkomtel S.A. (Plus) 8766 Entel Chile (Empresa Nacional de Telecomunicaciones SA) 8667 Movistar Argentina (Telefonica S.A.) 8568 Maxis Mobile Services Sdn. Bhd. 8469 Orange Polska (PTK Centertel) 8170 Avea (Turk Telekomunikasyon A.S. (Turk Telekom)) 8171 Movistar Chile (Telefonica S.A.) 8072 Vodafone España SAU 7073 Vodafone Turkey 6774 Digitel Mobile Philippines, Inc. (Sun Cellular) 6775 Globacom Limited 6576 Movistar Mexico (Telefonica S.A.) 6177 Bouygues Telecom 6078 Claro (America Movil S.A.B. DE C.V.) / CTI 5979 OJSC Rostelecom 5680 Etisalat Egypt (Emirates Telecommunications Corporation) 5381 Warid Telecom International 46

Page 26: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

26

#1Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

MTN Côte d'Ivoire

Overall Score 169/200

17.3%

-6.8%

2.8%

8.3%

34.4%

9.2% -6.8%

21.2%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 0%

-6.8%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 25 million – 10 million subscribers

Page 27: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

27

#2Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

MTN Cameroon

Overall Score 167/200

28.8%

1.5%

-12.7%

2.1%

8.5%

382.3%

12.2%

-14.0%

-12.5%

24.6%

MOU per Subscriber Growth

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 25 million – 10 million subscribers

Page 28: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

28

#3Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Nepal Telecom

Overall Score 166/200

17.5%

0.9%

2.7%

12.5%

-4.0%

15.2% 2.1%

39.5%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 0%

1.2%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 25 million – 10 million subscribers

Page 29: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

29

Tier 2 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

1 MTN Côte d'Ivoire (MTN Group) 1692 MTN Cameroon (MTN Group) 1673 Nepal Telecom (Nepal Telecommunications Corporation) 1664 Du (Emirates Integrated Telecommunications Company PJSC) 1635 Tigo Colombia (Millicom International Cellular S.A.) 1536 MTN Uganda (MTN Group) 1487 Vodafone Ghana (Vodafone Group plc) 1488 Etisalat UAE (Emirates Telecommunications Corporation) 1479 Telvenco S.A. (Digitel) 143

10 Vodacom Congo (Vodacom Group (Pty) Ltd) 14011 Tigo (Comunicaciones Celulares, S.A.) 13812 Astelit LLC (life:)) 13513 T-Mobile Hungary (Magyar Telekom Nyrt.) 13514 MTN Group (Spacetel) 13415 Bell Mobility Inc. 13216 Syriatel Mobile Telecom S.A. 13217 Orange Côte d'Ivoire (France Télécom S.A.) 13118 Dialog Axiata PLC 12919 Taiwan Mobile Co., Ltd. 12820 SOTELMA 12521 Telus Mobility 124

Page 30: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

30

Tier 2 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

22 Orange Senegal (France Télécom S.A.) 12323 TeliaSonera AB 12324 Movistar (Telefónica Móviles Ecuador) (Otecel S.A.) 12325 Zain Tanzania (Bharti Airtel Limited) 12126 Hutchison 3G UK Limited 12127 MTS (Mobile TeleSystems OJSC) 12028 Tunisiana (Orascom Telecom Holding SAE) 11929 Iusacell (Grupo Iusacell SAB de CV) 11830 Cosmote Mobile Telecommunications S.A. 11831 Cosmote Romania (Cosmote Mobile Telecommunications S.A.) 11732 I.C.E. (Instituto Costarricense de Electricidad) 11533 Kar-Tel LLP (BeeLine) 11434 MPT (Myanmar Posts and Telecommunications) 11435 mobilkom austria (Telekom Austria Group) 11436 T-Mobile Czech Republic a.s. 11137 Telefónica O2 Czech Republic a.s. 111

