GfK Verein Trust in Professions 2018 – a GfK Verein study
Transcript of GfK Verein Trust in Professions 2018 – a GfK Verein study
GfK Verein
Trust in Professions 2018 –a GfK Verein study
From firefighters to politicians
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
2
Copyright GfK Verein
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, or transmitted in any form without the prior (written) permission of the copyright holders.
March 2018
Responsible: Ronald Frank
GfK VereinGesellschaft für Konsum-, Markt- und Absatzforschung e.V.
District Court NurembergRegister of Associations VR200665
Nordwestring 101, 90419 Nuremberg, GermanyTel.: +49 911 95151-983 and -972 – Fax: +49 911 37677 872
Email: [email protected]: http://www.gfk-verein.org
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
3
GfK Consumer Experiences:
Birgit MüllerSusanne SiegertRolf Bürkl
GfK Verein:
Ronald Frank
Introduction 4 3 North and South America in detail 61
Brazil 62
1 Global trust 5 Mexico 64
USA 66
2 Europe in detail 25
France 26 4 Asia and the Pacific in detail
Germany 28 India 71
▪ World Wide Web-analysis 35 Indonesia 73
Italy 45 Iran 75
Netherlands 47 Japan 77
Poland 49 South Korea 79
Russia 51
Spain 53 5 Africa in detail 81
Sweden 55 Kenya 82
Turkey 57 South Africa 84
UK 59
6 Methodology 86
Trust in Professions 2018
Contents
70
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
4
The 2018 edition of the Trust in Professions study
conducted by GfK Verein now covers 20 countries worldwide.
While Mexico has been newly added, Argentina, Australia,
Belgium, Canada, Nigeria, Austria, Switzerland and the
Philippines are no longer included in the study. Professions are
of central importance to the functioning of societies resting on
the division of labour, as outside of their private sphere of life,
citizens and consumers primarily come into contact with
representatives of professional groups. Mutual trust is essential
for these relationships and transactions. This study examines
the empirically researched trust placed in over 30 professions
with which people come into contact directly or indirectly, in
other words, via the media. The level of trust awarded by the
respondents is partly influenced by both the extent and nature
of media coverage and political decisions. For example, in
Poland trust in judges and lawyers, but also in journalists and
TV presenters, has diminished against the background of a
controversial judicial reform.
In 2018, the global trust ranking continues to be headed
by firefighters, paramedics, technicians and doctors, but also
teachers and farmers. These professional groups can be
described as undisputed professions, which are indispensable
for the basic functioning of the economy and society, and which
must be reliable, especially in emergencies and other
exceptional circumstances. Although professions such as bank
assistants, retailers and sellers, judges, the police and
journalists are mid-table in the ranking, they appear to cause
some contention among the respondents, as their ratings vary
considerably from one country to the next (from less than 20%
to more than 90%).
This report also contains the results of a World Wide Web
analysis for three selected professions, which found that
politicians in Germany experience the most – and at the same
time the most negative – remarks or comments, followed by the
police. Market or opinion researchers are discussed very little in
comparison and, when they are, they tend to be commented on
in a more neutral editorial context than on social networks.
The Trust in Professions study is conducted by GfK
Verein every two years. The next edition will be published in
2020.
Ronald Frank | GfK Verein
Introduction
If you can trust someone,
you don't need a contract.
If you can't trust him, a
contract is useless (J.P.
Getty)
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
5
1 Global trust
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
6
By far the highest average level of trust across all
professional groups continues to be found in India. The
country has even strengthened its lead by increasing its rating
slightly to 85%. Along with the Netherlands (75%) and South
Africa (74%), countries from three continents occupy the top
three. Represented by the USA, the American continent,
meanwhile, only comes in at seventh place. Mean trust across
all countries is 72% this year and has thus remained stable
over the years. In order to be able to compare the current
results better, the results for the countries that no longer form
part of this study in 2018 were not considered when
calculating the average ratings for the previous years.
The greatest loss is recorded for Indonesia, which in
2016 was one of the two front runners in the country ranking.
After a clear increase in 2016, trust has now dropped again to
69%. A similarly high decline is also seen in Sweden (60%),
where the change in survey institute may have influenced the
results. Thus Sweden performs similarly to the newly added
Mexico, with both countries finding themselves in the lower
third of the ranking. According to the GfK Verein study
Challenges of Nations 2017, the top five challenges facing
Mexico include crime, politics/government and corruption. It
therefore comes as no surprise that Mexicans regard the
police, mayors and politicians as the least trustworthy
professions. In contrast, Turkey has shown the biggest
increase, its trust rating rising by 12 percentage points to
71%, which means it has once more achieved the level
attained in 2014. This is also reflected in the global ranking,
where Turkey has climbed to fourth place. In addition to India,
noticeable, albeit smaller gains, can also be found in the
Netherlands, Brazil and France. In the 2018 international
comparison, Japan and South Korea bring up the rear,
positioned only just behind Mexico with average trust levels of
under 60%.
In addition to the average level of trust, it is worth taking
a look at the number of professional groups that are rated as
reliable by less than half of the respondents in a country. A
similar picture emerges here as well, as countries with a high
level of overall trust, such as India, the Netherlands or South
Africa, occupy the top spots in this regard.
Complete overview /// Results (1)
More than 23,000 respondents in 20 countries represent about 1.3 billion people.
Average trust in professions
Range and mean across all countries
72
0 20 40 60 80 100
South Korea India
Number of professional groups trusted by less than half of the population
< 5
>10
TR ZAIN KE
SE JPMX KR
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
7
The countries at the lower end of the scale have certain
results in common. For example, South Koreans, Japanese,
Mexicans and Swedes are more critical overall and also
regard a larger number of professions with a high degree of
scepticism. The East African country of Kenya stands out in
particular. Although its average trust rating of 65% puts it in
the middle of the ranking, it is only especially mistrustful of
four professions. The widest range, i.e. the largest difference
between the lowest and the highest levels of trust, can be
found in Iran as well as in Spain and France.
In addition to the average level of trust per country, this
study also presents the average rating across all the countries
for each of the professions studied. This value, as well as the
total value, is calculated by weighting the country results in
accordance with the respective number of inhabitants. Across
all the countries, firefighters remain the most trusted
profession, followed closely by doctors, physicians and
paramedics, who are perceived as reliable by nine out of ten
people. Nurses and teachers follow hot on their heels, with
89%. Accordingly, these professions also frequently occupy
the top spots in the respective country rankings. In fact,
firefighters enjoy the greatest rate of approval in eleven
countries, while paramedics, doctors and physicians are
viewed most favourably in three countries. In Kenya, on the
other hand, farmers take pole position, while in Mexico it is
nurses and in Indonesia teachers who top the scale.
Of the most trustworthy professions, paramedics and
nurses are the least controversial in the international
comparison. However, the narrowest range of less than 20
percentage points is recorded for pilots, who are trusted by
86% of people worldwide. Approval for this profession is at its
highest in the Netherlands and – comparatively speaking – at
its lowest in Mexico and Turkey. In contrast, insurance
agents, pastors and priests, and retailers are the most
polarising. Priests also occupy last place in the mainly Muslim
countries of Iran and Indonesia. On the other hand, in
Sweden it is retailers who enjoy the least trust. In all other
countries, however, the last place in the ranking is
consistently occupied by politicians, who therefore also
perform the most poorly by far across all countries.
Complete overview /// Results (2)
Across all countries:Professional groups with the...
…narrowest range
…widest range
Pilots
Insurance agents
Pastors, priests
Retailers/sellers
highest trust
lowest trust
93%
Politicians17%
Firefighters
Professional groups with the...
Paramedics
Nurses
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
8
65 65 65 63 60 60 60 59 58 5765 64 63 60
69
5563
-
56 5964 64 63
68 6756
63
-
57 59
Average
all countries*
Kenya RussiaSpain France South KoreaJapanBrazilSweden Mexico
(Average of "I completely/generally trust" across all professional groups, in %)
Complete overview /// Average level of trust in each country
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
Germany
PolandTurkeyNetherlands USA ItalyUKIranSouth Africa Indonesia
8575 74 72 71 69 68 67 66 66 65
82
6974 71
59
7968 65 67 65 67
7870
8171 72 75
-
7365 65
60
India
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
9
8575 74 72 71 69 68 67 66 66 65
0
20
40
60
80
100
65 65 65 63 60 60 60 59 58 57
0
20
40
60
80
100
Kenya RussiaSpain France South KoreaJapanBrazilSweden Mexico
("I completely/generally trust", average across all professional groups, in %)
Complete overview /// Trust per country: range and average
Base: 23,519 respondents
Average
all countries
Germany
PolandTurkeyNetherlands USA ItalyUKIranSouth Africa IndonesiaIndia
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
10
Average
all countries
Mexico
Indonesia
9 9 9 910 10
12 1213
14
France South Korea
Turkey
Japan
Netherlands Brazil
USAUK Sweden
South Africa
1 12
34
56
7 7 7 7
("I completely/generally trust", number of professional groups < 50%)
Complete overview /// Number of professional groups trusted by less than half of the population
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents
Kenya Germany
Spain RussiaIran
PolandIndia Italy
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
11("I completely/generally trust", number of professional groups < 50%, average trust in %, the size of the points represents the population share of the countries)
Complete overview /// Number of professional groups trusted by less than half of the population and average trust
India
USA
GermanyItaly
France
Poland
Mexico
Russia
Spain
Sweden
UK
Netherlands
Turkey
BrazilIndonesia
Iran
Japan
South Korea
Kenya South Africa
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90
Nu
mb
er
of
pro
fes
sio
na
l g
rou
ps
tru
ste
d b
y
les
s t
ha
n h
alf
of
the
po
pu
lati
on
Average trust
Average 72
Base: 23,519 respondents; please note: weighted average "number of professional groups < 50%" is 1, due to the large influence of India (population)
In India, the country with the highest average trust rating, only one professional group is below the 50% mark. In South Korea and Japan, which show the lowest level of trust, 13 and 14 professional groups respectively are trusted by less than half of citizens.
Exception Kenya: although the average trust rating is comparatively low, only four professions have trust levels below 50%.
EuropeNorth and SouthAmerica
Asia and the PacificAfrica
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
12
Base: 23,519 respondents
Complete overview /// Professional groups with the highest trust rating per country
Netherlands
Paramedics 99%
Germany
Firefighters 96%
Sweden
Firefighters 97%
Poland
Firefighters 92%
Russia
Firefighters 90%
Turkey
Doctors, physicians 88%
Mexico
Nurses 90%Japan
Paramedics 90%
Iran
Firefighters 100%
Indonesia
Teachers 99%
South Korea
Firefighters 88%
UK
Paramedics 94%
Brazil
Firefighters 96%
South Africa
Doctors, physicians 93%
Kenya
Farmers 92%
India
Doctors, physicians 99%
USA
Firefighters 94%
Spain
Firefighters 97%
France
Firefighters 99%
Italy
Firefighters 91%
Contents
©G
fK V
ere
in 2
018
13
Complete overview /// Professional groups with the lowest trust rating per country
Base: 23,519 respondents
Netherlands
Politicians 29%
Germany
Politicians 14%
Sweden
Retailers, sellers 11%
Poland
Politicians 22%
Russia
Politicians 23%
Turkey
Politicians 34%
Mexico
Politicians 13%Japan
Politicians 12%
Iran
Pastors, priests 8%
Indonesia
Pastors, priests 26%
South Korea
Politicians 9%
UK
Politicians 22%
Brazil
Politicians 7%
South Africa
Politicians 35%
Kenya
Politicians 19%
India
Politicians 48%
USA
Politicians 16%
Spain
Politicians 5%
France
Politicians 7%
Italy
Politicians 13%
Contents
©G
fK V
ere
in 2
018
14(Average of "I completely/generally trust" across all countries, in %)
Complete overview /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents; restricted comparability due to additional country (Mexico)
-2
-1
1
2
3
0
0
1
1
2
1
0
0
3
1
1
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Doctors, physicians
Paramedics
Nurses
Teachers
Pharmacists
Farmers
Engineers
Pilots
Soldiers
Craftsmen
Architects
Computer or software specialists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Judges
Retailers, sellers
92
91
90
89
89
88
87
87
86
84
80
79
77
77
72
69
-1
-1
-1
-3
-2
1
3
2
7
1
0
1
2
1
4
1
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Bankers, bank assistants
Professional athletes, footballers
Cab drivers
Policemen
Civil servants
Lawyers
Market or opinion researchers
Journalists
TV hosts, TV presenters
Pastors, priests
Actors
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Advertising specialists
Mayors
Insurance agents
Politicians
69
69
67
67
67
66
64
63
62
62
62
62
57
56
54
29
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
15
92
91
90
89
89
88
87
87
0 20 40 60 80 100
("I completely/generally trust", minimum, maximum and average, in %)
Complete overview /// Trust in the professional groups: range and average (1)
Range Mean across all countries
86
84
80
79
77
77
72
69
0 20 40 60 80 100
Iran
India
Iran
Netherlands
Indonesia
Iran
India
Iran
Japan
Russia
Brazil
Kenya
Iran
Russia
South Korea
Brazil
Netherlands
India
India
Netherlands
India
Netherlands
India
Netherlands
Japan
Iran
Iran
Mexico,Turkey
Iran
Iran
Mexico
Sweden
Firefighters
Doctors, physicians
Paramedics
Nurses
Teachers
Pharmacists
Farmers
Engineers
Pilots
Soldiers
Craftsmen
Architects
Computer or software specialists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Judges
Retailers, sellers
Base: 23,519 respondents
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
16("I completely/generally trust", minimum, maximum and average, in %)
Complete overview /// Trust in the professional groups: range and average (2)
69
69
67
67
67
66
64
63
0 20 40 60 80 100
62
62
62
62
57
56
54
29
0 20 40 60 80 100
India
India
Iran
Iran
India
Iran
India
Iran
Iran
France
Sweden
Spain
Kenya
Mexico
Indonesia
Japan
India
India
Iran
India
India
Iran
India
Netherlands
France
Iran
South Korea
Japan
Iran
Japan
Brazil
Spain
Bankers, bank assistants
Professional athletes, footballers
Cab drivers
Policemen
Civil servants
Lawyers
Market or opinion researchers
Journalists
TV hosts, TV presenters
Pastors, priests
Actors
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Advertising specialists
Mayors
Insurance agents
Politicians
Base: 23,519 respondents
Range Mean across all countries
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
17
88 88 88 84 83 83 81 7973
66
8289 85
-
82 8274 75
6474
89 88 89
-
7987
80 79
6674
Average
all countries* Germany
PolandKenya Russia
Spain France
South KoreaTurkey Japan
Netherlands
BrazilUSA Italy
UK IranSweden
Mexico
South AfricaIndonesia
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
At a glance /// Doctors, physicians
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
99 96 94 93 91 90 90 89 89 89 8995 95
8996
89 88 92 89 92100
8897 93
8895
89 88 86 88 90
-
89
India
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
18
Average
all countries*
Netherlands
JapanTurkeySouth Korea
France SpainRussia
Kenya
Poland Germany
USA
ItalyUK
Iran Sweden
Mexico
South Africa IndonesiaIndia
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
At a glance /// Bankers, bank assistants
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
Brazil
8980
75 71 69 69 67 67 64 62 60
8575 77
67 68 67
50
86
40
61
75
8879 82
69 7076
-
7466
6172
56 55 52 5141 40 40 36 36
23
54
-
4943
3742 43
33 34
19
49
-
5546
41 4539 36
27
14
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
19
Average
all countries*
61 60 56 5550 46 45 45
37 35
64 6558 57
44 45
63
43 4230
5561 60 59
4940
6455
39 36
IndonesiaIndia
8782 79 75 74 71 70 70 69 65 61
77 81 7972
67
81 84
5966
55
-
6976
8474
56
72
-
5763
69
-
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
At a glance /// Professional athletes, footballers
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
Germany
PolandKenya Russia
Spain FranceSouth Korea
Turkey
Japan
Netherlands
USAItaly UK
Iran
Sweden
South Africa Mexico
Brazil
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
20
Average
all countries*
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
At a glance /// Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
Germany
Poland
Kenya
Russia
Spain
FranceSouth Korea
Turkey
Japan
Netherlands USA
Italy UK IranSweden
South Africa IndonesiaIndia Mexico
Brazil
80 7873 69 67 67
62 61 5953 53
8778
6470
-
84
6454
4449
54
7483
62
75
-
7261
5464
5851
49 4942 39 38 38 35 33 33 29
50 48 46 4837 41
3237
32 3339
4739
46 42 4132
40
53
-
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
21
Average
all countries*
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
At a glance /// Policemen
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
Germany
Poland KenyaRussia
SpainFrance
South KoreaTurkey
JapanNetherlands USAItalyUK Sweden
South AfricaIndonesia
India
MexicoBrazil
9489
84 84 81 81 80 78 7770 6870
84 82 83 8674
80 77 77
64 65
-
82 81 82 8276 75
8276
50
66
67 65 64 60 5752 49 48
3629
65 62 6554
4655
64
51
-
26
5948
59 5644
50
64 61
-
25
Iran
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
22
Average
all countries*
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
At a glance /// Market or opinion researchers
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
Germany
RussiaSpain FranceSouth Korea
Turkey
Japan
Netherlands
USA
ItalyUKIran
Sweden
South Africa
Indonesia
India
MexicoBrazil
Poland Kenya
9181
7267 64 64 63 60 60 59 56
8678 78
6963
37
5062 64 67
59
-
7785
69 6560 57
63 63 61 58
56 54 53 52 5042 41 37 36 33
72
51 5548
-
3948
33 36
6970
53 54 58
-
45 47
32
5464
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
23
Average
all countries*
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
At a glance /// Politicians
Base 2018: 23,519 respondents, *restricted comparability: 2016 and 2014 due to Iran (new); 2018 and 2016 due to Mexico (new) 2018 2016 2014
Germany
Poland KenyaRussia
SpainFranceSouth Korea
Turkey
Japan
Netherlands
USA Italy
UK
Iran
SwedenSouth AfricaIndonesiaIndia
Mexico Brazil
48
35 35 3429 29
23 22 22 19 16
48 51
38
2031 31 33
20 20 23 23
4350
4334 31 29 30
16 17 1622
16 14 13 13 12 11 9 7 7 512 14
-
15 1222
166 6 6
2315
-12 14
-
21
613
5
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
24
India
France
Germany
Italy
Poland
Russia
Spain
Sweden
UKNetherlands
TurkeyBrazil
IndonesiaIran
Japan
South Korea
Kenya
South Africa
USA
Mexico
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Co
rru
pti
on
Pe
rce
pti
on
s In
de
x 2
01
6
Trust in Professions
Average 48
Average 69
Average of "I completely/generally trust" across all public professions, in %; CPI in score points; the size of the displayed points represents the population of the countries
Level of trust: public professions and Corruption Perceptions Index 2016
Base: 23,519 respondents; definition of public professions: civil servants, mayors, policemen, judges, soldiers
Trust in public professions is greater in those countries where there is a climate of low perceived corruption. Exceptions: in Sweden and Japan, people tend to have little trust in public professions, although only a low level of corruption is perceived; the opposite is true in India, where trust in public professions is high, despite high levels of corruption.
little perceived
corruption, high trust
high perceived
corruption, high trust
high perceived
corruption, low trust
little perceived
corruption, low trustEuropeNorth and SouthAmerica
Asia and the PacificAfrica
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
25
2 Europe in detail
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
26
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.90
In 2018, the French rate a number of the professions
studied a little more positively. The average trust rating has
therefore increased slightly – but at 63% it is still in the lower
half of the global ranking.
In the spring of 2017, public debate in France was
particularly shaped by the presidential election. The
presidential candidate Macron was able to prevail against
those of the established parties, and his new party En Marche
achieved an absolute majority in the National Assembly. In
addition to reforms to the economy and the labour market, the
demand for increased honesty and a change of mentality in
politics was also on his agenda. France ranks 23rd on the
Corruption Perceptions Index published by Transparency
International, meaning it is behind countries with a similar
level of economic development. To combat corruption, a law
was passed in August 2017 prohibiting parliamentarians from
employing relatives at public expense. This practice had
caused particular harm to the conservative candidate Fillon
during the election campaign. At just 7%, the French continue
to have little faith in politicians and this profession occupies
last place in the ranking. As was the case in 2016, the
advertising industry is positioned only slightly ahead. In total,
ten of the professions studied are once again below the 50%
mark, including journalists, insurance agents and
businessmen and entrepreneurs, each of whom are only
trusted by around one in three French respondents.
The order of the first five professional groups also
remains the same as in 2016. With a trust rating of 99%,
firefighters have successfully defended first place, closely
followed by nurses, with 97%. The third and fourth places are
also occupied by medical professionals. In times of high
uncertainty, triggered by several Islamist-motivated terrorist
attacks, the population also has significantly more trust in
soldiers (89%) and the police (81%). Judges may also be
benefiting from this development, gaining 7 percentage points
to achieve 62%. Cab drivers, however, clock up the largest
increase in trust this year, securing a position in the lower-mid
range by climbing 9 percentage points to 62%. France's cab
drivers caused a sensation in 2016 with massive protests
against the transportation service provider Uber.
France /// Results
CPI 69Perceived corruption
65.0 MPopulation
40.5 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
87% of age 20-64secondary-educated
10.0%
Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
1.2% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
27("I completely/generally trust", in %)
France /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,064 respondents
0
1
1
2
1
5
6
2
3
3
7
5
6
2
0
5
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Nurses
Pharmacists
Paramedics
Doctors, physicians
Pilots
Soldiers
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Teachers
Farmers
Policemen
Engineers
Computer or software specialists
Craftsmen
Architects
Civil servants
99
97
93
92
89
89
89
87
84
82
81
79
74
72
70
70
-2
2
5
7
9
6
2
4
4
0
5
1
2
2
1
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Retailers, sellers
Mayors
Judges
Cab drivers
Lawyers
Actors
Pastors, priests
TV hosts, TV presenters
Bankers, bank assistants
Market or opinion researchers
Professional athletes, footballers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Journalists
Insurance agents
Advertising specialists
Politicians
63
62
62
62
57
52
45
44
41
36
35
33
31
30
16
7
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
28
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.93
In general, trust in the professions studied has remained
stable in Germany in 2018. The trust engendered in the
professional groups at the top of the ranking remains
constant, at around the 95% mark. The composition of this
group of frontrunners remains unchanged as well, with
firefighters, paramedics and nursing professions once again
leading the way. Next in the ranking are doctors, physicians,
bus and train drivers, and pilots, all of whom are trusted by
almost 90% of Germans.
Larger drops in trust are not seen until the second half
of the ranking. For example, lawyers witness a decline of 5
percentage points, taking them to 67%. This could be a
response to one of the highest profile trials of recent years,
the case against the right-wing terror cell NSU. Among other
things, the defendants' petitions on the grounds of bias
delayed the course of the trial so that the pleadings of the
Federal Prosecutor's Office and, above all, those of the co-
plaintiffs had to be postponed for several weeks. Professional
athletes and footballers have lost the same amount of
approval as lawyers (37%). This could be attributable, for
example, to the very high transfer fees paid in football, which
many citizens and fans no longer find appropriate. Trust in
bankers (40%) and pastors (57%) has sunk by 4 percentage
points. The drop in trust in priests corresponds with the
continued fall in membership numbers of the two major
churches in Germany. By contrast, the number of Orthodox
Christians and Muslims in the country has risen slightly.
A total of seven professional groups are considered
trustworthy by less than half of Germans, including advertising
specialists (25%) and insurance agents (23%). Politicians
continue to bring up the rear of the rankings, with an
unchanged trust rating of 14%. The 2017 Bundestag election,
which took place during the survey period, perhaps plays a
role in this. During the election, the two grand coalition parties
suffered losses, while the smaller parties made gains. This
meant that the FDP was able to return to the German
Bundestag and the right-wing populist AfD took up seats for
the first time. The AfD had already shifted the political
discourse to the right during the election campaign, and was
able to score points with immigration and domestic security
among both former non-voters and protest voters.
Germany /// Results
CPI 81Hardly any perceived corruption
82.1 MPopulation
54.1 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
97% of age 20-64secondary-educated
4.3% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
1.9% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
29("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Germany /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 2,056 respondents
-2
-1
-3
-2
0
0
0
0
0
2
2
3
0
0
0
3
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Paramedics
Nurses
Doctors, physicians
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Pilots
Pharmacists
Engineers
Policemen
Craftsmen
Teachers
Farmers
Architects
Judges
Cab drivers
Soldiers
96
96
95
89
89
89
87
85
84
80
80
78
75
74
71
69
-5
-2
-4
-2
-1
-2
-4
-5
-3
1
1
0
2
2
1
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Lawyers
Civil servants
Mayors
Computer or software specialists
Pastors, priests
Market or opinion researchers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Retailers, sellers
TV hosts, TV presenters
Actors
Bankers, bank assistants
Journalists
Professional athletes, footballers
Advertising specialists
Insurance agents
Politicians
67
60
60
60
57
56
53
51
50
46
40
38
37
25
23
14
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
30
Even 28 years after German reunification, differences
between East and West can still be found. In the East, for
example, there are hardly any large companies; rather, there
is less economic and purchasing power, and unemployment is
higher. With regard to professions, however, at present only
specific groups are perceived differently. Moreover, the
average trust ratings in the two parts of the country are even
virtually the same this year, with overall trust rising slightly to
64% in the East and dropping marginally to 65% in the West.