Page 31: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

31

Tier 2 Telecom Carriers: Sector Performers

Operator ScoreRanking

38 Far EasTone Telecommunications Co., Ltd. 11039 Mobitel Sri Lanka (Mobitel (Pvt.) Ltd.) 10940 Digicel Haiti (Digicel Group Limited) 10941 U Mobile Sdn Bhd 10942 KPN Mobile N.V. 10743 Econet Wireless (Private) Limited 10744 Nedjma (Wataniya Télécom Algérie) 10645 Swisscom AG 10546 Ucell (Coscom) 10347 Claro Dominican Republic (América Móvil, S.A.B. de C.V.) 10348 TMN -Telecomunicações Móveis Nacionais S.A. 10249 Telekom Srbija (MT:S) (Preduzeće za telekomunikacije Telekom Srbija a.d.) 10250 Bharti Airtel Limited (Zain Kenya) 10251 Unitel Angola (UNITEL SA) 10152 Korek Telecom Ltd. 9853 Proximus (Belgacom S.A.) 9854 MTS India (Sistema Shyam TeleServices Limited) 9755 Tigo Tanzania (Millicom International Cellular S.A.) 9656 MTS-Uzbekistan (Mobile TeleSystems OJSC) (Uzdunrobita) 9357 Zain Saudi Arabia (SMTC) 9158 Vodafone (Vodafone Hutchison Australia Pty Ltd) 90

Page 32: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

32

Tier 2 Telecom Carriers: Underperformers

Operator ScoreRanking

59 MTN Sudan (MTN Group) 8960 Claro (Sercom S.A.) 8961 MTN Afghanistan (MTN Group) 8662 Vodafone Netherlands (Vodafone Group Plc) 8663 Airtel (Warid Telecom) 8464 Vodafone Romania (Vodafone Group) 7765 Vodafone Portugal, Comunicações Pessoais, S.A. 7366 Orange Cameroon (France Télécom S.A.) 7267 SingTel Optus Pty Limited 6968 Zain Congo DRC (Bharti Airtel Limited) 6669 Nizhegorodskaya Cellular Communications 6470 Wana (ONA Group) 6371 PT Natrindo Telepon Seluler (Axis) 6272 MTN Syria (MTN Group) 5973 Free Mobile 5874 Roshan (Telecom Development Company Afghanistan Ltd.) 5275 PT. Bakrie Telecom Tbk 3976 Claro Chile S.A. 3377 Others 24

Page 33: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

33

#1Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Zain Malawi (Bharti Airtel Limited)

Overall Score 187/200

42.0%

51.9%

1.9%

11.1%

-31.4%

7.4% 52.3%

33.9%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 1.3%

50.0%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 32.5 million – 5 million subscribers

Page 34: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

34

#2Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

MTN Zambia

Overall Score 182/200

-3.1%

0%

16.6%

2.8%

48.4%

-348.8%

36.2%

16.4%

15.2%

21.1%

MOU per Subscriber Growth

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 32.5 million – 5 million subscribers

Page 35: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

35

#2Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

MTN Group (Spacetel Benin) (Areeba)

Overall Score 182/200

18.3%

1.0%

1.1%

2.5%

6.4%

23.8%

7.1%

0.1%

-1.6%

23.0%

MOU per Subscriber Growth

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 32.5 million – 5 million subscribers

Page 36: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

36

#3Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

TeleYemenOverall Score 171/200

9.0%

0%

2.2%

20.7%

0%

9.0% 0%

24.9%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 1.3%

-1.3%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 32.5 million – 5 million subscribers

Page 37: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

37

Tier 3 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

1 Zain Malawi (Bharti Airtel Limited) 1872 MTN Zambia (MTN Group) 1823 MTN Group (Spacetel Benin) (Areeba) 1824 TeleYemen (Yemen International Telecommunications Co.) 1715 Tigo (Millicom International Cellular S.A.) 1696 Velcom (FE VELCOM) 1677 Vivacom (Bulgarian Telecommunications Company) 1668 Babilon Mobile (CJSC Babilon-Mobile) 1639 Zain Niger (Bharti Airtel Limited) 163

10 Orange Guinee (France Télécom S.A.) 16111 Hong Kong CSL Limited (CSL New World) 15912 Movil de Entel (Entel S.A.) 15813 Zain Kuwait (Zain Group) 15514 Zain Ghana (Bharti Airtel Limited) 14815 Tigo - Millicom International Cellular S.A. (Telecel Bolivia) 14616 Movicel (Angola Telecom) 14317 China Mobile Hong Kong Company Limited (CMHK) 14218 Etisalat Benin S.A. (Telecel Benin) (Moov) 14219 Tele2 AB 139