In comparison with 2016, the western regions of the country
have more stable trust values, but citizens in both parts of the
country largely agree when it comes to the professions at the
top and bottom of the ranking.
As in 2016, the greatest differences are to be found in
the assessment of pastors. Regardless of age, West
Germans trust this professional group significantly more (by
25 percentage points). The fact that the proportion of citizens
with no religious affiliation is particularly high in the East – in
spite of the East German town of Wittenberg being
considered the cradle of the Reformation, the 500th
anniversary of which was celebrated in 2017 – is a legacy of
the socialist GDR.
The situation for lawyers, the police, judges, civil
servants and mayors is similar to that found in 2016, with
each of these professional groups enjoying a level of trust that
is at least 10 percentage points higher in Western Germany.
After the fall of the Berlin Wall, many positions in the judiciary,
public administration and universities in East Germany were
filled by West German candidates. This may be one of the
reasons why older citizens of former East Germany in
particular feel sceptical towards judges. It could also be a
hangover effect from the GDR judiciary, as there were hardly
any lawsuits during this time. Bankers are also rated very
critically by older people in the East.
By contrast, East Germans view retailers (59%) and
actors (56%) in a noticeably more positive light. At 63%, more
people in the East trust market and opinion researchers than
in the West (55%), especially the under-50s. The extent to
which the results found in this study will converge in the future
will partly depend on whether the degree of similarity between
the economy in the East and West continues to increase.
Germany /// Differences between West and East
West and East Germany
Average trust in professions
65%
64%
66%
62%
West
East
20182016
20182016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
31("I completely/generally trust", in %)
West Germany /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,651 respondents
-1
-1
-1
-2
-4
-1
-1
-1
-6
0
0
0
2
1
3
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Paramedics
Nurses
Doctors, physicians
Pharmacists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Pilots
Policemen
Engineers
Craftsmen
Teachers
Judges
Farmers
Architects
Cab drivers
Lawyers
96
95
94
90
89
89
89
86
86
80
79
77
77
76
70
69
-1
-4
-3
-4
-1
-4
-3
-6
-4
2
1
1
2
2
0
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Soldiers
Civil servants
Pastors, priests
Mayors
Computer or software specialists
Market or opinion researchers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
TV hosts, TV presenters
Retailers, sellers
Actors
Bankers, bank assistants
Journalists
Professional athletes, footballers
Advertising specialists
Insurance agents
Politicians
69
64
62
62
59
55
53
50
50
44
41
40
37
23
22
14
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
32
Paramedics
Nurses
Firefighters
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Pilots
Doctors, physicians
Engineers
Craftsmen
Teachers
Farmers
Pharmacists
Cab drivers
Policemen
Architects
Soldiers
Market or opinion researchers
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
East Germany /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 405 respondents
-2
-5
2
3
1
2
5
1
3
2
3
2
5
2
9
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
97
97
97
90
89
89
84
83
83
82
80
79
76
71
70
63
-1
-6
-1
-3
-3
-1
-6
1
2
6
10
3
1
2
3
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Computer or software specialists
Retailers, sellers
Lawyers
Judges
Actors
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Mayors
Civil servants
TV hosts, TV presenters
Pastors, priests
Professional athletes, footballers
Bankers, bank assistants
Journalists
Advertising specialists
Insurance agents
Politicians
62
59
59
58
56
53
52
48
47
37
37
34
31
31
27
14
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
33
Firefighters
Paramedics
Nurses
Doctors, physicians
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Pilots
Pharmacists
Engineers
Policemen
Craftsmen
Teachers
Farmers
Architects
Judges
Cab drivers
Soldiers
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Germany /// Trust in professional groupsComparison of East and West Germany
Base 2018: 2,056 respondents0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Lawyers
Civil servants
Mayors
Computer or software specialists
Pastors, priests
Market or opinion researchers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Retailers, sellers
TV hosts, TV presenters
Actors
Bankers, bank assistants
Journalists
Professional athletes, footballers
Advertising specialists
Insurance agents
Politicians
West
East
Contents
©G
fK V
ere
in 2
018
34
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Germany /// Trust in professional groupsComparison of East and West Germany by age group
Base 2018: 2,056 respondents0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Lawyers
Civil servants
Mayors
Computer or software specialists
Pastors, priests
Market or opinion researchers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Retailers, sellers
TV hosts, TV presenters
Actors
Bankers, bank assistants
Journalists
Professional athletes, footballers
Advertising specialists
Insurance agents
Politicians
West 50 plus
East 50 plus
West under 50 years old
East under 50 years old
Firefighters
Paramedics
Nurses
Doctors, physicians
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Pilots
Pharmacists
Engineers
Policemen
Craftsmen
Teachers
Farmers
Architects
Judges
Cab drivers
Soldiers
Contents
©G
fK V
ere
in 2
018
35Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW (1)
Remarks/comments absoluteComparison of online references made
0
40.000
80.000
120.000
160.000
Policemen Politicians Market researchers
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
total positive negative total positive negative total positive negative
Reputation at a glanceAssessment/perception of the professional groups online
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Policemen Politicians Market researchers
Negative
Neutral
Positive
Policemen Politicians Market researchers
Editorial
content
User-generated
content
Source of remarks/mentions/comments: Editorial content (e.g. from media, companies) vs user-generated content (e.g. from blogs, forums and social networks)
Of the professions studied,
politicians are most frequently
mentioned on the Internet.
Policemen follow in second
place. In contrast, significantly
less content is posted online
about market researchers.
Politicians are not only men-
tioned very often, but are also
presented in the most negative
light. Content concerning
market researchers is almost
exclusively neutral in tone.
Negative comments are more
likely to come from private
users – which is generally the
case for analyses on the Inter-
net.
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
36Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis" in %
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW (2)
Reliability
Prestige/renown/reputation
Future/security
Policemen
73 : 27 80 : 20 4 : 96
Politicians
85 : 15 70 : 30 57 : 43
Market researchers
11 : 89 40 : 60 9 : 91
Remarks/comments Share of topics
Reliability
Prestige/renown/reputation Future/security
18 : 7 : 76 18 : 2 : 81 96 : 4 : 0
7 : 6 : 86 27 : 8 : 65 57 : 43 : 0
58 : 0 : 42 48 : 36 : 16 74 : 21 : 5
ReputationAssessment of the topics
NegativeNeutralPositive
Source Topics user/supplier generated
Editorial contentUser-generated content
Remarks/comments Share of topics
34
18
82
696
11 64
2
94
The texts were analysed for
aspects that provide informa-
tion about the image of a pro-
fession (see the key on the
left). However, classifying
texts in this way often proves
impossible, meaning that each
profession has a high propor-
tion of "other topics" – most
often in the case of market
researchers. Most of these
"other topics" are reports
about various studies.
Politicians and the police are
rated similarly poorly in terms
of reliability and "prestige/
renown/reputation".
Pay Helpfulness Corruption
Prestige/renown/reputation
Reliability Future/security
Credibility
Other
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
37Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW (3)
Policemen
Politicians
Market researchers
59%
51%
24%
27%
29%
46%
4%
8%
1%
4%
5%
24%
3%
3%
1%
2%
3%
4%
Twitter News Social networks Web Forums Blogs
Remarks/comments Share of topics
Over half of the texts about the
police and politicians were
found on Twitter. Just over
one in four texts comes from
online news media.
In the case of market re-
searchers, in contrast, the
picture is almost reversed, as
this professional group is most
frequently mentioned in texts
from online news media.
Twitter, networks and forums
also play a role, but much less
so than for the police and poli-
ticians.
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
38Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis" (tag cloud in German language)
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW, common terms found in the articles
Policemen: the most common terms come from police reports and are
therefore very general in nature.
Politicians: during the period under review (November 2017), negotiations
about a possible Jamaica coalition were taking place, so many terms refer to
this.
Market researchers: in this case, terms such as "percent", "test" and "com-
panies" appear, which are very often found in evaluations of various studies.
Policemen
Market or
opinion re-
searchers
Politicians
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
39Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW, mentions over time: policemen
Increased attacks on the police.
Suspended police officer is suspected of being a supporter of the "right-wing"
scene.
Case reopened from 2005: asylum seeker burnt to death in a police cell in
Dessau. Did he set himself on fire or were the police involved?
"Citizen of the Reich" resists arrest, escapes and injures police officers.
Fraudsters impersonate police officers and trick senior citizens out of their money.
31.10. 03.11. 06.11. 09.11. 12.11. 15.11. 18.11. 21.11 24.11. 27.11. 30.11.2017
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
40Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW, mentions over time: politicians
Reports and comments on the coalition negotiations ("Jamaica out").
Angela Merkel is named the most powerful woman in the world by US magazine "Forbes" for the seventh time in a row.
Various political issues, including taxation of large corporations, EU climate change plans for cars, UN Climate Change Conference and the danger of video games for children.
Knife attack on CDU mayor.
Rising number of death threats against politicians.
31.10. 03.11. 06.11. 09.11. 12.11. 15.11. 18.11. 21.11 24.11. 27.11. 30.11.2017
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
41Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW, mentions over time: market researchers
Flixbus tries hand at train business (Locomore and Hamburg–Cologne Express).
Smartphone operating system Android holds over 80% of the market share in the smartphone sector.
The new Apple Watch takes the market by storm. The "middle-aged generation".
Anxieties about social inequality and poverty in old age.
Increased demand for DNA analysis and genetic testing detected.
Consumer sentiment before Christmas or before the Christmas sales.Poll on sexual
harassment of women: Germans have relatively high level of tolerance.
31.10. 03.11. 06.11. 09.11. 12.11. 15.11. 18.11. 21.11 24.11. 27.11. 30.11.2017
200
150
100
50
10
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
42
8%
92%
Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW in detail: market or opinion researchers (1)
Topic radarPositioning of ratings within topics100% = all ratings per topic in each case
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Marketresearch
Opinionpolling
Electionpolling
Datascientists
Other*
Positive Neutral Negative
Common terms found in the articles on the Internet – totalfrom headlines and text
Source of remarks/mentions/comments: Provider-generated vs user-generated
Editorial contentUser-generated content
Audicompanylearningpercentmarket researchemployeesmachinesareaintelligenceFraunhofer
percentcompanyeurotestsapplemarketAndroidmillionscustomersanalyses
machineslearningstudynaturemediacompanyInstagramadvertjournalismprivacy
Positive Neutral Negative
* Warning, low basis (<1% of mentions)
Most of the texts about market
researchers come from edi-
torial sources.
If only the positive contribu-
tions are considered, the
subgroup of data scientists
stands out clearly. Perhaps
this may be a sign of the future
viability of this particular pro-
fessional group?
Of all subgroups, however,
opinion pollsters seem to be
subject to the most criticism.
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
43Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW in detail: market or opinion researchers (2)
Remarks/comments Comparison of groups of market and opinion researchers
57%23%
15%5% 1%
66%
Remarks/comments absoluteShare of topics excluding "other topics"
42%
20%
17%
16%
4% 1%
0%
100%
Market research Data scientists
Election pollingOpinion polling
Other
Only 1% of the texts are job advertisements
Future/security of profession Prestige/renown/reputation
ReliabilityCredibility
Pay Corruption
Helpfulness
1%
If the category "other topics" is
omitted, it can be seen that the
future viability of the pro-
fession is the most important
topic.
At 57%, more than half of the
texts refer to classic market
researchers.
And almost a quarter of the
texts are about the group of
data scientists. This group of
professionals seems to be in
high demand, as two thirds of
the texts concerning this cate-
gory are job advertisements.
Remarks/comments Proportion of job advertisements
Market researchers Data scientists
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
44Results of "360° Social Media Status Quo Analysis"
Germany /// Professional groups reflected on the WWW in detail: market or opinion researchers (3)
From two word counts for Dimap up to 344 word counts for GfK
Common terms found in the articles on the Internet – totalfrom headlines and text
Around two-thirds of the word
cloud is dominated by men-
tions of the institutes GfK,
Nielsen and YouGov during
the investigation period (No-
vember 2017).
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
45
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.89
The trust expressed by Italians in most of the
professions investigated is somewhat lower in 2018, as a
result of which the average value has dropped slightly to 65%.
As the only professional group to be rated as reliable by more
than 90% of citizens, firefighters are clearly in the lead. Even
more clear cut are the results at the bottom of the scale. Here,
politicians reside in last place, viewed as credible by only 13%
of Italians. This positions them firmly behind the professions
occupying the following positions, namely advertising
specialists, mayors, insurance agents and bank employees.
After the failure of his proposed constitutional reform, Prime
Minister Renzi resigned as announced at the end of 2016. He
was succeeded by Foreign Minister Gentiloni. Regular new
elections are scheduled for the spring of 2018. However,
officials are still constantly being confronted with allegations of
corruption, which is also reflected in the Corruption
Perceptions Index (CPI) published by Transparency
International.