Page 38: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

38

Tier 3 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

20 Tigo Paraguay (Millicom International Cellular S.A.) (Telecel) 13721 Drei (Hutchison 3G Austria GmbH) 13522 Singapore Telecommunications Ltd. (SingTel) 13423 Telenor Mobil AS 13424 TeliaSonera AB 13325 Nuevatel PCS De Bolivia SA 13026 CamGSM Co. Ltd. (Cellcard, MobiTel) 12827 Indigo-Somoncom (CSJC Indigo Tajikistan) 12728 Moov Côte d'Ivoire (Atlantique Telecom, Etisalat) 12629 GLOBUL (Cosmo Bulgaria Mobile EAD) 12430 Onatel SA 12431 Tigo Honduras (Millicom International Cellular S.A.) (Celtel) 12332 Vodafone Czech Republic a.s. 12133 Vodacom Mozambique (Vodacom Group (Pty) Ltd) 11934 Zain Jordan (Zain Group) 11935 Telenor Serbia (Telenor d.o.o.) 11836 Tigo El Salvador (Telemovil, El salvador S.A.) 11737 Teletalk Bangladesh Limited (BTTB) 11638 SmarTone-Vodafone (SmarTone Mobile Communications Limited) 116

Page 39: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

39

Tier 3 Telecom Carriers: Growth Players

Operator ScoreRanking

39 Pelephone 11540 Telenor Hungary Ltd. (Pannon) 11441 ANCEL 11442 Sky Mobile LLC (BeeLine) (BITEL) 11443 Zain Uganda (Bharti Airtel Limited) 11344 Elisa Oyj 11345 Cellcom Israel Ltd. 11346 T-Mobile Netherlands (Ben) (T-Mobile International AG) 11247 Orange Slovensko (France Télécom S.A.) 11248 Digicel Papua New Guinea (Digicel Group Limited) 11149 Partner Communications Co. Ltd. (Orange) 111

Page 40: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

40

Tier 3 Telecom Carriers: Sector Performers

Operator ScoreRanking

50 Digicel Jamaica Ltd. (Mossel) 11051 Yoigo (Xfera Moviles S.A.) 11052 Orange Jordan (France Télécom S.A.) 11053 Tesco Mobile Ltd. 10854 TM Cell (Altyn Asyr MC) 10855 Movistar Panama (Telefonica Moviles Panama, S.A.) 10856 Virgin Mobile France 10857 Sabafon (Yemen Mobile Phone Company) 10758 Star Telecom Company Limited (STL) (LAT) 10759 Etisalat Afghanistan (Emirates Telecommunications Corporation) 10660 Vodafone-Panafon Hellenic Telecommunications Company S.A. 10661 Azerfon LLC (NAR Mobile) 10662 CTE Telecom Personal S.A. de C.V. (Claro) 10563 Enitel-Claro (Empresa Nicaraguense de Telecomunicaciones S.A.) 10464 Etisalat Sri Lanka (Emirates Telecommunication Corporation) (Celltel) 10365 Zain Zambia (Bharti Airtel Limited) 10366 Zain Burkina Faso (Bharti Airtel Limited) 10267 Mobistar N.V./S.A. 10268 Videocon Telecommunications Limited 9969 Uganda Telecom Ltd. 99

Page 41: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

41

Tier 3 Telecom Carriers: Sector Performers

Operator ScoreRanking

70 Bakcell Ltd. 9871 Vietnamobile (Hutchison Telecommunications International Limited) 9772 Optimus Telecomunicações, S.A. (Sonaecom) 9673 Azercell Telecom LLC 9574 U.S. Cellular (United States Cellular Corporation) 9475 TDC Mobile International A/S 9376 Palestinian Cellular Communications Company (Al-Jawwal) 9377 Ooredoo (Qatar Telecom (Qtel)) 9378 Vala (Post and Telecom of Kosovo) 90