Farmers and pharmacists once again find themselves
near the top of the ranking with trust ratings of 86%. Teachers
are also rated very positively at 85%, as are paramedics and
nurses, both at 84%. However, the latter have lost favour with
Italians, which may be due to various scandals in Italian
hospitals that have been widely reported in the media. These
range from the killing of several patients near Livorno to
systematic fraudulent absenteeism in a hospital in Naples.
Market or opinion researchers (59%), actors (55%), and
TV hosts and TV presenters (54%) have also suffered greater
losses in trust. Similarly, professions in the transport sector
are currently performing more poorly than in 2016. The latter
professional group went on strike in 2017, thereby affecting
traffic. Pilots and train drivers were criticising privatisation and
liberalisation in public local and long-distance transport, while
cab drivers were protesting against transportation service
intermediary Uber. Although – after the survey was conducted
– the national football team Squadra Azzurra failed to qualify
for the World Cup for the first time since 1958, trust in
professional athletes and footballers has only fallen slightly
(61%). Despite experiencing the strongest rate of growth (6
percentage points), lawyers are only trusted by just over half
of Italians.
Italy /// Results
CPI47High perceived corruption
59.4 MPopulation
37.9M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
93% of age 20-64secondary-educated
11.5%
Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
0.9%GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
46("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Italy /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,107 respondents
-3
-4
-2
-2
-7
-4
-4
-3
-6
-3
-4
-4
0
1
3
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Farmers
Pharmacists
Teachers
Paramedics
Nurses
Doctors, physicians
Craftsmen
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Engineers
Soldiers
Pilots
Policemen
Architects
Computer or software specialists
Retailers, sellers
91
86
86
85
84
84
83
83
83
81
81
81
80
78
73
68
-7
-3
-8
0
-8
-8
-3
-1
-1
-4
-2
3
6
4
0
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Cab drivers
Professional athletes, footballers
Market or opinion researchers
Judges
Actors
TV hosts, TV presenters
Civil servants
Lawyers
Pastors, priests
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Journalists
Advertising specialists
Mayors
Insurance agents
Bankers, bank assistants
Politicians
67
61
59
59
55
54
54
52
51
49
46
43
40
38
36
13
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
47
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.92
The average level of trust of 75% that the Dutch have in
the various professions not only represents an increase of 6
percentage points in 2018, but also places the Netherlands in
second place in the global trust ranking. With the exception of
politicians and insurance agents, all the professions studied
are witnessing stable, and in most cases even increasing
trust. This means that more than half of the professions
currently achieve approval ratings of at least 75%.
According to the Euro Health Consumer Index (EHCI),
the Netherlands has the best and most efficient health system
in Europe. Citizens seem to be rewarding this success, since
paramedics and nurses, along with firefighters, take the lead
in the Dutch ranking. The other healthcare professionals
(doctors, physicians and pharmacists) also achieve more than
90% approval.
The biggest rises in trust in 2018 are recorded for
engineers and technicians, who have gained 16 percentage
points, and market or opinion researchers, who have gained
14 points. Trust in retailers and sellers (76%) and professional
athletes (70%) has also increased by more than 10
percentage points. All these professions have thus been able
to recover from the loss of trust they experienced in 2016.
In contrast, only just under a third of the population
considers politicians and insurance agents to be trustworthy.
Both professions, together with bankers and bank assistants,
find themselves at the tail end of the ranking. The low level of
trust in elected representatives may possibly be related to the
general election held in March 2017. In the run-up to this, the
parties fought a very controversial election campaign in which
the right-wing populist PVV in particular divided opinions. In
December 2016, PVV leader Wilders was convicted of
discriminating against and insulting Moroccans. Despite
various forecasts to the contrary that had predicted an
electoral victory, the PVV became only the second strongest
force in parliament. Although it emerged as the most powerful
force, the conservative-liberal VVD suffered significant losses.
Due to the political fragmentation of parliament, it was difficult
to form a government, meaning that a new government
coalition was eventually established some seven months after
the election.
Netherlands /// Results
CPI 83Hardly any perceived corruption
17.0 MPopulation
11.1 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
93% of age 20-64secondary-educated
6.2% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
2.1% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
48("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Netherlands /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,000 respondents
4
2
4
7
7
5
8
6
3
5
5
16
8
9
7
9
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Paramedics
Firefighters
Nurses
Pilots
Teachers
Doctors, physicians
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Farmers
Pharmacists
Craftsmen
Policemen
Engineers
Architects
Judges
Soldiers
Mayors
99
99
98
96
95
94
93
92
92
91
89
88
86
85
85
82
-5
-3
10
12
10
8
11
2
1
14
7
7
6
1
7
3
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Computer or software specialists
Retailers, sellers
Actors
TV hosts, TV presenters
Professional athletes, footballers
Civil servants
Cab drivers
Market or opinion researchers
Lawyers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Journalists
Pastors, priests
Advertising specialists
Bankers, bank assistants
Insurance agents
Politicians
77
76
74
71
70
69
63
63
61
61
57
48
45
36
32
29
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
49
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.86
At 66%, trust across all professional groups remains
virtually stable in Poland in comparison with 2016. While the
professions at the top of the ranking have generally
experienced more growth, mayors and pastors in the lower
third have also made gains in 2018.
As the only group trusted by more than 90% of Poles,
firefighters once again lead the ranking this year. All in all,
healthcare professionals are also performing well again, with
nurses (88%) and paramedics (87%) occupying second and
third place. Meanwhile, doctors and physicians have achieved
the greatest increase in trust of all the professions, rising by 7
percentage points to 81%. The health system in Poland has
long been considered underfunded. Assistant doctors and
specialists in training often earn so little that they need to work
in multiple hospitals at the same time. Due to the poor
working conditions, many medical professionals are
emigrating. However, none of this seems to be having a
negative impact on how these professions are perceived.
In 2018, the greatest losses have been suffered by
lawyers (51%) and judges (46%), whose trust levels have
dropped by 7 and 8 percentage points respectively. Since July
2017, a reform has allowed the Polish Minister of Justice,
among other things, to dismiss judges without citing any
reasons and to appoint others instead. Critics see this as a
threat to the division of power in Poland. Since this regulation
violates EU directives, the European Commission has initiated
infringement proceedings against the country.
Journalists have also experienced a loss of trust, falling
by 5 percentage points to 48%. At the end of 2016, the
government initially imposed restrictions on reporting from
parliament, which were revoked only after protests by the
media and the opposition. In addition, at the beginning of
2016, the professional secrecy of journalists was restricted
under a new police law. This was strongly criticised by the
Council of Europe's legal experts. With a slightly improved
trust rating of 22%, politicians in Poland also lag far behind in
last place in 2018. However, they are rated better than their
counterparts in many Western European countries.
Advertising experts once again find themselves in penultimate
place, with 38% currently.
Poland /// Results
CPI 62Perceived corruption
38.2 MPopulation
26.5 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
100% of age 20-64secondary-educated
6.2% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
2.7% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
50("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Poland /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,000 respondents
-1
2
1
4
3
5
3
7
1
2
1
0
0
2
6
4
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Nurses
Paramedics
Soldiers
Pharmacists
Farmers
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Doctors, physicians
Engineers
Pilots
Craftsmen
Teachers
Retailers, sellers
Architects
Professional athletes, footballers
Cab drivers
92
88
87
85
84
82
81
81
80
79
78
78
76
75
74
68
-3
-1
-2
-5
-2
-7
-5
-8
0
-2
6
6
4
4
0
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Computer or software specialists
Policemen
Actors
TV hosts, TV presenters
Market or opinion researchers
Mayors
Pastors, priests
Bankers, bank assistants
Lawyers
Civil servants
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Journalists
Judges
Insurance agents
Advertising specialists
Politicians
67
64
63
61
60
55
53
52
51
51
49
48
46
44
38
22
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
51
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.80
In 2018, the Russian population rates the majority of the
professions studied more negatively than in 2016. The
average trust rating has therefore dropped to 60%, meaning
that Russia is still in the lower third of the global comparison.
Priests (61%) and journalists (38%) record the largest
declines, while TV hosts and presenters (52%) also perform
more poorly than in 2016. The latter result probably reflects
the fact that the government has a strong influence on the
media and that it is therefore almost impossible to report ne-
gatively on the government. For example, Russia ranks 148th
out of 180 countries in the Press Freedom Index published by
Reporters Without Borders. The lessened trust in priests
could be due to the increasingly close relationship between
the church and the state, as well as growing Christian funda-
mentalism. This manifested itself in protests in 2017 against a
feature film about Tsar Nicholas II, whom the Russian Ortho-
dox Church reveres as a saint. The director's office was
attacked several times and critics accused him of blasphemy.
Confidence in politicians has also fallen, with the professional
group ranking last again, with 23%. Mayors find themselves
just one position higher, but with 31% enjoy somewhat more
trust than politicians. In addition to the points mentioned
above, corruption may have caused the general feeling of dis-
content among the population. Young people in particular pro-
tested against this and other problems in March 2017. During
these protests, 900 people were arrested in Moscow alone. At
52%, trust in the police is below average in the country
comparison. In addition to the professions already mentioned,
entrepreneurs and insurance agents find themselves at the
tail end of the ranking, each with a trust rating of 33%.
Like numerous other nationalities, Russians also have
the most trust in firefighters (90%). Soldiers, teachers and
pilots complete the leading group, albeit lagging a fair way
behind. A noticeable loss of trust is recorded for doctors and
physicians, who have now dropped to 66%, which is the
lowest trust rating received by this group across all the
countries included in the study. 75% of Russians still find
professional athletes to be credible, despite the widespread
doping scandal uncovered towards the end of 2016. In
December 2017, the IOC decided to exclude the country from
the 2018 Winter Olympics. Many Russians disagree with this
decision and feel their national pride has been hurt.
Russia /// Results
CPI 29
High perceived corruption
144.0 M
Population
100.6 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
100% of age 20-64secondary-educated
5.7% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
-0.2% GDP growthrate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
52("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Russia /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 2,228 respondents
0
-4
-1
-5
-6
-3
-4
-7
-6
-3
-8
0
2
3
0
1
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Soldiers
Teachers
Pilots
Farmers
Paramedics
Nurses
Professional athletes, footballers
Craftsmen
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Pharmacists
Engineers
Architects
Computer or software specialists
Doctors, physicians
Cab drivers
90
83
82
82
79
78
77
75
74
74
74
72
71
68
66
63
-11
-5
-4
-9
-3
-5
-5
-7
-2
-11
-4
-7
-9
3
3
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Pastors, priests
Lawyers
Actors
TV hosts, TV presenters
Policemen
Retailers, sellers
Civil servants
Judges
Market or opinion researchers
Bankers, bank assistants
Journalists
Advertising specialists
Insurance agents
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Mayors
Politicians
61
58
57
52
52
50
47
44
42
40
38
35
33
33
31
23
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
53
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.88
Since the end of 2016, the Catalonian quest for
independence from Spain has become increasingly visible.
The regional Catalan government held a referendum on
independence just before this poll was taken, even though the
constitutional court had forbidden them from doing so.
Politicians are still viewed with great distrust in this
highly charged mood. There have also been several
corruption scandals in recent years and the formation of a
government was very protracted after the 2016 parliamentary
elections. Thus only 5% of Spaniards trust their elected
representatives. Although faith in politicians in the north-east
(Catalonia) is twice as high as that in total and has even
increased slightly, even here, trust levels only reach 10%.
There are numerous points of criticism. The now deposed
Catalan Prime Minister Puigdemont decided to hold the
referendum despite it being declared unconstitutional and
subsequently proclaimed independence, but then absconded
abroad. The central government in Madrid, on the other hand,
is under fire for its crackdown on those citizens who
participated in the referendum. In addition, it suspended the
regional government, arrested the remaining incumbents and
called for new elections in Catalonia, which in December 2017
led to an electoral victory for the separatists. Other
professional groups besides politicians are judged with
reservation as well. The police, for example, whose drastic
actions in Catalonia were pilloried by parts of the population,
have been unable to profit from the general growth in trust.
Meanwhile, many citizens perceive the media coverage in
their country to be heavily influenced by politics. This may
explain why Spaniards rate journalists (38%) as well as TV
hosts and TV presenters (37%) less favourably than in 2016.
Firefighters top the ranking, with 97%. Spaniards also
place great trust in train drivers and medical professionals
(90%). Farmers have lost a little of their popularity, although
they are still rated as credible by 90% of respondents.
Architects (80%), entrepreneurs (73%) and lawyers (61%)
have gained the most trust. Despite witnessing smaller
increases, priests, mayors and bankers continue to be viewed
with scepticism, thus bringing up the rear of the rankings.
Spain /// Results
CPI 58Perceived corruption
46.4 MPopulation
30.8M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
87% of age 20-64secondary-educated
19.4%
Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
3.2% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
54("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Spain /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,020 respondents
-2
0
2
2
0
1
2
0
2
6
8
5
5
1
5
5
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Nurses
Paramedics
Pharmacists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Doctors, physicians
Farmers
Teachers
Pilots
Craftsmen
Architects
Engineers
Cab drivers
Policemen
Soldiers
Computer or software specialists
97
96
94
92
91
90
90
87
85
84
80
80
79
77
75
73
-1
-2
-2
-6
-5
-2
0
8
1
3
7
5
2
2
2
4
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Retailers, sellers
Civil servants
Lawyers
Actors
Professional athletes, footballers
Market or opinion researchers
Judges
Journalists
TV hosts, TV presenters
Advertising specialists
Insurance agents
Pastors, priests
Mayors
Bankers, bank assistants
Politicians
73
66
61
61
59
56
53
45
38
37
35
32
29
23
23
5
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
55
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.91
In Sweden, trust in almost all professional groups has
decreased, sinking to an average of 60%. However, since
some of these fluctuations are due to the change in the
institute conducting this year's fieldwork, the following report
mainly interprets the rank order.
Firefighters, paramedics, nurses and pilots are once
again in the lead, each trusted by more than 90% of the
population. Conscription was reintroduced in Sweden at the
start of 2017 in order to ensure a reliable level of recruitment
even if the threat level changes. This may have benefitted the
image of soldiers, whose ranking has improved by four
positions.
In terms of rank order, the worst performing professional
group by far are market or opinion researchers, who have
dropped by eight positions. Swedes may currently be more
concerned about the protection of their personal data,
following a leak uncovered in mid-2017. It was discovered that
subcontractors in Eastern European countries whose
employees did not have to pass a security audit were
managing sensitive information concerning the state transport
authority. Although experts have not found any signs of
misuse to date, the two responsible ministers had to resign.
This may also have contributed to the increasingly sceptical
attitude towards politicians, who now occupy the penultimate
place, with 16%. However, the scandal does not seem to
have had much of an impact on the trust expressed by
Swedes in IT specialists in their own country, who continue to
find themselves in the middle of the ranking.
The Swedish government plans to invest about two
billion krona in recruiting additional staff for the police force by
2020, financed by the surplus generated in the 2016 state
budget. This prospect could be linked to the high level of trust
shown in the police in comparison with that found in the other
countries surveyed. Sweden is currently struggling with
increasing crime and violence in several major cities and their
suburbs. On top of this, a terrorist attack in Stockholm in April
2017 resulted in five people losing their lives. As was the case
in 2016, advertising specialists, with a low trust rating of just
under 20%, find themselves near the bottom of the ranking
alongside the aforementioned politicians. Retailers and sellers
bring up the rear once again in 2018, viewed as credible by
just a tenth of citizens.
Sweden /// Results
CPI 88Hardly any perceived corruption
9.9 MPopulation
Of which 6.2 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
98% of age 20-64secondary-educated
7.1% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
3.2% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
56("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Sweden /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,009 respondents, please note: change of institute
-1
-3
-2
-2
-2
-8
-7
-10
-5
-8
-5
-11
-12
-6
-11
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Paramedics
Nurses
Pilots
Doctors, physicians
Farmers
Engineers
Pharmacists
Policemen
Teachers
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Architects
Judges
Soldiers
Computer or software specialists
Pastors, priests
97
96
93
93
90
85
85
82
81
81
78
75
73
72
68
63
-6
-15
-6
-23
-15
-17
-19
-17
-9
-9
-36
-7
-8
-4
-7
-5
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Lawyers
Bankers, bank assistants
Craftsmen
Actors
Cab drivers
Professional athletes, footballers
Civil servants
TV hosts, TV presenters
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Insurance agents
Market or opinion researchers
Journalists
Mayors
Advertising specialists
Politicians
Retailers, sellers
61
60
58
50
47
45
43
41
39
38
33
29
26
18
16
11
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
57
In Turkey, trust in the professional groups under
investigation declined noticeably in 2016, but has now
recovered again by the same extent. The breakdown of trust
at the time was due to the fact that a long period of political
and economic stability had come to an end. The ultimately
unsuccessful coup attempt by sections of the army in July
2016 (after the last edition of this report was published) was
probably key to the current massive surge in trust. According
to the government, the Islamic preacher Gülen was primarily
responsible for the attempted coup. As a result of the ensuing
purges, more than 100,000 civil servants were dismissed from
their posts by mid-2017 because they were allegedly close to
the Gülen movement. As well as receiving a lot of criticism,
President Erdoğan also gained much popularity through the
resistance to the coup attempt and the subsequent series of
arrests and purges. For example, in a controversial
constitutional referendum in April 2017, more than half of the
electorate voted in favour of a presidential system that grants
the president far-reaching powers. Critical voices are likely to
find it increasingly difficult to be heard as a result.
It is noticeable that the level of trust stagnated in
particular among those professions that were particularly
affected by suspensions and lay-offs in the wake of the coup
attempt. These include civil servants, judges, teachers, the
police and soldiers. The amount of trust instilled by soldiers
and judges is also below that recorded in 2014. The only
group that is currently losing trust among the people is the
clergy, which includes imams and teachers of the Koran. This
is almost certainly also a response to the allegations against
the preacher Gülen and his followers.
Doctors, physicians, pharmacists and firefighters (88%
each) and nurses (87%) are again at the top of the trust listing
in turkey as well. Turkish politicians, in contrast, once more
ranked in last place, despite a rise to 34%. In the international
comparison, however, this score places them in the upper
third. Insurance agents, market or opinion researchers and
bankers are among the professions to be found in the lower
third of the national scale, but that nevertheless experienced
the largest gains in trust, each rising by around 25 percentage
points in 2018.
Turkey /// Results
CPI 41 High perceived corruption
80.7 MPopulation
53.9 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
52% of age 20-64secondary-educated
10.3%
Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
2.9% GDP growth rate 2016
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.77
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
58("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Turkey /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,001 respondents
7
7
6
5
1
8
0
17
17
2
18
3
6
21
20
16
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Doctors, physicians
Pharmacists
Firefighters
Nurses
Teachers
Paramedics
Farmers
Architects
Engineers
Soldiers
Craftsmen
Pilots
Civil servants
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Retailers, sellers
Actors
88
88
88
87
87
85
83
83
82
81
80
78
76
76
75
74
-4
19
20
20
20
3
10
4
26
27
24
22
16
18
16
14
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Computer or software specialists
Lawyers
Cab drivers
TV hosts, TV presenters
Policemen
Professional athletes, footballers
Judges
Insurance agents
Market or opinion researchers
Bankers, bank assistants
Advertising specialists
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Journalists
Mayors
Pastors, priests
Politicians
72
71
71
66
65
65
65
64
64
64
60
59
58
56
46
34
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
59
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.91
Compared with 2016, average trust in the UK has fallen
slightly, to 66%. A number of professional groups are affected
by this, including healthcare professionals at the top of the
ranking. With a rating of 94% each, paramedics and nurses
are trusted by a slightly smaller proportion of British people
than two years ago, the same applying to pharmacists (93%),
doctors and physicians (89%). Even firefighters (93%)
currently win slightly less trust. The country was alarmed by a
serious fire in a London skyscraper in mid-2017, which
claimed the lives of around 80 people.
Above all, however, it is Brexit that has dominated the
UK over the last two years. In 2016, the decision to leave the
EU caused the British pound to crash. At the time of this
survey, Prime Minister May had achieved very little success
during negotiations with the EU on the conditions of
withdrawal. In addition, several politicians had to resign
because they were accused of sexual harassment. Despite
slight gains, with a trust rating of 22%, politicians continue to
occupy the last place in the trust ranking by a long chalk. The
upcoming withdrawal from the EU is causing uncertainty
among British businesses because clear regulations are not
yet in place. Especially in the financial sector, companies are
considering relocating jobs or even their headquarters to other
EU countries. Trust in businessmen and entrepreneurs has
thus dropped by 4 percentage points, to 42%. At 67%, trust in
cab drivers is also down. This could be due to the fact that, for
security reasons, the private transportation service
intermediary Uber had its licence revoked in London. Uber
appealed against this and the court has not yet passed
judgement.
In the UK, several attacks were carried out in 2017,
most notably by the terrorist organisation ISIS. In response to
this, the government proclaimed the highest terror threat level
and mobilised nearly 4,000 soldiers. At 81%, trust in soldiers
lies within the European average, but has sunk by 5
percentage points. The police rank only slightly higher, with a
stable 84%. Actors have lost the most popularity of all the
professions in 2018, falling by 6 percentage points to 46%,
which is the same rating as in 2014. Notable gains in trust are
recorded at the tail end of the ranking, where, in addition to
politicians, insurance agents (39%) and journalists (34%) can
be found.
UK /// Results
CPI 81Hardly any perceived corruption
66.2 MPopulation
42.6 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
86% of age 20-64secondary-educated
4.8% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
1.8% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
60("I completely/generally trust", in %)
UK /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,031 respondents
-2
-1
-3
-3
-3
-4
-2
-5
-2
-3
-1
-4
-2
-3
1
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Paramedics
Nurses
Firefighters
Pharmacists
Doctors, physicians
Teachers
Pilots
Policemen
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Soldiers
Engineers
Farmers
Craftsmen
Judges
Architects
Civil servants
94
94
93
93
89
86
86
84
81
81
79
78
76
70
69
69
-2
-4
-1
-2
-2
-6
-4
0
3
2
2
1
1
4
5
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Retailers, sellers
Market or opinion researchers
Cab drivers
Pastors, priests
Lawyers
Computer or software specialists
Bankers, bank assistants
Mayors
Professional athletes, footballers
Actors
TV hosts, TV presenters
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Insurance agents
Journalists
Advertising specialists
Politicians
69
67
67
65
62
60
56
49
46
46
46
42
39
34
32
22
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
61
3 North and South America in detail
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
62
In 2018, Brazil once again occupies one of the lowest
rankings in the country comparison, although trust in the
professions in question has increased by 5 percentage points,
to 60%. All professional groups except journalists (63%) and
actors (50%) have gained a little more trust from the
populace.
Above all, soldiers (69%) and the police (57%) are
perceived more positively. These ensured the protection of
spectators and participants at the Olympic Games, which
were held in Rio de Janeiro in 2016. Heightened security
measures also prevented a planned terrorist attack.
Nevertheless, only firefighters and paramedics achieve trust
levels of more than 90%. They are followed immediately by
teachers, pilots, pharmacists and architects, who are also
considered to be very reliable, each scoring over 80% for
trustworthiness.
By contrast, trust in insurance agents, and businessmen
and entrepreneurs is rather low, at 38%. In recent years,
Brazil has uncovered a corruption network involving large
corporations and politicians, centred around the country's
semi-state-owned oil company, Petrobras. Added to this was
a cartel in the construction industry involving the construction
company Odebrecht. The corporations are said to have bribed
government officials in order to obtain public contracts. In
April 2017, the Supreme Court published a list of the names
of politicians being investigated. Ex-president Rousseff, who
was removed from office in mid-2016, is also listed. Her
successor, Vice-President Temer, was also investigated by
the state judiciary, among other things for illegal election
campaign funding. Brazilians give vent to their dissatisfaction
with the current political situation in protests and
demonstrations. It is therefore not surprising that mayors
(13%) and politicians (7%) find themselves at the bottom of
the ranking by a long margin, especially as the economy is
still in serious crisis.
In the meantime, however, signs of economic recovery
are beginning to emerge, the country successfully mastered
the costly major sporting events of recent years, and the fight
against corruption cannot be held back, even among high-
ranking politicians and business leaders. All this seems to
have increased the overall trust of the populace.
Brazil /// Results
CPI 40High perceived corruption
209.3 M
Population
144.8 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
63% of age 20-64secondary-educated
11.5%
Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
-3.6% GDP growthrate 2016
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.75
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
63("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Brazil /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,000 respondents
-1
2
7
1
4
5
7
6
9
11
5
7
9
6
6
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Paramedics
Teachers
Pilots
Pharmacists
Architects
Nurses
Doctors, physicians
Soldiers
Engineers
Journalists
Computer or software specialists
Retailers, sellers
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Farmers
Craftsmen
96
91
87
83
82
81
80
73
69
67
63
63
63
62
60
60
-3
2
6
11
5
3
2
8
6
4
6
8
1
7
3
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Judges
Cab drivers
Policemen
Civil servants
Market or opinion researchers
Advertising specialists
Bankers, bank assistants
Actors
Professional athletes, footballers
TV hosts, TV presenters
Pastors, priests
Lawyers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Insurance agents
Mayors
Politicians
59
58
57
55
54
51
51
50
50
49
49
48
38
38
13
7
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
64
2018 marks the first year in which Mexico is taking part
in this global Trust in Professions study. With an average trust
of 59% across all professions, the country ranks as one of the
last in the international comparison.
After the election of Donald Trump as President of the
neighbouring USA, the Mexican economy was initially in a
state of great uncertainty. Due to the protectionist "America
First" policy announced by Trump, business owners feared
lower investments by Mexico's important trading partner.