Page 42: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

42

Tier 3 Telecom Carriers: Underperformers

Operator ScoreRanking

79 Essar Telecom Kenya Limited (Yu) 8880 MTN Rwanda (MTN Group) 8781 Movistar (Telefónica S.A.) 8682 Virgin Mobile UK (Virgin Mobile Telecoms Ltd.) 8683 Afghan Wireless Communication Company (AWCC) 8584 Hutchison Hong Kong (Hutchison Telecommunications International Limited) 8485 Zain Madagascar (Bharti Airtel Limited) 8386 Areeba Guinea (MTN Group) (Investcom) 8287 Tele2 Kazakhstan (Mobile Telecom Service LLP) 8288 Omantel (Oman Telecommunications Company) 8189 Warid Telecom Uganda (Warid Telecom International Ltd.) 7990 EMOBILE Limited 7691 Umniah (Bahrain Telecommunications Company) 7392 Leap Wireless International, Inc. 7093 M-Tel (Mobiltel EAD) 6794 Telecel Zimbabwe (Pvt) Ltd 6795 Orange Dominicana S.A. 6696 Nextel (Comunicaciones Nextel de Mexico S.A. de C.V.) 6497 BASE (Royal KPN N.V.) 6498 Africell DRC 5899 Movitel Mozambique 58

100 Moçambique Celular, S.A.R.L. (mcel) 52

Page 43: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

43

Tier 3 Telecom Carriers: Underperformers

Operator ScoreRanking

101 T-Mobile Austria (Deutsche Telekom AG) 50102 Sibirtelecom JSC 47103 Tuntel (Tunisie Télécom) 44104 Loop Mobile (BPL Cellular) 44105 S Tel Pvt. Ltd. 42106 Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (MTNL) 40107 Uralsvyazinform JSC 39108 Wind Hellas Telecommunications S.A. 34109 Etisalat DB Telecom Pvt. Ltd 24110 New World PCS Limited (merged with CSL in 2006) 16

Page 44: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

44

#1Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Tigo Rwanda

Overall Score 135/200

29.1%

17.3%

2.2%

28.6%

829.4%

66.6% 22.0%

-8.0%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 2.1%

14.8%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 4Less than 2.5 million subscribers

Page 45: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

45

#1Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Vodafone Qatar

Overall Score 135/200

20.4%

6.7%

2.3%

18.8%

-40.0%

29.4% 6.7%

-9.1%

MOU per Subscriber Growth 7.1%

-0.3%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 4Less than 2.5 million subscribers

Page 46: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

46

#2Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Kuwait Telecom Company

Overall Score 132/200

32.7%

3.6%

-4.1%

2.6%

1641.5%

-25.0%

35.0%

-7.5%

22.7%

475.7%

MOU per Subscriber Growth

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 4Less than 2.5 million subscribers

Page 47: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

47

#2Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

T+ Telecomunicações

Overall Score 132/200

15.9%

6.3%

-7.4%

2.7%

73.1%

0.0%

53.3%

-12.9%

0.6%

20.5%

MOU per Subscriber Growth

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 4Less than 2.5 million subscribers

Page 48: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

48

#3Subscriber Connections Growth

Voice Revenue per Minute Growth

Data ARPU Growth

Voice ARPU Growth

Net Subscribers Additions Growth

Monthly Churn

Operator Service Revenue Growth

EBITDA GrowthOperator FCF %

(EBITDA-CAPEX/Service Revenue)

Companhia Santomense de Telecomunicações

Overall Score 127/200

7.4%

24.8%

1.6%

15.9%

0%

38.9% 24.5%

Not available

MOU per Subscriber Growth 3.0%

21.1%

Global Mobile Operator Rankings: Tier 4Less than 2.5 million subscribers

Page 49: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

The opinions expressed in this report are the true opinions of the analyst(s) and IE Market Research Corp. (IEMR) about the firm(s) and/or industry appearing in this report. Any “forward looking statements” are the best estimates and opinions of the analyst(s) and IEMR based upon information that is publicly available and that the analyst(s) and IEMR believes to be correct. There is no guarantee that forecasts appearing in this report will materialize.

The analyst(s) responsible for preparing this research report received compensation that is based upon various factors, including total revenues of IEMR, a portion of which are or have been generated by consulting and contract research activities undertaken by IEMR for firm(s) appearing in this report. The analyst(s) and/or IEMR does not own any shares of the firm(s) appearing in this report, does not make or offer for sale shares of the firm(s) appearing in this report, and does not have any investment banking business with firm(s) appearing in this report. IEMR may have been contracted by firm(s) appearing in this report to undertake competitive intelligence, business strategy, market research, branding research, and/or public opinion research activities. No part of the compensation of the responsible analyst(s) named herein is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific recommendations or views expressed by the responsible analyst(s) in this report.