Although the economy picked up again in the course of 2017,
the outcome of the negotiations on the North American Free
Trade Agreement, NAFTA, remains to be seen. Uncertainty
about this is one reason for the devaluation of the peso
against the US dollar and the associated price increases for
imports. According to Germany Trade & Invest (GTAI), the
inflation rate could rise to around 6% in 2017.
At the top of the trust ranking, with 90%, are nurses,
closely followed by firefighters, who have 89%. Around eight
out of every ten Mexicans also trust doctors, physicians,
paramedics, farmers, architects, pilots and engineers. The
relatively high trust in healthcare professions could be
attributed to extensive investments in this area. Among other
things, the two largest insurance providers in the public health
system have announced or have already begun the
construction of new hospitals.
According to the Challenges of Nations 2017 study (GfK
Verein 2017), the country's top five challenges include crime,
politics/government and corruption. Organised crime in
Mexico is in part closely linked to the police and politics, which
is reflected, among other things, in a high level of perceived
corruption. Representatives from professions related to this
are viewed with scepticism. For example, the population
expresses the least amount of trust in the police (36%),
mayors (30%) and politicians (13%). Judges fare only slightly
better, with a trust rating of 41%. Soldiers, on the other hand,
earn the trust of 71% of citizens. The Mexican armed forces
are considered to be less vulnerable to corruption than other
security forces.
Mexico /// Results
CPI 30High perceived corruption
129.2 MPopulation
85.2 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
67% of age 20-64secondary-educated
4.0% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
2.3% GDP growth rate 2016
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.76
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
65("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Mexico /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,001 respondents
Nurses
Firefighters
Doctors, physicians
Paramedics
Farmers
Architects
Pilots
Engineers
Pharmacists
Craftsmen
Soldiers
Computer or software specialists
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Civil servants
Retailers, sellers
Teachers
90
89
84
83
79
78
78
78
75
73
71
71
67
67
65
65
Professional athletes, footballers
Bankers, bank assistants
Advertising specialists
Market or opinion researchers
Insurance agents
Journalists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Pastors, priests
Judges
TV hosts, TV presenters
Cab drivers
Lawyers
Actors
Policemen
Mayors
Politicians
61
55
50
50
46
44
42
42
41
41
41
40
39
36
30
13
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
66
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.92
On average, 67% of Americans express trust in the
professional groups studied, which marks a slight increase of
2 percentage points. In comparison with 2016, the scores
achieved by the individual professions are practically stable.
The biggest changes are two separate increases of 6
percentage points, which take train, bus, underground and
tram drivers to 83% and IT specialists to 80%. The only
professional group to experience a drop in trust is the clergy.
However, despite falling by 5 percentage points, pastors and
priests are still trusted by 72% of Americans.
Firefighters, with 94%, instil the most trust in citizens,
possibly due to the frequent occurrence of tornadoes, floods
and forest fires in the US. Immediately after this come other
caring professions, such as paramedics and nurses, who
have thus defended their good positions. The same can be
said of pharmacists, doctors and physicians, who are trusted
by about 90% of the populace. President Trump is admittedly
currently seeking to abolish the Obamacare health insurance
reforms introduced by his predecessor. However, this does
not seem to be having any influence on trust in the
professions in this sector.
Two major gradations can be seen in the ranking. For
example, there are 15 percentage points between bankers
(69%) and cab drivers (54%), who are at the start of the
bottom third of the trust list. The second significant gap is at
the bottom of the list, where advertising specialists
(30%) followed far behind by politicians (16%) bring up the
rear. The latter have slightly improved their reputation, by 4
percentage points. However, trust in politicians virtually
halved from 2014 to 2016 (12%), which could perhaps be
attributed to disaffection with Obama's policies at the end of
his second term. Nevertheless, the slight rise in trust since the
changes at the White House in early 2017 seems surprising,
given that the presidential campaign was very controversial
and polarising. In addition, Trump was beset with substantial
personnel problems when subsequently filling important
government posts.
As in 2016, professions in the entertainment and media
industry, such as actors (39%), TV hosts/TV presenters (41%)
and journalists (47%), also performed below average this
year.
USA /// Results
CPI 74Perceived corruption
324.5 MPopulation
215.1 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
98% of age 20-64secondary-educated
4.9% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
1.6% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
67("I completely/generally trust", in %)
USA /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,000 respondents; *in contrast to the other countries, the US respondents were only asked about "professional athletes in general"
-1
-5
1
1
1
2
4
2
0
0
0
2
6
6
1
4
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Paramedics
Nurses
Pharmacists
Pilots
Farmers
Doctors, physicians
Engineers
Soldiers
Teachers
Architects
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Computer or software specialists
Policemen
Craftsmen
Pastors, priests
94
93
92
90
90
89
88
88
87
86
85
83
80
78
76
72
-1
-1
2
2
0
1
4
4
4
4
3
2
2
0
4
4
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Civil servants
Judges
Bankers, bank assistants
Cab drivers
Retailers, sellers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Market or opinion researchers
Mayors
Insurance agents
Journalists
Lawyers
Professional athletes*
TV hosts, TV presenters
Actors
Advertising specialists
Politicians
72
71
69
54
54
53
52
48
47
47
46
45
41
39
30
16
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
68
At the top of the ranking, which is occupied by the care
professions in the US, there are only marginal differences
between the three largest ethnic groups. However, divergent
ratings can even be found within the top 10. For example,
soldiers, who are trusted by a total of 87% of citizens, are
judged much more negatively by African Americans and His-
panic Americans than by whites. The same applies to crafts-
men, who have an overall trust rating of 76%. African Ameri-
cans are also less trusting of pilots, teachers and architects.
The biggest differences between ethnic groups can be
seen in relation to the police, who are trusted by a total of
78% of citizens. However, while 85% of white people classify
the police as reliable, this is expressed by only 71% of
Hispanic Americans – and by just 44% of African Americans.
This is almost certainly linked to numerous cases of police
violence against African Americans, in which even unarmed
people have been killed by security forces. After such killings,
there have often been violent protests. In addition, such
violence towards African Americans by people on duty often
has no consequences for the police officers concerned, as the
charges are dropped in court. This could possibly explain why
African Americans also have less trust in judges (57%) than
representatives of other ethnic groups, particularly white US
Americans (74%).
Conversely, actors, TV hosts, TV presenters and
politicians are rated more positively by African Americans.
The greater trust in these professional groups means that
African Americans only express 4 percentage points less
average trust across all the professions as a whole compared
to white Americans.
At 66%, the average level of trust expressed by
Hispanic Americans lies exactly between that voiced by white
and African Americans. Journalists are the only exception to
this, as Hispanics attribute far more credibility to this
professional group, especially in comparison to whites.
Businessmen and entrepreneurs, on the other hand, receive
the least approval from Hispanic Americans. Professional
athletes are the only professional group to be rated more
positively by both African and Hispanic Americans than by
white Americans. Perhaps ethnic minorities consider a career
as a professional athlete to be the preferred way for them to
achieve social advancement in the US.
USA /// Differences between the three largest ethnic groups
Whites
African Americans
Hispanic Americans
Average trust68%
Average trust64%
Average trust66%
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
69("I completely/generally trust", in %)
USA /// Trust in professional groups according to the largest ethnic groups
Base 2018: 1,000 respondents; *in contrast to the other countries, the US respondents were only asked about "professional athletes in general"0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
White n=644
Hispanic Americans n=158
Total
African Americans n=118
Firefighters
Paramedics
Nurses
Pharmacists
Pilots
Farmers
Doctors, physicians
Engineers
Soldiers
Teachers
Architects
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Computer or software specialists
Policemen
Craftsmen
Pastors, priests
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Civil servants
Judges
Bankers, bank assistants
Cab drivers
Retailers, sellers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Market or opinion researchers
Mayors
Insurance agents
Journalists
Lawyers
Professional athletes*
TV hosts, TV presenters
Actors
Advertising specialists
Politicians
Contents
©G
fK V
ere
in 2
018
70
4 Asia and the Pacific in detail
Contents
©G
fK V
ere
in 2
018
71
In India, the average trust across all professional groups
has grown by another 3 percentage points in 2018, to 85%,
once again putting the country first in the global ranking.
Almost all professions earn more trust than in 2016. In
particular, the professional groups at the top of the ranking –
doctors, physicians, teachers, engineers and technicians as
well as soldiers – are continuing to gain popularity among
citizens. In fact, these professions have now even reached
the 100% mark.
Lawyers have achieved the greatest growth in trust,
rising by a significant 19 percentage points to 86%. In January
2016, Indian lawyer and activist Tiphagne was awarded the
Human Rights Award by Amnesty International Germany. He
has been campaigning for years against the severe
discrimination faced by Dalits, who occupy the lowest level of
the caste system and are known as untouchables. India's
current president, Kovind, who was elected in mid-2017,
comes from this lowest caste, meaning that this post is now
filled by a Dalit for the second time in the country's history.
Politicians once again find themselves at the bottom of
the ranking in 2018, trusted by only just under half of Indians.
The penultimate place is occupied by the police, with 70%.
According to a study by Human Rights Watch, about 600
people died in police custody in India between 2010 and
2015, mostly as a result of maltreatment. This could be one of
the reasons why the population has relatively little trust in this
professional group. Added to this is widespread corruption,
which is also likely to be responsible for the relatively low level
of trust in civil servants (77%).
Priests (83%) and mayors (75%) are currently recording
a marked increase of 14 percentage points, meaning that
local representatives rate much higher than politicians as a
whole. Professions such as professional athletes (87%) and
actors (81%) are also enjoying increased popularity. The
cinema, especially the Bollywood film industry, is very
important in everyday Indian cultural life. However, train
drivers as well as businessmen and entrepreneurs have to
accept a loss of 5 percentage points, although with 80% they
still enjoy a great deal of trust compared to their counterparts
in the other countries surveyed.
India /// Results
CPI 40High perceived corruption
1,339.2 MPopulation
878.5 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
52% of age 20-64secondary-educated
3.5% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
7.1% GDP growth rate 2016
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.62
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
72("I completely/generally trust", in %)
India /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,078 respondents
-2
-1
4
2
6
2
2
3
3
3
3
6
1
4
0
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Doctors, physicians
Teachers
Engineers
Soldiers
Farmers
Judges
Firefighters
Pharmacists
Nurses
Computer or software specialists
Paramedics
Journalists
Bankers, bank assistants
Pilots
Retailers, sellers
Craftsmen
99
98
98
97
94
94
93
91
91
90
90
90
89
89
88
88
-5
-6
-1
-1
0
0
9
19
14
6
5
6
4
10
14
6
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Professional athletes, footballers
Lawyers
Pastors, priests
Architects
TV hosts, TV presenters
Advertising specialists
Market or opinion researchers
Actors
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Cab drivers
Civil servants
Insurance agents
Mayors
Policemen
Politicians
87
86
83
83
83
82
81
81
80
80
79
77
76
75
70
48
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
73
Following a further increase in 2016, the average level
of trust expressed by Indonesians in the professional groups
investigated has declined by 10 percentage points to 69% in
2018. This is perhaps partly due to dissatisfaction with the
government under President Widodo, who has been in office
since the end of 2014. The fight against widespread
corruption has had little effect to date, and Islamists are
gaining influence in Indonesia, which is the largest Muslim
country in the world. In mid-2016, Widodo reshuffled his
cabinet for the second time.
More than half of the professions have suffered losses
of trust in 2018, some of which are very marked. The top five
of the ranking remain stable. Teachers and farmers top the list
once more, trusted by almost all Indonesians. The image of
farmers is likely boosted by the fact that just under one fifth of
the working population is employed in the agricultural sector.
In addition, the medical professions, comprising doctors,
physicians, pharmacists, paramedics and nurses, enjoy high
levels of approval and also all rank above the 90% mark.
As is the case with the top rankings, the professions
occupying the lower end of the trust listing remain the same,
although they have all experienced further declines in trust.
As in 2016, this final group includes politicians and insurance
agents, who are trusted by around one third of Indonesians.
Priests take up the final position in the ranking, their trust
rating having fallen by 20 percentage points, to 26%. In
Indonesia, a moderate form of Islam is predominant, but now
there are signs of a strengthening of intolerant influences. In
early 2017, for example, the Islamist campaign against former
governor Purnama, who was standing for re-election in the
province of Jakarta, caused a sensation. The Christian
politician was sentenced to two years in prison in May 2017
for arguing during the election campaign that the Koran did
not forbid Muslims from voting for candidates of other
religious affiliations.
The noticeable corruption contributes to the fact that
judges, the police and politicians are at the bottom of the
ranking. Significant declines have also been observed for
advertising specialists, bank employees, TV hosts, TV
presenters and IT specialists. The latter, however, are still
trusted by three out of four Indonesians.