Forward Looking Statements

This report contains forward looking statements. Forward looking statements regarding firm(s) inherently involve risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ from such forward looking statements. Factors that could cause or contribute to such differences include, but are not limited to, continued acceptance of the firm(s)’ products/services in the marketplace; acceptance in the marketplace of the firm(s)’ new products/services; competitive factors; new products/services introductions by others; technological changes; dependence on suppliers; mergers and acquisitions; systematic risks and other risks discussed in the firm(s)’ periodic report filings, including interim reports, annual reports, and annual information forms filed with the appropriate securities regulators. By making these forward looking statements, the analyst(s) and IEMR undertake no obligation to update these statements for revisions or changes after the date of this report.

Warranties

The information contained in this report has been compiled by IEMR from sources believed to be reliable, but no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made by IEMR or any other person as to its accuracy, completeness or correctness. IEMR does not make any warranties, expressed or implied, as to results to be obtained from using this information and makes no express or implied warranties or fitness for a particular use. Clients using this report assume full responsibility for whatever results they obtain from whatever use the information was put to. To the full extent permitted by law neither IEMR nor any other person accept any liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from any use of this report or the information contained herein.

IE Market Research

Disclaimers, Disclosures & License Agreement

49

Page 50: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

Dissemination of Research

IEMR endeavours to make all reasonable efforts to provide research simultaneously to all eligible clients. However, IEMR’s premium clients may have access to IEMR research prior to research being disseminated more widely. IEMR’s research is posted to our proprietary website to ensure eligible clients receive intelligence in a timely manner. Additional distribution may be done by IEMR’s sales personnel via email, fax or regular mail. Clients may also receive our research via third party vendors. Please contact our research department at 1-888-322-IEMR for more information regarding our research.

Licensing Agreement

These license terms and conditions (the “License Terms”) are applicable to all orders (each, an “Order”) placed by an individual on his/her own behalf or on behalf of an organization (“you”) for any survey data, forecast data, research reports, publications, and any other Product(s) owned by IE MARKET RESEARCH CORP. (“IEMR”), including those created by IEMR in connection with any custom services contracted for by you (each, a “Product”, together “Product(s)”. Orders shall be binding upon acceptance by IEMR (or its authorized distributors), such acceptance shall be deemed to occur upon the delivery of a Product by IEMR (or its authorized distributors) to you. Orders may be placed by you: (i) through the website located at www.iemarketresearch.com (the “Website”), (ii) the use of an order form (whether provided on the Website or made available to you by a third party), or (iii) through an authorized distributor of IEMR. You shall not have the right to cancel or amend an Order without written consent from IEMR.

1. LICENSES

1.1 Single-User. Upon acceptance of an Order for a “Single-User” license, IEMR shall grant you a worldwide, non-exclusive, non-transferable license to: (a) download, store and display one electronic copy of the Product in machine readable form for use by a single user on up to two (2) different computers; and (b) print additional paper copies of the Product for internal business use within your organization, provided that IEMR is, in each case, cited as the source of the Product. Notwithstanding the foregoing, you shall NOT be permitted to:

(a) transmit (including, but not limited to, by email) to, or permit any, third party to use and/or gain access to an electronic copy of the Product;

(b) resell, sub-license, rent, lease, transfer or attempt to assign the rights in the Product (in whole or in part) to any third party;

(c) modify or alter the Product or create a database in electronic or structured manual form by systematically downloading and storing any of the content from such Product other than for internal business purposes;

(d) download, store, reproduce, transmit, display, copy, distribute, commercially exploit or use the Product other than as expressly permitted above; and

(e) use the Product in any manner that would contravene the terms and conditions contained in these License Terms or that would contravene laws in Canada, or in any other jurisdiction.