Indonesia /// results
CPI 37High perceived corruption
264.0 MPopulation
177.1 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
58% of age 20-64secondary-educated
5.6% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
5.0% GDP growthrate 2016
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.69
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
74("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Indonesia /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,040 respondents
-5
-6
-5
-9
-8
-7
-8
-18
-8
-10
-18
2
0
1
0
1
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Teachers
Farmers
Doctors, physicians
Pharmacists
Paramedics
Nurses
Firefighters
Craftsmen
Pilots
Engineers
Architects
Soldiers
Computer or software specialists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Professional athletes, footballers
TV hosts, TV presenters
99
98
96
93
93
92
92
88
87
84
82
79
75
71
71
70
-17
-17
-19
-10
-9
-16
-16
-17
-20
-15
-8
-11
-13
-15
-13
-20
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Mayors
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Bankers, bank assistants
Retailers, sellers
Cab drivers
Civil servants
Market or opinion researchers
Journalists
Advertising specialists
Policemen
Judges
Actors
Lawyers
Politicians
Insurance agents
Pastors, priests
70
67
67
65
64
63
56
53
52
49
48
44
40
35
33
26
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
75
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.77
Despite marked changes in comparison with 2016,
average trust in the professions surveyed in Iran is stable, at
68%. However, the range remains large: while 100% of
Iranians trust the two professions at the top of the list and
more than 90% trust the next eleven professions, only one out
of ten trust the two professions at the bottom of the ranking.
The rank order has shifted slightly at the top of the scale.
Although firefighters are still in first place, they are now
followed by farmers, who displace doctors and physicians
(89%) from second place. Paramedics (99%) and lawyers
(97%) occupy the third and fourth positions, each having
witnessed a surge in trust.
However, the largest increases (by 22 to 24 percentage
points in each case) can be observed among the police
(94%), nurses (74%) and journalists (64%). In Iran, critical
media reports are often interpreted in court as offences
against national security and are punished accordingly.
However, in 2017, President Rouhani announced another
revision of the Press Act, which may well have already lead to
a jump in trust levels and, in the near future, could result in
more independent reporting. Iran currently ranks 165th out of
180 countries in the Press Freedom Index published by
Reporters Without Borders.
The greatest losses of trust, of minus 30 and minus 34
percentage points respectively, have been suffered by
craftsmen (51%) and soldiers (35%). One reason for the latter
could be that in Iran, the armed forces are also deployed
against the domestic opposition. However, mayors (49%), civil
servants (28%) and judges (23%) are also much less popular
than in 2016. Trust in judges may be weakened by the fact
that Iranians are repeatedly sentenced to controversial long-
term prison sentences because of dual citizenship or human
rights activities, for example. The clear perceived corruption
probably also increases scepticism towards public professions
– and may explain the lack of trust in politicians (11%) and
pastors and priests (8%), who find themselves in the last
positions. In the Islamic Republic of Iran, the highest spiritual
leader is also the political head of state. Whether and how the
anti-government protests at the end of 2017 will impact on the
citizens' trust remains to be seen.
Iran /// Results
CPI 29High perceived corruption
81.2 MPopulation
57.8 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
63% of age 20-64secondary-educated
11.3%
Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
-1.5% GDP growthrate 2015
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
76
74
70
70
67
64
60
51
49
36
35
33
29
28
23
11
8
("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Iran /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,000 respondents
-4
-4
-11
-17
0
8
17
20
5
12
24
16
10
3
4
15
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Farmers
Paramedics
Lawyers
Pharmacists
Pilots
Policemen
Insurance agents
Teachers
Actors
Cab drivers
Market or opinion researchers
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Doctors, physicians
Engineers
Advertising specialists
100
100
99
97
96
95
94
93
93
92
91
91
91
89
77
77
-15
-3
-30
-19
-34
-3
-4
-18
-18
-11
-15
22
1
17
23
6
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Nurses
Computer or software specialists
Professional athletes, footballers
Bankers, bank assistants
Journalists
Architects
Craftsmen
Mayors
Retailers, sellers
Soldiers
TV hosts, TV presenters
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Civil servants
Judges
Politicians
Pastors, priests
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
77
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.90
In comparison with other countries, the Japanese tend
to withhold their trust from the professions surveyed. Although
its average trust rating has increased slightly to 58%, Japan
remains at the lower end of the global ranking.
Paramedics, firefighters, nurses, doctors and physicians
are perceived to be particularly credible, trusted by around
nine out of every ten Japanese. Certain professional groups
are currently enjoying increased trust, particularly those in the
middle of the pack. For example, the respondents rate
craftsmen (74%) and architects (71%) more positively.
Japanese architects are also attracting international attention
because many of them design minimalist homes that can be
built on small and thus affordable spaces. Soldiers (67%)
have also gained trust in 2018. This may be related to the
country feeling threatened by North Korea's controversial
missile tests. As part of these tests, missiles flew over
northern Japan shortly before this survey was conducted.
Because of the threat, the government had already put the
military on alert in 2016. The conflict intensified during the
second half of 2017 due to the verbal exchange between the
heads of state of the USA and North Korea. The Japanese
are also putting more trust in teachers, who now achieve a
rating of 61%. With an increase of 4 percentage points, the
performance of engineers and technicians (84%) is also more
strongly rewarded in this high-tech country. IT specialists
have gained an equal proportion of trust, but at 47% they rank
at a much lower level.
Once again, it is politicians who bring up the rear,
having stagnated at a trust rating of 12%. Trust in advertising
specialists (23%) and journalists (22%) is also low, the latter
group having lost the greatest amount of approval in 2018.
This corresponds to the assessment by Reporters Without
Borders, which in its Press Freedom Index ranks Japan last
among the G7 countries. This is a clear indication that the
country has problems with press freedom. Since 2013, the
work of journalists has been hampered by a law that
criminalises the distribution of classified information. This is
probably limiting the freedom of reporting.
Japan /// Results
CPI 72Hardly any perceived corruption
127.5 MPopulation
77.5 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
98% of age 20-64secondary-educated
3.1% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
1.0% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
78("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Japan /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,175 respondents
1
0
1
3
3
4
2
0
4
5
6
2
4
3
5
1
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Paramedics
Firefighters
Nurses
Doctors, physicians
Pharmacists
Engineers
Pilots
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Farmers
Craftsmen
Architects
Judges
Lawyers
Policemen
Soldiers
Bankers, bank assistants
90
89
88
88
85
84
80
80
77
74
71
70
69
68
67
62
-1
-1
-1
-4
5
1
3
3
4
1
4
3
3
2
1
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Teachers
Professional athletes, footballers
Cab drivers
Civil servants
Mayors
Computer or software specialists
Pastors, priests
Market or opinion researchers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
TV hosts, TV presenters
Insurance agents
Actors
Retailers, sellers
Advertising specialists
Journalists
Politicians
61
55
53
49
47
47
46
37
35
31
31
29
29
23
22
12
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
79
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.90
Overall, trust in the professions studied has fallen
slightly in South Korea. With an average trust rating of 57%,
the country is even in last place in the 2018 international
comparison. In particular, professions that were already in the
lower third of the ranking in 2016 have lost further popularity.
The Choi Soon-sil affair has been causing political
turmoil since the end of 2016. Former President Park allowed
her friend Choi to influence government affairs. On top of this,
Choi apparently also obtained donations from large
companies such as Samsung through illegal agreements.
Trust in businessmen and entrepreneurs has dropped slightly
to settle at 38%, while politicians are considered trustworthy
by fewer than one in ten South Koreans. With a drop of 18
percentage points, priests (39%) have lost the most trust. This
may also be caused by the link between ex-president Park
and her confidante Choi. Their long-standing friendship also
extended to Choi's father, a self-proclaimed pastor and sect
founder. Following Park's removal from office due to the
corruption scandal, new elections were held in May 2017. The
Democratic Party (DP) candidate, Moon, became the new
president.
Professions in the media industry such as TV hosts, TV
presenters and journalists are also performing more poorly
than in 2016. The traditional media have long been accused
of poor research. In addition, fake news is increasingly
becoming a problem, since in technologically advanced
country fake news reports spread very quickly via digital
networks. For example, during the 2017 presidential election
campaign, Ban, the leading candidate in the polls, withdrew
his candidacy after a video of him – which turned out to be a
video montage – had caused outrage. South Koreans also
trust opinion researchers and advertising specialists less than
they did two years ago.
On the other hand, the police and train drivers are
witnessing increases in trust, their respective ratings rising to
60%. At the upper end of the scale, medical professionals and
farmers, each of whom is trusted by about eight out of ten
South Koreans, enjoy stable or increasing trustworthiness.
The ranking is led by firefighters, with 88% approval.
South Korea /// Results
CPI 53Perceived corruption
51.0 MPopulation
37.2 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
96% of age 20-64secondary-educated
3.7% Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
2.8% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
80("I completely/generally trust", in %)
South Korea /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,500 respondents
-1
-2
-5
-1
-5
3
1
1
4
1
1
5
4
0
1
6
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Firefighters
Nurses
Paramedics
Farmers
Doctors, physicians
Pilots
Engineers
Computer or software specialists
Bankers, bank assistants
Pharmacists
Craftsmen
Soldiers
Teachers
Architects
Policemen
Professional athletes, footballers
88
85
82
82
79
79
77
75
71
70
70
66
66
65
60
60
-8
-4
-2
-5
-6
-6
-7
-9
-18
-3
-10
-6
-6
6
1
0
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
TV hosts, TV presenters
Civil servants
Actors
Cab drivers
Retailers, sellers
Judges
Lawyers
Market or opinion researchers
Advertising specialists
Pastors, priests
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Journalists
Mayors
Insurance agents
Politicians
60
57
48
48
46
45
44
44
41
40
39
38
34
34
21
9
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
81
5 Africa in detail
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
82
The average trust of Kenyans has hardly changed in
2018, and at 65% places the country in the lower mid-range of
the international ranking. The only professional groups that
are trusted by more than 90% of the population are farmers
and teachers. The latter has seen an increase of 8 percen-
tage points. Trust values of 80% or more are recorded by
pilots and healthcare professionals. National medical care
was paralysed for around 100 days when doctors working for
public hospitals went on strike to demand a salary increase
that the government had promised back in 2013. After initially
cracking down hard on the strikers, the government finally
gave way. It does not seem as if the strike has detracted from
the confidence placed in doctors, physicians and paramedics.
Bank employees and professional athletes also feature
among the most favourably rated professions, which means
that they rank more highly than they tend to do in the other
countries covered by this study. Kenya is among the best in
the world when it comes to running in particular, and at the
World Athletics Championships 2017, the country took second
place in the medal table. In contrast, the otherwise often high-
ly placed firefighters find themselves in the middle of the rank-
ing, with 70%. Advertising specialists (54%) and insurance
agents (38%) have experienced the strongest losses in trust.
Politicians occupy the last place in the ranking, having
dropped to 19%. This is surely a consequence of widespread
corruption and current political events. Following the re-
election of the incumbent President Kenyatta in August 2017,
opposition leader Odinga filed a complaint with the Supreme
Court, which subsequently declared the election victory to be
invalid due to irregularities. Amnesty International viewed the
decision as a sign of the independence of the judiciary. This
may also be reflected in the growing trust bestowed on judges
(63%) and lawyers (54%). However, prior to the new elections
in late October 2017, Odinga withdrew his candidacy and
called for a boycott of the election, as he believed that neces-
sary electoral reforms had not been implemented. As a result,
almost all votes went to the incumbent. At just under 40%, the
turnout was low – among other things, because in some
regions voting was impossible for security reasons. There
were clashes throughout the election period, with around 50
people being killed by police violence. Police officers occupy
penultimate place in the trust ranking, with 29%.
Kenya /// Results
CPI 26
High perceived corruption
49.7 M
Population
27.4 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
69% of age 20-64secondary-educated
11.0%Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
5.8% GDP growthrate2016
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.56
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
83("I completely/generally trust", in %)
Kenya /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,007 respondents
-5
-2
-2
-2
-1
-5
3
8
3
0
1
5
8
4
5
3
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Farmers
Teachers
Pilots
Doctors, physicians
Professional athletes, footballers
Nurses
Bankers, bank assistants
Paramedics
TV hosts, TV presenters
Architects
Pharmacists
Engineers
Firefighters
Craftsmen
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Retailers, sellers
92
91
85
83
82
80
80
80
74
73
72
72
70
69
69
68
-2
-2
-4
-6
-1
-10
-4
-9
-3
8
0
4
8
7
2
3
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Journalists
Actors
Judges
Market or opinion researchers
Computer or software specialists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Civil servants
Soldiers
Lawyers
Pastors, priests
Advertising specialists
Cab drivers
Mayors
Insurance agents
Policemen
Politicians
68
65
63
60
60
58
57
57
54
54
54
54
42
38
29
19
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
84
Human Develop-ment Index 20150: very low – 1: very high0.67
In South Africa, the confidence expressed in most
professional groups is stable. The average trust rating
therefore remains constant at 74%, meaning that the nation is
still among the top 5 countries in the global comparison.