1.2 Multi-User. Upon acceptance of an Order for a “Multi-User” license, IEMR shall grant you a worldwide, non-exclusive, non-transferable license to: (a) download, store, transmit and display multiple electronic copies of the relevant Product, in machine readable form, to employees of his/her company (“Personnel”); and (b) print additional paper copies of the Product for internal business use within your organization, provided that IEMR is cited as the source of the Product. Notwithstanding the foregoing, you shall NOT be permitted to:

(a) distribute or display an electronic or paper copy of the Product to any third party (i.e. non-Personnel);

(b) resell, sub-license, rent, lease, transfer or attempt to assign the rights in the Product (in whole or in part) to any third party;

.

IE Market Research

Disclaimers, Disclosures & License Agreement

50

Page 51: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

Licensing Agreement (contd.)

(c) modify or alter the Product or create a database in electronic or structured manual form by systematically downloading and storing any of the content from such Product;

(d) download, store, reproduce, transmit, display, copy, distribute, commercially exploit or use the Product other than as expressly permitted above; and

(e) use the Product in any manner that would contravene the terms and conditions contained in these License Terms or that would contravene laws in Canada, or in any other jurisdiction.

1.3 Annual Subscriptions. Where you use an order form (whether provided on the Website or made available to you by a third party) for an annual subscription to certain Product(s) made available by IEMR within a set duration of time (each, an “Annual Subscription”), such Annual Subscription shall either be a: (a) Single-User license, or (b) Multi-User license, for the relevant Product(s). These License Terms shall apply, mutatis mutandis, to each Annual Subscription and, regardless of the form of Order used, are deemed to be notified to, and accepted by, you.

2. PAYMENT

2.1 Fees. You shall pay IEMR all fees in accordance with the applicable payment terms set forth in the applicable Order (“Fees”), and at IEMR’s option, IEMR may suspend access to the Products if IEMR has not received payment of the Fees from you when due.

2.2 Taxes. All Fees payable hereunder to IEMR are exclusive of all goods and services, sales, use or other taxes, customs, duties and similar levies, if any, payable in or to any jurisdiction or authority whatsoever, which taxes, duties and levies will be your responsibility, excluding taxes levied on the income of IEMR.*

2.3 Overdue Amounts. If any Fees are not paid to IEMR when due, you will pay to IEMR interest on such overdue amount calculated from the date when due until the date that payment is received at the lesser of (a) the rate of two percent (2%) per month compounded monthly (equivalent of 26.86% per annum), or (b) the maximum rate allowed under applicable law.

2.4 Collection Expenses. You agree to reimburse IEMR for any and all collection related expenses incurred by IEMR (including, but not limited to, reasonable attorney’s fees) in the collection of any amounts owed to IEMR pursuant to an Order.

2.5 No Refunds. No refunds or credits will be issued for: (a) non-use or partial use of any Product(s), (b) upgrade/downgrade refunds, or (c) refunds for months unused with an Annual Subscription.

2.6 Compliance and Change of Scope. IEMR shall have the right to verify your compliance with these License Terms, through any method available, or preferred by, IEMR to perform such verification and the choice of such method shall be in the sole discretion of IEMR. In the event IEMR detects non-compliance on your part with these License Terms in connection with any Product(s) purchased, IEMR may, in its sole discretion, without limitation to any other rights of IEMR under these License Terms, without prior notice to you: (a) modify the scope of or upgrade the relevant license to bring it into compliance with the actual usage of the Product(s) by you, (b) invoice you with such additional fees to reflect the change of the scope of license, (c) take any further steps that IEMR deems necessary to correct such non-compliance.

2.7 IEMR utilizes Digital Rights Management (DRM) software on all reports ordered with unique identification to the end user’s account. Files purchased by a user under a Single-User license and which are opened on more than two (2) machines will be authorization for IEMR to automatically bill the user at the multi-user rate on the user’s credit card.

IE Market Research

Disclaimers, Disclosures & License Agreement

51

Page 52: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

3. OWNERSHIP

All copyrights, patents, utility models, trade-marks, service marks, design rights (whether registered or unregistered), database rights, proprietary information rights and all other proprietary rights that may exist relating to the Product(s) (“Intellectual Property Rights”) are the sole property of IEMR. You shall not obtain any Intellectual Property Rights in the Product(s) pursuant to or arising out of their use of the Product(s), except for the license granted by IEMR to use the Product(s) as set forth herein.

4. THIRD PARTY CLAIMS

You shall fully indemnify IEMR in respect of any infringement of any Intellectual Property Rights arising as a result of your use of the Product(s) in breach of these License Terms. You shall allow IEMR (or its licensors) to control any proceedings arising as a result of any infringement, threatened infringement or claim relating thereto. You shall make no admission as to liability nor accept any settlement. You shall also, at the request of IEMR, offer reasonable assistance and cooperation in relation to any such proceedings. Any recovery obtained from such proceedings shall accrue solely for the benefit of IEMR.

5. DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTIES; LIMITATION OF LIABILITY

5.1 Disclaimer. All Product(s) are provided on an “as is”, “as available” basis and IEMR expressly disclaims all warranties, including the warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose.

5.2 No Warranty. IEMR, its affiliates, and any officer, director, employee, subcontractor, agent, successor, or assign of IEMR or its affiliates do not warrant that any Product(s): (a) will meet any specific requirements; (b) will be uninterrupted, timely, secure, or error-free; or (c) will contain accurate or reliable results. Except as expressly set out in these License Terms, all such warranties are excluded to the maximum extent permissible by law. You assume sole responsibility for the selection, suitability and use of the Product(s) and acknowledge that, as stated above, IEMR does not provide any additional warranties or guarantees relating to the Product(s).

5.3 No Liability. IEMR, its affiliates, and any officer, director, employee, subcontractor, agent, successor, or assign of IEMR or its affiliates, shall not be liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, special, consequential or exemplary damages, including but not limited to, damages for loss of profits, goodwill, use, data or other intangible losses (even if IEMR has been advised of the possibility of such damages), resulting from: (a) the use or the inability to use any Product(s); (b) the cost of procurement of a substitute goods and services resulting from any goods, data, information or services purchased or obtained or messages received or transactions entered into through or from any Product(s); (c) any unauthorized access to or alteration of any Product(s); (d) any price change, suspension or discontinuance of any Product(s); or (e) any other matter relating to any Product(s).

6. CONFIDENTIALITY

Except as strictly required to use the Product(s) pursuant to these License Terms, you shall not use, copy, adapt, alter, disclose, publicize (or in any way part with possession of) any information of IEMR which comes into your possession as a result of these License Terms (“Confidential Information”). This obligation shall not apply to information which: (a) you can prove was already in your possession at the date it was received or obtained; or (b) you have obtained from a third party with good legal title thereto.

IE Market Research

Disclaimers, Disclosures & License Agreement

52

Page 53: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

7. NOTICES

Any notice, invoice or other document sent from one party to the other shall be duly given if sent to an authorized representative of the other party (including, but not limited to, any individual named in an Order) by: (a) registered mail or courier delivery to the other party’s principal place of business, (b) facsimile, or (c) email (with return receipt requested).

8. FORCE MAJEURE

IEMR shall not be liable for any delay or failure to perform any obligation under these License Terms insofar as the performance of such obligation is prevented by an event beyond IEMR’s reasonable control, including but not limited to, earthquake, fire, flood or any other natural disaster, labour dispute, riot, revolution, terrorism, acts of restraint by the government or regulatory authorities, failure of computer equipment and failure or delay of sources from which data is obtained.

9. TERM AND TERMINATION

9.1 General. These License Terms shall be deemed to be effective as of the date of acceptance of IEMR of an Order from You (the “Effective Date”) and shall continue in full force and effect until terminated in accordance with its terms. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Section 9, IEMR may, in its sole discretion, terminate any license granted to you hereunder without notice in the event of non-compliance by you with these License Terms, including, but not limited to the non-payment of any amounts due and payable to IEMR.

9.2 Annual Subscriptions. Each Annual Subscription shall commence on the Effective Date applicable to it and continue in full force and effect for a twelve (12) month period (the “Initial Term”). Thereafter, each Annual Subscription shall renew for successive twelve (12) month periods (each, a “Renewal Term”). Either party may cancel the relevant Annual Subscription with three (3) months advance written notice to the other party.