The political situation has for some time been coloured
by the demand for change. Zuma, the head of state, had been
criticised for corruption and mismanagement. He finally had to
resign in February 2018. It remains to be seen whether
Ramaphosa, the new head of the ruling ANC party, can live
up to expectations. Political uncertainty is inhibiting
confidence among international investors, which is why the
country is struggling with high unemployment and low
economic growth. The dissatisfaction felt towards President
Zuma is also likely reflected in the general regard for
politicians, who in 2018 occupy last place, following a slight
fall in trust levels. Their drop in position is also due to the
rating achieved by cab drivers, who have overtaken them
after achieving the largest growth in trust. Lawyers (70%) and
bus and train drivers (67%) record the second largest plus
with an increase of 6 percentage points each.
Trust has decreased most of all for market or opinion
researchers (72%) and nurses (88%), each of whom have lost
6 percentage points. However, along with other medical
professionals, nurses can be found in the top portion of the
trust ranking.
Pole position is occupied by doctors and physicians,
who are the only professional group to be trusted by more
than 90% of South Africans. However, even trust in doctors
and paramedics has gone down slightly. In fact, the health
system is suffering and critics complain of a two-tier medical
system. The governing ANC wants to fight this by introducing
state health insurance. However, since the country suffers
from high unemployment, financing for this has not yet been
sufficiently clarified. The top group also includes firefighters
and technicians, who occupy the second and third positions,
tied at 89%. Good education is likely to be of great importance
to South Africans, as it can be a way out of poverty. This is
reflected in the very positive rating (86%) recorded for
teachers. The protests against higher tuition fees in autumn
2016 turned out to be all the more massive.
South Africa /// results
CPI 45High perceived corruption
56.7 MPopulation
37.3 M
Working population(Age 15 to 64)
77% of age 20-64secondary-educated
25.9%
Unemployment rate 2016 (ILO)
0.3% GDP growth rate 2016
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
85("I completely/generally trust", in %)
South Africa /// Trust in professional groups
Base 2018: 1,202 respondents
-3
-1
-2
-6
-2
-3
-2
-2
-2
0
1
1
1
1
0
2
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Doctors, physicians
Firefighters
Engineers
Nurses
Pharmacists
Teachers
Paramedics
Architects
Pilots
Craftsmen
Professional athletes, footballers
Computer or software specialists
Farmers
Businessmen, entrepreneurs
Soldiers
TV hosts, TV presenters
93
89
89
88
86
86
86
83
83
79
79
79
79
78
77
75
-2
-1
-6
-2
-4
-2
-3
-3
2
3
6
6
3
1
1
12
Change vs 2016in percentage points
Bankers, bank assistants
Retailers, sellers
Civil servants
Judges
Market or opinion researchers
Actors
Pastors, priests
Lawyers
Advertising specialists
Train, bus, underground or tram drivers
Journalists
Insurance agents
Mayors
Policemen
Cab drivers
Politicians
75
75
73
73
72
72
72
70
70
67
65
60
59
48
41
35
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
86
6 Methodology
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
87
EuropeProportion sample/
total populationProportion sample/
total population Sample size Methodology Age Regional coverage Fieldwork
France 81.5% 53.0 M 1,064 CAPI 15+ Nationwide Sep 2017
Germany 88.0% 72.3 M 2,056 CAPI 14+ Nationwide Sep 2017
Italy 86.3% 51.2 M 1,107 CAPI 15+ Nationwide Sep 2017
Netherlands 80.0% 13.6 M 1,000 CATI ad hoc 18+ Nationwide Feb 2017
Poland 85.0% 32.4 M 1,000 CAPI 15+ Nationwide Sep 2017
Russia 82.4% 118.7 M 2,228 TAPI 16+Nationwide except for regions in Northern Russia
and North CaucasusSep 2017
Spain 85.2% 39.5 M 1,020 CAPI 15+ Nationwide Oct 2017
Sweden 81.8% 8.1 M 1,009 CATI 16-84 Nationwide Sep 2017
Turkey 74.3% 60.0 M 1,001 CAPI 15+12 regions: Istanbul, Ankara, İzmir, Bursa,
Kayseri, Malatya, Adana, Samsun, Trabzon, Tekirdağ, Diyarbakır and Erzurum
Sep 2017
UK 81.0% 53.6 M 1,031 CAPI 16+ Nationwide Nov 2017
Methodology Europe
Fieldwork carried out with GfK GLOBO BUS®
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
88
North and SouthAmerica
Proportion sample/total population
Proportion sample/total population Sample size Methodology Age Regional coverage Fieldwork
Brazil 72.0% 150.6 M 1,000 CATI 18+ Nationwide Oct 2017
Mexico 72.4% 93.5 M 1,001 CATI 15+ Nationwide Sep 2017
USA 77.3% 250.7 M 1,000 KP CAWI 18+ Nationwide Sep 2017
Asia and the Pacific
India 5.0% 67.0 M 1,078 PAPI 15-64 Mumbai, New Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai Feb/March 2017
Indonesia 7.0% 18.5 M 1,040 PAPI 15-64 Jakarta, Surabaya, Medan, Bandung, Makassar Feb/March 2017
Iran 29.0% 23.5 M 1,000 PAPI ad hoc 18+ Tehran, Mashhad, Esfahan, Tabrez, Shiraz Feb/March 2017
Japan 79.3% 101.1 M 1,175 PAPI 15-79 Nationwide Sep 2017
South Korea 80.9% 41.2 M 1,500 PAPI 19+ Nationwide Sep 2017
Africa
Kenya 11.2% 5.5 M 1,007 PAPI 18+ Nairobi, Mombasa, Kisumu Sep 2017
South Africa 22.9% 13.0 M 1,202 CAPI 16+Metropolitan Region of Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal,
Cape TownSep 2017
Methodology North and South America, Asia and the Pacific, Africa
Fieldwork carried out with GfK GLOBO BUS®
Contents
©G
fK V
ere
in 2
018
89
Changes to the methodology
Country Type of change
Netherlands Change of methodology (from CATI BUS to CATI ad hoc)
Sweden Change of institute
Mexico Included for the first time
ArgentinaNo longer included: In 2018, the Trust in Professions study was no longer conducted in any of the countries named on the left.
In the interests of comparability, these countries have been excluded from the mean values of previous years. As a result, there are slight differences between the mean values for 2016 and 2014 and the last two reports.
Australia
Belgium
Canada
Nigeria
Austria
Philippines
Switzerland
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
90
Categorisation for social media analysis (1)
Remarks Explanatory notes
The statements recorded from the Internet were categorised according to various freely combinable criteria, generally based on the source of the statement, reputation and topic parameters.
Source
Editorial content:
Content created and made available by the provider of a website, e.g. contributions from media websites (newspapers, magazines, TV and radio) or company websites (including job advertisements).
User-generated content:
Content on the World Wide Web that is not created or maintained by the website operator, but is produced by the site users themselves. Such content is increasingly to be found on the Web 2.0 and includes blogs, web forums, social networks or YouTube.
ReputationDepending on the context, the statements are divided into positive, neutral and negative content; in order to ensure that ironic content is assigned correctly, this categorisation is not automated.
Topic parameters for group comparison
In order to compare the assessment of the professional groups in terms of content, contributions on the Internet were categorised according to the following topics:
� Pay (good/bad/over-/underpaid)
� Helpfulness� Corruption (mercenary/in the sense of: only for one's own benefit)
� Prestige/renown/reputation (good, bad, arrogant, etc.)
� Reliability� Credibility� Future/security of the profession: is it a profession with a future, security in the sense of a secure income?
� Other topics/rest
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
91
Categorisation for social media analysis (2)
Remarks Explanatory notes
Professional group-specific topic parameters
In order to be able to better examine the professional groups themselves, individual topic categories were additionally provided for each professional group.
Policemen Politicians Market researchers
� Schutzpolizei, Streifendienst, Polizeistaffeln, Kontaktbereichsbeamte, Verkehrspolizei, Bereitschaftspolizei, Landespolizei, Polizeivollzugsdienst, Einsatzhundertschaften
� Bundespolizei, Bundesgrenzschutz, Bahnpolizei
� Kriminalpolizei, Bundeskriminalamt
� SEK, MEK, GSG9 und andere Spezialeinheiten
� Andere Polizisten
� Fiktion� Keine Fiktion
� UN-Ebene� Europaebene� Bundesebene� Länderebene� Kommunale Ebene oder
kleiner� Andere Politiker
� Marktforschung� Meinungsforschung� Wahlforschung� Data Scientists� Andere
� Stellenanzeigen� Keine Stellenanzeigen
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
92
Sample and weighting
Remarks Explanatory notes
Language areaTexts were collected from German-speaking countries, whereby texts from Austria and Switzerland could be excluded as far as possible.
PopulationThe population of all texts on a topic is usually very large. For example, in this study a total of 133,079 texts concerning the professional group of policemen was published over the course of one month. When using human coding, i.e. categorisation by a coding team, a sampling approach is used.
Sample taking
In order to categorise the content on the Web according to topic and tone, a sample is taken. The sampling procedure is similar to the logic of surveys (stratified sampling). That is to say, quotas are set, which are then extrapolated accordingly to provide a representation of the population. In this study, one quota per channel was specified for each week of data collection. This meant that at least n=245 articles were coded in total on a weekly basis. For each channel, a corresponding quota was specified proportionally. This allows us to ensure that enough articles are being coded per channel and thus a channel distribution is being achieved that represents the overall distribution.
Boosting
In the event that a channel contains very few texts and thus very few texts have been coded due to the quota, this channel is “boosted”. This means that a minimum number of articles overrepresenting the portion is coded. In this study, at least ten texts per week were coded for the following channels: blogs,e-commerce, forums, social networks, videos and the Web.
WeightingBoosted channels are balanced by weighting. All other channels are correspondingly extrapolated, so that the overall result represents the population.
Contents
©G
fK V
erei
n 20
18
93
List of references
Offline research:
− Der neue Fischer Weltalmanach 2017. Zahlen, Daten, Fakten.Frankfurt am Main 2016.
− Der neue Fischer Weltalmanach 2018. Zahlen, Daten. Fakten.Frankfurt am Main 2017.
Online research on websites, e.g.
− Federal Foreign Office.URL: http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de (as of: Q4/2017).
− German-Swedish Chamber of CommerceURL: http://www.handelskammer.se/de (as of: Q4/2017).
− Federal Department of Justice and Police FDJPURL: https://www.ejpd.admin.ch (as of: Q4/2017).
− Germany Trade and Invest (GTAI), Association for Foreign Trade and LocationMarketing mbHURL: http://www.gtai.de (as of: Q4/2017).
− ILOSTAT – ILO modelled estimates (used for infographics)URL: www.ilo.org (as of: Q4/2017).
− Open DoorsURL: https://www.opendoors.de/ (as of: Q4/2017).
− Pew Research Center.URL: http://www.pewresearch.org/ (as of: Q4/2017).
− Reporters Without Borders.URL: https://www.reporter-ohne-grenzen.de/ (as of: Q4/2017).
− Statista.URL: https://de.statista.com/ (as of: Q4/2017).
− Federal Statistical Office of GermanyURL: http://www.destatis.de/ (as of: Q4/2017).
− The World Bank. (used for infographics)URL: http://data.worldbank.org (as of: Q4/2017).
− Transparency International (Corruption Perceptions Index 2016, used forinfographics)URL: http://www.transparency.de (as of: Q4/2017).
− Trading EconomicsURL: https://tradingeconomics.com/ (as of: Q4/2017).
− United Nations Population and Human Development Index 2016 (used forinfographics)URL: http://www.un.org/ (as of: Q4/2017).
− Wittgenstein Centre for Demography and Global Human Capital (used forinfographics)URL: dataexplorer.wittgensteincentre.org (as of: Q4/2017).
− various German newspapers and magazines, such as Der Spiegel, DeutschesÄrzteblatt, Deutsche Wirtschafts Nachrichten, Die Welt, Die Zeit, FAZ,Frankfurter Rundschau, Handelsblatt, Heise, Rheinische Post, Runner's World,Süddeutsche Zeitung, Tagesspiegel, TAZ
− various radio and television stations, such as ARD, Bayerischer Rundfunk,Deutsche Welle, Deutschlandfunk, MDR, n-tv, ZDF
− various international newspapers, magazines, radio and TV broadcasters,such as the BBC, Business Live, CNN, Dagens Nyheter, Der Standard, DiePresse, Euronews, Eurotopics, Netralnews, Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ), Stol,Südtirol News, Svenska Dagbladet, Tagesanzeiger, The Guardian, TheWashington Post
− various websites on individual countries, regions and topics, such asJapandigest, Korea.net, NetherlandsNet, Vetenskap & Allmänhet
Background information and explanations by GfK in the respective countries surveyed
Contents