10. MISCELLANEOUS

10.1 Entire Agreement. These License Terms, along with any terms and conditions set forth in an Order, constitute the entire agreement between the parties relating to the licensing of the Product(s) and supersedes all previous agreements and understandings, whether oral or written, relating to such licensing. In the event of any inconsistency between these terms and conditions and any Order, these License Terms shall prevail. No modifications, amendments or supplements to these License Terms shall be effective for any purpose unless in writing signed by each party. Approvals or consents hereunder by a party shall also be in writing.

10.2 Assignment. You shall not have the right to assign your rights or obligations under these License Terms to another party without the prior written consent of IEMR.

10.3 No Waiver. Failure of IEMR at any time to enforce any of these terms and conditions or to require performance by you of any such term or condition shall not be construed as a waiver of such provision or affect the right of IEMR to enforce the same.

10.4 Severability. If any provision of these License Terms, or an Order, is held to be invalid or unenforceable by any court or administrative body of competent jurisdiction, the invalidity or unenforceability of such provision shall not affect the other provisions of these License Terms, and all provisions not so affected by such invalidity or unenforceability shall remain in full force and effect. The parties agree to attempt to substitute for any invalid or unenforceable provision a valid or enforceable provision which achieves to the greatest extent possible the economic objectives of the invalid or unenforceable provision.

10.5 Survival. Sections 2 through 8 and 10 shall survive the expiration of termination of these License Terms.

IE Market Research

Disclaimers, Disclosures & License Agreement

53

Page 54: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

10. MISCELLANEOUS (contd.)

10.6 Governing Law and Jurisdiction. These License Terms shall be governed by the laws of the Province of British Columbia (Canada), without regard to any principles of conflicts of law. Any disputes arising in connection with these License Terms (including non-contractual disputes) shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of the Province of British Columbia.

10.7 Equitable Relief. You acknowledge that your breach of these License Terms may cause IEMR irreparable damage for which recovery of money damages would be inadequate, and you agree that IEMR shall be entitled, in addition to any other remedies available to it, to seek (in any court of competent jurisdiction) injunctive relief and/or other equitable relief to prevent or restrain any breach by you or otherwise to protect its rights, without being required to post a bond or other security.

© 2012 IE Market Research Corp.

All rights reserved.

IE Market Research

Disclaimers, Disclosures & License Agreement

54

Page 55: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

Nokia ● Motorola ● Qualcomm ● Samsung ● Palm Canada ● Google ● SK

Telecom ● Tellabs ● PCCW ● Meteor Mobile ● Sunrise Communications AG

● Djezzy (Algeria) ● Anovoss ● Brightpoint de Colombia ● Embarq

Corporation ● Toppoly Optoelectronics ● SES Americom ● Total Choice

Communications ● Goldman Sachs ● Deutsche Bank ● Lazard Stifel

Financial Corp. ● Tatica Asset Management ● TA Associates ● Bain Capital ●

Westpac Banking Corporation ● PWC ● KPMG ● McKinsey ● Oliver Wyman

● Booz Allen Hamilton ● Monitor Group ● Bain & Company ● Womble

Carlyle LLP ● Salomaa Group/AS-Grey Oy ● OC&C Strategy Consultants ●

Accenture ● Amdocs

IE Market Research

Who are our Clients?

55

Page 56: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

ORDER FORM

IEMR’S GLOBAL MOBILE OPERATOR FORECAST

You can place your order in the following alternative ways:

1. Place your order online in our web shop at www.iemarketresearch.com

2. Mail this order sheet to us at: 2300 - 1066 West Hastings Street, Vancouver, B.C. V6E 3X2 CANADA

3. Email your order to: [email protected]

4. Phone us at: +1 604 876 4367

Family/Surname First Name Position Company

Address Country Postal Code

Telephone Fax Email

Card number Expiry date (MM/YY) CV code

/

Cardholder’s name Signature

Billing address

Postcode Country

Please charge my credit card

□ VISA □ Mastercard □ American Express

□ We enclose our cheque payable to IE Market Research Corporation

□ Please invoice me

Signature Date

Single-User (One-CountryMOF Report)

$500.00

Multi-User License (One-Country MOF Report

$1,250.00

Monthly Subscription* (All Reports)

*12-month commitment required

$299.00Per Month/User

I want the following Country / Regional Forecasts:

Page 57: Global mobile operator forecast 2Q 2014 presentation, 2003-2017

www.iemarketresearch.com [email protected]